Latest / Common Sense Rankings Podcast / CSR Podcast #22: Week 8 Review, another AP Poll Audit, and a new CSR Top 25
Transcript
- 0:13Hello, and welcome to episode number 22 of the Common Sense Rankings podcast, where we rank the resume, not the expectation.
- 0:20Today I'll be going through the CSR's most impactful results during week eight.
- 0:24I'll see if I can find some resumes to compare.
- 0:27I'll audit another week of AP poll votes, and we'll talk about what teams play the most critical games for the CSR in week nine.
- 0:35112 FBS teams had games scheduled for week eight, giving us 56 games to look forward to.
- 0:41There were no FCS opponents on the schedule, so the remaining 26 teams had the week off.
- 0:46Six of last week's top 25 in the CSR had byes, and because of the CSR's methodology of ranking the entirety of teams' games, those six teams would likely lose ground from last week to this week's rankings.
- 0:59Those teams moved down an average of two spots week to week.
- 1:04With each conference deep into league play, there were no non-conference match-ups on the docket, meaning our conference standings remain the same.
- 1:11A win against the SEC is still worth the most, followed by the Big Ten, then the Big 12 and the ACC.
- 1:17Among the group of six conferences, the American, Pac-12, and Sun Belt performed the best in out-of-conference play, followed by the Mountain West, Conference USA, and Mid-American down at the bottom I said last week this wasn't an X's and O's podcast, but that was before ranked teams continued to lose.
- 1:35So here's a timeline of week eight results that'll have the biggest impact in the CSR.
- 1:41James Madison played a Thursday night Sun Belt game against another of the conference's favorites, Appalachian State.
- 1:46A doink off the upright in overtime gave the App State Mountaineers a shot to take down the undefeated Dukes, and kicker Morgan Suarez made the best of his chance, sending JMU plummeting down both the AP and CSR rankings.
- 1:59Auburn and LSU battled in the noon Eastern game on ABC as two of the top two lost teams in the country, with a loss likely dooming either team to another CFP-free season.
- 2:10Auburn experienced the post-upset letdown, allowing the LSU Tigers to win 38-17.
- 2:16Miami ran all over Pitt on ESPN in the early games.
- 2:19Not much more to talk about there.
- 2:21The AP had Miami higher than the CSR, but after already facing an FCS squad and taking their bye, it's all in front of the Hurricanes for the common sense rankings.
- 2:31Texas Tech had a wins over under of 11 and a half this season, so it was undefeated or not at the betting sites.
- 2:36Turns out it'll be not.
- 2:38The Red Raiders fell to Cincinnati in the Sorsby Bowl on FS1.
- 2:42Oregon lost to Illinois in the second round of games, making USC's and Boise State's loss to the Ducks a larger stain on their resumes.
- 2:49Then, because there hasn't been enough circular cannibalism in the SEC, South Carolina took down Tennessee on ESPN 27-24.
- 2:57Without a predetermined formula calculating the value of each win and loss, it'd be impossible to rank SEC teams based strictly on who's beaten who.
- 3:06After winning at home over Notre Dame last week, many were calling BYU's trip to UCF a trap game.
- 3:12Those many were right.
- 3:13Insanity ensued down the stretch with both teams left scratching their heads on calls that went the other team's way.
- 3:19Double overtime was necessary, and a fourth-down pass fell incomplete for the Cougars, giving UCF the upset and the second undefeated Big 12 to fall in week eight.
- 3:29Meanwhile, on FS1, Iowa was back to their low-scoring ways from a few years ago, only managing 10 points against Minnesota.
- 3:36The Golden Gophers take the Floyd of Rosedale Trophy back home and boot Iowa from the CSR Top 25.
- 3:43UCLA, last week's number one team, held serve at home, where they welcomed Michigan State.
- 3:47A comfy 28 to 10 win kept the Bruins atop the CSR for another week.
- 3:52In the primetime games, Kentucky fell behind Vanderbilt early but coasted toward the end for a 17-point victory, and AP number 25 Arizona cooked Iowa State 39 to 3.
- 4:03Texas and Ole Miss was the lone ranked matchup among the primetime games for the East Coast.
- 4:07Texas allowed the Rebels to keep it close and even gave them a chance late, but the Longhorns prevailed, continuing the circle of defeat between two lost SEC schools.
- 4:16Southern Cal had been the darling of the CSR formula, playing in week zero and not hosting any FCS schools, but that is quickly changing, most recently due to the Trojans' loss to Wisconsin.
- 4:26The Badgers held USC to negative rush yards on the game and alerting the Big 12 to their potential bid for a trip to the conference championship game.
- 4:33Lastly, the last game of the night was the site of college game day last week, Utah hosting Houston.
- 4:39It was the second straight week the crew went to a school in Utah and the Big 12 after going to BYU a week earlier.
- 4:45A late Houston fumble gave the Utes the ball on the nine-yard line, and one play later, the Utes were up eight and didn't relinquish their lead.
- 4:52The Utes remain undefeated for another week.
- 4:57Alrighty.
- 4:57If we agree that resumes should be assessed when ranking teams and not answering the question, who would be the favorite or who would win on a neutral field, then we also agree that humans assessing college football teams are flawed.
- 5:09Let me prove it to you by putting some resumes side by side In our first blind resume test, Team A is six and one.
- 5:18They are four and one in the ACC with the other two wins coming against a Big Ten school and a MAC team.
- 5:24Their loss is to an undefeated team in their conference.
- 5:27The teams they've defeated have 10 Power Four wins and 12 overall FBS wins.
- 5:33Team B, meanwhile, is also six and one.
- 5:35They are three and one in the Big 12, granted a harder conference, but their other three wins are over the Pac-12, Conference USA, and FCS school.
- 5:43Their loss is to a five and two Big 12 team.
- 5:46Their opponents that they've beaten have a combined six Power Four wins and 13 FBS victories.
- 5:52So Team A has one more FBS win.
- 5:55They have two more Power Four wins.
- 5:57Their loss was to a team with no losses, and the opponents they've beaten on the field have defeated more Power Four schools.
- 6:04Put side by side, I think we can all agree that although the ACC falls just behind the Big 12 in conference strength, Team A's resume still reigns supreme at this point.
- 6:14Team A is Wake Forest, the number 14 school in the AP, but number 12 in the CSR.
- 6:19Team B is Texas Tech, who sits one spot above Wake in the AP at number 13, but is down at number 20 in the CSR Blind resume test number two.
- 6:32Team A is six and one.
- 6:33They started three and one in the Big 12 with another Power Four win and also a win over the Pac-12.
- 6:39Their loss is to a three-loss Big 12 school.
- 6:42Their five FBS wins have come against schools with 17 wins at the highest level and 10 Power Four wins.
- 6:48Team B, meanwhile, is five and two.
- 6:50They're two and two in the SEC.
- 6:52They also have wins over the Big Ten, Pac-12, and American.
- 6:56Their losses are to teams with a cumulative five losses, all against Power Four opponents.
- 7:01The five teams they've defeated have 25 FBS wins and 12 Power Four wins, including six wins against the SEC.
- 7:09So Team B has the same number of FBS wins, and those opponents have more wins and more Power Four wins.
- 7:15Their losses will likely hurt them slightly more as they have two of them, and the cumulative losses by those teams is slightly higher.
- 7:22In the CSR, Team B has the edge.
- 7:25That'd be Texas, who is ranked 11th in the AP, but seventh in the Common Sense rankings.
- 7:30Team A is BYU, who's ranked higher in the AP at number eight, but down at number 14 in the CSR, admittedly behind Notre Dame, a team they defeated.
- 7:39In the CSR, the value of those SEC wins by Texas outweigh the additional loss the Longhorns picked up in conference play.
- 7:47Their resume based solely on wins and losses is stronger right now One more blind resume test.
- 7:55We have two seven and one teams.
- 7:57Team A is five and one in the SEC, statistically the strongest conference.
- 8:02They also have a Sun Belt win and a win over an FCS school.
- 8:06Their loss is to a two-loss SEC team.
- 8:09Those six FBS wins against teams with 20 total FBS victories and 11 Power Four wins.
- 8:16Team B, also seven and one, they started four and one in the Big Ten, so one less win against a statistically less successful conference.
- 8:23Their other wins come against the American and Conference USA.
- 8:27Their loss is to a one-loss Big Ten team.
- 8:29The six teams they've defeated have 20 total FBS victories and nine Power Four wins.
- 8:35To recap, Team A has more conference wins in a superior conference.
- 8:39The opponents they've defeated have two more Power Four wins, including a strong showing in the SEC, but their loss is to a team with one more loss, albeit from a team from a stronger conference.
- 8:50Team A is Kentucky, number nine in the AP, but much higher in the CSR.
- 8:55Team B, Indiana, who sits number four in the AP, but just lower than Kentucky at CSR number six.
- 9:04Hopefully, these blind resumes are giving you a little insight into the CSR formulas and what it values.
- 9:09It also shows that there may be some biases coming out in the AP poll.
- 9:14So let me show you the top 10 teams in this week's Common Sense rankings.
- 9:18UCLA retains their spot at the top due to their seven FBS wins, most in the country, six Power Four wins, most in the country, and five Big Ten wins.
- 9:28The value of the seven wins they've accrued puts them atop the direct wins metric in the CSR formula.
- 9:34The value of their opponents' wins aren't quite as high as some of the other teams, as they sit 12th in that metric in the Common Sense rankings.
- 9:41But their lack of loss and strength of their seven FBS wins keeps them at the top another week.
- 9:47Number two also remains the same from last week's rankings.
- 9:50Let me reintroduce the Kentucky Wildcats.
- 9:53Kentucky, with their six FBS wins, have the second strongest value of wins thus far and the third strongest resume of opponent wins.
- 10:00The value of their loss took consecutive hits when Alabama lost two in a row, putting them squarely in the number two spot.
- 10:07The Cats are on bye this coming week, meaning there's a chance they slip down a spot or two next week.
- 10:13Number three will be the first where I get some eye rolls.
- 10:16Number three in the CSR resume rankings as of right now is the Alabama Crimson Tide.
- 10:21They have four SEC wins, another Power Four win over Florida State, and a win over the American in East Carolina.
- 10:28That combination of six wins over FBS teams puts them third in direct win points this week.
- 10:34Their two losses obviously hurt the resume, but the six teams they've won against have 20 combined FBS wins, including 10 SEC and 13 total Power Four victories.
- 10:44That puts them second among opponent win points this week and third overall.
- 10:49The Tide will slip the rest of the season for two reasons.
- 10:52They're on bye this week, as are several of their opponents they've played thus far.
- 10:56They also play an FCS school in week 12, which will further stunt their season-ending resume.
- 11:02Number four is another undefeated squad, one of just three remaining in college football in the Miami Hurricanes.
- 11:08Now, I went on a social media diatribe about why undefeated Miami is behind two-loss Alabama right now.
- 11:14It boils down to the front-loaded Alabama schedule compared to Miami's back-loaded schedule.
- 11:19Miami has already taken their bye and played an FCS team, while Alabama has yet to do either.
- 11:24Miami is also penalized by playing in the ACC, a conference that is the weakest among the Power Four for this season.
- 11:31Miami's value of wins is 13th in the country and value of opponent wins is seventh.
- 11:36They're up at the four spot due to their lack of losses to this point.
- 11:40The top Big 12 team is number five, the Utah Utes.
- 11:43Coming off their big game day win over Houston, Utah is third and final undefeated team this week in the CSR.
- 11:49Utah has the fourth best value of wins in the country, which helps offset the 20th ranked value of opponent wins.
- 11:56As the direct wins are still making up the majority of a team's resume evaluation, Utah benefits from the teams they've defeated, even if those teams are still looking for quality wins.
- 12:06Number six is Indiana, who, yes, comes in ahead of Ohio State even considering the head to head.
- 12:11Similar to the Alabama Miami situation, it's just a matter of Indiana having a late season bye.
- 12:17Number seven is two loss Texas, which may feel biased toward the SEC, but that win over Ohio State still looms large thanks to Ohio State being undefeated otherwise.
- 12:27Speaking of the Buckeyes, they're the number eight team this week after their bye.
- 12:30Without playing based on the results around them, they stayed stagnant from last edition.
- 12:35Number nine is Georgia, whose bye dropped them several spots in this week's rankings.
- 12:39The Dogs are in the driver's seat for a spot in the SEC championship, as it's only them and Kentucky who sit at one loss in the conference.
- 12:46To fill out the top 10, Notre Dame, who was also idle in week eight, stayed one spot behind Georgia.
- 12:52They lost points this week due to BYU's loss, but gained points thanks to Stanford and Wisconsin's wins.
- 13:00To complete the top 25, we have number 11, LSU, after their win over Auburn.
- 13:05Number 12, Wake Forest, another idle team last week.
- 13:0813, Ole Miss, so a fourth two-loss SEC team.
- 13:1214 is BYU, last week's CSR number three.
- 13:1515 is Southern Cal.
- 13:1716, Tennessee.
- 13:18Florida is 17.
- 13:20UTSA is the top group of 16 in the CSR this week.
- 13:24They're number 18.
- 13:25James Madison dropped all the way to number 19.
- 13:2820 is Texas Tech.
- 13:2921, Houston.
- 13:3022, Arizona.
- 13:3223, Northwestern.
- 13:3324, SMU.
- 13:35The Mustangs are finally top 25 in the CSR.
- 13:38And we wrap up with a third group of 16, Boise State.
- 13:41There are no three-loss teams in the CSR top 25 quite yet, but a few SEC three-loss schools are knocking on the door.
- 13:48If Mississippi State, Auburn, and Oklahoma win this coming week, we'll likely see at least one move into the CSR top 25.
- 13:57The CSR has more level-headed with eight SEC teams, five each from the Big Ten and Big 12, three from the ACC, then one each from the American, Pac-12, Sun Belt, and Notre Dame.
- 14:10In comparison with the AP poll, we have one fewer SEC team.
- 14:13Missouri is just barely outside the CSR top 25.
- 14:17The same number of Big Ten teams, but we have USC instead of Wisconsin, again, recognizing head-to-head, but we use the totality of the resumes.
- 14:25We have one fewer Big 12 team.
- 14:27Oklahoma State continues to be over ranked.
- 14:30The same number of ACC teams.
- 14:31And lastly, we have three group of 16 compared to the AP's one, Boise State.
- 14:38Let's construct our college football playoff matchups based on this week's common sense rankings.
- 14:42While controversial, the buys would go to UCLA, Kentucky, Alabama, and Miami.
- 14:48In the first round, we'd see number five, Utah, hosting the group of six rep UTSA.
- 14:53Number six, Indiana, welcoming number 11, LSU to Bloomington.
- 14:57Number seven, Texas, getting a visit from Notre Dame.
- 15:00That'd be a fun one.
- 15:01And the eight-nine matchup would be Georgia visiting Ohio State, another hypothetical banger.
- 15:06The first three teams to miss out on this week's CFP bracket would be Wake Forest, Ole Miss, and BYU.
- 15:14When we take a look at the sixty-nine AP poll ballots, we're seeing a better evaluations of teams' resumes, at least as far as who makes the top twenty-five.
- 15:22They got twenty-two of those top twenty-five correct this week and nine of the top ten, so a hesitant round of applause to the voters.
- 15:29It's what's within the top twenty-five where the CSR is scratching its head.
- 15:33First, what they got right.
- 15:35Boise State is finally deserving of a rank.
- 15:37UCLA and Kentucky are both appropriately in the top ten, and we're relatively keeping the SEC in check.
- 15:44Where they can improve, one loss and James Madison is suddenly off every ballot.
- 15:49Seems drastic.
- 15:50UTSA only got one vote.
- 15:52They're the top group of sixteen in the common sense rankings.
- 15:55And Oklahoma State is still vastly over appreciated by these voters, I'd assume because of the Oregon win and we're just ignoring the loss to Tulsa.
- 16:04So what voters ballots are aligning with the common sense rankings?
- 16:08I mentioned UTSA got one vote this week, and that comes from Ralph Russo.
- 16:12With The American being tied with the Pac-12 and Sun Belt as the best conferences among the group of six, it's fitting that a seven and one conference leader gets some attention, especially with their only loss being to two-loss Texas.
- 16:25UCLA and Kentucky are numbers one and two in the CSR this week.
- 16:29The lowest cumulative ranking of those two teams comes from Chris Murray of Nevada Sports Net.
- 16:34He had UCLA fourth and Kentucky sixth.
- 16:37Still underrated, but the least underrated of any ballot.
- 16:41Lastly, I think voters in general are underappreciating the entirety of Southern Cal's resume thus far.
- 16:47They have six FBS wins, the same as many of the teams at the top, and playing in the Big Ten should get them more credit than it does.
- 16:53Three voters included USC in their ballots this week, of which Harry Greenstein had them highest at number twenty-two.
- 16:59Pat Welter had them ranked twenty-fourth, and Steven Means had them twenty-fifth.
- 17:05And now the more fun part, let's talk about those ballots that were just terrible.
- 17:09If I feel I must call out ballots for ranking UCLA and Kentucky close to the correct spot, I must also call out a voter who not only under-ranked both, they were the lowest on both the Bruins and the Wildcats.
- 17:20Cokie Riley had UCLA at number 12 and Kentucky all the way down at number 16.
- 17:2619 voters had Oklahoma State off their ballots, so good for them, but one had them up at number 14, which is about 20 spots higher than the CSR ranks their resume.
- 17:35Adam Lichtenstein was that voter who had the Cowboys all the way up at the 14th spot.
- 17:41Lastly, Oregon State sits at five and two with two losses to Big 12 schools but aren't anywhere near the CSR top 25.
- 17:48They're all the way down at number 51 in the Common Sense rankings.
- 17:51Five voters included the Beavers this week with Ian Kress putting them number 23, the highest of anybody.
- 17:57Dylan Sinn also needs to double-check his ballot before submitting because he has Oregon State above Boise State and behind New Mexico, which is, we'll call it interesting Looking ahead to week nine, there are six teams in this week's CSR top 25 who are on bye.
- 18:14Numbers two and three, Kentucky and Alabama, as well as LSU, Tennessee, UTSA, and Houston.
- 18:20Depending on the results from teams they've played thus far, we can anticipate those teams to lose a little ground if the teams around them in the rankings win.
- 18:28Last week's idle teams lost an average of two spots week to week.
- 18:32The vast majority of teams are playing conference opponents in week nine, but CSR number one UCLA is playing non-conference.
- 18:39The Nevada Wolf Pack fly over to Los Angeles to play the Bruins this week.
- 18:43A Mountain West win would mean less to UCLA's resume when compared to an ACC win for Miami or a Big 12 win for Utah, so we'll see how the formulas shake out next week.
- 18:53UCLA has a large numerical advantage at the top, so I don't envision them losing the number one spot.
- 18:59This matchup won't impact the CSR conference rankings as the Big Ten has already wrapped up a head-to-head victory over the Mountain West this season.
- 19:08There are another three CSR ranked matchups this week.
- 19:11Ohio State is the highest ranked team in the CSR and AP poll to have a ranked opponent this week.
- 19:18They'll fly out to the West Coast to play the USC Trojans, who come in at number 15 in the CSR.
- 19:23USC's direct wins right now is ranked seventh in the country, so if the Buckeyes can pick up a dub over the Trojans, it would not only net them the points of a Big Ten win, they'd get credit for all the Trojans wins as well.
- 19:34That'd likely put them firmly in the CSR top five, pending results elsewhere.
- 19:39Eyeballing it, I'm not sure USC falls out of the CSR top 25 with a loss.
- 19:43Again, it would depend on all the games throughout the week.
- 19:46That game is at 7:30 Eastern on NBC.
- 19:49The second ranked matchup will be at 3:30 Eastern on ABC with the world's largest outdoor cocktail party.
- 19:55Usually played in Jacksonville, it'll be played in Atlanta at Mercedes-Benz Stadium this season due to EverBank Stadium in Jacksonville undergoing renovations.
- 20:02The Dogs are number nine in the CSR and Florida is 17, but they'd potentially swap places with a Gators win, while Georgia would continue their run in the top 10 with a victory.
- 20:12The last matchup between CSR ranked teams is CSR number 20, Texas Tech playing number 22, Arizona.
- 20:18They have the 12 noon game on ESPN, an interesting choice given the time zones of the teams involved.
- 20:24The Red Raiders likely need to win out to have a CFP chance, while the Wildcats are looking at a similar predicament.
- 20:30The winner of this game would not only get another Big 12 win on their resume, but would also get credit for the other five FBS wins of the opposing team as well.
- 20:38Game day will be in Bloomington, Indiana this week for Indiana's game against Minnesota.
- 20:42Another interesting choice, but I guess the Hoosiers are the defending champions.
- 20:46All right.
- 20:47I'm gonna stop it there this week.
- 20:49Thanks for the listen.
- 20:49I hoped you enjoyed it.
- 20:51If you'd like more interaction with the CSR, please give me a follow at CommSenseRanking.
- 20:55I also update commonsensrankings.com multiple times throughout every week with the live one through 138 rankings to that point.
- 21:03Recently, I dropped the CSR's College Basketball Preview podcast, where I run through each conference to give you an idea of what to expect, who's the best chance to win each of the auto bids, and which teams are the most important to their conference's success in the CSR.
- 21:17Thanks again for listening, and please, as you go about your day-to-day, use some common sense.