Latest / Where Parents Talk: Evidence-based Expert Advice on Raising Kids Today / Navigating the New Age: How to Raise Critical Thinkers in a World of Disinformation
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome
- 0:01to
- 0:01Where
- 0:01Parents
- 0:02Talk.
- 0:02My
- 0:02name
- 0:02is
- 0:02Leanne
- 0:03Castellino.
- 0:04Our
- 0:04guest
- 0:04today
- 0:05is
- 0:05the
- 0:05CEO
- 0:06of
- 0:06Brave,
- 0:06Writer
- 0:07and
- 0:07a
- 0:08thought
- 0:08leader
- 0:08in
- 0:08homeschooling.
- 0:09Julie
- 0:10Bogart
- 0:10is
- 0:11also
- 0:11an
- 0:11author
- 0:12and
- 0:12creator
- 0:12of
- 0:13an
- 0:13online
- 0:13writing
- 0:14program
- 0:14serving
- 0:15more
- 0:15than
- 0:15190
- 0:16countries
- 0:17over
- 0:17more
- 0:18than
- 0:1820
- 0:18years.
- 0:19Her
- 0:19latest
- 0:20book
- 0:20is
- 0:20called
- 0:21Becoming
- 0:21a
- 0:22Critical
- 0:22Thinker,
- 0:23a
- 0:23workbook
- 0:23to
- 0:24help
- 0:24students
- 0:24think
- 0:25well
- 0:25in
- 0:26an
- 0:26age
- 0:26of
- 0:26disinformation.
- 0:28Julie
- 0:28is
- 0:28also
- 0:29a
- 0:29mother
- 0:29of
- 0:29five,
- 0:30and
- 0:30she
- 0:30joins
- 0:31us
- 0:31today
- 0:32from
- 0:32Cincinnati,
- 0:33Ohio.
- 0:34Welcome
- 0:34and
- 0:34thank
- 0:34you
- 0:35so
- 0:35much
- 0:35for
- 0:35being
- 0:35here.
- 0:36Thanks
- 0:36for
- 0:36having
- 0:37me.
- 0:37Leanne,
- 0:38this
- 0:39student
- 0:39workbook
- 0:40that
- 0:40you've
- 0:40just.
- 0:40Recently
- 0:41published
- 0:43follows
- 0:43on
- 0:43the
- 0:44heels
- 0:44of
- 0:44a
- 0:44book
- 0:44that
- 0:44you
- 0:45wrote
- 0:45in
- 0:452022
- 0:46called
- 0:47Raising
- 0:47Critical
- 0:48Thinkers.
- 0:49Yeah,
- 0:50and
- 0:50that's
- 0:50geared
- 0:51towards
- 0:51parents.
- 0:52This
- 0:52current
- 0:52book
- 0:53is
- 0:53a
- 0:53workbook
- 0:54for
- 0:54students.
- 0:55Let's
- 0:55start,
- 0:56Julie,
- 0:56by
- 0:56having
- 0:57you
- 0:57describe
- 0:58how
- 0:59you
- 0:59define
- 1:00critical
- 1:00thinking.
- 1:02I
- 1:02love
- 1:02when
- 1:02we
- 1:03start
- 1:03there.
- 1:03Critical
- 1:04thinking,
- 1:04to
- 1:04me,
- 1:05is
- 1:05all
- 1:05about
- 1:06self
- 1:06awareness.
- 1:07So
- 1:08in
- 1:08most
- 1:08venues,
- 1:09people
- 1:09think
- 1:09critical
- 1:10thinking
- 1:10is
- 1:10the
- 1:10ability
- 1:11to
- 1:11critique
- 1:12someone
- 1:12else's
- 1:13ideas.
- 1:14But
- 1:14what
- 1:14I
- 1:14discovered
- 1:15as
- 1:15I
- 1:15spent
- 1:15time
- 1:15in
- 1:16education
- 1:16is
- 1:17that
- 1:17what's
- 1:17missing
- 1:18in
- 1:18most
- 1:18of
- 1:18our
- 1:18thinking
- 1:19is
- 1:19our
- 1:20own
- 1:20awareness
- 1:20of
- 1:21our
- 1:21biases
- 1:22when
- 1:22those
- 1:22get
- 1:23kicked
- 1:23into
- 1:23gear
- 1:24when
- 1:24we're
- 1:24triggered
- 1:25by
- 1:25an
- 1:25idea
- 1:25and
- 1:26are
- 1:26resistant
- 1:26to
- 1:26it.
- 1:27In
- 1:27other
- 1:27words,
- 1:28we
- 1:28can't
- 1:28think
- 1:28well
- 1:28if
- 1:29we
- 1:29don't
- 1:29understand
- 1:30the
- 1:30source
- 1:31of
- 1:31authority
- 1:31that
- 1:32drives
- 1:32our
- 1:33own
- 1:33thinking.
- 1:34So
- 1:34critical
- 1:34thinking,
- 1:35to
- 1:35me
- 1:35is
- 1:36the
- 1:36capacity
- 1:37to
- 1:37recognize
- 1:37your
- 1:38own
- 1:38bias
- 1:38as
- 1:38it
- 1:39kicks
- 1:39into
- 1:39gear
- 1:40to
- 1:40evaluate
- 1:41data,
- 1:41evidence
- 1:42and
- 1:42understand
- 1:43its
- 1:43sources
- 1:44of
- 1:44authority
- 1:45before
- 1:46you
- 1:46start
- 1:46critiquing
- 1:47someone
- 1:47else.
- 1:48Once
- 1:48you
- 1:48can
- 1:48do
- 1:48that,
- 1:49then,
- 1:49yes,
- 1:49you
- 1:49can
- 1:50examine
- 1:50ideas.
- 1:52It's
- 1:52such
- 1:53a
- 1:53great
- 1:53starting
- 1:53point.
- 1:53And
- 1:54we're
- 1:54going
- 1:54to
- 1:54unpack
- 1:55what
- 1:55you
- 1:55just
- 1:55said
- 1:55because
- 1:56there's
- 1:56a
- 1:56lot
- 1:56in
- 1:56there.
- 1:57But
- 1:57I'm
- 1:58curious
- 1:58as
- 1:58to
- 1:59why
- 1:59you
- 2:00believe
- 2:00raising
- 2:01a
- 2:01critical
- 2:01thinker
- 2:02with
- 2:03those
- 2:03attributes
- 2:04that
- 2:04you
- 2:04just
- 2:04described
- 2:05is
- 2:05important
- 2:06today.
- 2:07Well,
- 2:08of
- 2:08course,
- 2:08we
- 2:09have
- 2:09social
- 2:09media
- 2:10and
- 2:10the
- 2:10Internet,
- 2:10which
- 2:11we
- 2:11all
- 2:11complain
- 2:11about
- 2:12constantly
- 2:13because
- 2:13we
- 2:13don't
- 2:13like
- 2:14this
- 2:14idea
- 2:15that
- 2:15our
- 2:15minds
- 2:16and
- 2:16our
- 2:16values
- 2:16and
- 2:16our
- 2:17beliefs
- 2:17are
- 2:18being
- 2:18flooded
- 2:19with
- 2:19information
- 2:20and
- 2:20disinformation,
- 2:21and
- 2:21we
- 2:22find
- 2:22it
- 2:22more
- 2:22and
- 2:22more
- 2:23difficult
- 2:23to
- 2:23sort
- 2:24through
- 2:24that.
- 2:24Our
- 2:25kids
- 2:25seem
- 2:25to
- 2:25be
- 2:26even
- 2:26more
- 2:26ill
- 2:27equipped.
- 2:27But
- 2:28what
- 2:28I've
- 2:28noticed,
- 2:29actually,
- 2:29is
- 2:30that
- 2:30in
- 2:31this,
- 2:31this
- 2:31current
- 2:32era,
- 2:33where
- 2:33we
- 2:33are
- 2:33all
- 2:34very
- 2:34aware
- 2:35that
- 2:35information
- 2:36we
- 2:36get
- 2:36may
- 2:37not
- 2:37be
- 2:37accurate,
- 2:38we
- 2:38are
- 2:39all
- 2:39starting
- 2:40to
- 2:40actually
- 2:41evaluate
- 2:41our
- 2:42sources
- 2:42of
- 2:42authority
- 2:43in
- 2:43a
- 2:43much
- 2:43more
- 2:44rigorous
- 2:44way.
- 2:45So
- 2:45I
- 2:45think
- 2:45this
- 2:46moment
- 2:46is
- 2:46especially
- 2:47poised
- 2:47because
- 2:48of
- 2:48the
- 2:48rise
- 2:48of
- 2:48AI
- 2:49artificial
- 2:50intelligence,
- 2:50the
- 2:51large
- 2:51language
- 2:52models
- 2:52like
- 2:52chatgpt
- 2:53the
- 2:54capacity
- 2:54to
- 2:55sort
- 2:55through
- 2:56what
- 2:56we
- 2:57can
- 2:57trust
- 2:57and
- 2:57what
- 2:57we
- 2:58can't
- 2:58trust
- 2:59is
- 2:59a
- 2:59vital
- 3:00skill
- 3:00for
- 3:00anyone,
- 3:01and
- 3:01particularly
- 3:02our
- 3:02children
- 3:03who
- 3:03will
- 3:04eventually
- 3:04be
- 3:04working
- 3:05in
- 3:05jobs
- 3:05and
- 3:05having
- 3:06to
- 3:06deal
- 3:06with
- 3:06that
- 3:06kind
- 3:07of,
- 3:07you
- 3:08know,
- 3:08fire
- 3:08hose
- 3:08of
- 3:08information
- 3:09every
- 3:09day.
- 3:11So
- 3:12much
- 3:12to
- 3:12wade
- 3:12through.
- 3:13It's
- 3:13a
- 3:13daunting
- 3:14task
- 3:14for
- 3:14any
- 3:15of
- 3:15us
- 3:15to
- 3:15think
- 3:15about
- 3:16living
- 3:16in
- 3:16the
- 3:16knowledge
- 3:17age,
- 3:18and
- 3:18how
- 3:18do
- 3:18we
- 3:19trust
- 3:19what
- 3:20we're
- 3:20seeing,
- 3:20reading,
- 3:21hearing,
- 3:21listening
- 3:22to?
- 3:23So
- 3:23where
- 3:23is
- 3:24an
- 3:24appropriate
- 3:24place
- 3:25for
- 3:25a
- 3:25parent
- 3:26to
- 3:26start
- 3:27to
- 3:27ultimately
- 3:28help
- 3:28their
- 3:29child
- 3:29wade
- 3:29through
- 3:30this
- 3:30as
- 3:30well?
- 3:31So
- 3:31glad
- 3:31you
- 3:31asked
- 3:32that
- 3:32question.
- 3:33When
- 3:33we
- 3:33talk
- 3:33about
- 3:34critical
- 3:34thinking,
- 3:34adults
- 3:35always
- 3:35think
- 3:35about
- 3:36politics,
- 3:36social
- 3:37issues,
- 3:37and
- 3:38religion.
- 3:38But
- 3:39critical
- 3:39thinking
- 3:40actually
- 3:40starts
- 3:40from
- 3:41the
- 3:41time
- 3:41your
- 3:41child
- 3:41is
- 3:42born.
- 3:43Most
- 3:43of
- 3:43us
- 3:43adopt
- 3:44our
- 3:44values
- 3:45through
- 3:45two
- 3:46main
- 3:47lenses.
- 3:48We
- 3:48start
- 3:48as
- 3:49an
- 3:49individual
- 3:50with
- 3:50our
- 3:50own
- 3:51perceptions,
- 3:52and
- 3:52those
- 3:53drive
- 3:53us
- 3:53to
- 3:54act.
- 3:54So
- 3:55from
- 3:55the
- 3:55time
- 3:55you're
- 3:55born,
- 3:56you're
- 3:56crying
- 3:56because
- 3:56you're
- 3:57hungry.
- 3:57That
- 3:58is
- 3:58an
- 3:58expression
- 3:59of
- 3:59a
- 3:59desire.
- 4:00And
- 4:00you
- 4:01aren't
- 4:01sifting
- 4:01through
- 4:02whether
- 4:02or
- 4:02not
- 4:02that's
- 4:03inconvenient
- 4:03to
- 4:03your
- 4:04mother.
- 4:04You're
- 4:05simply
- 4:05expressing,
- 4:06this
- 4:06is
- 4:06my
- 4:06need,
- 4:07this
- 4:07is
- 4:07my
- 4:07perception.
- 4:08But
- 4:09what
- 4:09we
- 4:09don't
- 4:10often
- 4:10acknowledge
- 4:11is
- 4:11that
- 4:12the
- 4:12individual
- 4:12perceptions
- 4:13that
- 4:13we
- 4:14develop
- 4:14over
- 4:14our
- 4:15lifetimes
- 4:16get
- 4:16modified
- 4:17by
- 4:17the
- 4:17communities
- 4:18that
- 4:19we're
- 4:19a
- 4:19part
- 4:19of.
- 4:19And
- 4:20that
- 4:20is
- 4:20another
- 4:21lens
- 4:21for
- 4:22how
- 4:22we
- 4:22form
- 4:22our
- 4:22beliefs.
- 4:23And
- 4:24those
- 4:24communities
- 4:26actually
- 4:26exert
- 4:28a
- 4:28force
- 4:29against
- 4:29our
- 4:30perception.
- 4:30So,
- 4:31for
- 4:31instance,
- 4:31a
- 4:32baby
- 4:32wants
- 4:32to
- 4:33eat
- 4:33whenever
- 4:33it's
- 4:33hungry.
- 4:34But
- 4:34the
- 4:35family,
- 4:35that
- 4:35first
- 4:36community
- 4:36they're
- 4:36a
- 4:36part
- 4:37of,
- 4:37is
- 4:37on
- 4:38a
- 4:38propaganda
- 4:39campaign
- 4:39to
- 4:40convince
- 4:40that
- 4:40baby
- 4:41that
- 4:41eventually
- 4:42you'll
- 4:42be
- 4:42eating
- 4:42only
- 4:43three
- 4:43times
- 4:43a
- 4:43day
- 4:43with
- 4:44a
- 4:44snack.
- 4:45Right?
- 4:45We
- 4:46don't
- 4:46just
- 4:46continue
- 4:47to
- 4:47only
- 4:47eat
- 4:48whenever
- 4:48we
- 4:48feel
- 4:49like
- 4:49it.
- 4:49We
- 4:50have
- 4:50this
- 4:50logic
- 4:51story
- 4:51that
- 4:51we
- 4:52feed
- 4:52to
- 4:52our
- 4:53children.
- 4:53That
- 4:53is,
- 4:54food
- 4:55comes
- 4:55three
- 4:55times
- 4:55a
- 4:56day,
- 4:56not
- 4:5625
- 4:57times
- 4:57a
- 4:57day.
- 4:58And
- 4:58we're
- 4:58going
- 4:58to
- 4:59talk
- 4:59you
- 4:59into
- 4:59it,
- 4:59we're
- 5:00going
- 5:00to
- 5:00model
- 5:00it,
- 5:01we're
- 5:01going
- 5:01to
- 5:01convince
- 5:02you
- 5:02that
- 5:03this
- 5:03perception
- 5:03you
- 5:03have
- 5:04needs
- 5:04to
- 5:04be
- 5:04subordinated
- 5:05to
- 5:06this
- 5:06community
- 5:07value.
- 5:07Well,
- 5:08in
- 5:08a
- 5:08family,
- 5:09some
- 5:09of
- 5:09these
- 5:09are
- 5:09so
- 5:09natural
- 5:10and
- 5:10so
- 5:10obvious.
- 5:11You
- 5:11know,
- 5:11potty
- 5:12training,
- 5:12learning
- 5:12to
- 5:13dress
- 5:13yourself.
- 5:14These
- 5:14all
- 5:14seem
- 5:15like
- 5:15they
- 5:15aren't
- 5:16propaganda,
- 5:16they're
- 5:16just
- 5:17good
- 5:17sense.
- 5:18But
- 5:18the
- 5:19longer
- 5:19that
- 5:19we
- 5:20live
- 5:20and
- 5:20the
- 5:21more
- 5:21communities
- 5:21we
- 5:22join,
- 5:22those
- 5:23communities
- 5:23are
- 5:24interpreting
- 5:24that
- 5:25overwhelming
- 5:25experience
- 5:26of
- 5:26being
- 5:27an
- 5:27individual
- 5:28into
- 5:28a
- 5:28system
- 5:29that
- 5:29helps
- 5:30us
- 5:30feel
- 5:30like
- 5:30we
- 5:30belong
- 5:31and
- 5:31we
- 5:32know
- 5:32how
- 5:32to
- 5:32live
- 5:32and
- 5:33operate.
- 5:34So
- 5:34what
- 5:34parents
- 5:35can
- 5:35do
- 5:36is
- 5:36avoid
- 5:37the
- 5:37temptation
- 5:38to
- 5:38constantly
- 5:39modify
- 5:40a
- 5:40child's
- 5:40perceptions.
- 5:42I
- 5:42would
- 5:42like
- 5:42parents
- 5:43to
- 5:43be
- 5:43more
- 5:43Curious.
- 5:44So
- 5:45here's
- 5:45a
- 5:45good
- 5:45example.
- 5:46Let's
- 5:47say
- 5:47you've
- 5:47got
- 5:47like
- 5:48a
- 5:48seven
- 5:48year
- 5:48old
- 5:49child,
- 5:49it's
- 5:49time
- 5:49for
- 5:50dinner.
- 5:50And
- 5:50you
- 5:50say,
- 5:51hey,
- 5:51go
- 5:51wash
- 5:52your
- 5:52hands,
- 5:52let's
- 5:52eat
- 5:53dinner.
- 5:53And
- 5:53your
- 5:53child
- 5:53says,
- 5:54I
- 5:54don't
- 5:54want
- 5:55to
- 5:55wash
- 5:55my
- 5:55hands.
- 5:56Most
- 5:57parents
- 5:57of
- 5:57my
- 5:58generation
- 5:58see
- 5:59that
- 5:59as
- 5:59an
- 5:59authority
- 6:00contest.
- 6:01Parent
- 6:01will
- 6:01say,
- 6:01you
- 6:02have
- 6:02to.
- 6:02I
- 6:02said,
- 6:02so
- 6:03this
- 6:03is
- 6:03the
- 6:03end
- 6:03of
- 6:04the
- 6:04discussion.
- 6:05And
- 6:05so
- 6:05now
- 6:05the
- 6:06child
- 6:06is
- 6:06subordinating
- 6:07all
- 6:07the
- 6:08reasons
- 6:08they
- 6:08didn't
- 6:08want
- 6:09to
- 6:09wash
- 6:09their
- 6:09hands
- 6:10under
- 6:10this
- 6:10authority.
- 6:11That's
- 6:11telling
- 6:12them
- 6:12they
- 6:12have
- 6:12to
- 6:12anyway.
- 6:13In
- 6:14the
- 6:14current
- 6:14model
- 6:15of
- 6:15parenting,
- 6:15sort
- 6:16of
- 6:16this
- 6:16millennial
- 6:16and
- 6:17Gen
- 6:17X
- 6:17group,
- 6:18what
- 6:18a
- 6:19lot
- 6:19of
- 6:19them
- 6:19have
- 6:19done,
- 6:20instead
- 6:20of
- 6:20this
- 6:20authoritarian
- 6:21control,
- 6:22they've
- 6:22done
- 6:22what
- 6:23they
- 6:23call
- 6:24cooperation
- 6:24by
- 6:25explanation.
- 6:26So
- 6:26what
- 6:26they'll
- 6:26do
- 6:27is
- 6:27they'll
- 6:27say,
- 6:28well,
- 6:28you
- 6:28know,
- 6:28science
- 6:29says
- 6:29there
- 6:29are
- 6:29germs
- 6:30on
- 6:30your
- 6:30hands.
- 6:30You
- 6:31can't
- 6:31see
- 6:31them,
- 6:31but
- 6:31if
- 6:31you
- 6:32ingest
- 6:32them,
- 6:32you're
- 6:32going
- 6:33to
- 6:33get
- 6:33sick.
- 6:34What
- 6:34they've
- 6:34actually
- 6:34done
- 6:35is
- 6:35doubled
- 6:35down
- 6:35on
- 6:36authority.
- 6:36They've
- 6:37said,
- 6:37not
- 6:37only
- 6:37do
- 6:37you
- 6:37have
- 6:38to
- 6:38do
- 6:38it
- 6:38because
- 6:38I'm
- 6:38saying
- 6:39so,
- 6:39but
- 6:39now
- 6:39science
- 6:40that
- 6:40you've
- 6:40never
- 6:40read,
- 6:41haven't
- 6:41vetted,
- 6:42is
- 6:42also
- 6:42confirming
- 6:43that
- 6:43I'm
- 6:44right
- 6:44and
- 6:44you're
- 6:44wrong.
- 6:45What
- 6:46I
- 6:46tell
- 6:46parents
- 6:46all
- 6:47the
- 6:47time
- 6:47is
- 6:47even
- 6:48though
- 6:48giving
- 6:48explanations
- 6:49feels
- 6:50like
- 6:50you're
- 6:50empowering
- 6:51your
- 6:51child,
- 6:52what
- 6:52you're
- 6:52really
- 6:52doing
- 6:52is
- 6:53training
- 6:53them
- 6:54to
- 6:54trust
- 6:54and
- 6:55authority,
- 6:55even
- 6:56authorities
- 6:56they
- 6:56haven't
- 6:57vetted.
- 6:58So
- 6:58what
- 6:58I
- 6:58prefer
- 6:59is
- 6:59once
- 7:00a
- 7:00month,
- 7:00you
- 7:00can't
- 7:00do
- 7:00this
- 7:01every
- 7:01day.
- 7:01I
- 7:01know
- 7:01you're
- 7:01busy.
- 7:02When
- 7:03your
- 7:03child
- 7:03resists
- 7:04you
- 7:04or
- 7:05dissents,
- 7:06go
- 7:06down
- 7:06that
- 7:06rabbit
- 7:07hole.
- 7:07Oh,
- 7:08you
- 7:08don't
- 7:09want
- 7:09to
- 7:09wash
- 7:09your
- 7:09hands.
- 7:09Why
- 7:10is
- 7:10that?
- 7:11Find
- 7:11out
- 7:11what's
- 7:11driving
- 7:12that.
- 7:12It
- 7:12might
- 7:12just
- 7:13be
- 7:13they
- 7:13want
- 7:13more
- 7:13time
- 7:14on
- 7:14the
- 7:14computer
- 7:14and
- 7:14they
- 7:14don't
- 7:15want
- 7:15to
- 7:15disengage.
- 7:16It
- 7:16might
- 7:16be
- 7:16that
- 7:17they
- 7:17think
- 7:17the
- 7:17water
- 7:18is
- 7:18too
- 7:18hot
- 7:19and
- 7:19you've
- 7:20never
- 7:20thought
- 7:20about
- 7:20the
- 7:20water
- 7:21being
- 7:21too
- 7:21hot
- 7:21or
- 7:21too
- 7:22cold.
- 7:22Could
- 7:23you
- 7:23get
- 7:23a
- 7:23thermometer
- 7:24and
- 7:25test
- 7:25different
- 7:25temperatures
- 7:26to
- 7:26see
- 7:26which
- 7:26one
- 7:26they
- 7:27can
- 7:27tolerate?
- 7:28Could
- 7:28you
- 7:28look
- 7:28up
- 7:29other
- 7:29ways
- 7:29to
- 7:29get
- 7:30rid
- 7:30of
- 7:30germs?
- 7:30Like
- 7:31maybe
- 7:31with
- 7:31a
- 7:31blow
- 7:31dryer
- 7:32and
- 7:32heat
- 7:32instead
- 7:33of
- 7:33hand
- 7:33washing?
- 7:34But
- 7:35what
- 7:35if
- 7:36even
- 7:36at
- 7:36the
- 7:36base
- 7:36of
- 7:37all
- 7:37this,
- 7:37your
- 7:38child
- 7:38just
- 7:38doesn't
- 7:38believe
- 7:39hand
- 7:39washing
- 7:39makes
- 7:40a
- 7:40difference?
- 7:41Could
- 7:41you
- 7:42interrogate
- 7:42your
- 7:42own
- 7:42belief?
- 7:44Maybe
- 7:44that
- 7:44child
- 7:45saw
- 7:45you
- 7:45in
- 7:45Target
- 7:45yesterday
- 7:46and
- 7:47the
- 7:47baby
- 7:48sister
- 7:48spit
- 7:48out
- 7:49a
- 7:49pacifier
- 7:50and
- 7:50that
- 7:51child
- 7:51watched
- 7:51you
- 7:52pick
- 7:52it
- 7:52up
- 7:52off
- 7:52a
- 7:53dirty
- 7:53floor,
- 7:54suck
- 7:54the
- 7:55dirt
- 7:55off
- 7:55it
- 7:55into
- 7:56your
- 7:56own
- 7:56mouth,
- 7:56and
- 7:57pop
- 7:57it
- 7:57back
- 7:57in
- 7:57that
- 7:57baby's
- 7:58mouth.
- 7:59Could
- 7:59your
- 7:59child
- 8:00on
- 8:00some
- 8:00level
- 8:01see
- 8:01this
- 8:01as
- 8:02an
- 8:02empty,
- 8:02meaningless
- 8:03ritual
- 8:03that
- 8:03you
- 8:04yourself
- 8:04haven't
- 8:04interrogated
- 8:05yet?
- 8:05I
- 8:06mean,
- 8:06do
- 8:06we
- 8:06wash
- 8:06our
- 8:07hands
- 8:07every
- 8:07time
- 8:07we
- 8:07eat
- 8:07a
- 8:08snack?
- 8:08We
- 8:09don't.
- 8:09So
- 8:09is
- 8:10hand
- 8:10washing
- 8:11required?
- 8:13So
- 8:13part
- 8:13of
- 8:13what
- 8:14I
- 8:14hope
- 8:14parents
- 8:14will
- 8:14do
- 8:15is
- 8:15allow
- 8:16kids
- 8:17to
- 8:17dissent,
- 8:18to
- 8:19gather
- 8:19their
- 8:20own
- 8:20data
- 8:20and
- 8:20experiences,
- 8:21to
- 8:22challenge
- 8:22the
- 8:23authority
- 8:23of
- 8:23a
- 8:24parent's
- 8:24take,
- 8:25and
- 8:25for
- 8:25the
- 8:25parent
- 8:26to
- 8:27actually
- 8:27reframe
- 8:28their
- 8:28own
- 8:28understanding
- 8:29of
- 8:29that
- 8:29belief.
- 8:30Like
- 8:30to
- 8:30actually
- 8:30interrogate
- 8:31it
- 8:31for
- 8:31a
- 8:32moment.
- 8:32How
- 8:32much
- 8:33do
- 8:33I
- 8:33believe
- 8:33this?
- 8:34Is
- 8:34this
- 8:34something
- 8:35that
- 8:35was
- 8:35just
- 8:35passed
- 8:35on
- 8:36to
- 8:36me
- 8:36that
- 8:36I've
- 8:36never
- 8:37critically
- 8:37examined?
- 8:38So,
- 8:38like
- 8:39that.
- 8:40Such
- 8:41an
- 8:41interesting
- 8:41perspective.
- 8:42It
- 8:42makes
- 8:42complete
- 8:43sense
- 8:43the
- 8:43way
- 8:43you
- 8:43lay
- 8:44it
- 8:44out
- 8:44and
- 8:44explain
- 8:44it.
- 8:44It
- 8:45seems
- 8:45rational.
- 8:47But
- 8:47I
- 8:47can
- 8:48hear
- 8:48parents
- 8:48who
- 8:48watch
- 8:49or
- 8:49listen
- 8:49to
- 8:49this
- 8:49interview
- 8:50saying,
- 8:50I
- 8:50just
- 8:50don't
- 8:50think
- 8:51I
- 8:51have
- 8:51that
- 8:51kind
- 8:51of
- 8:51time.
- 8:52I'd
- 8:52be
- 8:52debating
- 8:53every
- 8:53single
- 8:53thing
- 8:53that
- 8:54we're
- 8:54doing
- 8:54all
- 8:54day
- 8:54long.
- 8:55So
- 8:55in
- 8:56other
- 8:56words,
- 8:56it's
- 8:56a
- 8:56fine
- 8:57balance.
- 8:57So
- 8:57how
- 8:58do
- 8:58you
- 8:58as
- 8:58a
- 8:58parent
- 8:59strike
- 8:59a
- 9:00balance?
- 9:00And
- 9:01can
- 9:01you
- 9:01provide
- 9:02an
- 9:02example
- 9:02similar
- 9:02to
- 9:03what
- 9:03you
- 9:03provided,
- 9:04but
- 9:04for
- 9:04the
- 9:05tween
- 9:05teen
- 9:06phase
- 9:06of
- 9:07life?
- 9:07Because
- 9:07they're
- 9:08then
- 9:08designed
- 9:09at
- 9:09that
- 9:09point
- 9:10to
- 9:10challenge
- 9:10you
- 9:10on
- 9:10just
- 9:11about
- 9:11everything
- 9:11naturally,
- 9:12right,
- 9:13Perfect.
- 9:13We'll
- 9:14take
- 9:14them
- 9:14one
- 9:14at
- 9:14a
- 9:15time.
- 9:15So
- 9:15first
- 9:15of
- 9:16all,
- 9:16even
- 9:16at
- 9:16the
- 9:16top,
- 9:17I
- 9:17said,
- 9:18do
- 9:18this
- 9:18once
- 9:19a
- 9:19month
- 9:19with
- 9:20a
- 9:20child,
- 9:20right?
- 9:21When
- 9:21they're
- 9:21climbing
- 9:22in
- 9:22the
- 9:22car
- 9:22seat
- 9:22and
- 9:22they're
- 9:22saying,
- 9:23I
- 9:23hate
- 9:23car
- 9:23seats.
- 9:24You
- 9:24have
- 9:24to
- 9:24get
- 9:25somewhere.
- 9:25You're
- 9:25going
- 9:25to
- 9:25strap
- 9:26them
- 9:26in.
- 9:26They
- 9:26may
- 9:26not
- 9:27like
- 9:27it,
- 9:27but
- 9:28you
- 9:28might
- 9:28revisit
- 9:29that
- 9:29at
- 9:29bedtime.
- 9:30You
- 9:30might
- 9:30say,
- 9:31you
- 9:31know
- 9:31it.
- 9:31I
- 9:32remember
- 9:32that
- 9:32you
- 9:33said
- 9:33you
- 9:33didn't
- 9:33like
- 9:34car
- 9:34seats,
- 9:34and
- 9:34I
- 9:34want
- 9:34to
- 9:35know
- 9:35more
- 9:35about
- 9:35that.
- 9:36I
- 9:36want
- 9:36to
- 9:36talk
- 9:36about
- 9:37this
- 9:37with
- 9:37you.
- 9:38You
- 9:38can't
- 9:38do
- 9:39it
- 9:39every
- 9:39day
- 9:39for
- 9:39everything.
- 9:40But
- 9:40here's
- 9:40what's
- 9:41really
- 9:41fascinating.
- 9:42We
- 9:42don't
- 9:43do
- 9:43it
- 9:43at
- 9:43all.
- 9:44We
- 9:44literally
- 9:45look
- 9:45over
- 9:45their
- 9:45heads
- 9:46and
- 9:46we
- 9:46insist
- 9:47and
- 9:47we
- 9:47get
- 9:47irritated
- 9:48when
- 9:48they
- 9:48won't
- 9:48cooperate
- 9:49and
- 9:49we
- 9:49think
- 9:50we've
- 9:50given
- 9:50them
- 9:50this
- 9:51friendly,
- 9:51nice
- 9:52explanation
- 9:53and
- 9:53all
- 9:54of
- 9:54it
- 9:54just
- 9:54feels
- 9:54like
- 9:55coercion.
- 9:56So
- 9:56if
- 9:56once
- 9:57in
- 9:57a
- 9:57while
- 9:57you
- 9:58surprise
- 9:58your
- 9:58child
- 9:59by
- 9:59being
- 10:00curious
- 10:00and
- 10:01actually
- 10:01giving
- 10:02support
- 10:03or
- 10:03validity
- 10:04to
- 10:04their
- 10:04perspective,
- 10:05the
- 10:06whole
- 10:06dynamic
- 10:06starts
- 10:07shifting
- 10:08and
- 10:08these
- 10:08stop
- 10:09being
- 10:09such
- 10:10contests
- 10:11and
- 10:11it
- 10:12won't
- 10:12take
- 10:12as
- 10:13long
- 10:13the
- 10:13second
- 10:13and
- 10:14third
- 10:14time,
- 10:14because
- 10:15now
- 10:15they
- 10:15know
- 10:15that
- 10:16you
- 10:16are
- 10:16actually
- 10:16curious
- 10:17and
- 10:17interested
- 10:18and
- 10:18you're
- 10:19going
- 10:19to
- 10:19go
- 10:19on
- 10:19this
- 10:19journey
- 10:20together,
- 10:20you'll
- 10:20be
- 10:20amazed.
- 10:21They'll
- 10:21come
- 10:22up
- 10:22sometimes
- 10:22with
- 10:22their
- 10:22own
- 10:23solutions,
- 10:24because
- 10:24the
- 10:24thing
- 10:24they
- 10:25were
- 10:25worried
- 10:25about
- 10:25isn't
- 10:26the
- 10:26thing
- 10:26you're
- 10:26explaining
- 10:27against.
- 10:27Right.
- 10:28So
- 10:28that's
- 10:29the
- 10:29first
- 10:29one.
- 10:30Now,
- 10:30teens
- 10:31are
- 10:31in
- 10:31a
- 10:31slightly
- 10:32different
- 10:32category,
- 10:33mostly
- 10:34because
- 10:34younger
- 10:35kids
- 10:35are
- 10:35more
- 10:35naturally
- 10:36cooperative.
- 10:37They
- 10:37want
- 10:37to
- 10:37please
- 10:37their
- 10:38parents.
- 10:38You
- 10:38can
- 10:39insist,
- 10:39and
- 10:39they
- 10:40will
- 10:40swallow
- 10:41their
- 10:41feelings
- 10:41and
- 10:42do
- 10:42what
- 10:42the
- 10:42family
- 10:42program
- 10:43is.
- 10:44Teens
- 10:44really
- 10:45want
- 10:45to
- 10:45find
- 10:45out,
- 10:46can
- 10:47I
- 10:47dissent?
- 10:47Am
- 10:48I
- 10:48in
- 10:48a
- 10:48cult,
- 10:49or
- 10:50am
- 10:50I
- 10:50in
- 10:50a
- 10:51group
- 10:51of
- 10:51people
- 10:52that
- 10:52have
- 10:52the
- 10:53capacity
- 10:54to.
- 10:54To
- 10:54think
- 10:54about
- 10:55ideas
- 10:55differently
- 10:56than
- 10:56I
- 10:56do?
- 10:57I'll
- 10:57give
- 10:57you
- 10:58an
- 10:58example
- 10:58from
- 10:58my
- 10:59own
- 10:59family.
- 10:59I
- 10:59had
- 10:59a
- 10:59son
- 11:00who's
- 11:00about
- 11:0016
- 11:01at
- 11:01the
- 11:01time,
- 11:02and
- 11:02there
- 11:03was
- 11:03a
- 11:03ballot
- 11:03measure
- 11:04in
- 11:04Ohio
- 11:04that
- 11:04he
- 11:05was
- 11:05really
- 11:05excited
- 11:05about,
- 11:06but
- 11:06he
- 11:06wasn't
- 11:06old
- 11:07enough
- 11:07to
- 11:07vote.
- 11:08So
- 11:08he
- 11:08got
- 11:09all
- 11:09of
- 11:09this
- 11:09data
- 11:10together
- 11:10for
- 11:11me.
- 11:11And
- 11:11just
- 11:11so
- 11:11you
- 11:11know,
- 11:12he's
- 11:12a
- 11:12human
- 11:12rights
- 11:12lawyer
- 11:13today,
- 11:14so
- 11:14this
- 11:14is
- 11:15very
- 11:15much
- 11:15like
- 11:15his
- 11:16personality.
- 11:17And
- 11:17he
- 11:17made
- 11:18this
- 11:18case.
- 11:19And
- 11:19I
- 11:20listened
- 11:20and
- 11:20I
- 11:20asked
- 11:20questions,
- 11:21and
- 11:21I
- 11:21was
- 11:21so
- 11:22interested,
- 11:22and
- 11:22I
- 11:23validated
- 11:24what
- 11:24he
- 11:25put
- 11:25together.
- 11:26And
- 11:26at
- 11:26the
- 11:26end
- 11:26he
- 11:27said,
- 11:27so
- 11:27are
- 11:27you
- 11:27going
- 11:27to
- 11:28vote
- 11:28yes?
- 11:29Said,
- 11:29actually,
- 11:29I'm
- 11:29going
- 11:30to
- 11:30vote
- 11:30no.
- 11:31And
- 11:31tears
- 11:32sprang
- 11:32from
- 11:33his
- 11:33eyes.
- 11:33And
- 11:33he
- 11:33said,
- 11:34mom,
- 11:34I
- 11:35count
- 11:35on
- 11:35you
- 11:36to
- 11:36be
- 11:36logical.
- 11:38And
- 11:38I
- 11:38said,
- 11:39oh,
- 11:39honey,
- 11:40everything
- 11:40you
- 11:41said
- 11:41actually
- 11:42supports
- 11:42your
- 11:43position.
- 11:44You
- 11:44didn't
- 11:45account
- 11:45for
- 11:45these
- 11:45three
- 11:46things
- 11:46I'm
- 11:46thinking
- 11:46about,
- 11:47and
- 11:47because
- 11:47you
- 11:48didn't
- 11:48ask,
- 11:48they
- 11:48didn't
- 11:49come
- 11:49up.
- 11:49I
- 11:50don't
- 11:50need
- 11:50you
- 11:50to
- 11:50account
- 11:51for
- 11:51them
- 11:51right
- 11:51now,
- 11:52but
- 11:52what
- 11:53you
- 11:53expressed
- 11:54is
- 11:54logically
- 11:55coherent.
- 11:56I
- 11:56get
- 11:56why
- 11:57you
- 11:57hold
- 11:57that
- 11:57view.
- 11:58And
- 11:58my
- 11:58thought
- 11:58is,
- 11:59eventually
- 11:59your
- 11:59side's
- 12:00going
- 12:00to
- 12:00win,
- 12:01but
- 12:01right
- 12:01now,
- 12:02these
- 12:02are
- 12:02the
- 12:02three
- 12:02reasons,
- 12:03and
- 12:04do
- 12:04you
- 12:04want
- 12:04to
- 12:04account
- 12:05for
- 12:05them?
- 12:06Which
- 12:06he
- 12:06couldn't
- 12:06because
- 12:07he
- 12:07didn't
- 12:07even
- 12:07know
- 12:07those
- 12:07reasons
- 12:08existed.
- 12:09And
- 12:09naturally,
- 12:10this
- 12:10ballot
- 12:10measure
- 12:11has
- 12:11now
- 12:11passed
- 12:12about
- 12:12a
- 12:12decade
- 12:12later,
- 12:13so
- 12:13he
- 12:13was
- 12:13even
- 12:14in
- 12:14the
- 12:14trajectory
- 12:15of
- 12:15where
- 12:15it
- 12:15was
- 12:15going.
- 12:16But
- 12:16it
- 12:16was
- 12:17a
- 12:17moment
- 12:17for
- 12:17me
- 12:17to
- 12:17be
- 12:18able
- 12:18to
- 12:18say,
- 12:18you're
- 12:19okay
- 12:19in
- 12:19my
- 12:20family
- 12:20having
- 12:21this
- 12:21completely
- 12:22different
- 12:22position
- 12:22than
- 12:23me,
- 12:23and
- 12:24I
- 12:24can
- 12:24even
- 12:24honor
- 12:25and
- 12:25value
- 12:25why
- 12:26that
- 12:26position
- 12:26is
- 12:26meaningful
- 12:27to
- 12:27you
- 12:27and
- 12:27still
- 12:28not
- 12:28hold
- 12:28it
- 12:28myself.
- 12:29Agreement
- 12:30is
- 12:31not
- 12:31the
- 12:31goal.
- 12:32It
- 12:32is
- 12:32the
- 12:33capacity
- 12:33to
- 12:34actually
- 12:34hold
- 12:35a
- 12:35position
- 12:36and
- 12:36not
- 12:36be
- 12:36shamed,
- 12:37kicked
- 12:38out.
- 12:38I've
- 12:38seen
- 12:39families
- 12:39actually
- 12:40excommunicate
- 12:41children
- 12:41over
- 12:42having
- 12:42positions
- 12:43they
- 12:43don't
- 12:43agree
- 12:43with.
- 12:44And
- 12:44that's
- 12:45the
- 12:45danger
- 12:45in
- 12:45the
- 12:46teen
- 12:46years,
- 12:46is
- 12:47that
- 12:47you
- 12:47actually
- 12:48push
- 12:48this
- 12:49parental
- 12:49propaganda
- 12:50program
- 12:50too
- 12:51far
- 12:51and
- 12:52you
- 12:52alienate
- 12:52your
- 12:53child
- 12:53instead
- 12:53of
- 12:54creating
- 12:54a
- 12:54community
- 12:54of
- 12:55thinkers.
- 12:56It's
- 12:56interesting
- 12:57because
- 12:57building
- 12:58on
- 12:58that
- 12:58point,
- 12:58and
- 12:59you're
- 12:59talking
- 12:59about
- 13:00an
- 13:00example
- 13:00that
- 13:01involves
- 13:01society
- 13:01in
- 13:02that
- 13:02ballot
- 13:02example
- 13:03that
- 13:03you
- 13:03shared.
- 13:03But
- 13:04you're
- 13:04seeing
- 13:05what
- 13:05you're
- 13:05talking
- 13:06about
- 13:06play
- 13:06out
- 13:07in
- 13:07real
- 13:07time
- 13:07all
- 13:08over
- 13:08the
- 13:08place
- 13:08these
- 13:09days.
- 13:09Yes.
- 13:10And
- 13:10it
- 13:10becomes
- 13:11such
- 13:12a
- 13:12lot
- 13:12of
- 13:13noise
- 13:13and
- 13:14louder
- 13:15noise
- 13:15as
- 13:15the
- 13:15days
- 13:16roll
- 13:16along.
- 13:17So
- 13:18if
- 13:18parents
- 13:19and
- 13:19adults
- 13:20are
- 13:20struggling
- 13:21to
- 13:21parse
- 13:21through
- 13:22this
- 13:22and
- 13:22make
- 13:23sense
- 13:23of
- 13:23it
- 13:23and
- 13:24fact
- 13:24check
- 13:24and
- 13:24research
- 13:25and,
- 13:25you
- 13:25know,
- 13:25all
- 13:26the
- 13:26things
- 13:26that
- 13:26you
- 13:26need
- 13:26to
- 13:27do
- 13:27to
- 13:27make
- 13:27sure
- 13:27that
- 13:27it's
- 13:28the
- 13:28truth.
- 13:28Right.
- 13:29How
- 13:29can
- 13:30we
- 13:30then
- 13:30plausibly
- 13:31expect
- 13:32them
- 13:32to
- 13:33decode
- 13:33that
- 13:33for
- 13:33their
- 13:34kids?
- 13:34And
- 13:35here's
- 13:35the
- 13:35thing.
- 13:36They're
- 13:36going
- 13:36to
- 13:37wade
- 13:37into
- 13:37some
- 13:38waters
- 13:38that
- 13:38are
- 13:39propaganda
- 13:40conspiracy
- 13:40theories.
- 13:41That
- 13:41same
- 13:41son
- 13:42at
- 13:42one
- 13:42point
- 13:42got
- 13:42very
- 13:43interested
- 13:43in
- 13:44a
- 13:44YouTube
- 13:44video
- 13:45that
- 13:45I
- 13:45knew
- 13:45was
- 13:46flat
- 13:46out
- 13:47conspiracy
- 13:47theory
- 13:48lunacy.
- 13:49But
- 13:50what
- 13:50I
- 13:50found
- 13:50fascinating
- 13:51was
- 13:52it
- 13:52was
- 13:52the
- 13:53first
- 13:53time
- 13:53he
- 13:54had
- 13:54an
- 13:54alternative
- 13:55way
- 13:55of
- 13:55thinking
- 13:56about
- 13:56how
- 13:57the
- 13:57world
- 13:57worked.
- 13:58And
- 13:58we
- 13:59want
- 13:59that.
- 13:59We
- 13:59want
- 14:00kids
- 14:00to
- 14:01be
- 14:01able
- 14:01to
- 14:02challenge
- 14:02the
- 14:03status
- 14:03quo
- 14:04thinking
- 14:04that
- 14:04has
- 14:04been
- 14:05handed
- 14:05down
- 14:05to
- 14:05them.
- 14:06That
- 14:06is
- 14:06part
- 14:06of
- 14:06becoming
- 14:07an
- 14:07educated
- 14:08person.
- 14:08So
- 14:09rather
- 14:09than
- 14:09just
- 14:09bashing
- 14:10the
- 14:10content,
- 14:11I
- 14:11sat
- 14:11with
- 14:12him
- 14:12and
- 14:12watched
- 14:12it.
- 14:13We
- 14:13talked
- 14:13about
- 14:13it.
- 14:14We
- 14:14clicked
- 14:15on
- 14:15some
- 14:15of
- 14:15the
- 14:15sources.
- 14:16We
- 14:16looked
- 14:16at
- 14:17it
- 14:17together.
- 14:18It's
- 14:18really
- 14:18why
- 14:18I
- 14:19wrote
- 14:19Becoming
- 14:19a
- 14:19Critical
- 14:20Thinker,
- 14:20because
- 14:20I
- 14:21actually
- 14:21give
- 14:21you
- 14:22tools
- 14:22that
- 14:22you
- 14:23can
- 14:23use
- 14:23to
- 14:24sort
- 14:24of
- 14:24vet
- 14:25information
- 14:26sources,
- 14:27your
- 14:27own
- 14:28sort
- 14:28of
- 14:28biased
- 14:29thinking
- 14:29that
- 14:29kicks
- 14:30into
- 14:30gear.
- 14:31And
- 14:32one
- 14:32of
- 14:32the
- 14:32first
- 14:32chapters
- 14:33in
- 14:33Raising
- 14:34Critical
- 14:34Thinkers
- 14:35and
- 14:35also
- 14:36in
- 14:36Becoming
- 14:36a
- 14:36Critical
- 14:37Thinker
- 14:37is
- 14:37called
- 14:38says
- 14:38who?
- 14:39And
- 14:39I
- 14:39use
- 14:39the
- 14:40illustration
- 14:40of
- 14:41the
- 14:41Three
- 14:42Little
- 14:42Pigs
- 14:42story.
- 14:43Most
- 14:43of
- 14:43you
- 14:43remember
- 14:44it.
- 14:44There's
- 14:44a
- 14:44big,
- 14:44bad
- 14:45wolf.
- 14:45He
- 14:45blows
- 14:45down
- 14:45the
- 14:46houses,
- 14:46he
- 14:46eats
- 14:46the
- 14:46pigs.
- 14:47Everybody
- 14:48hates
- 14:48him,
- 14:48right?
- 14:48You
- 14:49think
- 14:49of
- 14:49him
- 14:49as
- 14:50big
- 14:50and
- 14:50bad.
- 14:51Well,
- 14:51John
- 14:51Sheska,
- 14:52back
- 14:52in
- 14:521985,
- 14:53wrote
- 14:53a
- 14:54book
- 14:54called
- 14:54The
- 14:55True
- 14:55Story
- 14:56of
- 14:56the
- 14:56Three
- 14:56Little
- 14:56Pigs,
- 14:57written
- 14:57by
- 14:58a
- 14:58wolf.
- 14:59And
- 14:59this
- 15:00wolf
- 15:00does
- 15:01his
- 15:01own
- 15:01defense
- 15:02of
- 15:03why
- 15:03what
- 15:03he
- 15:03did
- 15:04was
- 15:04not
- 15:04only
- 15:04wrong,
- 15:04but
- 15:05has
- 15:05been
- 15:05grossly
- 15:06misunderstood.
- 15:07Now,
- 15:07for
- 15:08parents
- 15:08everywhere,
- 15:08we
- 15:09all
- 15:09laughed
- 15:09at
- 15:09this
- 15:10book
- 15:10because
- 15:10it
- 15:10was
- 15:10an
- 15:11obvious
- 15:11parody,
- 15:12but
- 15:13on
- 15:13the
- 15:13flip
- 15:13side,
- 15:13for
- 15:14small
- 15:14children,
- 15:15and
- 15:15I've
- 15:15interviewed
- 15:16many
- 15:16millennials
- 15:16who
- 15:17remember
- 15:17that
- 15:17book,
- 15:18they
- 15:18couldn't
- 15:19differentiate
- 15:20between
- 15:21the
- 15:21sort
- 15:22of
- 15:22standard
- 15:23version
- 15:24that
- 15:24we
- 15:24all
- 15:24know,
- 15:24which
- 15:25we
- 15:25don't
- 15:25know
- 15:25if
- 15:25it's
- 15:26true,
- 15:26it's
- 15:26a
- 15:26fairy
- 15:26tale,
- 15:26it's
- 15:27fiction,
- 15:27but
- 15:28it's
- 15:28told
- 15:28from
- 15:28a
- 15:29deliberate
- 15:29viewpoint
- 15:30that
- 15:30makes
- 15:30the
- 15:30wolf
- 15:31bad.
- 15:32It
- 15:32was
- 15:32their
- 15:33first
- 15:33exposure
- 15:34to
- 15:34the
- 15:34idea
- 15:35that
- 15:35a
- 15:35story
- 15:35can
- 15:36have
- 15:36multiple
- 15:36versions.
- 15:37And
- 15:38that's
- 15:38really
- 15:39our
- 15:39goal
- 15:39with
- 15:39teens.
- 15:40It's
- 15:40not
- 15:41to
- 15:41camp
- 15:41on
- 15:41any
- 15:42one
- 15:42position.
- 15:43It's
- 15:43to
- 15:44imagine
- 15:44what
- 15:45I
- 15:45call
- 15:45the
- 15:45rhetorical
- 15:46imagination.
- 15:47Imagine
- 15:47yourself
- 15:48into
- 15:48someone
- 15:49else's
- 15:49viewpoint.
- 15:50How
- 15:50does
- 15:51it
- 15:51logically
- 15:51cohere?
- 15:52What
- 15:53are
- 15:53the
- 15:53sources
- 15:53of
- 15:54data,
- 15:54experience
- 15:55and
- 15:55anecdote
- 15:55that
- 15:55they
- 15:56use
- 15:56for
- 15:57this
- 15:57to
- 15:57feel
- 15:58logical
- 15:58to
- 15:59them?
- 15:59And
- 16:00for
- 16:00our
- 16:00teens
- 16:01in
- 16:01particular,
- 16:02they
- 16:02are,
- 16:03a
- 16:03lot
- 16:04of
- 16:04them,
- 16:04more
- 16:04savvy
- 16:05than
- 16:05even
- 16:05my
- 16:06boomer
- 16:06generation
- 16:07is
- 16:07because
- 16:08they
- 16:08are
- 16:08aware
- 16:09that
- 16:10information
- 16:11can
- 16:11be
- 16:11modified,
- 16:12edited
- 16:12and
- 16:12tweaked.
- 16:13When
- 16:13I
- 16:14was
- 16:14growing
- 16:14up,
- 16:15I
- 16:15didn't
- 16:15know
- 16:15that
- 16:15was
- 16:15happening.
- 16:16It
- 16:16just
- 16:17seemed
- 16:17like
- 16:17the
- 16:17nightly
- 16:17news
- 16:18was
- 16:18presenting
- 16:18the
- 16:19facts.
- 16:19So
- 16:20we're
- 16:20in
- 16:20a
- 16:20really
- 16:21volatile
- 16:22era,
- 16:22but
- 16:22it's
- 16:22also
- 16:23one
- 16:23where
- 16:23kids
- 16:23are
- 16:24awake.
- 16:25They
- 16:25know
- 16:25what's
- 16:25going
- 16:25on,
- 16:26they're
- 16:26curious
- 16:27about
- 16:27it,
- 16:27they
- 16:27want
- 16:27to
- 16:28know.
- 16:29It's
- 16:29such
- 16:29an
- 16:30important
- 16:30point
- 16:30that
- 16:30you're
- 16:31bringing
- 16:31up,
- 16:31because
- 16:31the
- 16:31fact
- 16:32is,
- 16:32we
- 16:32wouldn't
- 16:32really
- 16:33be
- 16:33having
- 16:33this
- 16:33conversation
- 16:34if
- 16:34we
- 16:35weren't
- 16:35living
- 16:35in
- 16:35the
- 16:35times
- 16:36we're
- 16:36living
- 16:36in,
- 16:36with
- 16:37exposure
- 16:37to
- 16:37knowledge
- 16:38everywhere,
- 16:39you
- 16:39know,
- 16:40in
- 16:40the
- 16:40palm
- 16:40of
- 16:40our
- 16:41hands
- 16:41in
- 16:41the
- 16:42form
- 16:42of
- 16:42smartphones,
- 16:43et
- 16:43cetera.
- 16:44So
- 16:44what
- 16:44would
- 16:44you
- 16:44say
- 16:44to
- 16:45a
- 16:45parent
- 16:45who
- 16:45perhaps
- 16:46has
- 16:46been
- 16:47a
- 16:47little
- 16:47late
- 16:47to
- 16:47the
- 16:47game
- 16:48and
- 16:48is
- 16:48really
- 16:48struggling
- 16:49with
- 16:49technology
- 16:49and
- 16:50really
- 16:50doesn't
- 16:50think
- 16:50this
- 16:50is
- 16:51important?
- 16:51My
- 16:52kids
- 16:52will
- 16:52figure
- 16:52it
- 16:52out.
- 16:53They
- 16:53go
- 16:53to
- 16:53a
- 16:53good
- 16:54school.
- 16:54The
- 16:54teachers
- 16:55will
- 16:55sort
- 16:55it
- 16:55out.
- 16:56What
- 16:56would
- 16:56you
- 16:56say
- 16:57to
- 16:57them?
- 16:58That
- 16:59this
- 16:59is
- 16:59important
- 17:00for
- 17:00them
- 17:00to
- 17:00understand
- 17:01critical
- 17:02thinking
- 17:02and
- 17:03how
- 17:03to
- 17:03impart
- 17:04that
- 17:04on
- 17:04their
- 17:05kids?
- 17:05Why?
- 17:06How
- 17:06would
- 17:06you
- 17:06answer
- 17:06that?
- 17:07Well,
- 17:07first
- 17:08of
- 17:08all,
- 17:08I
- 17:08think
- 17:08you
- 17:08have
- 17:08a
- 17:08much
- 17:09richer,
- 17:10more
- 17:10satisfying
- 17:11life
- 17:11if
- 17:11you
- 17:11can
- 17:11think
- 17:12well.
- 17:12The
- 17:13solutions
- 17:14to
- 17:14our
- 17:14problems
- 17:15require
- 17:15us
- 17:16to
- 17:16include
- 17:17more
- 17:17viewpoints.
- 17:18Our
- 17:19culture
- 17:19is
- 17:19polarized
- 17:20because
- 17:20we
- 17:21are
- 17:21built
- 17:21on
- 17:21what
- 17:22I
- 17:22would
- 17:22call
- 17:22the
- 17:22missionary
- 17:23model.
- 17:24Everybody
- 17:24is
- 17:24an
- 17:25evangelist
- 17:26to
- 17:26convert
- 17:26people
- 17:27who
- 17:27don't
- 17:27want
- 17:27what
- 17:27you're
- 17:28offering
- 17:28to
- 17:29what
- 17:29you're
- 17:29offering.
- 17:30And
- 17:30that
- 17:31model
- 17:31fails.
- 17:32It
- 17:32is
- 17:32not
- 17:33an
- 17:33effective
- 17:34tool
- 17:35for
- 17:35creating
- 17:35movements
- 17:36or
- 17:36solutions.
- 17:37Because
- 17:38what
- 17:38you're
- 17:38saying
- 17:39is,
- 17:39discard
- 17:40those
- 17:41things
- 17:41that
- 17:41were
- 17:41important
- 17:42to
- 17:42you
- 17:42in
- 17:42order
- 17:43to
- 17:43embrace
- 17:43what
- 17:44I
- 17:44say
- 17:44is
- 17:44important.
- 17:45But
- 17:46if
- 17:46we're
- 17:46going
- 17:46to
- 17:47create
- 17:47solutions
- 17:48that
- 17:49last,
- 17:49we
- 17:50have
- 17:50to
- 17:50include
- 17:50everyone's
- 17:51viewpoint.
- 17:52So
- 17:52I
- 17:52have
- 17:52two
- 17:52ideas
- 17:53for
- 17:53you.
- 17:54The
- 17:54first
- 17:54one
- 17:54is
- 17:54a
- 17:55family
- 17:55one.
- 17:55The
- 17:55second
- 17:56one
- 17:56is
- 17:56how
- 17:56to
- 17:56approach
- 17:57a
- 17:57social
- 17:57issue.
- 17:58So
- 17:59in
- 17:59the
- 17:59family,
- 17:59you've
- 17:59got,
- 18:00let's
- 18:00say,
- 18:00teens
- 18:00who
- 18:01really
- 18:01want
- 18:01to
- 18:01be
- 18:01on
- 18:01video
- 18:02games
- 18:02all
- 18:02day,
- 18:02all
- 18:03night.
- 18:03Right?
- 18:03And
- 18:03then
- 18:04you
- 18:04have
- 18:04parents
- 18:04who
- 18:04are
- 18:04like,
- 18:05I've
- 18:05read
- 18:05the
- 18:05data,
- 18:05it's
- 18:06bad
- 18:06for
- 18:06you.
- 18:06I'm
- 18:06not
- 18:07going
- 18:07to
- 18:07let
- 18:07you.
- 18:08How
- 18:08do
- 18:08we
- 18:08solve
- 18:09this
- 18:09problem?
- 18:10Do
- 18:10we
- 18:10just
- 18:10lean
- 18:11on
- 18:11science
- 18:12do
- 18:12we
- 18:12just
- 18:12lean
- 18:13on
- 18:13parental
- 18:13authority
- 18:14or
- 18:14do
- 18:14we
- 18:15just
- 18:15give
- 18:15up
- 18:15and
- 18:15let
- 18:16our
- 18:16kids
- 18:17do
- 18:17whatever
- 18:17they
- 18:17want?
- 18:18I
- 18:19say
- 18:19let's
- 18:19get
- 18:20all
- 18:20the
- 18:20reasons
- 18:21on
- 18:21the
- 18:21table.
- 18:22So
- 18:23when
- 18:23I
- 18:23first
- 18:23asked
- 18:24my
- 18:24teenager,
- 18:24as
- 18:25another
- 18:25son,
- 18:26he
- 18:26wanted
- 18:26to
- 18:27play
- 18:27video
- 18:27games
- 18:27till
- 18:28like
- 18:28three
- 18:28in
- 18:28the
- 18:28morning.
- 18:29I
- 18:29thought
- 18:29that
- 18:29wasn't
- 18:30good
- 18:30on
- 18:30school
- 18:30nights.
- 18:31I
- 18:31had
- 18:31a
- 18:31very
- 18:31traditional
- 18:32view
- 18:32of
- 18:33school.
- 18:33And
- 18:33I
- 18:34asked
- 18:34him
- 18:35why?
- 18:35Why
- 18:36can't
- 18:36you
- 18:36just
- 18:37be
- 18:37done
- 18:37at
- 18:3711?
- 18:38Can't
- 18:38you
- 18:38just
- 18:39play
- 18:39from
- 18:39in
- 18:39the
- 18:39afternoons
- 18:40and
- 18:40evenings?
- 18:40Why
- 18:41until
- 18:41three
- 18:41in
- 18:42the
- 18:42morning?
- 18:42I
- 18:42found
- 18:43out
- 18:43his
- 18:43favorite
- 18:43gaming
- 18:44buddy
- 18:45lived
- 18:45in
- 18:45Croatia
- 18:46and
- 18:46this
- 18:46was
- 18:47a
- 18:47time
- 18:47they
- 18:47could
- 18:47both
- 18:48be
- 18:48on
- 18:48at
- 18:48the
- 18:48same
- 18:49time.
- 18:49That
- 18:50was
- 18:50insanely
- 18:51reasonable.
- 18:52Then
- 18:52I
- 18:52thought,
- 18:53well,
- 18:53who
- 18:53is
- 18:53this
- 18:54Croatian
- 18:54guy?
- 18:54Is
- 18:54he
- 18:55real?
- 18:56Yes.
- 18:57So
- 18:57we
- 18:57went
- 18:57down
- 18:58the
- 18:58rabbit
- 18:58hole
- 18:58to
- 18:58establish
- 18:59that
- 18:59he
- 18:59was
- 19:00real.
- 19:00This
- 19:00was
- 19:01the
- 19:01time
- 19:01they
- 19:01liked
- 19:01playing.
- 19:02Could
- 19:02I
- 19:03trust
- 19:03my
- 19:03son
- 19:03to
- 19:04evaluate
- 19:04whether
- 19:05or
- 19:05not
- 19:05his
- 19:05body
- 19:05was
- 19:06getting
- 19:06enough
- 19:06sleep
- 19:07at
- 19:07the
- 19:07time
- 19:07he
- 19:08was
- 19:08homeschooled.
- 19:08So
- 19:08he's
- 19:09like,
- 19:09mom,
- 19:09I
- 19:09can
- 19:09just
- 19:10sleep
- 19:10in
- 19:10and
- 19:10start
- 19:11homeschool
- 19:11later.
- 19:12Oh
- 19:12my
- 19:13gosh,
- 19:13that
- 19:13seems
- 19:14so
- 19:14reasonable.
- 19:14But
- 19:14for
- 19:15some
- 19:15reason
- 19:16I
- 19:16wasn't
- 19:16willing
- 19:17to
- 19:17find
- 19:17that
- 19:17out.
- 19:18Initially,
- 19:19I
- 19:19wanted
- 19:19to
- 19:20just
- 19:20put
- 19:20my
- 19:21superior
- 19:21information
- 19:22on
- 19:22him.
- 19:23So
- 19:23what
- 19:23we
- 19:23ended
- 19:24up
- 19:24doing
- 19:24is
- 19:25starting
- 19:25school
- 19:25later.
- 19:26He
- 19:26made
- 19:27sure
- 19:27that
- 19:27he
- 19:27did
- 19:28the
- 19:28schoolwork
- 19:28he
- 19:28was
- 19:28supposed
- 19:29to
- 19:29do.
- 19:29His
- 19:30gaming
- 19:30time
- 19:30was
- 19:31later
- 19:31in
- 19:31the
- 19:31day
- 19:31and
- 19:31at
- 19:32night
- 19:32so
- 19:32he
- 19:32could
- 19:32be
- 19:33with
- 19:33his
- 19:33friends.
- 19:34And
- 19:34it
- 19:34was
- 19:34a
- 19:34solution
- 19:35that
- 19:35met
- 19:35all
- 19:36of
- 19:36our
- 19:36needs.
- 19:37I
- 19:37think
- 19:37so
- 19:38often
- 19:38we're
- 19:38in
- 19:38these
- 19:39zero
- 19:39sum,
- 19:40high
- 19:40stakes
- 19:41dynamics
- 19:42where
- 19:42it's
- 19:42my
- 19:43way
- 19:43or
- 19:43the
- 19:43highway
- 19:43or
- 19:43your
- 19:44way
- 19:44and
- 19:44I'll
- 19:44get
- 19:44out
- 19:44of
- 19:45the
- 19:45way.
- 19:45But
- 19:45that's
- 19:46not
- 19:46really
- 19:46the
- 19:46best
- 19:47solution.
- 19:48We
- 19:49struggled
- 19:49with
- 19:49video
- 19:49gaming
- 19:50and
- 19:50screen
- 19:50time
- 19:50the
- 19:51whole
- 19:51time.
- 19:51I
- 19:51had
- 19:51five
- 19:51kids,
- 19:52one
- 19:52computer.
- 19:53I
- 19:53think
- 19:53we
- 19:53went
- 19:53through
- 19:5415
- 19:55different
- 19:55iterations
- 19:56of
- 19:56solutions.
- 19:57You
- 19:57have
- 19:57to
- 19:58be
- 19:58willing
- 19:58to
- 19:59recognize
- 19:59that
- 19:59you're
- 19:59not
- 20:00just
- 20:00going
- 20:00to
- 20:00problem
- 20:01solve
- 20:01one
- 20:01time.
- 20:02So
- 20:03that's
- 20:03kind
- 20:03of
- 20:03a
- 20:03family
- 20:04solution.
- 20:04But
- 20:05if
- 20:05we
- 20:05think
- 20:05about
- 20:05it
- 20:06like
- 20:06in
- 20:06the
- 20:06political
- 20:07landscape
- 20:08in
- 20:08school,
- 20:09you'll
- 20:09have
- 20:09like
- 20:09a
- 20:0910th
- 20:10grade
- 20:10teacher,
- 20:10social
- 20:11studies,
- 20:11and
- 20:11they'll
- 20:11say,
- 20:11let's
- 20:12debate
- 20:12gun
- 20:13rights.
- 20:13And
- 20:14then
- 20:14what
- 20:14they'll
- 20:14do
- 20:14is
- 20:15they'll
- 20:15divide
- 20:15the
- 20:15class
- 20:15in
- 20:16half
- 20:16and
- 20:16they'll
- 20:16say,
- 20:16you
- 20:17should
- 20:17be
- 20:17pro
- 20:18gun
- 20:18rights,
- 20:18you
- 20:18should
- 20:19be
- 20:19gun
- 20:20restriction.
- 20:21Come
- 20:21up
- 20:21with
- 20:21your
- 20:22cases,
- 20:22we'll
- 20:22have
- 20:22a
- 20:23debate
- 20:23and
- 20:23then
- 20:23everyone
- 20:24will
- 20:24hear
- 20:24both
- 20:24sides.
- 20:25But
- 20:26are
- 20:26there
- 20:26only
- 20:26two
- 20:27sides
- 20:27to
- 20:27these
- 20:28stories?
- 20:29My
- 20:29thought
- 20:30is,
- 20:30in
- 20:30a
- 20:30class
- 20:30of
- 20:3130,
- 20:31you
- 20:32would
- 20:32say,
- 20:32how
- 20:32many
- 20:33of
- 20:33you
- 20:33have
- 20:34parents
- 20:34in
- 20:34the
- 20:34military?
- 20:35We
- 20:35Find
- 20:36out
- 20:36how
- 20:36many
- 20:36of
- 20:37you
- 20:37have
- 20:37parents
- 20:37in
- 20:38law
- 20:38enforcement.
- 20:38We
- 20:39find
- 20:39out
- 20:39how
- 20:39many
- 20:40of
- 20:40you
- 20:40have
- 20:40family
- 20:40members
- 20:41who've
- 20:41been
- 20:41victims
- 20:41of
- 20:42gun
- 20:42violence.
- 20:42We
- 20:43find
- 20:43out
- 20:43how
- 20:44many
- 20:44of
- 20:44you
- 20:44live
- 20:45in
- 20:45parts
- 20:46of
- 20:46the
- 20:46city
- 20:46where
- 20:47gun
- 20:47violence
- 20:47is
- 20:48common.
- 20:48How
- 20:48many
- 20:48of
- 20:48you
- 20:49don't,
- 20:49how
- 20:50many
- 20:50of
- 20:50you
- 20:50never
- 20:51held
- 20:51a
- 20:51gun,
- 20:51never
- 20:51seen
- 20:52a
- 20:52gun,
- 20:52don't
- 20:52know
- 20:52a
- 20:52gun?
- 20:53Right.
- 20:54Stir
- 20:54up
- 20:55all
- 20:55of
- 20:55the
- 20:55attachments
- 20:56around
- 20:56guns,
- 20:57hear
- 20:58all
- 20:58of
- 20:58those
- 20:58stories
- 20:59before
- 20:59we
- 20:59even
- 20:59start
- 21:00talking
- 21:00about
- 21:00issues.
- 21:01And
- 21:01then
- 21:01when
- 21:02we
- 21:02get
- 21:02to
- 21:02what
- 21:03the
- 21:03key
- 21:03criteria
- 21:04is
- 21:04for
- 21:05thinking
- 21:05about
- 21:05gun
- 21:06rights,
- 21:06like
- 21:06background
- 21:07checks,
- 21:07types
- 21:07of
- 21:08guns,
- 21:08ballistics,
- 21:10public
- 21:10spaces,
- 21:11when
- 21:11we
- 21:12start
- 21:12doing
- 21:12those,
- 21:13figure
- 21:14out
- 21:14how
- 21:14many
- 21:14of
- 21:15these
- 21:15viewpoints,
- 21:16the
- 21:16hunter,
- 21:16the
- 21:16law
- 21:16enforcement
- 21:17and
- 21:17the
- 21:17victim,
- 21:18how
- 21:18many
- 21:18of
- 21:18those
- 21:19can
- 21:19we
- 21:19account
- 21:19for
- 21:20in
- 21:20the
- 21:20solution
- 21:21we're
- 21:21offering?
- 21:22That's
- 21:23what
- 21:23creates.
- 21:23It's
- 21:24not
- 21:24just
- 21:24bipartisan,
- 21:25it's
- 21:26multi
- 21:27perspectival
- 21:28solutions.
- 21:29And
- 21:30this
- 21:30is
- 21:30what
- 21:30has
- 21:31staying
- 21:31power
- 21:31when
- 21:31we
- 21:32think
- 21:32that
- 21:32way.
- 21:33But
- 21:33I
- 21:33always
- 21:34say
- 21:34the
- 21:34revolution
- 21:34has
- 21:35to
- 21:35start
- 21:35in
- 21:35the
- 21:35living
- 21:35room
- 21:36because
- 21:36schools
- 21:36are
- 21:37still
- 21:38on
- 21:38this
- 21:38idea
- 21:39of
- 21:39right
- 21:39answers.
- 21:40There's
- 21:40one
- 21:40answer.
- 21:41All
- 21:4130
- 21:41students
- 21:42will
- 21:42arrive
- 21:42at
- 21:42it
- 21:43because
- 21:43the
- 21:43teacher
- 21:44has
- 21:44decided
- 21:44it
- 21:44and
- 21:45that
- 21:45has
- 21:45created
- 21:45this
- 21:46crisis.
- 21:46I
- 21:46think
- 21:47we're
- 21:47in
- 21:47amplified
- 21:48of
- 21:48course,
- 21:48by
- 21:49the
- 21:49Internet
- 21:49and
- 21:49social
- 21:50media
- 21:51when.
- 21:51We
- 21:52talk
- 21:52about
- 21:52schools
- 21:53because
- 21:53it's
- 21:53such
- 21:53an
- 21:53important
- 21:54point.
- 21:54Our
- 21:54kids
- 21:54spend,
- 21:55you
- 21:55know,
- 21:55seven,
- 21:55eight,
- 21:56nine
- 21:56hours
- 21:56there
- 21:57daily.
- 21:59What
- 21:59do
- 21:59you
- 21:59believe
- 22:00needs
- 22:01to
- 22:01happen
- 22:01when
- 22:02it
- 22:02comes
- 22:02to
- 22:03teaching
- 22:04critical
- 22:04thinking
- 22:05in
- 22:05schools?
- 22:05And
- 22:05I
- 22:06asked
- 22:06this
- 22:06question
- 22:06because
- 22:07in
- 22:08many
- 22:08schools
- 22:09it
- 22:09is
- 22:09used
- 22:10as
- 22:10a
- 22:11marketing
- 22:11tool,
- 22:11as
- 22:12a
- 22:12sales
- 22:12tool
- 22:12to
- 22:13entice
- 22:13right
- 22:14and
- 22:14to
- 22:14entice
- 22:15parents
- 22:15to
- 22:15send
- 22:15their
- 22:16kids
- 22:16there.
- 22:17But
- 22:18at
- 22:18a
- 22:18granular
- 22:19level.
- 22:19What
- 22:19is
- 22:20going
- 22:20on
- 22:20in
- 22:20the
- 22:20classroom
- 22:21to
- 22:21impart
- 22:22critical
- 22:23thinking
- 22:23skills
- 22:24to
- 22:24these
- 22:24kids?
- 22:24What
- 22:25should
- 22:25that
- 22:25look
- 22:25like?
- 22:26Yeah,
- 22:27so
- 22:27I
- 22:27was
- 22:27interviewed
- 22:28not
- 22:28too
- 22:28long
- 22:28ago
- 22:29by
- 22:29someone
- 22:29who
- 22:30that's
- 22:30their
- 22:31mission,
- 22:31to
- 22:31bring
- 22:31critical
- 22:32thinking
- 22:32into
- 22:32schools.
- 22:33But
- 22:33what
- 22:34I
- 22:34discovered
- 22:34the
- 22:34longer
- 22:35we
- 22:35talked,
- 22:36the
- 22:37idea
- 22:37was
- 22:38to
- 22:38simply
- 22:38keep
- 22:39subverting
- 22:40the
- 22:40status
- 22:40quo
- 22:41answers
- 22:41like
- 22:41to
- 22:42get
- 22:42people
- 22:42to
- 22:42think
- 22:42beyond,
- 22:43which
- 22:43is
- 22:43a
- 22:44good
- 22:44starting
- 22:44place.
- 22:45But
- 22:46actually
- 22:46the
- 22:47problem,
- 22:47I
- 22:47think
- 22:47with
- 22:48most
- 22:48school
- 22:48training
- 22:49is
- 22:49that
- 22:50kids
- 22:51have
- 22:51been
- 22:52inculcated
- 22:52in
- 22:53this
- 22:53system
- 22:53that
- 22:54the
- 22:54teacher
- 22:55knows
- 22:55the
- 22:55right
- 22:55answers
- 22:56and
- 22:56their
- 22:56grades
- 22:57are
- 22:57dependent
- 22:57on
- 22:58those
- 22:58right
- 22:58answers.
- 22:59Multiple
- 23:00choice
- 23:00testing
- 23:00has
- 23:01been
- 23:01proven
- 23:01to
- 23:02be
- 23:02very
- 23:03difficult
- 23:03for
- 23:04kids
- 23:04who
- 23:04come
- 23:04with
- 23:04different
- 23:05sets
- 23:05of
- 23:05experiences
- 23:06and
- 23:06backgrounds
- 23:07because
- 23:07of
- 23:07language,
- 23:08because
- 23:08of
- 23:09the
- 23:09way
- 23:09the
- 23:09teacher
- 23:09architects
- 23:10the
- 23:10test.
- 23:11So
- 23:11I
- 23:12saw
- 23:12a
- 23:12study
- 23:13about
- 23:13Finland
- 23:14just
- 23:14the
- 23:14other
- 23:14day
- 23:15and
- 23:15they
- 23:15almost
- 23:16use
- 23:16no
- 23:17standardized
- 23:18testing,
- 23:19no
- 23:20multiple
- 23:20choice
- 23:20testing.
- 23:21Everything
- 23:21is
- 23:22either
- 23:22short
- 23:22answer
- 23:23or
- 23:23Oral.
- 23:24And
- 23:24the
- 23:25goal
- 23:25is
- 23:25for
- 23:26students
- 23:26to
- 23:27actually
- 23:27think
- 23:28through
- 23:28for
- 23:29themselves
- 23:29the
- 23:30answer,
- 23:30not
- 23:31guess
- 23:31based
- 23:32on
- 23:32four
- 23:32answers
- 23:33and
- 23:33then
- 23:33picking
- 23:34the
- 23:34one
- 23:34they
- 23:34think
- 23:34might
- 23:35be
- 23:35right,
- 23:35but
- 23:36actually
- 23:36being
- 23:36able
- 23:37to
- 23:37generate
- 23:38their
- 23:38own
- 23:38vocabulary
- 23:39to
- 23:39describe
- 23:40what
- 23:41they
- 23:41know.
- 23:42So
- 23:42in
- 23:42schools,
- 23:43the
- 23:43first
- 23:43place
- 23:44to
- 23:44start,
- 23:44in
- 23:44my
- 23:45opinion,
- 23:45is
- 23:46with
- 23:46helping
- 23:46them
- 23:46understand
- 23:47the
- 23:48idea
- 23:48of
- 23:48viewpoint.
- 23:49Where
- 23:50does
- 23:50viewpoint
- 23:50come
- 23:51from?
- 23:51How
- 23:52many
- 23:52different
- 23:52ones
- 23:52do
- 23:53we
- 23:53have
- 23:53in
- 23:53this
- 23:53room?
- 23:54How
- 23:54many
- 23:54different
- 23:54ways
- 23:55would
- 23:55there
- 23:55be
- 23:55to
- 23:56answer
- 23:56this
- 23:56one
- 23:56question?
- 23:57What
- 23:58criteria
- 23:58would
- 23:59one
- 23:59person
- 23:59use
- 23:59that
- 23:59would
- 24:00be
- 24:00different
- 24:00than
- 24:00someone
- 24:01else's
- 24:01to
- 24:01come
- 24:01up
- 24:02with
- 24:02a
- 24:02meaningful
- 24:02answer?
- 24:03And
- 24:03I
- 24:03give
- 24:04an
- 24:04example.
- 24:04In
- 24:04my
- 24:05book,
- 24:05there
- 24:06was
- 24:06a,
- 24:06a
- 24:06multiple
- 24:07choice
- 24:07test
- 24:08that
- 24:08says,
- 24:09what
- 24:10unit
- 24:10of
- 24:10length
- 24:10would
- 24:11you
- 24:11use
- 24:11to
- 24:11measure
- 24:12this?
- 24:13And
- 24:13there's
- 24:13an
- 24:13illustration
- 24:14of
- 24:14a
- 24:14tree.
- 24:16The
- 24:16answer
- 24:17choices
- 24:17were
- 24:17feet,
- 24:18centimeters,
- 24:19kilometers
- 24:20and
- 24:20quarts.
- 24:21And
- 24:21the
- 24:21right
- 24:21answer
- 24:22was
- 24:22supposedly
- 24:23feet,
- 24:23because
- 24:24the
- 24:24teacher
- 24:25had
- 24:25in
- 24:25mind
- 24:26that
- 24:26the
- 24:26student
- 24:26would
- 24:27imagine
- 24:27a
- 24:27tree
- 24:27in
- 24:28a
- 24:28forest
- 24:28that
- 24:29was
- 24:29tall.
- 24:30But
- 24:30one
- 24:30of
- 24:30her
- 24:31students,
- 24:31a
- 24:31friend
- 24:32of
- 24:32mine,
- 24:32it
- 24:32was
- 24:32her
- 24:33son,
- 24:33he
- 24:33selected
- 24:34centimeters
- 24:35because
- 24:35he
- 24:35was
- 24:35measuring
- 24:36the
- 24:36illustration
- 24:37on
- 24:38the
- 24:38page.
- 24:39And
- 24:39it
- 24:39all
- 24:39it
- 24:40said
- 24:40was
- 24:40this.
- 24:41And
- 24:41there's
- 24:41the
- 24:41illustration.
- 24:42So
- 24:43now
- 24:43what
- 24:43are
- 24:43we
- 24:43asking
- 24:44students
- 24:44to
- 24:44do?
- 24:45To
- 24:45guess
- 24:46their
- 24:46way
- 24:46into
- 24:46the
- 24:47imagination
- 24:47of
- 24:48the
- 24:48adult
- 24:49or
- 24:49to
- 24:49be
- 24:49able
- 24:49to
- 24:50defend
- 24:51the
- 24:51answer
- 24:51that
- 24:52made
- 24:52sense
- 24:53and
- 24:53is
- 24:53logical
- 24:54and
- 24:54by
- 24:54the
- 24:55way,
- 24:55is
- 24:55even
- 24:55accurate.
- 24:56It
- 24:56is
- 24:56a
- 24:56unit
- 24:57of
- 24:57length.
- 24:57Centimeters
- 24:58could
- 24:58be
- 24:58used
- 24:58even
- 24:59for
- 24:59a
- 24:59tall
- 24:59tree.
- 25:00They're
- 25:00both
- 25:00units
- 25:01of
- 25:01length.
- 25:02Those
- 25:02are
- 25:02the
- 25:03kinds
- 25:03of
- 25:03things
- 25:03that
- 25:04we
- 25:04want
- 25:04to
- 25:04help
- 25:04our
- 25:05kids
- 25:05start
- 25:05to
- 25:06notice
- 25:07that
- 25:07when
- 25:07we
- 25:07come
- 25:08to
- 25:08any
- 25:08subject
- 25:09area,
- 25:09it's
- 25:09multifaceted.
- 25:11It
- 25:11is
- 25:11not
- 25:11just
- 25:12a
- 25:12list
- 25:12of
- 25:12correct
- 25:13answers.
- 25:14So
- 25:15along
- 25:15those
- 25:15lines,
- 25:16then,
- 25:16what
- 25:16trends,
- 25:17if
- 25:17any,
- 25:17are
- 25:18you
- 25:18observing
- 25:19that
- 25:19give
- 25:19you
- 25:20pause
- 25:20that
- 25:20concern
- 25:21you
- 25:21when
- 25:21it
- 25:21comes
- 25:22to
- 25:22critical
- 25:23thinking
- 25:23and
- 25:23how
- 25:24that's
- 25:24being
- 25:25taught
- 25:25in
- 25:26the
- 25:26world,
- 25:26whether
- 25:26it's
- 25:26at
- 25:27home,
- 25:27in
- 25:27the
- 25:27school
- 25:28or
- 25:28elsewhere?
- 25:29So
- 25:29some
- 25:29critical
- 25:30thinking
- 25:30courses
- 25:31are
- 25:31actually
- 25:32designed
- 25:32to
- 25:32be
- 25:33apologetics.
- 25:35So
- 25:35there's
- 25:35a
- 25:36difference
- 25:36between
- 25:36thinking
- 25:37well
- 25:37and
- 25:37apologetics.
- 25:38Apologetics
- 25:39is
- 25:39where
- 25:39you
- 25:39start
- 25:40with
- 25:40a
- 25:40premise.
- 25:41This
- 25:42is
- 25:42what
- 25:42I
- 25:42believe
- 25:42is
- 25:43true.
- 25:43Now
- 25:43I'm
- 25:44going
- 25:44to
- 25:44go
- 25:44find
- 25:44all
- 25:44the
- 25:44supporting
- 25:45information
- 25:46to
- 25:46prove
- 25:46it's
- 25:47true.
- 25:47But
- 25:48critical
- 25:48thinking
- 25:48doesn't
- 25:49start
- 25:49with
- 25:49a
- 25:49conclusion.
- 25:50It
- 25:50starts
- 25:50with
- 25:51a
- 25:51question.
- 25:52I
- 25:52want
- 25:52to
- 25:53know
- 25:53more
- 25:53about.
- 25:53I
- 25:54don't
- 25:54know
- 25:54enough
- 25:55about
- 25:55this.
- 25:56So
- 25:57is
- 25:57climate
- 25:58change
- 25:58real?
- 25:59Might
- 25:59be
- 25:59a
- 25:59question,
- 26:00as
- 26:00opposed
- 26:00to
- 26:01climate
- 26:01change
- 26:01is
- 26:01real.
- 26:02Here's
- 26:02all
- 26:02the
- 26:02data.
- 26:03Or
- 26:03climate
- 26:03change
- 26:04isn't
- 26:04real.
- 26:04Here's
- 26:05all
- 26:05the
- 26:05data.
- 26:05And
- 26:06we
- 26:06do
- 26:06this
- 26:06all
- 26:06the
- 26:06time.
- 26:06It's
- 26:07very
- 26:07common
- 26:07in
- 26:07religion
- 26:08to
- 26:08have
- 26:08apologetics
- 26:09But
- 26:09I
- 26:09see
- 26:09it
- 26:10across
- 26:11the
- 26:11board.
- 26:12We
- 26:12don't
- 26:12start
- 26:13with
- 26:13curiosity.
- 26:14We
- 26:14typically
- 26:14start
- 26:15with
- 26:15an
- 26:15assertion
- 26:16and
- 26:16then
- 26:16we
- 26:16go
- 26:17and
- 26:17find
- 26:17research
- 26:18for
- 26:18it.
- 26:19So
- 26:19for
- 26:19high
- 26:19school,
- 26:19I
- 26:19think
- 26:20one
- 26:20of
- 26:20the
- 26:20most
- 26:20valuable
- 26:21essay
- 26:22formats
- 26:22that
- 26:22never
- 26:23gets
- 26:23taught
- 26:23is
- 26:23the
- 26:24exploratory
- 26:24essay
- 26:25which
- 26:25we
- 26:26teach
- 26:26in
- 26:26our
- 26:26school,
- 26:27in
- 26:27our
- 26:27online
- 26:27classes.
- 26:28And
- 26:28the
- 26:29reason
- 26:29for
- 26:29that
- 26:29is
- 26:30we
- 26:30want
- 26:30to
- 26:30teach
- 26:30kids
- 26:31how
- 26:31to
- 26:31do
- 26:31the
- 26:31research,
- 26:32read
- 26:33the
- 26:33research
- 26:34and
- 26:34think
- 26:34about
- 26:35the
- 26:35research,
- 26:36not
- 26:36just
- 26:36hunt
- 26:37and
- 26:37peck
- 26:37through
- 26:37the
- 26:38research
- 26:38for
- 26:39the
- 26:39data
- 26:39and
- 26:39the
- 26:40facts
- 26:40that
- 26:40will
- 26:40support
- 26:41the
- 26:41thesis
- 26:42that
- 26:42they
- 26:42felt
- 26:42required
- 26:43to
- 26:43generate
- 26:44before
- 26:44they
- 26:44know
- 26:44anything
- 26:45about
- 26:45the
- 26:45topic.
- 26:47Really
- 26:47interesting.
- 26:47When
- 26:47you
- 26:48look
- 26:48at
- 26:48it
- 26:48through
- 26:48that
- 26:48lens,
- 26:49it's
- 26:49a
- 26:49completely
- 26:50different
- 26:51mission
- 26:52and,
- 26:52and
- 26:52a
- 26:52different
- 26:53outcome.
- 26:53Certainly.
- 26:55Julie,
- 26:55you
- 26:56chose
- 26:56to
- 26:56homeschool
- 26:56all
- 26:57five
- 26:57of
- 26:57your
- 26:57children
- 26:58starting
- 26:58back
- 26:59in
- 26:59the
- 26:59early
- 26:5980s
- 27:00when
- 27:00it
- 27:00was
- 27:00not
- 27:01something
- 27:01that
- 27:01people
- 27:02even
- 27:02had
- 27:02probably
- 27:03heard
- 27:03about
- 27:03for
- 27:03the
- 27:04most
- 27:04part.
- 27:04I'm
- 27:05curious
- 27:05as
- 27:06to
- 27:06why
- 27:06you
- 27:07chose
- 27:07to
- 27:08to
- 27:08homeschool
- 27:08your
- 27:09kids
- 27:09and
- 27:10if
- 27:11the
- 27:12homeschooling
- 27:12has
- 27:13had
- 27:13an
- 27:13impact
- 27:14on
- 27:14their
- 27:14critical
- 27:15thinking
- 27:15skills
- 27:16across
- 27:16their
- 27:17their
- 27:17lives.
- 27:18Wow,
- 27:19great
- 27:19question.
- 27:19So
- 27:20first
- 27:20I
- 27:20just
- 27:20want
- 27:21to
- 27:21say
- 27:21my
- 27:21kids
- 27:22started
- 27:22being
- 27:22born
- 27:23in
- 27:2387,
- 27:24so
- 27:24I'm
- 27:24a
- 27:2490s
- 27:25homeschooler.
- 27:26And
- 27:27here's
- 27:27what
- 27:28I
- 27:28know
- 27:28at
- 27:28the
- 27:29time.
- 27:29I
- 27:30had
- 27:30a
- 27:31phenomenal
- 27:32public
- 27:32school
- 27:32education
- 27:33in
- 27:33the
- 27:331970s
- 27:34in
- 27:34California.
- 27:35I
- 27:35was
- 27:36raised
- 27:36in
- 27:36Los
- 27:36Angeles
- 27:37and
- 27:37I
- 27:37was
- 27:38in
- 27:38a
- 27:38school
- 27:38district
- 27:38that
- 27:39ironically
- 27:40was
- 27:40in
- 27:40Malibu
- 27:41Canyon.
- 27:41So
- 27:41I
- 27:41had
- 27:42hippies,
- 27:42I
- 27:42had
- 27:43ex
- 27:43Peace
- 27:44Corps
- 27:44volunteers,
- 27:44first
- 27:45generation,
- 27:45right.
- 27:46And
- 27:46they
- 27:46were
- 27:47very
- 27:47experimental
- 27:48in
- 27:48their
- 27:48methods.
- 27:48But
- 27:49the
- 27:49thing
- 27:49that
- 27:49I
- 27:50really
- 27:50cherished
- 27:51about
- 27:51my
- 27:51education
- 27:52is
- 27:52that
- 27:53I
- 27:53felt
- 27:53like
- 27:53it
- 27:53was
- 27:54in
- 27:54my
- 27:55body.
- 27:55It
- 27:55wasn't
- 27:55just
- 27:56a
- 27:56bunch
- 27:56of
- 27:56information
- 27:57that
- 27:57I
- 27:58had
- 27:58actively
- 27:58participated
- 27:59in
- 28:00co
- 28:00creating
- 28:00it
- 28:01and
- 28:01that
- 28:01what
- 28:01I
- 28:02learned
- 28:02was
- 28:02still
- 28:02with
- 28:03me
- 28:03today.
- 28:04And
- 28:04as
- 28:04I
- 28:05went
- 28:05off
- 28:05to
- 28:05college
- 28:06at
- 28:06ucla,
- 28:06I
- 28:07ended
- 28:07up
- 28:07being
- 28:07a
- 28:07teaching
- 28:08assistant
- 28:08in
- 28:09a
- 28:09school
- 28:09in
- 28:09Brentwood
- 28:10that
- 28:10was
- 28:11a
- 28:11busing
- 28:11school
- 28:12for
- 28:12desegregation.
- 28:13And
- 28:13what
- 28:13I
- 28:14saw
- 28:14in
- 28:14that
- 28:14school
- 28:14really
- 28:15worried
- 28:15me.
- 28:16It
- 28:16was
- 28:16first
- 28:17of
- 28:17all
- 28:17not
- 28:18a
- 28:18successful
- 28:18desegregating
- 28:19project.
- 28:20You
- 28:20know,
- 28:20Louisiana's
- 28:21come
- 28:21a
- 28:21long
- 28:21way
- 28:21since
- 28:22then.
- 28:22But
- 28:23it
- 28:23was
- 28:23also
- 28:24very
- 28:24outcome
- 28:25based.
- 28:25And
- 28:26there
- 28:26was
- 28:26this
- 28:27loss
- 28:27of
- 28:27sort
- 28:27of
- 28:28creativity
- 28:28and
- 28:29personal
- 28:30meaning
- 28:30making
- 28:30that
- 28:30seems
- 28:31so
- 28:31important
- 28:31to
- 28:31me.
- 28:32So
- 28:32when
- 28:32I
- 28:33started
- 28:33reading
- 28:33about
- 28:33homeschooling
- 28:34in
- 28:34the
- 28:3480s,
- 28:35I
- 28:35was
- 28:35drawn
- 28:36to
- 28:36it.
- 28:36I
- 28:36thought,
- 28:37oh,
- 28:37maybe
- 28:37I
- 28:38can
- 28:38protect
- 28:38and
- 28:38preserve
- 28:39what
- 28:39I
- 28:39had
- 28:39in
- 28:40school
- 28:40through
- 28:41homeschooling,
- 28:41which
- 28:41is
- 28:42really
- 28:42backwards.
- 28:42You
- 28:42don't
- 28:43hear
- 28:43that
- 28:43very
- 28:43often.
- 28:44And
- 28:45part
- 28:45of
- 28:45what
- 28:45was
- 28:46joyful
- 28:46about
- 28:46homeschooling
- 28:47was
- 28:47reading
- 28:48aloud
- 28:48to
- 28:48my
- 28:48kids.
- 28:49So
- 28:49I
- 28:49had
- 28:50the
- 28:50opportunity
- 28:50to
- 28:51select
- 28:51a
- 28:52wide
- 28:52variety
- 28:52of
- 28:53books.
- 28:53And
- 28:54it
- 28:54was
- 28:54their
- 28:54provocative
- 28:55questions
- 28:56that
- 28:57drove
- 28:57so
- 28:58much
- 28:58of
- 28:58what
- 28:58we
- 28:59learned,
- 28:59because
- 29:00they
- 29:00would
- 29:00ask
- 29:00me
- 29:00things
- 29:00I
- 29:01didn't
- 29:01know
- 29:01the
- 29:01answers
- 29:01to,
- 29:02and
- 29:02we
- 29:02would
- 29:02have
- 29:03to
- 29:03all
- 29:03go
- 29:03on
- 29:03this
- 29:03project
- 29:04together.
- 29:05By
- 29:05the
- 29:05time
- 29:05they
- 29:06were
- 29:06in
- 29:06high
- 29:07school,
- 29:07some
- 29:07of
- 29:08my
- 29:08cherished
- 29:08beliefs
- 29:09that
- 29:09I
- 29:09had
- 29:09been
- 29:10very
- 29:11full
- 29:11of
- 29:12effort,
- 29:12trying
- 29:12to
- 29:12inculcate
- 29:13into
- 29:13them,
- 29:14completely
- 29:14crashed
- 29:15and
- 29:15burned
- 29:16because
- 29:16they
- 29:16were
- 29:17resistant.
- 29:18And
- 29:18I
- 29:18famously
- 29:19tell
- 29:19in
- 29:19my
- 29:19other
- 29:19book,
- 29:20the
- 29:20Brave
- 29:20Learner,
- 29:21a
- 29:21story
- 29:22of
- 29:22how
- 29:22I
- 29:22tried
- 29:22to
- 29:23restrict
- 29:23and
- 29:23regulate
- 29:24my
- 29:24oldest
- 29:24son's
- 29:26listening
- 29:26to
- 29:26music
- 29:27habits,
- 29:27what
- 29:27books
- 29:28he
- 29:28would
- 29:28read.
- 29:29And
- 29:29it
- 29:30resulted
- 29:30in
- 29:31a
- 29:31massive,
- 29:32terrible
- 29:32parenting
- 29:33moment
- 29:33between
- 29:33my
- 29:34husband,
- 29:34me,
- 29:34and
- 29:34my
- 29:34son.
- 29:35And
- 29:35it
- 29:35was
- 29:36in
- 29:36that
- 29:36moment
- 29:36that
- 29:36I
- 29:36really
- 29:37had
- 29:37to
- 29:37pivot
- 29:37and
- 29:38realize
- 29:38I
- 29:39don't
- 29:39have
- 29:39control
- 29:39over
- 29:39this
- 29:40mind.
- 29:41I
- 29:41got
- 29:41to
- 29:41get
- 29:41curious
- 29:42about
- 29:42this
- 29:42mind.
- 29:43He's
- 29:43listening
- 29:44to
- 29:44Rage
- 29:44against
- 29:44the
- 29:44Machine
- 29:45for
- 29:45a
- 29:45reason.
- 29:45Let's
- 29:46look
- 29:46at
- 29:46the
- 29:46lyrics.
- 29:47My
- 29:47own
- 29:47mother,
- 29:48who
- 29:48was
- 29:48his
- 29:49grandmother,
- 29:50was
- 29:50more
- 29:50curious
- 29:51about
- 29:51the
- 29:51music
- 29:51he
- 29:52was
- 29:52listening
- 29:52to
- 29:52than
- 29:53I
- 29:53was,
- 29:53because
- 29:54she
- 29:54had
- 29:54learned
- 29:55that
- 29:55the
- 29:55way
- 29:56you
- 29:56grow
- 29:57a
- 29:57healthy
- 29:58person
- 29:59is
- 29:59to
- 29:59know
- 29:59about
- 30:00their
- 30:00interiors,
- 30:01not
- 30:01to
- 30:01drive
- 30:02all
- 30:02that
- 30:02underground,
- 30:03but
- 30:03to
- 30:03be
- 30:04in
- 30:04connection.
- 30:05So
- 30:05that
- 30:06was
- 30:06really
- 30:06the
- 30:06beginning
- 30:06for
- 30:07me.
- 30:07And
- 30:07I
- 30:07would
- 30:07say
- 30:08that
- 30:08my
- 30:08five
- 30:08kids
- 30:09are
- 30:09amazing
- 30:10thinkers.
- 30:11I've
- 30:11learned
- 30:12so
- 30:12much
- 30:12from
- 30:12them.
- 30:13They
- 30:14all
- 30:14have,
- 30:14you
- 30:15know,
- 30:15developed
- 30:15their
- 30:16own
- 30:16professions
- 30:16and
- 30:17traveled
- 30:17the
- 30:17world
- 30:18and
- 30:18speak
- 30:18different
- 30:19languages
- 30:19and,
- 30:20yeah,
- 30:20I'm
- 30:21humbled
- 30:21by
- 30:21them
- 30:22every
- 30:22day.
- 30:23What
- 30:23a
- 30:23wonderful
- 30:24story.
- 30:24Julie,
- 30:25let
- 30:25me
- 30:25ask
- 30:25you,
- 30:26what
- 30:26was
- 30:26the
- 30:26impetus
- 30:27for
- 30:27writing
- 30:28Raising
- 30:29Critical
- 30:29Thinkers
- 30:30and
- 30:30then
- 30:30this
- 30:30workbook
- 30:31and
- 30:31also,
- 30:31what
- 30:32do
- 30:32you
- 30:32want
- 30:32readers
- 30:33to
- 30:33take
- 30:33away
- 30:33from,
- 30:34from
- 30:34these
- 30:34pieces?
- 30:35Thank
- 30:36you.
- 30:36So
- 30:37Raising
- 30:37Critical
- 30:37Thinkers
- 30:38has
- 30:38been
- 30:38like
- 30:38a
- 30:3830
- 30:38year
- 30:39project
- 30:39for
- 30:39me.
- 30:40I
- 30:40didn't
- 30:40know
- 30:41when
- 30:41I
- 30:41started,
- 30:42but
- 30:42I
- 30:42hopped
- 30:43online
- 30:43in
- 30:43my
- 30:43mid-30s,
- 30:44joined
- 30:45this
- 30:45homeschool
- 30:45discussion
- 30:46board
- 30:46with
- 30:46all
- 30:46this,
- 30:46you
- 30:47know,
- 30:47married,
- 30:48white,
- 30:48religiously
- 30:49similar,
- 30:50politically
- 30:50similar
- 30:51women.
- 30:51And
- 30:52we
- 30:52found
- 30:52ourselves
- 30:53in
- 30:53online
- 30:53blood
- 30:53baths
- 30:54over
- 30:54who
- 30:55was
- 30:55destroying
- 30:55the
- 30:55planet
- 30:56faster.
- 30:56Parents
- 30:57with
- 30:57pampers
- 30:57or
- 30:58parents
- 30:58with
- 30:58cloth
- 30:58diaper
- 30:59services.
- 31:00We
- 31:00argued
- 31:00about
- 31:01VBACs
- 31:01and
- 31:01breastfeeding.
- 31:02We
- 31:02talked
- 31:02about
- 31:03our
- 31:03political
- 31:04perspectives
- 31:05and
- 31:05our
- 31:05religious
- 31:05doctrines,
- 31:06and
- 31:07no
- 31:07one
- 31:07agreed.
- 31:08I
- 31:08mean,
- 31:09we
- 31:09were
- 31:09nice
- 31:09to
- 31:09each
- 31:09other
- 31:10sometimes,
- 31:10but
- 31:11sometimes
- 31:11it
- 31:11was
- 31:11a
- 31:11full
- 31:11on
- 31:12troll
- 31:12war.
- 31:13And
- 31:14I
- 31:14started
- 31:14not
- 31:15asking
- 31:15the
- 31:15question,
- 31:16who
- 31:16was
- 31:16right?
- 31:17I
- 31:17was
- 31:18wondering,
- 31:18why
- 31:18do
- 31:18we
- 31:18all
- 31:19think
- 31:19we're
- 31:19right?
- 31:20Why
- 31:21does
- 31:21each
- 31:21person
- 31:22think,
- 31:22I
- 31:22can
- 31:22make
- 31:23an
- 31:23assertion,
- 31:24grab
- 31:24my
- 31:25source
- 31:25of
- 31:25authority,
- 31:26and
- 31:26everyone
- 31:26will
- 31:26fall
- 31:27in
- 31:27line?
- 31:28And
- 31:28what
- 31:28I
- 31:28started
- 31:29realizing
- 31:29is
- 31:29that's
- 31:30the
- 31:30Training
- 31:30from
- 31:30school.
- 31:31And
- 31:32the
- 31:32more
- 31:32I
- 31:32looked
- 31:33at
- 31:33the
- 31:33way
- 31:33school
- 31:34treats
- 31:34us
- 31:34that
- 31:34way,
- 31:35the
- 31:35more
- 31:36I
- 31:36saw
- 31:36that
- 31:37Internet
- 31:37was
- 31:37going
- 31:38to
- 31:38go
- 31:38down
- 31:38this
- 31:38horrible
- 31:39direction.
- 31:40Because
- 31:40it's
- 31:41obvious
- 31:41to
- 31:42me
- 31:42that
- 31:42we
- 31:42all
- 31:42believe
- 31:43that
- 31:43all
- 31:44we
- 31:44have
- 31:44to
- 31:44do
- 31:44is
- 31:44cite
- 31:45one
- 31:45source
- 31:45of
- 31:45authority
- 31:46and
- 31:46everyone
- 31:47will
- 31:47agree.
- 31:48But
- 31:48we
- 31:49don't
- 31:49all
- 31:49share
- 31:49the
- 31:49same
- 31:50sources
- 31:50of
- 31:50authority.
- 31:51So
- 31:51I
- 31:52started
- 31:52being
- 31:52curious
- 31:53about
- 31:53how
- 31:54do
- 31:54we
- 31:54grow
- 31:54those
- 31:54skills,
- 31:55not
- 31:55only
- 31:55in
- 31:55our
- 31:56children,
- 31:56but
- 31:56for
- 31:56ourselves?
- 31:57And
- 31:58then
- 31:58how
- 31:58do
- 31:58we
- 31:59live
- 31:59in
- 31:59a
- 32:00different
- 32:00way
- 32:00with
- 32:01each
- 32:01other?
- 32:01Online,
- 32:02I
- 32:02have
- 32:02an
- 32:02online
- 32:03community
- 32:03with
- 32:04my
- 32:04company
- 32:04called
- 32:04Brave
- 32:05Learner
- 32:05Home.
- 32:06And
- 32:06we've
- 32:06never
- 32:07had
- 32:07an
- 32:07argument
- 32:08over
- 32:09anything
- 32:09political,
- 32:10no
- 32:10social
- 32:11issue.
- 32:11And
- 32:12everyone
- 32:12from
- 32:12all
- 32:13perspectives
- 32:13is
- 32:13welcome
- 32:14because
- 32:15we
- 32:15come
- 32:15with
- 32:15this
- 32:15other
- 32:16way
- 32:16of
- 32:16addressing
- 32:17the
- 32:18world.
- 32:18We're
- 32:18not
- 32:19there
- 32:19in
- 32:19conversion
- 32:20mindset.
- 32:21So
- 32:21it's
- 32:21a
- 32:21big
- 32:21change.
- 32:22And
- 32:23I
- 32:23wrote
- 32:23this
- 32:23book
- 32:24because
- 32:24parents
- 32:25often
- 32:25think
- 32:25they're
- 32:26good
- 32:26critical
- 32:26thinkers.
- 32:27In
- 32:27fact,
- 32:28almost
- 32:29every
- 32:29radio
- 32:30show
- 32:30I've
- 32:30ever
- 32:30been
- 32:30on,
- 32:31especially
- 32:31the
- 32:31ones
- 32:31run
- 32:32by
- 32:32men,
- 32:32they
- 32:33always
- 32:33think
- 32:33I'm
- 32:33of
- 32:33the
- 32:33same
- 32:34political
- 32:34persuasion
- 32:35as
- 32:35them.
- 32:35And
- 32:36they're
- 32:36like,
- 32:36thank
- 32:36God
- 32:36you
- 32:37wrote
- 32:37this
- 32:37book
- 32:37for
- 32:37those
- 32:38other
- 32:38people.
- 32:40And
- 32:41my
- 32:41hope
- 32:41is
- 32:41that
- 32:42we'll
- 32:42all
- 32:42discover
- 32:43how
- 32:43far
- 32:44we
- 32:44have
- 32:44to
- 32:44go.
- 32:45When
- 32:45I'm
- 32:45reading
- 32:46Facebook,
- 32:46I'm
- 32:46like
- 32:47everyone
- 32:47else.
- 32:47I
- 32:47suddenly
- 32:48feel
- 32:48smug,
- 32:49annoyed.
- 32:50I
- 32:50think
- 32:50I'm
- 32:50superior
- 32:51to
- 32:51people.
- 32:52This
- 32:52is
- 32:52just
- 32:53the
- 32:53human
- 32:53condition.
- 32:54But
- 32:54now
- 32:54those
- 32:54are
- 32:55my
- 32:55critical
- 32:55thinking
- 32:56tells.
- 32:56I
- 32:56know.
- 32:56Oh,
- 32:57I'm
- 32:58not
- 32:58thinking
- 32:58well
- 32:58in
- 32:59this
- 32:59moment.
- 32:59I'm
- 32:59just
- 33:00defaulting
- 33:00to
- 33:00groupthink,
- 33:01to
- 33:02my
- 33:02team,
- 33:03to
- 33:03cheerleading
- 33:04my
- 33:04ideas.
- 33:05Critical
- 33:05thinking
- 33:06requires
- 33:06that
- 33:06pause.
- 33:07So
- 33:07I
- 33:08wrote
- 33:08Raising
- 33:08Critical
- 33:09Thinkers
- 33:09to
- 33:09help
- 33:10parents
- 33:10get
- 33:10good
- 33:11at
- 33:11it.
- 33:11There
- 33:12are
- 33:12activities
- 33:12they
- 33:13can
- 33:13do
- 33:13with
- 33:13their
- 33:13kids,
- 33:13ages
- 33:145
- 33:14to
- 33:1418.
- 33:15So
- 33:15that's
- 33:15in
- 33:15here,
- 33:16too.
- 33:16And
- 33:17then
- 33:17my
- 33:17publisher
- 33:18said,
- 33:19what
- 33:20about.
- 33:20Excuse
- 33:21me,
- 33:21my
- 33:21publisher
- 33:22said,
- 33:22what
- 33:22about
- 33:22teenagers?
- 33:23Could
- 33:24you
- 33:24write
- 33:24something
- 33:24for
- 33:25them?
- 33:25So
- 33:25we
- 33:25came
- 33:25up
- 33:26with,
- 33:26it's
- 33:26more
- 33:26like
- 33:27a
- 33:27journal,
- 33:27sort
- 33:28of
- 33:28like
- 33:28the
- 33:28artist's
- 33:28way,
- 33:29you
- 33:29know,
- 33:30but
- 33:30it's
- 33:30a
- 33:30workbook
- 33:31for
- 33:31them
- 33:32to
- 33:32have
- 33:32the
- 33:32privacy
- 33:33to
- 33:34think
- 33:34about
- 33:34their
- 33:34own
- 33:34thinking,
- 33:35to
- 33:35not
- 33:35have
- 33:35to
- 33:36always
- 33:36do
- 33:36that
- 33:36in
- 33:36public,
- 33:37to
- 33:37examine
- 33:38a
- 33:38view
- 33:38without
- 33:39someone
- 33:39telling
- 33:39them
- 33:39they're
- 33:40wrong.
- 33:41Certainly
- 33:42such
- 33:43an
- 33:43important
- 33:44area
- 33:44of
- 33:44discussion,
- 33:45of
- 33:46practice,
- 33:47of
- 33:47awareness.
- 33:47As
- 33:48you
- 33:48mentioned
- 33:48at
- 33:48the
- 33:48outset,
- 33:49given
- 33:50the
- 33:50global
- 33:50world
- 33:50we
- 33:51live
- 33:51in,
- 33:51given
- 33:52the
- 33:52knowledge
- 33:53that
- 33:53we're
- 33:53all
- 33:53exposed
- 33:54to.
- 33:55Julie
- 33:55Bogart,
- 33:56thank
- 33:56you
- 33:56so
- 33:56much
- 33:56for
- 33:56taking
- 33:57time
- 33:57to
- 33:57share
- 33:57your
- 33:58insight
- 33:58with
- 33:58us
- 33:58today.
- 33:59Thank
- 33:59you
- 34:00for
- 34:00having
- 34:00me.