Latest / Surrounded / Is There Only One Way to Read the Bible? | Surrounded Follow-Up w/ Allie Beth Stuckey
Transcript
- 0:00That is the very difficult place that we've gotten.
- 0:02It's not that our disagreements have become more complicated as Americans,
- 0:07it's that our disagreements have become a lot more fundamental.
- 0:10What is truth?
- 0:11What is morality?
- 0:12Who made us?
- 0:14What are rights and where did they come from?
- 0:16For hundreds of years,
- 0:17we at the very least on the left and right agreed on that.
- 0:20From Jubilee Media.
- 0:21This is the Surrounded podcast.
- 0:23I'm John Regalado,
- 0:24and today we're welcoming back Ali Beth Stuckey.
- 0:27She's a conservative Christian,
- 0:29and she was at the center of last week's episode,
- 0:31debating 20 liberal Christians.
- 0:32She's also the host of the relatable podcast,
- 0:35as well as an author.
- 0:36Her book is called Toxic Empathy.
- 0:38We're going to discuss homosexuality and whether or not the Bible approves of it,
- 0:42as well as other issues.
- 0:43Such as abortion,
- 0:44polarization in our political culture,
- 0:47the assassination of Charlie Kirk,
- 0:48and lots more.
- 0:49So without further ado,
- 0:51let's get into it.
- 0:51Welcome to the surrounded follow-up.
- 0:54Thank you so much for having me.
- 0:55I wanna react to some of kind of the highlights that stood out to me in your episode.
- 1:00I really enjoyed your episode.
- 1:02It's actually probably one of my favorites.
- 1:04Awesome.
- 1:05I think it just was,
- 1:06uh,
- 1:07It was a unique
- 1:08conversation and I felt like there was a lot of substance.
- 1:11First things first,
- 1:12I just kind of wanted to
- 1:14hear from you,
- 1:15you know,
- 1:15what was your expectations going into it,
- 1:18and then maybe what were your feelings coming out of it.
- 1:21I was a little nervous just because this is a unique
- 1:25scenario and I had never been in this kind of setup.
- 1:27I had had discussions,
- 1:28disagreements,
- 1:29debates in the past.
- 1:30Maybe the most similar thing was I testified before Congress a few years ago,
- 1:35was.
- 1:35The only pro-life
- 1:37witness there in front of a lot of congressional Democrats,
- 1:40and,
- 1:41um,
- 1:42you know,
- 1:42so maybe that was the only thing that I felt like had really prepared me for it,
- 1:46but I also was very good friends with Charlie Kirk,
- 1:48and he had done a lot more debates than I had,
- 1:51and that was really
- 1:53one of the last conversations that we had with him giving me advice on Jubilee.
- 1:58And when he told me,
- 1:59hey,
- 2:00this is really intense,
- 2:01this is really tough,
- 2:03you need to make sure that you're gonna take breaks.
- 2:05I was like,
- 2:05man,
- 2:05if Charlie Kirk,
- 2:06the
- 2:07debater of all debaters,
- 2:09is telling me that this is going to be really tense,
- 2:12then I'm nervous.
- 2:14Um,
- 2:14but then when I walked in,
- 2:17one of my things was,
- 2:18I was like,
- 2:19OK,
- 2:19I wanna be as compassionate,
- 2:21disarmingly compassionate as possible.
- 2:24Without compromising at all.
- 2:26But honestly,
- 2:27the
- 2:28participants also disarmed me with their kindness,
- 2:32because when I
- 2:33sat down and the first person said,
- 2:36hey,
- 2:36I'm really sorry
- 2:37for Charlie.
- 2:38I know that you guys were friends,
- 2:40that shifted the tone,
- 2:42I think.
- 2:43I was already going in hoping to make a kind impression on them,
- 2:47but they also made a kind impression on me.
- 2:50And even though,
- 2:51as we'll get into,
- 2:52it did get tense at times,
- 2:54of course,
- 2:54we're disagreeing on like really serious big stuff.
- 2:58I honestly felt like very tender towards them,
- 3:01and I felt like a lot of them felt like that towards me too,
- 3:04and I think that set us up to having
- 3:07a lot of really good dialogue.
- 3:08The first um claim that I
- 3:11want to kind of dive into,
- 3:13this was in the context of abortion is a grave moral evil.
- 3:17In the edit,
- 3:17this is your second claim.
- 3:19Um,
- 3:20and then this is a clip from your conversation
- 3:23with Angie.
- 3:25These are my personal beliefs,
- 3:26these are your personal beliefs.
- 3:27We should not be using the law to enforce our personal
- 3:30beliefs on people who are not who are not Christian.
- 3:33Every law enforces a personal belief on everyone.
- 3:35That's what a law is.
- 3:36But this is,
- 3:37yes,
- 3:37but this is like,
- 3:38these are,
- 3:38these are more universal laws.
- 3:40They are laws we have a law against No,
- 3:41no,
- 3:42no,
- 3:42let me,
- 3:43let me finish this point.
- 3:44There's a lot of these are common sense universal
- 3:45laws that are actually reflected in many different religions,
- 3:49not just Christianity,
- 3:50about murder,
- 3:51about stealing,
- 3:51about theft.
- 3:52These are things that I think that the Lord.
- 3:54founded our laws based on the principles of humanity.
- 3:57I'm sorry,
- 3:57I missed that.
- 3:58Our,
- 3:58our founders founded our laws and wrote our laws
- 4:01specifically with the principles of scripture in mind,
- 4:04not created a theocracy,
- 4:05but on the values of the principles.
- 4:07And so they weren't saying,
- 4:08well,
- 4:08let's just pick the laws that sound good to Buddhists too.
- 4:11That's not how they formed those laws.
- 4:13I mean,
- 4:13I'm sure they have limited access to Buddhists.
- 4:15I mean,
- 4:15let's be,
- 4:16let's be real and what their theology or,
- 4:18you know,
- 4:18but that's,
- 4:20I think we need to get back to the point that With Christians really trying to force
- 4:25our personal beliefs on non-Christians throughout the throughout our country,
- 4:30because we have these personal convictions,
- 4:32I think that is incorrect because it can go to so many different ways,
- 4:36especially if it's a different religion that came into power.
- 4:39Christians would be upset about that you see that that laws that allow abortions,
- 4:43laws that allow abortions
- 4:45is enforcing your personal belief system on that child.
- 4:48We don't see it as enforcing a personal belief system.
- 4:51I'm going back.
- 4:51I have to go back to Exodus the right to go back to Exodus 21.
- 4:55What I find is that Christian conservatives seem to be the only people who are
- 5:00told our worldview should not be brought into the public square or the public sphere
- 5:05or policymaking
- 5:07conversations.
- 5:07But say we have a secular progressive who comes to the table and says,
- 5:12you know,
- 5:12I think that we should allow
- 5:14people who identify as transgender to go to their bathroom of choice.
- 5:18Well,
- 5:18that is their particular.
- 5:20belief about what constitutes as a legitimate identity
- 5:24that affords to that individual certain rights,
- 5:27and that secular progressive bringing that belief to
- 5:30the table that then informs the law,
- 5:32that has an effect on me.
- 5:34Maybe I don't want someone who is the opposite sex of me to join
- 5:38me in the bathroom or in the locker room or something like that,
- 5:41but they have now forced their particular worldview on me,
- 5:45and that is what every law does.
- 5:47There is no such thing as some,
- 5:49neutral law,
- 5:50we are all bringing the fullness of our belief system to the table,
- 5:54and let the best idea win.
- 5:56That's I think why these discussions are so important,
- 5:59but
- 6:00when you tell one person,
- 6:01no,
- 6:02no,
- 6:02no,
- 6:02you have to
- 6:04leave your beliefs at your house,
- 6:06and you can't bring those to the table,
- 6:08but me,
- 6:08secular progressive over here,
- 6:10I'm gonna bring everything I believe about the
- 6:12world to the table in those discussions,
- 6:15well,
- 6:15that's,
- 6:16that's just not gonna work.
- 6:17I think that makes total sense.
- 6:19When you adopt a moral framework,
- 6:22um,
- 6:23especially through the lens of,
- 6:24of faith,
- 6:25how can that not inform
- 6:27your beliefs,
- 6:28you know,
- 6:29to the extent of how,
- 6:30how you think laws should be enacted,
- 6:32how do you think,
- 6:33um,
- 6:33what direction you want politics to move.
- 6:35So I think that makes total sense to me.
- 6:38I'm curious what you think about um
- 6:40kind of the delicate balance of like separation of church and state.
- 6:44In
- 6:45your discussion with Angie,
- 6:46this idea of,
- 6:47you know,
- 6:47uh,
- 6:47the founding fathers principles,
- 6:49I think all of the founding fathers were probably,
- 6:52would identify as Christian.
- 6:53I actually don't know for sure,
- 6:55but
- 6:56it,
- 6:56it was a,
- 6:57a Christian culture
- 6:58and a Christian context in which this country was founded.
- 7:02But there was also this idea of separation of church and state,
- 7:04and I'm curious,
- 7:05you know,
- 7:06have you seen instances where you think Christians maybe
- 7:09Well,
- 7:10there is certainly a prohibition against the establishment of a state religion,
- 7:14and despite what a lot of people on the progressive side say,
- 7:17I actually don't know any theocrats on the conservative side.
- 7:21I don't know anyone who was like,
- 7:22yeah,
- 7:22you know,
- 7:22we should pass laws that say you gotta be a Presbyterian,
- 7:26and you have to go to Presbyterian Church,
- 7:28and you have to worship God and pray
- 7:30the way that I do.
- 7:31What I think a lot of people don't realize is that the separation of church and state,
- 7:34first of all,
- 7:35that's not in the Constitution.
- 7:37But you could argue in the First Amendment,
- 7:38the principle is,
- 7:40but it's not a separation of God and law,
- 7:44and the founders were very clear about that.
- 7:45At the beginning of the Declaration of Independence,
- 7:48we have been endowed by our Creator with certain inalienable rights,
- 7:52among them being life,
- 7:52liberty,
- 7:53and the pursuit of happiness.
- 7:54So even if you could say that
- 7:57the founders didn't have all the same
- 7:58theological beliefs as evangelical Christians do today,
- 8:01there was still this underlying belief that there is a God.
- 8:05Uh,
- 8:06whose power transcends the power of the government,
- 8:09who gives us rights that the government cannot
- 8:12arbitrarily give or arbitrarily give or take away.
- 8:15So I think that that belief is fundamental.
- 8:18Now the debate comes in,
- 8:19how,
- 8:20what does that look like?
- 8:21How do we enact laws that manifest that reality?
- 8:26And there are always going to be debates over that.
- 8:28There's always going to be elections that try to determine that,
- 8:31and I think that that's a good thing.
- 8:33I think the place that we've gotten,
- 8:34which is a very difficult place to be,
- 8:37is
- 8:38the rejection of that idea that our rights are given to us by God.
- 8:42And,
- 8:42OK,
- 8:42well,
- 8:43if you've abandoned that foundational belief,
- 8:45then we're gonna have a really hard time discussing and debating everything else,
- 8:49which is exactly why John Adams said,
- 8:51look,
- 8:51our constitution was made for a moral and religious people,
- 8:54it is utterly inappropriate and just insufficient for,
- 8:59um,
- 8:59any other kind of people,
- 9:01and that is the very Difficult place that we've gotten.
- 9:04It's not that our disagreements have become more complicated as Americans,
- 9:09it's that our disagreements have become a lot more fundamental.
- 9:12What is truth?
- 9:13What is morality?
- 9:15Who made us?
- 9:16What are rights and where did they come from?
- 9:18For hundreds of years,
- 9:19we at the very least on the left and right agreed on that.
- 9:24I think abortion is especially as an issue which was uh what this claim was focused on
- 9:31really does hit on that.
- 9:33It's such a fundamental um
- 9:34um value
- 9:36and I imagine I had a great uh conversation with Lila
- 9:40Rose.
- 9:40I'm not sure if you guys know each other,
- 9:42um,
- 9:42but she's been on the show.
- 9:44She's great,
- 9:44yeah.
- 9:45You know,
- 9:46we had a a a conversation kind of about.
- 9:49Looking ahead towards the future of procreation and,
- 9:53and the technology
- 9:54and what
- 9:55the possibilities that unlocks in the future,
- 9:58it is kind of hard to envision a future
- 10:00without some sort of shared fundamental understanding.
- 10:03Around the value of life
- 10:05in the womb and,
- 10:06and how we interpret that.
- 10:07Well,
- 10:08and I think it points to a lot of the
- 10:10fundamental differences that we have because for so long we,
- 10:14you know,
- 10:14for most of human history,
- 10:15we didn't have the science to understand what was happening in the womb.
- 10:19There was an idea that,
- 10:20OK,
- 10:20maybe
- 10:21they become a person at quickening when a woman is able to
- 10:24feel the baby move inside the womb at like 20 weeks,
- 10:27or maybe it's later,
- 10:28maybe it's earlier than that.
- 10:29But now we have the science to not only know,
- 10:32but to see that at the very beginning,
- 10:34at the point of conception,
- 10:35this is a human being.
- 10:37Now whether you think that human being has rights can be debated,
- 10:40but it's a human with his or her own DNA
- 10:42with everything already determined at that point of conception.
- 10:45So now we're not arguing about what is a human,
- 10:48we see it scientifically,
- 10:50we're arguing about what is a person.
- 10:52And I just think that when you look at every human rights atrocity
- 10:56throughout history,
- 10:57that's really been the question,
- 10:58and you don't want to be on the wrong side of that question.
- 11:01What is a person?
- 11:02Is uh a black person a person?
- 11:05Is a Jewish person a person?
- 11:07Is this person on this side of this tribal conflict
- 11:10in Africa or in the Middle East a person?
- 11:12You want to be on the right side of saying yes,
- 11:15and I think pro-abortion people are.
- 11:17On the wrong side of that question.
- 11:19And that's a really big deal.
- 11:21I think that's a,
- 11:22that's a strong argument.
- 11:23And I,
- 11:24you know,
- 11:24in the,
- 11:24in the aftermath of the overturning of Roe,
- 11:28I'm actually really interested in where the pro-choice argument um
- 11:32evolves,
- 11:34because I,
- 11:35I do think that the foundation of
- 11:38personhood,
- 11:38like you're saying,
- 11:39you know,
- 11:40do you really think that's not a human?
- 11:42To me,
- 11:42that argument,
- 11:43it does really feel like the argument,
- 11:44of course,
- 11:45that's a human life,
- 11:46um,
- 11:47is the stronger one.
- 11:48So,
- 11:48I'll be curious to see um
- 11:50if the argument on the other side evolves or,
- 11:53or changes in the coming years,
- 11:54just given how much,
- 11:56you know,
- 11:56the political reality has changed around this issue.
- 11:59Something that came up
- 12:01uh
- 12:02in this argument around abortion was um the intentional killing of
- 12:07a life is wrong.
- 12:08Um,
- 12:09which I think makes total sense.
- 12:11And
- 12:11I just want to go into some
- 12:15into the Bible a little bit since so much of this episode is about the Bible.
- 12:18And I was curious,
- 12:19and you just,
- 12:20you seem so well versed in it.
- 12:22So I grew up a Catholic,
- 12:24and I watched uh the Moses movie with Charlton Heston.
- 12:27And I just remember as a as a kid being so afraid of um
- 12:32the scene where the,
- 12:33uh,
- 12:34I can't remember which plague it is,
- 12:35is it the 9th?
- 12:36It's the last one where the first born child is killed.
- 12:40And it's like the green smoke comes in and it goes under the doors.
- 12:45When I was when I was a child that terrified me.
- 12:47Um,
- 12:48it's terrifying,
- 12:48yes.
- 12:50Yeah,
- 12:50but I,
- 12:51you know,
- 12:51you talk a lot about like the example set by
- 12:53by God and,
- 12:54and,
- 12:55and sort of the truth he establishes.
- 12:57And so,
- 12:59In the context of killing,
- 13:01how should we interpret,
- 13:02or how do you interpret
- 13:04God's decision to,
- 13:06you know,
- 13:06take the life of the firstborn,
- 13:09um,
- 13:10To,
- 13:10to convince the Pharaoh to,
- 13:12to release,
- 13:12uh,
- 13:13the Israelites.
- 13:14I think there are so many different ways we can talk about this,
- 13:17and I recently had a conversation with uh one of my children about this.
- 13:21We read this story in
- 13:23one of the Jesus storybook Bibles,
- 13:25and of course,
- 13:26naturally,
- 13:26she's like,
- 13:27what in the world?
- 13:28Because of course we have been taught and we read in scripture that God is merciful,
- 13:32that he made all of us in His image that he.
- 13:34He sent his son to die for us.
- 13:36So
- 13:36how do we reconcile that reality,
- 13:38John 3:16,
- 13:39that God so loved the world that He gave His only Son,
- 13:43that whoever believes in Him should not perish but have everlasting life.
- 13:46And some of the seeming brutality that we see in the Old Testament,
- 13:50to us,
- 13:50we might say,
- 13:51well,
- 13:51that's just
- 13:52like needless death of people who didn't directly do anything wrong.
- 13:56I don't know that I have every single answer for every
- 13:59single description of that kind of thing in the Old Testament.
- 14:02I've asked,
- 14:03I've asked myself,
- 14:04and I've asked God some of those questions,
- 14:05like,
- 14:05give me the wisdom to understand because you tell
- 14:07me that you're good and merciful and love us,
- 14:10and I,
- 14:10like,
- 14:11I,
- 14:11and I know that I'm not perfect and
- 14:13always good,
- 14:14and I wouldn't condone something like that.
- 14:16So,
- 14:16like,
- 14:16help me understand.
- 14:18And the only thing that I can say is that,
- 14:21number one,
- 14:22We are not prescribed to do everything that God does,
- 14:25we are not permitted to do everything that God does,
- 14:28we are not even given the ability to understand everything that God does,
- 14:31but what we can see throughout scripture is that
- 14:33God will do absolutely anything to rescue his people.
- 14:37God will stop at nothing to bring Himself glory,
- 14:41He will part the Red Sea,
- 14:42He will stop Pharaoh's army,
- 14:44he will inflict the oppressive community with plagues,
- 14:47even death,
- 14:48if that means
- 14:49rescuing his own people.
- 14:51And what we see is that the Passover,
- 14:53so the Jewish people,
- 14:55you know,
- 14:55had to put the blood of a lamb
- 14:58over their doorpost so that
- 15:01the spirit would not go into their homes and kill their children.
- 15:05Well,
- 15:05that is a foreshadowing of
- 15:08the,
- 15:09the blood of Jesus,
- 15:10our spotless lamb that was shed for our
- 15:13behalf to spare us from eternal spiritual death.
- 15:16So while I don't fully understand it,
- 15:18I know that all of the sacrifices,
- 15:21and all of the loss,
- 15:22and all of the pain of the Old Testament was a foreshadowing
- 15:26of the sacrifice and ultimate redemption of Jesus Christ for me,
- 15:31so that
- 15:31I no longer have to put
- 15:33blood
- 15:34on an altar or blood over my doorpost.
- 15:37In order to be made clean,
- 15:38in order to be spared,
- 15:39because Jesus accomplished that perfectly on my behalf on the cross.
- 15:43And so sometimes I wonder
- 15:45if God allowed this kind of brutality in the
- 15:48Old Testament to point to the new and the better
- 15:52and bigger way and sacrifice of Jesus.
- 15:55Um,
- 15:55and I don't know if that's the perfect answer.
- 15:57But that's kind of how I've thought through things.
- 15:59Growing up,
- 16:00I,
- 16:00I,
- 16:00I've have heard similar arguments and,
- 16:03and,
- 16:03um,
- 16:03you know,
- 16:03like the distinction between the Old and New Testament and
- 16:07kind of before and after,
- 16:08uh,
- 16:08the crucifixion.
- 16:09So,
- 16:10that makes a lot of sense.
- 16:11My Catholic,
- 16:12uh,
- 16:13education is,
- 16:13is showing that I can hear the producer telling me to move to the next clip.
- 16:17So,
- 16:17uh,
- 16:18thank you for,
- 16:19for going into that.
- 16:20This one's actually really interesting.
- 16:21Uh,
- 16:22your claim was
- 16:25Empathy can be toxic and lead to sin,
- 16:27which is super fascinating because
- 16:30I have a podcast called Radical Empathy.
- 16:34You have a book called
- 16:35Toxic Empathy.
- 16:37Um,
- 16:37I think they're both interesting takes on a similar concept.
- 16:41And so,
- 16:42um,
- 16:43you and Kyle have an argument
- 16:45around,
- 16:46um,
- 16:47you know,
- 16:48how can being empathetic for somebody be,
- 16:50be toxic,
- 16:51and you bring up the example of a transgender person.
- 16:55And if they were assigned a certain gender at birth,
- 16:58But then are telling you that they feel another way.
- 17:01OK,
- 17:01let me give you an example of what I think is toxic empathy,
- 17:04and
- 17:04this will probably unleash a can of worms,
- 17:06which will be fun.
- 17:07If I feel so deeply that someone who sits across from me says,
- 17:11you know what,
- 17:11I was assigned male at birth,
- 17:13but I am trapped in the wrong body and I am,
- 17:16I,
- 17:16I identify
- 17:18as a girl.
- 17:19I would say that.
- 17:20so deeply
- 17:21how that person feels that you get to
- 17:23the point of affirming their identity and saying
- 17:26yes,
- 17:26you are the opposite sex.
- 17:28The Bible doesn't condemn transgender.
- 17:30Let's get there.
- 17:31Let hang on.
- 17:32That is an example of what I would say
- 17:35is empathy that has turned toxic because you are affirming something
- 17:38that is not true and is destructive for the individual.
- 17:42Affirming what feels true to them could be a harm to them,
- 17:46and that could be a form of toxic
- 17:47empathy cause you're affirming something that's not true.
- 17:51Um,
- 17:51and so that,
- 17:52this was sort of the example you offered to Kyle,
- 17:55and I thought it was a really interesting one.
- 17:59But I'm curious sort of how you grapple with,
- 18:02how do we identify truths in
- 18:05the context of kind of like a scientific biological reality.
- 18:08Um,
- 18:10outside of transgender,
- 18:11you know,
- 18:11I think of
- 18:12things like depression or very rare,
- 18:15um,
- 18:15physical ailments such as like conjoined twins or,
- 18:18or very rare genetic diseases.
- 18:20Um,
- 18:21I'm curious how
- 18:23You think about God's truth in the context of kind of those.
- 18:27Abnormalities or irregularities,
- 18:30or if you see them a similar way as as the the example of transgenderism.
- 18:36Hm,
- 18:37there's so many directions that I could take my answer to this.
- 18:40So it seems like it,
- 18:42no,
- 18:42that's OK.
- 18:43I mean,
- 18:43it's really interesting.
- 18:45There,
- 18:46so there's a presupposition that I see a lot of
- 18:48people who either identify as transgender or just who affirm
- 18:53the validity of transgenderism that it's possible that you could be assigned
- 18:57a gender based on your anatomy that is not in alignment with who you really are.
- 19:03And that is that there is some kind of like
- 19:07inner gendered identity or soul
- 19:10that is who you really are,
- 19:12that that's your genuine identity,
- 19:14and that the body is kind of just arbitrary.
- 19:18And because your inner identity is who you really are,
- 19:21you should change the body in order to match that inner identity.
- 19:26Well,
- 19:26that's
- 19:27not a Christian belief at all.
- 19:29Christians do not.
- 19:30believe that the body is arbitrary.
- 19:32We believe Christian,
- 19:33or that the creation rather,
- 19:35and that our bodies have something called a telos,
- 19:37which is a purpose,
- 19:39and that our bodies tell us a really important part of who we are.
- 19:43That's not to say that we don't have thoughts that are important,
- 19:45or feelings that are important,
- 19:46or personality,
- 19:47of course we believe that we have an eternal soul,
- 19:50but Christianity doesn't denigrate the body in that way.
- 19:53We don't believe that the soul and the body are two separate things,
- 19:55that the soul is Like who we really are.
- 19:58No,
- 19:58we believe that God purposely gave us our bodies,
- 20:01and that
- 20:02our biology tells us something about our tell loss,
- 20:05and tells us about our purpose.
- 20:07In the same way that a bird's body,
- 20:09and an elephant's body,
- 20:11they tell you about what they can do.
- 20:13They tell you about who they are,
- 20:15and no one is going to a bird and saying,
- 20:17Well,
- 20:17why don't you just act like an elephant?
- 20:19Like,
- 20:19why don't you raise your trunk up and
- 20:22stomp around?
- 20:23No one's going to tell
- 20:24Bird that,
- 20:24because they can see the bird's wings,
- 20:26and they could say,
- 20:27you were made for this,
- 20:28and no matter how that bird feels,
- 20:30that is what that is,
- 20:31that bird is going to be forever.
- 20:32And yet for some reason,
- 20:33when it comes to human beings,
- 20:35we decide that our bodies tell us nothing about who we are,
- 20:38that our biology tells us nothing about our functions,
- 20:41nothing about our identity,
- 20:43and I just think that doesn't make any sense,
- 20:45both from a Christian worldview standpoint,
- 20:47but just from a logical standpoint too.
- 20:49And of course we could get into all of the Consequences of
- 20:52people being able to identify as something that they biologically are not.
- 20:56Consequences for their own body,
- 20:58and then consequences for
- 21:01everyone else too.
- 21:02You also brought up depression,
- 21:03and I think it's interesting how depression and
- 21:05eating disorders are treated so differently than transgenderism.
- 21:09Like,
- 21:10depression,
- 21:10of course,
- 21:11you try to heal the mind as much as you can,
- 21:14and there might be outward things that you can do,
- 21:16but you don't tell,
- 21:17like,
- 21:17someone with any Eating disorder.
- 21:19Yeah,
- 21:19you know what?
- 21:20I know you're only 100 pounds,
- 21:21but you really should lose more weight.
- 21:24No,
- 21:24you try to heal their mind,
- 21:25you try to reconcile their mind with the outward reality.
- 21:28But we've decided with transgenderism that you have to change the body
- 21:32in order to reconcile to this delusion that you're the opposite gender,
- 21:35and it doesn't make any sense.
- 21:37That,
- 21:37that is clarifying to me.
- 21:38You,
- 21:38you,
- 21:39um,
- 21:39I think it's interesting this distinction between the mind and body,
- 21:42because I was actually interpreting the mind.
- 21:46More literally as an extension of the body,
- 21:48like,
- 21:49like the brain itself.
- 21:50And so
- 21:51I was wondering if you,
- 21:52you were resistant to like,
- 21:53um,
- 21:54I don't know,
- 21:55SSRIs,
- 21:56you know,
- 21:56uh,
- 21:57a medication that manipulates uh the brain to
- 22:01You know,
- 22:02prevent certain kind of mood disorders.
- 22:04Um,
- 22:05so that's how I was interpreting it,
- 22:06but I,
- 22:07you know,
- 22:08it was helpful to hear what you were,
- 22:09how you described it.
- 22:10Yeah,
- 22:11I have a whole other issue about SSRIs that
- 22:13doesn't really have to do with that argument.
- 22:15I just think that the things that on the market are actually can,
- 22:19can be very harmful to people's psychology.
- 22:21We don't treat transgenderism.
- 22:23With that kind of idea that,
- 22:24hey,
- 22:24we can give you something to help your mind
- 22:27think differently.
- 22:27We don't say that.
- 22:28In fact,
- 22:28if someone says that,
- 22:29then they're considered transphobic.
- 22:31The only thing that we're supposed to do is affirm and say,
- 22:34yes,
- 22:34get your double mastectomy because your mind is absolutely right about this,
- 22:38and
- 22:39that's just because it's politically dangerous to say otherwise,
- 22:42and I think that's very cowardly.
- 22:45Yeah,
- 22:45thank you for,
- 22:46for going deeper into that.
- 22:48I think it makes perfect sense,
- 22:49this idea that you can be too deep in empathy
- 22:53to the point where you almost get disoriented.
- 22:56When you withdraw from another person's feelings,
- 22:59um,
- 23:00You,
- 23:01you maybe
- 23:02are too aligned with them or,
- 23:04or,
- 23:04or your,
- 23:05your compass has sort of been,
- 23:07um.
- 23:08Offset.
- 23:09And so I think that makes a lot of sense.
- 23:12I'm curious,
- 23:13do you think like empathy became too trendy,
- 23:16um,
- 23:17in the last
- 23:18decade?
- 23:19Um,
- 23:20you're uh uh
- 23:21It,
- 23:22it's definitely like a word that sort of ebbed and flowed through culture and,
- 23:26and I'm curious if,
- 23:27if you just feel like it's,
- 23:28it's a trend that went too far,
- 23:30um,
- 23:31and maybe what the,
- 23:31the biggest factors were contributing to that.
- 23:34When we,
- 23:35we adopted empathy and moral relativism at the same time.
- 23:39And so if you believe that morality is relative,
- 23:41that you're not really tethered by any basic principles that are unmoved,
- 23:46depending
- 23:47on,
- 23:47you know,
- 23:48where you live or the time.
- 23:50Um,
- 23:50that you're in,
- 23:51well,
- 23:52empathy then becomes your guide,
- 23:54and the problem with empathy is that it's a strong feeling.
- 23:56Strong feelings aren't necessarily bad,
- 23:58but any strong feeling can either lead you in a good direction,
- 24:02or it can lead you in a dangerous direction,
- 24:04because feelings are so powerful,
- 24:06They can either help us see more clearly,
- 24:08or they can completely blind us to reality.
- 24:11And my argument about toxic empathy is not that all empathy is bad,
- 24:14it's actually that empathy by itself is neutral.
- 24:17If I feel deeply for you,
- 24:19that doesn't make me,
- 24:20or if I feel deeply how you feel.
- 24:22If I try to put myself in your feelings,
- 24:23that doesn't necessarily
- 24:25mean that I'm a good person.
- 24:26If I see someone on the side of the road and I'm like,
- 24:28wow,
- 24:29I can imagine how painful that is,
- 24:31and how awful that is.
- 24:32That sucks,
- 24:33and I keep driving,
- 24:34that doesn't make me a good person,
- 24:36but if I feel deeply for that person,
- 24:38how they feel,
- 24:39and then that compels me to stop and to lend them aid,
- 24:42it's not really the empathy that was the virtue,
- 24:45it is the sacrifice and the kindness and
- 24:48the sacrifice that I put into actually helping that person,
- 24:53which is why I think empathy
- 24:55could sometimes be an important vessel to morality.
- 24:58But it's not always,
- 25:00and it can also lead us to be really cruel.
- 25:03And an example of that,
- 25:04and Paul Bloom,
- 25:05he's a secular Yale psychologist,
- 25:07he wrote an entire book on against empathy,
- 25:09and what he found was that the more highly someone scores on empathy,
- 25:12the crueler they are to the out-group.
- 25:15And so,
- 25:15you've got this person,
- 25:17you believe that they're a victim,
- 25:18they're being marginalized in some way.
- 25:20You pour all of your empathy into that underdog.
- 25:23Then,
- 25:23And what happens is,
- 25:24naturally,
- 25:25you feel that the enemy or oppressor of that person is your enemy,
- 25:29and you hate them,
- 25:30which is what I see from progressives a lot.
- 25:32They've got so much empathy for the illegal immigrant,
- 25:36they've got so much empathy for the person who says they're transgender,
- 25:39they've got so much empathy for whoever they feel is being marginalized,
- 25:43that everyone they perceive as hurting that person
- 25:47becomes their dire enemy.
- 25:49And
- 25:49That person doesn't deserve anything.
- 25:51That person deserves cruelty,
- 25:53that person deserves to be protested,
- 25:54to be,
- 25:55you know,
- 25:56whatever,
- 25:56canceled,
- 25:57and then in some extreme cases,
- 25:59of course,
- 26:00they deserve pain,
- 26:01uh,
- 26:01to be inflicted upon them for what they're
- 26:03doing to this purported victim over there.
- 26:05So they have allowed their empathy for that person to blind them,
- 26:09I think,
- 26:09to reality and morality.
- 26:11That's the problem with being led by empathy,
- 26:13is that it
- 26:15is always competing against someone on the other side.
- 26:19Um,
- 26:20and so it's much better to be led by virtue,
- 26:22to be led by truth,
- 26:23to be led,
- 26:24I think,
- 26:25by love,
- 26:25which is better and more powerful than empathy,
- 26:28and I argue that love is always inextricably intertwined with the truth,
- 26:32that you can't love someone and lie to them.
- 26:34You can't love someone and support something that's bad
- 26:36for them and bad for the people around them.
- 26:38Um,
- 26:38so yeah,
- 26:39that's my argument that empathy,
- 26:42Really,
- 26:42like,
- 26:42it's not that helpful,
- 26:44um,
- 26:45of a feeling and can actually be very detrimental
- 26:47to making good decisions on a wide scale.
- 26:51That was perfect cause that,
- 26:52that
- 26:52cues up the next clip I wanted to bring in,
- 26:54which was um
- 26:56within the same claim,
- 26:58John came up to you
- 27:00and he's saying,
- 27:02Look,
- 27:02I,
- 27:03I hear what you're saying.
- 27:06Empathy can be toxic,
- 27:08but I actually feel like there's not enough empathy,
- 27:10and he talks about how algorithms are
- 27:12showing the worst versions of both sides,
- 27:14and he talks about kind of political polarization with algorithms,
- 27:18and his concern was that
- 27:20the messaging around toxic empathy
- 27:22might harden people's hearts
- 27:25more than
- 27:27it's intended to.
- 27:28I think it's because a lot of times on the right.
- 27:31It's the things you're not able to identify with that you're feeling.
- 27:34Why do you think homosexuality is,
- 27:36it's,
- 27:36it gives people on the right the ick
- 27:38in a lot of ways,
- 27:39because they don't
- 27:40get it.
- 27:40They're not,
- 27:41they're not entering into that.
- 27:42And so it's easier to say,
- 27:43oh,
- 27:44that is outrageously,
- 27:45God is frowning on that as opposed to,
- 27:48um,
- 27:48as opposed to pride,
- 27:50um,
- 27:50as opposed to the disparity between we should look at all of those as sins,
- 27:55but I'm probably the only one in this room right now.
- 27:58Say that both of those things that you just listed are sins.
- 28:01And that's really kind of the disparity in the disagreement that
- 28:04we see is that even if I have empathy for someone,
- 28:07that does not mean I'm going to affirm a sexual identity or
- 28:10a so-called gender identity that does not align with the Bible.
- 28:13And that's what I see a lot from my progressive
- 28:15friends.
- 28:15And that's why I wrote the book,
- 28:16not as a quip,
- 28:17not as just a hot take to put out there,
- 28:19but actually because I see very well intentioned,
- 28:22compassionate,
- 28:23deeply feeling people use.
- 28:26To justify things that I think are not only unbiblical,
- 28:29but destructive for society,
- 28:30whether it's immigration or gender or marriage or social justice.
- 28:34All of that starts with,
- 28:35well,
- 28:35I feel how this person feels,
- 28:37and that leads,
- 28:38I believe,
- 28:38to supporting policies that are bad for that person
- 28:41and bad for society.
- 28:42I understand where you're coming from.
- 28:43It's,
- 28:44it's,
- 28:44it's the parent who's not going to let their kid do
- 28:46things that are going to hurt them out of love.
- 28:48It's,
- 28:48it's,
- 28:48I totally get it.
- 28:50I don't draw the lines in the same places as you,
- 28:52but
- 28:53But I,
- 28:54I know,
- 28:54I understand the the essence of it.
- 28:56I think what's,
- 28:57what's,
- 28:57what's upsetting
- 28:58is that we need to lean further into
- 29:01identifying with one another and loving each other.
- 29:03Jesus talks about us being the vine and the branches,
- 29:05your pain should be my pain and we shouldn't just go,
- 29:07oh,
- 29:07you're on the right,
- 29:08you're on these,
- 29:09these,
- 29:09these labels,
- 29:09like Jesus actually wasn't
- 29:11either party.
- 29:12That's not what he was doing.
- 29:13He was breaking down all these divides.
- 29:16You
- 29:17responded to him with,
- 29:18I,
- 29:18I thought a really clear,
- 29:19um,
- 29:20retort,
- 29:21but I was curious.
- 29:22What,
- 29:22just what your thoughts were about kind of
- 29:24al algorithms from one content creator to another,
- 29:27you know.
- 29:28Do you feel a sense of conflict or concern about how algorithms maybe
- 29:33undermine or,
- 29:34or
- 29:35splice uh our intentions as
- 29:38You know,
- 29:38as,
- 29:39as
- 29:40storytellers or as truth tellers.
- 29:44Well,
- 29:45certainly it can change our perception of reality,
- 29:48and I think this really matters,
- 29:50especially on the fringes,
- 29:51on both the left and right,
- 29:53and you've got the vast majority of us who are like,
- 29:55no,
- 29:56political violence,
- 29:56bad idea.
- 29:57I don't care how much I disagree with someone,
- 29:59but then you've got people
- 30:01who
- 30:02just,
- 30:02they,
- 30:02for whatever reason,
- 30:03whatever components they have going on in their mind.
- 30:06They really don't need that much to be moved from anger to violence,
- 30:10and
- 30:11I think that when you are in an echo chamber on whatever chat room you're in,
- 30:15or whatever social media space you're in,
- 30:17and you are made to believe that everyone is as extreme as you.
- 30:21Everyone feels the same way you do.
- 30:23You start building yourself up,
- 30:24OK,
- 30:25everyone thinks this way.
- 30:26I'm gonna be a hero.
- 30:28Like,
- 30:28everyone thinks this way,
- 30:29I'm gonna do this thing,
- 30:30everyone's gonna love me,
- 30:31and then,
- 30:32you know,
- 30:32it's not until later that you realize,
- 30:34oh my gosh,
- 30:3499% of people,
- 30:36like,
- 30:36we're not with you on that.
- 30:38I saw people after Charlie Kirk was shot,
- 30:40people on the other side of the aisle say,
- 30:41wow,
- 30:42like I haven't seen anyone mourn this guy.
- 30:44Everyone on my timeline is celebrated.
- 30:46I'm like,
- 30:46Oh my gosh,
- 30:47I didn't see anyone celebrating.
- 30:49I had to go like,
- 30:50look for that on places like TikTok.
- 30:53Um,
- 30:53it really changes your perception
- 30:56of reality,
- 30:57and I,
- 30:58uh,
- 30:58of course,
- 30:59I think that liberals
- 31:00have a much
- 31:02more difficult time at seeing.
- 31:05How conservatives think,
- 31:07we see how liberals think every day.
- 31:09All we have to do is turn on a show,
- 31:11or watch a movie,
- 31:13or read the New York Times,
- 31:15and I think,
- 31:15not that,
- 31:16you know,
- 31:16every liberal is bad at debating,
- 31:18but I'm surprised at how little liberals understand.
- 31:22And the conservative position,
- 31:24and they think they've got this like
- 31:26perfect argument
- 31:27that is really easily unraveled
- 31:30that because they've never really been tested against that.
- 31:33So that's an issue.
- 31:34That's why conservatives are a lot braver when it comes to being 20 against one.
- 31:39Yeah,
- 31:39no,
- 31:39that is,
- 31:40uh,
- 31:40we could talk about that for a long time.
- 31:42Something that I thought was maybe the most empathetic thing I've seen.
- 31:46And I'm curious if you think this is empathy actually,
- 31:48but this was one of the most powerful moments that has maybe happened in
- 31:53culture that I can recall,
- 31:54and that was
- 31:55at
- 31:56Charlie Kirk's memorial,
- 31:58uh,
- 31:58just a little while ago when
- 32:00his wife,
- 32:01Erica,
- 32:03forgave the killer
- 32:04in,
- 32:05in such a public way.
- 32:07I saw,
- 32:09Very progressive
- 32:11people
- 32:12kind of like gobsmacked by that and and praising it and I thought,
- 32:16I just thought that was.
- 32:18One of the most powerful moments and
- 32:20kind of shocking moments I've witnessed recently,
- 32:22and I'm curious,
- 32:23is,
- 32:23do you see that as empathy
- 32:25and,
- 32:25and do you agree?
- 32:28No,
- 32:28I don't think
- 32:29that's empathy at all.
- 32:30In fact,
- 32:31I think she probably feels no empathy for the man who slaughtered her husband.
- 32:36To be empathetic means to be in someone's feelings,
- 32:39and I highly doubt
- 32:41that she can put herself in her shoes and be like,
- 32:43yeah,
- 32:43I could see that.
- 32:44I could see why he did that.
- 32:46What She did is so much more powerful than empathy.
- 32:49She said,
- 32:50just like the Good Samaritan
- 32:52in Jesus' parable,
- 32:53I don't know that person.
- 32:55I don't like that person.
- 32:57That person is so diametrically opposed,
- 32:59not only,
- 33:00and I'm,
- 33:00I,
- 33:00I don't know what her actual thoughts are.
- 33:03I'm just saying what I see from a biblical perspective,
- 33:06but.
- 33:08I don't like have anything.
- 33:10I can't relate to that person
- 33:11at all,
- 33:12but
- 33:13Christ calls me to something higher than just feeling how someone feels.
- 33:16Christ calls me to something that to most people looks impossible.
- 33:20Christ calls me to love that person,
- 33:22not because I feel how they feel,
- 33:23but because they're made in God's image.
- 33:25Because Christ died for them,
- 33:27and because Jesus calls me to forgive,
- 33:30because he forgave me,
- 33:31I'm going to forgive this person that
- 33:33most people think is completely unforgivable.
- 33:36So,
- 33:36that's actually a perfect example of what I
- 33:38think is so much more powerful than empathy.
- 33:40I saw so many people after Charlie died.
- 33:43Share a quote where he says,
- 33:44you know,
- 33:45I don't really like the word empathy,
- 33:47I like the word sympathy.
- 33:48And so a lot of people said,
- 33:50well,
- 33:50he didn't,
- 33:50he didn't care about empathy,
- 33:52why should I give him any empathy?
- 33:53Why should I feel for him?
- 33:55Yeah,
- 33:55that's the problem with empathy.
- 33:56It is so feelings-driven,
- 33:58it is so agreement-driven in many cases,
- 34:00not all.
- 34:01But it's so arbitrary because of that,
- 34:04that if you are driven by empathy,
- 34:05you're not gonna forgive someone just because it's the right thing to do.
- 34:09You're gonna try to decide how you feel about them
- 34:11and if you can relate to their feelings first.
- 34:13But what if we just took our feelings out of it and asked,
- 34:15what is right,
- 34:17and what is true,
- 34:18and what is good?
- 34:20Then I think that we make much better choices.
- 34:22To me,
- 34:23knowing that she's a Christian like I am,
- 34:26that is more of the mentality that she had,
- 34:28that she had,
- 34:29rather than,
- 34:30oh yeah,
- 34:30I can understand where he was coming from.
- 34:32Mhm,
- 34:33mhm.
- 34:34Yeah,
- 34:34no,
- 34:34I,
- 34:34I appreciate hearing your,
- 34:35your take on that.
- 34:37And,
- 34:37and yeah,
- 34:37I mean,
- 34:38obviously my thoughts go out to her and,
- 34:40and
- 34:41it was just,
- 34:41um,
- 34:42it felt like a really important,
- 34:44uh,
- 34:45thing to say,
- 34:46um.
- 34:48And to hear.
- 34:49The next clip I wanna
- 34:51talk about,
- 34:52um,
- 34:53is a conversation you had with Danny,
- 34:55and I think this was in the context of your final claim.
- 34:58Oh yeah,
- 34:59this is
- 35:00your
- 35:00You guys were talking about your claim,
- 35:02progressivism and Christianity
- 35:05are at odds.
- 35:05Should we define progressivism?
- 35:07Yeah,
- 35:07thank you so much.
- 35:08I would love to hear kind of where you're going on kind of an ideological.
- 35:11OK,
- 35:11so I was thinking about this and it's so broad.
- 35:13I don't know if we're going to be able to agree on an answer and a clear definition.
- 35:18So I'm happy to workshop it with you,
- 35:19but I kind of define progressivism as the belief that
- 35:22morality and truth evolve with culture and the human experience
- 35:26and that that would kind of encompass.
- 35:28A lot of the what I would call progressive views on sexuality and gender,
- 35:32even economics and justice.
- 35:34Um,
- 35:35what do you think about that definition?
- 35:36I think it's fabulous.
- 35:38It's,
- 35:38I think God is pulling us into greater levels of understanding
- 35:40of God's grace and justice and story and all that.
- 35:42So I would agree with that.
- 35:43So what do you think our authority is when we're
- 35:45trying to figure out what's moral and what's not?
- 35:47Well,
- 35:47I think,
- 35:48so we're going to use the word authority maybe differently.
- 35:50I look at scripture,
- 35:51but I think you and I look at scripture certainly differently.
- 35:53Yeah,
- 35:53how do you,
- 35:54how when you're looking at scripture.
- 35:56How do you decide?
- 35:57OK,
- 35:58yes,
- 35:58this is right.
- 36:00I need to listen to what Jesus says about praying for my enemies.
- 36:03But when he talks about the definition of marriage,
- 36:06I don't think that's literal.
- 36:07How do you work with that?
- 36:09Yes,
- 36:09I imagine we're both talking about the 66 book Protestant Bible as well.
- 36:12It's a lot of different compositions of scripture and all that.
- 36:15But I mean,
- 36:15I would look at it in terms of context.
- 36:17I try really hard not to prove text in anything.
- 36:19I try really hard not to pull something out and say,
- 36:21you know,
- 36:21the Bible says that,
- 36:22that settles it.
- 36:22I think if Any Christian,
- 36:24progressive or conservative tells you that
- 36:26they're a liar.
- 36:27The Bible is not a parlor trick,
- 36:29and it's not something that ought to be
- 36:30proof texted.
- 36:31So I think in the whole totality of scripture,
- 36:34the story that God is weaving and the story that God is writing,
- 36:36which is the story of God and us,
- 36:37like both of us,
- 36:38and that's not because we agree,
- 36:40it's because God loves us,
- 36:41both of us.
- 36:42God is telling a story of greater levels of justice and redemption.
- 36:45We look at this
- 36:46through,
- 36:47you talked about America being founded on Christian
- 36:49biblical principles.
- 36:50Right,
- 36:51there were a lot of my friends of color that were
- 36:53up here that the Bible would have condemned their personhood.
- 36:56The Bible would have conferred how people,
- 36:58how people interpreted the Bible may have condemned their personhood,
- 37:01but the Bible didn't change and God didn't change.
- 37:04So
- 37:05Hebrews 13:8 says that Jesus Christ is the same yesterday,
- 37:07today and forever.
- 37:09So he and his word don't change.
- 37:10But I agree.
- 37:10I think we both agree that human beings are fallible,
- 37:13that we're finite,
- 37:14and that we don't always always get it right.
- 37:16I would say there's one correct interpretation of.
- 37:18Scripture and that we do our very best to do exactly what you said,
- 37:21to read everything in context to try
- 37:23to understand what that correct interpretation is.
- 37:26I don't have a lot of time.
- 37:26Can I ask you a question?
- 37:28Where do you think maybe you were getting it wrong?
- 37:30Where do you think,
- 37:31when,
- 37:31when you're interpreting scripture,
- 37:32because who gets to be the arbiter of what's right and wrong?
- 37:34Like the people that thought slavery was just,
- 37:36they felt certainly right.
- 37:37The people that oppressed women
- 37:39have felt certainly right.
- 37:40I feel certainly right that the Bible doesn't condemn queer people,
- 37:42and I would affirm that there are things I probably get wrong.
- 37:45Would you?
- 37:46Say that there's anything you think you have missed
- 37:48the mark on or that you're open to.
- 37:49Oh,
- 37:49I'm sure because I'm a fallible person and so I
- 37:52could never say that I am the infallible interpreter.
- 37:55But of course I want to take the word of God as seriously in context as possible.
- 38:00And you know,
- 38:00there were Christians who tried to justify all kinds of things using scripture,
- 38:04as you,
- 38:04I'm sure would agree with,
- 38:06but also the abolitionist movement
- 38:08was motivated and led by Christians who were inspired by that very same Bible.
- 38:14In it is the gospel,
- 38:15of course,
- 38:15which says all people are made in God's image and equally
- 38:17dead and sin apart from Christ by grace through faith,
- 38:20you have been saved.
- 38:21And so yes,
- 38:22human beings get it wrong.
- 38:23God does not get it wrong and God does not change.
- 38:26I agree with that.
- 38:27So I would say
- 38:28I would love my friends across the aisle
- 38:30to have more humility.
- 38:32I don't think there's toxic humility.
- 38:34I think that when I look at scripture,
- 38:35I try really hard to come at it with humility.
- 38:38I take the Bible really seriously enough to
- 38:41dive into it and deconstruct it and find places that
- 38:44are not congruent with the story that God is writing,
- 38:46places that don't make sense,
- 38:48that are out of context,
- 38:49places that affirm the stories that are being said.
- 38:51I am certainly not right 100% of the way.
- 38:53And when I get up and preach in front of my congregation,
- 38:55I say that to them.
- 38:56I let them know,
- 38:57like,
- 38:58I am a person diving into God's word with you.
- 39:00See,
- 39:00I would argue that you're making Yourself
- 39:03the authority because you could read clearly,
- 39:05for example,
- 39:06that Romans 1 condemns homosexuality,
- 39:08but you're saying I don't find
- 39:11that congruent with the rest of scripture and you are deciding that that's not true.
- 39:15Whereas I might read something that,
- 39:17hey,
- 39:17is
- 39:18a little jarring for me,
- 39:20wives submit to their husbands.
- 39:21That's important.
- 39:22That's Ephesians 5.
- 39:23And should not be pastors.
- 39:25That's also in scripture and those things,
- 39:28you know,
- 39:28as a woman,
- 39:29as a strong woman,
- 39:30I still have to submit to myself to God's law and God's word,
- 39:35even when it might feel difficult because I'm a sinful person in my flesh.
- 39:40He asks this pretty provocative question.
- 39:42He's like,
- 39:42what do you think
- 39:43you might be getting wrong?
- 39:45Um,
- 39:46which I thought was a pretty bold thing to ask.
- 39:49Um,
- 39:50And I was just curious,
- 39:52you know,
- 39:52maybe like a different version of that question might be.
- 39:55What's something that maybe?
- 39:58Uh,
- 39:58provoked the,
- 39:59the most doubt in you or,
- 40:00or was just one of the biggest struggles of your faith.
- 40:03Um,
- 40:04I,
- 40:04I just,
- 40:05I would like to,
- 40:06to hear from you.
- 40:08Yeah,
- 40:08I'm happy to share that.
- 40:10You know,
- 40:10we've already touched on it a little bit,
- 40:12but I,
- 40:13just like anyone else,
- 40:14I don't like the thought of children being harmed.
- 40:17Like,
- 40:17I don't like the thought of children being the victims of war,
- 40:21the victims of conquest,
- 40:23or the victims of any kind of violence,
- 40:25and it's really hard for me.
- 40:27Like,
- 40:28I can kind of understand things like,
- 40:30Uh,
- 40:31a car wreck or cancer or things like that.
- 40:33OK,
- 40:34yes,
- 40:34we live in this fallen world and bad things happen,
- 40:37but when you think about whether it's,
- 40:39you know,
- 40:39in Bible times or today,
- 40:41the horrific things that happen to children,
- 40:45I'm like,
- 40:45OK,
- 40:45how is that part of God's greater plan?
- 40:48Like,
- 40:49like,
- 40:49I know that God is in charge,
- 40:52you know,
- 40:53in the greater sovereign sense,
- 40:55and I know that he's good.
- 40:57And I'm not in charge and I'm not always good,
- 40:59but if I could stop something like that,
- 41:01I would.
- 41:03So that has,
- 41:04you know,
- 41:04that's hard for me to grapple with.
- 41:06And
- 41:07what I come back to is in the Christian faith,
- 41:09we believe
- 41:11that one day Jesus is coming back
- 41:13and that he's not gonna come back as a baby,
- 41:14he's not gonna come back just as a rabbi,
- 41:16but that he actually comes back.
- 41:18Book of Revelation is kind of trippy,
- 41:19but comes back on.
- 41:20white horse with a sword coming out of his mouth and a tattoo on his thigh,
- 41:24and he comes back to avenge his people,
- 41:26and he comes back to shed the blood of the
- 41:28evildoer and do away with Satan forever and ever,
- 41:31and all of his minions and all of evil will be no more.
- 41:34And I actually think I could even get a secular progressive to agree
- 41:38that we are hoping for a better future
- 41:40in which there is not injustice and oppression,
- 41:42and Christianity actually.
- 41:44Promises that,
- 41:45that Jesus is gonna be the one that comes back and does away
- 41:49with all of that in a very warrior sense forever and ever.
- 41:52And so what I have to trust,
- 41:54I read a Psalm like Psalm 37 that says,
- 41:57basically,
- 41:58paraphrasing all the evil that evildoers do will come back on them,
- 42:02and all of the people that are,
- 42:04you know,
- 42:04wreaking this terrible oppression and violence,
- 42:07they will get their due.
- 42:08And so I have to trust that God is not doing nothing,
- 42:11that he also looks to that pain and he hates it,
- 42:13and that one day he's gonna do something about it,
- 42:16that his wrath is kindling against evil,
- 42:18and I think all of us who like superhero movies and
- 42:21all of that,
- 42:22we all feel that.
- 42:23We want the bad guy
- 42:24to get got.
- 42:25Like,
- 42:26we want his
- 42:27Reign to be over and we want the good guy to win,
- 42:30and Christianity promises that in a really big eternal sense.
- 42:33So I have to,
- 42:34I just have to trust that one day every injustice is gonna be made right,
- 42:37that every wrong is gonna be made right,
- 42:39that one day there's not gonna be any evil or violence anymore,
- 42:41and God is not sitting idly by,
- 42:44that he's gonna do something about it.
- 42:46Um,
- 42:47so again,
- 42:48but I don't have any perfect answer for anything because I'm not a perfect person.
- 42:51But
- 42:52that's something to wrestle with,
- 42:53and Tim Keller said that a faith without doubt is like a body without antibodies.
- 42:57It's really important for us to have doubts,
- 42:59but not to say,
- 43:00well,
- 43:01I just am gonna forget that or I'm gonna push it down,
- 43:04or I'm my,
- 43:04I'm gonna go to my feelings,
- 43:06but I'm gonna try to more deeply understand the word of God and the character of
- 43:09God and hope that I can land at some kind of peace on those questions.
- 43:14It's a great quote.
- 43:16Uh,
- 43:16what can you say it again?
- 43:18It's like a body without it.
- 43:19Yes,
- 43:21yeah,
- 43:21and I encourage people to get this book.
- 43:23I didn't agree with Tim Keller on everything,
- 43:24but Reason for God.
- 43:26Um,
- 43:26I first read it my senior year of high school,
- 43:28Reason for God.
- 43:29It's basically a skeptic's guide to understanding
- 43:32faith in Christianity.
- 43:33A faith without doubt
- 43:35is like a body without antibodies.
- 43:37Um,
- 43:38and it's been comforting to me.
- 43:40I think that's,
- 43:41that is a great idea.
- 43:43Um,
- 43:43and a,
- 43:44and a really well said one.
- 43:46The first person who came and sat
- 43:47down was Gilbert,
- 43:49um,
- 43:49and Gilbert offered
- 43:50his condolences,
- 43:51and then at the end you had an opportunity to debate somebody again,
- 43:55um,
- 43:56and you chose Gilbert,
- 43:57and Gilbert's claim
- 43:59was.
- 44:00The church's condemnation of same-sex marriages causes profound
- 44:05damage and unnecessary suffering to gay people.
- 44:08Can you please define
- 44:10damage and suffering for me in this context?
- 44:13So gay kids are 8 to 12 times more likely to commit suicide,
- 44:17especially if they come from religious
- 44:19homes,
- 44:19and it's because they have no way.
- 44:21To express.
- 44:22And I know we keep talking about sex,
- 44:24right?
- 44:25But I,
- 44:25the conversation piece that I think is always
- 44:27missing is that it's more than just sex.
- 44:29It's about love.
- 44:30It's who you love with.
- 44:31It's the way that you're wired,
- 44:32and I know we'll disagree with this,
- 44:34but I really feel that in my mother's womb,
- 44:36God designed me this way.
- 44:38I'm not just born in this in principle this way.
- 44:40It's the way that I'm designed.
- 44:41It's the way that I kind of see the.
- 44:42world.
- 44:42And I don't want to affirm a lot of stereotypes,
- 44:44but there's markers.
- 44:45You can tell when someone's gay.
- 44:46You don't have to watch them having sex,
- 44:48right?
- 44:48So there's different ways that you can spot a gay person,
- 44:51and I think there's a reason for that.
- 44:53And I've noticed so many pastors,
- 44:56kids come out as gay,
- 44:57and I really feel like there's this movement.
- 44:59What were your takeaways from,
- 45:01from your interactions with Gilbert and
- 45:03Yeah,
- 45:04yeah
- 45:06Sweet Gilbert,
- 45:07yes,
- 45:08that was the reason I had him back to talk cause.
- 45:11He's,
- 45:11he's so sweet.
- 45:12His disposition is so sweet,
- 45:13and I thought he had great,
- 45:15you know,
- 45:15great and interesting things to say,
- 45:16and I can understand why he believes the things he does.
- 45:19We've actually talked a little bit since the debate too,
- 45:22just gone back and forth on email.
- 45:24Um,
- 45:24yeah,
- 45:25and like I really,
- 45:26you know,
- 45:27want the best for him,
- 45:28but we're not going to agree on this because
- 45:31of not just the,
- 45:32you know,
- 45:33physical reality of marriage,
- 45:35which is in principle,
- 45:37although not always in practice for like the procreation of children.
- 45:41Um,
- 45:42but
- 45:43also that we see that it's supposed to
- 45:45be an earthly reflection of an eternal reality,
- 45:49which is the marriage between Christ and His church.
- 45:51Christ is described as the groom,
- 45:53church is described as the bride,
- 45:55and that is supposed to be,
- 45:57as we read in Ephesians 5,
- 45:58like that's the model.
- 46:00And if that's what marriage is supposed to be,
- 46:03and those gender specifications are so fixed,
- 46:06not just here,
- 46:07but in heaven,
- 46:08in eternity,
- 46:09then I just don't see any wiggle room on that.
- 46:12All of time,
- 46:13according to the Bible,
- 46:14starts with the marriage and ends with the marriage,
- 46:15starts with the marriage between Adam and Eve,
- 46:17ends with a marriage between Christ,
- 46:19the groom,
- 46:20and
- 46:20the church,
- 46:21his bride,
- 46:22and um,
- 46:24It seems like it's,
- 46:26uh,
- 46:27it's a lot of audacity to say,
- 46:29yeah,
- 46:29that thing that is such a fixture in Christian theology,
- 46:33I'm just gonna set it to the side because this is how I feel.
- 46:36Um,
- 46:36there are a lot of things that I feel that we
- 46:38all feel that are contrary to our calling as Christians that
- 46:42we are called to deny,
- 46:44and I do understand why that is a hard message.
- 46:48Yeah,
- 46:49and you could feel it,
- 46:50you know.
- 46:51And I'm sure you,
- 46:53you feel it even in your follow-up conversations,
- 46:55this,
- 46:55um,
- 46:57Begging is too strong of a word,
- 47:00but there was,
- 47:00there was like a,
- 47:01a deep,
- 47:01uh,
- 47:02pleading
- 47:03to try and find some alignment,
- 47:04uh,
- 47:05and I,
- 47:05it came from other cast members as well.
- 47:07That was actually probably the most prevalent issue,
- 47:10um,
- 47:11from the episode was disagreement around.
- 47:14LGBTQ
- 47:16issues and
- 47:18And sexuality.
- 47:20And I'm curious,
- 47:21you know,
- 47:22just looking forward,
- 47:23cause people are moving back towards religion.
- 47:25I think this is something that's
- 47:27being observed uh in a few different places.
- 47:31Do you think there's a,
- 47:32a peaceful
- 47:34and productive path forward,
- 47:36um,
- 47:37You know,
- 47:38as both
- 47:39gay and straight and.
- 47:42You know,
- 47:42whoever
- 47:43maybe finds their way back towards the faith,
- 47:45do you think there can be some sort of like peaceful coexistence,
- 47:48even if there is
- 47:50significant disagreement
- 47:52um between these kind of two camps of Christianity.
- 47:56Um,
- 47:57cause yeah,
- 47:57that,
- 47:58that there was like this tension,
- 47:59it was like,
- 47:59can we reconcile this
- 48:01difference
- 48:02or,
- 48:03or,
- 48:03or how do we move forward?
- 48:06Yeah,
- 48:07I mean,
- 48:07I think if there were more conversations like the one that we had,
- 48:11and if everyone were like Gilbert,
- 48:13and I'm not saying that everyone on my side of things is like,
- 48:16oh,
- 48:16so nice and peaceful,
- 48:17and I'm not trying to say that,
- 48:18but
- 48:19I,
- 48:20I do think those conversations help,
- 48:22but we have to be able to like,
- 48:25like I'm not,
- 48:26I'm not going to
- 48:27change on that,
- 48:28and I don't think God's word is gonna change on that.
- 48:30And so do I think that we would be going to the same church?
- 48:34No.
- 48:35But of course,
- 48:36do I want peace for him?
- 48:37Do I want joy for him?
- 48:39Do I want like closeness by God to him?
- 48:42Of course I want those things.
- 48:44And so
- 48:45I think that we can go from that perspective.
- 48:47I mean,
- 48:47obviously Jesus calls to calls us to love our neighbor
- 48:51and love our enemies,
- 48:52not to say that Gilbert or anyone is my enemy,
- 48:55but I'm just saying that's how radical the love.
- 48:58That Jesus calls us to is,
- 49:00we might not always have empathy for our enemies,
- 49:03but Jesus says,
- 49:04you know,
- 49:05it's not determined by how you feel about them,
- 49:07it's not determined by whether you can relate for them.
- 49:09I'm calling you to love them because I can give you the power to do that,
- 49:13um,
- 49:13and I think that's really,
- 49:14really important,
- 49:15and we can speak the truth in love,
- 49:17um,
- 49:17but what I think the other side has to be OK with
- 49:21is that,
- 49:23You
- 49:24cannot mistake my
- 49:26refusal to affirm your decisions and your stated identity as hate
- 49:32or as bigotry,
- 49:32because that,
- 49:33I mean,
- 49:33that just leaves us in a lurch.
- 49:35I mean,
- 49:36because I'm not gonna compromise,
- 49:37and if you say that you're not gonna change,
- 49:39but I still wanna be your friend,
- 49:41I still wanna love you,
- 49:43but I can't celebrate all of your choices,
- 49:46don't confuse love and affirmation.
- 49:49I think that is a form of toxic empathy,
- 49:51but if you confuse love and total affirmation of your decisions,
- 49:55that is going to create a really big divide.
- 49:58Hm.
- 49:59I think it's really well put.
- 50:01And it's a difficult task,
- 50:04but I really like the way,
- 50:05I really like the way you articulated it,
- 50:08um,
- 50:08because
- 50:09that task exists on multiple fronts,
- 50:12uh,
- 50:12culturally right now.
- 50:14Um,
- 50:16something new that came up in the episode,
- 50:18and you know
- 50:19there was,
- 50:20there were some stalemates,
- 50:21you know,
- 50:21like
- 50:22Gilbert was,
- 50:23was frustrated because he's like
- 50:25if somebody experiences,
- 50:26uh,
- 50:27same-sex attraction or they,
- 50:28they believe that they were made gay
- 50:31and they,
- 50:32they wanna love somebody but they can't act on that,
- 50:35we're asking them to be celibate and,
- 50:36and what a massive sacrifice that is and
- 50:39And there was lots of interesting debate around that.
- 50:41I'm curious what the biggest sacrifice.
- 50:45Or one of the biggest sacrifices you've made for your faith is,
- 50:48um,
- 50:49just,
- 50:50I just wanted to kind of know more on your side.
- 50:53Yeah,
- 50:54well,
- 50:54gosh,
- 50:54I,
- 50:55well,
- 50:55first of all,
- 50:55I think I did acknowledge in the
- 50:57conversation that it is.
- 50:59I'm not putting all sacrifices on the exact same level.
- 51:02We are all called to sacrifice,
- 51:05but I also see just as a mom,
- 51:06like
- 51:07my kids,
- 51:08and this is a smaller scale,
- 51:09I'm not saying this is the same thing what you're talking about,
- 51:11it's more of an analogy of like,
- 51:13my kids have different proclivities and different personalities,
- 51:16and one of my children is just a lot more,
- 51:19she's just a lot quicker to listen and to do exactly
- 51:22like what she needs to do.
- 51:23And she's just very naturally generous and naturally compassionate.
- 51:27Like
- 51:28she would give the shirt off her back.
- 51:30And of course we're trying to foster compassion in our kids,
- 51:32but that is natural for her,
- 51:33whereas,
- 51:34you know,
- 51:35maybe one of my other kids,
- 51:36that's not her first instinct.
- 51:38OK?
- 51:38She might be,
- 51:39she might do that eventually because it's the right thing to do,
- 51:41but her first instinct is like,
- 51:42hang on,
- 51:42are you gonna,
- 51:43are you gonna take my magnet tiles?
- 51:44because if you're gonna take it,
- 51:45then I'm not gonna play with you.
- 51:47So,
- 51:48I'm already.
- 51:48Seen
- 51:49that there are different things that all of us struggle with,
- 51:53and different things that we are called to sacrifice and deny ourselves on.
- 51:56But what I acknowledge to Gilbert,
- 51:58and I think it's important for Christians to acknowledge
- 52:00that asking someone or saying that God is calling you to total celibacy is not
- 52:05the same.
- 52:06I mean,
- 52:06it is the same,
- 52:07but it's
- 52:08much more difficult than someone saying,
- 52:10hey,
- 52:10like,
- 52:10don't steal,
- 52:12don't murder.
- 52:13Um,
- 52:13like,
- 52:14that's pretty easy for most people,
- 52:16but asking someone to not be in a committed relationship
- 52:21with someone that they feel they're in love with,
- 52:23that is a big sacrifice
- 52:26to ask someone to make a difficult sacrifice to ask someone to make.
- 52:30And so I think we,
- 52:31I acknowledge that,
- 52:32while at the same time,
- 52:34not being able to move an inch from where God is in His word.
- 52:38Because as soon as I start saying,
- 52:39well yeah,
- 52:40that's a really difficult burden to bear,
- 52:41so maybe God's word just doesn't say that,
- 52:44well then of course that opens the door to justifying all kinds of sin.
- 52:47So I'm not saying that I have the same exact sacrifices as Gilbert or someone else,
- 52:51you know,
- 52:52I believe is called to make according to God's word.
- 52:54But there are a lot of things.
- 52:56My beliefs about what the Bible says about like women,
- 52:58like preaching in church or like
- 53:00being a pastor.
- 53:02I believe that God forbids that in His word.
- 53:04And I don't really want to do that,
- 53:06but I could.
- 53:07Like,
- 53:07I'm,
- 53:07I'm a communicator,
- 53:09and I love the Bible,
- 53:10and I could probably
- 53:12get up there and do it.
- 53:13Good sermon
- 53:13and they're speaking engagements that I've turned down.
- 53:16I suspect you'd be really good there's things,
- 53:18there's opportunities that I have turned down,
- 53:21money
- 53:22that I've turned down,
- 53:23platforms that I've turned down because,
- 53:25you know,
- 53:25I won't preach to a mixed crowd at a church on Sunday morning.
- 53:29Um,
- 53:29and again,
- 53:29I'm not saying that's the same,
- 53:31but
- 53:32all of us are called to say no to certain things that God's word says no to.
- 53:42Ali,
- 53:42thank you so much.
- 53:43I wanna be respectful of your time.
- 53:44Just on behalf of Jubilee,
- 53:46thank you for stepping into the arena.
- 53:47And again,
- 53:48I,
- 53:48I really enjoyed the episode.
- 53:50I think people will get a lot from it,
- 53:52um,
- 53:52and I look forward to hopefully speaking again sometime.
- 53:55There's a lot more I would love to ask.
- 53:56Yeah,
- 53:57it was,
- 53:57it was really,
- 53:57really fun,
- 53:58and I just like,
- 53:59I loved the opportunity.
- 54:01I had a blast.
- 54:02So thank you to you and to everyone who was a part of it.
- 54:06It was really fun.
- 54:07Great.
- 54:08All right,
- 54:08well,
- 54:08take care and um,
- 54:10yeah,
- 54:10have a great rest of your day.
- 54:11Bye,
- 54:11Ali.
- 54:12You too.
- 54:14For more follow-up episodes of Surrounded,
- 54:16be sure to like,
- 54:17subscribe,
- 54:17leave us a positive review.
- 54:19If you want to see video versions of these discussions,
- 54:21they are on Jubilee's second YouTube channel called Tubili.
- 54:25If you want to hear more from me,
- 54:26you can find me on YouTube or on X,
- 54:28John Regalado.
- 54:30Thanks so much for listening.
- 54:31Remember,
- 54:32you could be wrong,
- 54:33so could I.
- 54:34Keep your mind open.
- 54:35Until next time.