Latest / Newcomer Pod / Jim Lanzone — "They Had a Chance to Sell for $44 Billion. They Didn't."
Transcript
- 0:00Those of us you know who ran search engines, we'd be on stage
- 0:03and, and and talking. But in the audience were all the
- 0:06spammers, all the. Whole SEO we take advantage.
- 0:09Of the whole SEO community and if you went outside or to the
- 0:12bar afterwards, everyone's together and that game of trying
- 0:16to send traffic for their own purposes, that's not new.
- 0:19Why is Yahoo Finance still #1 why is Yahoo Sports top two?
- 0:23Why do so many people want aggregated news?
- 0:25And like, what can we do to lean into that?
- 0:26Why is Yahoo Mail still so popular?
- 0:28And it it the spine of that book is is always goes back.
- 0:31What is it? What's?
- 0:32The answer It always goes back to Jerry and David's original
- 0:35founding of the company. They were trying to be the guide
- 0:37to the Internet, but every now and then that is.
- 0:38The norm that is contrary. To OK, but think about why that
- 0:42happened. Everyone who was involved was
- 0:44not a traditional search product manager or engineer.
- 0:47They all came out of academia and so the the UI, not
- 0:51surprisingly, looks like an academic research paper.
- 0:54My guest today has been CEO of ask.com, CEO of Tinder, and now
- 0:58CEO of Yahoo. If you're sensing a theme, it's
- 1:00that Jim Lanzone has spent his entire career betting on
- 1:03companies the Internet forgot about and making them matter
- 1:07again. The question is, can he do it
- 1:08one more time with guy closing in from every direction?
- 1:12Here's my conversation with Jim Lanzone.
- 1:22Search wars, the streaming wars and the search wars again.
- 1:25And I'm sure there are 50 other online wars you've been engaged
- 1:29in. You're obviously running Yahoo.
- 1:33Some people remember it from there.
- 1:35You know, maybe me. My college e-mail I think was
- 1:38Elfman. I won't say the exact numbers,
- 1:41Elfman something back in sort of a we'll go find AD and D type
- 1:44era of Eric Newcomer, but obviously still a huge Center
- 1:49for traffic. You're obviously doing a lot to
- 1:52stay current in the AI era, like where is just give us the
- 1:56snapshot of sort of Yahoo in terms of who's using it today.
- 2:00Yeah, I think it's it's surprising people for some
- 2:02reason, even though, you know, Google is 28 years old and
- 2:05Amazon's also 30 years old. eBay, I think Twitter just had
- 2:08its 20th anniversary. Yeah.
- 2:10It's funny that Yahoo, probably just because the history of it
- 2:13like does kind of get talked about as being around a long
- 2:16time you. Know it defined 1.
- 2:19Era, it has had a lot of ups and downs and that's part of the
- 2:22story. And and you know, we can talk
- 2:24about some of that. But the interesting thing about
- 2:26Yahoo is for all the corporate difficulties, you know, through
- 2:29time as a public company selling to Verizon, Then we bought it
- 2:32and spun it back out at the end 2021 which.
- 2:35Seems like a good deal. Apollo got it for around 5
- 2:39billion after all that, so it is still today.
- 2:44Now Fast forward to 2026, in the last comScore rankings, we were
- 2:48third in the United States until traffic.
- 2:50We're almost 250 million users in the US, which is almost 90%
- 2:54of the US Interestingly, about 50% of our audience stays Gen.
- 3:00Z and Millennial. I think when you cover 90% of
- 3:03the US, you have to be that cover that broad of a group and
- 3:08that's actually our fastest growing group and things like
- 3:10Yahoo Mail, which you might associate as being an older
- 3:12product for the Elf man and others.
- 3:16And it's about 700 million, you know, worldwide users and that
- 3:19that's after we've shut we actually got out of a lot of
- 3:22countries when I first got here and we were the turn around
- 3:24team. There were a lot of things that
- 3:25we had to do to kind of get the company on the right foot.
- 3:28So we kind of got out of some countries that that weren't that
- 3:31didn't make sense. So it is still that big and the
- 3:35way we get to that size is different than a lot of you know
- 3:38there are a lot of companies that are one product companies,
- 3:41right you got. Finance, you've got sort of this
- 3:43and. We are a conglomerate.
- 3:44They're, they're all Yahoo branded.
- 3:46And we, we did have some brands like AOL that, that were not
- 3:49Yahoo branded that we've sold along the way, but we are now
- 3:52all Yahoo branded. And yeah, finance, sports, mail,
- 3:56news is still top three things like weather are still, you
- 4:00know, top five and still still very big properties.
- 4:03And then search, I think is, is still surprised that in the US
- 4:07we're still the third ranked search engine.
- 4:08Now that's that's far away from from Google, but but still a lot
- 4:12of traffic in a very, you know, lucrative category.
- 4:15So we're all those things together kind of add up that the
- 4:17Yahoo brand itself doesn't mean one, there's not like, you know,
- 4:20just one property that yahoo.com, which we've kind of
- 4:24been working on over the past few years is a hub for all those
- 4:27things. But you know, again, there are
- 4:28many companies that just do one thing, and that's not us.
- 4:32Is and there are lots of pieces of it that I want to talk about
- 4:35you used to own tech crunch. You touch the news, obviously as
- 4:38a news person, it's interesting to me.
- 4:40I but you know, you Yahoo obviously fought with Google
- 4:44through search, made some, I guess failed partnership
- 4:48decisions. You've criticized them yourself.
- 4:50What was what was the key mistake?
- 4:51It's sort of outsourced search, right?
- 4:53Well, it's the interesting thing is Yahoo has always talked about
- 4:55as having lost search to Google and, and kind of shit on for
- 4:59that and talked about what, what you shouldn't do strategically,
- 5:01but that's not actually what happened.
- 5:03And again, that's 26 years since this happened.
- 5:06And, and it was before many generations of Yahoo, let alone
- 5:10mine. But from the beginning, 1995, it
- 5:13always Yahoo always outsourced search, interestingly, because I
- 5:17think they helped popularize search, but that search box was
- 5:21outsourced through enterprise deals.
- 5:23So I can't remember who it initially was, but it became ink
- 5:26to me. And then during the crash
- 5:29period, during the first web, you know, one point O crash in
- 5:33June of 2000, which is kind of the big month that it really
- 5:36felt everything fell apart for the industry.
- 5:39They switched to Google because it was the best search engine
- 5:42and that became the enterprise solution for Yahoo Search.
- 5:46The big mistake that was made is that in order to save money and
- 5:49get a better deal, they gave Google a link back to Google on
- 5:54every search results page. That was the Google logo.
- 5:57So if you did a search on Yahoo and you clicked on that logo, it
- 6:00would do the search on Google. And so people just they're.
- 6:03Training people just go. Oh my, I've said it's it's
- 6:06almost like Chacha PT or clawed having a logo on every Google
- 6:10search results page now you know, they would.
- 6:13So that's that, that kicked off, you know, I think, you know, a
- 6:18couple decades of trying to figure out, you know, how to
- 6:20make up for that because Google, you know, search became, you
- 6:23know, the, the best revenue model that you could possibly
- 6:25have. But in June of 2000, there
- 6:27wasn't one. Right.
- 6:28And you can see the philosophy. It's like we link out to news
- 6:30organizations where helpful. We we get people to go to the
- 6:34place we trust where you know, yeah, where the portal.
- 6:37But obviously in retrospect, a huge strategic error.
- 6:41So, you know, you're not even thinking probably about the
- 6:44company at the time, but now, you know, you run the company
- 6:47that made that decision. So now we enter the chatbot era.
- 6:51Like do you think first of all, does the chat bot replace the
- 6:56Internet or where, how much of sort of Internet activity do you
- 7:00think will, you know in a decade flow through me talking to a
- 7:04sort of an AI chat bot? Yeah, I mean, I'd say still
- 7:10somewhat unclear. It's, it's a bit of a misnomer
- 7:14to say that finally now going beyond 10 blue links in my, my
- 7:18first run through search, you know, I spent my first ten years
- 7:20in or so in search. That was when we really went
- 7:23beyond 10 blue links. It was literally 10 links.
- 7:26Alta Vista kind of popularized that UI.
- 7:28Google picked it up from there. And then in the mid 2000s, we
- 7:32all started building structured data search into the page.
- 7:35So if you think about like. You're getting answers.
- 7:37Whether lyrics, sports scores, you know, multimedia, these
- 7:42things all started to have local information maps.
- 7:45They all started happening over time.
- 7:48So it's interesting now that area is popular, you know on
- 7:53Google is populated by AI mode. So now you're kind of getting
- 7:57chatbot responses, which are their own flavor of search.
- 8:00They're not, they don't replace all of search.
- 8:03And I think this next step of a gentic, which is still very
- 8:07early, I think thinking about the the search box as the
- 8:12interface for doing anything probably does make a lot of
- 8:16sense. Interestingly, because that's
- 8:17where everything started. If you think about how Yahoo
- 8:19started in 1995, it was a directory that then led to news
- 8:23and mail and fancy sports and other things coming into that
- 8:26becoming the portal. But it started with the search
- 8:28box. And to think that all the way
- 8:31through now, 30 years later, that search box is about to
- 8:35become the Iron Man suit and and power everything that you might
- 8:38be able to do to do is really interesting.
- 8:41I do, I do think it tends to go that way.
- 8:43And you see that now where WhatsApp has a chatbot, you
- 8:47know, built in, Snap has it built in.
- 8:50So it's that is starting to happen.
- 8:52And what that turns into, I think is still to be written to.
- 8:55Defend the portal. My problem with chat bots is
- 8:58that I need to have an idea of what I want to do and it's sort
- 9:01of like I really need to have a plan and really sort of pursue
- 9:05something. There's value to be like, oh,
- 9:07what's going on? Like give me, give me sort of a
- 9:10picture of it. Like do you think sort of the, I
- 9:13mean, you're, you're sort of playing both in that you're
- 9:15making sure you're in a good position on chat bots and you
- 9:18obviously have the the key portal strategy.
- 9:20But do you think the regular consumer is going to want this
- 9:24chat bot all the time for all their sort of like information
- 9:27needs? Or is that is it too much work
- 9:29to ask the news consumer I. Think people in our industry
- 9:33can, especially everyone who's building all night now, you
- 9:37know, with all these new tools that are coming, you know, are
- 9:41available, do forget how much the industry itself is, is not
- 9:46the same as your average user out on the street.
- 9:49So those people do tend to want things done for them.
- 9:51They want things that are free. They don't want to put in the
- 9:55extra effort. I mean, if I go back to web one
- 9:57point O search, my favorite was that 85% of users if you
- 10:02surveyed them said they wanted advanced search, which you
- 10:05probably don't remember what that is.
- 10:06It was boolean. Search I remember.
- 10:09One less than 1% used it. They they said they wanted but
- 10:12they want the power. It didn't actually they, they
- 10:14want and we've all put in a lot of effort in that day and age
- 10:18into thinking about how to get, you know, them to construct
- 10:22queries a certain way. And that all went away.
- 10:24It just became go to the search box, spit it out.
- 10:27And it's up to us on the other side of that box to deal with
- 10:30it. And I do think, especially when
- 10:32it comes to search, that that's where it's going to head.
- 10:34And and we could talk about it, but we, you know, you know, a
- 10:38month and a half ago launched our own AI search product called
- 10:42Yahoo Scout. And to your point in the portal,
- 10:44we also just launched last week the next generation of what used
- 10:50to be known as my Yahoo, which was very popular Silk high value
- 10:53product, which is your own personalized version of the
- 10:56Yahoo portal. I feel like I had all these
- 10:58different colors. Yeah.
- 10:59And people loved it and they could move things around on the
- 11:00page and but that was done in a very rudimentary, you know, old
- 11:05school way. But it was popular.
- 11:07We had to shut that down when I got here because the the
- 11:11platform it was built on was so old that to upgrade it was just
- 11:14going to be just incredibly expensive.
- 11:17And we just decided to build it over again, knowing that AI was
- 11:20on the way. So we just last week launched my
- 11:23Scout, which looks a lot like the old my Yahoo, but it is it
- 11:26is built by and on top of our AI search platform.
- 11:31So it it automatically builds for you on on the page and just
- 11:37by querying, you know, querying scout, you can actually create
- 11:41your own categories. So anything you want can now
- 11:45become a tile for your own personalized portal on the page.
- 11:48Right. So it's not the chatbot can help
- 11:50you sort of have defaults and you can already see sometimes
- 11:52with Chachi BT, they're like suggesting questions you can ask
- 11:56like it's clear that all that's yeah, that's different than just
- 11:59like a portal you go to, but well.
- 12:01And also they're, they are limited to date by what the, the
- 12:04thing they know about you is your search history.
- 12:09And so Pulse, which is their first product was very much
- 12:11based on the searches you've been doing.
- 12:14Oh, do you want to know how to become a better CEO of Yahoo?
- 12:16How do you about these, these health issues you've asked me
- 12:19about, you know, whatever these things are going on with your
- 12:21kids, like whatever you've been asking is kind of what they
- 12:23suggest up in their portal. We do have a built in advantage
- 12:26in that if if you are a logged in Yahoo user and over 70% of
- 12:30our users are logged in on any given day, we start to populate
- 12:34it automatically with Yahoo Finance.
- 12:35You know, with stock quotes, with sports scores, with
- 12:37headlines, with your mail, all those things, your, your
- 12:40location, your weather, they all automatically populate and then
- 12:43you can add categories onto it from from there.
- 12:47All right, so you're, you're preparing for new fronts right
- 12:50now, which we are. You know what, you, you, I, I
- 12:53never covered like the media streaming wars.
- 12:55I, it was very important, I think in the, the peak streaming
- 12:59days, but it's, it's a moment to talk to advertisers.
- 13:02I, I imagine it's especially interesting with open AI mean
- 13:05like we want to get into advertising your sort of, you
- 13:08know, have more and more of an AI pitch.
- 13:11Like what is the dynamic in new fronts broadly today?
- 13:14Like what do you think the key themes that people are grabbing
- 13:16onto? And and then we can talk about
- 13:18Yahoo specifically. I mean, I think different for
- 13:20everybody. The way the way the new fronts
- 13:22started many years ago was to give online streamers and I used
- 13:27to work at CBS and and we had CBS All Access, which became
- 13:31Paramount Plus. We had our own version of this,
- 13:33but it was built on, not. Just workout.
- 13:34I think you're a pretty important guy.
- 13:36I ran digital for them. So, but they, you know, for
- 13:40decades they had the upfronts, which, which was, you know, for
- 13:43CBS, we had Carnegie Hall and, and the whole AG community would
- 13:47come in and you would, you would tell them the new shows for the
- 13:49next fall season and all the stars would show up and they'd
- 13:53have a party afterwards and they would be there to take photos.
- 13:56I think they called it the petting zoo where you would
- 13:59have, you would have the logos over every show and all the
- 14:01stars would be there to take photos with all the press and
- 14:03all the advertisers that would be in attendance.
- 14:05The new fronts was a version of that for Hulu and YouTube and
- 14:09and Netflix, you know eventually once they had advertising and
- 14:11others. So yahoos version of that is a
- 14:14little bit different because we do have shows so but they are
- 14:18very much part of our verticals. So for sports and for finance,
- 14:22we have nonfiction content that is, you know, really trying to
- 14:26help you with the decisions you're making, the goals you're
- 14:29trying to achieve in those categories.
- 14:30So they're we're, we're not breaking news, we're not getting
- 14:33scoops. We are providing context in that
- 14:36category. So we have Kevin O'Connor, who's
- 14:38the number one NBA podcast. We have Ariel Helwani, who's the
- 14:41number one MMA podcast, and Brian Sauzi and our our people
- 14:45on on Yahoo Finance and others. So we do about 60 hours a week
- 14:50of original programming now for sports, almost that much for
- 14:52finance. But for the most part, we also
- 14:55have, you know, this whole network of other products,
- 14:57right? We're a product company at the
- 14:59end of the day. And so our new front is really
- 15:02talking about all the new products that we're launching
- 15:05with the new Yahoo, all the things that have evolved in our
- 15:08audience. You guys are everybody's doing.
- 15:10Them this is just your own individual.
- 15:12OK, but do they happen? They all happen.
- 15:14Around different places. You all rent out CBS in the old
- 15:17days. It's the same period of time.
- 15:19Everybody's sort of NBC V Radio City.
- 15:21You would all have. So we have a place a few blocks
- 15:24away from here in midtown and tomorrow night at six O clock to
- 15:288:00 PM we will have two dedicated hours for Yahoo with
- 15:32me kicking it off. Somehow been convinced to wear a
- 15:36cowboy outfit on stage to start it off in the big opening and
- 15:41all our GMs get up and talk about all the all the parts of
- 15:44the company. Are you optimistic about
- 15:47advertising in language models in chat bots?
- 15:51Well, that one's a different. That's a whole new thing.
- 15:53Well, I just think I'm talking. Like advertisers on the mind
- 15:57that's, that's just a big question right now so.
- 16:01Yeah, we can. In way back in the day, my
- 16:03company, we were the first ones to switch from Overture to
- 16:06Google Adwords. Like I go way back in in the
- 16:08search category and I'm very passionate that that search
- 16:14advertising does need to cross the chasm to AI search in that
- 16:19while it won't be one for one efficient, meaning, you know,
- 16:23keyword targeted link blue links that look just like the
- 16:27editorial links. We're a great business model
- 16:29for, you know, 25 years now. It will look a little bit
- 16:34different and probably will be somewhat less efficient in this
- 16:37new UI. But I think actually the
- 16:39characteristics of the two are actually more similar than
- 16:42people would think. And there's a little work that
- 16:44needs to be done to, to bring them over and how you're going
- 16:46to match keywords and how you're going to render it.
- 16:48But I actually think, you know, this new environment will be
- 16:52more similar to to traditional search than people think in, in
- 16:56that way. With Yahoo Scout, we actually
- 16:59one of the core values of the product has been that
- 17:03forgetting, sorry, forgetting a very Italian with how I'm
- 17:07talking, forgetting, you know, the, the search advertising part
- 17:13of it for editorial for, you know, you know, just the
- 17:17traditional listings themselves for the results themselves.
- 17:21What we've done with Scout is we've actually put a lot of work
- 17:23into linking back out to publishers.
- 17:26So all in our results, which if you go to scout.com, you'll find
- 17:32our own, you know, Yahoo powered AI search products.
- 17:35The results are really good. They're really unique and I can
- 17:38talk about why that is, but also in the UI you'll see a lot of
- 17:41blue highlights all through. And that's what publishers like
- 17:45me want, right? We want the old world where it's
- 17:47like send us traffic. And in some ways you're sort of
- 17:51saying that aligns with advertisers because they would
- 17:53like people to actually go to their sites, Whereas the, the
- 17:57sort of ethos of a chat bot is the answer is here.
- 18:01And so I guess, do you think, well, you, you maybe disagree
- 18:04with that, but that is certainly the big, you know, anthropic
- 18:07open AI, they are trying to solve the problem in the box.
- 18:10Like, do you think that type of ad will send people elsewhere or
- 18:14advertisers are going to need to be content with?
- 18:18Well, they got exposure to me sort of in in this context, They
- 18:21didn't necessarily go to my website.
- 18:23We'll start with our editorial results at Scout.
- 18:26They link elsewhere so our results are by paragraph, but
- 18:31every now. And then contrary.
- 18:33To it, OK, but think about why that happened.
- 18:35So first of all, let's start here.
- 18:37It's extremely important to link out to the publishers who
- 18:40created this content in the 1st place.
- 18:42Without it, whether you're a large language model or anybody
- 18:45else, you won't have any content to bring together in a answer to
- 18:49provide value to the user, right?
- 18:51So those publishers surviving and thriving is extremely
- 18:55important to everyone involved. Why didn't that happen with the
- 18:59first generation of chatbot AI search results?
- 19:04I just don't think they prioritized it.
- 19:06Everyone who was involved was not a traditional search product
- 19:09manager or engineer. They all came out of academia,
- 19:12right? Whether they were deep mind and,
- 19:14and or then went to open AI, that was their background.
- 19:17And so the, the UI, not surprisingly, looks like an
- 19:21academic research paper. And they were, they had sources
- 19:24at the end that were, you know, footnotes essentially that you
- 19:27would find in a research paper. And so not surprisingly, they're
- 19:30not very prominent in the UI. Not that many people click on
- 19:34them. I mean, I think it's less than
- 19:35like 1% of, you know, AI search results in a Click to one of
- 19:40those sources. And I think that was just a, you
- 19:44know, trick of how the UI of this first generation was done.
- 19:48Google was caught flat footed, I think by the launch of Chacha
- 19:50PT. And of course, because they are
- 19:54by far number one in search, they had to counter that UI that
- 19:58Chachu is helping define, define the category.
- 20:02So whether or not they wanted to embrace it or or not, they they
- 20:05had to. And so that's why Gemini's
- 20:07first, you know, version of this looks like that with Scout, we
- 20:11are trying to take it a different direction.
- 20:13We're much smaller. We have less at stake.
- 20:17And we I think have have the luxury of being able to employ a
- 20:22different UI and kind of help show the way on that.
- 20:26I do think eventually all AI chat bots need to for the their
- 20:30own good meaning like being able to monetize without subscription
- 20:35because that's not going to get you all the way.
- 20:36There are going to need to find a way to link out both because
- 20:41it's good for the health of the Internet, good for the health of
- 20:43publishers without whom we won't have this content.
- 20:45And then, yeah, I do think that there will be paid versions of
- 20:48that that will look and operate somewhat like traditional search
- 20:52advertising. And without linking out, you
- 20:54won't be able to do that either. Right.
- 20:57I, I never, I hadn't connected the publisher piece to the
- 21:00advertising piece. That gives me the most hope that
- 21:03these models need to push out a little bit because they're going
- 21:05to need to push out for their advertisers.
- 21:07And so maybe then they push out. So I, I can see that, but I
- 21:12don't know, the tech industry has gotten so extractive like
- 21:14this, this view that you're articulating of we need to take
- 21:17care of the underlying like media organizations or content
- 21:21providers so that we have the content to aggregate that.
- 21:25That does seem like sort of the Yahoo Spirit like of yesteryear,
- 21:28but it feels like that's sort of been forgotten in a world where
- 21:31Google is just not linking to any.
- 21:33Like, I don't, I don't know, I don't see the rest of the tech
- 21:35industry embracing that sort of we need to maintain sort of all
- 21:40the fuel that we're using underneath.
- 21:42Well, I think another thing will drive them that way, which is I
- 21:44think it will wind up being shown over time that it is
- 21:48better for users as well to have the sources show up more
- 21:53prominently. In our case, not only do the
- 21:55blue highlights are they linking out, but if you hover over them,
- 21:57you see the source. And that's just extremely useful
- 22:01for someone, you know, doing the research.
- 22:03As you know, these things hallucinate.
- 22:05They're not they're, they're dated.
- 22:06Sometimes they don't always provide the right information
- 22:09depending on the category and the number one category for
- 22:11Yahoo Scout so far, you know, only a month and 1/2 in is
- 22:15health. You do want to validate these
- 22:17sources and not just take for granted that the engine will is
- 22:21providing an accurate result. So I actually think it's good
- 22:24for publishers. I think it's good from a
- 22:26monetization point of view, but I think most importantly, in a
- 22:29lot of ways it's better for the user as well just because it
- 22:33has, it is still early. We're still only three years
- 22:35into this, and that UI that has become the default I, I, you
- 22:40know, was a, you know, a fluke of how it was launched.
- 22:44I mean, I don't even think they anticipate how popular it was
- 22:46going to be if you go back and do this.
- 22:48Yeah, you know. Everybody, yeah, I'll ChatGPT.
- 22:50I was like Oh my God. Wow, this is crazy.
- 22:52That's right. And so, so that's, that isn't
- 22:55the UI that had to, you know, that had to be.
- 22:58And I don't think it's what Google would have launched if
- 23:00they had come out the gates first.
- 23:02Do you have a view on how copyrights going to net out?
- 23:05I mean, the Trump administration just put out their sort of AI
- 23:09guidelines, which I thought were somewhat thin.
- 23:11I don't have a full view on all of them.
- 23:13But one of them was sort of like, we should let the courts,
- 23:16I guess, decide on copyright. Like, we're not going to come
- 23:18down super hard. And that that's going to play
- 23:20out if it's into what we were talking about, just because if
- 23:23you're not, if you're not emphasizing pushing people to
- 23:27links, it feels more and more like you're just stealing their
- 23:30IP if you're just using it for your own answer.
- 23:32Like, have you done an analysis on how much you think sort of
- 23:36models could get hit with copyright at the end of this or
- 23:39they're just too ubiquitous and they've just won by being like,
- 23:42so dominant? Yeah, I'm not.
- 23:44Yeah, not a lawyer. Just play one on TVI.
- 23:47Have lawyers running around. Well, it's interesting.
- 23:49I mean, I do think that for 30 years the social contract of the
- 23:56Internet and of search was that a search engine would crawl you
- 24:00unless you with robots TXT you decide you didn't want to be
- 24:03crawled for whatever reason. And then search engines
- 24:05respected that or were supposed to.
- 24:08And that the social contract was that they would take a snippet
- 24:11and the link and they would link back out to you.
- 24:14And then if you wanted to have other information like, you
- 24:17know, lyrics, you would actually or, or images, you would acquire
- 24:20those from a structured data provider and then you would add
- 24:23those to the to the page. So, but the reason you wanted to
- 24:26be crawled and you want it was you want traffic.
- 24:28And that was how you had a business so that you could keep
- 24:31creating that content. So if you start to go to a world
- 24:33where that content is is taken, digested and interestingly, not
- 24:39even for the answers, but to be able to predict it's auto
- 24:43complete, you know, to predict the next word or a letter or
- 24:47token. I mean, it's just, you know,
- 24:49that was never contemplated when you were coming up with this.
- 24:51And I feel for the companies who are really based on Evergreen
- 24:56content. You know, with Yahoo, we are one
- 24:58of the top 20 publishers whose, you know, content shows up in an
- 25:03LLM. So we are on weirdly on both
- 25:05sides of this. With deals you struck or just.
- 25:08No, no, no. They're just taking, yeah.
- 25:11We are not suing over it. No, we haven't.
- 25:13We have not. We've not done that at this
- 25:16point, but. You know when the you have a
- 25:18clock, you're like, oh, we have to decide by.
- 25:21No, I mean it's, it's, you know, it's interesting that that even
- 25:25the people who are being paid don't believe that they're going
- 25:28to be able to make enough of a living that way.
- 25:31So that's the other interesting thing happening here.
- 25:33I think only 20% saw a survey. Only 20% of publishers believe
- 25:37that they can they can make enough money by selling their
- 25:41content to large language models.
- 25:43Well, like. The publish some publishers
- 25:46struck what seemed like a huge deal with Anthropic.
- 25:48I don't know the numbers, but then if you look on a per book
- 25:50basis, it's it's not like you could write books for a living.
- 25:53Just being like, Oh well, this book is going to well.
- 25:54That's books. I mean just talk about web
- 25:56publishers. I mean, 10s of 1,000,000 is
- 25:58probably not going to cut it for the, the level of businesses
- 26:00that, that these companies are running.
- 26:03So something else has to happen. I, I believe what needs to
- 26:06happen is, is they need to, before it's too late, do the
- 26:10right thing and link out and do the, let's do the right thing
- 26:13for the users and do the right thing for publishers.
- 26:15So let's start with trying to get there first, you know,
- 26:17before we worry about, you know, just just throwing in the towel
- 26:20and, and saying this is the way it's always going to be.
- 26:23But I, I really, you know, again, it's not just Pollyanna
- 26:26like, Hey, let's do this and try to be good, the good guys here.
- 26:30We are trying to be the good guys on that for sure.
- 26:34We think it's the right thing to do.
- 26:35But I also really do find it really valuable in the UI.
- 26:37And I think if you use Scout you'll feel the same way.
- 26:41Finance is obviously a huge important vertical one that I
- 26:44think about a lot. Do you, how much do you think a
- 26:50retail trader is going to become smarter because of LMS or do
- 26:53you, how much are you trying? Are you doing anything to give
- 26:55them advice based on what language models think and like
- 26:58what do you see in terms of, yeah, just like the retail
- 27:01trader and what they want or financial environment in this
- 27:04new world? Well, one dirty secret of that
- 27:07is is that, you know, of course, Yahoo Finance for 30 years, you
- 27:12know, people have tried to copy it, tried to kill it.
- 27:15Google themselves. Interestingly, the person who
- 27:17started it for Google is on my board at Yahoo now.
- 27:21Katie Stanton. But but it's interesting how
- 27:25resilient that property has been over the years.
- 27:27And that's before, you know, I think we've really tried to make
- 27:29it better and have some other things coming that I think would
- 27:33be a lot better. Again, you fall into the the an
- 27:38area where the most basic features are the ones that are
- 27:43used the most. And so that deep, deep research
- 27:45is used by a smaller and smaller percentage of the charter base.
- 27:48We are, yeah. But but really, you know, stock
- 27:52quotes and news wound up being at the very top of that pyramid.
- 27:56And we are building things, you know, using AI, using Scout that
- 28:01allow, you know, people to go deeper and do hardcore research.
- 28:05And, and we do have things in the pipeline for that.
- 28:09We've also as part of the launch of Scout, we, we did launch
- 28:12features straight into every one of our products so far, not just
- 28:15finance, but fancy Sports News, e-mail, everything has got some
- 28:20bit of Scout, we call it the Scout intelligence platform kind
- 28:23of pushing features into it. And one is, you know, explain to
- 28:27you like what changed about the stock, why, you know, why is it
- 28:30trending in this direction, things like that.
- 28:33But yes, I I think, I think there is a future of much richer
- 28:38detailed products in every category that AI can help drive.
- 28:43One we've, we've sort of hit on twice the situation where the
- 28:48consumer doesn't want sort of the Super cheap features or like
- 28:51they like advanced search. And then on finance we're
- 28:53talking about, you know, it's like they, they want a couple
- 28:56things they're not necessarily doing like intense hardcore
- 28:59research. I feel like in sort of the AI
- 29:02consumer, somebody I think had a tweet I'm stealing, I'll have to
- 29:06go find it and throw it up on the screen.
- 29:08But basically the idea is that I think there are a lot of people
- 29:10who think consumers want AI to like save them time like like in
- 29:16business or like make me sort of more efficient, better at like
- 29:19calendaring or something. But it, but in a lot of cases
- 29:21what they actually want is sort of to waste time sort of more
- 29:24enjoyably. And they want AI to be like fun
- 29:27and and lively. And I, I guess I'm just getting
- 29:30at like, what do you think the consumer really wants from AI?
- 29:34Like where, where do you think there are real needs that LLMS
- 29:38can satisfy versus right now they're sort of just getting
- 29:41thrown? Yeah, things that researchers
- 29:44built sort of natively to them and stuff that's working for
- 29:47enterprises but isn't, doesn't really have like the consumer.
- 29:50It it is, it always has been category by category.
- 29:54So I think AI now is, you know, horizontal across everything
- 29:58that's happening out there. And it depends.
- 30:00So, so yeah. And, and I don't know what part
- 30:05of it you're using for entertainment is that like it's,
- 30:07it's your buddy and you're having you're having
- 30:08conversations. With me, I had the sort of like,
- 30:11oh, we're going to create like slop videos.
- 30:13My my wife has recently been sending me these.
- 30:17I don't know how much TikTok you waste your life watching, but
- 30:21they're a very viral TikTok at the moment is fruits like, you
- 30:25know, arguing with each other, like cheating on each other.
- 30:27It's like as if it's like the bachelor, but it is fruit and it
- 30:31is like it's the first time I I don't I found it terrible.
- 30:34I was like, this is I don't know why you're watching this, but
- 30:36it's like slop. You know, he's sort of hitting
- 30:39story in a way. Like I feel like this sort of
- 30:41like time wasting video is where it like can be sort of tested
- 30:46enough and it's just like throw shit at the wall and see what
- 30:48resonates with people. I don't know, I.
- 30:50That makes sense. That's that's just incremental.
- 30:52I mean, Amazon just announced AI Studios.
- 30:54I think Albert Chang was formerly ABC and Disney and is
- 30:59now running it. So there obviously is a future
- 31:03for that. It makes more sense in short
- 31:04form videos, right? Lower consequences and and it's
- 31:08more time. Burning spin up the whole movie.
- 31:10Yeah, but Tik Tok's not new or, or Reels is not new to how you
- 31:13or YouTube Shorts to how you've been spending time, you know,
- 31:16that's consumed much, much more of your entertainment time than
- 31:19it used to. So, you know, I think that makes
- 31:21sense. We we tend to operate much more
- 31:23in categories where they you're trying to get things done.
- 31:29So you do have a little bit more of that professional?
- 31:31Well, again, it's some of them are utilities.
- 31:34So I would say e-mail search, maybe weather are in the
- 31:38utilities category. We do have content category,
- 31:41sports and finance. But again, in finance you're
- 31:43trying to make more money or save money.
- 31:46Sports is the one where, you know, obviously that's
- 31:48entertainment, but Yahoo users are using it to play fantasy,
- 31:53beat the snot out of their friends.
- 31:55Take it too. Seriously, that win money, you
- 31:57know, they're, they're actually using it for, for these things.
- 31:59So not to be cheesy about it, but we did have to reset the
- 32:03mission of the company. When I got here, Yahoo was the
- 32:06turn around. It had been owned by Verizon for
- 32:08many years before that, serving whatever purposes they bought it
- 32:11for. Before that, it was a struggling
- 32:13public company having to make really hard choices about what
- 32:17it was going to do to survive and, and try to grow against
- 32:20some really hard headwinds of Google and Facebook and YouTube
- 32:22and, you know, social media, other other things.
- 32:25So, you know, we had a, the benefit almost of being able to
- 32:31only focus on what was good about Yahoo.
- 32:33We didn't have to worry about the rest of it.
- 32:34Why is Yahoo Finance still #1? Why is Yahoo Sports top two?
- 32:38Why do so many people want aggregated news?
- 32:40And like, what can we do to lean into that?
- 32:42Why is Yahoo Mail so pop still so popular?
- 32:44And it it the spine of that book is is always.
- 32:47What is it? What's the?
- 32:48Answer it always goes back to Jerry and David's original
- 32:51founding of the company. They were trying to be the guide
- 32:53to the Internet. It says it right on the original
- 32:56page, Jerry and David's Guide to the World Wide Web.
- 32:58And that started because Andreessen had started Mosaic
- 33:01and it was originally for, it said on the page for Mosaic.
- 33:06And it was because that you had access to the Internet, but you
- 33:08didn't know how to find anything.
- 33:10And then that evolved into doing things.
- 33:12And Yahoo is your home base, you know, for that.
- 33:14So we, you know, did not have infinite resources taking this
- 33:18over. Our job to do is to make sure we
- 33:20understood that people were using Yahoo for, and that was
- 33:24for trying to accomplish these goals in whatever category it
- 33:27was. So all of our focus and road map
- 33:29started to go behind that and that's when we started move out
- 33:32things that didn't. Right, but it's still rooted in
- 33:34the Internet or it's. All, all Internet, but you're
- 33:37using the Internet to accomplish those things.
- 33:40So when it comes to AI, we just launched literally today as an
- 33:45example in e-mail and you talk about entertainment versus
- 33:48calendar and all that. But we launched a product called
- 33:50Planner and it does go in using Scout technology and extracts
- 33:55all these like next step things that are demand need to demand
- 34:00your attention, that you need to know, you know, a deadline,
- 34:03something for your kids school, a flight doctor's appointment.
- 34:07It extracts that out and automatically adds it to your
- 34:09calendar. If you're, you know, or to A to
- 34:12do list and, and Yahoo and you're, you know, we have that
- 34:15feature as well. And that's using AI to remove
- 34:19steps so that you can get things done better and faster that you
- 34:22didn't have to think about. Like, I think that's a good one.
- 34:24I had my first fantasy baseball draft of the season last night
- 34:28and if you are a Yahoo Plus subscriber, it will be your
- 34:33research assistant and help you do a better job in your draft.
- 34:36So. So it really is category by
- 34:38category. I I buy that Yahoo is more of a
- 34:42friend to the Internet and some of these LMS because it's like,
- 34:46OK, we want to get people to the good stuff out there so they can
- 34:50find it. And that's really what the
- 34:51business has been about. But has that raw material just
- 34:55gotten, like, worse over time? Like, is the Internet just
- 34:58degrading? It feels like media is getting
- 35:02worse. You know, I think of like, even
- 35:05Reddit, which for a while I think there was a meme, it's
- 35:07like, oh, if you wanted a good Google search result, you just
- 35:09search what are they saying on Reddit?
- 35:11Which I think is somewhat true, but to some degree I worry more
- 35:15and more that Reddit posts are becoming like was this an LLMAMA
- 35:19or or is this a real 1? I don't know.
- 35:22Do you worry about just like the raw materials that you rely on
- 35:26on the Internet getting worse right now?
- 35:29I mean, I hate to always bring it back to this isn't new, but
- 35:32you know, if you go back to my first time and search Danny
- 35:36Sullivan, if you remember Danny, but he had the biggest search
- 35:38engine conference 5000 people would go and it those of us you
- 35:43know who ran search engines, we'd be on stage and and and
- 35:47talking, but in the audience were all the spammers, all the.
- 35:51The whole SEO, how can we take advantage?
- 35:52Of the whole SEO community and if you went outside or or to the
- 35:55bar afterwards, everyone's together.
- 35:57And that game of trying to send traffic for their own purposes,
- 36:02that's not new. And yeah, there were there are
- 36:05really good SE OS who are trying to be helpful for publishers and
- 36:07there's ones who are trying to gain the engines to, you know,
- 36:10drive it to to, you know, lower tier traffic.
- 36:14That is not a new game. I don't think AI slop.
- 36:17I think that's another part of it.
- 36:18Think about the decade before clickbait.
- 36:20I mean, it's just, you know, all these attention vampires out
- 36:24there, like trying to think about how headlines change over
- 36:26the years and the ones that you would have written 10:15 no,
- 36:29probably 1520 years ago to over the last 10 years after
- 36:33BuzzFeed. And like how every, even New
- 36:35York Times headlines became very like BuzzFeed type headlines.
- 36:38So this trend has been out there.
- 36:40But I would say there's more good content than there's ever
- 36:42been certainly than 20 years ago on the Internet just by sheer
- 36:46volume. If you think about not only is
- 36:49the content on the Times and Washington Post and CNN and BBC
- 36:53and you know, all these places, like there's amazing content in
- 36:57these places, but then with Substack and then with YouTube,
- 37:00I mean, it's, it is endless how much great content is out there.
- 37:03So I, I think it is our job to help you find the good stuff and
- 37:07to, to be your guide through that digital wilderness and
- 37:10then, you know, avoid falling into, you know, off a Cliff or
- 37:13stepping on a rattlesnake or whatever.
- 37:14We have to help you do to, to get through it all that that is
- 37:17historically our job. And we have to, you know, do a
- 37:20good job of that. That job will get harder over
- 37:23the next 30 years, but it's not a new job.
- 37:26I think I agree with you that overall it's gotten better.
- 37:28I mean, YouTube explainers that whole category is sort of like
- 37:32the, you can go to YouTube for sort of any question you have
- 37:34about the world. I think the New York Times has
- 37:38gotten better, but obviously, like local papers have generally
- 37:41gotten worse. It's hard.
- 37:43It's hard to score overall. I mean, I yeah, there's some.
- 37:47There's some puts and takes. In this generation, unless like
- 37:50Jim Prosser, APR Guy in Silicon Valley, who I respect has a
- 37:53blog, he he basically argued that like the SEO optimization
- 37:58for LMS category, I forget what people are calling it, but yeah,
- 38:02but he said he thought that was sort of fake or like that, that
- 38:05there isn't as much to be done there.
- 38:08Do you agree with that? Honestly, I, I'd follow a lot of
- 38:11SEOSII, you know, came out of that industry.
- 38:15I, I, I know a lot of those people.
- 38:17I read on Twitter all day long, everything.
- 38:19They're just trying to do what they can to adapt and to get the
- 38:25that that traffic was pulled out from under them in a lot of
- 38:28extremely important categories that that have been.
- 38:31And and to your point, you know, not really with any heads up,
- 38:38you know, this was just done in the dark of night and all of a
- 38:41sudden it's like here are these, here are these.
- 38:42Products that everyone choose on the SC, so they're saying is
- 38:45there money to be made helping people optimize for language
- 38:48models right now or you think that's not going to be a big
- 38:50business? I mean, if it is the traditional
- 38:54large language model with, with footnotes at the end, it's going
- 38:57to be a hard, a hard one. But but yeah, it's the the
- 39:02industry will have to adapt to prioritizing traffic or it'll be
- 39:05hard. I mean, I do watch those
- 39:07discussions that they're having about trying to figure out like,
- 39:09oh, if you, you know, 'cause what they're hearing from Google
- 39:13and others is, you know, it's the same, do it the same.
- 39:17You know, you have to optimize for these characteristics in
- 39:21your on quality and speed and freshness and all these things.
- 39:26But at the end of the day, if the UI does not enable someone
- 39:29to easily click out or click out at all, it's going to be hard,
- 39:34right? Hard to see value from it's.
- 39:37Not hard to get traffic, Yeah. And by the way, I also think
- 39:40users have been trained. But, and this is where I go to,
- 39:43we're only three years into the next 30 years.
- 39:45So I think it can be evolved over time now, but it's not
- 39:49going to happen overnight. They have been trained initially
- 39:52with these products to not click, you know.
- 39:56Definitely the my biggest concern rather than like spam
- 40:00for language monolayer. Well, not my biggest concern.
- 40:02A concern is just whether the consumer is savvy enough, right?
- 40:06I think on Twitter especially, you see all this like AI writing
- 40:12that goes so viral and it just feels like.
- 40:16Who is the speaker? Like, the markets are moving,
- 40:19you know, off of reports that feel like they could have been
- 40:22written by AI. Yeah, although the mission for
- 40:25for Twitter is Wild West, it's free speech, anything goes.
- 40:30We're not going to curate it. And that's a good thing.
- 40:33So that's probably not the right place to go if you want to, but
- 40:35that's. What?
- 40:36I would argue those, yeah, but I would argue.
- 40:38Those users are getting what they're they're asking for in,
- 40:40in using that product. I mean, I use it, you know, all
- 40:43the time and you just have to know what you're getting
- 40:45yourself into. It is, you know, they, they have
- 40:47been launching more features to, to maybe help you curate it
- 40:50more. And but you know, look, every
- 40:53one of these product feed based products has is always trying to
- 40:56get you to the 4U column. You know, they're, they're all
- 41:00about that and that's the one that's most susceptible to that.
- 41:03What I mean your, but your answer for this problem is to
- 41:07trust sort of news outlets, right, Which you then sort of
- 41:10drive traffic like you're not personally going and saying like
- 41:13who's real, who's not, what's true, what's not your.
- 41:16And we definitely are when it comes to yahoo.com or Yahoo
- 41:20News. So what you're saying which
- 41:22outlets are true, right or like you?
- 41:25You we are trying to be purple in terms of left and right.
- 41:28And I would always remind people there's only one category.
- 41:31When people say they don't trust the media, they're not talking
- 41:33about sports or food critics or movie critics or, you know,
- 41:37people who cover the real estate.
- 41:39It's politics is the is the dividing category and, and, and
- 41:44so for that one, we really try to especially for people who are
- 41:47not logged in, just starting out, not move them one way or
- 41:49the other. Now you will by the algorithm be
- 41:51moved one way or the other based on your preferences over time.
- 41:54I think that's totally fair as long as the, the source is a
- 41:57trustworthy source. We, you know, we are partnered
- 42:00with hundreds into the thousands of publishers.
- 42:03So we we have vetted these sources that you will see
- 42:06showing. Up right you're deciding is
- 42:07Reuters. Trustworthy.
- 42:08The only thing that shows up on Yahoo is someone we've done a
- 42:10partnership with when it comes to, to news, when it comes to
- 42:14the to Yahoo scout or AI answer engine, you know, there's,
- 42:18there's all kinds of data that's coming into that, including
- 42:21vertical publisher data. We also grounded on on Bing and
- 42:27you know, we're, we're, you know, it's, it's based on usage
- 42:30data, query data, you know, all, all the things that Yahoo
- 42:34uniquely has over time. It's one reason our answers are,
- 42:36are pretty unique. But in that way, it is curated.
- 42:39It is not just a random pull. By digesting the entire Internet
- 42:43and then predicting the next, you're striking partnerships.
- 42:45Yeah, we're actually trying to have a high quality in our
- 42:49answers. I mean, the news business can
- 42:50feel essential, a trend we haven't touched on as much, you
- 42:53know, like prediction markets. I think there was a reporter who
- 42:56was worried he was getting threatened over saying that like
- 42:59a missile had hit something because a prediction market
- 43:02hungover. And there was an angry reader
- 43:04trying to get him to adjust the article to, I guess, help the
- 43:09bet. So, you know, prediction markets
- 43:11resolve to some of these news outlets obviously.
- 43:13Right, it's. Amazing language models.
- 43:16You know, it's like a lot of materials news.
- 43:19I mean you you own TechCrunch, which obviously.
- 43:21No, no, we sold. Yeah, you owned past tense,
- 43:23that's what I'm saying. Yes, past tense and decided not
- 43:26to continue owning. Like how much is your view that
- 43:30yeah, the news business is fucked?
- 43:33Well, that wasn't it. It was that we were kind of had
- 43:35one foot in hot water, one in cold water.
- 43:37Like who are we? We have to choose.
- 43:39We were bought by private equity.
- 43:40We're starting back out. Like you just have to focus, you
- 43:43know. And so for us over time, it was
- 43:47that we're not in the breaking news business.
- 43:49So we aren't having reporters on the front lines, you know,
- 43:54reporting the news out from there that we will aggregate
- 43:56that news and send them traffic. And we're glad they do it.
- 44:00But that's not that's all we do. We are our our content is for
- 44:04context to the things that people breaking the news, you
- 44:07know, report. And historically, Yahoo Sports
- 44:09is a good example. The best breaking news reporters
- 44:13in in basketball, you know, originally Woj, then Shawn's.
- 44:17They started at Yahoo. You were the breeding.
- 44:19Ground, it was the breeding ground for that.
- 44:20But again, within, and I saw this at CBS as well, it's
- 44:22because we ran CBSSports.com. We had all kinds of, you know,
- 44:27writers on the front lines and you know, SportsCenter would
- 44:30barely mention us, you know, in breaking the news and it was in
- 44:34within 5 seconds, you know, it's already out there.
- 44:36So we just felt like that's not where we can have the most value
- 44:39and maybe we don't find the most value ourselves.
- 44:41Which is it? Like and also why?
- 44:43Be the but is there value but? Also, why be the 200th player in
- 44:47that? It's, it's not where Yahoo
- 44:49should play. You know, we, we, we, we were
- 44:51literally competing against The Associated Press for news story
- 44:54that that's not our job. Our job is to send The
- 44:56Associated Press traffic. Yeah, I mean, you define your
- 44:59job. I mean, I guess to me the world
- 45:02is short on breaking news. I'm not saying you need to.
- 45:04Anybody is obligated to be in any particular business, but I
- 45:08want to disentangle like do you think breaking news is not like
- 45:11a great. Business again, I would say we
- 45:16have to go back to sometimes when people talk about someone
- 45:18buying our company and they're like, oh, but what do you get
- 45:20get by regulators. I'm like, I love that we're at
- 45:23this point in time 31 years that after all Yahoo went through and
- 45:27how much people in the industry kind of dragged the brand
- 45:30through the mud that they would think that we would be the
- 45:32source of, of being, you know, of a regulatory thing with, with
- 45:36an acquisition that doesn't make sense.
- 45:37But I would say the same thing here that Yahoo of of all you
- 45:41know, publishers would be the one that.
- 45:43That is being why hold us to account on.
- 45:45That no is is is the one that you're saying is missing from
- 45:48the front lines of of journalism.
- 45:50I I think there's a. Lot You're doing far more
- 45:51journalism than every other tech platform in the world.
- 45:54Right. We, we do a lot of journalism,
- 45:55but again, we do it from a certain point of view of like
- 45:58that is not the breaking news side that I think a lot of
- 46:00people, I'm not trying to put their.
- 46:02Resources into. In some ways, it's because
- 46:03you're the closest to it. You have to.
- 46:05Bring a turn around is is people, as you know, are saying
- 46:07like what's the formula for that?
- 46:08There's not always one people is the most important part, people
- 46:12who know what they're doing. And then they naturally put a
- 46:14great strategy in place and build great products and, and
- 46:19you know, and all that, but, but you know, one part of that is,
- 46:23is strategic focus. You can't do everything,
- 46:26especially when you're trying to fix the PNL, you know, build,
- 46:30get a solid foundation going for the for the future.
- 46:33That is where we really were coming from and all that.
- 46:36Would breaking news, I mean it becomes a headache or like you
- 46:39where are things getting like escalated up to you or just like
- 46:41the business of breaking news is hard to manage or.
- 46:45Not for very well. We we made these decisions
- 46:46fairly always like after we took over.
- 46:49But. But no, I wouldn't.
- 46:50We certainly no decisions would make their way up to me.
- 46:54Yeah. I mean, you remember back at
- 46:55CBS, I had all kinds of of news brands.
- 46:58This was my first rodeo running, running a news brand like we
- 47:00did. We did not get involved.
- 47:01No. Well, that's why I'm asking for
- 47:03your sort of overall perspective on news right now.
- 47:07Yeah, I mean, it's, it's an interesting spot.
- 47:10I mean, I think the corporate ownership of all these things,
- 47:16the the, you know, what's being pushed on journalists from an
- 47:21editorial perspective. And you know, at the same time,
- 47:25there are we, we work with hundreds, thousands of sources.
- 47:29You know, I think the ones or the flashpoints are, are always
- 47:32interesting. There's nothing more interesting
- 47:34to journalists than other journalists.
- 47:35And I've always found that too. And, and so, you know, it's it
- 47:41that is not happening across the board.
- 47:43There are, there are still the vast majority of sources are,
- 47:46are not falling into that camp. So I, what I would say is news
- 47:51sources are definitely seeing less traffic, you know, because
- 47:54of the way search has been evolving.
- 47:56So that part of it has been difficult for the industry.
- 48:00And you know, staffing in a premium way requires premium
- 48:04CPMS, right? And I think what happened over
- 48:07the previous 15 years was programmatic CPMS against
- 48:11premium staffing equals very difficult business model, right?
- 48:15So now other things have evolved like podcasting and other ways
- 48:18to, you know, to, to kind of to go with if, if, if you're those
- 48:23kinds of brands. But yeah, it is it has been a it
- 48:26has been a hard business and harder for some than others.
- 48:30You know, New York Times is still doing really well.
- 48:32There are there are others doing well.
- 48:34Anyone who's subscription based, and this could be, you know,
- 48:38really anybody, you have to start with a broad funnel
- 48:41usually of free. If you're Netflix and you're you
- 48:44define the category cha chi PT in some ways with that where it
- 48:47was a subscription model to start with.
- 48:49The only way you could use it was in many ways was
- 48:52subscription based. But at the end of the day, only
- 48:575% of chats CPT users are I believe are paying subscribers.
- 49:01So again, back to that broad funnel.
- 49:03And I think that requires brand that requires scale.
- 49:09So, so it's, it is, you know, for the few who are able to have
- 49:13that kind of a a model. And then on the other side of
- 49:15that, you will have more niche things.
- 49:17And that is where, you know, historically trade publications
- 49:20would fit in. They would charge a lot of money
- 49:22and not have a huge subscriber base, but they're prestigious in
- 49:25their industry. And I think I'm.
- 49:27Happy to take on that. Yep.
- 49:29Mantle and I think that Substack has and and others have come
- 49:32along in that niche and further that so.
- 49:36What Yahoo's obviously privately owned Like what?
- 49:39What can you say about the Business Today?
- 49:42That's good being private, I think.
- 49:45Do you want? To brag I feel like.
- 49:47No, not yet. At some point it's, you know,
- 49:51look, this was the kind of the white whale of turnarounds.
- 49:55It was one that, you know, I don't think a lot of people
- 49:57could thought could be pulled off and it was even, you know, I
- 50:00feel like we have done that. But I think it's been a 4 1/2
- 50:03year now journey to get there. And you realize like selling
- 50:06AOL, like how much have you do the math I guess for sort of the
- 50:11Apollo deal to to now? Yeah.
- 50:13So, yeah, I mean what they have said publicly is they've already
- 50:17returned the investment, the cash investment on it.
- 50:20So we're we're kind of playing for upside, you know on the on
- 50:23the rest of it. If you look at it as APE deal,
- 50:25we're a little, we're very unusual for that, right?
- 50:28Because we are part of the beast of Silicon Valley, you know, who
- 50:31we compete with for users, who we sell to, you know, all of
- 50:35that. It's not a, it's not really, it
- 50:37doesn't fit the model of a traditional, you know, PE deal
- 50:40in that way. And then AI, you know, when we
- 50:43bought the company, it was the middle of like stonks and, and
- 50:46all that. And then and then AI wasn't even
- 50:49on the map. And that happened November of
- 50:5022. We, we spun the company out in
- 50:52September of 21. So that's changed the whole
- 50:54game. So yeah, with deals like AOL,
- 50:57we, we actually sold the content delivery network that they own
- 50:59when we first joined, we sold the branding rights to Yahoo
- 51:03back to Yahoo Japan. We first started.
- 51:05So they're like, and you know, then smaller ones like
- 51:07TechCrunch and Rivals and Gadget.
- 51:10So you take those all together and it's been, you know, we've
- 51:12returned, you know, quite a bit. And then the amazing thing is
- 51:16that the core Yahoo business, we've really optimized that.
- 51:20We've gotten the cost in a really good place.
- 51:22The quality of the people is incredible now and, and they're
- 51:26all, you know, off and running traffic is growing at a really
- 51:29good rate. Revenue is growing at a really
- 51:31good rate, very profitable. But you know, this was a company
- 51:35that went public in April of 1996, you know, started running
- 51:40into some headwinds in the 2000s.
- 51:41And I think for the next 15 years, you know, it was kind of
- 51:44rough to be be Yahoo, the public company.
- 51:47If you think about the, the famous dealer, they didn't sell
- 51:50for 44 billion to Microsoft. That was 2008, you know, and it
- 51:54went on another almost 10 years before selling to Verizon.
- 51:58So that was a long time. So there it is good to be.
- 52:01I've worked, I've done 2 startups for it that I founded
- 52:04or Co founded. But you know, the majority of my
- 52:07careers want to be in public companies or or large companies.
- 52:11I'll just say there's some benefit to being public.
- 52:13I mean to being private to do the, you know, to do all the
- 52:17things to fix it because once you go public as you know like
- 52:20it is all about, you know, you, you are held to account quarter
- 52:23by quarter and you better understand what those next, you
- 52:26know five years are going to look like before you get there.
- 52:28What? And it's also hard to make
- 52:30changes in public. What is what is a win look like
- 52:34for Scout and sort of your AI strategy?
- 52:37How much is it about showing the industry what it should be doing
- 52:41and then playing with the industry versus you want this
- 52:44just be sort of a huge product on it's own?
- 52:46Like what? What is the goal with your AI
- 52:48strategy? So if you go back to the turn
- 52:51around strategy, it was a couple years of transformation work to
- 52:55the org to the team. And then once you got through
- 52:59all into the revenue model and the the revenue engine, you
- 53:02know, we we migrated from the old revenue engine to to a new
- 53:06one that that was just you know was better.
- 53:09And then once you get through that, we are in the right OK to
- 53:12then go and fix all the products.
- 53:13So then we went through that phase and now we're in the shots
- 53:18on goal period. We've actually we have the
- 53:20resources like it's working we're.
- 53:22Making money. We got rid of the stuff that
- 53:23doesn't. Make sense, do something with
- 53:24this audience and that is, you know, very loyal to us and the
- 53:28places that are very logical not to go do some rando innovation.
- 53:32Something has nothing to do with the spine of the book for for
- 53:35Yahoo, but things that our users would find unique, uniquely
- 53:37valuable, but also your asset base.
- 53:40So I would, I would say there's two big ones right now.
- 53:43One is Scout. The others are DSP, our demand
- 53:46demand side platform in the ad tech space, which is growing in
- 53:51a really good clip that competes with people like trade desk and
- 53:54DV 360 from Google and Amazon and a lot of smaller players.
- 53:59We're the largest private DSP and that is essentially, you
- 54:03know, you can target talking about the new fronts, you can
- 54:06target on Yahoo. Oh, no, we will sell ads to you
- 54:09directly to to go on to our properties.
- 54:12You can also using, you know, our data then go through us to,
- 54:18you know, have ads on other people's properties.
- 54:21And so that that has been a really good business.
- 54:23We shut down to ad tech businesses to focus on that one.
- 54:26And we think that could be potentially worth, you know,
- 54:29billions of dollars if we get that right.
- 54:30So we're in business. Is it I mean, it's a lot of top
- 54:33line revenue. You do, you know, there there's,
- 54:36there's a lot of revelation. That goes back, right?
- 54:40Yeah. So so you you do and how much
- 54:43are people using out of traffic that?
- 54:45Totally advertise off of Yahoo or it's mostly for people who
- 54:47are already doing a lot of Yahoo.
- 54:49Ad no, it's for only 9% of the impressions in that network are
- 54:54are Yahoo. So that's also our competitors
- 54:57will say you're only buying Yahoo and try to throw us under
- 54:59the bus that way. It's actually 90% or off of
- 55:02Yahoo and so Netflix and Spotify and many many.
- 55:05That's the DSP. Work with the Yahoo DSP Scout is
- 55:09interesting because there's a lot of great reasons to do it,
- 55:12which is why we built it ourselves.
- 55:14So Yahoo had outsourced search since 2009 to Bing and same same
- 55:20as Yahoo did originally. So it's almost like an
- 55:22enterprise search deal. And Bing did that to build up
- 55:26the volume in their network, right?
- 55:27The way search advertising works is it's not about the technology
- 55:30as as much as it's about volume. The NTH advertiser will, you
- 55:35know, increase prices in the auction, they'll expand
- 55:39coverage, they'll increase relevance, which will help the
- 55:41click through rate. That is really the secret is the
- 55:43NTH advertiser goes to Google. So if you put Bing and Yahoo
- 55:47together, you know, for the Bing marketplace, it actually
- 55:50increases the likelihood the NTH advertiser will also come into
- 55:53the into Bing. So that's why Yahoo and Bing
- 55:57have been partnered for so long. But when it came to this, we
- 56:01looked at the category about a year ago because we're coming
- 56:03through that transformation period felt like we, you know,
- 56:06this is the next obvious thing to focus on given search such a
- 56:09big part of our portfolio still, but outsourced it.
- 56:13And we looked at everything. We looked at every outsourced
- 56:16possibility that you could think of and it came back to the idea
- 56:19that given all the data, 30 years of search history, all of
- 56:23our usage data, our user data, the publisher data, you know,
- 56:27all of it, we actually were sitting on this goldmine of of
- 56:31data that you would you could use to create a really good AI
- 56:34answer engine. Right.
- 56:36You know. What I mean partner, partner
- 56:37with an index because you have to ground it for accuracy.
- 56:40But if you had that and and then it became very obvious that, you
- 56:45know, we already had a big search team that really weren't
- 56:48building index search that we could repurpose for this.
- 56:51So we we tried to figure that out.
- 56:53And then last summer we bought the company, a company, a start
- 56:56up run by a guy named Eric Feng, who's kind of a luminary in the
- 57:01industry. He he, you know, back in the
- 57:03day, he worked at Microsoft and ran the research lab in Beijing
- 57:06and he helped create Bing. But then he went with Jason
- 57:08Kilar and he Co founded Hulu. He was the head of technology
- 57:11and product for Hulu. So we both spent time in the
- 57:14streaming wars and then was at Kleiner Perkins and Meta and
- 57:18other places before the start up.
- 57:19So Eric shared a passion with our team that what he called
- 57:23Yahoo's toys would be an amazing set of data to work with to
- 57:28create a product like this. And so we went to buy his
- 57:32company last summer and we put him in charge of consumer
- 57:34search. And so early August last year we
- 57:37started building. And again, if we go back to why
- 57:41we did it, we have the third most search volume.
- 57:44It's small compared to Google, but still a very big business
- 57:47for us. We had to have the best AI
- 57:50search results or answers that we could possibly have.
- 57:54If we didn't we would lose users cuz search is evolving and
- 57:57changing and if it made sense we would have outsourced it but it
- 58:01actually made the most sense to to build it.
- 58:03How much of yahoo.com are you funneling people?
- 58:05Like are you? Nothing so far.
- 58:07Why not like? Because we are in beta and we're
- 58:12a, you know. Cost.
- 58:13Does it cost more money to distribute?
- 58:15We're a little more than a month and 1/2 in and yeah, there is a
- 58:18cost. There's a there's a cost both to
- 58:20grounding a Bing and we work with a very lightweight model
- 58:23the anthropic makes called Haiku.
- 58:26So it's super fast and it, it essentially processes our data.
- 58:30It's we're not, you know, using, you know, their, their answers.
- 58:33It's our, it's, it's ours running through their
- 58:36lightweight model that comes back to us to render in our kind
- 58:40of, you know, we love our UI. We, we think it's really rich UI
- 58:43that has some, some personality and some great answers.
- 58:47So all that together does cost some money.
- 58:49That cost is coming down over time.
- 58:51And and then again, over time, I think search advertising will
- 58:56come back into this category and be able to, you know, make this
- 58:59really profitable. So that's, but in this early
- 59:02stage, we are trying to hone it. We actually have a Slack channel
- 59:06called improve Scout and, and hundreds of Yahoo employees are
- 59:10in there all the time, like feeding back on what's
- 59:13happening. We're getting user data in from
- 59:15people coming through it. I mean, it's in the millions of
- 59:17people who are, you know, that have been through this and are
- 59:20using it. But, you know, at the right
- 59:24time, we'll come out of out of beta and want to unleash it
- 59:27across all 700 million users. But we just, we're not in a huge
- 59:31hurry to do that yet. Well, I'm cheering for the
- 59:33vision of getting traffic back out to the publishers.
- 59:36Yeah, man, great to hear it. Thank you so much for coming on
- 59:38the Newcomer podcast. Thanks, Eric.
- 59:40Great, thanks for sticking around to the end.
- 59:43Please. If you've made it this far,
- 59:45you've got to like comment, subscribe, excited to grow the
- 59:48channel. And of course, you can find our
- 59:50writing and reporting on sarps and venture capital at
- 59:53newcomer.co. We also host events.
- 59:57You can check out what we're doing at Newcomer dot events,
- 59:59share their podcasts, help us get distribution, support the
- 1:00:03channel, comment support, like comment, subscribe.
- 1:00:06You know, you know the deal. Thanks.
- 1:00:08Thanks for being on the journey with us.
- 1:00:09All right, see you next week.