Latest / Politics By Faith w/Mike Slater / What Most Don’t Realize About American Christianity
Transcript
- 0:04I wanna go to my friend Spencer Claven,
- 0:07author of the new book,
- 0:09Light of the Mind,
- 0:11Light of the World,
- 0:13Illuminating Science
- 0:14Through Faith.
- 0:16Also the host of the podcast,
- 0:17Young
- 0:18Heretics,
- 0:19and the Claremont Review of Books,
- 0:21uh,
- 0:21editor,
- 0:21and,
- 0:22uh,
- 0:22one of my favorite books,
- 0:23How to Save the West.
- 0:25That is his older book.
- 0:26Spencer,
- 0:26how are you,
- 0:26brother?
- 0:28Hey Mike,
- 0:29it's great to see you,
- 0:29man.
- 0:30I'm doing well.
- 0:30How about yourself?
- 0:31Great
- 0:31to talk to you.
- 0:32Uh,
- 0:33let's talk about the West first,
- 0:35and then we'll talk about America's role in the West.
- 0:37But when people talk about the West,
- 0:39what are we talking about and why is it good?
- 0:43Well,
- 0:44when we talk about the West,
- 0:45we're talking about an evil white cis
- 0:47hetero patriarchal construct created on stolen land.
- 0:51No,
- 0:52um,
- 0:52this is sort of the typical,
- 0:54right,
- 0:54you know,
- 0:54people think you're talking about some kind of
- 0:58exclusive club of only certain countries or only get certain races get to join.
- 1:03The opposite is actually true.
- 1:05Western civilization
- 1:07is uniquely a secret.
- 1:11Society that stretches across time and space.
- 1:15It's defined by the cultural inheritance of Athens
- 1:19and Jerusalem,
- 1:20and you need both of those in order to really make
- 1:23the West.
- 1:23When you talk about Athens,
- 1:24you're thinking,
- 1:25you know,
- 1:25the great philosophers of Greece and Rome.
- 1:28When you talk about Jerusalem,
- 1:30you're thinking about
- 1:31the scriptural tradition
- 1:34first of the Jews and then of the Christians and everything that we mean when we say.
- 1:38Judeo-Christian teaching and tradition,
- 1:40and those two things meet
- 1:42and transform the Roman Empire
- 1:45after the conversion of Constantine,
- 1:47so that what we now think of as the West becomes a
- 1:51series of nations as well.
- 1:53But America is the inheritor of that
- 1:56tradition,
- 1:57so it's not just limited to Europe or to a particular location.
- 2:00It's actually something that stretches across time,
- 2:02and we are,
- 2:02I think,
- 2:03at the latest and greatest thing that the West has produced.
- 2:07Mm,
- 2:07very good.
- 2:07Uh,
- 2:08as opposed to what?
- 2:09What are,
- 2:09what are the alternatives if you're not of the West,
- 2:11what else is there?
- 2:13Huh,
- 2:15great question.
- 2:15I mean,
- 2:17for us,
- 2:17I don't think
- 2:18there is any other option other than than conquest.
- 2:21I think that there are
- 2:22other noble traditions outside of the Western
- 2:26tradition.
- 2:26I'm
- 2:27particularly myself fascinated by Japanese
- 2:31history and culture,
- 2:32and that's a great example of a language and
- 2:34a culture and a tradition that does not come
- 2:36from the West.
- 2:37But One of the things we are
- 2:39learning in America right now is that there's no such thing as a post-Western
- 2:44America.
- 2:45There's only regression to a kind of pagan
- 2:48tribalism
- 2:49or conquest by a different
- 2:52way of life,
- 2:53probably a hostile way of life,
- 2:55the way things are shaping up on the world
- 2:57stage
- 2:58in order to really
- 3:00remain American.
- 3:02We actually can't escape,
- 3:04especially that Judeo-Christian part of our
- 3:07heritage,
- 3:08our ethics,
- 3:09our way of looking at the world,
- 3:11our aspirations for ourselves,
- 3:12our idea of virtue,
- 3:14all of these are steeped uniquely in biblical
- 3:18tradition,
- 3:18and we can't get out of them without transforming into something
- 3:22totally different and I think
- 3:24much uglier.
- 3:26Interesting.
- 3:26So do you,
- 3:27do,
- 3:27do you believe we can progress
- 3:29to something new and better,
- 3:31or is,
- 3:32can we only
- 3:34restore?
- 3:36No,
- 3:37I do think actually that there is progress
- 3:40ahead of us of a certain sort,
- 3:42and this has always been part of Western
- 3:45civilization.
- 3:45It's not just a museum exercise.
- 3:48We're not here to preserve these
- 3:50old ideas in amber or just like,
- 3:53you know,
- 3:53gently pour over our cherished collection of books.
- 3:56We are actually explorers.
- 3:58I mean,
- 3:59America,
- 3:59of course,
- 4:00itself
- 4:00is the product of the.
- 4:03English Empire and these intrepid,
- 4:05you know,
- 4:06the Puritans and others who came from
- 4:08England to colonize the New World.
- 4:10I actually think that right now we're on the edge of another
- 4:15precipice.
- 4:15We're looking at
- 4:16space travel.
- 4:17We're looking at what it looks like to
- 4:20be Americans in the digital world and how to preserve the integrity of our.
- 4:24Traditions in this new sphere,
- 4:26um,
- 4:27but we're,
- 4:28what we're really aiming for,
- 4:29I think,
- 4:29is continuity.
- 4:30CS Lewis talks about being able to tell when a
- 4:33tree puts forth new flowers that something different has happened,
- 4:37but it's still part of the tree.
- 4:38You can't just take a brick and pretend that that's also part of the same tree.
- 4:42There's an organic growth here that I think we're aiming for.
- 4:46Hm,
- 4:47very good.
- 4:48Can you
- 4:49name a value?
- 4:51That was cherished by
- 4:54either our founding fathers or before
- 4:57that we had in this country
- 5:00that maybe you feel we are,
- 5:02we have let go of or are losing.
- 5:05Yeah,
- 5:06I'm gonna insist upon one central value,
- 5:09and it is maybe the best candidate
- 5:11for
- 5:12a Judeo-Christian core,
- 5:15and that is
- 5:16what's called the Imago
- 5:18Dei,
- 5:18and it's a Latin term meaning the image of God.
- 5:22And this is a distinctive and even
- 5:24revolutionary idea.
- 5:26We take it for granted now a little bit,
- 5:29but we don't realize what a countercultural notion it was
- 5:33that the world not only had been created by one mind with a rational plan for
- 5:39the order of things,
- 5:41but that we have in our souls and in our minds a little blueprint of that order,
- 5:46a key to accessing.
- 5:48The cosmic mind
- 5:49and that makes every individual human life an infinitely valuable
- 5:55thing and we again think that we can just take this for granted in a secular world,
- 6:01but you're already starting to see with the
- 6:03way that we are building hierarchies of races,
- 6:06with the way that we devalue unborn
- 6:09life,
- 6:09we're starting to see people eat away at the edges of this idea that humanity.
- 6:14Itself is special.
- 6:16My new book Light of the Mind,
- 6:18Light of the World is really about this.
- 6:21It's about the loss of that idea that we are not just an accident,
- 6:24we're actually a product of the mind that made
- 6:28the universe,
- 6:28and that has serious intellectual consequences,
- 6:31serious moral consequences,
- 6:33and serious political consequences,
- 6:35which I think we're starting to see what happens
- 6:37when you get rid of that ancient notion.
- 6:41So getting rid of the image of God concept,
- 6:42I think it's,
- 6:43it's obvious to see how that would apply to abortion,
- 6:45right?
- 6:46That's,
- 6:46that's a kind of an easy one.
- 6:47Give me one that's maybe a little more subtle
- 6:49yet also profound.
- 6:52Another
- 6:53concept that's
- 6:55sort of another example of when we lose
- 6:58that image of God concept in our culture.
- 7:01OK,
- 7:02so here's a great one.
- 7:04Isaac Newton,
- 7:05we all learned about Isaac Newton in school.
- 7:08He,
- 7:09you know,
- 7:09outlined the three laws of motion.
- 7:11He wrote the Principia Mathematica.
- 7:13There's some basic stuff that you learn in physics class
- 7:15about Isaac Newton and maybe in history class too,
- 7:18but we have no idea how revolutionary Isaac Newton was because before him,
- 7:23before the publication of the Principia.
- 7:26There was this idea that
- 7:28beyond the moon,
- 7:29once you get past the moon,
- 7:31everything
- 7:32works differently.
- 7:33It was called the superlunary realm,
- 7:35the superlunary sphere,
- 7:36and the sublunary realm down here is where things
- 7:39are a little bit more chaotic and complicated,
- 7:41but Newton
- 7:43was able to come up with rules that applied both to fruit falling from trees on Earth
- 7:49and to quasars
- 7:51and the stars and all the all the planets.
- 7:55This shattered
- 7:57the boundary between the superlunary and the sublunary realm,
- 7:59and it delivered on a promise that was inherent in the Imago day.
- 8:04Newton would have had no reason to expect
- 8:07that his mind and the numbers and the abstractions that we happen to come up with,
- 8:12no reason to expect
- 8:13that those
- 8:14ideas would apply everywhere throughout the universe unless you think
- 8:18that the human mind is more than just an.
- 8:20Accident,
- 8:20not just an evolutionary mistake,
- 8:22not just a bunch of
- 8:23atoms kind of bouncing together,
- 8:25but actually a blueprint for the cosmos.
- 8:28Now,
- 8:29if you look at the way scientists talk about our
- 8:31current paradoxes,
- 8:33things like how do we figure out quantum gravity or why do some
- 8:37of the universes in the distant regions of space look so old,
- 8:40um,
- 8:41we have these paradoxes that we're faced with that are like our own version of the
- 8:45barrier between the superlunary and the sublunary realm,
- 8:48but we don't have any reason to believe that our minds
- 8:51can penetrate those boundaries into new regions of space unless we recover
- 8:56this idea of the image of God.
- 8:57The very foundation of the scientific enterprise is based on this idea
- 9:02that the human mind is a key to understanding
- 9:05the universe,
- 9:06and without that there's no guarantee that anything at all is going to work.
- 9:11Is it fair to say,
- 9:12I mean,
- 9:13who,
- 9:13uh,
- 9:13Bill Bryson,
- 9:14I read Bill Bryson's Short History of Nearly Everything,
- 9:16and I think he emphasized the point that
- 9:18Newton was like first and foremost a theologian,
- 9:21more so than any scientific writer,
- 9:24but we don't know him for that.
- 9:24Do you find that to be true?
- 9:27I think that's
- 9:29a profound insight.
- 9:30I mean,
- 9:30people are shocked when you say that Newton devoted
- 9:33page upon page to things like the genealogy of Noah's
- 9:37sons and who they all stood in for and whether
- 9:41they were associated with the Greek gods or what.
- 9:43I mean,
- 9:43he was like a real,
- 9:45he was an unorthodox Christian in some ways,
- 9:48but he was a deeply devoted Christ.
- 9:50With a profound interest in the relationship between
- 9:53what he was doing in his work within science
- 9:56and the cosmic order
- 9:58of the heavens as designed by God.
- 10:00Not only that,
- 10:01he insisted repeatedly
- 10:04that what he was doing in science could only make sense within a larger context of
- 10:10theology and
- 10:11metaphysics,
- 10:12and this is something that a lot.
- 10:13Of his followers got wrong
- 10:15and missed about his work,
- 10:16but he was
- 10:18often,
- 10:18for instance,
- 10:19in his dialogues with Leibniz and other of the great mathematicians
- 10:22and minds of the day,
- 10:24he was always insisting that science can't justify itself,
- 10:28that there are domains of knowledge that
- 10:31are inaccessible to
- 10:34human material observation and need to be.
- 10:36Seasoned
- 10:37using larger
- 10:38models like theology
- 10:40and this whole idea of him as a kind of,
- 10:44you know,
- 10:44pioneer for
- 10:45atheism or something or science versus religion is totally wrong.
- 10:50He was theological down to his bones,
- 10:53and it was only because he had that theology that
- 10:56he was confident enough to move forward with the science.
- 10:59Oh,
- 11:00what a great important line there.
- 11:01All right,
- 11:01I haven't read it yet,
- 11:02but I certainly will.
- 11:03Light of the Mind,
- 11:04Light of the world,
- 11:05illuminating Science Through faith.
- 11:06I have read
- 11:07How to Save the West,
- 11:09Claremount Review of Books,
- 11:10Young Heretics is the podcast,
- 11:11the great Spencer Clayman.
- 11:12Spencer,
- 11:13appreciate it.
- 11:13Keep up the wonderful work.
- 11:15It's a delight,
- 11:16brother.
- 11:16Thanks for having me on.
- 11:18I wanna take a minute here
- 11:19to honor the spiritual ancestors
- 11:22of all Americans,
- 11:23as
- 11:23Spencer was talking about,
- 11:24we all belong to the West,
- 11:26no matter what your skin color is or whatever,
- 11:27we all belong to the West and as Americans we all belong
- 11:31to
- 11:32the Pilgrims.
- 11:34These are people who
- 11:35We used to be,
- 11:37and I believe the people we should be again.
- 11:40So King James First was the
- 11:41King of England,
- 11:42and he
- 11:44really cemented the Church of England as the official religion
- 11:47of England,
- 11:47and the Puritans hated this.
- 11:49The king said to the Puritans,
- 11:50he said they agree with the monarchy
- 11:52as well as God agrees with the devil.
- 11:55Meaning not at all.
- 11:57And the Puritans finally said,
- 11:58we're out of here.
- 11:59We're gonna,
- 11:59we're gonna,
- 12:00we're gonna go off to a far distant place.
- 12:04Holland
- 12:06Especially not that far off
- 12:07and not that distant,
- 12:08just kind of just over the way
- 12:09there.
- 12:10So they first gave it a go in Holland.
- 12:12Things didn't go well there for a lot of reasons we don't have time for today.
- 12:15I think one of the most interesting ones is that
- 12:16the Puritans saw their kids
- 12:18assimilating with the kids of Holland.
- 12:20The Dutch kids were a bad example.
- 12:23So they're like,
- 12:23we gotta get out of here,
- 12:24and things had to be pretty bad.
- 12:26If they're like,
- 12:26hey,
- 12:27let's travel across the ocean,
- 12:30it's gotta be better than this.
- 12:33So they did.
- 12:34Uh,
- 12:35I think we need to know more about our founding Puritans.
- 12:38They did
- 12:39an incredible thing.
- 12:41One little boat,
- 12:42the Mayflower,
- 12:43102 passengers,
- 12:4530 crew,
- 12:461620
- 12:48left England in July,
- 12:49left,
- 12:50left Plymouth,
- 12:51England,
- 12:52hence where they landed Plymouth Rock,
- 12:53but
- 12:55they left
- 12:56July of 1620,
- 12:58turned back because the ship they were traveling with kept leaking.
- 13:02So they go back and they finally took off in September
- 13:05and it is not a great start.
- 13:07The living quarters for 132 people
- 13:10was 80 ft
- 13:12by 20 ft
- 13:13and 5 ft tall.
- 13:15So if you're if you're under the deck,
- 13:16you're always walking like this.
- 13:18Just as packed and cramped,
- 13:19132 people
- 13:21as packed and cramped as can be.
- 13:23Uh,
- 13:24one of the passengers in particular,
- 13:25his name was William Brewster.
- 13:26He lived a life of luxury back in England when he was
- 13:29growing up.
- 13:30He had big houses.
- 13:31He had clothes
- 13:32with pearls and gold thread
- 13:34and gave it all up,
- 13:36gave it all up.
- 13:37Now you're stuck on a boat
- 13:39with pigs and chickens and human feces
- 13:42going off
- 13:42the total wilderness,
- 13:44probably going to die on the way,
- 13:46but.
- 13:47Didn't matter.
- 13:47He knew it was right.
- 13:49He knew that life was short and God is good.
- 13:50By the way,
- 13:51short,
- 13:51life expectancy in England at the time was 40.
- 13:54So the Puritans,
- 13:55they truly believed that they had a covenant,
- 13:58like the Jewish people did in the Old Testament.
- 14:01And where the Jews searched for the promised land,
- 14:03the Puritans believed their promised land was in America.
- 14:06They not only hated monarchy,
- 14:07and of course they hated the blasphemous church,
- 14:10they wanted an escape from all the worldliness
- 14:13of England.
- 14:15They wanted to escape from everything.
- 14:17They wanted out of the king's wars.
- 14:19They wanted out of tyranny.
- 14:22I mean think about like like an escape to the wilderness
- 14:25was an improvement for them.
- 14:26Think about that worldview,
- 14:28the natural
- 14:29new world,
- 14:30like
- 14:31there's no towns,
- 14:32there was no
- 14:33inns when they arrived.
- 14:34There was nothing there and they knew it.
- 14:36There was nothing there,
- 14:37but that was better
- 14:39than civilized
- 14:41European society.
- 14:43The Puritans were so dedicated to leaving
- 14:46the wicked old world behind.
- 14:48They knew they were on a holy
- 14:50mission.
- 14:51I'm certain that if our kids
- 14:53were taught a story,
- 14:54the story of the pilgrims,
- 14:55and not just Thanksgiving Day,
- 14:57but if they truly were taught the story of who the pilgrims were,
- 15:00the life of the pilgrims,
- 15:02the hardships
- 15:03of the pilgrims,
- 15:04I know it would mold
- 15:06young people's characters
- 15:08in a profound way.
- 15:10It would make people's lives different if they knew.
- 15:13Who the pilgrims were,
- 15:14I think we'd be more grateful.
- 15:16I think the American people would be tougher
- 15:17because again,
- 15:18these are,
- 15:18this is like we are them,
- 15:20like this,
- 15:20they're us.
- 15:21They're our founders.
- 15:22They're our real.
- 15:22We think of our founders in 1776.
- 15:24These people are 1620.
- 15:26This is who we are.
- 15:27These people set the culture
- 15:28that our founders grew up in and created this country,
- 15:31but it all starts
- 15:32with the pilgrims.
- 15:33And I think if we knew about the pilgrims,
- 15:34we'd be more grateful,
- 15:35we'd be a tougher people,
- 15:36we'd be way less entitled.
- 15:38The journey was 2 months long across the ocean.
- 15:41I think about 2 months.
- 15:41We have no context for 2 months.
- 15:432 months.
- 15:45No Netflix.
- 15:47No iPhones,
- 15:48nothing.
- 15:492 months of nothing.
- 15:52Two months of misery.
- 15:542 months of chamber pots on the floor,
- 15:572 months of sleeping like this,
- 16:00like just misery.
- 16:03They got to Cape Cod in December.
- 16:04Remember there were delayed,
- 16:05they got in there in December.
- 16:06They had to stay on the boat
- 16:07out on the coast
- 16:09until April for the winter.
- 16:11And it's during that time,
- 16:12only one person died,
- 16:14I think a younger kid died on the journey.
- 16:17Everyone else who died,
- 16:1855 of them
- 16:20died
- 16:21just sitting on the,
- 16:22off the coast on the boat.
- 16:24They were just sitting there waiting for winter to be over.
- 16:26And it wasn't a clean,
- 16:27sanitary death
- 16:29like we have today.
- 16:30The person who died was right over there
- 16:32inside the,
- 16:32under the deck
- 16:34where you sleep,
- 16:35people dying,
- 16:36miserable,
- 16:37excruciating,
- 16:38painful deaths.
- 16:40Half of everyone,
- 16:41half of all the people there are dying.
- 16:43Imagine how horrible that is.
- 16:48No,
- 16:48I can't,
- 16:48I can't,
- 16:49I can't,
- 16:49I can't fathom
- 16:51freezing cold,
- 16:52no food,
- 16:53people are dying.
- 16:54Like half of everyone's dying around you.
- 16:56That's the pilgrims.
- 16:59What kept them going?
- 17:00Well,
- 17:00they believed
- 17:01that their journey across the ocean
- 17:04was like Moses
- 17:05leading the Israelites through the parted Red Sea.
- 17:09The Atlantic Ocean was the Red Sea.
- 17:11One of the most common,
- 17:12this is one of the most common themes
- 17:14that was preached to the
- 17:15about 20,000 pilgrims who made that journey over the next 20 years.
- 17:19If you survive the journey.
- 17:21And God is looking after you.
- 17:22Psalm 107:23 was a favorite of theirs.
- 17:25Some went down to the sea in ships
- 17:27doing business on the great waters.
- 17:29They saw the deeds of the Lord,
- 17:31His wondrous works
- 17:32in the deep.
- 17:34I get on the boat.
- 17:36Let's go.
- 17:38I just wish I learned about these amazing adventurers
- 17:41earlier in my life.
- 17:42They defined America.
- 17:45We have people today redefining America.
- 17:47I think we've lost it already.
- 17:48I,
- 17:48I think.
- 17:52We,
- 17:53we can go back,
- 17:54we can,
- 17:54we can
- 17:55bring back
- 17:56the soul
- 17:58of this country by learning about our pilgrims again.
- 18:01That's true.
- 18:02But most kids,
- 18:02I mean,
- 18:03I never learned about the pilgrims growing up other than like their funny hats.
- 18:07They've been forgotten.
- 18:08But they need to be rediscovered.
- 18:10And that's just up to us.
- 18:11Reverend Francis Higginson,
- 18:12he arrived in America 10 years after the Mayflower.
- 18:14He said those who stayed
- 18:16in their own chimney corner back in England
- 18:18would never have the honor
- 18:20to see these wonderful works of Almighty God.
- 18:24William Bradford,
- 18:25of course,
- 18:25was the leader of this group of pilgrims.
- 18:26He said,
- 18:26thus out of a,
- 18:27out of small beginnings,
- 18:29greater things have been produced by his hand
- 18:32that made all things of nothing.
- 18:34And gives being to all things that are.
- 18:36And as one small candle may light 1000,
- 18:39so the light here
- 18:40kindled
- 18:41hath shone unto many.
- 18:44Gosh,
- 18:44that's so true.
- 18:45Here we are today.
- 18:47Heirs,
- 18:48heirs to what these pilgrims did,
- 18:49we don't even care,
- 18:51don't even know.
- 18:53We're not living up to those standards today.
- 18:57These
- 18:57pilgrims weren't Americans.
- 18:59But I claim them as Americans.
- 19:01They are our
- 19:03spiritual
- 19:04ancestors.
- 19:05That's from a historian,
- 19:06his name is Samuel Elliott Morrison.
- 19:08He's about 100 years ago or so.
- 19:10He said the pilgrims
- 19:12are simple people.
- 19:14Inspired by the ardent,
- 19:15by an ardent faith in God,
- 19:17a dauntless
- 19:19courage in danger,
- 19:20a boundless resourcefulness in the face of difficulties we can't even imagine,
- 19:24an impregnable fortitude and adversity,
- 19:26thus they have in some measure become the spiritual ancestors
- 19:30of all Americans.
- 19:32The
- 19:33Founding fathers are great.
- 19:34Kicked off the show with our founding fathers,
- 19:36love the founding fathers.
- 19:36Not to take anything away from our founding fathers,
- 19:38of course,
- 19:39but they were born in a culture.
- 19:40And it was a culture established by our founding grandfathers,
- 19:43the Puritans.
- 19:45We need to know more about the Pilgrims.
- 19:47Dare I say,
- 19:48we need to be
- 19:49more like
- 19:50the Pilgrims.
- 19:51If you want to save this country.
- 19:54I know you do.
- 19:55I believe the only way to do it
- 19:57Is to get back to our roots.
- 20:00Mike Slater,
- 20:01Slater Radio
- 20:02on Twitter
- 20:03and Instagram.
- 20:04Spread the word.