Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️104 |Public Inquiry Week Beginning 28nd Sep Drinking water Day 3 |
Transcript
- 0:10Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign. And this podcast is following the Coronalt public inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins. If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast
- 0:28number 43, the first in this public inquiry series, that will give you some of the background before joining us here. As the inquiry continues, I'll be following the evidence and the arguments and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people, the water, and the landscapes of
- 0:50The Sperrins. Noticeably absent from the applicants' team are some of the great academic heavyweights of the mining world. Oh, make no mistake, there are expert witnesses aplenty. But where are those lofty figures of academic achievement, the professors whose names appear on the mining
- 1:27text-books and technical hand-books, the people who have spent their careers publishing research, contributing to academic papers, and advancing the science itself? They are rather noticeable by their absence. The Earth protectors, meanwhile, have been bulking out their ranks with professors and
- 1:49senior academics, and the applicant, well, they appear to have sent in the doobies. Now, for those of you too young to remember romper room, you may be wondering what on earth is a doobie. Romper Room featured mr. Dooby, an enormous bumblebee whose job was to encourage children to be good little
- 2:11doobies. Do what you're supposed to do, behave yourself, and follow the instructions. And over the years, doobies have taken on a useful second life as a description for the dependable soul who was sent off to do the job, which brings us neatly back to the public inquiry. On one side, the air protectors have
- 2:35brought in their professors; on the other, the applicant has brought its experts, or shall we affectionately call them from now on the doobies? And suddenly, Frank Sinatra seems strangely appropriate. Dooby dooby doo da da da da da dooby dooby doo da da da da da. Anyways, enough of that, because
- 3:02once the doobies had all taken their seats, we jumped straight into the topic of drinking water. The commissioner wanted to know why the drinking water protected area designation was needed in addition to the water framework directive considerations, and from there the discussion moved on very
- 3:20quickly to something far more immediate, private wells. We have families living in the area whose homes depend upon private water supplies, including two relatively recently built houses, and the evidence before the inquiry is that some of those supplies will be affected by mine de-watering. The
- 3:41applicant's position is that two shallow abstractions are predicted to go dry, with drawdown predicted at a further six, and there was discussion of monitoring, mitigation, and, if necessary, bringing in water by tanker. And that sounds okay until you start asking the questions of people that might
- 4:04be living there. How much water will be required? How often will it be delivered? Who supplies it? For how long? Who pays for it? What happens to farms, livestocks, and households that have depended upon their own water for generations. If a well lies within the influence of the mine's cone of depression,
- 4:30putting water back into that well may not solve the problem at all. If the groundwater system is being drawn towards the mine workings, that water may simply move through the ground and ultimately become part of the water being pumped out. So it isn't simply a matter of arriving with a tanker and
- 4:48filling up a well. Pat Haughty pointed out that there are no agreements in place with the affected householders. Fedelma O'Kane reminded the inquiry. That we are talking about an area designated under Article Seven of the Water Framework Directive as a drinking water protected area, and all of this
- 5:10led into a question which became increasingly important as the day went on: how much of this should already have been resolved before we reached a public inquiry, and that question became more pointed when we moved into nitrates. The commissioner raised the explosive residue that will
- 5:28remain in the rock after blasting, and eventually find its way into the water system. NIEA's evidence, as discussed today, anticipates nitrate levels remaining elevated for decades before eventually returning towards baseline.
- 5:46At that point, the commissioner asked one of those questions, which cuts through an enormous amount of technical material: should that not have been ironed out already? And then said, once the mine is mined, you can't unmine it, and that turns out to be one of the reoccurring lines of this inquiry, because the
- 6:06problem being discussed isn't something that can be corrected afterwards. Once the explosives have been used and the residues are there, the question becomes how that pollution is managed, how long it lasts, and what happens to the receiving environment in the meantime? There was discussion of the
- 6:26proposed betterment plan, removing farms from agricultural production, active treatment during operations, and passive treatment afterwards. The commissioner wanted to know what this meant at the Coronel Burn itself and at its confluence with the own caloo, particularly for protected species. That
- 6:47brought in the lox agency and the familiar problem with nitrates. Increased nutrients can encourage algal growth. When that material dies and decomposes, oxygen is consumed, which is hugely important when you're dealing with salmon eggs, fry, and the wider aquatic ecology. Freshwater permuss was
- 7:08also part of the discussion, as was the existing condition of the river. The applicant's case is that the betterment and offsetting proposals deal with the additional nitrate loading, and that the mine contribution would form a very small part of the overhaul nitrate load in the Omkalu. And then, shortly before
- 7:31lunch, the commissioner found something in the timings. Discussion had reached closure, and the period during which nitrate offsetting would continue. Full offsetting, we heard, is achieved by year 19 of the closure period. The closure plan, however, only refers to 15 years. So the commissioner asked
- 7:51the obvious question: If full offsetting isn't achieved until year 19, but the plan only runs to year 15, what happens during those four years, the answer from mr. Beatty was that awaits your recommendation. I'm not sure the commissioner was expecting to require responsibility for the missing
- 8:13four years, but there we are. And after lunch, we moved into groundwater modelling, acid mine drainage, and the applicant's predictions about what will happen after closure. mr. Bullen defended the groundwater model and explained that it had been tested against a range of parameters and conservative
- 8:32assumptions. There was also discussion of the change to emulsion explosives and whether the assessment of blasting residues remains sufficiently conservative, and then the commissioner moved to acid mine drainage. The applicant's evidence is that acid mine drainage is not expected from
- 8:52the dry stock facility, that potentially acid generating material will be encapsulated, and that the geochemical modelling predicts neutral conditions. The commissioner wanted to know what happens with time. Could materials oxidise? Could conditions become acidic later? The response was that the
- 9:14modelling does not predict that outcome, and that flooding of the underground workings after closure will isolate oxidizable material with the model extending out to 75 years, and then we came to the two little groundwater monitoring points, which have been hanging around this inquiry for some time now.
- 9:36GW05 and GW06 both produce elevated readings for arsenic and iron at particular times, and the applicant says those readings should be treated as anomalous. G W 06 had partly filled with sediment following earthworks around it. The explanation was that the sediment could have a. Samples
- 10:00and produced concentrations that were not representative of the groundwater. The commissioner asked, "Why did the well fill up? mr. Bullen explained that there had been earthworks around it. The commissioner followed up, "How do you know for certain it was an exploration? G.W. 05 included a different problem.
- 10:23Elevated concentrations appeared after the sampling method changed from purging three well volumes to a low flow sampling technique. The applicant says both are recognised methods, but that the results from that period were excluded as a precautionary approach. Their argument is that including them
- 10:43would actually increase the baseline and therefore increase the compliance limits against which future monitoring would be assessed. Then Dr. Stephen Ammerman was invited to speak, and he went straight to GW05 and GW06. His difficulty was fairly simple. He said he could not see a sufficient basis for throwing
- 11:04those samples out. He questioned whether the available information had established that the elevated concentrations resulted from sediment or sampling methodology, and raised the absence, as he saw it, of the necessary analysis of filtered and unfiltered samples.
- 11:24His point was that if sediment in the well was suspected of causing the high readings, the obvious way of demonstrating that would have been to continue purging and sampling until the concentrations came down. That evidence would then exist. His next point took us straight to those missing years. The closure
- 11:45pan, he said, provides for monitoring for 15 years after closure, while we had heard during the morning that nitrate monitoring might need to continue until a particular value is reached potentially beyond that period. Doctor Emmerman put it very plainly, we don't have a complete plan to
- 12:03evaluate. He also drew out an important distinction: a commitment to monitor something is not necessarily a commitment to do something if the monitoring reveals a problem. He then turned to acid mine drainage. Doctor Emmerman agreed that flooding underground workings can reduce further
- 12:24oxidation, but his evidence was that it does not erase oxidation, which has already taken place during the operating life of the mine. He raised the possibility of accumulated oxidation products being mobilised when the workings are eventually flooded. Again, that is an area of disagreement
- 12:46between the experts, and one which will presumably have to be worked through in the evidence. So, at the end of the day, I found myself coming back to the commissioner's questions: Why is this drinking water protected area important. What happens to the people whose wells are affected? How long will nitrate
- 13:07levels remain elevated? And what happens between year 15 and year 19? And why did G W 06 fill up with sediment? How certain can we be about why those elevated readings occurred, and perhaps the biggest question of the day: Should all of this not have been ironed out in advance? Because we are sitting in a public
- 13:33inquiry which is supposed to examine whether this development can safely proceed, and when the subject is somebody's drinking water, the own Kaloo, Atlantic salmon, freshwater pearl mussel, groundwater that will be still moving long after everyone in the inquiry room has gone home, and pollution which may have to
- 13:54be managed for decades. These are not details that can be simply tidied up later. The commissioner herself put it best: once the mine is mined, you can't unmine it. Did you know that today was day 40 of the Coronel Public Inquiry? And 40 has quite a history in the Bible: the flood, the
- 14:16wilderness, Moses on the Mount Sinai, Jesus in the desert, it tends to mark a period of testing and endurance. Well, we've done our 40 days, and there's certainly been testing and plenty of endurance. Whether there's any divine revelation coming remains to be seen. And I leave you with a final quote
- 14:37from Benjamin Franklin: "When the well is dry, we know the worth of water. See you all tomorrow. You've been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Frontline. Thank you for joining us today. All the links you'll need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well
- 14:59as links shared. By today's guests and resources mentioned in the conversation are available in the show notes. Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares about protecting our land and communities. And don't forget to hit the follow button on your
- 15:16podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people who protect them.