Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Conditioning Part 2
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I love you.
- 0:02Keep going podcast with George Hoss.
- 0:05For more information please visit our website at
- 0:07www.medicare.gov org that's www.a.
- 0:12Me TT a gr, oup dot-org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:19This is I love you. Keep going.
- 0:20It is October 27th. 2022 at 7:35 p.m.
- 0:25Pacific Daylight time and we've been talking about out.
- 0:32Have you mainly in relationship, to the attachment perspective?
- 0:36And now what I wanted to do was to shift a little bit and talk
- 0:41about conditioning but also from an attachment point of view, one
- 0:48of the things about traditional Buddhist practices were always
- 0:52talking about conditioning and and how conditioning affects the
- 0:56way that you create the perception of self.
- 1:00And And world and that water. A lot of the practices is about
- 1:06working through conditioning in order to see, clearly the nature
- 1:11of things and we would characterize Enlightenment as
- 1:15seeing clearly the nature of The Human Condition.
- 1:21Sound so far agreeable. I have wandered too far off.
- 1:33But it tends to be rather amorphous, this this idea of
- 1:36what conditioning is. And so I like to talk about it
- 1:42in a more specific way. The we were talking often about
- 1:53Ultimate Reality, what it is that we can know about the
- 1:57experience and we have and then how we formed that into
- 2:00conceptual reality And how we exist in this human form and are
- 2:10in some sense limited to the capacity of the human form to
- 2:16sense things. But also the capacity of the
- 2:19human form to be able to make sense out of the things or
- 2:24cognize, the things that we can sense.
- 2:33One of the things that we focus on quite a bit in the west,
- 2:38which is probably less. So, in the East is the four
- 2:40noble truths. The truth of the nature of the
- 2:44human conditioning that the desire to have that be different
- 2:49is the cause of suffering. There is a way out of that
- 2:54suffering of craving a version and Consciousness that that That
- 3:01path out is the Eightfold Path. But to see clearly the nature of
- 3:12what this life is that there is not a self, that's permanent
- 3:17that's ongoing, that's locatable that's continuous.
- 3:25And that we're in a body that will grow old get sick and die.
- 3:28That everything is impermanent that nothing lasts.
- 3:31If you can't really rely on anything, Which is the Tera
- 3:38vaada sort of view if you added to that, the more of a Tibetan
- 3:42view than you'd also add to that a sense of the sacredness of all
- 3:48of this, the one precious life that we have now.
- 3:56Reincarnation and Karma are also Central themes that we tend to
- 4:02talk about the nature of karma that each and in each intention
- 4:06and action that you take creates a karmic thread, if there's any
- 4:13kind of clinging to what happens and that these karmic threads
- 4:20come into fruition over many lifetimes And that if you become
- 4:26enlightened and work through these karmic, attachments you
- 4:31can become free of them and not reincarnate.
- 4:36In Tera vaada Buddhism, really the idea is to get out of here
- 4:41as fast as possible, you know, Enlightenment and out and in the
- 4:47Mahayana Zen and Tibetan Traditions.
- 4:50You there's the idea that you take the vote.
- 4:53He's hot for Val. You, you commit to being
- 4:58reincarnated into all beings can be liberated.
- 5:04All sentient beings I should say.
- 5:06And in the traditional Buddhist understanding of that that means
- 5:10humans only or no one else is sentient.
- 5:14But in the west of course we have science which would
- 5:17indicate to us that sentience is widely spread in species.
- 5:23And how do you reconcile that? It is only the humans that are
- 5:31liberated. The way that I like to talk
- 5:39about conditioning is like a database.
- 5:42So this sort of this modern view of a Database, a computer model
- 5:52technology metaphor. That you have the capacity to
- 5:58sense. Things touching touch, the
- 6:02tactile sense of the world, the visual sense of the world, the
- 6:05auditory sense of the world. The the smell of the world, the
- 6:10taste of the world that you gathered this information and
- 6:14you compare the patterns of that, as you sense them to a
- 6:20database of previously, experienced things.
- 6:23And if there's a close enough match, then That thread of
- 6:27meaning, that that, that threat of memory that attaches to the
- 6:32experience of the present moment and you form the experience of
- 6:38the present moment. Now, this is a remarkably quick
- 6:43thing. That happens one, example, we
- 6:45might use of that is that I'm speaking English and you are
- 6:49listening to me, the sound of English, my English, and you're
- 6:55interpreting Those sound vibrations and assigning meaning
- 7:00to them. If you have heard the words that
- 7:05I used before and assigned, meaning to them, then you are
- 7:09assembling sentences and paragraphs and assigning an
- 7:14understanding of what I'm saying.
- 7:18But you're using your definitions and your experience
- 7:21of what those words being not mine.
- 7:23And so you could easily form a perception of what I'm saying.
- 7:27That's different than what I might intend to say.
- 7:32And that if you weren't conditioned understand the
- 7:35vibratory sound of spoken English, then you would be
- 7:39hearing sounds, but you wouldn't be able to assign meaning to
- 7:43them because you're not conditioned to sign.
- 7:47A meaning. It's I speak English only and so
- 7:51when somebody speaks to me in another language, I hear the
- 7:55sound of it and sometimes I can make out words, but I don't
- 7:59really have much in the way of assigning meaning, it isn't.
- 8:03Of course, the only way that we communicate, there's a whole
- 8:07meditech that happens, which is body language.
- 8:12We can sometimes understand the body language of somebody, even
- 8:16if we can understand there, Words that were offered often
- 8:20often layering those kinds of meanings.
- 8:23It's one of the reasons why texting is so emotionally
- 8:26fraught for a lot of people because it's absent of the meta,
- 8:32text of the subtext of the presentation.
- 8:36Of experience, it's absent, the empathetic connection which you
- 8:40can also make sometimes with people so that there's a felt
- 8:44sense of them in addition to the presentation of their their face
- 8:49and body language. In addition to the words which
- 8:52really allows a different sense and then actually if you're
- 8:56close enough to somebody and you can touch them in addition to
- 9:00that there was a tactile sense of the experience of being with
- 9:05him all of which I can convey meaning that is not simply
- 9:11language. And, of course, all of those can
- 9:14be defined by the experiences that we actually have My no an
- 9:22example of that would be. I had a friend in his family
- 9:27system, his mother father, would say, oh, that's terrible.
- 9:35And that gesture would be followed by soothing.
- 9:38But in my family system, my father would say, oh, and it
- 9:42would be followed by Sadistic abuse.
- 9:47So there was the meanings are quite different and one of the
- 9:54issues that we had in the relationship is that he would
- 9:56say, oh, as a gesture of intending to be soothing and I
- 10:00would just brace waiting and he would feel rejected by that
- 10:07Christian George. Do you feel like the Buddhist
- 10:12path offers reconditioning around these kinds of really
- 10:16deep, really like really old like conditions or well, I
- 10:24certainly think that the what I'm describing is is insight
- 10:29into the nature of those things, right?
- 10:31That we have a database and when you understand that, you
- 10:38actually take in The experiences that you have and that you
- 10:44define them in the way that you do and that you want to be in
- 10:48Intimate communication with someone else that requires that
- 10:52you begin to learn their definition of things.
- 10:55So that actually, you can communicate to them in a way
- 10:58that that means something to me. If you want to offer me soothing
- 11:03or should not be the first thing that you say, because I don't
- 11:06hear that, I don't hear soothing when you say that.
- 11:10And so part of the training, if you take the phrase from the
- 11:19refrain of the, such a, putana ceuta, mindfulness of, inside
- 11:23mindfulness of outside, in mindfulness of Inside and
- 11:26outside. But you understand is that you
- 11:30want to be able to track your own reactions to the experience
- 11:34that you're having and understand that they're yours.
- 11:38You want to be able to track the experience.
- 11:40That somebody else is having understand that?
- 11:44They're having those experiences.
- 11:46You also want to understand that your reaction, to things when
- 11:49they experience that reaction has an effect on them and the
- 11:54way that they react both to the present moment into your
- 11:56reaction. You react to and so there's an
- 12:00engagement. That would be another way to
- 12:04describe. That would be active
- 12:06mentalizing. That you are able to understand
- 12:10that, you are cherry picking the environment and selecting what's
- 12:17interesting to you and the person that you're with is
- 12:21cherry picking the environment for things that are meaningful
- 12:25to them and you're likely picking different elements from
- 12:29whatever is happening because you have different
- 12:33understandings of what's meaningful.
- 12:35And then you're assembling conceptual reality.
- 12:38Valerie from that selection that you've made.
- 12:42Then the person that you're with is creating conceptual reality
- 12:46from the selection that they've made.
- 12:49So that you may be actually experiencing quite different
- 12:52things in the same environment. And that you come from this
- 12:57place of this is what I think is going on.
- 13:00What do you think is going on? Rather than this is my
- 13:03understanding of what's happening and you're having the
- 13:06same experience? And so I can assign meaning to
- 13:10that, it's a non mentalizing stance.
- 13:13So, in a non-buddhist frame, what we would be really saying
- 13:17is that, you understand the nature of the human condition is
- 13:20that Not that there's a universal experience that you
- 13:25can tap into that. Everybody has the same
- 13:29experience of that that making sense.
- 13:35So in some sense, what you do is learn the people that you're in
- 13:39relationship to an understand what, what what the meaning what
- 13:46their meanings are and then with a collaborative relationship, of
- 13:53course, they're doing the same thing for you.
- 13:58So that then when you communicate to each other,
- 14:00you're sensitive to the definitions that they use so
- 14:05that you can translate into a different language if you need
- 14:10to what you need to convince convey to them.
- 14:14So you understand in your definitions, what it is.
- 14:17You want to convey terms of meaning and translate in that
- 14:22into the definitions that they use.
- 14:24So that you're actually communicating. the thing that
- 14:27you want to mean, Stop making sense.
- 14:33And learning them learning them well enough that you can do it
- 14:36fast enough, right? So when you get, when you have a
- 14:41moment of stress and your cognitive mind collapses, that
- 14:47you can still from that place of emotional dysregulation,
- 14:53communicated in a way that skillful, Does that make sense?
- 15:07one of the things that conditioning does of course, is
- 15:12create these Meanings for things, but also these
- 15:19expectations through things. So you have the capacity to send
- 15:24something, you have an object that can be sensed by that
- 15:27capacity, right? You can't.
- 15:29Well, I was going to say you can't hear Light but I was at a
- 15:38performance of Mozart's Thirty Ninth Symphony last week and one
- 15:44of the people I was with is sinensis sinensis ascetic, you
- 15:50know what I mean of what? When they hear sound, it forms
- 15:54color in the mind and so they were they close their eyes and
- 15:59at a certain point, they grabbed my arm because the color
- 16:03experience that they were having was so intense, I don't have
- 16:07that. So I was just really in a moment
- 16:11of Envy for what that must be like to be able to hear color
- 16:19Christian. To what you were just saying,
- 16:23about the sort of personal conditioning.
- 16:26I have a friend with synesthesia and I asked her about that kind
- 16:29of stuff. And everyone was synesthesia has
- 16:31different color associations, right?
- 16:34None of the none of the like classical composers could agree
- 16:37on what keys were what colors they had.
- 16:45Exactly, that's it. I think that a real
- 16:51understanding of that is that it enriches everything that
- 16:54everybody's point of view is different, it's like different
- 16:56facets. Looking at the Jewel of the
- 16:58Dharma, there's so many ways of seeing things that that if you
- 17:03can get somebody to trust you enough to tell you what's going
- 17:07on. That's awesome.
- 17:09Right? And if you, if you can get
- 17:13somebody to be willing to listen to you, as you as you describe
- 17:17that experience, that's also 1. For its enriching and creates
- 17:23depth in the experience beyond what you alone can figure out.
- 17:30There's a wonderful poem. You've probably heard me read it
- 17:33because I like it so much the schinder poem about dying and
- 17:41really it is in a wild paraphrase.
- 17:43What's so wonderful about relationships is, particularly
- 17:49Intimate Relationships is getting out into the far end
- 17:53edge of what you can know about somebody else but they can know
- 17:57about you. And how that makes Feel seen in
- 18:01any way and that that sense of somebody really seeing you and
- 18:06and delighting in who you are, is so meaningful.
- 18:15One of the things, of course, as I say that that my daughter
- 18:20around that is we come into this world.
- 18:24My friend of Laura Chiba just came by with Maeve.
- 18:28The baby. Who's four months old?
- 18:31She's a little sparkling red head with blue eyes and You see
- 18:41this little one? No self, right?
- 18:45So it'll be so enchanting and engaging delightful and And yet,
- 19:00not everybody has that experience as a baby.
- 19:03That their caregivers think that their enchanting and delightful.
- 19:07Not everybody has caregivers who respond to the that natural
- 19:14innocence. And the way that we really
- 19:17understand that beingness that we have is as its reflected back
- 19:23to us in the faces of the caregivers that we have.
- 19:27They, we, we are simply these this vibrating and if you've
- 19:34ever been around a newborn, you can see them.
- 19:37Vibrating literally, you can see the waves of emotion, washing
- 19:42over them. And you can see the Fearfulness
- 19:47and all the rest of the things in a completely unmasked open
- 19:51way, is they have no sense of needing to do any of that?
- 19:55And and then each time they make that presentation.
- 20:01They're looking for the reassurance.
- 20:04They're looking for that reflection of what that
- 20:09experience is. And what that experience means,
- 20:11this is the the source of that early Listening. and what we
- 20:22tend to do in that process of being conditioned by our
- 20:26caregivers, is to assign meaning to those impulses based on the
- 20:31reflection back to us, which is not necessarily Who we are or
- 20:39what we're doing. That makes sense and then that
- 20:43begins to build up if we're really fussy, if we really
- 20:49uncomfortable if we cry a lot because her colicky and our our
- 20:54caregivers constantly reflect back to us that we're delightful
- 20:59and that they're happy to take care of us and happy to be there
- 21:02with us. Then, even those difficult
- 21:05States, we assign a sense of Did this to it, we assign a sense of
- 21:11acceptance to them, whereas if it overwhelms the caregiver,
- 21:16then we can assign a sense of fearfulness to expressing those
- 21:20kinds of things. And it it happens.
- 21:22So early. That we learn who we are, as a
- 21:30reflection of our caregivers interested us.
- 21:35And the way that we present ourselves This is the attachment
- 21:40frame. And so, if they do a good enough
- 21:45job, which is a fairly low bar, which is about, 30% of the time
- 21:50were better, then we develop a sense of ourselves as being
- 21:55capable sense of ourselves as being delightful and stuff
- 21:59ourselves as being desirable. And if we don't have that, we
- 22:03developed different maps of ourselves.
- 22:06And really the thing about this is that that is it Affecting our
- 22:12expectation of how the world will respond to us and Buddhism.
- 22:18Of course the world means other people that expectation of how
- 22:22people will respond to us. So that when we create the
- 22:25experience of conceptual reality, we are also creating as
- 22:30part of that, an expectation of what will happen.
- 22:36And so, one of the things that is important to begin to do in
- 22:41this practice of meditation, is to really watch all of these
- 22:44things happen. So that you can understand the,
- 22:47the way that you form, the sense of self and world the way that
- 22:52you, what do you expect from yourself?
- 22:55And also, what do you expect from the world?
- 23:00Because it in it also in forms the actions that you take or
- 23:05that you don't take the Expressions that you make sure
- 23:09that you don't make One of the metaphors that I like quite a
- 23:18bit, is this idea that we all have a seat at the table and
- 23:22there's I grew up in a rather formal Protestant household with
- 23:29rules and manners and place cards by the seat where he's
- 23:34supposed to sit down. Do you have the expectation that
- 23:39your you have a seat at the table that you should look for
- 23:42your place card and just sit down Do you hope that some
- 23:47crumbs fall off the tables that you don't starve to death?
- 23:53The range of expectations that we have.
- 23:59So you have the capacity to sense the object that can be
- 24:02sensed when there's contact consciousness of the sensing
- 24:05experience arises. It's processed for urgency.
- 24:09Does it need immediate attention?
- 24:11Does it not matter if you get to it is, if it's Pleasant, is
- 24:17there time to experience something that's Pleasant?
- 24:20And then those events has their ordered on that.
- 24:24Basis are compared to the perceptual.
- 24:28Database. And if there's an entry that's
- 24:30close enough, then that whole string of meaning of the whole
- 24:35lifetime, is associated with the experience of the present
- 24:39moment. And here we go.
- 24:40Again, into this understanding of things, we need to be careful
- 24:46at that moment of the creation of conceptual reality, not to
- 24:51slip out of the present moment into the memory and then limit
- 24:56ourselves to just What happened? One of the reasons that we get
- 25:00into these? Samsaric Loops is because we
- 25:05slip out of awareness of the present moment into the memory.
- 25:08And then the only outcomes that we can see, are the things that
- 25:12have already happened. We don't see in the moment in
- 25:16front of us, all of the possibilities, all of the
- 25:18choices that we are, we could make.
- 25:21If we could recognize that they are there, but then we make an
- 25:25intention. This is one of those.
- 25:29Ideas that I think really resonates with the way that it
- 25:33is, is we make it intention for an action with an expectation of
- 25:37what will happen. But the, the nature of the this
- 25:42life that we're in the nature of the world that were in is so
- 25:45complex that we can't predict accurately what the outcome is
- 25:50going to be. So we make an intention for
- 25:53that. We take the action and then the
- 25:58The process of the world forming around that action happens and
- 26:04sometimes it goes in a way that's you can expect and
- 26:08sometimes it doesn't go in that way.
- 26:11And so you have to take in the outcome of the decision you make
- 26:17so that you can reformulate it a new response to it and again,
- 26:22the process repeats. And in that moment that And
- 26:29experience of the present moment opening, what opens with it is,
- 26:33all of the choices that you could make in the next moment.
- 26:39And if you're seeing clearly in your free, you can choose any of
- 26:43them that if you're conditioned and slip out of the awareness of
- 26:46the present moment in your stunk, in the habit of the way
- 26:52that you expect the world to be, you limit the choices that that
- 26:58you can make to just the things that have already happened.
- 27:03That this works pretty well with condition things where the
- 27:07experience of the present moment is like other things that you've
- 27:12experienced. But if it's novel, if it's a
- 27:16novel experience that in been the imagination is meant to kick
- 27:23in and try to make sense out of the experience and then
- 27:29formulate a response which takes longer.
- 27:33So sometimes there's a delay in that processing.
- 27:40If we actually add into this, some biology of how this
- 27:44happens. The conscious mind, the thing
- 27:48that we know is ourselves that experience of, I'm experiencing
- 27:53this, the I am, is runs about a half a second behind what's
- 28:00actually happening. So, we're getting a report of
- 28:03what's Happening. We're not actually in the
- 28:05experience of what's Happening. The science on.
- 28:09This is pretty good. We tend to smooth over the
- 28:14absence. So that when we're in the
- 28:18spontaneous side that automatic side of things and we're just
- 28:21doing in response, we tend to be more in line with what's
- 28:26actually happening. And when we have to flip into
- 28:30the monitoring of the controlled side of things there, we're
- 28:34running behind that making sense.
- 28:37You cannot play tennis from the sense of self because the ball
- 28:42has already gone by a half, a second to go.
- 28:46Have you ever tried to play a game or sport or something or do
- 28:53something? We're actually have to be really
- 28:55in the zone play. Well, and then when you're not
- 28:59in that space, it doesn't happen very well, that's because of
- 29:04this time, differential. You can't really drive from the
- 29:10cell, you have to flow into the zone of it to drive smoothly
- 29:17into it. Do you notice that you can do
- 29:19that and you're just sort of driving along if you can drive a
- 29:22car and then itself is sort of monitoring it, maybe the maybe
- 29:26it's thinking oh I should change the radio with the whole rest of
- 29:29the body is driving the car. So we have that when if you can
- 29:38get into an ease of understanding that the self is
- 29:41not actually, the thing that's doing it itself is actually the
- 29:44audience watching, what you're actually doing.
- 29:48The Jonas is doing it. And Joan is watching, you know,
- 29:52the Christian mrs. Doing it.
- 29:54And Christian is watching the Peter.
- 29:56Earnest is doing it in Peters watching.
- 30:01What's happening? So that you can jump in if you
- 30:03need to save the day. If your mind cone paying
- 30:07attention, But all of the rest of it is pretty automatic,
- 30:12pretty unconscious. And that actually is a good
- 30:16thing. I'm not complaining about that
- 30:19in any way. I'm just trying to describe to
- 30:21the way that it is. And that one of the reasons why
- 30:24meditation is so useful for for changing the early conditioning
- 30:30is because you're actually the the, the place of the meditation
- 30:34effects is that unconscious automatic place. so, if you do
- 30:39the formal practices, And then you watch to see whether or not
- 30:44it's having an effect rather than whether you enjoy the
- 30:50practice or not. One of the things about
- 30:52particularly in the beginning of practice, before you really have
- 30:56a sense that it's having these facts is that it's not that fun.
- 31:03For the the audience part to watch you work in the
- 31:08unconscious automatic place of meditation.
- 31:11And effects. You know, that was a great set
- 31:15because I was relaxed and felt comfortable in the breeze was
- 31:18nice for. That was a terrible sit because
- 31:20I felt irritation the body was too hot and it was a mosquito,
- 31:26but either one of those doesn't really register in terms of the
- 31:32effect of what meditation can do, because what you're
- 31:37affecting in meditation is not conscious.
- 31:44So you do your practice and you do it in an organized in
- 31:46skillful way that you can direct yourself more into the
- 31:50understanding of the nature of The Human Condition, which is
- 31:54that you live in this body, which is going to grow old, it's
- 31:57going to get sick, it's going to die everyone.
- 32:00You know, and everything you have will be lost because
- 32:03everything is impermanent and Sometimes you get what you want
- 32:11but it's impermanent, so you lose it.
- 32:12Sometimes you don't get what you want.
- 32:15Sometimes you have to put up with things that you don't want.
- 32:17There's a constant subtle irritation that it's not really
- 32:21the way that you would like it if you were in charge, which
- 32:23means a, it's on how you want it and you're not in charge and
- 32:27somehow you have to come into a place of understanding that this
- 32:30is actually it. Joan.
- 32:38Could you talk a little bit more about what you just said that
- 32:42the effects of meditation or unconscious?
- 32:48I can. One of the things that we use in
- 32:55the attachment side of things, is the ideal parent figure
- 32:57protocol. And the ideal parent figure
- 33:00protocol is based on the Maha mudra, Tibetan practices of bon,
- 33:06bon tradition. And the reason I'm using that,
- 33:09instead of a terabyte of which, I'll try to compare it to in a
- 33:13minute is because you are visualizing ideal caregiver,
- 33:23child relationships, and you visualize them.
- 33:27And they're remembered Word in the perceptual database. and you
- 33:33tend to work around in the beginning, particularly
- 33:37difficult experiences of the the miss attunements or failures of
- 33:43the parent-child relationship to provide a really a foundation of
- 33:51security in in you because when that process of forming the
- 34:00experience of conceptual reality happens, You have alternative
- 34:04entries of the database to form the the meaning of conceptual
- 34:09reality in the moment. So you have the capacity to
- 34:13sense. The object can be sensed when
- 34:15there's contact consciousness of the sensing experience arises.
- 34:20None of this is known by the self experience yet, because
- 34:23it's happened before, that experiences happened.
- 34:26It's evaluated for urgency and then it's compared to the
- 34:30perceptual database and the mind.
- 34:33Can grab an entry from the perceptual database?
- 34:35That's, that's visualized as well as something that actually
- 34:39happens. And then you attach the meaning
- 34:41of that to the Ultimate Reality, and then it unfolds into
- 34:49conceptual reality, which is then conscious.
- 34:55But the way that you formed conceptual reality, the
- 34:59selection of how to define the patterns of experience is all
- 35:04unconscious. It's not making sense.
- 35:08So as it unfolds into conceptual reality you have the opportunity
- 35:14to see it from the self perspective and understand it.
- 35:19But the way that you decided in that process to make conceptual
- 35:23reality still unconscious, you'd have to reverse engineer to
- 35:29understand it which is a part of the meta cognition of
- 35:33mentalizing process. In meditation, we are creating
- 35:40these entries into the perceptual database so that we
- 35:43have a whole different range of choices in terms of how we
- 35:47create conceptual reality. And so, what you notice is that
- 35:53one conceptual reality unfolds, the self experience of watching
- 36:00conceptual reality unfold is unchanged but the the Creation
- 36:05of conceptual reality is different.
- 36:09So you notice himself perspective that you're just
- 36:13making reality differently, you're just choosing different
- 36:16ways of formulating an understanding of the moment of
- 36:20self and world but the experience of the self watching
- 36:25that happen is it different? That's why I think it's such an
- 36:34in the beginning. It's it's sort of a baffling
- 36:38Experience of the self that think you're just choosing
- 36:41better. How did that happen?
- 36:45I didn't make a decision to choose better.
- 36:47I just, it just was better in the beginning, of course, it's
- 36:55kind of the rickety is the word that's been coming up for me
- 36:59lately, to describe that you have these.
- 37:01These sort of sparse visualizations that you're using
- 37:09and so, you form a reality which is really based in an
- 37:14imagination, But then of course you've formed a reality and then
- 37:20you take make an intention and take an action and then you
- 37:24remember what actually happened. So the the visualized
- 37:29experiences are then reinforced by the meaning you've made and
- 37:33the actions that you've taken. And so memories of actual things
- 37:37happening, are associated in the database.
- 37:42And so these very plain sort of thin end.
- 37:48These are then built upon by actual experiences.
- 37:53And so over the course of time, the database gets much, much
- 37:57richer in the vein of better choices than when you started.
- 38:05Does that make sense? And it's really doing these.
- 38:10I like to say Dopey meditations that you're sitting out the
- 38:15cushion meditating and it doesn't seem like much is
- 38:18happening. Because the self experience
- 38:22isn't actually the place where it's happening.
- 38:26It's happening underneath that in unconsciously.
- 38:31And then once it's built up enough, you just are you're just
- 38:35different without the self, having an explanation.
- 38:40So shins and used to say this, the self is not going to
- 38:44understand. This is just going to have to
- 38:46get used to it Christian. You are that was a good enough
- 38:56answer drone. Yeah.
- 39:01I was just thinking it seems like there's kind of two
- 39:03independent axes here. Like one is kind of like
- 39:08solidity or identification of like Concepts or conditions.
- 39:16That seems like the vipassana one that vipassana can kind of
- 39:18break that down your identification with whatever
- 39:21your condition is, but it's not maybe and maybe this is.
- 39:26Maybe I'm just off base, but it seems It doesn't really add and
- 39:29there's like another axis of like positive or negative.
- 39:32We're like that's where you can actually add references in and
- 39:37that's kind of where like the ipf or even maybe meta.
- 39:41Would work in terms of adding in new possibilities or new new
- 39:47entries, but the pasta doesn't really do that part.
- 39:57I know I threw a lot of a theory I just made up three seconds
- 40:01ago, but The. So I would answer that by saying
- 40:14you really would do one understand how to organize your
- 40:19practice so that you're able to effectively address the
- 40:25conditioning that you have. You want to get to a place where
- 40:32you can be completely spontaneous and also monitoring,
- 40:38you want to train the mind so that it will in a completely
- 40:43automatic and spontaneous way form a skillful representation
- 40:49of conceptual reality, that you don't have to do much about
- 40:53that. You can just operate from this
- 40:55place. Of seeing clearly the nature of
- 40:59things and forming over and over again, skillful responses the
- 41:06more training, you do, the less correction, you have to do
- 41:10because you more and more are simply seeing things clearly and
- 41:15responding in a skillful way. It's, you do have to
- 41:19continuously monitor though, because if you haven't worked
- 41:23through all of the conditioning in, there are still areas where
- 41:26you're sort of Compacted and and the the training, or the skill
- 41:30set that you have results in unskillful action, you have to
- 41:35be able to train yourself out of that.
- 41:38So, in the beginning, of course, if there's a lot of a lot of
- 41:43conditioning that doesn't allow that to see things clearly and
- 41:50to respond skillfully, then there's a lot to do have to pull
- 41:53everything apart and see the the the nature of it and the
- 41:59different different Traditions have different ways of going
- 42:04about doing that. The Tera vaada system is really
- 42:08about pulling everything apart and then watching things come
- 42:12back together so that you can see how things are made.
- 42:19The Zen tradition is, you know, the two main paths.
- 42:22One is the I would describe it as the path of confusion and
- 42:26what is the path. So, the koan practice is the
- 42:33path of confusion and the just do nothing.
- 42:36Path of Soto is is to just really be fully present in the
- 42:42moment and watch how everything arrives is and Becomes
- 42:47meaningful. And then in the Tibetan
- 42:50practices depending on what you do, it's really this shifting of
- 42:54identification from the self experience to awareness and
- 43:00watching in that pets that spaciousness of awareness,
- 43:05everything, arise and pass. I did not one of the Striking
- 43:12things for me and my own practice is that the sense of
- 43:16sacredness that I experienced in in every moment comes from the
- 43:23Tibetan practices and, you know, never had any hint of that it in
- 43:29my Tera vaada practice. It's not to say that no one
- 43:33knows but I had no sense of that at all and I use a metal
- 43:39Positive practice. So really is kind of more nuts
- 43:44and bolts is how I think about it.
- 43:47And then that that spaciousness and that expands where
- 43:52everything dissolves into, just this profound sense of
- 43:56sacredness has Quite marvelous and had been on unknown before I
- 44:07did those practices. so, but each of you, you know, each of
- 44:13us have our conditioning. And each of us will find the
- 44:17PATH. One of the extraordinary things
- 44:21about the west, of course, is that there's so much here, so
- 44:25much of a mixture here that you can find your way.
- 44:30I hope recommend that you've you find teachers who will help you
- 44:35along the way. Because it's, it's, it's
- 44:38important to a nice your practice in such a way, that
- 44:43it's fruitful because if it isn't fruitful, you won't do
- 44:46enough of it and it won't have the effect that it might and
- 44:55then of course, we bring our conditioning to our capacity to
- 45:01form relationships with people that might help us with the
- 45:03practice and so that can also be a fruitful exploration that you
- 45:11can see how you have a tendency to relate to people in
- 45:19attempting to relate to a teacher who Hoping will help
- 45:24you. So in some sense, You're trying
- 45:29to present yourself authentically, I hope.
- 45:32And then the teacher is responding. and in that
- 45:35exchange, you reinforce your capacity for authenticity and
- 45:42also, As a result of that, have a sense of being seen.
- 45:51And then hopefully the teacher that you choose has the capacity
- 45:55then to Delight in who you are. So that that aspect of a
- 46:01experience history and forth Well, making sense so far.
- 46:10Why don't we do the meditation? Then?
- 46:18I'm always wanting to do Metta meditation.
- 46:24At the first self. So go ahead and take your
- 46:31meditation posture. So any comments or questions
- 46:46about the practice that we just did?
- 46:51So let's see, not this Saturday, but the following Saturday, in
- 46:56Central European Time we're doing a level 143 Saturdays in a
- 47:00row. So if you're a night owl and
- 47:03want a sip from 1:00 a.m. until 9 a.m. that would be a good
- 47:08thing to do or if you know somebody who's in Europe that
- 47:12you might want to. And the program to this is our
- 47:17first class in Central European Time.
- 47:24We're going to do a level one in January, I think, in Pacific
- 47:29time. And then in April of second
- 47:32level one in Central European Time, we'll do a level 2
- 47:39starting over the winter, and then I have a retreat schedule
- 47:44in Utrecht in the Netherlands, in June.
- 47:49We have a, we want to do a 15-day meta jhana Retreat here
- 47:57in the US at some point. We're looking for a new
- 48:00Meditation Center, because the one that we've been using now is
- 48:03closed, but if you happen to know of a smallish meditation
- 48:08centers that are open, if you could shoot me an email, that
- 48:14would appreciate it because we were trying to find a new place
- 48:17to hang. Have our Retreats.
- 48:21I think that's about everything that's coming up.
- 48:27Thank you for coming. I appreciate your practice.
- 48:30I offered the teach you how to databases' Donna's the Pali word
- 48:33for generosity. So I offered the teachings
- 48:38freely but that I hope that, if you're able to, you'll make a
- 48:41donation, there's a link on the website.
- 48:43How to do that. Any amount is appreciated to
- 48:46help support being. Also the work that met a group
- 48:48is doing and I hope to see you soon somewhere along the path.
- 48:52I'll Good to meet you, Peter. George what was the name of the
- 48:59poem you had mentioned? It's a Jason chinder poem, so
- 49:06it's three poems. I usually think of the one that
- 49:10I was talking about is called Kota So, and now I know what
- 49:18most deeply connects us after that summer so many years ago,
- 49:21and it is in poetry, although it is poetry and it is an illness.
- 49:25Although we have that in common and is it even gratitude for
- 49:29every moment? Even the terrifying ones, even
- 49:31the physical pain, though, we are grateful and it is not even
- 49:35death though. We're halfway through it or even
- 49:37the way you describe the magnificence of being alive,
- 49:40catching a glimpse in the store window of your blowing hair and
- 49:44chapped lips. Is beautiful.
- 49:47It is it is that you are my friend out here on the far
- 49:51reaches of what humans can find out about each other.
- 49:56It's a good one. Yeah, it's very beautiful.
- 50:04Good. Good cool.
- 50:07Thank you George. See you later.
- 50:09Yeah. Have a good one.
- 50:10Bye Sandy. Thank you.
- 50:15George. I just wanted to hear about the
- 50:17poem as well. Good night.
- 50:20All right, goodbye, I