Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / SB 440 and the Fair Payment Act: What Construction Lawyers Need to Know for 2026
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome, everyone. My name is Howard Gould. I'm
- 0:07co -chair of the real estate section for the
- 0:09Beverly Hills Bar Association. And we're very
- 0:13happy to have this program for you today about
- 0:18some new legislation that's going to be important
- 0:20for a lot of construction projects. Before I
- 0:24do the introductions for this, I want to let
- 0:26you all know about our upcoming programs for
- 0:28this section. next week on Thursday, February
- 0:3226. We're doing a real property tax program.
- 0:36We have Chris O 'Neill and Ruben Sissian of the
- 0:39Greenberg Trowrig firm presenting. They're going
- 0:44to talk about a subject that we really haven't
- 0:46done before when it comes to property taxes.
- 0:48They're going to talk about how you recover attorney's
- 0:51fees and tax proceedings. Chris has litigated
- 0:55all the way up through the California Supreme
- 0:57Court, certainly some cases probably that involve
- 0:59public policy, and it'll be interesting to hear
- 1:02if and when they've been able to recover attorney's
- 1:05fees. And they're also going to give an update
- 1:07on what's going on at the State Board of Equalization
- 1:09regarding property taxes. In March, we have our
- 1:13annual California Association of Realtors. That's
- 1:16a CAR update on their new and revised forms.
- 1:19And Jana Gardner is joining us again for what
- 1:22is always a very interesting program to find
- 1:25out what's new on the residential purchase agreements.
- 1:30In April, we have Howard Fisher, longtime volunteer
- 1:36with the Beverly Hills Bar, former president,
- 1:38talking about 1031 exchanges. April 23, we're
- 1:43doing our annual review of the prior year's real
- 1:45estate cases by Larry Jacobson. We're doing another
- 1:49new program for us on May 21st, which is a program
- 1:53on landlord insurance coverage for habitability
- 1:57claims in landlord tenant disputes. I'm sure
- 2:00everyone realizes that habitability is a major
- 2:02issue in any landlord tenant litigation, most
- 2:06landlord tenant litigation. Idea that you could
- 2:11get insurance to cover that where these habitability
- 2:14claims comes up is a big issue and Steve Rauch
- 2:16are also another former Officer of Beverly Hills
- 2:22bar is going to give that presentation Steve
- 2:24is a specialist on insurance Our June program
- 2:28is going to be Brian Mashin who many of you know
- 2:31lectures for AIR. He gave lectures the last two
- 2:33years for us on their purchase agreement and
- 2:36their lease agreement and this time we're going
- 2:39to again do a different program. Brian's going
- 2:41to talk about effectively representing the small
- 2:44tenant in negotiating a commercial lease and
- 2:47the nuances and the dynamics when you have a
- 2:51smaller tenant negotiating with the landlord
- 2:54on their commercial lease. Just to remind everyone
- 3:00that for these programs, if you have questions,
- 3:03put them in the Q &A. The chat will have a link
- 3:05to the program materials and some information
- 3:08about the bar, but otherwise, all the Q &A should
- 3:11be put in the Q &A section. So it's my great
- 3:15pleasure to welcome Brenda Rodmacher, who's a
- 3:19partner at Safe Force Shaw, to give our presentation
- 3:22today. Brenda's practice focuses on legal issues
- 3:26affecting landowners, developers, contractors,
- 3:29and design professionals. For nearly three decades,
- 3:32Brenda has handled complex construction disputes,
- 3:36and she advises clients nationwide and internationally
- 3:39on all aspects of construction and project delivery,
- 3:42including design, build, EPC, and public -private
- 3:46partnerships with experience in construction
- 3:49defects, insurance issues, payment disputes and
- 3:52high stakes infrastructure, energy and real estate
- 3:55projects. So she's worked on obviously some very
- 3:58substantial projects and we're looking forward
- 4:01to her in educating us about SB 440. Brenda,
- 4:05welcome and thank you. Thank you so much, Howard.
- 4:09I really appreciate you and the Beverly Hills
- 4:11Bar Association having us today. My colleague
- 4:14Jay Houghton was on the agenda. And fortunately,
- 4:18he, as a lot of litigators, got called into a
- 4:20last minute deposition. So I am here and will
- 4:23carry the torch. I'm going to see if I can share
- 4:28my screen and start the slideshow. And we'll
- 4:32jump in. All right, so. Let's see if I can make
- 4:41it happen. It failed to start. Give me a moment.
- 4:51Let's go back. We had it all set and ready to
- 4:57go. Looks like it's up. Except the wrong slide
- 5:13is on there. So let me do one more. Sorry about
- 5:16that. There we go. All right. Now can you see
- 5:25it? Yes. Great. Well, I'm going to go through.
- 5:30You already did a great job of giving us an overview
- 5:34of what we're going to be doing. We always like
- 5:37to start with a disclaimer that This is not intended
- 5:40for legal advice, but I'm happy to answer as
- 5:43many questions as the audience has in the Q &A
- 5:46as we go along. I do want to give you an overview
- 5:49of what we're going to cover because I like people
- 5:51to know where we're going. So we're going to
- 5:54start. I'm going to give a background and some
- 5:56overview about this new statute. We're going
- 5:59to talk about the historic context, how we got
- 6:01to where we are. Then I'm going to dig into some
- 6:04of the meat. We're going to talk about what the
- 6:06statute is, what the requirements are, some enforcement
- 6:10provisions we're going to look at. the protections
- 6:13for subcontractors as well. It's a little bit
- 6:15of a subsection about what's happening in the
- 6:17statute. And then we're going to do some talk
- 6:20and look at some practical things that hopefully
- 6:23the audience can really take and use to implement
- 6:27what the statute is going to be requiring, having
- 6:30an understanding that, and then close out the
- 6:33time with looking at some of the uncertainties
- 6:36that the statute has now presented, as well as
- 6:40some of the risks that may apply both to owners,
- 6:45developers, contractors and subcontractors all
- 6:47involved in the construction project. So let's
- 6:51start with and jumping in on an overview. First
- 6:54off is this law is started as SB 440 and it's
- 7:00called the title of the act that it may be cited
- 7:02as is the Private Works Change Order Fair Payment
- 7:07Act. And as we all see as we get into this, it's
- 7:09a bit of a misnomer of the law. I may refer to
- 7:14it as the Fair Payment Act as we go along for
- 7:16short. But you know how these things go and we
- 7:19have a statute we oftentimes call it by its bill
- 7:22number, so SB 440. is also how we may refer to
- 7:26it for short. So SB 440 is statutes that is effective
- 7:32on new construction contracts that are as of
- 7:36January 1, 2026. And as we'll see, the law is
- 7:40a little bit unclear as what does that mean if
- 7:42you have a multi -phased project and what happens
- 7:46there. It is currently scheduled to sunset. January
- 7:501st, 2030. So we are at a four -year period of
- 7:53time to see how this plays out and what goes
- 7:56on. For those of you following along in the statute,
- 8:01California Civil Code is 850 and 851 is the Private
- 8:06Works Change Order Fair Payment Act. And it has
- 8:10a very narrow focus on private construction projects.
- 8:17Some things we're going to talk about a little
- 8:19bit of there's a similar statute that was passed
- 8:2210 years ago that was governing public works
- 8:26projects and we can talk a little bit of the
- 8:29comparison is interesting. Now what we do have
- 8:33on SB 440 it governs any and all disputed contractor
- 8:38time and payment claims. As you remember I said
- 8:42That's a bit of a misnomer, Tang. It's change
- 8:44orders. It's interesting because the initial
- 8:48part of the statute seems to have developed out
- 8:52of disputes arising on construction projects
- 8:54that relate to change orders. So who's responsible
- 8:58for the change order? Is it an owner -driven
- 9:00issue? Is it a contractor -driven issue? Is it
- 9:03a design issue? Why has this change order occurred?
- 9:07Is there some type of a issue that was unknown
- 9:12at the time, a hidden condition or the like.
- 9:16However, as the statute, as you dig into it,
- 9:20it actually very specifically applies not only
- 9:23to change orders, but in fact to any disputed
- 9:27payment amount. between the contractor and the
- 9:30owner, as well as disputes over delays and time.
- 9:35And as I like to say, in construction, people
- 9:38ask, what are construction lawyers? And why is
- 9:40there a whole area of construction law? I said,
- 9:42well, in construction, there's two issues. It's
- 9:43time and money. And this statute for private
- 9:46projects applies to both. The statute is now
- 9:50in expressly states that it's mandatory and non
- 9:53-waivable. There are some portions of some of
- 9:57the implementation that The parties can negotiate
- 10:00and can skip through a few of the hurdles, but
- 10:03it is a non -waivable. And it would be found
- 10:06to be against public policy if parties try to
- 10:08contract around the requirements under the act.
- 10:14And interestingly, and probably most importantly,
- 10:17there are significant financial consequences
- 10:20imposed by the statute for failure to comply.
- 10:23And we'll talk about that. So let me give you
- 10:26a bit of historical context and background on
- 10:30the reason why we have this law. And it's very
- 10:34interesting in section 8850, section A, it states
- 10:41two reasons for this statute. One is that it's
- 10:45in the best. interest of all the citizens of
- 10:48the state of California as well as for the parties
- 10:54to ensure that all construction business performed
- 10:57on private works in the state. are complete and
- 11:01are not in dispute is paid in full and in a timely
- 11:04manner. So this was the number one. They're like,
- 11:06look, we have a rampant issue where construction
- 11:10work that's done that's complete is either not
- 11:12paid in full or not paid timely. And the reason
- 11:16behind that is that there is substantial significant
- 11:20financial hardships on communities and on the
- 11:25construction contractors and particularly small
- 11:28businesses. and minority and disabled veteran
- 11:32business owned contractors is the statutes underlying.
- 11:37And historically there has been in the construction
- 11:39industry, the subcontractors are usually the
- 11:42parties that are bearing the brunt of some of
- 11:46the payment disputes, even if it might be just
- 11:48between the owner and the general contractor.
- 11:50And as we'll talk about a little bit, the genesis
- 11:55of this statute really does seem to have come
- 11:58in large part from the construction and subcontractor
- 12:03interest groups and lobbies. We are seeing that
- 12:08also when there are disputes on payments, particularly
- 12:12and delay claims, they often do require extensive
- 12:17litigation that can last for years. And so then
- 12:19if you have this. position where parties aren't
- 12:22being paid and work might have been done and
- 12:24was owed, there's a substantial impact that's
- 12:27reducing the number of contractors who are staying
- 12:30in business. And so the legislature found that
- 12:32this was something important and that they thought
- 12:35would be useful. The Senate Judiciary's analysis
- 12:40actually noted that because change orders oftentimes
- 12:44were informal or not fully documented or maybe
- 12:48not executed during the middle of a construction
- 12:53project that there were late or partial payment
- 12:56issues that contractors were suffering and or
- 13:00that they weren't being meaningfully addressed
- 13:02until the end of the project, which under the
- 13:05Senate Judiciary's analysis was leading to extensive
- 13:09and expensive litigation with without having
- 13:14any structure. And so that the statute was intended
- 13:17to provide some structure for dispute resolution
- 13:19to make things more efficient in the private
- 13:23sector. And the sponsor, Southern California
- 13:28Association of Scaffold Contractors was one of
- 13:31the sponsors that was cited in the Senate floor
- 13:34analyses in the historical underlying for the
- 13:40statute being impacted and you know, talking
- 13:42about empower imbalances. And as we'll see, you
- 13:46know, a lot of times they say, well, is there
- 13:48really a power imbalance when you've got maybe
- 13:50a homeowner and a contractor, maybe a very different
- 13:53situation than when you have a multi -facility
- 13:56owner developer and a contractor. And the statute
- 13:59actually does try to address some of those issues.
- 14:04This SBA 440 framework has been inspired, as
- 14:07I mentioned, by laws governing the public work
- 14:09projects dispute resolution on payments. And
- 14:12you are all welcome to reference and read through
- 14:15public contracts code section 9204. And as I
- 14:20mentioned, that statute passed just under 10
- 14:23years ago is enacted in 2017 and will sunset
- 14:27if it's not extended the end of. this year. As
- 14:32of right now, we aren't seeing any issues of
- 14:36whether it will be extended or not that has not
- 14:38yet been passed through, but we're keeping an
- 14:40eye on that. Under the public contracts section
- 14:44and statute, there is a not a mandatory passer
- 14:48of subcontractor claims for a prime contractor.
- 14:51So they may under the statute under section 9204,
- 14:55they may pass through a claim to an owner, but
- 14:57they're not required to. And And under section
- 15:009204, there is a maximum of 7 % interest annually
- 15:06on payments that are not paid timely under the
- 15:09statute's requirements. Keep that in mind as
- 15:12we go through and talk now about CESB 440 and
- 15:18again, section 8850 and 8851 are you'll see some
- 15:23differences and we can do some comparisons. Now
- 15:25the law covers, as I mentioned, all private construction
- 15:29projects, but there are some limitations. The
- 15:31exceptions, it does not apply to residential
- 15:34projects that are under five stories that are
- 15:37not mixed use. So if you have a mixed use project,
- 15:42maybe your first floor has some commercial, I
- 15:46mean, you have only two floors that are residential,
- 15:49the statute apply. However, if it is solely residential
- 15:53under five stories. This statute does not apply
- 15:57and parties are free to try to negotiate and
- 16:01obtain payments and deal with those on their
- 16:05own. Now, this statute also governs not only
- 16:11owner general contractor disputes, but it governs
- 16:15also any subcontractor demands. It covers, as
- 16:20I mentioned, not just current change orders,
- 16:22but it covers time extensions, including liquidated
- 16:24damages, and also for payment for work under
- 16:28the contract. And this is, it's interesting,
- 16:31it's a quote here of not otherwise provided for
- 16:33or to which claimant is entitled. And the statute
- 16:36doesn't define exactly what that means, but the
- 16:39best interpretation that we've been able to determine
- 16:41is essentially it's. any disputed payment amount
- 16:45or payment issue for work performed by the contractor.
- 16:51And finally, it covers amounts disputed by the
- 16:55owner. So the owner may look at a change order
- 16:58or a payment request from a contractor and dispute
- 17:02that it was accurate or complied with the terms
- 17:04of the contract or the rates agreed upon. And
- 17:07that would also fall under what the statute covers.
- 17:11So let's look a little bit at some of the key
- 17:14requirements under SB 440. And there's a couple
- 17:19of slides here because there's quite a number
- 17:21of requirements. And let me before I'm gonna
- 17:24give you kind of a thing is really the way that
- 17:26the statute is, there's really three sections
- 17:29of what parties are going to have to do. The
- 17:32first section is a claims process. So you've
- 17:35got a claim being made. The second phase of that
- 17:39is going to be where there is an informal conference
- 17:44or a meet and confer requirement to address payment
- 17:49disputes and or time disputes. And then the third
- 17:51section is a required mediation. So we've got
- 17:55a three step process and here are some of these
- 17:57requirements and we'll walk through them a little
- 17:59bit. So the first issue is the contractor has
- 18:03a claim. The claim has to be submitted. Everything
- 18:06under the statute for communications by the parties
- 18:10when we say it has to be submitted, it has to
- 18:13be done registered mail or certified mail or
- 18:16some form of mailing with a return receipt requested.
- 18:23So when we say it's being submitted, that's what
- 18:25I mean every time certified mail, registered
- 18:28mail, return receipt requested. There's nothing
- 18:31in the statute that says the parties couldn't
- 18:33contract to have a different means of communication.
- 18:37So that's an open question, but the notice got
- 18:41to be done and that's one hurdle. If you don't
- 18:44issue your notices and your claims and your responses
- 18:46with certified registered mail return receipt
- 18:49requested, it could be deemed that you're in
- 18:51violation of the statute and we'll see the ramifications.
- 18:54So your claim by the contractor first has to
- 18:57be supported by reasonable documentation. There
- 19:00is no definition of what that requires. So it's
- 19:02up to everybody's interpretation of what would
- 19:04be reasonable to be documented. And that can
- 19:08be done at any point in time during the course
- 19:11of construction and then the statute and or at
- 19:14the end and the statutes then triggers the next
- 19:16steps. So the next step, the owner response.
- 19:19So far so good. So very simple claim is made
- 19:21owner response. Owner has written response. And
- 19:25that again is certified or registered mail, returned
- 19:27receipt requested. And they need to identify
- 19:30if there is any undisputed amount or disputed
- 19:35amounts in the request made by the contractor.
- 19:38That undisputed amount then goes to the next
- 19:42phase. But that timing, as you can see, the owner
- 19:45has 30 days from receipt of the written notice
- 19:48of claim to provide this response. They need
- 19:51to identify the undisputed amounts. And then
- 19:54if there are undisputed amounts, those need to
- 19:57be paid within 60 days of the issuance of the
- 20:01response. So you're kind of adding in, you've
- 20:04got 30 days as an owner to respond. And then
- 20:08another 60 days to pay, so 90 days if anybody's
- 20:11keeping track to issue that for undisputed. Now,
- 20:15if you have remaining disputed items, you go
- 20:18to the next phase. For the disputed issues, then
- 20:20you have a mandatory meet and confer requirement
- 20:24where the parties meet and confer about the disputed
- 20:27amount. The contractor is, well then after receipt
- 20:33of the notice from the owner, as we saw, you
- 20:35get 30 days owner says, I agree. Then you've
- 20:40got. 30 days contractor then can request a meet
- 20:44and confer. Within then that time if the meet
- 20:48and confer occurs the contractor the owner then
- 20:52can notify in as 10 days to notify about any
- 20:56remaining disputed amount with the hope that
- 20:59during that meet and confer there is agreement
- 21:01and resolution that all the issues there's no
- 21:04more disputed amounts they've been agreed upon.
- 21:07And for each time there's an agreed upon amount,
- 21:10undisputed, the owner has 60 days to pay that
- 21:13amount from that time. So we'll go through an
- 21:16example on that. But then you say, what happens
- 21:18next? We still have undisputed amounts. We may
- 21:21have gone down this, and we keep trying to, in
- 21:24a sense, whittle it down. So now we have remaining
- 21:26disputed amounts. And within the 10 days, the
- 21:31owner sends that. that notice, the parties then
- 21:34after receiving that notice have another 10 days
- 21:36to agree upon a mediator. If the parties can't
- 21:40agree upon a mediator, the contractor has the
- 21:43right to select one and commence that mediation
- 21:47process. The mediation is mandatory. non -binding,
- 21:52and there is not a time frame under the statute
- 21:55that the mediation must occur, with the assumption
- 21:59that the parties have agreed, they've got a mediator,
- 22:02and then they work with the mediator to schedule
- 22:04the time for the mediation. If there are still
- 22:08remaining disputed items or the mediation process
- 22:10is not successful in resolving all issues, then
- 22:14the parties can proceed either with their arbitration
- 22:18or litigation proceeding as provided for as their
- 22:22dispute resolution process under the contract.
- 22:25So it's a lot and there's a lot of moving parts,
- 22:28as you can see. Now, go ahead. I have a question.
- 22:33I've always questioned the right of for example,
- 22:37a court to force somebody to go pay a private
- 22:39mediator, and there's no mediator panel set up
- 22:43for this. Do you think this is going to be subject
- 22:46to some challenge where somebody says, you know,
- 22:48they don't have a right to force me to go basically
- 22:51to some other proceeding besides the court that
- 22:55I have to pay for? Yes. The short answer is yes.
- 22:59We are definitely anticipating that on several
- 23:04levels. However, it'll be very interesting to
- 23:08see how that plays out. Under the statute, the
- 23:13parties can agree mutually to waive either the
- 23:17informal conference or the mediation requirement.
- 23:20So that lies this issue where, well, if the parties
- 23:23agree to waive it, but it still is forcing if
- 23:27other party won't agree. So I think that is an
- 23:30area ripe for some challenge. We'll see if that
- 23:33actually comes in. And now the part that's interesting,
- 23:39so as I mentioned, the notices, the registered
- 23:41certified mail is important, but what happens
- 23:44if the owner doesn't respond? So that's always
- 23:46a concern. Whereas contractors is like, hey,
- 23:49we've done the work, the owner has ignored us
- 23:51or they're refusing to pay. Now we've gone through
- 23:53this process. We've done all the things. We've
- 23:55issued our notices timely and the owner fails
- 23:58to respond. or the owner fails to timely respond,
- 24:02either one, is deemed expressly under the statute
- 24:05as the entire claim is being denied. And then
- 24:09you can kind of skip through everything and go
- 24:12straight to your dispute resolution process under
- 24:14your contract. The interesting question, though,
- 24:19is the parties under the statute are supposed
- 24:21to share mediation costs equally. And Howard,
- 24:24as you phrased, now we've got the legislature
- 24:29forcing people to pay mediator fees for this.
- 24:33So I think that's an area that is a huge question
- 24:37mark as to what's going to happen with that.
- 24:40With the statute applying in large part to, even
- 24:44though they're residential, projects. They're
- 24:48more likely to be commercial owners, commercial
- 24:51and larger contractors that are doing these.
- 24:53They may end up saying we'd prefer to participate
- 24:57and spend some money on mediation instead of
- 24:59challenge it, but we will see. Now, the other
- 25:02thing that is interesting is the statute does
- 25:04say you can agree to additional change order
- 25:08or claim dispute resolution requirements as long
- 25:11as they don't eviscerate the procedures and the
- 25:16timing provided in the statute. Again, another
- 25:19ambiguity. So we expect there's, you know, assuming
- 25:22the statute continues and stays in place, that
- 25:26there will be challenges and issues raised about,
- 25:31hey, now the owner has modified the contract,
- 25:34even the parties agree. Is it something that
- 25:36is allowed under the law? So the ambiguity there
- 25:41still exists. Now, I'm going to give you a little
- 25:43visual aid because people are like, how do we
- 25:48deal with this? So I want to walk through what
- 25:51would happen. Here, we took a simple example.
- 25:54If you've got a contractor with a $1 ,000 claim,
- 25:58the owner has to respond within 30 days. If the
- 26:01owner in this case says, I agree, I owe you half
- 26:04of it, we don't dispute half. So the undisputed
- 26:07500, as you see to the - to the right on the
- 26:10chart, owner has 60 days to pay that. Owner pays
- 26:13the 560 days, that's done. The remaining amount
- 26:18of 500, there's no set deadline under the statute,
- 26:22but the contractor then can request an informal
- 26:25conference, which then triggers the timing from
- 26:28there. So we've got $500, they're going to have
- 26:3130 days to have an informal conference. There's
- 26:34no guidance as to what that needs to look like.
- 26:36in person by zoom a telephone who needs to be
- 26:39a part of that necessarily um someone with authority
- 26:42is about all that the statute provides um after
- 26:46the informal conference 10 days but howard you
- 26:48had a question yeah brenda does this mean that
- 26:51that seven percent interest provision doesn't
- 26:53apply during those 90 days oh good question now
- 26:58first i will tell you seven percent is seven
- 27:00percent annually is under the public uh Statute
- 27:04under the public contract, but for the for sba
- 27:06for for sp4 40. It's a two percent interest per
- 27:10month Yeah, that's really a huge amount of interest.
- 27:14Yes It can be that's up to 24 a year And i've
- 27:18got a whole section on this coming because it's
- 27:21an interesting question Of of when does that
- 27:25apply preview is the undisputed amounts? It's
- 27:29it's intended really, it's not called a penalty,
- 27:32it's interest, but it is really intended to try
- 27:34to get parties to agree as early as you can on
- 27:38undisputed amounts. And I know for a lot of the
- 27:41contractors and folks I've represented and owners,
- 27:44you know, a lot of times it's hard to like, well,
- 27:46we don't want to release the undisputed amount
- 27:48because that's our leverage. And, you know, my
- 27:51advice has always been just pay what it is because
- 27:53you're going to have interest potentially do.
- 27:56Yeah, and this statute really is pushing that
- 27:59it's like if there is any amount that's undisputed
- 28:02pay immediately. And if you have disputed amounts,
- 28:06you better be pretty certain that you've got
- 28:08a good basis to not pay as an owner. And because
- 28:12the penalties do start to attack to add up. Yeah,
- 28:17go ahead. Is that Let's say that you have a dispute
- 28:21with the contractor, but it's not regarding the
- 28:24particular payment they're talking about, but
- 28:26you've discovered some prior work they did that
- 28:28you already paid for that is defective or incomplete,
- 28:32and you want to raise that as a defense to this
- 28:35particular progress payment. The great question,
- 28:38it's not answered under the statute. And it would
- 28:42be part of that argument that you'd say, hey,
- 28:44we're not paying you for this payment for that
- 28:46reason. And that still the parties are supposed
- 28:49to try to negotiate that. in the informal conference
- 28:52or through the mediation. So it doesn't preclude
- 28:56you from making those as arguments and positions
- 28:59as well. And vice versa for the contractor. So
- 29:03if the contractor is claiming this money is owed
- 29:06because there was on a change order basis because
- 29:09the design changed and they needed to, it wasn't
- 29:12called for in the original drawings. And the
- 29:15owners, the argument from the owner is no, this
- 29:18was, and you should have seen it or you should
- 29:19have raised it. or there's some other issue that
- 29:21the contractor didn't do, those issues still
- 29:23are part of this whole negotiation process. And
- 29:28it remains to be seen how it all plays out. But
- 29:32assuming you get to the informal conference and
- 29:34there's still no agreement, contractor owner
- 29:38has 10 days from then the contract owner to notify
- 29:42the contractor. In this situation, we said, great,
- 29:44they were able to agree 50 % of the 500 that
- 29:48was remaining disputed. And in that informal
- 29:51conference, then they have another 60 days. So
- 29:54it's a new trigger date from the informal conference
- 29:56if there's agreed upon amounts. And the remaining
- 29:59disputed amounts continue to flow down to the
- 30:02next phase. The owner, after they notify that
- 30:05they still dispute amounts, they have 10 days
- 30:08to then mutually select a mediator, as we talked
- 30:12about. And then again, they can proceed to mediation.
- 30:15If there's no resolution, it goes to the dispute
- 30:18resolution. And your comment and your question,
- 30:20interestingly, there's not a panel of mediators,
- 30:23and I will say yet, to handle these claims. I
- 30:28am on American Arbitration Association's panel
- 30:30of mediator and arbitrator, as a lot of construction
- 30:33lawyers do serve in that role. And I believe
- 30:37that AAA, as well as a variety of the other dispute
- 30:40providers and jams and ADR services are looking
- 30:43at this and trying to say, do we have who are
- 30:45available to serve as, and there may be reduced
- 30:50rates depending on the size of the dispute. So
- 30:53I think that the mediation community is looking
- 30:55at this and is going to be responding to it as
- 30:58well, seeing the need that the statute may be
- 31:02creating. The interesting part of what can the
- 31:06contractor do here, so if the owner fails to
- 31:10pay timely or has paid the undisputed amounts,
- 31:14or if there are adjudicated amounts, so if they
- 31:16do go to an adjudication proceeding, the contractor
- 31:22can suspend work until the payment is made. And
- 31:28this applies, like I said, if they don't. respond
- 31:31during the process or on the payment side. So
- 31:34there is a 30 -day stop work notice that the
- 31:39contractor is required to issue. And after that,
- 31:42they have a 10 -day period they have to wait.
- 31:44So they have to say, hey, we're going to stop
- 31:46work. You've got 10 days to cure and pay. And
- 31:52if you don't, we then issue a 30 -day stop work
- 31:55notice, and they can stop in 30 days after that.
- 31:59Again, very little detail in the statute of what
- 32:02that looks like and how that works. So we expect
- 32:05there to be some issues and disputes coming out
- 32:09of that part of the statute as well. And as I
- 32:11mentioned, the 2 % interest, and Howard, your
- 32:14question was right on target of, well, when does
- 32:16this commence? And it's 2 % per month on each
- 32:20of the unpaid sums from the date it's deemed
- 32:23due and owing. So if the owner agrees and said
- 32:27this is an undisputed amount, that is deemed
- 32:31due and owing for the unpaid amounts. And they
- 32:34have 60 days to pay. And if they don't pay within
- 32:36that 60 -day period, then our interpretation
- 32:39is that the interest on the undisputed amounts
- 32:42not paid timely would commence after that 60
- 32:44-day period. For the disputed amounts, as you
- 32:48go through, if it's deemed due in owing, the
- 32:52interpretation is a little bit hard to tell what
- 32:54the statute means, but it does appear to be an
- 32:57argument that if it is disputed and you go through
- 33:01this process, it is not necessarily deemed due
- 33:06and owing until you go through the process. However,
- 33:09I can guarantee you that there also is an argument
- 33:12under the ambiguity in the statute to say it's
- 33:14triggered from day one when the owner rejects
- 33:17and says we find it, we dispute it and we go
- 33:21through this whole process and we litigate and
- 33:23we find that we do owe the money, that there
- 33:26will be arguments that it was due and owing from
- 33:29the date of claim. Lots of opportunities for
- 33:34disputes and a lot of legal arguments that we
- 33:37think are going to probably be forthcoming. Now,
- 33:40the way the statute's worded and written, it
- 33:42is discussing obligations and requirements between
- 33:47the contractor and the owner. There is a subsection
- 33:50that does address subcontractors. what happens
- 33:54to the subcontractors. And as we started, it's
- 33:57interestingly because the majority of the underlying
- 34:00historical context was trying to bring and protect
- 34:03some of the subcontractors. So you have a subcontractor
- 34:06who's deemed to have no contractual privity with
- 34:10the owner, but they are allowed to submit their
- 34:14own written requests for themselves or a lower
- 34:17steer. And again, certified mail return or return.
- 34:21registered mail return receipt requested. And
- 34:24they have to submit that to the prime contractor
- 34:27to submit to the owner as a pass through. The
- 34:30subcontractor under the statute has to do this
- 34:33quote unquote timely and provide reasonable supporting
- 34:36documentation, neither of which are defined.
- 34:40So, you know, is timely 30 days? I don't know.
- 34:43Is it 60 days? Is it? We're not sure. So timely,
- 34:48and my recommendation, do it as soon as there
- 34:50is an issue on payment. Get it going and provide
- 34:54the backup as to why the work was done and it
- 34:57was built. And then under SB 440, the subcontractor,
- 35:04if they're submitting a claim, has to cooperate
- 35:06with the contractor through this dispute resolution
- 35:09process. And again, it doesn't really tell us
- 35:13what that cooperation looks like. And that may
- 35:17lead to some disputes between the contractors
- 35:19and the subcontractors as, hey, I'm going to
- 35:22pass through your claim, but you got to do X,
- 35:23Y, and Z. And the sub says, I don't have to.
- 35:25So we'll see where that ends up going. But within
- 35:29this process, so what happens is the subcontractor
- 35:32makes a request. The contractor has an obligation
- 35:35to respond in writing. to the subcontractor and
- 35:39tell them if they're submitting the claim to
- 35:41the owner or not. They're not obligated to submit
- 35:43it, but they are obligated to respond to the
- 35:47subcontractor to identify in writing why they
- 35:50are not submitting it to the owner. The only
- 35:54requirement that the statute provides is the
- 35:56owner, the contractor has to act in good faith.
- 35:58Again, not defined. And finally, if they are
- 36:02going to negotiate and go through the process
- 36:04with the owner, a contractor cannot settle the
- 36:08subcontractor's claim without written approval
- 36:10from the subcontractor. Lots of layers in this.
- 36:14And as we saw, it's kind of a truncated time
- 36:17frame. So if you've got 10 days to agree upon
- 36:20the mediator, subcontractor under the statute
- 36:23doesn't have a right to demand or select that
- 36:26mediator. You can go through that as the contractor,
- 36:31the prime contractor with the owner, negotiate,
- 36:33but you've got to get the approval in writing
- 36:36from the subcontractor. In my mind, does that
- 36:40subcontractor then have to be in the mediation?
- 36:42And Howard, to your question, is the subcontractor
- 36:44now having to pay a portion of the mediation
- 36:46fees? So lots of different moving parts as to
- 36:50what the subcontractor protections and requirements
- 36:54are going to be. And again, the statute, it's
- 36:57a pretty short uh statutes quit pretty quick
- 37:01read there's not a lot of detail in that i'm
- 37:03also wondering brenda does this somehow create
- 37:06an obligation from an owner to a subcontractor
- 37:09they're not in privity with and does like the
- 37:12two percent a month apply to these sorts of claims
- 37:15So the claim, technically, is because it's a
- 37:18pass -through claim, it's coming to the contractor.
- 37:21So the 2 % would still be owed, but it would
- 37:25be owed to the contractor. So I don't see it
- 37:28as creating any other obligations out of privity,
- 37:30because it is going through the chain, so to
- 37:33speak, of command. Aren't there possible problems
- 37:37with the subcontractor's agreement with the contractor?
- 37:40It doesn't really align with the progress payments
- 37:42the contractor's entitled to get? Very, very
- 37:45true. Yes. And also, you know, one of the areas
- 37:49that we see as problematic is that the, you know,
- 37:55if it is it's creating kind of these two routes
- 37:58and two timings. And it does behoove owners to
- 38:02be asking their contractors to see the subcontract
- 38:05agreements and understand what what their negotiation
- 38:09and their payment process is with their subcontractors
- 38:12because of those issues. One would think that
- 38:15might be part of the documentation that the contractor
- 38:18has to supply with the claim. Otherwise, the
- 38:20claim is incomplete. Right. Right. Yeah. Yeah.
- 38:23And again, because it's ambiguous as to what
- 38:26needs to be included other than reasonable backup
- 38:29and reasonable documentation. It's an open question.
- 38:36And because it applies also to delay claims and
- 38:39not just payment disputes. We talk it's the easy
- 38:41way and the way the statute is written is really
- 38:44focusing on dollars. But the interesting question
- 38:47is, if you've got a payment delay issue or a
- 38:52scheduled delay on the project still is going
- 38:55to be an issue. And how do you evaluate that?
- 38:58And what portion of it is disputed or not? So
- 39:01there's some issues that that's brought up. It
- 39:05seems problematic because a lot of times the
- 39:07contractor may already have had issues with the
- 39:09subcontractor. That's why they haven't paid them.
- 39:13It isn't really the owner's fault because there's
- 39:16defective work. There's been delay by the subcontractor.
- 39:20They may even have a dispute between themselves
- 39:22on another job. And all of a sudden the owner
- 39:25is injected into this dispute that doesn't really
- 39:29involve them. I would say not necessarily though,
- 39:31because what the statute does provide is it doesn't
- 39:34require the contractor to pass through the subcontractor's
- 39:37claim. So the contractor can respond to the subcontractor
- 39:41in a situation like you've raised. I say, I'm
- 39:44not passing this claim through because you haven't
- 39:47performed or you have these other issues or whatever
- 39:50those claims may be. They just have to put that
- 39:53in writing and send it to the subcontractor.
- 39:55So that helps. I think a little bit in that regard,
- 39:59and it's not really putting the owner in that
- 40:00difficult position in those types of circumstances.
- 40:05The implementation, you know, this is what we're
- 40:08encouraging everyone in the construction industry
- 40:11to do, whether you're counsel, whether you're
- 40:14a contractor, you're an owner developer, you're
- 40:16a subcontractor. with it, you know, construction
- 40:20project managers as well need to be aware of
- 40:23these as we're looking at contracts and negotiating
- 40:25is understanding and reviewing the timelines.
- 40:29We are really recommending is setting up calendar
- 40:31alerts. So figuring out and really adjusting
- 40:34your payment. schedule if you're an owner and
- 40:37a contractor for your subcontractors, being sure
- 40:40you're tracking the payment timing, looking at
- 40:44any tracking software that you're currently using,
- 40:47and evaluating if those need to be updated. In
- 40:51addition, having documentation standards within
- 40:56your organization to be understood so that you
- 40:59know not only what your payment. request protocols
- 41:02are, but what documentation is being provided.
- 41:06And developing this, you know, the best thing
- 41:08I say is developing a notice template, because
- 41:10the time is short of how you've got to respond,
- 41:13and particularly for owners. And it is, you know,
- 41:16if you don't respond timely throughout this process
- 41:20each time, you then can, you know, it gets cut
- 41:24off, and then they can go, you know, the dispute
- 41:26resolution process proceeds under the contract.
- 41:29And you're your ability to collect interest,
- 41:33you know, or to fight that becomes problematic.
- 41:37So a notice template that can be used by your
- 41:39team is something really important. And one issue
- 41:43we've looked at is if you're going to agree upon
- 41:46that, you know, one way about coming about this
- 41:49is that the parties say we're going to agree
- 41:50to mediation, even though the statute requires
- 41:53it. putting it in the contracts, agreeing to
- 41:55it, and having a preselected mediator or a process
- 41:59for selecting a neutral to serve as the mediator.
- 42:03We do expect there to be an increase in mid -construction
- 42:07mediations as a result of this, assuming the
- 42:10statute stays in place. And as we talked about,
- 42:14probably more mediators getting into the fray,
- 42:17so to speak, trying to help parties resolve.
- 42:20Looked at this a little bit from the owner's
- 42:22perspective and the contractor's perspective,
- 42:24you know, owners really need to take a look at
- 42:26their contracts and update them. If your processes
- 42:30and procedures and payment request application
- 42:33and payment timing doesn't comply with the law,
- 42:36we are recommending to update that contract,
- 42:40as well as implementing your claim management
- 42:42systems to have a planned response and training
- 42:46your staff to do so. So people need to be on
- 42:48top of it. is part of project management from
- 42:51the owner's perspective, knowing what's coming
- 42:54and going and having a good documentation process
- 42:56for that. A really easy example of a way to solve
- 43:00is hire a reputable contractor and really check
- 43:04people's records and know what you're getting
- 43:06into. You still do have the right as an owner
- 43:11to trigger your contractual rights to withhold
- 43:15payment under appropriate situations. This isn't
- 43:18saying you just got to pay people, but documenting
- 43:21it is really important and complying with your
- 43:24contractual entitlement rights. to withhold payment
- 43:28is going to be very important because that will
- 43:30be part of that process that you can use. And
- 43:34being aware of cash flow considerations because
- 43:37I know a lot of owners have had their own different
- 43:39payment processes and this has got to be something
- 43:43out folded into your cash flow. One of the issues
- 43:46that the statute doesn't talk about is how this
- 43:50new law interacts with the prompt payment act.
- 43:54And that's another area that is unclear. But
- 43:58what it does do is it runs parallel. So there
- 44:00is a potential that if owners aren't paying promptly,
- 44:04they are subject not only to the private works
- 44:09change order fair payment act, but also the prompt
- 44:12payment act itself. And then for contractors,
- 44:16we've got a bunch of action items for you as
- 44:18well. So again, coming up with some good internal
- 44:22processes, including template and letters for
- 44:25your claims, making sure people you have somebody
- 44:28who is going to be sending the notices. certified
- 44:31registered or registered mail return receipt
- 44:33requested and also responding to your subcontractors.
- 44:37You've got that timeliness requirement as well.
- 44:40Educating your teams and your accounting teams
- 44:43is really important for the contractor. Thinking
- 44:47also again about some type of mediator that you
- 44:51would agree to if you do, and looking at your
- 44:55contracts for continuity between what you're
- 44:59contracting with your owner, as well as what
- 45:02your template of your standard subcontract agreement
- 45:05may be. You've got to make sure those marry together.
- 45:08And thinking through your dispute resolution
- 45:10process and provisions. One of the areas that
- 45:13a lot of construction contracts are if you know,
- 45:17have limitations and people don't spend a lot
- 45:20of time of drafting their dispute resolution
- 45:22process and their provisions in their contracts
- 45:25because everybody when you're negotiating agreements
- 45:27says they're never going to have a problem we're
- 45:28going to always get along and you know we really
- 45:32recommend looking closely and having a dispute
- 45:35resolution process built in carefully into your
- 45:39agreement and this law is actually going to help
- 45:42push that as well. Brenda, going back for a moment
- 45:46just to the owner's considerations and action
- 45:49items, do you see any interplay or anything that
- 45:53the owner needs to put in the contract that takes
- 45:56into account their agreement with their construction
- 45:58lender? And what's the construction lender's
- 46:01interplay with these requirements under this
- 46:04statute? So there's nothing direct for the lender,
- 46:08but the lender, you know, really would not be,
- 46:10I would say a consideration with what you're
- 46:13the owner agreements with the lender is an understanding.
- 46:16And that's where that cashflow consideration
- 46:18comes in. Because if you are looking at payment
- 46:22requests and that there's maybe you're thinking,
- 46:25you know, with the lender or the understanding
- 46:27that this was going to be at the end of the job,
- 46:29that you would have issues or different timing.
- 46:32You've got to look carefully at that. The statute
- 46:34itself doesn't really pull the lender in directly.
- 46:38I was thinking more than the case where the lender
- 46:40goes out and they do an inspection and say, we're
- 46:43not going to give you the payment you want because
- 46:46we don't think it's done. I guess the owner would
- 46:48just put that in his response as to why they're
- 46:51not paying because our construction lender won't
- 46:54pay us and their inspection shows you haven't
- 46:56really fulfilled everything you need to for this
- 46:58progress payment. Right. And that's pretty good
- 47:00for support for having a disputed payment claim.
- 47:04We do see that there is a potential for the contractors
- 47:08or subcontractors, not all of them, but some
- 47:12folks who might try to take advantage of this
- 47:15process and to use it somewhat as a sword as
- 47:19opposed to a shield and that That's where owners
- 47:23are going to really need to be careful of if
- 47:25they have a dispute, you've got to document it.
- 47:27And if you have a lender, exactly what you're
- 47:30talking about, Howard, then having that backup
- 47:33from the lender is going to support you if you
- 47:37go through and you'll have a defense to those
- 47:42arguments that those were not meritorious. I
- 47:45suppose the owner could write it into the contract
- 47:47and the contractor would have trouble refusing
- 47:50it to simply say that, We don't know a progress
- 47:53payment if our lender has inspected and found
- 47:55that the work hasn't been accomplished sufficiently
- 47:59for them to advance the money to us to make the
- 48:02payment. Yes. Yeah. A lot of the contracts I
- 48:04see you contain that as a standard provision.
- 48:09Great question. I love all your questions. You
- 48:11got good ones. So our next section, last section,
- 48:17is on uncertainties and risks. And I've alluded
- 48:20to several of them. But we do see this issue,
- 48:26and I talked about it really quickly, is the
- 48:28right to stop work related to these disputed
- 48:32payments. And you've If you're going through
- 48:36the process, and as we looked at that sample,
- 48:40you've got this really interesting issue of,
- 48:43can the contractor really utilize this stop work
- 48:47as an option on disputed amounts or issues? And
- 48:52like you just raised, well, do they have a? a
- 48:55good faith basis for that dispute and then is
- 48:57the owner now going to be in a position where
- 49:00you've got a contractor utilizing a threat of
- 49:03stopping work to uses leverage to say, well,
- 49:07just pay me because it's so much more difficult
- 49:09and much more expensive for the owner when the
- 49:13work actually stops. So you're going to go out
- 49:15and hire a replacement contractor. And then does
- 49:17that kind of unravel into a much larger dispute?
- 49:20So that is an area that is a substantial risk
- 49:22that we do see as a potential of rising out of
- 49:27SB 440. The interest payment issue, as we mentioned,
- 49:31even if you have a good faith dispute, And sometimes
- 49:35the parties can reasonably disagree in good faith.
- 49:40And then you have to get it adjudicated. And
- 49:42as we all know, for anyone who's done litigation,
- 49:45sometimes you have the right. argument and you
- 49:47still lose. And so you may have a good faith
- 49:51dispute and you may then be subject to interest
- 49:55being paid if you don't pay it. So again, it's
- 49:58leverage issue and the dollar amounts at issue
- 50:02may be a part of it as well. So it is very much
- 50:06an issue of uncertainty and risk. And I think
- 50:09it goes both ways also so that the contractor,
- 50:14if they're somehow think they're counting on
- 50:17getting interest. It's not that those arguments
- 50:19also go away. So if the contractor and there's
- 50:23nothing other than the mediation itself is the
- 50:27only part of this that's confidential. So all
- 50:30of the notices and responses from the owner and
- 50:36even the informal meet and confer conference
- 50:41all would be. open to be used as evidence in
- 50:45the dispute process, arbitration, or trial at
- 50:49the end. And so if people aren't acting really
- 50:51in good faith, then that seems to be the way
- 50:55the statute is written to try to make some common
- 50:58ground. As I mentioned, the uncertainty of the
- 51:01interaction with the 2 % prompt payment penalty
- 51:04under the prompt payment act, where you're really
- 51:08looking at some real potential exposures for
- 51:11not paying contractors promptly under either
- 51:14of the statutes. There are, and Howard, you stole
- 51:19my thunder here. We think there's a substantial
- 51:22areas for potential statutory amendments over
- 51:24the course, either through challenges or through
- 51:27amendments that may occur. We've seen this on
- 51:30a couple of the other statutes in in the real
- 51:33estate and construction arena where it comes
- 51:35out and the legislature, they're all excited
- 51:37and they thought they did a great job. And then
- 51:39we all look at it and say, what were they thinking?
- 51:42This doesn't work and what about this? And so
- 51:44we think that there is a potential. I do know
- 51:48I participate in a lot of different trade organizations.
- 51:50There are several trade groups that are looking
- 51:53at the statute and. not trying to determine if
- 51:57they're going to be presenting as lobbies to
- 51:59some of the different legislatures to evaluate
- 52:01that. The other uncertainty is how the industry
- 52:05is going to adapt and what people may do differently
- 52:10and how they may behave differently as a result.
- 52:14you know, the idea was, you know, hey, contractors
- 52:17should get paid timely for the work that they
- 52:19do, and that they've completed appropriately.
- 52:22I don't know that this statute is going to actually
- 52:25get there. But that is sort of the, I think,
- 52:30altruistic hope that people are going to get
- 52:33paid timely when they're doing work and then
- 52:35narrowing the disputed issues that are being
- 52:39litigated, as opposed to a lot of times. And
- 52:43some of these disputes, you see things that just
- 52:45kind of everything gets thrown in. And it's at
- 52:49the end of the project, and then trying to unravel
- 52:52what is disputed and what's not. And what the
- 52:55idea is to try to say is, hey, can we narrow
- 52:58at least the scope of the disputes? So it will
- 53:01be very interesting to see how this plays out
- 53:03over the next. six months or so, I think it's
- 53:06going to take six months to a year. And also
- 53:09to the extent anything from SB 440 has on whether
- 53:14or not the public works 9204, whether that gets
- 53:21amended and or is allowed to sunset, depending
- 53:24on how things are going and challenges here.
- 53:27So with that, I think that brings us to the end.
- 53:31And I don't know if we have some questions or
- 53:33answers in the Q &A. I don't really have much
- 53:36in the Q &A, but I had one or two other comments.
- 53:40I suppose that if I'm an owner and my lawyer
- 53:43advises me, by the way, there's this 2 % a month
- 53:47penalty that you're going to have to pay if.
- 53:49in this process under the statute, I'm going
- 53:52to want to come back and say, well, I want to
- 53:54write in the contract a 2 % a month penalty if
- 53:56they don't do things timely, for whatever it's
- 54:00costing me. Because that's like 26 .82 % a year
- 54:04at 2 % a month. And it seems very unfair that
- 54:09it goes only in one direction here. And it seems
- 54:13to me that that Appears to be a major reason
- 54:16for the statute because otherwise a lot of these
- 54:18things really Would have been taken care of just
- 54:21by having a well -written construction contract
- 54:23and yeah, a hundred percent Yeah, so it did makes
- 54:28one wonder about what's you know? What the dynamics
- 54:32politically were of the trade groups that were
- 54:35behind the statute the part That was the most
- 54:37interesting in digging into the historical portion
- 54:39is there was no opposition none zero this passed
- 54:43unanimously Mm -hmm The one other thing I guess
- 54:47which everybody kind of knows anyway, but it
- 54:49puts a little more emphasis on emphasis on your
- 54:52notice provisions and the addresses and making
- 54:55certain Proof that you you know, I'm like that
- 55:05just so you're getting your notices, which is
- 55:07always kind of an issue anyway But I was surprised
- 55:09it had to be mice only Certified mail you couldn't
- 55:12you can't personally deliver it seems strange
- 55:15It was very interesting and now there is you
- 55:18know I think that the parties would be able to
- 55:20amend that portion to say we're going to agree
- 55:23to email Notice if we would like to do so, but
- 55:26you're gonna want to make sure that's in your
- 55:28contract Yeah, it really seemed a bit archaic
- 55:31in that respect agreed agreed. Yeah. Yeah Yeah,
- 55:34so, you know every now and then we take three
- 55:36steps forward and two steps backwards But great.
- 55:41Thank you. This is going to be, you know, we
- 55:44may have to come back in a year and tell you
- 55:46how we're seeing this all play out. But any questions,
- 55:49people are welcome to contact me directly and
- 55:51I'm happy to answer questions or have you at
- 55:55your office, have you thought about any changes
- 55:58you're planning to put in your construction contracts
- 56:01as a result of the statute? Yeah. We have, we've
- 56:03been working with clients. The statute was actually
- 56:06passed in October, so we've had some clients
- 56:08that we've been working with already and redrafting
- 56:12some of their contracts. And it depends on who
- 56:15they are and what their role is and what type
- 56:16of projects they're working on. And so, yeah,
- 56:20we're really working out that and a lot of it
- 56:22is very dependent on our clients and their approaches
- 56:26to their subcontractors and their contractors.
- 56:32And I suppose where you really have the big issue
- 56:34is when you have out of state parties coming
- 56:36in here who would have no idea that something
- 56:39like this exists in California. Right. Right.
- 56:42Yeah. And it's interesting. And I think a lot
- 56:44of times we see this in the construction arena
- 56:46where people use the same contract that they've
- 56:50always used. And every now and then they go,
- 56:52I haven't updated that in four or five years.
- 56:55And if you're doing any development and construction
- 56:59in California, it behooves you to be reviewing
- 57:02your contracts annually and making sure that
- 57:05they're up to date on a variety of aspects. And
- 57:08this is yet one more to add to the checklist.
- 57:11Well, Brenda, thank you very much. Very interesting
- 57:14to hear a discussion from somebody who has really
- 57:18looked at this new statute to tell us what. what's
- 57:20coming in and so that people can try to adapt
- 57:24if we can remember all this the next time one
- 57:26of these comes into our office. Very good. I
- 57:29appreciate the time and everyone I hope this
- 57:33is useful and helpful for you and your clients
- 57:36as you are proceeding and I wish everyone luck
- 57:39and hopefully this helps resolve some disputes.
- 57:43Thank you very much. Great.