Latest / Politics with Paul / How Sincere are Polling Responses and How Much Do We Misinterpret Them? | Politics with Paul #105
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:05political science and civics.
- 0:07I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:10Today, we're gonna talk about the trustworthiness and sincerity of responses in
- 0:16public opinion polling.
- 0:18Because political polling faces many challenges today, and a large part of that is both the
- 0:24negative and positive misconceptions about it and how it works.
- 0:29And that goes for both the general public and those who are more involved in politics for a
- 0:34living.
- 0:35For some people, they think that polls are inherently lying or unreliable whenever
- 0:40election results don't exactly reflect polls or the polls say something that they personally
- 0:47don't want to hear.
- 0:48But you also have some people that read too much into polls, and they take things at face
- 0:54value or they don't critically evaluate why poll results are the way they are or what
- 1:02people might really think or what they might be willing to actually do.
- 1:08And so today is going to be more about that latter group, the ones that have those positive
- 1:12misconceptions about polling, or more accurately, positive misconceptions about
- 1:20certain polling results that they may like or be supportive of themselves.
- 1:25Whenever you take polling too much at face value or you extrapolate the results too far to
- 1:32say things that they're not actually saying, you can run into some pitfalls in campaign
- 1:36strategy and logic or just simply earnest discussion about public policy.
- 1:42And so this episode is going to be about how trustworthy and sincere the respondents and
- 1:48polls are and how that can affect how we interpret the results of these polls.
- 1:55Are these respondents and polls telling the truth about their feelings?
- 1:59Do they sometimes lie to or mislead pollsters or even themselves?
- 2:04Do respondents recognize their biases and the impacts of said biases on their own answers?
- 2:12Is there a correlation between public opinion and public action?
- 2:16And what are the implications of these answers for how we interpret public opinion?
- 2:21Well, first, let's talk about what makes a trustworthy and sincere respondent in a poll.
- 2:31Vast majority of people that answer poll questions are not purposely trying to lie or
- 2:37mislead the pollster and ruin a poll.
- 2:39They're not sitting there thinking, oh, this is a poll.
- 2:42Let me ruin this person's day who gets paid to make these polls or not to make the necessarily
- 2:46make these polls, but to administer these polls.
- 2:49They're not doing that necessarily.
- 2:51Probably a couple of people that are like that, but it's really not a common thing.
- 2:56They're not trying to screw over a poll.
- 3:00And this isn't necessarily a value judgment on the respondents either to say, oh, but are they
- 3:04really being sincere and truthful?
- 3:07But their opinions can be influenced in various ways by either their existing biases and
- 3:13prejudices or the potential biases of the poll itself.
- 3:19And so I don't wanna get caught up too much in actual value judgments on these respondents.
- 3:26It's not necessarily about, you know, whether these people are their whether they are natural
- 3:32liars or anything like that.
- 3:34But respondents can sometimes be not only necessarily not forthright about what they
- 3:41really think, but they can be inconsistent and give contradictory answers within the same
- 3:47poll.
- 3:47Doesn't necessarily mean they're lying, though.
- 3:50It may just be about how some questions are worded.
- 3:54As we'll see shortly, the wording of questions has a heavy impact on the results of polls.
- 4:00But sometimes respondents just don't see the contradictions as contradictions or
- 4:06inconsistencies.
- 4:07One poll I think of is within the past couple years, Georgetown University did one that it
- 4:13covered a whole bunch of different things.
- 4:15But one of the findings that it had was that most of the people in the poll wanted
- 4:21compromise.
- 4:23But in that same poll, they also felt that they had compromised enough and that the other side
- 4:29needed to compromise a little bit more.
- 4:32And then even further in the poll, some of those same people said, well, okay.
- 4:36I can maybe compromise a little bit more if I need
- 4:39to.
- 4:41Three seemingly inconsistent contradictory answers there, but it goes to show how
- 4:49ambivalent people can be, how they can have
- 4:53what seem to be differing opinions about a public policy or a political issue or whatever
- 4:59it is, but they can still actually hold them at the same time and not see any contradiction.
- 5:06And maybe it's not a contradiction.
- 5:07Maybe that's just maybe somebody else thinks it's a contradiction, but they don't.
- 5:12It's not necessarily objective that it's inconsistent either.
- 5:16There's also the fact that a lot of people say that they're open to voting for independents
- 5:21and third party candidates and that they want a third major party to contend with Republicans
- 5:26and Democrats, but voters rarely ever act on that.
- 5:32They rarely ever vote for an independent.
- 5:33A lot of times, they think that is simply a waste of a vote.
- 5:36So they vote for, quote, unquote, the lesser of two evils.
- 5:41Even if there is a strong independent candidate there.
- 5:45And by strong, I mean, not necessarily that I think that they have good views, but that they
- 5:49run a solid campaign, that they're that they're well funded, that they're able to compete with
- 5:57the two major parties or even against one major party.
- 6:04And so a lot of people can say that they really want an independent, but they don't often act
- 6:09upon it either.
- 6:11So it's one of those contradictions you sometimes see in polling.
- 6:18Regardless of whether they see things as contradictions or not, even if putting aside
- 6:23what can be potentially contradictory answers, there's just a lot of biases and incentives for
- 6:29respondents to answer certain ways when they're being questioned in a poll.
- 6:34And so polls must be crafted carefully to have as little bias in the results as possible.
- 6:39But even the most expertly designed ones aren't always foolproof, and they have to account for
- 6:44those things when they analyze polls.
- 6:46And that could get very grimy and in the muck and could be very boring for a lot of people to
- 6:53hear about, but it's important work to do.
- 6:56And so five of the biggest biases and incentives that can directly impact how a
- 7:01member of the public answers a poll and thus impacts the level of trustworthiness and
- 7:08sincerity of the responses in said poll.
- 7:13Social desirability bias, the impact of the wording of questions, the aspects of the
- 7:19pollster themselves, acquiescence bias, and party and ideological biases of the person
- 7:27answering the questions.
- 7:28So some of it is those preexisting biases of the people answering the polls, and some of it
- 7:34has to do with the pollster or the poll itself.
- 7:38So social desirability bias is just a general way to refer to when we say the things that we
- 7:45think are going to be more acceptable to whoever it is that is pulling us.
- 7:52Nobody wants to be stigmatized or ostracized, or at least they don't wanna be ostracized by
- 7:57everybody.
- 7:58We all want to find our people, so to speak, that we fit in with.
- 8:03And maybe we'll say screw what anybody else thinks, but we all want to fit in somewhere.
- 8:08So what is the socially desirable can appear to be different things to different people.
- 8:16Because what is socially desirable isn't necessarily totally objective or accepted by
- 8:21every segment in society.
- 8:23So maybe it's not society at large we're trying to be socially desirable to, but maybe it's to
- 8:27a specific segment that we subscribe to.
- 8:33In any case, several common examples of social desirability that you see is the self reporting
- 8:39of voting behavior being much higher than actual voter turnout.
- 8:44You might see something like actual voter turnout in an area being, like, 55%.
- 8:52But if you polled the people in that place, in that area, you would say you would see 75% of
- 9:01them say that, oh, yeah.
- 9:02I voted, which is obviously, some
- 9:04of them are lying.
- 9:06But it's it's a matter of even though we do have a lot
- 9:12of problems with voter turnout in this country, especially when you get to non presidential
- 9:15elections, you see a lot of people a lot of people do realize that there is sort of a
- 9:24social moray, a norm that you are supposed to go and vote even though a lot of people don't
- 9:30do it.
- 9:30And they don't want to seem like somebody who doesn't exercise that basic right to vote
- 9:36because they think that they're going to get ridiculed for it.
- 9:39So they just say, oh, yeah.
- 9:41I I voted, and I voted for so and so.
- 9:43Even if that may not actually be true.
- 9:45Or they would have voted for that person if they actually went out to vote, but they didn't
- 9:49go out to vote, so they didn't vote for that person.
- 9:51Shying away from something that that respondent might be afraid will make them seem bigoted.
- 9:58Whether it truly would be a bigoted thing to say or not is beside the point.
- 10:03If they think that somebody's going to accuse them of racism, sexism, homophobia, anything
- 10:08like that, they might respond in a way that they think won't get them that response.
- 10:15Now you might have some people that respond that way because they want to poke the bear, so
- 10:21to speak.
- 10:21They want to do something that they think will get a rise out of people.
- 10:26But in polling, you don't necessarily see that a whole lot.
- 10:30Another way or another example of social desirability bias is people saying what they
- 10:36expect their social group that they ascribe to would say.
- 10:40Maybe you have a segment of the population that is much more opposed to voting for Donald
- 10:46Trump, And maybe that individual is like, oh, you know what?
- 10:50I actually do support Donald Trump, but they don't wanna say that because they think they're
- 10:54going to get ostracized.
- 10:55Or if we go back to the twenty twenty four election, somebody who you would expect to vote
- 11:01for Donald Trump, maybe they actually wanna vote for wanted to vote for Kamala Harris.
- 11:05And maybe they actually did vote for Kamala Harris, but they thought that that would look
- 11:13bad for them because of the groups that they tend to ascribe to.
- 11:17That's another way that they might have been impacted by social desirability bias.
- 11:22But the calling for more compromise in politics.
- 11:25Usually, people don't wanna be considered extremists, or they think other people are
- 11:32extremists, but never themselves.
- 11:34And so they might say that they actually want more compromise in politics when really they
- 11:39don't.
- 11:40They actually just want people to acquiesce to what they want.
- 11:43And there was also the possibility of social desirability bias back in 2016 when Donald
- 11:49Trump won despite the fact that polls indicated that he had little shot to do it, and it seemed
- 11:56like Hillary Clinton was going to win, Donald Trump actually did.
- 12:01And some people speculated that was because a lot of voters didn't want to admit that they
- 12:05were voting for Donald Trump because they feared that they would be ostracized if they
- 12:09did that.
- 12:10And so one way you can limit social desirability bias is to assure these
- 12:14respondents that their answers are confidential and anonymous.
- 12:17They're not gonna be shared with anybody, and a pollster will do that if they are a reputable
- 12:22pollster.
- 12:23But even with these assurances, people won't necessarily believe that they're going to be
- 12:28anonymous, or they might think that the pollster will do whatever they can to keep
- 12:32those answers anonymous, but they fear that somehow those answers will be traced back to
- 12:36them.
- 12:38And so they still wanna sound like a good person to the pollster or at
- 12:42least what that person thinks
- 12:45would sound like a good person to that pollster.
- 12:48And so you see this social desirability bias pop up fairly frequently in polls, and,
- 12:56obviously, you try to minimize that as much as possible, and some of it is also with the
- 13:01wording of questions, which is our next key area to focus on when it comes to how people
- 13:10can be biased and incentivized to answer in certain ways on polls that they might not have
- 13:16answered without the bias and incentive.
- 13:20So with the wording of questions, even minor tweaks can skew how people respond.
- 13:26And it might be conscious.
- 13:28They might realize what's going on and still tweak the responses, or it might not even occur
- 13:35to them that this certain wording in a question will change the response.
- 13:41And if pollsters are not careful, they can intentionally or unintentionally lead
- 13:48respondents in the survey to answer a certain way and bias your results and not get an
- 13:54accurate reading on what the public opinion is about an issue or a candidate or whatever the
- 13:59case may be.
- 14:01And some of this might be words that inherently add value judgments to a question, and so you
- 14:07wanna use these as little as possible.
- 14:10Some of these value judgments might be obvious, others might not.
- 14:15Examples of this impact of wording, you can see it in things like a very common example of that
- 14:23would be using the term welfare versus government aid programs.
- 14:28When you ask people if they support welfare, they tend not to because they see that as well
- 14:32as government handouts.
- 14:34It's the government babying people when people should be able to fend for themselves.
- 14:38But if you say government aid programs, you start to think of it as, oh, okay.
- 14:41Well, these people are down on their luck, and we're just trying to give them a helping hand.
- 14:44We need to help them out here.
- 14:47Another way that you see it is when you talk about war versus special military operation
- 14:53versus conflict or some other semantic variation of those phrases.
- 15:03When Russia first invaded Ukraine, it it was not a war.
- 15:07It was a special military operation.
- 15:09Obviously, that's a
- 15:10bunch of BS.
- 15:11It is a war, but that's one example of
- 15:16that kind of thing in polls is when you describe a war as something a little bit more
- 15:23palatable like a special military operation or a conflict.
- 15:28Or if you take a conflict and call it a war when maybe not a lot of other people call it a
- 15:35war.
- 15:35Another thing that can lead to biases and incentives for people to change their answers
- 15:40in a poll is aspects of the pollster themselves.
- 15:43And the pollster isn't necessarily trying to to manipulate answers a lot.
- 15:49If they're reputable, they're not trying to manipulate answers, but they have to be very,
- 15:53very careful.
- 15:54Even the experts can trip up here.
- 15:57Things like who the individual pollster is, the polling firm they represent, how they ask
- 16:01questions, how they sound, all these things can influence people's responses in sometimes even
- 16:07the most subtle ways.
- 16:09For example, a friendlier pollster or a pollster that at least sounds like they're
- 16:15friendlier can make the respondent more relaxed and willing to open up about their true
- 16:21feelings.
- 16:21But if the pollster sounds more gruff, maybe the other person is like, oh, you know what?
- 16:25I'm gonna try to say things that sound more agreeable to this person who's asking me these
- 16:30questions.
- 16:32And so the perceptions of who the pollster is can change responses, and that might be through
- 16:38reasonable information, and some of it might just be based on preconceived biases.
- 16:44So if you if you hear a pollster that sounds like a female and you're a male respondent, you
- 16:50might respond in a way that you think a female would be more supportive of, or a female
- 16:55respondent might be more comfortable with that female pollster.
- 16:59Say, it can be the the same thing the other way around.
- 17:01If it sounds like a male pollster, a female respondent might respond more in a way that a
- 17:06male or what they think a male would be more supportive of, or a male respondent may feel
- 17:11like they can be more forthright with a male pollster.
- 17:16If the pollster sounds like the stereotype of a gay or lesbian person, the respondents, even if
- 17:24they're not necessarily all that supportive of of issues that are LGBTQ, they may respond more
- 17:33positively about LGBTQ issues and be more supportive of stances like gay marriage or
- 17:41transgender participation in women's sports.
- 17:45And so some pollsters try also try not to say what polling firm they represent in case it
- 17:52biases results.
- 17:53Because the respondents may look up that firm and either change their coming answers for
- 17:58various reasons, or they might disconnect from the survey because it's like, oh, you work for
- 18:02those kinds of people?
- 18:02Screw you.
- 18:03I'm not gonna answer for a republican firm or a democratic firm.
- 18:07Or you might say, then they probably think the way I do.
- 18:12I'm going to be more eager to answer this survey.
- 18:15Another potential bias or incentive is acquiescence bias, and this is the tendency to
- 18:20agree with survey questions or statements regardless of what that respondent really
- 18:26feels.
- 18:27Some people are predisposed to say yes for various reasons like the fact that agreeing is
- 18:33mentally much easier to do than disagreeing, and disagreeing is more likely to lead to a
- 18:39follow-up question of why.
- 18:41Some pollsters have that where they say, if this respondent disagrees with this sentiment,
- 18:47ask them why.
- 18:48And then so they have to think longer about about why they disagree with something.
- 18:52If you just say you agree and you're just you just don't want to cause any issues, you just
- 18:57or you're just naturally a more agreeable person.
- 19:00Like, if you do personality tests, some personality test test agreeableness as a
- 19:06personality trait.
- 19:07Some more agreeable people will simply agree with questions no matter what it is even if
- 19:14they don't actually agree with the questioner statement.
- 19:17They might think that it's just simply more pleasing to the pollster.
- 19:20This is similar similar to social desirability bias where they say, oh, well, you know what?
- 19:25This pollster probably wants me to say that I agree, so I'm gonna say I agree.
- 19:28Or based on their perceptions of who the pollster is, they might respond more agreeably
- 19:35with based on whatever the question is.
- 19:38Or there might have been cultural norms that taught those respondents to value what is
- 19:45viewed as politeness and respect for authority and avoidance of confrontation.
- 19:51And politeness has some I
- 19:56guess there's you could say
- 19:57there's just a certain level of debate about what's actually polite in politics, and some
- 20:03people think that just they just don't want to get into any sort of arguments with people, and
- 20:08they think that it's impolite to actually have any sort of disagreements, which is not true.
- 20:14But some people feel that that's the case and they've been taught that way, and so they think
- 20:18it's you know what?
- 20:19I'm just I think this is what the pollster wants me to say, so I'm just going to say it.
- 20:23And then lastly, the party and ideological biases of these respondents that can skew their
- 20:32answers.
- 20:33This is probably a more obvious one, but it can crop up in ways that you don't necessarily
- 20:39expect.
- 20:39So our party and ideological affiliations predispose us to think certain ways based on
- 20:45who is in office or whoever is in question.
- 20:49And if we already know who that person is, like, oh, tell
- 20:52us your opinion about candidate
- 20:57a, and they're a Republican and you're a Republican, you're probably gonna be more
- 21:00predisposed to say, oh, yeah.
- 21:02I like them.
- 21:02Even if you don't actually know who they are.
- 21:04Same thing with if it's a Democrat or Democratic voter being asked about a Democratic
- 21:10candidate.
- 21:11So there's some expectation that republicans will think a certain way or tend to think a
- 21:16certain way, and that democrats will tend to think a certain way.
- 21:19But even things that don't seem to have a partisan or ideological leaning may lead to a
- 21:24stark divide.
- 21:25And one very notable common instance of that is when there are questions about what do you
- 21:33think of the direction of the country?
- 21:34Well, if you're a voter who is in the party that's in power, you're gonna think that the
- 21:41direction of the country is great, usually.
- 21:43You're gonna say we're in a golden age and that your your finances are doing great or that they
- 21:48could be better, but they're going to be fixed by whoever's in charge.
- 21:51And then if you're in the party that's out of power, you think that everything sucks and that
- 21:55we're heading for an even worse time.
- 21:57And to some extent, there is that aspect of declinism where people just naturally have a
- 22:03predisposition to say that, oh, things suck, and they're and they're getting worse each each
- 22:08day regardless of whether your party's in power.
- 22:10But there is a noticeable divide where as soon as party power changes where republicans shift
- 22:17to democrats or democrats shift to republicans, suddenly, there is a noticeable flip between
- 22:22Republicans and Democrats in respondents where now Democrats say the opposite thing that they
- 22:28were saying before, and Republicans say the exact opposite thing that they were saying
- 22:31before, all because of who is in office.
- 22:34Not necessarily because they've really thought about whether or not things are going well for
- 22:39them, but because they have those partisan biases.
- 22:44And so there's a bunch of different ways that respondents in polls can be influenced to say
- 22:53or think a certain way even if it's not ultimately what they really think.
- 22:58But that's not the only part of the issue.
- 23:02The other part of the issue is when we see pundits and observers and campaigners and
- 23:12politicians look at these public opinion polls and start to read too much into what these
- 23:21opinions are saying.
- 23:23Regardless of how sincere respondents and polls are, let's just say for a moment that their
- 23:28opinions are a 100% sincere.
- 23:31Pundits and campaigners and so on make a common mistake that is quite an easy trap to fall
- 23:37into, and it can happen to pretty much all of us.
- 23:40I've certainly been guilty of this too.
- 23:42We fail to recognize that there is often a disconnect between public opinion and public
- 23:48willingness to take action on said opinions because it's great to want politics to be
- 23:54fixed.
- 23:55Who doesn't want politics to be fixed?
- 23:56It's all well and good to want to be open to all these big reforms, like reforming the
- 24:03primary system and wanting proportional representation and and all these things.
- 24:10That's the first step to making reforms and to making changes in politics.
- 24:16You need the public support behind it.
- 24:19But we often get caught up in these polls where we say, oh, look what the people want.
- 24:24Change is right around the corner.
- 24:26That this thing that I support, look at how many other people support it too.
- 24:30Or it creates easy fodder for political talk shows to say, oh, well, will this thing happen
- 24:35so they can get clicks and views about the thing that is the salient topic that is right
- 24:40now the topic of the day.
- 24:44And all sorts of proposals get this kind of coverage.
- 24:46You see it for voting for an independent for president.
- 24:49How many people say they want an independent to be president?
- 24:52People wanting a third major party to contend with Republicans and Democrats.
- 24:57Term limits, campaign finance reform, independent redistricting commissions across
- 25:04the board, Initiatives to depolarize politics, wanting better dialogue, and a spirit of
- 25:11compromise, proportional representation, the list is endless.
- 25:14But sentiment does not inherently translate into action.
- 25:18In fact, it often doesn't translate into action at all.
- 25:23Public opinion is a great luxury to have, but it only has so much power.
- 25:27If public opinion were as powerful as we act like it is, politics wouldn't suck so much.
- 25:32There would be far fewer scandals, more long lasting solutions to political woes, more
- 25:38earnest conversations across political divides, more politicians genuinely listening to their
- 25:43constituents instead of their donors and the most polarized voices.
- 25:49So respondents can say that they support all these reforms and so on, and they may be
- 25:54earnest about that, but they have to actually act on those opinions and pressure politicians
- 25:59in order to actually make those changes happen.
- 26:03And right now, there is little incentive for lawmakers to get the ball rolling on these
- 26:08changes like term limits, proportional representation, independent redistricting
- 26:14commissions for all states.
- 26:18And there's little incentive for them to make these changes because we don't actually punish
- 26:23politicians for not acting on this public support.
- 26:27When's the last time you saw somebody lose a campaign because they didn't support term
- 26:32limits?
- 26:33Because they didn't call for an independent redistricting commission in their states?
- 26:39Or because they didn't say that we should have a third major party contending for elections
- 26:45regularly like Republicans and Democrats do.
- 26:50Few times, if ever, have you seen that happen.
- 26:54The general public does not participate nearly enough in politics, and this is not a this is
- 27:00not an attempt to, you know, rag on people who don't vote all the time.
- 27:06Because some people do have understandable grievances about politics.
- 27:13Some people though are just plain lazy and just they want to complain, but they don't want to
- 27:18actually do something.
- 27:19Some people want to do something, but they feel like their opinion doesn't matter at all, and
- 27:24so they think what is even the point?
- 27:26And there's a big difference between those two opinions.
- 27:29Now, obviously, I think more people should be participating in politics.
- 27:33And part of the reason why I made this podcast and I do the work I do is to try to get more
- 27:41people to become more involved politics in a healthy manner.
- 27:46Fact of the matter is, amongst nations that have free elections, US tends to rank pretty
- 27:53low, and it's not just because some countries have mandatory voting.
- 27:56We just genuinely have low participation typically in politics, and not just in voting.
- 28:03You especially see it in actual participation in campaigns, for example.
- 28:10And so the general public just does not participate nearly enough in politics to push
- 28:15these politicians to actually make a lot of these changes.
- 28:20The most polarized voices do, and those are the ones that politicians typically listen to.
- 28:26And oftentimes, these polarized voices don't want a lot of these proposals for reforms that
- 28:31people have proposed, like proportional representation or expanding The US House so
- 28:37that it has more members.
- 28:40Or they are caught up in all these other issues that they want, and these are the ones that
- 28:46typically are higher up on the legislative agenda.
- 28:48And the legislative agenda is more folks on on a bunch of these other issues that often still
- 28:54fail to get resolved.
- 28:55And these are the ones that get more fanfare and more media coverage and voter involvement.
- 28:59It's a lot easier to get people going about things like abortion and guns and LGBTQ
- 29:06policies and the economy.
- 29:08It's a lot harder to get them really focused
- 29:13on things like term limits and proportional representation, and to have any issues like
- 29:20that or proposals like that for reform, supplant all these other highly charged issues
- 29:25that we see like abortion and guns.
- 29:29And also, incumbents get reelected upwards of 8090% all the time despite not actually working
- 29:37on a lot of these reforms.
- 29:38So we don't really punish politicians for not acting on all of these things that we want to
- 29:45see or that we say we want to see.
- 29:49Now does that mean that people aren't really sincere about wanting these things like
- 29:52proportional representation and term limits?
- 29:54No.
- 29:55But it does go to show that they're not necessarily enthusiastic about making those
- 30:01things happen or that they're not willing to take any steps to make those things happen.
- 30:05And that's not necessarily critical either.
- 30:08Sometimes people just don't know where to begin to try to get involved in any of these
- 30:16campaigns for reform.
- 30:18But people can say that they want all these things like campaign finance reform and
- 30:22competitive elections and term limits and more compromising politicians and so on in these
- 30:27polls.
- 30:28And they, a lot of times, do say that they want these things.
- 30:31Majority of these polling respondents do want those things frequently, and they may be
- 30:38sincere about that.
- 30:39But they have to actually get involved to try to make these changes happen and threaten
- 30:44politicians with real electoral consequences for not acting on what the public wants.
- 30:49And a lot of these reformers who are involved in trying to make these reforms happen, like
- 30:55proportional representation and term limits and so on, They get ahead of themselves and think,
- 31:02oh, because so much of the public wants this, surely, this means that we can make these
- 31:08things happen.
- 31:10Well, not exactly.
- 31:13Public support is one thing.
- 31:14Action is a totally other thing.
- 31:17So are respondents in polls trustworthy?
- 31:20Are they sincere?
- 31:21Are they really telling us what they feel?
- 31:23For the most part, yes, they are.
- 31:25And they want to be sincere for the most part.
- 31:28But their answers and polls can be manipulated in ways they are consciously aware of and in
- 31:33ways that they don't realize.
- 31:34And it's not a simple question of, well, do people lie about their feelings and polls?
- 31:39It's not necessarily that.
- 31:44And there's a difference between what people want and the desire to do something about it.
- 31:49And something that I'm going to cite at the end of this podcast in my show notes is my five day
- 31:56educational email course on polarized politics.
- 32:00And a lot of these mistakes that people who are involved in depolarizing politics or want to
- 32:05depolarize politics.
- 32:06They make that mistake too where they see who so many people sick of the fighting and
- 32:12polarization and the two parties' economy and all these things, but they don't necessarily
- 32:21want to take action on those things.
- 32:24Maybe they just don't know where to begin.
- 32:26Maybe they just think that their efforts are gonna be worthless.
- 32:30Some people just like to complain, but there is that difference, that disconnect between
- 32:37wanting something and wanting to do something about that something.
- 32:42It's where a lot of these campaigns get tripped up, such as those for these independent and
- 32:47third party candidates for elected office.
- 32:50Regardless of what public opinion says, however, those of us analyzing these responses
- 32:57have to be careful not reading too much into what they say.
- 33:01Having an opinion on reforms is easy.
- 33:04Acting on those opinions is not.
- 33:07And it's not always easy to know how enthusiastic members of the general public are
- 33:12about an issue.
- 33:13They can say that they're enthusiastic about it, but are they really something that you
- 33:18sometimes see in polls for candidates campaigns is they'll they'll ask respondents, how excited
- 33:25are you to vote in election, or how enthusiastic are you to vote in the upcoming
- 33:31election?
- 33:32And those two words, even though they seem like they're the same thing, can actually gather
- 33:37much different responses, or you can say, how much are you looking forward to voting an
- 33:42election?
- 33:42Because somebody might be ready to vote in an election.
- 33:47They're ready for it to come, and and then they're super eager about it, but they aren't
- 33:52necessarily excited about it.
- 33:53Some people, it is just they feel it's just their duty to vote in elections, and there's no
- 34:00bells
- 34:01and whistles to it.
- 34:02They're not gonna be ecstatic
- 34:05about doing it.
- 34:06It's just they think that's what they have to do.
- 34:08Admittedly, I have been that person very frequently.
- 34:12I don't usually get excited about campaigns.
- 34:17I just want to exercise my right to vote because I think it's very important for me to
- 34:22exercise my right to vote.
- 34:23And you would hope so considering that I've done this podcast and my career is in politics,
- 34:29but not everybody who's involved in politics is a voter.
- 34:32You'd be very surprised to see that.
- 34:35But in any case, there's a difference between having an opinion about something and wanting
- 34:43to do something about it, and whether you're enthusiastic about seeing that change happen.
- 34:50So don't assume poll respondents are lying, but also think critically about how forthright they
- 34:56are and whether they realize that they are changing their answers about something or that
- 35:00they're being contradictory or inconsistent, and whether those opinions will actually lead
- 35:05to them taking action.
- 35:10Because if you read too much into these public opinion polls, you might think that they're
- 35:16ready to actually do something when they aren't yet.
- 35:19And it might take time.
- 35:20It it might take years and years, and you find out that the people who wanted these things to
- 35:25happen are finally ready to take action.
- 35:28Or younger people who have now become old enough to vote, who are old enough to
- 35:33participate more regularly in politics are more eager to make these reforms that they support
- 35:40happen.
- 35:42And, of course, all that is easier said than done.
- 35:44You still have to actually have the right strategy to make these reforms happen too, and
- 35:49that comes with, in large part, incentivizing elected officials to act on these reforms like
- 35:56proportional representation, term limits, and so on.
- 36:01So always take responses in pulling with a little grain of salt.
- 36:08Don't assume that
- 36:09it's lying or insincerity, but remember that you still have to fill in that gap between
- 36:20wanting to see something happen and having the desire to make that something happen.
- 36:26And that's gonna end it for today's episode of politics with Paul.
- 36:30As always, thank you so much for listening and watching.
- 36:32Please like, share, and subscribe.
- 36:35Comment.
- 36:36Tell me what you think.
- 36:37And if you're interested in any particular topics, you can message me on LinkedIn or email
- 36:44me.
- 36:44But speaking of those links, my other works, mymedium.com profile, which I write on from
- 36:50time to time, my five day educational email course that I just cited about how we can more
- 36:55effectively depolarize politics, and some of some of the common mistakes that are made in
- 37:02regards to trying to depolarize politics.
- 37:05My book on Amazon, and several other retailers, but the Amazon links are on there too about
- 37:11political independence and why they struggle so much in elections and how they could possibly
- 37:16become more competitive.
- 37:17And then my links, my LinkedIn profile, my Facebook page, my website, and my email,
- 37:27PaulRaiderwrites@Gmail.com.
- 37:30So thank you so much for listening, and we'll see you next time.