Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Managing the Employee Who Always Says I Am Too Experienced
Transcript
- Lucas: You have an employee with fifteen years of experience — maybe more than you have. They know the systems, they've seen initiatives come and go, and when you suggest something new, their default response is a polite version of 'I've already tried that, it doesn't work.' Luna: The 'I am too experienced' move. It is one of the hardest dynamics for a manager, especially if you're younger or newer to the org. Lucas: Exactly. And the instinct is to take it as insubordination or arrogance. But I think it's usually something else — a kind of protective reflex. These employees have often been burned by fads or micromanagers before. Luna: So how do you distinguish between genuine expertise and a blocking tactic? Lucas: Start by assuming it is genuine expertise — and then test it. A blocking tactic gets defensive when you ask for specifics. Genuine expertise can explain exactly why the approach failed, under what conditions, and what would need to change. Luna: So you invite them into the problem rather than telling them the solution. Lucas: Right. You say something like: 'You have more context on this than I do. Help me understand — if we were to try this again, what would have to be different?' That question alone shifts the dynamic from 'you're wrong' to 'we're figuring this out together.' Luna: But what if the employee keeps circling back to 'I told you so' or 'this won't work' no matter how you frame it? Lucas: Then it might be about something deeper — fear of irrelevance, or a past experience where their input was ignored. I call this the 'dignity audit.' You need to explicitly separate your respect for their career from your expectation of current performance. Luna: Walk me through that. How do you actually do a dignity audit? Lucas: In a one-on-one, you say: 'I want to be clear — I value your experience enormously. That is not in question. What I need to talk about is how we apply that experience to this quarter's priorities. Some of those priorities may require approaches that feel unfamiliar, and I need your ability to stay open and experiment.' Luna: So you validate the past while setting a boundary on the future. Lucas: Exactly. The goal is to make them feel seen without letting them use tenure as a veto. And it works because you're not attacking their identity — you're asking for a specific behaviour: openness. Luna: I had a manager once who handled this really well with a senior designer. The designer kept saying 'we tried that layout in 2019 and it bombed.' Instead of pushing back, the manager asked: 'What was different about the audience then? What metrics did you use?' Lucas: Great example. That's testing the expertise without dismissing it. And often, the employee realises that conditions have changed — maybe the platform is different, or the customer base has shifted. Luna: Exactly. In that case, the designer actually became the champion of the new approach because she saw it could work now. Lucas: And that is the ideal outcome. You want to turn their resistance into ownership. Because once they own the new idea, they bring all that experience to making it succeed rather than using it to block. Luna: Before we go deeper into scripts for these conversations, I want to circle back to something you said about the ad-free nature of these episodes. We deliberately don't run ads on Manager Mondays or any Fexingo show. It's a choice we made because we want the content to be purely useful, no sponsors shaping the conversation. Lucas: Yeah, and we hear from listeners that they appreciate it. If that model works for you and you'd like to support it, there's a simple way — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No obligation, just a way to keep the episodes free and ad-free for everyone. Luna: Exactly. And it genuinely helps us keep doing this. Now back to that conversation script — what's the actual language you recommend for the moment where you need to call out the pattern directly? Lucas: I like a two-part move. First, name the pattern without accusation: 'I've noticed that when I bring up new approaches, your first reaction is often to explain why they won't work. I want to understand that better.' Then pause. Let them respond. Luna: That is so different from 'You always shoot down my ideas.' It's curious, not confrontational. Lucas: Exactly. And once they explain — maybe they feel their past contributions were ignored, or they're tired of change for change's sake — you have a real issue to work on. Then the second part is: 'I need you to try a new default. When I propose something, I want your first response to be: what would have to be true for this to work? Can we start there?' Luna: So you're literally re-training the reflex. That's powerful. Lucas: It is. And it respects their intelligence — you're asking for analytical thinking, not blind agreement. Most senior people actually prefer that to being told to just go along. Luna: What if the employee still refuses? Like, they say 'I can't pretend I believe this will work'? Lucas: Then you escalate to a clearer performance conversation. You say: 'I'm not asking you to pretend. I'm asking you to execute. You can disagree with the approach privately, but in team meetings and in your work, I need full engagement. If you cannot provide that, we have a bigger problem.' Luna: That's firm but fair. You've given them multiple chances to be part of the solution. Lucas: Exactly. And by that point, if they still won't move, it's not about the idea — it's about their ability to adapt. And that is a legitimate performance issue, regardless of tenure. Luna: I think the key takeaway is: don't let 'I am too experienced' become a get-out-of-jail-free card. But also don't assume it's malice. Start with curiosity, test the expertise, then set expectations. Lucas: Well said. And one last thing — if you're a newer manager, it can be intimidating to have these conversations with someone who has been at the company longer than you've been alive. But your title gives you the authority to set direction. Use it respectfully, but use it. Luna: Respect without abdication. That's the balance. Lucas: Exactly. And if you can strike that balance, you often turn your biggest resister into your biggest ally.