Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Rebecca Responds to Hate Mail and other topics
Transcript
- 0:00So, Rebecca, let's talk about the recent hubbub on the internet about you.
- 0:07What do you say? Okay, this is the Psychologist Out a podcast.
- 0:12I'm your host, doctor Kirkhanda. I'm a therapist and a professor.
- 0:14Who are you. Hi'm Rebecca Bloom. I've been an out lesbian person since
- 0:20like nineteen ninety one. I'm also a therapist specializing in adult complex trauma in
- 0:27celcil I had reached out to you last night over text on two TOPICSS.
- 0:32I asked if you wanted to talk about our last episode in which you talked
- 0:37about bisexual people and how they are often excluded from the LGBTQ community. And
- 0:45there were a number of people that had commented, and not just randos on
- 0:50the internet, but people who listen to this podcast and like you, enjoy
- 0:54your episodes might prefer them even and they were upset about the conclusions or what
- 1:03they were hearing you say. So I wondered if you wanted to respond,
- 1:07because it seemed like there's always some criticism on the internet, but this one
- 1:12seemed like it deserved a response. So what do you want to say to
- 1:17these people? Sh I mean, what is so hard? As I felt
- 1:22like I sandwiched that episode by saying, I understand that bisexual folks are extremely
- 1:29oppressed, and what got heard by bisexual folks is I am not an ally
- 1:37for bisexuals and just for folks to know. Like I read through all of
- 1:42the stuff and thought, oh fuck, yeah, the thing this might be
- 1:49the first time. I mean, like I said, criticism is always there,
- 1:53but this might be the first time among your fans that there would be
- 1:59this. And it wasn't just hey, Rebecca, love you but you messed
- 2:02up about it was I am disillusioned by you right now. I don't know
- 2:08if I like you anymore. I mean, people weren't saying that directly,
- 2:12but it was along those lines. Yeah, yeah, I mean so clearly
- 2:15I didn't get it right. What's hard is I don't know how to get
- 2:22it right. And when you wrote me, I thought you need to have
- 2:24like a bisexual advocate on the show to speak. I mean, clearly,
- 2:29if I didn't, I you know, I'm not going to get it right,
- 2:34not gonna get it right. And maybe that's okay. I mean,
- 2:37I think one of the things that came out of the episode was people felt
- 2:39like if they approached me and said hey, I'm bisexual, that I wouldn't
- 2:46be excited for them. And the thing that was hardest I was talking about
- 2:53was like, here's my experience being a parent in this complex community where people
- 2:58just want this one turns out actual interaction with me for support, but like
- 3:04we won't support each other in any other way, or I didn't feel supported
- 3:07by them in any other way, which you know, transactionally, I'm thinking
- 3:12like as a lesbian out lesbian parent, I am more oppressed in this situation.
- 3:16Like I was getting kind of competitive in that experience, and you know,
- 3:23I realized in that conversation, like, yeah, I realized in the
- 3:27comments that came back to me that yeah, I'm not an advocate in every
- 3:30situation. And is that okay? You know? Is that my role in
- 3:36the community to be absolutely supportive of every person that comes at me? And
- 3:39I realize I can't. I can't be And what do you mean, like,
- 3:45am am I going to be perfectly supportive of everyone that comes to me
- 3:53that says, hey, I'm marginalized? Am I going to get it right?
- 3:57And I've noticed, you know, things have changed in my lifetime.
- 4:01So it used to be if you were hanging out with a bunch of queer
- 4:06women, and they were bisexual women there, and you referred to them as
- 4:12like lesbian sisters. It was kind of a compliment to say, like,
- 4:15I see you with me, and it's really changed now. It's is they're
- 4:19like, I am not your lesbian sister. I'm your bisexual sister. I
- 4:23am different than you. I'm like, oh boy, Like things have changed,
- 4:27Like there is a separate identity there that does not want to be part
- 4:30of how I identify. So, yeah, I am behind the times,
- 4:35and I'm probably in our apology also not going to get it right, which
- 4:41I kind of hate, but I just have to admit, like, if
- 4:45I didn't get it right in the podcast, there's nothing I've learned in the
- 4:47last month that I'm going to get it right now. Well did the comments
- 4:51among the ones that were attempting to explain something, learn you anything. So
- 4:59the one that's stuck out to me the most was the woman who said,
- 5:02yeah, I have no allies, then if I can't come to you,
- 5:05Rebecca as a lesbian and say be my ally in this situation, if you
- 5:11roll your eyes at me, and I was like, yeah, that is
- 5:15harsh but true. I might not be like today, you wouldn't necessarily be
- 5:21inviting. Yeah, I might not in the sense that, like, so,
- 5:27what I had to realize for myself is if someone comes to me with
- 5:30a single identity and this is like not like at gay Pride where you're like,
- 5:35well, I'm bisexual and I'm like, woh you go, you know,
- 5:39like we're I'm not talking about like a one time interaction. If you
- 5:43walked up to me on the street and you were like, hey, I'm
- 5:45bisexual. It's really hard to be bisexual. I would be like, yeah,
- 5:49I totally feel that that. What I'm realizing is a really different interaction
- 5:54than what I was talking about on the podcast. What were you talking about?
- 5:57What I was talking about on the podcast was like being in community with
- 6:00people in the current world, Like if you had a friend or a developing
- 6:06friend who came out to you as by and was asking for your that's not
- 6:12even what It's even vaguer than that. It's like it's these they don't exist
- 6:17anymore because of the pandemic. But I was talking about like being in the
- 6:21parenting community where you're like stuck with all these people that you have really nothing
- 6:28in common with except your kids are all on the same basketball team, and
- 6:30that mom that's like never been emotionally available to you in any way comes up
- 6:36to you to secretly tell you that she's bisexual, secretly told me that she's
- 6:42bisexual. And then the moment I'm just like eah, meaning that there's a
- 6:50request or an expectation that you will be in solidarity with them. Yeah,
- 6:57in there, but also like in their closet, like us hold this secret
- 7:01with me. Yeah, I will only tell you this. So you're talking
- 7:05about only closeted bisexual people. I think so, because there's a bisexual mom
- 7:12that could come up to you and maybe look to you fem and hetero and
- 7:16in a hetero relationship at that moment, but they're not in the closet.
- 7:21They tell a lot of people. They might not tell all the moms on
- 7:25the sideline at the basketball game. They look like a heterosexual person. They
- 7:29slot right into that. You're saying, what would you do? Then there's
- 7:31not a because there's not an expectation I'd be like, hey, cool,
- 7:35combs up. You know I'm not going to become invested in them. And
- 7:40someone wrote in saying, you know, it's not safe for everyone to be
- 7:45out and I am looking for a few people to be out to. Who
- 7:49do I turn to? And I just had to realize, like for me,
- 7:56I don't have the energy to be that one of the few people that
- 8:01you're out to. And is that okay? Like am I an endless fountain
- 8:05of advocacy for people who what is the extra energy that you have to So
- 8:13if more lesbian looking lesbian came up to you, I mean that's literally what
- 8:18you're talking about, right, Like someone who coached, say, I would
- 8:22just say out like I would just say that other people know. So this
- 8:26is actually I'm realizing where this trauma comes from. So at the height of
- 8:31the AIDS epidemic, it is nineteen ninety two, I get my first job
- 8:37out of college. I'm working at Triple A. And what I didn't realize
- 8:41at the time is Triple A was like full of closeted gay men. So
- 8:46Triple A, for those who don't know from outside the United States, is
- 8:50a you're talking about the roadside assistance back in the day. Triple A.
- 8:54Was this before the Internet. Yeah, Triple A was like another religion to
- 9:00Americans because cars were constantly breaking down in the seventies and eighties and nineties,
- 9:05and you didn't have cell phones, and road trips were kind of common because
- 9:07you couldn't afford, at least in my family, to fly. So the
- 9:11you know, cars breaking down at some god forsaken small town America, which
- 9:16is what most America is. If you've ever driven through America, you realize,
- 9:20I don't think we have to worry about landfill space anytime soon. I
- 9:22mean there's a lot of ground. You know. Have you have you seen
- 9:26Nevada. I've driven through up you know, north south Nevada. There's a
- 9:31lot of room. And I'm not recommending landfills. I'm just saying just a
- 9:35little Joe, but if you broke down, then you'd go to a payphone
- 9:39and you'd have this Triple A card and you would call and lickety split,
- 9:43they knew the exact person that they had contracted with in the area, and
- 9:48you know, Joe's tow truck would show up and they would pay for Triple
- 9:54A would pay for the whole thing. And it was just it was like
- 9:56you're an angel from heaven just would come down and save you, you know,
- 10:01and uh, and every father was like you got to make sure you
- 10:05got a Triple A card, you know, and also Triple A offices.
- 10:09We used to go to ticks what yes, yes, maps and guides and
- 10:16special special trip ticks just for your trip. I'm so glad that we're talking
- 10:20about this. Yeah. I would. I would drive to a to a
- 10:24town that I didn't know that well, like Provo, Utah, and I
- 10:28would immediately go to the Triple A office and I would walk up to the
- 10:31counter and I would say I'm a Triple A member. I'd show my card
- 10:35and then I would say, I need some maps. I also need to
- 10:37know what to do books. Yeah, and there's all these free like road
- 10:43trip stuff. Again, for those are too young to know this, there
- 10:48was a time before the Internet when this information was just like unavailable and Triple
- 10:52A rated right. A liked the restaurant, right, So I would plan
- 10:58trips around Triple So you were working at Triple A Yeah, wow, Yeah,
- 11:03what did you do for them? I was in the call center.
- 11:07So you were one of those angels. Yes, I was the Triple A
- 11:09angel that lead to you becoming a therapist. Because I'm sure you're with people
- 11:13at their deepest, oh scariest moments, yeah, yeah, yeah, so,
- 11:20but tons of the management were gay, and my boss hired me to
- 11:26be his secret gay friend because I think I had said I liked Roseanne in
- 11:31the interview in nineteen ninety two, and he knew that was code that there
- 11:35was a gay character on that show, and he would pull me aside every
- 11:39Friday to tell me about the gay content of the episode before. And I
- 11:46felt really trapped in being his secret gay friend. And I didn't want to
- 11:48be his secret gay friend. Were you a secret lesbian? I think I
- 11:52was pretty out. I was way more out than he was. And what
- 11:56was it about that relationship that bothered you? I was just so trapped in
- 12:01it, Like I just knew that my employment depended on me listening and nodding,
- 12:07and I was like, I don't want this job if he were a
- 12:11nicer, more interesting person, you know, if you liked him as a
- 12:16human. It sounds like you also just didn't like him very much. I
- 12:18think I didn't realize I was getting hired to be a secret gay friend,
- 12:22like you felt like tokenized and used. Yeah, I was trapped in being
- 12:28his great gay depositing, like there was no there was no consent, There
- 12:35was no like invitation or natural progression of your relationship. If it did progress
- 12:39that way, say, he didn't pressure you, he didn't know you were
- 12:43gay in the beginning, and you just slowly kind of figure out some code
- 12:48of his and hey, you know, and starting up with a conversation and
- 12:54turns out that he is very closeted compared to you, And would that and
- 12:58you became friends with that bother you? I mean, I think it would
- 13:01have been more natural. But this was like I was so stuck, right,
- 13:03So it's not that a closeted person, especially back then, right,
- 13:09you would judge them or not want to hang out with them. If he
- 13:13asked you in this hypothetical where there was consent, maybe even you inviting him
- 13:18in a little bit, if he asked you for some solidarity behind the scenes,
- 13:22would you give it? Probably okay, yeah, I mean I'm not
- 13:26cruel in it, But would you feel solidarity with him? I mean,
- 13:31I was reminded in people's responses to the bisexual comments that I made that it's
- 13:39not safe for lots and lots of people to come out, and it is
- 13:43so safe for me to be out and I am professionally out, and I
- 13:50can't imagine going back in the closet, although I can code switch on a
- 13:52dime and be back in the closet. You know, it's not like you
- 13:58know, I know how to tone it down. What do you have to
- 14:03tone down? It's just what you say. It's just like, so,
- 14:07here's an exercise if you want to know what it's like to be in the
- 14:09closet. For those of you who are in a heterosexual relationship, just try
- 14:16to have a whole conversation where you don't reveal the gender of your partner.
- 14:20Oh yeah, well, yeah, that would be that's a big But like
- 14:24other topics, political things, probably you have to suppress baby or I mean
- 14:28I would say that's the that's the biggest one, is just choosing to identify
- 14:33the gender of my partner. Yeah, okay, so but I have to
- 14:37come out. I mean I don't scream gay like I have to come out
- 14:43constantly. Yeah. To me being an outsider, I don't have personal experience
- 14:52with this, but reading the comments, I remember one person saying as a
- 14:58bicycle rtual woman and a fan of you and the podcast, and she was
- 15:07I think hurt and also very angry. And the gist that I got from
- 15:11it was that she was saying, what so, unless I present in a
- 15:18certain way, then I'm not a viable member of the LGBTQIA community. I'm
- 15:24not acceptable somehow you don't know my circumstances or That's what bisexuality is is that
- 15:31you might be in a same sex relationship, you might be in another relationship.
- 15:35That's that's the definition. So if you catch me when I'm in a
- 15:39hetero looking relationship, then somehow I'm I'm you're not in solidarity with me.
- 15:46I'm not I'm not acceptable. And let me just say I don't think that
- 15:52at all, nor do I live that in my life. Right, Like
- 15:56when I chatty with my friends, said like hey, what's up, and
- 16:00I'm like, oh, there's this thing going on on the internet where I
- 16:04was told I was not by positive enough and they were all just kind of
- 16:08like WHOA Really, I was like, yeah, you know the Internet.
- 16:14I tried to really tell all sides of the story, and I've I pissed
- 16:19off fans and that's really hard, you know. So, I mean I
- 16:25have talked this through with my friends, meaning they're surprised because you don't live
- 16:30a life where you're anti bye. People are oh, my life is you
- 16:33know, I mean, and I hate like I was thinking about, you
- 16:37know, when the whole me too thing happened, and all these men are
- 16:41like, I have daughters, you know, They're like, of course I'm
- 16:44a good person, and I was like, oh my god, I'm doing
- 16:47the same thing, Like my life is full of by people that I'm completely
- 16:52supportive of. Well, there's a difference between using people around you as some
- 16:59mass of slam dunk indication that you're not some sort of ist, whether it's
- 17:03sexist or racist. You know, I have a black friend, or I
- 17:07hired a Mexican person, you know that sort of talk. There's a differ
- 17:11between that and saying, well, let me explain that I have a lot
- 17:17of folks in my life that identify this way, and at no point have
- 17:22they ever said to me that I was unfair to them because of their identity.
- 17:27I think that says something. I'll tell you, Rebecca, and I'll
- 17:30cut all this out if you want me to. It's not really your style
- 17:33to do that, but I will gladly oblige. But when we talked about
- 17:37this topic in the previous episode, I remember thinking, I don't know if
- 17:41this is going to go over that well, but I don't know. I
- 17:45mean, I just sort of deferred to you because I figured you would have
- 17:48known more than me. But I remember hearing things and I just thought like,
- 17:52well, and I mean, what's funny about that episode is it was
- 17:56not in my typical style. And then I was like, I will kind
- 17:59of talk about the bad things that happened in the gay community. And you
- 18:03know, we live in a very SoundBite culture, and you know, I
- 18:08listened to our episodes because it's like part of my improvement program, like I
- 18:12want to be a better podcaster, and so I listened to the whole episode,
- 18:18and for me, there was kind of like an arc to that story
- 18:22where I was like taking on different voices, and someone on the YouTube comments
- 18:26actually pointed that out, like she's speaking in another voice for some of this.
- 18:30But I realized, in this time, no one can that is that
- 18:34nuance is lost that I'm kind of well, hearing you clarify today is different
- 18:42than how I was hearing it at the time. That the way it sounded
- 18:47was that back in the old days, there were the gold star lesbians and
- 18:52there were bless them, there were this notion of Well, you're either in
- 18:57or you're out. And if you're half in and half out, then you're
- 19:02almost kind of the enemy because you're trying to have both worlds. You want
- 19:07all the benefits of our community, you want our welcoming hugs, and maybe
- 19:12you're a clandestine you know, romantic relationship, but you are you have all
- 19:18the benefits of privilege and society. And that's uh, you know, we've
- 19:25made this sacrifice to get here. And how dare you interlope intowards if you're
- 19:30transitioning into great but if you're just going to ride the line this whole time,
- 19:34like not not Okay, that's very different than a bisexual person who is
- 19:38just naturally that way, right, It's a very different situation. And uh
- 19:45that but I don't want to put words in your mouth. Is that?
- 19:48Is that what you're saying? Uh? There have There are definitely aspects of
- 19:56that. Did I live that life? No? Am I life? Are
- 20:00you saying? Am I a gold star lesbian? No? Like? Could
- 20:04would people view my life as bisexual? Sure? So? Could things get
- 20:14really black and white back in the day, Yes, because of the oppression
- 20:21from the outside required a very tall wall around protecting people from the outside.
- 20:29Is there more support for bisexuals now than ever and bisexual pride? Yes?
- 20:36Is it safe for me to be out? Yes? Is it safe for
- 20:40everyone to be out? No? Yeah? Am I the one person in
- 20:47the world that you're going to tell It depends on the intimacy of our relationship
- 20:52how supportive like that is? The nuance that is that the only part of
- 20:56it is that the only I don't know what this is that the only negative
- 21:02thing you would say is that someone saddles up next to you and secretly tells
- 21:06you and expects and is expecting you to be their solidarity buddy in this secret
- 21:12yet kind of coerced relationship. Is that the only thing we're talking about.
- 21:18I learned today that that is a trigger for me. Yeah, based on
- 21:22that job that I had. Believe me, I've been there many times on
- 21:25this podcast. The nothing points to a trauma of mine. Then reckoning with
- 21:33a number of fans that are upset at something that I said. Again,
- 21:37if it's some fly by Night like when I talk about Jordan Peterson, there's
- 21:41always a bunch of fly by Night cult members that will say cult things and
- 21:47it doesn't get under my skin because it's so easily identified as a cult member,
- 21:52but for a fan to say something, it's it's a lot more take
- 21:56it to heart, so better or for worse. But a lot of the
- 22:00times when I reckon with this, the realization that I make is, oh,
- 22:04I have a trauma around this, And what happened from that trauma is
- 22:11I developed an anger and a resentment and a rigid point of view that I
- 22:15hadn't really processed. I had acted from that place and maybe even spouted it
- 22:21at times, but there wasn't enough people around me to push back or they
- 22:26knew I was traumatized or something, and without giving that context, then it
- 22:32just comes across like you're a jerk face or I'm just speaking for myself.
- 22:37And then I also wonder about all the people that I am angry about on
- 22:41the internet, like what's their trauma? Right? And I just think,
- 22:44like politicians, I don't agree with what happened to them that led them that
- 22:48down that road. Right. I'm not saying it's a good thing. I'm
- 22:52just saying I think it's a common thing because why would anyone be why would
- 22:57anyone choose to have an unreasonable, unfair point of view? Right? We're
- 23:03all humans and we tend to love or at least like humans, and if
- 23:10something's getten in the way of that, then something must have gotten in the
- 23:14way of that. So has that ever happened to you before in this podcast
- 23:17where you realize this? Okay, you had to figure out, like where
- 23:22does this come from? Yeah? And I think that because to me,
- 23:27the idea that especially a bisexual woman would feel that I didn't support her like
- 23:34makes me really sad because there's nothing more that I want to do than support
- 23:41bisexual women. Well, also and any queer woman, like that's my like
- 23:47I lived my life hard, but that yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah
- 23:49yeah, And it's not just you, it's what you represent, I think,
- 23:56because I think the hurt that you poke at was that they're for a
- 24:02lot of bisexual people, whether they're coding is by or not, whether they're
- 24:07out to others. You know, out is a funny phrase because it depends
- 24:11on the observer, right, It's like what's out to one person wouldn't be
- 24:15out there to another person. But anyway, I would say for many by
- 24:18people, if not all, they feel obviously oppressed and rejected by heterosexual mainstream
- 24:26culture. But when they turn to the community, the larger queer community.
- 24:32They've also experienced pushback. You're not a full queer person, you're just playing
- 24:37games. You're oh, sure, you got drunk one night and made out
- 24:41with your friend. That doesn't make you buy or you know, these kinds
- 24:45of things, And they already have those internalized and press oppressive voices inside of
- 24:52them, and they already hate themselves. They you know, they've been shamed
- 24:56their whole life since they first figure this out or it was an inkling to
- 25:00them earlier on in life, and then to finally find the oasis, and
- 25:07there's a rejection in a wall that's put up, and as a bisexual person,
- 25:12just like, well, where the fuck am I supposed to go?
- 25:15Then? So any suggestion that there's a questioning or get away from me or
- 25:25don't bother me with your half measures, you know it obviously would be very
- 25:30hurtful, you know, yeah, And I think that's I think that's how
- 25:34it felt to some people. That's what I don't think that's what you're saying,
- 25:38right, So to those people, what would you say directly to them?
- 25:42I love your mind us, you know, like I care for you,
- 25:47and I know your struggles, and I know sexual identity is hard,
- 25:51and I know finding love is hard, and love who you love. I'm
- 25:56trying to do the same thing. We're in the same boat. Sorry,
- 26:00I hurt your feelings, so it's like not my attention at all. Yeah.
- 26:04Really, I come on this podcast to try and have nuanced conversations.
- 26:12All right, Well, god damn it, this has been like a what
- 26:18are what's next? Easier things? Let's take a break. All right,
- 26:27we're back from the break. So a number of really juicy emails to get
- 26:32to and I'm just gonna not say much so that we can get through them
- 26:36faster. Is this speed round? I mean, I don't want to promise
- 26:38anything, but not with you. Yeah. So middle tier patron CJ from
- 26:44New York. He says, I'm writing a novel centering the trauma associated with
- 26:48cluster B personality disorder symptoms. A major medium for processing trauma throughout my story
- 26:56I'm writing is kink and BDSM. So my question is, might someone struggling
- 27:02with narcissistic traits be more attracted to dominance and sadism or the opposite? And
- 27:10also what about borderline Rebecca, what do you think this is a huge.
- 27:14This is huge, But boy, how would someone in cluster be work out
- 27:19their kinks. They'd probably be very intense about it. They'd really want what
- 27:26they want and really expect that they're gonna get it. So I imagine this
- 27:37is totally speculation. I'm just playing out this character in my head. They
- 27:40might play really, really hard and look for people who play hard and expect
- 27:45an intense connection, and when that connection splits, they would be devastated.
- 27:52Right, So I actually looked up some research along these lines, and some
- 27:57research suggests that those if we're just thinking about the prevalence of kink within those
- 28:04people identified as having a cluster B personality sorder versus not. Some research suggests
- 28:10that those who are into kink or BDSM that they have the same rate of
- 28:15personality sh orders including cluster B is the non kink or BDSM folks, So
- 28:22there doesn't seem to be a huge signal there, although some research seems to
- 28:26suggest that maybe those with narcissistic personality traits and those with association might have a
- 28:33slightly higher rate of being into kink and BDSM, which makes some sense,
- 28:38but also it's not a huge signal. But if we're talking about how they
- 28:42play out. Some of the research suggests that people with borderline histrionic personality,
- 28:49these folks are associated with a greater likelihood of using sex to gain approval.
- 28:53Yes, which makes sense, of course, so that they are in a
- 28:59state of trying to grasp at attachment security because they come from a lot of
- 29:04betrayal and trauma, and so through sexuality makes sense they might use it or
- 29:14see it as a way of gaining approval. That doesn't mean it's pathological.
- 29:18All of us when we engage in sex, are seeking approval on some level.
- 29:25I would hope that you'd be wanting to seek approval, because that would
- 29:27mean that you're not just using someone else for your own needs. You're wanting
- 29:32them to enjoy it or something. Seeing which side note, did you see
- 29:36this clip that thirty percent of people who go out on dates just do it
- 29:40for the free meal? What? Yes? Oh my god, So at
- 29:45first I thought I was a joke, But then I'm realizing, no,
- 29:48that it's not just I could see that. Oh my god, So that
- 29:52is uncool. I mean, if it's a part of it, if you're
- 29:56just like, yeah, I'm going for a free meal because you know,
- 30:00times are kind of tough right now. And if I happen to meet someone,
- 30:03then great, but at least I get a free meal. Or is
- 30:06it I'm not actually interested in dating this person. I'm only going for the
- 30:08female. That is atrocious, That is that's psychopathic. Can you imagine sitting
- 30:15with someone that you know is there to talk with you about meeting you know,
- 30:21it might have taken them five years to just get up the nerve to
- 30:22actually meet someone in person, and you're just using them for like a burger
- 30:26in front shanga. I know, there's a whole nother. So anyways,
- 30:30there's a lot of pathology playing out in all kinds of dating, not just
- 30:33as m Yeah yeah, right, yeah, and we should say that upfront.
- 30:38I think, Yeah, what you're getting at is that whenever we talk
- 30:42about kink or BDSM, we're always thinking like, oh, what sort of
- 30:45trauma or what sort of fucked upness is involved, because that's the only way
- 30:49you get there, and that is ridiculous. King, BDSM, other sexual
- 30:56preferences are just sexual preferences as long as they're consensual. We are a widely
- 31:00varied species with a lot I mean, if anything, kink is more the
- 31:04norm. You know, kink is by definition supposed to be something that is
- 31:10outside the average. But when you actually get to know people, and we've
- 31:15known about this since the Kinsey report, that this is yeah, it's it
- 31:21would you're kinky if you're not kinky, you know what I mean, it's
- 31:22like, oh my god, you are like kinkily vanilla. Like I've never
- 31:27met someone so vanilla. And there's nothing wrong with being vanilla. It's just
- 31:32just another version anyway. And also people with Researchers found that people with narcissm
- 31:37and or psychopathy this is associated of course with self centered sexuality, right,
- 31:44I mean I would be curious of I don't know if there's any way to
- 31:48research this, but if someone is saying that can provide something or is asking
- 31:52for something really just wants that thing or wants something else, right, But
- 32:00to comment on what you were saying earlier, that I think that that would
- 32:02be likely that for people with custom B there well, with all of us,
- 32:07there's a tendency to play out in healthy and unhealthy ways. Are traumas
- 32:15in our sexual preferences and activity and behaviors and feelings. You know, if
- 32:21you tend to be preoccupied attachments in general, that's likely to play out with
- 32:27your partner during sex if you're avoidant, for example. Similarly, people with
- 32:32avoidant attachment tend to masturbate more because they don't want to depend on other people
- 32:37fascinating and they also, yeah, they also during sex tend to think about
- 32:45other things more, feel more disconnected because they're oriented and neurologically they're more that
- 32:51way. If you're preoccupied, you're more likely to fake an orgasm, for
- 32:53example, because you're more worried about losing your partner, and that will manifest
- 33:00during sex. So for people and cluster B, we're talking about severe attachment
- 33:07reactivity for these folks, and it would likely play itself out. But middle
- 33:13tier patron CJ from New York, I recommend if you're going to appeal to
- 33:16people like me with the novel, which of course you don't have to,
- 33:20which might even make your novel not very interesting to people, is not to
- 33:24write a novel that makes cluster b out to be this like, very exotic
- 33:30thing. It's just an extension of a dimension of human variability that is available
- 33:37to all of us. I hope that people hear that when I talk about
- 33:40borderline or narcissistic or historyonic. I mean psychopathy to be is kind of a
- 33:45different thing. But for those others, well, we're all a little narcissistic,
- 33:47we're all a little history ononic, we're all a little born. And
- 33:51I thinking about this character, are very curious, like will you get into
- 33:54the childhood issues or family history that led to this story or person's Will there
- 34:00be other aspects of like how this person was treated by the mental health system
- 34:05or you know, will it be a well rounded portrayal of cluster b Yeah,
- 34:10and also a destigmatized take on kink and b DSM because it's not talked
- 34:16about very often. So the way that it is portrayed often is that it's
- 34:20this dark and scary and horrific thing that only like rich men do in Seattle.
- 34:27You know? Was that fifty Yeah? So because that took place in
- 34:32Seattle, right, I never I don't know, because I think I think
- 34:37it did. I think it was fan fiction on on Twilight, which happens
- 34:43also near Seattle, you know. Yeah. And so Pete Davidson is very
- 34:50out about having borderline personality disorder, I believe, And there was a very
- 34:54funny skit on last week's Sturday Live where they did a I'm Just Ken but
- 35:00it's I'm just Pete and in it, I think they riffed on his VPD
- 35:05and it was very funny, so like there's but they riff about everything about
- 35:08him in that skit and I just enjoyed it. And it's him singing about
- 35:13all of how he is perceived and that's great. Yeah, you know,
- 35:17like just make it varied and interesting. So you also texted me and said
- 35:22you wanted to talk about complex PTSD. So you really got some requests for
- 35:27that? Would well, I have a deep dive I've been working on that
- 35:31I am excited to get my hands into, so I don't have that before
- 35:36me. But it sounded like you wanted to talk about something well, So
- 35:39one of the comments we got on the last episode was that someone didn't know
- 35:43that that's my specialization, and so, you know, did I have anything
- 35:47nuanced to say about it? So I'll just say that it is the work
- 35:52that has come to me. It is not what I imagined I has been
- 35:54my career doing at the beginning of my career. But you know, my
- 35:59joke is, if you've had a single car accident, I'm not your therapist.
- 36:02But if you're if we've got a complex immigration history, if you're there's
- 36:08drug addiction in your family, if people are in jail, if there's abuse
- 36:13of all kinds, you know, I'm your therapist. If there have been
- 36:19multiple traumas that you are sitting with, those are the clients that I have
- 36:24that stay with me forever. What is the vibe or approach that you have
- 36:29that is suited for that? So it is the work that came to me
- 36:34for a long time, and I relied a lot on the art therapy in
- 36:37order to help with that. I luckily found my way to sensory motorcycle therapy
- 36:42that helped me learn the body based way of asking people how is that sitting
- 36:45in their bodies? What is their body telling them by you know, feeling
- 36:52this way as we talk about this. That has really saved me and allowed
- 36:55me to continue to be a therapist. It saved me through COVID and suddenly
- 37:01becoming a telehealth therapist when I couldn't be an art therapist. Really meaning that
- 37:07over zoom you could therapy was not as great. Yeah, but you could
- 37:13do this sensor your motor worked great, But it's to do over over a
- 37:17camera. For me, I mean, I know people have found their way
- 37:20with it. I never did. That's more a statement of me than it
- 37:23is on the medium of art therapy. But in terms of how does a
- 37:30client stay grounded? So how I work as a trauma based therapist is I'm
- 37:37not addressing complex trauma. Is I don't need to know the quote whole story.
- 37:44We're not working a lot with trauma narrative. What we are working with
- 37:46is grounding the client in the moment, allowing the client to understand that complex
- 37:52feelings and complex selves. I mean, if you this is a lot about
- 37:57parts work. If you're interested in family systems, it has a lot of
- 38:00aspects of that that The quote I use a lot is from Jack Cornfield the
- 38:08oh my God, the map maker, so that when within all of us
- 38:12is a young self who came up with a way of coping with whatever was
- 38:19going down in our childhood, and the problem with the traumatized brain is we
- 38:23bring that child's self into every situation and unlocking the trauma. How the trauma
- 38:30impacts our lives. For most of my clients is thanking the map maker for
- 38:37their service and finding new ways to cope as an adult because the way that
- 38:43the map maker survived the trauma is probably not going to work great in the
- 38:47adult world. And that's the work right there with complex trauma is finding new
- 38:53ways a to tolerate current adult situations and then be finding new ways of being.
- 39:02Yeah, let's take a break. Okay, get back more questions?
- 39:06What you say? Yeah, okay, we're back from the break. So
- 39:12before I forget, I want to present with you the hard copy of Soft
- 39:17Noodle's art that she made for you. That is so sweet. So oh
- 39:24look read what is so so? Soft Noodles summarized your personhood and your presence
- 39:31on the podcast with the following art piece. So what does it say?
- 39:37On the top it says internalized Rebecca voice, and then there's an image of
- 39:43soft Noodles, and then in big words, it says make art, Fuck
- 39:49the patriarchy, be gay, never stop fighting the good fight, and then
- 39:54on the bottom it says say no to Tumeric. Yes. So email from
- 40:00patron Hannah wrote in saying I was wondering if you could be able to discuss
- 40:06the inclusion of mental illness as a criterion for euthanasia or medical assistance in dying
- 40:12or am a idea or made in Canada. I live in Canada, and
- 40:16my government is in the process of potentially including mental illness as a valid criterion
- 40:21for accessing medical assistance and dying. I am a mental health professional, and
- 40:27this really concerns me. It feels like my country is giving up on these
- 40:30vulnerable individuals instead of investing their efforts into increasing access to mental health support.
- 40:36I truly believe in the power of therapy and effective treatment, and this has
- 40:39been really disheartening. Furthermore, because suicidal ideation is a very common symptom of
- 40:45many mental disorders, I believe many of these individuals would not be in the
- 40:50right state of mind to make a decision of this nature. I do not
- 40:53believe that healthcare professionals should indulge these urges or inadvertently encourage their belief that death
- 40:59is the only option. Anyways, I would love to hear you speak more
- 41:02about this and hear your opinion, Rebecca, what do you think? Wow,
- 41:07so here in the States it is not in the criteria. So I'm
- 41:13just talking off the cuff because I've never even thought about this concept before.
- 41:19I imagine it would be very difficult to create a criteria like this. I
- 41:24mean, I'm thinking about the criteria in the States for medical assistant suicide is
- 41:30that you have under some amount of time to live due to a medical illness.
- 41:38So doing that for mental health, I just imagine this would be incredibly
- 41:43complicated, right, because there's not an illness that is going to kill you
- 41:49eventually. I mean, you know, is demensia a medical diagnosis or a
- 41:53mental health diagnosis? Because I think it's a medical dies because with that diagnosis
- 41:58you're given ten years to live usually. But so I do I know anyone.
- 42:04I know someone who fought very hard for medical assisted suicide to legalize it,
- 42:09but then by the time they were so sick they were too disoriented.
- 42:15But I have a friend who is is an angel who does the legal paperwork
- 42:22for someone to be in volunteers their time in order to do this and has
- 42:25been present at countless It gives the medication in order for someone to die and
- 42:31sits with them. As they say, it's a medical professional. This is
- 42:35a legal professional, and this individual administers the I don't know if they admit
- 42:39I think in Washington State it's just the pills. It's not like a lethal
- 42:45injection or anything. Okay, So I know from their stories this whole process
- 42:51is no joke. It's not easy to acquire. I can't imagine how you
- 42:58would do this about mental health. Well, I looked it up. So,
- 43:02yeah, there's a lot of debate around this topic, not only just
- 43:07medical aid in dying or medical assistance in dying, which is a different phrase
- 43:13than you know, medically assisted suicide or what's the phrase we use. That's
- 43:19what it's called here. Yeah, but it's the Death and Dignity Bill,
- 43:24is what got fought for in Washington State. Yeah. So there's a lot
- 43:29of taboos that are touched upon within this topic, particularly with mental illness being
- 43:36involved, because in mainstream American pciety, we don't like to talk about death
- 43:39or even acknowledge it, particularly suicide. We don't like to talk about mental
- 43:44illness or sadness in general, or grief in general, and it causes a
- 43:51lot of people to immediately have a knee dric reaction to it instead of slowing
- 43:57down and looking at the details and hearing the stories of the individuals. Right.
- 44:02So, for you, Patron Hannah, I looked into this because I
- 44:06had a similar reaction. At first. I was thinking, wait, So
- 44:08if I had a client that had been thinking about suicide for five years,
- 44:14which isn't uncommon, and they were moderate to severe thinking about it, right,
- 44:19there's people who kind of think about it as people are moderate more severe,
- 44:22And there's someone that is chronically this way and they have treatment resistant depression
- 44:30as they call it, and it takes a long time, and I'm doing
- 44:32everything I can. But maybe I think the client really isn't putting in the
- 44:37effort because they're depressed. It's catch twenty two. Maybe I think that the
- 44:42prescriber isn't doing enough. Maybe I think that their life is also because of
- 44:46the trauma they've been through in their current situation, their life circumstances are causing
- 44:52a lot of depression. What I personally, how would I feel if the
- 44:57system allowed that person to access a service like this? I would feel like
- 45:02we fail this individual as a society. If we just increase tax dollars or
- 45:07awareness, or if people in this person's life were more aware, then we
- 45:13could have turned this around. But because as you're saying, Hannah, it
- 45:15just like so wait, we're just supposed to sit by and watch society oppress
- 45:22these individuals and have these individuals go through racism and sexism and you know,
- 45:27homophobia or whatever and be traumatized and marginalized. They get depressed and sometimes suicidal.
- 45:34And then we also have this measure where you're like, yeah, yeah,
- 45:37we'll let you take yourself out, like that's deplorable, really right,
- 45:42And I get that, But when I looked into everything that's happening, it's
- 45:45it's more complicated in that. So first off, I just want to describe
- 45:52just what would be required in Canada, and it's similar to United States around
- 45:55medical assistance and dying. One, you have to be eligible for health service
- 46:00is funded by the government, which is always the case. You have to
- 46:02be at least eighteen. You have to be mentally competent and found to be
- 46:07mentally competent. And here's the kicker is that you have to have a grievous
- 46:12and irremediable medical condition, so a very horrible medical condition and something that is
- 46:19not going to go away. You have to have a serious illness or disability.
- 46:23You need to be in an advanced state of decline that cannot be reversed,
- 46:27and you don't necessarily have to be dying. It can be something that
- 46:30is very difficult that you are potentially likely to live in another thirty years,
- 46:36but you'll just be an utter pain or you'll be hooked up to all sorts
- 46:42of medical procedure kinds of things. So you don't have to be dying.
- 46:45It just has to be something that is grievous and irremediable, and you need
- 46:50to experience unbearable physical or mental suffering that cannot be relieved under conditions that you
- 46:55consider acceptable. So it's another little phrase there. Right, there might be
- 46:59a treatment available that, say, twenty percent of people recover, but if
- 47:05you are thinking, I don't want to go through that treatment, it sounds
- 47:07horriszic, right like, do you have to try that treatment in order to
- 47:10progress to the next step? Right Like, it might be twenty five years
- 47:15of treatment that has a twenty percent success rate and you might think, don't
- 47:20I don't want to go through that. So, even if there is a
- 47:23treatment available, if you consider it to be unacceptable, and I suppose if
- 47:28the medical professionals involved that are signing off on the forms consider that a reasonable
- 47:34opinion or take on the matter, then that is considered to be you might
- 47:39be considered eligible for this criterion. You need to make a voluntary request for
- 47:44medical assistance dayeing, meaning that you can't be influenced by other people and you
- 47:49need to give informed consent for it. Obviously, and generally speaking, visitors
- 47:53to Canada are not eligible, by the way, So there are a lot
- 47:57of safeguards in place. There must there must be two in Penan medical assessments.
- 48:00There's a ninety day mandatory assessment period, a second assessment by a healthcare
- 48:06practitioner who is a specialist in the condition itself. Okay, so when it
- 48:10comes to mental illness, starting in March of twenty twenty four, people with
- 48:15mental illnesses in Canada will be eligible as far as I know, but currently
- 48:19there's no agreed upon criteria to dictate this. But a government appointed expert panel
- 48:25have made recommendations and they recommended a number of things. They recommended that the
- 48:32evaluators to sign off on this happening, that they look at the number and
- 48:37types of treatment attempts. You know, there's a lot of folks out there
- 48:42that are just chronically depressed and thinking about suicide on a daily basis. For
- 48:46those people, have the practitioners signed off on the fact that that patient has
- 48:54exhausted the reasonable range of treatment options available. Currently, there is a requirement
- 49:00that the patient be informed of all available means to relieve their suffering. However,
- 49:07the law states that the person does not have to accept the treatments.
- 49:09So the person could be informed of like, hey, you've only been to
- 49:15six months of CBT, and there's psychiatry, there's trauma therapy, there's all
- 49:21these other things, but the law states the person doesn't have to accept those
- 49:23treatments. So to me, the challenges are like, yeah, what if
- 49:28the suicide suicidality is temporary. I mean you've seen that before clinically, right,
- 49:31yeah, so yeah, I mean in conclusion, what I'll say is,
- 49:35after looking at all the considerations and the plans, I hope that those
- 49:40involved, which is usually the case because it's dependent on experts. It's not
- 49:45dependent on some politician, it's dependent on experts. On the ground that the
- 49:50majority of those experts, particularly in the beginning, I'm guessing that there would
- 49:52be a lot of care and scrutiny, because that's usually the case in these
- 49:59cases. Is in North America, if someone has terminal cancer, it's not
- 50:04like people just go, oh, you just sign this form and to go
- 50:08through that door and we will kill you. You know, there's a very
- 50:13long process with a lot of emotion and a lot of humanity and a lot
- 50:16of care and a lot of life, and it can be a really beautiful
- 50:19process. Yeah. I mean I had a friend whose mother went through it
- 50:22recently and it was you know, it was lovely. Yeah, but it
- 50:27is weird to think about that someone one of our own clients, because you've
- 50:31you got to figure eventually this is gonna this is going to come to Washington
- 50:35State that one of our patients could be chronically depressed and suicidal and they might
- 50:40ask us to comment on this process. I'm listening to you thinking I am
- 50:49not ready for this, Like, yeah, they I hope there's some trainings.
- 50:53Yes, this is this is a complete paradigm shift of my twenty five
- 51:00years in the field. Yeah, because we're trained, and I think for
- 51:04a lot of good reasons that you know, we don't chastise clients for attempting
- 51:08or something, but we don't support it because the general rule is that there's
- 51:13always hope and there's always something to do. As a professional, there's always
- 51:19another rock that you can unturn, or sometimes it takes a while, and
- 51:22you just got to offer these clients, you know, they have minimal support
- 51:25systems. Like it's all of these things that you would hope would change for
- 51:30someone, that would change someone's life. Right, So I mean this is
- 51:36I say this all the time to my clients. I think I'm holding on
- 51:39to hope for you. I can tell that you've lost hope. Yeah,
- 51:45and that can go a long way, right, Yeah, Well, and
- 51:46I think the weird part of our work is we actually admit that this is
- 51:51happening for people. Most people might have no idea how often people are suicidal,
- 51:55right, But we're the safe place that someone can say, my life
- 52:00is completely hopeless right now, and I can't imagine staying alive. And I
- 52:05can say, oh, I can see a bunch of reasons why you would
- 52:07still stay alive. So to think that part of my work in the future
- 52:13would be like and I can see why. It's a why you've made the
- 52:17choice to end your life and the government will be paying for it, you
- 52:22know, Like it's yeah, it's wild. Yeah, it's completely different.
- 52:27That's never been a part of our equation. All right, final email,
- 52:31This one's this one. I'm really curious about what you're going to say could
- 52:36get you in trouble again? Oh boy, which I did? I'm not
- 52:38realizing. I don't think so. I don't think so. Upper tier patron
- 52:43Heather from New England. She says, I'm sure you are receiving many messages
- 52:47regarding the school shooting in Nashville. Do you remember in March of twenty twenty
- 52:53three there was a queer individual a transman. Well, I'll get to that
- 53:00in a second. So what Heather says is for me, as a non
- 53:04binary person, this is the most I've ever understood a killer's motive because the
- 53:08killer was non binary. Do you remember this? I blanked it out?
- 53:13Maybe you didn't. I mean it was a big story, but I don't
- 53:15know if it would have been on every platform. I mean it seems like
- 53:20I should attract it. I mean, I think I'm at the point now
- 53:22where there's so many traumas that I'm I don't absorb. Some people say this
- 53:25to me all the time, like you didn't follow that story, and I'm
- 53:28like no, yeah, so completely traumatized and flooded. So what Heather is
- 53:36saying is for me, as a non binary person, this is the most
- 53:40that I have ever understood a killer's motive. In no way whatsoever am I
- 53:45saying they were justified in what they did. Do you have any insight into
- 53:50what might drive someone like this killer to go on a rampage and take out
- 53:54instant people instead of just killing themselves. It is so difficult to explain that
- 54:00you have some sympathy for someone like this as I do. Well, at
- 54:05the same time, you know what they did was heinous. Unfortunately, this
- 54:07will also lead to more hate and fear of the trans community. Could you
- 54:13possibly discuss this and can you assure us that sympathizing with someone who perpetuates these
- 54:17crimes does not make us bad people? So end of email, I'll just
- 54:21describe what happened and then you can tell me what you think. So Nashville
- 54:25marched twenty twenty three. The Covenant School, a religious elementary school, and
- 54:30a transmand that I'm not going to name because it is the preferred way of
- 54:36reporting on these things not to say their name, because sometimes these folks want
- 54:38their name to be in the news. That's one of the reasons why they
- 54:43do it. So a transman and a former student of the school. I'm
- 54:49not going to say what he did, but he killed a bunch of people
- 54:52and then he was killed by the police. He was twenty eight years old,
- 54:55He had no criminal record. He legally purchased seven firearms. He lived
- 55:00with his parents. His family said he was autistic, but who knows.
- 55:05I didn't see any reporting specifically on that he reported struggling emotionally, and as
- 55:10of today that the last time I was looking at this, the motive was
- 55:14unclear. Investigators have read his journal and a manifesto describing by police. They
- 55:22were describing it as being rambling and didn't really reference any particular political issue.
- 55:28So it wasn't like I'm doing this because I'm trans or i was bullied or
- 55:31anything. According to the police. Anyway, who knows what that means.
- 55:35But what Heather is asking is for the first time, she feels like she
- 55:39can relate a little bit to the anger and to the frustration, while at
- 55:45the same time knowing what he did was horrific and totally unnecessary and bad.
- 55:53Right, what do you think about that? And does that make Heather a
- 55:55bad person for having some sympathy for the individual. I think Heather's able to
- 56:01take a really nuanced view of this person. I'm finding myself flooded by this
- 56:07story. I think that these acts of violence are so common now I'm just
- 56:20interested, Like I do know this story. I just blocked it out and
- 56:24I didn't know that he was trans I don't think that changes the story for
- 56:29me at all. Often shooters will say I was bullied, or I'm doing
- 56:35this because if any number of reasons. You know, But these people are
- 56:42human, right, I mean they are. We do already know them,
- 56:45they have already been around us. I just keep thinking, how does someone
- 56:51get to that level of violence and think it's a good idea to have a
- 56:55bunch of firearms. There's awful the level of planning and all of this is
- 57:02Is it premeditated murderers? You know, this is a crime of intent,
- 57:10And that's what keeps me distanced from folks who've committed these crimes. Yeah.
- 57:16I mean, it's one thing if you're in a fight and a gun comes
- 57:21out, it's also not great. But at least you didn't plan this over
- 57:27time. You didn't acquire the means and make a plan and drive down there
- 57:30and get out of your car and calmly walk into the school like it's truly
- 57:35mind boggling to think that someone would resort to that innocent kids, Like,
- 57:39what are you thinking? Why would you do that? Yeah? I mean
- 57:43I think we are all looking for the humanness in each other these days,
- 57:46or many of us are trying to find that there's still some humanness out there
- 57:52in the world, and so I'm wondering if this patron is trying to find
- 57:55the humanness and other people. It's weird how like shootings kind of come up,
- 58:04but the Pulse massacre comes up over and over again, and among queer
- 58:08people, we still talk about it as if it just happened and Orlando,
- 58:13Orlando Pulse Nightclub, you know, not it like fifty people or something,
- 58:19or it was at the time it was the largest mass shooting in US history,
- 58:24I believe. Yeah, you know, just that that because I think
- 58:29as queer people, we know that that event could happen at any time,
- 58:32and mostly people of color. Right. Yeah. By the way, yeah,
- 58:37I think someone had just told me they went an ally went to the
- 58:40memorial and I guess all of the there's images of all of the young people,
- 58:45and she was like, oh, they're so young, So I'll just
- 58:49tell everyone you recorded several times of how to tell the story of the shooting
- 58:53because and I'm assuming you did it because I gasped when you went through the
- 58:58details the first time. Yeah, meaning that I had stopped the recording because
- 59:04I would go back and record it again because I wanted to be careful with
- 59:08how I described what happened to Yeah. So yeah, I'm super interested in
- 59:15this patron if they feel, how they are feeling the humanness in general of
- 59:22people. You know, I think we're all trying to connect and understand each
- 59:25other, and is there a way to understand someone like this? And I'm
- 59:30assuming some of that is that I don't know. For me, that would
- 59:32be could I have helped if I had met this person? Could I have
- 59:37made a difference. Yeah, I often think that too. I remember thinking
- 59:39that about the Sandy Hook shooting. The individual was someone that I treated often
- 59:49when I was doing a lot of in home therapy, a lot of I
- 59:52mean, it wasn't a huge percentage, but I can think of a number
- 59:55of clients where they had been bullied, they were secluded in their bedroom playing
- 1:00:01video games all day and didn't want to talk to anybody, and they had
- 1:00:05a concerned parent and were having violent fantasies, and I would do some I
- 1:00:12mean, I remember there's this one kid I did all every single session.
- 1:00:15I sat on the ground outside of his bedroom door while he sat inside of
- 1:00:21his bedroom playing video games, and I would eke out this strained session over
- 1:00:27like two and a half hours, and I just knew that I was his
- 1:00:31only tether and without me, he didn't have anything, or he just had
- 1:00:37his weird echo chamber that he was in. And so when I hear about
- 1:00:39some of these cases, I just think, similar to you, it's like
- 1:00:43I wish that someone could have been there, because often that's all that it
- 1:00:46takes. It's just a connection, a hope, you know, some acceptance,
- 1:00:52you know, some way forward, or that people would have listened to
- 1:00:55the signs. So the Virginia Tech shooter, one of his he was in
- 1:01:01a poetry class with one of my favorite poets, Nikki Jioviani, and miss
- 1:01:06Joviani brought to attention to the authorities this student and said, I can see
- 1:01:13from his poetry there's something very very disturbed about this student. And the administration
- 1:01:20didn't do anything with that information. But I think about that moment all the
- 1:01:25time, Like you know, as anyone could probably see it in this person
- 1:01:32that something was really really off. Yeah, that's often the case, Like
- 1:01:37with the shooter in Uh Well, I'll say his name because he's become a
- 1:01:44cultural icon to the manisphere, Elliott Roger, And there were a number of
- 1:01:50moments of people, including the police, being alerted to his issues. Now,
- 1:01:58for every person that does something like this, there are thousands, if
- 1:02:04not millions of other people with identical markers, right, But what I think
- 1:02:08is, well, that doesn't mean we don't do anything. It just means
- 1:02:10that we should be treating all those people because the chance of catching one of
- 1:02:15them is a lot higher if we're actually doing something and maybe not have access
- 1:02:17to firearms, like if you've been to any other country. I mean I
- 1:02:23when I was in Spain for a month, there is no access to the
- 1:02:29only people that have guns in that country or police, And it was just
- 1:02:32so interesting. And there's this huge nightlife culture, not that anything bad doesn't
- 1:02:37happen there, but like there's a huge nightlife culture and people regularly come home
- 1:02:42at like three or four five in the morning. That's like very very common
- 1:02:46in Spain. And I was like, oh, it was my weird things
- 1:02:51that I was there after about a week is you could just feel it,
- 1:02:53like, oh, there's no guns here, like people are just out in
- 1:02:57the street. I don't he I live in a neighborhood where I hear gunfire
- 1:03:00from timetime, Like I don't hear any gunfire here, Like you know,
- 1:03:05I'm getting on a soapbox here for a minute. But if we don't have
- 1:03:07a mental health system that can protect ourselves from people's intense rage, can we
- 1:03:13at least not give people access to firearms or just limit it a little bit
- 1:03:19more, you know, yeah? Or you know, no AK forty seven's
- 1:03:22like those are we don't even need those in war? People like I just
- 1:03:28yeah, So there was there was a shooting here in Seattle. There's been
- 1:03:31This is the highest freate of homicide in Seattle this year ever, tons of
- 1:03:38it is happening where I live. And there was a shooting earlier in the
- 1:03:44year of a man that owned like a post office place, and just last
- 1:03:49week they closed permanently because there was a gunfire outside. Well, and then
- 1:03:53there's also about a mile away gunfire came through a preschool window by a week
- 1:04:00ago. I mean, it's just like I can see the common thread here
- 1:04:04personally for me, and it's access to firearms, right, and that is
- 1:04:10actually the number one way that suicide is completed. And yeah, it's a
- 1:04:15huge factor for people that are thinking about suicide. If they have a gun,
- 1:04:18their chance of dying or attempting skyrockets. You know, people think,
- 1:04:24well, if you want to do it, then you're going to find a
- 1:04:27way. And the research does not support that. People really want to do
- 1:04:30it, but they don't have a gun, they're far less likely to actually
- 1:04:33do it. But yeah, with this shooting in Nashville, the issue was
- 1:04:38that when it happened, it was this perfect story to perturb the echo chambers
- 1:04:45on the left and the right, because for the right, it's like,
- 1:04:48oh, parents, people are crazy. Right. But we never talk about
- 1:04:53school shootings because we don't want to go down that road because then we have
- 1:04:57to talk about firearms control and we might have to talk about raising taxes for
- 1:05:02mental health care. So we just gloss over those stories, or if we
- 1:05:06talk about it, we talk about how the person was crazy or something.
- 1:05:10But we will talk about this one because it happens to be a trans perpetrator
- 1:05:15and it falls into our narrative that all LGBTQ people are crazy and angry and
- 1:05:21bad and evil. I mean literally like doing the whole deep dive on the
- 1:05:27Duggers and the Mormons and IBLP. I don't know if you know that Mean
- 1:05:30and Berta were doing this, But of course I knew that our country has
- 1:05:34a strong religious theme, and of course I knew that they were fundamentalists,
- 1:05:43you know, like your Westborough people and you're more extreme evangelicals or something.
- 1:05:47But what I didn't know, or I didn't fully appreciate, was that fundamentalism
- 1:05:53is actually on the rise. Christianity is on the decline, Religiosity is on
- 1:05:58the decline, but fundamentalism is on the rise. So you have fewer religious
- 1:06:02people, but you have more intensity, more intensity among those those left,
- 1:06:09and the intensity is so regressive it's like they're out of the seventeen hundreds.
- 1:06:15The kind of shit that they think, which of course explains like QAnon and
- 1:06:20just all sorts of just it's like another world. And they live right next
- 1:06:27door because they're everywhere, you know. And so you have this notion in
- 1:06:30that community that LGBTQ people are literally possessed by the devil or influenced by the
- 1:06:34devil. Or demons or out to get you. You know, definitely going
- 1:06:39to hell, that's for sure. And you need to not only not be
- 1:06:45like them, but you need to actively reject them because that's what God is
- 1:06:47telling you to do. If you don't do that, then you're not a
- 1:06:49good evangelical, or you're not a good Mormon, or you're not a good
- 1:06:53whatever. So there's that side, and then on the left there was this
- 1:06:58cognitive dissonance around well, of course we're against school shootings, and we're more
- 1:07:01likely on the left echo chamber to talk about that, but we have a
- 1:07:04trans perpetrator, So how do we word this? What's the protocol do?
- 1:07:11So there was, you know, within that, and I'm not talking about
- 1:07:15all liberal people, I'm just talking about you know, Twitter and that kind
- 1:07:17of thing, there was what seemed to be a lack of coverage of this
- 1:07:24case in the way that they would have normally because the perpetrator was trans,
- 1:07:28you know, because they didn't want to get labeled as anti trans, even
- 1:07:30though it's a school shooter. To me, as you were saying earlier,
- 1:07:35there's a lot of school shooters, and there's also you know a percentage of
- 1:07:41trans people, and so being trans doesn't mean that you're automatically a wonderful human
- 1:07:45being. Newsflash. Being gay being in the LGBTQ community doesn't mean that you're
- 1:07:51like someone I want to be friends with necessarily, you know what I mean,
- 1:07:56just because of that. And conversely, if you're a cis head person
- 1:08:00and like myself, doesn't mean that you're evil and I don't want to be
- 1:08:02friends with you that. But in our discourse there's often that kind of heuristic,
- 1:08:08right, I mean, do you experience that? Oh yeah, it
- 1:08:10gets incredibly simplistic. I mean that also, you know, I think I
- 1:08:15see it as people enter into the queer community thinking it's going to be better
- 1:08:19than the outside community, and it's kind of a bumber to learn that it's
- 1:08:24just the same. Or I had clients say that to me this week.
- 1:08:28I converted to Judaism, thinking this would be the best thing ever, and
- 1:08:32it's oh god, well, right, because of the way it's often talked
- 1:08:38about, Right, because any dominant culture, especially if they're oppressive, is
- 1:08:45seen as all bad, All Christians are bad, and all non Christians are
- 1:08:49good. All you know, white people are bad, all people of color
- 1:08:54are good, and that is just so silly. It's just so silly.
- 1:09:00Should we fight against the oppressor? Yes? And also I think maybe for
- 1:09:06some folks when they learn about the Nashville shooting, it might open up a
- 1:09:11door. If you already have compassion for trans people and they're the oppression that
- 1:09:15they experience and you can relate to that, that could open a door of
- 1:09:19being able to relate to a lot of people that have done very heinous things
- 1:09:24well. And also as therapists, this was always the interesting part of training
- 1:09:28young therapists as they were Often it got coated and said in many different ways,
- 1:09:32but it often young therapists would basically be saying, I only want to
- 1:09:36work with the good people. And what's really rough about being a therapist is
- 1:09:42we don't need many therapists for the quote just good people. You know,
- 1:09:46you will be treating sex offenders and murderers and people who think wildly different thoughts
- 1:09:53than you do. And it's our training allows us to sit with someone who
- 1:09:58has done horrible things and you know, and sim with them, and that
- 1:10:05is part of the training being a therapist. I just I can't tell you
- 1:10:08how many people, how many different ways it gets coded of like I only
- 1:10:13want to work with the nice, good people. I hope to never see
- 1:10:15a bad person in my practice. Well, even if they don't say that
- 1:10:17outright, the thing that I would say in the first quarter to new students
- 1:10:23is half of your clients are going to be Republicans. You know, forty
- 1:10:28percent of your clients are going to be Trump supporters, and you have to
- 1:10:32have compassion and you have to empathize and let them have their political views.
- 1:10:40You can't reject them on the fact that they voted for a different candidate.
- 1:10:45That's not okay. That's against the ethical codes. And if you think that
- 1:10:49you're going to have the freedom to do that, then you're as bad as
- 1:10:53the other side that says they're not going to treat a gay person. That's
- 1:10:56not okay. That's not now. I know there's I'm severe in this,
- 1:11:00but I hear more people that make seemingly convincing arguments that if they did have
- 1:11:05an adamant Truans supporter as a client, that they would be justified in referring
- 1:11:11them out because there would be this inherent rub or conflict that would interfere with
- 1:11:15the treatment process. But to me, and maybe there's some discussion there,
- 1:11:21but I don't think that that's the ideal. I don't think that's what we
- 1:11:25should be shooting for. Sometimes that's necessary, given where a therapist is.
- 1:11:30But I think that people are so much deeper than who they voted for,
- 1:11:33and that's a part of it. But the fact that we look at someone
- 1:11:36and based on who they voted for, we just conclude the top, bottom,
- 1:11:42east, west, north, south of that person, I think is
- 1:11:46part of the problem. You know. Yeah, And I've had I've had
- 1:11:50people in my office that have diametrically opposed views about society. But they're a
- 1:11:58human being that I can relate to and love and care for and help,
- 1:12:03you know, because Republicans get traumatized too. Republicans have grief, Republicans get
- 1:12:12depressed. Republicans are sad, Republicans are hurt. Republicans want love and security
- 1:12:17and meaning in exactly the same way as non Republicans. And that's what I
- 1:12:24help them with, you know. And if you know, six months in
- 1:12:27I start dropping in little liberal brainwashing elements, you know, what are you
- 1:12:31gonna do? That's your program? I'm joking, of course. All right,
- 1:12:38Well, Rebecca, I was I think we talked about this and we'll
- 1:12:43talk about it on the air. I want to have you on the podcast
- 1:12:45more often ready. I think you were suggesting that as well, because there's
- 1:12:53enough There's never enough time. No. In fact, I was prepping last
- 1:12:56night and this morning for today, and I I was like, oh,
- 1:13:00there's so many great emails like there, and I'm sure we're not going to
- 1:13:03have enough time, which of course happened. So and we're going to get
- 1:13:08more emails because of what we talked about. Oh boys, So you know,
- 1:13:13let's let's have you on a little bit more of a regular basis.
- 1:13:15I'm excited. I'm ready to talk more to the interweb. Yeah, about
- 1:13:19my thoughts and feelings and my great stories and your great stories. I mean,
- 1:13:24you know, this is a treat for me because we just riffed me
- 1:13:27too. Yeah. I look forward to it. Yeah, to socialize and
- 1:13:31make a podcast. This was my socialization type. Yeah. I leave the
- 1:13:35house, I get dressed. Yeah, I washed my hair. Oh you
- 1:13:40did? Yeah? Yeah, I like your haircut. Yeah for those I
- 1:13:45got, I had a purple I had some fun purple streaks put in in
- 1:13:49May and we're in October and they were looking crunchy and I just got them
- 1:13:54all cut out. Well, when I first met you, you had short
- 1:13:58hair, yeah, kind of like a long boyish cut. That's the way
- 1:14:01I describe it. I don't know how you describe it. And then over
- 1:14:04time you had shoulder length yeah. And then now you're in the middle.
- 1:14:11Yeah, Well I have a scorpio moon. So you know, I'm never
- 1:14:15going to pick one style and stick with it. I'm just trying to think
- 1:14:17this style. It reminds me since I first saw you when you open the
- 1:14:21door. This is a middle aged bob for sure. I know, you
- 1:14:26know, in my head, I actually kind of thought that because I thought,
- 1:14:28like, is this kind of like what you do at a certain age
- 1:14:31where you're just like, h it's easy. But I think it's different than
- 1:14:35that because it doesn't look easy. Actually, it reminds me of a lot
- 1:14:40of eighties John Hughes if we leave, don't leave, I don't leave now,
- 1:14:45like with Mary Stuart Masterson in some kind of wonderful Yes, or Wilson
- 1:14:55Phillips. You know that sort of chin length bob that kind of goes up
- 1:15:00in the back. And I am rocking a little eighties asymmetrical and it's sort
- 1:15:03of layered. It looks like a little bit, so it's not just a
- 1:15:08give up, Bob, it's a it's a Mary Stewart Masterson, a punk
- 1:15:13drummer who falls in love with Eric Stilts in some kind of wonderful box.
- 1:15:16Thank you, I'll rock that and everyone out there. Enjoy your hair,
- 1:15:23however it looks, and take care of yourself because you're pretty fantastic. We'd
- 1:15:28like you to stick around.