Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 95: Navigating the French: 2022 Presidential Election edition with Emily Monaco
Transcript
- 0:07Timothy to the New Paris, I'm your host Lindsay trim, you do
- 0:12understanding life in France, and the foundation on which
- 0:15identity is based requires an understanding of certain words,
- 0:19themes and ideas words, like tell Hua, Lai City and copper
- 0:24now. And try among countless others.
- 0:27Grasping their complexity is not only important to culture.
- 0:30Integration but to being able to navigate daily life, it's also
- 0:34the focus of a podcast called navigating the French hosted by
- 0:38fellow journalist, Emily. Monaco, she joins me the day
- 0:41after the first round vote for president to discuss the words
- 0:44and ideas worth knowing, in order to make sense of this
- 0:47election, the candidates and how the population feels about both.
- 0:55Emily. Hello, welcome to the show.
- 0:57Hi Lindsay. Thank you so much for having me.
- 1:01Emily, you and I have similar things in common.
- 1:07We both love food, we talked about it, we write about it, we
- 1:11give people tours about it, we both podcast and I was delighted
- 1:17to be on your podcast which is called navigating the French and
- 1:21we talked about Lacey T the first time, which is a
- 1:25Obviously, a very important theme to anybody who's been
- 1:27listening to this show and I think we just recorded another
- 1:32conversation for your, for your show.
- 1:34I'm not sure when that's going to run but that one was super
- 1:36fun. And I love the idea of diving
- 1:39into very specific themes, that end up being part of either
- 1:45daily life or an integral part of life if not daily life when
- 1:50you're living in France. So I think that's just a
- 1:52brilliant idea. Can you talk about why You
- 1:55wanted to approach conversations on life, in France, through that
- 1:59lens. Yeah, absolutely.
- 2:02And I'm so glad that I was able to have you on the podcast twice
- 2:05so far, the second episode I think is going to run in season
- 2:083 so later this spring or early in the summer.
- 2:12But yeah, I navigating the French is about to wrap up its
- 2:17second season and it's a podcast where we examine French culture
- 2:22through one word at a time, with an expert.
- 2:24So, So lazy today. We discussed with you but I
- 2:28think it sort of came from this awareness that I had.
- 2:33And another thing that you and I share in common, of course, is
- 2:35that we both lived here for a really long time and we're both,
- 2:38you know, French were fluent in French or as fluent as one can
- 2:41get as a foreigner. But we spent a lot of time
- 2:44thinking about this language. And I think one thing about
- 2:47French that always interested me, and then about foreign
- 2:49languages in general, is that you it's not a code, right?
- 2:54It's not like that. Of thing where you can say,
- 2:56well, what's the equivalent word for this?
- 2:58And if you rehash your sentence, using French words, it'll come
- 3:01out, meaning the exact same thing as what you intended in
- 3:04English words, might be closed equivalents of one another.
- 3:09And I mean, the, the best example I have, is the word that
- 3:12I used for the very first episode of the podcast, which is
- 3:14Bourgeois module kind of means. Hello.
- 3:17But the French use it in a very different way than we use the
- 3:19word. Hello.
- 3:20In English. So, it's not a really, it's not
- 3:22the perfect translation for, for hello.
- 3:25So I wanted to sort of examine different words in French and
- 3:27see how the way that that word is used and the false
- 3:31equivalencies kind of reflected elements of French culture and
- 3:36helped me. And hopefully the listeners get
- 3:38a little bit closer to what to understanding French culture and
- 3:43what makes it so, makes it stand out, I mean I'm Americans before
- 3:46American culture but also I've had Canadians and Brits and and
- 3:50French people on the show. So what makes it stand out, what
- 3:53makes it special and how we can see that through one.
- 3:55At a time and the other thing is that you know they're very
- 3:58specific periods of time or moments where certain words are
- 4:04used more than others and and given that we are literally the
- 4:08day after the first round of the presidential election where we
- 4:13have learned that it will be to no true surprise.
- 4:18But at the same time I think there was a little bit of hope
- 4:21that something else would happen.
- 4:23So so we will Be in two weeks time, it will be the incumbent
- 4:29Mac home against Mountain Lupin, who continues to rise ahead,
- 4:34given everything we would hope about humanity.
- 4:37And, and there are very specific words around this experience
- 4:41around the, the campaigning around the vote and around what
- 4:47needs to happen. Now in the run-up to the second
- 4:49vote. Can you talk about if there are
- 4:52particular ways in your opinion that the French Express
- 4:55themselves during periods. Like this.
- 5:00I can think of a certain number of words that were very common
- 5:03in there in the recent weeks. But you know what Springs to
- 5:07mind? Yeah, I mean, I think my, my
- 5:10first instinct when you asked me that question, is that at the
- 5:14risk of being reductive or overly generalistic, which is
- 5:18what we're always trying to strike that balance, right as
- 5:20journalists of trying to explain something without explaining it
- 5:22into the ground. The fact is that the French have
- 5:28these double level double-headed elections, where we have a first
- 5:31round, where you can have a phenomenal number of candidates.
- 5:34Usually something like 10, and it allows people to express
- 5:39their true feelings before they end up voting for, you know, in
- 5:43scare quotes the lesser of two evils.
- 5:45Which I think as an American, you know, when we look at our
- 5:48elections, you if you belong to a party, you vote within your
- 5:51party. But when you go out to vote for
- 5:53the president, You might not adhere to the entire platform of
- 6:01the candidate that you're going to vote for.
- 6:02But often you're voting to keep the other guy out.
- 6:06I think that that's something that we hear Americans say a lot
- 6:09when they go out to vote is like, well, I don't love him but
- 6:13or I don't love her but, you know, this is who I'm going to
- 6:15vote for. Whereas in the France, I feel in
- 6:18France. I feel as though the French
- 6:20really do vote with their hearts first and with their heads in
- 6:24the second round. And and so I think that you get
- 6:27people like I was actually walking I was the other day I
- 6:33yesterday or to deny was two days ago saying walking behind
- 6:37this guy going into my building saying that you know if it came
- 6:40down to if it came down to you know to specific candidate.
- 6:48So if it came down to Le Pen the far, right candidate, who is
- 6:51going into the second round and made all show, who is the far
- 6:53left candidate? Who was kind of Third place.
- 6:55And there was a possibility that he was going to make it instead
- 6:59into the second round. He said, if it's Le Pen metal
- 7:01show, I won't vote at all in the second round.
- 7:04So I think you have people who are a little extreme in their
- 7:10worldview and then obviously, we have, you know, people who are
- 7:14willing to vote with their head in the second round and I think
- 7:16we're going to probably chat a little bit more about that.
- 7:20Absolutely. Because there was for those who
- 7:22don't know the I mean this This first round, there were 12
- 7:26candidates which, I mean, I understand the the ability to
- 7:33try to or the desire to try to reach people with perhaps a
- 7:37little bit of a fringe ideology or, you know, just try to speak
- 7:44to the people who feel really, really left behind.
- 7:46But obviously you know what? 12 candidates you start to, I
- 7:51mean, it's a numbers game. So, you know, quite early on
- 7:54you. How many candidates are just
- 7:56simply not going to even be able to make the 5% required to get
- 8:00their campaign financing sort of subsidized back from the
- 8:05government. You know and today we've learned
- 8:08that the Republicans so historically that was you know
- 8:12sarkozy's party that was represented by Vanity pay cuts
- 8:17who achieved in an incredibly embarrassing amount of votes.
- 8:25You know, she went on TV today to say, you know, well I
- 8:29invested 5 million of my own money, 5 million euros of my own
- 8:33wealth. I'm going to need the population
- 8:35to start. A sort of helped me get a like,
- 8:40raise money. I mean, she was basically
- 8:41calling for people to raise money to help her learn this
- 8:45back which is hilarious and absurd, you know, it's absurd
- 8:49but also the right loves to claim that the left is you know
- 8:52just a bunch of sec. So, that's another word.
- 8:55But basically like looking for handouts, essentially, and here
- 8:58she is basically going, please, please come save me now that
- 9:02I've made a mess of all of this anyway, but one of the big words
- 9:06we were talking about as recently, as yesterday morning,
- 9:10when the polls open was not the polls, but the voting booths
- 9:14opened was this idea of failed Basha as well fell behind Alex
- 9:20from the W. What does that mean?
- 9:22For people who are like? Okay, so you're making a choice.
- 9:25That would have a specific result in order to fail badge.
- 9:29Aw. And it's kind of what?
- 9:30What does that mean? Yeah, so I think the best way to
- 9:33explain this is to put it into the context of the election in
- 9:362002, which is the when we saw in, in a way that was much more
- 9:42shocking than it is this time. I think that there was there, a
- 9:45lot of people were kind of expecting this to happen.
- 9:49You know, we've been seeing fascist leanings across the
- 9:53world in recent. Years.
- 9:55But in 2002, Jean-Marie Jean-Marie Le Pen.
- 9:58Who is the father of mounting, the pain, who is the far right
- 10:02candidate who's going to be running against Mac hole in the
- 10:04elections at the end of the month.
- 10:06So Jean-Marie Le Pen made it into the second round.
- 10:09Along with Jacques Chirac injection, Dyke was sort of the
- 10:14head of the party. That was the ancestors to their
- 10:16hype. You can also the party of
- 10:17Nicolas Sarkozy. So we're basically looking at a
- 10:19far right candidate and a center, right candidate.
- 10:21And so you get lifelong socialist, lifelong.
- 10:24Enter left-leaning people who are faced with a choice.
- 10:28They can either not vote at all, which is what that man was
- 10:31saying, on the phone. When he was walking in my door,
- 10:33you know, if it's, if it's the two extremists, I won't vote at
- 10:35all, or they can fail Bhajan exclaimed W, so they can keep
- 10:41the extreme right from from getting in.
- 10:44And basically, cast a ballot for Jack's.
- 10:46Iraq, who's technically center, right?
- 10:48In order to keep the Jean Marie Le Pen out of office.
- 10:53So we see that again. And, you know, in this round
- 10:56with candidates like an adult ago who was running on the
- 11:01Socialist ticket or Fabian, who said, who was running with the
- 11:03Communists? Who already even before the
- 11:07voting booths open? Yesterday were calling for
- 11:10people to vote for the lesser of two evils end-to-end to fail by
- 11:13Maj. Aw, if they didn't make it into
- 11:15the final round to say, okay, well, if I don't make it, you
- 11:19know what to do, keep the extreme right from coming into
- 11:22office. So right, and Essentially just a
- 11:25word that means or an expression that means like to stand in the
- 11:29way of them or obstruct their progress forward.
- 11:34So stop the yeah, the hassle dribble Master, that'll the
- 11:37far-right party from getting any further.
- 11:40So I mean it's a strategic move, it's a strategic move.
- 11:43I think the word itself from a linguistic standpoint is really
- 11:46interesting because obviously in France we are inheriting the
- 11:52Revolution and not just the revolution of 1789.
- 11:55Fine. But the revolutions, that would
- 11:56come in the 19th century and there is that link between Baja
- 11:59Jean Valley. God, so you saw, for example,
- 12:02false teacher was talking about the Bosch the the Baja genetics
- 12:10found. My genetics came to watch and
- 12:12they were saying, you know, with fists raised want to duvet.
- 12:15So it's this idea of really. Once like the populace actually
- 12:19taking to the streets even though it's not actually in a
- 12:22material sense, what's happening?
- 12:23People are doing it with their vote.
- 12:24Ting ballots. There's no.
- 12:25Actual as far as we know right now revolts taking place or
- 12:30anything like that, but it is the symbolic barricade of.
- 12:35We must not let them pass. Right, right.
- 12:39So that's one strategy. And there were plenty of people
- 12:44who decided to express that by voting for mental shown who's
- 12:48the fox Assamese party, which is essentially I mean some people
- 12:55here, call it the radical left. I don't know that it's really
- 12:57all that radical, you know, for American listeners maybe it's it
- 13:04might approximate a you see in the US but even Are I mean her
- 13:08ideas are more radical because since because all of the social
- 13:12minded ideas and policies, don't really have a comfortable place
- 13:17in the discourse in the u.s. Whereas here, it's still part of
- 13:21the language. I mean as one of my previous
- 13:23guests reminded me during a conversation, we had about about
- 13:27politics here, not even my little pen.
- 13:29Is someone who's willing to challenge the?
- 13:32The Securities was Seattle. The the Healthcare System.
- 13:36You know. The idea is not to To question,
- 13:39whether it has a right to exist, this nationalized health care
- 13:42and that's something that is still very social, you know,
- 13:46even even coming from right minded.
- 13:50Politicians. So, all that to say the idea was
- 13:54okay. The if you're going to vote
- 13:57strategically and you're going to fail Bosch, Onyx, come to
- 13:59Lots. Ideally we want Metal Show,
- 14:02Who's, Who was already pulling third, and who had the best
- 14:06chances of actually making it through.
- 14:09We need to help him, we need to help him along.
- 14:11So instead of using your vote to vote for, let's say the green
- 14:14candidate or sadly, the Socialist, which the the
- 14:19Fractures in the Socialist Party are at this point.
- 14:22Absolutely caricature. I'll, I mean, they're they're
- 14:26they're the laughable there. It's embarrassing, right?
- 14:31So here we had this odd, this opportunity to get this guy in
- 14:34and that's what we were hoping to do now.
- 14:35Obviously it did not end up working but he did get closer
- 14:38than ever. There are other ways.
- 14:41People are speaking, though about what happens next, there's
- 14:44what they belong and then there's not voting at all so for
- 14:47those listening who aren't sure what the The blonde is, what is
- 14:51it? Yeah.
- 14:52So what Brian is basically, one of three things that can happen
- 14:57if you don't vote. So there's you can abstain from
- 15:02voting at all you can vote. Or then there's this idea of a
- 15:06vote, nuala, and the front and the French government recognizes
- 15:10those three things, as three completely different statuses.
- 15:12So a vet nude is the easiest to explain because it's usually an
- 15:16accident. So a good noodle is kind of what
- 15:19happened. The hanging Chads back in
- 15:21America. It's something is wrong with
- 15:22your ballot. That means that we can't count
- 15:24it, for whatever reason. So it's usually an accident.
- 15:28It's not something that people do on purpose, but an abstention
- 15:31is not showing up at the polls at all.
- 15:33It's refusing to vote. But blonde is where you actually
- 15:36do show up at the pole. At not the polls at the voting
- 15:39booth, you make a decision to choose, no one.
- 15:44So you write in someone else who's not running you, right?
- 15:49It in a joke, you right in nothing.
- 15:52But you go in. Basically, to Lodge your
- 15:55discontent in a way, that is material.
- 15:58And that is counted. Actually, since 2014 the Vets
- 16:03Brunel. So if you go in and you Lodge a
- 16:04vote for someone who's not running or you otherwise you
- 16:08know you put, you lead your envelope, empty, you put in a
- 16:10blank piece of paper those votes.
- 16:13Since the 21st of February 22 2014 are counted separately from
- 16:19the accident. Until vote Noodle and it's
- 16:21recognized as an act situation. So as Citizens act that is
- 16:26distinguished from abstention. So not showing up at all because
- 16:30the elector decided to come to the voting booth stand in line
- 16:36and formally Lodge his or her disc intact discontent.
- 16:40And so basically to show that he or she refuses to choose among
- 16:44the candidates that are on offer and what Did we see this time?
- 16:50I mean, obviously, this isn't the end of the the election, but
- 16:53it was still fairly High absenteeism, but I don't recall
- 16:58much discussion around. How many people actually voted
- 17:01blown. Yeah, I haven't heard much
- 17:03discussion about that either. I do know that that in the, in
- 17:09the days, leading up to the elections, when journalists were
- 17:14interviewing people about their intentions, the guardian
- 17:18actually published a really interesting.
- 17:19Piece about how people working class, French people, especially
- 17:25in rural areas, were basically, there's a man who's quoted in
- 17:31this article as saying the poor so disgusted, that they don't
- 17:33even vote. So the rich Walter all, turn out
- 17:35to vote and the poor, so discuss it, they don't even vote.
- 17:37So that there was an intention to abstain.
- 17:41I'm not sure. I haven't seen enough sort of
- 17:44discussion about what the actual, but blonde versus
- 17:47abstention rates were this year. But I know that a lot of people
- 17:50were unhappy with the choices that they were given.
- 17:53And I think that that's something that we do see
- 17:57frequently, I don't think it's Unique to France and I don't
- 17:59think it's Unique to this year, but I do think that people are
- 18:03kind of at, they're at their wit's end and they don't really
- 18:06they aren't happy with the choices that are being presented
- 18:08to them. So that that leaves us in a
- 18:12really tough spot, because now comes the ultimate
- 18:16decision-making time, we have two weeks Before the last
- 18:21election or the last vote where we need to, you know we're back
- 18:24home is going to really have to try to convince us us being the
- 18:28people who have felt that he completely let us down or that
- 18:33he didn't live up to all of his promises but what will happen
- 18:37where will all the metal shown supporters rally together?
- 18:41And just do what needs to be done to prevent repent from
- 18:44getting through and then Focus their attention on the
- 18:47legislative elections in June? Which can really help shift a
- 18:51balance in, in the rest of the government or will they sort of
- 18:58let the whole thing explode? But before we, you know, kind of
- 19:01hypothesis hypothesize on that. There's another angle to all of
- 19:06this. If I think back to the way the
- 19:09American candidates even right up to the end, you know, so
- 19:12obviously there's not a two-round election but you know,
- 19:15when we know who the two candidates are they go on a Very
- 19:20heavy, rotation meeting citizens, going to small towns,
- 19:24going to eat Foods in public. And that also is part of the
- 19:30French experience. If we think about, you know,
- 19:35before this particular vote. So leading up to, you know, this
- 19:38moment there's been a lot of campaigning.
- 19:40All of these individuals have been going around the cut.
- 19:43The the around France trying to meet with with voters and
- 19:47similarly food becomes a topic. Of conversation whether they're
- 19:50eating it or simply discussing it as a sort of metaphor for you
- 19:59know, what voters are really concerned about.
- 20:01So why do the French care about what their politicians eat or
- 20:06don't eat? And is it as simple as wanting
- 20:09to know that they actually know the price of, you know, a quart
- 20:14of milk of a price of a baguette?
- 20:15Like, how similar is that? Just to the interest of
- 20:21Americans who you know might see their their candidate show up to
- 20:26local fairs and eating corn. Dogs and hot dogs, you know.
- 20:28Is there a difference? What is that relationship?
- 20:32I mean I think that the French have always been interested in
- 20:34what their politicians eat and what their people have power
- 20:37eating. Before we can talk about
- 20:38politicians, you know, people were spreading rumors saying,
- 20:41Marie Antoinette in the days leading up to the French
- 20:43Revolution or during the French Revolution was saying, you know,
- 20:47it's people of Paris can't afford bread, let them eat cake
- 20:49which she didn't say. But you know it's allegorical
- 20:53and the fact that they were talking about bread was of
- 20:55course, really important and vital to the French because
- 21:00there was a bread shortage at the time.
- 21:01And the idea of this, you know, High falutin princess queen lady
- 21:06who didn't care what the people that the people of Paris were
- 21:09starving was you know, how it gave created a visceral reaction
- 21:15in in the minds of the French people.
- 21:18I think we still see that today with this idea of highlighting,
- 21:22a disconnect between the people in power and the people on the
- 21:26ground. You know, I think you have you
- 21:31No. In the in the same Guardian
- 21:33piece, you have, you know, people saying that they can't
- 21:38afford to eat that. They can't afford to retire and
- 21:41I know of course that like as to our American listeners, this
- 21:44might sound like less of a big deal than it is in France.
- 21:47But you know, there was a 73 year old man saying that because
- 21:51his pension was so low, he couldn't, he couldn't retire.
- 21:56And obviously, you know, we all know people in their 70s who
- 21:58can't retire in the States but in France.
- 22:00I mean it's just it's It's, it's mind-blowing that there are
- 22:04people who wouldn't be able to retire or people who, you know,
- 22:07as the as the guardian article said had to choose between
- 22:09eating or heating. So, you know, in France, we've
- 22:13always focused a lot on what our politicians eat.
- 22:16And I thank, you know, the one that was kind of anecdotal
- 22:19allegorical at the time and has and has started to feel really,
- 22:22really on point was in 2016 when Charles Voss Channel false, what
- 22:28could be was asked, how much Such a chocolate croissant, upon
- 22:33Shakalaka stand, he said, 10 or 15 cents, which, of course, it
- 22:37doesn't. It's, you know, somewhere closer
- 22:39to a Euro Euro 2000, Euro 50 if you're in Paris.
- 22:43So, I mean, just this fact of like being so out of touch with
- 22:47The costs of things is one piece of the puzzle, but there is
- 22:51another bright, so I don't know. Go ahead, I'm not only thing I
- 22:54was going to say it sounded like you were, you were touching on
- 22:57something that's a bit different, you know, in a way
- 23:00Americans want to see that their politicians, and I'm not saying
- 23:04it would work on all voters. It certainly doesn't work on me,
- 23:08it means nothing to me. But you know for certain
- 23:09populations it does to see you know that a candidate can get
- 23:13down and dirty with a the corn dog or a or a cheese.
- 23:17A can Philly, like, I guess there's an appeal to that,
- 23:20because it makes them feel closer to.
- 23:21These people makes them feel human.
- 23:23It makes them feel like, maybe they could be someone they'd
- 23:26have a beer with and that ultimately, how convincingly
- 23:29they're able to go through those motions, says, a lot to voters,
- 23:33I guess about, you know, how much maybe that candidate is
- 23:37willing to try to identify with them, but here, it doesn't seem
- 23:40as much. An issue of relatability in in
- 23:44in, in consumption. Habits, but really just you at
- 23:48least need to know what the cost of of living a feeding ourselves
- 23:56actually is for the, for the majority of the population.
- 23:58And less like, okay, fine, maybe you have caviar on your weekends
- 24:01but you know, you should at least know what the cost of a
- 24:04Powershell code. I is, I don't know if there's
- 24:07something there like that the the relationship or the the goal
- 24:12in. Connecting our politicians to
- 24:14food is perhaps slightly. Lee different.
- 24:19It is slightly different, and yet that down and dirty, kind of
- 24:23fair aspect of it does definitely reveal itself with a
- 24:28big event, a big trade show that we have, in Paris in February,
- 24:31which is the settled settled. Agriculture.
- 24:33Also, the agricultural trade, show of which Jacques Chirac was
- 24:39very notably the champion. I mean, he Jacques Chirac, I
- 24:42think as someone who was on the center, right?
- 24:47Right. Managed to be this kind of, or
- 24:49to, or to display, this kind of affability through his
- 24:54discourse. Despite the fact that he and
- 24:57his, he, you know, he was married to a woman or to
- 25:00Bernadette shock and they still use Drew with each other.
- 25:04So, the formal you. So they did have this sort of
- 25:07pointy, toity upper-class feel about them, but he would show up
- 25:11every year from 1972 to 2011. Chirac was this Link between
- 25:19Parisian politicians and the people of France outside of
- 25:24Paris. Because I think politicians tend
- 25:26to for anyone living in the countryside politicians often
- 25:30seem like they're Parisian wherever they went.
- 25:33They did end up starting from. And so having, you know, the
- 25:39mayor or the president of the mayor of Paris, the mayor of the
- 25:43Parisian suburbs or the president of France show up at
- 25:46this, Trade show and eat Ted davalloo and drink, you know,
- 25:51red wine and say, yes, I'll try your Associates on.
- 25:53Yes, I want to pet the head of your sheep.
- 25:56It showed him as someone that they maybe could have a beer
- 25:59with. Whereas, and it was sort of a,
- 26:03there was a huge discrepancy between his appearances and that
- 26:07of Meeting Hall, who never showed up, and never thought it
- 26:13was important, and he very much incarnated.
- 26:15I mean, you said caviar, he very much Incarnated the sort of idea
- 26:18of the, you know, gauche caviar and the, the halving, the
- 26:24distance, from the people of Paris or France.
- 26:27Rather in refusing to show up at the at the sun on.
- 26:33Thank a future. Now what I think is interesting
- 26:36obviously is that like it what I mean before Chirac?
- 26:40I don't think anybody necessarily looked at someone's
- 26:43longevity at the salon by kikuchiyo and thought you know
- 26:47Know if he's if he lasts for a long time, he's going to win.
- 26:50But then you have someone like Matt Cole who comes into Power
- 26:54after someone like not right after.
- 26:57But after I mean we had some interstitial folks.
- 27:00But Nicolas Sarkozy notably sort of was distant from that sure, a
- 27:05key and you know Gusto of eating and and and love of French
- 27:10products. And and then you in my call
- 27:13while, we don't really know what he eats on a personal level.
- 27:17Um, and I would argue that, we don't really know what schirach
- 27:20ate at home either, we can assume.
- 27:23But you know, his Chef sort of seems to think that we had a
- 27:26different idea of what he really ate.
- 27:28Then what was true at home but not cool, despite not
- 27:32communicating heavily on what he actually eats at home.
- 27:34Did spend 14 hours at the 2019, so I don't like it.
- 27:40She also, he understood how important it was for him to show
- 27:43up and for him to be present among the Farmers and producers,
- 27:49and all of the food adjacent Professionals in Paris who were
- 27:54at that trade show, and did he go to the one that we just had
- 27:58in February? Which was obviously the first
- 28:01one since covid. That's a really good question
- 28:03and I actually don't, I don't remember them.
- 28:05Communicating very heavily on it?
- 28:07Well, I think unfortunately, it came at a time when there were a
- 28:11slew of other, right? Emergencies, however, I mean, I
- 28:15think I do remember seeing that he Dropped by but it wasn't
- 28:18necessarily a lengthy stay. But you're right.
- 28:21I kind of forgot about that being an opportunity for for
- 28:26like a meet-and-greet of sorts and still being important.
- 28:29I think ultimately, as we've seen, if we can say anything
- 28:33about Mac home that is neither positive nor negative.
- 28:38He, he basically in coming in and winning on his own party,
- 28:43you know, that wasn't traditionally left or right, or
- 28:46at least not with In those established parties, he exploded
- 28:50the entire landscape and now even even the results of last
- 28:55night show and just how poor the right and socialist left
- 29:00performed highlight just how fractured those two historic
- 29:04parties are and you know and he really did shake things up which
- 29:08I guess in one way could be looked at as interesting you
- 29:11know those parties need to. So who met on kissed him as the
- 29:15French love to say which is basically Now, take a step back
- 29:18and do some self-reflecting. But, but but, you know, we're in
- 29:23this interesting time now where none of the behaviors or
- 29:29gestures or Traditions seem to hold the same weight, right?
- 29:34So I wonder moving forward. What will candidates have to do
- 29:38to reach people? What will they need to do to
- 29:41actually connect with with the voters?
- 29:43Because, you know, essentially everyone feels isolated to a
- 29:46degree Right. The young people, the students
- 29:48feel isolated, they don't feel like anyone's actually taking
- 29:51their interests to heart with the exception of perhaps mental
- 29:55shown because he wanted to do away with some highly
- 29:59problematic structures that exist for higher education.
- 30:02And that's a, you know, again another episode.
- 30:05But you know, everyone seems that there's no one who's
- 30:09speaking to them which, you know, leads us to a perhaps a
- 30:12greater State of similarity with the US and maybe even the UK.
- 30:20So, if there is one thing that that remains different, it is
- 30:24perhaps the emphasis placed on, you know, specifically between
- 30:29the u.s. and France, the difference placed on a Getti and
- 30:33me back T. So freedom and equality,
- 30:36Freedom, being the operative word in the US, and equality
- 30:40being the goal in France, both, you know, were And on those
- 30:46enlightenment-era philosophies and I think both of them have
- 30:53been, you know, kind of thrown up in the air and are being
- 30:56questioned with every single election that we have, whether
- 31:00it's the midterms, whether it's local elections, or whether it's
- 31:02presidential elections, so what do you see?
- 31:06I mean, I'm assuming you see that as a kind of primary
- 31:09difference between the two cultures.
- 31:10But how does that get communicated during the
- 31:12election? How is equality?
- 31:16Used as a platform. Yeah, I think, I think that
- 31:22sometimes it's really subtle which is really interesting.
- 31:26I think that what I notice a lot in the communication of multiple
- 31:32candidates be they left or right extreme extreme.
- 31:36I mean, far, far, reaching or more Center leaning, they do
- 31:41tend to represent themselves as being the inheritors of the
- 31:48Revolution or Revolutions. So I think that perhaps more
- 31:54than American political parties are willing to ascribe to the
- 32:00revolution, as being something to which we have, which we
- 32:03inherit the values. I mean, with the exception of
- 32:06maybe, you know, certain right-wing parties in the
- 32:10state's. I think that almost all of the
- 32:13part of the politicians in France believed themselves to be
- 32:18the inheritors. As of this of the Revolution and
- 32:21the revolution of course is, you know, it is a popular uprising.
- 32:27Of course it is, you know, built on the backs of the working
- 32:31class or, you know, before it's pre working class, you know,
- 32:34built on the backs of the Tails. It's at absolutely.
- 32:37But I think that there is a, there are certain
- 32:40enlightenment-era philosophies that wouldn't have that without
- 32:43which neither the American nor the French Revolution would have
- 32:46been possible and I think we do see equality and Liberty,
- 32:52equality and freedom being highlighted, you know, in both
- 32:55countries but I think there's some interesting analysis to be
- 33:03found. In Alexis de tocqueville, who is
- 33:05a French philosopher, writer, who observes American society
- 33:10quite closely in the in the time.
- 33:14Immediately following the Revolution and kind of, Is
- 33:21looking at quality and Liberty and saying, yes.
- 33:23Obviously we all want both, but if you had to choose, which one
- 33:30would you pick? And I think that it's quite
- 33:33clear to me in the absence of social social structures in
- 33:36America, for example, in the sort of self first, kind of
- 33:43mentality in the way in which we govern.
- 33:45But also the way that our society functions that we have
- 33:48chosen Freedom. First, you know, even here it
- 33:50would. Kids like it's a free country.
- 33:52You know. I can do what I want.
- 33:53Everybody has internalized, this idea of freedom.
- 33:56And France is also a free country, but we think the
- 34:01quality is more important and tocqueville actually says, you
- 34:05know, that that people want equality in Liberty, but if they
- 34:09cannot have both, they would still want equality in slavery,
- 34:14and they would suffer poverty, and they would suffer servitude
- 34:17and they would suffer barbarism, but they will not suffer. /
- 34:21aristocracy now aristocracy, of course, is the Counterpoint to
- 34:25equality at the time that he's writing.
- 34:27But I think that that's sort of what we see now and maybe what
- 34:30makes that what makes what you were saying about the, you know,
- 34:36asking the people for the five for the five million back, what
- 34:40makes it so much more abhorrent to us in France?
- 34:43As it might, I mean, it already wouldn't go over very well in
- 34:46the u.s. I don't think either, but but we
- 34:49have this This desire for equality, equality first, and
- 34:54for and maybe not to be told that we can be that we as people
- 34:58in France can be pulled up to the ranks of the elite, but
- 35:01rather that the elite is willing to sacrifice its own Elite - to
- 35:07be on the ground with us and to resonate with what matters to
- 35:12the people in France. And I think it always kind of
- 35:15feels to me as though, American politicians are pandering to the
- 35:17elite be, they left leaning a right-leaning which we saw Saw
- 35:20change a little bit with Donald Trump.
- 35:22Kind of, will it being willing to communicate to the working
- 35:28class and to end to end to showing Lee seeing that he was
- 35:33empathizing with their struggles.
- 35:35Whereas French politicians, always seemed to me to be quite
- 35:37aware, no matter where they fall on the political spectrum of the
- 35:41inherited history of a revolution wrought by the the
- 35:45TLC. Tha Well, yeah, that certainly I
- 35:48mean that's that's why there's religion, protests were handed
- 35:52handled with. I'm not saying the, the cia's
- 35:55police, handled it gingerly, but on a, on a governmental level,
- 36:02you know, in the easy, they were very careful, not to squash
- 36:07anything without actually having a conversation.
- 36:09I mean, I'm not saying it wasn't heated and it wasn't ugly but
- 36:13there's a real threat. You don't just Down protest,
- 36:17when it's part of the foundation of a society and what people
- 36:21have been granted as a means of expressing themselves.
- 36:26So, you know, I do think that some of what we've seen here in
- 36:30some of even the decisions with, you know, walking back, certain
- 36:36covid, measures and restrictions and you know, how hard do we go
- 36:41against people for not following rules.
- 36:42All of this seems like a little bit of walking on eggshells.
- 36:46Shells. Because there is a real fear
- 36:48that at some point there will be another Revolution and people
- 36:52are going to rise up and say enough is enough.
- 36:54And I think unfortunately unfortunately unfortunately for
- 37:00his own Camp Mac home has a level of arrogance and sense of
- 37:06self-importance that has really I guess blinded him to how
- 37:14important it was. To not lose a connection with
- 37:20the people who are willing to give him a chance, you know,
- 37:22back in 2017. The people who thought, okay,
- 37:25you're not perfect, you may end up being just, you know, a
- 37:30candidate of the of the wealthy. You're just a business guy and
- 37:34you know, in a lot of ways, he was really great.
- 37:37Has been good for small business.
- 37:39I have plenty of friends and I'm sure you do too who run small
- 37:42businesses here and you know they feel like they're back into
- 37:45a corner when it comes to. The labor labor laws and the the
- 37:49expense of hiring and getting rid of people and you know, it's
- 37:52one thing, when you're a big Corporation, it's another when
- 37:54you're a, you know, sort of mom and pop business.
- 37:58But but I do feel that we're in this position where that that,
- 38:02you know, he let down a lot of people the the the options we
- 38:08have as voters has been very underwhelming and it seems like
- 38:15the same face is coming back. Also, I mean, the ones who end
- 38:17up anyway, leading leading in the polls and, and it just sort
- 38:21of feels like, you know, something something big is
- 38:24around the around the corner, so I think you've touched on
- 38:28something. That's very true.
- 38:29And very different about the way, the two countries approach.
- 38:33Not just the political space, but the way that they live their
- 38:36lives and what they expect. Now, obviously, there's a big
- 38:40fight. If there's continuing fights for
- 38:41equality in France, this is, this is not something they've
- 38:45achieved much like, Freedom in America is really a question of
- 38:49opinion and perspective, but I, but I think you nailed something
- 38:53there. Just before we end, I'm curious
- 38:57as to, you know, what your thoughts are moving forward in
- 39:00the next two weeks, we're going to hear a lot more in the way of
- 39:03vocabulary election. Vocabulary, political
- 39:05vocabulary. What would you like, people who
- 39:08are listening to know about? I guess what's at stake and and
- 39:15you know, if you were to answer one of the questions that I've
- 39:17been getting already in the last 24 hours, which is how could
- 39:21people on the left, you know? Superb seemingly Progressive
- 39:26individuals. Even dare vote for someone on
- 39:31the extreme, right, what does that mean?
- 39:34I think that it it's obviously not the same and this is this is
- 39:41obviously just reducing things down to practice brass tacks,
- 39:44but I think that there's something.
- 39:47There's something a anti-establishment that appeals
- 39:51to certain people about Marine Le Pen that is, you know, you
- 39:55know, I think that the French are very good at expressing
- 39:58their discontent, right? So we haven't had a sitting
- 40:02president be re-elected in, what two?
- 40:05So your people are unhappy with the way that he's handled
- 40:10certain things and I agree with you that he he made a lot of
- 40:13promises, some of which he managed to keep specifically
- 40:17when it comes to small businesses or even to, to
- 40:21individual Mac. While I'm speaking of course,
- 40:23that that when it comes to people who are self-employed
- 40:27people who wanted to change careers, you know, that's
- 40:30something that requires a lot of red tape and time in France and
- 40:34he A lot of that, that may, it made it easier for people to
- 40:39make changes and for people to progress and grow.
- 40:43But I think that there are some people who are very unhappy with
- 40:47the way that he handled things. They think that he pandered to
- 40:51much too big business, they think that and you're right that
- 40:56these fights for equality or of course, you know, it's equality
- 40:59is a constant thought in our heads, but what equality
- 41:02actually looks like is a moving Target.
- 41:05And there are a lot of people who are feeling, as though,
- 41:07their rights towards freedom, and equality are being
- 41:10completely overlooked. And I can see how there might be
- 41:15something appealing about someone who is so far off of the
- 41:19center and so far off of the norm that that makes them
- 41:22gravitate towards promises. You know that, obviously, you
- 41:28know, everything is an empty promise until it's been
- 41:30fulfilled. I think there was a there was a
- 41:34senior Hello at Politico. Me drammen who wrote that
- 41:38there's the sort of it feels as though, there's a new binary
- 41:40right now. That feels more, European
- 41:44Progressive globalization versus populist, identitarian
- 41:49nationalism and maybe for as much as the French, fear
- 41:55communities, men like the formation of small groups,
- 41:58within a whole there might be something that feels a little
- 42:02bit reassuring to Rally. be behind someone who is
- 42:07Nationalist and, and purports to be populist and purports to have
- 42:11the the The concerns of the working class at heart.
- 42:18I mean, I think that's what we saw when we saw the splintering
- 42:21of an exam water versus amounting to Penn who were to,
- 42:25you know, right-wing candidates running ostensibly on similar
- 42:29platforms. But you know, we saw a massive
- 42:31splintering with they're dealing of Russia and and the right end
- 42:36and the concerns of a broad versus the concerns of right
- 42:39here. So I think maybe some people are
- 42:42feeling resonant with the with the fact that Marine Le Pen is
- 42:45Promising to pay attention to what's going on in France.
- 42:49And that might be what's attracting them to her, but I
- 42:52think this is going to be a case of people really needing to
- 42:58examine again. It's a really hard thing to have
- 43:03to do and I don't envy people who've been phone hoop and
- 43:06voting to the left their whole Lives who in 2002 already had to
- 43:10make the robots and and vote for.
- 43:14Center, right, candidate. And even though amended McCoy is
- 43:17positioning himself as a center candidate, I think the consensus
- 43:20is, you know, at least among Centrist.
- 43:23I mean, Anna delgo is one of them.
- 43:25Although she is more center-left, that he is more on
- 43:28the right than he is in the center.
- 43:31You know, to have to vote for someone who they perceive to be
- 43:33center. Right?
- 43:34Must be hard, but that is kind of what is what's at stake right
- 43:38now? Is is a center or center, right?
- 43:42Candidate versus an extreme, right candidate and And and, you
- 43:46know, I would say that voters do have other means of making
- 43:50themselves heard in, trying to shift the balance if they can,
- 43:55you know, what they say, hold their noses, which is what the
- 43:59suppose say to me and you know, just go forward and vote for Mac
- 44:03hole in the next round and make sure they're active and actually
- 44:06rallying people to get out there and vote properly.
- 44:09During the legislative election in June because this is the
- 44:11other issue. People get very upset, they feel
- 44:14defeated. And then, where are they during
- 44:16the summer vacation, when there's a another type of
- 44:18election, you know, you have to look at the numbers of people
- 44:22who abstain or aren't paying attention during another type of
- 44:26election that can mean something and can can help shift the
- 44:30balance. And we see that even the, in the
- 44:32US with people who don't vote in local elections or Municipal
- 44:35elections, when those are some of the most important because it
- 44:38will affect not only, will it affect, you know, passing policy
- 44:43or, or You know, vetoing certain propositions but you don't want
- 44:48to very, very local level. That's how you get to have a say
- 44:51in what happens in your immediate surroundings.
- 44:55So and also I don't know about you but in this in the in the 16
- 44:58years I've been here I've never seen more people, people who
- 45:04aren't necessarily, you know very visible on the Internet or
- 45:10you know they're not necessarily calling themselves activists but
- 45:13who are engaging in quite a lot of activism and I've seen that
- 45:17you know certainly with the the anti anti racism movement of the
- 45:22last two years. Certainly you know people have
- 45:25been coming together and and speaking up more easily and more
- 45:29freely and and I will say that these people are not going to
- 45:32give up just because you know, the the wealthy arrogant white
- 45:37dude is still in office. You know, I won't lie but I
- 45:41under but like you said, I understand where this feeling is
- 45:44coming. From the frustration.
- 45:45And but again, I'd like, you know, to any of those people
- 45:50listening who, you know, are feeling sympathy for this
- 45:55situation. I would also say like look a lot
- 45:59of us came together and voted for Biden.
- 46:01When he was not our ideal candidate but there are just
- 46:04certain things you have to do to.
- 46:09I don't know. Hope that the system doesn't
- 46:11completely crush and crumble and leave us in a A state that's
- 46:15even harder to put back together because I think that's
- 46:17ultimately what we're seeing with the u.s. is that for years
- 46:21of one God awful person can can do considerable damage.
- 46:26And I don't know, I mean for sure for some people not cone
- 46:29did consider a considerate considerable damage in their
- 46:33eyes but if you do look at it in a more of a comparison to other
- 46:39countries and in terms of our allies ski full severity Visa
- 46:45Yeah, yeah, but that's very challenging.
- 46:47I get it for people. I mean, it's, it's not that easy
- 46:50but of course, and there's a lot of frustration.
- 46:53There's a lot of anger in France.
- 46:54I mean, there's D-Day Joan movement might not seem as, you
- 46:58know, coordinated or as visible as it has been.
- 47:03But people are still suffering the same problems that they've
- 47:06been complaining about with, you know, that Rising fuel costs and
- 47:11and rising and, and, and salaries, not keeping up with
- 47:14the The rising price of cost of life.
- 47:16And, and people are still upset and angry.
- 47:19And I would agree with you that, you know, it's important to
- 47:22encourage people to come out for for the next elections, for the
- 47:27Municipal elections, for the legislative elections.
- 47:29And just, you know, to remember, as you said that, just because
- 47:33we elect someone that were not thrilled with as a head of state
- 47:38doesn't mean that we are then left with nothing to do for the
- 47:41next five years. And I can tell you exactly.
- 47:43And I can tell you that. No, the fact that the state
- 47:47devoted 0.006 six percent of its total budget to women's rights,
- 47:53which is the smallest since 2005 makes it look real bad on an
- 48:01international stage. So I think I think there are,
- 48:05you know, from what I'm hearing from very reliable sources in
- 48:09the political space of the political journalism, space.
- 48:12Anyway, people who have been very critical of the a
- 48:14government are at least feeding reports to to their you know to
- 48:22me in their friends that he knows that he's royally screwed
- 48:27up and that there are areas where he's really going to need
- 48:32to promise Improvement and actually get there or else he's
- 48:35you know, lost people forever and, you know, for me that's,
- 48:39you know, the women's rights is, is kind of like on on equal
- 48:44footing with The environment because they go hand-in-hand for
- 48:48other people. It's not the issue but he has a
- 48:51lot of work to do and and I think you've given us some
- 48:55language, some insight into what's at play in this in this
- 48:59election period. And Lord knows we're going to
- 49:03need to have a perhaps another conversation.
- 49:05Maybe get people together for a group therapy session after the
- 49:0824th to be determined Emily. What, what can where can people
- 49:14find? Navigating French.
- 49:16So navigating the French is hosted on the Paris on Paris
- 49:19underground radio network, but you can find it wherever you,
- 49:23listen to podcast. We're on Spotify were on Apple
- 49:25podcast where everywhere so it's navigating the French and you
- 49:30can find more from me. I'm on the internet.
- 49:35I tweet. I tweet, I I post things on
- 49:38Instagram. I'm Emily underscore and
- 49:40underscore France. So, come say hi.
- 49:44And that you have a lot more to learn dear listeners about
- 49:50navigating the French and, you know, check Emily out.
- 49:53Listen to the episodes catch up on what you've missed and pretty
- 49:56soon, you'll have an episode for us on work, right?
- 50:00That's what we talked about. We talked about work, culture
- 50:02and vacation, we did talk about work culture, which I think, you
- 50:06know, we talked about vacation, we talked about the French myth
- 50:08of laziness, but we also, as always with you Lindsay, we
- 50:11talked about some of the deeper underlying cultural issues as
- 50:14well. And I'm really excited to share
- 50:16the podcast with our listeners. Well, everyone, sign up.
- 50:19Get it on your podcast list. It's a great show.
- 50:22Emily. Thanks for coming on today to
- 50:24talk about well all this very heavy stuff.
- 50:28Yeah. Well thank you so much for
- 50:29having me and you know keep everybody.
- 50:31I hope everybody's keeping their their chin up and there you
- 50:34know, just we got to get through it kind of looks like, hush all
- 50:39sigh Kosh. Exactly.
- 50:42That's the show for today. As always, thank you for
- 50:45listening subscribing and sharing with Friends, you can
- 50:49find all previous episodes of The New Parish podcast wherever
- 50:52you stream your podcasts and on world radio Paris.
- 50:55If you're enjoying these conversations, please consider
- 50:57picking up a copy of the New Paris book or my recent release
- 51:01for new Keynesian from your local book sellers.
- 51:04Until next time our dentist