Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Investigating Cold Cases" with Peter Barth
Transcript
- 0:04You're listening to a stage talk titled Investigating
- 0:07Coal Cases. This week we were joined by my colleague
- 0:10Bellingcat researcher Peter Barth. Peter spoke
- 0:14about his latest investigation into the death
- 0:16of a Texan oilman and provided invaluable tips
- 0:19for investigating coal case crimes, admitting
- 0:22much of it he'd picked up over the three years
- 0:25he'd looked into this particular case. Sharing
- 0:27his lessons learned. He encourages everyone interested
- 0:31in open source research to have a look at local
- 0:33cold cases, as there are too many to count unsolved.
- 0:37This talk was hosted by me, Charlotte Ma, on
- 0:40Thursday the 3rd of July 2025 in the Bellingcat
- 0:43Discord server. Hi, you're tuning into this week's
- 0:51stage talk. Today we're joined by my fabulous
- 0:54colleague, Peter Bach. On an average day, you
- 0:56might find Peter reporting on environmental issues
- 1:00like the illicit wildlife trade or organized
- 1:03crime groups like the Kinnerheim cartel. But
- 1:06over the last year, he's been taking on something
- 1:09a little different, diving into a murder that
- 1:12took place over 50 years ago. Now, you might
- 1:15argue that cases like this don't necessarily
- 1:17matter, with so much time passing and many of
- 1:19those alive at the time now passed on. But the
- 1:22volume of cold cases that exist is staggering.
- 1:25In the USA alone, the Murder Accountability Project,
- 1:28MAP, counts almost 346 ,000 cold cases of homicide
- 1:33between 1965 and 2023. And this is still likely
- 1:37and undercount since many homicides from the
- 1:40earlier decades are excluded. and not all US
- 1:42police departments report to the FBI Uniform
- 1:45Crime Reporting Program on which this data is
- 1:48based. Online crowdsourcing efforts have also
- 1:51sprung up to tackle cold cases, including groups
- 1:54like Uncovered, with almost 50 ,000 unsolved
- 1:57murder and missing persons cases. All of these
- 2:00cases represent families who are still seeking
- 2:03justice, just like the one that Peter's going
- 2:06to talk about today. Peter's investigation was
- 2:08an exercise in showcasing what can be uncovered
- 2:11with modern investigative techniques. In this
- 2:14session, we'll hear a little of the tale he unraveled
- 2:17and how he unraveled it and talk about why open
- 2:20source techniques can be an incredibly beneficial
- 2:22skill set to have when looking into these cases.
- 2:27We'll discuss what it takes to investigate and
- 2:29what things you might need to look for as an
- 2:31independent researcher. As we talk, please make
- 2:34sure to add your questions in the chat box as
- 2:36I just mentioned. via the message bubble icon
- 2:38in the top right corner of your screen. And please
- 2:41note within your question if you do not want
- 2:43me to read your username out. Okay. Peter, tell
- 2:48us a story of murder, hitmen, and pigeons. Thank
- 2:52you, Charlie. Hello, everybody. Hopefully you
- 2:54can hear me okay. Thanks so much for joining
- 2:57us today. I'm really, really excited to talk
- 3:00about old case research and some of the ways
- 3:03we can use open source to shed light. on unsolved
- 3:06murders. So yeah, without further ado, I'll just
- 3:11kind of launch into it. I'm going to talk a little
- 3:13bit about my story just kind of touch on it here
- 3:15and there. But I mostly wanted to give you guys
- 3:18some tips in case you're interested in looking
- 3:20into cold cases yourselves from the open source
- 3:23side of things. I'll talk about a little bit
- 3:25about some of the lessons I learned in doing
- 3:28that and some of the challenges. And yeah, give
- 3:31you guys some suggestions and then just leave
- 3:33a ton of time open for questions at the end.
- 3:38So basically, I'm going to talk mostly today
- 3:41about unsolved homicides in the US, just because
- 3:45that's what I'm familiar with. That's what my
- 3:46story touched on. And it's a huge, huge issue
- 3:49here. It's obviously a huge issue in other countries
- 3:53as well. So hopefully what I'm talking about
- 3:54in the US still applies to wherever you are.
- 3:57And you can still take some of these open source
- 3:58techniques and adapt them to wherever you are
- 4:01around the world. And yeah, if the screen share
- 4:03hasn't worked, maybe you can pull up my story
- 4:05on the Bell and Cat website, and you'll see a
- 4:08lot of that in there too. So anyway, it'll be
- 4:10focused on the US today, but hopefully some of
- 4:12the same principles apply everywhere else. In
- 4:14the US, this problem is almost unfathomable in
- 4:18terms of scale of unsolved homicides, as Charlie
- 4:21was saying. The best estimates are about 346
- 4:25,000 unsolved cases is one estimate. The most
- 4:27conservative one I heard in the story was 270
- 4:30,000. hundreds of thousands of unsolved murders,
- 4:33which means even more folks, family members,
- 4:39friends of all of these victims who are left
- 4:42with a gaping hole in their lives from losing
- 4:44a loved one. It means that there are potentially
- 4:47tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of
- 4:49killers out there as well. Dead, alive in some
- 4:53cases. So ultimately, this is a huge problem
- 4:56for a whole lot of reasons. It's an accountability
- 4:58issue. It's a public safety issue. And it's a
- 5:02problem that's so big that we don't even really
- 5:06have the data that like fully captures it because
- 5:09murder is typically handled in the US by local,
- 5:12county and state law enforcement. it sometimes
- 5:16will be looked at by the FBI if the killing involves
- 5:19crossing state lines, if it's a prolific serial
- 5:22killer, if it's organized crime related, if there's
- 5:26some kind of federal crime tied to it, they might
- 5:28look at it, but usually it's local authorities
- 5:30investigating. Not all of those local authorities
- 5:32report all of their data to the federal government.
- 5:36It varies state by state. So states like Mississippi
- 5:38are not as great at reporting as some other states.
- 5:42So this is really just sort of a our best guess
- 5:44at the scale of the problem. Yeah, behind each
- 5:48one of these is a story of somebody who was killed
- 5:51and whose case remains a mystery. And it's also
- 5:55a problem because police are usually incredibly
- 6:00under -resourced to deal with this. And the story
- 6:03that I looked at, for example, takes place in
- 6:05a city called Corpus Christi in Texas, right
- 6:06on the coast. It's about 600 ,000 people. Their
- 6:09police department has two detectives who are
- 6:12working a hundred plus unsolved murders part
- 6:16time while they're working on murders that are
- 6:18happening every day right now. So these are detectives
- 6:21who are already struggling to keep up with current
- 6:23homicides and who are already dealing with that.
- 6:26And in any free time they have, they're working
- 6:29on historical cases. And bear in mind that when
- 6:32I say working on historical cases, they usually
- 6:34have a paper file with like old interview notes,
- 6:37old handwritten notes and stuff. And that's all
- 6:39they're working with. These cases often are so
- 6:41old. But the policemen who originally worked
- 6:44them are dead or retired. It's a huge, huge issue.
- 6:49And essentially, with several of the cases that
- 6:52I looked at through this story, the police didn't
- 6:54even know that these cases were still unsolved
- 6:57and that they had them on file. So that's kind
- 6:59of the issue we're talking about here. That's
- 7:02why I encourage anybody and everybody who's interested
- 7:05in this subject to try to join some kind of community,
- 7:08which I'll get into in a bit, and try to research
- 7:10this problem in your local area. because we need
- 7:13more folks working on it. We need more bodies
- 7:15on this problem trying to help with this issue.
- 7:21Okay. Homicides aside, there's also a huge problem
- 7:25with unidentified folks. Some of them are murder
- 7:27victims, some of them died of natural causes,
- 7:30but there are tens of thousands of unidentified
- 7:32bodies and unclaimed remains all over the country.
- 7:36It's a related problem. a lot of them are homicide
- 7:39victims. So you'll look into the, you know, a
- 7:42file of a skeleton found in the woods, for example,
- 7:44I was just doing this and had two bullet holes
- 7:46in the back of the skull, which means this person
- 7:48was murdered and dumped in the woods. And not
- 7:50only do we not know who killed that person and
- 7:52why and all of that, but we don't even know who
- 7:54that person was. It's a whole sort of separate
- 7:58and related issue. But I just I'm mentioning
- 8:01this because we just The scale of the problem
- 8:07is so huge, and not only do we have unsolved
- 8:10murders, we have unidentified victims themselves.
- 8:12We also have tons and tons, tens of thousands
- 8:14of missing folks out there. These problems, a
- 8:16lot of folks who work cold case homicides are
- 8:18also interested in missing persons cases, are
- 8:20also interested in unidentified remains. Okay,
- 8:25so one of the first things, if you're considering
- 8:27looking into cold cases, one of the first things
- 8:29you should ask yourself, and I think... Honestly,
- 8:33one of the most important questions you can ask
- 8:35in the whole course of it is, is the case you're
- 8:37interested in even mentioned online? Is there
- 8:40anything about it online at all? And the Bill
- 8:42Richardson murder that I looked into and wrote
- 8:45about, there was nothing on the open web about
- 8:47it. The only information out there in the public
- 8:50about this murder was in old newspapers, some
- 8:53of which had been digitized. So when I did Google
- 8:56searches for the victim, there was hardly anything
- 8:59at all. And I had to go out there and just collect
- 9:01everything I could. And honestly, my number one
- 9:04goal with the story was to collect anything I
- 9:07could about this victim and about his murder
- 9:08and put it online so that other folks in the
- 9:12community can access it in the future. So that
- 9:14if someone else wants to look into this, they
- 9:16can. And I talked to some folks who basically
- 9:19said, look, even just collecting, organizing
- 9:22and putting this stuff online is a huge help.
- 9:25even for law enforcement because these detectives
- 9:27have paper files and they go online and search
- 9:30for anything just like we would and there might
- 9:32not be any info out there on them. So there's
- 9:35a couple websites that are actually open source
- 9:38focused crowdsourcing efforts out there. They're
- 9:42both nonprofits and just a quick plug for them.
- 9:44Uncovered is one. It's the largest. There's about
- 9:4650 ,000 unsolved murders in the US logged on
- 9:51Uncovered. It's a community effort. It's really,
- 9:54really good for collecting and organizing information
- 9:57on victims. And it's run by a small nonprofit
- 9:59and managed by volunteers. A very similar one
- 10:02to that would be solve the case, which is a lot
- 10:04newer. It was actually created by a homicide
- 10:07detective that I interviewed for my story. And
- 10:10same thing, there's a community of people uploading
- 10:12information about cases and commenting on them
- 10:13and sharing info. So if you're working on this
- 10:16kind of issue, and you're wondering where to
- 10:17get started, start by participating in a community
- 10:20like this. There's Loads of other ones out there
- 10:23as well. There's all kinds of message boards
- 10:25and forums. I'm sure you guys know True Crime
- 10:27is a huge, huge community and world. There's
- 10:31different shades of it, but I would encourage
- 10:32you to kind of join a community if you're just
- 10:36getting started. Also, just a plug, we do have
- 10:40a cold case channel that's pretty new in our
- 10:42own Discord. So definitely join that if you're
- 10:45interested in the topic. There's a few of us
- 10:47in there chatting. I plan to be a lot more involved
- 10:49in there. And this is a topic I care about a
- 10:51lot. So I encourage you guys to join that one.
- 10:54Okay, jumping back in. So let's say you're interested
- 10:56in looking at cold cases from the open source.
- 10:59You need to think about whether the case you're
- 11:00looking at is even possible to research in open
- 11:03source. It's a big question to start with. Let's
- 11:08just start with the basic fact that people commit
- 11:09murder for a whole plethora of different reasons,
- 11:12right? You have sexually motivated crimes like
- 11:15serial killers usually are right where they're
- 11:17going out there and selecting a type of victim
- 11:19and Killing sort of someone who matches the same
- 11:22profile over and over again because of some sort
- 11:25of deep you know, psychological impulse that
- 11:30they can't control. You also have domestic violence,
- 11:32family disputes, disputes over money, robbery
- 11:35has gone wrong. There's all sorts of different
- 11:36reasons folks commit murder. That means that
- 11:40each murder you look at is going to be pretty
- 11:42sort of its own thing, right? They're each going
- 11:45to be unique. They're each going to be different.
- 11:47There are commonalities between them you can
- 11:49work with. But in my case, I happen to be really
- 11:52interested in organized crime, specifically the
- 11:56American mafia and different organized crime
- 11:57groups that have been active here in the U .S.
- 12:00over time. Some of them still are. Some of them
- 12:02aren't anymore. And one of the reasons I looked
- 12:05into Bill Richardson's murder in particular is
- 12:08that I gambled on the fact that it was pretty
- 12:12apparent he'd been killed by professional killers.
- 12:14And so I went off of the assumption that, hey,
- 12:16these people probably killed other folks and
- 12:19they probably have. pretty hefty paper trails
- 12:23through agencies like the FBI who are probably
- 12:26monitoring these people for other crimes. So
- 12:28what I figured was, okay, this is a killing that's
- 12:31probably mob related. I don't know which mob,
- 12:34I don't know who did it exactly yet, but it was
- 12:37so apparently done by professionals, by hitmen,
- 12:40that I figured if I could try to figure out who
- 12:42those hitmen were, I could discover more public
- 12:45records about them and work it from an open source
- 12:47angle. So some murders are going to be easier
- 12:50to cover from open source. Others are going to
- 12:52be extremely difficult, like the unidentified
- 12:55skeleton example I just gave. There's almost
- 12:58no public information out there on that. In order
- 13:01to dig into that, you would have to make information
- 13:04public by requesting police records and things
- 13:07like that. So just consider that when you're
- 13:09starting your case. I will get to the family
- 13:14question. That's really, really good. And we'll
- 13:16get to that. later. So a couple more considerations
- 13:20really quickly. When you're thinking about doing
- 13:22a case, it's important to consider how extensively
- 13:26it was covered originally. Is there maybe just
- 13:28one local media mention of it? Are there multiple
- 13:31newspaper articles? Are there TV reports on it?
- 13:35There's sort of a couple different sides to this.
- 13:39The more coverage you have, the more data points
- 13:41you have to start working with. However, the
- 13:44more coverage you have might mean that folks
- 13:46have already kind of run the public research
- 13:50side of this, the open source side of this to
- 13:53the end, right? So if it's covered extensively
- 13:55and there's a ton of journalists working on it
- 13:57and a ton of people in the true crime community
- 13:59or something who have worked on it and researched
- 14:01it and uploaded everything online, that's one
- 14:03thing. I will tell you guys just anecdotally
- 14:06that I found multiple murders looking into this
- 14:08one unsolved case. I found multiple murders that
- 14:11there was public data out there for, there were
- 14:14newspaper articles about. archival records and
- 14:17things like that, but there was nothing on them
- 14:19online. There's a lot of room to do really important
- 14:25good research here and to contribute towards
- 14:28research into these cold cases. I would just
- 14:32say that it's a huge problem and it doesn't take
- 14:34very long to find cases where you're like, oh
- 14:36my God, there's nothing off of Google about this
- 14:38murder that happened in my town. I have some
- 14:40newspaper articles about it. I should upload
- 14:42this to Uncovered or solve the case or something.
- 14:47Backing up a little bit, each case is going to
- 14:49be completely different, like I said. Is it even
- 14:52going to be possible to cover from a public record's
- 14:54open source angle? If it's someone like a gangster,
- 14:57a mobster, that means that there's going to be
- 14:59a hefty paper trail you can probably work with.
- 15:01It also means if it happened a long time ago
- 15:03that they probably committed, they probably went
- 15:05on to commit other crimes later on, and those
- 15:06might be relevant to the case you're looking
- 15:08at. What data points are public? What can you
- 15:12start to use to research? Do you have the victim's
- 15:14death certificate? Are there names of suspects
- 15:17involved with the murder? Were those suspects
- 15:19cleared already by the police? In my case, one
- 15:21of them was put on trial and acquitted. We found
- 15:25out some more information about him that actually
- 15:27turns out to be pretty incriminating. But yeah,
- 15:30it's something to consider. Did the police even
- 15:33reveal that many details about the death? In
- 15:36a lot of cases, they might withhold a lot of
- 15:38information, a lot of the details of how the
- 15:40person was killed, how the body was found, where
- 15:43it was found. they oftentimes strategically withhold
- 15:45that information so that it doesn't interfere
- 15:48with their investigation and so that if they
- 15:50get things like witness statements later on,
- 15:52they can corroborate it with information that
- 15:54kept secret. So it depends on how much information
- 15:57was released about the murder, how much has been
- 15:58reported, that sort of thing. A really key thing
- 16:02is were suspects named or not? Are they still
- 16:04alive or not? That's a huge question. Another,
- 16:09this is a little bit more, if you're doing a
- 16:10traditional journalist approach, where you'd
- 16:12be going and interviewing family members, which
- 16:14I'll talk about more later. And I saw we have
- 16:15some questions about. But if you're looking strictly
- 16:19from an open source side, are there family members,
- 16:22say, who've created a Facebook group for their
- 16:24loved one? Oftentimes with a cold case murder,
- 16:26there'll be a Facebook group with members of
- 16:28the local community that's open and you can see
- 16:30people. posting news articles about it, leaving
- 16:33comments, posting information about their family
- 16:35member, posting photos. There is a lot of that
- 16:38online around this topic. So. Other factor factor
- 16:42to consider, and then lastly, which law enforcement
- 16:44agencies worked the case because that determines
- 16:47where you're going to file your public records
- 16:49requests, which I'm going to focus on in just
- 16:51a second. And Bill Richardson's case, it had
- 16:54been reported a lot. Initially, there were a
- 16:56lot of newspaper articles for me to start with.
- 16:58None of them. were indexed by Google, I had to
- 17:01pay for a newspapers .com account to find this
- 17:05information and kind of unlock it. But there
- 17:08was enough for me to get started on the case
- 17:09where there were suspects named, there was a
- 17:12related murder that was mentioned. So there was
- 17:14some information I could start with and then
- 17:16I just started blasting out FOIAs based on that
- 17:18information that I started with. I also took
- 17:20information from those newspaper articles. went
- 17:23to Ancestry .com and started to use that to pull
- 17:26more. So I was able to get death certificates.
- 17:28I was able to find family members that were still
- 17:32alive that I could try to reach out to. I was
- 17:34able to find a lot of information that helped
- 17:36me dig further on using the combination of newspapers
- 17:39.com and Ancestry. Not an endorsement of them.
- 17:43Those just are the paid tools that I happen to
- 17:45use for this because they're great for US -focused
- 17:47research. Yeah, some key suspects were named.
- 17:51They had extensive criminal careers, which meant
- 17:54that I could file FOIAs with the FBI. I could
- 17:57request records from local and state police.
- 18:00I could map out the course of their criminal
- 18:02career and figure out whether that was relevant
- 18:05to this murder. And then because these guys were
- 18:08dead, the suspects in my case are dead, it made
- 18:11it much, much easier for me to get records from
- 18:15them from the FBI. because I could send them
- 18:18the death certificate and say, this person is
- 18:20deceased. I'm requesting any files related to
- 18:25their criminal history to FBI investigations
- 18:27into this person. And because of privacy laws,
- 18:31they're able to release more if the subject is
- 18:33deceased. OK, so I'll just keep going real quick.
- 18:37You guys all know this already as members of
- 18:39the Bill and Kat Discord, but these are the sort
- 18:41of typical tools we use for our open source work,
- 18:43right? If you're looking into a cold case homicide,
- 18:46it might look something more like this. I was
- 18:49using digitized newspapers, in my case, paid
- 18:51services. There are some freely available out
- 18:53there through libraries. If you're a student
- 18:56or you're a faculty member of a university, that's
- 18:58a nifty way to be able to access digitized newspapers
- 19:01as well. I also used ancestry .com, like I said,
- 19:05to pull some pretty vital information. So certificates,
- 19:09which gave me social security numbers and birthdays
- 19:11and surviving family members. I also did a lot
- 19:14of social media work, honestly, even though this
- 19:16case happened in 1971 before the internet. The
- 19:20survivors and family members are on Facebook,
- 19:23and they tend to be in this case, they were anywhere
- 19:26from in their 50s to their 80s and 90s even,
- 19:28and they were real active on Facebook. So I was
- 19:31able to reach out to some of them for interviews
- 19:34on here. There were people posting information
- 19:38and leaving comments and stuff like that. So
- 19:40social media, even for a case like this that's
- 19:42really old, was still relevant. And lastly, and
- 19:44crucially, FOIAs and public records requests,
- 19:47which I did entirely online. And many of them
- 19:51I did before I even joined Bill and Kat. I just
- 19:55had a completely different job. I wasn't a journalist.
- 19:57I wasn't working in the journalism space. And
- 19:59I was just filing FOIAs because I was interested
- 20:01in learning more about this murder. And because
- 20:04we have public record laws here in the US and
- 20:06in Texas that let me do that. So huge plug, huge
- 20:10plug for Muckrock. If you guys are at all interested
- 20:12in ever filing any kind of FOIA with any agency
- 20:14ever, Muckrock is your place to go. I say that
- 20:18because you can go in there, search for FOIAs
- 20:22that are similar to the ones that you want to
- 20:24file. So I can go in there and search for FOIAs
- 20:27sent to the FBI. And I can find example letters
- 20:30that other people, including journalists, have
- 20:33sent in. And I just use those as a template for
- 20:36my own. So I went in there and I found someone
- 20:38who had requested FBI records related to a mobster.
- 20:42It was a journalist and I took their letter.
- 20:45I changed a couple things around and I sent it
- 20:47into the FBI. And the second I started doing
- 20:50that was the second I started getting better
- 20:52results from FOIAs. So big plug for Muckrock.
- 20:56They're really, really awesome. You can also
- 20:58just file them directly through agency websites
- 21:01like the FBI. But more on that in just a second.
- 21:05Speed up here. What's the muckrock site? We can
- 21:10draw there. Charlie just dropped the link. There
- 21:11you go. Yeah, so I kind of I want to speed through
- 21:15this a little bit. But when we're doing our typical
- 21:17Bellingcat investigations, where we're looking
- 21:19at maybe the social media accounts of someone
- 21:21who's accused of some wrongdoing, right? We're
- 21:24pivoting around using different data points.
- 21:26We're finding a username and an email and a phone
- 21:29number. It's a very similar idea when you're
- 21:31doing this type of research. In my case, I often
- 21:34started with a newspaper article, which would
- 21:36give me the name of somebody, a suspect maybe.
- 21:39I could search for them on ancestry .com, figure
- 21:41out if they were alive or dead, figure out where
- 21:44they lived. So if they were deceased, I usually
- 21:47got a death certificate with a date of birth,
- 21:49surviving family members that I could find on
- 21:51Facebook. And using those points above, I could
- 21:54also file FOIAs. If the suspect was deceased,
- 21:57it meant that I could... Okay, and you know,
- 22:00it sucks. I can't talk to this person. I can't
- 22:01interview them. However, it does mean I can request
- 22:03their records from the FBI or the local police.
- 22:07So okay, just an example of how it worked with
- 22:11in this case, in my story, if you read it, there
- 22:15was a suspected hitman who belonged to something
- 22:17called the Dixie Mafia, this really fascinating,
- 22:21shadowy, extremely violent organized crime group
- 22:23that used to be real active all across the American
- 22:25South and the Midwest. This guy was tied to my
- 22:29murder. He was a suspected getaway driver. He
- 22:31belonged to essentially a team of hitmen who
- 22:34thought to have killed the murder victim in my
- 22:36case. He was murdered himself, it turned out.
- 22:39I figured that out researching. The local police
- 22:41didn't even realize that his case was still unsolved,
- 22:44which was really interesting. I filed a FOIA
- 22:46with them and they responded by saying, basically
- 22:49they acknowledged that they didn't realize that
- 22:52the case was still unsolved and that they were
- 22:53going to treat it as an unsolved case. And they
- 22:55gave me some files related to it, surprisingly.
- 22:59So I pivoted around with different data points.
- 23:02In this case, I ended up using his tattoos. I
- 23:04had his autopsy report. I could see different
- 23:06tattoos he had all over his body. And because
- 23:09he had multiple aliases, he used multiple names,
- 23:12his tattoos ended up being really important because
- 23:14I could match up the tattoos under his autopsy
- 23:18in one name with his prison records, which listed
- 23:21his tattoos under another name. And I could prove
- 23:23that, hey, this is the same guy. Did that all
- 23:26through open source? Yeah, too long. Okay, so
- 23:33the other thing is just search terms, just like
- 23:36you would with any other investigation, right?
- 23:38Increasingly, a lot of older documents, especially
- 23:40things like FBI documents related to mobsters,
- 23:44people with prolific criminal careers, serial
- 23:46killers, things like that. As government documents
- 23:50that have been foiled by other people are released
- 23:52online or even released by the government themselves,
- 23:56search engines are going to start indexing some
- 23:58of the language in there. Even if it's a document
- 24:00that's handwritten, that's been OCR'd, sometimes
- 24:03those terms will show up off a simple Google
- 24:05search. In my case, a huge finding came from
- 24:07the most simple Google search, essentially. I
- 24:13searched a variant of one of the friends of the
- 24:15victim. I searched for a variant of his name
- 24:17and I got a document from the JFK assassination
- 24:19record collection act. It kind of made my stomach
- 24:23churn because I thought like, Oh, boy, I'm getting
- 24:25into JFK territory. I'm not prepared for this.
- 24:28But it ended up being huge because it involved
- 24:31organized crime connections, actually, to the
- 24:34Sicilian -American mafia, because of Nostra.
- 24:37So it was just off a simple Google search, like
- 24:39many of our investigations are. So be creative
- 24:42with your search terms, use every possible combination,
- 24:46spelling variations, use search operators like
- 24:50quotation marks, file type, site. usual stuff
- 24:53that you guys know from our other Bellingcat
- 24:55cases. And then like I said with with FOIAs and
- 24:59public records, use Muckrock, find examples that
- 25:03are similar to the type of FOIA you want to file
- 25:05and file those early, as early as you possibly
- 25:07can. And then get ready to A, have to negotiate
- 25:11a little bit, you'll have a little bit of an
- 25:13email back and forth, right? They'll usually
- 25:16email you and say, like the FBI emailed me and
- 25:19was Hey, we have 12 ,000 pages on this one guy
- 25:22you just requested for. If you want all of those,
- 25:24you have to wait eight years, or we can give
- 25:26you 50 of them in the next two months. Which
- 25:28do you prefer? So I had to learn just off the
- 25:31cuff. I'd never done that before. I had to learn
- 25:32off the cuff how to negotiate with them. And
- 25:35once I did it once, twice, three times, it got
- 25:38much easier each time. I got more confident doing
- 25:40it. And anyway, Muckrock is a good resource for
- 25:44learning how to do that. And you can also just
- 25:46shoot me a message on Discord. I'm happy to help
- 25:48with FOIA questions. I find the whole process
- 25:50really fun, frustrating as well, but also really
- 25:53fun. A couple things to consider. Each state's
- 25:57totally different in the US. For example, in
- 26:00Texas, it's actually easier for me to get autopsy
- 26:02records than it is where I live in Massachusetts.
- 26:04It's a lot harder. They're not considered in
- 26:05the public record up here, unfortunately. So
- 26:08just learn your state's public records laws.
- 26:10Learn how to game it a little bit. There's different
- 26:14tips and tricks for that. There's folks that
- 26:16do really awesome FOIA work online. File it with
- 26:20as many agencies as you can. If you think your
- 26:23murder was looked at by the local police and
- 26:25the county sheriff, then file a public records
- 26:28request with both of them for the same case.
- 26:30Fire them off in the same go. I would just do
- 26:33it in the same morning. Don't be afraid to learn
- 26:36as you go. Don't be afraid to make mistakes.
- 26:39Don't be afraid to reach out to them. I was a
- 26:40little intimidated with my first couple of FOIAs.
- 26:43But these are public record laws for a reason.
- 26:45We're members of the public. We can request these.
- 26:47You're essentially requesting that information
- 26:49be made available to us because we are looking
- 26:52into a public issue, which is unsolved murders.
- 26:55So keep that in mind. Also keep in mind that
- 26:58a lot of these officials actually want to help
- 27:00you. Someone told me that early on and it actually
- 27:03It helped me out a little bit with the process
- 27:05because I kind of assumed that these people wanted
- 27:07to hide every record from me, right? And that
- 27:09they were trying to fight me on these record
- 27:10requests. In some cases, that was a little bit
- 27:12true. But in a lot of cases, the public information
- 27:15officer at the local police department, they're
- 27:17like excited that someone's looking into some
- 27:20case that they don't have time to deal with,
- 27:22right? And maybe they want to strategically release
- 27:24a little bit of information about it. That happened
- 27:26to me in a couple cases. So don't be afraid to
- 27:30head out to negotiate with them. You'll have
- 27:31some email back and forth. It's really common.
- 27:34A lot of people do this. You don't have to be
- 27:35a journalist to file FOIAs. Yeah, 404 Media also
- 27:40has a FOIA workshop. Yeah, thanks for that. 404
- 27:45is really, really awesome for that. And so is
- 27:47Muckrock. Those are my two faves. Okay, just
- 27:50a quick note. A lot of the research happens off
- 27:52of weird, obscure archives. A lot of the coolest
- 27:54stuff that I found that was very relevant to
- 27:57the murder I was looking into. was off of university
- 27:59libraries, was off of special collections at
- 28:02local libraries. They were bits of information
- 28:07available in archives that weren't reachable
- 28:09just from simple Google searches. I had to dig
- 28:11a little deeper, go to the library website, access
- 28:14photo collections, and search in there. They
- 28:16weren't all indexed, essentially. Get creative.
- 28:20Look around. You never know what you'll find.
- 28:21Go to your local library and talk to a reference
- 28:23librarian. Honestly, they're awesome, and they
- 28:25can help you get started, especially if you're
- 28:27looking at local cases. Hyperlocal Facebook groups.
- 28:31Find them if they're out there. Here's an example
- 28:33of this one, old gangster days in Fort Worth
- 28:35for mine. This is populated entirely by the kids
- 28:38and grandkids of the gangsters I was looking
- 28:40at. There are hundreds of family members of these
- 28:42gangsters who are posting photos of them. telling
- 28:44old stories. It's a treasure trove for journalists
- 28:47and crime historians and it's really awesome.
- 28:51And then those crowdsourcing sites I mentioned,
- 28:52that's a good place to start too. Maybe your
- 28:54case is already in there, you can start working
- 28:56from that. Another really good resource, NamUs.
- 29:00This is the national database basically for missing
- 29:04and unidentified people. I just searched my county
- 29:08in Massachusetts right before this. There's 27
- 29:11unidentified remains just in the database alone
- 29:14that I could start searching with. If you're
- 29:17looking at an unidentified murder victim, you
- 29:20can go in here and you can look for similar cases
- 29:23in a similar area. You can look for, you know,
- 29:26maybe victims who meet the same general profile,
- 29:29maybe the same age group, male or female, or
- 29:32you can search by different categories in here,
- 29:35and it's NamUs is a really good place to start
- 29:36as well. There's a couple other in here, and
- 29:39I really just wanted to emphasize One thing which
- 29:42is that if you're trying to get started in this
- 29:44topic and you're interested in it I urge you
- 29:47to look in your local area first And I urge you
- 29:50to dig a bit deeper than just google searches
- 29:53A lot of these murders are not even publicly
- 29:58listed online as I mentioned So get a paid, you
- 30:02know newspapers .com account go to your local
- 30:04library get a university account Ask a friend
- 30:07who has one start searching through your local
- 30:09paper or for terms like murder, Jane Doe. Look
- 30:16in your local area though and I guarantee you,
- 30:18you're going to find unsolved cases. In the couple
- 30:21of towns around me since I started this, I have
- 30:23been honestly appalled at the number and I also
- 30:26just hear people out and about. I heard a woman
- 30:28at breakfast the other day talking about how
- 30:30her mom is the victim of a cold case, actually
- 30:33a mafia related cold case too. So it's not that
- 30:36hard to find these everywhere. These people's
- 30:38family members are often posting on Facebook
- 30:42about it, like urging people to come forward
- 30:44or posting on the anniversary of their death
- 30:46or their birthday. Looking at these cases, we
- 30:49need people working on them, join groups that
- 30:51work on them. If you want to learn more skills
- 30:53about how to do this, how to do it responsibly,
- 30:56how to engage with, you know, family members
- 31:00in some cases are like parts of these groups
- 31:02and they're willing to chat with people you never
- 31:04know. So I'd say if you're just getting started,
- 31:06join a group and look local. Yeah. Okay. I'm
- 31:11going to open it up to questions. We went a little
- 31:13bit over time. Thanks for listening to Yap. The
- 31:15last point I'll say is that with a lot of these
- 31:19cases, especially if there's not much on them
- 31:22off of the Google search, if there's not much
- 31:24on them online, you might be the only person
- 31:27who is looking into that case. There's a really
- 31:29good chance that you will be the only person
- 31:31interested in a given case. So this is important
- 31:34stuff. There are too many of these to deal with
- 31:38and I hope people get out there and start working
- 31:41on them. Even in other countries, this is a huge
- 31:44problem everywhere. So reach out to me on Discord.
- 31:47Here's my Blue Sky account. Open the floor to
- 31:49questions. Thanks so much, Peter, for giving
- 31:52us so many useful tips there. Hopefully, we can
- 31:56find out some more in this discussion. Obviously,
- 32:00we've already dug a little bit into the FOIA
- 32:03requests, but quite a lot of the questions are
- 32:06focused on that. So I just want to Just return
- 32:10back to that conversation while we go. Thank
- 32:12you to everybody who's been popping really useful
- 32:14links in the chat, particularly for non -US based
- 32:19stories. For example, Miss B, thank you for sharing
- 32:22Right to Know that's useful in Australia, Ask
- 32:26the EU, which is useful in the EU, and the IGF
- 32:29.org, which is useful in Canada. Again, if you're
- 32:31listening to this on the podcast, all of these
- 32:34links will be in the description of the podcast,
- 32:35so you don't need to worry about that. And Scoot
- 32:38asked earlier, how long before the FOIA requests
- 32:41were answered? Because that's the big thing when
- 32:43it comes to FOIA requests is the actual length
- 32:46that it takes. And as someone who has filed a
- 32:49lot in her life, being an investigative journalist
- 32:51prior to this job, I know that often when it
- 32:54comes back, a certain word that you've used or
- 33:00a phrasing that you've used might not fit what
- 33:03they have on their side. And therefore you might
- 33:06get a rejection and that is gutting after you've
- 33:08waited months, maybe a year to get a response
- 33:11to then be rejected and not get the data you're
- 33:14looking for. So how long did it take you to get
- 33:17your data back? And did you have any instances
- 33:19like that where you realized that you weren't
- 33:22using the right legal speak or the right phrasing
- 33:25that you should have been to get the data that
- 33:27you needed? Yeah, yeah, oh man, so the the short
- 33:32answer to how long I waited it ranged from like
- 33:35a month in some cases To I think the longest
- 33:39FOIA that I filed was like close to 15 months
- 33:41with the FBI and that was I was the first big
- 33:44one that I filed with them and it took a lot
- 33:46of Negotiating but I also was new to it and and
- 33:49once I had learned Kind of what I was doing a
- 33:52little bit more. I could have sped that up. But
- 33:54essentially if you're doing a case like this
- 33:57put out the foyers at least months ahead of time
- 34:00and look at it like you're just you're putting
- 34:03irons in the fire. You're putting your casting
- 34:05fishing lines out there and you're hoping that
- 34:07months later they will start trickling back in.
- 34:10So the more of them you file, the more targeted
- 34:13you are in that language. So with the FBI, for
- 34:16example, I learned kind of instead of saying
- 34:20I'm requesting all of your files related to this
- 34:22person, I would And I did this just by kind of
- 34:26asking them how to do it too. Like I honestly
- 34:28would email back and forth with them and be like,
- 34:30I'm trying to get this, can you help me kind
- 34:32of adjust the language a little bit? And in some
- 34:34cases, they would help me do that. Not always,
- 34:35but sometimes. So I learned to be more specific.
- 34:39And I would say, I'm interested in any information
- 34:43you have on this person related to organized
- 34:45crime activity in Texas between 1965 and 1972.
- 34:50And that would narrow it down. And then they
- 34:51would say, okay, we have files from 1968 and
- 34:551969. We'll send those to you in a month. The
- 35:01more specific you can be, the better. But again,
- 35:03there's people posting like 404 and Muckrock
- 35:07have really, really good tips on how to use that
- 35:09language. I would just say, look for FOIAs at
- 35:14the same police department that you're interested
- 35:16in filing with. and try to find ones that are
- 35:19written by a journalist or a researcher that
- 35:21sounds professional and that are citing specific
- 35:25laws. Because the minute I started doing that
- 35:28and basing my FOIAs off of what other people
- 35:30do was the minute it started happening quicker.
- 35:33I'd start getting files back sooner, but I literally
- 35:37got FBI documents yesterday that I had filed
- 35:39eight months ago or something. Wow. More stuff
- 35:43to uncover then. Hopefully. I would also say
- 35:46that some authorities, not really the police,
- 35:50but if you're looking at local authority documents,
- 35:53like councils and state -led departments, sometimes
- 35:58they can be a little bit mean. If you start asking
- 36:00questions after you've filed your FOIA, they
- 36:03can then reset the clock. They can say, oh, well,
- 36:05you inquired about something. Therefore, we're
- 36:07going to reset the clock that we have to respond
- 36:10to. Just be aware of that. But absolutely, kind
- 36:15of being as specific as possible is really useful.
- 36:17And there's so many good books out there as well
- 36:20on FOIA requests per country as well. For example,
- 36:24if you're looking for it in Holland in the Netherlands,
- 36:27I'm sure you could find Netherlands specific
- 36:30advice as well in a book form, because there's
- 36:34lots of journalists that specialize in kind of
- 36:36the best forms of FOIAs for each country. Lots
- 36:39of questions coming in. Keith has asked, any
- 36:42comments on safety when investigating these?
- 36:46Did you encounter any issues? I was going to
- 36:48ask that as well, because obviously, you talked
- 36:50about reporting on mafias and organized crime.
- 36:54What would be your advice for people starting
- 36:56to investigate these kinds of cases in terms
- 36:58of safety for themselves? Yeah, that's a big
- 37:02issue. My murder was 54 years old. I had a lot
- 37:08of people who were very, I don't want to say
- 37:14afraid, but there was a stigma about talking
- 37:17about this, folks in their 80s, 90s, including
- 37:19folks in my family, by the way, because I'm from
- 37:21Texas, who it just didn't feel safe either talking
- 37:26about it or having their name attached to it
- 37:28because they just assume that there's this mafia
- 37:32presence that's still there. And understandably,
- 37:35they're They're worried about safety concerns
- 37:38for that. In my case though, because this was
- 37:41so old, the suspects that I was able to identify
- 37:46tied to this were all dead. All of them. I mean,
- 37:49every single person I was looking at, I found
- 37:51a couple of folks who were sort of tangentially
- 37:53related to them. But pretty much everyone was
- 37:56dead by this point. The mafia group that they
- 37:59belonged to, which was the Dixie mafia, was sort
- 38:02of... other topic is pretty much defunct. There's
- 38:05a couple guys left but pretty much gone. I'm
- 38:07also across the country now, which helped a little
- 38:10bit with safety. But if you're looking at a murder
- 38:13that's more recent, especially one tied to gang
- 38:15activity or organized crime, that's absolutely
- 38:17a concern. And it's more of a concern when you're
- 38:22starting to work on it publicly when you're when
- 38:24you're posting about it online or talking to
- 38:26folks. However, you're also keep in mind you're
- 38:29doing public records research. So filing foyers
- 38:32to the police department, looking for newspapers
- 38:34online, that sort of thing. Take the same precautions
- 38:38you would doing a modern day ongoing type of
- 38:42research or type of crime that's going on today.
- 38:46Take the same approach. A lot of cases are gonna
- 38:50be so old and they'll have suspects that are
- 38:53named who are now deceased. But you still might
- 38:56be able to find stuff in the open source out
- 38:58there. So don't let it hold you back either.
- 39:00But I would also say lastly, and most importantly,
- 39:03another good reason to join a community of people
- 39:05who are working on this issue. Participate in
- 39:08a forum and a local group of some kind. Plug
- 39:11in with other people who can share safety concerns
- 39:14and resources with you in your local area. Absolutely.
- 39:18Take away, don't do organized crime if you're
- 39:19interested in longevity. Yeah, that's a good
- 39:21one. We had a question earlier actually about
- 39:26how you find the family members, particularly
- 39:29as they probably aged quite a lot. Could you
- 39:32maybe talk about the technique of how you discover
- 39:34the people to talk to and then how you approach
- 39:37them on this particular subject? Because it's
- 39:40quite a hard thing to kind of bring up and possibly
- 39:43retrain someone about. Absolutely. It's a really
- 39:47good question. It's a really tough issue. It's
- 39:49something I was just at a... investigative journalism
- 39:51conference two weeks ago. And it's a thing that's
- 39:54like at the top of everyone's minds because each
- 39:56case is so different. And this is a really hard
- 39:59topic. I mean, even when these murders happened
- 40:0150 years ago, you can hear it when you're talking
- 40:03to these folks. I mean, this stuff is, it doesn't
- 40:06matter how much time has passed, it is raw. And
- 40:09there's a lot of anger often mixed in there.
- 40:11There's confusion at why the authorities have
- 40:13haven't been able to solve the case. There's
- 40:15suspicion. Who are you? Why are you looking into
- 40:17this? It's such a huge question, but I will start
- 40:21by saying I guess that I would find the family
- 40:24members usually I'd find their names on ancestry
- 40:26.com. So I would search for like I was looking
- 40:29at Bill Richardson, the main murder victim I
- 40:31was focusing my story on. I quickly was able
- 40:34to find birth records basically for his kids
- 40:37that had their names. I knew he was from Corpus
- 40:41Christi in Texas. So I started working with that
- 40:43information that I got off of genealogy websites.
- 40:46I started doing searches on Facebook, searching
- 40:49for people um, with those names in Corpus Christi.
- 40:53And I quickly found a couple of them. Some of
- 40:55them had changed their names, they'd been married
- 40:57or divorced and their names had changed and whatnot.
- 40:59Um, but I was able to find them. I was able to
- 41:01find them through mutual friends. I would, I
- 41:03would cold reach out to them and just say, you
- 41:06know, on Facebook, which isn't great because
- 41:08when you're not friends with somebody that, you
- 41:09know, it goes to their hidden inbox or whatever,
- 41:11I would then, um, later on I started finding
- 41:14phone numbers and stuff like that. But it was
- 41:16really scary at first because I'm I'm reaching
- 41:18out to them as a random nobody asking about their
- 41:21dad who was murdered 54 years ago. I sent out
- 41:25Facebook messages and I think it took about a
- 41:29month until I got my first reply back. It was
- 41:31one of the daughters and she said, hey, I heard
- 41:36through my family that you're trying to reach
- 41:37us. Why are you looking at my dad's case? It
- 41:41was a scary question to get, but I was straightforward
- 41:43and I just said, I'm a journalist with Bellingcat.
- 41:47I'm looking to publish an article on this murder.
- 41:51And I'm hoping to get some more information beyond
- 41:53just what's out there in the newspapers. And
- 41:55she very graciously agreed to talk with me. We
- 41:59still text all the time. So I was able to do
- 42:02that. But granted, I work in a journalism space.
- 42:05So I have a little bit of experience doing that
- 42:10already. So that helped. In the case, if you're
- 42:13not a journalist and just work in cold cases,
- 42:14it's a lot harder to do and it's harder to explain,
- 42:16hey, I'm just a random person who is into research
- 42:19cold cases. And yeah, so I'd say again, being
- 42:22part of a community where there's folks that
- 42:24know how to do that. Maybe there's victim advocates
- 42:26and stuff like that, even who already do that
- 42:28already. There's, in fact, here, I'll drop it
- 42:33in here later on, but there's a podcast that
- 42:34I love here in the US that's really good about
- 42:37how they reach out to family members and doing
- 42:40it in a considerate way and stuff. Otherwise,
- 42:42they're often available in Facebook groups and
- 42:45stuff too. They're literally often want people
- 42:47to be researching these and they're posting about
- 42:49it themselves or they've created a group about
- 42:51it themselves. Okay, I yapped a bunch about that.
- 42:53I want to make sure to get to other questions.
- 42:55If you have more questions on contacting family
- 42:57members, definitely reach out to me. You send
- 43:00me a message on Discord and stuff. I'm happy
- 43:02to chat. And we can also talk about it in the
- 43:06thread that we mentioned earlier that is in the
- 43:09Discord for cold cases, because we're always
- 43:11in there looking at potential tools and tips
- 43:14for looking into these cases. So please check
- 43:16that out. If you scroll up, you'll find it in
- 43:18the chat. I put it in there earlier. And thank
- 43:21you so much for everyone putting in missing person
- 43:23links as well for the various countries. They
- 43:27are super useful as well in these particular
- 43:29cases. Scoot asked, could you talk about your
- 43:32methodology a bit? Did you formulate hypotheses
- 43:35and then test them? You mentioned earlier that,
- 43:37for example, you kind of suspected that organized
- 43:40crime was involved in this particular case. I
- 43:42wanted to ask you, is it often hard to stop yourself
- 43:47pulling the thread because you found multiple
- 43:49murders and ended up with a huge pin board, as
- 43:52we see in the article? So how do you know once
- 43:56you've started pulling that thread, once you've
- 43:58started unraveling that methodology? How do you
- 44:01stop? How do you say, okay, well, this is the
- 44:04story. This is how far I can get at this point
- 44:07in time. Yeah. Yeah. First of all, hi, Scoot.
- 44:12Nice to see you here. Second of all, I wish I
- 44:15had an organized methodology behind doing this.
- 44:20I tend to work in all of the research I do pretty
- 44:22freeform. I have a running Google Doc of notes
- 44:25and I just... let myself go down to a rabbit
- 44:28holes and pursue it. However, with this one,
- 44:30I did develop a methodology kind of over time,
- 44:32because there were so many other murders tied
- 44:34to this, because it was a mafia thing. I say
- 44:39that loosely there, there was the mafia, but
- 44:40also other mafias involved with this. I started
- 44:44to see sort of the same types of like murders
- 44:46over and over again, the same suspects popping
- 44:48up over and over again, similar crimes. So there
- 44:51were a lot of different strands with this investigation.
- 44:55I would kind of treat each one like on an individual
- 44:59basis. So I'd get the name of a suspect, I'd
- 45:02start doing open web searches for them. I'd start
- 45:04running searches on newspapers .com for that
- 45:06same person. Same thing with ancestry .com. And
- 45:10I would try to find any family members online
- 45:11that might have posted photos about them on Facebook,
- 45:14for example, or posted in the forum somewhere.
- 45:19So I sort of I use the same set of tools on each
- 45:22person individually. And that was sort of the
- 45:25methodology approach. When it came to putting
- 45:27it all together, this crazy detective cork board
- 45:31that you see is like what was going on in my
- 45:33mind for three years. So I would definitely recommend
- 45:36being more organized. I would recommend a couple
- 45:39things. Become friends with Google Docs, learn
- 45:43how to use their organizational features, which
- 45:46are really awesome. I'm still learning them myself,
- 45:49but keep a running list of notes and keep it
- 45:51organized. So have contact information for people
- 45:53in one. Have a tab for each individual person
- 45:55with all of the data points you have about them,
- 45:57the knowns, the unknowns. That would be a good
- 46:00place to start. Definitely I would keep a spreadsheet
- 46:04of the foyers you've sent off. I would also keep
- 46:07a spreadsheet of like contact info for people.
- 46:10So in a lot of cases, I just have like four or
- 46:12five phone numbers per person. And I'd have to
- 46:14figure out which one was their current phone
- 46:15number, which ones were old. So yeah, being being
- 46:19a bit more methodical would be good. But I didn't
- 46:21I didn't have like a formal methodology of like
- 46:23hypothesis and test it was a lot looser than
- 46:27that. I wish I had a better answer, but pretty
- 46:30chaotic. Hey, we like chaos, as well as order.
- 46:35So I want to revisit, we've got about 10 minutes
- 46:38left. If you have any other questions, please
- 46:40pop them in the chat. I want to revisit Saiba's
- 46:42question. Saiba asked earlier about whether you
- 46:45felt the need to wait to publish in order to
- 46:49make sure that the family were informed and also
- 46:51local law enforcement. Perhaps you can talk a
- 46:55little bit about the ethics behind publishing.
- 46:58Perhaps if you can't get in touch with the family
- 47:02members that you might want to. Is it worth just
- 47:05not reporting if people aren't responding to
- 47:08you, for example? And then how you manage that
- 47:11local law enforcement issue if the law enforcement
- 47:14isn't happy to kind of share details with you
- 47:17and vice versa. Yeah. Okay. So a couple of sides
- 47:23to this. Okay. So to start with, it was really
- 47:28important for me to try to talk to someone from
- 47:30the family, because just from my own sense of
- 47:35Ethics behind it. I felt it was important that
- 47:37they know that I'm looking into it and I wanted
- 47:39to sort of for lack of a better term I kind of
- 47:42wanted their blessing a little bit just just
- 47:45to I'm digging up old heavy stuff, right their
- 47:49dad was murdered and in front of some of them
- 47:51and I'm I'm another person not in the family
- 47:55looking into it. So yeah when I heard from the
- 47:57daughter, it was sort of a big win for me and
- 48:00she basically said look We haven't heard from
- 48:03the police since the 1970s. We don't think this
- 48:06will ever be solved. So if you think you can
- 48:09find new information, good on you. Good luck.
- 48:11Here's what I know. And we kept in touch. That
- 48:14was really, really important for me. You're not
- 48:17going to get that in all cases. You might not
- 48:18even know who the person is. So how are you going
- 48:19to find their family? The victim could be an
- 48:21unidentified skeleton in the woods. That doesn't
- 48:24mean you shouldn't work on it. Those communities
- 48:27that I posted earlier uncovered and solve the
- 48:29case. There's others out there. There's tons
- 48:30of others out there Those are a good place to
- 48:33start because You know these people a lot of
- 48:36them might even have like fallen out of touch
- 48:38with their families You never know it could be
- 48:40a very stigmatized person like a sex worker or
- 48:43something who? Came from a rough family background
- 48:45or doesn't have a family or no one knows who
- 48:47they are there's still a person whose death remains
- 48:51unsolved their killer still remains out there
- 48:53and one way or another and That doesn't mean
- 48:55that if anything, that means I think people should
- 48:58be working on those cases even more. So it's
- 49:01ideal if if you're able to kind of have a family
- 49:05that's willing to share information and stuff.
- 49:08But that won't always be the case with the law
- 49:11enforcement side of that. I would basically file
- 49:15the public records request with them very early.
- 49:18I say, hey, I'm I'm looking at this murder. Please
- 49:20give me. The public information portions of your
- 49:25report on this murder, you know, I'm going to
- 49:28release it to the general public. I'm a journalist.
- 49:29That's what I would say. And sometimes they'd
- 49:32share more than I asked for. Usually they'd send
- 49:35me a heavily redacted single page document or
- 49:38they wouldn't respond or there'd be a back and
- 49:40forth. It was all over the place. Sometimes the
- 49:44public information officer was willing to chat
- 49:46and they were happy I was looking into it. Other
- 49:47times they clearly didn't want to be dealing
- 49:50with me. You know, they see I'm a journalist
- 49:52and automatically shut off because I'm talking
- 49:54about the American South here. So so it's kind
- 50:00of all over the place. Sometimes they'll be they'll
- 50:03be retired policemen, for example, who used to
- 50:05work for the police department, who've maybe
- 50:07spoken to journalists before who are involved.
- 50:11who've spoken publicly about the case, who've
- 50:13been interviewed in newspapers. You might be
- 50:14able to reach out to them and talk to them about,
- 50:16hey, you worked this case when you were back
- 50:18with the department. Can you share anything about
- 50:20it? They might even have old files sometimes.
- 50:22I mean, these cases are old on paper. Sometimes
- 50:25people share stuff like that. However, most of
- 50:29the time the police aren't going to release information
- 50:30to you. They'll consider it an active and ongoing
- 50:33case, even when it's not, even when they have
- 50:35a hundred other cases and they're not looking
- 50:36at this one and they know nothing about it. So
- 50:40by all your information requests, don't expect
- 50:41much from them. It doesn't mean that they are
- 50:44like, you know, hate folks looking into it, but
- 50:47they usually just are prohibited from releasing
- 50:49information about cases that are technically
- 50:51still open. What part of that question, Charlie,
- 50:54did I miss any? I think you answered it very
- 50:58well. I was going to just ask, did you send the
- 51:02information to the police as well afterwards?
- 51:07A couple of the public information officers,
- 51:11so sometimes it'll be like a policeman assigned
- 51:12to the role. Sometimes it's just an administrative
- 51:14person who responds to these. A couple of times
- 51:17when they were working with me and we had a little
- 51:19bit of a rapport when the article was published,
- 51:21I'd send it to them. Just because I kind of got
- 51:24to know the person a little bit or whatever,
- 51:26we talked on the phone, we had an email back
- 51:27and forth. I didn't know if it was just a police
- 51:32official who shared the bare minimum and I wouldn't
- 51:36send it to them. But once the article was published,
- 51:40I would. But I shared it to them in the published
- 51:43form. I wasn't going with them and working with
- 51:46them actively. Yeah, we don't do that at Bell
- 51:48and Cat, so it wasn't like that. The last part
- 51:51of the question, Charlie, that you asked ethically
- 51:55about like interacting with the family and when
- 51:58to publish and everything. That was the big reason
- 52:01why we partnered up with Texas Observer. We partnered
- 52:04with local journalists who cover crime in Texas
- 52:07because they're familiar with all of the nuances
- 52:11of that area. Again, the more local you can go,
- 52:17the more you can team up with folks in your local
- 52:19area to do this type of research. The better
- 52:23off you'll be. The reaction locally was pretty
- 52:26good, right? Yeah. There's a couple of things.
- 52:32Because this case dealt with the Southern mafia
- 52:35for lack of a better term, the Dixie mafia, there's
- 52:38still a lot of stigma around that. Especially
- 52:41folks in their 70s, 80s, and 90s. I don't want
- 52:44to talk about this stuff a lot of the time. So,
- 52:47for example, I learned through some of the family
- 52:50members and stuff that I talked to and keeping
- 52:52up with, that the article is definitely going
- 52:55around Corpus Christi, that people are sharing
- 52:57it and talking about it and calling each other
- 52:59and stuff like that. They're not necessarily
- 53:01commenting on it on social media, reaching out
- 53:05to me or anything like that, but I know that
- 53:06it's making the rounds because I've heard that
- 53:08from multiple people. And the reaction has been
- 53:12surprise from the family members. They had no
- 53:15idea that a lot of these people were tied to
- 53:19this kind of organized crime. They didn't know
- 53:21the extent of it. The murder victim's family
- 53:24knew he was probably involved with gambling,
- 53:27but his friends and stuff had suspected mafia
- 53:31ties and their families didn't know a lot of
- 53:34that. So it was a kind of a mix of surprise.
- 53:37Um, a little bit of shock. Um, uh, but it was,
- 53:42it was sort of mostly, wow, you know, we, we
- 53:45didn't know that this was kind of going on in
- 53:46the background and it kind of explains why the
- 53:50killing happened the way it did and who might've
- 53:52been involved in the types of people, um, that
- 53:55the victim was associating with. So it's been
- 53:58interesting and I'm still, I'm still hearing
- 53:59back from people. I've gotten some, some interesting
- 54:02texts and phone calls and stuff like that. So.
- 54:05I'm glad it's resonating on the ground. Last
- 54:08question, final one. Mossman asked, when investigating
- 54:11a cold case, how do you decide when or if to
- 54:15throw in the towel if you're not finding what
- 54:18you need to find? That was a question that a
- 54:21lot of journalists were just asking me, so it's
- 54:23a really good one. It's one that we all struggle
- 54:25with. I would say this, if you're hitting dead
- 54:27end after dead end, or if you're burning yourself
- 54:29out, or you're frustrated, or you've kind of...
- 54:34Run the public information open source Angles
- 54:38to their to their end. Don't give up on it. Just
- 54:40put it on the back burner have it like Have it
- 54:43on a Google Doc that you revisit every now and
- 54:45then I worked on this off and on for three plus
- 54:48years I wasn't Actively 100 % of the time. I
- 54:53was doing other stories. I had other jobs. I
- 54:56You know life happened So I would have to pause
- 54:59pause my research on do it and jump back in it
- 55:03at a later date I'd get like a shower thought
- 55:05where I'm like, oh my gosh, I didn't search for
- 55:07this set of search terms. I'm going to go do
- 55:09that. Just keep it on the back burner. Don't
- 55:12give it up. Be part of a group. Share information
- 55:15with them. Keep it going. You don't have to just
- 55:18like permanently give things up. It's not black
- 55:20or white. You can keep it on the back burner.
- 55:22So how do you know when to stop? I encourage
- 55:27you like with any other research. If it's coming
- 55:31from a place of curiosity and excitement at the
- 55:34most basic level, for me, I was just obsessed
- 55:37with this group of people. I need to know what
- 55:42their organized crime ties were because there
- 55:44were hitmen involved in gambling. I have to know
- 55:47which mafia this was, where these people were.
- 55:50I was obsessed with it. I just pursue that. getting
- 55:59tired of it. If you're hitting dead ends and
- 56:00you need to pause it, pause it, but you don't
- 56:02have to give it up. Hope that helps. Thanks so
- 56:06much, Peter. And excitingly, this week's, this
- 56:10month's Bell and Cat challenge is actually inspired
- 56:13by cold case research as well, which you helped
- 56:16design. So if you have been having a go at the
- 56:19Bell and Cat challenges, look out this Sunday
- 56:22slash Monday for the release of a new set of
- 56:26challenges from Peter. And you can let him know
- 56:29how you're doing on that in the Discord server
- 56:32as well. Yeah, good luck, everybody. It was hard
- 56:35to write them. So hopefully it's not impossible
- 56:38to solve. But it's been really fun. And some
- 56:40of them are tied to the story. And yeah, I love
- 56:44the historical stuff in general. So yeah, reach
- 56:47out to me guys on Discord. I'm on Blue Sky as
- 56:50well. But shoot me a DM on Discord if you have
- 56:52questions. I'm always happy to help with like
- 56:54a FOIA question or... even ethically, you know,
- 56:59just hit me up and work on cold cases. Please,
- 57:02please, please work on them. We need lots of
- 57:05people. Thank you for listening to the stage
- 57:07talk. If you'd like to catch a stage talk live
- 57:11where you can ask the guest questions, join the
- 57:14Bell and Cat Discord server by visiting www .discord.
- 57:21The music you've heard is titled Dawn by Newer
- 57:25Self and is courtesy of Artlist.