Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Rescuer Doctrine and Security for Costs
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for our regular segment with Michael Mulligan, barrister and solicitor, with Mulligan Defence Lawyers, legally speaking on CFAX Afternoon.
- 0:07Adam Stirling: Michael, how are we doing?
- 0:08Michael Mulligan: Hey, good afternoon.
- 0:09Michael Mulligan: I'm doing great.
- 0:10Michael Mulligan: Always good to be here.
- 0:11Adam Stirling: Some interesting items on the agenda today.
- 0:12Adam Stirling: For example I'm reading the first one here.
- 0:15Adam Stirling: I had no idea this existed.
- 0:16Adam Stirling: There's something called a rescuer doctrine, and it plays into a civil matter that we're discussing this week.
- 0:24Michael Mulligan: Indeed, that's a good sounding doctrine, isn't it?
- 0:25Michael Mulligan: The rescuer doctrine.
- 0:26Michael Mulligan: There's so many.
- 0:27Michael Mulligan: There's so many doctrines.
- 0:29Michael Mulligan: We just keep coming up with these things, right?
- 0:31Michael Mulligan: So the idea behind the rescuer doctrine is that if a person does something negligent and it results in a circumstance where a person's going to reasonably feel that they need to rescue a person, you can be civilly liable for injuries sustained by the rescuer.
- 0:51Michael Mulligan: So here's an example Back, I guess, when we were still responsible for car accidents.
- 0:56Michael Mulligan: Let's say you are careless, you crash into somebody, it causes their car to flip over and catch fire, right, and some brave passerby decides to rush over there and try to save the person by getting them out of their car to flip over and catch fire, right, and some brave passerby decides to rush over there and try to save the person by getting them out of their car and they wind up getting injured.
- 1:11Michael Mulligan: You could be responsible for that person too, right?
- 1:14Michael Mulligan: That kind of makes sense, right?
- 1:15Michael Mulligan: The idea is hey, you did something.
- 1:17Michael Mulligan: It caused somebody else to try to intervene to protect somebody.
- 1:20Michael Mulligan: You could be on the hook for that.
- 1:22Michael Mulligan: Well, the case to talk about today involves that concept and involves a train.
- 1:28Michael Mulligan: So I guess we don't have to worry about no fault.
- 1:31Michael Mulligan: And so the fact pattern was this it was in Broadway in Chilliwack and there was a railway crossing there and there was a person who was seated in his electric wheelchair when one or more of the wheels on his wheelchair may have become stuck in a gap alongside the railway track.
- 1:53Michael Mulligan: And you can see where this is going.
- 1:54Michael Mulligan: A train was approaching and the plaintiff in this case she rushed over and attempted to free the wheelchair from where it was stuck with the approaching train.
- 2:07Michael Mulligan: Very sadly, she failed.
- 2:09Michael Mulligan: The train struck the person in the wheelchair.
- 2:12Michael Mulligan: He died, and the train also injured the woman who went over there trying to save him.
- 2:19Michael Mulligan: He's got a civil claim against the railway company on the basis of physical, emotional, no doubt, and financial damages resulting from that incident, and so the first interesting thing is exactly what we just talked about is that the railway company is, at least potentially liable for her injuries.
- 2:44Michael Mulligan: Right, if the railway company was negligent or careless in terms of, I guess, how it maintained the tracks or how the train was driving, or whatever it might be and caused that circumstance, for a person in a wheelchair was stuck on the track, just like if you hit a car and it slipped over and on fire.
- 3:02Michael Mulligan: You might expect some people to come and help.
- 3:03Michael Mulligan: And so that's the basis of the case.
- 3:08Michael Mulligan: The other interesting thing about it this case is still is ongoing now and the other interesting element to it we've talked about this before is that the defendants, the railway company, are not surprisingly, I guess, on that fact pattern trying to prevent the woman from having a jury trial.
- 3:26Michael Mulligan: You might imagine how the woman who rushed over to save the person in the wheelchair from an approaching train is going to be a rather sympathetic figure, probably for a jury.
- 3:36Michael Mulligan: And so the railway company, in its defense, is planning to call at least 14 experts, I guess, trying to various things accident reconstruction people and psychiatric experts and occupational therapists, and all of that, you know.
- 3:52Michael Mulligan: Good luck to them.
- 3:54Michael Mulligan: And they're making the argument that because of all that expert evidence, the case would be so intricate or complex that it couldn't be fairly tried by a jury.
- 4:04Michael Mulligan: And so, while you have a general right to a jury trial, but the one side or the other could try to set that aside if they can prove to the judge that the issues couldn't be fairly tried by the jury on the basis of just how complicated they are, and so that's the argument made by the railway company, and that's what the part of the case that was just decided the judge, I think, wisely concluded that well, yes, there's a number of experts being called there the fact pattern wasn't so complicated that a jury would be unable to deal with it right, just like other personal injury cases.
- 4:37Michael Mulligan: And you know that rescuer doctrine we've just discussed it in a couple of minutes and so the judge has denied the application by the railway company to prevent the woman, the rescuer, from having a jury trial, and so, because of that, she'll be able to proceed as she wished, to have the jury decide the issue, and the jury will need to decide whether she was a rescuer and then whether the railway is responsible for, was negligent and caused that accident, I guess by the maintenance of the tracks or how the train was driving, and we'll find out the answer.
- 5:11Michael Mulligan: But I thought it was worth commenting on, because that rescuer doctrine may not be familiar to anyone and everyone, and it is something that can expand your liability if you do something that causes a dangerous circumstance where other people are going to intervene to try and help fascinating up next I'm reading it says security for costs on an appeal where the appellant appellant, excuse me has no.
- 5:35Adam Stirling: I think that says money yes, that's right.
- 5:39Michael Mulligan: So the uh as we've talked about in cases, if you sue somebody and lose, you are going to presumptively be on the hook for costs which are not all the cost of it but a portion of the legal expenses of the person that you sue unsuccessfully.
- 5:54Michael Mulligan: And the reverse is true as well If you are sued and there's a good claim against you and you didn't just pay for it and you lose in court, you can be on the hook for some of their expenses.
- 6:07Michael Mulligan: So the idea is get you to sort things out where you should, right, and so one of the challenges that can arise is where one party has no money and, in particular, this is a circumstance where there was a claim.
- 6:22Michael Mulligan: It was a claim against a woman suing a doctor, and she made this claim.
- 6:30Michael Mulligan: She was referred by her GP, apparently for treatment for a sore neck that was what apparently occurred here and she attended for treatment at an office of a physiatrist hopefully getting that pronounced correctly and there was some treatment involving the use of needles and the woman claimed that the needles pierced her bones and destroyed her bones and destabilized her body, claiming that they injured her spinal cord.
- 7:05Michael Mulligan: That was her claim.
- 7:06Michael Mulligan: Wow, that trial was a summary trial.
- 7:08Michael Mulligan: All of that got dismissed, in large part relying upon a report of another expert who said well, first of all, the doctor said at no point did these tiny needles touch her bones.
- 7:19Michael Mulligan: There was an expert report from another doctor saying there was just no way that could occur and as a result of that, the other part of the claim and this could be a common part of a medical negligence claim one of the requirements when you're getting medical treatment is that you provide informed consent to a procedure right and the degree of information that needs to be provided and the degree of care with which consent has to be provided is in accordance with, for example, you know how optional is this procedure right?
- 7:54Michael Mulligan: If, for example, you're wheeled into the emergency room with a knife sticking out of your back or whatever, right, they're probably not going to be spending too much time discussing with you the dangers of removing the knife and even if they don't, you're probably not going to have much of a claim against them for getting the knife out of your back on the basis that, well, look, you're about to die from this knife and so you know anyone and everyone is going to say yes to get the knife out of my back, right.
- 8:19Michael Mulligan: But when you're going in for procedures that are much more optional like maybe you know needles to cure a neck pain, right you may need to be getting quite detailed information about things like what risks exist so that you can decide, you know, would I in fact agree to this treatment right Now?
- 8:37Michael Mulligan: The woman claimed that she didn't know that there was going to be some treatment of her back and she claimed that she didn't, or treatment of her neck and she claimed she didn't have any neck pain.
- 8:48Michael Mulligan: Now, that didn't get too far at the original trial, because she had written a letter speaking after the treatment about her neck pain and there was an intake form about what was about to happen, and so there was some significant issue there and so it didn't succeed at trial and she was now trying to appeal that decision.
- 9:09Michael Mulligan: Largely, the appeal seemed to have little merit because it was just re-arguing it, re-arguing the case.
- 9:14Michael Mulligan: But the challenge here is the doctor was saying arguing the case.
- 9:20Michael Mulligan: But the challenge here is the doctor was saying, look, I should get some security for costs because this claim appears to have little merit.
- 9:23Michael Mulligan: The appeal seems to have little merit.
- 9:24Michael Mulligan: It didn't work at trial it's unlikely to work on the appeal.
- 9:28Michael Mulligan: And so the doctor was asking for what's called security for costs in the amount of $5,000.
- 9:34Michael Mulligan: And that would amount to a requirement that the person bringing a claim deposit the $5,000.
- 9:38Michael Mulligan: And that would amount to a requirement that the person bringing a claim deposit the $5,000 into court, like with the court registry, so if they lose they would, then there'd be money there to pay the court costs of the other side.
- 9:48Michael Mulligan: That's the idea there.
- 9:50Michael Mulligan: Now the balancing and the problem is that when the person who would be required to pay the costs has no money which is usually why somebody's asking for the security of costs to begin with, do you know what I mean?
- 10:02Michael Mulligan: Like, if you're suing Bill Gates, you're probably not asking for security for costs because he's going to have money to pay the judgment if he's unsuccessful, right, yeah, but this particular person she indicated she had no money and was on income assistance disability indicated she had no money and was on income assistance disability.
- 10:21Michael Mulligan: And so that's where the real rub arises, because on one hand, it seems very clear that if she loses, there's going to be no money to pay the cost of the doctor, right.
- 10:29Michael Mulligan: But on the other hand, if the court says, well, yeah, we don't want to have the doctor out all the court costs, if you're unsuccessful in your appeal, it may mean that the person with no money can't proceed at all, right, which also doesn't seem too fair.
- 10:43Michael Mulligan: So what do you do with that?
- 10:44Michael Mulligan: And that's what the court of appeal here was balancing, that sort of interest of not leaving the doctor high and dry.
- 10:50Michael Mulligan: If this you know claim that appeared to have, you know, kind of thin on its merits because it didn't succeed at trial, was unlikely to succeed on the appeal, versus not, you know, causing somebody to be unable to appeal their case because they don't have the $5,000.
- 11:06Michael Mulligan: So how do you weigh that Now?
- 11:09Michael Mulligan: It looked like it was sort of on the cusp of just being told no, pay the $5,000, your claim or your appeal has apparently no merit at all.
- 11:18Michael Mulligan: I guess you're just re-arguing it.
- 11:20Michael Mulligan: But the saving grace for the woman was that she got head before the court.
- 11:24Michael Mulligan: She self-represented a letter from her GP along with an affidavit which was unsworn.
- 11:31Michael Mulligan: I'm clear why it was not sworn, but the affidavit assuming that it is sworn and is accurate was from the doctor's office saying that the doctor's officer, gp, made a error and intended to refer her to a psychiatrist, not this other doctor.
- 11:50Michael Mulligan: Oh no, maybe that goes to that issue of.
- 11:53Michael Mulligan: It seems like a bit of an odd claim, right, this claim that, you know, the needles got in my bones and they destroyed my bones and that I've become destabilized in my whole body and all that.
- 12:04Michael Mulligan: Maybe that feeds into it.
- 12:05Michael Mulligan: But there appears to be some ember here of well, maybe something did go wrong here, right, despite the intake form and the letter and the claim, that seems to be a little bit out there.
- 12:16Michael Mulligan: Maybe there's something to it.
- 12:19Michael Mulligan: And so the Court of Appeal said well, you know, this woman may have a challenge, in part because if you're trying to get fresh evidence in on an appeal, one of the things you have to show is that you couldn't have reasonably got that evidence at your trial, right, you don't want somebody like running a trial, losing it and saying, oh, now I'll try this other evidence on right, if you have something or you could reasonably get some evidence that would be important, you're required to do that off the bat.
- 12:43Michael Mulligan: You can't kind of wait and try it on later.
- 12:45Michael Mulligan: And so the court said well, you know, this is still, you know, kind of on the margin, but you can't say that it's doomed to fail, right, there seems some ember here to blow on, assuming that you, assuming that affidavit is accurate and so on.
- 13:00Michael Mulligan: It was unsigned at the time and so with all of that and I guess it's the tough cases that get to the Court of Appeal they have to weigh up.
- 13:05Michael Mulligan: What do you do?
- 13:05Michael Mulligan: Do you require her to pay the $5,000?
- 13:08Michael Mulligan: It was within 30 days, was the request.
- 13:11Michael Mulligan: Or do you say no and the doctor is going to have to be basically on the hook if this thing continues to have no merit on the appeal?
- 13:17Michael Mulligan: What do you do?
- 13:18Michael Mulligan: Well, they cut it down the middle Maybe that's a sign of a just decision and they concluded that there should be security for costs, but only in the amount of $1,000.
- 13:28Michael Mulligan: And rather than 30 days, they'd give her 60 days to come up with it.
- 13:31Michael Mulligan: And so that's how they balanced it and we'll have to wait and see what the outcome is.
- 13:36Michael Mulligan: If she genuinely has absolutely no money, it may be that she just cannot advance this appeal, but on the other hand, the Court of Appeals said more time and a lower amount.
- 13:47Michael Mulligan: You know, she legitimately thinks she was aggrieved and there is at least a letter, an unsigned affidavit, that said maybe they were trying to refer it to a psychiatrist not somebody for her neck maybe and so we'll have to wait and see the outcome.
- 14:00Michael Mulligan: But that's how security for costs works, and that's what the Court of Appeal was just very recently wrestling with, this came out on Monday.
- 14:07Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking, will continue right after this.
- 14:11Adam Stirling: Back on the air here at CFAX 1070 as Legally Speaking continues with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 14:17Adam Stirling: Michael up next on our agenda with just under seven minutes or, excuse me, under six minutes remaining in our show today.
- 14:24Adam Stirling: Faith-based medical facilities, it says, refusing medically assisted death and who can intervene in the case.
- 14:36Michael Mulligan: A very morally complicated and understandably sensitive topic.
- 14:38Michael Mulligan: Absolutely A really interesting piece of litigation to watch.
- 14:42Michael Mulligan: It's a piece of litigation.
- 14:45Michael Mulligan: It arose out of a fact pattern involving a woman who was admitted to St Paul's Hospital in early 2022.
- 14:48Michael Mulligan: She was diagnosed with an advanced form of cervical cancer and, very sadly, by February of 2023, she was approved for medically assisted dying.
- 14:59Michael Mulligan: That was her wish.
- 15:00Michael Mulligan: The hospital, St Paul's, does not provide those services for religious reasons and, as a result, she was transferred to another facility and the claim is that the transfer caused her considerable pain and distress.
- 15:15Michael Mulligan: That's the fact pattern.
- 15:17Michael Mulligan: The claim is being brought against the province of British Columbia in various capacities and the health authority on the basis that it's their policies that allowed St Paul's to deny her the medical assistance and die and caused her that distress before the end of her life.
- 15:36Michael Mulligan: And so a sad, tragic fact pattern.
- 15:40Michael Mulligan: But that's how it's framed here, and the issue being dealt with by the Supreme Court at this stage is who all is permitted to come and argue about that, right?
- 15:52Michael Mulligan: I mean, they've got the claim brought on behalf of the woman, right her estate, but there's a whole host of people that want to show up and argue about that because it has broad societal implications.
- 16:06Michael Mulligan: And so there's a long list of people that wanted to participate in the legal argument.
- 16:12Michael Mulligan: They included things like Canadian Civil Liberties Association, the BC Humanist Association, you know, the Physicians for Life, the Christian Legal Fellowship, and on and on it goes.
- 16:23Michael Mulligan: One of the groups there is, the Canadian Constitutional Foundation that wanted to intervene, and so the judge deciding this had to decide, well, which of these can participate and, if so, in what way.
- 16:35Michael Mulligan: And the decision about who gets to participate and it's not a free-for-all right.
- 16:40Michael Mulligan: Not everyone, every busybody lawyer, can just show up and start making submissions on a case because they think it's interesting.
- 16:46Michael Mulligan: There's got to be some kind of a threshold and, like in many legal things, this has been given some thought in the past, and so there's an approach to be taken.
- 16:54Michael Mulligan: And so the first thing a judge needs to think about, they need to consider three different sort of threshold considerations.
- 17:01Michael Mulligan: First, the nature of the group seeking the intervener status, whether the directness of the group's interest in the matter.
- 17:08Michael Mulligan: You know, is this a busy body?
- 17:10Michael Mulligan: Do they have some real connection to it?
- 17:11Michael Mulligan: What's going on?
- 17:12Michael Mulligan: And then the suitability of the issues that the person wants to intervene on, like what is it they have to say here?
- 17:18Michael Mulligan: And then, when you consider those things, the other thing the court has to do is they need to ask themselves, first of all, does this group have a direct interest in it, In the sense that, you know, is the decision that's made going to have you're going to prejudice their interests or affect their obligations, that kind of thing.
- 17:35Michael Mulligan: And so you know, if you looked at a group like, let's say here, for example, Canadian Physicians for Life, like I can guess by the name, what their objective is likely to be right.
- 17:45Michael Mulligan: They would say well, look, you know, we think we have a direct interest in it because we might be required to assist in the medically assisted dying.
- 17:53Michael Mulligan: We don't want to, for example, right?
- 17:54Michael Mulligan: On the other hand, if you have somebody who does, and so that would be way in favor of allowing a group to participate in it, you know they're not the ones being sued, but they've got a direct interest in it.
- 18:05Michael Mulligan: If the group wanting to intervene does not have a direct interest in it, they then have to be some other considerations, like you know.
- 18:13Michael Mulligan: How broad is their representative base Do they have?
- 18:15Michael Mulligan: Are they legitimately engaged in the issues here?
- 18:18Michael Mulligan: Do they offer a unique perspective?
- 18:20Michael Mulligan: Right, you know, is there something useful in allowing them to intervene?
- 18:24Michael Mulligan: And another consideration is the parties.
- 18:26Michael Mulligan: Do they oppose it or are they supportive of the additional views being represented?
- 18:30Michael Mulligan: And in this case, the parties pursuing and the province were supportive of all the groups intervening, except that the Canadian Constitutional Foundation and the argument made against them allowing to participate was that the submissions they wished to make were ones that were in some respects, sort of more general considerations, because the constitutional issues here being argued is, first of all, whether this policy amounts to a breach of the Section 2A Freedom of Conscience and Religion or Section 7, life, liberty and Security of the Person.
- 19:11Michael Mulligan: And the Canadian Constitutional Foundation takes legal issue with how narrowly Section 2B has been interpreted, and their position is that that section should be interpreted more broadly to include things that they would describe as lifestyle choices, as opposed to a sort of a more narrow, you know, conscientiously held beliefs.
- 19:34Michael Mulligan: They want a more expansive definition of how that section is to be interpreted, and so the judge ultimately concluded that, you know, that really would wind up expanding this beyond what was really the focus of the litigation, and so, even though many of those other interests would have all had a general you know, many of them were religious groups that were in support of allowing exemptions, and this was sort of an alternative perspective on it the judge concluded that it wasn't appropriate to allow that particular entity to be involved with it, and then, finally, what the judge decided to do is to limit how all of these groups are going to be allowed to participate.
- 20:19Michael Mulligan: It's not just you get to go in and cross-examine every witness and so on.
- 20:22Michael Mulligan: The judge has allowed all the other groups to participate, but only to the extent of providing written submissions of no more than 10 pages, and then they would need to get permission from the trial judge to make oral submissions, and they're not allowed to call evidence or examine witnesses or do things like that, and they won't get costs, even if their side wins or loses.
- 20:42Michael Mulligan: And so that's how it was sorted out and that's the kind of approach that a judge needs to take when they're deciding.
- 20:48Michael Mulligan: Do you allow some group to show up and participate in litigation where there's this kind of broad public policy decision that could have an impact on people beyond the individuals who are actually directly involved in the litigation?
- 21:03Michael Mulligan: So we'll have to wait and see what comes of that decision and whether the policy allowing for religious exemptions continues or whether it's found to be unconstitutional.
- 21:13Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 21:18Adam Stirling: Michael, thank you so much.
- 21:19Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 21:19Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 21:20Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.