Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Understanding California RPC on Client Solicitation After a Natural Disaster with Erin Joyce
Transcript
- 0:05My name is Annie Thompson. I am the Chief Claims
- 0:09Officer at Lawyers Mutual Insurance Company,
- 0:11and I have the pleasure today of introducing
- 0:14your main speaker, Erin Joyce, who is a friend
- 0:18and a colleague and a premier ethics expert in
- 0:22the state of California. She has extensive experience
- 0:26in state bar investigations and disciplinary
- 0:28proceedings, plus over 25 years in civil litigation
- 0:32practice. She was admitted in 1990 and practiced
- 0:36for nearly eight years in an intellectual property
- 0:38boutique before joining the Office of Chief Trial
- 0:41Counsel as a prosecutor for the state bar from
- 0:441997 through 2016. Erin has over 20 years' experience
- 0:49in handling all aspects of disciplined cases
- 0:51against attorneys in state bar court from the
- 0:54filing of the complaint through trial and review.
- 0:57She's personally tried dozens of state bar trials
- 1:00and several appeals. Aaron has a comprehensive
- 1:03understanding of how State Bar investigations
- 1:05and appeals and proceedings unfold. Before going
- 1:09into private practice, Aaron served as chief
- 1:12special investigator for the Los Angeles Fire
- 1:14Department, as a prosecutor for the State Bar
- 1:17of California, and as a lawyer for multiple private
- 1:21practices. So you are in good hands today in
- 1:25understanding the rules of professional conduct
- 1:27in the wake of the recent wildfires. I have also
- 1:31been invited today to let you know that Lawyers
- 1:36Mutual is a sponsor of your On Demand platform
- 1:39and share with you a little bit about our Lawyer
- 1:43to Lawyer hotline. which is available to our
- 1:46members and will serve as sort of a triage ethics
- 1:52hotline. If you find yourself in situations that
- 1:56you believe may give you some ethical pause,
- 2:01call our lawyer to lawyer hotline so that you
- 2:03don't end up having to retain Aaron Joyce later
- 2:05after the state bar has begun to investigate
- 2:09you. we will walk you through the ethical conundrums
- 2:13you may face and answer any questions prior to
- 2:16picking up representation to see if this is the
- 2:19right fit for you and whether or not you are
- 2:22in any danger of a state bar repercussions. So
- 2:27dropped in the link will be some information
- 2:30about how to get additional details on that if
- 2:33you are a member or if you are a non -member
- 2:35interested in that service. Additionally, I will
- 2:40remain on this seminar to join Erin for any Q
- 2:45&A that you have for either of us about any of
- 2:48these issues. And with that, let's get started.
- 2:52And I present to you the esteemed Erin Joyce.
- 2:56Thank you so much, Kenny. And I appreciate being
- 2:58able to speak with you this afternoon about,
- 3:02we're talking about. In the wake of the recent
- 3:05wildfires in Eaton, Altadena, and the Palisades,
- 3:09and most specifically potential advertising and
- 3:13solicitation problems which we may be facing.
- 3:21Now, I'm sure all of you who lived through January
- 3:23and all those fires and all the winds and et
- 3:27cetera, and the extensive damage both in Palisades
- 3:30and Altadena. I myself was sitting in my office
- 3:34here in Pasadena on I think Tuesday and the whole
- 3:38literally I was speaking to one of my clients
- 3:40that morning who told me he was distracted because
- 3:43about five hours before that he had gotten a
- 3:45call to evacuate his apartment building over
- 3:50on La Cienega or around there near Palisades
- 3:53and he never got a chance to take anything out
- 3:56and his entire building went down. But that evening
- 3:58as I was driving along the 210 I looked north
- 4:01And I'm like, wait, I thought the palisades were
- 4:03on fire. But that was the glow of the Eaton fire
- 4:07and the majority of Altadena going up in flames.
- 4:11So you all live through it here in Southern California.
- 4:15And what ended up happening, or it's happening
- 4:16now, is that with the extensive property damage
- 4:23from both fires, there has been a swell of attorney
- 4:31advertising and solicitation of those potential
- 4:35prospective clients who may have either insurance
- 4:38issues, bad faith cases against their own carriers
- 4:41or especially with respect to the Altadena Eaton
- 4:44fire, potential third party claims against Southern
- 4:47California Edison and others that may be responsible
- 4:49for that fire. The attorney general, Bonta, put
- 4:53out a statement the beginning of April and he
- 4:56said, you know, basically, that he encourages
- 5:01lawyers practicing in California to familiarize
- 5:03themselves with the laws governing client solicitation
- 5:07after a national disaster or catastrophe. And
- 5:10given the great collective damage in the Los
- 5:13Angeles fires, attorneys need to ensure that
- 5:15they're practicing ethically and in compliance
- 5:17with the law. So the main points raised in the
- 5:22statement from April 1st were the public in general,
- 5:26but lawyers should be reminded that California
- 5:29law prohibits lawyers from soliciting clients
- 5:34by in -person or by telephone or real -time electronic
- 5:39contact. Also, soliciting clients that have already
- 5:44made their desire known not to reach out to them
- 5:47or any kind of solicitation that's either intrusive,
- 5:52involves coercion, duress, or harassment. Now,
- 5:56mailed communications are allowed. However, you
- 5:59have to be really careful and make sure that
- 6:02they comply with the rules and that they're not
- 6:04either false or misleading. And then sending
- 6:06recorded or electronic communications have to
- 6:11be identified as an advertisement as well. And
- 6:14I think one thing that's really important to
- 6:16know is that California, just like in many other
- 6:18areas, the rules with respect to advertising
- 6:21and solicitation are significantly different
- 6:23than the model rules promulgated by the ABA.
- 6:26and which most other states follow something
- 6:29more akin to the model rules. We're the only
- 6:32state, and we're going to get into this. Yes,
- 6:36we all understand what in -person solicitation
- 6:38is. That's like knocking on the doors. That's
- 6:40actual ambulance chasers at the emergency rooms.
- 6:43That's the typical look. Telephone, that should
- 6:47be pretty easy. That's phone calls. But real
- 6:50-time electronic contact, that is something that
- 6:53is unique in California, and we're going to talk
- 6:55about that a little bit later. What does that
- 6:57mean? Now. In addition to the Attorney General,
- 7:03you know, making a statement at the beginning
- 7:04of April, there are moves within Sacramento,
- 7:08both in the Assembly and the Senate to address
- 7:11what is seen as this this groundswell of legal
- 7:16advertising aimed at the victims of both the
- 7:19Eaton and the Palisades fire. And let's take
- 7:22a look at the first one. The first one is SB
- 7:2437. This is a proposed new business. These proposals,
- 7:30I want to be really clear, they are not at this
- 7:33point adopted. They're making their way through
- 7:35the Byzantine structure in Sacramento. We don't
- 7:40know if one or either of these different approaches
- 7:42that are currently being considered are going
- 7:44to make it through. I can say some, I think,
- 7:49and I want to say certainty, but with some sense
- 7:51of that actually this might happen, that the
- 7:54state bar Unlike in most areas, the State Bar
- 7:58also is interested in attorney advertising more
- 8:02than in general because of the high -profile
- 8:05nature of the large amount of solicitation and
- 8:09advertising related to these fires. So even irrespective
- 8:14of these proposed new legislation and legislative
- 8:18answers to deal with what is seen as a problem,
- 8:21you know, basically all these fire victims being
- 8:23besieged by attorney advertising and direct solicitations.
- 8:27There already are existing statutes and rules
- 8:31of professional conduct which do govern this
- 8:33area and may be implemented if there are problems.
- 8:37So let's take a look at the first of these new
- 8:40proposals, SB 37. The first factor I want to
- 8:46look at here is it proposes a private cause of
- 8:50action for capping under business and professions
- 8:53code 6152. It's already an illegal act in California
- 8:57to engage in capping. And capping for those that
- 9:00don't know, I'm so sorry, I went back. I think
- 9:04I'm here, so sorry. Capping is basically the
- 9:09classic ambulance chasing. It's basically having
- 9:11mostly non -attorneys go out and find clients
- 9:14and either pay clients or pay people to bring
- 9:17in clients. That is already illegal. under business
- 9:21and professions code 6152. But the proposed SB
- 9:2537 would create a new cause of action for capping
- 9:31under business and professions code 6153. And
- 9:34it would authorize statutory damages of up to
- 9:37$100 ,000 per violation and attorney's fees and
- 9:41injunctive relief. This isn't the law, this is
- 9:44a proposal, but this would certainly change the
- 9:47landscape on attorney solicitation and advertising
- 9:49should that be adopted. I have been doing ethics
- 9:55cases and state bar cases for decades. I have
- 9:58seen almost no cases that are involved solely
- 10:03in capping. There are some significant state
- 10:06bar discipline cases that capping has played
- 10:08a part. Generally, that also includes unauthorized
- 10:11practice of law, et cetera. But it's not something
- 10:14that the state bar spends a lot of resources
- 10:16pursuing and prosecuting. This type of a change
- 10:20would maybe change that landscape, as I said.
- 10:25Another part of the new SB 37 that's under consideration
- 10:28is creating a new cause of action about running
- 10:32an improper lawyer referral service or LRS. There
- 10:37already is existing legislative structure for
- 10:42registered lawyer referral services. Generally
- 10:45speaking, the lawyer referral services that operate
- 10:48in California are operated by the different various
- 10:52local bar associations. But there are unregistered
- 10:57lawyer referral services or websites that act
- 11:01as the referral services that do not comply with
- 11:04the requirements of business and professions
- 11:06code 6155. And this proposed legislation would
- 11:11authorize private causes of action for violating
- 11:14the LRS statute and again provide for significant
- 11:18statutory damages up to $100 ,000 per violation,
- 11:22allow injunctive relief and attorney's fees.
- 11:24So it puts teeth in both the LRS statute requiring
- 11:28registered lawyer referral services and also
- 11:32teeth to prohibit capping. Now, what's really
- 11:38important about SB 37 is that these remedies
- 11:41will be allowed to proceed without the action
- 11:46of the State Bar of California. So right now,
- 11:49for many reasons, not to be discussed here in
- 11:52particular, the State Bar has devoted very limited
- 11:57resources to policing lawyer referral services
- 12:00at all and capping. almost at all unless it's
- 12:04open and notorious with a lot of other types
- 12:06of violations by those attorneys being prosecuted.
- 12:10So allowing private citizens or lawyers that
- 12:15are seeing their competitors, you know, rampantly
- 12:19engaging in basically paying per lead or other
- 12:23type of capping activities will now have another
- 12:26tool in their arsenal to stop this kind of conduct,
- 12:29which is already illegal. There already is a
- 12:32legislative scheme for what it takes to become
- 12:35a registered lawyer referral service. And there
- 12:38are also criminal and other prohibitions against
- 12:42capping. It's just that the state bar and other
- 12:46authorities haven't done much to enforce those
- 12:49rules. So this SB 37 would give another way to
- 12:53get these rules and statutes have to give them
- 12:58teeth. Now, another part of the proposed legislation
- 13:05is to strengthen the attorney advertising rules.
- 13:10There already is on the books, basically, it's
- 13:14going to strengthen the obligation about restrictions
- 13:18on lawyer advertising. So the new section 6157
- 13:23would have a different, much more precise definition
- 13:26of what it means to have advertiser advertisement.
- 13:29and then it'll be any communication through any
- 13:31written recorded or electronic means whether
- 13:35available to or directed or generally to members
- 13:38of the public or a limited group of individuals
- 13:40that provides information concerning a lawyer
- 13:43or the lawyer's services for the purposes of
- 13:45engaging individuals to secure the services of
- 13:48the lawyer or the firm. So this is it's a much
- 13:51more precise definition. Now more changes being
- 13:55considered would be prohibiting, we already have
- 13:59rule of professional conduct 7 .1, which we're
- 14:01going to touch on a little bit later, which provides
- 14:04that lawyer communications can't be false or
- 14:07misleading. But the proposed 6157 .2 of the State
- 14:13Bar Act would prohibit misleading, deceptive
- 14:16or false statements, words or phrases regarding
- 14:19a lawyer's law firm skills, experience or record.
- 14:24I have seen some cases which touched on a violation
- 14:28of Rule 7 .1, when attorneys put on their website
- 14:35information about their background, which is
- 14:38not merely puffing, but misstates or misrepresents
- 14:42their experience. A really classic example of
- 14:45that would be when someone says, you know, 25
- 14:48jury trials. But in fact, the real truth is they
- 14:50were second chair at like 25 jury trials and
- 14:53they've never done a jury trial on their own.
- 14:55Without more information, that type of representation
- 14:59on the website would probably already violate
- 15:01rule 7 .1, but this proposed change in 6157 .2
- 15:07would make that type of misrepresentation have
- 15:12more potential downside. You'd also require that
- 15:19advertisements state the location and address
- 15:22of record. listed with the state bar for the
- 15:25lawyer or the law firm. Right now, and we're
- 15:28going to see this more in particular what the
- 15:29rules are now, you have to have at least one
- 15:32attorney identified on any lawyer advertisement
- 15:35and an address. But in today's digital world,
- 15:38what does address mean? Address probably doesn't
- 15:41mean a street address. Probably under the current
- 15:44rules, it's sufficient to have a link to your
- 15:47website that has addresses and email addresses
- 15:50and contact information. But this would make
- 15:53it more particularized that the address of record
- 15:56with the state bar of California would have to
- 15:57be identified on advertising. And I think probably
- 16:03what's really important here is that this legislation
- 16:06is adopted. It would create a private cause of
- 16:08action for a consumer misled by an advertisement
- 16:11and not just for a person. Because right now
- 16:14the attorney advertising statutes don't allow
- 16:20for a private cause of action for any consumers
- 16:22that may have been misled. So this will open
- 16:24up potential areas of litigation concerning legal
- 16:27advertising. And I think that's what the point
- 16:29of this is, obviously. So now, in the assembly,
- 16:35there's a different approach being considered
- 16:37to tackle what is identified as a problem arising
- 16:41from the recent fires. And that is, again, this
- 16:44this you know groundswell of a major advertising
- 16:46from both in -state and out -of -state lawyers.
- 16:50So here violations of the attorney advertising
- 16:53rules would be able to be prosecuted by consumers
- 16:56as unfair competition or false advertising. So
- 16:59as a business and professions code 17200 or under
- 17:03717536 of the business and professions code.
- 17:08Now Also, AB -931 would prohibit the splitting
- 17:14between a California lawyer and an out -of -state
- 17:18ABS or alternate business structure. Right now,
- 17:22there's just a handful of states which allow
- 17:24alternate business structures, most notably Arizona.
- 17:29And we can see what's happening in Arizona. A
- 17:31lot of the personal injury or mass tort firms
- 17:34are consolidating as a result of the ABS adoption.
- 17:39So this AB 931 would prohibit California lawyers
- 17:43from sharing fees with an ABS out of Arizona
- 17:46or anywhere else. It also authorizes statutory
- 17:50damages in attorney's fees and injunctive relief,
- 17:53and it does provide another basis for state bar
- 17:55discipline. But frankly, most of the time, the
- 18:00state bar doesn't pursue standalone false advertising
- 18:04cases. We'll see a couple of the very notable
- 18:06examples of which there are very few. Again,
- 18:10the resources bar haven't been directed at advertising
- 18:13issues, but because this is now in the news,
- 18:16there's, you know, I would imagine that there's
- 18:18more likelihood going forward that that will
- 18:20change. The 89 931 also. It's very ambitious.
- 18:27It's taking on the problem with legal funding.
- 18:30It would allow it would prohibit. litigation
- 18:33finance companies from paying any consideration
- 18:36for referrals from attorneys. It would prohibit
- 18:40them from making referrals to any attorney in
- 18:43the furtherance of legal funding. So in the situation
- 18:46where you see, hey, you can get you money upfront
- 18:50on this case, if you go with this lawyer, that
- 18:52type of conduct would be prohibited. And also,
- 18:56they would only be able to, that a litigation
- 18:58finance company or litigation funding loan company
- 19:01would only be able to make referrals to a registered
- 19:04or a referral service. One that's operating with
- 19:07a basically registration with the state bar under
- 19:10business and professions code 6155. We don't
- 19:13know how that, you know, two different approaches,
- 19:16both one in the Senate, one in the assembly is
- 19:18going to pan out. Maybe neither one of them will
- 19:20be adopted. But one thing we can say is that
- 19:23Attorney advertising and solicitation is front
- 19:26and center now, probably because of the recent
- 19:31natural disasters have created so much more advertising
- 19:35in this area and more uproar with all these people
- 19:38displaced from their homes and then constantly
- 19:40getting mail about like lawyers looking to capitalize
- 19:46on helping them recover from their injuries or
- 19:50even like real estate agents trying to get them
- 19:52to sell their now vacant lots were really inexpensive.
- 19:56So the seminal case, now you might say, okay,
- 19:59can the state bar, does the state of California
- 20:01have a right to legislate or regulate attorney
- 20:06advertising? And that was not even a question
- 20:08at all up until the mid to late 1970s. Bar associations
- 20:13regularly prohibited any kind of advertising
- 20:16by lawyers because idea, in one way, you can
- 20:20consider it protecting the guild. and the professionalism
- 20:23of the profession. The whole argument, is it
- 20:25a business, is it a profession, still was up
- 20:28in the air. But in 1977, in Bates versus Arizona
- 20:31State Bar, the Supreme Court found that, yes,
- 20:34even lawyers have First Amendment rights, basically.
- 20:37That, yes, the state and the state bar can, in
- 20:42order to protect the public, has an inherent
- 20:45right to prohibit false or misleading type of
- 20:49advertising. But generally speaking, allowing
- 20:51lawyers to advertise fosters the idea of access
- 20:56to justice. It gives consumers and potential
- 20:59clients more opportunities. So instead of protecting
- 21:03the guild and the profession, the basis is to
- 21:07allow the free market ideas in advertising to
- 21:10allow clients to get the best legal services
- 21:13at the lowest cost. Now, okay, urgent. legal
- 21:20needs and demands coupled with unethical advertising
- 21:26and retention practices obviously could lead
- 21:29to potential ethical pitfalls and state bar complaints
- 21:33and potential discipline. And I myself have done
- 21:36consultations with respect to what are the outlying
- 21:41limits with respect to solicitation or even advertising
- 21:44with many, many of my clients. And one thing
- 21:48I would say is that how do these kind of cases
- 21:52get to the state bar in the first place? Most
- 21:55of these kind of cases are not cases that come
- 21:57in a typical course of action, which is, you
- 22:00know, a client says, you know, a typical bar
- 22:03complaint would be from a client and a client
- 22:05that says my lawyer either didn't return phone
- 22:07calls or didn't work well on my case or both.
- 22:11These kind of complaints don't generally emanate
- 22:13from a client or at least a happy client. Most
- 22:17of the advertising kind of complaints come from
- 22:19a competitor. Someone that's chasing the same
- 22:23business as the lawyer who's being accused of
- 22:26cutting corners or making active misrepresentations
- 22:30in either advertising or improperly soliciting
- 22:33prospective clients. Because even though, yes,
- 22:36there's 9 ,000, 10 ,000 structures that burned
- 22:39in the Eaton fire and a huge number of... victims
- 22:43in the Palisades fire, there still is a limited
- 22:45number of prospects and they're getting solicited
- 22:48by many, many different sources all the time.
- 22:50So these type of complaints come to the attention
- 22:54of the state bar, usually by a competitor who's
- 22:56trying to bring to the attention of their licensing
- 23:00authority, another lawyer who's not following
- 23:03the rules. So it's very important to, especially
- 23:08when there's incredible scrutiny, on all the
- 23:12legal advertising in every different media that's
- 23:15gonna be generated will result looking for those
- 23:17same prospective clients who were injured in
- 23:19these fires to ensure that these are proper and
- 23:22appropriate type of solicitations and or advertising
- 23:26because you have so many people that are gonna
- 23:28be watching. And those are people that are gonna
- 23:30be happy to report people that aren't following
- 23:33the rules to the state bar. And that's how the
- 23:35state bar gets these cases. They're not out there
- 23:37looking for them on the road. Under Rule 7 .1,
- 23:41which deals generally with communication concerning
- 23:44a lawyer's services, a lawyer shall not make
- 23:47a false or misleading communication about the
- 23:50lawyer or the lawyer's services. A communication
- 23:53is false or misleading if it contains a material
- 23:56misrepresentation of law or fact, or it omits
- 24:00a fact necessary to make the communication considered
- 24:03as a whole not materially misleading. So, directly
- 24:07false, that should be easy. But what does it
- 24:09mean to be misleading? Now, rule 7 .1 goes on
- 24:16in subsection B to talk about that the Board
- 24:18of Trustees can formulate or adopt standards
- 24:22as to communications presumed to violate the
- 24:25advertising and solicitation rules, the chapter
- 24:28seven series. And standards are to be used as
- 24:32presumptions affecting burden of proof. A presumption,
- 24:35as you all know, means it's it's basically going
- 24:39to be affecting burden of proof in a disciplinary
- 24:41case. The good news is that there aren't these,
- 24:45under the prior rule 1 -400, there were really
- 24:48extensive rules even governing the thought size
- 24:52on advertising. The Board of Trustees has not
- 24:55adopted those kind of strictures. In fact, In
- 24:58general, I would say with respect to the current
- 25:00rules of professional conduct and in advertising
- 25:03its solicitation in particular, there's been
- 25:05a relaxation of the prior rules, favoring more
- 25:09ways and requirements with respect to attorney
- 25:13communications. Now, what does it mean to be
- 25:19a false or misleading statement? So under Rule
- 25:237 .1, It is always implicated in attorney communications,
- 25:28a general prohibition about making false or misleading
- 25:31communications to anyone in any way, right? Including
- 25:34an advertisement. So that is, I think, a basic
- 25:37fact. A communication is false or misleading
- 25:41where there are misrepresentations of factor
- 25:44law, or again, it omits something that's necessary
- 25:46to put everything in context. If you think back,
- 25:50I mean, when I was growing up and all of the
- 25:53TV that was surrounding late afternoon or even
- 25:57like Saturday morning cartoons. I remember Larry
- 26:01H. Parker commercial. He got me $2 .1 million
- 26:05and you saw the complaint, you know, the client
- 26:09from the neck up. You didn't know he's sitting
- 26:11in a wheelchair and he was a quadriplegic or
- 26:13whatever he was. So potentially false or misleading
- 26:18and also in no, and that's actually a really
- 26:21good example of a problem commercial on a lot
- 26:25of levels. One of them being every single case
- 26:28turns on the facts and circumstances of the individual
- 26:30case. Testimonials are valuable because they
- 26:34have so much of an opportunity to be persuasive.
- 26:37Any testimonial that is used either in a website,
- 26:41in a social media post, or anywhere. If you're
- 26:43using testimonials, they're very powerful. Of
- 26:46course, they have to be true. You can't make
- 26:47up testimonials. I've had cases like that where
- 26:50an attorney's website had a bunch of um concocted
- 26:56testimonials and reviews that that obviously
- 26:58is more is more than just a misleading that's
- 27:02directly false but if you're going to use even
- 27:04legitimate true testimonials from really really
- 27:07happy clients that got a really great result
- 27:09they really potentially would be misleading because
- 27:13they are they don't have a disclaimer so you
- 27:15really need to have a disclaimer if you're using
- 27:16testimonials now When you're talking about being
- 27:23of counsel to a firm, if you look at formal opinion
- 27:29of the state bar, 1986 -88, it provides guidance.
- 27:33To avoid a misleading the public, a lawyer or
- 27:36a law firm contemplating listing an out -of -state
- 27:38lawyer or law firm as of counsel or with any
- 27:41other relationship must negate any impression
- 27:44that the firm or lawyer is a California firm
- 27:47or lawyer, that the firm employs licensed and
- 27:50lawyers to practice law in California, or that
- 27:53the firm is available for employment in California
- 27:56when it is not. Appropriate disclosures must
- 27:59be made when listing an out -of -state lawyer
- 28:01on any communication to the clients, either on
- 28:04your letterhead, on advertisements, in an email,
- 28:08or anywhere else. So be very, very careful. If
- 28:11you call yourself a California lawyer or if you
- 28:14call yourself a lawyer, even on LinkedIn, and
- 28:18you use a California address, you have to be
- 28:20admitted in California and if instead you're
- 28:22just admitted in Nevada and let's say New York,
- 28:26you have to have an asterisk and say not admitted
- 28:28in California, admitted only in New York and
- 28:31Nevada. Even there are cases that say by saying
- 28:35you're admitted in Nevada and New York, if you
- 28:38don't disclaim the fact that you're not admitted
- 28:43in California, that may not be enough to avoid
- 28:47a perception of being a California lawyer. And
- 28:51under the unauthorized practice of law statutes
- 28:54in California, there's two different aspects
- 28:56of unauthorized practice of law. One is actually
- 28:59practicing law, but the other is holding yourself
- 29:01out as able to practice. So you don't want to
- 29:05be, if you're like, let's say partnering with
- 29:07an out -of -state law firm to provide legal services
- 29:11related to the fires, you have to be very careful
- 29:13to identify that other law firm. And if they
- 29:16are only entitled to practice out of state, clearly
- 29:20you have to make clear where they are entitled
- 29:22to practice, and that they're not entitled to
- 29:24practice in California, if that's true. Now,
- 29:28under formal opinion from COPRAC, which is the
- 29:32State Bar's Ethics Committee, under 1993 -129,
- 29:37in order to avoid false, deceptive, or confusing
- 29:40communications, a principal member of a law firm
- 29:44may hold out another member of the firm as of
- 29:47counsel only where their relationship is close,
- 29:50personal, continuous, and regular. So long as
- 29:54that standard is observed, there's no absolute
- 29:56limit to the number of counsel relationships
- 29:58which the member or firm can participate in as
- 30:01of counsel. So this is another potential advertising
- 30:06type issue. Because if you're holding someone
- 30:09out to be of counsel with your firm, you're basically
- 30:13warranting that they have a close, personal,
- 30:16continuous, or regular relationship with your
- 30:17firm. And as I kind of already touched on, if
- 30:23you look at, it's very important, especially
- 30:26in the advertising series. There's the chapter
- 30:28seven series of multiple professional conduct.
- 30:31The rules themselves give a lot of guidance,
- 30:33but you really have to read the comments. The
- 30:35comments kind of put the meat on the bones to
- 30:37understand what is meant by the rule. So here,
- 30:40if you look at Comment 2 to Rule 7 .1, it warns
- 30:43that communications guaranteeing a result are
- 30:46also misleading. Very, very serious problem if
- 30:49you guarantee results. In fact, you probably
- 30:51should say the opposite, because results are
- 30:53not guaranteed, and each case is going to be
- 30:56based on facts and circumstances of that case.
- 30:59And with respect to your testimonial of your
- 31:02super happy, very, very satisfied client, you
- 31:05say the results are atypical, because you cannot
- 31:08warrant any particular result. Now, comment three
- 31:12talks about even truthful statements can be misleading
- 31:16if you don't have all of the facts there for
- 31:21a reasonable reader to understand. So the example
- 31:25is no fee without recovery has to be clear. Does
- 31:28that mean no fee without recovery? Does that
- 31:30include litigation costs are going to be waived
- 31:33if there's no recovery or do you expect the litigation
- 31:35costs to still be paid? Either way is okay, but
- 31:38it has to be laid out. Otherwise that that representation
- 31:41is not going to pass muster Now I touched on
- 31:48testimonials earlier But there's a reason why
- 31:50people use testimonials all the time because
- 31:52they're very persuasive. They really sway opinion
- 31:56case results Endorsements, you know five -star
- 32:01reviews. All of those are great. We want those
- 32:04the comment for to rule seven point one provides
- 32:07that even a truthful statement can be misleading
- 32:10and a violation if it would lead a reasonable
- 32:13person to form an unjustified expectation that
- 32:16they could obtain the same results. Again, that's
- 32:18why having a disclaimer is so important. Now,
- 32:22if an advertisement or solicitation guarantees
- 32:24a result, it's a presumptive violation. So depending
- 32:28on how you word your website or your advertising,
- 32:31you have to be very careful not to, like, promise
- 32:33the results. You should only post testimonials
- 32:39with informed consent and ensure it does not
- 32:41create an unjustified expectation to achieve
- 32:43the same result for others. So a lot of attorneys,
- 32:47when at the end of a successful representation,
- 32:49will send out like a link so that the person,
- 32:52probably only to people that were happy, would
- 32:56be able to post a review or something on your
- 32:58Google business, et cetera. Always make sure
- 33:01that the person who's filling out the the questionnaire
- 33:04or the review knows that it's likely to be posted
- 33:07or may be posted. Now I did say earlier on that
- 33:12the state bar seldom wades into purely advertising
- 33:16cases and that is absolutely true because the
- 33:20last big big advertising case was in Ray Morris
- 33:23from 1995 and this was not a typical advertising
- 33:27case at all. This attorney mailed out millions
- 33:31like four million solicitations about Homestead.
- 33:36And pretty much he ticked off every box of what
- 33:40you should not have in an advertisement. And
- 33:43Mr. Morris got multiple cease and desist letters
- 33:46before the State Bar Office of Chief Trial Counsel
- 33:49decided to take some action. And that's the first
- 33:52line of defense. When the State Bar does an investigation
- 33:55and determines during the investigation that
- 33:58there may have been either an improper reach
- 34:01out through let's say Facebook messenger or something,
- 34:04or maybe the advertisement didn't have all the
- 34:07information needed, they will issue what's called
- 34:09a cease and desist letter and then close the
- 34:11case. But if they have to have sent out multiple
- 34:14cease and desist letters and the conduct persists,
- 34:17that's when potentially the state bar would take
- 34:19some action. So in this case, Mr. Morse, he used
- 34:23government insignia to get the homeowners to
- 34:26open these envelopes. He targeted people who
- 34:29had already gotten a notice about being behind
- 34:33in their mortgages, so they were already susceptible.
- 34:36And he omitted the fact that even without filing
- 34:40this homestead exemption, the homeowner had exactly
- 34:43the same rights, that the work that Mr. Morstead
- 34:47provided zero benefit at all to the client. And
- 34:50with all of those facts, he ended up getting
- 34:52actual suspension. In my experience, if an attorney
- 34:59is approached about their advertising, if they
- 35:02have a good faith explanation of what was going
- 35:04on with that ad, even if there were problems
- 35:07with it, there'll be an opportunity to remediate
- 35:09before the state bar takes action past that investigation
- 35:13stage. That's generally what I've seen. Now let's
- 35:16take a look at, we've now kind of covered 7 .1.
- 35:19So let's look in 7 .2, which is the attorney
- 35:21advertising rule as it currently exists. Under
- 35:26subpart A, subject to rule 7 .1, which prohibits,
- 35:30again, we already looked at that, false or misleading,
- 35:33common communications from a lawyer, and rule
- 35:367 .3, which deals with solicitation, a lawyer
- 35:39may advertise services in any written, recorded,
- 35:42or electronic means of communication, including
- 35:45public media. And as you all know, in this new
- 35:47media age, you know, Facebook and Instagram and
- 35:51TikTok are full of attorney type of... you know,
- 35:54infomercials, you know, informational, and also
- 35:58potentially advertising. Now under subpart B,
- 36:04a lawyer shall not compensate, promise, or give
- 36:07anything of value to a person for the purpose
- 36:09of recommending or securing the services of the
- 36:11lawyer or the firm except, and there's a bunch
- 36:14of exceptions. The first one, yes, you can pay
- 36:17reasonable costs for advertising. That is permitted.
- 36:23Then you can pay for being part of an LRS. In
- 36:28three, you can pay via law practice. Now, in
- 36:33subpart four, you can refer clients to another
- 36:37lawyer or non -lawyer professional, so long as
- 36:41that is not otherwise prohibited. So you can't
- 36:44share fees with a non -lawyer. That's a violation
- 36:46of rule 5 .4. It's otherwise prohibited. Provided
- 36:50that you have a referral arrangement that's reciprocal,
- 36:56so long as that reciprocal referral arrangement
- 36:59is not exclusive and that the client is informed
- 37:03of the existence and nature of the arrangement.
- 37:06So let's imagine you're an estate planning lawyer
- 37:08and you get a lot of potential family law clients.
- 37:11So if you have one family law lawyer and you
- 37:15say, I'm gonna send you all of my family law
- 37:17cases, so long as you send me all of your estate
- 37:19planning prospects, that would violate 7 .24
- 37:23subsection one. So it's very important in your
- 37:27natural area of referrals to have multiple sources
- 37:30to be able to make referrals to. And the part
- 37:33about the client being informed of the existence
- 37:35and nature of the arrangement, that's why organic
- 37:38referrals work best. Because then you can say
- 37:41with all certainty and honesty, I'm referring
- 37:44to Joe because I know his work. I've come to
- 37:47know I can trust Joe. because of my networking
- 37:50and I know his type of work and the quality of
- 37:52his work from I've talked to other happy clients,
- 37:54etc. If there is money being exchanged for the
- 37:59referral between lawyers, which is totally acceptable,
- 38:02no problem at all, as long as you're in full
- 38:04compliance with rule 1 .5 .1 of the rules of
- 38:08professional conduct, meaning at the time of
- 38:10the referral, you have to ensure that the client
- 38:13is aware of the referral, the client approves
- 38:16the referral and that the client is made aware
- 38:18of exactly the nature of how the fees are going
- 38:21to be split, what type of referral fees can be
- 38:23paid, and who is sharing the fees, either by
- 38:26law firms or by the lawyers. And that type of
- 38:29an agreement has to be signed by the client.
- 38:32The referring attorney and the referral attorney
- 38:34all have to have it in writing. It does not need
- 38:37to all be in one document, however. So if your
- 38:40firm has a existing referral arrangement with
- 38:43a particular law firm, you can have that in writing.
- 38:46and then each individual case that is signed
- 38:49up, the client can approve the referral in the
- 38:51engagement agreement. And really that's outside
- 38:53the scope of what we're talking about here, but
- 38:55if you have more questions, we can follow up
- 38:56on that out maybe in the questions. Now, under
- 39:00subpart five, you can offer or give a gift or
- 39:04gratuity to a person having made a recommendation
- 39:06resulting in your employment, provided the gift
- 39:09or gratuity was not offered or given in consideration
- 39:12or understanding that the gift would be forthcoming.
- 39:15or that referrals would be made in the future.
- 39:18So all this is saying is that you cannot have
- 39:20a quid pro quo. Like, hey, hey, adjust, you know,
- 39:24public adjuster. Every time you send me a client
- 39:28that signs me up for his first party bad faith
- 39:31case against his insurance company, I'm gonna
- 39:32give you $1 ,000. That wouldn't work because
- 39:35that would be paying, that would be either splitting
- 39:37fees under rule 5 .4, or it would certainly be
- 39:41a violation of this rule if you consider it a
- 39:43gift. because it's a quid pro quo for that referral,
- 39:46basically buying a lead, which is prohibited
- 39:49by, it's also a capping violation. But absolutely
- 39:54you can be generous to people that send you business.
- 39:58And unlike under the ABA model rule, there's
- 40:00no proportionality under rule 7 .2 on the subset
- 40:05B5. Meaning if someone sends you a case where
- 40:08you net out a million dollars of fees, to thank
- 40:11them, even if they're not a lawyer, you can have
- 40:14like a nice red sports car with a big red bow
- 40:17delivered to their office as long as it wasn't
- 40:20approved in advance. It's something that, you
- 40:24know, by happy coincidence, you are a generous
- 40:27person and you recognize what people are good
- 40:29to you. Now, under subpart C of 7 .2, it says
- 40:35any communication made pursuant to the rule has
- 40:38to include the name and address of at least one
- 40:41lawyer responsible for the content. And as I
- 40:44already said, address in today's digital world
- 40:46probably doesn't require a street address. If
- 40:50you have a link in your TikTok post back to your
- 40:53website, which has all of your contact information,
- 40:56that probably would suffice. Ethics opinions
- 41:00surrounding advertising are behind the times.
- 41:03This technology is growing and becoming more
- 41:09and more sophisticated. In fact, the difference
- 41:11between advertising and solicitation is becoming
- 41:14blurred because of what's available out there
- 41:18to really target your market on advertising.
- 41:21So we don't have advertising ethics opinions
- 41:26that really get into the details about whether
- 41:28or not a link in the address would be enough.
- 41:31But at this point, based on what the technology
- 41:36is available, it's probably going to be sufficient.
- 41:41Now, the rules of professional conduct don't
- 41:46generally specifically talk about website marketing.
- 41:50And if you look back at a really ancient history,
- 41:53ethics opinion, 2001 -55 talks about online advertising.
- 41:59And 2001 -55 talks about attorney advertising
- 42:03on a website is governed on the same rules as
- 42:06print advertising, like it was in a magazine.
- 42:10So a website is going to be considered not a
- 42:13solicitation, but a communication. That's probably
- 42:18still sound, that part of this rule. But again,
- 42:22websites are almost required for lawyers, because
- 42:25even if your whole business is based on referrals,
- 42:29by word of mouth, whoever gets that referral
- 42:31from their trusted source is going to get on
- 42:34the Google and find your website and make sure
- 42:36you're real. and make sure that you have credentials.
- 42:39So having a website is pretty important. So at
- 42:43this point, most lawyers don't just have a website.
- 42:47They do a lot of other things to do outreach
- 42:49through even the website and having like a chat
- 42:51bot or at least a question box. So again, a lot
- 42:56of the ethics opinions have not, they haven't
- 42:58caught up to this area. Now under 6155 of the
- 43:03Business and Professions Code, it talks about
- 43:05joint advertising. There's nothing that prohibits
- 43:11lawyers from engaging in joint advertising for
- 43:14their services. You can have that. And when you
- 43:17do that, it has to identify the advertising attorneys
- 43:20who are doing this together and any certifiable
- 43:25referral activity involves some other person
- 43:28other than the consumer. So, it's very important
- 43:31to identify with cooperative or joint advertising
- 43:35who's involved. Now, if you look at, this is
- 43:45a case on solicitation from the Supreme Court.
- 43:48Now, for -profit solicitation is not entitled
- 43:51to the same degree of constitutional protection
- 43:53as other types of commercial speech, which makes
- 43:55sense. This is a case out of the 11th Circuit
- 44:03here. Basically, having a, ban on in -person
- 44:11solicitation is allowable, because again, you
- 44:15have very susceptible prospects. In our case
- 44:20that we're talking about here, people that lost
- 44:22their homes, maybe every single picture of their
- 44:25father. I've heard a lot of horror stories. I've
- 44:28had people that had home offices, yes, they had
- 44:31cloud -based files, but they still had original
- 44:33documents that now cannot be retrieved. So these
- 44:36are very... susceptible prospects. So in -person
- 44:41solicitation is very dangerous for those. So
- 44:45having a prohibition against direct in -person
- 44:49solicitation, directly like ambulance chasing,
- 44:52think about it, bringing the engagement agreement
- 44:54into the hospital room, that's prohibited. And
- 44:57what's the reason for prohibiting solicitation?
- 45:00It really does bring the entire profession down
- 45:04in the esteem of the general public. There's
- 45:08so much of a risk for overreaching, overcharging
- 45:12these very susceptible, you know, prospects that
- 45:15are targeted. There's a major risk of misrepresentations
- 45:21in these in -person verbal communications. There's
- 45:26other ways to solicit those potential prospects
- 45:28so that they can get information so that they
- 45:30can make an informed choice about counsel, whether
- 45:32they need it or not, or if they're going to pick
- 45:34any counsel, who they're going to pick. Also,
- 45:37victims of natural disasters or prospects for
- 45:42this type of in -person solicitation, like let's
- 45:45say the family that just lost the kids, or the
- 45:48family or the person who's in the hospital, or
- 45:51in our case, all those people that lost their
- 45:53homes that when they go to their mail drop and
- 45:56pick up their mail have a whole, you know, it's
- 45:58entirely full of lawyer letters. Lawyer letters
- 46:03can be read out differently than if they keep
- 46:05getting phone calls or direct people showing
- 46:08up at their apartment now that they had to rent.
- 46:12And it's very difficult to monitor. So a client
- 46:15can't waive improper solicitation in a fee agreement.
- 46:19So you can't go out there to the hospital and
- 46:21have someone sign off, oh, it's OK, I did this.
- 46:23In fact, not just this, any. A lawyer cannot
- 46:27have a client waive violations of the rules of
- 46:29professional conduct. That itself is a violation.
- 46:32It's an added violation of overreaching. Now,
- 46:36subpart A of rule 7 .3, I kind of touched on
- 46:40this earlier, but let's highlight it now. It
- 46:42says a lawyer shall not by in -person live telephone
- 46:47or real -time electronic contact solicit professional
- 46:51employment when a significant motive for doing
- 46:54so is the lawyer's pecuniary gain. Unless, okay,
- 46:58one, it's another lawyer, because we're immune,
- 47:02or unless, The lawyer has a family, close personal
- 47:08or professional, prior professional relationship
- 47:11with the lawyer. So let's talk about these. In
- 47:14person, knock on the door. We get that. And if
- 47:18they're out of their door, because they don't
- 47:19even have their house anymore, it's not that
- 47:22hard. It's a couple clicks of a computer to find
- 47:24out where they're rented now, where they're staying
- 47:27now. You can't go in person. That's prohibited.
- 47:32Unless they're, OK, we're going to get to the
- 47:34unless in a minute. Okay, live telephone, that's
- 47:37easy, right? Taking up the phone and making a
- 47:39call. But in today's world, who does that anymore?
- 47:43No, most people text. And here is a real strange
- 47:47anomaly with respect to the California advertising
- 47:51and solicitation rules. Because your same smartphone,
- 47:57your same smartphone that gets emails can beep
- 48:01and have an email and can beep and have a text
- 48:03message. An email is analyzed just like it's
- 48:09a direct mail. Just like you sent a mailer out,
- 48:14that's what an email is. An email, and this may
- 48:17have some, make sense when you think about where
- 48:20email came from. Electronic mail, email, really
- 48:25started in offices. It was business communication.
- 48:30So just like every day, if you go through your
- 48:33mail at home, you have all these direct mails
- 48:35from the grocery store, this and that, there's
- 48:39junk mail. You can weed that out. Email has that
- 48:44same, I guess, concept. It's gonna be analyzed
- 48:47like it's a direct mailer. You can either put
- 48:50it in the stack to look at later or you can just
- 48:51trash it. Click, click, click, delete, delete,
- 48:54delete, delete, delete. But. live telephone or
- 48:59real time electronic contact. What does that
- 49:03mean? That is a text message. Now, okay, I'll
- 49:10be very clear. There's no California ethics opinion
- 49:14directly on this point. And really, really ancient
- 49:17ethics, you know, advisories talk about being
- 49:20in a chat room, you know, back, what, 30 years
- 49:23ago, 25 years ago, chat room as being real time
- 49:25electronic contact. That is not real -time electronic
- 49:28contact as of 2018 when these rules were adopted.
- 49:32It's text messages. It's also in this brand new
- 49:35area where you through your social media post,
- 49:39you can actually have direct messages and Facebook
- 49:42messenger. You can have, I think Instagram has
- 49:45that. I don't know on TikTok, but maybe they
- 49:47have that too. There are so many different ways
- 49:50to do real -time electronic contact. So well,
- 49:54whereas email, is appropriate and allowed if
- 49:57you get someone's email address, a text message
- 50:00to their phone number or finding out their social
- 50:03media handle and getting to them through Facebook
- 50:07Messenger will be prohibited under real -time
- 50:10electronic contact. And this is an advancing
- 50:15area. I mean, the sky's the limit and someone's
- 50:18imagination that does that kind of work will
- 50:20tell you all the different ways that they're
- 50:21able to get to you on that same phone. at the
- 50:25same and with the same speed. And this may, you
- 50:29know, shake out. But the idea is people pick
- 50:32up their phone, you know, and it rings. They
- 50:35don't have that same ability to like just weed
- 50:37through click, click, click when they're deleting
- 50:39emails or throwing away the direct mailers when
- 50:43they're going through their mail at the end of
- 50:44the day when they get home. Now, who can you
- 50:48solicit in these ways in person, live telephone
- 50:52or real time electronic contact? That would be
- 50:55a lawyer. So other lawyers were immune. So sending
- 51:00solicitations, making phone calls to other lawyers,
- 51:03totally fine. Anyone that you have a family,
- 51:07and family doesn't probably mean mom and dad
- 51:10and siblings and direct children. Family is a
- 51:14much more broad term than that. It could be even
- 51:17not blood relatives. It could be your spouse's
- 51:22family. It could even be godmother that grew
- 51:24up with you. That would also probably be under
- 51:27close personal. And what does it mean a close
- 51:29personal relationship? Probably it doesn't mean
- 51:33someone that you went to grade school with and
- 51:35you have not seen since, you know, 1982. That
- 51:39probably is not a close. Actually, I'll go out
- 51:41on the limb and say that's not a close personal
- 51:43relationship. But if we met in 1982 and we've
- 51:46been continuously always getting together at
- 51:48Christmas every year when you come back into
- 51:49town, that could be a close personal relationship.
- 51:52Just like most things with lawyers, it's going
- 51:54to turn on the facts. And prior professional
- 51:58relationship clearly involves, for sure, former
- 52:01clients. But is it limited to former clients?
- 52:05Unlikely. Because if you are someone that sits
- 52:08on different professional organizations, both
- 52:10within the law and maybe you're on the GLAZA
- 52:13board for the zoo, maybe you're on the board
- 52:16at the school, maybe you, you know, there's other
- 52:19professional relationships other than simply
- 52:23a client. Maybe this is someone that served as
- 52:27an expert witness for you on multiple cases.
- 52:29So they've never, that's your prior professional
- 52:31relationship. The idea here is you might have
- 52:34another reason to reach out to these people other
- 52:36than just trying to secure a case. And you know
- 52:38what? If your friend, your close personal friend
- 52:41lost their home in the Palisades, you may be
- 52:43calling to offer help more than just to get your
- 52:45own pecuniary gain. So if you have a reason to
- 52:47be checking up in on somebody, that probably
- 52:50means you're going to be okay. with respect to
- 52:52this, that it passes that smell test, like there
- 52:55would be a reason why you would call because
- 52:57you know them and you know their loss. That makes
- 52:59sense. Okay, now under subpart B, a lawyer shall
- 53:08not solicit professional employment by a written,
- 53:10recorded or electronic communication or by in
- 53:13-person telephone or real -time electronic contact
- 53:16when not otherwise prohibited if they've already
- 53:19told you stop. I don't want to get any more of
- 53:22these. You can't keep at it. And then also, you
- 53:26can't use the other kind of means, like even
- 53:28a direct mailer, if it involves intrusion, coercion,
- 53:31duress, or harassment. So Mr. Morse, he had a
- 53:35lot of this intrusion, coercion, duress, and
- 53:37harassment. He continued to send out these mailers.
- 53:41He used the insignia of the government to try
- 53:45to get them to open and get them to open these
- 53:47mailings. He didn't identify them as advertising,
- 53:49that's for sure. And he was basically threatening
- 53:52horrible consequences. So he misrepresented the
- 53:55nature of the services he was offering. So he
- 53:58hit a lot of different violations of what would
- 54:00be 7 .3 now, and previously 1 -400, which is
- 54:04what he was prosecuted under. Now, under subpart
- 54:09C, every written recorded or electronic communication
- 54:12from a lawyer soliciting professional employment
- 54:14for a targeted person. Someone that you know
- 54:18that may be in need of legal services has to
- 54:21include the word advertisement. But here's the
- 54:25part that's important, and here's the relaxation.
- 54:28Unless it is apparent from the context that the
- 54:30communication is an advertisement. So you don't
- 54:33have to put advertisement on your newsletter.
- 54:37It's obvious. So in the context of what you sent
- 54:40out, it's clearly an advertisement. You don't
- 54:42have to say it's an advertisement. And most of
- 54:46the time, that's gonna be true. And under 7 .3,
- 54:51even not withstanding those prohibitions, a lawyer
- 54:54can be in a prepaid or group legal services plan
- 54:58that does have in -person live or real -time
- 55:01electronic contact. But that means that those
- 55:04services have to be, those reach outs happen
- 55:06through the LRS, not directly from the lawyer.
- 55:12Now, Solicitation and solicit under the rule
- 55:16refers to an oral or written targeted communication
- 55:19initiated on behalf of the lawyer directed to
- 55:23a specific person that offers to provide legal
- 55:27services. So it has to be targeted. That's the
- 55:30difference between an advertisement and a solicitation,
- 55:33which frankly with the way this technology is
- 55:36going is getting very, very harder and harder
- 55:40to distinguish. because you're able to so closely
- 55:44target advertising. Now it's almost becoming
- 55:47a solicitation. But again, here's a great place.
- 55:50Read those comments. They help a lot. A lawyer's
- 55:53communication doesn't constitute a solicitation
- 55:57if it's directed to the general public, like
- 55:59a billboard. So even if you have the billboard
- 56:02right outside of Northridge Hospital and you
- 56:04are trying to target like the accident victims,
- 56:08that doesn't make it a solicitation. It's still
- 56:10an advertisement. And subpart A only deals with
- 56:16when the primary purpose of the communication
- 56:18was pecuniary gain. So it doesn't apply when
- 56:21other motives are at play. So it doesn't prohibit
- 56:26a lawyer from participating in constitutionally
- 56:29protected activities of a bona fide public or
- 56:32charitable legal service organization or a political,
- 56:35social, civic, fraternal, employer, trade organization
- 56:39for purposes of providing or recommending legal
- 56:41services. So if the purpose of the communication
- 56:45is not for pecuniary gain primarily, it doesn't,
- 56:50the prohibition against in -person live telephone
- 56:53or real -time electronic contact goes by the
- 56:56wayside. So, and also, 7 .3 does not prohibit
- 57:04a lawyer from contacting representatives of organizations
- 57:07or groups that may be interested in establishing
- 57:10a group or a pre -created legal plan. And those
- 57:13that participate in the services plan are permitted
- 57:17to be a part of that cooperative advertising,
- 57:22so long as it complies with rule 7 .1, it's not
- 57:25false and misleading, 7 .2 as an advertisement,
- 57:28and 7 .3b. Now, under business and professions
- 57:37code 6152, this is the prohibition against running
- 57:41and capping, which is acting for consideration
- 57:44as an agent for a lawyer or law firm in the solicitation
- 57:47or procurement of business for the lawyer. You
- 57:50cannot just give out business cards to a mechanic
- 57:52and to give you clients, like with the idea,
- 57:59oh, if I get so many clients from your office
- 58:01or your auto body shop, I'll pay you so much
- 58:04money. That is capping. What about a multi -claimant
- 58:10accident? Attorneys contacting other claimants
- 58:12for legitimate investigative purposes are not
- 58:15barred from representing them if they're requested
- 58:17to do so, but it's misconduct to directly solicit
- 58:22that employment. So if you are investigating,
- 58:26because you've signed up one client and you're
- 58:28looking for witnesses, and in the context of
- 58:31those interviews, you may pick up additional
- 58:34clients, that's fine. In the employment case,
- 58:37let's imagine you have a couple of employees
- 58:39that have a wage and hour case, and now you're
- 58:41doing investigation to find other like similarly
- 58:44situated clients, not clients, witnesses who
- 58:48can vouch for what happened to your client. Maybe
- 58:51those could become potential clients, but you
- 58:53have to be very careful to document. that those
- 58:56outreach were for the legitimate purpose of investigation
- 58:59and not for direct solicitation of new clients.
- 59:04Now, under Rule 5 .1, you have supervising authority
- 59:09and responsibilities. So you cannot just have
- 59:12your staff violate the solicitation rules and
- 59:15be okay. You have to be monitoring to make sure
- 59:18that the advertising and solicitation activities
- 59:20of your firm are appropriate and follow the rules.
- 59:25Now, you also should be careful about, hey, we
- 59:30have to be careful not to be communicating with
- 59:31represented persons. So there's going to be a
- 59:33lot of lawyers going after those same set of
- 59:36prospective clients. Some of them may have already
- 59:38signed up retainers with lawyers. Be careful
- 59:42about soliciting people that already have found
- 59:46their lawyer, and then comment four permits communications
- 59:49on matters outside the representation, and comment
- 59:52five permits a lawyer to initiate contact seeking
- 59:55advice from an independent lawyer. So it is literally
- 59:57not improper for a lawyer to offer second opinions.
- 1:00:04You can do that. Clients are entitled to seek
- 1:00:08second opinions. That is not improper advertising
- 1:00:11or solicitation. Now, under Rule 4 .3, communicating
- 1:00:18with a client who's not represented, you cannot
- 1:00:21state or imply that you're disinterested. When
- 1:00:24you know that the unrepresented person incorrectly
- 1:00:26believes you're disinterested, you have to make
- 1:00:28sure to take reasonable efforts to correct that
- 1:00:30misunderstanding. And if you know that their
- 1:00:33interests are in conflict with the interests
- 1:00:35of your client, you can't give them any legal
- 1:00:37advice, except you can tell them, go get a lawyer.
- 1:00:41And that would probably be the best thing you
- 1:00:42do in that situation. Also, in communicating
- 1:00:47with an unrepresented person, you cannot seek
- 1:00:50to obtain privileged or otherwise confidential
- 1:00:52information that you know that they're not allowed
- 1:00:54to reveal without violating a duty to another
- 1:00:57or which you know that you're not otherwise entitled
- 1:01:00to receive and that you're kind of getting it
- 1:01:02from them because they don't have a council to
- 1:01:04protect them. Now, under 7 .4, this is the rule
- 1:01:10about communications about your practice area.
- 1:01:13You cannot state you're a certified specialist
- 1:01:15unless you have a current certified specialization
- 1:01:19certificate. And the relaxation in this role
- 1:01:23is that there's only 19 areas that are certified
- 1:01:29specialists under the state bar. But you can
- 1:01:31still say in another area, I specialize in this
- 1:01:34or that. As long as it's true, I focus my practice
- 1:01:38in this or that area as long as it's true. You
- 1:01:40just can't say specialist. or certified specialist
- 1:01:44unless you have that certification that's active.
- 1:01:49And you also can say what areas of law you do
- 1:01:52practice and you don't practice. And basically,
- 1:01:58like I already said, you have to have that current
- 1:01:59certificate to say you're a certified specialist.
- 1:02:02In the context of solicitation and advertising,
- 1:02:06it's always good to touch on fee sharing. Under
- 1:02:091 .5 .1, you can share things with a lawyer.
- 1:02:12Never with a non -lawyer. But with a non -lawyer
- 1:02:16that sends you valuable business, certainly it's
- 1:02:19okay to send gifts. So with that, I think we're
- 1:02:23just about done. And if there are any questions,
- 1:02:29let me take a look and hit a couple questions.
- 1:02:32Let me see if I can read it. This is the question.
- 1:02:36It says under 1 .5 .1 are the rules of professional
- 1:02:38conduct. What if an attorney within the same
- 1:02:41firm refers or rather originates a case and brings
- 1:02:45it to the same firm and that attorney receives
- 1:02:48a percentage of the recovery? Is that subject
- 1:02:50to the same rule to inform the client at the
- 1:02:53time of referral or is it treated differently?
- 1:02:56Okay, great question. Rule 1 .5 .1 is necessary.
- 1:03:02You need a fee sharing agreement for lawyers
- 1:03:04outside of your firm. And yes, 30 years ago,
- 1:03:08there were only certain ways to be part of a
- 1:03:10firm. You were either an associate of the W -2
- 1:03:13or you were a partner. But in today's world,
- 1:03:15there's a lot of different or a lot of different
- 1:03:17connections that you can have with a law firm
- 1:03:20to be regular, not just a W -2 person, but especially
- 1:03:26if you're a W -2 employee of a firm as either
- 1:03:29a non -equity partner or a associate. You don't
- 1:03:33have to disclose origination incentives to the
- 1:03:39client. You do not need to do that. The only
- 1:03:41time you have to have permission and client consent
- 1:03:47is when it's a attorney, a lawyer or law firm
- 1:03:50outside of your law firm. So if it's someone
- 1:03:53inside of your law firm, you can say, I mean,
- 1:03:56many, many law firms have a bonus structure where
- 1:03:58like they have a base salary. And then the lawyers
- 1:04:01get a bonus or additional compensation based
- 1:04:04on either a percentage of the cases they originate
- 1:04:07and or a percentage of the cases that they settle.
- 1:04:11Both of those are totally fine. And that's private.
- 1:04:13That's within the firm. So no answer to that.
- 1:04:16Sorry. Long, long answer for no. You don't need
- 1:04:19it. That's what I would say. So with that, I
- 1:04:23don't think I think we're over time and we answer
- 1:04:26all your questions or the ones that were there.
- 1:04:27If you still have questions. Please reach out
- 1:04:30to me. Yes, and if you want more information,
- 1:04:35Annie's hotline is fantastic. Also, I'm sure
- 1:04:37she'd be happy to talk to you about all the advertising
- 1:04:39questions and solicitation issues you might have.
- 1:04:43But you can always shoot me an email, Erin at
- 1:04:46ErinJoyceLaw .com, about anything that kind of
- 1:04:50spurs your fancy with respect to this presentation.
- 1:04:52And I'm happy to field your questions. And with
- 1:04:55that, thank you very much. Wonderful presentation.
- 1:04:59Thank you. Thank you. You may be eligible for
- 1:05:03CLE credit in your state. Visit bhba .org slash
- 1:05:07podcasts for more information.