Latest / The Vegan Report / Most People Oppose Factory Farming | Science of Activism
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, welcome to The Vegan Report,
- 0:03my name is Ryan and this is your Wednesday Science
- 0:06of Activism segment, where you'll learn about
- 0:09the latest research in animal advocacy. Today
- 0:13we examine a new survey commissioned by the UK
- 0:16non -profit Project Phoenix, revealing that the
- 0:19majority of British people think that the country
- 0:23should eat less meat, that most want factory
- 0:27farming to be phased out, and that many want
- 0:31it gone fast. To dissect these exciting findings,
- 0:37I have with me the lead researcher behind the
- 0:39study, Bjorn Olfsen. You may know Bjorn from
- 0:43his other appearances on the show, such as Do
- 0:47Protests Help or Hurt Animals? and Can We Veganize
- 0:51Supermarkets? But mostly from his amazing substack,
- 0:56More Than Meet the Eyes, I highly recommend signing
- 0:59up for it, you'll find the link in the episode
- 1:03notes. Together we discuss why most people can't
- 1:07wrap their heads around the scale of factory
- 1:10farming. When our activism should be bold and
- 1:15ambitious. And why some people told surveyors
- 1:18that factory farms were perfectly acceptable.
- 1:26Share this episode with the pessimistic vegans
- 1:30you know. Follow the show for more Wednesday
- 1:33science of activism episodes. And leave a 5 star
- 1:36review. Your encouragement is always appreciated.
- 1:40Thank you. I'm so happy to have you on because
- 1:43you're I consider you like the godfather of the
- 1:47science of activism initiative on the show. It
- 1:50all started with a conversation with you on a
- 1:54study you did about protests in the movement.
- 1:57And now we'll celebrate I think about a year
- 2:00of segments and episodes on the science of activism.
- 2:05And we've had So many contributors from analytics
- 2:09to animal charity evaluators and so much fun,
- 2:13you know, sharing studies about what's effective
- 2:16animal advocacy. And so let me start by saying,
- 2:20thank you for starting this with me for what's
- 2:24the expression, something, the ball, getting
- 2:27the ball rolling. Is that a phrase? Yes. Getting
- 2:30the ball rolling with this project. Well, thank
- 2:33you for having me back. It's always a pleasure
- 2:35to be back on the vegan report and excited to
- 2:38talk about the latest research. Wonderful. Before
- 2:43we get started, maybe a few words about why it
- 2:46is important to align your activism with the
- 2:50research and studies out there. Well, research
- 2:56The research of activism is just trying to understand
- 2:59what works best, what doesn't work best, what
- 3:02we should be doing, what we shouldn't be doing.
- 3:04So any activist out there who's thought maybe
- 3:08they've been thinking at night, not being able
- 3:10to sleep, but what's the best way forward? What
- 3:12are the best ways I can use my skills to help
- 3:14animals? You are essentially doing research and
- 3:18it's purest form. The only difference between
- 3:20what you're doing and what I'm doing is that
- 3:22I spent all of my time on it and I use numbers
- 3:25and data and charts and everything. But the the
- 3:29the kernel is the same. This curiosity about
- 3:31how do we actually make our tactics and strategies
- 3:34work better underlies both activism and research.
- 3:38So they they always have to go hand in hand if
- 3:41we just keep doing activism without strategies
- 3:45and strategic thinking and research. We're just
- 3:48going to be stumbling around. Maybe we'll have
- 3:50a victory here and there, but not as much as
- 3:52we could have. So Every activist should be thinking
- 3:56about research questions that could help them
- 3:59and every researcher should be thinking about
- 4:01the application of their work into the real world.
- 4:04They always need to be connected. Amazing. Well
- 4:08said. Okay, let's talk about one of your latest
- 4:14studies because you're very productive. You said
- 4:17you're doing this full time. Titled, the British
- 4:21public is ready for an end to factory farming.
- 4:24and sooner than we might think. So you did this
- 4:28in collaboration with Project Phoenix. Can you
- 4:31say a few words about this organization? What
- 4:33are they about? I never heard of them before.
- 4:37The name is evocative. The Phoenix is that mythological
- 4:43creature that is reborn from its ashes. Yeah,
- 4:47tell me more about that organization. So Project
- 4:53Phoenix, just to be clear as well, as Mike collaborated
- 4:56with this project, I'm not a formal representative
- 4:59of the organization, but we've worked together
- 5:01quite a bit, and I can speak to their values
- 5:03a little bit. Project Phoenix is based in the
- 5:05UK, and they are trying to mobilize the entire
- 5:10movement. So there's a lot of grassroots movement
- 5:14building, network building, strategic alignment,
- 5:17and things like that. They have a very clear
- 5:20mission of trying to end factory farming or animal
- 5:23factories within the next couple of decades.
- 5:27I believe by 2040, if I remember correctly. So
- 5:30they have a clear, ambitious target. They are
- 5:34trying to make sure that all of the organizations
- 5:36are working together so that the collaboration
- 5:39can make this target more and more feasible as
- 5:42we continue to our activism. They also are Led
- 5:46by people who have very strong research mindsets
- 5:49many who are former researchers themselves or
- 5:51currently do research with project unix so that's
- 5:54one of the reasons why our collaboration work
- 5:56so well. Is they have they always have the strategic
- 6:00thinking caps on that's like the only way they
- 6:03know how to approach this building which i think
- 6:05is amazing so together we are working on this
- 6:08is the first project we work together that's
- 6:10public. Um, and we're really excited because
- 6:12we think it could help a lot of people, especially
- 6:14in the UK, but across the world be a bit more
- 6:17strategic and network. And the, the results of
- 6:25this study are very interesting. I was recently
- 6:29doing a presentation to a Buddhist audience at
- 6:32a Buddhist temple. And I basically, my approach
- 6:38was to present. the results of different surveys
- 6:42that were done on factory farming showing that
- 6:46most people were against factory farming and
- 6:49then the whole presentation that my angle was
- 6:52let's validate the results of that study and
- 6:55see if the people in this room are like the people
- 6:59who were surveyed and find that those factory
- 7:02farm practices are unacceptable. It was very
- 7:06fun and most of the people in the audience were
- 7:09not vegan or vegetarian even and they were still
- 7:14very much in agreement that factory farming was
- 7:18wrong. Is it what you study found? Yeah, absolutely.
- 7:24Our headline. So basically, I'll give a bit of
- 7:28background on the study itself. It's essentially
- 7:31an opinion poll of the British public. It's a
- 7:33representative sample, which means that we've
- 7:36taken people from all walks of life, all across
- 7:39Britain, all age groups, gender, things like
- 7:42that, to make sure that we're getting the voices
- 7:44of everybody. So we really took our time to make
- 7:47sure that we're getting a good pulse check of
- 7:50what the public actually thinks. And what we
- 7:53found is that the majority of people opposed
- 7:56factory farm. Two -thirds, 67%, are either morally
- 8:01opposed to factory farming or have significant
- 8:04moral concerns related to factory farming. Only
- 8:083 % of people said factory farming is morally
- 8:11acceptable all the time, which is basically nobody,
- 8:15right? Like, you know, one in 20 or people or
- 8:18so think that factory farming is always going
- 8:21to be acceptable. So that's good. We wanted to
- 8:27start there because this is not a novel finding.
- 8:31Lots of studies have found that if you ask people
- 8:32about factory farming, it's usually a net negative
- 8:35response. So we wanted to start there and then
- 8:38dive deeper into what kind of, how does this
- 8:42break down across demographics? How does this
- 8:44break down across different asks, campaign asks
- 8:47that we could use in the UK and beyond. Then
- 8:51we started asking people about what they understand
- 8:54about factory farming. So for example, most people
- 8:59have a pretty good definition understanding of
- 9:02what it actually is. So we asked an open response.
- 9:06So we basically said, type in some words that
- 9:08come to mind when you think of the phrase factory
- 9:10farming. And the biggest category people have
- 9:13mentioned was the scale of it, the industry.
- 9:17And then confinement and cages, keeping animals
- 9:20in very small quarters. Then not giving them
- 9:23access to the outdoors, prioritizing efficiency
- 9:27over welfare, et cetera, et cetera, all things
- 9:29that people mentioned. This matches up pretty
- 9:33well with what most of us think about factored
- 9:35farming. Something we noted in the report is
- 9:38that they didn't mention any sort of psychological
- 9:41harms that animals might suffer under in factory
- 9:44farms. For example, family separation or lack
- 9:47of enrichment in the environment. But all of
- 9:51the other things that we animal activists are
- 9:54really concerned about and angry about are things
- 9:57that they're mentioning for the most part. However,
- 10:01they didn't understand the scale of factory farming.
- 10:05So most people think factory farming in the UK
- 10:07represented about 40 to 60 % of animals that
- 10:11are raised in farms. We also found that 97 %
- 10:18of people underestimated it entirely. Across
- 10:21the penny on the definition of factory farming,
- 10:24A vast majority of animals are factory farmed.
- 10:27In the US, it's around 99%. In the world, it's
- 10:30between 85 % and 95%, depending on what types
- 10:34of species we include. In the UK, it's at minimum
- 10:3785%. Although, in our report we noted, we think
- 10:40this is a conservative estimate. So even with
- 10:44the most conservative estimate possible, we still
- 10:46farm. A vast majority of people underestimate
- 10:48this. So there's a little bit of a contradiction
- 10:52here that we're trying to explore. Most people
- 10:55oppose factory farming. Most people understand
- 10:59what factory farming is, but most people don't
- 11:03know how prevalent it is. They don't know that
- 11:06it is the majority percentage of the farming
- 11:12that exists in the world or in the UK. So that's
- 11:16where we started with this report, is trying
- 11:18to understand people's perceptions and moral
- 11:21opposition to this industry that we're trying
- 11:23to fight. Interesting. I guess my first thought
- 11:28is, is it because it's the UK? It's the birthplace
- 11:34of veganism. It's where the vegan society started.
- 11:37So we have decades and decades of activism there.
- 11:41Is the UK a special place? Or do we get the same
- 11:45results everywhere? So I would have to say, well,
- 11:51first of all, judging from my accent, I am not
- 11:53British. I don't know if your audience could
- 11:55tell already. So I can't give a firsthand account
- 11:58of this myself. But I can say that most of the
- 12:01questions we asked in the report haven't been
- 12:03asked to other countries. So I can't say for
- 12:06certain whether or not this would replicate across
- 12:08the board. My hunch is that most of this would,
- 12:15I think the animal welfare conversation in the
- 12:17UK is more advanced than it is in most countries
- 12:20or at least in most industrial countries. You're
- 12:26absolutely correct. Like the mainstream vegan
- 12:29NGOs had a big start in the UK. The RSPCA has
- 12:33a long history in the UK compared to similar
- 12:35charities in other countries. However, there's
- 12:39also disadvantages with that in that many, I've
- 12:43heard the phrase, the UK is a nation of animal
- 12:46lovers many times. And I think there's absolutely
- 12:49some truth to that. However, there's also a myth
- 12:53of this idea like a small family farm that treats
- 12:56their animals with a lot of respect that I think
- 12:59is very common in the UK as opposed to other
- 13:02types of countries. So I can't say for certain
- 13:08without replicating the survey in other places,
- 13:11but I think it is possible that more Brits underestimate
- 13:15factory farming as compared to people in other
- 13:17countries. I think that might be very possible.
- 13:22However, there are positive attitudes towards
- 13:25animal charities, which is another thing that
- 13:27we found in the report, is also a big benefit.
- 13:30I think it's possible that other countries might
- 13:32not. and value it in all charities with the same
- 13:34positive lens that they are in the UK. Yeah,
- 13:40I was talking to a animal welfare foundation
- 13:43that was based in the UK and a hundred, I think,
- 13:48and seventy five years old, which is older than
- 13:52Canada. Yeah, exactly. It's incredible. OK, then
- 13:57explain this. Why? aren't more people from the
- 14:03UK more aligned with vegans? Why aren't we finding
- 14:08more vegans in the UK? Why aren't we finding
- 14:11more appetite for more laws that protect animals
- 14:17if most British people oppose factory farming?
- 14:24That's a great question. In a way, that's like
- 14:28the question that we're trying to answer. It's
- 14:29like, why aren't you vegan? Across the world,
- 14:32there are many answers that have been brought
- 14:35to us by previous research. Most of the barriers
- 14:38to veganism and diet change tend to be social
- 14:41in nature. Things like you're concerned about
- 14:45whether you can talk about this with your family
- 14:48and friends, whether you could go to restaurants
- 14:50and find easy options, whether or not you'd have
- 14:52to be inconveniencing people around you. Obviously
- 14:56we have health concerns, obviously we have monetary
- 14:58concerns, even though as I've broken up previously,
- 15:02often tend not to be the case. So there are these
- 15:07giant barriers to individual daily dietary change
- 15:13that exists in every single country on earth.
- 15:16However, One thing that we were asking about
- 15:19is how much do people support collective meat
- 15:22reduction? If there were to be laws or initiatives
- 15:26passed to reduce everybody's meat consumption,
- 15:29would this be something that you would support?
- 15:32And this was also pretty popular. We found that
- 15:37a lot of people are actually okay with collective
- 15:40meat reduction because one of the barriers to
- 15:43individual meat reduction is you might feel that
- 15:44your actions might not. have any actual impact
- 15:47in the world, but if we're all doing it together,
- 15:49if we're working together to create a better
- 15:51world to evolve our eating habits and our food
- 15:54production systems, people are more likely to
- 15:58be on board. So I can pull up the numbers for
- 16:00you right now. It was 51 % believe that the UK
- 16:07should reduce or eliminate their entire meat
- 16:10consumption. 39 % said that the UK shouldn't
- 16:15reduce their meat consumption and the rest said
- 16:18they didn't know. So again, that's a majority.
- 16:21A slightly smaller majority that supports ending
- 16:24or raising up factory farming, but that's still
- 16:27a majority of people who would find it okay to
- 16:29reduce meat consumption. So I think this is also
- 16:35quite positive. If the government would create
- 16:39some sort of national plant -based food consumption
- 16:43strategy or some sort of food transition, diet
- 16:47transition law to kind of work on this over time,
- 16:51a majority of people would probably accept it
- 16:54as according to our research. So to me, this
- 16:56shows us that going up to a single person and
- 16:59telling them to go vegan for the animals or for
- 17:01the planet usually doesn't work. This is something
- 17:06that we do know. Most of the time people don't
- 17:08just drop their meat consumption habits overnight.
- 17:11But if we were to go up to a collection of people
- 17:14and say if we were all to do this together in
- 17:17a systematized phase out, that type of ask is
- 17:22more likely to succeed. Yeah, that's what I like
- 17:26about this study. It is the very act of doing
- 17:30that study is activism, not just because it supports
- 17:34like actual activism or more active on the street
- 17:38and all of that activism, but also because this
- 17:44is something, a resource that you can present
- 17:46to politicians, to leaders and show them that
- 17:50if there is support and if they want to pass
- 17:53a law or something, a policy that they have,
- 17:58that they won't be against public opinion. Yeah,
- 18:03that's one of the ways that we hope the study
- 18:06can be used is by generating proof that this
- 18:11social change is popular. We would love if a
- 18:15British politician would create some sort of
- 18:17plant -based food initiative and we want to show
- 18:20them that it's possible. So for example, I don't
- 18:23know how familiar your listeners are with some
- 18:26of the policies in other countries. Like in Denmark,
- 18:30there is a couple of years ago, I believe over
- 18:33100 million euros was invested in plant -based
- 18:35foods and initiatives, chef trainings, alternative
- 18:39proteins, all sort of stuff to get diet transition
- 18:41to be easier for the public. If we were to see
- 18:45something like that happen in the UK, there would
- 18:47be a lot of progress made and our data shows
- 18:50that it would be popular. Or at least it wouldn't
- 18:53be opposed by the majority of people, 51 % to
- 18:55about 38%. To me, that's a clear net positive
- 19:00rating. If any politicians want an easy way and
- 19:03we're listening to this podcast, maybe this is
- 19:06the time to get that one going. Yeah, we discussed
- 19:11that with Rune Christopher. Yes. And yeah, it's
- 19:15amazing the work he has been able to accomplish.
- 19:18Let's go back quickly on the point about people
- 19:23don't realize the scale of it. I think most of
- 19:26us are in kind of an echo chamber. Most of the
- 19:30people I talk with are vegans or animal rights
- 19:34activists. And when we hear that, it is a bit
- 19:38shocking. It's a surprise. Why aren't people
- 19:42aware of the scale of it? We've been talking
- 19:45about it for so long, making documentaries and
- 19:49all of that, but also they can just go grocery
- 19:53shopping and they see the meat. dairy and egg
- 19:56aisles full. Where do they think this all comes
- 20:01from? How do they think that the demand for those
- 20:04products is met? How do you explain this ignorance
- 20:08that people still have around the scale of factory
- 20:12farming? When I saw that statistic about the
- 20:17vast majority of people underestimating this,
- 20:19it really stuck with me. Because you're right
- 20:22to us it is obvious to you to me to I'm imagining
- 20:25most people listening to this This is something
- 20:29that's almost like Impossible to disentangle
- 20:32from the reality of the world of which we live
- 20:34in but for most people it's not that way It turns
- 20:37out I did a lot of research into this and published
- 20:39my own companion piece where there were I dove
- 20:42into the statistic It turns out that the human
- 20:45mind is extremely bad at understanding traumatic
- 20:52or difficult or emotionally complicated statistics
- 20:55on this scale. We cannot understand grandiose
- 21:00trauma like our brains won't let us. You've probably
- 21:04heard the phrase one death is a tragedy. One
- 21:08million is a statistic. It's basically true because
- 21:11imagine the empathy that you would feel if you
- 21:13saw let's say somebody get hit by a car. in front
- 21:17of you and like the the empathy and the grief
- 21:20and the sadness and maybe anger all of these
- 21:22negative emotions that you would feel for seeing
- 21:24one person either be hurt or maimed or killed
- 21:27and if you were to multiply that by a million
- 21:31the human brain we wouldn't be able to take it
- 21:35like our brains cannot handle that so the same
- 21:38is true of an animal that if you saw a dog's
- 21:41A dog being trapped in a tiny cage and multiplied
- 21:44it by a billion or a trillion, depending on what
- 21:47type of species you're talking about. Our human
- 21:50brains just don't compute. This is replicated
- 21:52across lots of different types of studies, and
- 21:55it's often called psychic numbing. We numb our
- 21:58brains to this type of mass tragedy. This is
- 22:02difficult for advocates against genocide, advocates
- 22:06against climate change, and of course, advocates
- 22:08against factory farming because we What we are
- 22:11facing is so horrific and so dark that people
- 22:16genuinely cannot understand it. So what I think
- 22:20we should do is only communicate the scale of
- 22:24factory farming in certain contexts. So for example,
- 22:29if somebody is making a calculated decision,
- 22:32like deciding they're at a career fair and choosing
- 22:36a type of job to get it to. That might be a good
- 22:40place to talk about the scale, the problem they
- 22:42could work on. If they're choosing a charity
- 22:44to donate 10 % of their income to, for example,
- 22:47to give you what we can pledge, that's a good
- 22:49place to talk about the scale of factory farming.
- 22:51But if somebody is sitting down to eat food or
- 22:55choose their next meal, the scale of factory
- 22:57farming, the trillions or billions of animals
- 22:59that are being far isn't going to dissuade somebody
- 23:01from eating meat in that moment, unfortunately.
- 23:04So I think we could either shrink the problem
- 23:08to make it more palatable. So this is one instance
- 23:13of where focus on perhaps local initiatives or
- 23:17like local factory farms or local animals that
- 23:21they can help might make it easier for them.
- 23:24If we work together in our community, we could
- 23:27stop a factory farm from being built or we can
- 23:29reduce the pressure on this specific domestic
- 23:32food production, for example. Or alternatively,
- 23:36we just don't use scale at all because it might
- 23:39not trigger people to act. If we can communicate
- 23:43about individual animals that need help, for
- 23:47example, a rescue pig who escaped a factory farm,
- 23:53for instance, that's more likely to get people
- 23:55to be emotionally invested because their brains
- 23:57are literally able to handle the scale of this
- 24:00issue. They're literally able to connect with
- 24:03one individual. People cannot connect with billions
- 24:05of individuals. Nobody can. So we need to, instead
- 24:09of railing against this impossibility of the
- 24:13human mind, I think we should work within the
- 24:15limitations of the human mind to get people to
- 24:17be more likely to do what's good for the animals.
- 24:21Do you think the wording itself, the factory
- 24:26farming, the name we have chosen, for this industry,
- 24:30for that horrendous thing. Do you think it goes
- 24:34against our main goal of raising awareness around
- 24:38the issue? We've had a guest on the show, I think
- 24:42the last science of activism segment talk about
- 24:45using animal factories instead of factory farms
- 24:49in our activism in order to have a more less
- 24:55objective language, more positioned language.
- 24:58What do you think about that? Yeah, I did. I
- 25:04did see that study and I think I think it's a
- 25:07very interesting way to think about our messaging.
- 25:11So I think it's I think it's cool that animal
- 25:14factories is more negative than factory farming
- 25:16because factory farming. Well, I think you mentioned
- 25:20that it's a bit more neutral. I actually think
- 25:21it's more emotional than what the industry would
- 25:24use. um the meat industry what it means they
- 25:27would never use the term factory farming they
- 25:29would use a term more similar to industrial animal
- 25:32agriculture or intensive animal agriculture or
- 25:35something along those lines which uh activists
- 25:39might use factory farming because the word factory
- 25:42usually has a lot more negative connotations
- 25:44however the word farming for most people conjures
- 25:47images of you know cows in the green fields and
- 25:51pastures and we have a big soft spot for farmers
- 25:54in most people's culture um there's an idea of
- 25:58like farmer exceptionalism that they are the
- 26:00ones who grow the food they're like the bedrock
- 26:02of our society um so a lot of people have these
- 26:05positive connotations with the word farming so
- 26:10animal factories takes out that word with the
- 26:12positive connotations and just focuses on the
- 26:15idea of a factory I think it's a very evocative
- 26:18image, and I like that we're experimenting with
- 26:22new vocabulary and messaging frameworks. I'm
- 26:26very personally, I'm interested in trying these
- 26:28words out in campaigns. My one hesitation is
- 26:32I don't know if everybody would understand immediately
- 26:36what an animal factory is, or if they would understand
- 26:39that that's the dominant model of food production.
- 26:44I don't think that means we shouldn't use the
- 26:46term at all. But I feel like it feels like the
- 26:49first study in a couple of Massachusetts studies
- 26:52I would want to see about these ideas. So I was
- 26:54very curious. I loved reading it. And maybe I'll
- 26:59be publishing something about that in a similar
- 27:02way in the next year or so, because I do think
- 27:05it's a very good idea worth exploring more. But
- 27:07you'll have to stay tuned for that because when
- 27:11I publish that study, I'll be on the show and
- 27:12talk about it more, I promise. Intriguing. Thank
- 27:15you. Yes. Looking forward to this. Okay. We talked
- 27:19about the scale. What about the nature of this
- 27:22industry itself? Are they aware of what's happening
- 27:27to animals? I would guess not, because they're
- 27:30not even aware of the scale of it. Right. So
- 27:35when we asked them to fill out what they thought
- 27:38Bakri Farid was, they were mostly correct. They
- 27:42talked they talked about confinement as a big
- 27:45issue. They talked about negative environmental
- 27:48impacts as an issue. They talked about Sometimes
- 27:52they talked about mutilations and they also mentioned
- 27:57Putting up my notes here on the study You can
- 28:05edit this out, right So they mentioned confinement,
- 28:13they mentioned environmental harm, they mentioned
- 28:16no access to the outdoors, they mentioned prioritizing
- 28:19efficiency over welfare of the animals. So to
- 28:25me, this is pretty accurate. I don't think the
- 28:28average person could write a definition of factory
- 28:30farming that an activist might write. You know,
- 28:33an activist might think about more complex issues
- 28:36like how the industries work together, things
- 28:39like chick collate. Things like genetically modified
- 28:42breeds of animals that are designed to grow faster.
- 28:45The prevalence of, for example, vaccine uses
- 28:51in farms or all of the antibiotic resistance.
- 28:58Yes, exactly. Thank you. Thank you. The antibiotic
- 29:01resistance that are on farms, for example. And
- 29:05of course, the psychological harms weren't mentioned
- 29:07by most people. family separation, calves taken
- 29:11from mothers, animals not having enough enrichment,
- 29:15enough toys, being able to like enjoy and frolic
- 29:19and all the things that we would like to see
- 29:20in animals. So I think the definitions are relatively
- 29:25good. It's just that number one, people don't
- 29:29see the scale of it. And number two, people don't
- 29:32understand as much about these species of animals
- 29:34as they would for. other types of animals. When
- 29:37they think of a pig's welfare, they're more likely
- 29:40to think about, oh, this pig should have enough
- 29:41space to move around, or factory farming is not
- 29:45good because it confines the pig too much. But
- 29:47they might not think about the pig's desire to
- 29:51play, or the pig's desire to have friends and
- 29:54a family and enjoy the company of other individuals,
- 29:58be they pig or other species. So they might not
- 30:02think about The way that the pigs genetics has
- 30:05been modified in the last couple of decades To
- 30:08make it harder for the pig to have like a full
- 30:11life so I think the public's understanding is
- 30:16most of the way there but it's not quite all
- 30:20of the way there and something that project Phoenix
- 30:23is taking away from this actually is focusing
- 30:25on these psychological harms is a big underrated
- 30:29lever that activists could be using because We
- 30:32are we do think about psychological well -being
- 30:35for other species. You know dogs and cats like
- 30:38most people feel sad when their dogs home alone
- 30:41all day with with nothing to do no toys to play
- 30:43with and nobody to play with. And that's a feeling
- 30:46that humans are used to is is empathizing with
- 30:49that sort of emotion. If we can connect it to
- 30:52farmed animals I think there might be a lot of
- 30:55possibility for more progress. Yeah, you talk
- 30:59about the psychological aspect of things and
- 31:02also the how many British people frame that issue
- 31:07as a moral one, which is very interesting because
- 31:10you hear a lot of organizations or initiatives
- 31:14out there pushing the idea that we should not
- 31:18touch on the welfare argument for closing down
- 31:22factory farms or going vegan, that we should
- 31:25highlight the environmental argument more or
- 31:29other less provocative arguments or at least
- 31:33they are perceived as provocative to welfare
- 31:36arguments, highlighting the suffering of the
- 31:39animal and all of that. So what kind of insight
- 31:44does this study give us in making those decisions?
- 31:49Yeah, great question. This study is primarily
- 31:53focused on understanding the public's perceptions
- 31:55and current attitudes. In future research, we're
- 31:58going to go more into message testing and things
- 32:01like that. But right now, it's very good at exposing
- 32:04the gaps in our understanding. So the gaps are
- 32:08most people don't understand the psychological
- 32:11harm. Most people don't understand the extent
- 32:13of it. And most people don't really think about
- 32:19other minor issues like mutilations, for example,
- 32:24or also some finally interrupt the environmental
- 32:26harms weren't as commonly mentioned as one might
- 32:29think. Only 4 % of people associated factory
- 32:33farms with environmental harm. They might associate
- 32:36meat production with environmental harm, but
- 32:39not the actual concept of a factory farm itself.
- 32:42To me, that stuck out as well. Like there are
- 32:45these big gaps that we could be exploring quite
- 32:48a bit more. But the moral, I think the moral
- 32:54issue in general is something that I don't want
- 32:58to say is under explored because I know there
- 33:00are many activists out there who have stuck to
- 33:01the moral issue for their entire lives, their
- 33:04entire NGOs, campaigning seasons. Like they always
- 33:08go back to the morality and there's evidence
- 33:12in our report that this is a good strategy. So
- 33:15because the majority of people are opposed morally
- 33:19to factory farming, it means that there is an
- 33:21audience for this type of thing. Interestingly
- 33:24enough, we also found that older people are actually
- 33:30more morally opposed to factory farming than
- 33:32younger people, even though younger people are
- 33:35more open to personally reducing their meat consumption.
- 33:41There are also some other demographic details
- 33:43in there as well, such as the fact that people
- 33:45with high meat consumption are less opposed to
- 33:49meat reduction, which makes sense because they
- 33:51eat a lot of meat, but their opposition of factory
- 33:55farming didn't change. So factory farming is
- 33:57almost like universal across dietary groups.
- 34:00People don't like it, even though they might
- 34:02not like the solutions that we would propose,
- 34:05but their opposition to the production side of
- 34:07things is pretty standard. So this shows that
- 34:12we might want to focus on different types of
- 34:14asks based on the type of person that we're speaking
- 34:17to. For example, if it's a younger person, they
- 34:20might be more open to producing meat consumption.
- 34:23They might think that veganism or vegetarianism
- 34:25is perhaps trendier or something their social
- 34:29group is more supportive of, or they might have
- 34:31more familiarity with these types of foods. But
- 34:34they might be less opposed morally to factory
- 34:36farming compared to older people, which I find
- 34:39quite interesting and something that we're going
- 34:41to continue to research and grapple with because
- 34:43this surprised us. when we saw this, or at least
- 34:45it surprised me quite a bit. Well, about that,
- 34:51should we look at this study as kind of a report
- 34:55card of how well we have done activism for the
- 34:59past decades in the UK? This is those are the
- 35:02fruits of all our efforts. And this is how strong
- 35:08or effective our activism was. Yeah, so can we
- 35:13see that as the difference we have made? I would
- 35:18be I would be hesitant to say that personally,
- 35:25maybe this is the research brain inside of me.
- 35:27I would always want to compare like a pre and
- 35:30post evaluation to show change. I think it's
- 35:33good to have it as report card. But I couldn't
- 35:38compare this to data from the 70s or 80s or 90s
- 35:40to show how decades of activism has changed people's
- 35:43minds. So I would be hesitant to say we can show
- 35:47our progress from the past. But I do agree that
- 35:50this is a benchmark, right? This is the benchmark
- 35:54of progress that we're at right now. Hopefully,
- 35:58every few years, every 10 years, we can do more
- 36:01and more of these benchmarks to see how attitudes
- 36:03are changing over time. So in that regard, I
- 36:06would agree with you to show the change. But
- 36:09historically, I think the movement has prioritized
- 36:12other benchmarks of things like the number of
- 36:17vegetarians or vegans within a country, for example.
- 36:20This is a bit harder because the survey data
- 36:23is quite messy. And it can go up and down. And
- 36:27people's personal definitions of a vegetarian,
- 36:29a vegan, a flexitarian can change based on the
- 36:31survey. I like the idea of expanding our benchmarks
- 36:35of success to things like attitude change, proposed
- 36:38support for certain policies and things like
- 36:40that. So that's the research side of me answering
- 36:45this question. But I also want to acknowledge,
- 36:47if you're a person who's been campaigning in
- 36:49the UK for a few years, for a few decades, that
- 36:54work is visible. It is helping the world. We
- 37:03if you see positive results about how people
- 37:06think about these issues that doesn't. That doesn't
- 37:10just emerge miraculously like the idea of factory
- 37:14farming as something that's immoral is something
- 37:16that people have been talking about and speaking
- 37:18about for so long so in a way it is a good it
- 37:23is a good way to show. Growth of the movement.
- 37:28So if you if this if this makes you feel proud
- 37:31of the work that you've done. I'm not going to
- 37:33tell you not to feel proud. Of course, you should
- 37:34feel proud. You should feel proud of every single
- 37:36person that you've spoken to and worked with
- 37:38and gotten to think about these issues a bit
- 37:40more. So I'm hoping that we can compare this
- 37:44to more of these benchmarks in the future to
- 37:47really quantify their growth. Yeah, it's another
- 37:51reason why I love this study. I think among vegans,
- 37:55we tend to reduce as an indicator of our progress,
- 38:01reduce it to how many people are vegan. And we
- 38:07don't see the rest, how many welfare laws have
- 38:10been passed, how perceptions of factory farms
- 38:14have changed. So many more indicators that show
- 38:19that our activism has been making progress. I
- 38:27think it's small -minded to only think about
- 38:31dietary categories as a marker of progress. I
- 38:34think most people have moved beyond that at this
- 38:36point. Most people that I speak to are a lot
- 38:39more curious and open -minded about this. Even
- 38:41if they don't have their personal benchmarks
- 38:43that they're looking towards, they are open to
- 38:44hearing other people's, which to me is a very
- 38:46good sign, because it's true. Most people just
- 38:52aren't going to go vegan overnight. We just have
- 38:54to accept that. That's just the reality of the
- 38:57world that we live in. So we have to look at
- 38:59two other things to show us the likelihood of
- 39:01creating a vegan world or eliminating animal
- 39:03factors or factory farms. And people's attitudes
- 39:07towards this are one of those, which I'm excited
- 39:09to keep marking and identifying in the future.
- 39:16Another finding of your study is that where we
- 39:21should consider seriously or we should not feel
- 39:25constrained to be moderate in our approach and
- 39:30to show more boldness and ambition in our activism.
- 39:33Can you say more about that? Absolutely. One
- 39:38of our takeaways was don't be afraid to ask for
- 39:42an end to factory farming. We can be bold. We
- 39:45can be ambitious in what we are asking for. So
- 39:48the data shows that people are morally opposed
- 39:51to factory farming. Many people would support
- 39:55phasing out factory farming in five years and
- 39:5710 years and 15 years. A slim majority of people
- 40:02support collective meat reduction. These are
- 40:06pretty ambitious things to ask for. We're not
- 40:09asking people if they think... You know, should
- 40:13we should we ban cages, which I think is an easier
- 40:16ask We're acting we're talking about ending factory
- 40:19farming We are talking about reducing everybody's
- 40:21meats consumption and this is still a small A
- 40:26slim majority of people is still going to support
- 40:27this so this shows us that there is a huge part
- 40:31of the population That would be okay with us
- 40:35going for going for broke saying we'd want to
- 40:38end it Maybe not maybe not next year. We want
- 40:42to end it by phasing it out by giving transition
- 40:44by having a transition plan Having farmers transition
- 40:48moving the animal farmer to a different industry
- 40:50by making sure there's enough alternatives available
- 40:52in the supermarket so people know what to do
- 40:54but slowly making this entirely something of
- 40:58the past that is something people would accept
- 41:01and I think our data shows that we don't have
- 41:06to be moderate But we do have to be cautious
- 41:11and aware of the phase out. But I think it's
- 41:16okay to be ambitious as long as we have a long
- 41:19term vision for the future that we want to create.
- 41:23I was having this conversation recently with
- 41:26someone that for some people becoming a vegan
- 41:30takes time and it takes small steps and maybe
- 41:36a year or something like that. And for others,
- 41:39it needs to be an overnight thing. And I'm part
- 41:43of that latter group. For me, in all the things
- 41:47I do, it needs to be instant and overnight. But
- 41:53our default is to think about everything as we
- 41:58need a more moderate approach to it and we need
- 42:00small installments of progress and all of that.
- 42:05When it's some things go against that intuition.
- 42:10And we should, again, that's the magic of data
- 42:14and studies like this one, adopt a more aggressive,
- 42:18maybe that's too strong of a word, but a more
- 42:21proactive approach. Yeah, I think you're touching
- 42:26on something interesting, Ryan, which is there's
- 42:28a difference between moderate and incremental.
- 42:34And I think a lot of us conflate the two. We
- 42:37can be ambitious but still be incremental. That's
- 42:41something I admire about Project Phoenix is that
- 42:43they are working with the timeline. They are
- 42:45creating timeline of progress. But they are aware
- 42:49that we cannot end factory farming by next year.
- 42:52It's just not gonna happen. But if we are going
- 42:55to end factory farming with an ambitious goal
- 42:57like that, we can have incremental progress along
- 43:00the way. For example, maybe we start with ending
- 43:04With the factory farm moratorium, we're going
- 43:07to stop building more of them. Then we're going
- 43:10to start creating a plan to get farmers to transition
- 43:14away from factory farming. Maybe we're going
- 43:16to subsidize alternative proteins along the way.
- 43:19Maybe we're going to have national campaigns
- 43:21about dietary change to get people to be more
- 43:24aware. of the impacts of their choices, for example.
- 43:27All of those are incremental effects. By themselves,
- 43:30none of those are going to stop factory farming.
- 43:32But if every two or three years we make another
- 43:35incremental step forward towards an ambitious
- 43:38goal, we're not being moderate. We're being strategic.
- 43:42So it's OK for us to be ambitious as long as
- 43:46we are aware that it's going to take time, that
- 43:49phase -outs take time. We don't have to be moderate,
- 43:57but we do need to be incremental. I understand.
- 44:02It's a question of methodology. How do we get
- 44:05there? Just out of curiosity, are there situations
- 44:11where we can be bold, ambitious, but also we
- 44:16should discard being incremental? I think if
- 44:20it's possible for a society to make a change
- 44:23right away, I think it is possible to do that.
- 44:27I don't think with factory farming that's likely
- 44:29to happen anytime soon, unless it's for a specific
- 44:31aspect of factory farming. For example, inobosexane
- 44:35replacing chick choline, which is becoming a
- 44:37lot more popular in Europe. is one of those instances
- 44:40in which maybe incremental isn't necessary because
- 44:43we have the technology to basically face this
- 44:45out very, very soon. Everybody hates this practice
- 44:49of chip culling. I think we can be ambitious
- 44:52and don't need to be incremental right now. Other
- 44:56instances might be in certain countries that
- 44:58oppose animal testing with cosmetic products.
- 45:02We could be ambitious and ban that. Those types
- 45:06of things, as long as there's political support,
- 45:08Usually people are okay with it. They don't really
- 45:11care enough about cosmetic products to oppose
- 45:15it. But I don't think with the existence of factory
- 45:19farming, we can afford to be not incremental
- 45:23because changing an entire industry. This is
- 45:27the same as shifting from oil to solar power
- 45:31or wind power. It's going to take a little bit
- 45:33of time. And that's okay as long as we have an
- 45:36ambitious target. But we cannot do that by snapping
- 45:40our fingers as much as I'd like it to. I wish
- 45:43I could snap my fingers and make that happen,
- 45:45but we just can't. So I do think it's fine to
- 45:48be ambitious and want immediate change for specific
- 45:54asks that warrant it. But most of the time, I
- 45:58think we need to have always a long -term vision
- 46:01for the future. In your experience, did... How
- 46:07true is that Arabic expression of that you should
- 46:11aim for the moon and if you miss target, you'll
- 46:15fall into the stars. So basically even failure
- 46:18means a certain degree of victory every time.
- 46:23If you show enough, you know, ambition, does
- 46:27that hold hold true with activism for animals?
- 46:32Just an interesting question. I like that. Well,
- 46:37my association with that phrase is often for
- 46:40people who are seeking success for themselves.
- 46:43So if they fail, they are going to be the victims
- 46:48of their, they're going to suffer the consequences
- 46:50of their own actions. I always imagine like somebody
- 46:52trying to like become famous or something. When
- 46:55I hear that phrase, I think it's different with
- 46:58activism because especially analogism, because
- 47:00we are not the people who would suffer the consequences
- 47:02of our own actions. If we make a miscalculation
- 47:06with a campaign and we set back progress, it's
- 47:10of course the animals who are going to be suffering
- 47:12the consequences, not ourselves. Maybe we might
- 47:15be embarrassed or not get any more funding, but
- 47:19we're not really the victims of that situation.
- 47:23So I think in some instances going really, really
- 47:28big, could have benefits. If you're trying to
- 47:32generate media coverage, for example, going big
- 47:35could be beneficial. But there are many instances
- 47:39which campaigns can create backlash and set progress
- 47:43back. If we alienate potential allies, then the
- 47:49next group comes along to try and work with those
- 47:52politicians or those stakeholders, and they have
- 47:54a negative perception of animal activists. We
- 47:58can't undo those actually we can't change their
- 48:00minds in a single meeting. So I in general think
- 48:07Ambition by itself isn't enough. We have to have
- 48:10ambition with strategy because there are moments
- 48:14where being too ambitious can alienate people
- 48:17and Once people's opinions are made up. It's
- 48:20really hard to change them so we can't just I
- 48:25mean, shooting for the moon is great, but we
- 48:27have to have a plan in mind, don't we? We do.
- 48:31And we need to be smart about it. Before I forget,
- 48:35I want to get back to the 3 % I think of people
- 48:39who think factory farms are totally acceptable.
- 48:453 % is not a lot, but it is a lot of people if
- 48:49we think about the whole population of the UK.
- 48:54thousands and thousands, hundreds of thousands
- 48:56of people. Why do you think they find that percent
- 49:01acceptable? I don't want to go into their psychopaths
- 49:06and I think it's an easy answer and we're just
- 49:09demonizing people at this point, making caricatures
- 49:13out of them. But have you thought about why the
- 49:17answer being totally for it? It's possible that
- 49:24they're working for the factory farms themselves.
- 49:30I can't prove it, but it's 3 % of the population.
- 49:33It might just be the people who are employed
- 49:35by the industry. I'm laughing. I probably shouldn't
- 49:39be laughing, but that's my gut instinct about
- 49:42what's going on there. To give a little bit more
- 49:48depth to the answer, 14 % said, it's acceptable
- 49:52if animal suffering is minimized as much as possible,
- 49:56and 3 % said it's always acceptable. So that
- 49:583%. First of all, in sociology and psychology,
- 50:03there's always going to be somebody who disagrees
- 50:05with the majority, no matter what the survey.
- 50:08You could have a story that says it's wrong to
- 50:11step on puppies, and it'd be like 98 % say yes,
- 50:142 % say no, or you know. It's whatever the instance
- 50:18like there's always gonna be somebody who disagrees
- 50:20like it is impossible to have a question where
- 50:22a hundred percent of people answer yes. So whenever
- 50:24I see something that's less than five percent
- 50:26I just kind of discard it because that's one
- 50:29of the in that's humans are weird and sometimes
- 50:31people have weird opinions but it doesn't really
- 50:33matter the grand scheme of things. But with those
- 50:36three percent I imagine they are either connected
- 50:39to the industry maybe they don't understand the
- 50:42industry very well maybe they. are just trying
- 50:46to be contrarian. Maybe they are psychopaths.
- 50:49I don't know, but I think it's always more positive
- 50:53to focus on the people who are persuadable. There
- 50:56are always going to be people who always support
- 50:58something evil in the world, but as long as they're
- 51:00a minority and as long as we can work around
- 51:02them to create systems where their power is minimized,
- 51:06that's where the real strength is. And I learned
- 51:13from economy classes, not true activism. I think
- 51:19the main reason why the agriculture industry
- 51:22is powerful in a certain country is because they
- 51:25are a minority and so they can easily engage
- 51:30their members and create roadblocks for policies.
- 51:35It's actually a strength here, not a negative.
- 51:41And if the majority is silent, then why should
- 51:45we need them? I would prefer at any day, an active,
- 51:50loud minority than the silent majority. Do you
- 51:55agree? I think it depends on the type of ask
- 52:03we're looking for a very well organized minority
- 52:07group that wants to delay progress on something
- 52:11to to keep things at the status quo, for example,
- 52:14which I think describes most farming industries
- 52:18across the world, does have a lot of political
- 52:20power because if they stop working, if they do
- 52:24a giant protest by taking their tractors from
- 52:26the countryside into the middle of the big city,
- 52:28which has happened once a year in some European
- 52:31country for the last decade, that does give them
- 52:34a lot of political power. But at the end of the
- 52:40day in most democracies the number of votes wins
- 52:43and then we have to figure out a way to work
- 52:45within Within those the large number of votes
- 52:50the issue is that most people aren't thinking
- 52:52about animal rights or animal welfare when they
- 52:55go to the voting box because very rarely are
- 52:58these issues actually on the ballot in terms
- 53:01of it or other like a Ballot issue and it's very
- 53:04rare to see politicians talking about this They'll
- 53:08talk about food security. They'll talk about
- 53:09food prices. They'll talk about import, export,
- 53:12economics. But in terms of animal welfare, that's
- 53:15pretty rarely done. So I think in this instance,
- 53:20the farmers have a lot more political power because
- 53:23the way that they frame the conversation is the
- 53:26way the politicians frame the conversation as
- 53:28well. If we had a silent majority that supported
- 53:31animal welfare and And politicians talk about
- 53:35animal welfare and farmers talk about animal
- 53:38welfare. Now the narrative arena is in our favor
- 53:41because now we actually do have the majority.
- 53:44But farmers don't talk about animal welfare when
- 53:45they do their protests. They talk about production
- 53:48costs. And then suddenly the silent majority
- 53:51in this instance might be, oh, maybe we should
- 53:53talk about production costs. So I think if we
- 53:59are able to create a political arena in which
- 54:01we are thinking about the issues in a way that
- 54:04actually focuses on animals, we are much more
- 54:07likely to win all of those arguments, all of
- 54:09those debates and eventually elections because
- 54:14most people support our side of things when it
- 54:17gets down to it, not the animal farmers. Yeah.
- 54:22And that's good news. Not to get too meta about
- 54:26this, but we are actually the minority here as
- 54:29animal rights activists and vegans and all of
- 54:32that. And we are making. progress and changing
- 54:35things. So yeah, we can frame the agriculture
- 54:41industry as like a parallel minority group, like
- 54:46two minority groups going against each other
- 54:49for a majority appeal. That's one way of picturing
- 54:54this issue. I think we should separate opinion
- 55:00and behavior. if we're thinking about this, because
- 55:04we are in the majority of opinions. Most people
- 55:06support animal lawfare and other rights. We are
- 55:09in the minority in that we have actually changed
- 55:11something about our lives to match up with that
- 55:13opinion, right? And the same with farmers. Like
- 55:16an animal farmer, their behavior is what we would
- 55:19call anti -animal, harming animals. But most
- 55:22people in their daily lives are not harming animals
- 55:25directly, indirectly with their economic purchases
- 55:28of meat. but not directly themselves. So this
- 55:33is one of those tricky instances where we meet.
- 55:35It's helpful to separate intention, attitude
- 55:38and behavior themselves, because most people
- 55:42don't go around thinking in that way, you know.
- 55:47Okay, Bjorn, did you want to add something more
- 55:50before we stop the recording? No, I think this
- 55:54is great. Thank you so much for having me on.
- 55:56Amazing. And So, appreciative of your work. Thank
- 56:00you so much for all that you're doing and thank
- 56:04you for having answered my questions. Of course,
- 56:07thank you. Thank you everyone for listening.
- 56:18I kindly invite you to share this podcast with
- 56:21the vegans you know. Let's encourage more people
- 56:24to take action. Again, thank you so much for
- 56:27caring, and I will see you next Tuesday for a
- 56:30new episode.