Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Stablecoin Supercycle: The GENIUS Catalyst for Bitcoin’s Next Surge
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous extra
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of that business, 1974198792972000
- 0:17and whatever we're going to call this, it's all just the same
- 0:20thing over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we sell. Hey, OK.
- 0:27I say when we sell. This week we sat down with
- 0:34Steven Pollack from the Bitcoin Policy Institute.
- 0:36As you may guess, we talked a lot about policy, what's
- 0:39happening in DC, the federal level, the state level.
- 0:42Talked about the Genius Act as well, which passed the Senate
- 0:45this week, implications for stable coins on dollar
- 0:48dominance, and also Bitcoin adoption.
- 0:50But then we went pretty deep on what is happening with the
- 0:52Bitcoin Policy Institute, what they're seeing on the ground,
- 0:55what they're advocating for, some of the challenges there.
- 0:58And ultimately it tied back into just how early we are with with
- 1:01adoption. We cited A stat about 3%
- 1:04adoption for Bitcoin in the world, maybe lower though,
- 1:07depending on how you measure it. So it's incredibly early.
- 1:10We also talked about some of the things that happened in the
- 1:14Middle East this week with the largest crypto exchange and the
- 1:17believe it was one of the largest banks or perhaps the
- 1:20largest bank in Iran that was attacked, a cyber attack
- 1:24happened this week. And so we just talked about
- 1:26digital and physical security in the context of Bitcoin
- 1:29ultimately ties into what we do here at on ramp.
- 1:32And so you can see here check out our website on
- 1:34rampbitcoin.com. You can sign up in about 15
- 1:37minutes, get access to multi institution custody.
- 1:40You have seamless inheritance planning, financial services
- 1:43support from the team, including you can see Cam there in the
- 1:46bottom right. Or if you just want to learn
- 1:48more about what we do here and how it might be a good fit for
- 1:51you, you can always schedule a consultation here.
- 1:53You see as well on the screen. So hope you enjoyed the episode
- 1:55and maybe we'll see you next week in DC for the Bitcoin
- 1:58Policy Summit. All right, we're live.
- 2:00It's the last trade we're recording Thursday, June 19th.
- 2:04We're here today with Brian Cabela's and Michael Tanguma
- 2:07from On Ramp. And then we have a honorable
- 2:10special guest from the Bitcoin Policy Institute, which will be
- 2:14hosting the Bitcoin Policy Summit next week.
- 2:18Steven Pollock, thank you for joining us.
- 2:20How are you doing? Well, Jackson, Michael, Bryan,
- 2:23thanks for having me on. It is a very busy week in BTI
- 2:29land with the summit next week. So I think I'm doing OK.
- 2:33I'll be doing really well once we, you know, RIP the Band-Aid
- 2:37off and start announcing speakers next Wednesday in DC.
- 2:41Yeah, We appreciate you carving out time.
- 2:42We know it's a busy time for everything going on and you guys
- 2:46are doing special work there. So appreciate you joining us
- 2:48that this week. No, it's a it's an honor.
- 2:51I think it's important to I mean, we've got a lot to talk
- 2:54about just what's happening this week.
- 2:55I know, and you guys got some things you want to hit and and
- 2:58then anyone talk a little bit about the summit.
- 2:59So there there is a ton going on.
- 3:01The world doesn't stop for the Bitcoin policy summit,
- 3:03unfortunately. So, you know, thanks for having
- 3:06me excited to excited to catch you up and and cover some
- 3:09things. Excellent.
- 3:11And yeah, thank you, Steven. Really appreciate you joining.
- 3:14So what we do, just real quick, Michael sometimes gives me
- 3:17grief, but I do it. I don't do it for Michael.
- 3:19I do it for the listeners of this show.
- 3:21We pull up the price just every week, get a baseline of where
- 3:24we're at. So we're trading at about 104.
- 3:27We've actually notably enough, we've been here for probably at
- 3:30this point over 40 days over 100K despite all of the
- 3:35volatility in markets and what's happening in the Middle East and
- 3:38just geopolitical tensions rising.
- 3:41And so I think this is a remarkable thing just to call
- 3:43out. Not to say that anyone on this
- 3:46show or people listening are necessarily short term trading
- 3:49the asset, maybe a few of you are, but we are long term
- 3:51oriented here. And this is just I think a
- 3:53testament to how resilient the market is currently.
- 3:56Curious if we have any thoughts before we talk about something
- 3:58very timely which will be stable coins because some big news just
- 4:02broke this week. Yes, Steven, just to just to
- 4:05call out real quick, the reason, the reason why Jackson focuses
- 4:08on the price is because he's been looking at look taking out
- 4:11leverage for a while and I've been trying to caution him
- 4:13against it. And so he's seen this price
- 4:15fluctuate from 79 back to 110. And he's just trying to figure
- 4:18out if he leverages the house so he can move out into the burbs
- 4:21in Philadelphia if he's going to be stuck in the city for much
- 4:24longer. Yeah, that's smart.
- 4:25I'm glad you guys are talking about that.
- 4:28And, you know, and now I know why he really brought me on was
- 4:30for some financial advice. No, so I mean, Bitcoin has
- 4:35crashed all the way to 104,000, Jackson.
- 4:38So it's a perfect time to go 100X Max full cent.
- 4:41Do you see? I mean, who was it like chef or
- 4:45you know, whoever everyone that's been, you know, been
- 4:49saying Bitcoin was going to die for however many, you know, 10
- 4:52years that there's. There was some like, yeah, now
- 4:55the bitcoins crashed to 104,000, which is the funniest sentence
- 4:58I've read in a very long time. Yeah, people, people love their
- 5:01premature victory laps in the sort of immediate aftermath of
- 5:04some of these geopolitical global shocks.
- 5:08And but it is fascinating, right?
- 5:09Like, I think if we reround the clock a few years, even 12
- 5:13months ago, I think you would have expected Bitcoin to sell
- 5:16off much harder in the wake of, you know, boiling tensions in
- 5:20the Middle East than it than it has this time around.
- 5:23Yeah. In all seriousness, yes, like
- 5:26it's I think it's an incredible feat that bitcoins maintained
- 5:29like 6 figure status through not just, you know, through
- 5:33everything that's happened last couple months and then
- 5:35specifically, yeah, the last couple weeks with but maybe
- 5:38bitcoiners have finally gotten better about fading geopolitical
- 5:41risk. You know, I like normally, you
- 5:45know, something happens, even the, you know, you get a whiff
- 5:48of war or potential war and everything's going down and
- 5:53Bitcoin showing resilience. And I think it's smart to fade
- 5:56that risk. Usually.
- 5:57Usually things are either never nearly as bad as they're made
- 6:00out to be or as good as they're made out to be.
- 6:02So when things, you know, and we're kind of in the as bad as
- 6:05they're made out to be, hopefully we're right to fade
- 6:08the risk. I hope, hope, hopefully this
- 6:10isn't something that in, you know, we're listening to in
- 6:13three weeks. And you're like, man, I wish you
- 6:15wouldn't have said that, but we'll find out soon enough.
- 6:19I'm, I'm not taking any leverage by the way.
- 6:21I guess I'm not sophisticated enough.
- 6:24I'm good with my spot exposure. It's actually.
- 6:26Real quick before transitioning, it is a good thought that maybe
- 6:30that's embedded and we've seen Bitcoin and the the the
- 6:34volatility when real geopolitical risk comes on.
- 6:37I think previous to the tariffs, there was another, there was
- 6:39something else that happened. There's been no shortage, but
- 6:42the most notable, but the tariffs were real.
- 6:45There was real uncertainty in the markets.
- 6:46And that's where we saw a lot of that dipping into 78.
- 6:50I think maybe that's maybe a component of this is that what's
- 6:53happening isn't as big as what the market would try to get you
- 6:56to perceive. And your friend and colleague
- 6:58who was recently on Matthew Pines had a tweet I think last
- 7:02night was said shortly after this Iranian brouhaha concludes.
- 7:05I suspect attention will turn, as it periodically does to G and
- 7:08the silent coupe rumors, you know, and Matt, Matt's a sharp
- 7:12dude, so maybe he kind of is. That's his way of saying
- 7:15there's, you know, this is just a short blip in Bitcoins prices
- 7:18reflecting that. I don't think we've talked about
- 7:20that before. That's come up.
- 7:22That's an interesting angle. Yeah, I think whatever Matthew
- 7:26Pine said, you can, you can just take that to the bank.
- 7:29And I don't have anything to add or detract from that.
- 7:33Learned that I've learned that over the years.
- 7:35I've known Matt a long time. He was our first fellow at
- 7:38Bitcoin Policy Institute. I've been here a few a few years
- 7:42now and he actually wrote the first white paper for BPI.
- 7:45So he other than David and Grant, who like started and
- 7:48launched BPI, Matt is, has been there as long as anyone else
- 7:53writing papers. And so now obviously or not
- 7:56obviously to to some people who don't follow us closely or
- 7:59obsessed over all the details, they're like, he's now our
- 8:01executive director. He's announced that a few months
- 8:03ago. And I mean, we couldn't have
- 8:05made a better choice for spoiled rotten to have him.
- 8:08And he's, yeah, he's one of the sharpest individuals I've met in
- 8:11a long time. And so whatever Matt says goes.
- 8:14TLDR, whatever Matt says. I I generally think even if I
- 8:18don't agree with it, I will and and act accordingly.
- 8:24Totally agree. He's usually one of the highest
- 8:26single folks in the space. And it's great to say that
- 8:29because then you get to talk about Uaps and then kind of
- 8:32counterbalances because then people will naturally have it's,
- 8:35it holds some validity when bringing it up that he's very,
- 8:39very gets in the weeds there. Yeah, that's one of the few
- 8:42people can talk about aliens and people start taking in more
- 8:44seriously, right? Everybody else I know if you
- 8:48start, if you start bringing up aliens or Uaps, you know, start
- 8:50kind of talking about that, suddenly people are just like
- 8:53not listening to you at all. If I, if I started talking about
- 8:55aliens right now, everybody would just turn off the podcast.
- 8:57But when Matt talks about it, everybody's like, Oh yeah, wait
- 9:00a minute. Yeah, I'm taking this seriously.
- 9:02Not too, which is great. Glad we haven't.
- 9:05We do have a lot of alien talk to get through toward the end of
- 9:08this podcast, so I just want people to be aware about that so
- 9:11they stick around until the end of the show, but not too alien
- 9:14talk. One thing I did want to talk
- 9:18about, especially since Stevens on today, let's talk about some
- 9:21policy, one thing that happened this week that is going to be
- 9:25incredibly important for not only Bitcoin, but really I would
- 9:29say this country and certainly the dollar and that's why
- 9:33there's so much embedded interest in it these days, is
- 9:35the Genius Act, which is the stable coin bill passed the
- 9:39Senate by a wide margin this week.
- 9:42And so I want to go through a couple things here and then I
- 9:45want to get reaction. So this is Alex Thorne from
- 9:47Galaxy. We had him on recently.
- 9:49He actually did say something I think is incredibly true about
- 9:52the way to think about the Genius Act is it's a dollar
- 9:55bill. It's not a crypto bill.
- 9:56It's and people in Washington, they recognize that and that's
- 9:59ultimately why there was such widespread approval for it.
- 10:02It's going to support dollar dominance in a world where trust
- 10:06in the US Treasury market, trust in the dollar is decaying.
- 10:09Unfortunately, people are going to be forced to take their
- 10:11medicine. They're going to have to be, you
- 10:13know, buying and disable coins to access dollar liquidity.
- 10:16That's where this all goes. I want to bring this up as well,
- 10:20just a funny post from Donald Trump on Truth Social where
- 10:24we're talking about an incredible bill which ultimately
- 10:27will make America the undisputed leader in digital assets.
- 10:30It's pure genius, he says. So I always just like to bring
- 10:34up the Donnie, but more importantly, we have somewhat
- 10:36more, more balance takes here from the Treasury Secretary.
- 10:41So reactions to the bill here. He besant mentions that
- 10:45stablecoins could grow into a $3.7 trillion market by the end
- 10:48of the decade. And this scenario becomes more
- 10:51likely with the passage of the Genius Act.
- 10:54So he says that a thriving stablecoin ecosystem will drive
- 10:57demand for from the private sector for U.S.
- 11:00Treasuries, which backs stablecoins.
- 11:02This new found demand could lower government borrowing costs
- 11:05and help rain in national debt. It could also on ramp millions
- 11:09of new users across the globe to the dollar based digital asset
- 11:12economy. Also, you can see these hyphens
- 11:14here. I think this was ChatGPT
- 11:16generated, but we all use it. There's no shame in that.
- 11:19And then finally here and then I want to get the group's
- 11:22reactions. We don't have to play the clip,
- 11:23but it was interesting. He mentions this is still the
- 11:27Treasury Secretary mentions a a book that was published this
- 11:30year called King Dollar. And I forget who authored it,
- 11:32but it was someone who's been adjacent to the Treasury for
- 11:37about 40 years and talks about how every time there's a lot of
- 11:40narratives about the end of the dollar, you know, the dollar is
- 11:43done, etcetera. There's always a new narrative,
- 11:46there's always a new shift in the market structure that
- 11:48extends dollar dominance. And so Besson talks about how
- 11:52stablecoins is ultimately going to be the tool to extend dollar
- 11:57dominance and get U.S. Treasuries in the hands of more
- 11:59people. So big news here.
- 12:01Maybe, Steven, I'll toss it over to you.
- 12:02First is our Guest of the week. Just initial reactions to the
- 12:07Genius Act passing the Senate. Yeah, I think, well, first of
- 12:13all, I know Senator Bill Haggerty and his team have been
- 12:15working on this a long time. And I'm, I'm a Tennessee guy.
- 12:18He's one of my senators here along with Senator Blackburn.
- 12:22And, and so, you know, shout out to them.
- 12:24They've pushed and pushed on this and has to feel good to get
- 12:27this across the finish line there in the Senate.
- 12:30Great, great guy, great team. And you don't get things like
- 12:34this done without. I mean, you can be the most
- 12:37incredible, you know, Senator since you know whoever and but
- 12:42without a good team around you, just you just don't get these
- 12:45kinds of things done. And I think what's really,
- 12:47really stands out to me is the vote count 68 to 30 with quite a
- 12:56few Democrats voting in favor. I think that's, I think that's
- 13:00pretty bullish for not just this, but like sort of the some
- 13:04of the other priorities for the administration and then
- 13:08specifically for, for Bitcoin and digital assets.
- 13:11So that's what I'm saying. And I think that's, I think it's
- 13:13fantastic. Glad it passed.
- 13:15It hasn't been like a major focal point for BPI for obvious
- 13:18reasons, but we, you know, it's glad it got glad they got it
- 13:22done. And I think you know kind of
- 13:24what it signals is is also really important.
- 13:29Yeah, 100%. I think it's it's a signal, at
- 13:32least for one that they're serious about this stuff.
- 13:34And I think there was always an order of operations to you know,
- 13:37how Senator alumnus has talked about this, that stablecoin bill
- 13:40would come first. And so now there's been real
- 13:43follow through on that and even Trump's tweet being like, you
- 13:46know, no delays on this, get this to my desk ASAP.
- 13:49I'm ready to sign. It is all super constructive.
- 13:53I think, you know, something that we've talked about a bit in
- 13:57the past and, and Michael and I have sort of been thinking about
- 14:00is like, I think you can get tripped up by thinking like this
- 14:03is not good for Bitcoin in the sense that, you know, if you're
- 14:06extending dollar dominance, you know, that sort of impinges
- 14:11perhaps bitcoins adoption, particularly in the medium of
- 14:14exchange realm. But I think that's missing the
- 14:17larger picture of general normalization of digital monies
- 14:22and crypto rails that is now about to proliferate in a, in a
- 14:26real way. And so I think it's, it's
- 14:29insanely bullish for Bitcoin because, you know, we are as a,
- 14:34as a country, as a, as an administration leaning in
- 14:37heavily to crypto native dollars.
- 14:41And what that, what the 2nd order effect of that is, is that
- 14:44Bitcoin becomes a natural extension of someone's
- 14:48understanding of this, this sort of new realm of, of how money
- 14:51operates. And it'll become commonplace.
- 14:54The frictions will be reduced to effectively spending dollars and
- 14:58saving Bitcoin. And I kind of think that's where
- 15:00this is all headed. And this is a really first, you
- 15:03know, important first step in, in terms of normalizing that
- 15:07sort of ideology or or line of thinking.
- 15:09Yeah, I think, I think like there's nothing really new under
- 15:13the sun. You know, we know history
- 15:15repeats itself. But also in the crypto cycles,
- 15:18like you can probably go back to 9 to 12 or 13 and 13 to 1717 to
- 15:232121 to 25. Like they're naturally when you
- 15:28hear about like the Bitcoin individual talk about the having
- 15:32cycles and having cycles, the way I look at them is
- 15:34accelerated business cycles because you ultimately don't
- 15:37have anybody like animal spirits come in because it's a free
- 15:40market. And then liquidity things
- 15:43deleverage and you kind of wash out the bad actors.
- 15:46And we saw FTX Celsius block 5 point and sharing that is it's
- 15:49similar to I had this acknowledgement or realization a
- 15:52few months ago when I don't know what it was, whether it was
- 15:55percent or somebody realizing like this bill was going to
- 15:58happen at some point and it was going to be insanely bullish for
- 16:01BTC. And also just for the
- 16:03recognition of what Brian was alluding to is digital money,
- 16:06because this is how Tether has operated.
- 16:08This was the main reason for Tether and the trading pair with
- 16:12Tether and BTC. But then also how Circle and
- 16:15before it was called Circle, I forgot the consortium that was
- 16:18built on was around FX trading for BTC to dollars and really
- 16:23net settling capital accounts after hours and on weekends
- 16:27because the banking system didn't.
- 16:28If you're going to provide tight spreads, you need to be able to
- 16:32settle those assets. Obviously super microscopic
- 16:36example, but in the same way FTX is going to be microscopic
- 16:39versus what's going to happen with these treasury companies.
- 16:41And whatever else is going to come down, at least from my
- 16:43point of view, because we've already seen these things.
- 16:45We've seen what happens with centralization, we've seen what
- 16:47happens with counterparty risk and so similar we've seen what
- 16:50happens when you inject a little bit of, you know, digital
- 16:54dollars into the bet cone ecosystem and how that supports
- 16:57bitcoins price. And so to Brian's point, like
- 16:59now we see, you know, part of that bill is interesting about
- 17:03fintechs and other companies within certain, you know,
- 17:07regulatory, you know, framework, they can actually launch
- 17:10stablecoins. And so we saw Walmart, Amazon
- 17:13and other firms come to the table that they're working on
- 17:16this stuff. And so the notion that every
- 17:18bank and every checking account and every wallet you on board to
- 17:21is going to have, you know, U.S. dollar that can be converted to
- 17:24BTC. I don't see how like Jackson was
- 17:27looking for $1,000,000 call from Brian so he could have a, a big
- 17:30thing to push. I don't see how we don't get to
- 17:32these like crazy prices if all this stuff comes to fruition in
- 17:35the next 2024 months because it just normalizes that there's a
- 17:39digital form of money and bitcoins right next to that
- 17:41after you get your dollars. So what's the price target then?
- 17:47No, I'm just kidding. I'm curious like anyone in the
- 17:52group, how I should think about and how people should think
- 17:54about just stable coins as it relates to the financial
- 17:58services companies stepping in. Like you think about banks and
- 18:02Wall Street stepping into stable coin markets versus technology
- 18:05companies. We don't need to spend a ton of
- 18:07time on it, but like just an interesting, interesting
- 18:11development. We'll see, you know, Fortune 500
- 18:13companies of all shapes and sizes, I guess look to launch
- 18:16stable coin. So how do I think about that?
- 18:19It's a good, it's a good question because this is
- 18:21something I've sort of wrestled with around stable coins for a
- 18:25while. Is like, well, you don't need
- 18:26like dozens or hundreds of different stable coin issuers.
- 18:30Like I, I don't see a world where you know, you have your
- 18:33Amazon stable coin, you have your bank stable coin.
- 18:35Like I do think that, you know, there will be sort of winner
- 18:39take most over time with these things where I think it gets
- 18:42really interesting is like, OK, well, how does that occur?
- 18:44How does that play out? How do these issuers actually
- 18:47differentiate between each other?
- 18:50And I think where it ultimately ends up going is like, you have
- 18:53to offer some sort of yield or return on holding the stable
- 18:57coin. So like right now, Tether just
- 18:59takes all of that yield for themselves, buys Bitcoin, buys
- 19:02gold, et cetera. They're not passing any of that
- 19:04along to the actual holders of the stable coins.
- 19:07So I think that's a natural progression of this is you're
- 19:10going to see people have to differentiate to out compete
- 19:13each other and offering, you know, some form of yield,
- 19:16whether that's just from the treasuries backing them
- 19:18themselves or it's partially backed by Bitcoin.
- 19:21And then you're passing along some, you know, portion of the
- 19:23appreciation of Bitcoin in your reserves.
- 19:25That's the really interesting thing to me that I think is an
- 19:28open question of how this evolves because I, I, I don't
- 19:31see a world where there's, you know, 100 different stable coins
- 19:34and none of them are doing anything different.
- 19:38Yeah. I mean, I, I line there, I think
- 19:41like the, the more macro theme is we go back to free banking
- 19:46and free banking is the maybe it's not exact free banking, but
- 19:49it's basically reputation based. So in a world where Amazon's
- 19:54effectively going to be a bank because they can naturally issue
- 19:56these stable coins into to Brian's point, they will not
- 19:59only have feature sets because they have a large customer base,
- 20:02but then what do they provide, whether it's discounts or.
- 20:05A creative, you know, passing back whatever yields or however
- 20:08they're backing it. We had this conversation over
- 20:11like maybe a year and a half ago with Joe Rebel when Wyoming was
- 20:14talking about announcing their sovereign stable coin and backed
- 20:17by kind of, you know, assets based in the state of Wyoming.
- 20:20And we kind of work through in real time how this was the
- 20:23natural progression of all stable coins are going to have
- 20:25to back with the most credible asset, which is BTBTC.
- 20:29And then it was interesting because Safe had a similar talk,
- 20:32you know, at this past conference referencing it's just
- 20:34the logical progression that Tether, they're already doing
- 20:36this with gold land and treasuries backing their stable
- 20:39coin because that's what's implied, right?
- 20:41If the, the stable ever deep eggs, you naturally are going to
- 20:44have these other assets for the credible to make people whole.
- 20:47And so that's where I think this all goes is just free banking.
- 20:49And then you'll have interoperable dollars, but then
- 20:52people have certain affiliations, affinity via brand
- 20:54recognition to start, because everyone knows who JP Morgan is.
- 20:59But as volatility inserts into the system, then you're
- 21:04naturally going to start to have reputation based on who you want
- 21:08your dollars to be parked with. One thing we didn't touch on
- 21:11here is while stable coins are going to be great, it's also
- 21:13going to actually accelerate this notion of bank runs and
- 21:16movement of capital. And there's going to be
- 21:17increased volatility because now money can move a lot freer.
- 21:21And I don't think people are prepared for that, including the
- 21:23people that are passing these bills because you can't actually
- 21:25prepare. I mean, we all know what
- 21:26happened with SVB and that would they, you know, put a product of
- 21:30that is because of digital flows in the in a banking era, that's
- 21:33online. Well, what happens when you can
- 21:35move it at 3:00 AM? There's a big problem there.
- 21:39Yeah, with, with bills like this or, you know, guidance or any
- 21:46sort of there's, there's AI, don't know if it's a motto, but
- 21:48the way I think about it is like you have regulation or
- 21:52deregulation, but I call it regulation because you're just
- 21:56saying what the rules are, you know, and if it's a
- 21:57deregulation, you're just, you know, there's less rules, you're
- 22:00just restating the rules. So regulation and you said you
- 22:04get regulatory clarity, regulation, then you have
- 22:07proliferation. So then everybody jumps in the
- 22:09market, nobody tries to do it. And then you have consolidation.
- 22:14And so you have your regulation, you have your proliferation, you
- 22:16have your consolidation. And I think we're going to see
- 22:18that. I don't know how many years it
- 22:20takes for that to play out. I don't think it's going to be
- 22:23like a consolidation, a sense of like what we've seen in some
- 22:26things. You mentioned bank runs and
- 22:28hopefully it's not, you know, sort of banks collapsing and,
- 22:32you know, rug pulls like we saw in the whole Define mess a
- 22:35couple years ago. And, and so, but I think we're
- 22:39going to see lots of people try lots of different things to get
- 22:41really creative. Kind of like, you know, we're
- 22:44seeing now different Fortune 500 companies sort of floating the
- 22:48idea that they might be doing something, looking at their
- 22:51competitors, see even if it's worth it.
- 22:55And then some of them are going to probably regret that or
- 22:59they're not going to, you know, you're going to see other people
- 23:00do it better. I think it's going to slowly
- 23:02kind of come back together, not to like a single currency or
- 23:05anything like that, but those are going to be definitely going
- 23:07to be a number of winners and losers in the sense of, you
- 23:11know, and I think what you said like the Bitcoin backed type of
- 23:14stables or if there's any sort of, you know, way to kind of L
- 23:18to it, that could be interesting.
- 23:20I think it's going to. I think if you don't do that,
- 23:22you probably wish you had. Yeah, just Speaking of all these
- 23:26different, you know, threat factors and I guess risk to
- 23:29consider. Steven and Michael, you both
- 23:31mentioned bank runs. Something that happened this
- 23:33week in Iran was both the largest crypto exchange there
- 23:37was hacked. They had hot wallets that were
- 23:39hacked and nearly 100 million was drained from those hot
- 23:42wallets and then I guess just burned.
- 23:44And then also I think it was the largest bank as well.
- 23:48There was a cyber attack that took place this week.
- 23:50And so I'm curious just like general thoughts on the the
- 23:57evolving digital threat landscape, Like we're obviously
- 23:59in this very tumultuous time, you know, from a very macro
- 24:03level with tensions seemingly rising every day or at least
- 24:07fluctuating back and forth. And there's just a lot of
- 24:09uncertainty in the market and, and things are evolving to, you
- 24:12know, financial warfare. And so I think a lot of what we
- 24:15need to think about in this space, and it could certainly
- 24:18tie into policy, is just how to ensure that there are adequate
- 24:23protections around Bitcoin custody infrastructure and how
- 24:27people should be thinking about these concerns.
- 24:29I mean, there's also something else we want to talk about that
- 24:31I believe we hit record on a massive data breach.
- 24:34So there's a lot of different directions we could go in.
- 24:36But this is going to be incredibly important for people
- 24:39to think about as we go forward because of course, Bitcoin's at
- 24:43100K and it's a beautiful thing to be able to protect your
- 24:46wealth in something so scarce, finite.
- 24:48And the flip side of that, of course, is that it's becoming
- 24:52increasingly valuable. And Bitcoin is going to become,
- 24:56if not it already is a asset that a lot of malicious actors
- 25:01are going to be coming after. And then of course, you have to
- 25:03think about the old, you know, the traditional financial system
- 25:05in that context as well. So curious, just like between
- 25:07the the few piece of news that I cited this week, if there's any
- 25:11reactions there or or thoughts you want to share?
- 25:15We, we talked about this, I'll be brief.
- 25:17We talked about this earlier because we had a pod with
- 25:20Brahman. I think it goes to the notion of
- 25:23just like custody in general and how their traditional financial
- 25:26institutions aren't necessarily prepared for Bitcoin custody
- 25:29because the way that they traditionally have done it is
- 25:31via omnibus structures. And so you're housing a pooled
- 25:33amount of assets and you have a Ledger and a database.
- 25:36And while the assets are secure and you can know where the
- 25:40Bitcoin is via, you know, the blockchain of the UTXO said, you
- 25:43don't actually necessarily, you don't have a bulletproof version
- 25:46of unless you keep them offline records whose Bitcoin tracks to
- 25:51whose ownership. And so this kind of like I've
- 25:54been thinking about it more and more, but the Iranian situation,
- 25:57there was multiple, one was the banking system was supposedly
- 26:04hacked. But then we brought this up
- 26:05like, well, what if they just said, you know, their accounts
- 26:07were wiped out or they couldn't access it?
- 26:08But like what happened in the world where somebody says they
- 26:11were hacked in there? They weren't like, how do you
- 26:13prove that it was, you know, Iran that was hacked by external
- 26:16partners versus they, you know, their balance sheet was offsides
- 26:19and they couldn't make holes. So what a convenient way to say
- 26:22and you get, you know, made pennies on the dollar or
- 26:24whatever. So that's just one angle on the
- 26:26banking side. But then on the the crypto side,
- 26:29there was an exchange that was hacked and they burned the
- 26:30Bitcoin or whatever crypto assets.
- 26:32But point being is there's going to be other ways like obviously
- 26:37what we do with multi institution custody, there's, we
- 26:39don't talk about it enough, but that there's three independent
- 26:41custodians that are effectively attesting to the Providence of
- 26:46the Bitcoin because again, it's just still it's nerdy and early,
- 26:50but it's never been done where you have an address on chain and
- 26:52you can basically have three independent regulated custodians
- 26:55say that BTC belongs to that person because they've all gone
- 26:58through the onboarding process. And the point where that's
- 27:01valuable is because not only is the record there, but via
- 27:05multiple jurisdictions, but also could be multiple jurisdictions.
- 27:09It's not an omnibus. So it's directly tied to that
- 27:12person. But if something bad happens to
- 27:141 entity and they get wiped out completely, EMP or whatever you
- 27:18want to like make up, the assets are still going to be a track or
- 27:21a record, which that just historically wouldn't be there
- 27:24in an omnibus fashion depending on the construct.
- 27:27So they're just going to be a lot of things.
- 27:28I think they're in the digital age that I don't think we
- 27:30thought. And that's outside of just all
- 27:32the data leaks that are coming and then the realization that
- 27:35physical attacks are increasing because most people don't
- 27:38realize people are holding 500K in their house and when they do,
- 27:42it's going to be a very bad day. Yeah, I, I the only other thing
- 27:46that's very well articulated, but the where mine mine goes
- 27:50with this is sort of higher level, more bird's eye.
- 27:53Like what is the, you know, while these types of events are
- 27:56very unfortunate for the individuals and the citizens
- 27:59involved, like if there's any silver lining, like it is in my
- 28:04mind a very important catalyst for education and learning.
- 28:07Like these events speak directly to why Bitcoin exists, the
- 28:11ability to have, you know, decentralized ownership, better
- 28:17property rights, greater assurances over your ownership
- 28:20is, you know, speaks directly to the value prop and merit of
- 28:23Bitcoin. And so it's, it's sort of akin
- 28:25to like, you know, when the Canadian truckers happened a few
- 28:28years ago, like that was a big wake up call for people and it
- 28:32educated a lot of people on the merits of Bitcoin.
- 28:34And so while they're unfortunate in the moment, like I, I do
- 28:37think that it's kind of just the necessary pain to to help
- 28:40educate and catalyze education on why Bitcoin exists.
- 28:47Yeah, I, I think where, where my mind goes, I mean, it's a, you
- 28:51know, kind of kicking that off. It's a between, you know, data
- 28:55breach like privacy, the kind of bite of the elephant.
- 29:00I think that we're focused on right now and think you'll see
- 29:03next week. We kind of talked about what
- 29:05what BP is working on next week. One of our major focuses is on
- 29:09this clarity Act, which is sort of this market structure Bill
- 29:13and another another focus, and it's kind of part and parcel of
- 29:18that that we've been working on for over a year is the PDP
- 29:22rights fund, PDP rights campaign.
- 29:24So peer-to-peer rights, privacy tools, not non custodial
- 29:28developers, self custody. I think it this when, when these
- 29:34things sort of, you know, bubble up to the surface of the public
- 29:37consciousness, when you see whatever it was 60 billion
- 29:40people or whatever that got, it's not funny.
- 29:44It's just so ridiculous. 16 billion, sorry, only 16 billion
- 29:52people had their data leaked. This is sort of top of mind.
- 29:56It's an opportunity to to to highlight something that a lot
- 30:01of times when, when I'm talking with someone who doesn't, you
- 30:05know, isn't super familiar with Bitcoin or quite understand the
- 30:09rationale behind why it's so valuable or why it's important.
- 30:14You talk about like self custody and they're like, OK, whatever,
- 30:17you know, self custody hasn't really isn't really something at
- 30:21least U.S. citizens have been that concerned about or felt
- 30:24that they needed to be that concerned about.
- 30:27But when you look at you start seeing leaks and things and it's
- 30:30like, oh, that's your personal information.
- 30:31Suddenly it, it sort of sort sort of makes sense.
- 30:34A lot of times I've had to share stories or kind of make up
- 30:39scenarios for people in third world countries and it's like,
- 30:42oh, that clicks. People understand why self
- 30:45custody is important when you're, you know, in Afghanistan
- 30:48or whatever, right? Whenever you're in Iran right
- 30:51now, your regime's being able to thrown and there's all this like
- 30:54turmoil. And I think when they see these
- 30:56type of headlines to understand, they start to understand it a
- 31:00little, internalize it a little more versus just, you know, it's
- 31:03like 3 seconds. And I'm moving on to what I'm
- 31:05having for dinner tonight. And I'm not that worried about
- 31:07it. Everything's going to be fine.
- 31:09So when we look at and we're doing a lot, we're focusing on
- 31:12the so the BRCBRCA language that that was really important has
- 31:17now been incorporated the clarity Act.
- 31:19And so clarity Acts, what we're focusing on.
- 31:21We're going to be talking about a lot of the summit and this
- 31:25protects or, you know, stops the Bank Secrecy Act from applying
- 31:30to non custodial developers. Non custodial tools protect self
- 31:33custody. So I think that's how that's
- 31:37what I see. I'm like, man, we have to get
- 31:39this done and it's more important than ever to be able
- 31:45to to allow, you know, free individuals to access these type
- 31:50of tools, freedom tools. So that's like, that's my bite.
- 31:56I've seen that, Apple. I'm curious from your vantage,
- 32:00is there similar bipartisan support for the stuff that you
- 32:06just referenced in the Clarity Act?
- 32:08You know, relative to what we saw with the stable coin bill,
- 32:10where I think it was pretty easy to get people on board for, as
- 32:13we said, like this is a dollar bill, not really a crypto bill.
- 32:15Do you see similar support or is there more dissidents on that
- 32:19side? I hope so.
- 32:21I, I really do. I think there's an article kind
- 32:25of came out earlier this week that, you know, not all
- 32:29Democrats hate digital assets like you're kind of taught to
- 32:34think or told to think. I think there's a lot of
- 32:36centrist Democrats that are, that are friendlier than it than
- 32:39it seems. And again, that's why I'm
- 32:41bullish on the genius act passing like a dead.
- 32:42It can kind of signals like, hey, maybe there's maybe more
- 32:45allies here. He would otherwise think so.
- 32:48And I think, you know, I don't think it's a long shot to pass
- 32:51clarity. I think I think I think we can
- 32:54get it done. There's not a slam dunk by any
- 32:57stretch. And you know, I think if you
- 32:59look at you look at our agenda for next week at the summit to
- 33:02be surprised seat, it's not just Republicans who are speaking at
- 33:05a big point policy summit. So again, I think we do, I think
- 33:10we do well to in this, you know, BPI, we're a, we're A5O1C3,
- 33:15we're non profit. So in our charters, we're, we're
- 33:18non partisan and we've always maintained that we will work
- 33:23with anyone who's willing to work with us.
- 33:24I don't care who you are or you know what you said a month ago,
- 33:28if you're like, oh, no, you know what?
- 33:30I want to work. We, we have, we have short,
- 33:33short memories and we'll work with everybody because it, the
- 33:36stakes are too high to, for us to or for anyone, I think to
- 33:41play games, you know, Hey, you know, I didn't understand, but
- 33:44there were, there was a time not that long ago, you know, a few
- 33:47years ago that I didn't understand anything about
- 33:48Bitcoin either, you know, and, and so I think we're, I think
- 33:53it's an industry we do well to remain arms open and embrace
- 33:56both sides at as often as as we possibly can.
- 34:01And I think that's what we're seeing, man.
- 34:02I think that's one thing Bitcoiners are great about, you
- 34:05know, kind of the heart and soul of it is, is welcoming people in
- 34:09and and helping educate, get them up to speed, help them
- 34:12understand being patient. And that's and I take it, you
- 34:19know, one step further. We have a, we haven't done this
- 34:23before, but I don't mean to go on and on about the summit, but
- 34:27it's a good time to mention this.
- 34:28I had made a note because I'm really proud of it.
- 34:31It's not something we've done, but we did a day two this year
- 34:34for the summit. So Summit's on Wednesday, day
- 34:362's on Thursday and we stood up a day on the Hill, which I don't
- 34:41know if you guys have ever been on a day on the Hill or heard of
- 34:44a day on the Hill. But it's sort of this industry
- 34:46play where you know, if you're a trade association or whatever,
- 34:49which we're not, or a lobbying group, you bring your clients in
- 34:54or you bring, you know, a bunch of construction workers in or
- 34:58whatever, whatever your industry is.
- 35:00And you take them to Capitol Hill.
- 35:02You walk around the halls, you meet, greet, greet, meet and
- 35:05greet, you know, staffers and elected officials.
- 35:08And we've never done that just for a few reasons, but we felt
- 35:13like it was the time was right. Ken Egan, who's our government
- 35:15affairs director, helped stand us up.
- 35:17And man, we have sold out. We have so many Bitcoin, not
- 35:24that just coming to DC, but staying for a second day and
- 35:27then going on the Capitol Hill and meeting some of them.
- 35:31They're elected officials, some of them that they just want to
- 35:33kind of like, you know, meet generally with staffers and talk
- 35:37about Bitcoin. I think of any industry of any,
- 35:41of any trade group, if you're just bringing like people who
- 35:44don't do this every day, I have, I would bet on Bitcoiners to be
- 35:48able to bridge the gap, whether it's people who staffers who
- 35:53maybe kind of understand a little bit, want to know more
- 35:55people are maybe a little hostile.
- 35:56I trust the Bitcoin crew. I think we have like almost 200
- 36:00people going to Capitol Hill next Thursday.
- 36:03And and so I'm super excited to hear what comes of that.
- 36:07And I think, you know, I think we're seeing like, I think if I
- 36:10did this two years ago, we said, let's do a day on the hill.
- 36:12I don't know if anybody came. They're really why.
- 36:14What do we do? You know what we do up here?
- 36:15And now I think it's starting to get it.
- 36:17Bitcoiners are getting it and they're like, no, we're showing
- 36:18up. We want to do it.
- 36:19Let's go. So really, really sad about it.
- 36:22No, I, it's, it's well said and I think that that's something
- 36:25that that doesn't get talked about or is underappreciated
- 36:29enough is the economic weight as Bitcoin grows to execute on what
- 36:35you just described. Because you know, not a student
- 36:38of this, but you go back to choke .1 point O with gambling
- 36:41sites and other kind of like illicit or quote UN quote
- 36:44illicit services that were cut off.
- 36:48And you go back to even like firearms and some of the
- 36:51unconstitutional ways that you have to register and manage that
- 36:53aren't necessarily, and I know like the, what is the big group
- 36:58for? Not the I guess the NRA like
- 37:00there's a there's a lot of like push and pull, but historically
- 37:03it all goes into One Direction, which is centralization of
- 37:06control. But and it's still early in this
- 37:09game, but it's trending in the direction of positive.
- 37:12What Stevens saying, because historically you didn't have the
- 37:14unit growing and purchasing power and starting to embed in
- 37:17self in different politicians pockets.
- 37:20But also the people that are fighting for these things that
- 37:22are actually getting wealthier and able to affect their express
- 37:25their version of the the future and how they want.
- 37:28And it's really this whole like every time we look at Bitcoin,
- 37:30it just gets crazy and crazier. The amount of alignment of
- 37:33incentives, and I think that's what Stevens referencing
- 37:36specifically around two years ago, well, Bitcoin's price was,
- 37:38you know, 50% less or whatever. So you don't just have the
- 37:40economic weight and coordination that you can from the highest
- 37:43levels to the president all the way down to individuals.
- 37:46And so that's that notion of I think where a lot of people feel
- 37:48the inevitability because as long as Bitcoin's successful,
- 37:50you're going to naturally be able to do that.
- 37:52The last thing that that says that's kind of the meta angle of
- 37:55everyone gets Bitcoin at the price they deserve.
- 37:57It's because it's this notion that like the people that were
- 38:00meant to see or adopt Bitcoin at the time were the people that
- 38:03were going to affect the change. And then it's kind of like the
- 38:05center of Warrens that are the last people to see it.
- 38:06It's like, yeah, you kind of don't want her to have really
- 38:08much control in the future. So it's like it was always that
- 38:10taken. I think that's the sub context
- 38:12of a lot of these memes that are really expressed have a lot of
- 38:15validity to them. So anyway, I think that that
- 38:18what we're seeing is just kind of playing out.
- 38:19And if we're here today at 100K, just crazy.
- 38:22What is it going to be at 250 K, $500 million in the amount of
- 38:26change we're going to see in the world?
- 38:28All right. And I think, sorry, I'll let one
- 38:30of you guys hop in on your, on your podcast here soon.
- 38:33But I, you said economic weight and, and that, you know, brought
- 38:38this to mind. I think I'm sure Matt probably
- 38:40brought this up when he was on, but do you guys talk about the
- 38:44sort of like gold versus Bitcoin US holdings?
- 38:47Did he hit that the other day? You know, US holds roughly of
- 38:51gold supply like around 10% of total gold supply.
- 38:54United States holds between like individuals, companies and
- 38:57government around 40% of Bitcoin.
- 38:59And so you're like a $2 trillion asset, 40% of its domestic, you
- 39:04know, either in somebody's hands inside these walls, you know,
- 39:08inside these inside the borders, the United States, that economic
- 39:12weight. And then when you begin to, like
- 39:14you said, project that out over what's this going to be in two
- 39:17years and five years, you know, not just the market cap, but the
- 39:21percentage of the economy market cap.
- 39:23You know, it's hard to know, like you say it's a $10 trillion
- 39:26asset, but you know, what's happened with inflation in those
- 39:291020 years. But the percentage of wealth and
- 39:33the the, the demographic of Bitcoin owners and suddenly you
- 39:40realize how they're like, yeah, OK, we need to we need to get,
- 39:43we need to, you know, interact with these guys.
- 39:45We want to hear what this industry has to say.
- 39:48We want to start kind of listening.
- 39:49And it's when you hear JD Vance, Vice President Vance at the
- 39:53Bitcoin conference in Las Vegas, get up there.
- 39:57One of his main points was we need to not try to be this
- 40:01bureaucracy telling you guys what to do.
- 40:04The second most powerful man in the world.
- 40:07On track to be the most powerful man in the world.
- 40:10Like he's got. Last I checked, he was like plus
- 40:12250 odds to be the next president.
- 40:14Next closest was +2000. So, you know, one in three odds.
- 40:18This is the, you know #2 guy for four years, number one guy
- 40:23probably for eight years. So 12 years, You know, Pop two
- 40:27said, we want to listen to you. We want to know what you think
- 40:31we want to hear. And I think we need to do a
- 40:33better job of that. And I don't think I've I've made
- 40:39this point a lot. So this last week.
- 40:42But like, this is not a campaign speech either.
- 40:44This isn't a guy who's like trying to jump off some votes,
- 40:46trying to get some, you know, donations.
- 40:48He's not running for office. He's good.
- 40:50You know, he's not in the midterm, he's getting elected in
- 40:53the midterms. He's good Now he's got a
- 40:55presidential campaign coming up, but like he's saying he really
- 41:00means it. You know, there's policy
- 41:02reasons, not campaign reasons that he's saying some of these
- 41:04things. So I it's.
- 41:06And just to be clear, mind blowing.
- 41:07Stevens referenced referencing like future potential nominees
- 41:12or bids to be president. Not saying something's going to
- 41:14happen to Trump and Vance would be coming in because there are
- 41:17some conspiracy theorists. No, no, yeah, I'm saying I'm
- 41:20saying that's why it's a 12. Years or whatever.
- 41:23Yeah, All right, Yeah, I I'm like, there's no telling what I
- 41:26just said on accident, so thanks for telling me.
- 41:29You're. Yeah, I think it'll be.
- 41:30I think it'll be. I think it's, I think it's one
- 41:33of the coolest things I've. I I heard was him, was him
- 41:35speaking to Congo. Trump speaking last year was
- 41:38awesome. But that's a guy campaigning for
- 41:40president. He's not.
- 41:42It wasn't the president and this is the actual vice president.
- 41:44And I think sometimes we get those people have been like, you
- 41:46know, it wasn't Trump, but, you know, JD did pretty good.
- 41:49Like now this is a complete paradigm shift.
- 41:52It was wild. And you, you were too humble to
- 41:54admit that he mentioned the, the Bitcoin Policy Institute as well
- 41:58in that speech. I forgot about that.
- 42:01Sure. Well, you know, a lot of what
- 42:04you said resonates with me because I, I was thinking about
- 42:08that the week of the conference. The fact that it, I think it
- 42:13wasn't Vance's speech where he cites 50 million Americans owned
- 42:17crypto or Bitcoin, however he phrased it, but then we talked
- 42:21about it before, might have been a recurring theme of the show
- 42:24where sure, 50 million people have maybe a Coinbase account or
- 42:29a Kraken account, whatever, and they have $100.00 of Dogecoin
- 42:32and $200.00 of Bitcoin. But when you really drill down,
- 42:35it's a very small contingent of people who have a material
- 42:40allocation to Bitcoin and have a deep understanding of the
- 42:43technology and of the asset. And so that even puts it into
- 42:47more perspective, the fact that you do have the sitting vice
- 42:50president going to an industry conference to address a crowd of
- 42:5535,000 people. And then maybe it's streamed
- 42:57out, you know, a couple 100,000 over YouTube and socials.
- 43:01But we're incredibly early, right?
- 43:04Just to put that in perspective, we have the incentives aligning
- 43:10from the highest powers from the most for the most influential
- 43:14people in the world that are now coalescing around Bitcoin.
- 43:18And in large part, I think Steven, it does tie into the
- 43:21stat you mentioned about 40% of the wealth or industry.
- 43:25However I want to think about it or we think about it of Bitcoin
- 43:28sits within the United States. And I, I don't know, I don't, I
- 43:31don't know every single industry enough to say if there are any
- 43:35others where there's that much concentration within the borders
- 43:38of the United States. But my gut instinct is there's
- 43:41not. And so I'm really curious, you
- 43:44know, we talked a little bit about just the support as a
- 43:46whole, But I would love to hear in a little more detail the
- 43:50conversations that are happening now in DC at the federal level,
- 43:55at the state level. And as politicians and other
- 43:59stakeholders really come to terms with the amount of
- 44:02influence and the amount of wealth and technology that
- 44:07exists within the United States for Bitcoin specifically.
- 44:10And why and how, what you know, what's going on behind the
- 44:13scenes now that is going to keep the United States as the leader?
- 44:17Yeah, well, let me, I'll, I'm going to answer your question a
- 44:20few different ways, but one, and, and this isn't something
- 44:23I've actually said before, but as you were saying, it kind of
- 44:26combined a few, a few thoughts. If I'm a politician and either
- 44:32just trying to do a good job, which I think there are a lot of
- 44:35those that are like, hey, I'm here.
- 44:36It's it's sort of public service.
- 44:42You know, I don't know if I'm the best person for the job.
- 44:44I'm one of the best, but I'm, I'm the one in the job and I'm
- 44:46going to, I want to do well by my constituents.
- 44:48I, I genuinely believe that, that there are many politicians
- 44:51that that's the way they operate.
- 44:52I know not everybody will agree with that assessment, but I've
- 44:54worked with a lot of them over the years.
- 44:57And but whether it's that or whether it's sort of the, and I
- 45:01always, always do this because there's so many different people
- 45:03who listen and kind of see it different ways.
- 45:05And I don't think it matters if it's, if you're a little more
- 45:08cynical about it, right? And you're like, I just think
- 45:10they're in it for the, you know, whatever the money or the power
- 45:12or whatever, I don't think it matters.
- 45:15I think if I'm a politician and I'm looking and I say, you know,
- 45:19there's 50 million people using digital that have digital assets
- 45:22in America. And I think you raise the point
- 45:24like, well, most of them like what couple 100 bucks got a
- 45:27little bit on Robin Hood or whatever the case is and they
- 45:31dabbled. They probably got rugged a
- 45:32couple times. You know, they're buying, they
- 45:34bought a little Bitcoin. They got $100 in Bitcoin in
- 45:36case, you know what if, you know, they got a little bit of
- 45:39doge, whatever. We rewind to the 90s.
- 45:44I think probably there were people on a podcast similar to
- 45:47this. I don't know if they had
- 45:48podcasts. They didn't have podcasts.
- 45:50They're on a whatever little public forum and, and meeting
- 45:57and, and talking about the Internet, right?
- 46:00And maybe a chat room, one of the first first Gen. chat rooms.
- 46:04But they're like, Hey, you know, how many million people and
- 46:08maybe the late 90s by that point, how many million people?
- 46:10There's X million people that have Internet access in the
- 46:13United States. And people like us from the
- 46:17Internet Policy Institute are probably like, yeah, but like,
- 46:20come on, man. Like if only a million of those
- 46:22people really even know what the Internet is and really use it on
- 46:25a daily basis, you can say that millions and millions of people
- 46:28have Internet access. But like, they don't even, you
- 46:31know, they don't barely even know to turn on a computer.
- 46:33And I think we're in a similar spot.
- 46:35I think you guys think that too. Yeah.
- 46:38These people only have a little bit now and I'm only dabbled in
- 46:40it now, but you, what do you, what do you do before you become
- 46:46a daily user of like the Internet, you have it.
- 46:48I remember the reason I brought up chat rooms is and this came
- 46:51to mind. I remember the first time I used
- 46:54the Internet. I had an uncle. him and I were
- 46:56both like really into dirt bikes.
- 46:58I was young, you know, and he, you know, he got me into dirt
- 47:01bikes and like talking about dirt bikes and super fun.
- 47:04And he was over at my house and he was kind of the tech guy of
- 47:08our family tree. He was like, check this out, you
- 47:10know, and he plugged in, you know, plugged our phone into a
- 47:14computer. It took our phone line into a
- 47:16computer and dialed up. And he was like, does anybody
- 47:18like dirt bikes? I was like in this AOL chat room
- 47:21and all these people like, I like dirt bikes and everybody's
- 47:23talking about dirt bikes. And he moved the computer like
- 47:25this and it cut the Internet off and we lost.
- 47:29He was like, you know, and every time we would just barely move
- 47:31the computer. It was like cutting the Internet
- 47:33off and we would have to start over and find more dirt bike
- 47:35people. And I just remember thinking
- 47:37like, this is really cool, but is this it?
- 47:40Is this like the whole everybody told this Internet thing?
- 47:43Like come on. Like I thought it'd be there's a
- 47:45little anti climatic. And I think that's how people
- 47:46experience Bitcoin, right? Right now.
- 47:49They're like, man, all these other things are, you know,
- 47:51going way up and down as well as volatility.
- 47:53And Bitcoin's got a little boring.
- 47:55It's 6 figures. You know, it goes from 1:14 to
- 47:57104. Nobody cares.
- 48:00And but I think when those 50 million people turn into like
- 48:04legitimate users, which is going to be super fast.
- 48:06I think politicians are looking at that and they're like, Oh my
- 48:10God, this is about to get insane.
- 48:14And if you have 2550 million serious users, I mean, you're,
- 48:20it's unstoppable. It's over.
- 48:22And so we better prepare for that title wave to hit.
- 48:25We got to think through it from the policy standpoint, from a
- 48:27political standpoint, both parties are having this come to
- 48:29Jesus moment. I think that's what you're
- 48:30seeing on the Democratic side too.
- 48:31They're like, what are you talking about?
- 48:34We're anti digital assets. That's like saying you're anti
- 48:37Internet. Well, you have we, this is not
- 48:40a, we have no leg to stand on. This is this is actually
- 48:43irresponsible from a, from a platform standpoint.
- 48:46So I think that's why we're seeing some of the migration,
- 48:48some of the, you know, kind of bipartisan support on some of
- 48:53these bills. Hope you're enjoying the
- 48:54episode. Just a quick break.
- 48:56Would really appreciate if you can hit the like button to
- 48:59subscribe. Leave a comment if you're on
- 49:01YouTube. But yeah, a five star rating on
- 49:04Spotify, Apple, all this really goes a long way to support the
- 49:07show. We spend a lot of time to
- 49:09prepare for it, book guests, have the conversations, edit
- 49:12them. And so if you could show your
- 49:14appreciation, just hit the like button, leave a comment, leave a
- 49:17five star review really goes a long way.
- 49:19We appreciate it and if you haven't checked it out already,
- 49:22would also point you to our website where you can subscribe
- 49:25to our weekly research newsletter.
- 49:28So you'll get information on what's happening in Bitcoin
- 49:31markets, macro. You'll get podcasts that you
- 49:33might have missed as well, deep dive reports, white papers, just
- 49:37a great way to stay up to date with everything that's happening
- 49:40at our business and also how we're viewing the investable
- 49:43landscape for Bitcoin and the broader macro picture.
- 49:46Hope you enjoyed the rest of the episode.
- 49:48Yeah, I love a lot of the analogies you made there.
- 49:51And thank you for pioneering the chat room.
- 49:52So then by the time I was in elementary school, I was able to
- 49:56easily communicate with my classmates.
- 49:59Forget which one I was at this point, But this reminds me of a
- 50:02chart that River put out this week.
- 50:07I think it's interesting. I mean, it may be redundant for
- 50:10us and for some people, but it also is important to put in
- 50:13perspective because I know there's people who listen to the
- 50:15show, I know that this will be distributed in other places.
- 50:17And they look at the price of Bitcoin and they think
- 50:19immediately I miss it, right? And then they go down the shit
- 50:22coin rabbit hole because everything is so cheap and the
- 50:24market caps are small. And I'm going to, you know, I'm
- 50:26going to 100 X my position and then sell and buy a Lambo and I
- 50:30don't have to work for Michael anymore.
- 50:31But that's not how it works. You were actually incredibly
- 50:35early and you have 3% adoption of Bitcoin.
- 50:37And when I think about these other things here for reference,
- 50:40online banking in 1996 or social media in 2005 or the Internet in
- 50:441990, I would have to imagine like in social media in 2005,
- 50:50there were very few proponents of it who understood how
- 50:55fundamentally that would change traditional media, how people
- 50:58would communicate more online than they do in person.
- 51:01Online banking may be even a better parallel because everyone
- 51:05used to bank in person. And that's really sensitive
- 51:07information, right? And people are, you know, like
- 51:09to keep their finances close to them.
- 51:11Still, even to this day, some people don't want to bank
- 51:13online. They prefer to go into a branch.
- 51:15And now you have Bitcoin. It's in even more radical
- 51:19proposition in the sense that you're we're putting our, what
- 51:23we perceive to be physical dollars, but they're digital
- 51:25dollars right into a new form of money that didn't exist like 17
- 51:32years ago. And so that is probably the
- 51:35biggest inertia to overcome out of any one of these.
- 51:38And and still to this day, we're only a 3% adoption, you know, 15
- 51:41years later. Yeah, I think that ties into the
- 51:45Bank of America analysts report that came out about, you know,
- 51:49bitcoins like a once in 1000 years technological disruption.
- 51:54And I think you guys the one that I come to, and I don't
- 51:56think there's a right analogy, but his e-mail because e-mail
- 51:59was like valuable for people, allowed you think about having
- 52:02to like send a snail mail and the process and all of that.
- 52:06And e-mail was relatively easily for people to get access to.
- 52:09They can just get on their phone.
- 52:10It provided value similar to Bitcoin has a store of value.
- 52:13But if you looked at that was all the Internet was good for
- 52:16you were missing, you know, so much more.
- 52:18And it took years. It took time for the Internet to
- 52:21proliferate, mobile phones to come out and GPS.
- 52:25But yeah, this is AI think what's I think the most
- 52:28interesting is that we've all known this, but the powers that
- 52:31be, whether it's the banking sector or from a policy
- 52:34perspective, people in those realms have also known it.
- 52:38But the, the zeitgeist, the narrative, it's changing in our
- 52:41direction that OK, it's here, it's here to stay.
- 52:42Now they're ready to like embrace it, which is what
- 52:45matters at the end of the day. Everyone's known.
- 52:47There's been negative yielding bonds, but now people are
- 52:49talking about it and they're going to do something by holding
- 52:51money and hard assets, specifically sovereigns.
- 52:54And so that's really where things changed.
- 52:56Gold bugs have been talking about this forever, but it
- 52:58didn't really matter until now. We're stacking gold and Bitcoin.
- 53:02Yeah. Can you go back to that river
- 53:04slide real fast if you can? So just a couple quick things.
- 53:13So first of all, River, I'm really excited.
- 53:16Alex is going to be doing a presentation at the summit next
- 53:20week about some of this like Bitcoin and adoption in the
- 53:24United States. And some of the research they're
- 53:26doing is is phenomenal. And they have just the access to
- 53:31data and kind of the way they parse it.
- 53:34Some really, really interesting things.
- 53:36The other thing I want to hit, if you look at social media in
- 53:392005, Jackson, you were saying thanks for the chat room, you
- 53:43know, kind of kind of breaking ground there.
- 53:47Date. So I'll date myself.
- 53:49My freshman year of college was the year Facebook came out and
- 53:52piloted with with with freshmen. And so I was the first batch of
- 53:57Facebook users that year and it was like a LAN, you know, type
- 54:03of thing where you only were within your own little
- 54:06university circle and you and, and yeah, I think, you know,
- 54:10your point. Like, it was crazy.
- 54:11It's crazy to see like, well, you know, what am I do with this
- 54:14fake Facebook thing? Like, I thought it was kind of
- 54:15stupid. I still kind of do.
- 54:18I don't have a Facebook account anymore, but but you know, I, I,
- 54:21I saw, I rode the way for, for, you know, whatever, 15 years
- 54:25and, and it's crazy to see how some things go.
- 54:28You, you start out and that was like a 3% that was probably 3%
- 54:32penetration of the market that first year.
- 54:34And now it's, it's insane. So, but yeah, man, everybody
- 54:39TuneIn to that river talk. If you if you think this is
- 54:42interesting, like Alex is going to, Alex is going to go to town,
- 54:46it's going to be great. Yeah.
- 54:48The only thing I would add to that is, you know, I think that
- 54:513% that's quoted on that chart is, is probably looking at
- 54:54users. So these these numbers that
- 54:56we've been referencing and I think those are always
- 54:59inherently overstated because if you're just looking at, you
- 55:02know, unique addresses, you know, people could have multiple
- 55:05addresses. So typically overstates that
- 55:07amount. And I would almost, I think a
- 55:09better gauge of like adoption is just like the actual monetary
- 55:13value relative to global assets, which is much lower than 3%,
- 55:17like the 2 trillion versus 1000 trillion or a quadrillion of
- 55:22global asset value at, you know, 0.2%.
- 55:25Like that's the real adoption rate to me because it's like
- 55:28this, you know, put aside like how many users there are, it's
- 55:31just how much, how much value is being stored in this new store
- 55:34value is like the real adoption rate in my mind.
- 55:36So it's just like there's different frames of reference
- 55:39you can look at the adoption reality is we're we're extremely
- 55:44early no matter how you slice it, But just wanted to add that.
- 55:50Yeah, go ahead. I was going to say there are two
- 55:53sides of the same coin, because as more dollar or more value
- 55:58goes into the system, that means that more people value the
- 56:01asset. And so then they inherently will
- 56:03want to receive it. And so that's the big thing that
- 56:08like if you look at one like one out of 100 people, if we agree
- 56:11that one out of 100 hold any form of Bitcoin, when you look
- 56:15at the number of pairs that like are tied in the, there's only
- 56:19.8% of the total amount of connections that would be able
- 56:23to be made via that one out of 100.
- 56:25Or like I think roughly like in that ratio, maybe it's like 2
- 56:28out of 100. But the notion is as you
- 56:31increase adoption and connectivity, the value starts
- 56:34to grow because people are naturally starting to find value
- 56:37and not having a centralized entity.
- 56:38And then the middle and the amount of connections grow
- 56:41similar to the Internet, like as more it's the Metcalf's law
- 56:44effectively. And so that's the other side is
- 56:47that we don't still have the connections.
- 56:48People aren't like accepting this for payments.
- 56:51And as that starts to grow because the value's grown, then
- 56:54that naturally brings more value to the system.
- 56:57So it's a chicken or egg problems like you have more
- 56:58value in it than more people recognize it as valuable, they
- 57:01want and accept it, which derives more value from the
- 57:03network like connectivity. Price target, Steven, I have AI
- 57:10have kind of like A2 fold question for you.
- 57:13So yeah, there's been circles online in the Bitcoin community
- 57:19for a while that talk about Bitcoin obsoletes the state, and
- 57:24clearly that doesn't happen anytime soon at least.
- 57:29And so there was this thinking within the US government, at
- 57:34least that's from my perception of it, because of how hostile
- 57:37the government was, you know, an administration ago or even 2
- 57:39administrations ago. So there was this shift in
- 57:43thinking from your Bitcoin is a threat to the dollar to really
- 57:47it's part of the statecraft of the United States.
- 57:52It's a tool for advancing your prosperity within the country.
- 57:56It's a new technology. Some of the things we just
- 57:58discussed, I'm curious, you know, when you perceive that
- 58:02inflection point to happen since you've been at BPI for a while
- 58:05now. And then the second part to that
- 58:07question would be, you know, now that that inflection point has
- 58:10happened and we talked about, you know, some of the adoption
- 58:13metrics and just the prosperity and, and concentration of wealth
- 58:18and technology of Bitcoin in the United States.
- 58:20What is resonating the most with people now?
- 58:22So it's like when did the inflection point happen in, in
- 58:24you and the team's opinion? And now with ongoing
- 58:28conversations, what are some of the core narratives or or focal
- 58:31points, topics that are being discussed to further that?
- 58:37Yeah. Big questions good, good stuff
- 58:42to to cover here. So you know, there there are a
- 58:47number of different opinions in the Bitcoin ecosystem,
- 58:51individuals of like bitcoins interaction with with the state.
- 58:57Our thesis is pretty much always been the same.
- 59:00I mentioned Matt, Matt Pine's first white paper, if you have
- 59:04asked and look like our one of our very first white papers,
- 59:06like 100 pages, Matt Pine's talking about Bitcoin's role in
- 59:11the US versus China geopolitical conflict.
- 59:14And I mean, here we are and we're in the middle of a tariff
- 59:18war and hopefully, you know, not more over the next few years.
- 59:24I think there's we're on a collision course with China and
- 59:26I think he knew that because of his background and and rightly
- 59:30called that out and did 100 pages on why, you know, why
- 59:33should we should think about Bitcoin?
- 59:34We're with regards to China, their belt and Rd. initiative,
- 59:38like all of the sort of tentacles of this conflict that,
- 59:42you know, we're already making their way through the system
- 59:44back then. And I know a lot of a lot of
- 59:48people, you know, a lot of Bitcoiners think Bitcoin, you
- 59:50know, or thought or do think Bitcoin obsoletes the state.
- 59:53If that's the case, then don't worry about it.
- 59:55You don't really have to worry about, you know, the government
- 59:58or like what any institute or whoever's working on if you
- 1:00:02think the state's a concern. Or an obstacle or a potential,
- 1:00:08you know, just whatever issue then I would say whether it's us
- 1:00:14or whoever, I think it's really important that we have been
- 1:00:20preparing for Bitcoin to be taken seriously by the United
- 1:00:23States government for quite some time.
- 1:00:25To me, I know it's I'm sorry, I'm getting a little echo.
- 1:00:29So if I start him and Holland, it's hard to hear yourself on
- 1:00:32the echo when you're when you're going probably my Airpods are
- 1:00:35dying. But I think if you think
- 1:00:37Bitcoin's going to, you know, become what it's already become
- 1:00:40$2 trillion asset class and then keep going.
- 1:00:42Like we were just talking about if we're if we are that early,
- 1:00:46then it was just a matter of time for the largest, most
- 1:00:49powerful government in the world starts to take it super
- 1:00:51seriously. It starts to look into it, be
- 1:00:52like, what is this about? Who's behind this?
- 1:00:55What is this a threat or this an asset?
- 1:00:58And when they're asking that question, it's a little too late
- 1:01:01to start making the case. When you're in front of the
- 1:01:04judge, you know, or the jury, it's a little too late to start
- 1:01:06in your in your in your speaking.
- 1:01:08It's a little too late to start figuring out what you're going
- 1:01:09to say. And so I'm just making like
- 1:01:13dumbing this down like super simple.
- 1:01:15So we've been thinking, OK, one day we think bitcoiners going to
- 1:01:19be super successful. We are bitcoiners, we believe in
- 1:01:22it, we think it makes sense. It's freedom money.
- 1:01:24It's like one of those powerful tools, technology, technological
- 1:01:28tools that's ever been thrown out there and people are
- 1:01:31adopting it like, you know, like Mad Men.
- 1:01:33It's mayhem and the market's right, but Bitcoin's going
- 1:01:36crazy. It's $100,000.
- 1:01:40US government's going to take a hard look at this and there's
- 1:01:43going to be legislation, there's going to be regulation, there's
- 1:01:46going to be all these sorts of things.
- 1:01:47There's start to start to notice it and do things about it.
- 1:01:51That's what the government does. That's what bureaucracies do.
- 1:01:54They take notice and they start doing things.
- 1:01:55And sometimes they're bad things.
- 1:01:58A lot of times they're, they're wrong because they don't
- 1:02:00understand something. They're I got to get my mind
- 1:02:02around it. Like if you're actually start
- 1:02:03trying to get their head around things and they make rules and
- 1:02:08you know, like a like, you know, if you're a parent, you have
- 1:02:11teenagers, you don't really understand, you know, your first
- 1:02:13couple years, I don't know how to handle this teenager.
- 1:02:15So you start trying to figure things about, get your arms
- 1:02:17around the situation and you probably make mistakes.
- 1:02:21And that's what the government's best at.
- 1:02:22That's what bureaucracy is the best at.
- 1:02:24It's groupthink, like the worst example of groupthink ever.
- 1:02:28It's just like these institutions making sweeping
- 1:02:32decisions about things they have 0 understanding on.
- 1:02:35And in this case, the stakes are even higher because you're
- 1:02:37talking about a top five asset on its way to being number one.
- 1:02:40Many people listening to this podcast think this is the, you
- 1:02:43know, the best asset, the hardest money ever invented.
- 1:02:46And it's going to be, it's going to quickly surpass gold in terms
- 1:02:50of market cap. And, and, and so if that's the
- 1:02:54case, then the stakes could not be higher for us to make sure
- 1:02:59that the right people understand, at least at a
- 1:03:04kindergartner level, why Bitcoin's important and why and,
- 1:03:08and maximize the public benefit, you know, for individuals, but
- 1:03:14and maximize the, the benefit of the United States, which is kind
- 1:03:17of our charter. We, we think Bitcoin in the
- 1:03:19United States can be, can be good.
- 1:03:22This can be good for that. And, and making that case,
- 1:03:26select officials, agencies. And that's, that's why we're
- 1:03:30doing what we do. Next week's third year.
- 1:03:31We've done it. I know I'm kind of going down a,
- 1:03:34going on a tangent here and answering all of your questions,
- 1:03:36but, but I, I just wanted to get that out of the way.
- 1:03:39Like, that's why I think that's why I think our work and the
- 1:03:44work of other groups and, and now we have Senator Alamis is we
- 1:03:47have all these, you know, elected officials, Senator
- 1:03:49Blackburn, Senator Haggard, leave anybody out.
- 1:03:51I could, I could go on and on about, you know, them, uh,
- 1:03:54elected officials that are advocates for Bitcoin and they
- 1:03:56get it and they understand it. They think, Oh my God, this is,
- 1:04:00we can't mess this up and we need them.
- 1:04:02We need, you know, groups, we need lobbyists, whoever to keep
- 1:04:05pushing because we we don't want what's really dangerous and when
- 1:04:09isn't just people who are like curious and don't understand
- 1:04:12Bitcoin at all because they're not, you know, they're going to
- 1:04:15say, OK, hey, we need to kind of get our heads around this.
- 1:04:17It's the people who think they understand and they don't,
- 1:04:19they're wrong. Those people are dangerous.
- 1:04:21And so we want to find them help, you know, help bring them
- 1:04:25up to speed. Yeah, it's, it's well said.
- 1:04:28And the other thing I would reference is like, you know,
- 1:04:32we're talking about them trying to get their arms around it.
- 1:04:35Understand it, but at the same time, like they're themselves
- 1:04:38looking at becoming a quote UN quote user, right?
- 1:04:41Like we have this Bitcoin. Maybe this is a good time to
- 1:04:44ask, you know, status of the SBR, where's the audit?
- 1:04:47How much Bitcoin do we have? I think that's a first step in
- 1:04:50like their literal adoption and becoming a user, which will be
- 1:04:53very a very powerful signal if and when that does happen where
- 1:04:57we explicitly state this is how much Bitcoin we have, we're
- 1:05:00holding it forever. We're going to look to acquire
- 1:05:02more. That's that's a very strong
- 1:05:07signal that like we ourselves as a government, as a sovereign are
- 1:05:10going to become a user of this network.
- 1:05:13Yeah, I wish I could tell you the what what the hold up is on
- 1:05:18the on the audit. I think obviously they're
- 1:05:22running some snags, but I'll leave it at that.
- 1:05:26I think I do expect that audit to come through.
- 1:05:30I know the deadlines and deadlines have been broken, so I
- 1:05:34don't know when it'll happen, but I'm optimistic that we'll
- 1:05:37get that. I mean, it's executive order, so
- 1:05:40it seems like you kind of got to do it.
- 1:05:42But I think, yeah, I think, you know, you look at the Bitcoin
- 1:05:47Act, you look at Senator Lemus's bill, which has been Co signed
- 1:05:50by a number of people getting a buying program going.
- 1:05:53I'm optimistic that we're going to, you know, this stuff just
- 1:05:55doesn't happen as quickly as we've been a little spoiled as
- 1:05:59an industry saying, Hey, we had our timeline's hilarious.
- 1:06:05Bitcoin, Bitcoin's timelines are hilarious, right?
- 1:06:07We're we, we're like gradually, then suddenly, well, like most
- 1:06:11things are just gradually and then gradually and then
- 1:06:13gradually, you know, use people grind in Washington DC as
- 1:06:17lobbyists for like decades to get things done.
- 1:06:20And some of that's by design, you know, because if you pass
- 1:06:22the bill and like, well, I guess you don't have to, I guess I
- 1:06:26don't need to pay you anymore if you got it done.
- 1:06:29And so we've seen go. We went from like complete
- 1:06:34regulatory, I would say capture, but like, you know, choke point,
- 1:06:42like a chokehold, regulatory chokehold, you know, 2 point 2.0
- 1:06:47to candidate who was kind of mentioning Bitcoin made some
- 1:06:51crazy promises. There's like no way he's going
- 1:06:53to do any of that. Did most of it.
- 1:06:55One won the election. President's talking about
- 1:06:58Bitcoin executive orders day week 1, but that doesn't happen
- 1:07:04like that. That's insane.
- 1:07:05Like I don't, you don't fully appreciate it because we've, you
- 1:07:08know, we're like, Oh yeah, great.
- 1:07:10Because how it works. Presidents talk about you and
- 1:07:12they do all this stuff. It doesn't work like that.
- 1:07:15It's it's hilariously like bullish like this is wild.
- 1:07:20And we've I spent years and years.
- 1:07:24We're going to we're going to the state level, just trying to
- 1:07:27get like state representatives and governors to do basic
- 1:07:30things. And it's like maybe next year,
- 1:07:33you know, maybe next cycle. And so to have the president
- 1:07:35United States do all that is just so wild.
- 1:07:37Not to mention the executive order, which was a huge win.
- 1:07:40And so I think, I guess I'm encouraging some patience.
- 1:07:44I I mean, I want to see it all here, too.
- 1:07:46I'm just like, there's so much going on.
- 1:07:49And I think the, the fact, I guess what I'm trying to
- 1:07:52communicate is the fact that it has been delayed.
- 1:07:53It has taken a little while longer than we thought or than
- 1:07:56it was originally said. Doesn't surprise me and doesn't
- 1:07:59like send me into like, you know, I'm not like, well, the
- 1:08:04whole thing's over now. I mean, I'm just, it's kind of
- 1:08:06what I expected. It's just going to take a while.
- 1:08:08Poor. It's poor Brian.
- 1:08:10It's a great point to contextualize like it goes back
- 1:08:14to the accelerated business cycles like we witnessed first
- 1:08:17hand and asked to go from 0 to $2 trillion, which it's never
- 1:08:21really happened at that speed. You see what happened with the
- 1:08:24ETFs and the record versus gold. And similarly, just the notion
- 1:08:30like calling out, we could have been in a different spot if an
- 1:08:33alternative universe, if Trump's not president, like completely
- 1:08:37different, like not like 180 right in where the left and a
- 1:08:42lot of the things happening from regulatory, the the, you know,
- 1:08:46from the KYC to exchanges to the market structure.
- 1:08:51So, yeah, it's been interesting to watch that happened in real
- 1:08:54time, whether it was like Ross took two days instead of 1 and
- 1:08:58all the way to, you know, if it makes sense, right?
- 1:09:00Because in a world of TikTok, it's not the same, but it is
- 1:09:03that we see this price moving and it's insanely volatile and
- 1:09:06it's usually volatile to the upside.
- 1:09:07So we're just like primed for that serotonin hit till you like
- 1:09:12the the movement goes and you're waiting for the next like
- 1:09:14bullish catalyst. When in reality, it's you just
- 1:09:18got to like take a step back and realize where we're at.
- 1:09:22Right. Yeah, I, I just think we're,
- 1:09:25we're really, we're spoiled a little bit and, and we can't
- 1:09:29control that, You know, it's, this is like the coolest roller
- 1:09:32coaster ride. And we talk about the BPI like,
- 1:09:35I'm like, this doesn't work like this, you know, and, and it
- 1:09:39does, it has for for for us and for the industry.
- 1:09:42And it helps, I think something else I've said just like beating
- 1:09:48this drum, like, OK, why? Like, why is this working like
- 1:09:52this? Well, it helps to be right.
- 1:09:55It helps to be on the right side of history.
- 1:09:57And I think bit corners are like helps to be right that like,
- 1:10:01yeah, hey, the Internet is one of the most powerful inventions
- 1:10:03in the, you know, last 1000 years.
- 1:10:06Like this is going to like forever change civilization like
- 1:10:09you out of your mind, you know, like for what for e-mail like
- 1:10:13sounds crazy. Helps to be right.
- 1:10:19I was going to say earlier just I feel bad for Brian in
- 1:10:21particular because Brian really wants to see the audit, Steven,
- 1:10:26he was hoping. Where's the corn?
- 1:10:27He's hoping that you brought the audit with you today.
- 1:10:30So I know he's he's a little disappointed, but that's all
- 1:10:33right. Next up to say?
- 1:10:36I have a tally sheet. It's just, you know, but I
- 1:10:42promise, Brian, that they do not have more than 21 million.
- 1:10:45I can guarantee you that. Good.
- 1:10:47Take that. I was concerned about that
- 1:10:50actually. But all right, I mean we get,
- 1:10:54we're a little over an hour into this.
- 1:10:56I'll be curious to hear if maybe there's anything else topical
- 1:11:00from the week that we might have missed.
- 1:11:02And if not, I would like to just discuss a little bit more about
- 1:11:06the summit that's happening next week.
- 1:11:07Give a teaser to what will be happening there.
- 1:11:10You know, some of the notable speakers.
- 1:11:13Let's get people excited about what's going on with the Bitcoin
- 1:11:16Policy Summit, if if there's nothing else.
- 1:11:19Brian, Michael, anything else from From your side?
- 1:11:22No, let's talk, Let's talk, summit.
- 1:11:24Cool. Yeah, let's talk Summit.
- 1:11:27I, I encourage, I'll just do the, do the bit here, like if
- 1:11:31you're in DC, if you're going to be in the area, if you want to
- 1:11:36just fly in last minute, we'd love to have you.
- 1:11:39We do have a few tickets, not a lot.
- 1:11:40We have a few left though. Did not expect that to be an
- 1:11:44issue. We moved to a larger venue this
- 1:11:46year and we're like, all right. We just like, we want people to
- 1:11:48be able to show up and want to be like, you know, just so
- 1:11:51update of and register and I don't think it's going to
- 1:11:53happen. So if you can, if you're
- 1:11:56interested, go to btcpolicysummit.org, btcpolicy
- 1:12:00summit.org and you can request a ticket there.
- 1:12:05It is pending approval to keep the riffraff out.
- 1:12:11So it's going to be a full day, man, we have packed so much.
- 1:12:16It's we're basically packed 2 summits into one day because so
- 1:12:19much we want to cover. I think the important one
- 1:12:22important thing I kind of give you the history.
- 1:12:24This is our third annual summit. We started this back, you know,
- 1:12:28a few years ago because we realized we had a massive issue
- 1:12:33the first time most people in Washington, DC ever were
- 1:12:36acquainted or introduced to Bitcoin.
- 1:12:38Who's in the wake of the FTX collapse.
- 1:12:40And so Bitcoin was finally in the headlines like for the first
- 1:12:43time in a while, price, you know, price is doing well.
- 1:12:46It's something crazy. And then FTX, of course, you
- 1:12:49know, super, you know, Super Bowl stadiums are named after
- 1:12:52it. So everybody's like, wait a
- 1:12:53second. And it hit everyone.
- 1:12:56The fallout kind of splattered everywhere.
- 1:12:57So we're like, we need to get the the key people in a room and
- 1:13:04kind of re educate. You never want to re educate.
- 1:13:09You want to educate people. You want to catch someone there
- 1:13:11a blank slate. It's far more difficult to, if
- 1:13:15you've ever had like a bad teacher growing up and they,
- 1:13:17they tried to teach you something, but it was like all
- 1:13:20messed up. And then you kind of got to
- 1:13:21reprogram that. It's way more difficult to learn
- 1:13:23something after you've thought you've already learned it.
- 1:13:26And we so we had to step up to that challenge.
- 1:13:29And I think our website said basically like FTX collapsed.
- 1:13:33Many people think Bitcoin, you know, is a scam.
- 1:13:37Is it a scam? Like what's wrong with Bitcoin?
- 1:13:39You know, come find out. It was like, let's just lean
- 1:13:42into it. You know, policy makers are are
- 1:13:46faced with protecting the public from, you know, things like
- 1:13:50that. So we just leaned into it and
- 1:13:53said, like, let's be curious together, show up, let's talk.
- 1:13:55We got Bitcoin experts and we're we're going to we're just, you
- 1:13:59know, stoned unturned, you know, this isn't a marketing play.
- 1:14:02Let's just talk. And they did feel like, OK, I
- 1:14:07like that vibe like. So that's what that was the
- 1:14:10launch of of the summit last year.
- 1:14:13We said, OK, should America embrace Bitcoin?
- 1:14:17Like we're starting to get there.
- 1:14:18Things are starting to happen. And now that America seemingly
- 1:14:22has at least at some level, first is a year ago we said, OK,
- 1:14:27America seems to be embracing Bitcoin.
- 1:14:29What what happens now? So that's the point of departure
- 1:14:31for the summit. And we have a number of
- 1:14:33keynotes. We have industry players, we
- 1:14:36have mining companies. I kind of mentioned River.
- 1:14:38Let me just kind of go through the kind of different buckets.
- 1:14:40I'm not going to read the entire schedule, but kind of give you a
- 1:14:42vision for it. So we're kicking off the future
- 1:14:45of Bitcoin in America Part 1. So we just released not that
- 1:14:51long ago Bitcoin Policy Institute did, it's top of our
- 1:14:55website. Kind of first thing you're going
- 1:14:57to see if you look at our our white papers and our
- 1:15:00publications like a like a policy framework, like what we
- 1:15:05think's important, why we think it's important, kind of like on
- 1:15:07the policy side, like what we're working on and focused on.
- 1:15:10And Zach Shapiro, our head of policy, he's going to unpack
- 1:15:14that in like 10 minutes. I have no idea how, but he's
- 1:15:16going to do it in 10 minutes. And then we have Bo Hines who I
- 1:15:21know everybody here is familiar with White House cancel and
- 1:15:24digital assets executive director and Connor Brown from
- 1:15:28Senator Lemus office going to do a fireside chat there about
- 1:15:30Bitcoin and the future of America is sort of like like
- 1:15:35kind of broadcasting out like what what were things to look
- 1:15:37like down the road. We have three US senators
- 1:15:43talking about the Bitcoin legislative agenda and and then
- 1:15:48you mentioned Alex Thorne. Alex, he's doing a keynote.
- 1:15:50We have some of our fellows speaking.
- 1:15:52Then we're kind of going to pivot for the second-half of the
- 1:15:54morning to domestic and global Bitcoin adoption.
- 1:16:01And that's where Alex River, CCO River is going to do like do a,
- 1:16:06do a bit on the American Bitcoin advantage, like the advantage we
- 1:16:09have, and that's a huge part of our, our pitch to Washington is
- 1:16:14like, we have an unprecedented advantage.
- 1:16:18We have a lead. And the last thing we do when
- 1:16:21you have a lead like this is just fumble the ball.
- 1:16:23So we got to seize the momentum. And it's sort of this once in a
- 1:16:28generation opportunity kind of like we did with the Internet.
- 1:16:31We we could have, we could have, could have messed that up.
- 1:16:35Good thing we didn't look at what look what's happening.
- 1:16:37We have some of the most valuable companies in the world
- 1:16:39that had, you know, the most valuable companies in the world.
- 1:16:42They're all here and we're losing some of that now.
- 1:16:44This is a chance to take it back.
- 1:16:48Let me find another one. There's another couple cool bits
- 1:16:51we have planned. So this is, I'm really excited
- 1:16:55about this illicit finance. Let's touch on illicit finance
- 1:16:59in America. Like how do these work?
- 1:17:02Where's Bitcoin fit into that? Is Bitcoin used for money
- 1:17:05laundering? Let's blow some of these false
- 1:17:07narratives out of the water. Obviously, if you want to
- 1:17:10launder money, you use cash. If you don't, you're going to
- 1:17:13get busted. Just launder your money.
- 1:17:16If you want to launder money, don't use Bitcoin.
- 1:17:18Some of those types of basic things.
- 1:17:20It's we need to tell this, we need to tell these tales.
- 1:17:23We need to dispel these like false narratives.
- 1:17:27And then the other big farsight. I think I think the thing I'm
- 1:17:30I'm really look forward to more than anything is Matt Pines, our
- 1:17:32executive writer sat down with deputy director, the CIA,
- 1:17:35Michael Ellis, and that's going to be fascinating.
- 1:17:40We're super honored to have him join us.
- 1:17:42And I think this first time publicly speaking about Bitcoin,
- 1:17:46coming to Bitcoin event, so excited to have that.
- 1:17:49That's going to be awesome. It's like can't miss level TV
- 1:17:53right there. And then we're going to pivot to
- 1:17:56BRCA and Richie Torres. We were talking about Democrat
- 1:18:03Congressman. He's one who's on the right side
- 1:18:06of history here and doing everything he can fight hard.
- 1:18:08So he's coming in joining us and that's just the first like third
- 1:18:13of the day. Any questions so far guys?
- 1:18:17Yeah, I mean, it's a great recap.
- 1:18:19I think one of the the big things that sticks out about
- 1:18:22Bpis, like you guys are genuinely having a lot of fun.
- 1:18:25And I remember when we first met before Pines came on full time,
- 1:18:29you were referencing just the prerequisite to come on as a
- 1:18:31fellow. And it was just like like, you
- 1:18:33know, the Navy Seal's and Marines of kind of Bitcoin and
- 1:18:35understanding, but also come and having a professional
- 1:18:37experience. And I think you're keen in on
- 1:18:40something that's super profound is you guys are just right.
- 1:18:44And it's just true. We all know where Bitcoins going
- 1:18:46and that it reminds me of the notion of like technology acts
- 1:18:49as a fulcrum and it's like a point of leverage that the
- 1:18:53greater the technology, the larger the amplification is.
- 1:18:56And similar to like what you guys are able to achieve with
- 1:18:58the budget as it compares to the other kind of.
- 1:19:02I know it's different in the sense that you guys aren't a
- 1:19:04trade association, but similar in the sense that you're
- 1:19:07advocating for an industry that's growing, but you're
- 1:19:09advocating for the right area of the industry and being done in
- 1:19:12the right way. And I think that presents itself
- 1:19:14in like how the taste of what you guys have achieved, but also
- 1:19:16the group coming together and so super excited.
- 1:19:19I won't personally be there, but they I can't make it for some
- 1:19:22personal reasons, but the team will be here along with some
- 1:19:24other folks. And so I'm going to feel the
- 1:19:26FOMO, but I know they'll they'll fill me in and the on ramp and
- 1:19:30early writers presence will be in DC in full force.
- 1:19:33Yeah, I, I said to have some of you guys join and, and I mean,
- 1:19:38we have, I don't know, 708 hundred people coming right now.
- 1:19:42So it's going to be, it's going to be awesome.
- 1:19:44It's going to be packed. I think you mentioned being
- 1:19:48right. I think for an industry, for
- 1:19:52trade group, for, you know, for, for think tank, whatever.
- 1:19:57I think being right is a necessary but but not sufficient
- 1:20:00condition. To being successful.
- 1:20:02So like you can be right and still lose.
- 1:20:03You can be right and be, you know, a number of different
- 1:20:06things. It can be pricks and I think you
- 1:20:09know, you still lose. But I think being being correct
- 1:20:14and then also just like being honest about what you know and
- 1:20:17don't know what you understand and what you don't understand is
- 1:20:20important. I think then working just your
- 1:20:26tail off and being kind, being generous, you know, and, and
- 1:20:32bringing the right people together, being strategic.
- 1:20:36I think those are all like, you can be right and not do all
- 1:20:39those things well and, and still still pretty, you know, get
- 1:20:42cooked. But you also it helps when
- 1:20:46you're, if you're doing all those things and you're right,
- 1:20:48then you're going to find success.
- 1:20:50And I think that's what we're seeing as an industry man.
- 1:20:52Like everybody, everybody works hard.
- 1:20:56Everybody's real sharp. Everybody's very strategic, but
- 1:20:59also like sort of generous with their time, generous with their,
- 1:21:06you know, like social circles, you know, our political circles,
- 1:21:13like we, we're open and I think we have the right posture to
- 1:21:16find success in DC. And I think that's what we're
- 1:21:18seeing like elected officials kind of pile in.
- 1:21:22They're like, not only, you know, there's the what we were
- 1:21:25talking about like for the 3%. Now we're headed toward, you
- 1:21:28know, whatever market cap, like whatever percentage of the
- 1:21:31market cap is going to be in the United States.
- 1:21:34There's that there's like the population thing.
- 1:21:37And then there's like, we like being around these guys.
- 1:21:39We like speaking at their events.
- 1:21:41They're nice people. They're they're good to us.
- 1:21:44They help us. Like I've said this a few times
- 1:21:48about lobbyists, like the best lobbyists, which we're not
- 1:21:51lobbyists, we're a think tank, but like advocates, I guess I
- 1:21:55should say the best advocates and lobbyists are those who have
- 1:21:58strong subject matter, subject matter expertise and experience.
- 1:22:04And so when you are a staffer, when you're an elected official,
- 1:22:08you go to those people and you give a couple, you know, you get
- 1:22:13one or two shots and one of the few things happened, you either
- 1:22:16embarrass them because you told something that was a lie.
- 1:22:20And you might win that day, but you're going to lose the rest of
- 1:22:24your kind of career. You're a liar or you're just
- 1:22:27like an idiot or another other things.
- 1:22:31But if you're reliable and sharp and you're like, I'm here to
- 1:22:34help you, to help you do your job and make your job easier and
- 1:22:37make you look good, then generally they're going to like
- 1:22:41being around you. And I think that's what we're
- 1:22:43trying to do it as like a BPI. And I think I see a lot of
- 1:22:46Bitcoiners like the 200, some that are coming today on the
- 1:22:49Hill. It's like, hey, we're here to
- 1:22:51support. We don't agree with everything
- 1:22:53you guys do up here. I don't agree with everything
- 1:22:55everybody does individually, right?
- 1:22:57But like with this, we can come together, we can work, we can be
- 1:23:00collaborative, we can educate you If you have questions, we're
- 1:23:03here to answer and we'll give you damn good answers.
- 1:23:05Answers. Some of them are 100 page white
- 1:23:07papers like here. Is this helpful?
- 1:23:10All right, you know, and we won't be able to give talking
- 1:23:13points. If you're like, I'm trying to
- 1:23:15figure out, you know, whatever, we're here to deliver that.
- 1:23:17Why are help me get my head around?
- 1:23:20Why is self custody important? It's not like you idiot, you
- 1:23:23don't understand stuff. No, no, let's bring in some self
- 1:23:26customers, let's bring in some wallets like you guys talk talk
- 1:23:30to them. We're just, you know, think tank
- 1:23:32guys, whatever it is. What's Bitcoin mining mining is
- 1:23:36that data centers? Well, sort of you know, let's
- 1:23:39let's educate you. Let's like how deep you want to
- 1:23:41go, man, we can do, we can, we can do a week of, of meetings,
- 1:23:46but then also being able to like package that we're, we're a,
- 1:23:52we're an industry of engineers. You know, like mentioned to
- 1:23:57somebody the other day, they even talked to my wife about it.
- 1:24:00I was like, man, Bitcoiners, man, so sorry for outsiders.
- 1:24:04Because it's kind of like your neighbor, you know, and you're
- 1:24:07like, hey, man, my car's kind of running a little rough or you're
- 1:24:10or you're, you know, I said neighbor because one of my
- 1:24:12neighbors was a mechanic at one point.
- 1:24:16It was like you and your mechanic cars run a little rough
- 1:24:19and they're like, OK, I don't need to know why, you know, I'm
- 1:24:23not a mechanic. I just need to know what you
- 1:24:25need me to do or pay you, but that's it.
- 1:24:29And they're like, no, no, no. Here, listen.
- 1:24:32So when they built this car, well, actually, let's go back to
- 1:24:35the, you know, the Ford Model T and then they iterated this and
- 1:24:39then they did a diesel engine and then this like, man, I don't
- 1:24:42have time and I just don't like understand anything you're
- 1:24:45saying. I don't need to know how the car
- 1:24:47was built. I seem to know kind of why
- 1:24:48what's wrong with it, why this is important, You know, and I
- 1:24:51think that bitcoins are a lot like engineers and mechanics
- 1:24:54like we want to because we we think this is the most beautiful
- 1:24:57engine ever conceived. You know, it's a, it's a 57
- 1:24:59Hemi, like you don't understand, like how the Hemi came to be.
- 1:25:04We're passionate about it. And I think sometimes we forget
- 1:25:07other people. They they just want to know the
- 1:25:09benefits, like why? And they don't need to know the
- 1:25:12entire history. And we think if someone's not
- 1:25:15interested in that, that that means maybe they don't take it
- 1:25:17as seriously. But anyway, I think that that's
- 1:25:22what we're doing in Washington is like wherever, how do you
- 1:25:24want to go or not go? We'll meet you right there.
- 1:25:28I love it. Well, yes, Steven, really
- 1:25:30appreciate you joining us today. Michael just had to jump, I
- 1:25:33think for another call, but it was a great conversation.
- 1:25:36It was a pleasure to get to know you.
- 1:25:38And we'll share as well in the show notes, the link to the
- 1:25:42summit. So if there are any stragglers
- 1:25:44on the fence that are local or maybe even have the opportunity
- 1:25:47to fly in and join, just go to believeitsbtcpolicysummit.org
- 1:25:53and there you can find the tickets online.
- 1:25:55Steven, is there anything else you wanted to shout out before
- 1:25:58we wrap up here? No, Jackson, Brian, Michael, I
- 1:26:01just want to say appreciate you guys.
- 1:26:03Appreciate on Ramp. It's a great show and thanks for
- 1:26:06having me on. Look forward to seeing some of
- 1:26:08you guys next week. Really, really do appreciate it.
- 1:26:12Thanks, Steven. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:26:15week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:26:17valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:26:19rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:26:22All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:26:24notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:26:27reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 1:26:29entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:26:32investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:26:35your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:26:38Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:26:42one of our private client advisors.