Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Chasing Yield: Bitcoin Is Money, Everything Else Is Credit
Transcript
- 0:00Hey Internet, welcome to another episode of the Bitcoin for
- 0:02Businesses podcast. I'm joined in studio for episode
- 0:052 with Liam Nelson, Matt Ball and Michael Tanguma.
- 0:09We kind of represent the early riders portfolio on Ramp and
- 0:13Acropolis and we're all builders in the Bitcoin space.
- 0:16And this podcast is for operators and builders and
- 0:20executives and finance teams that are looking at how to
- 0:23integrate Bitcoin into the various aspects of their
- 0:26business. So the way this works is we kind
- 0:29of kick around some of the interesting news in the business
- 0:32and Bitcoin world and then get into kind of best practices
- 0:36around implementation and how we would see these types of
- 0:39activities. And so the four of us and the
- 0:42broader on ramp and Acropolis teams did just get back from the
- 0:45Bitcoin Park Bitcoins treasury custody Summit in Nashville.
- 0:51We heard a lot of interesting things.
- 0:53MIC multi institution custody came up a few times, but
- 0:56definitely not as much as it should have a Liam you I know
- 0:59had some some thoughts to kind of kick us off.
- 1:01Yeah, I was also at a event here in New York called The Signal by
- 1:06Two Prime, their institutional lender and asset manager focused
- 1:09on Bitcoin in particular. There was a number of, you know,
- 1:13more institutional typefacing names in the industry.
- 1:16I thought there was some interesting commentary on a
- 1:20yield generation which we can get to in the future.
- 1:22But really it's just like the basis or base level has a lot of
- 1:26education left to do. It was interesting.
- 1:28I think the President a Bitwise said, you know, the best that
- 1:32you could do is look to 20 different custodians in order to
- 1:36diversify your assets if you are in a treasury company in the
- 1:39space as well as continue to monitor and make sure that they
- 1:43upgrade their solutions over time.
- 1:45It's we're, we're pretty early that it was very obvious that
- 1:50many people were uncomfortable with their custody.
- 1:52And we're trying to outsource some of that to many of the
- 1:55Bitcoin treasury companies in order to try to just make sure
- 1:58that they did the due diligence themselves.
- 2:00Because many people were on a or individuals were unable to do
- 2:04the due diligence right for custodians.
- 2:06And then even the treasury companies, it was pretty clear
- 2:09that they weren't able to be super comfortable with just one
- 2:12custodian or or how they are managing their Bitcoin, which
- 2:16ties in pretty directly to the other events that we were just
- 2:19at of the Bitcoin treasury and custody Summit in Nashville.
- 2:22And then imagine if right after till.
- 2:24Yeah. And we, we were in Nashville and
- 2:27I think one of the panels, Parker Lewis specifically came
- 2:29out and said if you're not pretty candidly, he said if
- 2:32you're not worried about your your custody solution or how
- 2:35you're holding your Bitcoin in some way to some extent, you're
- 2:39probably lacking some knowledge, which is, which is an
- 2:41interesting take. But I think it kind of just goes
- 2:44to show that there's just a lack of understanding even on the MIC
- 2:48side and really seeing the opportunity there for Peace of
- 2:51Mind and kind of offsetting that stress of just the custody
- 2:55solution and holding your Bitcoin.
- 2:57It's a good point, but often important to consider MIC in
- 3:00that context and just that sort of ability for it to give that
- 3:04Peace of Mind, which again, I think Liam touched on it wasn't
- 3:07nearly talked enough, talked about enough in Nashville,
- 3:10although a little bit. It's an interesting take.
- 3:13I didn't realize he said it in that framing, but makes complete
- 3:16sense because the the core pillar or the core idea to think
- 3:20about is the majority of the world doesn't use Bitcoin as a
- 3:23savings technology or money. They look at it as an
- 3:25investment. An investment, you know,
- 3:27naturally would be an investment into something to trade back for
- 3:30a common denominator, which would be dollars.
- 3:32And so to the point where I believe he was making is if
- 3:35you're not worried about it, well then ultimately you're
- 3:37either don't have enough exposure because if you have
- 3:40enough exposure, once anyone gets to a position of material
- 3:43size, whether it's a personal or corporate balance sheet, well,
- 3:45you naturally have to think about, well, what would happen
- 3:47if that, you know, counterparty that you're custodying that went
- 3:50away, whether it's self custody or third party custody.
- 3:53And then there's the other side, if you just have heavy exposure,
- 3:55but you're not thinking about custody when you have another
- 3:57problem. This comes up very often when
- 3:59you talk to like CIOs, where they'll often say, I can get the
- 4:03thesis wrong on investment. I can't get the custodian where
- 4:05I place it wrong. And it's still just so widely
- 4:08underappreciated and understood. And then to Liam's point, the
- 4:11most quote UN quote sophisticated people in this
- 4:13industry just literally parked their assets all over the place
- 4:17hoping to God that if one goes away, they only lose 20 to 40%
- 4:20of their assets, which is kind of comical when you think about
- 4:23it. But that's where we're at, how
- 4:24big the opportunity is. And then as it relates to
- 4:27businesses, well, again, it's a, it's a weird substrate or
- 4:32subconscious version into how people look at Bitcoin as
- 4:35speculative at best or Ponzi at worst, in the sense that all
- 4:40they hear all day long is that people fail and the assets
- 4:44evaporate, right? The thread that I always pull on
- 4:47is if you ask somebody that's not deeply involved in the
- 4:50space, they probably heard of Bitcoin and they assume that it
- 4:53ends up in a hard drive in the United Kingdom or it ends up in
- 4:56servers in North Korea. Because what they hear every
- 5:00cycle is FTX Celsius blocked by Mount Box Quadra go, you can go
- 5:04down the laundry list. And so they just forces them to
- 5:06not look at it. But it ultimately that's where
- 5:08the custody comes into because the notion I, I like to say is
- 5:12think about how great product market fit Bitcoin got to from a
- 5:15personal or corporate balance sheet, which this is what we're
- 5:18discussing is it got to $2 trillion in asset market cap
- 5:22with nobody really feeling fully confident for the next day.
- 5:25It won't go evaporate and go up and smoke, whether it's because
- 5:28a wildfire burns down your setup, you get hit by a bus or
- 5:31the third party custodian goes away.
- 5:32That's like how early we are, but how asymmetric the
- 5:34opportunity is as well for people that understand deeply
- 5:37the stuff we talk about. I think it's a great point,
- 5:40Michael, because what you're kind of saying there is that
- 5:42many people are still seeing Bitcoin as an investment and
- 5:44therefore a trade and therefore a short term or a short time
- 5:48horizon. And so thinking about kind of a
- 5:51permanent long term custody solution is not top of mind
- 5:55because they're really ultimately planning on taking
- 5:57that single counterparty risk with a custodian for only a
- 6:00limited amount of time until they plan to sell back into
- 6:02Fiat. And then I think it's also fair
- 6:05that the space in general is kind of learning about what a
- 6:09decentralized bearer asset is, right?
- 6:12Because if I think a lot of companies in the space are
- 6:14treating it like gold, where they're like, OK, I get it, it's
- 6:17a bare asset. So how do I diversify?
- 6:20Well, I send 20% of the gold to five different custodians.
- 6:25But obviously we here in this group understand that the true
- 6:29way to diversify that risk is to diversify away from us, any
- 6:33single counterparty. Instead of taking complete
- 6:36single counterparty risk with 20% chunks of your Bitcoin
- 6:40holdings, you can actually decentralize that risk, delegate
- 6:44it to kind of a two of three custodial quorum and you've
- 6:47removed all single counterparty risk altogether.
- 6:49And and that seems to just be an education game that even the
- 6:53folks that all came together at Nashville still seem to need to
- 6:57get educated a bit more on themselves.
- 6:59Yeah. We'll have to set this up on a
- 7:01future podcast, but we can talk about and go deeper on
- 7:04sophisticated quote, UN quote again, sophisticated holders
- 7:07that have 50 to 100,000 BTC that know first hand have 5 to 6
- 7:12different relationships, 5 to 6 different whitelist, 5 to 6
- 7:15different trade accounts. And everyone generally knows
- 7:17that's looked at the space for any length of time.
- 7:19Complexity is the enemy of security.
- 7:21So we don't do it on this pod, but I do think that'll be a good
- 7:24exercise to walk through. And then exercising some of that
- 7:27simplicity and controls start to make more sense for a business.
- 7:32And it really maps to how individuals naturally manage
- 7:36their balance sheet when it comes to unified experience
- 7:39where you're able to aggregate and simplify the back office
- 7:43process around Capital Management, treasury management.
- 7:46Yeah. And I think double tapping on
- 7:48what Liam brought up with the signal at 2 prime is that there
- 7:52still seems to be this strong desire out there to generate
- 7:54cash flow or fixed income or yield on your Bitcoin, as if the
- 7:58compound annual growth rate of the asset itself is not enough.
- 8:01And I think part of why we're seeing that is that treasury
- 8:04companies who are holding this Bitcoin need to justify a
- 8:07premium above their NAV. And so they need to kind of be
- 8:10able to signal that you can do things with your Bitcoin, you
- 8:13can generate new revenue streams with your Bitcoin.
- 8:15I'm curious how this group thinks about just Bitcoin yield
- 8:18in general. Are there areas that are safe
- 8:21and reasonable to pursue, or is this just a fool's errand?
- 8:25Yeah, it was interesting to see at the conference there were
- 8:30they pretty much identified or or majority of people said that,
- 8:34you know, it's been very difficult in the past, but now
- 8:37there are abilities to offer, you know, 3% denominated Bitcoin
- 8:42yield through unsecured lending, which seems insanely risky to
- 8:45me. You just naturally don't know
- 8:47your counterparty and your Bitcoin isn't on your balance
- 8:50sheet if you do something like that and it just kind of it
- 8:53comes and goes with every single cycle is the price runs.
- 8:56There are new people who come and say, hey, I'm new to
- 8:59Bitcoin, I know how to finally solve this problem with the
- 9:02asset and it just naturally introduces so many levels of
- 9:06counterparty risk. There are in addition to that,
- 9:09there were other people who are saying everything under the sun
- 9:13related to, you know, selling covered calls, etcetera, just
- 9:16options trading around the asset in order to try to get more
- 9:19Bitcoin. And that's not necessarily just
- 9:21a bad thing in itself. If you understand that, you know
- 9:24you're going to go out very far on the risk curve and you know
- 9:27allocate to a hedge fund type strategy.
- 9:30But I think that's fundamentally different from an operating
- 9:34business in which you have a core strategy in which you are
- 9:38planning to deliver value to the world and through goods and
- 9:40services that people really want and need versus outperforming
- 9:44through trading. And I would just say give
- 9:47extreme amount of caution to anybody who's thinking about
- 9:50allocating to those types of yield generating strategies just
- 9:54because of how many bodies that have been buried in the past
- 9:58through thinking that they are immune.
- 10:00And, and you know, even now there are more professional
- 10:03people who perhaps have a more sophisticated financial
- 10:06background who are, are going to pitch this story.
- 10:09And it's, it's a great story for people who haven't been in space
- 10:12for a while. But I would just caution to
- 10:15anybody who's allocating to the strategy to, you know, think
- 10:19about this very conservatively and perhaps just think about it
- 10:22very conservatively. Yeah, I think it's well said.
- 10:26I think we have to isolate, you know, from an individual or
- 10:29corporation that has Bitcoin exposure.
- 10:32We're trying to generate incremental yield versus the
- 10:34digital asset treasury strategy and focusing on the forward, not
- 10:37the latter. To Liam's point, it's a great
- 10:40story. It's the story of Fiat that
- 10:42you're a sucker if you hold the underlying, so you need to go
- 10:44generate some nominal yield. And it's something we talked
- 10:47about on a lot of the other pauses.
- 10:48There's a lot of great truths in every lie, and then there's a
- 10:52lot of lies in every truth, the lie and the truth.
- 10:54And that analogy is like peer-to-peer cash or whatever.
- 10:58It's like people look at it and it's like, well, this needs to,
- 11:00you know, be on chain for everything's like that's
- 11:02obviously not true. But then the truths in the lie
- 11:04are that today at scale, there really isn't a credible way, a
- 11:08risk free rate to generate any kind of material yield in
- 11:11Bitcoin. Now, it's not to say that
- 11:14somebody in a small hedge fund shop can do that, but the
- 11:17reality is that scale it's not possible.
- 11:19And so for for large holdings and then the other side of that
- 11:22is on a long enough time horizon as Bitcoin financializes, there
- 11:25will be opportunities. And if you squint, you can see
- 11:29them when it comes to whether it's second and third layers
- 11:32needing liquidity and generating some, but there's still risk and
- 11:34you have to manage the channel. Somebody has to, you know, make
- 11:36sure they're managed, not exited.
- 11:37But the point being is this all will occur.
- 11:40But today there's still so much opportunity in bitcoins growth
- 11:43that it goes back to the first thing we talked about.
- 11:45If you just treat it as a savings technology and money,
- 11:50you've already earned it. You already went out on the risk
- 11:52curve. If we're talking to businesses
- 11:53to go and operate and go through everything and all the risk it
- 11:56takes to run a business, you found the money, why would you
- 11:58put it back at risk for something that is there's no
- 12:01credible way yet to fully do it. And to Liam's point is, for 15
- 12:05years, we've seen that nobody's actually been able to, you know,
- 12:07be naked with a Bitcoin and come back and return more on a long
- 12:10enough time horizon. So, yeah, I think it's it's
- 12:12definitely the problem is that such a small percentage of the
- 12:16world is in Bitcoin. And what that means is such a
- 12:18small percentage of the world has learned what we're talking
- 12:20about here. This is where hopefully the
- 12:22education research, because very few people remember 2022.
- 12:25It's kind of crazy how many people were around in 2022 that
- 12:28think like things have changed because SPFS in jail, like the
- 12:32market structure still exist the same.
- 12:34There's still single counterparties that manage and
- 12:35hold the underline and there's still people out there selling
- 12:38that they can generate A yield. And so if all the things have
- 12:41stayed the same, but more liquidity is going to come in to
- 12:43the system, well, that kind of, you know, paints a picture that
- 12:46there's going to be more and more counterpart heroes.
- 12:49Michael, how much of this is just that there's an entire
- 12:52industry of money managers and middle men who after 16 years
- 12:56have to acknowledge that Bitcoin is a high performing asset that
- 13:00has a place in a portfolio. But if they simply say, yeah, go
- 13:04buy Bitcoin, they're not making money on that because
- 13:07individuals, investors, family offices, etcetera can self
- 13:10custody. They don't actually need that
- 13:12person once they've kind of gotten that recommendation.
- 13:16And so these middle men, these these money managers kind of
- 13:20need to come up with some kind of a way to outperform or
- 13:23promise to outperform Bitcoin through tricks that only they
- 13:27have access to or understand in order to still make their
- 13:31payday. So I usually don't like to talk
- 13:33about digital asset treasury companies that way, but it
- 13:35sounds like that's you're the rag you're taking.
- 13:38And so, yeah, I mean, this is the tale of financial products,
- 13:41right? Whether it's rent seeking,
- 13:43inserting, you know, financial products, you see this, I love
- 13:46the Bitwise guys because you know, they'll say these things,
- 13:49they'll say they're sophisticated, but they'll also
- 13:52have no idea what they're doing. I remember you can still go
- 13:54back. There was a multi coin top five
- 13:56top ten index of NFTS that they partner with and it got
- 14:00completely scrubbed from their website.
- 14:01And you know, they sold this to institutional people.
- 14:04But point being is that the game is because we got so far away.
- 14:08And this is ultimately, I think what I hope this podcast really
- 14:11speaks to is businesses that are producing real value in the real
- 14:14world, trying to preserve, protect their capital and then
- 14:17take more and more market share, right?
- 14:18What a business ultimately is meant to do finds the signal of
- 14:22OK, well, I want this asset. I can, you know, we talked about
- 14:25in the first podcast margin compression, all the things
- 14:27inflation, you know, the insidious part of it can get
- 14:30from it and then realize, OK, well, the value is custody,
- 14:34being able to buy, lend against it if you need operating
- 14:36capital. But we got so far away from
- 14:39people delivering value that the way that people monetize is by
- 14:43inserting themselves in the middle of the asset.
- 14:45And so this is where the top 10 cryptocurrency basket, to your
- 14:49point, the digital asset treasury company, I'm going to
- 14:51generate more yield or other financial products because if
- 14:55they don't have any differentiated way to custody,
- 14:57well then we already seen this distribution go to Fidelity and
- 15:00Coinbase. So they're not going to be able
- 15:01to custody and get really scale there, especially for their
- 15:04investors. Execution is another example.
- 15:07Sure, they'll get some execution, but that's already
- 15:08starting to go to best in class market makers.
- 15:11So you have to be able to develop a different position.
- 15:13And to Liam's point, it's a great story to say, well, we can
- 15:17generate nominal yield because who doesn't want additional
- 15:19interest on the underlying? But it all stems back from they
- 15:23just forgot how to deliver value.
- 15:25And so this is how you can do it is by effectively inserting
- 15:28yourself your asset management fees.
- 15:31But when you go and look at the back testing and all these like
- 15:33performance, everything is basically outside of like MSTR
- 15:37and even MSTR on a long time horizon has it.
- 15:39But outside of MSTR in the past five years, like nothing's
- 15:41outperformed just holding spot BTC.
- 15:43Yeah, Yeah. I think that's a great point.
- 15:45Like I think to our audience here in this podcast, Bitcoin
- 15:48for businesses, I think like when you, when you adopt
- 15:53Bitcoin, when you build that Bitcoin treasury, you're,
- 15:56you're, you're hedging against that Fiat debasement.
- 15:58And, and often I would, I would maybe challenge that if you're
- 16:01sort of chasing yield or want to, to find the yield there with
- 16:06that allocation, you're, I would kind of challenge like, well,
- 16:09why would you, why would you want to have yield on that when
- 16:12you can just protect the asset that you have that will protect
- 16:15against Fiat debasement and, and have that opportunity to, to
- 16:19really leverage Bitcoin in that way.
- 16:21Because if you're a business, like ultimately that's your
- 16:23goal. And I think not losing sight of
- 16:26that is is very important. Yeah.
- 16:28And so at the end of the day to generate that yield you, you are
- 16:31kind of having to give up your access, your control over the
- 16:35underlying that Bitcoin is probably being re hypothecated
- 16:38in some way. And so it kind of ties into the
- 16:42next topic, which is credit risk, right, Liam, I'm going to
- 16:46kind of kick it over to you. There's we're seeing some
- 16:49turmoil regarding auto loans and and we've seen kind of in many
- 16:55industries, a lot of businesses writing credit to folks who
- 16:59don't have great credit scores and maybe are are kind of
- 17:03unreliable repairs of those loans.
- 17:06Why don't you kick us off there and then we can get into the
- 17:08conversation of kind of money versus credit?
- 17:10Thanks, Jace. Yeah.
- 17:12Well, Tricolor Credit Party, which is a very large auto
- 17:17lender in the used auto market, they essentially just went
- 17:21bankrupt due to fraud as well as underwriting customers who had
- 17:25pretty much no credit scores. These loans were then secured
- 17:28and sold by the biggest banks in the space, JP Morgan's, a few
- 17:32others. And then, you know, the entire
- 17:34used auto market is, you know, kind of crashing a little bit.
- 17:39So Carmack stock dropped like 20%, etcetera, but it's, it's
- 17:43just kind of goes back to the understanding that the consumer
- 17:46is under pressure. And we've seen a lot of
- 17:49challenges with underwriting correctly in areas of the market
- 17:54where consumers are challenged. And you know, we've seen
- 17:57everything from, you know, all the payday loan shops and used
- 18:01auto market now is the prices of those just absolutely
- 18:04skyrocketed in 2021. And thinking that money was
- 18:07going to grow on trees forever, which we all know is just like a
- 18:09complete fallacy. And many of these companies are
- 18:13just kind of now, despite the fact that they would write loans
- 18:16to anybody under the sun back in the day when the cost of credit
- 18:21was essentially 0. Now a lending standards are a
- 18:24bit more tighter just given the lack of income for lower income
- 18:28consumers and everything that we've talked about there,
- 18:31there's a decent amount of defaults in the space.
- 18:33And so it's just kind of a cascading effect where you
- 18:37generally, if you're a auto dealer who has other, you
- 18:42necessarily like pretty much have to go to outsourced lenders
- 18:46in order to sell your vehicles. Because otherwise, if your
- 18:49customer can't have credit, they're just not, you're not
- 18:52going to be able to compete with others who can buy on credit.
- 18:54But that's a massive risk to understanding what you are, what
- 18:59you're actually going to get in terms of your revenue when it's
- 19:02going to come to you, as well as if it's going to be done
- 19:06tranched off and sold from those lenders back to somebody else.
- 19:11It's it's essentially just a massive Ponzi.
- 19:13And the take away is just you need to store your money in
- 19:17Bitcoin because you never know if your counterparty who says
- 19:21that they're going to be able to pay you is going to be good on
- 19:24their money. And you know, the big ones will
- 19:26get bailed out. But on a long enough time
- 19:28horizon, you're going to be defaulted, either implicitly
- 19:32through them not having the credit or just needing bailouts
- 19:35from the necessity of governments printing more money
- 19:39in order to make those lenders whole.
- 19:40Yeah. I think the way I interpret that
- 19:44is from a holistic perspective. There is AI mean almost every
- 19:49business, but there is a acute level of businesses that are
- 19:53tied to interest rates and we've seen this happen as interest
- 19:58rates have risen. The one that was a great example
- 20:01was Open Store I believe. Which had a billion dollar
- 20:05valuation at its peak. Now they just recently raised it
- 20:08like a 5050 million valuation, you know, a very big down round.
- 20:13They were like an aggregator of Shopify, D2C companies.
- 20:17And then they ultimately like end up just going to a singular
- 20:19Shopify like selling shoes or something.
- 20:21But the point being is that if you do not what's the Texas slim
- 20:25is like you can either engineer your suffering or the market
- 20:28will. It's like if your company and
- 20:30your whole business and livelihood has been, you know,
- 20:32you didn't know it because it's the water you swam in, but is
- 20:35predicated on lower interest rates.
- 20:38Well, it's out of your control. And if you recognize you're in
- 20:41that you can play that game, but it'll ultimately be at your
- 20:44demise because it'll inevitably crash.
- 20:46Because whether the prices go back up and down, it's no way to
- 20:49build a solid foundation. I think we're Liam's driving ad
- 20:52is ultimately, once you recognize this, you can start to
- 20:54insulate yourself not only by holding better form of capital,
- 20:57but you can start to rethink your business model to protect
- 21:00yourself. Whether it's if you have a
- 21:01larger Bitcoin balance sheet, you can lend against that and
- 21:03you can have an actual underlying collateral, you can
- 21:05restructure how your business built.
- 21:06You know, obviously you can't do this to every business, but I
- 21:09think that's a core thing I take from that is that all these
- 21:11different systems are insanely fragile.
- 21:13And if your business is predicated on the cost of
- 21:16capital being low, whether it's SAS or any other, you know,
- 21:19we'll talk about AI later, that ties into this that you're right
- 21:22for whether it's competition to come in and do things cheaper or
- 21:26ultimately for the Fed to change the interest rate and then
- 21:28ultimately change your clientele demand for it, or also your cost
- 21:32of services, which will ultimately compressed prices,
- 21:35margins and, and put you out of business on a long enough time,
- 21:37right? Yeah, I think the age-old JP
- 21:40Morgan kind of quote for the modern days, Bitcoin is money,
- 21:43everything else is credit. We've heard it thrown around a
- 21:46lot. I think a lot of business owners
- 21:48don't realize that their revenue streams if they're making
- 21:52dollars and storing and kind of Fiat based treasuries that they
- 21:56are taking credit risk. They don't often think about it.
- 21:58They think, oh, cash is liquid, cash is value, but they are
- 22:01taking credit risk in some ways to the United States government
- 22:04and their ability to just print your treasury and debase your
- 22:09treasury away. And so Bitcoin really has that
- 22:12no credit risk. That's what makes it money
- 22:14versus dollars, which are some form of credit.
- 22:18And I think what we're kind of saying here is that these credit
- 22:20based revenue streams got themselves into trouble, not
- 22:23just because it's a flawed revenue stream on the surface,
- 22:26but it's almost like a credit squared situation where they're
- 22:30also earning in Fiat and taking credit risk with their treasury
- 22:35and their revenue stream. And so we would all here
- 22:37encourage companies to either accept Bitcoin as payment or
- 22:40convert those dollars into Bitcoin treasuries as quickly as
- 22:44possible and start to think about your business on a Bitcoin
- 22:47standard. Any final thoughts on that?
- 22:49Matt, did you have any thoughts? No, I think you bring up a good
- 22:53point on even accepting the Bitcoin payments like the using
- 22:56tools like the Lightning Network are just gonna create that
- 23:00increased opportunity for businesses to really increase
- 23:04their margins and have more survivability in the business
- 23:09competition. And so we should keep an eye on
- 23:11that. And especially with things
- 23:13coming out like cashew and cashew mints and all of these
- 23:16mints, I think it's a it's a really big opportunity for
- 23:18businesses to accept payments and just increase their
- 23:21competition and their power of of doing business in such a
- 23:26competitive marketplace. Yeah.
- 23:28I mean, I didn't, I was going to go here with a different topic,
- 23:31but I'll share it here is I do think the sweeping becoming a
- 23:35Bitcoin business, the different types of sophisticated payments
- 23:39will will come. But I think for at least a
- 23:41portion of this podcast, hoping it goes in this direction that
- 23:44people share it is there is a very pragmatic reason.
- 23:48While every business like that will make sense because a lot of
- 23:50people don't know what cashier's.
- 23:51But there's a pragmatic reason where every business should not
- 23:54only have like 1 to 3% of capital in Bitcoin today and
- 23:58also have flow of payments. And the first one is Silicon
- 24:03Valley Bank 2022 goes out of business or goes, goes, goes
- 24:08belly up over the weekend at least.
- 24:10And a bunch of people were worried about making payroll.
- 24:12So from a business continuity perspective, whether you need
- 24:15good services, food, payroll, you should have something that's
- 24:19outside the system. That's just like the prudent
- 24:21thing to do. Doesn't matter how much you
- 24:22don't like Bitcoin unless you're going to part gold somewhere.
- 24:25And I don't know how many employees are going to take gold
- 24:27or you're going to be able to switch it into dollars on Monday
- 24:30morning to get payroll. And then on the other side,
- 24:32which I've always really appreciated, what Zaprite has
- 24:35done is they don't force you to have to accept Bitcoin.
- 24:38They just put Bitcoin next to it.
- 24:40So they connect the rails from any core business to anybody
- 24:44that wants to pay. And the reason why you would
- 24:46want to start thinking about that is ultimately in different
- 24:49places, whether it's interchange fees or just ultimately where,
- 24:54again, it goes back to continuity for whatever reason,
- 24:56if somebody wants to pay in something that has no
- 24:58intermediary, it's available while everyone else can still
- 25:01pay via credit card. ACH and all the other things
- 25:05like these are just core tenants of a world that is increasingly
- 25:08looking volatile that you would want and not have to understand
- 25:11any of this, just that your business needs to be anti
- 25:13fragile. I think every business owner
- 25:15would want that. So I do think it's important.
- 25:17We'll talk about innovation as well, but just from like a
- 25:20holistic experience like any personal planet Earth would.
- 25:22Ideally, if they're pragmatic, want both of those too.
- 25:25It doesn't even require them having to understand Bitcoin
- 25:27from a store value long term perspective.
- 25:29Yeah, one of the pieces you're getting at is just the speed at
- 25:32which you can teleport money in the digital age.
- 25:35And that kind of leads into the next topic we wanted to cover.
- 25:38So cloud Fair, they're coming out with what you would I guess
- 25:41call their own native token for their AI agents.
- 25:45And I'll read off a quote from the press release.
- 25:47The AI driven Internet will need money that is instant, global
- 25:51and secure so that AI agents, developers and creators can
- 25:55transact instantly, automatically, and reliably.
- 26:00End of quote. So obviously the folks on this
- 26:02call would expect Bitcoin to play that role.
- 26:05But I'm curious if this is a situation where kind of early
- 26:09Internet, we saw intranet versus Internet and that the open
- 26:13protocol eventually won out the day.
- 26:16Because when I look at this, I think, OK, great, your AI is
- 26:19transacting with someone else or some other entity.
- 26:22Are they really going to want this net dollar as they've
- 26:26termed it? Or are those businesses and
- 26:28those individuals eventually going to demand Bitcoin?
- 26:31So I think this is important that I think individuals at
- 26:35least early stage of this pod and us here would be like, yes,
- 26:38of course it's going to be Bitcoin, but it makes complete
- 26:40sense that it starts with stable coins.
- 26:41Because if for better or worse, more people are interested
- 26:46today, whether it's a bank or an enterprise in stable coins and
- 26:50what are they going to do to get dollars into stable coins?
- 26:53What are they going to do to help companies hold stable
- 26:55coins? There's a lot more value, to be
- 26:57honest, to administer stable coins from a cross-border.
- 27:00There's like the, the, the, the number is Stripe only powers 1%
- 27:06of the total B to B payment flows.
- 27:09So like when you think about if you're a company sending company
- 27:12to where what other specifically internationally, they're only at
- 27:151% of that. So it's a huge opportunity.
- 27:19And from volatility to education, people are just not
- 27:23going to adopt Bitcoin today, they're going to adopt dollars.
- 27:27And so if you take that same lens and go into if they already
- 27:31understand that will the logical progression is if they're using
- 27:34AI and they already have access to the unit of account that is
- 27:37used globally in dollars and stable coins are understood,
- 27:40that is going to be the first step.
- 27:42But I think the natural progression because the same
- 27:45problems that exist with interchange and ACH and
- 27:47centralization and debasement occur with or going to occur in
- 27:50a different form with stable coins via a genetic AI.
- 27:53Because you'll still have whether it's micro or just other
- 27:57factors that programmability in a unified or a non unified like
- 28:02global decentralized asset versus all these different
- 28:05stable coins have their own kind of permissioning will naturally
- 28:08take place of, oh, this is just better.
- 28:11But I don't think it's going to happen like right off the bat.
- 28:13And this is where I think it makes sense that you're seeing
- 28:15cloud for do their thing. I think USDC came out last week.
- 28:19I think it was USDC with Google. So I think that's just like the
- 28:22call and it's a natural thing to be like we want it to be
- 28:24Bitcoin. But the reality is it's a lot
- 28:26easier to meet them with a stable coin because that's
- 28:29already kind of pretty disruptive and radical in those
- 28:32wall, in the walls of that organization.
- 28:34Agreed, there's just so much that's going to go into swapping
- 28:38for whichever other stable coin that they want to pay another
- 28:41agent getting it into actual dollars.
- 28:44Or I assume that they're not going to be massive cross-border
- 28:46payments within the cloud fair token and that people will
- 28:51naturally just want to have different tokens for different
- 28:54use cases at 1st. And it doesn't necessarily make
- 28:57sense to have a ton of different monies.
- 29:00It's just not something you want interoperable money.
- 29:03Now the US dollar has the biggest market cap, Lindy of
- 29:07people are just going to naturally use that.
- 29:09And so it's, it's really exciting to see everybody kind
- 29:12of come into this space. But naturally it's, it's kind of
- 29:16like just what we talked about lending on your Bitcoin
- 29:19originally and trying to essentially be a casino just
- 29:23like people who naturally, and this isn't naturally one that's
- 29:28pernicious, but they just think that they have finally solved
- 29:32the problem for the industry. But naturally money converges
- 29:35into one. People want to use just the same
- 29:37money as everybody else. So it's either going to be 1
- 29:40stable point is going to win or and eventually there are issues
- 29:44with that whether it comes to censorship resistant circles
- 29:47talking about potentially reversing some of their
- 29:49transactions to have the same type of payments like credit
- 29:53cards. There can be fraud with that.
- 29:55And then just the issues of, you know, censorship resistant are
- 30:00just going to naturally make Bitcoin become more adopted as
- 30:03well as just the fact that there's only 21 million.
- 30:05So naturally that will grow over time with adoption and get more
- 30:08of the market cap that will take away for share from the dollar
- 30:11and stable coins. Hey guys, a quick word from
- 30:14Early Riders. If you like concepts like
- 30:17Bitcoin is a hurdle rate as well as following along with
- 30:19everything across Bitcoin infrastructure, Bitcoin startups
- 30:23today, I highly recommend you check out Early Riders and
- 30:26everything that we're doing there.
- 30:27We're putting out a ton of research.
- 30:29So please subscribe at earlyriders.com/research and
- 30:33please reach out if you're ever interested in how to get
- 30:35involved. Thanks.
- 30:36Yeah, ultimately these are value transfer protocols and whether
- 30:40we like it or not, the majority of the world still sees the
- 30:42dollar as perhaps the best store of value, especially in non-us
- 30:47jurisdictions. And you know, it's a long uphill
- 30:50battle until the world sees Bitcoin as the premier store of
- 30:53value. So to be continued and as
- 30:57expected there. So one other piece on this AI
- 31:00front, Elon Musk came out with some comments that I know,
- 31:03Michael, you wanted to touch on basically saying that if you're
- 31:07going to define artificial general intelligence as AI that
- 31:10is smarter than the smartest human on Earth, that we could be
- 31:13there within months, but definitely within the next two
- 31:16years. I guess I know how they would
- 31:18quantify that from the AI standpoint.
- 31:21But Michael, when they're testing against the AI and the
- 31:26smartest human, are they plugging you into a server?
- 31:29Is it a neural link? How are they running those tests
- 31:32with you? I don't know if it's with me
- 31:34particular, I think I think the core notion of the AI stuff ties
- 31:38back to what Liam was sharing that it will naturally converge
- 31:42in the sense that, and this is a big business opportunity and it
- 31:45ties also to the very beginning about it's just a savings
- 31:48technology. So if you have dollars and
- 31:49you're bringing them in, eventually you're just going to
- 31:51realize one goes down in value, one goes up and it's going to be
- 31:54very nice to seamlessly switch into it.
- 31:56And then over time, you're going to wonder why you're not just
- 31:58doing everything else with it. And that's where, you know, part
- 32:00of the convergence with Agentic, yeah, using Bitcoin, there'll be
- 32:03also better programmability. Where this ties into all of that
- 32:07is the notion is coming. We know it.
- 32:11I don't think it's fully understood how asymmetric and
- 32:15fast a lot of these tool, the tooling will be from robotics to
- 32:19just software. And it's naturally like going to
- 32:23converge on as it increases in the usage, meaning the ability
- 32:29to whether it's back office, we see it with legal, we see it
- 32:32with all these different programs.
- 32:34But then also that's going to in a vacuum, if everything was like
- 32:37fine and there was no inflation, there wasn't a focus with
- 32:41interest rates, whip sign and margin compression where people
- 32:45were fine, it would be probably a slower adoption.
- 32:47Or companies have to cut and they have a mandate to cut.
- 32:50And it's almost becoming like a thematic version of how are you
- 32:54getting rid of people for AI? They're going to be forced to
- 32:57figure it out. And that's really what gets
- 32:59crazy. And the topic I brought it for
- 33:00businesses is because if you're not doing this or have this on
- 33:04your radar, that AI is going to be inherently deflationary to
- 33:08your business. And the cost you're able to
- 33:10derive from goods and services, you will get out competed on
- 33:14that side. And then the other side is if
- 33:16you're not protecting yourself from it, because if you're able
- 33:19to do both, if you're able to leverage the tools that are
- 33:21exists so you can compete at the highest level while also storing
- 33:25money in the best form of savings technology, well, you're
- 33:28going to be really good moving forward.
- 33:30But if you do one or the other, you're probably still going to
- 33:32make it. But if you're doing neither,
- 33:33which is most people, you're in a very bad place.
- 33:37And I think if that's the essence, at least why I'm most
- 33:39excited about this podcast and these discussions is because
- 33:42this isn't on people's radar yet.
- 33:43And it's going to just, like, hit him across the head to the
- 33:46point where they're going to knock him out for good.
- 33:48Yeah, well, this is another good one.
- 33:50We should talk about more and figure out a segment to dive
- 33:53into use cases, whether it's at the companies we're building.
- 33:57The one I always like to talk about is the podcast and the
- 33:59number of pods. And when we first started, we
- 34:01would go and talk to traditional producers and they'd say it's
- 34:03$1000 an episode to produce. And that's historically what it
- 34:07would cost. And, you know, now we know for
- 34:092999 and, you know, Riverside and some AI tools that will cut
- 34:12up and make the shorts and programmatically distribute, you
- 34:16can do that for 2999 a month. Like that's the kind of stuff.
- 34:19So where does that guy go now? And a lot of businesses still
- 34:22spend that money on production. And so you Add all of that fat
- 34:26in a traditional company, while others are just going to
- 34:29leverage the tooling, their cost to deliver the services.
- 34:32They'll pass that through the consumer if they're a good
- 34:34business, which will lower the cost of the product and then
- 34:38you'll take more market share. And that's just a reflexive
- 34:40flywheel that historically had been there, but with inflation
- 34:43and the fat we see in the market.
- 34:45So anyway, I think this is part of like a different topic, but
- 34:49another one we should go into is why the digital asset treasury
- 34:53company kind of thematic version of like we can aggregate a war
- 34:56chest and allocate it. Unless that's widely understood
- 35:00on how do you adopt like anything you acquire or go and
- 35:02build, you have to deeply understand where what you're
- 35:05buying and how they built it by being a builder or that it just
- 35:08because you can allocate money doesn't make it necessarily a
- 35:11productive use of that capital. And that's really the kind of
- 35:15notion that I think still isn't understood by the market is that
- 35:18it goes back to the yield generation point.
- 35:20If you don't know how they're generated because you've never
- 35:22developed how to generate yield, you won't know where the risk
- 35:24lies and you're ultimately throwing good money after bad
- 35:27effectively all. Right, one last topic that we
- 35:30wanted to cover with the last few minutes of the podcast.
- 35:33Here is this interesting story that 90% of Y Combinator B to B
- 35:37companies have 50% of their revenue generation coming from
- 35:42other YC companies. It's very interesting.
- 35:46I wonder how sustainable it is. Perhaps YC would argue that it's
- 35:50one of the benefits of joining their program is that you get
- 35:53kind of these network effects and you get easy sales into the
- 35:56other YC companies. And but curious what you guys
- 35:59think about this dynamic, Is this healthy?
- 36:02Yeah, I'll share it quickly and then I'm going to jump for you
- 36:04guys to wrap. I experienced this first hand at
- 36:06We Work when I saw everyone in the we Work was DoorDash, Uber
- 36:12and there was a very like fly. It was a flex, a flywheel to the
- 36:15upside and then it unwound. It's very similar to like, you
- 36:18know, yield generation in this space where the leverage gets
- 36:20built in via 0 interest rate and SoftBank in A16Z and these other
- 36:25firms, you naturally have that incentive pricing up rounds,
- 36:29getting more users. You have the network effect of,
- 36:31you know, why see companies making the introductions.
- 36:33But again, it all ties back to the lacking of fundamentals
- 36:36because if their capital actually 50% of it is predicated
- 36:40on somebody else, that's tied into the same ecosystem because
- 36:43those companies are funded. They're also pre revenue,
- 36:45generally startups. Well, if your company has 50% of
- 36:49its revenue coming from companies that are unprofitable,
- 36:51that's generally not a sound business structure to start
- 36:54from. And it's also distorts the
- 36:55pricing mechanism because those companies inherently are going
- 36:59to go out of business because it's startups in Silicon Valley.
- 37:01So they're not going to bat probably what's known as 10 to
- 37:0520% success rate, meaning you don't even know who actually
- 37:07needs your product or not. And so, yeah, it was an
- 37:10interesting, the main reason I called it out was because it was
- 37:13a tweet that was looking back at NVIDIA and NVIDIA.
- 37:18And it's not Oracle. It's the other firm that's
- 37:21heavily like, there's another, what was the other?
- 37:24Yeah, open AI and NVIDIA, it's like you give 100 million and
- 37:27they invest 300 million. And there's something also going
- 37:29on with a similar loop with Oracle.
- 37:32And the point being is that this is just a product of again, too
- 37:36much capital, misaligned incentives and really getting
- 37:40back to the studs of the fundamentals will inherently
- 37:44come about. I don't think know if there's
- 37:45anything necessarily actionable here except for if you're going
- 37:48to build a business, you naturally want to make sure that
- 37:50your users, you have not necessarily a Moat, but your
- 37:54acquisition of clients have not only stickiness, but they're
- 37:58not, they are not prone to fluctuations in the market that
- 38:03will effectively put them insolvent and then you won't
- 38:06have a business with that. Yeah, I think it's, I think it's
- 38:09a good point. And specifically on the Y
- 38:11Combinator front, I mean living in the Bay Area, seeing many of
- 38:15my friends that would have start-ups that are in the
- 38:17classes for Y Combinator. I think they often comment on
- 38:21the fact that those start-ups that they're working within,
- 38:25they often serve as each other's initial customers.
- 38:28And they kind of use that as like a testing grounds for how
- 38:32kind of work and go to market, which is interesting.
- 38:37I think something like 4% of the Y Combinator companies drive
- 38:41like over like almost 90% of the realized gains coming out of Y
- 38:45Combinator. So it's, it's definitely
- 38:47something that should be talked about.
- 38:50And I think Michael spoke about it about that just misallocation
- 38:53of capital and the potential for them to kind of lean out and
- 38:58potentially even combined companies.
- 38:59But at the end of the day, there's a lot of ego in those
- 39:02environments and those customers and those companies want to kind
- 39:06of build out into in creating those Airbnb is those coin bases
- 39:11that have come out of Y Combinator.
- 39:12So the competition is certainly interesting.
- 39:15And then also layer on the fact that a lot of those companies
- 39:18are there their own customers within that ecosystem.
- 39:21It's quite an interesting sort of dichotomy that's going on in
- 39:25the in the Y Combinator bubble. Yeah, exactly.
- 39:27This kind of goes back to what we touched on last week too.
- 39:30You want your entire supply chain to be sound for the long
- 39:34term of wanting your just like at home.
- 39:37You want your family to adopt Bitcoin, you want your neighbors
- 39:39to adopt Bitcoin so you can have a strong community.
- 39:42And there's a lot of people doing great things on that.
- 39:45And we saw how that it's working out at Bitcoin Park in a
- 39:47positive way. But just like that, you want all
- 39:50of your suppliers and customers to operate under a Bitcoin
- 39:53standard as well. Do we have a negative impact if
- 39:55a Bitcoin does go down 80% again, and not saying that'll
- 39:59never happened, but everything that Michael talked about from
- 40:02having enough working capital in both dollars and Bitcoin, being
- 40:04able to sweep a reasonable amount of your free cash flow
- 40:07into Bitcoin in order to sustain your business for a long term
- 40:11and operate with sound fundamentals.
- 40:13To not just having essentially big deep pockets fund you for a
- 40:19short amount of time in which you're you necessarily need to
- 40:22lose cash and. Be burning it and have your
- 40:24customers losing cash, it means just you're extremely
- 40:27susceptible to any changes in the market and would rather kind
- 40:31of fortify yourself and your customers and suppliers with
- 40:34Bitcoin rather than short Y Combinator or any other venture
- 40:38backed. Yeah.
- 40:39Ultimately, to run a sound business, you need to store your
- 40:44retained earnings in sound capital.
- 40:46But you also have a financial or moral duty to become profitable
- 40:50as quickly as possible. And too many companies today
- 40:53rely on the next round of investor cash, building out
- 40:56products and services that may or may not have product market
- 40:59fit, may or may not reach those economies of scale that allow
- 41:03them to flip into profitability. But with tools like AI that are
- 41:08naturally deflationary and allow for smaller teams and tools like
- 41:12Bitcoin as savings technology on the balance sheet that can give
- 41:15you infinite runway to some degree, as long as you're not
- 41:18tapping it too frequently, we really are seeing a moment in
- 41:21time where business operators need to lean into both
- 41:23technologies. Consider it a moral duty to
- 41:26become profitable so that, again, you're not selling the
- 41:29Bitcoin, you're not relying on investor cash.
- 41:31That's dilutive, and you can really own your own future.
- 41:35I think this been another great episode, episode number 2 of
- 41:39Bitcoin for businesses. Give us some feedback in the
- 41:42comments if we're touching on the topics that you're
- 41:44interested in. Are we two in the weeds?
- 41:46Are we not in the weeds enough? We really want this to be
- 41:49actionable insights as well as mixing in some relevant news of
- 41:53the week. So give us that feedback.
- 41:55Give us the like, subscribe and a share to a business owner that
- 41:58you think needs to start integrating Bitcoin into various
- 42:01areas of their business. And of course, reach out to the
- 42:04early Riders on Ramp or Acropolis team if you'd like to
- 42:07do more than just listen to podcasts and you're ready to
- 42:10take action. Thank you so much for joining me
- 42:13again today. Thanks so much, Chase.
- 42:15Thanks, Chase. Every business will hold
- 42:17Bitcoin. Some already do.
- 42:18Others are developing a plan. Acropolis is how smart companies
- 42:22take action today. Built on multi Institution
- 42:25Custody, Acropolis delivers a turnkey Bitcoin treasury
- 42:28solution designed specifically for businesses.
- 42:31Here's why that matters. Multi Institution custody is the
- 42:34breakthrough that unlocks the corporate adoption of Bitcoin.
- 42:37It eliminates the need for employees to hold cryptographic
- 42:40material and removes reliance on any single custodian.
- 42:43Instead, Bitcoin is secured using a two of three multi
- 42:46signature quorum, where each key is held by a separate regulated
- 42:50institution. No single party can move funds
- 42:53on their own, eliminating single points of failure and greatly
- 42:56reducing risk. We act as an extension of your
- 42:59treasury team, managing institutional grade custody,
- 43:02insurance, continuity planning and strategic advisory so your
- 43:06company can adopt Bitcoin confidently and securely.
- 43:09If your team has been sitting on the sidelines, unsure of how to
- 43:12get started or worried about getting it wrong, this is your
- 43:15signal. Visit Acropolis Treasury Calm
- 43:18and schedule a consultation. Bitcoin is reshaping corporate
- 43:21finance. Don't get left behind.