Latest / Views and News with Clarence Ford / Roundtable on Homelessness and Socio-Economic Issues
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: But let's move this conversation on now, on the issues
- 0:03Speaker 1: that affect Cape Town. And it's quite clear that we
- 0:07Speaker 1: have a city that.
- 0:09Speaker 2: Lives on two different planets.
- 0:13Speaker 1: We have a city that is increasingly affluent, and we
- 0:17Speaker 1: have a city who is increasingly getting poorer. You couple
- 0:22Speaker 1: that with a housing crisis, and you see an.
- 0:25Speaker 2: Explosion of homelessness.
- 0:30Speaker 1: On our streets the NGOs the shelters the churches the
- 0:34Speaker 1: civic organizations the neighborhood watches the community activists they are
- 0:38Speaker 1: trying to fill the gaps here how do we deal
- 0:41Speaker 1: how do we help the unhoused and I thought it
- 0:46Speaker 1: would be prudent Clarence that we invite guests here today
- 0:50Speaker 1: that would experience we have experienced but we'll talk to
- 0:54Speaker 1: what the city has been experiencing and where the city
- 0:57Speaker 1: needs to go to would you mind introducing.
- 0:58Speaker 2: Our guests Yes, indeed.
- 1:00Speaker 3: And of course, we see it on the streets of
- 1:03Speaker 3: Cape Town.
- 1:03Speaker 4: We see homelessness in this community where Lester and I live.
- 1:09Speaker 4: And yeah, it is increasingly a conversational point on WhatsApp groups.
- 1:15Speaker 4: And the people that we've gathered around to help us
- 1:17Speaker 4: understand issues have been working in this area for a
- 1:20Speaker 4: very long time. And you would have seen them, heard
- 1:22Speaker 4: them featured on Cape Talk as well. Shadi Valeyadum is
- 1:26Speaker 4: the CEO of the Haven Night Shelter.
- 1:27Speaker 5: He's here with us.
- 1:29Speaker 4: We've got U-Turn Homeless Ministries. We've spoken to Stephen Underwood
- 1:32Speaker 4: on so many occasions. Of course, Ria Toussaint, our foundation,
- 1:36Speaker 4: Phineas Sabitsani has joined us in the past. And Magda Reynolds,
- 1:42Speaker 4: business and development manager at NICRA, an organization certainly very
- 1:45Speaker 4: dear to my heart and doing amazing work with crime
- 1:49Speaker 4: and the rehabilitation of offenders. So a lot of mind
- 1:53Speaker 4: power gathered in this particular room to tackle issues.
- 1:57Speaker 1: I want to start this conversation with Phineas, who I've
- 2:00Speaker 1: known for some time now in his work, not only
- 2:03Speaker 1: in ministry within Paul's More Prison, but with quite deep,
- 2:08Speaker 1: literal friendships with people who are housed in the Musenberg area.
- 2:15Speaker 2: He sees those who are unseen.
- 2:18Speaker 1: He has mourned people who have died under sheets of cardboard.
- 2:24Speaker 6: Phineas.
- 2:25Speaker 2: Just talk to us about how much, how big.
- 2:27Speaker 1: Is this issue of unhoused people in this city? The
- 2:34Speaker 1: statistics give us a very big picture, but we also
- 2:37Speaker 1: say the statistics isn't the only picture.
- 2:41Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 2:42Speaker 7: I think for me, looking over the ocean, I feel
- 2:44Speaker 7: like with homelessness, it feels like we're mopping the ocean.
- 2:49Speaker 7: It seems like we are going backward, not forward.
- 2:51Speaker 8: Right.
- 2:52Speaker 7: Because one of the problems that I'm seeing is that
- 2:54Speaker 7: you can't solve homelessness in one of the most expensive
- 3:00Speaker 7: cities in the world, where you're pricing people into homelessness.
- 3:05Speaker 7: So I am for safe spaces, but safe spaces comes
- 3:08Speaker 7: with access to affordable housing. Poverty is a real thing
- 3:12Speaker 7: in our communities. We have so many people who are
- 3:15Speaker 7: coming out of prison who end up on the street.
- 3:18Speaker 7: We have too many people who come out of foster
- 3:19Speaker 7: systems who end up on the street. So it's not
- 3:22Speaker 7: just an issue of somebody growing up in poverty where
- 3:26Speaker 7: we blame somebody for not succeeding in a toxic environment.
- 3:31Speaker 7: And my issue oftentimes is that we criminalize homeless people
- 3:35Speaker 7: and we blame them for not growing in an environment
- 3:39Speaker 7: where they were put.
- 3:40Speaker 5: Into that is very toxic.
- 3:42Speaker 7: And what we're trying to do is as much as
- 3:44Speaker 7: we're trying to rehabilitate the seed, we need to also
- 3:47Speaker 7: look at the soil. We also need to look at
- 3:49Speaker 7: the city on how it treats those who are living
- 3:52Speaker 7: on the street, whether through law enforcement or any sort
- 3:56Speaker 7: of system that keeps on oppressing people who are living
- 3:59Speaker 7: on the street. Like you said, I have too many
- 4:01Speaker 7: friends that died on the street, and a lot of
- 4:04Speaker 7: them have been treated like litter or passed around like
- 4:08Speaker 7: a rugby ball from one place to another. And that's
- 4:11Speaker 7: why the question is always, are we trying to get
- 4:14Speaker 7: rid of homeless people or are we trying to help
- 4:17Speaker 7: homeless people?
- 4:18Speaker 4: It's 10.23 and, of course, we're looking at homelessness and
- 4:22Speaker 4: socioeconomic issues. And you're welcome to join the conversation via
- 4:26Speaker 4: WhatsApp at 0725671567. Phineas, you've written extensively about homelessness of
- 4:33Speaker 4: not belonging, and.
- 4:33Speaker 3: I'm trying to understand it. You essentially highlight.
- 4:37Speaker 4: That homelessness is more than just a lack of a shelter.
- 4:40Speaker 3: It's a lack of a relationship and community.
- 4:43Speaker 5: Yeah. I think.
- 4:46Speaker 7: The reason why I say that is because I met
- 4:47Speaker 7: a lot of people who live in nice houses who
- 4:50Speaker 7: are homeless. There's a lot of homeless people who are
- 4:54Speaker 7: at the risk of becoming homeless. Homelessness starts not from
- 5:00Speaker 7: I don't have a house to stay. It's an issue
- 5:03Speaker 7: of friendships. It's an issue of belonging. It's an issue
- 5:06Speaker 7: of family. The minute somebody does not feel like they
- 5:10Speaker 7: belong or they have community in a shelter, don't expect
- 5:13Speaker 7: them to stay in a shelter. I don't care how
- 5:15Speaker 7: beautiful it is. If there's no community, if there's no
- 5:18Speaker 7: belonging in that shelter, they're going to leave. Because what
- 5:21Speaker 7: you're trying to solve is a human issue at the core.
- 5:25Speaker 7: It is not a housing shelter issue. You know, what
- 5:28Speaker 7: people eat, what they wear, how they sleep matters in
- 5:33Speaker 7: that space of a shelter. So that's why I'm saying
- 5:35Speaker 7: that more than just looking at a homeless person, we
- 5:38Speaker 7: need to look at what do people need at their core.
- 5:41Speaker 5: And it goes back to our history in terms of
- 5:43Speaker 5: forced removals.
- 5:44Speaker 7: Where people were removed and scattered everywhere with no community
- 5:48Speaker 7: and belonging. And that's why you have gangsterism.
- 5:50Speaker 5: So fixed communities. Fixed communities is fixed belonging.
- 5:55Speaker 3: And that's the core business of local government.
- 5:58Speaker 8: Yeah.
- 5:59Speaker 3: Productive communities. Communities that are working for everybody in it.
- 6:03Speaker 8: Yeah.
- 6:03Speaker 5: Okay.
- 6:05Speaker 3: So clearly we're not fixing communities if the homeless problem
- 6:08Speaker 3: is growing. Shadi, you there at the coalface as well?
- 6:13Speaker 9: Yeah, good morning, everyone. Yeah, no, the homeless community definitely
- 6:17Speaker 9: is growing. We're looking at the economy. We're looking at
- 6:20Speaker 9: the rise of everything except salaries. Not for the haven,
- 6:26Speaker 9: of course. But, no, definitely seeing an increase in the
- 6:30Speaker 9: city when it comes to homelessness. And I think the
- 6:33Speaker 9: bigger problem is that we obviously do not have enough
- 6:38Speaker 9: shelter beds to accommodate all the homeless people.
- 6:43Speaker 6: Now, it's a three-sphere.
- 6:45Speaker 9: Approach between national government, provincial government, and local government.
- 6:52Speaker 6: Now, this is where there's a major call.
- 6:54Speaker 9: We know how much the city is doing, but there's
- 6:57Speaker 9: a call for national government as well to get involved
- 7:01Speaker 9: to help us with this pandemic. So the shelters are transitional.
- 7:07Speaker 9: We bring them in from the streets into the shelters locally.
- 7:10Speaker 9: And as you know, Clarence, we've just taken over.
- 7:13Speaker 6: All the safe spaces as well, the haven. So it's
- 7:16Speaker 6: now included.
- 7:17Speaker 9: We have now 17 sites across the Western Cape. And
- 7:20Speaker 9: with that, we're bringing in the phased approach. So your
- 7:24Speaker 9: entry is into the safe spaces, and then you move
- 7:28Speaker 9: on to the second phase and the third phase. So ideally,
- 7:31Speaker 9: a homeless person that comes off the street can live
- 7:34Speaker 9: with us for up to 18 to 24 months.
- 7:37Speaker 6: In that time, and this is what we....
- 7:41Speaker 9: We're pushing through our 33 social workers is the reunification
- 7:46Speaker 9: with the families. It's the mending of that hurt and
- 7:51Speaker 9: the disintegration of the scars that are very existent as
- 7:56Speaker 9: a result of that hurt.
- 7:57Speaker 6: As a result of drugs, as a result of theft, etc.
- 8:01Speaker 3: So our social workers.
- 8:02Speaker 9: Are working with the homeless people to try and reunify
- 8:06Speaker 9: them and mediate that process.
- 8:08Speaker 6: Then we remove them off the street permanently.
- 8:11Speaker 9: So with us taking over the safe spaces, we can
- 8:16Speaker 9: now do that phased approach.
- 8:18Speaker 1: Let's then talk about intervention. And Stephen, you represent Utah Ministries,
- 8:23Speaker 1: has done a remarkable job in.
- 8:27Speaker 1: Taking people in, but also upskilling and training them, offering
- 8:31Speaker 1: them a form of income through work, and it is
- 8:35Speaker 1: the stepping stone for a different life. How has it
- 8:41Speaker 1: benefited the people, your clients, that you have seen? What
- 8:46Speaker 1: are some of the stories there? But also, where would
- 8:48Speaker 1: you admit to be areas that could be done better?
- 8:54Speaker 5: Yeah, thanks, Lester, and hi to the listeners.
- 8:56Speaker 8: Yeah, I think Phineas has mentioned the relational side of things,
- 8:59Speaker 8: and you turn operator along four continuums, and one of
- 9:03Speaker 8: them is relationships. It's trying to get people from being
- 9:06Speaker 8: isolated and disconnected to being, you know, back united with family,
- 9:10Speaker 8: with friends, part of a community. Pastor Shadia has spoken
- 9:14Speaker 8: about housing, and we also have a housing continuum, and
- 9:16Speaker 8: I agree with Phineas. We need safe spaces, but we
- 9:19Speaker 8: also need affordable housing that's at the end of that line.
- 9:22Speaker 8: So people can move through safe spaces, shelters, transitional houses,
- 9:25Speaker 8: and into affordable housing along that continuum. And the one
- 9:28Speaker 8: you brought up there is employment, and that's one that
- 9:31Speaker 8: U-Turn definitely specializes in, is how to get someone who's
- 9:34Speaker 8: unemployed and living on the streets with very low skills
- 9:37Speaker 8: through the different phases of work until they can get
- 9:40Speaker 8: work in the open labor market. And we do it
- 9:43Speaker 8: through a phased intervention. So our clients start out by
- 9:47Speaker 8: earning vouchers for two hours a day, doing very basic
- 9:50Speaker 8: work tasks. This makes our clients engaging with work, and
- 9:54Speaker 8: it means that they are earning vouchers which they redeem
- 9:57Speaker 8: for their own basic services. So we're putting agency and
- 9:59Speaker 8: dignity back into the hands of our clients. We're not
- 10:02Speaker 8: saying to them, shame, you guys will never make it.
- 10:05Speaker 8: You're always going to need help for the rest of
- 10:07Speaker 8: your lives. We're saying to them, you can do it,
- 10:10Speaker 8: but you just need someone to come alongside you. From there,
- 10:13Speaker 8: they moved to volunteering half days. From there, they moved
- 10:16Speaker 8: to working in our social enterprises, and thank you to
- 10:18Speaker 8: all the listeners who support our shops. And from there,
- 10:20Speaker 8: into the open market. So, yeah, it's looking at those
- 10:25Speaker 8: three continuums as well as the sobriety continuum because that
- 10:28Speaker 8: is an issue, and I'm sure Magda probably has a
- 10:30Speaker 8: lot to say on that as well.
- 10:31Speaker 4: And we're going to be turning to you, Magda, in
- 10:33Speaker 4: a short while. Clearly, the family unity is under threat,
- 10:36Speaker 4: and you probably– seeing the kind of threats that are
- 10:39Speaker 4: coming there. So we'll talk that after 10.30. It is 10.30. Absolutely,
- 10:44Speaker 4: it's more than local. It's absolutely personal. And we are
- 10:48Speaker 4: getting into the thick of things. We are getting into
- 10:51Speaker 4: economic issues, homelessness, socioeconomic issues. And we're going to turn
- 10:56Speaker 4: to Magda. Magda is with NICRO. And, yeah, we've seen
- 11:01Speaker 4: over a very long period of time people running away
- 11:04Speaker 4: from home, finding safety on the streets of Cape Town.
- 11:07Speaker 5: So we need to.
- 11:07Speaker 3: Understand why that is.
- 11:10Speaker 1: Children.
- 11:11Speaker 4: And when does homelessness translate into crime?
- 11:15Speaker 5: Give us a sense of what you are in country.
- 11:19Speaker 10: What all the colleagues have said, I echo, because what
- 11:24Speaker 10: we are seeing is very much the history of trauma
- 11:28Speaker 10: and developmental trauma that is echoing and fracturing communities and
- 11:32Speaker 10: family bonds. And people are not as resilient anymore because
- 11:37Speaker 10: there's this history of trauma that's there. And now something
- 11:41Speaker 10: happens and you have no skill to cope with it.
- 11:43Speaker 10: You have no real support system. And then things start
- 11:46Speaker 10: to unravel. So you return to substances or it would
- 11:49Speaker 10: be easier to not live at home. I, in fact,
- 11:53Speaker 10: had a few clients in this week who told me
- 11:57Speaker 10: stretches of time that they were homeless. And I would
- 12:01Speaker 10: now almost say. they made that decision themselves because one
- 12:05Speaker 10: of them said, I'm not living in a house and
- 12:07Speaker 10: he listed all the things that were happening in the
- 12:10Speaker 10: house and he said, I made the choice.
- 12:11Speaker 6: This was what I had to do to get by.
- 12:15Speaker 10: And the same with some of the other clients where
- 12:17Speaker 10: they would say, you know, issues in the family or
- 12:19Speaker 10: things that happen are to such an extent unbearable that
- 12:23Speaker 10: they would rather resort.
- 12:25Speaker 3: To living on the streets.
- 12:26Speaker 10: So very much we need to address the communities and
- 12:30Speaker 10: create that belonging and supportiveness in communities again and in
- 12:35Speaker 10: family units because you would see with the economy, parents
- 12:39Speaker 10: having to work multiple jobs. They're not there when the
- 12:42Speaker 10: kids get home from school. They're not able to be there.
- 12:45Speaker 10: And these things all tie together. Kids being able to
- 12:49Speaker 10: stay out of school because there's nobody there to watch
- 12:51Speaker 10: them because you have to work if you want to
- 12:53Speaker 10: put something on the table. So it's a very, very
- 12:57Speaker 10: complex issue that, you know, from our side, we have
- 13:01Speaker 10: tried on our website, we have a bunch of resources
- 13:05Speaker 10: available that are free to use like workbooks and courses
- 13:08Speaker 10: that you can get certificates for that are all free
- 13:10Speaker 10: to use that the general public can download and access
- 13:13Speaker 10: and use via our website that at least, you know,
- 13:16Speaker 10: if you are able to access a local library, which
- 13:19Speaker 10: thankfully in Cape Town we're blessed that there are multiple
- 13:23Speaker 10: libraries that are in very good condition. that allow access
- 13:27Speaker 10: to these things that you can then spend some time
- 13:30Speaker 10: going through the resources in your day, building your CV
- 13:33Speaker 10: as an attempt to assist in that space, like whilst
- 13:36Speaker 10: they're at the Haven or at U-Turn. These are things
- 13:39Speaker 10: that they can use more to just resource that period
- 13:42Speaker 10: of time for them. We have programs online for those
- 13:45Speaker 10: who might not necessarily be able to travel in. We
- 13:48Speaker 10: have an app that is zero-rated that people can access
- 13:51Speaker 10: some of the micro-content with the So we've tried from
- 13:54Speaker 10: our side to do as much as possible, but this
- 13:56Speaker 10: is a multi-sectoral thing. It's not going to be fixed
- 13:59Speaker 10: by one organization or one sphere of society. It needs
- 14:02Speaker 10: to be everyone together.
- 14:03Speaker 1: Vinya, sitting and listening here, and I'm also self-critiquing ourselves,
- 14:08Speaker 1: because we're talking, the issue is homelessness. We're not talking
- 14:13Speaker 1: about the constituency of people who are homeless. We have
- 14:18Speaker 1: even in our conversation here, that homelessness is an issue.
- 14:23Speaker 1: Not saying that people who are homeless are also constituents
- 14:27Speaker 1: and could also be voters in this local government election.
- 14:32Speaker 7: I think we have dehumanized people who are experiencing homelessness.
- 14:38Speaker 7: And I say that intentionally because the minute we define
- 14:43Speaker 7: people as a problem, they cannot heal themselves. or separate
- 14:48Speaker 7: themselves from that problem. So we need to start seeing
- 14:51Speaker 7: people who are experiencing homelessness as people first before their problems.
- 14:56Speaker 7: And our definition of homelessness determines how we treat homeless people.
- 15:01Speaker 7: So of course we will not encourage them to even
- 15:03Speaker 7: vote because we have told those people that they are
- 15:05Speaker 7: not met in the society. Their vote means nothing. So
- 15:09Speaker 7: we need to humanize homeless people in order to get
- 15:12Speaker 7: them to a place of, hey, you can exercise your
- 15:16Speaker 7: freedom to vote And I hope in the shelters they're
- 15:19Speaker 7: actually having that conversation because they need to have that conversation.
- 15:22Speaker 1: Are you encouraging people in your shelters to register to vote?
- 15:27Speaker 9: No, absolutely, absolutely, because, I mean, I think Phineas hit
- 15:32Speaker 9: the nail on the head. Most definitely we've done some
- 15:35Speaker 9: education and orientations, et cetera, and we've encouraged all of
- 15:40Speaker 9: them to vote. Actually, the voting stations, the IEC and
- 15:44Speaker 9: the ward councillors, came to the shelters, encouraging them as well.
- 15:48Speaker 6: Because their votes matter. Every single individual's vote.
- 15:53Speaker 9: We are South Africans, we had to stay through thick
- 15:56Speaker 9: and thin, so yes, their votes count to us.
- 16:00Speaker 4: I think also the road to hell is littered with
- 16:03Speaker 4: good intentions, and we see that in the way people
- 16:07Speaker 4: respond to homelessness with a lot of heart, but effort
- 16:11Speaker 4: that is not necessarily helping the situation. We've also, I think,
- 16:13Speaker 4: encountered organizations that maybe show a little more efficacy in
- 16:17Speaker 4: terms of outcomes than others?
- 16:21Speaker 3: Is it maybe necessary for us to collectivize the effort.
- 16:26Speaker 4: You know, instead of having so very many organizations working
- 16:28Speaker 4: on this particular front and maybe not delivering the ideal outcomes?
- 16:32Speaker 5: I don't know.
- 16:34Speaker 3: What are your thoughts?
- 16:35Speaker 9: My thoughts are homelessness is a very complex issue and
- 16:40Speaker 9: deals with various underlying issues. And I think we need
- 16:45Speaker 9: to individualize it and then treat everyone according to what
- 16:50Speaker 9: their own challenges are. We cannot go and blanket it
- 16:53Speaker 9: and all homeless people are criminals, all homeless people are druggies,
- 16:56Speaker 9: all homeless people are vagrants, which is vagrants, which I
- 16:59Speaker 9: don't like the term. So, you know, it's about taking
- 17:02Speaker 9: the time. and spending time with that individual and consulting
- 17:09Speaker 9: with him and saying, how can we help you break
- 17:12Speaker 9: the cycle of homelessness? You matter to us. I mean,
- 17:16Speaker 9: there's this thing about all lives matter. Your life matters
- 17:19Speaker 9: to us. And because you have fallen on tough ground,
- 17:23Speaker 9: it doesn't mean to say that you must get up
- 17:24Speaker 9: on your own.
- 17:25Speaker 6: We're here to lend a hand to you.
- 17:27Speaker 1: And so then can I ask each of our panelists here,
- 17:32Speaker 1: their thoughts.
- 17:34Speaker 2: Whether they condone or condemn.
- 17:36Speaker 1: So what I'm seeing are many incumbent councillors who are
- 17:42Speaker 1: doing clean-up programs in their wards.
- 17:46Speaker 2: And this is.
- 17:49Speaker 1: Aslam Richards Ward 48 and 60, cleaning up areas. And
- 17:53Speaker 1: they say, we're cleaning up vagrants. This is not to
- 18:00Speaker 1: solve an issue of homelessness. This is to appease... the
- 18:04Speaker 1: middle class voters in the area, each one of you,
- 18:07Speaker 1: do you condemn or do you condone cleaner programs before elections?
- 18:14Speaker 2: Shad, I'll start with you.
- 18:15Speaker 9: Yeah, you know, homeless people, by that statement, homeless people
- 18:19Speaker 9: are litter on the ground. Let's just kick them into
- 18:22Speaker 9: the rubbish bin and then hopefully they'll get picked up
- 18:24Speaker 9: by a rubbish truck and we won't see them again
- 18:26Speaker 9: for the rest of our lives.
- 18:27Speaker 6: These are human beings.
- 18:29Speaker 5: We kind of.
- 18:31Speaker 6: Spend more time. I condemn it, by the way. We
- 18:35Speaker 6: give animals more thought.
- 18:37Speaker 9: I mean, I come from the far south. There's a
- 18:39Speaker 9: whole thing about the baboons than we do human beings.
- 18:44Speaker 6: No, no way. They are human beings. They have emotions.
- 18:48Speaker 9: You cut their skin, blood comes out, the same color
- 18:50Speaker 9: blood that runs through my veins.
- 18:52Speaker 6: So I condemn it.
- 18:53Speaker 5: Stephen?
- 18:54Speaker 8: Yeah, I hear what Clarence is saying about good intentions,
- 18:56Speaker 8: and maybe that's why it's being done, but definitely from
- 19:00Speaker 8: Uten's perspective, we condemn that. I think you sometimes see
- 19:03Speaker 8: these before and after photos where there's a public space
- 19:06Speaker 8: that's got litter and, let's say, unhoused people in it,
- 19:09Speaker 8: and then afterwards it's clear and it's clean. But what
- 19:12Speaker 8: is the before and after on the people that are
- 19:15Speaker 8: in that space? And I think from Uten's perspective, our
- 19:18Speaker 8: whole approach is a person-centered approach, as Phineas was talking
- 19:21Speaker 8: in the beginning. So Yeah, it's more about what is
- 19:24Speaker 8: the before and after on the people in those spaces
- 19:26Speaker 8: than the litter and the interactions.
- 19:28Speaker 2: I'd like to get Phineas and then Marta's response.
- 19:31Speaker 7: Yeah, I mean, there's a saying, what you see as
- 19:33Speaker 7: trash is treasure to somebody. I've met homeless people who
- 19:37Speaker 7: have lost their IDs, who have lost their ARV medication,
- 19:40Speaker 7: who have lost their TB medication because of all these cleanups.
- 19:43Speaker 7: So I condemn them because I've seen, homeless people being
- 19:48Speaker 7: re-traumatized because of those experiences of law enforcement approach. That's
- 19:52Speaker 7: why I tell them all the time, you need a
- 19:54Speaker 7: double-edged sword. A law enforcement officer needs to be accompanied
- 19:57Speaker 7: by a social worker because their approach is a little
- 19:58Speaker 7: bit different. So if you just have law enforcement approaching
- 20:01Speaker 7: homeless people without a social worker, you're not going to
- 20:04Speaker 7: solve the problem. You're just going to traumatize people. and
- 20:06Speaker 7: keep them on the street. So I condemn it in
- 20:10Speaker 7: Afrikaans and in Sepedi, in any other language.
- 20:15Speaker 10: Absolutely the same sentiment as was echoed by my colleagues.
- 20:18Speaker 10: And I will just add that, you know, a clean
- 20:22Speaker 10: up in quotation marks is not doing anything for anybody.
- 20:26Speaker 10: It literally reinforces that stereotype that these are not people.
- 20:30Speaker 10: We are not seeing them as people. And then, you know,
- 20:32Speaker 10: creating the documentation issue because now you can't vote because
- 20:35Speaker 10: you don't have your ID or anything else. You can't
- 20:38Speaker 10: have access to your clinic, your medications. If we want
- 20:41Speaker 10: a better society, multifaceted approach, mental health included, other sectors included,
- 20:48Speaker 10: that we can actually make a lasting difference and not
- 20:51Speaker 10: have a little cleanup close to election time.
- 20:55Speaker 3: And I think that was the intention of my question.
- 20:58Speaker 4: If a council is doing a cleanup, that suggests that
- 21:00Speaker 4: there are no protocols at a city of Cape Town level.
- 21:04Speaker 3: And I think that is an indictment. So you're saying
- 21:08Speaker 3: we can.
- 21:09Speaker 4: Actually implement such protocols so we engage it collectively with,
- 21:14Speaker 4: of course, fully understanding what we've achieved, what the best
- 21:19Speaker 4: outcomes are that we are looking for?
- 21:23Speaker 3: Can we ask the city of Cape Town to do that?
- 21:28Speaker 7: Yeah, I think what I've communicated a lot of times
- 21:31Speaker 7: is the city needs to follow the bylaws. homeless people
- 21:34Speaker 7: need to be approached by social workers before law enforcement
- 21:38Speaker 7: even comes into that phase. So I think it's a
- 21:43Speaker 7: collective problem that means.
- 21:46Speaker 5: Systems of care as much as law. Are you saying
- 21:50Speaker 5: the protocols exist?
- 21:51Speaker 7: Yes, there's a bylaw that tells, even I educate homeless
- 21:54Speaker 7: people about their rights. They need to know that they
- 21:57Speaker 7: have rights.
- 21:57Speaker 5: And these protocols are being disregarded?
- 21:58Speaker 7: Sometimes, a lot of times they are, because sometimes you
- 22:01Speaker 7: need to invite people like Phineas to deal with that
- 22:03Speaker 7: but sometimes you don't invite Finians because you know Finians
- 22:06Speaker 7: is going to speak out and protect them.
- 22:09Speaker 3: It's nearly quarter to 11. We're going to take a
- 22:11Speaker 3: short break.
- 22:12Speaker 4: We're talking about pretty serious issues, homelessness and socioeconomic issues,
- 22:16Speaker 4: and getting a sense of what it is that we
- 22:18Speaker 4: can demand from our city.
- 22:19Speaker 3: It's the Cape Talk Roundtable. Lester Kivitt here with me
- 22:22Speaker 3: through to 12 o'clock.
- 22:24Speaker 5: Download the EWN app.
- 22:26Speaker 4: It's the Cape Town Town Hall live from the Bloberg Hotel.
- 22:30Speaker 3: Beautiful view across the bay. to the city, Lester Kevitt
- 22:33Speaker 3: and I.
- 22:35Speaker 5: Through till 12 o'clock, Lester.
- 22:36Speaker 2: Through till 12 o'clock. From 11 o'clock, then we let
- 22:40Speaker 2: the animals in. That's when we have.
- 22:43Speaker 1: No politicians will be hurt in the course of this debate.
- 22:47Speaker 1: I see there are already a few of them.
- 22:48Speaker 2: Hello, Ferlin. You're welcome. Coming up is a question. The
- 22:57Speaker 2: harsh reality of homelessness.
- 23:00Speaker 1: Is that there is the connection between substances, and not
- 23:04Speaker 1: every homeless person uses substances, but it.
- 23:08Speaker 6: Is a.
- 23:09Speaker 2: Tool used to.
- 23:13Speaker 5: Live through the trauma.
- 23:16Speaker 1: Shadi, many people decline access to safe spaces because they
- 23:22Speaker 1: are not permitted to use substances, even if it is
- 23:26Speaker 1: substances that is meant to wean them off the drugs.
- 23:30Speaker 1: Why doesn't the Haven Night Shelter allow for spaces where
- 23:34Speaker 1: drug replacement therapy can be offered?
- 23:37Speaker 9: So, it's a great question. And the Haven believes that
- 23:44Speaker 9: once you come into our shelters, you should abstain. Because
- 23:50Speaker 9: if you continue using, you could be a trigger to
- 23:53Speaker 9: someone else who is in a rehabilitation program. We are
- 23:58Speaker 9: in conversation with our social workers, our social work supervisors,
- 24:02Speaker 9: to start outpatient rehabilitation programs at different sites.
- 24:08Speaker 6: So that will help them.
- 24:09Speaker 9: But in terms of harm reduction and opiate substitution therapy,
- 24:14Speaker 9: methadone and whatever else, we obviously do not allow it.
- 24:21Speaker 6: We believe that those that.
- 24:23Speaker 9: Are weaning themselves off heroin should go to a medical professional,
- 24:28Speaker 9: a clinic, et cetera, and they should be the ones
- 24:31Speaker 9: dispensing that methadone. Because, you know, people don't look at
- 24:37Speaker 9: the flip side of methadone. If you give someone who's
- 24:41Speaker 9: on methamphetamine methadone, you could kill them. If someone decides
- 24:47Speaker 9: to spike methadone, they could.
- 24:50Speaker 6: They could die.
- 24:52Speaker 9: So there's the dangers attached to methadone and opiate substitution therapy.
- 24:57Speaker 9: So that is why we believe that it should be
- 25:01Speaker 9: dispensed by a clinic or a day hospital, et cetera.
- 25:05Speaker 6: In terms of needling.
- 25:07Speaker 9: In a generally patriarchal society, the male will use first
- 25:12Speaker 9: and then hand it over to the female. And together
- 25:14Speaker 9: with that, the transfer of HIV, TB, hepatitis, et cetera.
- 25:19Speaker 9: So that we have special people that deals with that.
- 25:23Speaker 5: Maka, your thoughts?
- 25:26Speaker 10: I am a big believer in harm reduction, and I feel.
- 25:30Speaker 6: More.
- 25:30Speaker 10: Spaces in Cape Town should be available because, yes, the
- 25:34Speaker 10: clinics and everything is where that's supposed to happen, but
- 25:37Speaker 10: we need more of those. Because the rate of the
- 25:40Speaker 10: problem we're seeing, we don't have the capacity to deal
- 25:44Speaker 10: with the extent of the problem. So if there are
- 25:47Speaker 10: more clinics and more people doing outpatient procedures, because getting
- 25:51Speaker 10: somebody into rehab in the state is a wait list.
- 25:56Speaker 4: You....
- 25:58Speaker 10: You have better luck trying to perform a miracle than
- 26:02Speaker 10: that if somebody needs rapid access help. So definitely more
- 26:07Speaker 10: resources where that is concerned and just more, I think,
- 26:11Speaker 10: information and social support around that.
- 26:17Speaker 4: And drug use, are we still perceiving it as a
- 26:21Speaker 4: criminal act or are we seeing it as a chronic
- 26:25Speaker 4: health issue?
- 26:29Speaker 5: Who's answering?
- 26:31Speaker 6: It's an open one.
- 26:32Speaker 5: It's an open one.
- 26:33Speaker 9: For some, it may be a criminal act. For some,
- 26:35Speaker 9: it may be just a place of refuge, a default setting.
- 26:41Speaker 9: A guy that comes in the street who's just been
- 26:45Speaker 9: put out because his mom passed away and he's got
- 26:47Speaker 9: no place to stay, he has to cope. So it
- 26:51Speaker 9: could be a coping mechanism. I don't condone it, but
- 26:54Speaker 9: it could be a coping mechanism for some. And for others,
- 26:58Speaker 9: it could be chronic.
- 26:59Speaker 5: It could be chronic. It could be chronic. Okay.
- 27:02Speaker 7: I'll give you a story. I met a homeless woman yesterday.
- 27:06Speaker 7: She's on her cycle. And I gave her sanitary towels.
- 27:11Speaker 7: And I asked her, what do you use for your pain?
- 27:13Speaker 7: And she said, I use drugs. Because she doesn't have,
- 27:17Speaker 7: you know, she's not using drugs because she wants to.
- 27:20Speaker 7: She's using drugs because she's going through a lot of pain.
- 27:23Speaker 7: And the only thing that she has is taking men's drugs.
- 27:26Speaker 7: So how do you judge somebody like that who you
- 27:28Speaker 7: haven't provided any options for, you know, in terms of
- 27:31Speaker 7: an escape?
- 27:31Speaker 5: So it's a coping mechanism.
- 27:32Speaker 7: So you can judge that person or you can try
- 27:34Speaker 7: to get to know them a little bit and ask
- 27:37Speaker 7: questions rather than assuming that they want to use drugs
- 27:39Speaker 7: because they want to use drugs. A lot of people
- 27:41Speaker 7: are using drugs because they're trying to survive. If they
- 27:43Speaker 7: stop doing that, many of them will die on the street.
- 27:46Speaker 3: Steve, you're pretty close to the action.
- 27:47Speaker 4: Maybe you want to weigh it in there as well.
- 27:48Speaker 3: How do you perceive it?
- 27:49Speaker 8: So Newton's approach is that we don't– stop people from
- 27:53Speaker 8: coming into our safe spaces if they're high, if they
- 27:56Speaker 8: have been using, but we don't allow usage onsite for
- 27:58Speaker 8: the same reasons that Shadi says, that people are recovering
- 28:01Speaker 8: in that space and it's a temptation to them. But
- 28:03Speaker 8: if we say, that said, if you're using, you can't
- 28:05Speaker 8: come in, you actually stop people from actually going through
- 28:08Speaker 8: the system that they need to. So from our point
- 28:10Speaker 8: of view, we don't necessarily go for harm reduction approach
- 28:14Speaker 8: in the true sense. But we kind of bridge that
- 28:16Speaker 8: gap by allowing people to still come into our shelters,
- 28:19Speaker 8: even if they're a little bit high, a little bit drunk,
- 28:21Speaker 8: as long as they're not abusive or violent. They can
- 28:24Speaker 8: access the shelter. And then because there's a routine and
- 28:27Speaker 8: a structure around their day and their approach, already there's
- 28:30Speaker 8: a harm reduction approach because they're using less of the substance.
- 28:33Speaker 8: And I think that's something that we don't talk about either,
- 28:35Speaker 8: is how much of the substance you take has an
- 28:38Speaker 8: effect on your life. So you don't go from high
- 28:41Speaker 8: usage to completely sober. It does go down slowly over time.
- 28:45Speaker 8: And we work with our clients to encourage them to
- 28:47Speaker 8: then go to the next phase, which is drug and
- 28:49Speaker 8: alcohol rehab, which is complete sobriety, and from there into
- 28:52Speaker 8: the employment phase. So there's a whole phased approach to
- 28:55Speaker 8: everything we're doing there.
- 28:56Speaker 1: I have a general question in your opinions working in
- 29:00Speaker 1: this sector. Do you think political parties use homelessness as
- 29:06Speaker 1: a dog whistle or homelessness as a real societal issue,
- 29:13Speaker 1: systemic issue that needs.
- 29:15Speaker 5: To be confronted?
- 29:16Speaker 4: Phineas?
- 29:16Speaker 8: Yes.
- 29:20Speaker 5: It's getting me into trouble, but it's fine.
- 29:23Speaker 2: It's fine.
- 29:25Speaker 7: I mean, for me, homelessness is a systemic issue. That
- 29:29Speaker 7: means systemic change. And like I said, the problem is
- 29:32Speaker 7: not the seed, it's the soil. And like Desmond Tutu said,
- 29:36Speaker 7: it's either we go upstream and prevent people from jumping
- 29:39Speaker 7: to the river, or we spend too much resources and
- 29:41Speaker 7: money pulling people from the river. And I think that's
- 29:43Speaker 7: what we're doing. That's why I'm saying that we're mopping
- 29:45Speaker 7: the ocean as parties who are trying to solve these issues,
- 29:49Speaker 7: because we're not trying to get to know people, and
- 29:52Speaker 7: we're not living in context with where these people come
- 29:54Speaker 7: from and what enables them to be on the street
- 29:56Speaker 7: in the first place. So there's a blaming, criminalizing of
- 29:59Speaker 7: homeless people without really understanding the genesis of where these
- 30:03Speaker 7: people come from and the system that we have created
- 30:05Speaker 7: that keep them unemployed, living in poverty, festering into gangsterism,
- 30:10Speaker 7: and then criminalizing them and putting them into POSMO, thinking
- 30:13Speaker 7: that's going to solve the problem. That's not going to
- 30:14Speaker 7: solve the problem. And also you can't police trauma. We
- 30:17Speaker 7: need to be trauma-informed as politicians. Politicians need to go
- 30:22Speaker 7: to a university of trauma and be informed. learn trauma
- 30:25Speaker 7: before they even try to work with people who are traumatized.
- 30:28Speaker 2: Shadi, your final word?
- 30:29Speaker 9: Do not, to the politicians, we don't want to know
- 30:33Speaker 9: what happened. We want to know the solutions for the
- 30:36Speaker 9: future for our country that has been crying for many,
- 30:39Speaker 9: many years. Do not use homeless individuals, vulnerable individuals, as
- 30:45Speaker 9: a launchpad for your political agenda and to get to
- 30:48Speaker 9: where you need to be.
- 30:50Speaker 5: It's a sin.
- 30:51Speaker 4: Stephen?
- 30:52Speaker 8: Yeah, I think government struggles when anything is intersectional, and
- 30:55Speaker 8: it requires a lot of departmental coordination, and that's what
- 30:58Speaker 8: happens around homelessness. So they do struggle with the issue,
- 31:01Speaker 8: but I'd also like to say that it's not just
- 31:03Speaker 8: government that is involved in homelessness. We as a society
- 31:06Speaker 8: are involved, and that's why I also want to challenge
- 31:08Speaker 8: the listeners, and I respect the show so much, because
- 31:10Speaker 8: the listener base is educated and informed and engaged. We
- 31:15Speaker 8: have a lot of scenarios where our interventions are actually
- 31:17Speaker 8: blocked by people who don't want support in their backyard,
- 31:21Speaker 8: and so Please don't just vote in November and leave
- 31:24Speaker 8: it there.
- 31:24Speaker 5: Stay engaged for four years.
- 31:26Speaker 2: Very quickly, Martha, we.
- 31:27Speaker 1: Have to go.
- 31:28Speaker 10: Homelessness, addiction, all those things are tied together under the
- 31:32Speaker 10: criminal banner, and I say this in quotation marks, and
- 31:35Speaker 10: then we use being tough on crime as a voting
- 31:37Speaker 10: platform instead of actually engaging with the civil societies and
- 31:41Speaker 10: really seeing how we can all come together to address
- 31:45Speaker 10: the problem holistically.
- 31:47Speaker 2: Politicians should note that it takes.
- 31:49Speaker 1: 10,000 votes to get a single seat in the city
- 31:53Speaker 1: of Cape Town's council. There are 14,000 homeless people, according
- 31:57Speaker 1: to Uten's study. Imagine speaking to each and every one
- 32:01Speaker 1: of them. Get them registered to vote for you.
- 32:06Speaker 2: A guaranteed seat.
- 32:07Speaker 1: But then, you have then signed a promise that you
- 32:11Speaker 1: would have to speak to their needs.
- 32:14Speaker 2: 10,000 votes for a seat.
- 32:16Speaker 1: There are 14,000 homeless people in the city of Cape Town.
- 32:19Speaker 1: We have to go to a break.
- 32:21Speaker 5: Yes, indeed.
- 32:21Speaker 4: Time approaching two minutes to 11 o'clock. Natalie Martha standing
- 32:25Speaker 4: by with eyewitness news at the top of the hour.
- 32:29Speaker 4: In the last 24 hours, what's happened in your world?
- 32:33Speaker 1: President Cyril Ramaphosa has committed more resources to the fight
- 32:37Speaker 1: against gender-based violence during the upcoming midterm budget.
- 32:40Speaker 3: Ramaphosa announced a national strategy to