Latest / The Morning Rundown / Alberta's Referendum Day, a Deadly Base Fire, and Ebola's Spread
Transcript
- 0:14[Maya] Okay, I'm on my second coffee, and it's still not doing anything.
- 0:18[Maya] Hazelnut.
- 0:19[Maya] Terrible decision.
- 0:21[David] Hazelnut at this hour?
- 0:22[David] I mean, come on.
- 0:24[Maya] Don't judge me.
- 0:25[Maya] It's the only thing keeping me upright, and we've got a heavy
- 0:28[Maya] one today.
- 0:29[David] We do.
- 0:29[David] I'm David, that's Maya, and this is the morning rundown.
- 0:32[Maya] Three stories.
- 0:33[Maya] One province is voting on its own future, and it's doing that
- 0:36[Maya] while grieving.
- 0:37[David] Hmm, grieving what exactly?
- 0:40[Maya] A deadly fire on a military base.
- 0:42[Maya] Hold that thought because it matters for the vote.
- 0:45[David] And then there's the third one, the Ebola outbreak, which-- Wait, I
- 0:48[David] don't love saying that before breakfast.
- 0:50[Maya] Nobody does, right?
- 0:52[David] So give people the quick map.
- 0:53[David] Alberta's referendum day, the base fire at Wainwright, and then Congo.
- 0:58[Maya] That's the order.
- 0:59[Maya] We'll keep it plain and stick to what's confirmed.
- 1:02[David] And we'll flag the dates on the numbers, because with these stories,
- 1:05[David] the date matters as much as the figure.
- 1:07[Maya] Let's start with the tragedy in Alberta because it sets the scene
- 1:10[Maya] for the vote.
- 1:12[Maya] The Department of National Defence put out an official release.
- 1:15[Maya] Four Canadian Armed Forces members died in a fire-related training incident at
- 1:20[Maya] CFB Wainwright.
- 1:22[David] When was this?
- 1:23[Maya] Saturday, October seventeenth, around four PM Mountain Time.
- 1:27[David] Hmm.
- 1:28[David] Who were they?
- 1:29[Maya] Soldiers from the Third Battalion PPCLI.
- 1:33[Maya] They were doing live fire training in something called Exercise APOLLO SHOOTER.
- 1:38[Maya] The release names Sergeant Morgan Wong and Privates Shaun Farrell, Aidan Goulding,
- 1:43[Maya] and Hayden Lykkemark.
- 1:45[David] Four names.
- 1:46[David] Four families getting that knock on the door.
- 1:48[Maya] Yeah.
- 1:51[David] Let me make sure I have this straight.
- 1:52[David] The release is the official source, so the date, the unit, and
- 1:56[David] the names all come from DND itself.
- 1:59[Maya] Right.
- 1:59[Maya] The release is where the confirmed details come from.
- 2:03[Maya] The date, the unit, the exercise, the four names.
- 2:07[Maya] Everything else we're about to cover is reporting around it, and I'll
- 2:10[Maya] say where each piece comes from.
- 2:12[David] And it's not just the four, right?
- 2:13[David] There were people hurt.
- 2:14[Maya] Lots of them.
- 2:16[Maya] CBS News reported that Canada's defense minister said dozens of others were
- 2:20[Maya] wounded in an incident that caused a major fire.
- 2:23[David] Dozens.
- 2:25[David] Do we have a hospital number?
- 2:27[Maya] Alberta Premier Danielle Smith said thirty-nine patients were in hospital.
- 2:31[Maya] At least nineteen of those were critical.
- 2:34[David] Nineteen critical.
- 2:36[David] That's a lot of families still waiting by a phone.
- 2:39[Maya] And those are from live coverage, so it may have moved since.
- 2:43[Maya] I'd treat it as a snapshot, you know what I mean?
- 2:46[David] What does critical actually mean here?
- 2:48[David] Do we know?
- 2:49[Maya] Only what the coverage says.
- 2:51[Maya] At least nineteen of the thirty-nine were described as critical.
- 2:54[Maya] I don't have a breakdown beyond that, and I'm not going to
- 2:57[Maya] guess at one.
- 2:58[David] Fair enough.
- 2:59[David] And those are two different kinds of statement, right?
- 3:02[David] The minister's dozens and the premier's thirty-nine in hospital.
- 3:05[Maya] Right.
- 3:06[Maya] Dozens is the minister's word, as CBS reported it.
- 3:10[Maya] Thirty-nine is the premier's hospital figure.
- 3:13[Maya] I wouldn't try to add them together or reconcile them.
- 3:16[Maya] They're just two pieces of the same picture.
- 3:18[David] Totally.
- 3:19[David] Which brings me to the early chaos.
- 3:22[David] I remember seeing seven dead floating around.
- 3:25[Maya] Right.
- 3:25[Maya] Early reports said seven.
- 3:27[Maya] Those were never confirmed.
- 3:28[Maya] Officials confirmed four.
- 3:30[David] Wait, so seven was just wrong?
- 3:32[Maya] Not confirmed is the careful way to say it.
- 3:35[Maya] The official count is four, and that's the one we're going with.
- 3:39[David] Fair.
- 3:39[David] First hours of anything like this are messy.
- 3:42[Maya] They are, and people always jump to the worst explanation.
- 3:45[Maya] So on that, DND said there was no indication of terrorist activity.
- 3:49[David] Okay.
- 3:50[David] That's an important thing to hear early.
- 3:52[Maya] A military official also said a grass fire ignited in the training
- 3:55[Maya] area.
- 3:56[Maya] It was not caused by a natural gas explosion.
- 3:59[David] A grass fire on a live fire range.
- 4:03[Maya] I know where your head goes.
- 4:04[Maya] Mine too.
- 4:05[Maya] But how it started and how it spread to people, that's still
- 4:08[Maya] being established.
- 4:10[David] Yeah.
- 4:10[David] We shouldn't guess.
- 4:11[David] Not about this.
- 4:12[Maya] No.
- 4:13[Maya] These are young soldiers who were training.
- 4:15[Maya] They were doing the job.
- 4:16[Maya] That's what we know, and that's where we leave it until investigators
- 4:19[Maya] say more.
- 4:20[David] Agreed.
- 4:21[David] Honestly, the only right thing is to say their names and wait.
- 4:24[Maya] And that's really the caution for this whole story.
- 4:27[Maya] Early reporting gets revised, and a number you heard in the first
- 4:31[Maya] hours may not be the one that holds.
- 4:33[Maya] When the official statements change, we'll tell you.
- 4:36[David] That's fair to listeners too.
- 4:37[David] If you saw seven somewhere early on, you weren't imagining it.
- 4:41[David] It just wasn't confirmed, and the confirmed number is four.
- 4:44[Maya] And here's the timing that makes it heavier.
- 4:47[Maya] That grief is landing in Alberta on the very day the whole
- 4:50[Maya] province is voting on its future.
- 4:53[Maya] So the vote itself.
- 4:55[Maya] Polls open today, and the Al Jazeera piece from Tamara Khandaker, published
- 4:59[Maya] the day before, starts from a pretty blunt place.
- 5:03[David] Which is?
- 5:03[Maya] Alberta's independence movement faces likely defeat, but the same piece says history
- 5:09[Maya] suggests losing a referendum may not end the fight.
- 5:13[David] Hmm.
- 5:14[David] Okay, I'll say it.
- 5:15[David] That's the part I find interesting.
- 5:16[David] Everybody's staring at who wins today, and the better question is what
- 5:19[David] happens after the votes are counted.
- 5:21[Maya] Wait, you don't want to call it?
- 5:23[David] No.
- 5:23[David] Nobody should be calling anything while people are still standing in line.
- 5:27[David] I'd rather talk about what the polling says about the morning after.
- 5:30[Maya] Fair.
- 5:31[Maya] And just so we're straight on the history bit, the piece's argument
- 5:34[Maya] is that history suggests a loss doesn't automatically close the question.
- 5:39[Maya] We're not going to pretend we can recite every past referendum off
- 5:42[Maya] the top of our heads.
- 5:44[David] Right.
- 5:44[David] And the stakes are plain enough.
- 5:46[David] It's a vote on the future of the province on a day
- 5:48[David] when people are also mourning soldiers.
- 5:49[David] That's a lot for one day.
- 5:51[Maya] Okay, so polling.
- 5:53[Maya] Abacus Data did a survey, and CBC reported it ahead of the
- 5:56[Maya] vote.
- 5:57[Maya] Sixty-one percent of respondents expect another vote on separation at some point.
- 6:02[David] Sixty-one.
- 6:03[David] That's about six in ten people.
- 6:05[Maya] Right.
- 6:06[Maya] Six in ten.
- 6:07[Maya] Even people who might vote to stay.
- 6:09[David] Hmm.
- 6:09[David] Careful there, though.
- 6:10[David] The poll says they expect another vote.
- 6:12[David] It doesn't say they want one.
- 6:14[Maya] Fair.
- 6:15[Maya] Expecting and wanting are different.
- 6:18[David] Totally.
- 6:18[David] Expecting rain isn't the same as rooting for rain.
- 6:22[Maya] I mean, come on.
- 6:23[Maya] That's a good comparison.
- 6:24[David] So that's one number.
- 6:25[David] The other is the one that stopped me.
- 6:27[Maya] Go on.
- 6:28[David] Twenty-four percent think the debate gets settled for a generation or longer
- 6:31[David] even if Remain wins.
- 6:33[Maya] Fourteen.
- 6:34[David] Fourteen.
- 6:35[David] So a clean win for Remain, and about one in seven people
- 6:39[David] think it actually closes the book.
- 6:40[Maya] Wild, right?
- 6:41[Maya] You win, and almost nobody believes you've won anything permanent.
- 6:45[David] And this is where I get a little protective of the boring
- 6:48[David] stuff.
- 6:48[David] I tend to like institutions that hold still.
- 6:51[David] A country, a province, a constitutional arrangement.
- 6:54[David] They work because people assume they're not up for renegotiation every few
- 6:57[David] years.
- 6:58[Maya] Sure.
- 6:58[Maya] But people also say the same thing about a lot of rules
- 7:01[Maya] until they get tired of them.
- 7:02[David] Right.
- 7:02[David] And I'm not saying anyone's wrong to vote.
- 7:04[David] A referendum is the legitimate way to do this.
- 7:07[David] I'm saying a society that expects a rerun has a different feel
- 7:11[David] than one that thinks it's done.
- 7:12[Maya] Okay.
- 7:13[Maya] So where does the premier come in?
- 7:14[David] Premier Smith has said that if Remain wins, there will be no
- 7:17[David] repeat vote while she's in premier.
- 7:20[Maya] Huh.
- 7:20[Maya] That's a firm line.
- 7:22[David] It is, and that's the gap I keep circling.
- 7:24[David] She's promising no rerun on her watch.
- 7:27[David] Meanwhile, most of the people being polled expect one anyway.
- 7:30[Maya] Sure, but those can both be true.
- 7:32[Maya] She can hold the line for as long as she's in the
- 7:34[Maya] job.
- 7:35[David] Exactly.
- 7:35[David] The pledge has a built-in expiration date.
- 7:37[David] It runs as long as she's Premier.
- 7:40[Maya] Oh.
- 7:41[Maya] Yeah, and the poll is asking about, what, someday?
- 7:44[David] Someday.
- 7:45[David] At some point.
- 7:45[David] Those aren't the same clock.
- 7:47[Maya] And that's what makes the morning after interesting.
- 7:50[Maya] If Remain wins, the people who wanted out haven't necessarily gone anywhere.
- 7:54[David] Right.
- 7:55[David] Winning the vote and settling the question are two different jobs.
- 7:58[David] The poll suggests people already sense that.
- 8:00[Maya] And that's not a knock on anyone who votes Remain.
- 8:02[Maya] It's just an honest read of how the people in the poll
- 8:05[Maya] see it.
- 8:05[David] Exactly.
- 8:06[David] Nobody's saying the vote doesn't count, only that a count and a
- 8:09[David] settlement are different things, and the poll is about the second one.
- 8:13[Maya] So anyway, nobody listening should take this as a forecast.
- 8:16[Maya] We're just reading the numbers.
- 8:18[David] Right.
- 8:18[David] Voters decide, and whether anyone treats the result as final is a
- 8:22[David] separate story.
- 8:23[Maya] Which we'll be watching.
- 8:24[Maya] Before we go too deep into Alberta, though, there's a crisis farther
- 8:27[Maya] away that keeps growing.
- 8:29[David] That would be the Ebola outbreak in Congo.
- 8:32[Maya] Right.
- 8:32[Maya] Let's go there.
- 8:34[Maya] Okay.
- 8:35[Maya] Ebola.
- 8:35[Maya] And this one has moved again.
- 8:38[Maya] AP News reported on October eighteenth that Congo's fast-moving outbreak has now
- 8:43[Maya] spread to an eighth province.
- 8:46[David] Eighth.
- 8:46[David] Wait, so how many was it before?
- 8:48[Maya] Seven, going by the WHO's earlier update.
- 8:51[Maya] So it's one more province on the map.
- 8:54[David] Hmm.
- 8:54[David] That's a lot of country.
- 8:56[Maya] Right?
- 8:56[Maya] And the case counts are big.
- 8:58[Maya] The CDC's situation page, updated October thirteenth, lists about ninety-three hundred confirmed
- 9:05[Maya] cases as of October fourteenth.
- 9:07[David] And deaths?
- 9:09[Maya] Four thousand four hundred and forty-one confirmed deaths.
- 9:13[Maya] That's the CDC's figure.
- 9:15[David] So nearly half of the confirmed cases.
- 9:18[Maya] Roughly, yeah.
- 9:19[Maya] And I'd rather you hear the number than my adjectives on it.
- 9:23[David] Fair.
- 9:24[David] Okay.
- 9:24[David] The question everybody has at home: Is this coming here?
- 9:28[Maya] The CDC says no cases have been confirmed in the US, and
- 9:32[Maya] it rates the risk to the American public and travelers as low.
- 9:36[David] Low.
- 9:37[David] Good.
- 9:37[David] I'll take low.
- 9:38[Maya] Me too.
- 9:39[Maya] But the WHO has one detail that matters for how far it
- 9:43[Maya] travels.
- 9:44[David] Go on.
- 9:45[Maya] The WHO's disease outbreak update from October eighth describes an imported fatal
- 9:50[Maya] case in Kenya.
- 9:52[Maya] The person traveled there via Uganda.
- 9:55[David] Hmm.
- 9:55[David] So it's already crossed a border.
- 9:57[Maya] One case that we know of, and it's one case.
- 10:00[Maya] I don't want to make that bigger than the WHO does.
- 10:03[David] Right.
- 10:04[David] No.
- 10:04[David] Agreed.
- 10:05[David] What does the WHO say about how the spread is going overall?
- 10:08[Maya] It calls transmission intense, slowing in some areas, still growing in others.
- 10:14[David] So a mixed picture, not a clean trend line either way.
- 10:17[Maya] Exactly.
- 10:18[Maya] And there's the part that makes this harder.
- 10:21[David] Uh, let me guess.
- 10:22[David] No vaccine?
- 10:23[Maya] The WHO's outbreak page says there's no vaccine and no specific treatment
- 10:28[Maya] for the Bundibugyo species.
- 10:30[Maya] That's the strain here.
- 10:31[David] Okay.
- 10:32[David] That's sobering.
- 10:33[David] I mean, we've all heard of Ebola vaccines, so it's easy to
- 10:36[David] assume there's one.
- 10:37[Maya] Right, and that assumption doesn't hold for this species.
- 10:41[David] Okay.
- 10:41[David] One housekeeping thing, 'cause the numbers might confuse people.
- 10:44[David] The CDC and WHO figures don't match.
- 10:47[Maya] Oh, good catch.
- 10:48[Maya] They're from different dates.
- 10:49[Maya] The WHO's count was through October sixth, and the CDC's runs through
- 10:53[Maya] October fourteenth.
- 10:54[David] So the gap is mostly time.
- 10:56[David] The count grew in between.
- 10:58[Maya] That's how I read it.
- 10:59[Maya] The WHO's earlier number was lower, the CDC's later one is higher,
- 11:03[Maya] and neither is a contradiction.
- 11:05[David] So if someone sees one set of numbers in one place and
- 11:08[David] a different set somewhere else, what should they look for first?
- 11:11[Maya] The date.
- 11:12[Maya] The WHO's reported eight thousand seven hundred twenty-eight confirmed cases and four
- 11:16[Maya] thousand two hundred and five deaths as of October sixth across seven
- 11:20[Maya] provinces and put the crude fatality ratio at about forty-eight percent.
- 11:25[Maya] The CDC's later figures are about nine thousand three hundred cases and
- 11:29[Maya] four thousand four hundred forty-one deaths.
- 11:32[Maya] Same outbreak, different snapshots.
- 11:34[David] The part of the WHO update worth keeping next to those big
- 11:36[David] totals is the slowing in some areas.
- 11:39[David] Not everywhere is moving the same way.
- 11:41[Maya] Right.
- 11:41[Maya] Though it's the same update that says still growing in others.
- 11:45[Maya] So I wouldn't lean on it in either direction.
- 11:47[Maya] The calm, factual version is it's serious there, the risk here is
- 11:51[Maya] rated low, and we keep watching the official updates.
- 11:55[David] Yep.
- 11:55[David] No panic, just paying attention.
- 11:57[Maya] And the dates on those updates tell you how current the numbers
- 12:00[Maya] are, which is the thing to check each time.
- 12:03[Maya] Okay, David, you're up.
- 12:05[Maya] One takeaway per story, and keep it short, because my coffee's gone
- 12:09[Maya] cold.
- 12:10[David] Alberta first.
- 12:11[David] Even if Remain wins, the vote may not end the debate.
- 12:14[Maya] Hmm.
- 12:15[Maya] Yeah.
- 12:16[Maya] The poll said most people expect another vote someday, and the premier's
- 12:19[Maya] pledge only covers her time in office.
- 12:22[David] The fire at Wainwright is next.
- 12:24[David] The investigation is still developing, and the families are owed real answers,
- 12:28[David] not guesses.
- 12:29[Maya] Totally.
- 12:30[Maya] Nobody should rush that.
- 12:32[David] And Ebola.
- 12:33[David] It's still being tracked, and the numbers will keep moving, so watch
- 12:36[David] the dates on them.
- 12:37[David] The CDC and WHO figures came from different dates, so a bigger
- 12:41[David] number later isn't a contradiction.
- 12:43[Maya] That's a heavy trio for a morning.
- 12:45[Maya] You know what I mean?
- 12:47[David] It is.
- 12:47[David] We'll keep following all three, and we'll tell you what's confirmed and
- 12:50[David] what isn't.
- 12:51[David] For now, take a minute today for the people around you, and
- 12:55[David] go easy on whoever you run into.
- 12:57[Maya] Do that.
- 12:58[Maya] Our thoughts are with the families at Wainwright.
- 13:00[Maya] Thanks for spending part of your day with us, everybody, and that's
- 13:02[Maya] the rundown.