Latest / The Vegan Report / Can We Veganize Supermarkets? | Science of Activism
Transcript
- 0:00This is Dior Olufsen for The Vegan Report. Today,
- 0:03we're going to talk about supermarkets. How can
- 0:06we make the retail sector a bit more vegan -friendly,
- 0:09showing more plants instead of animals? If you'd
- 0:11like to connect with me, you could follow my
- 0:13sub stack, More Than Meets The Eye. A link will
- 0:16be provided in the episode description. You could
- 0:19buy new episodes on Wednesdays on this podcast.
- 0:22You could share this episode with your community
- 0:23to learn more about the science of vegan activism.
- 0:26I'm a vegan, and I'm sure many people listening
- 0:28to this are vegan. So we can all relate to the
- 0:30struggle of walking into a supermarket and not
- 0:33knowing where to find the foods that we need
- 0:35to eat. You know, fruits and veggies, that's
- 0:38easy. We just go to the produce section. You
- 0:40know, grains and cereals and everything like
- 0:42that, also easy. But if we want to get the plant
- 0:45-based proteins, it's often a little bit more
- 0:47difficult. Lots of people tend to say that the
- 0:50best situation is to have an entirely vegan section
- 0:54of a supermarket with bright green letters, vegan
- 0:57or plant -based, and that's where you find all
- 0:59your tofu and your tempehs, your plant -based
- 1:01meats and your Beyond Burgers and everything
- 1:02like that. Other people say that those products
- 1:06should be integrated into the meat aisles or
- 1:09the dairy aisles. So if you're strolling through
- 1:11the meat aisle, you pass by all the animal -based
- 1:14meats, and then you'd find a a box of plant -based
- 1:17meats right there. Which one is inherently better?
- 1:22For me personally, it's more convenient for me
- 1:24if there's an entirely vegetarian or vegan section,
- 1:28but that's not necessarily better for the animals.
- 1:32Remember, I come back to this again and again
- 1:35in my research. What's most convenient for us
- 1:37vegans or for us animal advocates is not always
- 1:40what's most convenient for animals. Sometimes,
- 1:45Our lives need to be a little bit less convenient
- 1:48so that more people are going to be eating plant
- 1:50-based and eating fewer animals. And that's more
- 1:53or less what the data shows. So in one real -world
- 1:58experiment, having a vegetarian shelf and placing
- 2:03meat substitutes into the meat aisle actually
- 2:05had a 30 % sales boost compared to just having
- 2:09a veg shelf or a meat aisle alone. We're trying
- 2:13to appeal to multiple types of audiences here.
- 2:16We want to make sure that the vegans and vegetarians
- 2:18in supermarkets are able to find the foods that
- 2:21they want to very conveniently. But we also want
- 2:24to nudge some meat eaters and vegetarians to
- 2:27eat more plants when possible. If they're strolling
- 2:30through the meat aisle, they're more likely to
- 2:33see, let's say, a Beyond Burger. And they might
- 2:36say, I'll give it a try. Or, oh, I have a friend
- 2:38who's vegan. Maybe they'll like this and put
- 2:40it into their shopping cart. However, if we have
- 2:44to choose between the two, it is better to have
- 2:51the plant -based products integrated into the
- 2:53store to increase the odds of a flexitarian buying
- 2:56them. Most vegans are more likely to search the
- 3:01store with a bit more thoroughness and carefulness.
- 3:04to find exactly what they're looking for, then
- 3:06a non -vegan is to try new products like a vegan
- 3:11meat product, for example. I know that's true
- 3:13for me. When I walk into a store, especially
- 3:15a new supermarket, I accept the fact that I'm
- 3:18going to have to be searching through every single
- 3:20aisle to find the plant -based proteins that
- 3:21I eat. If we can increase the amounts of plant
- 3:26-based products in supermarkets and integrate
- 3:28them throughout the entire store to increase
- 3:31their uptake, we might be able to make sure that
- 3:34they are bought more frequently. Not the good
- 3:37news. The bad news is that in the studies that
- 3:42I was able to find, an increase in plant -based
- 3:45meat consumption in supermarkets very rarely
- 3:48occurred alongside a decrease of meat sales.
- 3:51Why is that? That's because when people are buying
- 3:56more plant -based meat products, they are often
- 3:58doing so to supplement their meat purchases,
- 4:02not offset them entirely. So I looked at five
- 4:06different studies, and only two of them were
- 4:10able to find statistically significant increases
- 4:13in plant -based meat sales. In those two instances,
- 4:18there was no statistically significant decrease
- 4:21in meat sales. In one of them, there was actually
- 4:23an increase in meat sales. This was during a
- 4:26vegan worry promotion. So to me, this indicates
- 4:31that just increasing plant -based meat consumption
- 4:35isn't enough in supermarkets. We have to start
- 4:39thinking about offsetting, not supplementing.
- 4:43I think this is a huge untapped problem for the
- 4:48vegan movement. We talk a lot about things like
- 4:52restaurants. We talk a lot about dining halls.
- 4:54We talk a lot about cafeterias. We talk a lot
- 4:56about oat milk lattes and things like that. And
- 4:58that's all great. I love all of that. I think
- 5:00that is necessary. But I very rarely hear activists
- 5:04talking about working directly with supermarkets
- 5:06to decrease their sales of animal -based meats.
- 5:12We might see things like vegan, you worry promotions
- 5:15for to increase plant -based consumption in January.
- 5:18And that's still good, but I very rarely see
- 5:21long -term campaigns against supermarkets themselves.
- 5:26There is some, I'm not going to say that there's
- 5:28absolutely nothing. That's not true. For example,
- 5:31in many places in central and Northern Europe,
- 5:33there have been a lot of strides made towards
- 5:35increased plant -based meat sales and decreased
- 5:37animal -based meat sales. Many grocery stores
- 5:41in the Netherlands have taken pledges to increase
- 5:45their plant -based alternative sales. Lidl, which
- 5:47is a budget supermarket here in Europe, especially
- 5:52based in Germany, but it's in many different
- 5:54European countries, has been doubling their plant
- 5:56-based alternatives with their Vimondo, which
- 6:00is a vegan retail brand line. That's pretty good.
- 6:06When we look at supermarkets outside of this
- 6:09section of Europe, we're not seeing much progress.
- 6:12I wasn't able to find any evidence either in
- 6:16news media or research studies showing that other
- 6:19supermarkets are committed to decreasing their
- 6:22animal -based consumption or increase in the
- 6:24plant -based consumption. This doesn't mean inherently
- 6:27it's not happening, but I can't really find evidence
- 6:31of it anywhere. That's a big missed opportunity,
- 6:38in my opinion. Depending on the country, lots
- 6:41of people are getting over 50 % of their calories
- 6:44from supermarkets and can be even higher in a
- 6:48lot of places where people don't tend to eat
- 6:50out quite as much. That means that if we are
- 6:53able to get these big retail stores to commit
- 6:57to decreasing animal product consumption significantly,
- 7:01that's going to have huge ripple effects across
- 7:03that society. So my research did show that increases
- 7:10of plant -based meat sales don't correspond to
- 7:12decreases of animal -based meat sales. Some of
- 7:16my critics have pointed out just might just be
- 7:18because it's not statistically significant. It's
- 7:22harder to find decreases in meat sales. I think
- 7:25that's possible. I don't know if that's inherently
- 7:28true or not because the data doesn't really show
- 7:30it. If we look at the demographics of people
- 7:33who are buying plant -based and animal -based
- 7:35meats, we can get a little bit more information.
- 7:38So for example, when we think of someone who
- 7:41eats a Beyond Burger, we tend to think of a vegan
- 7:43or a vegetarian, right? But 86 % of people who
- 7:48buy plant -based meats in the grocery store also
- 7:52eat meat, or at least they also buy meat in the
- 7:57grocery store. Think about why this is. So when
- 8:04I walk into a grocery store, first of all, not
- 8:07everybody goes grocery shopping. Many households
- 8:09have a point person who does all of the grocery
- 8:12shopping, either a parent or somebody or like
- 8:15one of the partners in a relationship, for example,
- 8:18and they might be buying for more than one person,
- 8:20your entire family even or their friends and
- 8:23family or like a large group of people. So they
- 8:27If that person isn't vegan, they might buy a
- 8:29few vegan products for that one vegan family
- 8:32member, but then themselves, they're not going
- 8:34to be decreasing their own animal products assumption.
- 8:38Secondly, most people go into grocery stores
- 8:40with some sort of an internal list in mind. At
- 8:45least I do. Maybe I don't have it written down,
- 8:47but I might have some notes or mental notes somewhere
- 8:49about various things that I need to get. Oh,
- 8:52I'm running low on almond milk. Oh, I'm running
- 8:54low on this. I need to get some fruits and vegetables
- 8:56because it's January and I'm trying to be healthy,
- 8:58things like that. And I'm less likely to make
- 9:02an impulse buy or try something new in a grocery
- 9:04store as compared to a restaurant where I'd be
- 9:07more likely to experiment with something new.
- 9:10So these are some of the reasons that might explain
- 9:14why we're not seeing much changes in grocery
- 9:20stores. Despite these promotions, we might get
- 9:23people to add it into their cart, but they're
- 9:25not going to take out the animal -based needs.
- 9:29So what does this mean? Can we fix this at all?
- 9:35I think the answer is yes, but I think it depends
- 9:37on something really, really important. is money.
- 9:41You probably guessed it was money, but it does
- 9:44come back to money a lot of the time. I found
- 9:49in one study that people who regularly consume
- 9:55meat, let's call them the meat lovers, they would
- 9:58need to see a far lower price point for plant
- 10:01-based products to buy them as compared to flexitarian,
- 10:05vegetarian, and vegans. So I'll give you some
- 10:08numbers here. The lowest amount of money that
- 10:12a meat lover would pay for an impossible burger
- 10:14is $4 .80. This is a US study. Compared to vegetarians,
- 10:21vegans, and flexitarians who are willing to pay
- 10:22$9 .20. That is basically twice as much. So if
- 10:30we are to convince somebody who's a meat lover
- 10:32to put these products into their carts, those
- 10:35products are going to need to be cheap. really
- 10:37cheap, cheaper than meat, significantly. Those
- 10:41meat lovers are willing to pay, for example,
- 10:44$4 .9 for ground beef, $6 .6 for chicken breasts,
- 10:51et cetera, et cetera. So it needs to be cheaper,
- 10:54not even at price parity. It needs to be cheaper
- 10:56than the animal -based meat products in order
- 10:58to make it enticing for them. This isn't true
- 11:03for flexitarians, vegans, vegetarian. I will
- 11:05buy plant -based meats, no matter the cost point.
- 11:08I might buy fewer of them. If they are expensive,
- 11:11I might buy more tofu or more lentils, but I'm
- 11:14still going to buy it to some degree, right?
- 11:17And I'm sure many of the listeners can relate
- 11:19to this. How willing are you to buy these products
- 11:22compared to maybe a meat -loving family or friend
- 11:25of yours? So how do I make these products cheaper?
- 11:31it's going to take a lot of these plant -based
- 11:34meat companies to scale up their existing resources.
- 11:37But on the other side, I think there's a lot
- 11:40of potential for more active organizations to
- 11:43be working with supermarkets to be lowering the
- 11:46prices of these products and potentially even
- 11:49increasing the prices of the animal -based products.
- 11:52It might be possible for the supermarkets to
- 11:54make the same amount of profit by slightly changing
- 11:57the prices into a more sustainable way. to incentivize
- 12:02their consumers to choose a sustainable option,
- 12:05and then making more profit off of the consumers
- 12:07who choose to buy the meat. Most organizations
- 12:11aren't really working on this. To my knowledge,
- 12:14I'm not aware of any organizations that are exclusively
- 12:17working directly with supermarkets. There are
- 12:20plenty that work with supermarkets that's part
- 12:21of a larger strategy. But I do think this has
- 12:24a lot of potential going forward. So what does
- 12:29this mean? for the vegan movement. If you are
- 12:32a person who wants to think about systemic meat
- 12:35reduction, I would encourage you to perhaps talk
- 12:39to your local supermarkets and see if they could
- 12:41increase the ratio or see the price of the plant
- 12:45-based products, especially if you're in a region
- 12:49that takes these sustainability claims more seriously,
- 12:51which is more likely in places like I mentioned,
- 12:54Central and Northern Europe, not exclusively,
- 12:57of course. think there's a lot more money and
- 13:03staff power that we can put towards solving this
- 13:05problem. If we were to build up organizations
- 13:09to tackle supermarkets more aggressively, we
- 13:12might be able to make a lot of switches from
- 13:16animal -based to plant -based products. That
- 13:20is what my research has concluded, more or less.
- 13:24Some good news and some bad news, but to me,
- 13:26this is the huge untapped lever that I don't
- 13:28see many people talking about, at least compared
- 13:32to the restaurants and dining halls. If you have
- 13:36any questions, you can read the full resource,
- 13:38which is going to be linked in the show notes.
- 13:41And if you liked this kind of thing, I encourage
- 13:43you to keep listening to The Vegan Report and
- 13:45follow my newsletter where I talk about this
- 13:47stuff. all the time, the science of vegan activism.
- 13:51Thank you very much. My name is Pior Olufsen,
- 13:53and I'll see you next time.