Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / SPCX and TSLA Q3 Earnings: Financials, Valuation, and Risks
Transcript
- 0:00In the third quarter of 2026, the world's most famous and most
- 0:04technologically advanced rocket company actually lost money
- 0:08launching rockets. Which is wild to think about.
- 0:10Right. It's completely
- 0:11counterintuitive, yet they simultaneously reported this
- 0:15massive $4.4 billion net profit for that exact same quarter.
- 0:21So how does a rocket company lose money on spaceflight but
- 0:25still make billions? Well, because behind the scenes
- 0:28they are quietly becoming the biggest artificial intelligence
- 0:31server landlord on the planet. Exactly.
- 0:34Meanwhile, you look at their older sibling Tesla, and they
- 0:36saw their core automotive revenue just entirely flatline.
- 0:40Completely stall that. Yeah.
- 0:41But it's stock valuation just continue to price in this total
- 0:46global robotics dominance. Right, it's a massive
- 0:48disconnect. And we know this because we are
- 0:50sitting on a massive stack of highly detailed financial
- 0:54dossiers and earnings reports and SEC filings for Q32026.
- 0:58So much data. And I want to point out right at
- 1:01the top that this intelligence was compiled by Deep Value
- 1:05Intelligence. Which is an incredible tool.
- 1:06It really is. It's this multi agent AI
- 1:09research framework that is specifically designed to parse
- 1:11dense financial architecture. You can actually find their full
- 1:15research at deepvalues dot AI if you want to dig in yourself.
- 1:18Yeah, highly recommend checking that out.
- 1:20And the data from this deep dive reveals A fundamental structural
- 1:24mutation. I mean, both of these iconic
- 1:26hardware companies have essentially abandoned their
- 1:28original identities. They really have.
- 1:31They are morphing into these massive AI compute leviathans,
- 1:35right? And in the process, they are
- 1:37basically tearing up every traditional rule of valuation
- 1:40and capital allocation that we have.
- 1:41Yeah. And before we jump fully in, I
- 1:43just want to say a quick welcome to you, the listener.
- 1:47We are doing another rigorous deep dive today.
- 1:49And just as a quick disclaimer, this is all educational and
- 1:52research content only. Right, not investment advice.
- 1:55Exactly not investment advice. It's based on public sources
- 1:58that could be revised or interpreted differently.
- 2:00So always do your own due diligence before making
- 2:02investment decisions. Absolutely.
- 2:05So diving into this data, it really forces a complete re
- 2:10evaluation of what you are actually buying when you invest
- 2:12in these entities. It does, yeah.
- 2:14Because if you look at the raw documentation like the S1
- 2:17prospectuses from the recent SpaceX public offering, right?
- 2:20Back in June. Yeah, or the 10K reports and the
- 2:22proxy governance data. You just see this volume of
- 2:25capital deployment that completely defies historical
- 2:28comparison. It's just unprecedented.
- 2:31It is traditional investors are looking at these numbers and
- 2:34they're they're trying to apply the metrics of physical
- 2:37manufacturing to companies that are now aggressively
- 2:40prioritizing intangible decentralized digital
- 2:44infrastructure. And the dissonance in the public
- 2:46markets right now is born from that exact misclassification.
- 2:49I mean, I look at the traditional 20th century metrics
- 2:52being applied to these companies by certain analysts and honestly
- 2:55it feels like watching an inspector try to value a modern
- 2:57commercial airline using the financial models of a 19th
- 3:01century horse drawn carriage company.
- 3:03That is a perfect analogy. Right, like the inspector is
- 3:06complaining about the astronomical cost of jet fuel
- 3:09and the terrifying capital expenditure required to build a
- 3:12runway. Completely missing the point.
- 3:14Entirely missing the point that the vehicle can cross an ocean
- 3:17in six hours. Exactly.
- 3:19The carriage metrics aren't just conservative, they are
- 3:21fundamentally incapable of measuring the machine.
- 3:24So let's ground this in the actual mechanics of the third
- 3:27quarter. I want to start with the newly
- 3:29public sibling SpaceX trading under the ticker SPCX.
- 3:33Let's do it. They reported their Q3 earnings
- 3:35on October 20th and this was their first profitable quarter
- 3:38since the IPO in June. Right, a huge milestone.
- 3:41Massive. The top line revenue hit $14.6
- 3:44billion. That is a 161% increase year
- 3:49over year. Staggering growth, but you have
- 3:51to look under the hood of where those billions actually came
- 3:54from because like we said earlier, the rocket company is
- 3:57not making its money on rockets. No, they really aren't.
- 4:00And that revenue breakdown is basically the most critical
- 4:03piece of financial intelligence in the entire dossier.
- 4:06Walk us through it. OK.
- 4:07So let's isolate this space division first, OK?
- 4:10Because this is the core identity of the company, right?
- 4:13This division encompasses the Falcon 9 launches, the Dragon
- 4:16capsule logistics, and that historic Flight 14 Starship
- 4:20mission. The one that delivered 26 of
- 4:23those new Starlink V3 satellites in orbit.
- 4:25Exactly that exact mission. So all the physical hardware
- 4:28launching into the atmosphere that generated $1.8 billion in
- 4:32revenue. OK, 1.8 billion sounds good.
- 4:35It does sound good, but here is the catch.
- 4:38After accounting for the immense research and development burns
- 4:41specifically tied to the Starship program, the space
- 4:44division actually operated at a $7,000,000 loss.
- 4:47Wait, so they lost $7,000,000 launching the most advanced
- 4:50rockets in human history? Which I guess makes sense if you
- 4:54actually understand their engineering philosophy, right?
- 4:57How so? Well, they don't do what the old
- 4:59school companies do. They don't build a perfect
- 5:01rocket in a vacuum for a decade and then fly it.
- 5:03Right, they build it and fly it. They build it, they fly it, they
- 5:06blow it up or they land it. They analyze the telemetry, and
- 5:09then they literally build the next iteration right there on
- 5:12the launchpad. And that iterative design
- 5:14process requires burning through millions of dollars of physical
- 5:17steel and methane and engineering hours.
- 5:20It's basically a calculated R&D expense.
- 5:23Precisely. It is the exact opposite of the
- 5:25legacy aerospace model, which like you said, spends a decade
- 5:29in the simulation phase before even bending a single piece of
- 5:31metal. Right, but that rapid physical
- 5:34iteration is phenomenally expensive on a quarterly balance
- 5:37sheet. It.
- 5:38Burns Cash. Exactly.
- 5:40So the Rockets operate at a slight loss.
- 5:42OK, so where is the money coming from?
- 5:44Well, moving to the next pillar, we have Starlink, the satellite
- 5:47connectivity division. Right, the Internet from space.
- 5:50Exactly. Now that unit generated a very
- 5:52healthy $5.2 billion. OK, wow.
- 5:55Supported by 13.6 million active users globally.
- 5:58That's a huge user base. It is, and the economics of a
- 6:02low Earth orbit constellation begin to scale beautifully once
- 6:04the initial satellite web is dense enough.
- 6:06Because the upfront cost of putting them up there is
- 6:08basically done. Right, your margins expand, but
- 6:11even Starlink is completely dwarfed by the 3rd and newest
- 6:14business unit. And this is the shocker the
- 6:17Super Intelligence Division, which for those who don't know,
- 6:20is the internal corporate umbrella for XAI and the Grok
- 6:22models, which formally merged into SpaceX earlier in February
- 6:26of 2026. Alongside the data architecture
- 6:29of the social platform X. Right.
- 6:31And this division generated A staggering $7.6 billion in the
- 6:35third quarter alone. That's hard to even process that
- 6:39number. That is a nine fold increase
- 6:41from the prior year. The AI division has completely
- 6:43eclipsed the global Internet constellation and the entire
- 6:46orbital launch manifesto. It is now Spacex's largest
- 6:49revenue generator. By a wide margin.
- 6:52So I have to ask, how exactly is a company known for welding
- 6:55stainless steel in South Texas generating $7.6 billion in
- 6:59artificial intelligence revenue? What is the actual mechanism of
- 7:03that transaction? Yeah.
- 7:04So the mechanism is a highly evolved form of digital real
- 7:07estate. Digital real estate.
- 7:09Right. The analyst transcripts refer to
- 7:11this as the Landlord model. OK, the landlord model, how does
- 7:15that work? Well, SpaceX isn't just selling
- 7:17access to its own AI software like Grok.
- 7:20They are heavily renting out the raw compute power from their
- 7:23massive data centers to other artificial intelligence
- 7:26developers. Oh, I see.
- 7:28So the hyperscalers, the massive tech conglomerates and
- 7:31independent AI labs like Anthropic, they all require 10s
- 7:34of thousands of advanced GPU's. Like the NVIDIA H1 hundreds and
- 7:39those newer B2 hundreds. Exactly to train their models.
- 7:43But acquiring the chips is only half the battle.
- 7:45You have to house them, you have to power them and you have to
- 7:47cool them. Right, the physical
- 7:49infrastructure. And SpaceX foresaw this physical
- 7:52bottleneck of AI, and they just built massive data clusters.
- 7:55They scaled their compute capacity up to 1.7 gigawatts.
- 7:591.7 gigawatts. That's insane.
- 8:02It's massive. That's wild.
- 8:03And now that you're leasing out partition access to that
- 8:06cluster, Elon Musk actually stated on the Q3 earnings call
- 8:09that they are relentlessly hounded by companies desperate
- 8:13to rent compute. Relentlessly hounded.
- 8:16Yeah, he claimed they could lease their server racks several
- 8:19times over if they just had the physical capacity to say yes to
- 8:22everyone who asked. So they are essentially the
- 8:24people selling the shovels and the pickaxes during the AI gold
- 8:27rush. Exactly.
- 8:28But wait, if we look at that $4.4 billion net income figure
- 8:32they proudly plastered on the earnings release, I really want
- 8:35to break that down. Yeah, let's look at the math.
- 8:37Because when you see net income on a press release, you
- 8:39naturally assume that is the cash the company put in its
- 8:42pocket from selling its products.
- 8:43Right, that's the common assumption.
- 8:45But the Deep Value Audit dissects this and the core
- 8:48operational profit, the actual money made from renting servers
- 8:52and selling Internet and launching rockets, was only $2.8
- 8:56billion. Right 2.8.
- 8:58That leaves a massive $1.6 billion gap between the
- 9:01operational reality and the headline net income.
- 9:04So where does that extra profit materialize from?
- 9:08Well, it materializes from the complexities of corporate
- 9:10accounting. OK.
- 9:12About $1 billion of that difference is categorized simply
- 9:15as other income. Just other income.
- 9:18Yeah. And when you dig into the
- 9:19footnotes of the 10K, you see that over half of that other
- 9:22income is derived from affiliate relationships.
- 9:26What does that mean exactly? It's essentially intercompany
- 9:29transfers or favorable licensing agreements with other entities
- 9:32within the broader Musk corporate ecosystem.
- 9:35OK. So moving money around between
- 9:37the different companies. Basically, yes.
- 9:39Then you also have a $400 million tax benefit recognized
- 9:43in this quarter. OK.
- 9:45And finally, you have the interest income.
- 9:48Following their massive public offering in June, Spectacus is
- 9:51sitting on a mountain of cash. Right from the IPO.
- 9:54And when you park billions of dollars in short term treasuries
- 9:57or money market funds in a relatively high interest rate
- 10:00environment, you generate hundreds of millions of dollars
- 10:03in pure interest income. Which is entirely separate from
- 10:06your core business operations. Exactly.
- 10:08It's just money making money. But the accounting knife cuts
- 10:11both ways, doesn't it? It does because there are also
- 10:14massive expenses dragging down the profit that don't
- 10:16necessarily reflect cash walking out the door.
- 10:19Like the income statement shows a $1.2 billion stock
- 10:23compensation expense. Yes, it's specifically tied to
- 10:25their acquisition of Cursor. Right, that AI coding tool they
- 10:28bought back in August. Right.
- 10:30And the stock compensation expense is a vital concept to
- 10:33understand here. Explain that for the listener.
- 10:35So when SpaceX acquired Cursor, they didn't just back up a truck
- 10:38and hand over 1.2 billion in cash from their vault, right?
- 10:42They issued $1.2 billion worth of new SpaceX shares to the
- 10:47founders and employees of CURSOR.
- 10:48OK. Under Generally Accepted
- 10:51Accounting Principles or GAP, that issuance must be recorded
- 10:54as an expense against their quarterly profits.
- 10:57Even though no physical cash actually left the building.
- 11:00Exactly. It dilutes the ownership stake
- 11:02of existing shareholders, which is a very real economic cost,
- 11:06but it doesn't drain the company's operating liquidity.
- 11:09OK, that makes sense. And then there is the
- 11:11depreciation. Oh yeah, the depreciation is
- 11:14massive. They recorded $2.5 billion in
- 11:17depreciation and amortization. Now, in a regular software
- 11:20company, depreciation is often a pretty minor line item.
- 11:24Usually, yeah. But when you are building 1.7 GW
- 11:27data centers, depreciation is a massive tangible reality.
- 11:30Because the hardware physically degrades.
- 11:33Right. Those AI chips run incredibly
- 11:35hot, they degrade, and more importantly, their architecture
- 11:38becomes obsolete every 18 to 24 months as new, faster silicon is
- 11:42released. You are constantly playing
- 11:43catch. Up.
- 11:44You have to constantly RIP out the old servers and install new
- 11:47ones. That 2.5 billion isn't just an
- 11:49accounting fiction, it represents the real world decay
- 11:52of their hardware advantage. It really does.
- 11:54And if you strip out the non cash stock compensation and that
- 11:57depreciation, the Super intelligence division alone
- 12:00generated almost $5 billion in raw cash profit.
- 12:05But as you rightly point out, ignoring depreciation in a
- 12:08heavily capital intensive infrastructure business is a
- 12:12very dangerous analytical flop. Because the bill eventually
- 12:15comes due. You have to pay to replace the
- 12:18servers eventually and that bridges us to the most
- 12:21polarizing metric in the entire Q3 dossier.
- 12:24They are capital expenditures. Yes, the CapEx.
- 12:28The rate at which SpaceX is spending cash to build physical
- 12:31infrastructure is literally fracturing the analyst community
- 12:34right now. I want to spend a lot of time on
- 12:36this because the numbers here dictate the entire future of the
- 12:39company. Absolutely.
- 12:41So Space XS Q3 capital expenditures, commonly referred
- 12:44to as CapEx, which for anyone unaware is the money spent
- 12:48acquiring or maintaining physical assets like buildings
- 12:51and land and equipment, it hit an astonishing $19.6 billion.
- 12:57In a single three month window. Let me frame that for you.
- 13:00Their total revenue for the quarter, every dollar they
- 13:03brought in from every customer on Earth and in orbit was 14.6
- 13:08billion. Yeah, they spent $5 billion more
- 13:12on building infrastructure than they generated in total sales.
- 13:15It's hard to wrap your head around.
- 13:17And out of that 19.6 billion in CapEx, an overwhelming 16.4
- 13:22billion was poured directly into constructing AI data centers and
- 13:26purchasing silicon chips. And if we zoom out to the first
- 13:29nine months of 2026, the contrast is even starker.
- 13:33What do those numbers look like? Well, they generated $13.1
- 13:36billion in cash from their operations, but they spent 48.1
- 13:41billion on CapEx. Wait, 48.1 billion?
- 13:44Yes, the mathematical gap between what they make and what
- 13:48they are building is over $35 billion.
- 13:53That is a staggering cash burn. They are plugging that massive
- 13:57hole with the cash raise during their June IPO and by
- 14:00aggressively accessing debt markets.
- 14:03Wow. Furthermore, the forward
- 14:04guidance provided by the Chief Financial Officer projects Q4
- 14:08CapEx to accelerate dramatically.
- 14:10They're estimating a spend between 35 billion and $40
- 14:13billion in the final quarter of the year alone.
- 14:16How is it physically possible to spend $40 billion on buildings
- 14:20in three months? What exactly are they buying?
- 14:23Well, we know the bottleneck for deploying artificial
- 14:26intelligence is no longer just convincing NVIDIA to tell you
- 14:29what GPU. The bottleneck has entirely
- 14:32shifted to the physical world. It is about electricity,
- 14:36industrial scale, liquid cooling and the massive concrete and
- 14:39steel foundations required to house these incredibly dense
- 14:42computing systems. The logistics of that must be
- 14:46insane. The physical logistics of a GW
- 14:49scale data center are just staggering.
- 14:52You are essentially building a medium sized city's power
- 14:55infrastructure in a single rural county.
- 14:58Yeah, you need heavy duty electrical substations, you need
- 15:02miles of high voltage transmission lines, and you need
- 15:05water rights for the millions of gallons of coolant required to
- 15:08keep the servers from literally melting.
- 15:10Unbelievable. And when you attempt to pull
- 15:13that much power from a localized grid, the traditional utility
- 15:16companies simply cannot accommodate you.
- 15:18Because they move too slow. They operate on decadal planning
- 15:21cycles. They cannot just spin up a new
- 15:24natural gas or nuclear plant in 12 months just because an AI
- 15:27company asks for it. And this leads to one of the
- 15:29most fascinating operational pivots in the entire research
- 15:33packet. It really is brilliant.
- 15:34Because the traditional utilities couldn't move fast
- 15:36enough, SpaceX simply decided to build the power generation
- 15:40themselves, and they are using their rocket manufacturing
- 15:44supply chain to do it. Which is mind blowing.
- 15:46The dossier notes they are actually manufacturing their own
- 15:49turbine blades for power generation.
- 15:52They are utilizing the highly advanced metal casting
- 15:54capabilities they originally developed for their Raptor
- 15:57rocket engines. It is a profound example of
- 16:01industrial cross pollination. Walk us through the science of
- 16:04that. Well, the combustion chamber and
- 16:05the bell of a rocket engine must withstand extreme pressures and
- 16:09temperatures that rival the surface of the sun, right?
- 16:12That requires specialized super alloys like in Canal and highly
- 16:16guarded metallurgical casting techniques.
- 16:17OK, SpaceX has spent 15 years perfecting how to rapidly cast
- 16:23and 3D print these super alloys. Right for the Rockets.
- 16:27Now a natural gas turbine used for electricity generation
- 16:30operates on incredibly similar thermodynamic principles.
- 16:34It requires turbine blaze that can spin at thousands of
- 16:37revolutions per minute while bathed in super heated gas
- 16:40without warping or fracturing. I see the connection now.
- 16:44So rather than waiting three years in a backlog queue for a
- 16:47traditional industrial conglomerate like GE or Siemens
- 16:50to deliver a turbine, SpaceX just retooled a portion of the
- 16:54rocket manufacturing line to cast their own power generation
- 16:57hardware. That is vertical integration
- 16:59taken to its absolute extreme. It really is.
- 17:02When the power grid tells you no, you just build your own
- 17:05power plant using rocket science.
- 17:06Exactly. But from a purely financial
- 17:08perspective, if you are a value investor looking at a company
- 17:12burning $48 billion in nine months to build data centers and
- 17:16gas turbines, I mean it causes a complete mathematical system
- 17:20failure. It completely breaks the models.
- 17:23The research runs SpaceX through a deep value standard analysis,
- 17:27and the results look like a crime scene.
- 17:29Let's examine those valuation metrics to understand the
- 17:31perspective of the traditional market.
- 17:33Sure, the first anchor of value investing is the price to
- 17:36earnings ratio or PE, right? Disciplined deep value investor
- 17:40typically seeks APE of 15 or less, meaning you are paying
- 17:45$15.00 for every $1.00 of current earnings.
- 17:48And where's SpaceX? SpaceX is currently trading at a
- 17:51trailing 12 month PE of roughly 137.
- 17:54Wow, 137 times earnings. But wait, applying A strict
- 17:58Benjamin Graham PE test to a hyper growth infrastructure
- 18:01company feels entirely misaligned.
- 18:04It is a massive debate right now.
- 18:06Because Graham developed those metrics in the 1930s for
- 18:09evaluating railroad companies and textile mills, right?
- 18:13Businesses with slow, predictable growth and massive
- 18:15physical inventories? Yeah.
- 18:17Why would we penalize an AI infrastructure company for
- 18:20failing a metric design for a tractor manufacturer?
- 18:23That is the exact debate raging in institutional finance.
- 18:27You argue that the PE ratio is blind to exponential growth.
- 18:31Right. So we introduced the PEG ratio
- 18:34price earnings to growth, which was popularized by Peter Lynch.
- 18:37OK. That divides the PE by the
- 18:39company's earnings growth rate. The PEG ratio under 1.0 suggests
- 18:44the stock is undervalued relative to its growth
- 18:47trajectory. So how did they do on that
- 18:48metric? Well, however, even with
- 18:50Spacex's earnings growing in an explosive triple digit rate,
- 18:54their valuation multiple is so stratospheric that their PE
- 18:57ratio still remains elevated well above the deep value
- 19:00target. So it's still way too expensive.
- 19:02Exactly. The market is pricing in not
- 19:04just their current explosive growth, but the assumption that
- 19:07this growth will persist uninterrupted for years.
- 19:11What about the balance sheet metrics like price to book
- 19:14value? The deep value target for price
- 19:17to book is generally 1.5 or less.
- 19:20Meaning what exactly? Meaning you aren't paying a
- 19:22massive premium over the literal liquidation value of the
- 19:25company's tangible assets. Their land, their buildings,
- 19:28their cash. Right.
- 19:30SpaceX fails this metric completely.
- 19:33It is trading at a massive multiple of its book value.
- 19:36Which means the market is looking past the physical assets
- 19:38entirely. Exactly.
- 19:40The market is capitalizing the company purely based on the
- 19:43momentum of its technological narrative, the intangible value
- 19:46of its proprietary software models, and the promise of
- 19:49future cash flows rather than the physical assets it currently
- 19:52holds. OK, let's look at the ultimate
- 19:55arbiter evaluation, the discounted cash flow model or
- 19:58DCF. The ultimate test.
- 19:59For anyone unfamiliar, ADCF model attempts to calculate the
- 20:03present day value of all the cash a company will ever
- 20:05generate in the future, right. You project out the cash they
- 20:08will make over the next decade, and then you discount it back to
- 20:11today's dollars, Usually factoring in inflation and the
- 20:14opportunity cost of putting your money somewhere safer, like a
- 20:17government bond. Yes, the DOS.
- 20:18CA ran an exhaustive DCF for space MEX using a 10% discount
- 20:22rate and demanding a 30% margin of safety.
- 20:25Very standard conservative parameters.
- 20:27And in a baseline scenario where we assume they successfully
- 20:30scale, the AI Starship becomes operational and they grow cash
- 20:35flows at an incredibly aggressive 35% annually.
- 20:38Which is extremely hard to do. Right, the model calculates the
- 20:42intrinsic value of the company at $1.8 trillion.
- 20:46And the current market capitalization of SpaceX sits at
- 20:49approximately $2.01 trillion. Therefore, even if you assume
- 20:53flawless execution, massive 35% sustained growth, and complete
- 20:57dominance of the AI infrastructure layer over the
- 20:59next decade, there's absolutely 0 mathematical margin of safety.
- 21:050 margin of safety. You're paying a $200 billion
- 21:08premium today for a best case scenario that hasn't even
- 21:11happened yet. This level of capital
- 21:13expenditure and valuation, it really reminds me of building a
- 21:16utility grid. How so?
- 21:19Imagine a company deciding to build a massive nationwide
- 21:22electrical grid, laying thousands of miles of copper
- 21:26wire and building nuclear plants, and they are borrowing
- 21:29billions of dollars at high interest rates to do it before a
- 21:32single house has plugged into the network.
- 21:34That's a huge gamble. Right.
- 21:35If society embraces electricity and everyone buys a
- 21:38refrigerator, the company becomes a multi generational
- 21:41monopoly. They're hailed as visionaries.
- 21:43But if the demand for electricity stalls, or if a
- 21:46cheaper alternative is discovered, that company is
- 21:48instantly bankrupted by its own debt, sitting on an empire of
- 21:52useless copper wire. That is exactly and the analyst
- 21:55community is violently divided right now precisely because they
- 21:59are trying to predict whether society will plug into the grid
- 22:02or if the AI hype will cool down.
- 22:04What are the Bulls saying? You have aggressive bullish
- 22:07firms like Goldman Sachs and Evercore, who focus entirely on
- 22:11the speed of execution. They are raising their price
- 22:13targets to 230 and $275 per share.
- 22:17Wow. Morgan Stanley published A
- 22:19fascinating framework. They basically bypassed
- 22:22traditional earnings metrics entirely and calculated that
- 22:25every extra GW of compute capacity SpaceX brings online
- 22:29inherently adds $27.00 to the stock price.
- 22:32That is a wild way to value a company.
- 22:35They are projecting future AI revenues in the trillions,
- 22:38arguing that the annualized run rate of this single quarter is
- 22:41already pointing toward a $60 billion business.
- 22:44But the bears look at that exact same physical reality and see a
- 22:48catastrophic risk. The Bears focus on the 48
- 22:51billion spent in nine months. Right, the cash burn.
- 22:54They issue strong sell ratings with a target price of $114.00.
- 22:58They argue that the capital intensity required to simply
- 23:01maintain a competitive edge and artificial intelligence is a
- 23:04treadmill that continually destroys shareholder value.
- 23:07Because the chips keep getting better.
- 23:09Exactly, If NVIDIA releases a chip next year that makes the
- 23:13current 1.7 GW cluster obsolete, SpaceX will have to spend
- 23:16another 50 billion just to stay in the exact same place.
- 23:20And adding fuel to this fire, there is a massive market
- 23:23catalyst approaching. A very big one.
- 23:26The dossier notes that a lock of expiration is looming right
- 23:29after this earnings report. Yeah.
- 23:31When a company goes public, insiders and early employees are
- 23:34typically locked into their shares for a certain period,
- 23:37usually six months. Right, to prevent them from
- 23:39flooding the market and crashing the price on day one.
- 23:41Exactly. Well, that lock up is expiring,
- 23:44meaning approximately 1.3 billion shares are suddenly
- 23:47becoming liquid and available to sell.
- 23:49It's a lot of shares. If the early engineers and
- 23:51venture capitalists decide they want to cash out and buy a
- 23:54house, that represents A tidal wave of potential downward
- 23:57pressure on the stock price. And the second catalyst
- 24:00mentioned in the corporate governance proxy filings is even
- 24:03more monumental. Tell me about it.
- 24:05Both Tesla and SpaceX have formally established special
- 24:07independent committees within their boards of directors to
- 24:10evaluate the feasibility of a complete corporate merger
- 24:14between the two entities. Wait, merging the car company
- 24:17and the rocket company? Yes, on the surface that sounds
- 24:20like a complete logistical nightmare.
- 24:22It does. But as we've just established,
- 24:24neither of them are actually operating within their legacy
- 24:27identities anymore. Exactly.
- 24:28They are both rapidly transforming into AI, compute
- 24:31and robotics infrastructure platforms.
- 24:34To truly grasp the implications of a merger, we have to
- 24:36interrogate the financial realities of the older sibling.
- 24:39Right, we need to look at Tesla. If SpaceX is the hypergrowth
- 24:42startup, setting 10s of billions of dollars on fire to build the
- 24:45future, what is happening over at Tesla?
- 24:48Let's transition to the Q32026 data for Tesla because the
- 24:51contrast is stark. It is very stark.
- 24:54While SpaceX demonstrated 161% year over year top line growth,
- 25:00Tesla's revenue for the third quarter of 2026 essentially
- 25:03flatlined. Really.
- 25:04Yes, they reported $28.05 billion in total consolidated
- 25:09revenue. OK.
- 25:10For context, in the third quarter of the previous year,
- 25:13they reported 28.10 billion. So it's basically the exact
- 25:18same. The top line growth engine of
- 25:21the core automotive business has completely paused.
- 25:24But flat revenue is only half the story because the
- 25:27profitability profile suffered a severe contraction.
- 25:30Oh yeah, it dropped hard. GAAP net income dropped sharply
- 25:34by 43%, falling down to $787 million, which translates to
- 25:39just $0.22 per share. Yeah.
- 25:42So how does a company maintain the exact same amount of
- 25:45revenue, but see its net income cut nearly in half?
- 25:48The deterioration in net income is almost entirely attributable
- 25:52to the evaporation of a highly specific, historically lucrative
- 25:56profit buffer. Which is.
- 25:58Automotive regulatory compliance credits.
- 26:01OK, let's unpack that. To understand this, we have to
- 26:03look at the structural mechanics of the automotive industry over
- 26:06the last decade. Governments, particularly in
- 26:09places like California and the European Union, mandate that
- 26:12automaker sells certain percentage of 0 emission
- 26:14vehicles. Right to fight climate change.
- 26:16Exactly. If a legacy automaker, say Ford
- 26:19or Volkswagen, fails to meet that quota, they are faced with
- 26:22massive government fines, right? However, the system allows them
- 26:26to purchase surplus credits from companies that exceed the
- 26:29mandate. It's essentially A subsidized
- 26:31bridge toll. I like that.
- 26:34For years, legacy auto companies refused to build their own
- 26:36bridges. They refused to invest heavily
- 26:38in EV manufacturing. So to get their gas guzzling
- 26:42cars across the regulatory river, they had to pay a massive
- 26:45toll to Tesla because Tesla was generating excess credits
- 26:48because every single car they sold was electric.
- 26:51Every single one. Tesla essentially used the fines
- 26:54of their competitors to fund the construction of their early
- 26:56gigafactories. It was a brilliant pure profit
- 27:00mechanism. It was a 100% margin revenue
- 27:02stream that fell straight to the bottom line, but that dynamic is
- 27:07structural, not permanent. In Q32026, that regulatory
- 27:12credit revenue plummeted by 73% year over year. 73%.
- 27:17It dropped from $417 million down to a mere 113,000,000.
- 27:22So why did it drop so fast? Because the legacy automakers
- 27:25and the rising Chinese competitors finally scaled their
- 27:29own EV production enough to meet regional mandates so.
- 27:33They built their own bridges. Exactly.
- 27:35They built their own bridges. They no longer need to pay the
- 27:37toll to Tesla. When you remove hundreds of
- 27:41millions of dollars of pure profit from a flat revenue base,
- 27:45your net income inevitably collapses.
- 27:49Yet Despite that collapse in free money, the actual physical
- 27:52business of manufacturing and selling the cars demonstrated
- 27:55surprising resilience. You really did.
- 27:57If you exclude those evaporating regulatory credits, Tesla's
- 28:00automotive gross margin actually expanded sequentially to 18.1%.
- 28:04Which is very impressive. It was 16.3% in the second
- 28:08quarter and 15.4% a year ago. How does an automaker increase
- 28:12their margins while simultaneously cutting the
- 28:15retail price of their vehicles to stimulate demand?
- 28:18The margin expansion in a deflationary pricing environment
- 28:21points to extreme operational leverage and supply chain
- 28:24optimization. What are they doing differently?
- 28:27Well, the cost of goods sold per vehicle decreased significantly.
- 28:31This is driven by heavily localized supply chains
- 28:33manufacturing the components adjacent to the final assembly
- 28:36line to eliminate global shipping logistics.
- 28:39Oh, so they aren't shipping parts across the ocean anymore?
- 28:42Exactly. And there is a dramatic
- 28:44reduction in the cost of raw materials.
- 28:47The commodity prices for critical battery metals,
- 28:49particularly lithium, carbonate and nickel, have stabilized at
- 28:53much lower levels compared to the supply shocks of earlier
- 28:56years. That makes a huge difference.
- 28:58It does. Furthermore, they are
- 29:00recognizing an increasing percentage of revenue from their
- 29:02full self driving software subscriptions.
- 29:05Which carry software level margins rather than heavy
- 29:07manufacturing margins. Exactly.
- 29:08It's pure profit basically. That software recognition points
- 29:11directly to the broader strategic pivot.
- 29:14The 10K filings make it explicitly clear that Tesla is
- 29:17no longer operating with the mindset of an aggressive top
- 29:21line growth auto manufacturer desperate to double vehicle
- 29:24deliveries every 12 months. The era of 50% auto growth is
- 29:28over. The capital allocation is
- 29:30flowing away from simply pouring concrete for new car assembly
- 29:33lines and flowing heavily toward AI compute clusters, autonomous
- 29:37software training architecture, and decentralized energy
- 29:40storage. And we see the concrete evidence
- 29:42of that pivot in their energy generation and storage segment.
- 29:46Yes, let's talk about the batteries.
- 29:47This division is rapidly becoming the financial backbone
- 29:50of the physical operations energy storage deployments,
- 29:54primarily their industrial scale Megapack batteries used for
- 29:57utility grid stabilization. They hit 13.7 GW hours in the
- 30:01third quarter. That's massive.
- 30:04And the margins on this heavy infrastructure are phenomenal.
- 30:07The energy division reported a 33.1% gross margin, which is an
- 30:12expansion of 933 basis points from the prior year.
- 30:16Compared to the low margin knife fight of selling consumer
- 30:19vehicles, the Megapacks are a highly lucrative enterprise.
- 30:22And on the digital side, the active Full Self Driving or FSD
- 30:26subscription base grew 67% year over year, reaching 1.74 million
- 30:31active users. That's a huge recurring revenue
- 30:34base. That is recurring high margin
- 30:36software revenue that isn't dependent on selling a new car
- 30:39every month. But here is where I have to push
- 30:41back on the prevailing narrative.
- 30:43Management continually dominates the earnings calls by pointing
- 30:46to future paradigms. Robotaxis operating autonomously
- 30:50optimists humanoid robots replacing industrial labor and
- 30:53their own massive AI compute capabilities to justify the
- 30:56future value of the entire enterprise.
- 30:58Right, the future vision. But if we were being objective,
- 31:01isn't this the exact same narrative playbook from 2016?
- 31:05Investors have been promised that full autonomy was a year
- 31:08away for nearly a decade. It's been a long wait.
- 31:11How long can the market tolerate flat core automotive sales while
- 31:14waiting for an AI robotics revolution that keeps getting
- 31:17pushed to the horizon? To answer that, we must
- 31:19introduce a critical analytical framework utilized by macro
- 31:22economists distinguishing between cyclical headwinds and
- 31:26structural headwinds. OK, let's define those.
- 31:28Understanding the difference between these two forces is
- 31:31essential for evaluating Tesla's current stagnation.
- 31:34A cyclical headwind is a temporary macroeconomic
- 31:36condition. Like what?
- 31:38For example, high global interest rates.
- 31:41When central banks raise rates, auto loans become significantly
- 31:44more expensive for the consumer. This suppresses demand and
- 31:47forces automakers to cut prices to move inventory right.
- 31:51However, economic cycles turn eventually inflation cools,
- 31:54central banks lower rates, auto loans become cheap again, and
- 31:58margins recover. That is a cyclical temporary
- 32:01headwind. Right.
- 32:02It's painful, but you know it will eventually pass.
- 32:06But a structural headwind is a permanent alteration to the
- 32:09landscape. Exactly.
- 32:11A structural headwind is irreversible in the automotive
- 32:14sector. The structural headwind is the
- 32:16maturation of Chinese EV competitors like BYD, Jili and
- 32:20Neo. Right, the Chinese market.
- 32:22These companies have achieved a level of low cost, vertically
- 32:25integrated manufacturing scale that permanently alters the
- 32:28pricing power dynamics across Europe, Southeast Asia and South
- 32:32America. They are just so much cheaper to
- 32:34build. Even when global interest rates
- 32:37eventually drop, that Chinese competition is not going away.
- 32:41The barrier to entry for building a decent electric
- 32:44vehicle has fundamentally lowered.
- 32:46That is a permanent structural change to the industry.
- 32:48So Tesla has to pivot. Yes, Tesla's aggressive pivot
- 32:52toward artificial intelligence, compute networks, and humanoid
- 32:56robotics is in many ways a tacit admission that the structural
- 32:59margins of the pure automotive business will never return to
- 33:02their peak levels from 2021. Because the competition has
- 33:06caught up to the hardware. Exactly.
- 33:08They must find a new defensible software paradigm.
- 33:11And that reality check brings us to the most brutal section of
- 33:14the research dossier. The deep value audit.
- 33:17Right. If the automotive revenue is
- 33:19flat and that income is dropping 43%, the competitive landscape
- 33:23is structurally permanently tougher and the company is
- 33:26leaning entirely on a highly speculative future AI narrative,
- 33:31how does a disciplined traditional investor even price
- 33:35this company today? The short answer is they can't.
- 33:38When we run the deep value audit on Tesla, it completely shatters
- 33:41the Graham Dodd framework. It completely breaks the model.
- 33:45And just as a quick side note, if you the listener want to
- 33:48actually run these kinds of metrics yourself, like checking
- 33:51the intrinsic value or seeing if the broader market is
- 33:53overpriced, you can actually download tools like the Deep
- 33:57Values iOS app or the Buffett Indicator app.
- 34:00They let you run this exact style of Graham Dodd math on
- 34:04your phone. That's super useful.
- 34:06I know Android users have Bubble Watch too, which does basically
- 34:09the same thing. Exactly.
- 34:11It's great for gut checking this kind of hype.
- 34:13But back to the dossier. The research subjects Tesla to a
- 34:17rigorous 19 point deep value scorecard.
- 34:20Let's get into it. This methodology is rooted in
- 34:23the principles developed by Benjamin Graham and David Dodd
- 34:26in their Seminole 1934 text Security Analysis Principles
- 34:30later championed and refined by investors like Warren Buffett.
- 34:33The ultimate value investors. Right.
- 34:36The test evaluate valuation, profitability, historical
- 34:40consistency and balance sheet safety.
- 34:42Out of those 19 rigorous tests, Tesla passes only four.
- 34:47Only four. Let's breakdown exactly why they
- 34:50fail so spectacularly. Let's start with valuation
- 34:53discipline. The benchmark rule for a mature
- 34:55industrial company is a price to earnings ratio of 15 or less.
- 34:59Where does Tesla sit in Q32026? Tesla is trading at a trailing
- 35:03PE of 411. 411. You're paying $411.00 for a
- 35:10single dollar of current earnings.
- 35:12That's astronomical. It also categorically fails the
- 35:14Peter Lynch PEG ratio test, primarily because their net
- 35:17income actually contracted by over 40% this year.
- 35:21When your earnings are shrinking rather than growing, the PEG
- 35:23ratio calculation becomes technically negative and
- 35:26completely non compliant with any growth at a reasonable price
- 35:29metric. What about price to book?
- 35:31This is a core metric for evaluating heavy manufacturers.
- 35:34Yes, it measures the market value of the company against its
- 35:36actual physical book value. The factories, the stamping
- 35:39machines, the land, the raw materials.
- 35:41Exactly. The deep value target is usually
- 35:431.5 or less, meaning you don't want to pay more than a 50%
- 35:46premium over what you could theoretically liquidate the
- 35:48physical assets for, right? Where are they at?
- 35:51Tesla is currently trading at a price to book of 15.715. .7.
- 35:58The market is capitalizing the company at nearly 16 times the
- 36:01value of its tangible equity. To a traditional value investor,
- 36:04you are paying a massive premium for intangible hopes rather than
- 36:08hard assets. The long term profitability
- 36:11metrics are equally challenged. Value investing demands decadal
- 36:15consistency to prove adorable competitive advantage.
- 36:18The target for a 10 year average return on equity is 15% or
- 36:22higher. Tesla's 10 year average Roe is a
- 36:25meager 2.7%. Wait, how can it be 2.7% when
- 36:30they had those wildly profitable years in 2021 and 2022?
- 36:34Because a 10 year average includes the grueling years
- 36:36prior to the Model 3 scale up, when the company was burning
- 36:40billions of dollars and teetering on the edge of its
- 36:42solvency. Oh right, I remember that.
- 36:44The deep value framework does not forgive historical
- 36:47inconsistency. Similarly, the target for free
- 36:50cash flow margin is consistently greater than 5%.
- 36:54And what's Tesla's? Tesla's current free cash flow
- 36:57margin is 3.5%. The capital reinvestment
- 37:00requirements to continually upgrade their automotive
- 37:02factories while simultaneously building massive new AI server
- 37:06clusters are simply too high to generate the deep value levels
- 37:10of cash return demanded by the Graham Dodd model.
- 37:13They just have to spend too much money.
- 37:14They also failed the specific test on gross margin
- 37:17consistency, net profit margin stability, return on invested
- 37:21capital and the ratio of depreciation to gross profit.
- 37:25So out of 19 tests designed to find safe, predictable,
- 37:28undervalued businesses, they fail 15 What are the four tests
- 37:32they actually managed to pass? The passes are entirely confined
- 37:35to the realm of balance sheet safety and short term liquidity.
- 37:38OK. This is the one area where
- 37:40Tesla's financial architecture is undeniably robust.
- 37:44Their debt to equity ratio is incredibly low at 0.10.
- 37:47That's great. They aggressively deleverage
- 37:50their balance sheet during the high margin boom years between
- 37:522020 and 2022. Because they carry so little
- 37:56long term debt, they easily pass the interest coverage test,
- 37:59generating more than enough operating income to service
- 38:02their minimal interest obligations.
- 38:04And their current ratio. Their current ratio stands at a
- 38:06very healthy 2.04. Meaning.
- 38:09This means they possess twice as many short term liquid assets as
- 38:12they do short term liabilities. This immense liquidity is
- 38:15anchored by a massive war chest. They are holding $46.1 billion
- 38:20in cash and short term investments. 46 billion in cash.
- 38:24From a strict solvency perspective, the risk of Tesla
- 38:27going bankrupt in the near term is functionally 0.
- 38:30They have the capital to weather severe macroeconomic storms.
- 38:34Which is a huge advantage. However, the foundational
- 38:37principle of value investing is that a pristine balance sheet
- 38:40alone does not automatically transform and egregiously
- 38:43overpriced stock into a good investment.
- 38:45The historical context provided in the dossier regarding how
- 38:48legendary investors have treated Tesla is fascinating.
- 38:51It reads like a master class in disciplined avoidance.
- 38:55It really does. The late Charlie Munger, Warren
- 38:57Buffett's long time business partner, famously characterized
- 39:00Elon Musk's ability to pull Tesla through the production
- 39:02hell of the Model 3 as a minor miracle.
- 39:05He acknowledged the monumental achievement.
- 39:07Right, but he outright refused to invest a single dollar of
- 39:10Berkshire Hathaway's capital into the enterprise.
- 39:12Deep value purists like Lee Liu of Himalaya Capital or Manish
- 39:16Pabre. They operate on strict
- 39:17frameworks that demand highly predictable competitive
- 39:20advantages, durable economic modes that are immune to
- 39:23technological disruption, and a deep discount to replacement
- 39:26value. None of which Tesla has.
- 39:28Capital intensive manufacturing that is perpetually exposed to
- 39:31rapid sweeping technological obsolescence, which is the
- 39:35defining characteristic of the electric vehicle, battery and AI
- 39:38space that almost never provides the requisite margin of safety
- 39:41these investors demand. And then you have the other end
- 39:44of the spectrum, investors who looked at the math and actively
- 39:47bet against it. Right, the short sellers.
- 39:49Michael Bury, the investor made famous by The Big Short for
- 39:52predicting the 2008 housing collapse.
- 39:55He took massive short positions against Tesla back in 2021, when
- 39:59its market cap first crossed a trillion dollars.
- 40:02Yes, he did. His thesis was entirely grounded
- 40:05in the math we just discussed. The valuation was entirely
- 40:08dependent on the temporary regulatory credits and
- 40:11speculative multiples that defied historical gravity.
- 40:14But what happened? But he eventually had to close
- 40:18that short position at a massive loss, which serves as a
- 40:21terrifying lesson. It is incredibly dangerous to
- 40:24bet against the stock powered by massive brand momentum and
- 40:27retail fervor, even if the underlying mathematics of your
- 40:30short thesis are technically correct.
- 40:33The market can remain irrational much longer than you can remain
- 40:36solvent. That unique brand momentum is
- 40:38driven by a shareholder base that looks unlike any other mega
- 40:41cap technology company. While institutional ownership
- 40:44from giants like Vanguard and BlackRock is present, those
- 40:48traditional funds often clash with management regarding
- 40:50conventional corporate governance.
- 40:52Right, they want standard procedures.
- 40:54What makes Tesla mathematically anomalous is the power of its
- 40:57retail investor base. Individual retail investors
- 41:00control approximately 40% of Tesla's voting shares. 40%
- 41:05retail ownership for a trillion dollar company is completely
- 41:08unprecedented. It really is.
- 41:10Traditional retail ownership in a company that size is usually
- 41:13in the low single digits, and that massive retail block is
- 41:17fiercely, almost ideologically, loyal to the CE OS vision.
- 41:20We saw this play out in real time this year.
- 41:23The pay package vote. Exactly.
- 41:25When a judge in the Delaware Court of Chancery struck down
- 41:27Elon Musk's multibillion dollar performance compensation
- 41:30package, arguing the board process was flawed, the board
- 41:33Simply put the package back up for a shareholder revote.
- 41:37Traditional institutional advisory firms like ISS and
- 41:40Glass Lewis strongly recommended voting against it.
- 41:44Major sovereign wealth funds formally opposed it.
- 41:47By all traditional corporate governance metrics, it should
- 41:49have failed. But it didn't.
- 41:51But the retail base rallied in mass and the package was
- 41:54reinstated with 78% support. That's incredible.
- 41:58That exact same retail base then approved moving the company's
- 42:01corporate incorporation out of Delaware and into Texas.
- 42:04They wield incredible unified power, and they fundamentally
- 42:07prioritize the founders technological vision over any
- 42:10traditional concerns regarding valuation multiples or
- 42:14governance norms. Which brings me to a metaphor to
- 42:16try and reconcile this behavior. Let's hear it.
- 42:20Trying to evaluate Tesla using traditional value investor logic
- 42:24is like trying to value a pharmaceutical company purely by
- 42:28calculating the cost of the glass beakers in their
- 42:30laboratory. The Graham Dodd purists are
- 42:33looking at the glass beakers. They are looking at the 411 PE
- 42:37ratio, and they're saying these beakers are way too expensive.
- 42:40I am not paying $373 for $50.00 worth of glass.
- 42:45But the retail investors, the ones holding the stock, they are
- 42:49buying the glass. They're buying the patent for
- 42:51the cure to a disease that they firmly believe the scientists
- 42:54are going to synthesize in those beakers tomorrow.
- 42:57That is a great way to look at it.
- 42:59They are pricing in a pharmaceutical miracle that
- 43:02hasn't passed clinical trials yet.
- 43:04That framing perfectly encapsulates the structural
- 43:06divide. Value investors meticulously
- 43:09price what currently exists. Growth and momentum investors
- 43:13aggressively price what they believe is inevitable exactly.
- 43:16And right now, the market believes complete technological
- 43:19dominance is inevitable. But we must quantify exactly
- 43:22what that inevitable future looks like mathematically.
- 43:24Let's do that. Let's dig into the discounted
- 43:26cash flow engine from the research dossier, because this
- 43:30is where the mathematical disconnect becomes truly
- 43:32terrifying. OK, let's break down the DCF.
- 43:34For anyone who hasn't built one of these models in a
- 43:36spreadsheet, ADCF is the ultimate truth teller in
- 43:39finance. It strips away the narrative.
- 43:42Right. You take the cash the company
- 43:44generates today, you estimate how fast that cash will grow
- 43:47every year for the next 10 years, and then you apply a
- 43:51discount rate. And the discount rate is
- 43:53crucial, right? Yes, it represents the time
- 43:55value of money. A dollar today is worth more
- 43:58than a dollar in 10 years because of inflation and because
- 44:02you could have invested that dollar in a risk free government
- 44:04bond and earn 5% guaranteed. Makes sense?
- 44:07For a high risk capital intensive manufacturing stock
- 44:10like Tesla, the analysts apply a strict 10% discount rate and
- 44:14they demand a 30% margin of safety before initiating A by
- 44:17position. The dossier ran three base
- 44:20scenarios. Walk us through the first one.
- 44:22The first scenario is the no growth case.
- 44:25This model assumes that Tesla has fundamentally reached market
- 44:28saturation. It assumes they merely stabilize
- 44:30their current $3.6 billion in free cash flow and never grow
- 44:35that cash pile again into perpetuity.
- 44:37OK, pretty bleak. Under the strict parameters of
- 44:39that no growth scenario, the intrinsic value of the stock
- 44:42calculates to exactly $20.96 per share.
- 44:47If you apply the required 30% margin of safety to protect your
- 44:50capital, your actual buy target is $14.67. $14.67 and the stock
- 44:58is currently trading around $373.
- 45:02OK, clearly the market does not believe Tesla has stopped
- 45:05growing. What about the middle ground?
- 45:07The Conservative case. The conservative case models a
- 45:10near term contraction in free cash flow, which is historically
- 45:14accurate during cyclical automotive downturns, right?
- 45:17It assumes free cash flow drops, stabilizes at 0 growth for three
- 45:21years, and then slowly recovers to a terminal growth rate of
- 45:24just 2% annually, matching long term inflation.
- 45:28And the intrinsic value under this conservative model.
- 45:31Is $16.96 per share. Still light years away from
- 45:36reality. All right, let's look at the
- 45:38absolute bowl case, the nominal case.
- 45:40Let's assume the automotive margins stabilize, the energy
- 45:43storage division scales to dominate the global grid.
- 45:46The full self driving software achieves massive high margin
- 45:50subscription adoption and they execute on the core foundations
- 45:53of their AI infrastructure. The nominal case is highly
- 45:57optimistic. It assumes a massive 18% annual
- 46:00free cash flow growth for the next 3 consecutive years, slowly
- 46:04tapering down to a mature 6% growth rate by year 10.
- 46:07OK. Ending with a 2.5% terminal
- 46:10growth rate forever, this scenario factors in tremendous
- 46:14success of both software and energy deployment.
- 46:17And what's the number? The intrinsic mathematical value
- 46:20in this optimistic scenario is $38.89 per share.
- 46:25I need to pause and emphasize this because this is the crux of
- 46:29the entire deep dive, The highly optimistic Everything Goes Right
- 46:33nominal case values the company's future cash flows at
- 46:36roughly $39.00 a share. The current market price on the
- 46:40ticker is $373.71. The mathematical conclusion is
- 46:46absolute. The current market price of 373
- 46:49represents an 861% premium, even over the most optimistic
- 46:55traditional intrinsic value scenario.
- 46:58An 861% premium. That implies the market is
- 47:02pricing in cash flows that traditional models literally
- 47:05cannot accommodate. Yes.
- 47:07To visualize what is required to justify today's market price
- 47:09using standard discounted cash flow math, the researchers had
- 47:13to abandon the standard models entirely.
- 47:15What did they do? They ran what they termed a
- 47:17historical Max sensitivity test. They looked back at the single
- 47:22most explosive year of cash flow growth Tesla ever recorded,
- 47:25which is a 158.4% jump in the year 2020 during the peak
- 47:30scaling of the Model 3 and Model Y.
- 47:33That was a once in a generation manufacturing scale up.
- 47:36Correct. To mathematically justify a $373
- 47:39share price today, the DCF model dictates that Tesla would have
- 47:43to sustain that exact absurd 158.4% annual free cash flow
- 47:48growth rate for five consecutive years.
- 47:51That's insane. Let's extrapolate that into
- 47:54physical reality. If they grew cash flows at 158%
- 47:58annually, by Year 5, Tesla would need to be generating $381
- 48:04billion in pure free cash flow. I am not talking about top line
- 48:09revenue. I am talking about 381 billion
- 48:13in cash leftover after paying every expense and building every
- 48:17factory. That is more free cash than
- 48:20Apple, Microsoft and Saudi Aramco generate combined.
- 48:24It is a financial impossibility for a company that manufacturers
- 48:27physical goods. So what is the actual take away
- 48:31from this mathematical breakdown?
- 48:33It means the traditional mechanisms of the stock market
- 48:35are broken when applied to this specific asset.
- 48:39Completely broken. The market valuation has
- 48:42entirely structurally decoupled from Tesla's present day
- 48:45financial reality and any rational projection of its
- 48:48future cash flows. The stock is no longer a
- 48:51mechanism for valuing how many cars they sell or how many mega
- 48:54packs they install on the grid. The stock is transformed into a
- 48:57pure binary options bet on the achievement of artificial
- 49:03general intelligence and total global robotics dominance.
- 49:07It is a speculation on a civilizational paradigm shift.
- 49:10Exactly. If Tesla solves unsupervised
- 49:14full self driving and deploys 10s of millions of autonomous
- 49:17robo taxis that replace human transportation, and if the
- 49:22Optimus humanoid robot becomes a ubiquitous standard industrial
- 49:26and consumer product that replaces manual labor globally,
- 49:30then perhaps the resulting cash flows one day align with a multi
- 49:34trillion dollar valuation. Perhaps.
- 49:37But right now, today, an investor is paying a massive,
- 49:41unprecedented premium for a highly uncertain future that
- 49:45requires solving the most difficult engineering challenges
- 49:48in human history. And this leads to my final push
- 49:51back, an analytical framework I want to pose directly to you,
- 49:54the listener, go ahead. If you deploy your capital into
- 49:57this stock today at $373, you have to acknowledge that you are
- 50:02not buying an equity share in an automotive company.
- 50:04Not at all. You are funding a massive,
- 50:06privately controlled space exploration and artificial
- 50:09intelligence research laboratory, and you are
- 50:12voluntarily paying an 800% premium over the nominal
- 50:16intrinsic value simply for the privilege of participating in
- 50:19the narrative. Is that still considered
- 50:21investing or is that venture Capital Economics happening on
- 50:24the public markets? It's a great question.
- 50:26Because in the private venture capital world, you expect 9 out
- 50:29of 10 of your bets to go to 0. But you accept that risk because
- 50:33the one company that succeeds pays for all the failures,
- 50:36right? But if you put your public
- 50:37retirement savings into a company with absolutely 0
- 50:40mathematical margin of safety, you are taking asymmetric
- 50:43venture capital risks with public equity capital without
- 50:46the protections that private VC firms demand.
- 50:49It represents A profound structural shift in market
- 50:52mechanics. We are observing public
- 50:54entities, both Tesla and SpaceX operating with the extreme
- 50:58capital intensity, the volatile cash burn and the narrative
- 51:01driven speculative valuation of early stage venture bets.
- 51:05But they are doing so at multi trillion dollar scales funded by
- 51:09public shareholders. It fundamentally redefines the
- 51:12concept of risk in a diversified portfolio.
- 51:16And that brings us to the end of our journey through this massive
- 51:18stack of intelligence. Let's rigorously recap what
- 51:21we've discovered diving through the Q32026 data.
- 51:25Let's sum it up. We have mapped exactly how
- 51:27SpaceX has completely pivoted its financial identity.
- 51:31They evolved from a company primarily concerned with
- 51:33launching orbital rockets into an AI compute landlord,
- 51:37generating $7.6 billion from their super intelligence
- 51:41division while simultaneously spending a jaw-dropping 19.6
- 51:45billion in a single quarter on data centers, cooling
- 51:48infrastructure and manufacturing their own gas turbines.
- 51:51We have analyzed how Tesla score automotive business has
- 51:54stagnated under the weight of structural headwinds in the
- 51:57evaporation of regulatory credits, resulting in flat
- 52:00revenues and a 43% drop in net income.
- 52:03Yeah, yet they're relying on their incredible $46 billion
- 52:07liquidity war chest to aggressively fund their own AI,
- 52:10compute and robotics ambitions while steadily expanding their
- 52:14highly profitable energy storage footprint in the background.
- 52:17And perhaps most critically, we've demonstrated exactly how
- 52:20and why traditional deep value mathematics completely breakdown
- 52:24when applied to these transitioning leviathans.
- 52:26Completely shatter. Tesla passes only four out of 19
- 52:30deep value tests, fails the Graham Dodd framework entirely,
- 52:34and trades at an 861% premium to its optimistic intrinsic value.
- 52:40Which leaves the listener with the ultimate analytical
- 52:42framework to take away from this entire deep dive.
- 52:46What's the bottom line? The vital, uncompromising
- 52:49importance of separating a great business from a great
- 52:53investment. They are not the same thing.
- 52:55They are not the same thing. A company can invent the future.
- 52:59They can build miraculous reusable rockets that land on
- 53:02drone ships, they can shift the entire global energy paradigm
- 53:06with massive lithium ion grid batteries, and they can force
- 53:10the entire automotive industry to pivot to electric propulsion.
- 53:13They can be the most important businesses of the century.
- 53:16But if the public market price already assumes they will
- 53:20Florida State execute every ambition and conquer the Galaxy
- 53:24over the next decade, there is absolutely 0 margin of safety
- 53:27left for the investor right? If they don't believe in
- 53:30slightly, if inflation ticks up, or if an engineering hurdle
- 53:34delays autonomy by just two more years, the valuation multiple
- 53:38will compress violently, destroying shareholder wealth
- 53:42even as the company continues to build great products.
- 53:45It's all priced in. And then some.
- 53:47It is priced for perfection. And I want to leave you with one
- 53:49final provocative thought to Mull over as you evaluate your
- 53:53own exposure to these markets. Laid on us.
- 53:56Both of these companies are pouring unprecedented
- 53:59astronomical billions of dollars into artificial intelligence and
- 54:02compute infrastructure. They are cross pollinating their
- 54:05engineering resources, their supply chains and their capital
- 54:09to the point where they have formed independent committees to
- 54:12evaluate a complete corporate merger.
- 54:14They are pushing all their chips into the center of the AI table.
- 54:18But what if the artificial intelligence revolution takes a
- 54:21decade longer than expected to mature?
- 54:24Or what if the AI compute bubble burst entirely and all those
- 54:28hyper scalers and independent labs currently renting servers
- 54:31from SpaceX suddenly burn through their venture funding
- 54:34and go bankrupt? Wow, what happens to the
- 54:37physical world of cars, grid batteries, and rockets that are
- 54:41currently footing the bill for this massive digital
- 54:43infrastructure? If the AI dream falters, where
- 54:46does that leave the minor miracles they've already built?
- 54:49That is the multi trillion dollar question, because if that
- 54:53carriage manual is obsolete and we are indeed flying a
- 54:56hyperdrive Starship, you better hope the navigation system
- 54:59actually knows where it's going. Because we are moving way too
- 55:02fast and burning way too much fuel to safely hit the brakes
- 55:04now. Thank you so much for joining us
- 55:06on this deep dive. If you enjoyed this level of
- 55:09rigorous analysis and want to continue exploring the deep
- 55:11value methodology, just a reminder that the research today
- 55:14was powered by the Multi Agent AI framework at Deep Value
- 55:18Intelligence. Which you could find at Deep
- 55:20Values AI. You can also always find more of
- 55:23our deep dives into the mechanics of investing and the
- 55:26philosophy of markets on Spotify and Apple Podcasts.
- 55:29Until next time, stay curious and always demand a margin of
- 55:33safety.