Latest / Forgotten Hollywood / Episode 236- The Fixer with Josh Young and Manfred Westphal
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to You've Forgotten Hollywood with Doug Hesse here on Jiljmedia. Hello everyone,
- 0:22and welcome to Forgotten Hollywood, your podcasts and memories of yesteryear. My
- 0:26name is Doug Hess, and you're for tuning in and Forgotten Hollywood for the
- 0:28first time. What I do on this podcast is take you on a journey
- 0:32back in time and share with you pieces of Hollywood that you may or may
- 0:35not know about. And in this episode, we have two very special guests
- 0:39with us today, authors Josh Young and Manfred westfall Amy seeing that credit you
- 0:47got it, okay, in their latest book The Fixer, Muguls, Mobsters,
- 0:52movie stars and Maryland gentlemen. Welcome to Forgotten Hollywood. Thank you well,
- 0:59thank you, and thank you for coming on and spend a few minutes
- 1:02with us today to talk about your book The Fixer. And you know,
- 1:06first question I always ask all my guests is just kind of share a little
- 1:08bit about what this book is about. I know the title kind of gives
- 1:11it away, but maybe just provided the listeners a little bit more information.
- 1:15Sure, yeah, sure, sure, Doug. This is this is Josh.
- 1:19The Fixer chronicles the extraordinary life and career of Fred Otash, who was
- 1:25the premier private investigator and go to fixer to the stars in Hollywood in the
- 1:30nineteen fifties. He was a man who lied to federal authorities to protect Frank
- 1:38Sinatra from criminal liability. He recorded Rock Hudson's coming out confession, He moved
- 1:44in with Judy Garland to get her sober, and he take the Kennedy's tragic
- 1:48love affairs with Marilyn Monroe. And beyond that, it delves into where Fred
- 1:53grew up, how he came to Los Angeles and rose up through the lapd
- 1:59and then ultimately became the fixer to the stars. And this is something that
- 2:07was not unusual for movie studios to have a quote unquote fixer. Yeah,
- 2:16this is Manfred. Certainly that was It happened quite a bit. But Fred
- 2:23was definitely the pre eminent fixer to the stars in the nineteen fifties and sixties.
- 2:29He was kind of the go to the master, if you will,
- 2:32the godfather of fixers, the go to dark knight who came to the age
- 2:38of the rich and powerful when conventional law enforcement was not an option. Sure.
- 2:45Yeah, in those days, the Hollywood studios and the Hollywood bosses controlled
- 2:50the movie stars, they controlled their lives, and they controlled Los Angeles to
- 2:53a large part. So when things went wrong, they didn't go to the
- 2:58lapd. They would go to someone like thread Otash to come in and clean
- 3:01up whatever mess there was, so as not to dismerge the reputations of their
- 3:07movie stars or their studios. Yeah, because they had a lot writing on
- 3:13this. I mean, they invested a lot in the stars, and so
- 3:17it was like an investment to them, or it was an investment to them,
- 3:21and so they had a lot of writing on making sure that an image
- 3:27was being maintained. Yes, they definitely wanted to protect the glamorous facade that
- 3:32they had spent so much money creating. Yes, and because that was going
- 3:39to affect not only current films but future films and probably also going to affect
- 3:45the way that they were going to be able to trade the stars between studios
- 3:50with their contracts as well. Yeah, that's true. And there was another
- 3:53element too. At the time, the mob was very prevalent in Los Angeles,
- 3:57Mickey Cohen being one of the largest mobsters. They controlled all of the
- 4:02unions. The studios needed the unions obviously to make their film. So in
- 4:10the case of Fred Otash, the Ultimate Fixer, a lot of it was
- 4:13maintaining the balance between that balance of power between the mob and the studios,
- 4:18and and keeping the peace so the town could keep running forward, which obviously
- 4:26left Bread in the gray area. Let's say, on a lot of occasions.
- 4:30Sure, yes, and he probably pretty much had the green light to
- 4:34do whatever he needed to do in order to quote unquote fix the issue that
- 4:39was at hand. You might say that, yes, absolutely right, short
- 4:44of murder, right, yeah, and probably didn't. It probably crossed his
- 4:47mind a few times to do that as well. What caused you to write
- 4:58this book or what was maybe something that brought you to this subject? Well,
- 5:04this is Manfred. Unfortunately, Fred's real life persona has been rather raped
- 5:11and pillaged by various authors ever since his mysterious death in nineteen ninety two.
- 5:18So when Josh and I sat down to write this book, our primary objective
- 5:25was to tell Fred's authentic truth juxtaposed to all the farce and fiction out there
- 5:32that sadly has become rather embedded in the cultural zeitgeist. But that goal would
- 5:38have never been possible or credible if not for Fred's daughter Colline, who so
- 5:45graciously granted us exclusive and unfettered access to her father's personal archives that until recently
- 5:51sad dormant inside a secure, climate controlled storage facility for nearly three decades.
- 5:59It's it's this incredible, never before seen time capsule of Fred's personal and investigative
- 6:05files that served as the primary source material for the fixers, so we could
- 6:11give readers a firsthand knowledge and eyewitness account of the events of his life as
- 6:16he said they actually happened. In essence, we're allowing to speak from the
- 6:21grave, you might say, to set the record straight, and ultimately we
- 6:27hope reclaim is humanity. Yeah, yeah, no, I completely understand that.
- 6:33Unfortunately, that is not uncommon. We see a lot of that where
- 6:40reputations have been over exaggerated or ruined in order to push somebody else's agenda in
- 6:48that process. And so I think it's great that you've been able to have
- 6:54it sounds like complete access to her father's files and for the first time,
- 7:01you know, we were getting a sneak peek into what he was thinking,
- 7:04what he was doing, basically in his own words and his own actions,
- 7:09to a lack of a better word, Yeah, I mean, it's it's
- 7:13way overdue. And you know, I think there's also a very interesting subtext
- 7:17to Fred's story that gives readers a sort of a historical snapshot, if you
- 7:23will, of just how far we've come or not as a society since that
- 7:30era when it comes to myriad cultural issues that we're still grappling with today,
- 7:35such as racism, xenophobia, homophobia, women's rights, organized crime, and
- 7:44of course the you know, the birth of our modern day obsession with celebrity
- 7:48culture, you know, absolutely, And you know, one positive thing that
- 7:55Fred didn't have to deal with that is today is is the social media aspect.
- 8:03And I would assume that it was a little bit easier to control the
- 8:05newspaper and the magazines and the gossip columns compared to what it is today when
- 8:13everybody is a reporter. Yeah, I mean that was kind of that period
- 8:18was certainly not the birth but part of the dawn of you know, checkbook
- 8:26journalism and editorial horse trading, you know, issues that you still see going
- 8:33on today. Yeah, but we also want to make sure that it's clear
- 8:39that it was a two way street. A lot of times they were going
- 8:43to reporters to stop stories but they could also use it to their advantage to
- 8:48start a story if they needed to help guide a particular issue one way or
- 8:54another. Yeah. Absolutely, there were many times times where you had to
- 9:03kind of a quick pro quo, you had to trade one thing for the
- 9:05other. Do you think somebody like Fred could survive in today's environment? Oh?
- 9:13Absolutely, you know. Fred was. He was very smart, very
- 9:18cunning. He played both sides against the middle for his own survival and and
- 9:28in doing that, I think is what established whatever power base he had,
- 9:33And I think that that's certainly something that he could do today. Interestingly enough,
- 9:41the creator of Ray Donovan and it's star Leeb Schreiber have said several times
- 9:48that the Ray Donovan character is partly based on Fred and his life. Now,
- 9:56Fred might not have been extreme as some of the things that you've seen
- 10:00on Ray Donovan if you've seen that show, but he certainly a little more
- 10:05extreme than you know, say, Jim Rockford, right, Jim, Yeah,
- 10:11you also this is Bamford again. I mean you have to remember Fred
- 10:15launched his eponymous Detective Bureau in nineteen fifty five with a skill set that easily
- 10:22eclipsed his contemporaries. Courtesy of the emerging surveillance technology that he honed on the
- 10:28LAPD. You know, in addition to his wiretapping prowess, he had retrofitted
- 10:35retrofitted at nineteen fifty Ford f one panel delivery truck disguised as a twenty four
- 10:41hour TV repair band and loaded it with expensive transmitters and parabolic microphones and long
- 10:48range cameras. So, you know, seeing how adept he was at that
- 10:56technology, then I can only imagine what he would do today. Yeah,
- 11:01And that was what ultimately led to some of the best stories in the book
- 11:05because we had access to those transcripts, you know, the tape recorded sessions
- 11:11he did of h candidate then candidate Senator John Kennedy and his lovers and Bobby
- 11:18Kennedy and uh and Meril Monroe and so all of that. Rock Hudson,
- 11:24Rock Hudson, all of that. Uh that that ability of him to to
- 11:30in those days take those those houses and those residents really provided for great material
- 11:37for the book. And I'm sure if he was alive today doing that,
- 11:39he would have the most sophisticated equipment. He just have better he'd have better
- 11:45poise today than he had back did yes, well and Fred Fred called that
- 11:50equal justice a way in which he could provide his clients with technology that at
- 11:56the time was only available to law enforcement. Yea could have help even the
- 12:01playing field a little bit. Did anything surprise you during your research and the
- 12:09writing of this book, I mean, I think the most the most this
- 12:13is Josh, the most interesting. One of the most interesting thing things was
- 12:20Bred's very nuanced, complicated, and tumultuous relationship with Marilyn and Roe. He
- 12:26first met her when she was a young ANGENEU named Norma Jean, and he
- 12:31was a rookie LAPD cop, and as you can see in the book,
- 12:35their friendship spanned the respective course of their Hollywood journeys right up until Maryland's death
- 12:41in nineteen sixty two, which Fred recorded because her house was buged. So
- 12:48I think that probably that relationship. I don't know if it surprised me the
- 12:54most, but I was the most interesting and complex. Yeah, I mean,
- 13:01this is this is Manford. It's it's kind of hard to pick your
- 13:03favorite child, but certainly his work with Marilyn Monroe and Judy Garland and Lana
- 13:09Turner are at the top of the list. Honestly, it was all rather
- 13:13surprising and fascinating, because it's not often one gets the opportunity to take a
- 13:18deep dive into a notorious private Eyzed library of Alexandria. You might say,
- 13:24sure, Fred's archives provide such a wealth of content and stories and granular details
- 13:31from his one of a kind journey through arguably one of the most iconic periods
- 13:37in Hollywood history. And you know, there were there were many cases we
- 13:41didn't include, such as Betty Davis, Lucille Ball, Jajah Gabor, Errol
- 13:48Flynn, Anita Ekberg, to name a few. Otherwise the book would have
- 13:52would have been well over eight hundred pages. So you know, there's plenty
- 13:56of materials to write a sequel, right, just couldn't have fit all into
- 14:00one book in terms of that, And it sounds like we're very lucky that
- 14:05he had very extensive notes. Oh god, it's the material is amazing.
- 14:13I mean, it's literally like you're taking a trip back in time. Wow,
- 14:18and you're holding these original documents. You know, some of them are
- 14:22still on the original onion skin paper. And he even kept like old Hollywood
- 14:28reporters and flyers for for for clubs, I mean, for the Macambo and
- 14:33Ciro's and all this amazing artwork and photography. I mean it really is museum
- 14:39quality material. That's great. There was anything off limits that when his daughter
- 14:46allowed you to kind of peer inside, did you say you could have this
- 14:50but stay away from this. Was there any restrictions that you were given?
- 14:54None at all, None at all. No, no, no, no,
- 14:58none at all. And and in fact, you know there are there
- 15:01are some stories in the book that, you know, if you were looking
- 15:05to sanitize his life, you might not include. But you know, it's
- 15:09it's it's it's the works at all, which gives you a full picture of
- 15:13who he really was. And I think that is one of the things that
- 15:20is interesting about the book that it doesn't pull any punches, and it it
- 15:24really, you know, doesn't leave out anything that might not shine, you
- 15:31know, a super positive light on him. And it's not a hagiography a
- 15:35boy anything. Yeah, I mean, no person is black and white.
- 15:37I mean yeah, well, and so many times when you pick up a
- 15:45biography or not even necessarily a biography or an autobiography, but just a book
- 15:48about somebody, it kind of gets tainted one way or the other. Somebody's
- 15:54got an agenda, and it really didn't feel like you guys had that.
- 15:58But I just wanted to make sure that there was nothing that his daughter was
- 16:02telling you behind the scenes that you couldn't or couldn't include in the book.
- 16:07No, I mean again, absolutely not. That the only agenda here was
- 16:10to tell the truth. And she she had been so devastated by how her
- 16:14father's persona had been treated over the years by by a number of authors,
- 16:19most most notably James Elroy, that she was very keen on us really opening
- 16:29the coffers, so to speak, and letting the world know the truth,
- 16:33you know, well, which is very I would say brave of her,
- 16:37because again not you don't always get that honesty where somebody's saying, hey,
- 16:41write about the good, the bad, and the ugly. You don't always
- 16:47get that. Absolutely, but she understood that her father was a very nuanced
- 16:52character, and you know, navigating the kind of murky and clandestine and underbelly
- 17:00of Hollywood in the nineteen fifties and sixties takes a certain type of person.
- 17:07You might say, you know, yeah, but he was definitely a man
- 17:11of integrity, yeah, which is very interesting for being in a position as
- 17:18quote unquote a fixer that wouldn't necessarily go hand in hand integrity being a fixer.
- 17:26But I think he was also very this is Josh, he was another
- 17:30interesting quality. Yet he was very protective of women in his day. There
- 17:34are several stories in the book where he breaks up a cast and couch to
- 17:37help a young ANGEEU who has come to town. He helps get Judy Garland
- 17:44sober. He helps Rock Hudson's you know, Rock Hudson's wife who is divorcing
- 17:51and you know, basically kicking to the kurb. He helps her extract the
- 17:56settlement from Rock that's fair so she can continue to live her life. So
- 18:03there's also that aspect of the book that frankly was pretty rare, you know,
- 18:07in the nineteen fifties for people in those positions of power. And this
- 18:12is manfred I. You know, I think there are detectives and there are
- 18:18detectives, and I think that the most powerful celebrities and power brokers and attorneys
- 18:27in Hollywood during that period would not have hired him if he wasn't I had,
- 18:34if he didn't have a certain level of integrity and conviction for his job.
- 18:40Yeah, because the studios and lawyers and everything. They had a bit
- 18:44image too, and so it's a fine line. It sounds like that they
- 18:48had to walk absolutely. I mean you had you had to navigate that world
- 18:53in a way that was conducive to to your success. And if you are
- 19:02a schmuck, I don't think I don't think that that would have been very
- 19:07successful. And unfortunately, sometimes you have to do things that are a little
- 19:12ugly at times, Josh, I'll let you. Yeah, and and and
- 19:21frankly, frankly illegal. I mean, the wiretapping that he was doing absolutely
- 19:26was admitted by his own admission illegal, But as Manford mentioned earlier, I
- 19:30mean, the the FBI and the LAPD had had sophisticated wire tapping equipment that
- 19:38private investigators didn't have. So in a way, yeah, that was illegal,
- 19:41but he was using that to level the playing field in a lot of
- 19:45ways. Yeah, kind of like we talked a little earlier. Well,
- 19:48Jim, I know we're getting here close on time, but I'm going to
- 19:51ask you both, is there one particular story that you really enjoyed. I'll
- 19:56kind of ask you each to answer that as we ra things up here.
- 20:03Well, for me, this is Manfred, it would have to be his
- 20:07One of my favorites is his his work with Judy Garland, which is,
- 20:11you know, I think it's a movie in itself. You know, she
- 20:15had just filed for divorce from her third husband's left and and she was afraid
- 20:21to be alone in her home and she feared that left might kidnap her her
- 20:23kids. So so her attorney, Jerry Geisler, hired Otash to kind of
- 20:29serve as his body as her bodyguard, and which was kind of one of
- 20:33the one of the situations that uh was his entree into becoming a fixer.
- 20:41So he moved in with her into her you know, sprawling Hombie Hills mansion
- 20:45for for a month, and and when he discovered that she was her her
- 20:51acute dependency on alcohol and prescription drugs, he immediately realized that he had to
- 21:00do something about it. So he locked up all the booze in the garage
- 21:03and flushed all her pills down the toilet, and in doing so essentially forced
- 21:07Judy to address her demons and addictions cold turkey. And he spent a month
- 21:15staying up late at night and into the wee hours of the morning, keeping
- 21:19a sleepless Judy company as andiently, patiently listening to her as she poured her
- 21:26heart out on all the trials and tribulations of her Hollywood journey, which in
- 21:32a way was kind of a you know, looking at it now, was
- 21:37kind of a form of therapy. And in long story short, his work
- 21:41helped her reconcile her marriage to Sid loved And I think that's really cool because
- 21:48a lot of times when you hear the word the fixer, it's a negative
- 21:55connotation. You always think of maybe helping somebody get an abortion or something kind
- 22:00of in that negative light, you think of something lurid. Yes, and
- 22:04this is a very positive impact that he had as quote unquote the fixer Again,
- 22:11like Josh said, he was a champion of his causes. Absolutely,
- 22:17absolutely, Josh, maybe your story, Yeah, I would have to say
- 22:22the events of August fourth and August fifth, nineteen sixty two, the night
- 22:30that Marilyn died. I don't know if they're my most favorite, but they
- 22:36are certainly the most startling and interesting, and they have been written about before,
- 22:42but not with the information that we had available to us. So I
- 22:48think that anyone who reads the book that will pretty much take the cake.
- 22:53Yeah, and you know, circling back on Maril Monroe and her death,
- 22:56and there's all all types of different theories and thoughts, and unfortunately that tragedy
- 23:07kind of gets diluted a little bit, if you will, with all the
- 23:11different misinformation and theories that are out there. And it's nice just to have
- 23:17a for lack of a better word, somebody with a bird's eye view of
- 23:21the situation. Well, it's funny you said that, because which is absolutely
- 23:26true. I was listening to an historian speaking of the day on NPR and
- 23:30he was saying, one of the easiest ways to hide the truth is to
- 23:37completely drown it in hearsay and suspicion and various different theories and conspiracy theories,
- 23:45to the point that nobody really knows one from the other. Right, same
- 23:51thing that happened with the Kennedy assassination. You just dilute it. Now nobody
- 23:56really knows. And it's when what sixty years later, whatever it is,
- 24:00and when you're still wondering, Yeah, we're still writing about it. Yes,
- 24:07absolutely, uh. And I guess if anything, it keeps her memory
- 24:12alive. I guess if you were looking for a silver lining in that that
- 24:17that that may be a positive. I don't know, it's just very unfortunate.
- 24:22Well, I you know, I think sometimes I wonder if if if
- 24:26Marilyn was alive, or you know, if I think she would have wanted
- 24:30people to know the truth and and and what's so fascinating, like Josh said,
- 24:37is to hear Fred's I mean, Fred was one of a handful of
- 24:44people who who had listened to those tapes and to hear him talk about it
- 24:51was just groundbreaking. Yeah, very fast talking, you know, all of
- 24:57those feelings. Yeah, gentlemen, thank you so much for coming on and
- 25:03spending some time with us today. And to the listeners out there, please
- 25:07go out and get a copy of the book The Fixers, Moguls, Mobsters,
- 25:11movie Stars and Maryland. You're not going to be disappointed. I mean,
- 25:15this is really a fascinating story. Like you said, we're getting to
- 25:19look behind the curtain a little bit because you were able to actually have his
- 25:25notes and his research and very grateful for his daughter to allow you to kind
- 25:30of peek behind the curtain a little bit. Yes, thank you, Dog.
- 25:36We appreciate appreciate you having us on. Thank you very thank you very
- 25:40much. Doug. It was a pleasure. Yes, well, thank you
- 25:41and thank you for listening to this episode of Forgotten Hollywood. Just search for
- 25:45Dodcaster Forgotten Hollywood. You can also find me on Twitter, Instagram at has
- 25:48Doug fourteen. If you listen to this podcast on iTunes another podcast service,
- 25:52please subscribe to rate and review this episode. Tune in next week for the
- 25:56latest episode of Forgotten Hollywood. Thank you for listening and we will see you soon.