Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Projection and Jung
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, servant listeners. We have a very special guest with us today on
- 0:04the podcast. My good friend Anne Blake from Antioch University. We were co
- 0:11workers that would chat a lot before and after meetings and during meetings sometimes.
- 0:18And is this really nice but professional, smart, dynamic person. Interesting person.
- 0:28She's been on the podcast before talking about Myers Briggs and Jungian psychology like
- 0:34ten years ago, a long time ago ago, and we ran into each
- 0:39other at Jerry's memorial and talked and I said, Hey, do you have
- 0:45anything you want to chat about to the world And said, oh, I
- 0:50got a few juicy things. And I always like it when people say that
- 0:54because I'll throw it out there to people and often they will say like,
- 0:58oh, I'll get back to you, and then they ever do. And
- 1:00it's such a great thing because I always want to highlight all the intelligence and
- 1:07knowledge and wisdom among just the people that I know. There's so much wisdom
- 1:12behind the Ivory Tower doors that needs to be shared with everyone, and it's
- 1:18a great opportunity for us to talk shit about people that we want to talk
- 1:23about before we start recording it. So welcome to the podcast, Dan,
- 1:27Thank you so much. I'm smiling broadly and normally at you. Yeah.
- 1:32Yeah, another detail that I talk about on this podcast. Listeners will know
- 1:37that I'm notorious for my thin skin not only with students when they would criticize
- 1:41me, but also when listeners or people online will criticize me. And the
- 1:47one professor that I could relate to that had a similar reactivity, and another
- 1:53way of putting it as a similar dedication to the experience for students. You
- 1:57know, you don't want them to have a bad experience. You're really dedicated
- 2:00to being a professor? Was you? I always felt like you were the
- 2:05one person that I was like, Okay, at least there's another person that
- 2:08takes this as seriously and will have sleepless nights when there's a bad evaluation.
- 2:14So it's a sensitivity in that there's another way of talking about Yeah, and
- 2:20some kind of trauma, some kind of perfectionism, some kind of shame,
- 2:24some some something something's going on, but also I think just an empathy for
- 2:29students and wanting them to have not just a mediocre experience, but like a
- 2:34you know, a transformative experience, which it often can be so anyway,
- 2:38and so we brought ourselves, which is being vulnerable yet, right, right,
- 2:45So I don't just show up. You don't show up and mail it
- 2:47in. We're really showing up our whole person. You know, If I
- 2:52go to the McDonald's and I order a big Mac and they criticize the way
- 2:55I ordered it, I'm not going to cry myself to sleep because how I
- 3:00wasn't pouring my life and sold to how it was ordering that. When I
- 3:01show up to class, you know, all guns are blazing on that thing,
- 3:06you know, So you understood that, and I felt in solidarity with
- 3:12you. So one more thing in that is in the sixties. I forget
- 3:16who said it. Somebody really important said the political is personal for me,
- 3:22the psychology is personal. Yeah. So I'm always processing through myself, my
- 3:28YOUNGI and colleagues, at least the way they talk in workshops, they're processing
- 3:31through their clients. I'm processing through myself. And so again that makes it
- 3:37more vulnerable and for me, more real, right exactly, yeah, right,
- 3:43And when you operate that way, then there's a lot more on the
- 3:46line. Yeah, absolutely, And you're more open and vulnerable and real and
- 3:53you don't shut things up. So what do you want to talk about with
- 3:57podcast land? Today, So I want to talk today about projection, the
- 4:03everyday ness of projection. So projection is taking the things about ourselves, both
- 4:09the too bright and shiny and the too stinky and slimy. Unconsciously we take
- 4:15the worst and the best of those most of us do and project it out
- 4:19under somebody else, which means we see it in somebody else and not ourselves.
- 4:24And I want to talk about the good news about that. Right,
- 4:28Because people use projection colloquially in the non psychoanalytic, non union way, they'll
- 4:34basically be using it in a displacement or a distortion thing, so support it.
- 4:41Right. So projection and its psychoanalytic definition is that we have an aspect
- 4:46of self that we don't like. What what did you put to it?
- 4:49Slimy or slimy and icky and bright and shiny, something about the two poles,
- 4:55the two poles, and we will project it, well, see it
- 4:59on someone and unconsciously we do that. But the good news is that we
- 5:03have tells and so I'm going to talk about those tells today to be able
- 5:09to identify right when we are projecting. So one of the things that I
- 5:15observe in our field is what I call disparaging words, and so lots of
- 5:19psychological theories use words for clients such as avoidance, defending, deflecting, denial,
- 5:28justification, projection, resistance, and so forth. I think those are
- 5:32disparaging in terms of it gets us into our left brain and we are distancing
- 5:38ourselves from clients and on some level criticizing them and holding them responsible for things
- 5:43that are really not yet responsible for. Part of our job is to help
- 5:46people be accountable. So instead of those words, I use the word protection.
- 5:53So people are protecting themselves. Then my heart swings open and then I'm
- 5:58empathic, and then I'm still in the in the juice with them, rather
- 6:01than I stepped back and I'm like, what's what's going on here? So
- 6:05that's one thing. And projection is one of those words. So instead of
- 6:09judging, which interferes with empathic assessment, then we are more in with the
- 6:16client and looking at the issues from that something happened, What happened that they
- 6:24decided they couldn't be here completely. One of the things I love about family
- 6:28therapy, which is your field, is that all the behaviors and Freud said
- 6:32this too. I almost said young. Freud said this too, that all
- 6:34the behaviors are attempts to solve a problem. They're not effective when we have
- 6:39trauma from our childhood that skews our thinking and pushes that back into some again
- 6:45that that hyper protection. But they are attempts to solve the problem. And
- 6:48this can apply not just to clinician therapist client, but also your spouse or
- 6:55your kids. Yeah, your coworker projection and project time all the time.
- 7:00I'm in fact, my dear friend Kirkanda, when you were giving the introduction
- 7:05of me and you were you were using some very nice words, I was
- 7:08thinking, huh, and he's projecting at the same time, because if we
- 7:13if we don't have those things, we can't see those things. Yeah,
- 7:15that this is how I think of projection too. I'm glad that you see
- 7:19because not every I would say a minority of us see it this way.
- 7:23That we can project positive things. Oh, absolutely, both sides, both
- 7:28sides of that yell has both sides. When we are physically intimate with our
- 7:33partners, it might be a projection of when we were cuddling with our parents.
- 7:38Absolutely internalized that diad, that relational experience, and then we recreate it
- 7:46and absolutely we're replicators, we're pattern makers and replicators. And then when some
- 7:51of those patterns again get formed so early before our precognitions in our prefrontal cortex
- 7:58is going on, when we experienced trauma and abandonment and attachment ruptures, then
- 8:05our little mind that's not yet fully on board makes some decisions about here's what
- 8:11the world is like for me, and then behavior starts to cluster around those.
- 8:16So the other good piece of news is that we are capable. This
- 8:20is my opinion of everything. Each one of us is cable of everything,
- 8:24for the good and the bad, and for those of us who were fortunate
- 8:28enough to have good enough parenting as much what we call it in the field,
- 8:31we don't see ideal. We don't say good good enough, because we're
- 8:35all human beings. When we had good enough parenting, then we decide I'm
- 8:41making a funny face about that, because the side is a pretty big word.
- 8:46But we're more attracted to things that are communal and beneficial for both.
- 8:54I'm not going to remember the interview I saw. I'm not going to remember
- 8:56the name of the interview that I saw this morning, actually early this morning,
- 9:01about a new book that's coming out, But the guy is talking about
- 9:03morality and sort of golden rule kind of things about this is what human beings
- 9:11could achieve together, and then we all feel good enough. Eric Byrne talked
- 9:18and transactional analysity. He talked about I'm okay, you're okay, and then
- 9:22variations on I'm okay, you're not okay, I'm not okay, you're not
- 9:26okay. Neither one of us is okay, but I'm okay, you're okay
- 9:28again. Is that good enough that we strive for? So again, those
- 9:33of us who have good enough backgrounds can make those discernments and not do some
- 9:39of the awful, terrible, inhumane things that people do to each other because
- 9:43of their protections. Exactly exactly, exactly so when I taught at Normal psych
- 9:48I talked about we behave badly because we're in pain, and that's a perspective.
- 9:54And there are certainly some genetic things as well, and some that nature
- 9:58nurture what we learn, what we're born with. It's a it's a convoluted
- 10:05and still kind of mysterious balancing ratio. And I tend to as a Jungian
- 10:11psychotherapist, I tend to look at the at the developmental issues me too,
- 10:16I mean not from the Jungian side, but the psychodynamic side and attachment side.
- 10:22In my practice, I do both supervision and individual therapy, and so
- 10:28in the in the supervision, I talk a lot about counter transference, which
- 10:33is again a form of projection, so transference from the client to the clinician,
- 10:37which is about living through in a diad a variety of relationships with previous
- 10:43person in their lives. And then the counter transference is then the clinicians projection
- 10:50of my unresolved things onto the client. And so the more I know about
- 10:56myself and resolve and metabolizes the word I use, my traumas and my stuck
- 11:01places and you'll call them complexes, the better I'm able to then access the
- 11:05energy that goes between us. And so I'm a lot about wondering about what
- 11:11I'm thinking, feeling, sensing, imaging, and then when I get that,
- 11:18then I hypothesize the degree to which that's also true for the client.
- 11:22So I'm using myself as the barometer, Like if you start to feel insecure
- 11:28about yourself as a therapist, then you might through this quick self analysis and
- 11:35the moment and maybe afterwards in your own consultation, you might start to wonder,
- 11:39is this manifestation of my client's own insecurity. I remember, fifteen years
- 11:46ago you gave me by the Xerox machine this handout that had this all graphically
- 11:54depicted. There's like the client, the therapist, and there's these arrows going
- 11:58like conscious and unconscious, and we call it enactments and the counter transference and
- 12:05transparence and the back and forth. And whenever I think about this, I
- 12:09would say half the time I think about that handout that you said, Hey,
- 12:15I'm giving my students this handout. I kind of looked at it and
- 12:16I was like, oh, yeah, I like that. You know,
- 12:20in the therapy office, it's a two person system, both people bringing their
- 12:26relational traumas and positive experiences to the table unconsciously melding together and affecting both people
- 12:33and understanding that and using it is the key to therapy. Absolutely. And
- 12:39so we're monitoring all those vectors. So they're one to five maybe six.
- 12:43Yeah, math is not my strong the conscious, the conscious to the unconscious,
- 12:48the unconscious to the unconscious, and unconscious to the conscious. Yeah,
- 12:50yeah, And we're monitoring all of that. And so then what I try
- 12:56to do and what I invite supervisors to do, to say, is it
- 13:01something like this for you? So I don't say, oh, my gosh,
- 13:03I'm feeling sad right now? Are you feeling sad? Because then they're
- 13:05going to focus on me and be worried about me and go out of themselves.
- 13:09So you're saying that when you're hearing your supervisor you talk about their clients.
- 13:15When I'm talking with when I'm talking with the client, oh, your
- 13:18own clients. Yeah, I don't say I I'm feeling sad. Are you
- 13:22feeling sad? Because I'm one of the two situations that I talk about in
- 13:28terms of my clients. I usually talked only about myself. Is a client
- 13:31was talking about some loss, I don't remember what it was, and of
- 13:35course I wouldn't say what it was anyway, but I don't remember. I
- 13:39was flooded with grief, and so I, you know, it kind of
- 13:43shook me. And then I said, okay, okay, this is mine,
- 13:46this is mine, And a specific grief came up for you. Oh,
- 13:48lots of griefs, lots of unresolved griefing. I'm flooded with grief,
- 13:54and so then I said to myself, Okay, I got to address that
- 13:56later, and then said something like deep sorrow to the person and boom,
- 14:01the person went down into the effect. So that doesn't always happen, but
- 14:07it did happen that time. But I don't say, oh my gosh,
- 14:09I was just flooded with grief, how are you doing? That? Is
- 14:11that sad for you? Because that's about me. You don't want them to
- 14:15worry about you. That's right, that's right, or or distract from themselves
- 14:20because it's so hard to do that grieving. And if I say and I,
- 14:24they'll just go how are you doing? And you know they won't say
- 14:26it out loud probably anyway. So let me get back to some reading here.
- 14:31Let me do some definitions. So I'm a Jungi in not a union
- 14:37but a young in. I'll come from Union Union Town in Minnesota, mining
- 14:45town, so Jungi and Carl Jung c G Jung So. He described projection
- 14:50as everything that irritates us about others can lead us to an understanding of ourselves.
- 14:56There's the key. There is no coming to consciousness with out pain.
- 15:01People will do anything, no matter how absurd, in order to avoid facing
- 15:07their own soul. Everyone carries a shadow, that's the receiver, the receptacle
- 15:13for the things that I project outward unconsciously, and the less the shadow is
- 15:18embodied in the individual's conscious life, the darker and denser the shadow is.
- 15:24So then when dark and dence, we mean it controls me rather than I
- 15:28manage it. So then I'm acting out, which we'll talk about in a
- 15:33few moments, not out of my volition, but out of something that's got
- 15:37control of me. When an inner situation is not made conscious, it appears
- 15:41outside as fate, So my unresolvedness. It's I don't know exactly what I
- 15:48believe in what I accept, but I do wonder about that energy in the
- 15:52world that when I need to work on something, something presents itself to me.
- 15:56Now am I looking for it? Am I recognizing it? I don't
- 16:00think somebody is up there managing this, putting people in my way, but
- 16:07sometimes it seems like that. Yeah, I think about this a lot.
- 16:10Because I don't believe that there's a divine puller of strings. It's not a
- 16:17useful way of looking at psychology and what we do, so I often will
- 16:22wonder, For example, the Biggie is marrying your parent and for bad reasons,
- 16:30you know, like your dad was abusive, and you marry an abusive
- 16:33person, even though you grew up knowing how horrible it is to be with
- 16:37an abusive person or sometimes being the abusive person. Yeah, but it just
- 16:44going with that one example of oh my god, I'm twenty years into a
- 16:48marriage and this person is abusive, just like my dad was. I swore
- 16:53that I would never be like my mom and marry someone like this. If
- 16:59anyone knows how to identify these people, it's me, how did this happen?
- 17:03And they get a divorce, they go on a date, and you
- 17:07know, five dates in this person's abusage. What's happening here? And it's
- 17:11such a known, at least anecdotal pattern that how does this happen? Because
- 17:17people are smart and they're focused and they're trying to avoid things, and so
- 17:22what's going on there? Because it's one thing to let things go in the
- 17:25beginning of relationship where you will say, well, you know it's normal that
- 17:30he's getting upsets at the waiter. You know that's normal because that's been normalized
- 17:36them. But how did they sniff them out to begin with? Like,
- 17:38how did they even know to respond to them or go after them. And
- 17:45I think about this a lot because people ask me this a lot, and
- 17:48you know, it's subtle, and I could come up with some examples of
- 17:52how that could play out, where you could see a certain marker and the
- 17:56way they dress or stand or on hinder, they're sort of photos that they
- 18:02choose. There's certain subtle cues that they might be in that category of a
- 18:07dominant, aggressive, macho sort of person. So there's that angle. But
- 18:11I think that it's it's a huge question mark for me, though, and
- 18:15I think an important one because if we can answer this, at least to
- 18:18some extent, I think you could save a lot of people from repeating the
- 18:22past, you know, and that energetic transmission that happens too. So one
- 18:27of the reasons I like vibe you get from some exactly exactly it's recognizable unconsciously,
- 18:33like oh I know this. There's some comfort in knowing the unknown is
- 18:38always scary for us, even though it's like some folks are are risk takers,
- 18:47there's a better phrase for that, but lots of us are like,
- 18:49no, I'm going to hedge my bets right the devil, you know,
- 18:52Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Right. Through all my
- 18:56travels, I identified a few different reasons why we repeat as Freud and Jung
- 19:03would talk about participate potion. One being double you know, the other being
- 19:08trying unconsciously to correct for the past, which can go well sometimes can also
- 19:15become disastrous if you choose someone that is so similar to the past, and
- 19:19when it's good enough parenting, that's what it's supposed to be. We're supposed
- 19:25to look for somebody who's got those similar characteristics of kindness and morality. And
- 19:30yeah, yeah, my mother's two nieces, two of my mother's no,
- 19:38two of my mother's cousins. Our family is is on an incline in terms
- 19:44of some of the generations were really long, and so my mother's cousins are
- 19:49almost more like her children, a little older than her children. But anyway,
- 19:55two of one of my grandmother's brothers was a and his wife were just
- 20:00horrible, horrible alcoholics. They were just fall down drunk people, and it
- 20:04just looked so bodily genetic. Somehow it was not so much trauma based,
- 20:12I don't think, although some of it could be. But they just couldn't
- 20:15help themselves. They just couldn't and we didn't have a in those days.
- 20:19And they had two daughters. So those are my mother's cousins, and I've
- 20:25gotten close to one of them. The other one died young, unfortunately in
- 20:27an accent. But I said to her one day, how did you avoid
- 20:33that in your life? Because she had a really nice husband and you know,
- 20:37good kids and grandkids, and she said, literally, my sister and
- 20:41I sat down together and had a conversation on we were late teens, early
- 20:45twenties and said we're not going to do that and supported each other consciously saying
- 20:51this is not going to happen in our generation. So sometimes that can happen.
- 20:56Yeah, Yeah, on their own, they can get therapy and right,
- 21:00just had that spunk in them. Yeah. Well, and it sounds
- 21:03like they didn't. But classic is that they become a workaholic or something else.
- 21:08You have, some other pulls them away from life, some destructive activity.
- 21:15But it sounds like that didn't happen. I don't know them well enough
- 21:18to say none of that happened, but they look like they had pretty good
- 21:22lives. Yeah, reasonable right, right, self awareness and dedication and said
- 21:30together, let's support it, support and enjoying that. Yeah, let me
- 21:36do another definition. This is from Paully young Eisendrath, who's a young analysts
- 21:42who I like a lot. The situation in one the projection is the situation
- 21:47in one unconsciously invests another person or object with notions or characteristics of one's own
- 21:55feelings, images, and thoughts can be projected onto others and union theory,
- 21:59as we said, a moment ago be called the projected content our shadow.
- 22:03And I always gestured towards the back of my head in terms of being unconscious
- 22:07and out of our sight, out of our psychological site. And Bilford Yulanoff
- 22:14is a national treasure as a Jungian analyst, and she writes in a book
- 22:19recently published Back to Basics, she says, in praise of projection, so
- 22:23sometimes I think I've got a corner on this, and this is the way
- 22:29I think, and I like the way I think, And then I read
- 22:30something like, well, on one hand, the good news as somebody else
- 22:34thinks this way too, But hey, this is actually mine. But because
- 22:41other people talk about we have to cite them, and between you and me
- 22:45and the audience, I got there first without reading this. I have a
- 22:48similar thought with Ift with emotionally focused therapy. Yeah. That it was emerging
- 22:56in popularity around the time that I was becoming a clinician. And when I
- 23:03talk, people will sometimes say, oh, you're an emotionally focused therapist,
- 23:07and I have said, no, I have the same foundation that they do
- 23:11or similar But I had developed those ideas before. Emotionally focused therapy was not
- 23:18that I don't like emotionally but I don't don't think, you know, I
- 23:22just feel like I always have to say something like that, because like,
- 23:25you know, we're more cousins. You know, they're not my father,
- 23:29you know they're anyway. I get it. I get that, I don't
- 23:32I understand that feeling. And because I admire this person much, it's great
- 23:36that that I know that we think alike. So she says, in praise
- 23:40of projection, or at least in defense of projection. It is a normal
- 23:44and inevitable happening in our psychics, both individually and together. We do not
- 23:48outgrow it. So here's the union thing. We don't get cured, we
- 23:52get more conscious and more I'm actually the driver rather than the passenger. We
- 23:59do not grow though becoming conscious of this pattern and in particular what we ourselves
- 24:03project onto others can change our relationship to it. We become curious. That's
- 24:08a big deal for us, therapist about curious. We become curious what content
- 24:14and ethics we put onto others, Why these contents and why onto specific others?
- 24:19So why these contents and why onto specific others? We become merciful,
- 24:25refraining from harsh judgments against ourselves and others for dumping into the common atmosphere what
- 24:30we avoid in ourselves. That's a lovely phrase. We become patient and invest
- 24:34time and effort to not pollute our surroundings with their undigested rage and lamentation.
- 24:41Now this is really sert of stuff. And I'm smiling brightly because I just
- 24:44love how she says it, and I just agree with this makes sense to
- 24:48me. Yeah, there's some academic writing that every sentence can be mulled over
- 24:52for weeks. Yeah, yeah, she's one of those people. For me,
- 24:56we accept this basic process of being human. Young's insight is immensely helpful.
- 25:00Here. Projection happens when an emotion, thought, impulse is on its
- 25:06way to consciousness. The first step is projection. So that's the deal,
- 25:11and again that's my jam is that there are tells, and so let's talk
- 25:15about the tells. So I want to ground it just just a brief moment
- 25:19here for the listeners that if you want to play along, you can pause
- 25:25the podcast and think about three people recently that have annoyed you greatly, especially
- 25:30if you think that other people wouldn't necessarily be as annoyed as you are with
- 25:34them. It could be your partner, it could be someone at work.
- 25:37It could be someone at the grocery market. It could be your father,
- 25:41your kid, whatever, could be someone in the media, like a politician
- 25:47or a pundit or a celebrity, something where you just had a fair amount
- 25:52of energy around it, just like I can't believe that they did that thing,
- 25:56or it just once again, and you know, just jot down,
- 26:00you know, a couple of words or a sentence, just to for each
- 26:04of the three, and then it's possible that that's an indication of this protective
- 26:11projection that is that Anne is talking about. So I'm nodding vigorously, and
- 26:18thank you for using the word protection. And you just did what the last
- 26:22three pages of this presentation is going to be about. So that's exactly right,
- 26:30and so and also to pause and look at and I do I do
- 26:34the three so three people that you admire excessively, so the annoyance and the
- 26:41admiration, and then do a little writing about that. And so so I
- 26:48can say, oh, my goodness, Kirkanda, like he's got his PhD.
- 26:52He's published a book about supervision, which is my one of my favorite
- 26:56things. And so I can go on and on about oh my gosh,
- 26:59oh my gosh, Kirkanda. And then I put myself away and out of
- 27:03peering with you. And that's that projection of my talent as well. I
- 27:10put it onto you and export it from myself. And is it a protection
- 27:15at that point or is it just normal normal life at that point? Let
- 27:21me just whoops, grab your tote bag of academia. Actually, but first,
- 27:27let's take a break in my calendar. Would I keep a hard copy
- 27:36calendar? That's how old I am. In Here is Mary Anne Williamson,
- 27:41who was quoted by Nelson Mandela in his inaugural speech. She says, our
- 27:48deepest fear is not that we are inadequate. Our deepest fheares that we are
- 27:52powerful beyond measure. So that part of the fear, the protection is well,
- 27:56if I acknowledge the completeess of me, including the wonderfulness as well as
- 28:02the stinkiness. In terms of the wonderfulness, I'm going to have to live
- 28:06up to that. Maybe I mean I don't have to. But part of
- 28:08the fear of acknowledging the best, shiniest part of ourselves is some I think,
- 28:15some responsibility. So that protection is. There was a fear of success
- 28:21dissertation. I forget who did that. Maybe I don't think Jacobe, but
- 28:26that was a big deal when I was in grad school in the mid nineteen
- 28:32seventies. So that fear of success thing. Yeah, yeah, right,
- 28:37And so you can also, dear listener, think about those admiration absolute thoughts
- 28:45that you have and think about what you might be trying to protect. Yeah
- 28:51through that. So here's we might as well just go there. Okay.
- 28:53So the second piece to making that list and filling it out some is and
- 29:00then the next piece of that there are three parts here. The next piece
- 29:03is to say, write some sentences. I to am like that in the
- 29:07following ways, so that now we're reclaiming the projection for all six Yeah,
- 29:14for the negative ones and the positive ones, I too, am like that
- 29:19in these ways. So I too am conversant about supervision, and I'm actually
- 29:25trying to do some writing about that. I am writing about that, and
- 29:27so that inspiration I can take from your doing it rather than oh, Kirk
- 29:33did that, but I certainly can't do that. I haven't done it yet,
- 29:37you know, blah blah blah. Yeah, so I put you up
- 29:40on a pedestal, then I'm lower then, So I too have that interest
- 29:45in that articulateness and some really useful, clear, helpful thinking about that.
- 29:53And that feels scary to you. That's why you project it the responsibility.
- 30:00I haven't done it yet. Yeah, I've started and haven't completed it yet.
- 30:03Yeah. Yeah, But completing it, or presumably if that's the goal
- 30:10or the destiny, then the path, at least to some extent, involves
- 30:14facing this projection. Absolutely, absolutely, Yeah. Can you admire someone without
- 30:18it being protective? It's the excessiveness, the annoyance. The annoyance gets us
- 30:26out of ourselves. So it's like the again Yung's words, where the complex
- 30:32grabs hold of me. So if somebody were to run into me at the
- 30:37supermarket with their cart because they weren't looking and I get annoyed. That's not
- 30:41the projection. That's just like but if I if I ruminate about that for
- 30:48three weeks, or you say something loud and annoying and domaining, right,
- 30:53then that points to a complex projection. And still in our projection of both
- 31:00the positive and negative, it's still true about the other. You are bright
- 31:04and shiny, and you did publish this book about supervision and that I envy
- 31:11that. That's really what it's about underneath that. That's another part of the
- 31:15of the projection. The protection is I envy that because I haven't done it
- 31:19yet, and surely I can't. Who do I think I am? That
- 31:23I can also contribute to the field, By the way, and was famous
- 31:30for her self disclosure as a professor. It's what makes her so powerful and
- 31:36relatable and lovable and got me in a lot of troubles, right right,
- 31:41we're talking a while. Once in a while got me in trouble. Yeah,
- 31:42but it's worth it, well, yeah, because for some students it's
- 31:47hard. It's a challenge. It's like, wait, I thought I was
- 31:52just going to be here learning facts, not having to deal with humanness and
- 31:57emotion and realizing that my professor as a human being with vulnerabilities. I want
- 32:04you to be perfect. That's right, that's right, because my parents weren't
- 32:06perfect, so I want you to be perfect. Right. So the third
- 32:09part, so the first part is making a list of those things that annoy
- 32:13us in others, those things that we overly admire in others so greatly annoyed.
- 32:17And then the second one is saying, and I too, am like
- 32:21that in the following ways. And then the third piece of that is wondering
- 32:25with great compassion about the genesis of that. What does that remind me of?
- 32:31How is that familiar? Whose voices in my head that are telling me
- 32:37that I'm not good enough or that I'm a victim always somebody's always doing something
- 32:42that's irritating and gets in my way, or people are always better than I
- 32:45am. So whose voices are those? Where did that come from? Because
- 32:50we don't come out of the womb that way. That's learned behavior, right,
- 32:54Yeah, And those are the hallmarks for therapy, you know, there's
- 32:59up sounds like you talking exactly, and for self awareness. It was like,
- 33:02oh, that's my mom inside of my head right now. Yeah,
- 33:07So let me talk about my grandma a little bit okay. So my grandmother,
- 33:10my maternal grandmother, incredibly bright woman. My mother was getting her masters
- 33:19in teaching kids who had learning disabilities, and so part of that, like
- 33:24my training and your training, we learned how to do the Wexler Adult Intelligence
- 33:30Scale, which was part of my dissertation. And so she was giving the
- 33:35intelligence tests to my grandmother, who just went on and on and on like
- 33:39in definitions and problem solving. She was just off the charts bright and bright
- 33:46in a schooling kind of way, which is what the Wexer tests. And
- 33:53because my grandmother was so bright, she thought that what she thought and what
- 34:00she decided and what she knew should be accepted by the rest of us.
- 34:06So I remember a very specific time I was old enough to drive, so
- 34:09I must have been sixteen or older. She lived in my hometown as well.
- 34:14I lived in her hometown, and so I came over to do her
- 34:16an errand, and she told me, this is a town of twenty five
- 34:21thousand People's a little tiny town, Hibbing, Minnesota. Minnesota. Yeah,
- 34:25the iron our capital of the world. And so we have open art or
- 34:31pits and slag which we thought was beautiful dumps. We called them anyway,
- 34:37it's a little town, so I know my way around this town. And
- 34:39she told me exactly how to drive, with pretty big insistence, here's how
- 34:45you do this, and and Bess she called me. And so even today
- 34:50I have much more awareness of it, but still it gets under my under
- 34:53my skin when people tell me how to do things. Like a friend and
- 34:59I were up in bellingh We're going off to Trader Joe's and we drive into
- 35:02this little, tiny parking lot. She said, there's a parking space right
- 35:06there. And my first response is, do you think I'm too stupid to
- 35:09find a parking space? It's such a big thing for me. I know
- 35:15it. I talk about it with friends and they say, why do you
- 35:17react that way? I said, well, number one, I don't need
- 35:21to be told we're at a park. I mean, you know, it's
- 35:22annoying to anybody, particularly annoying, really annoying to me. So that's an
- 35:27example of that projection of and specifically my thinking that that means that I'm stupid
- 35:36and incapable, and that's a big deal. That's the way you felt,
- 35:39and maybe that's the way your grandma felt growing up. It's for me to
- 35:45imagine her feeling stupid, but anyway, and then so that's an example of
- 35:52that negative projection and the way the cues, the way we know that we're
- 35:59in projection, because this is not rocket science at all. So when so
- 36:04the bell shaped curve, I got one here because it's pretty. So this
- 36:09one says sixty eight percent. Usually it's more like seventy four or seventy five
- 36:14percent. It's just normative. So the bell shaped curve is used to measure
- 36:17like height and weight and intelligence, and over a large population of people tested,
- 36:24we even out to most of us fall under this big cap and then
- 36:29the sides go down slowly and then boom, they go out into these little
- 36:32tails. And the little tails are the things that there are people who are
- 36:36taller than anybody else and people who are smarter than anybody else. So those
- 36:40are those tail, those tails on either side, so people who way more
- 36:45than anybody else, people who are not as smart as anybody else. So
- 36:49but most of us fall in that underneath that on broad curve. And so
- 36:53when when I am beside myself, when I don't recognize my behavior and other
- 37:00people don't recognize behavior, that means I'm in projection. That means I am
- 37:06stuck in something that is under my craw under my skin, pebbles underneath my
- 37:15feet and my shoe, that I'm just annoyed or I'm subservient and obsequious.
- 37:20In terms of that positive counter transfers or transference to somebody projection. So that's
- 37:27that's recognizable in ourselves. So when I see my overreactions, sometimes my underreactions,
- 37:34my sister calls it, I pull the shade, I just go away.
- 37:37It's like, this is nonsense. I'm not gonna have anything to do
- 37:39with it. That's also a projection. So when I'm overreacting or underreacting,
- 37:45that's the cue, and I know something's going on in me. And it
- 37:49takes a lot of self awareness to identify that because at first glance, our
- 37:54reactivity is justified. Yeah, everyone with half a brain would react this way.
- 38:01Of course I'm reacting this way. And that's where therapy comes in because
- 38:06it can ask questions that can illuminate what different Yeah, or are good enough
- 38:12friends say what's going on with you? What just happened? Is such a
- 38:16good question to interact. So when when I get into my thing, if
- 38:22someone would say to me, what just happened. Then I'm curious. I'm
- 38:28not defensive, or I could be defensive, but it's a stop and get
- 38:31curious, like, oh, why did I scream out into those little tails
- 38:37on the end of the bell shade curve, and a differentiation of I'm going
- 38:42to look at myself. I'm not just going to operate as if this is
- 38:46the truth. I'm going to look at myself and maybe it is fine that
- 38:50I reacted that way, but that pull away from ourselves, looking at ourselves
- 38:53gives us an opportunity to see that. And when I'm beside myself, then
- 38:59I know that something's going on. And we call those process comments, both
- 39:05in terms of therapy and in the world. And we don't have permission in
- 39:09the world. Although we should have permissions, we don't have permission to say
- 39:14what just happened there? Or it's not what you're saying is the tone?
- 39:17When we say tone to people, they get outraged. Yeah, I learned
- 39:22that the tough way. I posted little video on TikTok about tone because in
- 39:28my couple therapy sessions it's a frequent topic. People will come into my office
- 39:32having had a fight the night before, and I'll look into it, and
- 39:37part of it, if not a majority, of the fight was about tone,
- 39:42about like, yeah, you said that, but that was the verbatim,
- 39:45but you didn't say it in that way. You said it in a
- 39:47judgmental or angry or punitive way. And then universally people will either say no,
- 39:54I didn't or well, what's the difference, right, And it's a
- 40:00all the difference in the world. So having tone an awareness of tone,
- 40:04and so I work with couples a lot because it takes a long time to
- 40:07become aware of tone, to be humble about your you know, like recording
- 40:14a fight and actually listening back to it, often, if not universally,
- 40:17you will hear yourself and go, my god, I have tone. I
- 40:22had no idea how much tone bad tone I have. I thought I was
- 40:28being neutral, but I'm so like critical in that tone. And you know,
- 40:35it's a big, big part of helpfulness and relationship. I talk about
- 40:37it on TikTok and like there's all at least from memory talking about the thin
- 40:42skinny and all these comments about just like when people tell me to watch my
- 40:46tone, I tell them to fuck off or whatever. And because you know,
- 40:51certainly you can use the tone conversation in an uncool way of just like
- 40:57someone's reacting normally and you say, hey, that's not cool. Right.
- 41:01So I think a lot of people have some issues with that stopped them from
- 41:06looking at themselves, and that that's the clue to be able to look at
- 41:10self, and that we're projecting something. We're projecting something that is unmeantabolized,
- 41:15uncompleted, undigested in ourselves, some emotional something or other. And couples,
- 41:22it's probably about mom or dad, no matter the composition of the couple.
- 41:28No matter whether we had both a mom and a dad, or two moms
- 41:30or two dads or just one of either one, we still got stuff about
- 41:34parents. Right. Anytime you run into this, a good starting point is
- 41:38did this come from my parents? Yeah? Exactly, It might not have,
- 41:40but it's a good starting point. Well there's that phrase. If it's
- 41:45not one thing, it's your mother, and of course if it's not one
- 41:47thing, that's your father. Yeah. So yeah, we have such a
- 41:51protracted dependency with human beings as contrasted to other animals. Yeah, never ends,
- 42:00right, write a lifetime, Yeah lifetime. Yeah, So let me
- 42:04glance down here. So again, beside myself, different from my persona,
- 42:08which is the way I present myself to the world, different from my personal
- 42:13self image, different from the usual expected behavior interactions being beside myself or outside
- 42:19myself, and different from my usual interactive Let me ask about if you had
- 42:22not become a psychologist and a professor and a supervisor and a clinician and a
- 42:28professor emerita and a professor Emeredis Mereda as emeritus. Is that Amerethith is female?
- 42:34Okay, Amereda for you? If you hadn't done that, would you
- 42:40know when you were beside yourself? Because it's a hard thing to get used
- 42:45to it, right right right? I can't even I mean I can't.
- 42:51I'm not. I won't even imagining. I got into therapy when I was
- 42:57twenty six. I'm still in therapy at seventy nine. That's a lot of
- 43:01years of therapy. Most recently, I've been with the Union Analyst for thirty
- 43:07three years. It's just such a comfort and an annoyance sometimes and such an
- 43:14integral part of my being. As I was saying earlier that for me,
- 43:20this psychology is personal, the way that politics are personal. I just take
- 43:24it so seriously, and I've got some sensitivity, and so that processing with
- 43:30another person is really important to me. So I feel so fortunate. I
- 43:37come from a mining town. Luckily, my family members on both sides are
- 43:40really bright people and valued education. And because the mind moved the town twice.
- 43:49The second time, the town said you owe us something, and they
- 43:52built I'm so bad with numbers, but let's call it a million dollar high
- 43:54school in nineteen eighteen ish, and then invested in really good curriculum and instructors.
- 44:02I went to a public private school, a public prep school, and
- 44:08that circumstance that evolved out of who knows where. My mother came back to
- 44:15that town after she was in Washington, d c. During World War two
- 44:20and met my biological father came back to that ton. So we have this
- 44:23incredible education possibility. So might have known regardless. Maybe there's a movie called
- 44:32Northern Northern Exposure, North Country. Yeah, so seris therein Yeah that's my
- 44:40hometown. Oh really, that's my hometown. But Wahbick. But that's the
- 44:44next town over. I could have been her. I could have worked in
- 44:47the minds and gotten all kinds of crap and sexual abuse and sexual harassment.
- 44:52Yeah, that could have been me. And my family had some different circumstances.
- 44:55I'm also white, which is a privilege beyond privileges. There was no
- 45:00question that I could if I wanted to, both with the color of my
- 45:04skin and the genetics that I inherited, there was no question that I could
- 45:09do what I wanted. Yeah, but it's interesting to think about if you
- 45:14hadn't fallen into this career, if you would be as self aware and so
- 45:21quick Because for us, with this type of therapy and mindset and philosophy and
- 45:27personal credo that you and I have, which is similar, we want to
- 45:31be as quick as we can possibly be to recognize our being outside of ourselves,
- 45:39so that when we're in front of our clients, we don't have to
- 45:44take a break and contemplate. We can right then in half a second,
- 45:49as we are empathically listening totally on our game, the back of our mind
- 45:58immediately because it's done it thousands of times, goes, oh, there's that
- 46:01thing. I know, the feeling. I know, you know, I
- 46:05have it all mapped out because I've done it before absolutely, and I can
- 46:09now know what to do with that so that I don't screw things up or
- 46:15harm myself you know, get burnt out or something, but at the very
- 46:17least don't harm the client. So to be able to do that takes tremendous
- 46:22practice and pain and commitment. Yeah, and annoyance. You know, I
- 46:29talked about having been frustrated with your union analysts. I think about A very
- 46:35important time for me was in my twenties when I was, you know,
- 46:38getting very serious about being a client in therapy, and half the time I'd
- 46:45be going to therapy, my hands would be sweating because I'd just be thinking,
- 46:49oh God, I have to face absolutely that side of myself that I'm
- 46:52ashamed of, and I don't like. This isn't going to feel good.
- 46:57I still have dread, Yeah, and might go to my own analysts.
- 47:01Yeah, it's so easy just to mail it in as a client or to
- 47:07say you feel like you're done and you want to take a break. It
- 47:10takes a lot to rise the occasion and push through it without any concrete benefit.
- 47:17You just have to go on faith that it's worth it, you know,
- 47:21and it is. But it's just interesting think like who would have and
- 47:25Blake been if it weren't further Well, here's this. So unions are one
- 47:30of the things we think about is synchronicity, which is more than a coincidence.
- 47:35So it's like, again, it's not somebody pulling the strings from up
- 47:37above, but it is being awake enough to recognize when it happens. So
- 47:43when I was probably in ninth grade some class, Missus Lundine was teaching it.
- 47:49I had three in four incredible female instructors when I was in high school,
- 47:53and I would graduate from high school in sixty two, so this is
- 47:55like a long time ago. And they were all a little bit old.
- 48:00And in high school Miss Scott taught math, which I'm not great at,
- 48:07but I got up to Trigg and she made it possible. And this one
- 48:12teacher, missus lundein there was also a Miss London. Missus Lundeen gave us
- 48:15an assignment of writing about a professional career. And the Mickey Mouse Club was
- 48:22big in those days. And one of the segments was a little Girl and
- 48:27little boy and they were I think it was t w A and they got
- 48:30the little their little uniforms, and of course the girl was an attendant and
- 48:35the boy was a pilot. And so we had to hand in a piece
- 48:38of paper saying what we're going to write on and I said an airline attendant
- 48:44Stewart as we called them in those days, and she wrote she called me
- 48:45up to Jess and said, huh no, you write about a profession.
- 48:50And that flipped me. And so even though yes, I was going to
- 48:53go to college and yeah, my family was my dad said I couldn't go
- 48:58into the service. I don't know where I got that I did. Yeah,
- 49:00but and people were teachers in my family that I didn't pay much attention
- 49:05to. But that shifted my trajectory. So sometimes those again, those things
- 49:12that fall on my path that I'm not expecting. But I paid attention to
- 49:17her. I mean, I sort of I had no choice. I had
- 49:21to do something because she told me too. But there's a message, which
- 49:24is that she believes in you. Yeah, yeah, yeah, And there's
- 49:28nothing wrong with being a Stewart Stewart. And Stewart asked, I know lots
- 49:31of friends who are and they've had great lives. It just wasn't for me.
- 49:37I actually did my paper on journalism, and I didn't become a didn't
- 49:42go into journalism, but I like writing a lot, as you know.
- 49:45And yeah, yeah, and I was always a questioner. So sometimes things
- 49:52just didn't make sense to me, and I've wondered aloud about them, or
- 49:58I certainly wondered inside myself of about that. Yeah. Yeah, I annoyed
- 50:01my family with a lot of questions. Yeah yeah, totally. Yeah.
- 50:07Okay, well let's take a break here. Well let me look at my
- 50:15notes here and see what are we doing with time here? Well, there's
- 50:17no time limit. Okay, let's see. So let me so, so
- 50:22you knowledgeably and empathically and synchronosity came up with that that thing about Okay,
- 50:35write down some things about people you are annoyed buying, people you admire a
- 50:39lot, and so let me so this last thing here, it doesn't have
- 50:45to be the last thing. But again, the good news about this unconscious
- 50:50mechanism, a protective measurement mechanism is by protecting our behaviors and characteristics, projecting
- 50:59sorry projecting our behaviors and characters onto external sources so we export them, means
- 51:05that the information is no longer, at least in that moment, instant situation,
- 51:09unconscious, because I just did something that I can see and other people
- 51:15can see. And again, if I take it seriously enough and I'm invested
- 51:21in trying to figure myself out and being as authentic person as I can be.
- 51:27Then when I go off the grid, it catches my attention. So
- 51:31then it's no longer unconscious, rejected or hidden my unconscious. The information is
- 51:37accessible outside of us, and when we recognize the cues, we are able
- 51:42to get into a conscious process to integrate those personal behaviors and characteristics. So
- 51:47the goal for all therapeutic methods and orientations, theoretical orientations is to bring all
- 51:55of the person into presence. So I think of it as a three dim
- 52:00sphere is what people are. And so the more I integrate all of the
- 52:05pieces into me, the yin Yong I don't tattoo, but if I did,
- 52:12the yennyong is so important to me in terms of number one is a
- 52:15circle rather than a square, and the dividing line is curved rather than straight,
- 52:22and then it's got the dark in the light and the light in the
- 52:25dark. I mean, it's just so fantastic as an image. And so
- 52:30that piece of incorporating all of that into us and knowing all of us have
- 52:37bright and all of us have dark, and there's a dot of the other
- 52:40in each. Yeah, I'm trying to think if I can think of something
- 52:45for myself to walk us through this. I'm trying to think who has annoyed
- 52:50me recently online or in my real and oh well, let's see, being
- 53:00married, there's always something that comes up, right. Oh well, the
- 53:06other day I had my family over for a joint birthday party and I was
- 53:14there. We play this game in my family called Spoons, and it's this
- 53:17fun kind of chaotic card game where when someone gets for of a kind,
- 53:24everyone reaches out for a spoon. It's sort of like music chairs. If
- 53:30you don't have a spoon, then you're out. So it's a fun chaotic
- 53:37yeah, you know, there's a lot of laughing and oh my god,
- 53:39you know. And we were about to play in our dining room and I
- 53:46was removing things from the table so that we could play, and my sister
- 53:52said, oh, do you want to put something down to protect your table?
- 53:58And I had a just a quick thought and into it and thinking,
- 54:04yeah, it'll be fine. I just kind of made this face like,
- 54:06ah, it'll be okay. But you know, there's metal spoons. There's
- 54:08a lot of grabbing and wrestling away of metal things on top of a dining
- 54:15table and it's you know, it's a newer wood and it didn't look like
- 54:19it could really handle that kind of thing. But I don't know. I'm
- 54:22the sort of person that I'm like, look, tables are meant to be
- 54:27lived on, and they're going to get dinged, and you can't live your
- 54:29life constantly worrying about that. I don't really care, and so I just
- 54:34made this old face. And then my wife, Stacy, she said,
- 54:38well you no, no, you should get a tablecloth. And I had
- 54:44this split second of similar to, hey, there's a parking spot of just
- 54:50like and I can't really identify what I was upset about, because it's you
- 54:54know, I got a tablecloth, put it down, and it made it
- 54:58actually out more play. You know, when you got a tablecloth down,
- 55:00it just feels nic served to the touch, you know. And I thought
- 55:06about it later, I you know, I thought like, what is that
- 55:08exactly? And why? I mean, my wife just suggested something that was
- 55:15that was right, you know, it was it was a better option,
- 55:19and I don't care. The tablecloth was you know, three feet away in
- 55:23a drawer and it ended up making things better for everybody. Why was I
- 55:30Why did I get that irk? You know that sort of ugh, don't
- 55:34tell me what to do, or and it's my wife's table too, so
- 55:39yeah, but it's this projection of I don't know, control or nippick or
- 55:49criticism or having to share authority maybe because it's not just my space, it's
- 55:57her space too. Saying it in front of my family could be a thing
- 56:01as well. And then I have to look at the slimy aspect of myself
- 56:07of being controlling or dominant or invasive or critical or humiliating to others in a
- 56:15way, or even caring about things. Because there's a part of it that
- 56:19says it's all right, there's no problem. There's probably another part of you
- 56:23that cares about things right, And maybe you even question how much you care
- 56:29about things right right, like a conflict a complex around caring about possessions or
- 56:37about the longevity of items or something. You know, we all have traumas
- 56:40about that, right. You as a kid will be rambunctious and break a
- 56:46vase in the house or something, Or you're driving your dad's car and you
- 56:54take a corner too fast and run into the curb and break the axle and
- 57:04flatten the tire, you know, to just name a random example and then
- 57:10to be and you know, my parents were nice enough about it, but
- 57:16the worry, probably the worry before getting home that day was bigger than the
- 57:23actual you know, consequence, but that feeling of wait, so I'm irresponsible
- 57:30and I don't want people to hold me to those standards or I want to
- 57:36be flip it and free from those kinds of demands, you know, And
- 57:40come to think of it, like I do kind of have a complex around
- 57:43that. Like when people in my life will break something, or a guest
- 57:49in my house will damage something, I am like, militantly it's okay.
- 57:54It's just a thing. Like I'll have thoughts like I'll be having a part
- 58:00or something that people be coming over and I'll have a thought like, oh,
- 58:02maybe I should move that thing so it doesn't get hurt, and I'm
- 58:06like, no, no, no. If if my friend's kid breaks that
- 58:08thing, you need to be front and center and say it's fine, it's
- 58:14just an object. I don't care. So there's going out to this kind
- 58:19of those tales, right, I'm trying to like really plan ahead and compensate,
- 58:23so, you know, so this probably has to do with that.
- 58:28So there's a lot of branching out. It's not just my wife's saying get
- 58:32up tablecloth. It's it's a lot of aspects of who I am. That's
- 58:37how complicated we are as organized. It's amazing that we learn how to control
- 58:42our bladder and our rectum, and that we can walk and talk and feed
- 58:45ourselves. That's amazing. Yeah, given all the complexity of our childhood's even
- 58:52the ones that are good enough, yeah, let alone the ones that aren't
- 58:54good enough. Right, So I really respect and admire and I'm grateful for
- 58:59you're also looking at yourself. And again it's such a good example Kirk of
- 59:04the again the branches. I think about the E M d R, not
- 59:12them, Yeah, am DR. The eye movement reprocessing in which they talk
- 59:17about the railroad center house that has railroad lines going off in all directions,
- 59:23and they moved the cars around and put them in that in another direction.
- 59:28And that's what happened for you. And the key there was I forgot it
- 59:31now, something about on second thought or on you had some phrase that went
- 59:37oops, there we go. Yeah. Yeah, I was like, actually,
- 59:39come to think of it, that's that was it. Come to think
- 59:42of it, Come to think of it, that then we go, okay,
- 59:44here we are. Yeah, and then the connections happen, and the
- 59:47connections happen and the synapses fire and right, yeah, yeah, And I
- 59:52had really gone down that road even five percent as I did just and it's
- 1:00:00illuminating exactly, and it's a calming and so like when we were talking earlier
- 1:00:07in terms of when something I'm in a therapy session where a client that something
- 1:00:10happens in me and awareness could be an image passing through my mind, it
- 1:00:14could be a tightening in my body, could certainly be an affect of feeling.
- 1:00:19And I say, oh, that's mine, and I'm going to process
- 1:00:22more of that later. And then I offer it out as a hypothesis.
- 1:00:25Is it something like this for you? My system clears I'm done with that.
- 1:00:30I still have to process my stuff. But once I metabolize it and
- 1:00:34offer it as a hypothesis, then and I'm also not invested in am I
- 1:00:38right? Is this the right thing? Because clients will either say, oh,
- 1:00:45yeah, some version, or they'll say in some way or other,
- 1:00:49not yet, I'm not ready to do that yet, or I'll just be
- 1:00:52wrong. But once I metabolize my own I don't have an investment in being
- 1:00:59right right, so they can do what they need to do in that moment.
- 1:01:02You're not tied to it. Yeah, so there's a freeingness to metabolizing.
- 1:01:09Yeah, it feels scary as you step into the unknown, but ye,
- 1:01:17it is so much freeing to I don't know, you know, we
- 1:01:22could talk about these feeling that you have when you unearth things, or when
- 1:01:28you get your hands on something, or when you just admit that you're a
- 1:01:31human being and that it's okay and someone hears you and doesn't immediately shame you
- 1:01:39for it. It's like, oh, okay, so this thing I was
- 1:01:43trying to protect isn't so bad after all. Yeah, we're smiling warmly at
- 1:01:46each other. Well, so is that your stick of today that you have?
- 1:01:54Well, I got one more thing to add in terms of what you
- 1:01:57were just talking about. When I was teaching it full time at Antioch,
- 1:02:00a colleague was out for a conference. She was teaching communication and counseling skills
- 1:02:06and asked me would I step in and substitute for Of course we did that,
- 1:02:09and so this one was about confrontations like these students don't know me.
- 1:02:14It's three quarters way through the quarter, I'm going to come in the stranger
- 1:02:17and talk about confrontation. And so it took a while for someone to volunteer
- 1:02:22because we do role playing. I'm going to be the clinician. They're going
- 1:02:24to be the client. And so some brave soul came up and said something
- 1:02:30and I was struck as though something had hit me in the chest, some
- 1:02:36energy hit me in the chest. And I said to myself, you have
- 1:02:38to say something right now. And I said, but I don't want to,
- 1:02:44and I said, but you have to, And then I know I
- 1:02:46said something. It wasn't It wasn't. It was just innocuous. But it
- 1:02:52was just like so energetic and so real and so true this thing that this
- 1:02:57person had said. So it was a big deal that what I had to
- 1:03:02say. But to launch into that intimate space really took some courage to do
- 1:03:07that, and that's what we do as human beings every day to go it
- 1:03:14went really well, did you self disclose about it? No, it was
- 1:03:17in response to what the person said, so some empathic connecting. Was it
- 1:03:23a confrontational thing that you said? No, well, I mean everything is
- 1:03:28a confrontation. So the confrontation has a bad rap of something negative. It's
- 1:03:32just feedback, And so I said something in a responsibility, but what the
- 1:03:37person said was so powerful that I had to show up and say something in
- 1:03:43kind. In terms of validating and right, you can confront through empathy by
- 1:03:49saying yes, any response like wow, that sounds really rough, it's a
- 1:03:53confrontation because it would perhaps stretch them beyond their typical pattern of over it or
- 1:04:00not feeling their feelings. Yeah, and this is the best profession, the
- 1:04:06least boring profession. It's always a mystery. It's always something new. More
- 1:04:13often than not, when we hear something, we've heard something like it before.
- 1:04:17But every once in a while it's something that I have never heard this
- 1:04:20before. And that honor that somebody shares something with us that they've never told
- 1:04:29another human being is just mind blowing. It's humbling. Yeah. Yeah,
- 1:04:33and it's so precious. Yeah. Yeah, the amount of stories that we
- 1:04:40could tell, particularly you, you've been in the field a long time.
- 1:04:44I'm a lot older than you are, fifty years, fifty plus years in
- 1:04:47the field. Let's see. I graduated from grad school in eighty three,
- 1:04:53so forty years, yeah, forty years. Yeah. I got into therapy
- 1:04:57the first time when I was twenty six, So long ago and so valuable
- 1:05:01every moment of it. Well, and it was great to chat with you,
- 1:05:05Abe. And at seventy nine, your my parents' age, were you
- 1:05:12young? Were you young for your class because I was. My dad graduated
- 1:05:17in sixty two. Well, one of my parents graduated sixty two and they're
- 1:05:23both older than you. Yeah, I was. I started school early by
- 1:05:27a year exactly for you at seventy nine. Still I can tell sharpest attack.
- 1:05:34You haven't lost a step to have a full practice three days a week
- 1:05:40and that's not full well, it's pretty still like three eight hour days or
- 1:05:45six hour days, six hour days, okay, Still, that's that's you
- 1:05:49know, that's for many, that's a full time practice. Yeah. Yeah,
- 1:05:55I certainly can pay the bills with that, and then you have your
- 1:05:57supervision in that, in that in that okay, and that you know you're
- 1:06:02still going strong and still enjoying it absolutely, or I wouldn't do it because
- 1:06:08I I could have stopped a long time ago. But yeah, no reason
- 1:06:13to. Yeah, yeah, I think about that for myself. People talk
- 1:06:15about retirement. My accountant started asking me questions about it, and I'm starting
- 1:06:20to get the double ARP letters, and I think I don't know, I
- 1:06:27don't know if I would want to. Maybe i'd slow down, but I
- 1:06:30don't think I would want to be doing much of anything else. Yeah,
- 1:06:34I mean, you know, there's other maybe vacations that you want to go
- 1:06:39on or projects or whatever. But but I'm definitely I would. I would
- 1:06:45definitely miss it. So absolutely, whether it's clinical work or podcasting, I
- 1:06:50don't see myself. So it's just nice to see how long have you been
- 1:06:54doing this? Just over fifteen years? That's great. It's a real service
- 1:07:00to the community. Kirk. I've students supervised in some students and one of
- 1:07:04them said that she knew me before we got connected as supervisor sup supervisor because
- 1:07:12she'd heard the podcast. Oh really, Yeah, you also had another topic
- 1:07:15you want to get to at a different time. Didn't we talk about this
- 1:07:17at Jersey? So there's this thing that I discovered in a workshop. I'm
- 1:07:21in twenty nineteen, I went to a two day workshop about sexism and racism
- 1:07:30for white women and an organization here in town. And in that time they
- 1:07:39asked us to begin a poem called I'm from and minus five pages by now
- 1:07:45I like to write and I like to express, and that's a lot of
- 1:07:48pages for a poem, and it's a fascinating, wonderful and it would be
- 1:07:55interesting to talk about here because usually it's in a workshop and people are writing
- 1:07:58and then they give feedback back and forth. So it's probably not a long
- 1:08:01conversation. All you and I do long conversations, which is wonderful and great
- 1:08:05and lovely. But we could easily talk about that. Yeah, ok,
- 1:08:10yeah, so we'll have to be back lovely format. I would love to
- 1:08:13come. Yeah. I mean all my regular co hosts are my best friends,
- 1:08:18yes, before they were on the podcast. So you know, you
- 1:08:24get older and it's harder to schedule to get together, and it's a good
- 1:08:29opportunity for that. And I don't get opportunities like today to nerd out on
- 1:08:36psychoanalytic and union psychology stuff. It's something that I think about and talk about,
- 1:08:43but I don't have anyone like Rebecca Bloom, who you know absolutely and
- 1:08:49Bob gott All and other colleague friend of mine are neither of them are really
- 1:08:55oriented in this. I mean, Rebecca will say that she's union to some
- 1:08:58extent, but she's steeped in all this technical language stuff, the way that
- 1:09:03you and I are, so it's there's an opportunity to talk about well.
- 1:09:10So at the end of every episode, I say, take care of yourself
- 1:09:13because you deserve it so but but I'll let you finish why people, So
- 1:09:17everyone out there, that's the end of the episode, and please take care
- 1:09:21of yourself. And why should people take care of themselves? Because it's good
- 1:09:26for all of us. It's good to feel authentic and real and whole.
- 1:09:30It is and I have little tears starting, Oh why, because it's just
- 1:09:35so yummy and wonderful and touching and intimate and right yeah,