Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Ethical Calendaring: Protecting Clients, Cases, and Your Practice with Annie L. Thompson
Transcript
- 0:05Hi, I'm Dean Sirwin. I am the chair of the Beverly
- 0:09Hills Bar's law practice management and wellness
- 0:12section. We're presenting this panel today or
- 0:16this program. It's not really a panel. And I've
- 0:19got a little bit of housekeeping. As you can
- 0:22see in the chat, there's some notices going up.
- 0:25This is part of the Beverly Hills Bar's on -demand
- 0:29program. So this program will, within 24 hours
- 0:33or so, the recording will be available. on the
- 0:36BHB on demand. It's a fantastic program. If you
- 0:40haven't been utilizing it, please do. It makes
- 0:42your MCLE compliance literally a snap. It took
- 0:46me about two minutes last time because I'd gone
- 0:49to, I'd done enough of these programs. They're
- 0:52all right there in a locker. You do a couple
- 0:54of clicks and you're done. It has all the harder
- 0:58to get programs and there are new interesting,
- 1:03exciting programs as opposed to things that are
- 1:0610, 20 years old, like some of the, you know,
- 1:08get everything for $75 systems. So I encourage
- 1:12you to check it out, tell your friends about
- 1:14it. And if there's something in here that you
- 1:18wanted to, you know, refresh, you can go back
- 1:21and watch it yourself. Anyway. Now on to a little
- 1:27bit more housekeeping. As you see in the chat,
- 1:30there are some materials. Those are available
- 1:32in the chat. They'll get reposted a few times.
- 1:36This is a webinar. So instead of being able to
- 1:40directly communicate with Annie, she will be
- 1:44presenting. There is a Q &A button though down
- 1:48at the bottom. So you can. At least I believe
- 1:51there is. There was before. I'm not seeing it
- 1:54right now. So you can post any questions. You
- 1:58can't chat directly with her, but at the end,
- 2:02there will be a Q &A section and someone from
- 2:05the Little Hills Bar will be monitoring that
- 2:07to answer anything that the bar can answer for
- 2:11you like, hey, where are the materials kinds
- 2:12of things. So anyway, let's introduce you to
- 2:15Anne L. Thompson. She's the Chief Claims Officer
- 2:18for Lawyers Mutual Insurance Company, who is
- 2:21a co -sponsor with us of the BHBA On Demand Program.
- 2:25They've provided professional liability insurance
- 2:29to California lawyers since 1978. She oversees
- 2:32the claims department, managing litigation strategy,
- 2:35legal analysis, and coverage evaluations. Ms.
- 2:38Thompson also assists policyholders with ethical
- 2:41concerns and participates in mediation and settlement
- 2:44negotiations. We're very excited to have her
- 2:48here presenting this program, ethical calendaring,
- 2:51protecting clients, cases. and most importantly,
- 2:55your practice. So with that, I'm going to go
- 2:58off camera and say, take it away, Annie. Well,
- 3:02thank you, Dean, for that introduction. Yes,
- 3:05I'm Annie Thompson, and I'm the Chief Claims
- 3:08Officer of Lawyers Mutual and also a certified
- 3:12legal malpractice specialist in the state of
- 3:16California, of which there are approximately
- 3:18100 of us, and that's about it. I am also, along
- 3:26with my very talented team at Lawyers Mutual,
- 3:29I answer a hotline, which is where our members
- 3:34can call in about best practices for how to handle
- 3:38things like disengagements, conflicts, things
- 3:41like that, as well as an interesting topic that
- 3:45does come up, which is calendaring. It's overlooked.
- 3:47It doesn't feel particularly Exciting, but hopefully
- 3:51we will get through the seminar with you learning
- 3:54some good practical tips about calendaring. If
- 4:00you've ever seen me speak, this program is going
- 4:03to be a little bit different. I'd like it to
- 4:05be a little more conversational. I welcome the
- 4:08Q &A and I'm going to talk about various topics,
- 4:12but what I'm going to do is I'm going to veer
- 4:14off into my sort of best practices slash hotline.
- 4:18practical advice based upon things that I have
- 4:21seen in 25 years of defending lawyers. I originally
- 4:25was a litigator defending lawyers in legal malpractice
- 4:28actions for 10 years before I went in -house
- 4:3215 years ago as a claims attorney with Lawyers
- 4:35Mutual. And now, like Dean said, I oversee the
- 4:39department. So again, if you have any questions,
- 4:42feel free to interrupt in the presentation as
- 4:45someone else may have that same question. or
- 4:47I will save time at the end. So thank you for
- 4:52joining me. In the next hour, we're going to
- 4:55explore a critical but overlooked aspect of legal
- 4:59practice, which is calendaring. Specifically,
- 5:02we're going to delve into the importance of calendaring
- 5:04for California lawyers, the ethical obligations
- 5:08associated with it, the potential consequences
- 5:11of failing to implement an effective calendaring
- 5:13system. and the tools available to you to ensure
- 5:17compliance and efficiency. And I'm going to start
- 5:20with a little bit of a history lesson as to sort
- 5:23of how we got here and where we're going. So
- 5:26California became a state in the 1850s. By 1872,
- 5:30we already had the California Code of Civil Procedure.
- 5:35It was not formalized in the way that it is now.
- 5:38So we based our California system after English
- 5:42common law, and everything was primarily handled
- 5:46manual calendaring with clerks maintaining handwritten
- 5:50dockets and ledgers, and the court proceedings
- 5:53and deadlines were in the physical log books.
- 5:56And thereafter, in the 1900s, the growth of the
- 5:59court system, the volume of legal cases increased
- 6:03necessitated organized calendaring systems, and
- 6:07organization is going to be kind of a, you know,
- 6:11a throughfare in this presentation. So then we
- 6:17had these paper -based systems, including printed
- 6:20calendars, and they became standard for scheduling
- 6:23hearings, trials, and deadlines. What the courts
- 6:26did is they used term calendars where cases were
- 6:29set for certain terms, and that led to greater
- 6:32consistency. consistency, again, is going to
- 6:35be a thoroughfare of this presentation because
- 6:39it is going to be critical to your practice.
- 6:44And then in the 50s and 60s, the CCP finally
- 6:49gave us a system of structured rules for deadlines,
- 6:55filings, hearings. There were statutory rules
- 6:58that formalized response deadlines for pleadings,
- 7:02motions, and appeals. and the law firms were
- 7:04still relying on paper for that. But I'm guessing
- 7:09that's when legal malpractice actions probably
- 7:11started as well because the formalization of
- 7:15the CCP and the rules led to a more uniform guide
- 7:21for lawyers to follow and deadlines that were
- 7:27meaningful and practical and consequential. And
- 7:30then in the 80s, when we got our computers, the
- 7:34first digital calendaring systems came. And this
- 7:37is, I'm talking about calendaring today, but
- 7:39ultimately I'm gonna end up talking about digital
- 7:42calendaring. A lot of people I know are still
- 7:45in paper calendars and maybe have another paper
- 7:50backup, but I'm going to encourage you today
- 7:53that best practice is going to have electronic
- 7:56calendaring and I'm gonna share with you why.
- 8:00So law firms started using the early case management
- 8:03systems in the late 90s and that introduced digital
- 8:08docketing systems. And then in the 2000s we got
- 8:12e -filing and then the case management systems
- 8:14became widely used. I highly recommend them.
- 8:18I don't have a particular provider that I would
- 8:23track you to, but a lot of law firms are using
- 8:26Clio, My Case, practice panther and that implements
- 8:30electronic case access as well as calendaring
- 8:34uh completion and and collaboration with your
- 8:38case management software the case management
- 8:41software really can um you make your practice
- 8:46uniform in the sense that you can track your
- 8:50trial that you can input your trial date and
- 8:52it will populate and your venue and it will populate
- 8:55all the deadlines, you know, with a formula that
- 8:59is a lot less room for human error. Footnote
- 9:02to that on the best practices is you have to
- 9:05vet your vendors, you have to make sure they're
- 9:07updating regularly with the legislation. Like,
- 9:11I don't know if Clio, my case, and Practice Panther
- 9:14have implemented the new rules on the timing
- 9:18for motions for summary judgment in California.
- 9:21That obligation lies with you. So there's going
- 9:25to be a lot about sort of non -delicable duties
- 9:28on calendaring that I'm going to talk about.
- 9:32The interesting thing also is that this talk
- 9:34may become irrelevant in 10 years because AI
- 9:38is already generating calendaring tools to assist
- 9:42attorneys with deadline calculations and compliance,
- 9:46integrating with court rules databases to ensure
- 9:49automatic updates when laws change. And there's
- 9:53also a push for statewide uniform electronic
- 9:56calendaring aiming to streamline scheduling across
- 9:59counties. So we are not there yet, but I think
- 10:03we will be very soon. So now that we've completed
- 10:08our history lesson, the landscape in California
- 10:11now is that we have heavy, heavy caseloads of
- 10:15increasing complexity. and the court has adopted
- 10:18e -filing and other digital processes to make
- 10:21these things a lot easier and have a lot less
- 10:23room for error. If you have not yet implemented
- 10:29any electronic calendaring system and you are
- 10:33using paper calendars, there are a lot of benefits
- 10:38and sometimes people need to be motivated. by
- 10:42benefits in a win -win situation. And there's
- 10:45really three things that I have selected as the
- 10:48reasons why. I'll list them and then I'll go
- 10:52through the reasons and then I'll give you some
- 10:57real life reasons why this matters or should
- 11:00matter to you. Efficiency and productivity is
- 11:05a benefit of electronic calendaring. Accuracy
- 11:08and reliability. and client service. Those are
- 11:12the three main topics that I've identified as
- 11:15the benefits of electronic calendaring. Now,
- 11:18going through them individually, efficiency and
- 11:22productivity, automatic reminders for critical
- 11:25deadlines, court dates, and client meetings.
- 11:29I'm going to talk about client meetings in a
- 11:30second and how calendaring goes. And the integration
- 11:34with other tools like your document management
- 11:37system. which is going to lead me off course
- 11:39a little bit to you need to look at CRPC 1 .6
- 11:45about keeping client data secure. Your calendaring
- 11:50system and your CMS systems need to be secure.
- 11:56It implicates rule 1 .6 of the rules of professional
- 11:59conduct. You as a fiduciary have an obligation
- 12:04to safeguard all of your client's information.
- 12:07So when it comes to those case management document
- 12:11systems, there's some homework to do, which we
- 12:14will get to, and I have a checklist for you as
- 12:17well on that. Another benefit is accuracy and
- 12:22reliability. The human error in penciling and
- 12:26erasing in your black day planner that many of
- 12:31us have, if you're over the age of 40. We had
- 12:37the black day planners that we wrote everything
- 12:40in, and there's a lot of room for human error.
- 12:43This reduces human error in tracking statutes
- 12:47of limitation and court deadlines, and it synchronizes
- 12:50across, it can, has the ability to synchronize
- 12:53across devices to ensure access anywhere, anytime.
- 12:57My calendar is here. My calendar is here. My
- 13:00calendar is in the computer. It's in the cloud.
- 13:03I have three different calendar systems. Outlook
- 13:07calendar I have Google calendar. I have an app
- 13:09called one calendar They are all integrated if
- 13:12any one of them fails I still have access to
- 13:14all my information in the cloud and I'm not a
- 13:17litigator and I will tell you that I think the
- 13:21reason I was asked by Beverly Hills bar to do
- 13:25This program is because this is what my calendar
- 13:28looks like This is how I stay efficient. It is
- 13:31color -coded It is filled in with all sorts of
- 13:35information. And while it may give some people
- 13:38anxiety, it allows for a lot of accountability.
- 13:43So talking about accuracy and reliability on
- 13:47statutes of limitations and court deadlines,
- 13:50I'm going to veer off into do not wait until
- 13:53the last day. to calendar your statute of limitations.
- 13:58This is sort of my practical advice, my hotline
- 14:00advice here is I have seen so many claims come
- 14:04in because someone strategically or because of
- 14:08the way they calendar filed too late because
- 14:12they calendared one day late and or on the last
- 14:16day and one of the you know parade of horribles
- 14:19happened and it didn't get filed. There is absolutely
- 14:23No strategic reason that I can think of that
- 14:27outweighs the risk that you've calculated incorrectly.
- 14:31Add that cushion. We have seen that far too many
- 14:35times where it's one day late, one day early,
- 14:39there's reliance on documents that have confusion.
- 14:44Always calculate the earliest possible date and
- 14:47then add time to that. I've seen lawyers that
- 14:50have had cases come in you know, a two -year
- 14:53personal injury, statute of limitations, they
- 14:56get right after the accident, they get the case,
- 14:58and then they wait two years to file. Sometimes
- 15:01I understand they're still treating, you want
- 15:03things like that. File anyway. If you need to
- 15:06toll afterwards for continued treatment, if you
- 15:10need to stay the case, do that, but do not wait
- 15:13until the last day to file. Calendar a month
- 15:17before, six months before, whatever it is. And
- 15:21as far as calendaring goes also, that also means
- 15:23make sure your calendaring and your CMS system,
- 15:26if it's a partial injury case, you know, accounts
- 15:29for, you know, if you have other pre -filing
- 15:31obligations like a government tort claim or something
- 15:34like that. So that's the reducing human error
- 15:38in tracking deadlines is you can input that and
- 15:43your electronic based system will. greatly guide
- 15:48you in doing that. But my practical tip is not
- 15:52to wait till the last day, even if your electronic
- 15:54system tells you this is the day, because I'll
- 15:57go through some more stories in a bit to show
- 16:00you exactly how this can backfire. And then the
- 16:04last benefit of electronic calendaring systems
- 16:07that I mentioned is client service. Timely updates
- 16:13and proactive communication with your clients,
- 16:19and enhanced transparency in managing deadlines.
- 16:22I believe no matter what your practice area is,
- 16:25you should be calendaring regular client updates.
- 16:29It does not matter if you are contingency, hourly,
- 16:34or doing defense work. How you handle a client
- 16:38and how you communicate with a client honestly
- 16:41dictates how your relationship will go. how it
- 16:45will end. It avoids conflicts in the middle of
- 16:48the case because the duty of communication of
- 16:52rule 1 .4, you have a duty to communicate all
- 16:56relevant details to your client. As lawyers,
- 16:59as busy lawyers, there's a lot of dormant times
- 17:02sometimes, and clients don't necessarily realize
- 17:06that if you've gotten their case resolved in
- 17:09three years, you're basically a hero. But Clients
- 17:13still need to be communicated with. Most of them
- 17:15are lay people, depending on your practice. Calendar
- 17:2030 -day updates. Dear so -and -so, you know,
- 17:23the past 30 days I've been in a discovery battle.
- 17:25I don't have any documents yet, but I will provide
- 17:28you an update as to the impact and meaning of
- 17:31the documents as they apply to damages as soon
- 17:35as I get them. Clients want communication. And
- 17:39so in addition to cowering deadlines, you should
- 17:42be calendaring client meetings. If you're contingent,
- 17:46you have a nervous client who doesn't really
- 17:49know the legal system and you have a duty to
- 17:52educate them of the material things going on.
- 17:55If you are hourly in a plaintiff's case or a
- 18:00defense case and you're billing clients, they're
- 18:03entitled to know what the... outcome or consequence
- 18:09of what you've been doing. If you're sending
- 18:11a bill, you also need to be sending a letter
- 18:14indicating what that work revealed, how it impacts
- 18:21the case, whether it was beneficial or detrimental
- 18:23to the case. And I'll talk a little bit about
- 18:27later about, you know, if you do make a mistake
- 18:30or a calendaring error, all of this communication.
- 18:35can lead to a healthier resolution that avoids
- 18:40malpractice claims. A quick example on the statute
- 18:46of limitations and not waiting until the last
- 18:49day. We had a claim that just came in where the
- 18:52client put the wrong date of injury on the intake
- 18:57form. The lawyer relied on it. The lawyer had
- 19:01documents, hadn't gone through the documents
- 19:03because they calendar the statute of limitations
- 19:06date based on client intake information. All
- 19:09the documents had a different date that was earlier.
- 19:12And it's going to be, can be hard to defend a
- 19:17case where you've had the documents and haven't
- 19:20looked at them because you've calendared a date
- 19:23the day before it's due to be filed. So there
- 19:27are a lot of risks in that. I've taken up a lot
- 19:31of time on that, but I think that it is it's
- 19:34critically important that and also if you are
- 19:38regularly calendaring updates to your client
- 19:41even pre lit Then you're going to continue to
- 19:46be reminded as to what the statute of limitations
- 19:48is if you're continually communicating with your
- 19:51client Which is can be onerous depending on your
- 19:54caseload, but can you know be? highly beneficial
- 19:59down the road if you are ever sued for legal
- 20:02malpractice. So we'll talk about that as well.
- 20:05So calendaring is not just about managing appointments.
- 20:08It's about safeguarding the rights and interests
- 20:10of your clients, maintaining professional integrity,
- 20:14and ensuring compliance with legal deadlines.
- 20:18The practice of law is very deadline -driven,
- 20:21whether it's filing a motion, responding to discovery,
- 20:25or appearing at a hearing, missing a single deadline
- 20:28can have big consequences for your client and
- 20:31your practice. So missing a deadline, dismissal
- 20:36of a case, sanctions, other adverse rulings,
- 20:39they harm your client. So the real life consequence
- 20:44of that is a lot of times, you know, it's a delay,
- 20:48but a delay doesn't make the client happy and
- 20:51can result in you getting substituted out. Sanctions
- 20:55against you or your client can create a conflict
- 20:57and obviously a financial burden. Adverse rulings
- 21:02for which you have not notified the client of
- 21:05the possible risks of also can put you at risk
- 21:08for malpractice and ethical violations. So the
- 21:13reality of that is, you know, you miss a deadline.
- 21:16The client still has a lot of hopes to jump through.
- 21:19And I do want to share that with you that missing
- 21:21a deadline isn't the end of the world. I'm going
- 21:25to walk you through how to disclose that later
- 21:28on. But what the practical thing that happens
- 21:32and I'll use, you know, an auto accident as the
- 21:35easiest example is, you know, if you fail to
- 21:39file on time, that doesn't mean necessarily that
- 21:42anybody has a great malpractice case. It all
- 21:45depends on what the value was of the underlying
- 21:47case. So the client still has to jump through
- 21:49the hoops of proving not only duty breach causation
- 21:54and damage against you, but the case within the
- 21:57case, which means they have to litigate the underlying
- 22:00case and they can have a million dollars worth
- 22:02of injuries. But if the underlying defendant
- 22:05was uncollectible, but for a $15 ,000 auto policy,
- 22:12those are the damages. So, but we're fiduciaries.
- 22:16We don't want our clients to have to jump through
- 22:18those hoops. We're not here to to screw them
- 22:23in any way, and we're not here to do our jobs
- 22:26improperly. We are here to make those deadlines,
- 22:30argue these cases, and get them to conclusion
- 22:33with a good client relationship. So one of the
- 22:45things that I'm going to talk about because this
- 22:48is an ethics presentation, is what the rules
- 22:51of professional conduct that mandate competence
- 22:55and diligence, how they apply and why they should
- 23:00be important to you. And the other thing I'm
- 23:04going to talk quite a bit about is your professional
- 23:06reputation. Consistently meeting deadlines fosters
- 23:10trust among clients, colleagues, and enhances
- 23:14your professional reputation. A lawyer that repeatedly
- 23:17misses deadlines is going to miss out on referrals.
- 23:20A lawyer that is not communicating with their
- 23:23clients is going to miss out on client referrals.
- 23:29Communication and calendaring that communication
- 23:33in electronic format so that you have time specifically
- 23:36set aside, meeting with so -and -so, call with
- 23:40so -and -so. Clients want to be touched. They
- 23:43want to know exactly what's happening. If you
- 23:46have one of those clients that says only contact
- 23:48me with something, you know, when you need me
- 23:50to make a decision, fine. Most clients are not
- 23:53like that. And if you ignore the client because
- 23:56nothing's going on, that leads to a lot of distrust.
- 24:00And I see that a lot. And the lawyer's defense
- 24:02is, you know, there was nothing going on. I was
- 24:05in a discovery war. I have no documents. And,
- 24:09you know, the court hasn't set us for a hearing
- 24:11for six months out. Well, the client still wants
- 24:13to hear that, and you should be calendaring all
- 24:16of those things. And your professional reputation,
- 24:20if you're consistently missing deadlines with,
- 24:23you know, the bench and the bar, is not something
- 24:26that you want to be known for. So going through,
- 24:31you know, the key ethical rules for lawyers,
- 24:35and the most important one is rule 1 .1, which
- 24:39is competence, requiring the legal knowledge,
- 24:43skill, thoroughness, and preparation reasonably
- 24:46necessary for representation. The key here is
- 24:52as of March 22nd, 2021, the California Supreme
- 24:57Court altered rule 1 .1 of the CRPC and changed
- 25:03not the text, but added language in comment one.
- 25:08And it says the duties set forth in this rule
- 25:11include the duty to keep abreast of the changes
- 25:14in the law and its practice, including the benefits
- 25:18and risks associated with relevant technology,
- 25:21which is why I'm here saying your old paper calendars
- 25:25may have been good enough before, but I don't
- 25:27think they're good enough now. And you don't
- 25:31have to necessarily invest in the most. I mean,
- 25:36if you're a solo practitioner, you can do things
- 25:40through Outlook and Google Calendar. You don't
- 25:44have to necessarily make a big investment, but
- 25:47I will share with you that the investment pays
- 25:49off. The other rules that apply equally are diligence.
- 25:58Failing to act with reasonable diligence in representing
- 26:01a client is a violation of the California rules
- 26:06of professional conduct. Again, this is an ethical
- 26:09issue failing to act with competence includes,
- 26:12you know the deal I mean with diligence Diligence
- 26:17and competence go hand -in -hand being a diligent
- 26:20lawyer means being a communicative lawyer being
- 26:23a communicative lawyer means Carving out the
- 26:27time to communicate with your client with regularity
- 26:30so that they are sufficiently informed Which
- 26:33then brings us to rule 1 .4 communication? ensuring
- 26:38clients are informed about significant developments.
- 26:41And this is really the rule that I think actually
- 26:44should inspire lawyers to use their calendaring
- 26:50systems to their benefit. It makes you a better
- 26:53lawyer if you are continually making sure that
- 26:58your clients are satisfied with your representation.
- 27:01A client will not be upset if nothing is going
- 27:03on, but a client will be upset if nothing's going
- 27:06on and they've left three phone calls and messages
- 27:09that you have ignored. Which again, I'm laying
- 27:14the groundwork for a landscape in which you may
- 27:18have to disclose a calendaring or other error.
- 27:22So again, this bedside manner in communication
- 27:25and utilizing calendaring for communication.
- 27:29Again will make you a better lawyer with a better
- 27:32reputation and more referrals and more client
- 27:36satisfaction I talked a little bit about rule
- 27:401 .6 again. This is an ethics presentation. So
- 27:44I'm going to present you with all the ethical
- 27:46rules that apply to this when you Collaborate
- 27:51your case management system in your calendar
- 27:54system. I also recommend that you have another
- 27:57system as well for just your calendaring because
- 28:01your CMS system is great and it's probably going
- 28:03to give you the most accurate information, but
- 28:06you also need to make sure that you have something
- 28:10else that if anything happens to that CMS and
- 28:14it goes down, that you have not lost your calendar
- 28:18and your schedule of when things either need
- 28:22to be filed, whether you have meetings coming
- 28:24up, court appearances. case management conference,
- 28:28mediation, mandatory settlement conference, all
- 28:31those things, you still need to know when they're
- 28:34going to occur. So backups to backups to backups
- 28:38are really the key on this, and it seems onerous,
- 28:41and your, you know, your black, you know, daily
- 28:44planner may have served you well for a long time,
- 28:47but when that gets stolen from the front seat
- 28:49of your car, you're in trouble. So when you integrate
- 28:56also make sure, and I have a checklist at the
- 29:00end and we're gonna talk about how to evaluate
- 29:03features and vet vendors a bit, but you do have
- 29:09the ultimate task of making sure that your client's
- 29:14confidential information is safeguarded. And
- 29:19then the last rule, which I think is as important
- 29:24as, you know, the competence rule and the new
- 29:26addition to it is rule 5 .3. Again, this is an
- 29:33ethics presentation, and I'm going to go through
- 29:35all the rules that could conceivably apply to
- 29:41calendaring. And this is responsibilities regarding
- 29:44non -lawyer assistance. And this is a big deal.
- 29:47because a lawyer shall make reasonable efforts
- 29:50to ensure that the person's conduct is compatible
- 29:53with the professional obligations of the lawyer
- 29:55and the lawyer is responsible for the conduct
- 29:58of that person. If you delegate your calendaring,
- 30:04you need to have double confirmation systems
- 30:06in place. I saw a case where a lawyer communicated
- 30:13to his assistant These are the, you know, please
- 30:19calendar these dates. Well, the assistant writes
- 30:21back and says, one of these dates is a Saturday.
- 30:23I think you have it wrong. And the attorney never
- 30:26responds and the date never gets calendared.
- 30:29Nobody follows up. So there needs to be protocols.
- 30:33Again, that's the lifeline through all of this
- 30:36is protocols and consistency. And everyone's
- 30:40buying in on technology. Everybody knows how
- 30:42to do it, what their job is. But if you are emailing
- 30:46your assistant to calendar a date, it's your
- 30:49job to double check that that date is in there
- 30:52and is accurate. Again, that's where the human
- 30:56error component comes in. And everything lays
- 30:59at your doorstep. So you cannot say, and we've
- 31:05seen this happen before, we've seen assistants
- 31:08who've basically just sort of given up, who have
- 31:13Old school ticklers that they just haven't given
- 31:16the lawyer to file. That's why that doesn't work
- 31:19anymore. So you really need a lot of redundancy
- 31:24in this department. But again, it makes you a
- 31:27better lawyer with a better reputation. And if
- 31:31you have calendar entries for each client, even
- 31:35pre litigation, you minimize this risk. If you
- 31:38are in communication with your clients regularly.
- 31:42pursuant to rule 1 .4, you are going to minimize
- 31:46the risk of missing deadlines because you're
- 31:48gonna be in communication with your clients regularly.
- 31:55Okay, so what are the risks of noncompliance?
- 31:59Missed deadlines lead to malpractice claims.
- 32:01We've talked about that. Yes, your client has
- 32:04hurdles and the legal malpractice law in California
- 32:06is very defense -friendly. Again, we don't. want
- 32:10to put our clients through that. Generally, we
- 32:12want to do the best work we can as fiduciaries.
- 32:16And as fiduciaries, you are subject to disciplinary
- 32:21action. And the state bar, I can tell you, is
- 32:25not super interested in I miss the statute of
- 32:29limitations. They'll say this is for the civil
- 32:32courts. If you repeatedly and recklessly Miss
- 32:36deadlines, even on a single case, if you miss
- 32:39an opposition date, if you miss a court date,
- 32:42you miss all these things. This is a great example
- 32:45of a case that maybe there's time to get a new
- 32:48lawyer and maybe it's all fixable and maybe it
- 32:51had no legal consequence to the underlying case.
- 32:56The state bar will care about that and you could
- 32:58end up on the receiving end of disciplinary charges.
- 33:01So that goes both ways. There are certain things
- 33:04that will lead to your breach of duty to the
- 33:07client can lead to damages, but not a state bar
- 33:12complaint. And then there are situations where
- 33:15there will be no damages that could be ascertainable
- 33:19by the client. But because of repeated and reckless
- 33:23conduct, the state bar will care about your duties
- 33:27of competence and loyalty and diligence. with
- 33:33this particular client. So these are not small
- 33:37risks. These are big risks. Hopefully everybody
- 33:39has insurance. If you don't call Lawyers Mutual,
- 33:42shameless plug. But those are the risks. And
- 33:47there's also data security risks if you are using
- 33:49outdated or unsecured calendaring methods. You
- 33:53have to make sure just because you implement
- 33:55something once that you're not, it is fluid and
- 33:58you need to continue to monitor these systems
- 34:03that you utilize to make sure that they are secure.
- 34:06I mean, we have at our company an add -on to
- 34:14the policy for cyber breaches, and they happen.
- 34:19I just had one the other day where a criminal
- 34:21lawyer literally saw before her eyes all of her
- 34:25Dropbox documents disappearing. So you need to
- 34:30make sure, what happens in the event of that?
- 34:33How are you, my vendor, who I'm paying, how are
- 34:37you securing my confidential client information?
- 34:42And again, tech compliance, now that that's a
- 34:46real rule, it's really hard to say that your
- 34:51calendaring system in your Black Notebook is
- 34:54sufficient. So let me go through some real -world
- 34:59examples when you fill the calendar. I have six
- 35:03here. I may have gone over some of them. But
- 35:08again, a missed filing deadline, California attorney
- 35:10representing a client in a personal injury case
- 35:13forgot to file a lawsuit before the statute of
- 35:15limitations expired, claim forever barred leading
- 35:18to a malpractice suit. I would say in that situation,
- 35:21my sort of side note on this is Call your carrier.
- 35:24As soon as you figure out or realize that you've
- 35:27missed a deadline, call your carrier. They may
- 35:30have some guidance for you on whether or not
- 35:34there is a fix, whether there's a remedy, whether
- 35:38there's a way to continue to represent the client,
- 35:42whether you can file and allege some sort of,
- 35:44whether it's tolling provisions, how old the
- 35:46client was, whether if it's a government tort
- 35:48claim, if you can file a late one. If you have
- 35:52a carrier that has that kind of hotline and assistance,
- 35:55call your carrier and they'll walk you through
- 35:59that. I will walk you through what to do in that
- 36:05situation and I'll talk about it in a bit about
- 36:09how you make that disclosure to a client because
- 36:12that's a really important ethical issue as well.
- 36:17Court sanctions. If you don't have effective
- 36:20calendaring systems, you can fail to appear in
- 36:25a mandatory case management conference or mandatory
- 36:28settlement conference because a date isn't calendared,
- 36:32you can get sanctions against you and your client.
- 36:34Your client has suffered unnecessary delays,
- 36:38which they're allowed to complain about. They
- 36:41may not ultimately affect the outcome of your
- 36:44case, but it does cause client distrust. when
- 36:47they see you being sloppy. Effective electronic
- 36:51calendaring keeps you clean. You don't want to
- 36:56be messy about any of this with your clients.
- 37:00And again, administrative errors, which goes
- 37:02back to the rule about 5 .3, about delegating
- 37:08to your assistant. You've got paper notes to
- 37:13track deadlines. your assistant inadvertently
- 37:17misplaces a file, the attorney missed a deadline,
- 37:21resulting again, tarnished reputation sanctions.
- 37:25Reputational injury, although it's one of those
- 37:29things that people talk about, getting sued,
- 37:31I don't think is reputational injury. It happens
- 37:35to everyone. It's a cost of doing business, and
- 37:38it happens. But reputational injury, if you...
- 37:43are in a certain practice area and you have a
- 37:47reputation for being messy, for missing deadlines,
- 37:50for constantly asking for extensions, for serving
- 37:56objections only, to delay. Your referral system
- 38:02will dry up from your lawyers in your bar, from
- 38:07your clients who may refer you to a friend. It
- 38:10will lead to distrust in the bar. the bench officer
- 38:15who sees this, who you may be appearing in front
- 38:18of regularly, you don't want that reputational
- 38:20harm. Again, good calendaring systems avoid this.
- 38:25Again, another example, and I may sort of go
- 38:30to the worst example, but the old school example
- 38:34was, you've got 45 minutes before deadline, you
- 38:38sent the courier to the courthouse, the courier
- 38:41got stuck in traffic. now you're a minute late
- 38:43and you know again this goes to don't wait till
- 38:47the last minute and and if you do make sure that
- 38:54you have sufficient guarantees in place that
- 38:57it can get filed on the correct day because if
- 39:02that was a valuable claim your client has lost
- 39:04you know i talked about the case that you know
- 39:06may not have been so valuable with the fifteen
- 39:09thousand dollar limits There are cases that are
- 39:12valuable, and if you've got a million -dollar
- 39:15case that you didn't file timely, then you've
- 39:18got a million -dollar claim on your hands and
- 39:21underwriting history and things that you just
- 39:24don't want to deal with. You want the actual
- 39:27proper defendant to be paying that. You don't
- 39:31want to be paying that because of your own error
- 39:34due to miscalendering. And these are all sort
- 39:40of like, it's asymmetric risk. It's associated
- 39:43with calendar and docketing errors, meaning like
- 39:47a minor mistake can lead to a major problem.
- 39:50And here's where the most major problems come.
- 39:53And I call this the triple error coverup. First,
- 39:56you file in the wrong jurisdiction, and then
- 40:00the corrected suit isn't filed until after the
- 40:03statute is expired. And then you attempt to cover
- 40:07it up. So this is based on a real world example.
- 40:11And what the court in that case did is they issued
- 40:14a combined compensatory impugnative damage award
- 40:17of $35 million in the malpractice suit that followed.
- 40:21The coverup is worse than the crime. Always,
- 40:26always, always. Because then that can lead to
- 40:29fraud allegations. So I want to talk about, and
- 40:32malpractice claims are going up, the profile
- 40:34of legal malpractice claims that the ABA put
- 40:36out. in 2012 to 2015 and then again 2020 to 2023
- 40:41basically aggregates data from malpractice insurance
- 40:46carriers and it says the volume of malpractice
- 40:49claims and associated costs have grown and are
- 40:52continuing to grow. Going back to the cover -up
- 40:56is worse than the crime and disclosing an error.
- 41:00This is really important and it's not necessarily
- 41:03giving, it doesn't give you the the context of
- 41:09the calendaring vetting, but it gives you the
- 41:16context of what happens when you make that calendaring
- 41:18error. And if you were to call in on the hotline,
- 41:22the best practices that I always tell everyone
- 41:24is you cannot cover it up. You have a duty to
- 41:27disclose to your client what happened. And I
- 41:30believe that that should be a two to three part
- 41:34process. the first thing you do, presuming you
- 41:37have a good relationship with the client because
- 41:39you've been communicating, you call the client
- 41:43in for an in -person meeting, you offer to go
- 41:46to their house, you talk to them on the phone,
- 41:48you have a Zoom meeting, but you have something
- 41:51oral where you factually say what happened. All
- 41:56you're doing is saying what happened. You're
- 41:58saying the deadline was X. I filed on Y or I
- 42:03didn't file on X, this obviously impairs your
- 42:07ability to move forward with this case. You may
- 42:11have a claim against me. And there's two parts
- 42:15to this. If it's something you think you can
- 42:17correct, at the very least you need a conflict
- 42:19disclosure or a waiver to continue to represent
- 42:23them to try to fix the error. I say this in every
- 42:27presentation, but you're never more aligned with
- 42:30your client than you are when you've made a mistake
- 42:31that you want a remedy. Nevertheless, it is required
- 42:36that you disclose the potential conflict and
- 42:40a waiver would be best practices. Following up
- 42:45on that telephone call, which you are not saying.
- 42:50I'm so sorry, I made such a huge mistake and
- 42:53you're factually disclosing, you know, your carrier
- 42:56doesn't allow you to admit liability on anything
- 42:58in any policy. So you don't want coverage concerns.
- 43:02But then you tell the client, I am obligated
- 43:07to follow up under the ethical rules with a letter
- 43:10to you. And that letter to you, I want you to
- 43:13look at. If you want independent counsel, please
- 43:16have them look at it. But that will allow me
- 43:19to continue to represent you. And if it's that
- 43:23kind of situation, if it's something they wear,
- 43:25you know that there's nothing you can correct.
- 43:27You can disclose. You will disclose it in person
- 43:32or orally, and your writing will be very simple.
- 43:36You know, dear so and so as we discussed, the
- 43:39time to file your action is now time barred.
- 43:43You may have an action against me. you should
- 43:46consult with another lawyer, I can no longer
- 43:48represent you in this case. You know, sincerely,
- 43:52Annie Thompson, mistakes happen. Again, going
- 43:56back to that, sometimes it's not the worst thing
- 43:58in the world because they still have to prove
- 43:59the case within a case. But disclosing calendar
- 44:03errors is part of the ethics of this. And so
- 44:07not making the calendar errors in the first place
- 44:09is obviously the the most critical part of this.
- 44:17So we've talked about the benefits of electronic
- 44:20calendaring as far as integration, compliance
- 44:23and risk reduction and enhanced accuracy and
- 44:26efficiency. But there's also a cost effectiveness
- 44:30part of this that depending on the size of your
- 44:34practice, you need to evaluate because you can
- 44:39have long -term savings on administrative overhead.
- 44:43and risk mitigation in the same program that
- 44:47may be a cost savings to you. Although while
- 44:52these services are not free and you may think
- 44:54that your small practice doesn't need it, it
- 44:57may be something that long term is cost effective
- 45:01for you. So it's also important when you are
- 45:10vetting, calendaring, software that you adopt
- 45:16calendaring systems that are tailored to your
- 45:20legal practice. And again, the most popular ones
- 45:23that I know of are Clio, MyCase, and Practice
- 45:26Panther. And they offer integrated calendaring
- 45:29features that sync with case management tasks
- 45:32and deadlines. They have automated reminders,
- 45:35deadline calculations, and cloud -based access.
- 45:37That is a lot of protection for you, and that's
- 45:41really what you want is as much protection as
- 45:44possible. There's also Law Toolbox, and that's
- 45:48a court rule -based calendaring system. And they
- 45:51will specialize in calculating deadlines based
- 45:55on court rules and jurisdiction. And the benefits
- 45:59of that is their accurate jurisdiction -specific
- 46:02deadline tracking. People's practices since 2020
- 46:08have become geographically more diverse is what
- 46:12I see. The world got smaller by virtue of integrating
- 46:19electronic technology. I can take a deposition
- 46:23in Northern California. and be a Southern California
- 46:27lawyer. Obviously, you have to worry about unauthorized
- 46:30practice of law outside of a jurisdiction. But
- 46:33because the way that we litigate now is different,
- 46:39you may be in different jurisdictions than you
- 46:43used to be. So knowing those local rules and
- 46:47having a court -based calendaring system to give
- 46:50you jurisdiction -specific deadline tracking,
- 46:53is another important consideration to make. And
- 47:01then, lastly, what I will say before I get to
- 47:08my checklist is tools like Outlook, Google Calendar,
- 47:13Apple Calendar, those can all be adapted for
- 47:15easy use too. They're easy integration with email
- 47:18and mobile devices. They require manual input
- 47:22of deadlines. I prefer manual input of deadlines
- 47:25because I'm doing that myself. You don't need
- 47:29the most sophisticated tools, but you need tools
- 47:36and you need electronic tools and you need repetition
- 47:39and duplication. And if you're delegating this,
- 47:44you need everybody's buy -on and everybody's
- 47:46consistency in how they're calendaring and color
- 47:50calendaring and features that are apparent to
- 47:56everybody within your law firm. OK. I have a
- 48:00question here in my Q &A. And it's hypothetical.
- 48:05Oh, goodness. International entity client in
- 48:09-house counsel is located in a different jurisdiction
- 48:12slash country, may not be licensed in form or
- 48:16state. PMK is scheduling necessarily delegated
- 48:21through in -house counsel. The court has ordered
- 48:24you to produce PMK in 10 days. Scheduling efforts
- 48:28fail and you are at a continued hearing without
- 48:31a date. How do you explain this hypothetical
- 48:33to the judge in compliance with business and
- 48:37professions code 6068E1. This is an extreme hypothetical,
- 48:42dot, dot, dot. It is an extreme hypothetical,
- 48:45and I can issue spot a number of things with
- 48:52that. I mean, it raises issues of unauthorized
- 48:55practice of law. So this really isn't a calendaring
- 48:59issue. You have an international entity client
- 49:01located in a different jurisdiction. and you're
- 49:05not licensed to practice in that jurisdiction,
- 49:09you've got some problems. You're ordered to produce
- 49:13the PMK in 10 days, and it's unclear to me, but
- 49:19it sounds like maybe your scheduling efforts
- 49:22with the PMK have failed, and you're adhering
- 49:25now with the court, and how much can you disclose
- 49:28about your inability to get your... international
- 49:33clients compliance with this. This raises a whole
- 49:36host of issues completely separate and apart
- 49:40from calendaring. So I would just point out,
- 49:44you know, your duties of confidentiality, your
- 49:47duties of candor to the court. You have to zealously
- 49:52protect your client and make sure that you're
- 49:55not revealing any confidential communications
- 49:58or information in that scenario. Again, but show
- 50:04up in the 10 days and see what you can do. So
- 50:07I guess it can apply to calendaring in that regard.
- 50:11But that is an extreme hypothetical and very
- 50:15complex. And I would go through it piece by piece
- 50:18with you on a hotline, but I'm not sure it's
- 50:24right for this audience on this topic right now.
- 50:27But hopefully I've identified what I can for
- 50:31you. And then a question, does my case syncing
- 50:35to Google Calendar meet the redundancy requirement?
- 50:40Do I need an additional service? So that seems
- 50:46to me to be sufficient. My case syncing to Google
- 50:51Calendar and Google Calendar being presumably
- 50:54in the cloud and on your phone and my case. has
- 50:59a redundancy element. I will tell you that I
- 51:02have Google Calendar and OneCalendar and Outlook
- 51:07Calendar for like triple redundancy. I don't
- 51:10know that that is the standard of care. I do
- 51:13think there may be a sort of best practices element
- 51:17to, you know, Google's gone down before, but
- 51:21so is Outlook. But I do think that certainly
- 51:24you're meeting an ethical requirement of having
- 51:28redundancy in place, having case management software
- 51:31in place, grading the documents, but it is your
- 51:35duty. Google Calendar is manual entry sometimes,
- 51:39so it's not going to capture all the things you
- 51:42need it to capture, like your client meetings,
- 51:44but it is going to capture all the case information
- 51:47that my case will sync. With your with your system.
- 51:54So that is definitely a fine way of handling
- 51:58it as long as you're vetting your systems and
- 52:01and Making sure that you're you know, consistently
- 52:06updating like I'm having an issue right now One
- 52:09of my calendars is not syncing with the other
- 52:11so I'm missing appointments I have backups because
- 52:14I know that it's on the other one, but one of
- 52:17my calendars is not syncing with the other one
- 52:19That's why you need redundancy Ironically that
- 52:23just started happening in the last few days before
- 52:26I do a calendar and seminar of course The last
- 52:30thing I'm going I'm going to share a screen with
- 52:33you because this is really going to be it's in
- 52:36your materials and this is Going to be kind of
- 52:42it's welcome to share it So this is a checklist
- 52:49And it's in your materials. And this is a checklist
- 52:55for evaluating and implementing electronic calendaring
- 52:58systems. Essentially, the message I'm leaving
- 53:03you with in this seminar is that electronic calendaring
- 53:10systems are the future, the present, and your
- 53:16future. You need to leave your paper calendars
- 53:18in the past, or they can be part of your redundancy.
- 53:21They just can't be the only thing you have. So
- 53:23this is a very, um, hopefully complete, um, checklist
- 53:30of evaluating and implementing electronic calendaring
- 53:34for California lawyers. And you want to make
- 53:37sure that this is tailored to your practice.
- 53:42So you look at, you know, compliance with California
- 53:45rule law. Port rule integration, customizable
- 53:49workflows, recurring appointments, conflict checking,
- 53:53which is huge, and it's definitely a whole different
- 53:57CLE. But integration, mobile and cloud access,
- 54:02and then collaboration depending on the size
- 54:05of your firm. Security and compliance. Data encryption
- 54:10is on our cyber side, encryption, encryption,
- 54:15encryption. And if your data is encrypted and
- 54:19a bad actor accesses it, all they get is gobbledygook.
- 54:25They won't get anything readable. So encrypting
- 54:28data, again, cyber is probably a whole different
- 54:30CLE, but it's something that you need to be aware
- 54:33of for your security and compliance with calendaring
- 54:36is finding out if somebody does access my system,
- 54:40is my data encrypted in such a way that if I
- 54:43have 20 years of files, that nobody can do anything
- 54:47with them. Again, you need controls as to who
- 54:51can access the calendar data. If you have a disgruntled
- 54:55employee who leaves, you want to make sure you
- 54:57can turn that access off immediately. With respect
- 55:02to integrity, you want logging and audit trails,
- 55:07so the integrity of the information is intact.
- 55:11Then again, backup and disaster recovery. compliance
- 55:14with the ABA, but most of the lawyer -based things
- 55:20will meet the ethical obligations for client
- 55:23confidentiality, but you need to make sure. Again,
- 55:27integration and compatibility. We talked about
- 55:30syncing with email and calendar apps. Sometimes,
- 55:34depending on what your system is, it will read
- 55:37your emails and automatically create calendar
- 55:39entries, which is very nice. and make sure that
- 55:43everything you do is compatible with each other
- 55:45so that you're not running into syncing problems
- 55:48and that you have the right people and tools
- 55:54to make sure that that doesn't happen. Again,
- 55:58implementation and training, and you'll have
- 56:02this checklist to use, data migration. If you
- 56:07have existing calendar data, how do you move
- 56:09it into your new system? User training, again,
- 56:13that goes back to the rule about delegations
- 56:16to assistance on calendaring, and then customizing
- 56:20and scaling it to your firm size and needs, which
- 56:22is huge because you don't want a system made
- 56:26for big law if you have a two -person law firm
- 56:29or a one -person law firm. And then lastly, and
- 56:33this was the sort of the cost benefit analysis
- 56:35that I talked about before, where I really believe
- 56:39that if you find the right product for the size
- 56:44and needs of your firm, the benefits outweigh
- 56:49the risks of not having a vendor to assist you
- 56:54with respect to your calendaring and your and
- 57:00your communication needs as it pertains to your
- 57:05ethical responsibilities to your clients. So
- 57:10I am going to, if there are no more questions,
- 57:14I'm gonna conclude this presentation and just
- 57:17share with you, you know, calendaring isn't merely
- 57:19an administrative task. It's a fundamental aspect
- 57:22of legal practice that directly impacts your
- 57:25clients, your compliance with ethical obligations,
- 57:28and the reputation of your practice. By employing
- 57:31an effective electronic calendaring system, you
- 57:34can reduce risks, enhance efficiency, and uphold
- 57:38the highest standards of professional responsibility.
- 57:42Remember that the investment you make in your
- 57:43calendaring system is an investment in your clients,
- 57:46your career, and the integrity of the legal profession.
- 57:50Thank you for your attention today, and I really
- 57:53appreciate. You all taking the time to be here.
- 57:57And if there are any questions, I remain available
- 58:01after the program if you would like to contact
- 58:06me about whether it's Lawyers Mutual or any other
- 58:10needs you may have with regard to this presentation.
- 58:13So thank you all for coming today. You may be
- 58:16eligible for CLE credit in your state. Visit
- 58:18bhba .org slash podcasts for more information.