Latest / Bloomberg Law / Weekend Law: Election Suits, Shadow Trading & 'Top Gun'
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 1: The weed of the crime bears bitter fruit.
- 0:13Speaker 2: I like this.
- 0:15Speaker 1: Did you think you'd get away with it? What did
- 0:19Speaker 1: you think I would know? The shadow knows?
- 0:29Speaker 3: Perhaps that explains why a novel theory of the SEC's
- 0:34Speaker 3: is being called shadow trading. A corporate insider may think
- 0:38Speaker 3: he got away with it, after all, he used inside
- 0:42Speaker 3: information from his company to trade in the stock of
- 0:44Speaker 3: a rival company. But it seems like the SEC is
- 0:48Speaker 3: trying to show that, like the shadow, it knows all.
- 0:52Speaker 3: Ask former Metivation executive Matthew Panawat a California jury convicted
- 0:57Speaker 3: him in the regulator's first enforcement action targeting so called
- 1:02Speaker 3: shadow trading. Joining me is securities law expert James Park,
- 1:06Speaker 3: a professor at UCLA Law School. Jim, this case has
- 1:10Speaker 3: been called groundbreaking. Do you think it's groundbreaking and if so,
- 1:14Speaker 3: why it is?
- 1:15Speaker 4: In some ways, but in other ways, I think it's
- 1:17Speaker 4: the standard case. The reason why it's unusual is I
- 1:21Speaker 4: believe it's the first time the SDC has brought and
- 1:25Speaker 4: won a case involving something called shadow trading, which is
- 1:29Speaker 4: a type of insider trading where you're using information that
- 1:34Speaker 4: you obtained from your own company to trade in the
- 1:37Speaker 4: stock of another company. This is the first time the
- 1:40Speaker 4: SDC has brought such a case and pursued serious sanctions.
- 1:46Speaker 4: It's not all that unusual, though, in that most of
- 1:50Speaker 4: the sort of outcome hinged upon factual issues. Did you
- 1:56Speaker 4: believe that this individual got and read the email from
- 2:01Speaker 4: the CEO which said that the company was going to
- 2:03Speaker 4: be acquired? Factual issues which are fairly routine in insider
- 2:08Speaker 4: trading cases. And I think you could argue that this
- 2:12Speaker 4: is a straightforward extension of existing law that has been
- 2:17Speaker 4: in place since the US Supreme Court's decision in the
- 2:21Speaker 4: United States versus o'hagen. But I do think that it
- 2:25Speaker 4: is significant because it shows the SEC is willing to
- 2:28Speaker 4: bring these types of cases and could do so in
- 2:33Speaker 4: the future.
- 2:34Speaker 3: What was the evidence against the defendant here?
- 2:38Speaker 4: Some of the evidence was circumstantial, so they knew the
- 2:42Speaker 4: CEO sent an email that included him and other individuals
- 2:47Speaker 4: in the company. They didn't necessarily know though, whether or
- 2:52Speaker 4: not he read the email, and he claimed the trial
- 2:54Speaker 4: that he did not read the email. But what they
- 2:57Speaker 4: do know is that minutes after the email was sent
- 3:03Speaker 4: and would have been received. He spent one hundred thousand
- 3:06Speaker 4: dollars in options in this company that was likely to
- 3:11Speaker 4: go up in price upon the announcement that his company
- 3:15Speaker 4: would be acquired, And so that is circumstantial evidence. We
- 3:18Speaker 4: don't know for a fact, you know, one hundred percent
- 3:21Speaker 4: certainty that he actually knew of this inside information and
- 3:25Speaker 4: that he read the email. But you know, that's what
- 3:28Speaker 4: a jury's for. Does a jury believe his explanation for
- 3:32Speaker 4: buying all of these options, which is that he read
- 3:34Speaker 4: a research analyst report by Goldman Sachs and that he
- 3:38Speaker 4: had been following this company for a long time. You know,
- 3:42Speaker 4: that's up to the jury. And recall that this is
- 3:44Speaker 4: a civil case. It's not a criminal case where the
- 3:47Speaker 4: SEC has to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he
- 3:51Speaker 4: violated Rule ten B five, which is the major securities
- 3:55Speaker 4: fraud provision that prohibits insider trading. They only have to
- 3:58Speaker 4: prove by a propondance of the evidence.
- 4:02Speaker 3: The defense also argued that the SEC couldn't prove that
- 4:05Speaker 3: Panawat had an intent to defraud or see enter because
- 4:09Speaker 3: he didn't know it was illegal to trade in a
- 4:11Speaker 3: company that wasn't his employer and didn't conduct business with
- 4:15Speaker 3: his employer. So his attorney told the jury, the evidence
- 4:18Speaker 3: will show that the entire SEC case is an attempt
- 4:21Speaker 3: to put thoughts in mister Panawat's head that were not
- 4:25Speaker 3: there when he made the trades.
- 4:27Speaker 4: It's a substantial argument, and these cases depend on intent,
- 4:32Speaker 4: and because we don't know for sure what someone's intent is,
- 4:36Speaker 4: that's up for the jury to decide. And the jury
- 4:39Speaker 4: looked at the evidence and they believed circumstantially that he
- 4:42Speaker 4: acted with bad intent. And you know, one fact in
- 4:45Speaker 4: favor of the SEC is that he buys one hundred
- 4:48Speaker 4: thousand dollars in option. His purchase is represented around eighty
- 4:52Speaker 4: percent of the options trading in that stock on that
- 4:56Speaker 4: particular day. That is very unusual. And you know, the
- 5:01Speaker 4: other point I would make is that ignorance of the
- 5:04Speaker 4: law is not a defense. Even if you don't know
- 5:06Speaker 4: all the ins and outs of insider trading law, which
- 5:09Speaker 4: is complicated, that is not a defense to liability. Now,
- 5:14Speaker 4: he does have an argument that I just was not
- 5:16Speaker 4: conscious of doing anything wrong, because you know, I didn't
- 5:19Speaker 4: understand I couldn't trade in the stock of other companies,
- 5:23Speaker 4: and the fact of the matter is he signs the
- 5:25Speaker 4: policy saying that you cannot use company information to trade
- 5:30Speaker 4: in the securities of another publicly traded company. Now, you know,
- 5:34Speaker 4: I think, mister Pano, what would say, You know, we
- 5:37Speaker 4: sign all sorts of things when he joined a new company.
- 5:40Speaker 4: We may not read these things carefully. And I just
- 5:43Speaker 4: didn't understand this. The jury could have decided you are accountable,
- 5:47Speaker 4: and you are accountable because you signed the policy, and
- 5:51Speaker 4: because you signed it, you have to follow it. And
- 5:54Speaker 4: if you're not following it, you know you're deceiving your company.
- 5:57Speaker 4: And that sort of deception is a type of missuppropriation
- 6:01Speaker 4: of the company's confidential information. You know, another argument you
- 6:05Speaker 4: could make might be a you know, I found a
- 6:07Speaker 4: loophole and I'm gaving the system. I don't know how
- 6:09Speaker 4: sympathetic the jury would be to that argument, but you know,
- 6:12Speaker 4: that is the sort of argument that one could give
- 6:14Speaker 4: some weights to. But the jury rejected those arguments.
- 6:18Speaker 3: You mentioned the policy, the confidentiality agreement that Panawat signed.
- 6:22Speaker 3: Could the SEC have brought this case without that confidentiality agreement?
- 6:27Speaker 2: This is the.
- 6:28Speaker 4: Foundation of the case. Without this policy, the SEC would
- 6:32Speaker 4: not have an insider trading case, you can only misappropriate
- 6:36Speaker 4: confidential information and violate Rule ten B five based on
- 6:40Speaker 4: inside information if you have a fiduciary duty to the
- 6:45Speaker 4: corporation who stock your trading in, or you have agreed
- 6:50Speaker 4: to keep information confidential. Those are the two mechanisms by
- 6:54Speaker 4: which you can violate insider trading prohibitions. The first avenue
- 6:59Speaker 4: is called the classical theory of insider trading, and that
- 7:02Speaker 4: actually does not apply to this case because Panawat does
- 7:07Speaker 4: not have any fiduciary duties to Insight, which is the
- 7:10Speaker 4: company that he traded in. He might have some juduciary
- 7:14Speaker 4: like duties to his company metivation. But that's why you
- 7:19Speaker 4: know this is seen or was seen as a type
- 7:21Speaker 4: of loophole. It gets you around the classical theory. But
- 7:25Speaker 4: there's a second theory which has just as much status,
- 7:29Speaker 4: has been approved by the Supreme Court called the misappropriation theory.
- 7:33Speaker 4: And under that theory, the deception is when you sign
- 7:37Speaker 4: a policy of confidentiality with your company that commits you
- 7:41Speaker 4: to complying with that policy, and if you deceptively trade
- 7:45Speaker 4: and violation of that policy, you have violated Rule ten
- 7:48Speaker 4: D five. So it is absolutely essential that they had
- 7:52Speaker 4: a policy that specified you cannot trade in the securities
- 7:55Speaker 4: of another publicly traded company. If they did not have
- 7:59Speaker 4: that policy and a general policy of confidentiality, the SEC
- 8:03Speaker 4: would not have had a case. Many public companies are
- 8:07Speaker 4: adopting these types of broad insider trading policies that cover
- 8:11Speaker 4: securities of other publicly traded companies.
- 8:14Speaker 3: Do you think that this case will survive and appeal this.
- 8:17Speaker 4: Theory, It's always hard to say. I think on the
- 8:20Speaker 4: factual determinations, there's not much of a basis for overturning
- 8:25Speaker 4: the case. The vulnerable point to me, I think is
- 8:28Speaker 4: on the enter. I think that is the one argument
- 8:31Speaker 4: that a judge on the Ninth Circuit or perhaps the
- 8:34Speaker 4: Supreme Court could look at very closely on these facts
- 8:38Speaker 4: and could be a little bit skeptical of the sec
- 8:42Speaker 4: theory of the case. On the other hand, you know,
- 8:45Speaker 4: these are typically factual matters. The fraudulent intent is a
- 8:49Speaker 4: matter for the jury, and many appellate courts will defer
- 8:52Speaker 4: to that, and the Supreme Court may not think of
- 8:55Speaker 4: this as a good vessel for clarifying the boundaries of
- 8:58Speaker 4: insider trading laws.
- 9:00Speaker 3: The SEC has been criticized for pushing into new territory
- 9:04Speaker 3: and stretching its enforcement powers beyond its jurisdiction, for example,
- 9:09Speaker 3: bringing cases over McDonald's CEO's relationship with an employee, the
- 9:14Speaker 3: workplace culture at a video game developer, and several cutting
- 9:18Speaker 3: edge cases to gain greater control over cryptocurrency.
- 9:22Speaker 4: That is the criticism, and one response the SEC might
- 9:26Speaker 4: have is that these are novel problems and the reason
- 9:30Speaker 4: we were not addressing them before is the SEC was
- 9:33Speaker 4: too passive. We need to get out there, We need
- 9:35Speaker 4: to enforce the laws the novel situations and educate people
- 9:40Speaker 4: about what the law is. You can't simply ignore these
- 9:43Speaker 4: broader standards and principles. And if you're applying the definition
- 9:48Speaker 4: of insider trading in this appropriation in security and good faith,
- 9:52Speaker 4: you would know that in some cases that there are
- 9:54Speaker 4: violations of securities laws. Now, the argument on the other
- 9:58Speaker 4: side is that certainly the SEC has become more aggressive
- 10:02Speaker 4: and I would say more entrepreneurial in certain ways, and
- 10:05Speaker 4: part of that is that you have a more expansive,
- 10:08Speaker 4: aggressive regulatory policy, and enforcement is a way to develop
- 10:12Speaker 4: that policy. And you know they're positives and negatives, I think,
- 10:16Speaker 4: but recall that there are times when the SEC is
- 10:18Speaker 4: criticized as too passive, too much of a bureaucracy captured
- 10:22Speaker 4: by the industry because the lawyers want to get good
- 10:26Speaker 4: jobs with law firms, and so, you know, I think
- 10:28Speaker 4: either way, if you're too passive, if you're too aggressive,
- 10:31Speaker 4: the SEC is going to face some criticism for its
- 10:34Speaker 4: enforcement policies. But I would say that I do think
- 10:37Speaker 4: that this administration, for better or worse, has implemented a
- 10:41Speaker 4: more entrepreneurial or aggressive approach to enforcement.
- 10:45Speaker 3: Finally, how big a victory is this for the SEC?
- 10:49Speaker 3: A ten on a ten scale or.
- 10:51Speaker 4: Five, it's a big victory. Every trial win is a
- 10:54Speaker 4: big thing and a good thing for the SEC, because
- 10:57Speaker 4: you're not just settling cases. That's the criticism of the
- 11:00Speaker 4: SEC is that too often they just settle cases the
- 11:04Speaker 4: defendant doesn't admit too wrongdoing or deny it, and the
- 11:08Speaker 4: SEC has been afraid or doesn't have the resources to
- 11:11Speaker 4: actually go in front of judges and juries and test
- 11:14Speaker 4: their theory. So I think this is very significant, and
- 11:19Speaker 4: you know, along with their win in the Coinbase motion
- 11:23Speaker 4: to dismiss, it's been a good few weeks for the SDC,
- 11:28Speaker 4: and these are needed wins because when you're getting criticized
- 11:31Speaker 4: for stretching the law regulating by enforcement. The suurest response
- 11:36Speaker 4: is winning cases in courts, and you know they have
- 11:39Speaker 4: won these cases. They need to keep litigating cases and
- 11:43Speaker 4: winning them fairly consistently in order to enhance the legitimacy
- 11:48Speaker 4: of their enforcement effort.
- 11:49Speaker 3: Thanks so much, Jim. That's Professor James Park of UCLA
- 11:52Speaker 3: Law School coming up. The twenty twenty four election is
- 11:56Speaker 3: already being fought out in the courts. I'm June Gross
- 12:00Speaker 3: and you're listening to Bloomberg and.
- 12:03Speaker 5: That was a rigged election and it's a shame that
- 12:06Speaker 5: we had to go through, and it's very bad for
- 12:07Speaker 5: our country.
- 12:08Speaker 3: We've heard that false claim from Donald Trump about the
- 12:11Speaker 3: twenty twenty presidential election over and over and over, despite
- 12:16Speaker 3: the fact that sixty court cases found no evidence of
- 12:19Speaker 3: fraud or illegality. It seems to be part of Trump's repertoire.
- 12:23Speaker 5: The election is being rigged by corrupt media, pushing false
- 12:28Speaker 5: allegations and outright lies in an effort to elect Hillary
- 12:33Speaker 5: Clinton president.
- 12:34Speaker 3: Of course, he dropped those rigged election claims after he won,
- 12:39Speaker 3: but they're just below the surface of this year's election.
- 12:42Speaker 5: Republicans must win.
- 12:44Speaker 3: We want to landslide.
- 12:45Speaker 5: We wanted to be too big, too rigged.
- 12:48Speaker 3: Will there be a repeat this year of the litigation
- 12:51Speaker 3: frenzy that followed the twenty twenty election. Well, the election
- 12:55Speaker 3: is more than six months away, but political groups are
- 12:58Speaker 3: filing so many lawsuits over voting rules that the numbers
- 13:03Speaker 3: could reach the record set in that bitterly contested election.
- 13:07Speaker 3: The Democratic and Republican parties have raised about forty one
- 13:10Speaker 3: point three million dollars to spend on court fights, and nonprofits,
- 13:15Speaker 3: including some dark money groups, have likely raised hundreds of
- 13:20Speaker 3: millions more. Joining me is elections law expert Derek Muller,
- 13:23Speaker 3: a professor at Notre Dame Law School. Fighting over election
- 13:27Speaker 3: rules in court is big business for lawyers and the
- 13:31Speaker 3: groups challenging them. Just how big?
- 13:33Speaker 1: So we know that the political parties can collect significant
- 13:38Speaker 1: amounts of money ear mark designated for election expenses. So
- 13:42Speaker 1: the RNC and DNC have large pools of money that
- 13:46Speaker 1: are upwards of one hundred million dollars a year now
- 13:49Speaker 1: to be thinking about these kinds of expenditures. So they
- 13:52Speaker 1: have significant funds that they can use to involve them
- 13:56Speaker 1: self mitigation to start litigation to intervene in litigation. Not
- 14:00Speaker 1: even just the parties, the growth of additional five LLANC
- 14:03Speaker 1: three's nonprofits organizations dedicated to rooting out voter fraud or
- 14:08Speaker 1: protecting democracy or whatever we might label the organizations and
- 14:12Speaker 1: those we don't even have a sense of the scope
- 14:14Speaker 1: and scale of these things. So it's significant amounts of
- 14:17Speaker 1: money coming into the system specifically for litigation.
- 14:21Speaker 3: And there are groups nonprofits where we don't know where
- 14:25Speaker 3: their money is coming from or how they're spending it.
- 14:28Speaker 1: So when it comes to the DNC or the RNC,
- 14:31Speaker 1: we know their donors, we know the individuals who have
- 14:34Speaker 1: contributed to these entities. You know, there are limitations about
- 14:38Speaker 1: what packs can contribute to parties, so we have some
- 14:43Speaker 1: transparency about where that money is coming from, at least
- 14:45Speaker 1: in terms of the direct contributions to the parties. Where
- 14:48Speaker 1: the so called dark money groups comes in would be
- 14:51Speaker 1: if there are other outside groups on the right or
- 14:54Speaker 1: the left who are starting litigation, engaged in litigation, funding litigation,
- 14:59Speaker 1: in beingian litigation, who want to support or promote certain
- 15:04Speaker 1: kinds of laws or anticipate those ahead of the twenty
- 15:06Speaker 1: twenty four election, So you've seen some of these organizations
- 15:09Speaker 1: from you know, former government officials, you know, both on
- 15:12Speaker 1: the right and the left, to support Trump who opposed Trump.
- 15:15Speaker 1: I think often think of it in those terms, maybe
- 15:16Speaker 1: rather than a Republican and Democrats these days. But those organizations,
- 15:20Speaker 1: you know, we don't necessarily know where their funding's coming from,
- 15:23Speaker 1: who's supporting them? Are the reasons why they're litigating. But
- 15:26Speaker 1: when it comes to the parties, at least we have
- 15:28Speaker 1: some some pretty good transparency.
- 15:30Speaker 6: This, you know, sort of fierce challenging of election laws
- 15:35Speaker 6: and venus election laws. Did it start after Bush v.
- 15:39Speaker 6: Gore or did it start in twenty twenty?
- 15:44Speaker 1: It keeps rising, So there's lots of inflection points. So
- 15:48Speaker 1: Professor Rickhats in his tracked how Bush versus Gore was
- 15:51Speaker 1: sort of the first wave of these things because Bush
- 15:53Speaker 1: versus Gore, it's not just that, you know, a very
- 15:55Speaker 1: small margin to Florida could affect the outcome of a
- 15:58Speaker 1: presidential election. It also signified the federal courts were open
- 16:01Speaker 1: for business about how you get a recount right, how
- 16:04Speaker 1: your machines were counting ballots. So we see a steady
- 16:08Speaker 1: uptick in election litigation after the two thousand election. But again,
- 16:12Speaker 1: there are different inflection points that arise, you know, throughout
- 16:15Speaker 1: this period of time, as states introduce vot identification laws
- 16:19Speaker 1: and those become a sort of rallying cry and a
- 16:22Speaker 1: challenging point for different groups or different legislatures. We see
- 16:26Speaker 1: just the significant uptick in litigation around those things FROMNIBUS
- 16:30Speaker 1: Bill twenty fourteen. Twenty fifteen creates this mechanism for more
- 16:33Speaker 1: funding and elections. You know, after the twenty sixteen election
- 16:37Speaker 1: we see Green Party candidate Jill Steine pressing for recounts
- 16:40Speaker 1: around the United States, and twenty twenty we see the
- 16:43Speaker 1: run up to the election is a lot of changes
- 16:46Speaker 1: due to COVID, and then there's just tons of litigation
- 16:49Speaker 1: being filed to challenge the rules or to last accommodations
- 16:52Speaker 1: from the rules, followed by all those challenges after the
- 16:55Speaker 1: twenty twenty election. So every cycle just seems to be
- 16:59Speaker 1: bringing its own new challenges, new crises, new rallying points
- 17:03Speaker 1: to fundraise off of. You know, a lot of election
- 17:06Speaker 1: laws that were enacted by legislatures in the past that
- 17:09Speaker 1: might have been ignored or sort of just moved beyond,
- 17:12Speaker 1: and party organizers would have accommoded them or handled them
- 17:15Speaker 1: now are being challenged. Almost any change to your election
- 17:19Speaker 1: machinery in very basic terms, from the buying of a
- 17:21Speaker 1: machine to the list maintenance of your voter roles, gets
- 17:26Speaker 1: challenged by some group on the right or left. So
- 17:28Speaker 1: we're just seeing this escalation, and I think part of
- 17:30Speaker 1: it is the availability of funding, and maybe part of
- 17:32Speaker 1: it is the awareness that parties think that very small
- 17:35Speaker 1: differences can matter, and so they want to challenge as
- 17:38Speaker 1: much as they can, anticipating that a small change might
- 17:41Speaker 1: matter in their election.
- 17:42Speaker 6: And are the big groups that are challenging and defending
- 17:47Speaker 6: these laws. Are they all tied to a party or
- 17:50Speaker 6: a candidate, or any of them independent?
- 17:54Speaker 1: So a number are at least extensively independent right, But
- 17:57Speaker 1: a number of them do tend to file on one
- 17:59Speaker 1: side or the other. So some of them will have
- 18:01Speaker 1: former Republican officials think about restoring integrity and trust and elections,
- 18:05Speaker 1: the Honest Elections Project or things like that, or some
- 18:08Speaker 1: of them will have former Democratic officials or of never
- 18:10Speaker 1: Trump officials who are participating. Some of them States, United
- 18:13Speaker 1: Democracy Center, Protect Democracy, or some of these organizations tend
- 18:16Speaker 1: to file much more heavily on the democratic side, and
- 18:18Speaker 1: the Republican side, so you can trace what these organizations
- 18:22Speaker 1: are doing and see where their officials are. And they
- 18:25Speaker 1: can't formally coordinate with the parties because if you have
- 18:28Speaker 1: that coordination, it creates campaign finance problems. But it's that
- 18:33Speaker 1: they are going around. They're filing litigation and again places
- 18:36Speaker 1: maybe where the party doesn't have the resources to do it,
- 18:38Speaker 1: or isn't aware of it, or wants another group president
- 18:41Speaker 1: the party to be involved. That said, the parties do
- 18:44Speaker 1: still have some significant involvement. I'sk the most significant party
- 18:46Speaker 1: level litigation right now. It's Democratic National Committee leading a
- 18:50Speaker 1: number of challenges to keep Robert F. Kennedy's name off
- 18:53Speaker 1: the ballot in a number of states, I think, viewing
- 18:56Speaker 1: him as a third party threat. I think the R
- 18:58Speaker 1: and T might view him as a threat too, but
- 18:59Speaker 1: hasn't all those challenges. So again, it's hard to pin
- 19:03Speaker 1: down exactly who's leading the litigation in some of these places.
- 19:06Speaker 1: It's following the headlines, seeing who's led on the docket,
- 19:10Speaker 1: what the lead party's name is, and then trying to
- 19:12Speaker 1: identify who they tend to support or where their attorneys
- 19:15Speaker 1: have come from.
- 19:17Speaker 3: And it seems like so many of these lawsuits.
- 19:21Speaker 6: Are not helping to clarify things, but they're attacking this
- 19:25Speaker 6: minutia to deter the process.
- 19:28Speaker 1: So I think about this from kind of an economic standpoint.
- 19:31Speaker 1: If you have limited resources to challenge the rules governing elections,
- 19:37Speaker 1: you are going to challenge the things that you think
- 19:40Speaker 1: are the biggest deal, right, the most important ones, the
- 19:43Speaker 1: ones that you think are really truly changing the game.
- 19:47Speaker 1: And that's also the case that if you didn't have
- 19:49Speaker 1: money earmarked for litigation as a campaign, you would have
- 19:52Speaker 1: to make a judgment call, do I think this two
- 19:55Speaker 1: hundred and fifty thousand dollars is better spent on advertisements
- 20:00Speaker 1: in our district or on litigating you know, this absentee
- 20:04Speaker 1: voter rule or this drop box rule or whatever it is.
- 20:08Speaker 1: So in the past, you would focus your resources on
- 20:12Speaker 1: those things that were the most salient, issues that you
- 20:15Speaker 1: thought had the highest likelihood of winning, and those things
- 20:17Speaker 1: that you thought were better uses of resources than sort
- 20:21Speaker 1: of ordinary political expenses. Now, when you earmark the funds,
- 20:25Speaker 1: you are saying this money is for only litigation. These
- 20:28Speaker 1: contributions can only be for litigation purposes, So you don't
- 20:31Speaker 1: have to make that trade off, and the more resources
- 20:34Speaker 1: you have, the more money you have to spend on litigation,
- 20:37Speaker 1: then the more things you can challenge, and the more
- 20:40Speaker 1: things you challenge, by definition, you are challenging weaker and
- 20:43Speaker 1: weaker claims, or more and more marginal claims, more and
- 20:46Speaker 1: more minutia of elections. To say, you know, we're dealing
- 20:49Speaker 1: with a very small subset of what we think could
- 20:52Speaker 1: be at stake here. So if we can say, you know,
- 20:54Speaker 1: at a very high level, of course, we want elections
- 20:57Speaker 1: to be run fairly and with integrity. We want every
- 21:00Speaker 1: eligible voter to have a reasonable opportunity to vote, and
- 21:03Speaker 1: we don't want that vote unreasonably burdened. But we now
- 21:07Speaker 1: expect a lot of things, even what we could describe
- 21:10Speaker 1: as fairly small things about how elections are run, on
- 21:14Speaker 1: how counties are purchasing voting equipment, or the methods they
- 21:18Speaker 1: use to tabulate ballots. They're just being routinely challenged. So
- 21:22Speaker 1: many of these lawsuits just don't go anywhere. They're not
- 21:24Speaker 1: going to end up being successful, or even if they're
- 21:26Speaker 1: successful at the district court level, they're likely to be
- 21:28Speaker 1: reversed and appeal. We're watching that escalation and trying to
- 21:33Speaker 1: calculate what's the actual added value at the end of
- 21:36Speaker 1: the day, how much of it is win loss rate,
- 21:38Speaker 1: and how much of it is convincing donors. They're convincing
- 21:41Speaker 1: those are your fund raised from to say, hey, we've
- 21:44Speaker 1: filed lawsuit, we're fighting the fight, and then even if
- 21:46Speaker 1: we lose, the point is we're fighting. So that's been
- 21:49Speaker 1: a change in the dynamic, I would say, over the
- 21:51Speaker 1: last couple of decades.
- 21:52Speaker 3: So could this year be worse in terms of election
- 21:55Speaker 3: litigation than the seemingly endless litigation we saw in twenty twenty.
- 22:02Speaker 1: Well, it could be. It always depends on how close
- 22:05Speaker 1: it is, right, the closer the margin, the more lidiation.
- 22:08Speaker 1: Now we say that, you know, twenty twenty in a
- 22:10Speaker 1: way wasn't particularly close because you would have had to
- 22:13Speaker 1: flip several states with somewhat significant margins of victory in
- 22:19Speaker 1: those jurisdictions, even after a recount in places like Georgia.
- 22:23Speaker 1: So we'll have to see, you know, if it's a
- 22:25Speaker 1: Republican loss or an apparent Republican loss. There are a
- 22:29Speaker 1: number of attorneys who promoted things in twenty twenty and
- 22:33Speaker 1: filed lawsuits who are facing sanctions or have been disbarred,
- 22:36Speaker 1: and I don't know if that's going to be sobering
- 22:38Speaker 1: for attorneys on the Republican side to think about the
- 22:41Speaker 1: quality of the claims they bring. And again it depends
- 22:43Speaker 1: on the side of the loss, the scope of the laws,
- 22:45Speaker 1: and many of the strategies in twenty twenty turn on
- 22:48Speaker 1: allegations that states change their laws in the middle of
- 22:51Speaker 1: the pandemic inappropriately. You're not going to see that kind
- 22:54Speaker 1: of dynamic effect in twenty twenty four, And there are
- 22:57Speaker 1: changes to Electoral Account Reform Act that sort of tighten
- 23:00Speaker 1: some of the deadlines and force governors to submit certificates
- 23:04Speaker 1: in an earlier and more timely fashion. So I think
- 23:07Speaker 1: there's a decent chance we would see less litigation on
- 23:10Speaker 1: that front for Democrats and a close loss. Again, it's
- 23:13Speaker 1: hard to know exactly what that would look like. You know,
- 23:15Speaker 1: how many resources would be focused on certain jurisdictions to
- 23:18Speaker 1: allege their violations of federal law. Again, I think it
- 23:22Speaker 1: depends on the kinds of jurisdictions where places like Pennsylvania,
- 23:26Speaker 1: where you have more disparate methods in how ballots are
- 23:30Speaker 1: counted across counties, you have more opportunities to bring those
- 23:33Speaker 1: challenges and to try to get more absentee other kinds
- 23:36Speaker 1: of ballots counted, which might redound to the benefits of
- 23:40Speaker 1: whichever candidate is trailing at the time. But it's a
- 23:42Speaker 1: high degree of uncertainty. We might see more in twenty
- 23:46Speaker 1: twenty four. And you know, I go back to the
- 23:48Speaker 1: two thousand elections. We didn't see a lot of states
- 23:50Speaker 1: with litigation. We just saw a lot of litigation concentrated
- 23:53Speaker 1: in one state. I think the thing about twenty twenty
- 23:56Speaker 1: that was more remarkable with seeing how diffuse and spread
- 23:58Speaker 1: out the litigation was. I think that's less likely to
- 24:01Speaker 1: see that kind of litigation spread out. But if the
- 24:03Speaker 1: election turns on a close result in one or two states,
- 24:07Speaker 1: not just four or five states, I would not be
- 24:09Speaker 1: surprised to see a significant uptake in litigation.
- 24:12Speaker 3: So I guess what we do is hope for wide margins.
- 24:16Speaker 3: Thanks so much for your insights, Derek. That's Professor Derek
- 24:19Speaker 3: Muller of Notre Dame Law School. I'm June Grosso and
- 24:22Speaker 3: you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 24:35Speaker 5: Thirty plus years of service calmbat note citation. If you
- 24:41Speaker 5: can't get a promotion, you won't retire and despite your
- 24:44Speaker 5: best effort.
- 24:45Speaker 4: To refuse to die the kindest headed for extinction.
- 24:50Speaker 1: Maybe so, sir, but.
- 24:52Speaker 3: Not today, Certainly not today or even tomorrow. In fact,
- 24:58Speaker 3: there's already another seat to the sequel in the works,
- 25:02Speaker 3: Top Gun three. After all, Top Gun Maverick gross nearly
- 25:06Speaker 3: one point five billion dollars at the box office, Tom
- 25:10Speaker 3: Cruise's biggest film, So Paramount must have been breathing a
- 25:14Speaker 3: huge sigh of relief when a judge threw out a
- 25:17Speaker 3: copyright lawsuit seeking some of the profits from that twenty
- 25:20Speaker 3: twenty two sequel. A California federal judge found that the
- 25:24Speaker 3: sequel featured a plot, settings, characters, and themes that diverged
- 25:29Speaker 3: far from anything found in the article that inspired the
- 25:32Speaker 3: first Top Gun movie. Here to unravel all this is
- 25:36Speaker 3: intellectual property litigator Terrence Ross a partner Katon Nutchen Rosenman Terry.
- 25:41Speaker 3: This suit was by the heirs of the writer who
- 25:44Speaker 3: wrote the article that inspired the original movie. Why were
- 25:48Speaker 3: they suing Paramount over Top Gun Maverick?
- 25:51Speaker 2: Way back in nineteen eighty three, coud Yunai wrote this
- 25:55Speaker 2: article in California Magazine on the Top Gun program. DANNQS
- 26:00Speaker 2: Navy Fighter weapons school, but wrote it in a sort
- 26:03Speaker 2: of an interesting way where he wrote it from the
- 26:05Speaker 2: perspective of a pilot in his backseat going through the program,
- 26:08Speaker 2: and it caught somebody's eye in Hollywood, and bear Mount
- 26:12Speaker 2: went out and got an assignment of rights for a
- 26:15Speaker 2: movie from him. When I look at such agreements, I
- 26:17Speaker 2: was focused on what's the credit being called for, you know,
- 26:20Speaker 2: at the end of the movie. And he got the
- 26:22Speaker 2: lowest possible credit you could get, which is suggested by
- 26:25Speaker 2: story written by Jinay I mean suggested by is like
- 26:29Speaker 2: the lowest language you can get and still get some
- 26:32Speaker 2: sort of credit. But they have complete rights in the
- 26:34Speaker 2: article for purposes of a movie, and they went out made
- 26:37Speaker 2: the movie unclear whether they really needed those rights, but
- 26:40Speaker 2: they did it. So the you know, I said, Copyright
- 26:43Speaker 2: Act has a provision in it that allows heirs to
- 26:46Speaker 2: a copyright to terminate a license in the copyright years
- 26:51Speaker 2: after the license was given, on sort of the theory
- 26:54Speaker 2: that young up and coming writers artists often get cheated
- 26:58Speaker 2: in these licenses, and so we have to leave a
- 27:01Speaker 2: window of opportunity later on if the work has been
- 27:03Speaker 2: worth something for them to recover some value. So they're
- 27:06Speaker 2: allowed to terminate the license, and after Yone's death in
- 27:10Speaker 2: twenty eighteen, his son and widow did exactly that. They
- 27:14Speaker 2: sent a letter to Paramount saying they've terminated the rights
- 27:19Speaker 2: in the nineteen eighty three California Magazine article because they
- 27:23Speaker 2: had seen somewhere that there was a sequel being worked on,
- 27:27Speaker 2: and that sort of got us up to the top
- 27:29Speaker 2: gun Maverick.
- 27:30Speaker 3: The sequel, the judge seemed to address every possible angle here.
- 27:34Speaker 3: One thing he said was similarities between the two works
- 27:38Speaker 3: based on facts can't be protected. So doesn't that pretty
- 27:42Speaker 3: much cover everything? Because the initial magazine article was nonfiction, right,
- 27:47Speaker 3: it was about real people.
- 27:49Speaker 2: So I agree with you, June. As the judge found
- 27:52Speaker 2: at one point the magazine article was really just a
- 27:55Speaker 2: factual recitation of what went on at Navy Cider Weapons
- 28:01Speaker 2: Skull dan A Miramar, and therefore there really wasn't much
- 28:05Speaker 2: that could be protected by copyright. And I have to say,
- 28:08Speaker 2: I mean, you said the judge went through this carefully.
- 28:09Speaker 2: I agree with you completely. Judge Anderson did a very
- 28:13Speaker 2: careful job here with this decision. He went through every
- 28:17Speaker 2: possible argument raised by the plaintiffs and succinctly described what
- 28:23Speaker 2: was wrong with those arguments as a matter of law,
- 28:26Speaker 2: which is going to make it very hard to appeal
- 28:29Speaker 2: this case to the Ninth Circuit.
- 28:30Speaker 3: Why did Paramount even get a license for the first movie?
- 28:34Speaker 3: It seems like they wouldn't have needed a license.
- 28:37Speaker 2: So in the age of copyright lawsuits, at the drop
- 28:41Speaker 2: of a hat that we live in, lawyers in house
- 28:45Speaker 2: at creative organizations such as Paramount Pictures had to be
- 28:49Speaker 2: very careful and the cost of getting a license here
- 28:53Speaker 2: was relatively inexpensive. They didn't have to give away much
- 28:56Speaker 2: credit in the movie for getting a license Swiss relatively
- 29:01Speaker 2: low as these things go. So I mean it made
- 29:03Speaker 2: sense even if the in house lawyer thought there was
- 29:06Speaker 2: no need to get a copyright license, why not get
- 29:10Speaker 2: it as an insurance mechanism. I sort of get it.
- 29:12Speaker 2: Although it did lead to these problems down the road
- 29:15Speaker 2: at that point in time, back in nineteen eighty four,
- 29:19Speaker 2: I think it was a very reasonable decision and the
- 29:22Speaker 2: part of the Paramount lawyers.
- 29:24Speaker 3: So Terry, will you go through some of what the
- 29:26Speaker 3: judge considered in making this decision.
- 29:29Speaker 2: So you know, the planet raised a number of alleged
- 29:34Speaker 2: similarities between the top the Maverick and this California magazine article.
- 29:40Speaker 2: I think I saw somewhere in the opinion as on
- 29:44Speaker 2: the order magnitude of seventy seven zero different alleged similarity.
- 29:49Speaker 2: And the judge source said they all fit into certain categories,
- 29:52Speaker 2: and he went through the category by category and pointed
- 29:55Speaker 2: out there are certain things that just not protected by copyright.
- 29:58Speaker 2: We talked about facts not protected. So the fact that
- 30:01Speaker 2: there is this top gun program, the fact that Navy
- 30:04Speaker 2: pilots that are selected to go through are the best
- 30:06Speaker 2: in the navy. Those are all factual elements that get
- 30:09Speaker 2: no protection whatsoever. But then there are literary expression elements
- 30:14Speaker 2: that also get no protection. So general plot ideas a
- 30:17Speaker 2: murder mystery, you can't protect that. You know, stock characters,
- 30:21Speaker 2: the detective solving the mystery, the British secret agent, you
- 30:26Speaker 2: don't get protection for that. And then there certain SEMs
- 30:28Speaker 2: are fair, which are sort of situations that arise naturally
- 30:33Speaker 2: out of the plot. So if you've got a World
- 30:35Speaker 2: War II drama set in Europe, the bad guys are
- 30:38Speaker 2: gonna be Nazis, right, and they're gonna be wearing SATs
- 30:40Speaker 2: Because you don't get to copyright that. All those things
- 30:43Speaker 2: are unprotected and the bulk of what was in the
- 30:47Speaker 2: California magazine article, which is the allegedly in French work,
- 30:51Speaker 2: fit into a category such as that.
- 30:53Speaker 3: The plaintiff's attorney said they disagree with the court's ruling,
- 30:57Speaker 3: particularly on summary judgment, and they will appear now. The
- 31:01Speaker 3: Ninth Circuit has warned against dismissing copyright lawsuits before allowing
- 31:06Speaker 3: experts to testify and hear. The judge excluded testimony from
- 31:10Speaker 3: the plaintiff's expert. How does that play in?
- 31:13Speaker 2: So the Ninth Circuit has caution district court judges about
- 31:16Speaker 2: dismissing copyright lawsuits at too early a point in the case,
- 31:20Speaker 2: particularly prior to jury trial. The defendants had brought a
- 31:24Speaker 2: motion to dismiss right after the complaint was filed, the
- 31:28Speaker 2: earliest possible time to get a dismissal. It's basically an
- 31:31Speaker 2: attack on the pleating itself, saying the way you've played
- 31:35Speaker 2: this doesn't amount to a cognizable legal claim. And the
- 31:39Speaker 2: court had heard that way back in November of twenty
- 31:42Speaker 2: twenty two. If I recall correctly and said, look, this
- 31:45Speaker 2: is way too early. I think within the four corners
- 31:47Speaker 2: of the complaints the judge that have within this, I
- 31:50Speaker 2: think there's enough to make out a cognizable legal claim,
- 31:53Speaker 2: but I'm not going to comment upon where this might
- 31:55Speaker 2: go in the future. So we go through discovery, we
- 31:58Speaker 2: get expert reports, and Paramount comes back at the end
- 32:01Speaker 2: of discovery. The last thing you do before the jury
- 32:04Speaker 2: trial and files most for summary judgment says you're on.
- 32:07Speaker 2: We're back. You said we needed to allow the facts
- 32:10Speaker 2: to be developed and get expert testimony. We did, and
- 32:12Speaker 2: we say this is still not a legally cognizable claim,
- 32:16Speaker 2: and therefore we should be entitled summery judgment. And at
- 32:19Speaker 2: that point I think the judge was perfectly within his
- 32:22Speaker 2: rights to consider such emotion and given what we now
- 32:27Speaker 2: know about those various alleged points of infringement, I think
- 32:32Speaker 2: the judge got it right and was allowed to do
- 32:33Speaker 2: this on summary judgment. Now there's a second question that's
- 32:37Speaker 2: raised by the plaintiff, which is, well, yes, you did
- 32:40Speaker 2: allow experts to give testimony, but you refuse to accept
- 32:46Speaker 2: the testimony of our expert. This is where it gets complicated.
- 32:50Speaker 2: In my view, it was not that the plaintiff wasn't
- 32:53Speaker 2: allowed to put up expert testimony in my view, I
- 32:55Speaker 2: think in the judges the plaintiff copyright owners put up
- 32:59Speaker 2: expert testimony that wasn't competent and relevant to the case.
- 33:04Speaker 2: The expert for the plaintiff had failed to take into
- 33:08Speaker 2: account any of these defenses to copyright and infringement. You
- 33:12Speaker 2: know that they're just facts, that their sins are fair,
- 33:15Speaker 2: that they're non protectable elements. The expert for the plaianffs
- 33:18Speaker 2: have just assumed everything was copyrightable. And the judge said,
- 33:21Speaker 2: you know, that's what this case is all about, whether
- 33:22Speaker 2: or not it's copyrightable, whether it's protectable in the first place.
- 33:25Speaker 2: You can't assume that away. Therefore, your expert opinion is
- 33:28Speaker 2: of no value here and we're not going to allow it.
- 33:30Speaker 2: And I again think the judge got that right, and
- 33:33Speaker 2: therefore I really do not think that that's a legitimate
- 33:36Speaker 2: complaint on appeal. I'm sure the plaintiffs will appeal to
- 33:39Speaker 2: the Ninth Circuit and raise this point, but judges have
- 33:43Speaker 2: enormous discretion at the trial court level into what testimony
- 33:47Speaker 2: they will allow into evidence what they will not, And
- 33:50Speaker 2: I just don't see the Ninth Circuit overturning his decision here.
- 33:53Speaker 3: And let me just say that you are on record
- 33:56Speaker 3: that when we discussed this case, when the suit was
- 33:58Speaker 3: first filed, you said it wasn't going to fly, so
- 34:02Speaker 3: to speak. So I just want to credit you for that.
- 34:05Speaker 2: Terry Well, I appreciate the question.
- 34:09Speaker 3: Anything.
- 34:10Speaker 2: You know, when you've been doing this as long as
- 34:12Speaker 2: I have, you sort of get a flavor for the
- 34:15Speaker 2: types of cases that get brought. And you know, one
- 34:18Speaker 2: of the really telling things to me was the planners
- 34:21Speaker 2: were only able to identify a single sentence, and the
- 34:26Speaker 2: sentences being generous because it's only a two word sentence,
- 34:29Speaker 2: a single sentence of dialogue that was similar between the
- 34:33Speaker 2: article and Top Gun Maverick the sequel. And that's one
- 34:37Speaker 2: of the things I always look for. Are there a
- 34:39Speaker 2: lot of similarities in dialogue? Are there really unique settings
- 34:43Speaker 2: that are similar? And here the only dialogue that was
- 34:47Speaker 2: similar was a phrase fight on, which apparently is the
- 34:52Speaker 2: code word at the Top Gun school that these pilots
- 34:55Speaker 2: used to say that the mock engagement is starting. And
- 34:59Speaker 2: again that's telling that that's the only dialogue similarity they
- 35:03Speaker 2: could come up with. And quite frankly, Idi itself is
- 35:06Speaker 2: not copyrightable because the Copyright Office does not allow copyrights
- 35:10Speaker 2: in short phrases that would come within that exception to
- 35:13Speaker 2: the rules. So when you look at and you see
- 35:15Speaker 2: no dialogue, similar, no settings that are really unique, and
- 35:19Speaker 2: just all these generalities, it's impossible to not have those
- 35:22Speaker 2: gut reactions that this isn't go anywhere. Do's greg get dismissed.
- 35:25Speaker 2: I guess I got it right this one.
- 35:27Speaker 3: You always get it right. But why appeal?
- 35:29Speaker 2: Then?
- 35:30Speaker 3: I'd say they're looking for some sort of settlement. But
- 35:32Speaker 3: is Paramount going to want to settle when top Gune
- 35:35Speaker 3: three is coming out and they have the win.
- 35:38Speaker 2: I don't know what this plaintiff's specific motivation will be
- 35:43Speaker 2: to appeal, And I can only tell you in general
- 35:46Speaker 2: how attorneys think about this. And you know, there's no
- 35:48Speaker 2: doubt that this had to have been I have no
- 35:50Speaker 2: inside information, but this had to be a contingent V
- 35:52Speaker 2: litigation where the lawyer only gets paid if they win.
- 35:55Speaker 2: So that's the factor. Second, Tops the Maverick made enormous.
- 36:00Speaker 2: I believe the box office gross was one point five billion. Yeah,
- 36:04Speaker 2: And I think it had to do something with the
- 36:05Speaker 2: timing of being one of the first released after the
- 36:07Speaker 2: pandemic and people are coming back in theaters and desperate
- 36:10Speaker 2: for content. But if you can believe this June, that
- 36:12Speaker 2: is the largest gross of any Tom Cruise movie of
- 36:16Speaker 2: all time. It's bigger than the Jackie Reach your movies,
- 36:18Speaker 2: bigger than any of the I don't all. We're up
- 36:20Speaker 2: to six or seven missions possible series. This is the
- 36:23Speaker 2: enormous amount of money. And you know, the argument for
- 36:26Speaker 2: damages if there was copyright infringement is that we're entitled
- 36:29Speaker 2: to the reasonable royalty based on that amount. And so
- 36:32Speaker 2: the amount at steak is enormous. And so when you
- 36:35Speaker 2: have large amounts at steak, even if you have a
- 36:38Speaker 2: minimal chance of success, you know, the math works out
- 36:41Speaker 2: that you ought to pursue the appeal on the off
- 36:44Speaker 2: chance that you get two out of three judges on
- 36:46Speaker 2: the appellate panels have some problem with what the district
- 36:49Speaker 2: court did. And of course the longer it drags out,
- 36:52Speaker 2: the hope on the planet side is always that defendants
- 36:54Speaker 2: get tired of paying their attorneys because this is expensive
- 36:58Speaker 2: sort of litigation, and then they might just consent to
- 37:00Speaker 2: the settlement and so they get some money out of it,
- 37:02Speaker 2: and you're right, pop gun free. The script is already
- 37:05Speaker 2: being written, their negotiations with director and other principal roles,
- 37:10Speaker 2: so it looks like it semi green. Lena ready, and
- 37:13Speaker 2: so there's that much more money to be had, and
- 37:15Speaker 2: that's my speculation in my opinion, based on past experience,
- 37:18Speaker 2: as to why they might appeal.
- 37:20Speaker 3: Well, you have a winning record on this show, Terry,
- 37:22Speaker 3: so I trust your opinions. Thanks so much. That's Terrence
- 37:26Speaker 3: Ross of Kata, Nutchen Rosenmann, and that's it for this
- 37:29Speaker 3: edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Remember you've can always
- 37:32Speaker 3: get the latest legal news by subscribing and listening to
- 37:35Speaker 3: the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at Bloomberg dot com,
- 37:39Speaker 3: slash podcast, slash Law. I'm June Grosso and this is
- 37:43Speaker 3: Bloomberg