Latest / Ask the Lawyer / 07/18/24 - Ask the Lawyer with Harvey Peyton including Baby Dog Justice Lawsuit

Transcript

07/18/24 - Ask the Lawyer with Harvey Peyton including Baby Dog Justice Lawsuit · Ask the Lawyer

0:00
Unlock your dream property with meex Realty Group, where Rich the realtor makes real
0:04
estate dreams a reality, whether it's residential or commercial. We've got Charleston to
0:08
Huntington covered. Your key to exceptional real estate experience is start here Meeks Realtygroup.
0:13
Contact us at Meeks dot us. The views and opinions expressed on this
0:18
program do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of five ADWCHS it's employees or
0:24
WVRC Media. Put the power of Peyton on the side. We have the
0:31
court room experience such you need. We never give up. We're prepared to
0:38
fight for your rights when you need action. Count on us puts the power
0:47
of Payson on your side, the power of me and good morning, and
0:53
it's eight twenty two on five eighty WUCCHS the Voice of Charleston on Jeff Jenkins
0:58
with Harvey Payton of Peyton Law Firm in Nitro. The number to call three
1:02
oh four three four five fifty eight fifty eight three oh four three four five
1:07
of fifty eight fifty eight. Harvey is here. I am here. How
1:11
you doing so well? Quite well? I don't think I can hear you
1:14
in my headphone. But we'll check that out. But since you're sitting right
1:17
across from me, I can hear what you're saying, looking, I can't
1:19
hear you through the headphones, but okay, we'll be fine. Well I'm
1:23
doing very well, can you hear me? Yeah? Well, it was
1:26
a nice drive up this morning. I certainly cooled off a good bit over
1:29
the last couple of days. And as I was driving up the valley road,
1:33
I was listening to Metro News and their local news, your local news
1:38
here, and I was listening to Nancy Bruyns, who's one of the Dickinson
1:42
ears up here at the Salt Company and a community leader. Apparently it's heavily
1:48
involved in this sports complex, which will not now be the Capital Sports Complex,
1:53
because there are capital sports complexes all over the country, So we're going
1:57
to find another name. I think that's sort of at the West Virginia International
2:02
Jaeger Airport, your Gateway to the World, which has changed the name,
2:07
announcing that there would be no swimming pool, which was one of the big
2:09
features. As I was listening to that, I was driving by the entrance
2:15
into the Valley Point in Putnam County, where yesterday Our announcement was they were
2:23
going to be over three hundred new housing units built right there off the Tayes
2:28
Valley Road. And what is this town of Hirk And I mean it's not
2:30
in the what we considered the town of Hurk and proper down around main Street.
2:35
It's about halfway down Tayes Valley Road. But that is a part of
2:38
the town of Hirk. And then Alan bell a really good solid citizen.
2:43
Allen. I haven't seen Allen maybe in twenty years, and never did anything
2:46
work for him. He was involved. He bought a piece of property down
2:50
in Point Pleasant or Henderson from a klein of mine a couple of decades ago.
2:54
He said, go get her. You know ab contract. They bought
2:57
the National Bank of Commerce building over here and converted in and bought a piece
3:01
of property down near the golf course from the Hawaiian Airs and put in old
3:06
probably sixty units of housing that sold out. So now we're going to have
3:09
three hundred more. The only distressing thing to me is that's about five hundred
3:15
yards from my house. And now we're going to have another traffic light,
3:19
which is good break up the traffic on the road because you put three hundred
3:23
homes back there. We're moving forward and not to be I mean, I
3:28
admire the polks and can lock out it for doing what they can do.
3:30
I saw Mayor Goodwin at the Bar Association meeting in Wheeling last Friday. Her
3:38
father in law, Joe Bob Goodwin was being honored by the Bar Association for
3:43
his long service as a district judge. And Amy's from Wheeling, so she
3:47
always enjoys going back to Ogilby, which is really really quite nice. But
3:53
it's tough. You know, you've got a city here that was built to
3:58
have eighty thousand people and not as less than fifty thousand. What do you
4:04
do with the detritis the excess and how do you provide for that infrastructure and
4:11
keep things going. It's tough cheese. So I really hope this sports complex
4:15
gets off the ground and does what the city hopes it will. We can
4:18
use more recreational facilities. But housing in Putnam County is when Mayor Edwins was
4:26
talking yesterday about at the grant at the announcement about the critical housing shortage in
4:32
Putnam County. Certainly we do have I mean, we've got new industry,
4:36
we've got new Core, which is near Putnam County. You've got the ever
4:41
expanding Toyota Plants, You've got the medical community in Tays Valley, light manufacturing,
4:47
you've got the power company. The power company is expanding down on Route
4:50
thirty four, and just no place for people to live on the next step
4:55
is some more moderate load of moderate income housing. This is going to be
4:59
high, as I understand it that Allen's building with a clubhouse and a pool,
5:03
et cetera, but more moderately rental priced apartments and houses would be a
5:13
big help. We've got a situation where folks at the service work end of
5:18
the economy, which they're not high dollar jobs, but there's a job,
5:23
and if it's a fifteen or eighteen dollars an hour job, that's that's what
5:28
you're qualified to do, and it's available. But if someone wants that job
5:32
and they live in Charleston and a restaurant closes here or some service facility closes
5:39
here, and you're living in Knaw County, in Charleston or Cedar Grove or
5:46
Allam Creek, well, can you drive every day to and from Hurricane or
5:55
Scott Depot or Tays Valley or Buffalo to do a service to work in the
6:01
service industry, childcare, What do you do about childcare? What do you
6:06
do about your gasoline, your automobiles, transportation expense? A lot of people
6:11
ride the bus. We have no bus service in Putnam County. So it
6:15
is at a point that I know because it's people who I know in respect
6:20
who are small business folks, most of them in the food service business,
6:26
who will drive, who will have a way to pick up drive and provide
6:30
transportation for their wage staff and kitchen staff just so they can get to work.
6:36
So I'm certainly admire Allen for his work, and I think the Mayor's
6:42
correct. This is going to address a pretty critical need and probably open up
6:46
some additional housing in Putnam County because folks who bought houses in the eighties in
6:51
the nineties that are now empty nesters, but they're sitting in a four bedroom,
6:58
two story house. I said, well, if I put this on
7:00
the market, where am I going to go? Maybe they don't want to
7:03
buy another house. So if they can move into a long term rental arrangement,
7:09
sell their house, put their money in their investment account, and live
7:12
comfortably, that opens up that house. Your original home on the market.
7:15
We'll see what happens. It's interesting. It's going to be a good thing
7:20
for the real estate agents and industry and the lawyers who do a lot of
7:26
real estate work, because we don't we do some And again I'll address this,
7:30
you know, I will stop at the courthouse today on my way from
7:34
here back to Nitro, the Kanaw County Courthouse, because the only way I
7:39
can check on whether a release was recorded that I need to help a cloud
7:46
of mine settle on a state is to go look it up on the computer
7:50
which is sitting on a counter at the corner of Virginia Street and Knaul Boulevard.
7:56
Now, if that was in Pottnham County, Cabal County, Wayne County,
7:59
Green Pendalton, Monroe, Logan, any number of other counties around the
8:03
state, I could sit at my desk and go online and look that up
8:07
and I wouldn't have to charge my client or take the time to run to
8:11
the courthouse for whatever reason. And I haven't heard I guess I've heard nobody
8:18
ask the question. It's not very exciting, but I haven't heard any county
8:20
commissioner address the issue. Why are your records not online? When almost every
8:26
surrounding county and almost every county in the state has some online record search capacity.
8:35
That's up to the people in kanaw County. I mean, if you
8:37
want to put up with it, put up with it. We wouldn't put
8:39
up with it. In Putnam County, we started computerizing records. Brian Wood
8:46
did probably twenty years ago. I'm proud of the fact that we represented the
8:52
county and a dispute against their insurance carrier because they had declined to pay a
8:56
claim arising from some deputies PA and we ended up recovering on the counties behind
9:03
several hundred thousand dollars, which Brian then glommed on to. Some of that.
9:07
I want some of that because I want to start putting these records online.
9:11
And now we are. You can look at everything, well not everything
9:16
when there's some books in the old books. But if you're a citizen in
9:20
kanawh County and you have to see one of these county commissioners, they just
9:24
ask who Mark Slotnik does title work. Now he's an interim he's only serving
9:30
an unexpired term. But once whoever's going to win this race, it's either
9:35
going to be Walters or Natalie Tennant. They just should answer that question.
9:41
Somebody should pose it, they should answer it. Three oh four three four
9:45
five fifty eight fifty Harvey. Payton's here three oh four, three four five
9:48
fifty eight fifty eight Harvey. I wanted to get your take. You know,
9:52
you keep up with the news, obviously your take about Saturday. What
9:56
happened in Butler. It was horrible, Yeah, absolutely horrible. I mean,
10:01
but you know, we've got a violent history in the United States.
10:07
Andrew Jackson was the subject of an assassination attempt. Abraham Lincoln was murdered McKinley
10:15
Garfield Kennedy. There was an attempt on Truman's life. Teddy Roosevelt was shot
10:20
as a candidate. FDR was well. When he was a president elect.
10:26
He was in a car with Anton Sermac, the mayor of Chicago. There's
10:30
an attempt on both their lives. The mayor was killed, Reagan was shot.
10:35
Gerald Ford was two legitimate attempts on his life. There was actually an
10:39
earlier attempt on the life of Jack Kennedy before he took office in December nineteen
10:46
sixty. After he was elected, he was vacationing with his family in the
10:50
Palm Spring, Palm Beach, when a man with a car load of explosives
10:56
was sitting outside the house waiting for Kennedy to come out to detonate the bomb
11:01
and kill him. M Kennedy came out, but he had Jackie and Caroline
11:05
with him, and the guy just crumpled. The Secret Service got him and
11:11
they eventually found the guy. He had written some notes who fell fell from
11:13
Wisconsin crazy and we'll find out that, you know what, not much you
11:18
can say about the shooter. It's like all of them, it's like they're
11:22
all mostly all they're all lone wolves that we know about. And he's ever
11:26
going to know what was in this fella's mind. He was looking on his
11:28
phone for images of both Biden and Trump. So Donald Trump may have just
11:33
simply been the target of opportunity. If it had been Joe Biden, it
11:39
could have been the same attempt. It's terrible, just terrible. But we'll
11:43
see, you know tonight. I guess is the Trump acceptance? He has
11:48
the Trump acceptance. Let's see what I mean. I refer to as President
11:52
Trump because it's an honorific I mean, he's the former president. But I
11:56
think you know, if you talk about President Bush or President Clinton or President
12:00
Obama. I mean, it's a term that stays with you. He was
12:03
once elected president of the United States. But I'm not for him. That's
12:07
just a given fact. But I don't hate him, and everybody has an
12:15
opportunity for redemption. Donald Trump is cast as an amoral, prevaricating person and
12:22
that, but that doesn't say that that person can't be better. I mean
12:26
he could accept. I mean he surrounds himself with preachers. I think they
12:35
can impose upon him to look, just open your heart, open your life,
12:37
to accept this higher power and live like the person God man you to
12:41
be, and govern this country that way. And he could say that publicly
12:46
and boom, it'll be interesting, Series says to absolutely. If I go
12:50
to the line now and Jay is on the line, Jay, go ahead
12:54
your own Harvey j H. To answer answer your question about the county.
13:01
There are six counties in the state that don't have online access now. Mingo
13:07
County is going on the end of this month, according to their clerk.
13:11
But it's can all Clay Braxton, Webster pleasants and Jackson and Jackson is supposed
13:18
to be on this here. Well, I appreciate. I mean, thanks
13:22
Jane, thank you very much. Jay. Again, my question is why
13:28
not well carper about this quite a bit. I mean, that's the question
13:31
for the people of Kanaw County to ask their elected officials. The County Commission
13:37
controls the budget. I mean, I don't think you can simply say,
13:39
well, the county Clerk doesn't want to do it. You control the county
13:41
clerk's budget, So if you control the purse strings, you control what goes
13:48
on. I don't understand. I can't understand it. I know I recognize
13:52
Jay's voice, and he is a person who is quite familiar with real estate
13:58
and the necessity just the lawyers, it's people like engineers who need to look
14:03
up a piece of property, surveyors who need to get started on a project
14:07
by looking up looking up deeds and descriptions. It's real estate agents and brokers
14:13
who need to take a quick look to find a dealer description. It is
14:18
people who are bankers who want to see if a particular release may have been
14:22
recorded or not. It's across the board or just a member of the public.
14:28
Can I tell people all the time here if you want to go look
14:31
at something in Putnam county. Just go to this website. Go to the
14:33
county Clerk's website, signing as a guest out. There may be a little
14:37
charge to do it as a guess. We have an open account. But
14:43
access this and you can look and see what If you want to see your
14:46
dad's will, well I've never seen that will. And maybe this person lives
14:50
in Ohio or Kentucky or Florida. So well, no matter where you are,
14:54
go online. If you've died sometime after nineteen ninety two, will book
15:00
record is online. And if you want to see what was listed as a
15:03
part of his estate, the appraisement forums there and if you want to see
15:09
who has identified as heirs, that's on the appraisement forum, along with the
15:13
final order closing the estate. So and that heads awful lot of acrimony among
15:22
families. Well I don't know anything. Well maybe you don't understand. Just
15:24
go online and look at it. Now. I look at records online.
15:26
For people that have on the phone all the time who call about a question.
15:31
He end up saying, look, you don't really need a lawyer on
15:33
this is This is not the sinister thing you think it is. This is
15:37
all on record. And if you want it, you can go online,
15:41
pay a fee and get it, or you can go to the courthouse and
15:43
get it for a fee. Why it's not done in the capital city.
15:48
What's now still I think the most populous county in the state. It won't
15:52
be. And Berkeley County is going to lap Kanall County I think in the
15:56
next clearly in the next census. But before then, before then, I
16:00
think, sorry very much for the info. And uh, six counties left.
16:06
We're maybe maybe maybe four after Jackson did I knew Jackson wasn't online,
16:12
but Jackson has a pretty good clerk's office exactly. Okay, let's uh oh,
16:17
I have take this text comment. Okay, Harvey before we go to
16:21
the break now with the home title insurance ads, I'm glad to hear that
16:25
we're protected by knagh County isn't online. I feel my property is more secure.
16:30
Well what's about what about the security about? Well, I mean it's
16:36
a secure as if you go online and buy buy a pair of underwear or
16:40
socks and give somebody your credit card number, and I mean how secure is
16:45
that transaction? It's secure? Is it's going to be? I mean that
16:48
is one of the things you pay for UH is UH is the security on
16:55
the site. And I'll let me say another thing about this. These ads
16:57
about buy this insurance against fraud on your own, well, it's a rip
17:03
for West Virginia period paragraph. I have my own opinion about title insurance,
17:10
you know, the title insurance that's forced on you by lenders when you borrow
17:15
money to buy a house. Mix. He had a conversation with one of
17:18
the title insurance regional representatives that they weren't happy with. But you know,
17:23
why is it that you can hire an agent, you know, employ these
17:27
lawyers as agents to sell your product, and say the premiums eight hundred dollars.
17:33
And the lawyer, because he sells your insurance, he gets the referral
17:38
to do the other work. He charges six seven hundred dollars to do a
17:41
title and to do to some document prep. And then there's a separate charge
17:48
of seven or eight hundred dollars for title insurance. And nobody discloses to the
17:52
consumer that the lawyer is getting sixty five or seventy percent of that is a
17:56
premium. Right, he's doing it to generate your business. And when you
18:03
get paid your premium, which is only like thirty percent or thirty five percent
18:07
of the total that the customer pays. Your total payout of claims is less
18:12
than one percent nationwide. Now tell me why that's not a ripoff, why
18:17
that's not an abuse of consumer protection laws. But apparents it's not. President
18:23
Biden through his administration. I think they're going to take some action. They
18:26
took the action has been taken already about and I trust aspects of multiple listing
18:34
services where you have the buyer pays both sides of a transaction. And if
18:41
you want to talk about lowering some costs, take a look at the title
18:42
insurance industry that's making a heck. They're all billionaires. The people have owned
18:48
these companies and with good reason, they don't pay any claims. Very few,
18:52
if less than one percent. You know, as State Farm what they
18:56
pay out, and they're the best underwriting company in the world. Ari State
19:00
Farm probably pays out twenty percent as a loss ratio, and they I don't
19:06
think that's acceptable. They don't like to pay any claims. But it's no
19:10
if you're concerned about security. I haven't seen any great rash of of fraudulent
19:18
lean recordings and free citizen recordings and all that stuff in Putnam County and we've
19:22
got a different system from most other counties and those other counties. I don't
19:27
hear anybody complaining and they've been online for ten years, so well, thank
19:33
thanks for the text question. Thank yea and three O four three four five
19:37
fifty eight fifty It's eight forty one. Harvey's with us lines are open.
19:41
The text line is open, and give us a caller, give us a
19:44
text. It's eight forty one back with Harvey on five eighty WHS. This
19:48
is Tom Payton, my father, Harvey and I are the Peyton Law Firm.
19:52
We live here, we grew up here, and we take pride in
19:55
representing you and winning against the most powerful members of the insurance end street.
20:00
If you want an experienced law firm that understands your needs and gets results,
20:03
contact Peyton Law Firm. When you've been hurt in an accident and times are
20:07
tough, you need lawyers you can trust. That's us Peyton Law Firm.
20:12
Contact us at Peytonlawfirm dot com or visit us at our office in nightrip Hey.
20:18
It's stay valid for Parmer stores. And now that the warm weather monster
20:22
here, you know where you need to be your local Parmer store, heading
20:26
to the lake, the ballfield, or your favorite picnic side are just working
20:30
around your place. Parmer has everything you'll need from gas, to grocery,
20:33
snacks, and much much more. Download the Palmer app and sign up for
20:37
the Parmar Rewards card Ohio, West Virginia, Kentucky, Maryland, Pennsylvania and
20:42
Virginia. If there's not a par of Our store near you now, there
20:45
will be set. Wow, it feels like summer just started, but time
20:49
sure is flying by, and before you know it, school will be back
20:52
in session this school year. Members Choice West Virginia can help you check off
20:56
everything on your school shopping list with a back to School line now through August
21:00
first. You can get all the school supplies you need with a back to
21:02
school loan of up to fifteen hundred dollars with rates as low as seven point
21:06
nine nine percent and at the twelve months to pay back. Apply today at
21:08
two to one Ohio Avenue in Charlson, or visit MCWV online at members choicewv
21:14
dot com. Lea's are Suption credit rovle Deditional restartions may apply. Make sure
21:18
you're retirement ready with City Wealth Management, a division of City National Bank.
21:22
Call your local city branch to schedule a complimentary review of your current accounts.
21:26
Good morning, here's your traffic update. In Boone County. A disabled vehicle
21:30
on US one nineteen south at Conall County Line. It's on the right shoulder
21:36
bridge Deeck repairs on West Virginia sixty one from mile marker twenty seven to mile
21:41
marker twenty seven point two. The eastbound right lane is closed. And a
21:45
disabled vehicle on I sixty four east at mile marker forty one, right before
21:49
Saint Aubans. Drive safely. I'm Chapel in the WCCHS Network traffic studio.
21:56
What the boy on the side. We have the court room experience such a
22:03
need, we never give up. We're prepared to fight for your rise.
22:11
When you need action. Count on us puts the power of pains on your
22:18
side, the power of and it's a forty three on five any WCHS the
22:23
voice of Charleston. Don't forget that. You can call us. Call Harvey
22:26
Harvey, Payton and the Peyton Law Firm in Nitro three oh four three four
22:30
five fifty eight fifty eight to be on the air, or the text line
22:33
is three oh four nine three five five zero zero eight. Three oh four
22:37
nine three five five zero zero eight, and Tim is on the line.
22:41
Tim, go ahead, You're on with Harvey. Tim. Are you there?
22:47
Yes? Okay? Go ahead, Tim, go ahead, you're with
22:48
Harvey. Okay. I see ads for the last couple of years in the
22:53
paper from a now of state legal firm advertising that if you had worked at
23:00
FMC prior to nineteen eighty two and suffered from a form of cancer, that
23:07
you may well have the grounds for acclaim. So I guess I've got two
23:14
questions, you know. Number one is this worth pursuing? And it would
23:18
concern actually my father? And the other question is why would I want to
23:25
do it with an out of state law firm. I'll hang up and listen
23:30
to the answer. All right, all question Harvey in reverse order. There
23:36
really would be no benefit to dealing with an out of state law firm.
23:41
We have more than perfectly competent lawyers here in West Virginia, in Kanaw County
23:49
and Putnam County, and our office Wheeling, Eastern Panhandle, all of whom
23:57
either as small for our practitioners like us or as part of larger firms,
24:06
deal with environmental employment issues with regularity. And even if it is a claim
24:17
that, for instance, in our office we may not deal with that particular
24:22
expertise with regard to an FMC claim, we can certainly listen to the history
24:32
that you have and then pick up the phone and call one of our brethren
24:37
at the bar here in West Virginia who can guide us and you through the
24:45
process and get you to some place where you can sit down and talk to
24:49
a lawyer here. Now, let's not to say that lawyers here may not
24:56
be affiliated with National Counsel on some matter. There's affirm ingm Ness Motley down
25:02
in South Carolina that they don't solicit clients to hire them as South Carolina attorneys.
25:14
They work with local attorneys to see that you get the best possible advice
25:19
and if need be representation that you can get. Now, I'm not saying
25:26
that whoever ran that ad may not be competent. I don't know. I
25:30
don't know who ran the ad, but I'm saying there's no advantage to you
25:37
in answering that ad. Now, the question about your father and whether it's
25:41
a viable claim, certainly many of these claims are worth pursuing for relatively significant
25:52
amounts of money. A lot of that depends on work history. It depends
25:57
on the type of answer, the day to death and things of that nature.
26:02
So my advice would be, if you're just even thinking about we can
26:04
call us. You can call me or talk to Tom and we'll get some
26:08
history from you. We'll see if we can't uh, if we can't help
26:12
you, we can point you in the direction to get somebody right here who
26:18
can do the job for we. S'll have an office you can actually go
26:21
to and sit down in and talk to your lawyer. Yeah, does that
26:25
make sense? Yeah, thank you, Tim. Yeah, he hung out,
26:27
he's hung up to Okay, Well, well thanks a lot, Tiam.
26:30
I mean that would be my answer. Yeah, three oh five,
26:32
seven five five fifty fifty five fifty six. That's correct. Yeah, seven
26:36
five fifty fifty five fifty six. I got another call Harvey. Good popular
26:40
God this morning. Mark. You're on the line with Harvey Payton. Go
26:42
ahead, good morning, Harvey. Uh. Hey, I got a tip
26:47
yesterday that Harvey was going to file a lawsuit against the state or the governor's
26:51
office or the Cultural Affairs office regarding baby Dog being depicted in the murals at
26:56
the Capitol. Is that true? And what would be the grounds for the
26:57
lawsuit? Okay, this is leads right into it. Well, I want
27:00
to talk about it a little bit. Go ahead, Thank you, Mark.
27:06
There have been a couple of stories I mean, and a column in
27:11
the gazette called Capital b and I Think or whatever it is on Sunday,
27:15
and then on Metro News last evening in an exet this morning about some lawsuit
27:21
relative to baby Dog. Let me say this. I have some clients who
27:26
are concerned about the manner in which the mural project in the Capital Rotunda was
27:37
implemented, and whether that project in Toto in total was implemented and what we've
27:45
got now, which is going to cost the state over a half million dollars,
27:51
was done in accordance with the law. The fact that there's a depiction
27:56
of the governor's pet in the final version simply drew attention to well, wait
28:06
a minute, if we can make these changes in this project in the two
28:11
months that elapse between it's unveiling in twenty twenty four, how did we get
28:15
this thing to start with? And so I'm looking into that on behalf of
28:25
clients. And we have a purchasing law in West Virginia for a reason.
28:32
I'm old enough to have sat in a courtroom in Kanah County back in nineteen
28:36
seventy and observed people being tried for bribery and conspiracy as a part of the
28:41
Baron administration because they managed to jockey contracts around so that there were essentially no
28:48
bid contracts. Now, I'm not saying that there's any criminality involved at all
28:52
in what may or may not have happened with regard to this Bureau project,
28:57
but I'm saying this. We have a Capitol Building Commission. It's been in
29:03
effect since the twenties when the Capitol burned down in downtown Charleson. A new
29:07
building is being built and it has been transformed. Its role has changed into
29:15
an agency or a sub agency that protects and preserves a building and building complex
29:22
that we all own, that is the Capitol Building. And there are specific
29:26
statutes which say that any contract, any contract that involves a change to the
29:33
physical structure or the esthetic appearance of the Capitol must be approved by the Capitol
29:38
Building Commission, and the action of the Commission in response to a request for
29:45
such approval must be in writing and must be submitted within ninety days of the
29:49
request for approval. Now all I have done on behalf of my clients has
29:53
asked the Commissioner and the the Department of Administration and the Purchasing Division to show
30:03
me that document. And the other factor is In twenty ten, Steve Canterbury,
30:15
who was then the State Supreme Court Administrator, made a motion on the
30:21
Building Commission he was a member, authorizing the quote preliminary steps to select an
30:30
artist or company to provide these period That was it preliminary. Now Purchasing acted
30:37
on that. They actually sent out a request for proposals, which they got
30:42
in June twenty ten, and by the end of June twenty ten they got
30:48
actual submissions from vendors. They had people signed vendors affidavits more than one and
30:56
then in April twenty eleven the vendors were sent a letter from pur saying this
31:00
project is canceled cncled right, So the preliminary work that was authorized by the
31:10
motion of Steve Canterbury, which was pursued through the middle of twenty ten,
31:15
was canceled by the Purchasing Division. Now we know that I have seen the
31:21
letters. I have asked for the other letters from administration and Purchasing, and
31:26
they have ignored my Foyer requests. Right, all we want to see is
31:30
the documents to prove that this was done correctly. We know that project was
31:34
canceled. Now, what we also know is sometime in twenty nineteen, the
31:42
then Curator of Arts, History and Whatever sent a request over to Purchasing to
31:48
treat this mirror project as a quote impossible to bid project. So what we've
31:56
asked for is what was the justification for converting a project that was submitted through
32:02
the bidding process in twenty ten? How did it become converted to an impossible
32:08
to bid project that can be so that the commissioner could select his favorite vendor
32:14
without bids eight years later, and again that was a Foyer request to the
32:20
Purchasing Division and to Mark Scott an administration that they simply have not responded to
32:25
in a timely fashion. There is a specific provision in the Purchasing Manual,
32:34
it's captured capital structure changes CAPATL not capitalism in money, which says no contract
32:47
can be awarded or let without for any change subject to the jurisdiction of the
32:57
CBC Capitol Building Commission US that contract is first approved in writing, and all
33:05
we've asked for is, well, let's see that writing. Where is it.
33:10
I attended the meeting of the Capitol Building Commission yesterday not because I care
33:15
about baby Dog. We all know about that debacle. But I just wanted
33:20
to see what their normal procedures are. And I watched while the Capitol Building
33:23
Commission listen to a contractor who's already been awarded a contract to rehabilitate and restore
33:31
the Holygrove Mansion, ask for approval about the wallpaper patterns, the paint color,
33:38
the height of a banister, the angle of a roof. I listened
33:43
to the Capitol Building Commission consider and approve the paint color and a third floor
33:47
bathroom in the west wing of the State House, the tile pattern on the
33:52
floor of that bathroom, and the appearance of the pedestal sinks right. So
33:59
in my mind, my question is I've just asked them to tell me,
34:01
well, if that's what you consider. I know that three years ago they
34:05
spent a whole meeting talking about replacing flood damaged carpeting with floating floor. If
34:13
that's the case. Tell me my clients, who represent the people of West
34:17
Virginia, they're citizens. Why these murals were not submitted, why there is
34:24
no and if there was a motion and an approval by the Capitol Building Commission,
34:32
where is it. I don't want to bring a lawsuit. My clients
34:37
don't want to get involved in litigation. But in order to have jurisdiction to
34:40
sue if we have to, we had to send a notice that we were
34:45
going to we may bring an action. That's all we did. That gives
34:52
us at least we can't do anything for thirty days from the date of that
34:54
notice. And I'm thinking, Okay, we'll send them the notice, We'll
34:59
ask for the information, and if we get the information showing that this is
35:02
not what it appears to be, well that may be the end of it.
35:07
Because what it appears to be right now, I mean, there was
35:10
a written contract signed by this canning company dated April twenty twenty two. But
35:20
where is the minutes or the order of the decision of the Capitol Building Commission
35:25
to approve that contract. I mean, I'm getting a transcript prepared of an
35:30
interview that the Secretary of Arts gave to Hopy Kerchival where he said, oh,
35:36
the contract was all done, this was all approved back in twenty ten.
35:39
Well, then just tell me why if it was done in twenty ten
35:45
canceled in twenty eleven, why that validates a contract that was signed in twenty
35:52
twenty two, And how did you send that over to purchasing and justify it
35:57
as a no bid contract? A no bid contract. What it looks like
36:01
is that they got some requests for proposals back in two thousand, some of
36:06
which were submitted by West Virginia Artists. Twenty eleven, twenty ten, twenty
36:12
ten. Yeah, found something they liked and then just trotted it over to
36:20
Purchasing nine years later and said, well, we have to do this on
36:24
a new bid basis so I can give this job to the people I like.
36:30
I'm not saying anybody's getting anything under the table. It's just I am
36:35
the boss and this is what I want. Now. That's just not what
36:38
purchasing's about. That's not what changes to the State House is about. Now.
36:43
It's got these people on the Capitol Building Commission and a crack. I
36:45
think you had Dave Marshall, an architect, Janelle Armstrong. You know an
36:52
engineer, Brent Boggs. So I forget Michael the fell from wheelings on.
36:57
There. You know, what are they going to say. I mean,
37:01
I suppose they could issue a statement to the press say well, we actually
37:05
did approve this, and here is the letter decision we made to approve it,
37:08
and we specifically discussed this contract back in April twenty twenty two and approved
37:14
it to spend a half million dollars on murals that had not yet been formulated,
37:23
they were in development. Now that's all this is about. It's not
37:25
about baby dog. That was the instigating factor to do attention to this.
37:32
It just to me it is unless it appears to be simply another extension of
37:39
the arrogance and disregard for the law that it appears who followed this project.
37:45
So there that's my answer. Peyton Law Firm in Nitri in Nitro. We're
37:49
thorough, we're good, and we're here to help you if you've been injured,
37:52
if you've suffered a loss in your family or financially or your property.
37:57
Tom Payton is the best lawyer under fifty in the state of westernin into practicing
38:00
right now. We're certainly the best law firm to represent your interests. If
38:05
you've had a problem in Patnam or Mason or Kanaw County or the Southern District,
38:09
go online to Peyton Lawfirm dot com. Send us an email. We'll
38:13
get right back with you, all right. That's three or four, seven,
38:15
five, five fifty five fifty six is the phone number. Then right
38:20
along first avenue there in nitro Ok. Stay tuned. ABC News is next
38:22
on five eighty WCHS.