Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / When Indigenous Identity Emerges After Sentencing
Transcript
- 0:27Mchael Mulligan: Well, it's uh what the background of it is this.
- 0:29Mchael Mulligan: So back in 2011, uh this fellow was uh charged with assault causing bodily harm, or he pled guilty to assault causing bodily harm.
- 0:38Mchael Mulligan: Um the background of the particular offense, the he was on a bus with somebody he had previously had some uh, I guess, bad dealings with in the past.
- 0:46Mchael Mulligan: They were arguing on the bus, the other bus passenger and he got off, the other person followed him, uh, and the accused pulled out a jack knife from his pocket and stabbed the person four times in the chest, armpit, and forearm.
- 1:00Mchael Mulligan: Uh happily he survived.
- 1:02Mchael Mulligan: Uh, but that was the basis of the original charge.
- 1:07Mchael Mulligan: Uh and ultimately, after some machinations uh in court, uh he agreed to plead guilty uh on the basis that uh the amount of force he used, if it was for self-defense, was excessive.
- 1:20Mchael Mulligan: Uh and that perhaps was no surprise given that during the course of a police interview um he told the police that while he believed he was acting in self-defense, he said he could have stopped after stabbing the person once, but he had to hold his ground.
- 1:34Mchael Mulligan: That was his explanation.
- 1:35Mchael Mulligan: Anyways, uh if you're using force for self-defense, it's got to be reasonable.
- 1:40Mchael Mulligan: And uh that comment probably took it outside that realm.
- 1:43Mchael Mulligan: So he wound up pleading guilty back in 2011.
- 1:47Mchael Mulligan: Um, and uh his lawyer, who's represented by counsel, came to an agreement with uh Crown, and there was what's referred to as a joint submission, where the Crown and the defense agreed in terms of what sentence should be imposed, and they agreed on an 18-month conditional sentence, like house arrest, basically, uh where somebody could be let out to go to work or things like that.
- 2:08Mchael Mulligan: Uh and the man served his sentence uh back in 2011, uh starting in 2011, uh, and then nothing more happened uh until uh recently, but in 2022 the uh man realized uh he uh found out for the very first time that his father was indigenous.
- 2:26Mchael Mulligan: Um and uh he uh after learning that information, he applied himself for um status, and it looks like he got that.
- 2:35Mchael Mulligan: Um and that brings us to the interesting grounds of appeal here.
- 2:41Mchael Mulligan: Uh the first part of which is uh an application for an extension of time to appeal.
- 2:46Mchael Mulligan: Because ordinarily, if you want to appeal, either a conviction or sentence, you need to do that within 30 days, right?
- 2:53Mchael Mulligan: You can't just wait a decade and appeal later.
- 2:56Mchael Mulligan: Um and uh so here the man applied for an extension of time to appeal uh both his guilty plea and the sentence that was imposed, even though he had served all of it.
- 3:08Mchael Mulligan: Uh and his argument for doing so um was that uh he had discovered this fresh evidence in 2022 uh that he was in fact indigenous, uh and his argument was that uh as a result of um some uh a provision of the criminal code at seven eighteen point two, um which says this, I'll just read that to you so it's aware of that.
- 3:30Mchael Mulligan: 718.2 sub E says this.
- 3:33Mchael Mulligan: All available sanctions other than imprisonment that are reasonable in the circumstances and consistent with the harm done to victims or the community should be considered for all offenders with particular attention to the circumstances of aboriginal offenders.
- 3:49Mchael Mulligan: So the criminal code has a specific provision dealing with the sentencing of aboriginal offenders, and that provision has been considered and interpreted by various courts, including the Supreme Court of Canada in a famous case called Gladue from 1999, um, that speaks about um uh sort of why that is and how that should be interpreted.
- 4:10Mchael Mulligan: Um and the the concept there is that there should be consideration given to things like unique systemic background and factors that might have brought an indigenous person to court, um, and uh the underlying um uh concern uh that uh indigenous people are massively overrepresented in the prison population.
- 4:31Mchael Mulligan: And so that's the rationale for the um that provision and why it is that indeed an indigenous person uh might receive a different and lower sentence than somebody who was not indigenous, uh taking into account their background.
- 4:46Mchael Mulligan: And so this man's argument was well, look, um had I known that I was indigenous back in 2011, um his argument was that uh he could have been treated in a completely different um fashion.
- 4:58Mchael Mulligan: He suggested that he may not have chosen to plead guilty, um, and that the sentence that uh would have been imposed back in 2011 um could have been different and less than uh what was indeed uh imposed when they did not know that he was indigenous.
- 5:12Mchael Mulligan: Um and so it brings into rather sharp relief the issue of like, well, how you know how should sentences work for somebody who's indigenous and not indigenous?
- 5:22Mchael Mulligan: That interesting fact pattern of somebody not knowing that they were indigenous.
- 5:26Mchael Mulligan: Uh and in fairness to him as well, in terms of the argument, um, there is also some uh authority for the proposition that you know where you can have a circumstance where somebody, for example, is you know not aware of their uh indigenous background.
- 5:40Mchael Mulligan: If you know somebody thought uh you know, family thought they shouldn't tell a child, or for some reason um thought it was better not letting them know that that can be even a consideration in terms of sort of loss of cultural identity and a consideration as well as part of that sentencing process.
- 5:55Mchael Mulligan: And so that's the fact pattern.
- 5:57Mchael Mulligan: Uh and the uh case wound up uh in the uh court of appeal, it was actually the second layer of appeal.
- 6:05Mchael Mulligan: Um and the first thing that the uh uh judge had to consider, the court of appeal, was the the test for uh an extension of time to appeal.
- 6:14Mchael Mulligan: Because as they mentioned earlier, you if you want to appeal, you're supposed to get on with that and give a notice of a your uh it plan to appeal within 30 days.
- 6:22Mchael Mulligan: And the list of traditional things to be considered there include did the person have uh an actual intention to appeal before the 30 days ran out?
- 6:30Mchael Mulligan: You know, like sometimes that happens and a person's like, well, they're just in prison and they can't get to the paper required to file the thing or don't have a stamp or something.
- 6:37Mchael Mulligan: You wouldn't want to deprive them of an appeal if they wanted to, but couldn't.
- 6:41Mchael Mulligan: Uh, did they inform the crown of their intention to appeal?
- 6:44Mchael Mulligan: That could be a factor, right?
- 6:46Mchael Mulligan: Um was there any prejudice to the crown as a result of not doing it in time?
- 6:50Mchael Mulligan: Importantly, is there any merit to the appeal, right?
- 6:53Mchael Mulligan: Uh and then finally, a broad consideration about whether it's in the interests of justice to extend the time to file your notice of appeal.
- 7:00Mchael Mulligan: So that was the that's sort of the intellectual legal framework in which this uh fellow's application was being considered.
- 7:07Mchael Mulligan: Um and the Court of Appeal pointed out here significantly that um while it is true uh that that uh provision of the uh criminal code uh does require specific attention uh to the circumstances of Aboriginal offenders uh when uh imposing a sentence, um the Court of Appeal first of all pointed out um that the man did in fact uh receive a non-custodial sentence.
- 7:34Mchael Mulligan: It was a house arrest, but he was not sentenced to an actual jail sentence at the uh time as in one that would have to be served in prison based on this joint submission that his lawyer came to.
- 7:45Mchael Mulligan: He was represented by counsel uh at the time he entered the uh guilty plea.
- 7:51Mchael Mulligan: Um and as well, the Court of Appeal pointed out uh that the man had not um had prepared what is referred to as a GLADU report, which is something named after that case that I mentioned, that sort of seminal Supreme Court of Canada case about sentencing of indigenous offenders.
- 8:07Mchael Mulligan: And a GLADDU report is something which would be prepared uh that would look at things like the person's background or systemic factors that might have led to somebody's offending, for example.
- 8:17Mchael Mulligan: Like some of the many of those things are genuinely tragic when you read them, right?
- 8:21Mchael Mulligan: You wind up with circumstances like you know, somebody who uh had just great deprivation as a child, or they may have had fetal alcohol syndrome, or they may have had uh disrupted home environment, uh all sorts of uh background, which unfortunately is too common for indigenous people.
- 8:37Mchael Mulligan: Uh but he had not provided that sort of information.
- 8:41Mchael Mulligan: His argument was, look, I'm indigenous, so I should have received, I didn't know that, and because that wasn't uh known, uh it meant that I wasn't sentenced appropriately at the time.
- 8:50Mchael Mulligan: Um and the court pointed out that the mere fact of being indigenous is not uh a basis for an adjustment in sentence.
- 8:59Mchael Mulligan: There has to be some tethering of that uh to those sort of legitimate considerations which are spoken about by the Supreme Court of Canada in that Gluidou case, and he hadn't had that sort of purport uh repaired, prepared, and there's no information about that.
- 9:13Mchael Mulligan: And the court pointed out that, you know, while this fellow is uh they described is understandably angry that he wasn't made aware of his indigenous uh status until his mid-30s, um, and uh he was uh upset that uh had he known that earlier, he might have benefited from um societal or financial supports or other things that could have made his life uh easier during that time period, and he didn't have those things because he didn't know about his uh background.
- 9:39Mchael Mulligan: Um, that there was no basis here to conclude that the sentence that was imposed was inappropriate, or that the um fact that the uh neither he nor his lawyer nor the judge who imposed the conditional sentence um, you know, they didn't know about his background.
- 9:55Mchael Mulligan: There's no indication that the sentence is inappropriate, or given the lack of any information about how his background impacted him, uh that it would have had any impact at the time.
- 10:05Mchael Mulligan: Uh and so as a result of all of that, uh the Court of Appeal, as the BC Supreme Court did, denied his application for an extension of time uh to uh appeal the sentence that was imposed, um pointed out that uh the man is pursuing other remedies, uh including apparently a civil action against his parents and against vital statistics for some reason.
- 10:28Mchael Mulligan: It's unexplained in the decision why it was he didn't know that his father was indigenous until he was in his thirties.
- 10:35Mchael Mulligan: Uh, but apparently the man is suing uh his parents and others uh uh trying to get some uh compensation for things that he might have missed out on uh as a result of not being aware of his indigenous status at an earlier time.
- 10:48Mchael Mulligan: So a very interesting, very recent case for the BC Court of Appeal that covers a whole lot of ground there just in terms of sentencing of indigenous offenders and how that uh can be different, um, and also that issue of, you know, can you come along uh many years later and ask that there be some change uh to what was imposed when you somebody finds out later they're indigenous, and that was unknown at the time.
- 11:11Mchael Mulligan: So that's the latest from the uh Court of Appeal uh on Indigenous Offenders and out-of-time uh sentence appeals and how those relate to that uh provision uh in the criminal code seven eighteen uh point two.
- 11:23Adam Stirling: Legally Michael Morgan will continue right after that.
- 11:27Adam Stirling: Michael Morgan is Michael.
- 11:42Mchael Mulligan: Well, this is a Victoria case, uh, and it it's interesting both for the outcome and I think also important for listeners to be generally familiar with this particular scam so they don't wind up in a similar position.
- 11:54Mchael Mulligan: And the background here um is that a woman uh in Victoria uh described in the judgment here as befriended someone she cannot was befriended by someone she cannot name, probably online if you have to guess that.
- 12:07Mchael Mulligan: Um and this uh new friend uh persuaded her to initially invest money in cryptocurrency.
- 12:14Mchael Mulligan: Uh in this case it was a cryptocurrency called Ethereum, through a competitor for Bitcoin.
- 12:20Mchael Mulligan: Um and originally she provided uh to this friend uh relatively small amounts of money, but uh five hundred dollars and a thousand dollars, and the new mysterious friend returned the money, the cryptocurrency, along with generous returns, which caused her to have trust in this person.
- 12:40Mchael Mulligan: Um and she got returns that amounted to one percent per day, so a very substantial return when you add that up.
- 12:48Mchael Mulligan: As the judge pointed out right at the beginning of her judgment, she said, if an investment proposal sounds too good to be true, it probably is.
- 12:56Mchael Mulligan: And so the friend, having uh built up trust in that way, uh then uh uh the uh persuaded the uh woman to uh take out further money and deposit it into the a cryptocurrency exchange, which is like a company that does cryptocurrency transfers and so on.
- 13:15Mchael Mulligan: And that's the entity which ultimately is getting sued in this case.
- 13:19Mchael Mulligan: Um and that cryptocurrency sort of exchange company, um, she the woman eventually deposited a total of six hundred and seventy-one thousand dollars into that, money which she raised by remortgaging her home and borrowing money from a friend and put all of this money into this uh cryptocurrency uh account, um, and then uh proceeded to uh uh uh try to transfer the money to this uh wallet of the mysterious friend she'd made who was giving these great returns on the smaller amounts of money.
- 13:52Mchael Mulligan: Now, this then brings us to the issue of who can be responsible for what everyone can tell is coming in this case, right?
- 14:00Mchael Mulligan: Um is there any obligation on like the cryptocurrency exchange company, right, uh to stop this kind of fraud?
- 14:11Mchael Mulligan: Um and there is a legal test for that, and it's born out of the general principle of the idea of negligence, right?
- 14:18Mchael Mulligan: Um and in order to succeed, if you're suing something like a bank or a cryptocurrency exchange for negligence, you need to, the plaintiff needs to establish a number of things.
- 14:28Mchael Mulligan: They've got to show that uh that person that you're suing or entity owed you a duty of care.
- 14:34Mchael Mulligan: You have to show that the uh conduct of the person you're suing fell below the standard uh standard of care for somebody who does owe you a duty of care, so is that concept of standard of care and duty of care?
- 14:45Mchael Mulligan: You then have to show that you sustained damages and that the damages were caused by the defendant's breach of their duty.
- 14:51Mchael Mulligan: That's the broad, those are the broad principles.
- 14:54Mchael Mulligan: And for financial institutions, uh that those things are uh and for example, like if you're suing a bank, the the standard there would be did the banker exercise a standard of care of a reasonable banker, right?
- 15:07Mchael Mulligan: So it doesn't require perfection, but there has to be sort of reasonable care taken by uh an entity like that.
- 15:14Mchael Mulligan: And there are cases that do stand for that proposition, right?
- 15:16Mchael Mulligan: Like a bank owes its customers a duty to exercise reasonable care and skill, discharging their obligations to their customers, right?
- 15:24Mchael Mulligan: Uh and there's also law in BC that suggests that uh where a like a bank or another financial institution would cover these kind of currency exchanges, um, where they have uh where they uh are aware of unusual circumstances, like um money being transferred in a way that's sort of out of accordance with the kind of account or purpose the person in an account for, or you know, the amount of money being transferred was you know very large in some contexts, right?
- 15:53Mchael Mulligan: Or there was something odd about uh the uh conduct of the transaction, or the bank had knowledge of similar scams uh targeting similar demographics.
- 16:02Mchael Mulligan: There can be circumstances where a financial institution does owe a duty of care, and if they fell below the standard of a reasonable banker or cryptocurrency exchange, there could be liability there.
- 16:14Mchael Mulligan: So that's what she was arguing, is well, this is the fault of this uh currency cryptocurrency exchange.
- 16:20Mchael Mulligan: They should not have uh allowed the allowed her to ultimately transfer the six hundred seventy-one thousand dollars to her new mysterious friend's uh cryptocurrency account.
- 16:31Mchael Mulligan: But here there was uh a very considerable amount of evidence about efforts the cryptocurrency exchange made, much to their credit, I've got to say, uh, to try to stop her from doing this.
- 16:43Mchael Mulligan: First of all, the cryptocurrency exchange complied with all like the FinTrack requirements for financial tracking of uh proceeds of crime, that kind of thing.
- 16:52Adam Stirling: Yes.
- 16:53Mchael Mulligan: Uh and before they even allowed her to sign up, they sent a general warning to her and anyone else who's signing up, telling them don't send cryptocurrency to untrusted wallets can result in permanent loss of funds, warning people in a general way about cryptocurrency scams and you know, uh don't respond to unsolicited messages and so on.
- 17:12Mchael Mulligan: Uh and she acknowledged she read all of that and clicked, you know, I accept.
- 17:15Mchael Mulligan: Fair enough, right?
- 17:16Mchael Mulligan: I guess every uh agreement, uh anything you sign up for these days will have a bunch of warnings.
- 17:20Mchael Mulligan: But not just that.
- 17:22Mchael Mulligan: When she went to do something, a secondary written warning was sent to her, telling her that you know, if you transfer funds in this way it's irreversible and the exchange is not liable for your losses, and she got that as well.
- 17:32Mchael Mulligan: Furthermore, when she tried to transfer all this money, uh a diligent employee at the cryptocurrency exchange took the time to call her and warned her that she is likely being scammed and she should not proceed with the transaction.
- 17:46Mchael Mulligan: So an actual human call telling her, Don't do this, um, which was recorded.
- 17:52Mchael Mulligan: Uh uh, there's then a follow-up call from a supervisor telling her again, don't do this.
- 17:58Mchael Mulligan: It looks like a scam.
- 17:59Mchael Mulligan: Uh and that one was recorded.
- 18:02Mchael Mulligan: The woman said agreed that that was her voice, but claimed somehow that it wasn't a complete recording, although she couldn't recall what was missing from it.
- 18:10Mchael Mulligan: Then uh the woman, in response to this third this extra call from the supervisor telling her, don't do this.
- 18:16Mchael Mulligan: Um, she told the supervisor in the recording she knew what she was doing, no one could control her, uh, and that she'd been trading for over twenty years, she understood the risks of trading cryptocurrency, uh, and then she threatened to sue the cryptocurrency exchange if they didn't complete the transaction promptly.
- 18:32Mchael Mulligan: Uh she did that in writing.
- 18:34Mchael Mulligan: Okay.
- 18:35Mchael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 18:36Mchael Mulligan: You know, both in the call and then uh follow up multiple email messages uh threatening to sue if they didn't hurry up and complete this transaction.
- 18:46Mchael Mulligan: And so eventually, despite their various efforts to tell her don't do this, um, she insisted.
- 18:53Mchael Mulligan: Uh and upon being threatened and told repeatedly in writing and personally, they did it.
- 18:58Mchael Mulligan: The cryptocurrency exchange did what she demanded they do.
- 19:01Mchael Mulligan: Uh and so the cryptocurrency exchange sent the six hundred and seventy, whatever it was, thousand dollars or mortgage money and money from the friend off to the uh cryptocurrency wallet of the unknown per friend that she'd met, and that was gone.
- 19:16Mchael Mulligan: Um and so as a result of all of that, you know, well the judge said, yes, there is a duty of care owed here.
- 19:22Mchael Mulligan: Certainly what the cryptocurrency exchange this in that did in this case met the uh standard of care of a reasonable cryptocurrency exchange, telling her repeatedly, stop, stop, stop, this is a likely scam, it's a likely scam.
- 19:36Mchael Mulligan: She argued that they should have been even clearer telling you, telling her that they knew this was a scam was account was a scam.
- 19:43Mchael Mulligan: Uh but uh again, the cryptocurrency exchange, they actually had in place uh uh some sort of a technical program to try to determine whether the risk associated with different cryptocurrency accounts might be.
- 19:54Mchael Mulligan: So they're obviously doing some things here.
- 19:57Mchael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 19:57Mchael Mulligan: Uh and that particular wallet she was trying to transfer the money to had a score that didn't indicate it had previously been flagged for fraudulent activity.
- 20:05Mchael Mulligan: And that wasn't challenged.
- 20:07Mchael Mulligan: And so the cryptocurrency exchange position at this trial, and judge accepted, was they just they didn't know that this was a scam.
- 20:14Mchael Mulligan: They didn't know that account is a scam account, but all signs were pointing to that, and that's why they kept telling her stop, stop, stop, uh, and she wouldn't listen.
- 20:23Mchael Mulligan: Um, and so even though there was a duty of care, uh they met it here.
- 20:28Mchael Mulligan: It looks like in spades with all these efforts to tell her to stop.
- 20:31Mchael Mulligan: Um, and so the uh the claim was dismissed, not surprisingly, I don't think, on that fact pattern, and now there's been costs awarded against her for having unsuccessfully sued the cryptocurrency exchange.
- 20:43Mchael Mulligan: So there's several important things in wrapped up in all that.
- 20:46Mchael Mulligan: There can be a duty of care, right?
- 20:48Mchael Mulligan: Obviously, this company was doing its best to try to stop her, but it's also an example of somebody who, you know, you start getting dollar signs in your eyes because you saw, look at getting 1% every day, and look, they gave me this money back at the beginning.
- 21:00Mchael Mulligan: Somebody would be just very, very tempting to try to continue uh with that.
- 21:05Mchael Mulligan: And as the judge said, if an investment proposal sounds too good to be true, it probably is.
- 21:10Mchael Mulligan: And so uh this isn't going to be an isolated thing.
- 21:13Mchael Mulligan: As they said, this is a Victoria case.
- 21:15Mchael Mulligan: And so uh if you're contacted with this kind of an investment opportunity by somebody, even if you think, oh, look, they've uh come through uh with these amounts I've previously provided, that does not mean uh that eventually once they've uh hooked you, uh you're going to get your money back with the big promised uh returns.
- 21:33Mchael Mulligan: So very terrible story.
- 21:35Mchael Mulligan: She'll be left with a big mortgage on her home and money to her friend, but it's not the cryptocurrency exchange's fault.
- 21:40Mchael Mulligan: And so when you do these things, don't assume there's going to be somebody there to catch you.
- 21:44Mchael Mulligan: So that's the latest on cryptocurrency scans right here in Victoria.
- 21:47Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Advanced Lawyers.
- 21:49Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 21:53Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.
- 21:53Adam Stirling: All right, quick break.
- 21:54Adam Stirling: News is next.