Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Why Amazon's stock fell despite record earnings?
Transcript
- 0:00You know, normally when a massive company announces that
- 0:03they just completely shattered their earnings estimates, Wall
- 0:07Street throws an absolute party. Oh yeah, totally.
- 0:10The stock rockets up, everyone goes home happy.
- 0:12Right. It's supposed to be this clean,
- 0:14simple cause and effect. But then you look at Amazons
- 0:17first quarter 2026 earnings and you realize you've just walked
- 0:21into this bizarre alternate reality.
- 0:24Yeah, the numbers were, well, they were staggering.
- 0:26Insane. I mean they just posted an eye
- 0:28watering $30.3 billion in net income for the quarter.
- 0:32They blew past estimates by over 70% and in response the stock
- 0:35actually tanked in after hours trading.
- 0:37Which, you know, it defies basic financial gravity.
- 0:40On the surface, you win the quarter that decisively you
- 0:43generally expect to get rewarded.
- 0:45Exactly. So today we are figuring out why
- 0:47that logic completely flipped. We're tearing into this massive
- 0:51equity research report that breaks down those Q1 earnings,
- 0:55maps out Amazon's hidden profit engines, and runs a really
- 0:59strict, ruthless deep value analysis on the stock itself.
- 1:03It's a huge report, yeah. Lots to get into.
- 1:05Definitely, but before we get to the bottom of this paradox, a
- 1:08quick note for you to access more advanced researches,
- 1:11applications, and our latest personal deep value agents.
- 1:14Welcome to explore and join Deep Values dot AI frac Total market
- 1:19temperature. Welcome to Search and download
- 1:21iOS App Buffett Indicator from Apple App Store or Bubble Watch
- 1:26from Google Play. Always good to have those tools.
- 1:28Right and also disclaimer All analysis is based on publicly
- 1:33available sources and may be subject to revisions or
- 1:35differing interpretations. All contents from this channel
- 1:38is for research and entertainment purposes only and
- 1:41does not constitute any investment or financial advice.
- 1:45Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 1:47financial decisions. Don't forget to like this video.
- 1:50Much appreciated. Awesome.
- 1:51OK, all right, back to the paradox.
- 1:54I'm looking at your backdrop today, by the way.
- 1:55This like glowing, sprawling cityscape of digital and
- 1:59physical infrastructure. It feels like we are staring at
- 2:01the literal grid of the Internet itself.
- 2:03Yeah, well, that was the goal today because to understand
- 2:07Amazon's numbers right now, you really have to stop thinking of
- 2:09them as just a retail store. Right, the whole everything
- 2:12store label is kind of outdated. Completely.
- 2:14You have to view them as this digital and physical metropolis.
- 2:18You have to understand the underlying infrastructure to
- 2:22make any sense of those wild headline numbers we just saw.
- 2:25OK, let's unpack this starting with those Q 12026 numbers,
- 2:30because when you first glance at the sheet, it looks like an
- 2:33absolute monster of a quarter. Oh.
- 2:34Absolutely. The sales hit $181.5 billion,
- 2:39which is what, a 17% jump from the year before?
- 2:4217%, yeah. And then you have that net
- 2:44income figure, 30.3 billion on the bottom line.
- 2:48That breaks down to $2.78 per share when Wall Street was only
- 2:52expecting $1.63. Right.
- 2:54It's a massive beat. But reading through the
- 2:56research, it becomes pretty clear that the accounting rules
- 2:59are creating a bit of a mirage here, right?
- 3:01Yeah, what's fascinating here is how a single line item can
- 3:04completely distort a company's operational reality.
- 3:07How so? Well, that 30.3 billion is real
- 3:10money technically, but it was not generated by, you know,
- 3:14moving cardboard boxes or hosting websites over the last
- 3:1790 days. Wait, really?
- 3:18Where did it come from then? Over half of it, like 16.8
- 3:22billion to be exact, was a pre tax valuation game from an
- 3:25equity investment Amazon made in the AI startup Anthropic.
- 3:28Oh wow. OK, so let's breakdown how that
- 3:30works for a second. That means it is essentially a
- 3:33paper game. Exactly.
- 3:35They own a piece of a company that became significantly more
- 3:38valuable. So they have to like report that
- 3:41increased value is income even though nobody actually handed
- 3:45them 16.8 billion in physical cash this quarter.
- 3:48Yeah, the accounting rules literally require them to mark
- 3:51that investment to market. So it just sits there in their
- 3:54non operating income puffing up the bottom line.
- 3:57Got it. If you strip that paper gain
- 3:58out, Amazon's actual core operational net income was
- 4:03closer to 13.5 billion. Which OK, 13.5 billion in
- 4:07operational profit for a single quarter is still staggering.
- 4:10Oh, it's a phenomenal performance, but it is not the
- 4:13$30 billion miracle the headlines were screaming about.
- 4:17Right, so this headline profit is basically like bragging about
- 4:20making $100,000 this year but forgetting to mention that
- 4:2480,000 of it was from a single lucky hand of poker while
- 4:28simultaneously taking out a second mortgage to build a
- 4:30casino in your backyard. That is, yeah, that's actually a
- 4:34brilliant way to put it. And the market definitely
- 4:36noticed that second mortgage you.
- 4:37Mentioned the spending. Exactly.
- 4:38That is the fundamental reason the stock dropped, because while
- 4:41the retail investors were looking at the poker winnings,
- 4:44the institutional investors were looking at the cash flow.
- 4:47And it wasn't pretty. No, Amazon's trailing 12 month
- 4:51free cash flow went into a complete freefall.
- 4:55It plummeted from 25.9 billion down to a measly 1.2 billion.
- 5:00Wow. That is a drop of nearly $24
- 5:03billion in free cash flow. I mean that money has to be
- 5:06going somewhere physical. We are talking about capital
- 5:09expenditure here, right, CapEx? Yes, CapEx, which is basically
- 5:12just the cash a company spends to buy, I maintain or upgrade
- 5:16its physical assets. And in Amazons case, this cash
- 5:19drop was driven entirely by a massive $59.3 billion year over
- 5:24year increase in property and equipment purchases. 59 billion
- 5:28in new purchases, just casually. Right, because they are
- 5:32currently locked into this unprecedented $200 billion
- 5:36capital expenditure plan. We are witnessing an AI
- 5:39infrastructure super cycle. So what are they actually buying
- 5:42with all that? They are aggressively building
- 5:44out huge new data centers. They're fabricating their own
- 5:47custom AI silicon, the Tranium and Graviton chips, and
- 5:52launching the Project Kuiper satellite broadband network.
- 5:55$200 billion. I mean, even for a giant like
- 5:58Amazon, that is an unfathomable amount of money to sink an
- 6:02infrastructure all at once. It really is.
- 6:03If I am an investor, seeing cash flows just evaporate like that
- 6:06to fund future tech projects makes me incredibly nervous.
- 6:10It completely explains the after hours sell.
- 6:12Off right, it's terrifying if you don't see the big picture.
- 6:15But management, however, views this not as a reckless spending
- 6:18spree, but as an absolute existential defense mechanism.
- 6:21Defending against 2. Mostly Microsoft and Google.
- 6:24Look Amazon Web Services. AWS currently holds roughly a 30
- 6:29Watt under 33% market share in global cloud infrastructure.
- 6:33They're the king of the cloud. For now, but Microsoft and
- 6:35Google are deploying their own massive AI data centers.
- 6:39If Amazon does not build the physical foundation for this
- 6:42next generation of generative AI right now, they risk losing
- 6:47their most lucrative business mode entirely.
- 6:50Yeah. That scale of spending forces
- 6:52you to look at where the cash is actually coming from to fund all
- 6:54this. Exactly.
- 6:55Because when you ask someone on the street what Amazon is, they
- 6:57think of the cardboard boxes with the Smile logo sitting on
- 7:00their porch. They think of retail.
- 7:02Naturally, but. The math in this report
- 7:04completely shatters that perception.
- 7:06It really does. The website you visit to buy
- 7:08running shoes or you know, toothpaste is essentially just a
- 7:11top of funnel customer acquisition tool.
- 7:13Just a way to get people on the. Door.
- 7:15Exactly. First party retail, where Amazon
- 7:17actually buys a product, stores it, and sells it to you
- 7:20directly, accounts for about 37.5% of their total revenue.
- 7:25That's a huge shunk of revenue. It is, but the operating margin
- 7:28on that is razor thin. It's estimated at just one to 3%
- 7:32for every $100 you spend. They might be keeping a dollar
- 7:35or two in actual profit. So the website that everyone
- 7:38thinks is Amazon is actually just a loss leader.
- 7:41It's the world's most expensive billboard, used to trap you in
- 7:45an ecosystem where they make real money off the ads you see
- 7:49and the server is running the Internet you use.
- 7:51Bingo. Behind that billboard are the
- 7:54real profit engines. Right, let's talk about those.
- 7:56The first big one is third party seller services, which now makes
- 8:00up 24% of their revenue. Wow.
- 8:02Yeah, that segment is actually larger than AWS in terms of
- 8:06revenue. This includes all the
- 8:07fulfillment fees, the shipping fees and marketplace commissions
- 8:11they charge to independent merchants.
- 8:13Because the merchants really have no choice but to sell that.
- 8:15Exactly because that is where the buyers are.
- 8:18It's the network effect. Right.
- 8:19And then there's the advertising side.
- 8:21The report highlights they brought in $69.4 billion in high
- 8:26margin commerce intent advertising.
- 8:29It's a goldmine. It makes total sense when you
- 8:31think about it. Brands are willing to pay
- 8:33astronomical rates to show up at the very top of your search
- 8:36results on Amazon because you aren't just like scrolling past
- 8:40photos of your friends vacations.
- 8:41Right, you're not on Instagram. You are on the site with your
- 8:43credit card out ready to buy. It is arguably the most valuable
- 8:47digital real estate in the world for an advertiser because the
- 8:51intent to purchase is already there.
- 8:52Yeah, that's huge. And then of course there is the
- 8:54crown jewel AWS. It only accounts for 17.9% of
- 8:59their total revenue. But get this?
- 9:02It generates over half of Amazon's corporate operating
- 9:05profit. Over half the profit from less
- 9:07than 1/5 of the revenue. Because the segment margin for
- 9:11AWS is approaching 38%. OK, let's translate that for a
- 9:14second to really grasp the scale.
- 9:16A 38% segment margin means for every dollar AWS brings in by
- 9:21renting out cloud computing power, they're keeping roughly
- 9:25$0.38 in operating profit. Yes, compared to the one or two
- 9:28cents they keep from selling you a physical product, it is night
- 9:31and day. It is the financial engine that
- 9:33funds the entire operation, and the behavioral glue holding this
- 9:37massive structure together is prime.
- 9:39Oh, of course. There are 260 million global
- 9:43members, with 185 million in the US alone, and the behavioral
- 9:48psychology of a prime member is fascinating.
- 9:51How so? A US member spends an average of
- 9:54$1400 annually compared to just $600.00 for a non member.
- 9:59Because once you have paid that subscription fee, you feel
- 10:01compelled to use it for everything.
- 10:03You stop comparison shopping on other sites because you want to
- 10:06get your money's worth out of the free shipping.
- 10:08Right, and that intense loyalty provides the sheer volume Amazon
- 10:12needs to optimize its physical network, which they really
- 10:16needed to do because during the pandemic they overbuilt their
- 10:18warehouses. I remember that their logistics
- 10:21costs skyrocketed to the point where their North American
- 10:24operating margin actually went negative for a bit.
- 10:26Yikes. But recently they overhauled
- 10:28their entire fulfillment architecture, shifting from a
- 10:31national model to 8 regional nodes across the US.
- 10:34So instead of a package flying across the country from a
- 10:37central warehouse in California to New York, it is just moving a
- 10:41few hours down the highway from a regional hub.
- 10:43Exactly. That cuts up the planes in the
- 10:45long haul trucking. It drastically lowers the cost
- 10:48per unit shipped by reducing those transportation distances
- 10:51that. Makes a ton of sense.
- 10:53And that single architectural shift pushed their North
- 10:56American operating margin back up to a healthy 10.8%.
- 11:00So I want to ask you, the listener, to pause and consider
- 11:03something. What stands out to you here?
- 11:06Is it the sheer logistical nightmare of managing 600
- 11:10million distinct products across those regional nodes?
- 11:13Or is it how invisibly Amazon has integrated into the backbone
- 11:17of the Internet itself through AWS?
- 11:20Man it's the invisibility of AWS for me.
- 11:22Most people interact with it every day without knowing it
- 11:24totally. But, you know, executing A pivot
- 11:27this massive willingly destroying your own cash flow
- 11:31for the $200 billion AI bet that requires a management team that
- 11:35is completely immune to Wall Street's pressure.
- 11:37Oh, without a doubt. And the research highlights some
- 11:40intense friction right now between Amazon's leadership and
- 11:44the outside world. Yeah, CEO Andy Jassy and the
- 11:47executive team are notoriously stoic.
- 11:50They refuse to play the typical Wall Street game of giving
- 11:53detailed forward guidance beyond the immediate upcoming.
- 11:56Quarter which analysts hate. They despise it, but management
- 12:00focuses almost entirely on long term enterprise value, largely
- 12:04because of how they are compensated.
- 12:06Executives receive almost no short term cash bonuses based on
- 12:10quarterly metrics. Barely any.
- 12:12They are paid in time vested restricted stock units or RSU.
- 12:17If the multi year value of the stock does not go up, their
- 12:20compensation flatlines. Oh wow, so they have to think
- 12:23long term. Right.
- 12:24Add in the fact that Jeff Bezos still owns about 10.8% of the
- 12:27company and shares the board and you have a culture heavily
- 12:30insulated against short term market demands.
- 12:32So what does this all mean? If management gets paid in stock
- 12:35regardless of quarterly performance and they justify
- 12:38massive cash draining CapEx as long term investments, how do
- 12:42investors know they aren't just empire building?
- 12:44It's a fair question. Like, how do we know this 200
- 12:47billion isn't just a blank check for executives to play with
- 12:50shiny new AI toys while ignoring profitability?
- 12:53Well, if we connect this to the bigger picture, the standard way
- 12:56we measure whether management is actually creating value with
- 12:59that retained cash is a metric called return on retained
- 13:02earnings. Over the last 10 years, instead
- 13:05of paying out dividends or executing massive stock
- 13:09buybacks, Amazon kept roughly $275 billion in earnings inside
- 13:14the company. That's a lot of retained cash.
- 13:16It is, But during that same period, their net income grew by
- 13:20nearly $88 billion. Oh, so it's like having a choice
- 13:24between taking your money out of the bank to buy a fancy car or
- 13:28leaving it in a high yield savings account.
- 13:30Pretty much if your savings account is consistently
- 13:32generating massive returns, you leave the money in the bank.
- 13:35Yeah, Amazon is proving they are the ultimate high yield account.
- 13:39For every dollar they keep, they generate a massive amount of new
- 13:42profit. Exactly That return historically
- 13:45exceeds the 12% benchmark most value investors demand.
- 13:49They have proven they can take retained cash and turn it into
- 13:52highly profitable logistics and cloud networks.
- 13:56But maintaining this trajectory is not happening in a vacuum.
- 14:00There are significant structural headwinds they're dealing with.
- 14:04Yeah, let's look at those headwinds objectively, just
- 14:06laying out the facts in the report without taking sides on
- 14:09the regulatory front. In 2025, the FTC hit them with a
- 14:13$2.5 billion charge. Yeah, that was a big.
- 14:17One, this centers around their dual role.
- 14:19They run the marketplace, but they also compete directly
- 14:21against the third party merchants who rely on that very
- 14:24same marketplace. That is a massive conflict of
- 14:27interest target on their back. Internally, too, there is rising
- 14:30friction with their own shareholder base regarding
- 14:32environmental, social and governance issues.
- 14:35ESG stuff. Right.
- 14:36During the 2026 Annual General Meeting, activist investors
- 14:40actually organized a Vote No campaign against specific board
- 14:44members. Jonathan Rubenstein, the chair
- 14:46of the Nominating and Corporate Governance Committee, only
- 14:49managed an 88.64% support rate when you exclude insider shares.
- 14:54And for an uncontested corporate director, that is unusually low.
- 14:58Very low. It shows real discontent.
- 15:00What are the shareholders specifically protesting through
- 15:03these votes? The primary proposals focused on
- 15:06the climate impact of all those new AI data centers,
- 15:09specifically demanding audits on their massive power consumption.
- 15:13Because those things drain the grid.
- 15:14Exactly. There were also proposals
- 15:17regarding ongoing unionization efforts within the warehouse
- 15:20network. The board routinely recommends
- 15:23voting against these measures, but the fragmented vote
- 15:25indicates that institutional patients is wearing thin on
- 15:28these issues. And you know, as a reminder, we
- 15:31are strictly looking at the structural risks and boardroom
- 15:34friction outlined in the research here.
- 15:36We're not endorsing any political stance on either side
- 15:39of the ESG debate. No, of course not.
- 15:41We're just reading the temperature of the room and the
- 15:44room is clearly getting a bit heated.
- 15:46Yeah, definitely. So with all that boardroom
- 15:49friction, the regulatory targets on their back, and the
- 15:52incredible cash burn for the AI stuff, you might assume the
- 15:56stock would be trading at a massive discount right now.
- 15:59You would think so. But when we look at the
- 16:00valuation, the market is doing something incredibly
- 16:04counterintuitive. Yeah, it really is.
- 16:07If you try to value Amazon using traditional deep value
- 16:10methodology like the strict Benjamin Graham tests, it is a
- 16:15bloodbath. A bloodbath.
- 16:16It fails almost every single metric.
- 16:18Wow. The price to earnings or PE
- 16:20ratio sits at 28.6. Yes, that is way down from the
- 16:24150 times earnings they used to trade at.
- 16:26But a strict value investor wants APE under 15, right?
- 16:30The price to book ratio is 5.9, failing the 1.5 threshold.
- 16:34And as we discussed earlier, current free cash flow is deeply
- 16:37negative. Here's where it gets really
- 16:39interesting. Applying traditional Benjamin
- 16:41Graham value metrics to Amazon sounds like trying to measure
- 16:44ocean temperatures with a meat thermometer.
- 16:46Yeah, it's just the wrong tool for an entity that intentionally
- 16:50destroys its own cash flow to build monopolies.
- 16:53Graham's rules were built for railroads and textile mills, not
- 16:57cloud computing empires. The meat thermometer analogy is
- 17:00perfect because it highlights why those metrics fall short
- 17:03Here. The traditional gap book value
- 17:06Generally Accepted Accounting Principles only looks at
- 17:09tangible assets. The physical stuff.
- 17:10Right. It completely ignores the
- 17:12intangible value of the AWS ecosystem, the proprietary
- 17:16software, or the behavioral lock in of 260 million Prime
- 17:20subscribers. And none of that shows up on a
- 17:22traditional balance sheet. Exactly.
- 17:24Furthermore, despite the cash flow drop, the balance sheet is
- 17:27basically bulletproof. Their debt to equity ratio is a
- 17:30highly conservative .27. That's practically 0 debt.
- 17:34And structurally, because they are shifting more weight to high
- 17:37margin services like AWS and advertising, their overall gross
- 17:41margin has expanded to nearly 51%.
- 17:44OK, so if the meat thermometer is useless, how did the analysts
- 17:47behind this report figure out what the stock is actually worth
- 17:49today? They relied on a discounted cash
- 17:52flow or DCF model, but they ran into a problem immediately,
- 17:56which was if you plug a negative cash flow number into ADCF, the
- 17:59formula tells you the company is worthless.
- 18:01Which we know isn't true. Right.
- 18:03So they had to normalize the cash flow.
- 18:06They took Amazon's massive operating cash flow and
- 18:09subtracted only the maintenance capital expenditures, which they
- 18:12estimated at $74.3 billion. Wait, let's breakdown
- 18:17maintenance CapEx for a second. That basically means asking if
- 18:20Amazon woke up tomorrow, canceled the entire $200 billion
- 18:25AI war, and just spent whatever was absolutely necessary to keep
- 18:29the current servers humming and the warehouse roofs from
- 18:32leaking. Yeah.
- 18:33How much cash would they have leftover at the end of the?
- 18:35Year exactly. It isolates the pure cash
- 18:37generating power of the business as it stands today.
- 18:39OK, that makes a lot of sense. So using that 74.3 billion as a
- 18:43starting baseline, they ran a nominal case scenario.
- 18:47They assumed Amazon could grow that normalized cash flow by 12%
- 18:51every year for the next 10 years.
- 18:53After that decade of growth, they applied a 3% perpetual
- 18:56terminal growth rate. Let's clarify terminal growth
- 18:59rate too because it sounds highly technical to some people.
- 19:02Yeah, that is just the assumption of how fast the
- 19:04company will grow into Infinity once it stops being a hyper
- 19:08growth tech stock. Right.
- 19:09Basically yes. It assumes they eventually
- 19:10mature and just pace with standard economic inflation.
- 19:14You've. Got it.
- 19:14It is the steady state growth forever.
- 19:17So when you run all those assumptions through the math,
- 19:21the model spits out an intrinsic value of $232.37 per share.
- 19:25OK. But looking at the current
- 19:27market data in the report, the stock is trading around $242,
- 19:31right? It's actually trading above what
- 19:34the model says it's perfectly worth.
- 19:35And this raises an important question, is the market
- 19:38efficiently pricing in the absolute flawless success of
- 19:41this $200 billion AI super cycle?
- 19:44Because if it's a 242, there's no room for error.
- 19:47None. At 2:42 there is 0 margin of
- 19:50safety. Deep value investor normally
- 19:52demands a 30% discount to intrinsic value to protect
- 19:55themselves in case management makes a mistake or a recession
- 19:58hits. So to get that 30% discount,
- 20:00where would the stock need to be?
- 20:01The stock would need to fall to about $162.
- 20:04Wow, that's a big drop from 2:42.
- 20:07Yeah, the fact that it is at 242 means investors are paying full
- 20:11price right now. They're assuming AWS maintains
- 20:14those 38% margins and the Neutranium chips dominate the
- 20:18market without a single hiccup. It totally explains why value
- 20:22purists like Berkshire Hathaway hold Amazon as a long term
- 20:25compounder, but probably aren't backing up the truck to buy
- 20:28massive new stakes at this price level.
- 20:30Exactly, you are buying an apex predator of a company but you
- 20:34are paying a premium for it. Yeah, Speaking of Apex Tech, I
- 20:37love the little met and odd at the very end of this report.
- 20:40Oh the Python script. Yes, the analysts noted that the
- 20:43entire 39 metric analysis we just went through, the DCF
- 20:46modeling, scraing the historical data, generating the charts in
- 20:50CSV files was fully automated by a Python script in seconds.
- 20:54It is a beautiful irony, isn't it?
- 20:56The massive computing power required to execute that complex
- 20:59analytical script instantly is the exact same cloud
- 21:03infrastructure Amazon is currently spending billions to
- 21:05upgrade. It all feeds back into the same
- 21:07machine. It really does.
- 21:08Well, we have covered a staggering amount of ground
- 21:11today. We demystified a $30 billion
- 21:14earnings illusion, mapped out the hidden advertising and cloud
- 21:18profit engines, and explored why traditional valuation metrics
- 21:22completely misread the company's real worth.
- 21:25It's a lot to process for sure, but I want to leave the listener
- 21:28with one final thought, building on something we touched on
- 21:30earlier regarding the shareholder protests.
- 21:33OK, laying on us. Amazon is spending $200 billion
- 21:36to win the AI war, but the real bottleneck might not be
- 21:40Microsoft or Google. Who is it then?
- 21:43Well, if AI did a center power demand double S by 20-30,
- 21:46threatening global electrical grids and corporate climate
- 21:49pledges, what happens if the ultimate limit to Amazon's
- 21:52growth isn't capitalism or competition, but literal physics
- 21:56and government energy rationing? Oh wow, now that is a thought to
- 21:59Mull over next time you click buy now.
- 22:01Thank you for joining us on this deep dive.
- 22:04Stay insanely curious and we'll catch you on the next one.