Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / The Legacy of Henry Kissinger: A Reflection by Irina Tsukerman | KAJ Masterclass
Transcript
- 0:02Right, right. Now let's move on to the story
- 0:05of Henry Kissinger. Finally he has, you know, he he
- 0:10is gone. He is gone from this earth.
- 0:13But because a lot of people have looked at him as a war criminal
- 0:18and that is why there he has gotten a Nobel Peace Prize.
- 0:22People have loved him for that. Many people have hated it for
- 0:25that. So there was always a lot of
- 0:27many people considering as an American patriot as the, you
- 0:32know, one who who loved the American way of life and
- 0:35everything to protect it, so. In that.
- 0:37Aspect. Many people will look at it in
- 0:40their own manner, independently. How do you look at it?
- 0:45Who was Henry Kissinger? Finally?
- 0:47How will the world remember him? How do you see it all?
- 0:54You know it's funny. There's a saying only the good
- 0:56day young if that saying it's true.
- 1:00Kissinger who looked to be 100 is the illustrates this is
- 1:07saying his legacy is controversial and for good
- 1:10reason. He was very much part of the
- 1:13until his dying day, he never repent, recanted his support for
- 1:17China and its imperial ambitions, which is terrible for
- 1:22the United States is an American, forget, you know, the
- 1:26global communities, an American. He should have come to
- 1:28understand that there China is never going to be argued out of
- 1:32looking down on everyone, including the US But that's just
- 1:38fine. Anyone can be wrong, and it's
- 1:41not criminal to have wrong foreign policy views.
- 1:45The problem is when these wrong foreign policy views turn into a
- 1:50downward, completely unethical implementation of policies, as
- 1:54was the case with Cambodia. We don't need to retell that
- 1:58story. The people there remember all
- 2:00too well and of course back in the Pakistan's abuses in
- 2:07Bangladesh, which of course caused a massive security
- 2:11problem for engine horrific human rights abuses.
- 2:14So his complete disregard for human rights made him not a real
- 2:19politic politician, but what the as opposite, a very short
- 2:22sighted politician who did not understand that good as human
- 2:26rights abuses turn into massive security problems and they're
- 2:31detrimental toward peace and stability.
- 2:33So I think his legacy is wrong. All the people who are suddenly
- 2:38working had geographies of him. I have no idea who they're
- 2:41trying to impress. He's not even there.
- 2:44He had somehow become the godfather of foreign policy and
- 2:48every leader in every foreign policy thinker and journalist
- 2:52was trying to get in on him before his death.
- 2:55But I don't just because he lived a long time, just because
- 2:58he was successful personally, as in making an impact that doesn't
- 3:05make the impact desirable. Good.
- 3:08So yes, his legacy is huge, but it's not positive.
- 3:12A lot of it is highly damaging and the impact of it is seen to
- 3:15this day, in my opinion. Right, Right.
- 3:20Kissinger was, you know of a man of a different era altogether,
- 3:24born in 1923. That was.
- 3:26His family had to flee from Germany during those tough
- 3:30times. He was, you know, born in a
- 3:32Jewish family, came to the US and then he went into, he fought
- 3:37there, he fought at the Battle of the World was part of this
- 3:41whole World War 2 and then built his life back in the US,
- 3:45studying political science and getting into him and the good
- 3:49the thing. Is that whether?
- 3:51Love him or hate him. But almost every president
- 3:54after. This when he was in the midst in
- 3:56the power corridors, they consulted him, was it?
- 4:00What was it that? People, whatever.
- 4:03Their opinion? People in power.
- 4:05Always. Wanted his opinion even till
- 4:07today he was known. Famous for his shuttle diplomacy
- 4:11and this continued even at this. Age.
- 4:14What was it about him that? You know, they always.
- 4:18Needed him around and is. There another man that could
- 4:21take his place. Obviously in history there are
- 4:24always people around, but what was special about him and what
- 4:27will the American foreign policy?
- 4:30Or diplomats will miss. Or the?
- 4:32President's event will miss about him, about his, you know,
- 4:36going away from this active life.
- 4:43You know what I'm going to say something extremely
- 4:45controversial. I think a lot of this
- 4:48presidential quota into somebody whose legacy was quite wrong,
- 4:52quite short sighted quite self-serving and sometimes
- 4:57downright anti-Semitic as as as with them quite.
- 5:01You know, as with the time he he did not want to send arms to to
- 5:06Israel and Nixon who is not known for his love of Jews or
- 5:10Israel had to actually intervene.
- 5:13You know what? If people are looking to embrace
- 5:16that to virtue signal because he was an intelligence person.
- 5:20He was not anyone foolish or who failed to understand the issues.
- 5:27He was wrong handed. He was arrogant and that he
- 5:30refused to change his mind and he was.
- 5:33You know, I'm not even going to speculate on his motivations,
- 5:36but I can talk about the impact of them and the impact was
- 5:40without a question damaging policy.
- 5:43And so when I see presidents go after time after time again to
- 5:47somebody who wasn't just wrong once or twice and admitted and
- 5:52reconsidered their action and is seeking the wisdom of somebody
- 5:55who's had to grapple with different complex problems.
- 5:58But when they going to somebody who's been adamantly wrong and
- 6:02the principles by which she operated were wrong, you know,
- 6:06it makes me wonder whether this is not the Emperor is naked
- 6:10phenomenon where people are afraid to admit that this
- 6:14fixture foreign policy is just an empty suit, someone who's who
- 6:21should be discarded. Because so much of Washington is
- 6:23built on the policies and the legacy of the past precedents,
- 6:28political precedents that are very now very difficult to
- 6:31dislodge. And I think this conventional
- 6:35way of thinking, this establishmentarianism is serving
- 6:40consequent that administration is quite badly, quite poorly.
- 6:45I think the reason our foreign policies has gone off the rails
- 6:50so much and has been so entrenched in in troops that
- 6:55need to be discarded and you know, very short sighted, very
- 7:00bubble mentalities precisely because everyone is afraid to
- 7:05say the emperor is naked. We need to move on from past
- 7:10mistakes, from past individuals, however impactful, who did
- 7:16damage. We have to admit that this never
- 7:18worked, and it's not going to work just because we tried
- 7:21again. Now can we find masterful
- 7:25diplomats with, you know, the worst complex experiences?
- 7:29I have no doubt that one day such people will emerge.
- 7:35Right now it's very difficult to say because this is something
- 7:38that can only be judged in hindsight.
- 7:40We've had, we've got, we've had those types of diplomats before,
- 7:45aside from kissing right now, it's very hard to say who they
- 7:49are because quite frankly, a lot of our diplomacy is very
- 7:53shallow, very short sighted, very tactical and not very
- 7:58impactful in a positive way. That doesn't mean that out of
- 8:02this morass we won't see great diplomats in the future.
- 8:07Maybe they are already there and we just don't see them.
- 8:10Maybe it's in the process. The history is in the process of
- 8:13being made. But do we necessarily need
- 8:16Titans of wrong headed policies just to make us feel good about
- 8:21themselves? Do we need one guy, one person
- 8:25to tell us how to think? No.
- 8:27We can learn the art of diplomacy and foreign policy
- 8:30from various different examples and from the many hard working
- 8:34people who are try are dedicated to promoting US interest in
- 8:40global peace and prosperity. So I think this is something
- 8:44that can be found. We can learn from many different
- 8:47people. We don't need to just rely on a
- 8:50couple of big influence in this sphere.
- 8:54Absolutely, absolutely. Henry Kissinger may be gone, but
- 8:58he has left a lot for people to continue to talk about,
- 9:02especially in the last so many years.
- 9:04You know, the world has changed the way he has impacted all
- 9:08those things positively or negatively.
- 9:11People will see it in their own ways.
- 9:12Countries will see it in their own ways.
- 9:14But I'm sure a lot of people will try and understand and gain
- 9:18insights into what could have done been done better and how we
- 9:22can look at foreign policy perhaps in a better manner.
- 9:26Be that as it may, let's move on to other issues in terms of.