Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Strategic Bitcoin Reserve Playbook: Inside BPI’s Toolkit for Sovereign Adoption
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous extra
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1970. 419-8790,
- 0:16297-2000 and whatever we want to call this, it's all just the
- 0:19same. Thing over and over we can't.
- 0:21Help ourselves, I say, when we sell.
- 0:26Hey, OK, I say when we sell. We just finished recording with
- 0:34Zach Shapiro and Zach Cohen from the Bitcoin Policy Institute.
- 0:37We covered the report that just dropped today actually.
- 0:40So they released a report and both Zachs authored the report
- 0:44on state level Strategic Bitcoin Reserve Toolkit.
- 0:48So it laid out a framework for how states can adopt legislation
- 0:53for a strategic Bitcoin reserve. Really goes into a ton of detail
- 0:57would encourage you to check out the whole thing.
- 0:59We did our best today to cover as much of it as we could, but
- 1:02it's a 30 page report so certainly encourage you to read
- 1:05it. If you want to dive in a little
- 1:07bit more, We did have the opportunity at on ramp to
- 1:10contribute on the custody framework, specifically around
- 1:12multi institution custody and how states can think about that
- 1:16as part of securing their strategic Bitcoin reserve.
- 1:19So that was a great honor. And then it begs the question as
- 1:22well, you know, if if MIC or multi institution custody is
- 1:26good enough for states to secure strategic Bitcoin reserve, but
- 1:30maybe it's good enough for you. And so at On Ramp, we're not
- 1:32only helping institutions, businesses, and even speaking to
- 1:36state level legislators, we're also helping individuals like
- 1:39yourself, helping secure your Bitcoin for the long term.
- 1:42And so if you want to learn more about what we do, you can check
- 1:45out our website at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 1:48Plenty of information there. You can also book a consultation
- 1:50just to learn more about how we can work together.
- 1:53Hope you enjoyed this episode and leave a comment if you have
- 1:56any thoughts, questions, or feedback.
- 1:57Appreciate it. All right, welcome back to the
- 1:59last trade. This is going to be a good one.
- 2:01We're joined by Zach Shapiro and Zach Cohen.
- 2:04We have two Zacks today from the Bitcoin Policy Institute.
- 2:08This is actually a special episode.
- 2:09And Zach's, you may be wondering if I say that every week, I
- 2:13actually do not say that every week.
- 2:14So the reason why this is special is twofold.
- 2:17Michael mentioned that he actually prepared for this
- 2:19podcast, which I don't think he's ever done in over 100
- 2:22episodes of the last trade. And then the second would be
- 2:25that you released a state level strategic Bitcoin reserve
- 2:28toolkit today. And so this is kind of breaking
- 2:32news. We're going to be diving into
- 2:33the report and the framework you put together for states in the
- 2:37US to be putting forth legislation to adopt Bitcoin as
- 2:41a strategic asset as a technology.
- 2:43So gentlemen, really a pleasure to have you both joining us
- 2:46today. Zach Shapiro, maybe I'll hand it
- 2:48over to you just for a quick background and then Zach Cohen,
- 2:51and then we can get into the report.
- 2:53Absolutely. Well, first of all, thanks for
- 2:54for having me. The background story behind this
- 2:59toolkit we created actually came from a request in advance of an
- 3:03event we did in March called Bitcoin for America that was
- 3:07really focused on the concept of strategic Bitcoin reserves.
- 3:10And the event was really about the idea of a strategic Bitcoin
- 3:14reserve at the federal level. And the executive order that
- 3:19created the federal strategic Bitcoin Reserve dropped right
- 3:22before the event, which was exciting for us.
- 3:25But before that, it seemed like states were making faster
- 3:29progress than the federal government was.
- 3:32It was moving more quickly than Senator Lummus's Bitcoin Act.
- 3:35It was moving more quickly than it seemed at the time, like the
- 3:38Trump administration was moving. And so actually, I, I don't
- 3:43think he'll mind saying this. Michael Saylor reached out to us
- 3:45and said, you know, can, can we do a speech about the state of
- 3:49the States and, and how states are leading the way on these
- 3:52reserve efforts. And as head of policy at BPI, my
- 3:57role is to figure out sort of the granular details of of what
- 4:00our policy area should be in what position we should take.
- 4:03And I'm, I'm a lawyer by training.
- 4:05And so it sort of fell to me to look at all of the different
- 4:09state level efforts to create a Bitcoin reserve.
- 4:13And what it turned out was there, there were a whole bunch
- 4:16of efforts. There were 32 different bills
- 4:18out there from 26 different states, I think, but they were
- 4:22all kind of garbage. You know, none of the bills
- 4:26would outright create a Bitcoin reserve that was funded upon
- 4:30passing. A lot of them also had, I won't
- 4:34use the swear word, but altcoins as part of them and precious
- 4:37metals. And some of them were just like
- 4:402 pages long. And we figured, you know, we
- 4:44could probably just do a better job than the current efforts out
- 4:48there. So we announced in my speech at
- 4:51our March event that we were going to create an open source
- 4:54framework where we were going to try and create comprehensive
- 4:59legislation that states could use to do Bitcoin reserves the
- 5:03right way to do it sort of in a smarter way.
- 5:07After the March event, we sat down, sat Cohen and myself, and
- 5:11we tried to think through, all right, like what does this
- 5:13actually look like in practice? And there are three, I think,
- 5:17important design choices we made that explain the end product
- 5:21that we have now. 1 is that this should be a modular piece of
- 5:26legislation. They, we wanted to do something
- 5:28open source where, you know, we would put our name on it, but
- 5:31wouldn't have pride of ownership.
- 5:32Anyone can steal this, anyone can plagiarize it, anyone can
- 5:36fork it or modify it in any way they need.
- 5:38And because of that, I think the most helpful way to do this
- 5:42legislation is to create a menu of options.
- 5:46That's not just here's one way to do an SBR that states can
- 5:49copy or tweak, but here's like a bunch of different ways, right?
- 5:51And that includes A standalone SBR, which is a pool of Bitcoin
- 5:55that's held in self custody that states hold for a long period of
- 5:58time. It could be other types of
- 6:00public investment in Bitcoin. So putting Bitcoin into
- 6:03pre-existing pension plans or state investment accounts.
- 6:07It could be something in between where there's an SBR, but it's
- 6:10held by a custodian. And so we wanted to create
- 6:13language not just for one way of doing things, but sort of all of
- 6:17the well done, you know, versions of of how you could do
- 6:21an SBR that could meet different state needs.
- 6:23Understanding that different states will have sort of the the
- 6:27political know how the technical know how to do some of these
- 6:30things and and not others. The second design choice related
- 6:33that that we made was to throw the kitchen sink at this.
- 6:36So it's not just going to be SBRS, but it's going to be
- 6:39public investment in Bitcoin more broadly, states are in sort
- 6:42of a unique position compared to the federal government because
- 6:45unlike the federal government, they don't get to print the
- 6:47world reserve currency. And when they issue debt, it's
- 6:50not T-bills, it's, you know, local muni bonds.
- 6:53And it's and they're much more constrained because they have to
- 6:56have balanced budgets and they can't borrow as much in what
- 6:58they can do. And so SBRS, or if anything,
- 7:01arguably more important for states than they are for the US
- 7:03federal government, which at the end of the day, you talk about
- 7:06the the last trade, the real last trade here might be the
- 7:08United States government printing money to buy Bitcoin.
- 7:11That's not a, you know, break glass in case of emergency
- 7:14option that individual states have.
- 7:16And so there really is urgency for states to do this and, and
- 7:19to do this right. And so we also included things
- 7:23like bit bonds. We included things like, you
- 7:25know, more specific definition of qualified custodians and, and
- 7:29really tried to give, you know, be a Swiss Army knife for
- 7:32states. And then the third choice that
- 7:35we made, which I think is germane to the the conversation
- 7:38we're having now is that, you know, while BPI is pretty good
- 7:42at thinking through the SPR issue and we've got pretty good
- 7:46chops at writing legislative texts, we're not experts at
- 7:50every domain area that's going to have to be in this toolkit.
- 7:55We're not experts on executing large sort of public state level
- 8:00trades to buy Bitcoin where you're not moving the price and
- 8:02you're getting best execution. We're not experts on on custody,
- 8:06we're not experts on insurance, we're not experts on a whole lot
- 8:09of things, but we have friends that are.
- 8:13And, you know, we know a lot of sort of the best Bitcoin
- 8:16companies like yourself that are, that are experts in these
- 8:19various domains. And so we reached out to our
- 8:22friends and we got input from the people who do this all the
- 8:27time, sort of understanding that there aren't going to be people
- 8:31in all likelihood in state government that know how to do
- 8:35Bitcoin stuff, at least so far. That's not how you get elected
- 8:38to state positions. And so I think sort of this like
- 8:44broad toolkit that we have that reaches, you know, everything
- 8:47you could want to do with Bitcoin at the state level.
- 8:50That is set up in a modular fashion where states can pick
- 8:53and choose these various things like they're they're choosing
- 8:55off a menu and where each of the individual parts have been
- 8:59carefully thought through to produce the sort of right
- 9:02result. That's the best policy for
- 9:03states informed by the best in class practices by the Bitcoin
- 9:08industry creates, you know, the end product.
- 9:11A really strong document that we we hope will be much more
- 9:15helpful to states than the rest of the stuff that's been
- 9:17floating out there. Appreciate that, Zach and maybe
- 9:21before we go into Zach Cohen, I just have to comment on
- 9:24Jackson's dig about preparation. And so I listened to so many
- 9:27podcasts that they form they're a former preparation and the
- 9:31Bitcoin policy hour is probably the highest signal podcast.
- 9:34So it was in my docket and I just made sure I listened to it
- 9:37right before the podcast to, to be able to speak to a lot of
- 9:41stuff. But I would encourage folks to
- 9:43listen to the the guys chat. It's a little trying to be
- 9:46frequently, but every week. But I guess sometimes if you
- 9:49guys are busy throwing huge conferences, you might miss a
- 9:51week. But I've really enjoyed it.
- 9:53And one of the topics that came up there that I think Pines
- 9:57brought up with with you both was around seeing around corners
- 10:00and being prepared for where the market is.
- 10:02Because ultimately Bitcoin moves very quickly.
- 10:05And I think this is what we've seen in the past 15 years of
- 10:08Bitcoin and crypto's history is that, and this is just general
- 10:11policy making, right? Like if the market moves too
- 10:13fast in One Direction, you get these bad outcomes when it comes
- 10:17to regulation and policy. And this it could be one of them
- 10:20when it comes to custody. And we, I think we all agree
- 10:22here, we don't want all this Bitcoin, whether it's states or
- 10:24sovereign sitting that coin base.
- 10:26And so I think these are all very important aspects.
- 10:29Execution. Another one we had our good
- 10:31friend Lee Bratcher from, you know, Texas Blockchain Council,
- 10:35and he referenced all the different minutiae that went
- 10:36into that bill around just things we wouldn't think of when
- 10:39it came to execution. And who's working for the state
- 10:42and how do they have the right governance around them when they
- 10:44execute that sell or buy because that's other people's money.
- 10:47It's not their money. And we have to like, you know,
- 10:48have a process for that. So a lot of that makes sense
- 10:51that you shared. Yeah, I mean, you know, just to
- 10:56jump in here, we we looked at, you know, as Zach was saying
- 11:00what some of the other proposals looked like and and some of
- 11:03those bills have actually passed, right.
- 11:05I think we've had three state level SBRS pass.
- 11:08And you know, broadly speaking, I think that's a good thing.
- 11:11I think these are things that are moving the Overton window.
- 11:14You know, most of BP is work is done at the federal level.
- 11:17And so having states pushing on this is, you know, it's, it's
- 11:20not trivial. With that said, I think there's
- 11:23also an appetite for these bills to be sort of stronger and
- 11:27deeper and, you know, more informed.
- 11:29And so that was really where we came in.
- 11:31And and Michael, you know, you mentioned how we talked about,
- 11:34you know, seen around corners and, you know, when Trump got
- 11:38elected, there was a big push for these bills to come out,
- 11:41right? She's like, OK, we've got the
- 11:43administration on our side. The Overton window is shifted.
- 11:47Let's take full advantage. And, you know, maybe those early
- 11:50bills weren't sort of up to snuff.
- 11:53And so now we've taken the time, stepped back, put together, you
- 11:56know, all of the the best resources in one place.
- 11:59And so now the push is, you know, we've got some momentum
- 12:02here. The Overton window is shifted.
- 12:04Let's let's really put it into practice here.
- 12:08I love it, yeah. So why I'm pulling up the
- 12:10report, I have it here. I just want to echo sentiment
- 12:14for the people who are listening.
- 12:15I think it's incredibly important to advocate for state
- 12:20adoption of Bitcoin. Of course, the federal level is
- 12:24playing out as we've seen over the past several months.
- 12:27And Zach, to your point with the Trump administration, it's been
- 12:29effectively a full 180 from prior administration.
- 12:32So things are moving very quickly.
- 12:34What I'm excited about as it relates to the state adoption is
- 12:38I ultimately think and I probably would speak for all
- 12:41everyone here, that the states that are early and forward
- 12:45thinking as it relates to Bitcoin are really going to be
- 12:47the economic powerhouses of the future.
- 12:50One thing I've always paid attention to is if you look like
- 12:5220 years ago to the most, I think it's like the the
- 12:57wealthiest counties in the country 20 years ago is like
- 13:01maybe two or three of them were in the Washington, DC metro
- 13:03area. But you Fast forward to the
- 13:05present, it's about 6 of them, right?
- 13:07And so as we've seen the growth of the state, you know, deficit
- 13:11spending, really robust spending in the Defense Department,
- 13:14intelligence agencies, a lot of wealth is concentrated in
- 13:17Washington DC. Not necessarily a good or bad
- 13:20thing. I guess it depends on how you
- 13:23parse that information out. But what ultimately the next 20
- 13:26years is going to look like, I think is that states that are
- 13:28early to Bitcoin and use the framework that you've provided
- 13:32in this toolkit are really going to be where a lot of the wealth
- 13:36talent, you know, Bitcoin ends up within the United States.
- 13:39So without further ado, I want to pull the report up and I will
- 13:44defer to both of you because you authored this over 30 page
- 13:48report, this toolkit where you'd like to start because we have
- 13:52here a beautiful glossy cover, by the way.
- 13:54I love it. And then if you just scroll real
- 13:56quick, you can see BIOS on Zach Shapiro, Zach Cohen, and then
- 14:00you have the table of contents. And so as you think about, you
- 14:02know, where you'd like to start, I just want to call out for
- 14:04people who are not on video, really starting at the highest
- 14:08levels findings, right? We're defining things about what
- 14:10is Bitcoin? Why is this relevant now?
- 14:12And then you go into establishment of SBRS, Bitcoin
- 14:16purchasing programs, economic development initiatives.
- 14:19That kind of ties into what I just said.
- 14:20There's a lot of information here.
- 14:22So anyone who you know, after this hour or so of recording
- 14:25wants to dive into more. We'll have that in the show
- 14:27notes. But Zach Shapiro, maybe I'll
- 14:28hand it over to you. There's a lot to go into here.
- 14:31Where do you think is the most logical place to start?
- 14:33To start, you know, setting the stage beyond what we've already
- 14:35shared? Why don't, why don't we do just
- 14:37a high level comment on each of them and then I'll leave it to
- 14:41you all to dig in and ask more specific questions where you're,
- 14:45you're interested. But I, I think because this is
- 14:48meant to be sort of comprehensive and modular at the
- 14:50same time, it's useful to just get a broad overview of, of all
- 14:54of it. So starting with the finding
- 14:57section, you know when you have a finding section in legislation
- 15:02that's not legal language, that's setting specific rules,
- 15:05right? That is it's really preamble
- 15:08about why you are passing the the legislation that comes after
- 15:12the finding section. But we actually think this is
- 15:15really important and really important for our work at at
- 15:17BPI. So the finding section is
- 15:19basically where we get to smuggle into the legislation all
- 15:22the nice stuff that we want to say about Bitcoin.
- 15:25And, and this is important primarily for two reasons.
- 15:28The first is, you know, there are a lot of folks in state
- 15:32legislatures that want to be friendly, vaguely friendly
- 15:36towards Bitcoin and crypto. And they, they don't necessarily
- 15:39know the difference between the two.
- 15:40Or sometimes they'll say digital assets or Web 3 and they don't
- 15:46really know why they are asked to vote on a piece of
- 15:49legislation. And we think that state Bitcoin
- 15:52reserves are such an important topic of legislation that for
- 15:57people who are looking at whether or not to pass this bill
- 16:00or why this makes sense or how we move the Overton window on
- 16:03the idea of Bitcoin is an asset that should be on public balance
- 16:07sheets. We really need to be very
- 16:09specific and clear about why. And so the finding section
- 16:12really sort of puts the reason behind why we're we're doing
- 16:16this all, what separates Bitcoin from the rest of crypto, What
- 16:19makes Bitcoin a long term valuable asset that states
- 16:22should hold and protection against monetary debasement that
- 16:26we're going to see at the federal level that states are
- 16:27not in control of and really helps lawmakers who are
- 16:31considering this legislation understand why.
- 16:33The other thing that's helpful is the extent that these things
- 16:36pass when we have legislatures that have looked at these
- 16:41fighting sections, they've included them in a bill.
- 16:43And then it is a matter of public record that a state has
- 16:48passed a law that says, you know, Bitcoin is real.
- 16:51Bitcoin is a legitimate asset. Bitcoin is unique.
- 16:54That is something that we can then as BPI, as advocates for
- 16:57Bitcoin, take to other states, take to the federal government
- 17:00and and really explain like, look, this is serious traction,
- 17:04right? This is not just us saying it.
- 17:06It's not just crazy people on the Internet.
- 17:07It's not, you know, Reddit or whatever, this is actual
- 17:11government policy that Bitcoin is all these things that that we
- 17:15are saying it is. So, you know, while not the most
- 17:19important from like how law gets rolled out perspective, we
- 17:22actually took some time with these findings to to add what we
- 17:25think are are important justifications for the for the
- 17:27rest of the the law. So then that's, that's findings
- 17:35definitions, you know, won't belabor this part, but we think
- 17:39precise definitions are really important.
- 17:41A lot of the other bills out there we've seen defined as you
- 17:44know, Bitcoin is a cryptocurrency that has at least
- 17:46X market cap. Just don't think that's like a
- 17:48good long term definition. So like we want to define
- 17:50Bitcoin more carefully. We want to define cold storage
- 17:53more carefully. The extent that we're using
- 17:56these concepts, when you think about writing legislation, you
- 18:00need something to be like general enough that it's
- 18:03understandable and leaves flexibility to do the right
- 18:06stuff, but specific enough that it provides constraints on non
- 18:10experts of how the law should be implemented.
- 18:12So the definition section was really important in terms of
- 18:15like being very clear about what we meant and and how things
- 18:18should should go in once it's implemented.
- 18:21Third is the establishment of the strategic Bitcoin reserve.
- 18:25This is, you know, one of the really important media parts
- 18:28this in the next section three and four establishment of the of
- 18:31the Bitcoin reserve and then the Bitcoin purchase program.
- 18:34This is sort of the menu of options for public investment in
- 18:37Bitcoin. And that could be anything from
- 18:41a, you know, pure strategic Bitcoin reserve in the mold of
- 18:45Senator Lummus's Bitcoin Act to sort of more modest
- 18:48incorporation of Bitcoin into other public investment.
- 18:51And so maybe this is this 3 and 4 might be a good place to sort
- 18:55of pause and, and discuss what the what the options are.
- 18:58And you know, maybe how we all collectively think about how
- 19:01states can can leverage Bitcoin. Yeah, maybe before jumping in
- 19:05there, I do want to thank you guys and appreciate kind of a
- 19:08lot of the work you're doing because there's it's for me
- 19:11specifically, that's not how my brain thinks and I can never do
- 19:14it. I, we've been approached by
- 19:15multiple states to help them and, and share some light on
- 19:18what custody is and other things.
- 19:20And I just happen to be in certain states at the time to
- 19:22meet policy makers. And the way that they explain,
- 19:25like you referenced the definitions, not only the, the
- 19:28clarity of the definitions and the, the structure, but the
- 19:30amount of pushing and pulling and jockeying when it comes to,
- 19:35you know, partnering with different parts of the policy
- 19:39makers and you getting themselves attached to it
- 19:41because they're trying to navigate some other bill.
- 19:44They're trying to get it just, it sounds like so much work and
- 19:48it requires a lot of like tactfulness and aggression.
- 19:51And I know you guys are working on a lot of this.
- 19:53So I think this is the, this is going to be hugely beneficial
- 19:57for all these states that don't know what Bitcoin is, don't know
- 20:00there's 21 million fixed cap supply.
- 20:02And then all the way through, as we go through this to just have
- 20:04a frame of reference of like, OK, this is a body of work that
- 20:07I could use as a like anchor and then can build upon it where
- 20:11they're just kind of like nothing that exists today.
- 20:14Yeah, I appreciate that. I mean, look, PPI is a really
- 20:16small organization and we are in the business of trying to have
- 20:19asymmetric impacts and that's very much the spirit of this,
- 20:22right? This is something that saves us
- 20:24a lot of time because if anyone asks us about state SBRS, we can
- 20:27sort of shove this document in their direction and say we think
- 20:30this is the right starting point.
- 20:31Anything you could realistically want to do is in there and we've
- 20:35made it easy for you. We've actually, we're not.
- 20:36This is not like our white paper or think piece about why state
- 20:41Bitcoin reserves are good or conceptually how they should be.
- 20:44Like this is language you can cut and paste and throw into
- 20:47ChatGPT. And like, honestly, you could
- 20:50take this entire document, put it in like, you know, one of the
- 20:53better LLM models, say which parts of it you want, and you
- 20:57probably get a pretty good bill out the other end.
- 20:59And so we're trying to make it as easy as possible for state
- 21:01legislatures that are not expert in this.
- 21:04Unless you're in Connecticut, right?
- 21:07Unless you're in Connecticut and then you go right to jail for
- 21:09even looking at this document. Just a follow on point, you
- 21:13know, for folks who maybe are wondering like why we did this
- 21:16as a toolkit instead of just a straight up piece of model
- 21:18legislation, right, there's there's the parts that Zach was
- 21:21mentioning right there. Different needs state to state.
- 21:24You know, Michael, you mentioned there's some jockeying that
- 21:26happening that's happening. I think the key element here too
- 21:30is that this can serve as an educational piece, right?
- 21:32Like when folks take this to their legislator and they say,
- 21:36hey, you know, we've got a full toolkit here.
- 21:38Obviously you're probably not going to put all 36 pages of
- 21:41this into a bill, but hey, you want to learn what Bitcoin is?
- 21:44Oh, you don't know what a hard fork is or what that would mean
- 21:47for, you know, a strategic Bitcoin reserve or hey, I've
- 21:50never heard of multi institution custody.
- 21:52Like is that something that like works on Bitcoin, you know,
- 21:56etcetera, etcetera. And so that was that was also a
- 21:59decision that we made early in the process to say, you know,
- 22:03this is good for for more than maybe just producing bills.
- 22:08I love it. And if we were, so if we dig
- 22:10into more of the establishment of the strategic Bitcoin Reserve
- 22:15section a little bit more maybe before getting into the nuance
- 22:18and practicalities of implementing it that you've laid
- 22:22out in the toolkit. I would love to just set the
- 22:24stage on why are states considering establishing A
- 22:28strategic Bitcoin reserve. It sounds like maybe an obvious
- 22:31question, but it's a nuanced question because Bitcoin's a
- 22:34very nuanced technology. It's unique, unlike anything
- 22:37we've ever seen before. And so I'm curious from the
- 22:40conversations you've been having with policy makers, is it mostly
- 22:45a focus just from that main area we discussed at the top about
- 22:49kind of hedging against the fiscal irresponsibility of the
- 22:54federal government? Are there many other reasons
- 22:56from like censorship resistance and having decentralized
- 22:59technology and economic development?
- 23:02What are you seeing in terms of interest from policy makers at
- 23:05the state level as to why they're considering a strategic
- 23:08Bitcoin reserve I. Think it really runs the gamut
- 23:11of reasons, but the sort of two clusters of what we hear.
- 23:16One is there are state legislators who understand
- 23:20Bitcoin and are orange pilled. And the reasons they would give
- 23:23you probably sound like the reasons that I mentioned at the
- 23:26beginning of this episode that are the states can't print
- 23:29money. They're constrained in terms of
- 23:31borrowing. They need to run balanced
- 23:32budgets and they have long term duration liabilities that for
- 23:37example, pension plans where people depend on them to provide
- 23:40over the long term. And if the dollar is going to
- 23:43get continuously debased, you can't just have dollar assets.
- 23:46And so Bitcoin is a good hedge against debasement over the long
- 23:49term for states investment accounts.
- 23:54And then there are, you know, when we get into more exotic
- 23:56stuff like bit bonds, there are people who really understand,
- 24:00you know, to come back to asymmetric opportunities, like
- 24:02the first local municipality that figures out you can
- 24:05probably do a bit bond that gives tax free Bitcoin upside.
- 24:09They're going to just be able to raise.
- 24:11I mean, it's, it's going to be like the treasury companies.
- 24:12You can just it's the infinite money glitch.
- 24:14And now all of a sudden you can invest in your physical
- 24:17infrastructure, you can invest in, you know, police and
- 24:19firefighters and services, and you can also share in the upside
- 24:23from Bitcoin. And so there are people that
- 24:25understand it on that level. And then there are a larger
- 24:28group of people that, like, are kind of wannabe Bitcoin and
- 24:31crypto cheerleaders at this point, and they want to do
- 24:33something useful, but they don't really know what that means or
- 24:35what to do. And so this is also meant for
- 24:38those folks to be like, yeah, you want to do something.
- 24:41You want to row in the right direction.
- 24:42You have some vague sense that, you know, Bitcoin or blockchains
- 24:45or something like that is important.
- 24:47We are the people who spent a borderline unhealthy amount of
- 24:50time thinking about it. And like this is our best answer
- 24:53to that question. Yeah, with it, I mean, we're
- 24:58going to do our best to be objective because a lot of this
- 25:00going about multi institutions, what we focus on, but I make the
- 25:04case a lot of these things can be potentially done wrong and be
- 25:08okay. You can't mess up custody.
- 25:10And in our view, this is what has kept most people out from
- 25:13the industry. I'm sure you guys have seen
- 25:14this, but I'm just going to flash it on the screen.
- 25:16Like we have this slide that we share and and most people don't
- 25:20see it and we get desensitized by numbers.
- 25:23And this is a little bit shy of what it really is.
- 25:25It on the screen we're showing $655 billion in losses.
- 25:29It's a little closer to 700 billion just given some of the
- 25:31recent losses. But the point being here is I've
- 25:35always thought through, if you're sitting and you're trying
- 25:38to generate consensus, how do you say this will never happen
- 25:41to me, right? Like how do you, how do you
- 25:44verifiably say, because there's a lot of the process will go
- 25:46through this doc that you can't actually ever verify from an
- 25:49operational security perspective, Coinbase's custody,
- 25:52Fidelity's or wherever they are. And then there's also this
- 25:54component that I've always thought through from sovereign
- 25:57adoption. It's kind of non sensible when
- 25:59you think about how El Salvador at some point had their Bitcoin
- 26:02at Coinbase and then they got enough pressure, whatever and
- 26:04they brought those keys home. But it's kind of weird that
- 26:07somebody in the UAE is buying an ETF in San Francisco and it sits
- 26:11there. And so part of, you know, in
- 26:13this, in this document references within the state
- 26:15walls. And so there's a lot of things
- 26:17that go into the custody that has to like make sense if states
- 26:21are going to really lean into this, right?
- 26:23Because it's one thing to do a gimmick and put a couple
- 26:241,000,000 bucks. And it's another thing if you're
- 26:26going to hold hundreds of millions, if not billions of
- 26:27dollars and be able to show up the next day to work and or be
- 26:31able to sleep good at night, not knowing an FTX or every other
- 26:35issue we've had the past 15 years.
- 26:37So just curious how you guys thought through like custody and
- 26:40this component? Cause multi institution ended up
- 26:42being a big part of this whole article and naturally did a
- 26:44control F and, and saw there was a, you know, a very large number
- 26:48of sightings. So just curious how you guys
- 26:49thought about custody and this framework?
- 26:52I think honestly it's just conviction at this point.
- 26:57So aside from my work with BPI have I have a law practice, I
- 27:01work with a lot of different Bitcoin startups sort of across
- 27:04the industry. And I have come to the view that
- 27:07like for institutional clients, just in the marketplace, multi
- 27:13institutional custody is the best set of trade-offs, right?
- 27:17It is you're not reliant just on your own keys.
- 27:20There's less risk of internal collusion, there's less risk of
- 27:23external collusion. And this is an incredibly
- 27:28powerful sort of best in class custody solution that is only
- 27:32available because of Bitcoins native technology.
- 27:34It's not something we've had for previous assets.
- 27:36And so then when I put it on my BPI hat and I'm like, OK, how
- 27:39does this translate over into the government?
- 27:42It it does in exactly the same way as As for large
- 27:45institutions. If you have a bunch of public
- 27:49balance sheet Bitcoin, you're not going to do better in my
- 27:52view than multi institutional custody.
- 27:54When you when you look at all of the different trade-offs, you
- 27:57know, the one risk is losing keys.
- 27:59One risk is a a wrench attack. One risk, you know, the, the
- 28:03real big risk here is, is collusion from from insiders.
- 28:07Even if you have some sort of multi sig, you know, it's been
- 28:10known to happen. And so multi institution, I
- 28:14think is, is the right answer. So we include as a big part of
- 28:17this. And then, you know, at our
- 28:20summit a couple weeks ago, I also, I did a fireside chat with
- 28:23Commissioner Esther Purse at the at the SEC, I push her on that
- 28:27as well, which she seemed open to that.
- 28:29When the SEC is formalizing its rules for what it means to be a
- 28:32qualified custodian for Bitcoin, if, if indeed they, they come to
- 28:36the conclusion that they can make those rules because Bitcoin
- 28:38is a commodity and not a security.
- 28:39So there's a question of whether that's in their jurisdiction at
- 28:42all. I think for the Bitcoin
- 28:45companies, I assume like yourself, it would be better if
- 28:48they just said yes and gave you a clear rule.
- 28:50And so you could go to clients and say, hey, we're a qualified
- 28:52custodian. To the extent the SEC is going
- 28:54to do that, they really should take the properties of Bitcoin
- 28:59into account and and think about Bitcoin differently than you
- 29:01would think about a sort of stock certificate for
- 29:03traditional security or a physical asset like gold where
- 29:06you know, you have to think what is the best way to custody this
- 29:09thing and the the best way to custody the thing Bitcoin.
- 29:13I think certainly multi institutional custody maybe with
- 29:17you know either current available scripting language or
- 29:21future updates like covenants, hard to beat that when you look
- 29:25at all of the different threat factors.
- 29:27Yeah, I think that it's a great call out.
- 29:30A lot of people will reference like a legacy like tech is multi
- 29:35sig. It's like it is like we're so
- 29:37far on the fringes with Bitcoin and multi sig.
- 29:39It's how all the Bitcoin at these large custodians is
- 29:41leveraged. And I think covenants and mini
- 29:43scripts and all these things will be the future, but they're
- 29:46effectively haven't necessarily been battle tested and they'll
- 29:48require years and hundreds of billions, if not trillions of
- 29:50dollars to be secured before somebody's going to really park
- 29:53serious capital, which you outlined, Zach, was a big
- 29:58component of like the founding of this business.
- 29:59Because this was something that I'm glad you brought up because
- 30:02it's all about, as you guys know, getting these concepts
- 30:04into the zeitgeist because it felt like it was Hazard Pierce's
- 30:08first time hearing multi institution custody.
- 30:10And that notion doesn't get appreciate enough in the Bitcoin
- 30:14community is like, again, this might sound a little taboo, but
- 30:17I fundamentally feel that you can change the the IT could be
- 30:2120,000,022 million. You could even have inflation.
- 30:24I'm not saying we should have inflation, but gold had
- 30:26inflation was was global. Is, is still kind of the global
- 30:28reserve asset, but the reason why it failed is because there
- 30:32was no governance at the protocol level.
- 30:34And so it has centralization problems.
- 30:36And where Bitcoin, you know, flies or kind of changes in that
- 30:40dynamic is there's governance at the protocol level and what that
- 30:44allows us for multiple entities in multiple potential
- 30:46jurisdictions. But then a few things to call
- 30:49out because I think they're a little bit still we're so early
- 30:52in this that I think are important for this topic is it's
- 30:55interoperable and it scales proportionally with the amount
- 30:59of assets. So today if Texas bought 10
- 31:01million and the next day have a billion or a trillion, you can
- 31:05have five key holders, you can have seven, you can scale that
- 31:08nicely. And this was always kind of the
- 31:09vision with the ETFs and we're seeing this now with pub codes
- 31:11that are coming to us. So you can actually grow that
- 31:15there's Providence and added station built into it that most
- 31:18people don't necessarily talk about.
- 31:20So traditionally, if you if you generate a wallet address,
- 31:23you're telling me it's your address.
- 31:24And if you go to Coinbase, Coinbase has to tell you they
- 31:26control that address. But this is the first time you
- 31:28can have multiple entities and especially regulated entities
- 31:32all say that this address is definable and it's owned by you
- 31:35because you've actually on board, which is just something
- 31:36that is nuanced. We don't talk about enough.
- 31:39And then the last one that I personally find interesting is
- 31:42the proof of reserves notion because I kind of think proof of
- 31:45reserves and it's the way that it's talked about today is
- 31:47almost like a fallacy in the sense that if I do proof of
- 31:50reserves today and I'm a single custodian and I collude tonight
- 31:54or my team colludes against me or I lose all the assets, Well,
- 31:56what was the point in the proof of reserves?
- 31:58And so inherit in multi institution is proof of reserves
- 32:01because it's audible and it's on chain.
- 32:03And these are some of the things that are just natural when it
- 32:05comes to large pools of capital. The beauty of multi institution
- 32:08is we all can use it in the same way an institution can leverage
- 32:11it, which is the beauty of technology.
- 32:13It's democratizes across, you know, scale and time.
- 32:19Yeah, I think maybe one other thing to add to those comments,
- 32:22Michael, is just like zooming out and just thinking about
- 32:27multi institution as really just like a new implementation of
- 32:29multi SIG. As you referenced, multi sig is
- 32:32sort of the standard. It's battle tested for a decade.
- 32:34The coin bases of the world use multi sig for their cold Bitcoin
- 32:38storage. The issue is that you still have
- 32:40single entity exposure. And so this is something that
- 32:43is, is a bit of a nuance, but like, if you think about the buy
- 32:46bit hack, four or five months ago, they were using a form of
- 32:49multi sig, but the, you know, the compromise had happened at
- 32:54the entity level. And so the distribution of keys
- 32:56within the single entity actually didn't end up
- 32:59mattering. And so the the actual sort of
- 33:01secret sauce to to what we're building at on ramp.
- 33:04And really, you know, any, any implementation of multi
- 33:07institution custody, because as Michael mentioned, it's it's
- 33:10interoperable open source. Anyone can spin up a, a multi
- 33:12institution quorum if they wanted to.
- 33:15The real secret sauce is the distribution of control across
- 33:18distinct entities, because what that actually provides for the
- 33:21first time in Bitcoin's history is a level of fault tolerance
- 33:24and redundancy, which is required for any material
- 33:27exposure to the asset, particularly at the sovereign
- 33:29level. Like you can't have, you know,
- 33:31this thesis on Bitcoin that it's it's, you know, going to
- 33:34appreciate into the future and we want this as a reserve asset.
- 33:37And you can't just have that, you know, wake up one day and
- 33:39have the allocation go to 0 because you happen to pick the
- 33:42wrong custodian. And so the ability to actually
- 33:45have fault tolerance and redundancy built in, I think is
- 33:47super critical to just thinking about this asset, right?
- 33:50Because you know, in terms of, you know, the educational
- 33:54process that needs to occur here, as we referenced sort of
- 33:56the beginning of the report laying out the findings why
- 33:58bitcoins important in different definitions.
- 34:02You know, that's all super critical because this is just a
- 34:04very different asset, a digital bearer instrument.
- 34:06There are no, they're on our fall backs.
- 34:08Like it's very unique in that sense that custody is actually
- 34:12the most important thing to get right.
- 34:14And if you can build in a level of fault tolerance, tolerance to
- 34:17that structure, then you can actually, you know, foreseeably,
- 34:22you know, have this thing progress into the future where
- 34:26you're not worried about something going wrong, which
- 34:28historically has been the case in Bitcoin.
- 34:29Whether it's self custody or trusting a single entity,
- 34:31there's always that thing in the back, back of your mind that
- 34:34like, oh, this could go wrong. And that's also the, you know,
- 34:37from the outsiders perspective, like that's the perception of
- 34:40like this is going to end up in a landfill or North Korean
- 34:42hackers are going to get it. Like those are the tropes for a
- 34:45reason. Like there's, there's empirical
- 34:47evidence to state that that that does happen in other custody
- 34:50models. So I think that's just
- 34:52important. Like higher level framework of
- 34:54like this is very different. There's a lot of education that
- 34:57needs to occur. And I think, you know, the
- 34:59toolkit is, is, you know, going to be a great resource for folks
- 35:03as they dig into this going forward.
- 35:06Yeah, I think that that's a helpful comment, right?
- 35:08We're we're at a point in time where there's momentum behind
- 35:11these kinds of proposals, right, where there is interest from
- 35:14state legislators and, you know, integrating Bitcoin into their,
- 35:18you know, balance sheet. However it may be at the same
- 35:21time, you know, they might not be aware of of what's involved
- 35:24with that. It's not like going on there,
- 35:27you know, or an individual going on their Fidelity account and
- 35:30buying a stock, you know, in order for a state to, to do this
- 35:34effectively, there's a fair amount of due diligence, a fair
- 35:37amount of, you know, engaging stakeholders.
- 35:39And so, you know, the goal, again, with this tool kit was
- 35:42put it all in one place. Have you know the companies that
- 35:45contributed language like on ramp, like the other companies
- 35:48that we worked with available as resources so that when and or if
- 35:55you know these state legislations want more
- 35:57information or want to learn more, that they know where to go
- 36:01and that the people that they go to are not the FT XS of the
- 36:04world That they are, you know, trusted, reputable, sort of best
- 36:08in class. Yeah, Zach Shapiro, I think we
- 36:13probably both share the a little bit of the annoyance with the QC
- 36:15rules. So maybe want to chat a little
- 36:17bit about about that because I think it's an important, it
- 36:20reminds me a little bit of the banking regulator saying, you
- 36:23know, most Ras and pub Cos don't necessarily by the letter, by
- 36:28the true letter, the law have to use a qualified custodian.
- 36:30But it's the kind of thing like nobody ever got fired for going
- 36:32to coin base. And so you see a lot of these
- 36:34pub codes and Ras just opt for qualified custodians when
- 36:37historically qualified custodians have been unqualified
- 36:40custodians. And so curious just how you
- 36:45think about that. We're actively working on just
- 36:47from a letter of law, how it reads today, because we can only
- 36:49work with the the within the confines of what's exists.
- 36:53So we're working on qualified custody around the existing with
- 36:55the first key holder being a qualified custodian.
- 36:57How does it get written at the state level?
- 37:00But curious how you're thinking about that because I think this
- 37:02is going to underpin not only the SBRS pub Cos, but then also
- 37:06bit bonds because multi institution embeds across
- 37:09multiple asset products. Because you're naturally
- 37:12thinking about duration risk, because custody may work for a
- 37:14day in a bit bonds. But if it's a duration of 10
- 37:17plus years, you need that custodian to be a long, very, a
- 37:20very, very long time. And historically, most
- 37:22institutions outside of Coinbase haven't been around for 10
- 37:24years. So it's inherent to like a lot
- 37:26of these core products that you guys are thinking through, I
- 37:28think is going to underpin from a fiduciary perspective that
- 37:31fault tolerance will have to be there.
- 37:33Yeah, I think there are four things that are annoying about
- 37:35the qualified custodian situation.
- 37:37The 1st is that, so far as I can tell, this is not actually a
- 37:40legal problem. This is a business problem,
- 37:42which is, you know, stupid when we're talking about regulatory
- 37:45stuff. There's not any meaningful legal
- 37:48requirement that a Bitcoin custodian BAQC under, under the
- 37:53SE CS rules. The reason why this comes up,
- 37:55the reason why you care about this, the reason why I care
- 37:57about this is because clients demand it.
- 37:59That's what you just said, that no one ever got fired for
- 38:01working with it. Like it is a, it is a CYA, you
- 38:05know, maneuver from people's Fas, from trusts, from large
- 38:10companies. And so you know, that that
- 38:13starts us off on the wrong foot #2 It's not clear at all.
- 38:16I think, as I mentioned before, that such a concept can exist
- 38:20for Bitcoin, which is a commodity, right, qualified
- 38:23custodian as a securities law concept.
- 38:25If you listen to my fireside with Esther Purse, she
- 38:28acknowledges like she's not sure that they have jurisdiction to
- 38:31answer this question at all. And they're, they're thinking it
- 38:33through. But this it might not be a
- 38:35thing. And so if you combine that with
- 38:37#1 it's a business problem that may have no solution because the
- 38:40SEC doesn't have jurisdiction to answer the question.
- 38:43That's a problem. Compounding it #3 to the extent
- 38:46that the SEC says stuff like there is such a thing as a
- 38:49qualified concern for Bitcoin, it's entirely unclear what that
- 38:52means. The current best understanding
- 38:55among crypto lawyers is a nationally chartered trust would
- 38:59do it. That's so far, I think just
- 39:01Anchorage a state chartered trust, of which there are a few
- 39:07that would cut it. But in the Gensler era, they
- 39:09stopped giving out those trusts because to crypto companies
- 39:13because they were worried Operation Show point 2.0 type of
- 39:16stuff. I assume that will resume more.
- 39:18I know companies are trying to get those now.
- 39:20Okay, those two, probably the federal one, definitely the
- 39:23state one probably. And then beyond that, like what
- 39:25about a statutory trust? What about some other kind?
- 39:28Like we just don't know where the line is.
- 39:30And then the last thing that's annoying is, is the conversation
- 39:32we sort of just had. And maybe what you're referring
- 39:35to in terms of unqualified custodians, the credentials
- 39:38you'd need, the technology you need to be a good custodian for
- 39:41Bitcoin has nothing to do with the credentials you need to be a
- 39:45qualified custodian if people are understanding the rules
- 39:47correctly. And so this whole thing is just
- 39:49a, it's just a mess that's really getting in the way of a
- 39:53lot of the best actual Bitcoin custodians being able to serve
- 39:57the biggest potential clients. Yeah.
- 39:59And to put a little meat on that, there's like just to share
- 40:02how kind of opaque it is. There's three different
- 40:05implementations like I'm familiar with, There's probably
- 40:07more, but there's the like Bitco has their South Dakota trust,
- 40:12they house all the keys. So they have direct control and
- 40:15they're the fiduciary and the record the the, the legal record
- 40:18of the asset. And then there's.
- 40:21The sub custodial model that we saw that that's the unqualified
- 40:24custodian where prime trust, fortress trust got in trouble
- 40:27because they leveraged a third party, you know, multi party
- 40:29computation. They lost different, there's
- 40:31different explanations and why, but they at the end of the day,
- 40:33they lost client assets, but they're the legal record and
- 40:37then they're directing the control and then friends at 2
- 40:41Ocean and have an interpretation of it from the Wyoming regulator
- 40:44is that they're qualified custodian, legal record and
- 40:47fiduciary. And then they house the assets
- 40:50within an environment that gives them control, even though they
- 40:52don't touch it and they're not signing like they're still,
- 40:54there's these different minutia that everyone's playing with
- 40:56based on their regulator, but there's no clear answer.
- 40:59And so everyone just takes their interpretation that they feel
- 41:01from their legal team and that's going to protect them and then
- 41:04everyone else just ends up on the outside.
- 41:05And that's where Anchorage and and really Anchorage Coinbase
- 41:08infidelity have end up as the defaults in institutional
- 41:12allocations because they just have the state or the federal
- 41:15charters and then they have infrastructure in place.
- 41:21We'd love to talk about the Section 4 now on the purchase
- 41:25side because so we laid out some of the considerations as relates
- 41:28to governance custody controls around the strategic Bitcoin
- 41:33reserve. But everyone wants to know,
- 41:35well, how are these states actually going to acquire
- 41:38Bitcoin? And so I know Texas and I
- 41:42believe it was New Hampshire have actually passed
- 41:44legislation. I haven't dug into either one of
- 41:46them in great detail. I know the Texas legislation
- 41:49allows for a $10 million initial purchase.
- 41:52I'm curious if the two of you could please just provide some
- 41:56more color on as states get strategic Bitcoin reserves up
- 42:00and running as part of this legislation, what are you
- 42:02typically seeing? What did you recommend or
- 42:05suggest as part of the toolkit for states to start to acquire
- 42:09Bitcoin? I know we mentioned bit bonds
- 42:10just in passing, but that's only one of many options as as far as
- 42:14I understand it, that states could actually start acquiring
- 42:17Bitcoin to, you know, bolster their balance sheet to help the
- 42:22constituents within their state. So I'd love to just better
- 42:24understand that because a lot of people want to know, you know,
- 42:26practically going from we're going to implement a strategic
- 42:30book when reserve. Well, how do we actually now
- 42:32acquire the Bitcoin? How does that all work?
- 42:34Yeah, I can get us started here and then kick it over to Zach.
- 42:38You know, just before we dig into the specifics here, I think
- 42:41broadly speaking, the states face the same issue that the
- 42:44federal government is facing, which is, you know, taxpayers
- 42:48maybe don't want their tax dollars being spent to buy
- 42:51Bitcoin. And so one of the things we've
- 42:53heard repeatedly out of the White House is we need budget
- 42:56neutral means for acquiring more Bitcoin.
- 42:59And so that's, you know, get a little bit more creative with
- 43:02with how that works. And one of the major proposals
- 43:05for that is is obviously bit bonds.
- 43:08At the same time, there's a lot of funds that sort of already
- 43:11exist on the balance sheet of these states.
- 43:14Pension funds have, you know, a a ton of available assets, some
- 43:18of which could be, you know, fairly easily rotated into
- 43:21Bitcoin. We spoke briefly with Andrew
- 43:24Hones about this. And, you know, when Zach and I
- 43:27were putting the drafts together, we were like, well,
- 43:29wouldn't it be great if, you know, they just rotated these
- 43:31assets? And he said, well, you know, I
- 43:33don't think it's going to go over very well.
- 43:34I don't think it's even possible for a state legislature to tell
- 43:38a pension fund like you need to rotate these assets.
- 43:42And so the workaround on that side was to basically direct all
- 43:46these pension funds, all of these, you know, accounts that
- 43:50weren't directly controlled by the state treasurer or the
- 43:53Comptroller, whoever managed the assets to say you need to do a
- 43:57review of the existing assets you have.
- 43:59You need to assess what your sort of Bitcoin exposure is at
- 44:03the moment. And then you need to include in
- 44:06that report, you know, a proposal for adding exposure.
- 44:11And so that's one front. There's obviously operating
- 44:14accounts and that's a little bit easier for for a state
- 44:17legislature to direct. But bottom line, you know, most
- 44:23of these states are, are sort of wary.
- 44:26You know, I think the the folks who are sponsoring these bills
- 44:29are excited about the proposals, but they're also sort of
- 44:32recognizing that, you know, there's a number of constituents
- 44:34who maybe haven't come around to Bitcoin yet.
- 44:37And so there's, you know, a balance to be struck in
- 44:40acquiring Bitcoin without necessarily, you know, pissing
- 44:43anyone off or, or making any enemies.
- 44:47Right. And and that piece you mentioned
- 44:49as well, Zach, on the public pension side, I mean, that
- 44:52really just addresses as, as far as I understand it, correct me
- 44:55if I'm wrong, they would only address a Bitcoin allocation to
- 44:58the extent you have a state pension if you're a government
- 45:01employee of that state. So then everyone else who works
- 45:03in the private sector, I guess is not really getting Bitcoin
- 45:07exposure unless they're buying it as an individual, right?
- 45:09So beyond, I guess, and to your point as well, that's a long
- 45:13process. I mean, we came from the world
- 45:14of institutional allocators and due diligence.
- 45:17And when you're dealing with equities or fixed income or
- 45:21other asset classes that have existed a while, even those due
- 45:24diligence cycles on a specific product or fund can take a year
- 45:27or two. So let alone a new asset class
- 45:30that people are still looking to wrap their heads around may take
- 45:33even longer. And we saw some of those smaller
- 45:36BIP allocations in 2024 last year with a few of the public
- 45:41pension plans. I think some of them have since
- 45:43sold their exposure, others may still be hanging on, but it's a
- 45:46very small allocation. Again, we're we're still very
- 45:49early not only as individuals, but as it relates to states
- 45:51getting involved. So I would love to just
- 45:54understand if. I wouldn't undersell pension
- 45:56plans though. I mean, so there just aren't
- 45:58that many private sector companies that offer real
- 46:01pensions. States typically have very large
- 46:03pension plans. And that is just one area where
- 46:05you really run into this acute problem of the idea is you're
- 46:09setting people up for the rest of their lives.
- 46:11People are living longer and we're, you know, going to debase
- 46:14the dollar, you know, again and again and again until we can't
- 46:19do it anymore. And so, and that is like even
- 46:22just solving public sector pensions, even through a, you
- 46:26know, reasonable, you know, or small sized allocation, I think
- 46:29that's a, that is a huge pain point for states.
- 46:32I agree, sorry if it came off, if it came off to the contrary,
- 46:36but I agree with that. And then on the private side,
- 46:38right, it's just a matter of kind of outside of the scope of
- 46:41this report, allowing for 401K and other type of contributions
- 46:45to be made to spot Bitcoin directly, which I don't know if
- 46:47we're quite there yet, but yeah. What else would you like to
- 46:50highlight on the purchase side? I mean, I think there's a lot of
- 46:53interesting things, but there's also 30 pages of a toolkit that
- 46:55you publish. So I want to make sure we can
- 46:57get through as much of it as possible.
- 47:00Yeah, I think two things to highlight on the execution side.
- 47:04One being, you know, the sort of folding of tax revenue into the
- 47:09strategic Bitcoin Reserve. This is something that I think
- 47:12did actually exist before our toolkit.
- 47:15And and I haven't read the final language in the Texas SPR bill,
- 47:19but I know that earlier drafts of that bill had provisions to
- 47:22say that, you know, any Bitcoin or crypto that is sort of
- 47:28pledged for tax purposes can be folded into the strategic
- 47:33Bitcoin reserve. An interesting thing that that
- 47:36Zach and I came across there as well was so basically the
- 47:40language suggested that if cryptocurrency, so, you know,
- 47:44anything other than Bitcoin was used to pay taxes to a state
- 47:49agency. And obviously this hasn't been
- 47:51authorized yet or at least until the bill goes into effect.
- 47:54But when that does get authorized, that actually all
- 47:58the crypto that gets sort of used for tax purposes is to be
- 48:03sold and converted into Bitcoin. If so chosen, but so chosen by,
- 48:09you know, by the state. And so that was, you know, kind
- 48:12of a fun thing for us to see in there.
- 48:14You know, the the the state policy is is to not ship coin,
- 48:18which is, you know, fun for us. And so that's that's a big
- 48:22pillar. You know, I don't know how big
- 48:25that will end up being, but certainly interesting.
- 48:28And then the other thing to hit on here is the execution.
- 48:31So Zach and I spoke with the team at Falcon X.
- 48:36They're, you know, one of the sort of leaders in, in executing
- 48:40these trades, making sure that when they purchase large
- 48:43amounts, they're not moving the market.
- 48:45And, and so we, you know, spent a fair amount of time with them.
- 48:48I think we had multiple phone calls to, you know, answer
- 48:50questions, figure out exactly, you know, how they would go
- 48:53about this. And, and the language is, is
- 48:54pretty much straight from them. So, you know, really kind of
- 48:58high signal, maybe alpha in there about, you know, how
- 49:02they're acquiring Bitcoin. I have AI have a question more
- 49:08sort of high level, just zooming out for both of you, like, you
- 49:11know, where in your minds are the biggest educational gaps
- 49:17today? And and sort of we've sort of
- 49:19alluded to this throughout the conversation, but you have
- 49:22certain folks in government and policy who our orange build,
- 49:26they're all about Bitcoin. They're trying to convince their
- 49:29other policy makers, their colleagues.
- 49:32You have other people that feel like it's a good idea, but
- 49:34they're not really sure why perhaps.
- 49:37And so there's all these different cohorts of people that
- 49:39are now getting up to speed on this thing.
- 49:41And you know, if you just think about even 1224 months ago, like
- 49:46the conversation was so different, right, Like it was,
- 49:49you know, questioning whether governments were going to ban
- 49:51Bitcoin. And now we're debating, is the
- 49:53government going to buy Bitcoin and which states are going to
- 49:55buy Bitcoin first, right? Like a complete departure from
- 49:59where we were a couple years ago.
- 50:01But that being said, there's still these, you know, these,
- 50:03these gaps. So I'm, I'm curious, like, you
- 50:06know, I think the, the toolkit is a fantastic effort to sort of
- 50:09fill in those gaps. But I'm curious from your
- 50:11vantage, you know, boots on the ground, talking with people
- 50:14every day, where are the, the biggest gaps currently?
- 50:18And, and you know, where do we need to focus our educational
- 50:20efforts going forward? I think the biggest gap, it's
- 50:25easy to lose sight of on this if you're a listener to this
- 50:27podcast, but it's just understanding Bitcoin as a store
- 50:29of value. You know, that's why I like
- 50:32starting with the the finding section.
- 50:36But people really need to understand what Bitcoin is, why
- 50:39it's important. And you know, if you, if you
- 50:43think through the implications of the existence of Bitcoin,
- 50:48you're going to be going down the right path.
- 50:50I so I get my opening speech at the the summit the other week
- 50:55and I showed this scene from 2001, a space odyssey.
- 50:58There's a famous jump cut in the movie where there are monkeys
- 51:01hitting each other with a bone and someone throws the bone up
- 51:03and it becomes a nuclear armed satellite.
- 51:06And like, that's the kind of jump we're talking about here,
- 51:10right? Like imagine you came across an
- 51:13element like gold and you study your history of money and
- 51:16understand why gold is good money and it's gold that you can
- 51:18e-mail. Well, OK, that creates a lot of
- 51:212nd and 3rd order implications for what's going to happen in
- 51:23the world and just getting people there.
- 51:26And the, the challenge is you can say that to someone and you
- 51:29can show them the Bitcoin chart, which I actually think is not
- 51:31super helpful to this conversation.
- 51:33And you can show someone technically how Bitcoin works,
- 51:36which I think is extra not helpful to this conversation.
- 51:39But you know, I didn't want to say it on, on speech in, in the
- 51:42speech in front of our, our audience of policymakers.
- 51:45But there's some element of this.
- 51:46It's like you need to take the like freshman year dorm room
- 51:49bong RIP approach to this, which is like, let it blow your mind
- 51:53for a second that we invented digital gold.
- 51:55Like that's going to cure you of thinking it's the same as meme
- 51:59coins very quickly. That's going to cure you of a
- 52:02lot of the misconceptions people have.
- 52:04And then you start to think about, well, shit, what if China
- 52:07does this first, right? You know, what if people figure
- 52:12out that there just is a better form of money?
- 52:14Like we need to, we need to get on this.
- 52:15And so I think that's still a lot of where the educational
- 52:19efforts are. And then once we get people to
- 52:22that point, then it's sort of channeling in the right policy
- 52:25directions. And and you know, we have
- 52:26technocratic answers for all of the things to do, but, but the
- 52:29big hurdle is getting people to to understand the why.
- 52:34Yeah, that was a big unlock for me on just a lot of the things
- 52:37you guys are doing. And I wasn't unfortunately able
- 52:39to make it, but I know Brian and Liam were there in the sense of
- 52:42like individuals have all the, there's no silver bullet to get
- 52:45an individual to understand Bitcoin because they all have
- 52:47their frame of references that they come from in their
- 52:49backgrounds. And similarly, there's not a
- 52:51civil bullet within policy and government or at a state or even
- 52:58a country level, but you guys are now creating a network and
- 53:04that can go very deep on the different geopolitical
- 53:07ramifications that Bitcoin will have.
- 53:08And they all have different appealing.
- 53:10It's like if this thing grows in its price or it grows in the
- 53:13amount of energy that it consumes or grows in the amount
- 53:15of illicit activity, this is how it has implications now.
- 53:18You should be paying attention. And I think that is something
- 53:21that we just never have seen before.
- 53:23And and it's just exciting because as more of those
- 53:25conversations come out, everyone starts to get more specialized.
- 53:28This is probably how the Internet really came.
- 53:29You know, when you think about it, right?
- 53:30It's like it was this niche thing and then it eventually
- 53:33started to touch on all these different ancillary areas of the
- 53:36world and, and the market and regular regulation.
- 53:40And then everyone started to wake up and then everyone.
- 53:42And that's just how you have these things proliferate and
- 53:44they all start to like intertwine with each other.
- 53:46If you're enjoyed the episode, really would appreciate a like a
- 53:49comment subscribe if you haven't done so already, if you're on a
- 53:53podcast player, if you could rate US five stars really goes a
- 53:55long way. Ultimately, the reason why this
- 53:58helps is it helps our content to be discovered by more people who
- 54:01maybe want to hear it or should hear it.
- 54:04And so if you could just take a few seconds to leave a like a
- 54:07comment subscribe, that helps a ton.
- 54:10There is a lot of effort from the team, myself included, to
- 54:13book guests, prepare for episodes, edit them, all the
- 54:17post production work as well and distribute them.
- 54:19So if you could just leave as a quick token of your appreciation
- 54:23if you're enjoying the content, that really helps.
- 54:26And then the other place I'd point you to as well is on
- 54:28rampbitcoin.com/research. If you want to get our weekly
- 54:32round up product announcements, you know, other things that
- 54:36we're working on behind the scenes looks, you can subscribe
- 54:39there. Typically we send out two issues
- 54:41per week. We're not spamming your inbox,
- 54:43so check us out there if you're not subscribed already and enjoy
- 54:46the rest of the episode. We'd love to talk about as well.
- 54:48Just in the nature of covering a lot of this report the section
- 54:526:00 and 7:00. So talk about economic
- 54:55development initiatives, I know from today's covering some
- 54:58private real estate stuff in a former life, you know, there's a
- 55:01lot of different tax incentives, qualified opportunity zones as
- 55:05one example, and something laid out in this report that I
- 55:07thought was interesting were Bitcoin tax advantage zones and
- 55:11other areas for economic development.
- 55:14And then I think another area that people would really like to
- 55:16hear more about is just what you've laid out in the toolkit
- 55:19as it relates to protection of private property.
- 55:23So throw it over to you guys, Section 6 and seven, just
- 55:27general thoughts there. You want to walk?
- 55:28That's why you take 6, I'll take 7.
- 55:30Perfect. Yeah.
- 55:31So, so 6, there's sort of two branches of 6/1 is obviously
- 55:37the, you know, tax advantage zones.
- 55:39And then the the second branch is the environmental benefits.
- 55:42So both of these actually spawn from a conversation with Andrew
- 55:46Hones, who, you know, also helped us out with the bit bond
- 55:50section. But Andrew maybe was actually
- 55:53more fired up about the these two portions.
- 55:58You know, it's not to underplay how fired up he is about bit
- 56:00bonds. But, you know, this was the
- 56:02first time that I think this had entered the the conversation or,
- 56:05or had an easy route into, you know, policy discussions.
- 56:09So the tax advantage zones was, you know, the impetus is that,
- 56:15you know, Jackson, as you were mentioning earlier, the idea is
- 56:18that Bitcoin companies, Bitcoin holders, any sort of economic
- 56:23activity related to Bitcoin, you know, in the coming years is, is
- 56:27very likely, if not, you know, fairly certain to, you know,
- 56:33lead economic development wherever it may be.
- 56:35So the goal here being to basically attract Bitcoiners,
- 56:40Bitcoin companies, economic activity around Bitcoin to
- 56:44particular jurisdictions. And so states could effectively
- 56:48incentivize those people and those businesses to move from
- 56:52one place to another or, or, you know, some companies that had
- 56:55been traditionally remote, you know, with these incentives.
- 56:58So you know that that has to do with zoning, designations, tax
- 57:03incentives, you know, there's a little bit more minutiae here.
- 57:07This is really kind of tip of the iceberg, but pretty excited
- 57:12to have this in here. And I think something that that
- 57:14we'll probably talk about more in the future.
- 57:16I think this is this is somewhat of a new thing.
- 57:18And then if we jump down to the environmental benefits, this is
- 57:24effectively codifying many of the conversations we've had
- 57:28about how Bitcoin has the potential to, you know, sort of
- 57:32renovate and upgrade existing energy systems.
- 57:36You know, we, we talked about California with Andrew Hones
- 57:38And, you know, bottom line is, is somebody did, you know, an
- 57:42assessment of, you know, PG and ES, which is, you know, Northern
- 57:45California power grid, how much uptime versus utilization they
- 57:51have. And basically they found it
- 57:52that, you know, at an average point, only 50% of PG and ES
- 57:56grid was being used. And so, you know, the point here
- 57:59being let's incentivize more of that energy to be used to mine
- 58:04Bitcoin. And you know, there are
- 58:06incentives in here to to do exactly that.
- 58:09There's a little bit more minutiae here that that I don't
- 58:11think we need to dig into. But if if folks want to look at
- 58:13that more closely, you know, there's some interesting stuff.
- 58:21All right, So Section 7, this one's very short, but I'll go
- 58:27into each term. So the number one pushback that
- 58:29we've had at BPI on strategic reserves by governments in
- 58:34general is doesn't this provide an incentive for the state to
- 58:38just steal your coins or to move coins that they're holding that
- 58:42belong to victims like the, you know, Bit Fenix, move those into
- 58:46government custody. And so the first thing we did is
- 58:49just prevent that from happening.
- 58:52So this language is meant to be very broad.
- 58:54Nothing in the actual be construed to authorize the
- 58:57seizure, confiscation or impairment.
- 59:00And impairment is a very broad word here, right?
- 59:02This is meant to be protections for people running nodes and non
- 59:05custodial software. It's not just the coins will be
- 59:08taken, it's we're not going to impair your ability to use your
- 59:12coins with your own private keys of any person, business or
- 59:17organization. So that's meant to be just a
- 59:19completely broad prohibition on the state reserve being a
- 59:22vehicle for government capture of Bitcoin.
- 59:26And then the next two terms here, affirmation of self
- 59:30custody rights and legal protection come from another
- 59:34frustration I have with other state level bills.
- 59:38I think there are, you know, well meaning Bitcoin folks and
- 59:41Bitcoin advocates in state legislatures that have been
- 59:44going around passing a bunch of, I think very misguided laws that
- 59:49purport to create a state level right to self custody.
- 59:53My view is there are multiple rights embedded in the Bill of
- 59:57Rights in the United States Constitutions that protect your
- 59:59right to self custody. There is a Fourth Amendment
- 1:00:01right against unreasonable search and seizure.
- 1:00:03There's a First Amendment right to free speech when you're doing
- 1:00:06speech activity with Bitcoin to freedom of association right to
- 1:00:10all sorts of things that we could use on the 1st Amendment.
- 1:00:14There are the 5th Amendment due process rights against just
- 1:00:17confiscating Bitcoin. There are. 9th Amendment and
- 1:00:2110th Amendment rights right based on either state versus
- 1:00:24federal law or unenumerated rights.
- 1:00:25There are number rights. And if we have states,
- 1:00:30especially just on partisan lines, having Republicans say,
- 1:00:33OK, you know, we create a state law and now in X state, you
- 1:00:37know, we can't, you can't ban self custody.
- 1:00:40That's going to make it seem like when political power
- 1:00:42shifts, like someone else has the right and those those laws
- 1:00:45could be cited in a, in a legal case saying, look, there isn't a
- 1:00:48constitutional right in our proof of that is that states
- 1:00:50felt the need to write these laws protecting self custody
- 1:00:52when that right was there all along.
- 1:00:55So if you look at B here, this act affirms and protects the
- 1:00:58fundamental right of individuals, right?
- 1:01:00And we're not creating a right here.
- 1:01:02We are affirming a right that already existed as an essential
- 1:01:06component of financial sovereignty and personal
- 1:01:08liberty. We're providing the why for that
- 1:01:10right. It's broader than just taking
- 1:01:12your coins. It's you have to be able to use
- 1:01:15self custody tools and then legal protection.
- 1:01:18The state recognizes Bitcoin as a legitimate digital property
- 1:01:21entitled to the full protection under applicable property rights
- 1:01:24and constitutional protections. We're we're calling that out
- 1:01:27right there. The the rights pre existed.
- 1:01:30You always had the right to self custody Bitcoin.
- 1:01:33We're just making that clear. As opposed to purporting to
- 1:01:36create some new state level rule, which, by the way, would
- 1:01:39be superseded by any federal law anyway, if that's where the
- 1:01:42protection was coming from. I I love all of these sections
- 1:01:46just quick hits because again, I did my homework.
- 1:01:50So you guys had some really great points on the previous
- 1:01:52pause referencing. It's so simple, but if you
- 1:01:54cannot custody your Bitcoin or you cannot transfer it, the
- 1:01:57whole blockchain industry doesn't have any value like it
- 1:02:00has. It all goes away because
- 1:02:02everything's derivative of bitcoins value and I think we
- 1:02:05forget that. So it's, it's a notion or it's
- 1:02:09a, the nod to you guys and the work you're doing, but also just
- 1:02:11the first principles. Thinking of like this has to be
- 1:02:14a core principle of all the different ways and, and you can
- 1:02:17take delivery, but you can leverage other products, but you
- 1:02:20have to have that notion. And then on the the other two
- 1:02:24parts, it's always that thing that I think we've all known
- 1:02:27that Bitcoin is the most ESG asset in the truest sense,
- 1:02:30right? When it comes from the
- 1:02:31environmental, social and governance.
- 1:02:33And we've seen this like obviously biased, but there's
- 1:02:35also a lot of empirical evidence with Texas, whether it's the
- 1:02:38grid, different studies they've done, but then also the amount
- 1:02:41of capital from, you know, the different mining firms and also
- 1:02:44just Bitcoin companies that exist there without the actual
- 1:02:48opportunity zones in place. And we see this in like in El
- 1:02:51Salvador and UAE. I don't think a lot of people
- 1:02:53want to live in those places. I mean, some people do they
- 1:02:55rather live at home. It's just that it's been so
- 1:02:57antagonistic to this industry and as states start to lean into
- 1:03:01this, you're just going to see in Tennessee and Texas and
- 1:03:03Florida have really already reaped the rewards of this and,
- 1:03:06and by codifying it and enacting it, it's just going to
- 1:03:09accelerate that across the board.
- 1:03:11Yeah, this, this derivative point you're making is really
- 1:03:13important. And this is a sort of constant
- 1:03:15frustration for the work we do in DC.
- 1:03:17The day before our summit, I took six or seven meetings on
- 1:03:22Capitol Hill about the the Clarity Act.
- 1:03:25And there are like two or three really important pages of the
- 1:03:27Clarity Act that protect non custodial developers and service
- 1:03:30providers. And I went with policy leads
- 1:03:34from excess wallet and Ledger. And we were just focused on this
- 1:03:37topic and that and that was the first time that most of these
- 1:03:39Staffs had heard of this provision.
- 1:03:42Why it's important, whereas everybody in crypto is sending
- 1:03:45lobbyists DC to talk about what's a security versus what's
- 1:03:48a commodity. And what I would say to the
- 1:03:50crypto companies is if you really mean all the stuff you
- 1:03:54say about decentralization and web 3 and this being innovation
- 1:03:57in the future, that doesn't mean anything If you can't use non
- 1:04:01custodial tools, right, Then it's just a really expensive
- 1:04:04slow database. If you're not doing peer-to-peer
- 1:04:07finance right, it's not actually defy.
- 1:04:09It's you know, it then just boils down to VC pump and dumps.
- 1:04:13So if you'd like this industry to like stick around and mean
- 1:04:16something and build something valuable, all of that rests on
- 1:04:19the ability to have a new paradigm of peer-to-peer
- 1:04:22transfers using blockchains and smart contracts.
- 1:04:25And that's what that stuff in theory is all good for.
- 1:04:28And then in the Bitcoin industry, I know everyone's
- 1:04:30really excited about treasury companies right now, but the
- 1:04:33whole idea of a treasury company is you're buying a valuable
- 1:04:37scarce asset and you're doing a speculative attack and, and
- 1:04:40fine, like, you know, that seems like that fits with the game
- 1:04:43theory on Bitcoin. But what makes Bitcoin the asset
- 1:04:45good? The reason why Bitcoin is
- 1:04:48digital gold and different from all of the forks of Bitcoin or
- 1:04:51other crypto tokens or whatever has to do with its credible
- 1:04:56scarcity and its credible scarcity.
- 1:04:58And it has to do with the fact that it can't be censored, that
- 1:05:02you can't coerce people to change what the code is.
- 1:05:05That it has this decentralized governance mechanism where
- 1:05:08there's a sort of checks and balances between the miners and
- 1:05:11the holders and the node runners and the software developers.
- 1:05:13And none of that works if you can't custody the asset
- 1:05:17yourself, right? The digital gold thesis falls
- 1:05:19apart. So all of this stuff that like
- 1:05:22is about number go up in both Bitcoin and crypto more broadly
- 1:05:26is downstream of you get to do with that technology what it's
- 1:05:30built for, which is use it in a sovereign peer-to-peer fashion.
- 1:05:34That's that's where the value flows from.
- 1:05:36And so we can't forget that part.
- 1:05:39There's a lot of discussion. Bitcoin is can we get to a world
- 1:05:41where Bitcoin is no longer freedom money, but then it's
- 1:05:44millions of dollars a coin. I actually think that's mostly a
- 1:05:48fantasy. There may be some ways in which
- 1:05:49Bitcoin can kind of be Co opted and still be valuable, but over
- 1:05:53the long run, probably most of the scenarios that people are
- 1:05:56envisioning where it becomes sort of BlackRock coin, you're
- 1:05:59not going to be rich for that long because it's going to lose
- 1:06:01it's fundamental value compared to other assets.
- 1:06:03And so even if you're a number go up person, this is something
- 1:06:07you need to care about. Yeah, it's incredibly well said.
- 1:06:11And I think that's a great underpinning and framing for a
- 1:06:14lot of the fervor that exists from the hardcore.
- 1:06:16We've seen it Bitcoiners that have taken a notion to these sub
- 1:06:20codes is I think there's just a lot this is how far we've got in
- 1:06:23the the clown world of first principles, thinking of
- 1:06:26understanding like how did let's play this out?
- 1:06:28Because there's been these crazy numbers going around with how
- 1:06:30much Bitcoin treasury companies will end up holding.
- 1:06:32And it's almost like it really is nonsensical because like, if
- 1:06:34you play this out, they end up having no value because you just
- 1:06:37neutered the whole reason why it does have value.
- 1:06:40And I think either way, it's like gravity, it'll flow in the
- 1:06:43right direction and this will be, you know, all kind of like
- 1:06:45leveled out over time. But it's still just a very
- 1:06:48important notion to bring up. But I don't think people have
- 1:06:51fully thought through the game theory and how this will work
- 1:06:53out if Bitcoin ends up being centralized by 100 large
- 1:06:56institutions. Look, there's a lot of, there's
- 1:07:02a lot to go into on the report. Either one of you would be
- 1:07:06curious just to hear like any other thoughts that we didn't
- 1:07:09get to cover yet that you wanted to make sure we flagged.
- 1:07:11And then I did have a question as it relates to just like state
- 1:07:13level game theory. And then I think we'll wrap up
- 1:07:16if we have time, just a few topical things, but I want to
- 1:07:19make sure we covered our bases here.
- 1:07:21Anything else that we we need to go over?
- 1:07:23Yeah, I think just one quick note, which is, you know, I've
- 1:07:27personally and Zach probably has to had conversations with, you
- 1:07:31know, folks maybe state level blockchain associations folks
- 1:07:35doing state level policy work who are, you know, sort of
- 1:07:39beyond excited to have a resource that has all the the
- 1:07:43bits and pieces that they were looking for.
- 1:07:45And so the note here being, you know, if that is you, if you are
- 1:07:49someone who is sort of actively involved with your state
- 1:07:53legislative process, if you're somebody who wants to, you know,
- 1:07:57push a strategic Bitcoin reserve in your state, you know, we,
- 1:08:02Zach and I are, are are both open to having a conversation to
- 1:08:05supporting that in any way. You know, BPI is, is very sort
- 1:08:09of narrowly focused at the federal level.
- 1:08:12This was really kind of the first thing we did that, you
- 1:08:14know, even sort of slowly verged into the state level stuff.
- 1:08:18And, you know, our resources will sort of continue to be
- 1:08:21focused on the federal level. But at the same time, like we
- 1:08:25put this out there, we'd like to see it succeed.
- 1:08:27And so, you know, we are relying to some extent on on the Bitcoin
- 1:08:31community to to put this into practice.
- 1:08:34So, yeah, open, open channels here.
- 1:08:37I think my emails on the website, so on the BPI website.
- 1:08:41And so if you want to reach me there, that's that's the place
- 1:08:44to do it. I love it.
- 1:08:48Well, yeah. So I'm curious, like, to the
- 1:08:50extent you guys want to spend some time on it quickly,
- 1:08:54Everyone loves to talk about game theory in the Bitcoin
- 1:08:56space. And there's, you know, 11 idea
- 1:09:00or one center of that conversation is at the federal
- 1:09:03level. How does the United States
- 1:09:04compete against adversarial nations, Right.
- 1:09:07China, Russia being some obvious ones, but I do think in the
- 1:09:11nature of this conversation being focused on the state
- 1:09:13toolkit, we'd love to just hear like any parting thoughts in
- 1:09:17terms of how you think this plays out over the next 12
- 1:09:19months or so as it relates to game theory within the United
- 1:09:22States. Because we did touch on Texas.
- 1:09:25We briefly passed on New Hampshire, talked about
- 1:09:27Connecticut as well, you know, taking the wrong approach.
- 1:09:31But I'm curious just in terms of how this all plays out and let's
- 1:09:34call it the next year. I know that's a short amount of
- 1:09:36time, but just what are you paying attention to?
- 1:09:40You know, where do you think states may lead or fall behind
- 1:09:43and just maybe anything else that I'm, I'm not thinking of.
- 1:09:46Would love to hear how you think this plays out within a state
- 1:09:49game theory level. You know, I just think this is a
- 1:09:54situation broadly where being early is huge.
- 1:09:58If we have a huge price run up over the next year, you want to
- 1:10:01be the state that's accumulating now and not the state that's
- 1:10:03accumulating at at 300,000 per coin.
- 1:10:07And if you're the state that's accumulating now when it is
- 1:10:09300,000 per coin, it's going to give you a lot of optionality
- 1:10:12and a lot of freedom. And I think similarly with with
- 1:10:16bit bonds, there is a huge amount of spoils to the state
- 1:10:21that figures this out first, especially if you can get
- 1:10:23comfortable with tax free municipal bonds that give
- 1:10:27upside. You're just going to be able to
- 1:10:29borrow a ton of money now, participate in the Bitcoin
- 1:10:32upside, give Bitcoin upside to the people who are lending money
- 1:10:36to you, and then you're going to be able to finance the
- 1:10:39initiatives. You want to just have a huge
- 1:10:41pool of capital that are otherwise probably not muni bond
- 1:10:43investors that come flooding in. Another point here, and this is
- 1:10:49obviously in the same vein, which is, you know, it also is
- 1:10:53sort of exceedingly clear that the administration is posturing
- 1:10:56to start adding Bitcoin. And, you know, there was a
- 1:10:59comment made, we don't know if this was intended to be made by
- 1:11:04Patrick Witt, who is basically Bo Hines's understudy in the
- 1:11:08White House with reference to an accumulation plan, which, you
- 1:11:13know, is a tie to this White House report that we're
- 1:11:16expecting, you know, sometime in July.
- 1:11:19And so, you know, for states to be looking at that and saying,
- 1:11:22oh, well, what happens if the, you know, most powerful
- 1:11:25government in the world starts accumulating Bitcoin?
- 1:11:29You know, there's, there's massive upside to that as well.
- 1:11:33You know, being the state that that jumped on before the
- 1:11:36federal government started buying, you know that that
- 1:11:38should have some pretty clear upside.
- 1:11:41So. Got to get Pennsylvania in the
- 1:11:44mix. I'm going to be sending the
- 1:11:46toolkit over their way. All right, that all sounds
- 1:11:50great. Michael, did you want to jump in
- 1:11:51or do you want to talk about some of the topical things
- 1:11:54before we close? Yeah, I know we're coming up on
- 1:11:56time. So I think we can do a couple of
- 1:11:58topical things. One thing you guys mentioned, I
- 1:12:02don't think it's been referenced in this way, but like 7%, you
- 1:12:05know the amount of debt being issued referencing to GDP I
- 1:12:08think is that hurdle rate or that notion is gonna become more
- 1:12:12like we know this right? Like inflation is probably year
- 1:12:15over year, 10% roughly, if not even greater based on just like
- 1:12:18the things that we need daily. And as that becomes more in the
- 1:12:23zeitgeist and narrative, people are just gonna seek, We see this
- 1:12:25already shifting, but it's just gonna increase.
- 1:12:27And I think that's where you start to see hard assets and you
- 1:12:30can't. Like I know we like to forget
- 1:12:31about it, but gold is gonna exist for a while and these
- 1:12:33states are probably gonna be piling strategic reserves in
- 1:12:36gold and Bitcoin. And I think that's a healthy
- 1:12:39first step for some of these states is to put Bitcoin next to
- 1:12:42gold. Gold has, you know, precedent as
- 1:12:44global money and existing for thousands of years.
- 1:12:46I think that's another angle we're starting to play around
- 1:12:48with, trying to, you know, move away from crypto and move it
- 1:12:52closer to this other asset that has fundamental value.
- 1:12:58Yeah. On the top of the subject or go
- 1:13:00ahead. Well, I was going to say, we're
- 1:13:02already starting to see inflation as a topic breaking
- 1:13:06into the political zeitgeist and the way that the economy is not
- 1:13:10going to work for Gen. Z and Gen.
- 1:13:12Alpha. They can't afford a home, you
- 1:13:14know, and and you know, the jobs are fewer and fewer between and
- 1:13:18there's returns to capital and not returns to labor.
- 1:13:21And what that's going to do is what it's been doing since 1971
- 1:13:26and an accelerated pace since 2008, which is to make wealthy
- 1:13:30people wealthier as their assets appreciate against Fiat, and
- 1:13:34then people whose only asset is their income relatively poorer.
- 1:13:38And that's going to create a lot of unhappiness.
- 1:13:42And, you know, I think this is unfortunate situation where
- 1:13:46nothing is going to stop this train.
- 1:13:48You know, Bitcoin in the short term is not going to fix it.
- 1:13:50It's going to allow people an escape boat from this, but it's
- 1:13:53not going to fix that effect. And I think, you know, over the,
- 1:13:58you know, short to medium term, the next few years, you maybe
- 1:14:02see the United States in some ways start to look more like
- 1:14:04South America, where wealthy people are sending their kids to
- 1:14:06school and armored cars. And you get more and more
- 1:14:09dislocation between the haves and the have nots.
- 1:14:11And then at some point in the medium term, you get a populist
- 1:14:14backlash to that, like you've seen in a lot of of South
- 1:14:17American countries where you, you know, elect someone on the
- 1:14:20far left who wants to confiscate assets.
- 1:14:24And that all that energy in in both the political left and the
- 1:14:28right could be channelled into incredibly destructive
- 1:14:31tendencies. And you could see violence and
- 1:14:33all sorts of stuff. And Bitcoin is both a relatively
- 1:14:38painless sort of peaceful solution to this problem, like
- 1:14:42an actual productive solution rather than just fighting it
- 1:14:45out. Also, just as an individual
- 1:14:48who's looking at like, what is your game theoretic outcome
- 1:14:50here? It helps you in both directions.
- 1:14:52It helps you with the debasement, preserving your
- 1:14:55wealth and being on the right side of the divide between asset
- 1:14:57holders and someone who lives on a Fiat standard.
- 1:15:00And then you know, if things go badly in the other direction, it
- 1:15:04protects you against the risk of confiscation.
- 1:15:07Real estate, which is in a physical jurisdiction is
- 1:15:09impossible to move and really easy to confiscate.
- 1:15:11Bitcoin is not. You memorize 12 words.
- 1:15:14You can walk across the border naked with a billion dollars.
- 1:15:17And so I, I think people will start to realize that both of
- 1:15:21those sort of features of, of Bitcoin, it's, it's scarcity and
- 1:15:23it's censorship resistance, you know, really make it the perfect
- 1:15:29asset to navigate some of the darker parts of the, the 21st
- 1:15:33century. Yeah, it's a great call if that
- 1:15:36doesn't get discussed. I've been thinking personally
- 1:15:38about it. We see fires, floods and all
- 1:15:41these just different geopolitical things happening.
- 1:15:43And the notion of everyone's capital being in their house, of
- 1:15:46their land is in a bulletproof solution.
- 1:15:48I think it was for a very long time, but especially in the US
- 1:15:52But it's just not necessarily the case.
- 1:15:54And the notion to be able to preserve your asset and move
- 1:15:57across, you know, state borders or, or, you know, larger federal
- 1:16:01borders is going to be a big, I think, like part of this thesis.
- 1:16:06I'd be curious to get sort of a state of play of where we are
- 1:16:12with all the federal legislation.
- 1:16:14So we've referenced a few things throughout the conversation.
- 1:16:17The CLARITY Act, we didn't touch on the Genius bill, but that
- 1:16:20seems to have progressed the farthest to date.
- 1:16:23Can we get sort of just like an update on where we are?
- 1:16:26What are some key dates to look forward to?
- 1:16:29I know that crypto report is due in a few weeks from the
- 1:16:32administration. And then also, you know, if you
- 1:16:35could touch on where the Clarity Act is, what ramifications that
- 1:16:38possibly has and and sort of what to look out for going
- 1:16:41forward here from a legislative perspective.
- 1:16:44My best guess to go sort of quickly on each and then if you
- 1:16:47want me to drill down with the time we've left, I can, we will
- 1:16:50see the Genius Act signed into law and we'll see the crypto
- 1:16:54report. I think both by the end of this
- 1:16:56month. I think quite high likelihood
- 1:17:00that the Genius Act passes and makes it through the House
- 1:17:05probably is a standalone bill, not including market structure.
- 1:17:07Market structure. The Senate is working on their
- 1:17:10version to match the Houses version, the Clarity Act.
- 1:17:14My understanding from talking to folks on Capitol Hill is like
- 1:17:17there might be a discussion draft out there by the end of
- 1:17:19the summer and voting on some sort of final draft later in the
- 1:17:23year in the fall or, you know, the winter.
- 1:17:26That's going to be a bigger political lift.
- 1:17:29There's going to be intense national security FUD about
- 1:17:32that. There are some moderate
- 1:17:35Republicans who feel burned by being pulled too fast to sign on
- 1:17:39to the Genius Act, and Democrats are going to try and put in
- 1:17:41provisions to make the Trump family divest from crypto, which
- 1:17:45is going to be politically difficult.
- 1:17:48So I think probably 5050 chance that that ultimately passes
- 1:17:53based on the current dynamics. But that is our biggest focus is
- 1:17:58making sure that that passes and it passes with the protections
- 1:18:01for open source developers in Section 110 of the Clarity Act.
- 1:18:06Then there's the Bitcoin Act. That's a bigger lift right now.
- 1:18:11You know the person, our team who's closest to that is, is
- 1:18:14Grant McCarthy, who I think recently publicly said he thinks
- 1:18:16it's a double digit chance, but he doesn't want to commit to a
- 1:18:19number. I think that that's probably far
- 1:18:21off. We need to move the Overton
- 1:18:23window on that one. But I think more likely than
- 1:18:25that is that either as part of the crypto report which will
- 1:18:31come out this month or sometime thereafter, we get an actual
- 1:18:35plan from the executive branch on how to accumulate Bitcoin in
- 1:18:38a budget neutral way. I think that is the more likely
- 1:18:42nearer term outcome than the standalone Bitcoin Act passing.
- 1:18:46Maybe just to to drill down on that last point, like what would
- 1:18:49be the difference in your eyes between some sort of executive
- 1:18:54branch LED accumulation plan relative to the Bitcoin act just
- 1:19:00from like a robustness perspective?
- 1:19:02It's less robust. Yeah, it would.
- 1:19:04It would be smaller. There's less money they can draw
- 1:19:06from because it needs to be budget neutral.
- 1:19:09They can't do the revaluation of gold, which is what funds the
- 1:19:12the Bitcoin Act. But it would be meaningful,
- 1:19:16right, If the United States government is like, all right,
- 1:19:17we're doing it. We're out there buying Bitcoin
- 1:19:19to put on the balance sheet. I would not underestimate the
- 1:19:23knock on effects that has, especially internationally.
- 1:19:26I think there are a lot of countries that have been
- 1:19:28stacking that really don't want to front run the US on this,
- 1:19:31that this will both give cover and and frankly FOMO to to
- 1:19:35leaders around the world. So I think that really could
- 1:19:37kick start some craziness, but it is something that a future
- 1:19:40administration could undo, unlike with the Bitcoin Act
- 1:19:44where you'd have to pass a different law.
- 1:19:49Excellent. Well, I know we're coming up on
- 1:19:51time. I think just one other thing to
- 1:19:53call out quickly would be the big beautiful bill.
- 1:19:56Last week, we raised the debt ceiling for the 79th time.
- 1:20:01Maybe this could be the final one.
- 1:20:03We're going to get it all under order now.
- 1:20:05But now the debt, the debt ceiling is 41 trillion.
- 1:20:08We're sitting at about $37 trillion of federal debt.
- 1:20:12And then I saw this tweet yesterday.
- 1:20:15Here it is. So with that, we added another
- 1:20:19called $400 billion or so in one day of new federal debt.
- 1:20:23Zach, you had mentioned that inflation is in the lexicon of
- 1:20:27policy makers. I don't think people were as
- 1:20:28concerned about inflation A decade ago.
- 1:20:30But certainly in the past five years with fiscal dominance and
- 1:20:33handing out cash and 0 interest rate policy, negative interest
- 1:20:37rate policy abroad, this is going to continue to be an
- 1:20:39issue, You know, with the debt ceiling.
- 1:20:41The idea, the idea to other people who are not as involved
- 1:20:45in the industry as we are is that while this delays a
- 1:20:48potential default on the debt, but every time the debt ceiling
- 1:20:53is raised, the US government is defaulting on the obligations.
- 1:20:56And I'm just curious, like in DC, what the sentiment is around
- 1:21:00federal debt as it stands today. Obviously, the bill passed last
- 1:21:03week, but is there like an acknowledgement that this is
- 1:21:07really not going to ever be resolved?
- 1:21:10Nothing stops his train. Is that kind of why we're seeing
- 1:21:12zeitgeist with Elon? I think we are.
- 1:21:14We are seeing that. I mean, people know that the
- 1:21:17debt's not getting smaller. The problem is that is is the
- 1:21:21game theory in DC. There's not political will for
- 1:21:23it. The left, the Democrats, they
- 1:21:26want to do a huge amount of spending on social programs.
- 1:21:29The right wants to do a huge amount of spending on give backs
- 1:21:33to to corporate donors. Neither really hates the other
- 1:21:38one doing their thing so much. They both hate raising tax.
- 1:21:41I mean, the Democrats talk about raising taxes, but that's not
- 1:21:44popular. They're not going to win on
- 1:21:45that. And so like the compromise, the
- 1:21:48Pareto efficient outcome is that we just monetize our debt over
- 1:21:53time and then we covertly take money from savers.
- 1:21:56And that is what's happening. It's what's happened.
- 1:21:58It's what will continue to happen.
- 1:22:00And smart people understand that.
- 1:22:03I think more people will come to understand that we're, you know,
- 1:22:06one other part of this bill. I mean, the the like tax cuts
- 1:22:10are being made permanent. The pay fors are temporary and
- 1:22:14in the future. There was a parliamentary trick
- 1:22:18that allows for more spending that the Republicans use that
- 1:22:20you can just bet the Democrats are going to use next time
- 1:22:23they're in power to do their spending priorities.
- 1:22:25And this, it's a self reinforcing thing, right?
- 1:22:28The train is not, you know, you're not going to not only not
- 1:22:31stop it, the train is accelerating.
- 1:22:34And So what do you do about that?
- 1:22:37And yeah, I mean like it's, it's super bearish for fiscal
- 1:22:43responsibility and it's super bullish for the Bitcoin price.
- 1:22:47Well, I think that's a good place to end.
- 1:22:49Everyone wants to hear some bullish sentiment.
- 1:22:51Gentlemen, really appreciate the time you spent with us today.
- 1:22:54Excited to see the report out in the public.
- 1:22:57You'll get this podcast out as well.
- 1:23:00Where would you like people to send?
- 1:23:01You'll obviously link out to the report, but if people want to
- 1:23:04get in touch with either one of you individually, where would
- 1:23:06you like to send them? Yeah.
- 1:23:08So the the report will be up on GitHub and also there will be
- 1:23:12like a directory from our main website, whichisbtcpolicy.org.
- 1:23:17So that's probably the best place for for folks to go check
- 1:23:19this out. It will be on on the homepage
- 1:23:22pretty close to the top. And then Zach and I both have
- 1:23:25profiles on our about page. Mine has an e-mail on it.
- 1:23:28So if you want to reach out, you can loop Zach in pretty easily
- 1:23:31there. And then we're both on Twitter
- 1:23:34at Zach Cohen under Score. And I'm at Zach B Shapiro.
- 1:23:40Well, Zach, awesome. Thank you very much.
- 1:23:42Appreciate the. Time.
- 1:23:43Thanks. For joining us.
- 1:23:45Thanks for having. US Thanks for listening to this
- 1:23:47week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:23:50valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:23:52rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:23:54All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:23:56notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:23:59reminder that on Ramp Media is for informational and
- 1:24:01entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:24:04investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:24:07your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:24:10Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:24:14one of our private Client advisors.