Latest / Totally Classic / Does the Body Keeps the Score?
Transcript
- 0:03Andy Swindler: So, I have been living the bachelor life for the last week, as my wife and daughter have been.
- 0:11Andy Swindler: gallivanting around Paris.
- 0:13Brendan McNamara: Pretty awesome.
- 0:14Andy Swindler: And it's been… productive, and… Relaxing, and I've dug back into…
- 0:24Andy Swindler: Where I caught up with some of the newer incarnations of Star Trek, which I'm loving.
- 0:29Andy Swindler: But I'm noticing a phenomenon that is still… A mystery to me.
- 0:36Andy Swindler: So there's certain things that happen around the house that really just bug me.
- 0:41Andy Swindler: And sometimes bug me to the level of, like.
- 0:45Andy Swindler: having a pretty big reaction. Like, it might be…
- 0:51Andy Swindler: Why can't anybody bother to close a cabinet?
- 0:54Brendan McNamara: Yeah. Or something like that. Walk away.
- 0:57Andy Swindler: And walk away.
- 0:59Andy Swindler: The mystery, though, is that, since I'm the only one here with my kittens and my iguana.
- 1:05Brendan McNamara: Hmm.
- 1:06Andy Swindler: I've noticed sometimes this still happens.
- 1:11Brendan McNamara: Hmm.
- 1:12Brendan McNamara: Why did they do this?
- 1:14Andy Swindler: And how? How do they do this from thousands of miles away?
- 1:18Brendan McNamara: Yep.
- 1:19Andy Swindler: So… So I'm wondering if that has anything to do with our topic today.
- 1:28Andy Swindler: What's happening in my brain and my body?
- 1:30Brendan McNamara: Mmm.
- 1:32Brendan McNamara: That is, oh, that is casting your own errors on other people. Oh, that… wow, you… you leapt, like, 3 to 7 layers deep already.
- 1:40Brendan McNamara: See, people think lived experience and anecdotes are cheap, Brendan McNamara.
- 1:45Brendan McNamara: But… That's actually pretty profound.
- 1:48Brendan McNamara: The subject today is, does the body keep the score?
- 1:53Brendan McNamara: Which is in reference to, if you're in certain communities, this phrase has been ringing around your head for almost a decade.
- 2:01Brendan McNamara: published, I think, in 2014?
- 2:03Brendan McNamara: And swiftly became… Sort of the underpinnings of vast swaths of social science.
- 2:11Brendan McNamara: And recently, an article came out that was published in Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience, The Body Does Not Keep the Score, Trauma, Predictive Coding, and the Restoration of Metastability, by four authors, but most famously here, a man named Carl Friston.
- 2:30Brendan McNamara: who is at the University College London, more influential
- 2:36Brendan McNamara: theoretical neurologists and brain mapping scientists in the world, and I don't know why it took them
- 2:43Brendan McNamara: 6… 12 years to…
- 2:46Brendan McNamara: bump out a… this decade of the body keeps score enticing metaphor, implying that experience is literally inscribed in flesh, that the body bears the scars of what the mind cannot face. Yet, recent advances in computational and systems neuroscience reveal that this image, while emotionally compelling, is biologically inaccurate.
- 3:08Brendan McNamara: Now, to people who have built entire frameworks on this concept, this is a huge deal. To the rest of the world, maybe this means nothing at all, but that is our episode, because it is an interesting flashpoint and echoes all the way
- 3:23Brendan McNamara: 3 to 7 layers down.
- 3:25Brendan McNamara: Even deep into the… the fascinating way that, Andy, you've already introduced
- 3:32Brendan McNamara: How it can influence our perceptions of others, and basically.
- 3:37Brendan McNamara: Let me restate your thing. Put our ship On other people's plate.
- 3:45Andy Swindler: Well said.
- 3:46Andy Swindler: And you, you sort of tucked in your name there. I am Andy Swindler.
- 3:51Brendan McNamara: This is totally classic. So we're gonna ask this question, we're gonna talk about this question, and we're gonna try to answer it in binary fashion.
- 3:58Andy Swindler: Yes, yes, with our pre-vote.
- 4:01Brendan McNamara: Yeah. My pre-vote is, does Buddy keep the score?
- 4:05Brendan McNamara: In the way that that phrase is meant.
- 4:09Brendan McNamara: I'm gonna go ahead and say, thumbs down.
- 4:13Brendan McNamara: But I think it was a thumbs down even before this paper came out. I was just like, that doesn't sound… because it doesn't sound folk wisdom true to me, even, or common sense. So it was like, oh, that's an interesting way to think about it. Like, does the body suffer from stress?
- 4:28Brendan McNamara: Absolutely. Is that the same thing that's being claimed by the body that keeps the score? I think early on, I didn't know what it meant.
- 4:34Brendan McNamara: But now we're gears deep, and I'm pretty immersed in what has been built on top of it, and almost everything that's been built on top of it is wildly unstable, so I think I was just like, well, sort of a commonality. The commonality is this concept of
- 4:50Brendan McNamara: sort of stress-changing physical form, or even it goes, we'll get into later, has gone in to be stated as elaborate as it alters our DNA in a way that can be passed down to our progeny. And I remember that this came up in Christian circles, too. There's this whole sense of, like, breaking generational curses.
- 5:08Brendan McNamara: So to me, I recognize this pretty immediately as, oh, this is a metaphysical concept. This is not.
- 5:15Brendan McNamara: scientific, and I don't know why people are trying to make it scientific. Actually, very similar to one of my bailiwicks. Subjective gender identity.
- 5:22Brendan McNamara: That's a metaphysical concept. I have no idea why people are trying to make it into a literal or scientific concept. It isn't. That's like trying to make generational curses. It's basically a return… this is a fascinating thing, the whole thing is a return to superstition.
- 5:36Brendan McNamara: pseudoscience and, you know, I feel like we're regressing as a culture, even as we advance our technology to support our regression, question mark?
- 5:46Brendan McNamara: What's your pre-vote?
- 5:48Andy Swindler: Well, this… this might be a juicy one. My pre-vote is yes.
- 5:51Brendan McNamara: Okay.
- 5:52Andy Swindler: I realize that has a lot to do with, how I have
- 5:56Andy Swindler: absorbed the work, and the… Yeah.
- 6:00Andy Swindler: that I perceive it's done more good than harm.
- 6:04Andy Swindler: But this will be really cool, because I have not remotely researched, like, the tentacles.
- 6:09Brendan McNamara: Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 6:10Andy Swindler: You know, in my own life, in my own work, and…
- 6:13Andy Swindler: I guess the people I've encountered
- 6:17Andy Swindler: that reference this, you know, it seems to be useful.
- 6:21Andy Swindler: So… I just wanna… there's a couple of excerpts from the article that I think would be valuable.
- 6:29Andy Swindler: I have a funny connection to this, too, because I've… I have met Stephen Cutler, the lead author.
- 6:36Andy Swindler: In fact, a month ago, I saw him speak again at Human Tech Week. So there… there he is on the right there.
- 6:43Brendan McNamara: Very cool.
- 6:44Andy Swindler: Talks a lot about flow, or the,
- 6:47Andy Swindler: kind of fast-talking, well-spoken dude, and…
- 6:52Andy Swindler: the… you've sort of summarized, I think, well, the basic thesis of this article.
- 6:58Andy Swindler: So, but one thing, you know, they… this is a rebuttal to Bessel van der Kolk,
- 7:04Andy Swindler: Which I… I've read. I've read The Body Keeps the Score a while back. Just for context, I do not remotely consider myself an expert. I'm not… I don't have, like, formal trauma training, and yet I realize, as we're doing this episode, I'm like, oh.
- 7:17Andy Swindler: This is my, sort of, chosen,
- 7:21Andy Swindler: Pleasure reading path, if you will.
- 7:23Brendan McNamara: Oh, for sure, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 7:24Andy Swindler: my… you referenced My Grandmother's Hands by Resmond Menachem, I've just…
- 7:28Andy Swindler: you know, went through Lisa Feldman Barrett, who… I… I don't know that they… I don't think they name her, but they talk a lot about the brain predictions, which is, like, sort of the whole cornerstone of her work about emotions. And, and now I'm actually returning to… I took a break, but I'm returning to The Myth of Normal by Gabor Mate and his son Daniel.
- 7:48Andy Swindler: So… Yeah, I'm like…
- 7:51Andy Swindler: And I, you know, I know an undercurrent for us is, like, how do we reduce harm? And so, obviously, adjacent to that is, how do we heal?
- 7:59Andy Swindler: And how do we heal is… Pretty importantly defined by What is harm, right?
- 8:06Brendan McNamara: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 8:07Andy Swindler: in the first place.
- 8:08Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 8:09Brendan McNamara: Or it goes into, immediately into the metaphysical and religious realm. Meaning, how do we heal from our fundamental brokenness, as opposed to, once things take on this air of, like, science or pseudoscience, then you're like, oh, this means healing.
- 8:23Brendan McNamara: Actual objective injury.
- 8:25Brendan McNamara: And I think that's what's…
- 8:27Brendan McNamara: have attempted to… I think maybe in some ways that's where the theory went awry, was being like, oh, okay, so it's real.
- 8:33Brendan McNamara: And people were like, right, like, oh, what is it, misgendering is violence, silence is violence, like, this whole thing of, like, oh, we're making harm, or you're being offended, equal to…
- 8:45Brendan McNamara: like, trauma. And my kids grow up with it, too. They joke about it, but it's kind of… and they're 10 and 12, they joke about, like, ugh, that's trauma. Oh, all backstories have trauma.
- 8:57Andy Swindler: It has become a…
- 8:59Brendan McNamara: You're just like…
- 9:00Andy Swindler: almost throwaway word. That… that… and I… that's interesting, because I… I hadn't thought about if that's correlated to…
- 9:07Andy Swindler: this book.
- 9:08Brendan McNamara: Yeah. Yeah, I think it has to be! I mean, that's the underpinnings of the whole idea that, like, anything that you don't like then… I think it basically collided with the safetyism movement that we… that all the hack comics made fun of, and we made fun of the hack comics for making fun of, not realizing they were pointing out something…
- 9:24Brendan McNamara: socially, civilizationally devastating. Jonathan Haidt, like, is probably the most prominent figure who criticizes this. So it seems like the two collided, where it was like, now all the, like, helicopter… what do they call it? Helicopter moms, or whatever? Helicopter dads, they can now justify their own
- 9:42Brendan McNamara: psychosis or paranoia. Their hypochondria, or sort of, like, almost like moon chasm by proxy, that they're pushing on their children by being helicopter parents, and go, see? See, we were justified. I was worried, because if they were hurt by that.
- 9:56Brendan McNamara: emotionally, they would then be traumatized, which means it's gonna damage them forever. Their body, you know, they're going to have cancer at higher rates, and blah blah blah blah. And I think it also tried to synergize, like, stress… high-stress environments seem to produce deleterious health conditions.
- 10:11Brendan McNamara: I don't think that's crazy, but I think they just formed a sort of wacky theory.
- 10:15Brendan McNamara: Again, it's almost exactly kindred to this whole idea of gender identity, where it's like.
- 10:20Brendan McNamara: If you believe something to be true, then that makes it… objectively true.
- 10:26Brendan McNamara: So then, I mean, we're in a… that's… which is pretty intense. Now, listen, we… later on, we can get if there's a nocebo effect here, meaning the more you say you have trauma…
- 10:35Brendan McNamara: Do you essentially give your brain trauma responses?
- 10:38Brendan McNamara: Meaning… and the right… because we're getting to level mental health rates, whereas we're going to have to redefine normal.
- 10:45Brendan McNamara: Because if, let's say, 30% of people are on SSRIs or whatever, you know, extreme amount in certain cohorts, then…
- 10:52Brendan McNamara: That's not abnormal anymore. Like, that is a significant enough percentage of the population that that's just…
- 10:58Brendan McNamara: That's a basic divergence within norm.
- 11:01Brendan McNamara: And so, is part of that. So in terms of, like, the downstream harm, even just psychologically, seems, as far as I can tell.
- 11:08Brendan McNamara: Probably dominantly harm-based.
- 11:12Andy Swindler: Well, it's… you remind me of, you know, with all the biometrics available now, the Oura Ring or whatever.
- 11:18Andy Swindler: Now we're starting to study… What's the impact?
- 11:22Andy Swindler: To you, of seeing that reading, or becoming so vigilant about
- 11:27Andy Swindler: you know, paying attention, you know, there's value to it, you know? My mom just started, like, monitoring her glucose, and it's like, oh wow, that's… that's amazing. I can literally see how my body reacts to…
- 11:39Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 11:39Andy Swindler: The thing I just ate? Wow, isn't that cool? But yeah, I think maybe that's the theme throughout, is do we take these things too far? That is a… I think, a theme we're always…
- 11:51Andy Swindler: investigating, and this, I was saying, is an example… yet another great example of how horrible the internet is at debate.
- 12:00Andy Swindler: large, because it's.
- 12:01Brendan McNamara: Yeah, yeah.
- 12:02Andy Swindler: It's not a debate. It's like, we're all, you know, sort of like, I'm posting your post. It's not a real conversation, because you're just sort of talking…
- 12:08Andy Swindler: Sometimes they intersect, but I feel like they're often just talking past each other. But that was a great setup for the first excerpt from the article. Van der Kolk is not naive about neural substrates. Our concern is not with his invocation of neuroscience, but with the rhetorical emphasis of the work, and, more importantly, its reception.
- 12:27Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 12:28Andy Swindler: The body… the book's most memorable language that trauma, quote, lives in the body.
- 12:32Andy Swindler: Has often been taken fully and literally, suggesting that traumatic experience is stored in bodily tissues apart from neural innervation.
- 12:41Andy Swindler: This is a reading that the metaphor invites, even if the text occasionally qualifies it.
- 12:48Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 12:49Brendan McNamara: That's… I think that's a huge… yeah, that's an exact match to what we've talked about on this podcast probably 15 times.
- 12:56Andy Swindler: Well, I have to really investigate
- 12:59Andy Swindler: I almost wish I'd asked myself this question before I started reading.
- 13:02Brendan McNamara: Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 13:03Andy Swindler: this.
- 13:06Andy Swindler: I… it's… it's kind of funny, because I don't…
- 13:09Andy Swindler: I don't think I took it that literally when I first read it.
- 13:14Brendan McNamara: Okay.
- 13:17Andy Swindler: I don't know, that's a really…
- 13:19Andy Swindler: I gotta think about that more. Like, maybe in some cases, because I think I probably have referenced, like.
- 13:24Andy Swindler: Oh yeah, like, this sensation here…
- 13:27Andy Swindler: But they… but they… they reference, and some of the science gets a little over my head, but it's like, they do reference, like.
- 13:34Andy Swindler: there are connections. You know, so I think everybody's saying it's connected, and there are certain interpret, you know, sensations and interpretations, you know, that exist in the body, and then it's, like, how the brain interprets that.
- 13:47Andy Swindler: And it doesn't seem like van der Kolk was, like, dismissing the brain and saying, oh, it all lives in the body, at all.
- 13:55Brendan McNamara: No, I don't think so.
- 13:56Andy Swindler: And, you know, so… I don't know, I don't know, to me it was…
- 14:02Andy Swindler: the reason I guess, I hope it did more good than harm was… To just start to…
- 14:08Andy Swindler: normalize the connection, to just… because I think so much of 20th century psychology was just about
- 14:15Andy Swindler: Like, talk therapy in the head, and so now…
- 14:18Andy Swindler: through all these different lenses, we're like, oh, this is… this is more complex, and… and there… and I want to hear your response, but then in a minute, I… I found one really good kind of rebuttal.
- 14:29Andy Swindler: Rebuttal to the rebuttal on Instagram.
- 14:31Brendan McNamara: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 14:33Andy Swindler: And he helped me… I don't know, I thought he wove it together in a beautiful way, but yeah, what do you… what do you think about this?
- 14:39Brendan McNamara: Yeah, well, it's interesting, like, especially, yeah, within the therapeutic… schema.
- 14:44Brendan McNamara: I think this is one of the reasons why it caught on like wildfire, is for a small percentage of the population, but a very influential one.
- 14:53Brendan McNamara: Therapy is similar to church.
- 14:56Brendan McNamara: or religion.
- 14:58Brendan McNamara: I speak from personal experience, but I've also seen this in the literature. In personal experience, I noted I had friends who were
- 15:05Brendan McNamara: Serial dating. Like, trying to really date enough people until they found someone who could be a real partner.
- 15:11Brendan McNamara: in it.
- 15:12Brendan McNamara: I heard easily a dozen times in a year.
- 15:15Brendan McNamara: Multiple people say, well, yeah, you know, he's this, he's that.
- 15:20Brendan McNamara: But I don't know how emotionally intelligent he is. You know, he's not even in therapy.
- 15:26Andy Swindler: Or the one that is more common in my world is, like, are they doing the work?
- 15:31Brendan McNamara: Do it again.
- 15:31Andy Swindler: I have certainly said myself, and, you know…
- 15:34Brendan McNamara: Totally, yeah, yeah, yeah, so it's that same phenomenon, which, when I first, a couple times I heard it, I was like, I have never heard this outside of a movie about Jewish people.
- 15:43Brendan McNamara: they're like, is she Jewish? That's, like, the Jewish mother whose first question, you know, in every Neil Simon dating scenario, or whatever for, you know, 100 years, it's, like, whatever. Borscht humor.
- 15:55Brendan McNamara: And so, I was like, what a phenomenal thing that this has become, like, religious, even though not that many people are in therapy, nor is therapy relevant to most people. Maybe it would be functional for you for a couple weeks, maybe a month, maybe a couple years. Maybe for some people, long-term care is helpful.
- 16:11Brendan McNamara: What I liked about it is that it actually just highlights
- 16:14Brendan McNamara: The impossibility of therapy and talk therapy.
- 16:18Brendan McNamara: being… Solely a function of cognition.
- 16:22Brendan McNamara: I think this is a mistake a lot of people make.
- 16:25Brendan McNamara: I am a person who My entire life, is to pick up words, Read them.
- 16:32Brendan McNamara: Figured out what that does to my body, how my body is going to stand, how my character is going to stand, because he speaks in this way, which tells me, if a script's good enough, you know how he…
- 16:43Brendan McNamara: he or she, whoever I'm playing, stands based on their words, based on sentence structure. Now, bad writers can infer all sorts of things they didn't mean, but an actor's job is to draw everything out of as possible. They speak in short.
- 16:55Brendan McNamara: you know, short sentences, short clip sentences, I'm probably borrowing from… I'm looking at pictures of Ernest Hemingway, watching Tommy Lee Jones, how he acts, right? You're immediately… there are physical
- 17:07Brendan McNamara: Somatic things occurring.
- 17:09Brendan McNamara: with every sonic receipt.
- 17:12Brendan McNamara: Your body vibrates differently with different words.
- 17:15Brendan McNamara: Different parts of your brain are activated by different sound forms. I wrote a whole paper that I haven't published yet called The Body Keeps the Score, the music of Gender, because the Gen root, which roots gender, is the idea for 6,000 years, human beings in hundreds of languages now receive the sound gen, or gen.
- 17:33Brendan McNamara: and know what it means. Like, your body responds to gain, because it has kin… it's a kin-related length thing, which means you start thinking.
- 17:42Brendan McNamara: Mother, father, uncle?
- 17:44Brendan McNamara: like, or generative AI, right? As soon as it's generative AI, we know what that means. That means it can create things, it can reproduce. So, as soon as you hear gen, and this is… you know this for branding, right? When you had to build COGO or anything.
- 17:57Brendan McNamara: You're like, the… it's not just what the words mean that's also important, it's the sound they make, it's how they feel in your body. And so, talk therapy has always been a body-based therapy. The good part that I really agree with with you is
- 18:11Brendan McNamara: Dancing is… Medicine in the same way that talking is medicine.
- 18:17Brendan McNamara: Movement is medicine. Going for a walk, I don't like it, but it's medicine. Getting in the sun, these are things that are true, and I think in some ways, people were sort of trying to colonize Indigenous wisdom, as they are with gender, too, and then, like.
- 18:31Brendan McNamara: cram it into a science thing, and then smash it, smash it up like paste, and then be like, this is the truth, you know? I was like, it's just… but it's that sort of limited attention span application. So in some ways, I'm glad that they addressed it, just to be like.
- 18:46Brendan McNamara: None of y'all are being rational about this, and I do this on a daily basis, and I'm trying to slow down.
- 18:52Brendan McNamara: Same thing with gender identity, right? It was coined as…
- 18:55Brendan McNamara: A subjective sense of one's own gender, one's own sex.
- 19:01Brendan McNamara: Cool!
- 19:02Brendan McNamara: In no world does that constitute reality. That's… there's completely different layers. You can think about yourself a billion, trillion ways, but that doesn't define in any way what's occurring with your body. And of course, I have to bring that up, because that's one of the things that this theory underpins.
- 19:18Brendan McNamara: That essentially, like, what you take in, or even what you believe about reality or yourself, is as real as anything else. And I'm a writer, so I've said many times in my life, sometimes metaphor is more true
- 19:31Brendan McNamara: quote-unquote, and I've already used quotes, is more true than reality.
- 19:36Brendan McNamara: And so that's what I think exactly they're confronting. People took the metaphor here, or even the metaphor of gender, as this, like, oh, I don't know, it means, like, femininity, masculinity. That's just a metaphor use. The metaphor is not the reality. That's a like or as, it's a simile or metaphor.
- 19:52Brendan McNamara: Similarly, I think that's essentially what they're addressing.
- 19:57Brendan McNamara: And it's not that the metaphor doesn't have some value like you're talking about, but it's not true.
- 20:01Brendan McNamara: truth. It's just not in that realm, and I think people… that's what people are trying to cram it into. Put it into the truth box. Oh, this is real.
- 20:09Brendan McNamara: You know?
- 20:09Andy Swindler: Oh, yeah, words matter, right? I… there was something I saw recently where there was a guy, I think he was a therapist, was studying, just the impact of journaling.
- 20:21Andy Swindler: Journaling for 20 minutes.
- 20:23Andy Swindler: had more impact than… I think he was actually saying more impact than talk therapy in particular.
- 20:30Andy Swindler: And that's… that's words, right? You know, so what is it about… and I want to dig into that more, because I didn't know… I know there's research about writing versus typing and all that.
- 20:38Brendan McNamara: Yep.
- 20:39Andy Swindler: Versus speaking, right?
- 20:40Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 20:41Andy Swindler: It's really relevant to what we're building, because we're… it's a voice…
- 20:43Andy Swindler: The voice experience, so it's like…
- 20:45Brendan McNamara: What?
- 20:46Andy Swindler: Because… what does that mean in…
- 20:48Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 20:49Andy Swindler: And, you know, even… it's funny, it's always a little funny to me even separating the brain and the body to begin with, right? Because they're…
- 20:56Brendan McNamara: It's interesting. Yeah.
- 20:57Andy Swindler: I don't even… how many cells and nerve endings and, you know…
- 21:02Andy Swindler: like, what is the brain, you know, doing? And I get that we need
- 21:06Andy Swindler: Well, I was gonna say we need to. We do, in the way we think scientifically, separate things,
- 21:13Andy Swindler: probably to simplify them or to study them, but in some ways, probably too much, right? Because… Sometimes, yeah. And it, you know, even this article, like I said, was, you know, I don't know, I'm not, like, steeped in all the science of it, I'm not a neuroscientist.
- 21:26Andy Swindler: I don't even play one on TV. But I appreciate what you said about acting, because…
- 21:31Andy Swindler: I have… at some point, I decided acting was arguably the most embodied experience there is, or no, the most… well, that, maybe, but the most mindful experience, because it's like.
- 21:42Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 21:42Andy Swindler: Mindfulness is all about being present.
- 21:44Andy Swindler: And as an actor who's being witnessed, like, especially if it's being recorded, like, and replayed.
- 21:52Andy Swindler: You know, every dimension of how you are in that moment.
- 21:57Brendan McNamara: Oh, yeah.
- 21:57Andy Swindler: You know, so I'm…
- 21:59Andy Swindler: I'd actually be curious for you to talk a little bit more about that, maybe in the context of mindfulness, which I do think is relevant here, because…
- 22:07Andy Swindler: you know, sitting around meditating, I mean, that's what…
- 22:10Andy Swindler: a lot of us do in mindfulness, and it's, the goal is not to sort of dispel thoughts, like, you can't really do that, they're there. So I'm curious, actually, in acting.
- 22:20Andy Swindler: How does that work? Like…
- 22:22Andy Swindler: Do… surely other thoughts come in, like, when you're in the middle of that, you know?
- 22:27Brendan McNamara: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 22:28Brendan McNamara: I think most… mindfulness.
- 22:31Brendan McNamara: is… Someone can challenge me on this. Globally.
- 22:37Brendan McNamara: To do with resonating with thoughts.
- 22:40Brendan McNamara: Meaning…
- 22:42Brendan McNamara: in biblical corpus, right, which is hugely influential in the West, but worldwide, globally, it's the most culturally and racially diverse religion, so its tentacles are everywhere.
- 22:53Brendan McNamara: To meditate means to ruminate on
- 22:57Brendan McNamara: and specifically, by the way, to speak out loud, to meditate, to speak out loud the things that you are pondering, the words that you were pondering. So if it says, meditate on the law, the flow.
- 23:08Andy Swindler: Right.
- 23:08Brendan McNamara: the Torah, then it means, say the words out loud. Now, it can mean, to be very specific semantically, because that's my jam, mumbling, or like, sort of… but you're saying the things.
- 23:20Brendan McNamara: the idea of absence or empty, emptied thought is much more Zen, maybe the little Zen Buddhist origins. That's really not how anybody meditates.
- 23:30Brendan McNamara: In the broader sense, as any sort of normative function.
- 23:35Brendan McNamara: So, acting is similar to basic mindfulness, or, like, essential mindfulness, which is, you exist where you are, your thoughts are either what you speak, or hopefully communicate somehow.
- 23:47Brendan McNamara: And that's why close-ups are kind of cheating in acting, because we read so much as audiences into eyes, and it's actually, in some ways, people who are bad at close-up acting, like, I don't know, your average CBS actor, he says, dissing CBS for no particular reason. No, but for years, it was known for a very wooden style.
- 24:04Andy Swindler: There goes our sponsorship.
- 24:05Brendan McNamara: I know, yeah, exactly. But no, but, like, you'll see… you can see people, and you're like, there's nothing going on behind their eyes.
- 24:11Brendan McNamara: Like, that's weird. Billy Bob Thornton once did that, and he said he tried to do that, and the man who wasn't there.
- 24:16Brendan McNamara: Was to constantly never think any of his thoughts he would not think.
- 24:22Brendan McNamara: Based on where he was, in response. So he was either trying to, like, blank his mind out, or thinking about some… a concrete something else than he… the scene he was in.
- 24:31Andy Swindler: It's like the opposite of mindfulness.
- 24:33Brendan McNamara: Yeah, yeah, yeah, it literally is, like, it's… but in some ways, it's actually an extremely intentional mindfulness, meaning he is intensely… he has to be so aware of his presence.
- 24:42Andy Swindler: Right.
- 24:43Brendan McNamara: in order to inhabit fullness of non-presence. I mean, it's pretty heady malarkey there to think about it.
- 24:49Andy Swindler: Yeah.
- 24:49Brendan McNamara: So, but acting is like that, meaning if… when it's in flow state, when you're actually just kind of finally just doing it, it is much more similar to the biblical adage commandment to pray without ceasing.
- 25:02Brendan McNamara: Now, that doesn't mean you're, like, bowed down to the ground, that we worship, but you are continually in that state where you are aware of
- 25:10Brendan McNamara: of God and truth, and you are aware of yourself as fallible, and just continue, like, never stopping. So I'm gonna never stop being mindful.
- 25:17Brendan McNamara: So, in some of my greatest acting experiences, I'm thinking as somebody else.
- 25:23Brendan McNamara: Like, the thoughts I'm deriving aren't really fully me anymore, or they're not… they're certainly atypical me. They're obviously not outside of my cognitive range, but my brain does start helping cognate things as this person would cognate.
- 25:38Brendan McNamara: So if, like, if I'm… because I'm not… I'm highly verbal, and I play characters who are not highly verbal, which means, eventually, if I'm in it enough, and it doesn't always last that long, it's easier in theater, actually, I think, than film.
- 25:48Brendan McNamara: You… because you're doing it for so long that you get in and out of that state, as opposed to, like, you have… you've got 3 minutes here, or at most, or you've got 20 seconds to go ahead and inhabit reality.
- 25:58Brendan McNamara: you start thinking as the character. So you're just mindful as someone else's, like, fully imagined or empathized mind.
- 26:08Andy Swindler: Yeah, it's… it's beautiful.
- 26:10Andy Swindler: Oh, I do have more questions about that, but that might be a separate episode.
- 26:15Andy Swindler: I want to do one more excerpt from the main article, and then briefly kind of comment on this one response, and then I have a question for you. So, from the article…
- 26:25Andy Swindler: If… actually, spoiler alert, because I…
- 26:27Brendan McNamara: This is a…
- 26:27Andy Swindler: skip to the end kind of deal. Yeah, yeah.
- 26:29Andy Swindler: It's not an academic article, so they didn't put the abstract at the beginning, they kind of put it at the end.
- 26:34Andy Swindler: If the old story held that, quote, the body keeps the score.
- 26:39Andy Swindler: The emerging narrative elides somatic chauvinism.
- 26:43Andy Swindler: It's subtler and more hopeful.
- 26:46Andy Swindler: The body does not keep the score. The brain keeps predicting it.
- 26:51Andy Swindler: When prediction becomes too rigid, experience repeats itself, not because it is stored, but because it cannot yet be reinterpreted.
- 27:00Andy Swindler: Flow, and other states that expand metastability, offer the nervous system a chance to update its model of the world, to reassign precision where it belongs, and to rediscover safety in uncertainty.
- 27:16Andy Swindler: Healing, in the end, is not the erasure of what happened, but the return of movement
- 27:22Andy Swindler: Within the mind, within the networks, within action, within life itself.
- 27:27Brendan McNamara: I mean, that's really very beautifully said, by the way. They… well, it's funny that they were, like, trying to be like, let's be real specific, but they almost can't not… you can't not address the metaphoric richness of what attracted people to this in the first place. So I actually thought that was really smart from a, like.
- 27:43Brendan McNamara: neuroscience nerd point of view, to be like, we have to make this richness in narrative as well, because that's the quote-unquote human problem. Turning every little thing we think into a narrative.
- 27:54Brendan McNamara: you know, main character syndrome, or whatever, you know. Sorry, go ahead.
- 27:58Andy Swindler: So, yeah, I'll do this just brief. This is a video, so these are kind of my notes from Carden Raven, R-A-B-I-N.
- 28:07Andy Swindler: Perhaps Robin, his…
- 28:10Andy Swindler: whole premise. He just said, look, this was always a metaphor. It was kind of a…
- 28:15Andy Swindler: what, like, this rebuttal assumes that people took this too literally. Which, you know, they actually do kind of address in the article, so I don't… but this is another good example of, like, well, they swung that far, and I'm gonna swing this far.
- 28:28Brendan McNamara: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 28:28Andy Swindler: However, I did… I did like it because he…
- 28:31Andy Swindler: he sort of connected the dots in a slightly different way, so… which is related to the summary, right? He said.
- 28:36Brendan McNamara: Yep.
- 28:37Andy Swindler: Okay, so if the brain keeps us looping…
- 28:41Andy Swindler: That sounds a lot like being stuck.
- 28:45Andy Swindler: And if we're stuck, then…
- 28:47Andy Swindler: were being kept. I think that was… I'm paraphrasing, but that was sort of his chain of reasoning.
- 28:52Brendan McNamara: Yes.
- 28:53Andy Swindler: And then he went on to say, in his practice, he's like.
- 28:56Andy Swindler: The virtue of this is it opened the door for many practitioners
- 29:02Andy Swindler: to somatic healing. So the body is a gateway to…
- 29:07Andy Swindler: A kind of healing practice, which ultimately is a way to shift
- 29:12Andy Swindler: These patterns in the brain and the brain's threat prediction system.
- 29:17Andy Swindler: Which… so I… I liked it, because it… to me, it tied it together in a slightly more constructive way.
- 29:24Andy Swindler: way than some of the other rebuttals, which is just swinging to, like.
- 29:28Andy Swindler: you know, as we lovingly do in our binary question, does it or does it not? Come on, can't we just simplify the world?
- 29:34Brendan McNamara: Yeah, yeah. Well, I think in some ways, it's a good point to make if it was an argument in response to straw man, because you're arguing the weakest aspect of what they're saying. No one… this doesn't… this rebuttal in no way addresses somatic modalities of healing.
- 29:51Brendan McNamara: Has nothing to do with it. The nice thing about Somatic is
- 29:55Brendan McNamara: And this is also the problem of where this theory was taken.
- 29:59Brendan McNamara: The theory was taken as reality fully. To say that that wasn't… I mean, Menachem literally says it's encoded in your DNA, and you can pass it on to your children, so…
- 30:09Brendan McNamara: To say that it didn't occur on a massive scale, that people took it literally, is completely false, so that's incorrect completely. Are somatic healing modalities helpful? I would say almost certainly yes.
- 30:21Brendan McNamara: Nothing new, novel.
- 30:23Brendan McNamara: unusual about that. But what was taken, and I think you can see this too, or tell me if you've seen this.
- 30:28Brendan McNamara: People took this theory, built things on top of it, and almost every single time, the… what they built pointed the finger outside of themselves.
- 30:39Brendan McNamara: Systemic racism, causing systemic oppression, causing.
- 30:45Brendan McNamara: being misgendered by outside of myself. Hegemonic, patriarchal, forces, you know, whatever.
- 30:51Andy Swindler: Lava doesn't exist in a vacuum, right?
- 30:53Brendan McNamara: androcentric trauma, it's your fault. The nice thing about this is.
- 30:57Brendan McNamara: You're not stuck because someone else stuck you there.
- 31:02Andy Swindler: You're stuck because you're still there.
- 31:03Brendan McNamara: You're stuck because you are the there. That's you… that's on you, dude. So this is the fascinating thing, that people took the thing, made it real, and made it everybody else's fault.
- 31:12Brendan McNamara: In pretty much every single construction of how this was used in the world.
- 31:17Brendan McNamara: That is substantial and absolutely needs to be refuted. And it's built in many ways, on the…
- 31:25Brendan McNamara: taking a metaphor as reality, and then employing it, trying to employ it in objective law, science, all sorts of, like, social science, which is barely a science anyway, it's so deeply unscientific to do that. So once you start doing that in science, then you're corrupting the whole idea of knowledge, as opposed to, like, sensation or experience.
- 31:44Brendan McNamara: Both of which are helpful and useful, but they absolutely… and they can overlap and intermingle, but they are separate beings. So this is the… this is the body-brain thing can get a little muddy. But yes, movement…
- 31:56Brendan McNamara: go ahead and do all these things, because you know what? Whose fault it is? Like, who did… no one can cause you… can create the trauma. Your brain doesn't.
- 32:06Brendan McNamara: Your brain does it.
- 32:07Brendan McNamara: So, do they do things and you don't like what they've done, and they sinned against you, and they need to apologize, all sorts of stuff? Of course, that's fundamental to society! But, can you get up and go for a walk? Can you go outside? Can you do something about it? It's up to you to heal it.
- 32:22Andy Swindler: Right, so the… it may be about the cost there, right? If… especially in the case of, I don't know, let's just say something like assault, where there's, like, a much more obvious, kind of.
- 32:29Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 32:30Andy Swindler: Is that, doesn'.
- 32:31Brendan McNamara: Listen, my mom has said this my whole life, so maybe I'm biased.
- 32:34Brendan McNamara: She's like, I had to put myself into… state control.
- 32:40Brendan McNamara: In my teens. My mother died at 12.
- 32:42Brendan McNamara: By 16, my father didn't want me in the house, so I put myself in state control. I was pregnant at 21. Like, this long litany of, like, pretty terrible experiences. And she's like, but I'll meet people who are like, yeah, my dad was a yeller.
- 32:56Brendan McNamara: And then they have this, like, Trauma personality?
- 33:00Brendan McNamara: Around it, and they're like, ugh.
- 33:02Brendan McNamara: Like, I'm wounded, and all these people did things to me. She's just like… Get over yourself.
- 33:08Andy Swindler: Okay.
- 33:08Brendan McNamara: And so, like, wait a second, because it became, and you know this too, it becomes Trauma Olympics, and then eventually it became Trauma Olympics personal into Trauma Olympics identity-based. Well, I belong to this category, who has been historically marginalized, which means my body has taken on so many scores and so many scars, and I just…
- 33:27Brendan McNamara: It's all too much. No, some people can have the exact same circumstances. People could be in, like, the exact same, like, war.
- 33:33Brendan McNamara: Right? IED, I almost said IUD. An IED explodes.
- 33:38Brendan McNamara: And two guys are in the truck, and they both lose one of their legs, and blah blah blah blah blah, and someone can have a trauma brain lock response, and someone else doesn't.
- 33:47Brendan McNamara: So it's not…
- 33:48Brendan McNamara: purely causal, ever, even when it's direct assault. And I think this is the thing, people just want to be like.
- 33:54Brendan McNamara: Not my fault. Not my fault. Like, it's the idea of, like… and this happens in Christianity, too. Wow, the devil made me do it.
- 34:00Brendan McNamara: They really didn't.
- 34:02Brendan McNamara: You did it! Well, the deal was really after me this week.
- 34:05Andy Swindler: So the question I was holding was.
- 34:07Andy Swindler: Thank you, I didn't mean to imply assault. Always equals trauma, or…
- 34:11Brendan McNamara: No, no, no, no, no, I don't think so.
- 34:13Andy Swindler: I'm guessing there's a… at least slightly higher correlation of, like.
- 34:16Brendan McNamara: Yes.
- 34:17Andy Swindler: That leading… leading to… The need, for lack of a better way to phrase it, of more healing.
- 34:25Brendan McNamara: Yes, oh yeah, yeah.
- 34:26Andy Swindler: And so that's what I'm wondering, if that's what people are really…
- 34:29Andy Swindler: Complaining about is, like, you have cost me
- 34:35Andy Swindler: time and energy, you know, like, you… your action, externally, whatever, system, person, whatever, has… has led me to spend more, right? Time and energy, whatever, healing. Not… that's not a refutation, I'm just sort of like, huh, is that… is that what's, like, under that.
- 34:53Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 34:53Andy Swindler: Really. Yeah, yeah. Other than what you were just getting to, which was basically victim mentality, and so another term that's emerged, I was accused of this once in a really bizarre conversation of victim blaming.
- 35:07Brendan McNamara: Oh, yeah.
- 35:08Andy Swindler: That's like a… like a locked loop, you know, where, like.
- 35:13Brendan McNamara: If…
- 35:14Andy Swindler: Yeah.
- 35:15Brendan McNamara: But when you haven't been victimized, then it's fully your fault.
- 35:18Brendan McNamara: Like, if, for example, someone says something that offends you, or just refutes your subjective sense of self, perhaps.
- 35:25Brendan McNamara: You're not a victim.
- 35:26Brendan McNamara: you've not been a victim… when people say, like, oh, I was a victim of a misgendering, no, you…
- 35:31Brendan McNamara: You weren't.
- 35:32Brendan McNamara: So this is the problem. You've taken metaphor and receipt of something as perceived as offense as an injury. So this is how the theory… again, this is why I don't understand the response exactly of the guy you were talking about, who said a good thing. Yes, somatic healing modalities, let's use them. Flippin' great. And if it expanded our…
- 35:49Brendan McNamara: therapists take their patients on… or walks, or whatever, or they do jumping jacks, or they shake, stand and shake. Great! Yeah, let's get some of that anxiety out of… it does get the, like, tension stuff out of our body to move, to get in the sun. Like, we're made for movement and creation. That's, like.
- 36:05Brendan McNamara: we're human beings, that's what we do. So that's great. But to not notice how it's carried through…
- 36:13Brendan McNamara: Massively, to where it's illegal in some states to cause this trauma to people.
- 36:19Brendan McNamara: And it's not… so the… this is the problem, it's…
- 36:22Brendan McNamara: when it gets turned, and maybe this is what happened in your experience, when you're like, oh, you're blaming the victim. You're like.
- 36:26Brendan McNamara: Victim of what?
- 36:28Brendan McNamara: Like, of a metaphoric crime?
- 36:32Brendan McNamara: A crime of metaphor?
- 36:34Brendan McNamara: That's not…
- 36:35Brendan McNamara: That's not… again, you've changed harm, the definition of harm, changed the definition of violence, changed the definition of trauma, changed the definition of victim, changed the definition of oppressor, change… like, once you change 15 to 20 definitions, and you're pretending it's rooted in science, which this Body Keeps the score was constantly referenced as though it was literal.
- 36:55Brendan McNamara: Like, it's a…
- 36:56Brendan McNamara: That's a massive systemic failure to where, as people… we've talked about it before, you're essentially creating a society in whoever cries loudest wins.
- 37:07Brendan McNamara: So if you cry foul the loudest, and if you're a protected identity now, because we have identity supremacy in law, then…
- 37:15Brendan McNamara: If you cried file loud, and you're a protected, identity category, you're like a… you're occupying a supremacy position?
- 37:23Brendan McNamara: It's unassailable.
- 37:25Brendan McNamara: So it's like white people and Jim Crow, if it's like someone said, well, that… he didn't say sir at the end of his sentence, that is an offense against God.
- 37:33Brendan McNamara: He must be beaten or hung. Like, that's where we are as a society, in part because of this theory.
- 37:39Brendan McNamara: Good.
- 37:40Andy Swindler: That doesn't lead to a lot of sovereignty and accountability.
- 37:44Brendan McNamara: Yes, and again, and the thing we've often talked about, and then just mutuality.
- 37:49Brendan McNamara: like…
- 37:49Brendan McNamara: And it's this, and I hate this phrase. Oh, I hate this phrase. This is my new, it is what it is.
- 37:55Brendan McNamara: You know, hurt people hurt people.
- 37:59Brendan McNamara: Oh, my… what a thought-stopping… yes, of course, but we're all hurt, so then why are we even saying that? That's like saying, people hurt people.
- 38:07Andy Swindler: I heard an upgrade, though.
- 38:08Brendan McNamara: I remember, yeah.
- 38:09Andy Swindler: Hurt, healed people, heal people.
- 38:11Brendan McNamara: Oh, interesting. But healed people hurt people, and hurt people heal people.
- 38:15Brendan McNamara: No, it's all…
- 38:16Andy Swindler: To make everything more complicated.
- 38:17Brendan McNamara: Well, I mean, they're making it more complicated, just, like, people, people, people and people, people, people and people, people, people. There you go, that's the.
- 38:24Andy Swindler: People, people, people.
- 38:25Brendan McNamara: People, people, people and people, people, people. Okay, that's what happens. So that's, it's this, but it's all this, the same recursive concept of
- 38:33Brendan McNamara: Of trying to make… Especially trying to make ourselves God, man. That's really all we're trying to do.
- 38:39Brendan McNamara: To where, like, we decide for everybody what sin is, and it's, you know, and if sin… someone sins against us, it is a violation not only of just, like, my preferences, it's a violation of, like, moral
- 38:52Brendan McNamara: law. Like, you've done something Not just, like.
- 38:57Brendan McNamara: in a way I do not prefer.
- 38:59Brendan McNamara: And again, this theory underpins that so strongly that I don't understand being like, well.
- 39:05Brendan McNamara: No one took this that seriously. Like, that part… listen, again, 50% of what that person said sounds great, the other 50% is… is I don't understand what world he exists in, where people haven't used this, or whatever.
- 39:19Andy Swindler: Yeah, my interpretation was that
- 39:22Andy Swindler: like me, maybe he was not versed in, sort of, how far it went. Although, as a…
- 39:28Andy Swindler: actual practitioner, yeah, I would hope he would have more responsibility to do that.
- 39:32Andy Swindler: But I…
- 39:34Andy Swindler: Yeah, even as I was explaining it, there were, like, 3 layers of, like, well, they said it's not stuck, but… but if you think about it, like, this way, and this way, and this way, then that sounds a lot like stuck. And I'm like, well, when I first heard it, it was like…
- 39:48Brendan McNamara: I mean, again.
- 39:49Andy Swindler: Yeah, yeah, yeah, I get that, but again, it's like… Assume… maybe it's, like.
- 39:55Andy Swindler: I'm not taking it to the extreme, but I'm assuming that person took it too far, so I'm gonna choose an argument here to sort of sound more reasonable and bring them back.
- 40:05Brendan McNamara: Yeah, yeah. Which, again, I think cognitively makes a lot of sense. I try to do that, too. You try to look in the middle and go, what can I… what's true about both sides, so I can kind of…
- 40:14Brendan McNamara: chill in the middle and kind of wobble and wobble and see which is steadiest. It makes a ton of sense. But stuck, you can't just use stuck as though that explains anything, because someone can be stuck because they've been super glued, like in a jackass movie, they've been super glued to this toilet seat.
- 40:29Brendan McNamara: That's completely different stuck than just, like.
- 40:32Brendan McNamara: I feel like I can't break through to this thought.
- 40:35Brendan McNamara: someone can be stuck in a box in a field in a prisoner war camp, you know what I mean? Like, so you can't just throw stuck out and be like, well, that solves everything. It's like, it's a little bit… it's the sort of thing of, like, it's like a glitter bomb and run away. Because I've done this. You just go, hey.
- 40:52Brendan McNamara: We're all friends, too! Haha!
- 40:55Brendan McNamara: And then deal with no. It's like the opposite of when people come in and go, nobody is ever right when they blank, and then…
- 41:01Brendan McNamara: run away and I won't talk about it. So it's, like, the positive side of that. So I appreciate that it's positive, I suppose, but, like, let me just briefly list what that person, because this is great, what this person missed. Here's what's built on the fallacy of
- 41:13Brendan McNamara: The potential fallacy. Listen, again, I'm not a neuroscientist either.
- 41:17Brendan McNamara: Built on this fallacy of the body, keeps the score.
- 41:21Brendan McNamara: Lived experience is primary evidence. This is just an epistemological foundations. Testimony is data.
- 41:26Brendan McNamara: Subjective apprehension as objective harm measurement.
- 41:30Brendan McNamara: Your truth as an epistemically valid category, as opposed to just a system of self-explanation.
- 41:35Brendan McNamara: In clinical psychology, somatic therapy frameworks. Thumbs up. Trauma-informed care as universal default. Trigger warnings as medical necessity, safe spaces as clinical intervention, intergenerational trauma inheritance, epigenetic oppression transmission, adverse childhood experiences as deterministic, -oh.
- 41:54Brendan McNamara: Minority stress theory in sociology. Intersectionality as biological harm accumulator. Oppression as an objective, measurable metric. Internalized oppression as a clinical category, microaggressions as cumulative neurological damage, hate speech as literal violence, disagreement as harm.
- 42:11Brendan McNamara: Political, speech regulation justified by harm claims, hostile environment legal frameworks, disability extensions to identity stress, institutional trauma-informed policy mandates, reparation arguments grounded in biological transmission?
- 42:24Brendan McNamara: DEI frameworks premised on measurable oppression load, that relates to Arlene Geronimus.
- 42:30Brendan McNamara: gender and identity, experience gender overriding biological gender, gender-affirming care urgency justified specifically, concretely, by minority stress harm, detransition harm frameworks, and social contagion dismissed as invalidating.
- 42:46Brendan McNamara: That's just a… compiled in… Half an hour list of all the things that are built on this across
- 42:56Brendan McNamara: vast schema. So that's the only problem, I would say, with the Glitter Bomb.
- 43:01Brendan McNamara: is that's…
- 43:02Andy Swindler: What's wrong with all that?
- 43:03Brendan McNamara: That's a lot of stuff.
- 43:05Andy Swindler: Well, maybe you might have answered a question I was… I was gonna ask, which is, like, why… why now? Like, why did this article strike this chord? Surely, there have been other rebuttals to this in the last 12 years.
- 43:16Brendan McNamara: You don't know, that's the scary thing, man.
- 43:19Brendan McNamara: Is if you look at Like, the rebuttals to minority stress theory are slim to none.
- 43:25Andy Swindler: Mmm.
- 43:25Brendan McNamara: A, especially in the social sciences, again, people can research this for themselves. I believe the average, it fluctuates from, like, 29, 30% to about 70-something percent, but the average, somewhere around 49, just under half of, social science publications.
- 43:40Brendan McNamara: Were unable to be reproduced.
- 43:44Brendan McNamara: So what we have is, we have a field where it's a coin flip, whether it means a damn thing.
- 43:50Andy Swindler: Well, and neuroscience is evolving, right? They reference that, they admit that. They're like, this is based on new…
- 43:57Andy Swindler: you know, I felt like they were respectful of Vander Koch's work, and they were like, well, this is what we do as scientists, we build, and…
- 44:05Brendan McNamara: just go, well, yeah, no, that was an interesting idea, but that's not really… it's just not the origin point. So then you're out there. This is the same thing with dysphoria, right? You're treating the dysphoria and not the fundamental… you're treating the symptoms. But again, this is…
- 44:18Brendan McNamara: This is corporate capture.
- 44:21Brendan McNamara: Why would you ever heal a disease when you can charge for healing the symptoms forever? This is the therapy problem, this is… I'm on a biologic right now, which all it does is suppress the symptoms. It doesn't heal the…
- 44:32Brendan McNamara: And it costs $20,000 a pop every 2 months. Thank you, insurance, that sucks, but still, whatever, I'm happy to have it, because I can't afford it, so…
- 44:41Andy Swindler: Right?
- 44:41Brendan McNamara: This is a terrible system. So what I think the powerful thing is here, and this is getting into theory now.
- 44:47Brendan McNamara: I believe.
- 44:49Brendan McNamara: Institutional or corporate capture, you'll notice across this entire schema of what's built on this, it creates a society, or at least a larger and larger cohort, of continual victims you can sell shit to.
- 45:06Andy Swindler: And I do know from Kotler in particular, hearing him speak a few times, about flow, I mean, his whole premise is that flow is available to all of us. It's the…
- 45:18Andy Swindler: Ability to get into a flow state.
- 45:22Andy Swindler: which I think, based on this, he, yeah, he's relating directly to healing, is just innate. It's part of the brain, it's part of our body, it's part of our…
- 45:31Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 45:31Andy Swindler: the way we're built, you know? And so, yeah, you don't… so I think, refreshingly, yeah, he's not like, oh, we need a pill, he's just like…
- 45:38Andy Swindler: I mean, yes, of course, he has his own, you know, whatever, whatever he's selling, but, like, it's…
- 45:44Andy Swindler: it's about learning to do this, I think, legitimately, not… you need another pill to buy forever, yeah.
- 45:51Brendan McNamara: Yeah, yeah. Well, and we've noticed this too. So many of the topics we talk about are…
- 45:55Brendan McNamara: Fostered by people who cannot remotely handle Like, neurological plasticity.
- 46:05Brendan McNamara: Like, we play with the binary.
- 46:07Brendan McNamara: And sort of like, we can try it, we can play with it. It can be… it's a useful tool.
- 46:12Brendan McNamara: On, off, something, yes, no, something.
- 46:14Brendan McNamara: But it's not… A reality that if anyone refutes, they're bad.
- 46:20Brendan McNamara: They're phobic, they're hateful, they're whatever.
- 46:23Brendan McNamara: You're just like, what do you… like, what are you taught? What world…
- 46:26Brendan McNamara: What world are you living in?
- 46:28Brendan McNamara: Where you have it so all figured out that you're always right, and you're so always right that if someone attacks you, then that means they sort of hate your category? Like…
- 46:37Brendan McNamara: Look, like, that is such… it's such an insane over-explosion of just… Basically, my theory is…
- 46:48Brendan McNamara: aren't… you're so non-neurally plastic. I think for most people, intentionally, they've chosen that as a path.
- 46:55Brendan McNamara: Or maybe even created it through their nocebo effect of, like, oh, this is… I've experienced trauma, and they've noticed this is how trauma people act, or maybe it's just their imagination, like an actor, of what a trauma person would be like, just overreacting to everything. And then they just live that. And eventually.
- 47:10Brendan McNamara: Because they have such rigidity of, like.
- 47:12Brendan McNamara: No, to go outside of it is super dangerous. It's like… it's hell outside. It's hell to be outside of my cohort. If you're in MAGA or whatever, right? Whatever cohort they're vilifying. Like, that would be like being a demon. Like, being evil. Like, you'd be like a zombie horde. And so you create this, like.
- 47:28Brendan McNamara: complete instability. And again, I argue with folks like that all the time, and I'm just like.
- 47:34Brendan McNamara: getting them to shift from discipline to discipline, to, like, pull in cross-discipline analysis, or, okay, well, take that problem outside of yourself, and look at it from this, that people are like, what? No, no, no, no. They sort of… people who… I don't know what they're… whether they have any actual trauma at all.
- 47:49Brendan McNamara: Nor would I be able to prove that they do.
- 47:51Brendan McNamara: Nor would they be able to prove that they do.
- 47:53Brendan McNamara: Without exot… like, neurological scans.
- 47:57Brendan McNamara: Are responding with just zero plasticity.
- 48:01Brendan McNamara: I shouldn't say zero, that's not fair.
- 48:03Brendan McNamara: limited or hardly any plasticity whatsoever. And you've seen that in your own circles, that if you bring something up that's not what everyone else is already thinking.
- 48:13Brendan McNamara: Or that they think everyone's thinking.
- 48:16Brendan McNamara: It's like the swift hand of, out! Out, ye foul demon!
- 48:20Andy Swindler: I see it in myself. I don't know… I don't know how true this is for you, but I mean, that's the number one thing I've…
- 48:26Andy Swindler: chosen to observe this last week. It's like, how am I reacting? I've reduced, like, to…
- 48:31Andy Swindler: I temporarily removed the two… biggest…
- 48:36Andy Swindler: And, and most lovable, pieces of stimuli in my life.
- 48:40Brendan McNamara: Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 48:41Andy Swindler: Two human beings, you know, and so that's… that's a really interesting scientific experiment.
- 48:46Andy Swindler: How do I react to what's left?
- 48:48Andy Swindler: Right? Okay, I do have two kittens, that's its own universe, but…
- 48:53Andy Swindler: this is why I've had an iguana for 27 years, you know, because, I mean, she's… and this is its own adjacent, hilarious thing, because people still reference, like, the reptilian brain stem. And I… it was helpful reading Lisa Feldman Barrett, especially, because she has a whole chapter about animals, and she's like, well, they don't really contain the brain.
- 49:11Andy Swindler: That… to… to have emotions in the way that we think about them.
- 49:16Andy Swindler: And I think that… there is a stuckness there. Like, we are designed to hold onto things. You know, it's like our brains are so big and so amazing.
- 49:26Andy Swindler: But I think compared to a lot of animals.
- 49:28Andy Swindler: There's a real danger there, because our brains also.
- 49:30Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 49:31Andy Swindler: incredible capacity.
- 49:33Andy Swindler: 2… I don't know, keep… maybe the brain keeps the score, there's a whole.
- 49:37Brendan McNamara: There you go. Yeah, there you go.
- 49:39Andy Swindler: I'm sure somebody's, like, published that, but… But,
- 49:45Andy Swindler: I notice I'm reactive. I mean, this is my number one… I think this is the thing that's actually attracted me to this body of work. And I'm not somebody who can point to some huge
- 49:55Andy Swindler: trauma in my life, some obvious thing, you know?
- 49:58Brendan McNamara: Journal products, yeah.
- 49:59Andy Swindler: Yeah, through any lens, through, like, my upbringing.
- 50:04Andy Swindler: I do not pass any checkboxes in the woke, you know, lens. I don't, you know, it's like…
- 50:10Andy Swindler: And yet, I'm reactive. Now, it was interesting going to Resmond and Occam's work, because.
- 50:15Brendan McNamara: Hmm.
- 50:15Andy Swindler: He basically is like, well, here's black trauma, here's white trauma, and here's police trauma.
- 50:19Andy Swindler: And it was like, oh, okay, got it. So…
- 50:23Andy Swindler: yeah, as a white man in America, I've been… I've had this training, I have my ancestors, I have, you know.
- 50:29Andy Swindler: Like, to have enslaved people is… is its own kind of drama, because you're working against, like, the…
- 50:36Andy Swindler: I don't want to say the natural order, because it's so damn common, it's pretty… seems pretty natural, but it's like…
- 50:40Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 50:41Andy Swindler: against, I don't know, I guess what we would consider the care ethic or the loving order of caring for people, but…
- 50:48Andy Swindler: I… anyway, it's just… so I'm really in this inquiry of, like.
- 50:53Andy Swindler: And what I've come to is… Yeah, I…
- 50:57Andy Swindler: studied mindfulness, and I've meditated on and off for 11 years. I've…
- 51:01Andy Swindler: I mean, I've studied so much, I've explored a lot of modalities, yeah.
- 51:06Andy Swindler: I haven't gone deep into psychedelics as a medicine. I mean, I've done it recreationally, but I'm really curious about that.
- 51:13Andy Swindler: And I guess that's where Van der Koch and some folks are going now, and the fact that that is becoming decriminalized enough to study it is, I think, really appealing, that we, you know.
- 51:25Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 51:25Andy Swindler: Because there's evidence that…
- 51:27Andy Swindler: Like, psilocybin can rewire the brain in a much more, you know, timely fashion than a lot of other modalities.
- 51:34Brendan McNamara: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Instant!
- 51:35Andy Swindler: But the one I really get… come back to, I think I referenced this, before the… before we got on, was…
- 51:41Andy Swindler: what can I do… Some of it just boils down to, like,
- 51:48Andy Swindler: How can I take good care of myself?
- 51:50Brendan McNamara: Hmm.
- 51:50Andy Swindler: How can I, like… You know…
- 51:57Andy Swindler: I remember hearing somebody say this in a seminar years ago, and she's like, does anybody in this room not really know
- 52:03Andy Swindler: What you should be doing to be healthy.
- 52:05Andy Swindler: You know, and yet there's, like, a whatever, $15 billion or whatever.
- 52:09Andy Swindler: dollar, health industry. She's like, you really not know what you should be eating, what your body needs? Do you not know that you should exercise for 30, you know, whatever.
- 52:18Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 52:18Andy Swindler: So… That's my current inquiry, is what can I do
- 52:25Andy Swindler: to stabilize myself and my nervous system to become less reactive. I think that's my curiosity.
- 52:31Brendan McNamara: It is, yeah, well, it is interesting. And it pursues the idea of, like, Moralizing reactivity is interesting.
- 52:42Brendan McNamara: Where… why? Why?
- 52:45Brendan McNamara: Like, why modulate reactivity?
- 52:48Andy Swindler: Well, yeah, I didn't finish that thought about my iguana, because…
- 52:50Brendan McNamara: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 52:50Andy Swindler: Every time I pick… she's…
- 52:52Andy Swindler: like, 130 years old in human… I mean, she's off every scale. I mean, we usually say 15 to 20 years, and I'm like, the vet's just like, keep doing what you're doing. So I'm like, okay, I don't… again, though, I've localized my expertise. I'm like, I don't claim to be an expert in iguanas. I claim to be an expert in.
- 53:07Brendan McNamara: Disagree. Yes, yes, yes, yes, disagree.
- 53:09Andy Swindler: Which is important. But every time I pick her up, she has a reaction.
- 53:14Andy Swindler: Jesus goes… That's my Phaedrus impersonation. You know Phaedrus, you lived with her.
- 53:19Brendan McNamara: I do.
- 53:21Andy Swindler: But… I… your wife was with me when I got her.
- 53:27Andy Swindler: It's been very helpful to understand that that's just a physiological reaction she's having.
- 53:34Andy Swindler: And she's not gonna hate me 5 minutes later.
- 53:37Brendan McNamara: Oh, gosh, yeah. You know? Yeah, who knows if it's even coded in as a pattern?
- 53:43Brendan McNamara: Like, it's just, like, it's just response?
- 53:45Andy Swindler: Yeah.
- 53:46Brendan McNamara: response. And then the fascinating thing becomes how we, like, how do we moralize response?
- 53:51Brendan McNamara: Like, why do we go, this is better, this is worse, this is more…
- 53:56Brendan McNamara: Whereas, I would say it's situationally dependent. Like, reactivity, instant, strong, vehement.
- 54:03Brendan McNamara: Insane in common context reactivity is absolutely necessary, so we can't… we don't want to get rid of it.
- 54:10Andy Swindler: Well, and my… and my concern is, does it create harm, especially with the people I love? Like, that's…
- 54:15Brendan McNamara: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 54:16Andy Swindler: hopefully the motivation. So, my cat… these are, you know, they're kittens. I open a cabinet.
- 54:23Andy Swindler: Instantly, he's in there, and I'm like…
- 54:25Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 54:25Andy Swindler: And I… I had a… big… negative reaction, and… Yanked him out of there.
- 54:31Andy Swindler: Yeah. And then, of course, I'm like, oh, damn, you know, I should really be kinder to my cat.
- 54:36Andy Swindler: But guess what? He thought I was playing.
- 54:39Brendan McNamara: Oh, for sure.
- 54:39Andy Swindler: He's just like, oh, yeah, yeah, let's do it again.
- 54:42Brendan McNamara: He's gonna gnaw on you. Yeah. Well, that's… this is, again, this is that we… how much have we programmed in this gen… couple generations of helicopter parenting?
- 54:50Brendan McNamara: This idea of, like.
- 54:52Brendan McNamara: intense reactivity. Again, it's based on the same idea. Oh, no, I'm gonna… if I scream at my children, they're really… they're gonna have…
- 54:59Brendan McNamara: long-term harm, and it's gonna be in their body, and they're gonna give it to their children, and da-da. You can pass on learned behaviors, because you watch someone do it, and you look around and do it, but, like.
- 55:10Brendan McNamara: So, had you seen what animals do?
- 55:13Brendan McNamara: to other animals? Like…
- 55:16Brendan McNamara: They literally… you'll watch a mom or a dad cat or whatever in the jungle, like, slap its child, and the child rolls across the flipping forest floor, like…
- 55:25Brendan McNamara: So you didn't do that. So in some ways, you're actually so underreactive as to be… Useless.
- 55:32Andy Swindler: Like, not there. Not even engaging.
- 55:36Brendan McNamara: It's a form of… it's a strange form of neutering.
- 55:38Brendan McNamara: like, response, as opposed to… I don't know, wouldn't it be great for a child, even, to see what
- 55:45Brendan McNamara: happens when you drive people past the breaking point? I've occasionally screamed at my kids so loud, I've had to apologize to them. I've occasionally screamed at them the same level of loudness.
- 55:54Brendan McNamara: And nor… I have no impetus to apologize whatsoever.
- 55:57Brendan McNamara: I was like, they need to know that they keep doing repetitive behaviors which in some way.
- 56:03Brendan McNamara: Do this, this, and this to people.
- 56:05Brendan McNamara: people, like myself, are going to have enormous reactions. And when I'm like, alright, this is a great teaching moment.
- 56:12Brendan McNamara: And if you say the wrong thing.
- 56:15Brendan McNamara: in the wrong place, you might get punched in the face. Sometimes you can say the right thing and get punched in the face. You have to learn those reactivity
- 56:22Brendan McNamara: Strong reactivity is not de facto evidence.
- 56:26Brendan McNamara: You have done anything wrong.
- 56:28Brendan McNamara: And I think this is part of the problem. You have a generation of kids who are like, well, my parents never yelled at me, why is this person being like, that's stupid?
- 56:34Brendan McNamara: That person hates me, and they're mean, and they're bad. Now we have adults walking around like that? Like, what in the heck, dude? That's crazy. Like, strong reactivity is normal.
- 56:44Brendan McNamara: It's… it's normal, it's how we process life. What sort of… isn't this where people go eat, pray, love? You go to Italy, and people are screaming at each other one moment, and kissing the next, and throwing wine glasses… like, we love… that's…
- 56:57Brendan McNamara: Just another way of being.
- 56:59Brendan McNamara: So if you… if you…
- 57:01Brendan McNamara: scream at someone, if you… hey, every once in a while, if you punch a wall, we need this. And I would say men need it more than women, because it's kind of one of the reasons we're useful to die, because we don't create more humans, so we're just less important.
- 57:14Brendan McNamara: You need it if someone breaks into your house. Sure, you can then be like, I'm gonna stay really calm, so they don't get reactive, and they don't start hurting people.
- 57:21Brendan McNamara: Or, you become immediately strongly reactive, and the person who sought to do you harm, you must harm them.
- 57:28Brendan McNamara: Because harm is not bad.
- 57:30Brendan McNamara: Let me say that again. Harm is not bad.
- 57:34Brendan McNamara: Harm CAN be bad, but it's a fallacy of composition to say that harm is bad.
- 57:40Brendan McNamara: If someone's raping my wife.
- 57:42Brendan McNamara: And I shh, and I cut his throat. That's gonna be messy, but that's just how I prefer to do it. I don't like guns that much.
- 57:47Brendan McNamara: If I slice his throat, and then he dies there, and I pull him out of my wife.
- 57:52Brendan McNamara: I've caused harm.
- 57:54Brendan McNamara: Was that bad harm?
- 57:55Brendan McNamara: Was there anything that I should go, gosh, I really sort of overreacted there? No! What is wrong with you? No!
- 58:02Brendan McNamara: Like, this is just a necessary part of human existence. I think, again, because you can charge people for this stuff, and you can breed generations of people who won't do anything when you victimize them.
- 58:14Brendan McNamara: Great.
- 58:15Brendan McNamara: That really works out for totalitarianism. Like…
- 58:18Brendan McNamara: So then, what a strange thing. But again, I think even that sense of, like, I don't want to be improperly reactive? Yes, absolutely!
- 58:26Brendan McNamara: Of course! We're all trying to control our impulses, hopefully, to some degree, but then it…
- 58:31Andy Swindler: Be accountable to the impact.
- 58:32Brendan McNamara: Yeah, yeah. Understand. But no, no, I would say, no, we're not… we're not accountable for the impact.
- 58:38Brendan McNamara: We're accountable for the errors we've made.
- 58:42Brendan McNamara: So let's say you overreact completely properly, and the person is like, that really hurt my feelings so bad!
- 58:50Brendan McNamara: Mike?
- 58:52Brendan McNamara: So what?
- 58:53Brendan McNamara: You know what I mean? Now, you can love that person or whatever, but then… But the…
- 58:57Brendan McNamara: The idea you then have to correct the behavior that causes that response?
- 59:02Brendan McNamara: Not true. And I think some of that is built on this same framework of the body keeping the score, because it's like, oh no, I'm doing long-term damage to them by making them feel bad.
- 59:09Brendan McNamara: No, you could be. It's equally possible. You have just helped them heal for the rest of their lives by causing them harm.
- 59:20Andy Swindler: Well, one adjacent…
- 59:22Andy Swindler: thought in there is, I've come to understand that in the category of, like, sexual abuse.
- 59:28Andy Swindler: The terminology is preferred now to say survivor rather than victim.
- 59:33Brendan McNamara: Oh, interesting.
- 59:36Brendan McNamara: That's a bad idea, but sure.
- 59:38Brendan McNamara: Because then you take away the person who did the wrong thing.
- 59:43Brendan McNamara: If there's… you're just a survivor, then something just happened.
- 59:46Brendan McNamara: You survived an animal attack, you survived an earthquake. You survived cancer.
- 59:52Brendan McNamara: It's a pretty terrible… that's a terrible idea.
- 59:56Brendan McNamara: It's, it's basically taking away accountability.
- 59:59Brendan McNamara: the person who, in that case, caused harm. So isn't this interesting? These systems tend to build these things where it's just, like, it becomes vague, amorphous, sin nature, or the devil.
- 1:00:10Brendan McNamara: You know, you survived. You survived it.
- 1:00:12Brendan McNamara: I mean, you were, but no, you are a victim, because you were… a crime was perpetrated upon you, so to somehow remove that person as though all you did was just survive something. But again, because we don't use that language in human-related categories. We use it in animals and natural disasters.
- 1:00:31Brendan McNamara: You survived a monsoon, you survived a tornado, you ba-ba-ba-ba-ba, you know, ba-ba, 40 days in the desert, and I survived. You're like, no, I survived an assault?
- 1:00:41Brendan McNamara: No, I was assaulted. I was victimized. A person did this intentionally.
- 1:00:46Brendan McNamara: So if you pull that person out, all the… this is the kind of, like, whatever, the stuff we talked about, what's it, restorative justice? This is sort of restorative justice error, which is just like, well, there's no such thing as a criminal.
- 1:00:56Brendan McNamara: There's a victim, there's a victim, a hurt person who hurt people, and a survivor.
- 1:01:04Andy Swindler: Yeah, I think the idea was, that they got the lens of sovereignty. Like, like, oh, if I… if I get stuck in the victim… victimness of it.
- 1:01:12Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 1:01:13Andy Swindler: How do I…
- 1:01:14Andy Swindler: move out of that. But I hear what you're saying. My experience with restorative justice, actually sitting in
- 1:01:20Andy Swindler: you know, the legal restorative justice circles here is that, you've… you never, absolutely never lost sight. I'm glad I… I'm glad I saw RJ through the legal lens, and Chicago's one of the places where I think.
- 1:01:34Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 1:01:34Andy Swindler: The experiment is sort of… more… Funny enough.
- 1:01:39Andy Swindler: Been around one of the longest.
- 1:01:41Brendan McNamara: Yeah, yeah.
- 1:01:43Andy Swindler: Modeled after, I think, Red Hook in New York?
- 1:01:45Andy Swindler: but you never… you're sitting in circle…
- 1:01:49Andy Swindler: But you're never losing sight of what happened, and who perpetrated, and… You're just…
- 1:01:55Andy Swindler: you're just stretching it out a little more and doing it in a more relational way than the sort of courtroom power structures. Then you end up with…
- 1:02:05Andy Swindler: Theoretically, something that's more…
- 1:02:08Andy Swindler: healing and generative, but there's still a… God, what do we call it? Oh, it's been so long.
- 1:02:14Andy Swindler: Anyway, there's, like, still, like, a… Okay, here's all the… like…
- 1:02:18Andy Swindler: especially because these are not applied to, like, violent crimes. These are, like, party minor offenses, just as an initial experiment. Something in the order of community service, but it's, like, the whole point is to learn something about them so that community service
- 1:02:31Andy Swindler: Bends towards something that may be generative in their life.
- 1:02:34Andy Swindler: Right? And not just like, oh, you're gonna…
- 1:02:39Andy Swindler: Yeah, because that's, you know, that's the basic premise, I think. It's like, okay, how can we set people
- 1:02:44Andy Swindler: Can this process at all be restorative in a way that's…
- 1:02:48Andy Swindler: You know, primarily restoring the, you know, victim or person who was perpetrated against
- 1:02:55Andy Swindler: But also restoring, like, the perpetrator, like, and…
- 1:02:59Brendan McNamara: Yeah, maybe.
- 1:02:59Andy Swindler: Yes, that's…
- 1:03:00Brendan McNamara: That's what I keep seeing. The focus seems to be much more on the perpetrator.
- 1:03:03Brendan McNamara: In terms of public discussion on it, but maybe that's because what they consider that the novel portion of the outcome.
- 1:03:10Andy Swindler: I think that's a really good way to put it, because… yes, and so I could see why that would be, like, over-indexed, because it's like, oh, this is… I love the way you said, that's the novel thing, and I've heard that criticism. I've been in communities where that's the criticism, where it's like.
- 1:03:23Andy Swindler: Wait a minute, like, we're… we are so over…
- 1:03:27Andy Swindler: compensating for… for this idea of, you know, not only, like, realizing the perpetrator is, like, a human being, and we shouldn't maybe just…
- 1:03:35Brendan McNamara: Sure.
- 1:03:35Andy Swindler: I don't know, excommunicate them from the, you know, whatever, but…
- 1:03:40Andy Swindler: But here's where it ties back into our topic today, is that…
- 1:03:47Andy Swindler: In a world where the body keeps the score.
- 1:03:50Andy Swindler: You look at everything through… every behavior through the lens of, like, well, what was the trauma that could have possibly led them
- 1:03:57Andy Swindler: To have… have done such a thing.
- 1:03:59Brendan McNamara: Yeah, that is wild. That's, again, this is the silliness of hurt people, hurt people.
- 1:04:05Brendan McNamara: You're just like, no, hurt people also go on to heal people forever. So, no, so the hurt people who decided to hurt people decided to hurt people.
- 1:04:14Brendan McNamara: That's them. Like, it cannot be anyone's fault. You may be like, oh, some situations produce higher recurrence, right? You know, abusive households tend to abuse… tend to produce a higher rate of abusers, but it's not causal, that's correlational.
- 1:04:28Brendan McNamara: So then, this is the wild thing, yeah, making it…
- 1:04:32Brendan McNamara: It's… and so it tends to just… it's weird, it vilifies harm, but at the same time, the cohort that's elevating it tends to be the most…
- 1:04:40Brendan McNamara: harm-sensitive cohort.
- 1:04:41Brendan McNamara: planet. So the… you know what I mean? It's a… it's a weird… it's a… some part of it that's happening is a game, and this was used to play a game.
- 1:04:50Brendan McNamara: With all of society, like a civilizational-level game.
- 1:04:56Andy Swindler: So one… Question I have is, if… if people took it this literally, that it's in the body.
- 1:05:03Andy Swindler: Wouldn't we hear accounts of people trying to, like, cut this out?
- 1:05:07Andy Swindler: Literally, like, with a knife.
- 1:05:10Andy Swindler: Saying, oh, this is where this trauma lives, I'm cutting it out. Maybe we have, I don't know.
- 1:05:14Brendan McNamara: Oh, we have, we absolutely have. People call it gender-affirming care.
- 1:05:19Brendan McNamara: That's literally what people are doing.
- 1:05:21Brendan McNamara: They're like, this penis is the source of my trauma.
- 1:05:24Brendan McNamara: And so they have it chopped off. These breasts are the source of my trauma.
- 1:05:29Brendan McNamara: And they have them chopped off.
- 1:05:31Brendan McNamara: So they have literally carried this through.
- 1:05:34Brendan McNamara: And people call it affirming one's sex, which doesn't really make any sense, but… .
- 1:05:41Andy Swindler: Are there other examples? Like, other categories of trauma?
- 1:05:44Brendan McNamara: I mean, self…
- 1:05:45Andy Swindler: But, you know.
- 1:05:46Brendan McNamara: Cutting? Self-harm? Yep.
- 1:05:48Brendan McNamara: Cutting, you know, Cutting's a massive phenomenon. You could probably…
- 1:05:54Brendan McNamara: Yeah. Now, whether they're doing it specifically for this motivation.
- 1:05:58Brendan McNamara: I don't know. Gender-affirming care is the only one that we know is specifically built on this exact premise.
- 1:06:03Andy Swindler: Yeah.
- 1:06:04Brendan McNamara: Which is, like, the parts of your body that…
- 1:06:06Brendan McNamara: Are the… essentially your triggers, right?
- 1:06:09Brendan McNamara: It's triggering your trauma, it's triggering your dysphoria. Even if you haven't been diagnosed with trauma, you're self-diagnosing the trauma, you're your own WebMD,
- 1:06:17Brendan McNamara: And then you say, well, if I get rid of this.
- 1:06:19Brendan McNamara: I have to get rid of this part of my body, because this is where… this is where my trauma is stored, is in my penis.
- 1:06:25Brendan McNamara: So I'm gonna have that just chopped up, flipped inside out, I never have to see it again.
- 1:06:31Brendan McNamara: And there are people who've done it with limbs, too.
- 1:06:33Brendan McNamara: Where they're like, this limb is not mine.
- 1:06:35Brendan McNamara: So they've essentially just placed the trauma in the limb, and they've… Elective limb removal.
- 1:06:40Brendan McNamara: Now, that rarely happens, but it has happened. It's very similar to gender-affirming care in that way.
- 1:06:46Brendan McNamara: So yeah, that's, I mean, that's the most concrete example, and it's set our whole society on fire. Meaning, like, people are like, you're trying to kill these kids, and they're like, you're trying to mutilate these kids, and that's basically our social argument at the moment.
- 1:07:00Andy Swindler: Well, I imagine if you were leading this
- 1:07:03Andy Swindler: well, just so people know, we alternate who comes up with the questions, and I don't know if it's leading, but in some ways it is, or it turns into an interview, or whatever, but somebody poses the question, so I posed this question.
- 1:07:14Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 1:07:15Andy Swindler: But typically, I think when you pose a question, you start with the linguistic analysis, which I want to do at the end here, because I do think it's relevant, and we touched on it in various ways, but these three words are important, right? Body, keep, and score. That's right.
- 1:07:30Andy Swindler: Basically, what we're…
- 1:07:33Andy Swindler: Asking about, and we talked a little bit about, you know, the body as distinct from the brain, and how…
- 1:07:39Andy Swindler: That just seems… like, I get it in a way, but it's also not… true, scientifically.
- 1:07:46Andy Swindler: And then… keep…
- 1:07:50Andy Swindler: And this, I think, is maybe the biggest source of controversy, like, what is the word… the keep and score are probably the even bigger controversies, like, of…
- 1:07:58Andy Swindler: Or interpretive controversies, right? It's like, okay, keep. Well, what does that mean? I'm not looking… I know you always do the dictionary, but I'm like, just… just even casually, like.
- 1:08:07Brendan McNamara: Yes.
- 1:08:07Andy Swindler: store, right? Yes. I'm holding onto something, right? Yes.
- 1:08:11Brendan McNamara: We both do, yeah, we both keep probably more things that we need to keep.
- 1:08:14Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 1:08:16Andy Swindler: True.
- 1:08:16Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 1:08:17Andy Swindler: and then score, I don't know, evidence? Records?
- 1:08:23Andy Swindler: In the popular vernacular receipts these days?
- 1:08:26Brendan McNamara: Oh, yeah, I guess score for me is always just, like, 5 to 4. It's like a sports… probably a sports usage, I guess.
- 1:08:31Andy Swindler: Mmm… Yeah.
- 1:08:34Brendan McNamara: Although I've used it in my piece to mean scorers and, like, musical composition. But I don't think that's how it's meant in Body Keeps the Score. It's Body Keeps the Tally.
- 1:08:42Andy Swindler: Yeah, no, you're… yeah, I'm sure you're absolutely right.
- 1:08:44Brendan McNamara: 4, 7, 8, blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 1:08:46Andy Swindler: how non-supporty I am.
- 1:08:48Brendan McNamara: Well, I don't.
- 1:08:49Andy Swindler: So that's…
- 1:08:49Brendan McNamara: That's just my cultural reference.
- 1:08:51Andy Swindler: Well, that's even more interesting, if that's true, because then it, like, it built in is this, I mean, competitive…
- 1:09:01Andy Swindler: Right.
- 1:09:02Brendan McNamara: Yeah, and how many did I score? Yeah, versus… well, the intersectionality… remember there was those websites? You could look up your own intersectional oppression score?
- 1:09:08Brendan McNamara: That was…
- 1:09:09Andy Swindler: I, like, designed one. I, like, wrote…
- 1:09:11Brendan McNamara: Okay.
- 1:09:11Andy Swindler: I'm one of those websites.
- 1:09:13Brendan McNamara: is, like, a body keeps the score scorecard, score sheet. And you're like, look how traumatized my body is by virtue of inheriting this trauma intergenerationally. I gotta… I win.
- 1:09:24Andy Swindler: I had a super low score. It was really pissing me off.
- 1:09:27Brendan McNamara: That's too bad. Well, luckily, this is all… it was all bullshit anyway, so…
- 1:09:30Brendan McNamara: The… well, I would say this is the interesting thing. This is why the brain-body distinction matters, because the body and not I
- 1:09:37Brendan McNamara: is being used.
- 1:09:40Brendan McNamara: I keep the score.
- 1:09:44Brendan McNamara: That's body, that's brain, that's everything, and that's pretty true.
- 1:09:50Brendan McNamara: I keep score.
- 1:09:52Brendan McNamara: It's me, but isn't this interesting? Well, no, it's just what my body's doing it. I can't control it. It's not me. It's, again, it's putting responsibility off yourself. Well, my brain just makes me do it. No, that's not what they're saying either.
- 1:10:03Brendan McNamara: They're saying if you're stuck in patterns, then you're…
- 1:10:06Brendan McNamara: You're failing to resolve an error in pattern recognition.
- 1:10:10Brendan McNamara: That's on you, dude. If you need help doing it, hey, holler out, let us know.
- 1:10:14Brendan McNamara: But that's you.
- 1:10:15Brendan McNamara: So I think that's why the body-brain distinction still does matter, because there's already a body-eye.
- 1:10:21Brendan McNamara: But again, this is… and again, this is why this is gender identity related. I am not… my gender identity says I am not my embodied self.
- 1:10:30Brendan McNamara: My body is separate from meanness.
- 1:10:34Brendan McNamara: So my sense of myself is my true self. Myself, my embodied self, not myself.
- 1:10:39Brendan McNamara: So that's why this… this is how this body thing penetrated all sorts of society, and then this is also, like, why the body distinction is being made.
- 1:10:48Brendan McNamara: Because it says. Just, like, whatever. So, like, I have someone… if they believe this, they're like, I have intergenerational…
- 1:10:54Brendan McNamara: male trauma, because I'm a son of a son of a son of a son.
- 1:10:58Brendan McNamara: But that's my… my bodily gender. But my real gender is not that, because I don't… and I think this is part of the reality, by the way. I don't want to inherit
- 1:11:08Brendan McNamara: Generations of patriarchal trauma.
- 1:11:10Brendan McNamara: Or… Patriarchal harm production.
- 1:11:14Brendan McNamara: So I would like to step out of maleness.
- 1:11:17Brendan McNamara: And be like, that's just my potty. That's not me.
- 1:11:21Brendan McNamara: I don't want that score to be had anymore. I mean, I think, honestly, I think this thesis has helped frighten people into
- 1:11:28Brendan McNamara: Somatic disassociation more than it's helped people.
- 1:11:31Brendan McNamara: settle into.
- 1:11:33Brendan McNamara: like, somatic presence. But that's just because I'm not witnessing direct inhabitation of either one, I'm just watching the one that's gone the way the farthest in society.
- 1:11:44Brendan McNamara: in a way that was novel, meaning people have always taken walks when they're sad. People go for a run, people dance when they're mad. Like, this is… that's… we've always done that. So the only novel production of this theory seems to be…
- 1:11:57Brendan McNamara: making people Put their bodies far, far away from themselves.
- 1:12:02Andy Swindler: sometimes when I think about The way we talk about healing, Psychologically.
- 1:12:09Andy Swindler: It's helpful to just… Remember how the body heals a physical wound.
- 1:12:15Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 1:12:16Andy Swindler: And, and… and how powerful.
- 1:12:18Andy Swindler: we are. I mean, how beautifully we were made to heal.
- 1:12:23Brendan McNamara: Yeah, it's really cool.
- 1:12:25Andy Swindler: Yeah, I had a bike…
- 1:12:28Andy Swindler: I don't know, accident, I guess. It was just me, but skidding out pretty bad last… about a year ago, and so I got to watch my skin, like, regrow, you know? It was like…
- 1:12:39Andy Swindler: it was fascinating, because I was like, when was the last time I had a skin to knee, you know? Like, that's some… that's some stuff kids do, you know?
- 1:12:46Brendan McNamara: Yeah, that's good stuff.
- 1:12:49Andy Swindler: Yeah, so that's really alive for me, just that… holding that question. Well, what does that mean in this context? What does it mean to trust our own ability to heal? But then also in the context of score, because scars are…
- 1:13:01Andy Swindler: like.
- 1:13:01Brendan McNamara: Yes.
- 1:13:02Andy Swindler: That's, like, tick marks, you know, on the wall.
- 1:13:05Brendan McNamara: It really is, it is, yeah.
- 1:13:09Andy Swindler: So, you know, in that way, I'm like.
- 1:13:11Andy Swindler: I don't know, I guess what this is saying is there's no…
- 1:13:15Andy Swindler: There's no, like, physical evidence under the skin.
- 1:13:19Andy Swindler: Yeah. That psychological trauma Literally, creates scar tissue in your muscles, or whatever.
- 1:13:26Brendan McNamara: Yeah, or any part of your… any part of you whatsoever, yeah. Even in your… yeah, in your neurological processing or anything. It just doesn't…
- 1:13:33Brendan McNamara: It doesn't… yeah, there's no corollary. I think that's the thing, people are trying to make a metaphor into something concrete.
- 1:13:39Andy Swindler: But it… Seems to create more rigidity in the brain.
- 1:13:43Brendan McNamara: Yeah, way more.
- 1:13:45Andy Swindler: and looping.
- 1:13:46Brendan McNamara: Yep.
- 1:13:47Andy Swindler: So…
- 1:13:48Andy Swindler: The easiest hack here would just be to be like, well, why are you separating the brain from the body?
- 1:13:52Brendan McNamara: Yeah, and yourself, and yourself from your body. Yeah. Who else is responsible for your body besides you?
- 1:13:58Andy Swindler: I mean, if your brain… if your brain's keeping the score, well… I don't know.
- 1:14:03Brendan McNamara: It's included.
- 1:14:03Andy Swindler: That's you. Yeah, that's you.
- 1:14:05Brendan McNamara: Yeah, but people are like, no, I'm a disembodied something. This is what it propagates. I don't… I exist as a sort of ineffable, metaphoric soul.
- 1:14:14Andy Swindler: Bill.
- 1:14:14Brendan McNamara: Listen, even Christians sometimes claim that, and that's not remotely, like,
- 1:14:19Brendan McNamara: That's not biblical teaching. Well, your healing is interesting, too, we've talked about this before. Like, the process of debriding is necessary, which means, oh my gosh, that's my wounding, leave that wounding alone, don't touch it.
- 1:14:29Brendan McNamara: Cool, that's how you get sepsis. That's how you die.
- 1:14:33Brendan McNamara: If your wound is healing and you start noticing it's inflamed, sometimes you've got to Rip the scab.
- 1:14:41Brendan McNamara: Wash it with burns and stuff, or, like, shark bites.
- 1:14:45Brendan McNamara: It's almost like a… it's somewhere… it's almost like a Brillo pad.
- 1:14:48Brendan McNamara: It's not quite a bill of power, but it's like that. It's a hard thing, and you have to go…
- 1:14:53Brendan McNamara: And rub it into your wound.
- 1:14:56Brendan McNamara: To get all the necrotic tissue ripped Or you will never heal.
- 1:15:01Brendan McNamara: So that's the fascinating thing, because it says, get away from me, I'm reacting! Like, this is a react… I want to type back into your reactive concept. If you're so reactive, you won't let anyone help you, and you assume anyone who hurts you when they're touching you is harming you.
- 1:15:13Brendan McNamara: That's like, you haven't progressed past the metacognition of an 8-year-old.
- 1:15:18Brendan McNamara: You know, when kids are 4, they don't understand why you're cleaning their teeth and it hurts, you know what I mean? You're like, well, cavities can cause damage, blah blah blah, you know, whatever, you're just trying to stave off other harm. But once you're a grown-up, this is the crazy thing, we're…
- 1:15:31Brendan McNamara: Preserving this extended, not even pre-adolescence, well into the 20s, 30s, 40s, maybe even 50s.
- 1:15:38Brendan McNamara: To where we're like, no, some harm is necessary. Like, if you have a gangrenous hand, you gotta chop it off, it's gonna hurt like the heck.
- 1:15:46Brendan McNamara: And that's just like, or if you've got a burn, and it's healing, and you're just… and it's bubbled up and oozing, you've gotta rip it open.
- 1:15:53Brendan McNamara: Tired up, and sometimes therapy can be that, dancing can be that.
- 1:15:57Brendan McNamara: conversation can be that. Like, you can do that in all sorts of ways, but it's not lo… like, people just have this perpetration of, like.
- 1:16:04Brendan McNamara: If it hurts, you don't love me.
- 1:16:10Andy Swindler: Last word, it's not in the…
- 1:16:13Andy Swindler: Framing originally, but you mentioned it, and it seems just…
- 1:16:17Andy Swindler: Inextricable from all of this is trigger.
- 1:16:20Brendan McNamara: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:16:21Andy Swindler: And…
- 1:16:25Andy Swindler: Yeah, do we… do we overuse the word trigger?
- 1:16:28Brendan McNamara: Oh, for sure. Yeah, my friend.
- 1:16:30Andy Swindler: That's a slightly leading question. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:16:32Brendan McNamara: Karen and Nicole, years and years ago, did a whole series that did pretty well called I'm Triggered.
- 1:16:37Andy Swindler: That is, like, pretty much in my mind, that series, every time. It was so good. It was early! I feel like that was kind of early in the…
- 1:16:43Brendan McNamara: It was, like, yeah, it was… I feel like it was, like, right at the early crest of the wave. Honestly, by the time the show was done, it was already… like, they caught their wave at a really smart time. But that was, like, 15 years ago.
- 1:16:53Brendan McNamara: And now it's just like… People have integrated as though it's real.
- 1:16:58Brendan McNamara: trigger warnings on his shows and stuff, like, oh, trigger warning. NPR does it for their trigger warning, there is.
- 1:17:04Brendan McNamara: conversation about sexual assault and this thing. You're just like, what is happening?
- 1:17:09Brendan McNamara: Like, why is the news a helicopter parent? Like, this is insane. Yeah, so it's very similar, where it's just like, well, because again, they bought into this lie that, like.
- 1:17:17Brendan McNamara: If someone experiences Something negative that…
- 1:17:21Brendan McNamara: To them, according to their subjective valuation.
- 1:17:24Brendan McNamara: hurting them.
- 1:17:25Brendan McNamara: Like, that's like… That's… it's maybe beyond metaphor of me, like, kind of stabbing them with Needle or something.
- 1:17:31Brendan McNamara: You're just like, I mean, so in some ways, again, this is where it carried way too far for…
- 1:17:38Brendan McNamara: It's a pretty similar amount of time, right? 2014? It's right around the time Triggered was getting going.
- 1:17:44Brendan McNamara: Coincidence? I think not.
- 1:17:48Andy Swindler: Well, Peter's my iguano's coming up a lot in this episode, and she's had this…
- 1:17:52Andy Swindler: Growth on her back for… I don't know, a while now, several weeks, and…
- 1:17:58Andy Swindler: I hadn't taken her to the vet in, like, 10 years, because, like I said, last time he was just like, keep doing what you're doing.
- 1:18:04Andy Swindler: But, to your point, I'm like, okay, this is not going away, it's not healing, it's not changing. It could be something, you know, worse than…
- 1:18:12Andy Swindler: I don't know, I imagine, like, cancer? So I finally take her to the vet.
- 1:18:16Andy Swindler: And… I mean, this vet is hilariously young, I'm like…
- 1:18:20Andy Swindler: My iguana might be older than you.
- 1:18:23Andy Swindler: But… you know, so I'm now giving her anti,
- 1:18:32Andy Swindler: Antibiotic shots, which in itself is a novel experience, like, giving.
- 1:18:36Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 1:18:36Andy Swindler: Because the way you give shots to a reptile is fascinating, because you have to go between their scales.
- 1:18:41Andy Swindler: But… not only do I, you know, not love needles, but I'm… It can be hard.
- 1:18:50Brendan McNamara: to hurt.
- 1:18:51Andy Swindler: Something or somebody you love.
- 1:18:55Andy Swindler: Even when you know they need it.
- 1:18:56Brendan McNamara: It's needed, yeah, oh, for sure.
- 1:18:59Brendan McNamara: Yeah, but the sad thing is, it's like, we're building a system by which we discourage
- 1:19:06Brendan McNamara: Doing that hard thing.
- 1:19:08Brendan McNamara: Which is, like…
- 1:19:11Brendan McNamara: And then the weird thing is, because that impulse doesn't go away, it's gone into all these weird corrections, where, like, you're not supposed to speak this way, you're not supposed to say these words. So we've actually become a far more rigorous policer of harm.
- 1:19:23Brendan McNamara: Across thousands of metrics we can't prove.
- 1:19:26Brendan McNamara: don't really like, like, let's say speaking the truth. Let's say something was genuinely true and it hurt somebody, like, that has been vilified.
- 1:19:34Brendan McNamara: So we've taken away our best medicine, and then we're trying to replace it with, like, 1,000 new medicines that are
- 1:19:40Brendan McNamara: worse.
- 1:19:42Brendan McNamara: Because, yes, it is hard, and actually, I think it should be… have some degree of difficulty for you to be like, oof.
- 1:19:47Brendan McNamara: This is gonna hurt.
- 1:19:49Brendan McNamara: I'm going to do it anyway, because it's the right thing to do.
- 1:19:55Andy Swindler: There's… there's a… there's a metaphor there with… Petrus's growth.
- 1:20:00Brendan McNamara: Yeah, like, this is… this could kill you.
- 1:20:03Brendan McNamara: This could kill you, homie.
- 1:20:05Andy Swindler: Keep you from growing.
- 1:20:07Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 1:20:08Andy Swindler: Growth could keep you from growing.
- 1:20:09Brendan McNamara: Yeah, this might be assist, sis.
- 1:20:12Brendan McNamara: Alright, brother, I think we solved the world.
- 1:20:14Andy Swindler: I think we did. I think we did. We've thoroughly unpacked this one. Good.
- 1:20:19Brendan McNamara: What is your, post-vote? My post-vote, I'm gonna…
- 1:20:22Andy Swindler: I have to hold up my.
- 1:20:23Brendan McNamara: Oh, hey, there's.
- 1:20:23Andy Swindler: I usually listen to books, but I did have an actual visual aid I forgot to hold up for this.
- 1:20:27Brendan McNamara: Nice. I'm gonna state… I'm stuck with thumbs down.
- 1:20:32Andy Swindler: I am at least drifting to the semi-useless place in the middle.
- 1:20:39Andy Swindler: Which we probably should have never introduced.
- 1:20:42Andy Swindler: I think I got the most stuck on score. I think that was helpful, to reorient around that as a…
- 1:20:51Brendan McNamara: Yeah.
- 1:20:52Andy Swindler: Leading to this tremendous.
- 1:20:53Brendan McNamara: You built… yeah, you built a website to literally keep the score, to track an actual metric of the body-kept score.
- 1:21:00Brendan McNamara: Based not even on personal experience, but simply, like, identity category. So you built something that employed it, which I think that would make a lot of sense then. And then the fact that you missed it earlier.
- 1:21:11Brendan McNamara: You are, no offense.
- 1:21:13Brendan McNamara: Not a sporty guy.
- 1:21:16Brendan McNamara: I don't mean that as a purpose.
- 1:21:17Andy Swindler: I did get that… I think you were there when I got that fortune cookie, though, that said you like competitive sports.
- 1:21:22Brendan McNamara: Yes! One of the greatest slash worst ones ever. But yeah, but no, but, like, so for you not to take that as, like, oh, this is, like, a score, like, blah blah blah versus blah blah blah, as a inference, you're like, I don't inhabit that world, so why would I even think about that? Also kind of makes sense.
- 1:21:38Andy Swindler: Rude.
- 1:21:40Andy Swindler: I got a new one, I'm gonna do a… Quarter…
- 1:21:45Brendan McNamara: I mean, in a binary system, just so you know, that's a thumbstep.
- 1:21:51Brendan McNamara: Oh, there you go!
- 1:21:52Andy Swindler: Fucking hilarious. Zoom, Zoom interpreted the, the,
- 1:21:57Andy Swindler: 3 quarters down as… as a… Yeah.
- 1:21:59Brendan McNamara: Yeah, they're like, I don't have that many categories, guy. It's up or down. Yeah.
- 1:22:04Brendan McNamara: Rotation of some…
- 1:22:07Andy Swindler: I guess it's gonna take me into the down, so…
- 1:22:10Andy Swindler: Thank you, Brendan, and thank you, Authors and Peanut Gallery, for helping me expand my…
- 1:22:17Andy Swindler: Knowledge, and hopefully my healing.
- 1:22:20Brendan McNamara: Absolutely. Thank you for helping me heal, man.
- 1:22:23Andy Swindler: Love you.
- 1:22:23Brendan McNamara: Love you.