Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Obtaining a Permanent Spousal Support Order: Practical Frameworks andUse of Xspouse
Transcript
- 0:04Welcome to Obtaining a Permanent Spousal Support
- 0:07Order, Practical Frameworks, and Use of Ex -Spouse
- 0:10with Commissioner Patty Radekin. I am Ryan Whitekin,
- 0:13co -chair of the Beverly Hills Bar Association's
- 0:16Family Law Section. The Family Law Section is
- 0:19sponsored by White Zuckerman, Worzowski Luna
- 0:21Hunt, LLP, Lawyers Mutual Insurance, Soberlink,
- 0:25and Our Family Wizard. White Zuckerman provides
- 0:28a wide variety of resources to complete almost
- 0:30any project, large or small. They also provide
- 0:33traditional accounting and tax practice services.
- 0:36We invite you to contact them to discuss your
- 0:38specific accounting needs and to learn how they
- 0:40can be of service to you. Learn more at WZWLH
- 0:44.com. Silverlink provides objective real -time
- 0:47data that can be used to reduce disputes over
- 0:49alcohol consumption, leading to less conflict
- 0:52in custody cases. To help ensure smoother negotiations
- 0:55for a more efficient legal process, consider
- 0:57using Silverlink's trusted alcohol monitoring
- 1:00system to eliminate hearsay and protect your
- 1:03client's best interests. With an unprecedented
- 1:05combination of features, including advanced reporting,
- 1:08facial recognition, tamper resistance, real -time
- 1:11results, and customized testing, the discrete
- 1:13system has been the leader in remote alcohol
- 1:16monitoring since 2011. Learn more at soberlink
- 1:19.com. For five decades, Lawyers Mutual Insurance
- 1:23Company has been the only California -based company
- 1:26to continuously provide lawyers throughout the
- 1:29state with professional liability insurance coverage.
- 1:32Their experience and expertise are complemented
- 1:35by the fact that Lawyers Mutual is directed by
- 1:38a group of dedicated lawyers. They offer special
- 1:41rates with competitive premiums for a wide range
- 1:43of areas of practice, including family law. Learn
- 1:46more at lawyersmutual .com. Our Family Wizard
- 1:51is a co -parenting platform designed to help
- 1:54families communicate more effectively, reduce
- 1:56conflict, and create reliable court admissible
- 1:59records. Features like Tone Meter, shared calendars,
- 2:03expense tracking, and in -app audio and video
- 2:05calling help support compliance and better outcomes
- 2:08for families navigating custody matters. Lastly,
- 2:13I will note our BHBA family law section meetings
- 2:17fall on the third Wednesday of each month, so
- 2:21the next meeting will be held on July 22nd, 2026
- 2:25at 430 p .m. Please join us. If you're missing
- 2:29these meetings, you're missing out on sort of
- 2:32the state of Department Two. We often hear from
- 2:37Judge Kaufman. and kind of get the rundown on
- 2:41the latest and greatest down at department two.
- 2:43So if you're missing meetings, you're missing
- 2:46out on basically a monthly state of department
- 2:49two meeting. In addition, you're missing out
- 2:51on a lot of great family law content that Jack
- 2:54and I have put together, including little sort
- 2:56of modular CLEs that are breezy, you know, sort
- 3:02of a five to 10. uh minute minute thing and uh
- 3:06you know we've got you in and out and under an
- 3:07hour so please join us again that's every third
- 3:11wednesday of the month uh the next meeting will
- 3:13be held july 20 july 22nd 2026 at 4 30 and now
- 3:19i am delighted to introduce our speakers today
- 3:21commissioner patty radigan commissioner radigan
- 3:24brings over 31 years of experience in the family
- 3:26law court a certified family law specialist Her
- 3:30expertise spans alternative dispute resolution,
- 3:32child support, and spousal support matters. She
- 3:35has served on the Department of Child Support
- 3:37Services guideline, Child Support Calculation
- 3:41Task Force, the Superior Court Family Law Committee,
- 3:44Superior Court Rules Committee, and the CJER
- 3:47Family Law Curriculum Committee. She created
- 3:50the curriculum for the primary assignment training
- 3:52for AB 1058, child support commissioners, and
- 3:56has lectured extensively on family law across
- 3:59California. She is currently serving as a neutral,
- 4:02privately compensated temporary judge, special
- 4:04master, arbitrator, and parenting plan coordinator
- 4:07at Signature Resolution in San Diego. Now, let's
- 4:11get started. Commissioner Patty Radekin, I will
- 4:15hand it over to you. Thank you, Ryan, for your
- 4:18kind words and thanks to the Beverly Hills Bar
- 4:20for allowing me to be here today. And thank everyone
- 4:24for taking time out of their busy day to come
- 4:26and listen to the seminar. So I'm going to do
- 4:30my best to give you tips and tools to obtain
- 4:33a more favorable result for your client and how
- 4:37to set up the case for a modification procedure.
- 4:46Today, the objectives are to understand the legal
- 4:49foundation of permanent spousal support. Keep
- 4:52in mind, nothing is permanent about it, but that's
- 4:55the word that continues to be used in the law
- 4:58and the cases and everything else, but it's really
- 5:01not. I think you need to let your clients understand
- 5:05that there are, you know, there's a good chance
- 5:08it'll be modified, terminated in the future.
- 5:12I'm going to give you some tools to use to prepare
- 5:15for subsequent modifications where the court's
- 5:17jurisdiction is limited as to ordering spousal
- 5:20support. And when you can use ex -spouse and
- 5:24only to determine tax consequences, we'll get
- 5:27into that a little bit later, and income available
- 5:30to both spouses. The purpose of long -term spousal
- 5:36support is to maintain the marital standard of
- 5:38living. And all of you who practice family law
- 5:41know that that is somewhat of an unreasonable
- 5:43expectation. You're taking two households, splitting
- 5:47it, or one household, splitting it into two and
- 5:50expecting everybody to have the same amount of
- 5:52income to meet the marital standard of living.
- 5:55So. What's really important about that is when
- 5:58you're crafting stipulations for spousal support,
- 6:02make sure you indicate whether it does or it
- 6:05does not meet the marital standard of living.
- 6:08If you have a dispute, my suggestion to you is
- 6:11that you put that in your order as the petitioner
- 6:14believes this meets the marital standard of living,
- 6:16respondent doesn't, and then the court can decide
- 6:20that at a later modification hearing. It also
- 6:25addresses economic disadvantage between the parties,
- 6:27shares the financial consequences of the breakdown
- 6:30of the marriage, and hopefully promotes self
- 6:32-sufficiency where appropriate. How do you obtain
- 6:36a long -term spousal order? Either by stipulation
- 6:40or going to trial. The important thing to keep
- 6:44in mind is you cannot bifurcate spousal support
- 6:47separately. Division of the property has to be
- 6:51completed before the trial court can deal with
- 6:53the issue of long -term support. So if you can
- 6:58agree on the property, you can bifurcate spousal
- 7:01and just make sure your judgment is filed before
- 7:03the court has the trial on spousal support. The
- 7:10family code section 4320 factors are extremely
- 7:14important in a in a judgment or an order for
- 7:18spousal support because that sets the standard
- 7:23for whether or not it can be modified in the
- 7:26future. Now I know having been a practitioner
- 7:29for quite some time when you're Getting a stipulation
- 7:33and your client has agreed to this and you're
- 7:36sitting at the table and they don't want to spend
- 7:38any more money on you. And you say, OK, we're
- 7:41just going to file a judgment with no 4320 factors
- 7:44in it. This can be a mistake and at times can
- 7:47be a catastrophic mistake. So. One of the issues
- 7:54that continues to come up in these cases is whether
- 7:57or not the court, if the court's faced with deciding
- 8:00on the spousal support issue, whether they need
- 8:03to make findings on each and every one of the
- 8:054320 factors. There's no case that deals with
- 8:08it exactly on point. There's some that say no,
- 8:12some that say yes, but its best practice is to
- 8:16have the court and ask the court to make findings
- 8:20on all of the relevant 4320 factors and if a
- 8:24factor isn't appropriate, have them make that
- 8:27finding that it's not relevant. The 4320 factors,
- 8:32the best way to present them to court is to get
- 8:36a compelling story through your client's testimony
- 8:39and the information available to you with your
- 8:44client. So the importance of them is it is a
- 8:48benchmark for determining whether a change of
- 8:51circumstances has occurred. And in a lot of cases,
- 8:54it was that I had for a modification. It was
- 8:58really difficult to try to figure out because
- 9:01there was no FL 150 from the time of the original
- 9:05order. There's not enough information in the
- 9:07judgment. Everybody's telling a different story
- 9:10years from now. It also facilitates future modification
- 9:16and it supports judicial economy by minimizing
- 9:20disputes later on. The practice tip that I have
- 9:24for you is to make sure that you have an FL -150
- 9:28near or at the time of the order or judgment
- 9:32that you're relying on, and that a copy of that
- 9:35is either in the file or kept to be able to be
- 9:39produced to the court later on. What used to
- 9:44happen to me is I would get a modification request.
- 9:47There would be no 4320 findings in the judgment.
- 9:50I would have to order the parties and continue
- 9:54the hearing for them to do a declaration regarding
- 9:57the 4320s which existed at the time and they
- 10:02exist now. So I could determine whether or not
- 10:04there was a change of circumstance. If you run
- 10:07into a situation where there's a dispute by the
- 10:10parties over what the 4320 factors are, one of
- 10:13the ways that I have seen it handled and suggested
- 10:17that the parties handle it is to have each party
- 10:20state what they believe the 4320 factors to be
- 10:23and attach those either as include them in the
- 10:27judgment or attach them as an exhibit to the
- 10:29judgment. That issue can then be determined later
- 10:32if necessary by the court. The marital standard
- 10:37of living, the words that you always hear about
- 10:40this, it's neither a floor nor a ceiling for
- 10:43spousal support, but merely a basis or reference
- 10:45point for determining need and support. There's
- 10:49the regular marital standard of living. Everybody
- 10:52agrees that it was a middle class, upper middle
- 10:54class or some definition like that. And you have
- 10:59the two kind of exceptions to that. The artificially
- 11:02reduced standard of living, like the Watt marriage,
- 11:04where the husband was a doctor, the wife was
- 11:07a nurse. She put husband through medical school.
- 11:09They lived a very sparse lifestyle because of
- 11:12him going to school and her not having sufficient
- 11:14income to meet the expenses of the family. Then
- 11:18he gets a divorce and the court found that she's
- 11:21entitled to write up on his increased income.
- 11:24living above your means, where you're living
- 11:26off credit card debts, you're living off loans,
- 11:29you're living off HELOCs. So one of the things
- 11:35that I find exceptionally helpful in my mediations
- 11:38even is to let the client tell their story in
- 11:42a narrative form. about the marital standard
- 11:46of living, their expenses, where they went, their
- 11:48vacations, and things like that. You can gain
- 11:51a lot of information that you can use in this
- 11:54type of analysis for the court. Be creative in
- 11:57telling your story. Use photos. Not too many
- 12:00photos, but use photos. Use vacations, houses.
- 12:03Tell the story of their life. And if you intend
- 12:08to prove that they either lived in an artificially
- 12:10reduced standard or above their means, You cannot
- 12:14rely on just mere conjecture or argument. You
- 12:17have to have proof. And so try very hard to gather
- 12:20that evidence that will prove that to the court.
- 12:28So you're defining their marital standard of
- 12:30living, their luxury, their upper middle class,
- 12:33their poor, their poverty level, whatever it
- 12:36is, define it in words that a judge can understand.
- 12:41Demonstrate this is where a lot of cases go sideways
- 12:45in my opinion is everybody or not everybody I
- 12:49should say, but some people just forget about
- 12:51that need and ability argument. Need and ability
- 12:54should be the first thing you start dealing with
- 12:57when it comes to marital standard of living and
- 12:59the 4320 factors. Because we're going to talk
- 13:02a little bit more about the limitations on the
- 13:05court's jurisdiction, but 4321 and 4322 come
- 13:10into play in this. Connect your expenses to the
- 13:14marital lifestyle. If you need an expert to do
- 13:18that, get one and have, you know, that's evidence
- 13:21that the court can rely on to determine whether
- 13:24or not the supported spouse has a need for ongoing
- 13:28spousal support. So a picture's worth a thousand
- 13:32words. The one on the left, upper middle class
- 13:37luxury. The one on the right, I've probably had
- 13:40someone describe that as a middle class lifestyle.
- 13:43So be creative with the documentation that you
- 13:47present to the court. So the rest of the 4320
- 13:52factors, need and ability, as I said, is the
- 13:54most important thing to focus on. The marketable
- 13:58skills of the supported party, earning capacity
- 14:00of the supported party, unemployment during the
- 14:04marriage, devoted to domestic duties. One of
- 14:07the things that I run into quite a bit is the
- 14:10argument, well, I stayed home and took care of
- 14:12the kids, or I stayed home, I had no kids, but
- 14:16I supported the other person totally, 100%. A
- 14:21lot of times there's no evidence to support either
- 14:24part, either side of that argument. So, you know,
- 14:27if you have a situation where somebody is arguing,
- 14:30I stayed home to take care of the kids and you
- 14:32can show that there was always a nanny there,
- 14:34that's going to carry less weight than if, you
- 14:37know, somebody did stay home and, you know, you
- 14:40had a disabled child or something like that.
- 14:42Those types of, that type of evidence is going
- 14:45to be very important to the court. The assets
- 14:48and obligations of each party. That sometimes
- 14:52is very overinflated on somebody's income and
- 14:54expense declaration. The age and health of the
- 14:57parties. As I said, need and ability is a factor
- 15:03to spend quite a bit of time on proving to the
- 15:06court what that looked like. 90 % of the income
- 15:09and expense declarations that I saw while I was
- 15:12on the bench were pure works of fiction. You
- 15:16have two cases that deal with this particular
- 15:19issue. One is Hofmeister and it's Hofmeister
- 15:21two that says income and expense declaration
- 15:24should be accurate. Representation of the party's
- 15:29needs. Zinke says expenses of the supported spouse
- 15:32as listed on the income and expense declaration
- 15:35need not be exact. So what does exact mean? My
- 15:39groceries were precisely $642 .17. That's exact.
- 15:45A reasonable estimate of that would be my groceries
- 15:47are somewhere between six and $700. not my groceries
- 15:51are $1 ,800 a month or $2 ,800 a month. You've
- 15:55got to be close to the reality of the situation.
- 16:01And the FL -150 gives you an opportunity to provide
- 16:05estimated actual and proposed needs. And estimated
- 16:10is, like I said, you don't have for every expense,
- 16:13you just have to do your best guess or, you know,
- 16:16at what they're spending monthly. Have your staff
- 16:19spend some time on that. Make a reasonable, honest
- 16:25estimate based on recent bills, bank statements,
- 16:27or normal spending patterns. In other words,
- 16:30have proof if called upon to prove it to the
- 16:33court that this is the expenditure. Avoid intentionally
- 16:37overstating or understating expenses, and that
- 16:40goes both ways, because oftentimes the supported
- 16:43parties i n e says their expenses are forty thousand
- 16:47a month and the supporting party says my expenses
- 16:50are ten thousand a month and probably neither
- 16:52one of them are correct but one of the things
- 16:55that happens and i've talked to a couple of my
- 16:57friends who are judges when about this particular
- 17:00issue and the consensus is when you file an income
- 17:03and expense declaration that's over inflated
- 17:06to you know, just out of control. You lose, not
- 17:10you particularly, but your client loses credibility
- 17:13and it can definitely affect the outcome of your
- 17:17case. One of the practice tips I have for you
- 17:22is do your actual and estimated expenses on one
- 17:27page three of the FL 150. Indicate which are
- 17:30actual. But for estimated, use an asterisk or
- 17:34some numbering system so the judge knows that
- 17:37you have estimated those expenses. If you're
- 17:40trying to go to show what the proposed needs
- 17:43are based on the marital standard of living,
- 17:45do a second page three for the proposed needs.
- 17:49Because I can't tell you how often I had a case
- 17:52where They came in for a hearing and all I had
- 17:57was estimated expenses or, you know, nothing
- 18:00was actual. I had no idea where the person really
- 18:03was. And I think I would oftentimes send them
- 18:06out to do an income and expense declaration with
- 18:09actual expenses on it. So the other thing, the
- 18:15age and health, the 65, no one can force to be
- 18:18work or the court can't force someone to work
- 18:21past 65 to pay support. But if there's passive
- 18:24income, that's a little different story. It's
- 18:27also not applicable to child support. But it
- 18:34seems to me that because social security has
- 18:37determined that the full retirement age for most
- 18:42people that are working these days is 67 years
- 18:45old, it seems like there's a good faith argument
- 18:48for extension of the 65 rule. Okay, the next
- 18:54thing we're going to talk about is the length
- 18:55of the marriage. So for a marriage less than
- 18:5710 years, there's a presumption that spousal
- 19:00support jurisdiction is one half the life of
- 19:02the marriage. So the issue that comes up there
- 19:08is Is temporary support that's paid considered
- 19:13as part of that period of time? The judge has
- 19:17wide discretion to determine that. And it is,
- 19:20in my opinion, a very factually... You need facts
- 19:26to convince a judge to go one way or the other.
- 19:29So if you have a spouse who's never worked and
- 19:32the supported... The supporting party cuts off
- 19:35all income, they have to fight for that and they
- 19:39get a temporary order. That would be a case where
- 19:42the judge could say, no, I'm going to only start
- 19:45the half the life of the marriage when the permanent
- 19:47order exists. But you've got cases that there's
- 19:51no case on point on this particular issue. So.
- 19:56One of the things that's important in my opinion,
- 19:59I was I believe in Gavron warnings. I believe
- 20:02in giving them early and giving them often and
- 20:05not just for the person paying support, but for
- 20:08the person receiving support because there are
- 20:11so many things that can happen to someone who's
- 20:14receiving support. My I had a third. It just
- 20:19can go very badly for someone receiving support
- 20:22if the supported the supporting party loses their
- 20:26job and they let's say they lose their job for
- 20:30sexual harassment their their employment in the
- 20:32future could be. potentially affected and the
- 20:35support order is going to go to zero while they
- 20:38have no job. So you have to kind of warn your
- 20:41clients about those kinds of things. A marriage
- 20:44of more than 10 years, it's an abuse of discretion
- 20:47for the court to terminate absent certain circumstances.
- 20:52But one practice tip, do not ask for a termination
- 20:56of spousal support on a request for order. That's
- 20:58a temporary order and a termination of support
- 21:01is a permanent order. So don't That's a trial
- 21:04issue unless you can get a stipulation to do
- 21:07so. So these are the limitations on the court's
- 21:12jurisdiction to award spousal support. And I
- 21:14think we talked a little bit about this in part
- 21:17one of it, but I'm going to go over it again.
- 21:19There is a presumption against spousal support.
- 21:22It is a rebuttable presumption. that if there
- 21:25is a conviction for a domestic violence misdemeanor,
- 21:28and that means anything that started as a domestic
- 21:31violence charge, even if it was pled down to
- 21:33a 415, that creates the rebuttable presumption
- 21:37against spousal support. And that's temporary
- 21:39and permanent. So if you have the payor, and
- 21:45if you have a less experienced judge, file points
- 21:48and authorities prior to the first RFO regarding
- 21:50the rebuttable presumption. If you're the person
- 21:53who's got the perpetrator and they're asking
- 21:55for support, you have some work to do, but focus
- 21:59on whether if support's not granted, the perpetrator
- 22:02is gonna be left as a public charge because that
- 22:05seems like where the case law goes with overcoming
- 22:08the presumption. So there is a prohibition against
- 22:14spousal support under 4324 and 4324 .5. Is a
- 22:22lifetime ban and that's 4324. The other one has
- 22:26a time limit for 5 years before or following
- 22:29the conviction. So if you have a situation where
- 22:33you have somebody who's convicted of 1 of the
- 22:35charges, it's outlined in these statutes. Make
- 22:38sure you understand where you are in the timeline.
- 22:47So. The the 1. Section also affects the date.
- 22:54There's all kinds of benefits to your client.
- 22:56If they're in this framework, there's community
- 22:59assets. It's the closest as we can get to fault
- 23:02in California. They get community assets. They
- 23:05get 100 % of their retirement. They get to pick
- 23:07their data separation. So if you have this case,
- 23:10make sure you look at it from what your client
- 23:13is entitled to get as a result of these convictions.
- 23:18Family code section 4321 and 4322, I call them
- 23:22the forgotten sections because people don't argue
- 23:24these enough in my opinion. 4321 is a situation
- 23:30where in a judgment of disillusion, the supported
- 23:33party has separate properties sufficient for
- 23:36their support. Technically, let's say you have
- 23:42a case where somebody is Receiving 10 million
- 23:46dollars in assets and. The the argument could
- 23:51be is that that's sufficient to provide proper
- 23:53support. There's judges that are just don't feel
- 23:58comfortable with this. Section, so do some work
- 24:01around this. If you have this situation, at least
- 24:04try 4321 also is can be used. If you have the
- 24:09person who's paying support. the other person
- 24:12has very little custody of the children, that
- 24:15falls within the B section. You can argue that,
- 24:18that, you know, all the income that the supporting
- 24:20spouse has should be used for the child and not
- 24:23the spouse. Now, 43 -22 is a little different.
- 24:28It is, 43 -21 is a may, so that the court has
- 24:31wide discretion there. 43 -22 is a shall. And
- 24:36when it says shall in the, in the section, the
- 24:38court shall follow that order. So the elements
- 24:42of this is either in an original order, a modification
- 24:46proceeding, there's no children, and the party
- 24:48has a separate estate sufficient for their proper
- 24:51support. The court's not supposed to grant spousal
- 24:55support. Whether you'd get a termination on a
- 24:59long -term marriage, probably not, but you'd
- 25:01probably get a set to zero. The next thing I'm
- 25:07going to talk about is a Richmond step down order.
- 25:10And that is something where it shifts the burden
- 25:13to the other party when the modification proceeding
- 25:16comes forward. They have to prove. that they
- 25:20had a plan for self -supporting and that they
- 25:23met the plan or didn't meet the plan. That's
- 25:25where the vocational evaluation is super important.
- 25:28And give clear instructions to the evaluator
- 25:31to direct the scope of the evaluation and all
- 25:34of, you know, the individualized return to work
- 25:36and self -sufficiency plan. Have the evaluator
- 25:40identify the training, the education, any rehabilitation
- 25:43services that are necessary, and how long they
- 25:46think it's gonna take. Clearly define your expectations
- 25:49with measurable benchmarks. Failure of expectation
- 25:53will get you into a modification. So if they're,
- 25:55if they, let's say their part was to get a teaching
- 25:59credential, they couldn't get their classes and
- 26:03therefore they had an unrealized expectation.
- 26:07But it has to be under no control of theirs where
- 26:10they were the ones, it was something out of their
- 26:13control. Use of the calculator. Like I said,
- 26:18only to compute tax consequences and, you know,
- 26:21figure out what the incomes of the parties are.
- 26:24Since the change in the federal and state law
- 26:26for tax consequences, it's not really relevant
- 26:29unless you have a grandfathered order which allows
- 26:32for either federal or state deductions. Common
- 26:36mistakes are inflated budgets, unsupported expenses,
- 26:40and failure to link expenses to the marital standard
- 26:42of living. Statement of decision. Always ask
- 26:47for a statement of decision on a spousal support
- 26:49case. If the court fails to issue a statement
- 26:53of decision when requested, it renders the order
- 26:56void. Think what you could do with that. Effective
- 26:59January 1st, 2027, a request for statement of
- 27:02decision must be made before the matter is submitted
- 27:05to the court after argument. Continuing exclusive
- 27:11jurisdiction. If California issues a spousal
- 27:14support order, it's California's forever. Even
- 27:17if both parties move out of the state. And California
- 27:21taxability. California changed income tax treatment
- 27:25of spousal support effective January 1st, 2026.
- 27:29So keep that in mind when you're calculating
- 27:31your support. So we have just a few minutes for
- 27:35questions. I'm willing to stay a little bit over
- 27:37if anybody has questions. I know I went pretty
- 27:43fast. Hi, Commissioner Radkin. It looks like
- 27:49we do have a few questions within the Q &A box.
- 27:51One from Alina. How to handle a spouse that went
- 27:55to court on a modification and did not notice
- 27:57the other side got the modification. File a motion
- 28:03to set aside based upon lack of service. Look
- 28:05at. the line of cases that deal with failure
- 28:09to serve. One being one of mine, Gorham. But
- 28:15you would have to prove that whoever signed that
- 28:19proof of service, unless the judge just forgot
- 28:21to look for it, you would have to prove with
- 28:24your process server that they were served. Right.
- 28:31And then we have another one. Is it worthwhile
- 28:33to attach an ex -spouse calculation of support
- 28:36to the MSA to show what the income tax deductions
- 28:39and filing statuses of the parties were? You
- 28:43can, but one of the things that I would suggest
- 28:46is that rather than using a guideline, I would
- 28:48put, you know, the where you I can't remember.
- 28:53Let me see what it is. It's a user specified
- 28:56spousal support. So put your number in user specified.
- 29:00And you can file it that way. And I have another
- 29:071, any idea why the judicial council removed
- 29:10the Gavin warning from FL. 1, 80 years ago. I
- 29:16don't know why they did that. I think because.
- 29:21They kind of know people don't read those things,
- 29:23and it was such an important issue and a public
- 29:26policy issue to keep people supported that they
- 29:30felt that it had to be. I think. understood by
- 29:37the person who's receiving it, and that means
- 29:39it's in the body of an MSA. One of the things
- 29:42that I thought about is, can an attorney issue
- 29:45a gab run warning? And I actually did look that
- 29:47up. And I think you could, I just don't think
- 29:50it would carry the same weight as the court's
- 29:52admonition. to have another one here, is a Richmond
- 30:01order appropriate in most long -term marriage
- 30:04cases? Specifically, do you have an opinion on
- 30:07what type of cases should utilize a Richmond
- 30:10order? I love Richmond orders because then people
- 30:14knew where they were going. And unless your judge
- 30:18just Doesn't like that. I think they're they're
- 30:21good in all cases, except where you have a person
- 30:24who realistically isn't going to go to work and
- 30:27they don't really have the ability to earn any
- 30:30additional income that probably wouldn't be a
- 30:33good place to use it. But otherwise, I think.
- 30:37It sets expectations for the person who's receiving
- 30:40support that. you know, there's nothing worse
- 30:43than getting to a situation like Shaughnessy
- 30:46where they just get cut off and they really don't
- 30:50know what happened to them. So I think planning
- 30:52for that is a much better idea. All right, and
- 30:59then we have another one here. In my experience,
- 31:01over 90 % of all family law cases are settled
- 31:03and the attorneys involved routinely use DisoMaster,
- 31:06now DisoExpouse, discounted by 10 to 20 % to
- 31:10determine the amount of permanent special support.
- 31:14Okay, then another one. What is considered mandatory
- 31:17retirement for input on the ex -spouse? Mandatory
- 31:21retirement is usually a government -based retirement
- 31:24system because they have to pay into it. The
- 31:28only time I found a civilian that I allowed a
- 31:32mandatory retirement, he was a lawyer at a big
- 31:36law firm and in order to be employed, he had
- 31:39to contribute to this account. So I allowed that
- 31:43as a mandatory deduction, but most of the time
- 31:45it's government employees, state, federal, post
- 31:48office, you know, those type of things. But if
- 31:51it is like the defined benefit plan or the defined
- 31:54contribution plan by an employer that says you
- 31:57must contribute, that is the evidence that I
- 32:00would bring to the court to say, There's no choice
- 32:04here, because that's the issue. If they don't
- 32:06have a choice, it can be mandatory. Right. And
- 32:12then another question here. What was the other
- 32:15case you mentioned after Hofmeister or regarding
- 32:18accurate IDs? Zinki. What I'll do is I'm going
- 32:23to do a list of the cases that I referenced,
- 32:25and I'll provide them with the sites. Can we
- 32:30get that out to them? Yes, we can we can distribute
- 32:34that the I'll put that in the materials link
- 32:37that they have and yours can just refresh it
- 32:40later. Okay. I'll try to get that done tonight.
- 32:44Okay. All right. And then I have another one.
- 32:48If H has W -2 wages and is trying to offset wages
- 32:52by ongoing losses related to, quote, unquote,
- 32:56hobby of farming on his personal time property
- 32:58for past several years, how do you think the
- 33:01court will consider this as it relates to temporary
- 33:04or permanent support? Will they reduce W -2 wages?
- 33:08Well, I hate to answer a question with it depends,
- 33:13but it depends on the judge. It's really, you
- 33:18know, a lot of it depends on whether the, what
- 33:22they're doing has produced income in the past
- 33:24and we're in a drought and they can't produce
- 33:27it now. That would be a very, very fact specific
- 33:31determination for a court. And I think you have
- 33:34a real high evidence burden to show that it's
- 33:38really a hobby. It's really not. any chance of
- 33:41producing income and especially on a, you know,
- 33:45spousal support is probably a little easier climb
- 33:47up that hill, but child support, I think you've
- 33:50got a real uphill battle on that one. Great.
- 34:05Let's see. Any creative ways you have seen for
- 34:08finding cash income? Well, that is probably a
- 34:14really difficult one. But if you can show that,
- 34:20like one of the things I always looked at is
- 34:22they're saying that their expenses are $10 ,000
- 34:25a month. Their income is $1 ,000 a month. They
- 34:28have no credit card debt where they, you know,
- 34:32all their expenses are paid. The argument is
- 34:35it's coming from somewhere. private investigator
- 34:40to set them up on a situation where you create
- 34:44a payment, a large payment of support or a large
- 34:47payment of expenses to them. Like let's say they're
- 34:51running a side business and they say they're
- 34:52not doing it. You go and you have this person,
- 34:56you know, you expend a little bit of money. You
- 34:58haven't pay it, then you submit a request for
- 35:00production, a document saying, give us a list
- 35:02of all the cash payments you've gotten in the
- 35:04last 30 days or 40 days. And when they lie, you
- 35:07have that person come in and testify. Yeah, I
- 35:09paid him $5 ,000. So sometimes it requires a
- 35:13little sneaky work. Ready? And let's see. This
- 35:26one's a little bit longer. I suspect that my
- 35:29client does not have any 4320 findings in his
- 35:34MSA. He's mailing me a copy. I heard that I should
- 35:36get the FL -150s filed near the time of the MSA
- 35:39or at the time and that the court may require
- 35:42a declaration of 4320 factors at the time of
- 35:46the MSA if an RFO is filed. Do you have any other
- 35:50suggestions for an eternally? attorney handling
- 35:53his first post -judgment SS modification, RFO.
- 35:56My client is 82 and seeking to retire. Obtaining
- 36:00his MSA, FL150s, and the tax returns to get his
- 36:04income at the time of marriage and now. Well,
- 36:08you know, the thing about it is everybody's supposed
- 36:10to serve a declaration of disclosure, which necessarily
- 36:13includes the FL150 and two years of tax returns.
- 36:16So One of the things you can preventatively do
- 36:20to set yourself up for a modification is explain
- 36:22to your client how very important it is to hold
- 36:25on to that declaration of disclosure because
- 36:27they're going to need it if they're paying support
- 36:30at a later date. If you don't have one and you
- 36:33can't get one, what I would do is to have my
- 36:37client do a declaration with their information,
- 36:41you know, their tax returns during the marriage.
- 36:44Do a declaration about the 4320s at the time
- 36:47of the judgment and now what the 4320 changes
- 36:51are now. And I think that's probably the best
- 36:54you can do. All right, and let's see. Here's
- 37:04another 1 is it your experience in a long term
- 37:07marriage that temporary support is usually 10
- 37:09to 20 % higher than permanent support so that
- 37:13for efficiency discounting the guideline for
- 37:15settlement purposes is fair. Well, you know,
- 37:20I I've been hearing that a lot lately. Is yeah,
- 37:22everybody's just deducting 20 % from the guideline.
- 37:25That's not the law. The law is the court is supposed
- 37:29to engage in an analysis of all the 4320 factors.
- 37:33If you see a judge consistently being 20 % below
- 37:37guideline, that's an issue. And if you have a
- 37:41spousal support case, you might want to consider.
- 37:46doing something different with your case, you
- 37:48know, getting to mediation, going to private
- 37:51judge or doing something. But no, it's, you know,
- 37:55the bottom line is what are the 4320 factors?
- 37:59You know, getting your client a settlement is
- 38:01gold. I mean, not having to litigate, you have
- 38:04to take into account what it's going to cost
- 38:06you to litigate over the next year and a half.
- 38:09Your fees, the expert fees, the court fees, the
- 38:12frustration and to everything to your client.
- 38:15And if you can settle a case by doing that, by
- 38:18all means, yes. But, you know, still include
- 38:21the 4320 factors so that the judge has some basis
- 38:24to understand where you were at the time. And
- 38:28also, you know, always include the findings in
- 38:30your Your judgment, but any way you can get to
- 38:36settlement is is better than litigation. Right,
- 38:41so it looks like the audience has quite a few
- 38:43more questions. Do we have the time commissioner?
- 38:46I do. Okay, if they do, I do. All right, perfect
- 38:51just wanted to check. All right, so I have a
- 38:53question here. Do you have any input or insight
- 38:56on earlier comment that over 90 %? Oh, I think
- 38:59this might be related to the question. Do you
- 39:02have any input or insight on the earlier comment
- 39:03that 90 % of all family law cases are settled
- 39:06and the attorneys involved routinely used as
- 39:08a master discounted by 10 or 20 % to determine
- 39:10the amount of permanent spousal support? I don't
- 39:15think that's what I said. I said 90 % of INEs
- 39:18are fictitious. I mean, you know, we use tools
- 39:24all the time to try and settle cases. You can
- 39:27do anything you want on a settlement. You're
- 39:29not tied to 4320. You can use a guideline calculator
- 39:34for support, but one of the issues that brings
- 39:37up later on is the court says, was this a temporary
- 39:40or was this a permanent order? That's the issue
- 39:43that that brings up. But anything you can do
- 39:46as a lawyer to solve your client's case, do it
- 39:49because You have to realize a lot of judges are
- 39:54public defenders and district attorneys and they
- 39:57have never had to deal with billing a family
- 40:00law client for their time. So sometimes they
- 40:03don't really understand the attorney fee concept
- 40:07of what it really costs to litigate a case. I'm
- 40:10not. Trying to criticize any judge. Just that's
- 40:13kind of the way it is. And so you have to weigh
- 40:17what it's going to cost you to litigate this
- 40:19case versus what your client can get. I call
- 40:23it the equal distribution of dissatisfaction.
- 40:25If you can get your clients somewhere without
- 40:28having to have them go to trial and pay lawyers
- 40:32fees and all the frustration taking off work
- 40:35and do it because it doesn't matter how you get
- 40:39there. Just get them settled, but like I said,
- 40:42include the 4320 is the best you can. All righty
- 40:50and it looks like. On here, if a pair spouse
- 40:54has unilaterally dismissed their support obligation
- 40:57by not becoming gainfully employed, is it a continued
- 41:00pursuit of imputation of income helpful if there's
- 41:04no change to become gainfully employed prior
- 41:06to trial? Well, you know, the imputation of income,
- 41:12you run into the situations where they've gotten
- 41:16a bifurcated judgment, they're divorced and the
- 41:18other person's remarried, remarried a rich person
- 41:20and they get to stay home with their kids. That's
- 41:23a right case for imputation of income because
- 41:25they're choosing to stay home and they could
- 41:28be imputed income. You know, it's it's never
- 41:32a bad idea to seek an imputation of income. It's
- 41:35just how are you going to convince the court
- 41:37that this person can earn this amount of money?
- 41:41Keep in mind you got LaBass and Muncie and you
- 41:44can use the one ads. But you know, oftentimes
- 41:46I got, you know, 100 pages of one ads and none
- 41:49of them had one amount of income that they could
- 41:52earn. So if you're going to use the LaBass and
- 41:55Muncie formula for your proving an imputed income,
- 41:58make sure your job. contacts have the amount
- 42:01of support that they'd be paid make sure they
- 42:03also have that it meets their ability their professional
- 42:08training their education their experience don't
- 42:12submit job applications that or job contacts
- 42:15that they are not qualified for. So the appropriate
- 42:19way to do that is do a declaration about what
- 42:21the client knows about the past earning history,
- 42:24what they've earned, what they did in their job,
- 42:27what job they would be qualified for, and then
- 42:29produce, you know, job want ads for those types
- 42:33of jobs with the money in it. I have another
- 42:39one. MSOL, time of judgment or time of separation?
- 42:46I think it's time of separation because the marriage,
- 42:50you know, date of separation there, it's over.
- 42:53And what, you know, there's, I think it's Hofmeister
- 42:56that says the person, the supporting spouse is...
- 42:59Earnings after separation are not used for purposes
- 43:04of support, unless you're in a what situation
- 43:07where the person who's receiving support contributed
- 43:09greatly to their earning capacity. But yeah,
- 43:14I definitely think it's time of separation. And
- 43:16one of the things that I think is particularly
- 43:18helpful on that is a person's social security
- 43:20earnings statement. I always ask for those when
- 43:23I'm in mediation, because they're very helpful
- 43:26in determining what, you know, if you're doing
- 43:28a riddle analysis, what were the last five years
- 43:33of income for the parties? What does the marital
- 43:35standard living look like? All right, and let's
- 43:43see here, it says, okay. How do you feel about
- 43:48FL 157 form with the 4320 factors? Is that typically
- 43:54referenced or is it a better use of time to go
- 43:56through them in a declaration where you can tailor
- 43:59to the client and case more closely? Well, you
- 44:03can do both. You could do the 157 and use that
- 44:06for the factors that aren't that relevant or
- 44:09that there's minimal information about. But if
- 44:11you have a factor that's particularly important
- 44:14in your case and you want to expound on it, just
- 44:16say, see attachment, whatever the number is,
- 44:18and attach it. So you can actually do both. I
- 44:21like judicial counsel forms that are there for
- 44:23a reason. The judges are familiar with them.
- 44:25And so they know where to go to look for it.
- 44:28So a combination of the two, I think, is really
- 44:30a good idea. And then I see one here. If someone
- 44:37chooses to retire at 62, not 65 or 67, will the
- 44:42court impute the party with his wages prior to
- 44:45early retirement? It depends on the judge, but
- 44:49the case law. A lot of it depends on if the person
- 44:54retires because they have to, like you got pilots
- 44:58who have to retire at 60. You've got people who
- 45:00work for Ernst Young, they have to retire at
- 45:0260. They have no choice. So the court's not gonna
- 45:05impute their previous wages to them if they retire
- 45:09as they have to under the terms of their employment.
- 45:12If you're on the other end of that, there's an
- 45:15exception. in an Ernst Young contract for them
- 45:19to allow extensions to that. So you may want
- 45:22to take a deposition of somebody at the company
- 45:24saying, can you offer him an extension? Did he
- 45:27turn down an extension? But if you have somebody
- 45:30who just quits their job at 62, the judge can
- 45:33use their income for imputation. But in that
- 45:38situation, one of the things I would really warn
- 45:40my client about is, yes, the judge can impute
- 45:43income to your ex, whoever it is, but that doesn't
- 45:46mean you're gonna get the money. So you can't
- 45:49take that piece of paper that says you get $5
- 45:51,000 a month to the gas and electric company
- 45:53and say, gee, I have a spousal support order
- 45:55for 5 ,000. Could you please take this until
- 45:57I get some of this money? Just doesn't work.
- 46:00They need to be made aware that a piece of paper
- 46:03with a spousal support order on it is really
- 46:05only as good as the person who's willing to pay
- 46:08it. So a little bit of client education goes
- 46:12a long way on those types of situations. All
- 46:19right, and let's see. If an injured spouse gets
- 46:23a family law DV restraining order, do the same
- 46:27presumptions apply regarding spouse with support
- 46:29payable to the abusive spouse by the injured
- 46:31spouse? Well, that's 4320. one of those 4320
- 46:36factors. It's a presumption if it's a misdemeanor
- 46:41conviction. But yeah, DV matters in spousal support.
- 46:47And the arguments are for this person, you know,
- 46:51and the thing about it is we have this DV that's
- 46:55just disturbing the piece. And then we have the
- 46:57DV that's much more serious where there's been
- 47:00broken bones and broken hips and things like
- 47:03that. The arguments need to be tailored to the
- 47:06severity of the DV when you have no conviction,
- 47:10no prior police reports, no prior hospital reports,
- 47:15no, you know, no documented history of DV. You
- 47:18just get a DV restraining order. It's going to
- 47:20it's going to matter, but it's not going to matter
- 47:22as much as some of the, you know, when you have
- 47:24the presumption behind it. All right, and then
- 47:32I have one. Today it seems that people are using
- 47:36Indeed and like web -based job searches. What
- 47:39would be a way to demonstrate this is insufficient
- 47:41or are there cases on this issue? The problem
- 47:45is it's not because hardly anybody's doing in
- 47:48-person interviews and that's one of the problems
- 47:50is that it's really hard to get an in -person
- 47:53interview. So those are really the only things
- 47:56that people can do when they're doing the job
- 47:58contacts for, you know, getting a job. That's
- 48:01really all that's available. But if you could
- 48:05find a job that this person is qualified for,
- 48:09and that employment person is willing to do a
- 48:14interview, then you would have a declaration
- 48:16filed that said they would do an in -person interview.
- 48:20I want him to go do that, him or her to do that.
- 48:31Another one, say right after separation the payer
- 48:33is earning more and can now both parties can
- 48:37live at the MSOL, but as a result permanent support
- 48:41would be higher than temp support. Do you see
- 48:43or make orders like that or do you feel constrained
- 48:45by guideline support? No, I don't. And I never
- 48:51felt constrained by guideline. I always followed
- 48:55what I thought was my obligation to analyze the
- 48:58case from every perspective. But, you know, one
- 49:04of the things, it's a very rare case where both
- 49:09parties are going to be able to live at the marital
- 49:12standard of living. And then, you know, the case
- 49:15law says the permanent order is usually less
- 49:18than the temporary order because the purpose
- 49:21of the temporary is to maintain the status quo.
- 49:24The purpose of the permanent is to go forward.
- 49:27And, you know, the situation is, I think, arguments
- 49:30need to be made regarding the length of marriage.
- 49:32I think this is where the length of marriage
- 49:34really comes in. If you have a 60 year marriage
- 49:37and they're getting a divorce called the gray
- 49:40divorce, I used to just split the income between
- 49:43them because they'd worked all those years, they
- 49:45married all those years, so I would split the
- 49:47income between them. But if, these are all arguments
- 49:53and a lot of it depends on your judges. how they
- 49:58treat spousal support. I know spousal support
- 50:01is not as favorable as it used to be, that's
- 50:04for sure. And it is an abuse of discretion standard,
- 50:11so unless any other judge in the entire state
- 50:14wouldn't make that order on appeal, they're gonna
- 50:17be upheld even if it looks not like a good idea
- 50:20from the outside of the case. Commissioner radical,
- 50:27it looks like we have 1 last question. What if
- 50:30the recipient spouse retires at 62 years? Can
- 50:33the payer spouse seek an imputation of income
- 50:36based upon pre retirement earnings? You mean,
- 50:39if somebody who's getting support. Based on their,
- 50:43their job quits their job. And then seek some
- 50:47an increase in support is that is that the question.
- 50:52Because it would go right back to if somebody
- 50:54quits their job, you can impute their previous
- 50:56wages to them. And set support appropriately.
- 51:00So in a situation where somebody is getting support,
- 51:02they quit their job and then they say, oh, I
- 51:04need more support. I'd say no. Unless there were
- 51:08factors why they had to retire, they got sick
- 51:11or, you know, some reason why they had to retire.
- 51:14That's a legitimate reason why they can no longer
- 51:17work. Does that answer the question? I hope all
- 51:23right. It looks like that's it for for today.
- 51:27Do you have any other closing remarks you'd like
- 51:29to make commissioner? Well, we are doing part
- 51:323 on July 7th. It's spouse support, modification,
- 51:35establishing arrears, documentation, enforcement
- 51:38and remedies. So stay stay tuned and I'll see
- 51:41you again on July 7th. All right, this concludes
- 51:45today's presentation. Thank you so much. Commissioner
- 51:48for joining us. audience. Thank you so much.
- 51:51Have a great night everyone. Thank you.