Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / The Private Life of Henry VIII (1933)
Transcript
- 0:13Hello, everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:16at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:18every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:21I'm Kyle. And I'm Ryan. Which Ryan? The second,
- 0:25third? You know, if I had to think about the
- 0:29number Ryan that I would be, I wouldn't say that
- 0:31I'm first, second, third, or fourth. Oh. But
- 0:35I would say that I'm five, six, seven, eight.
- 0:40And I ate it. Yeah, you did. We have had so much
- 0:43fun this morning alone talking about Henry the
- 0:47Eight, but then doing a little snap like Slay
- 0:51Queen. Yeah. Because he ate that. You did that.
- 0:55You commented. I did the pose. You did the pose.
- 0:59Ashton, I want you to know right now, I crushed
- 1:02it. You make a fist, but then you hold your thumb
- 1:05over your fist. Yes. And you hold it up. Yes.
- 1:08And I crushed that. And I did it. And the reason
- 1:10I do this is because there is a road called,
- 1:14oh, it's Mars Hill Road. Okay. It's Mars Hill
- 1:18Road. And there's a sign that says there's construction
- 1:20happening for the next seven months. So I'm passing
- 1:23it constantly. But they have to abbreviate it
- 1:26because they can't put all those letters in the
- 1:28electronic sign. So it says Mrs. Hill Road. Oh.
- 1:31And every time we pass it, I'm like, it's Mrs.
- 1:33Hill Road. And I throw the fist up with the thumb.
- 1:36And Taylor, this is the funniest thing I've ever
- 1:38done, apparently. It's like she's always like
- 1:40clapping, like do it again. So anyways, I have
- 1:43practiced doing this. Mars Hill Road. Mrs. Hill
- 1:47if you're nasty. Mrs. Hill if you're nasty. Yeah,
- 1:50that's almost exactly what I'm doing. We're talking
- 1:52about the private life. If you couldn't tell.
- 1:55The private life of Henry VIII. I feel like we're,
- 1:58do you feel like we're a little delirious? Not
- 2:00so much in today, but like this is our eighth
- 2:02movie of this month. Of this year, so to speak?
- 2:06I think not. Oh, my God. I didn't even think
- 2:08about that. Because this isn't like, we didn't
- 2:10just choose this order out of nowhere. This is
- 2:12by release. Yeah. So this was God's order. This
- 2:14was God's will. Yeah. Thanks, God. Yeah, man.
- 2:17Appreciate you. You ate that. Private Life of
- 2:19Henry VIII. You've never seen this before? No.
- 2:21Have you seen a Charles Lawton picture before?
- 2:24No. I don't think I have either. So this is the
- 2:26first time for me, too. Yeah. Yeah, I didn't
- 2:28even know who he was. Neither did I. My understanding
- 2:30is it's put him on the map pretty well. Sweet.
- 2:32And what we're talking about is Charles Lawton,
- 2:34the lead actor of this film who portrays Henry
- 2:37VIII. And I mention him because he is one of
- 2:40two nominations for this film. The second nomination,
- 2:43you're not going to believe this, is Best Picture,
- 2:45Outstanding Production. And that is on behalf
- 2:48of London Films. Previously mentioned, Charles
- 2:51Lawton was nominated for Best Actor in a Leading
- 2:53Role for his role of Henry VIII. London Films,
- 2:57huh? It's interesting. I had to do a double check
- 3:01on this to make sure that was correct. That's
- 3:03what I have. And they put them on the map pretty
- 3:05heavily. This is the first... International film
- 3:09nominated for Outstanding Picture, I think. Not
- 3:11only is it the first non -U .S. film to be nominated
- 3:13for Best Picture, it is also the first time that
- 3:15a lead actor has been nominated for a non -U
- 3:17.S. film. Wow. Yeah. This is a big deal, then.
- 3:20Yeah. Agreed, man. Yeah, totally. No, it is.
- 3:24It is a big deal. The movie is a big deal, too.
- 3:27I feel like it's our first, not first, but it's
- 3:29a very notable period piece that we don't get
- 3:33a ton of. Yeah, that's true. Yeah. And this is
- 3:36going to happen time and time again. So I wonder
- 3:39if the reception received for Charles Lawton
- 3:41in this film is part of the reason for that.
- 3:44But a period piece like this is not something
- 3:46we've seen often in what we've talked about,
- 3:48but will be prominent in the future. Yeah. It's
- 3:51funny. I don't normally think of like this doesn't
- 3:54stand out as, oh, a unique period piece because
- 3:56everything takes place like 100 years ago. Right.
- 3:59So I'm just like, they're all period pieces now.
- 4:01But you're right. Yeah. This is, you know, of
- 4:04course. in like the 1500s following Henry VIII.
- 4:09So yeah. Let's dive into that. I was just about
- 4:12to start talking about the movie and I realized
- 4:13we haven't talked about the cast yet. So let's
- 4:14talk about the cast. Directed by Alexander Korda.
- 4:18Like you said, stars Charles Lawton as Henry
- 4:20VIII. Beanie Barnes is probably the most prominent
- 4:23female lead in the movie. I agree. She plays
- 4:26Catherine Howard. And then you have Robert Donnett
- 4:29as Thomas Culpepper. So Henry VIII has historically
- 4:34at least six wives right he might have more beyond
- 4:37this movie but in this he's got six wives so
- 4:41you've got quite a few women here portraying
- 4:44all of his wives and i figure rather than list
- 4:46them we'll talk about them as they come up as
- 4:48they come up i think it's the best way to do
- 4:49it uh the first thing i want to talk about is
- 4:52the opening to this movie and the opening is
- 4:54a title card uh title card that tells us everything
- 4:57that's happened i i think it's interesting when
- 4:59you think about henry the eighth the first thing
- 5:02you think about is the multiple wives right yeah
- 5:05and you think about well i wonder how it's going
- 5:08to portray like you know him going into like
- 5:11this uh royalty and then his first wife and then
- 5:14how that leads to the other wives and the opening
- 5:16card is like the first marriage didn't work out
- 5:18and you're like oh okay so it already establishes
- 5:22that there has been a wife and now there's a
- 5:24second wife and also worth noting the the cast
- 5:28card that pulls up, it says the names of the
- 5:32women, but it also labels them as the number
- 5:34wife that they are. Do you notice that? Yeah.
- 5:36So first wife, second wife, fifth wife. So Catherine
- 5:39Howard is listed as the fifth wife. Anne Boleyn,
- 5:42played by Merle Oberon, is portrayed as a second
- 5:45wife. So this just continues. But the first wife
- 5:48that we actually meet is Anne Boleyn. Right.
- 5:51Who is extremely well known to the story. Absolutely.
- 5:53Extremely prominent. And, you know, I think that
- 5:56Like you said, when you think of Henry VIII,
- 5:57you think of the wives. And this is kind of portraying
- 6:00that element of his life kind of as a comedy.
- 6:04Sure. That's the intention. Whether it is comical
- 6:08or not, like, that's what this movie's going
- 6:10for. It kind of takes the man, Henry VIII, and
- 6:14it makes you want to roll your eyes at his character
- 6:18a lot. Correct. And it's successful in that sense.
- 6:21Yes. I think I'm sensing... a little bit of displeasure
- 6:27in the movie. But I think that comes from us
- 6:30just watching his behavior in this movie and
- 6:32being like, yeah, it might be trying to be funny,
- 6:36but what are we doing here? Sure. I mean, if
- 6:40it's intended to be a satire, then I kind of
- 6:42understand. But the tone of it, we just got done
- 6:45talking about 42nd Street and how it can kind
- 6:48of misread the tone a little bit with that final
- 6:50scene with Julian Marsh. And I think this is
- 6:52a similar potential issue for me, is that the
- 6:56tone of the movie doesn't seem to match the tone
- 6:58of the performance for Charles Lawton. I have
- 7:02some questions about that, and we'll get into
- 7:03it. But ultimately, when it comes to the synopsis
- 7:06of the movie, you're right. The ultimate story
- 7:08is, starting with Anne Boleyn, his relationship
- 7:12with women, and how that lends him to his relationship
- 7:15with Catherine Howard. Right. Yeah. And, I mean,
- 7:19we can get into it now. When we're introduced
- 7:21to Anne Boleyn, and really the opening of this
- 7:23movie, it's the day of Anne Boleyn's execution.
- 7:26The moment the satire becomes kind of a little
- 7:30clear, at least what it's trying to convey, is
- 7:32that title card where it mentions that the first
- 7:34marriage didn't work out. Yes. And it was an
- 7:36amicable split where there was a divorce. And
- 7:38so the second marriage was not quite so. Right.
- 7:41And it says the first marriage was to Catherine
- 7:43of Aragorn. And it says it didn't work out. She
- 7:46was a respectable woman. Yes. And that's why
- 7:49it didn't work out. So yeah, with Anne Boleyn,
- 7:52it's the day of her execution. And we'll talk
- 7:56about Charles Lawton a lot because he is, without
- 7:59a doubt, the powerhouse of the film. But I do
- 8:02want to talk about Merle Oberyn playing Anne
- 8:04Boleyn because she broke my heart in this movie.
- 8:08I mean, I'm not sure that I wrote it down here,
- 8:10but when I was doing my research, it was noted
- 8:12that a lot of people were watching her performance
- 8:15on set and were just like, blown away by uh i
- 8:20think one director said not the director of the
- 8:22film but one director said that like that was
- 8:25the fastest they've ever seen like themselves
- 8:27connecting to a person or a character because
- 8:30of her performance she is great in the movie
- 8:32she's so good and i think it it kind of builds
- 8:35a problem in viewing the movie at first because
- 8:39you're hit with that zinger of katherine was
- 8:41a respectable woman and then anne boleyn then
- 8:45she shows up and she's like i'm i'm I'll be okay,
- 8:48right? And she has tears in her eyes. She says
- 8:51something about, like, it's a shame that such
- 8:52a pretty neck is going to have a rope around
- 8:54it. Yeah, such a pretty head is going to, I don't
- 8:58know, be removed from their body. It's really
- 9:00sad. Right. But she's asking the executioner
- 9:03at one point, like, is it going to hurt? And
- 9:06he's like, no, no, no. It's clean. It's quick.
- 9:08You won't feel a thing. And she says, and I have
- 9:12such a little neck, haven't I? And you're like,
- 9:15oh, my God. please because the expectation here
- 9:20and they don't really don't show much obviously
- 9:22is uh the beheading right multiple beheadings
- 9:25and i mean it's devastating like and this to
- 9:29me i think is like where the tone of the movie
- 9:31kind of like shifts drastically is that it doesn't
- 9:34feel like quite a satire. That opening card does.
- 9:37But then you getting to spend that time with
- 9:39Anne Boleyn and hearing everything she's saying,
- 9:41at no point is she being, it sounds like she's
- 9:43kind of being jokey about it, but it's never
- 9:45like a, ha ha, right, because I'm being beheaded.
- 9:48It's more like, can you believe this is something
- 9:50that's actually going to happen to me? This is
- 9:52terrible. And then Charles Lawton appears, and
- 9:55then it's all, assumingly, humorous satire of
- 10:01his performance. Right. And it just feels like
- 10:03mismatched to me, and I couldn't get into it.
- 10:05So it's hard to read this movie up front. And
- 10:08I don't mean that as a negative against Merle
- 10:10Oberon, because she is phenomenal. She's so good.
- 10:12She's so good. And I think Charles Lawton is
- 10:14even doing a good job for what he's doing, but
- 10:16we'll get to him in a minute. But she's so effective.
- 10:18Yeah. And I loved her scenes, even though they
- 10:20were really front -loaded in this. But she's
- 10:23a character, obviously, that is very prominent,
- 10:25but will be talked about through the rest of
- 10:27the story as well. Yeah. Man, and right off the
- 10:30bat, because she... she she's gone so soon i
- 10:33i just felt like the the meme of that cat like
- 10:36reaching out like no come back because she's
- 10:39so good and i really loved her she is but and
- 10:42that leads us to the introduction of charles
- 10:45lawton as henry the eighth man it takes a minute
- 10:48it's like 20 minutes or so yeah it shows up it's
- 10:51a little while and it's it's kind of similar
- 10:52to the way she done him wrong introduced may
- 10:55west where everybody's kind of chittering about
- 10:58Okay. This big person. You probably just got
- 11:00me to like Private Life of Henry VIII because
- 11:02now I'm just imagining him coming down the stairwell
- 11:04being like, come up and see me sometime. Man.
- 11:08But yeah, his introduction is kind of like that,
- 11:11where all of the handmaidens are in his bedroom
- 11:15and they're talking like, oh, well, Anne Boland's
- 11:18losing her head today. And Jane Seymour is next
- 11:21in line, who's played by Wendy Berry. And they're
- 11:24all kind of just poking fun at the king. And
- 11:28during this chit chat they're having, Charles
- 11:33Lawton, you just hear his voice boom from the
- 11:35other room. And he's like, what's going on? What
- 11:38are you saying? And the camera turns and you
- 11:40just see him like just like Mae West, really
- 11:42standing full center frame in like his regal
- 11:46attire. And he's like. just a domineering figure.
- 11:50He's a domineering presence in this for sure.
- 11:53Although that shot that you're talking about,
- 11:55I completely agree in the effectiveness of it.
- 11:56However, it did make me think of Revenge of the
- 11:59Sith with Obi -Wan and the way that Ewan McGregor
- 12:01is standing on the ship. They're like, Obi -Wan
- 12:04isn't going to harm you. And it cuts to him very
- 12:06intimidatingly standing on the doorway. It did
- 12:08look a little bit like that when they introduced
- 12:10Charles Lawton in this. So I thought that was
- 12:12very funny. I immediately was just like... He
- 12:15doesn't mean good for any of these people here.
- 12:16Yeah, so Charles Lawton, obviously nominated
- 12:19for lead actor for his role here. He is going
- 12:22for it. Yes. Fully going for it in this. And
- 12:25he's leaning into the horrible nature of this
- 12:29individual and playing him appropriately so.
- 12:32There's a scene I kind of want to jump to before
- 12:34we get much into the story of it. There's a banquet
- 12:38scene. You know what I'm talking about? Oh, yeah.
- 12:40His banquet scene where he's eating. Where he's
- 12:42eating with like a... his bare hands he's eating
- 12:44a rotisserie chicken yeah obviously this is meant
- 12:48to disgruntle or not disgruntle but meant to
- 12:50disturb you and like kind of like catch you off
- 12:52guard and it's interesting because there's a
- 12:54couple things behind this one did you catch this
- 12:57is the first audible belch or burp on screen
- 13:01uh grand hotel had what's his name kenick kren
- 13:06krenlich Kringlin. Yeah. Kraglin from Guardians
- 13:10of the Galaxy. Wasn't that more of a hiccup?
- 13:12I didn't think it was like a full blown belch
- 13:14like this one, like while he's eating. No, no.
- 13:16Yeah, he goes off. Oh, interesting. In Grand
- 13:18Hotel. Well, I'd read this was like one of the
- 13:20first like sighted examples of that happening,
- 13:23where it was like the decency board gave this
- 13:26movie a C. Oh, really? But the C is like, not
- 13:30like, hey, middle of the road. It's more like.
- 13:32I'm trying to think of what the word was for
- 13:34it, but C was like canceled, basically, of like
- 13:36terrible, like absolutely no decency in this.
- 13:39So the belch was a big part of that. Maybe in
- 13:42the UK. There you go. Maybe that's what it was.
- 13:45That might be what it is. In the US, we're like,
- 13:46we've been belching. Yeah. Get back on board.
- 13:49But the other side of this, too, is that in my
- 13:51research, I saw that after this movie came out,
- 13:53years after this movie came out, whenever Charles
- 13:57Lawton would go to a restaurant, Restaurant owners
- 14:00would give him a free roasted chicken, but not
- 14:03bring any utensils out. So the expectation was
- 14:06that he would eat the roasted chicken or the
- 14:08rotisserie chicken without any utensils. I gotta
- 14:11imagine if you're Charles Lawton, you're like,
- 14:13funny joke, give me a fork. Yeah. Like, I'm not
- 14:16just gonna do this for you. Well, let me ask
- 14:18you this, Ryan. Yeah. You show up to any restaurant,
- 14:21you get a free chicken. Which, rotisserie chicken,
- 14:24so an entire chicken. Right. Not just like a
- 14:26leg. I mean, at what point do you think you'd
- 14:29be like, all right, I'm getting tired of this?
- 14:31Or would you just be like, well, I got dinner
- 14:33for the week. Taylor loves a rotisserie chicken.
- 14:36So I think she would be like, this is the best
- 14:39thing that you've ever, you're famous. All you
- 14:41got to do is pull off a drumstick and be like,
- 14:42no, yes, you're so funny. Which you eat a drumstick
- 14:46with your hands anyway. Right. But the problem.
- 14:48You just take the rest to go. To go back. And
- 14:51Taylor's good. That's right. However, I don't
- 14:54know if she would love that the implication of
- 14:55me getting this rotisserie chicken is that I
- 14:57played a character and I'm now portraying that
- 14:59same character, calling back that same character
- 15:02who has his wives beheaded. It's a free chicken,
- 15:05Ryan. You're doing the Tim Heidecker, it's free
- 15:09real estate. It's free chicken. Yeah, I'm sure
- 15:11she'll agree with you. Absolutely zero issue.
- 15:13Hi, babe. So, I mean, clearly some memorable
- 15:15things done for this role. Sure. I guess it's
- 15:18a good time to go and say, I did not care for
- 15:20this movie. I did not care for this overall.
- 15:23It was a difficult movie for me to grab onto,
- 15:25and it is a performance -led movie. This movie
- 15:28is the performance of Charles Lawton as Henry
- 15:31VIII. I think my problem is that it feels like
- 15:35the movie wasn't quite confident in what it was
- 15:38trying to say versus what Charles Lawton was
- 15:40trying to do. And it felt more like we captured
- 15:43this performance on screen and less what the
- 15:45movie was trying to say. So. The majority of
- 15:48the movie is that we see the inner workings of
- 15:51Henry VIII navigating marriages. Yeah. Who he
- 15:55wants to be married to, who can challenge him,
- 15:58how much he wants to be challenged if he doesn't
- 16:01really want to be challenged, and how he wants
- 16:04to rule. And even ruling kind of comes secondary
- 16:06in story and to his character. It's mostly just
- 16:09like who his companion is at the time. Yeah.
- 16:12And the person that's always on his mind throughout
- 16:14the movie is Catherine. Right. Catherine is someone
- 16:17that he sees. However, she has a relationship
- 16:20with Thomas Culpepper, who you mentioned was
- 16:22portrayed by Robert Donat. Yeah. Yeah. So this
- 16:28is kind of the majority of the movie. The only
- 16:30thing that to me was like, oh, now we're cooking,
- 16:33is at one point he finds himself in a relationship
- 16:36with Anne of Cleves. Cleves? I think Cleves.
- 16:39Yeah, I think it's Cleves. Anne of Cleves, who
- 16:42was his fourth wife. Right. With Jane Seymour.
- 16:46Oh, what happened with them? I don't even remember
- 16:48what happened to Jane. Jane was kind of brought
- 16:51over and he was like, oh, cool. Well, I don't
- 16:54think this is going to work out. I don't think
- 16:56there's any infidelity. No, no, no. Oh, it did
- 16:59happen with her. Yeah, I really don't remember.
- 17:02I think they just split. They had like a divorce.
- 17:06That's right, because there's two divorces technically
- 17:08in this that we see. The first one we don't,
- 17:11we just hear about. It was Catherine. That was
- 17:13Jane Seymour's character, and then Anne of Cleves.
- 17:16So Anne of Cleves is played by Elsa Lanchester.
- 17:20Yeah, she is. Let's talk about this. So with
- 17:23Elsa Lanchester, she actually was married to
- 17:26Charles Lawton. In 1929 is when they got married.
- 17:30And they were together for a very long time.
- 17:33So in this movie, they've been married for four
- 17:35years already. Yeah. The actors have. Their chemistry
- 17:39was explosive. And it's not like your typical
- 17:44romantic chemistry. Where you're like, oh, I
- 17:46can see these two people together. They were
- 17:48destined to not work out. But their chemistry
- 17:50is still so good because he wants to be challenged.
- 17:54But she wants to find the way to which she can
- 17:57get out of this marriage very quickly and have
- 17:58some money. Right? Exactly. So she's playing
- 18:01him a little bit, almost literally, in the way
- 18:04that they play cards. The moment that I think
- 18:06the movie kind of understands the performance
- 18:09of Charles Lawton the most is in the scenes that
- 18:12he has with Elsa Lanchester in the bedroom. Not
- 18:15like that. Calm down. Where they're playing cards.
- 18:18Well, that's the thing. It starts like that,
- 18:20where he comes in. After they're married and
- 18:22he's like, listen, you seem a little ditzy. Yep.
- 18:27I just want to make sure you're aware of, like,
- 18:30what we're doing here. I do want a son. And she's
- 18:33like, yeah, no problem. Stork will show up and
- 18:35we're good, right? And he's like, listen. This
- 18:40reminded me a lot of, was it The Smiling Lieutenant?
- 18:43Where she's like, you know, we could, you know.
- 18:46He's like, I don't follow. And it was like two
- 18:48minutes straight of just her being like trying
- 18:50to find the word sex. Yes. Yeah. That reminded
- 18:52me a lot of that too. It's the cards that really
- 18:55are interesting for me because the way that they
- 18:58play this is she is sharking him. Yeah. Right.
- 19:00She's so good at cards. He thinks he's the best.
- 19:03And then he has that whole like scene where he's
- 19:05screaming to his assistants to bring in more
- 19:08money, like bring more money. You bring it to
- 19:10me because I'm going to win this game. And this
- 19:12is where we start seeing the dynamics between
- 19:13them really shift where she's playing him and
- 19:15he thinks he's playing her. And ultimately, instead
- 19:18of like her getting one over on him, she ultimately
- 19:20gets what she wants, but she gives him what he
- 19:22wants to, which is freedom. Right. To like then
- 19:26marry Catherine instead. And that's the thing,
- 19:28too, is like she forces him to not want her.
- 19:32Yes. Because she does. She like makes herself
- 19:34look, quote unquote, ugly. And she starts acting
- 19:36just absurd, really, so that she can. She approaches
- 19:41him beautiful and, you know, attractive and all
- 19:44of this so that he will marry her. And then once
- 19:46they're married, she's like, hey, now, you know,
- 19:49the real me. And that whole bit she does is so
- 19:53funny when she first walks out into that bedroom
- 19:55scene and she kind of slinks out all really creepy.
- 19:59Like, yeah, from that moment, I was like, oh,
- 20:02I love Elsa Lanchester. She's so good in this.
- 20:04And there's a couple of things I'm getting ahead
- 20:06of myself. There's a couple of things that I
- 20:08think do paint the picture of what this movie
- 20:11ultimately wants itself to be. And that's the
- 20:13satire that you talked about. This is obviously
- 20:15a big part of that. The other is leading up to
- 20:18the scene in their marriage, Henry VIII has been
- 20:22seeing Catherine on the side. Right. Whether
- 20:24it be romantically or not, he's been going to
- 20:26her bedroom and like talking to her. And there's
- 20:28a scene where he like sneaks into her room. Sorry,
- 20:32sneaks into her room. And he gets there and she's
- 20:36like, what are you doing here? And he says, no
- 20:37one saw me, I swear. And the camera cuts to outside
- 20:41of the room with like, 10 guards just like staring
- 20:44at the door and i laughed so hard at the cut
- 20:48of this and that's when i was like oh cool the
- 20:51movie's like finally understanding what it wants
- 20:53what it needs to be right and i loved that scene
- 20:56and i was kind of expecting more of that there's
- 20:58not a ton but that stood out and i was like wow
- 21:01i love that cut because it wasn't just like what
- 21:03a funny cut that they didn't intend that was
- 21:05a hundred percent intentional right and also
- 21:07that man did not sneak in there because he's
- 21:09walking past all of his guards Who, by the way,
- 21:12this is the other part that I think they get
- 21:14right, showed that it almost felt very Doctor
- 21:17Strangelove, like kind of a commentary on the
- 21:19ludicrous nature of his importance. Right. Of
- 21:23whenever they would communicate that something
- 21:26was happening, one guard would shout it. So another
- 21:28one that's two rooms away can shout it again.
- 21:31So another guard who's two rooms past that can
- 21:33shout it again. And just so on and so forth.
- 21:35And that leads itself to the people that he passes
- 21:38on the way to Catherine's room. When he's like,
- 21:40don't you dare announce anyone that I'm here.
- 21:42And he sneaks in. I'm like, yeah, but they all
- 21:44saw you. Whether they announced it or not, there
- 21:46are at least four guards who have seen you. And
- 21:48now 10 of them are standing outside of her room
- 21:49just looking at your door. So funny. Thought
- 21:51that was a great cut. And I enjoyed that a good
- 21:54bit. The relationship and the connection, chemistry
- 21:56is the word I'm looking for, between Elsa Lanchester
- 21:59and Charles Lawton was so dynamic. And I was
- 22:02like, wow. This is incredible, and I love seeing
- 22:04this. It's also kind of a nice middle finger
- 22:07to the idea of what the, not production code,
- 22:11but the MPPDA at the time was kind of allowing
- 22:14when it comes to couples in bedrooms. Yeah. In
- 22:17that they are married as characters, but at the
- 22:20same time, these actors are married to each other.
- 22:24right so it's interesting to be like well you
- 22:25can't really show them like in the same bed or
- 22:27anything and the bed that we're talking about
- 22:29is like them sitting on the bed playing cards
- 22:31with each other so it's not like a scandalous
- 22:33in any way sure but it's such a nice like interesting
- 22:36thing that i'm sure wasn't intentional but it's
- 22:38kind of funny how it worked out of the reason
- 22:41you don't do this is because you don't want to
- 22:42show like unmarried people well not only are
- 22:44the characters married but so are the actors
- 22:46yeah nice touch the only downside of this is
- 22:49that that comes about maybe 60 of the movie And
- 22:53then shortly after that, the arrangement that
- 22:55they make is for her to go away. Yeah, they get
- 22:58divorced. And there's that great moment, too,
- 23:00where he's like, what if I just behead you? And
- 23:04she's like, you won't do that because I'll start
- 23:06drama. And he's like, fair play. Yeah, good call.
- 23:09Divorce. And it's funny because it seems like
- 23:14he isn't willing to budge for anyone or anything.
- 23:17And then he's like, all right, fine. What are
- 23:19your terms? She's like, it's very light. I need
- 23:22these six things. And he's like, done, done,
- 23:24done, done. And it's not small stuff either.
- 23:27It's like, I need this much money as a retainer.
- 23:30And he's like, done. I need my own castle, essentially.
- 23:33He's like, yeah, of course, done. And it's just
- 23:38immediately, you get everything you want. And
- 23:40then she just bounces. She does. She just takes
- 23:43off. And then that clears everything in his path
- 23:46for Catherine, which in his eyes, he has been
- 23:49interested in the marriages. But Catherine is
- 23:51the one. Right. So he has been chasing her this
- 23:54whole time. The difficulty here is that she has
- 23:57also established a relationship with Thomas Culpepper.
- 24:01Exactly. Even actually before this. But Thomas,
- 24:03I guess this is a detail we haven't gone over
- 24:05just yet, is essentially the right -hand man
- 24:07to Henry VIII. Yeah, this is scandalous. Yes,
- 24:11very much so. And also kind of uninteresting.
- 24:14I agree with you. Yeah, I... Anytime I was watching
- 24:17Catherine, who was played again by Benny Barnes
- 24:20and Thomas Culpepper, anytime they were together,
- 24:25I just did not care. And that goes to show how
- 24:28important Charles Lawton's performance is to
- 24:30any type of success from this movie. They're
- 24:33so dull. They're so boring. I didn't think they
- 24:35had any chemistry, and I just wanted more Charles.
- 24:38Or Elsa. Yeah, agreed. And I think that's the
- 24:41problem is that the chemistry is so good between
- 24:43Charles and Elsa. But that wasn't the focus.
- 24:46Yeah. And I feel like they could have made that
- 24:48more of the focus because they do have lightning
- 24:50in a bottle. But again, that's something that
- 24:52happens on screen and not when you're writing
- 24:53the screenplay. Right. I get that. But it makes
- 24:56the movie less interesting because I mean, and
- 24:59as good as Benny Barnes is as Catherine, it just
- 25:03you can't match the chemistry that he has with
- 25:05Elsa in the terms of like the woman he can't
- 25:07tame. Yeah. Which is ultimately the more interesting
- 25:10story for him than just look how difficult it
- 25:12was for you to keep a woman because you were.
- 25:14not that appealing and there's more men around
- 25:16you that were more appealing yeah and it's not
- 25:18something that like you can be mad at the screenplay
- 25:21for because this is historical you didn't end
- 25:23up with Anne of Cleves sure totally you can't
- 25:25change the story yeah totally heard it's just
- 25:28how it kind of happens it's just a bummer it's
- 25:31like man I wish you would have stayed with Anne
- 25:32well you know ultimately it's like you're right
- 25:34you can't change the history of things and you
- 25:35can't change the story of who it's about but
- 25:38you can add flourishes of like okay well hey
- 25:40this isn't really working what can we do about
- 25:41this yeah but that's when you have time And some
- 25:44of these movies, you know, we talk about how
- 25:45often people are starring in like, hey, how many
- 25:48movies did you star in in this one year? Oh,
- 25:5020? Yeah. Like you just, you're in a ton of movies
- 25:52because these things move quickly. Yes. So you
- 25:55don't have the time to kind of be like, hey,
- 25:56this isn't working. What can we do to change
- 25:57that? And I get that. Now we have a little bit
- 26:00more time of like, hey, give us a little bit
- 26:01more time in this. Let's be more strategic about
- 26:03this and have like, you know, well, instead let's
- 26:06do the camera angle this way or let's introduce
- 26:07this character that makes this feel this way.
- 26:09This just kind of suffers as a result of that.
- 26:12Yeah. One thing I want to bring up is we skipped
- 26:16over. You talked about Wendy Berry and she played
- 26:18his second wife. Third wife. Third wife. Sorry.
- 26:21Yeah. Not Anne Boleyn. Played his third wife.
- 26:23And I think about this. Did you read about this?
- 26:26What happened on set? No. Wonderful. So Charles
- 26:31Lawton was a bit of a method actor, which I wonder
- 26:34how that affected with his scenes with his real
- 26:36life partner, Elsa Lanchester. Yeah. Or his consumption
- 26:39of chickens. Correct. I mean, well, we'll see
- 26:42if he's method afterwards at the restaurant.
- 26:44Yeah. A lot of restaurant owners beheaded. So
- 26:47he was method on set. And there's a moment with
- 26:50Wendy Berry where she was like giggling during
- 26:53a scene. And I'm not clear if she was supposed
- 26:56to giggle or maybe she was giggling at a line
- 26:59that he said and that was not scripted. He wasn't
- 27:01happy with this. And he actually bit her on the
- 27:04arm. What? Yeah. He bit Wendy Berry on the arm.
- 27:08And because he had cited that she aggravated
- 27:10him. And the reason he did this is that Henry
- 27:12VIII actually did this with his wives, where
- 27:14he would, like, bite them on the arm to kind
- 27:16of, like, you know, almost like when you, I mean,
- 27:19this is not the proper analogy you should be
- 27:21making, but, like, when you're trying to scold
- 27:23someone or, like, scold the dog with, like, a
- 27:25newspaper, I think that's how Henry VIII saw
- 27:27it, is like, oh, don't do that again, bite you
- 27:29on the arm. Or, like, slap on the hand, right?
- 27:31Yeah. Something terrible. So in his method sense,
- 27:35he thought, why don't I continue that? And bit
- 27:37her on the arm. Can't say that's a good look.
- 27:39Can't say I like that. Yeah. Yeah, I'm not loving
- 27:42that. Pretty bad. I did not know that. Yeah,
- 27:45that was something that was cited. And it was
- 27:47something that was caught by Benny Barnes, I
- 27:50think, reported that. So they're just like, yeah,
- 27:52that happened. Terrible thing. How come every
- 27:55time one of these guys gets nominated for this...
- 27:59you know, huge achievement, they're doing something
- 28:02weird. They're shooting dogs or they're firing.
- 28:04Fake shooting dogs. You're right. How could I
- 28:08mislead the public with false information? It's
- 28:12only 1 % better, but it is better. What are we
- 28:17doing? I would argue that the reason that this
- 28:19continues to happen is that we continue to award
- 28:21it. Yeah, that's a good point. Right? That's
- 28:24fair. Both times that that's happened with directors,
- 28:26they won Best Director of that movie. I like
- 28:29Charles Lawton in this, and now I feel like I
- 28:31can't, which, you know, whatever. He might have
- 28:34felt bad about it. I'm not going to say he was
- 28:36like, I hope he did. Yeah. He's not the one who
- 28:38reported this. He's like, yeah, I bit her on
- 28:39the arm. At this point, when I got my free chicken,
- 28:42I'd start biting the waiter's arms just to keep
- 28:45up and be like, look, it wasn't anything personal.
- 28:47Well, that's the way that you determine that
- 28:49it never happens again. Right? Yeah. This is
- 28:51my 10th rotisserie chicken of the week. I'm going
- 28:53to bite this guy in the arm so I never get another
- 28:55rotisserie chicken. They start throwing the chickens
- 28:56into the room and they're like, good luck, Charles.
- 28:59I got to tell you, that is a funny joke. And
- 29:01I don't know if I cited this earlier. That's
- 29:03why the restaurant owners did it is they thought
- 29:05it was a very funny joke that like they could
- 29:06keep doing this. That's a very expensive joke.
- 29:09It is. I also love the idea of him going to like.
- 29:12a Wendy's and then being like, somebody run to
- 29:15Costco. Exactly. I need you to run to Costco
- 29:18right now and pick up a rotisserie chicken. It's
- 29:20Dave Thomas. He's like, no, no, he's back. He's
- 29:24like, look, my daughter, Wendy, if you run and
- 29:27go do this, I'll name the chain after you. Yeah.
- 29:30She's like, done. Pigtails flying in the wind.
- 29:32Good bit of lore. Look at us. I also kind of
- 29:34want to do a little behind the scenes before
- 29:35we talk about the rest of it. So this is not
- 29:38the last time that Charles Lawton reprises the
- 29:41role. of henry the eighth oh yeah he also did
- 29:44this in young bess in 1953 kind of a nice touch
- 29:48it's not like a sequel to this it's just kind
- 29:49of reprising the character yeah uh but we talk
- 29:52a lot about like these movies where there are
- 29:54radio broadcasts done of it like you know 10
- 29:5715 years later and the cast at least some of
- 29:59them comes back and reprises the role this is
- 30:02one of the only times i think where we've seen
- 30:03a character reprised on screen by the same actor
- 30:06yeah let alone one notable like this yeah and
- 30:09really the only time you ever see that in general
- 30:12are for sequels true like i who is it it's like
- 30:16michael keaton was in jackie brown and then he
- 30:20comes back in another role playing the same character
- 30:23but like it's it's a different studio it's a
- 30:24different director and i can't remember what
- 30:26that is but like those are the weird moments
- 30:28of like almost like crossovers sure Interesting.
- 30:32Yeah. Yeah. You don't see this happen a ton.
- 30:35This is also one of the first times this has
- 30:37happened, obviously. Yeah. But kind of cool to
- 30:39see that it did a character in a role like this
- 30:42that is that, I guess, iconic. Sure. Is the best
- 30:46way to put it. Iconic makes it sound like, you
- 30:48know, Slay. But I don't mean it that way. He
- 30:53ate. I mean, Henry the Eight. It's more just
- 30:57the import of that character in that performance.
- 31:01Right. So it's interesting to see that reprise
- 31:03that way. The other thing that I want to note
- 31:05here is that we talked about how this is a British
- 31:06film. This is London film specifically that did
- 31:09it. British cast. This was kind of a smoke. What's
- 31:14the word I'm looking for? Smoke signal. This
- 31:16was kind of a sign to Hollywood that there is
- 31:18like an excess of British talent. So this is
- 31:22one of the key factors in this awareness and
- 31:26exodus of talent from UK. to Hollywood. So they
- 31:30actually brought a lot of UK talent into Hollywood
- 31:32specifically because of this movie, because it
- 31:35did serve as an awareness of how much talent
- 31:38there was overseas. Now, Charles Lawton is a
- 31:41big part of that, but I'm sure the chemistry
- 31:42of Elsa Lanchester as well, and certainly the
- 31:45performances that we talked about, Meryl Oberon,
- 31:48who portrayed Anne Boleyn, she's incredible.
- 31:52Yeah, I mean, she's so effective. And Benny Barnes
- 31:55as Catherine Howard. She's a lot of the emotional
- 31:57grounding. Of the movie. She is. And, like, she
- 32:00has a moment where she sings for the king. You
- 32:03know, she actually has a musical number. And
- 32:05it is, it's a good song. She sounds great. So,
- 32:07yeah, I mean, she's kind of supposed to represent,
- 32:10like, the ultimate beauty and the ultimate love
- 32:13for the king. And they do a good job at, like,
- 32:16showcasing her as this very desirable woman.
- 32:19Especially when she shows up after Elsa Lanchester,
- 32:23who's just being so... She's so silly goofy.
- 32:27That's what I wrote in my review. I'm like, shout
- 32:29out to Elsa just being a silly goofy girl. Yeah.
- 32:32And she does do a great job of that. I enjoyed
- 32:35her performance a lot. To me, it feels kind of
- 32:38like when you have like a Looney Tunes intermission.
- 32:39Yeah. When it's like, oh, I had a lot of fun
- 32:42in between this movie with a cartoon. And Elsa
- 32:44Lanchester is that cartoon. Absolutely. And then
- 32:47we get back to the high drama. Yes. We should
- 32:50call out, too, for anyone who doesn't know Elsa
- 32:53Lanchester. She is eventually the bride of Frankenstein.
- 32:57So if you watch this and you recognize her face
- 33:00a little bit, she'll be screaming in about two
- 33:02years. Wow, I never picked up that she was the
- 33:06bride of Frankenstein. Really? I mean, the name
- 33:08sounds so familiar, so that makes sense. Yeah.
- 33:09But no, I never picked that up. Well, there you
- 33:11go. And that's a good example. I know Charles
- 33:13Lawton was like, you gotta make me Frankenstein's
- 33:15monster. Already did, bud. Already did. But yeah,
- 33:18there's an example right there of, you know,
- 33:19the exodus to Hollywood. Elsa shows up on the
- 33:22doorstep of Universal in 1935 with James Whale,
- 33:26and she's the Bride of Frankenstein, her most
- 33:28iconic role. Wow. So that's really cool. It's
- 33:31not the last we'll see of her. No. Well, maybe
- 33:33on the podcast. No. Not you and I, though. Yeah.
- 33:35No. No. Please. Please. Yeah. So, I mean, that
- 33:39leads to... Kind of the crux of the movie, and
- 33:43the crux is that he has this fight in the banquet
- 33:46scene. Not the banquet scene, but in the banquet.
- 33:48He has this fight where he wrestles another individual.
- 33:51Yeah, he's like defending his honor. Yeah. He's
- 33:54kind of challenged. Yes. He's having a conversation
- 33:56with Catherine, and they're talking about Thomas
- 33:58Culpepper. And she's like, he's so strong. He's
- 34:03like, yeah, he's pretty strong, but you know.
- 34:05He's not me. Not this strong. And he like eats
- 34:08another chicken. Yeah, but how many rotisserie
- 34:11chickens can he eat with his bare hand though?
- 34:13Exactly. That scene where he has a chicken in
- 34:16front of him and he starts like pounding it to
- 34:18flatten the meat and all of the people around
- 34:21him at the table are very discreetly like wiping
- 34:25chicken juice off their face. That was pretty
- 34:28good. Yeah, I mean, you're right that there's
- 34:30a little bit of satire in there of how absurd
- 34:32that these people had to live among him. But
- 34:34again, the camera just does not want to capture
- 34:37those things as well or focus on it as much.
- 34:39It's more the background. And maybe that's more
- 34:41on me, but it's just... That brought on me not
- 34:44feeling as connected to the story and what it
- 34:46was trying to say. But so he starts this... He
- 34:49has this wrestling match with this individual,
- 34:51which gets him very tired and worked up. He ends
- 34:53up having a medical condition where the doctor...
- 34:56Did you catch the doctor's name? I did not. Dr.
- 34:59Butts. Oh, yes. That's right. She was like, call
- 35:01Dr. Butts. And I was like, this is really funny.
- 35:04I was watching it on Tubi. And with some of these
- 35:08films, especially when the restoration is not
- 35:09fantastic, I try to have the captions on so I
- 35:12can really see what they're saying. I can't hear
- 35:16my stories without my closed captions, so to
- 35:18speak. Right. When she said Dr. Butts, I was
- 35:21like, oh, that's funny. I wonder what the name
- 35:22really was. It was Dr. Butts. Yeah, it was. 100%.
- 35:25With an S or a Z? S. Oh, wow. And it wasn't even
- 35:28B -U -T -T -E -S. It was B -U -T -T -S. It was
- 35:32like, just straight up Dr. Butts. Great. I love
- 35:35it could have been S, Z, or dollar sign. Dollar
- 35:39sign would have been revolutionary for the time.
- 35:42He's a plastic surgeon doctor. Like millionaires,
- 35:45but with the dollar sign. Yeah. Shout out to
- 35:48all my friends who caught the millionaires reference
- 35:50from the 2000s. I see you and I respect you.
- 35:53So Dr. Butch shows up and he's like, yeah, you
- 35:56need some rest, man. You're just completely out
- 35:57of it. You're okay. Right. Because they have
- 35:59the fight and King Henry wins. Right. But as
- 36:02he walks back to the table, he's like, wasn't
- 36:03that great? He's like. that was a breeze yeah
- 36:08it falls over so he needs rest and he needs to
- 36:11go to his room and all this is an excuse for
- 36:13him to go to his bed and have like the curtains
- 36:16up and everything while thomas culpepper is in
- 36:19the room with katherine and they have this conversation
- 36:21of like we can't keep doing this like there is
- 36:24no end game to this ends up well this is very
- 36:26disraeli coded i think that's my disdain for
- 36:29this is that so much of it feels like it's hinged
- 36:33on his performance yeah Although I'm not going
- 36:36to do the thing where I'm like, this is just
- 36:37Disraeli because Elsa Lanchester is proof alone,
- 36:41but also Merle Oberon and Benny Barnes, how he
- 36:46is not stealing the scene or scenes from these
- 36:49women. Like they are having their chance to like
- 36:51captivate the screen and they do. So it's not
- 36:53Disraeli, but it does suffer a little bit from
- 36:56the melodrama of that. And it doesn't have the
- 37:00commentary of. the satire to kind of like the
- 37:04camera work doesn't have nor the direction has
- 37:07the satire there to differentiate so there are
- 37:10times that feel like disraeli i'm with you on
- 37:12that and this is one of them where it's like
- 37:14you couldn't have picked another room well i
- 37:16mostly meant that he's a sick boy little sick
- 37:18boy yeah true yeah curtains are drawn there's
- 37:20also like a fire i mean granted just because
- 37:23you have fire doesn't mean it's israeli but being
- 37:24in a room with a little sick boy and having this
- 37:26conversation with a fire yeah Kind of eavesdropping
- 37:30too. Yeah. And then there's the whole drama of
- 37:32like them having this moment and then they kiss.
- 37:35And while they're like embracing each other,
- 37:37you can hear King Charles has woken up. King
- 37:40Henry has woken up. Charles showed up at another.
- 37:43Henry wakes up and calls for Catherine. Yeah.
- 37:46And there's a great like sudden look from both
- 37:49of them. Kind of reminded me of Paul Muni in
- 37:53I Am a Fugitive from a Chain Gang. When his partner
- 37:56at the time reads his letter without him knowing.
- 37:59And is like, yeah, I guess it's better than me
- 38:00on a chain gang, huh? And there's a camera cut
- 38:02of his face like cutting and looking. They're
- 38:05both doing a little bit of that. But this leads
- 38:08to someone having seen Thomas and Catherine together.
- 38:12A lot of people haven't seen. A lot of people
- 38:15have been seeing. That's another example of like
- 38:17the dark humor where. One of Hendry's confidants
- 38:20shows up and he's like, sir, I got something
- 38:23to tell you, but you got to be chill. And he's
- 38:25like, tell me. And he's like, well, you seem
- 38:28a little tense, so maybe I'll wait. And he's
- 38:29like, tell me. He just freaks out. I'm not tense.
- 38:32Yeah. And he's like, listen, somebody saw Catherine
- 38:37with another man. Somebody saw Goody Proctor.
- 38:40Yeah. And like grabs him by the throat and like
- 38:43slams him on the table. And he's like, oh. And
- 38:45he's like, ah. Starts listing off like 37 different
- 38:49people. And it's... Because he doesn't think
- 38:53it's... Man. Yeah. The whole movie really is
- 38:56supposed to be you watching Henry VIII and just
- 38:59pointing and going, what a baby. And that's the
- 39:03dark comedy bit of it, I think. Your mileage
- 39:06may vary on whether you giggle and laugh at him
- 39:09being just a detestable baby of a king. Or you're
- 39:13just like, this guy sucks. And that I fall in
- 39:18the latter camp. The latter camp for me, it was
- 39:20less like, oh, yeah, what a comedic performance
- 39:23done by Charles Lawton to give this character
- 39:25like, you know, the satire that it needed. It
- 39:28really is more just I think a lot of people would
- 39:30walk away from this movie and like what an incredible
- 39:32performance by Charles Lawton playing the ever
- 39:34popular Henry VIII. Like, right. Yeah, it's not
- 39:38really what this is. This felt a lot to me like
- 39:41don't look up. Sure. That movie did not. jive
- 39:45with me at all and it's because of that satire
- 39:48and you're supposed to watch just the most detestable
- 39:51people in like positions of power and laugh at
- 39:54it and i think especially political satire like
- 39:57i struggle a lot with that because i'm just like
- 39:59maybe it's the climate we live in now where i'm
- 40:02just like we don't need this we get it yeah ha
- 40:06ha he let's move on let's fix some things and
- 40:09there's a little bit of that here where you're
- 40:11watching just this man be awful to not only everybody
- 40:14in his entire kingdom, but especially the women.
- 40:18And you're just like, I don't know if I can laugh
- 40:20at this for much longer. Yeah, I think the problem
- 40:22is that it has a very dry sense of humor, which
- 40:25it makes sense. A lot of the humor that comes
- 40:27from London and England specifically does tend
- 40:30to be a bit drier. So there's a real chance that
- 40:32this was misunderstood in the U .S. and by myself
- 40:34as well. But the history of this also shows that
- 40:38this was very much a celebration of his performance,
- 40:41Charles Lawton. Which is good. It is good. It's
- 40:44a good performance. But I think it takes the
- 40:45wrong lessons from it. Yeah. Not saying anyone
- 40:47got beheaded because of this movie. They're like,
- 40:49yeah, Henry VIII was right. But they're celebrating
- 40:52the dramatic performance of it and not the comedic
- 40:55performance of it. Right. Right. You're watching
- 40:57this awful guy and the intention is to be like,
- 40:59ha ha, that Henry VIII. Instead of being like,
- 41:02wow, this guy was awful. Yeah, exactly. And both
- 41:05could be true. Both reactions. Yeah. But it's
- 41:08not one that's conveyed very clearly. Yes. And
- 41:10to me, the way that this really, the way this
- 41:13kind of wraps up is in the final scene that he
- 41:15has. And he ends up sharing it with Elsa Lanchester.
- 41:18Or at least one of the last scenes. Is that not
- 41:20right? No, it's not Elsa. She's gone. She's out
- 41:23of the movie. I thought it was End of Clives.
- 41:25No. She's skedaddled. She's chilling in her castle
- 41:28penthouse by herself. What it is, is Catherine.
- 41:32And Thomas get beheaded once they're discovered.
- 41:35Right. And he is distraught about this. And he
- 41:37stays single for a long time because he's lost
- 41:40his true love or who he believes is his true
- 41:43love. To a point where when we catch up with
- 41:44him, he has a lot of gray in his hair. Yes. Much
- 41:47older. Yes. And he meets his sixth wife. And
- 41:51that's who he spends this scene with. Understood.
- 41:54This is... par which he has a moment where when
- 41:58he meets her she's like oh hi my name's catherine
- 42:00and she's like the the nanny kind of of the castle
- 42:03uh and one of his servants or something is like
- 42:07hey you know who'd be good for you this woman
- 42:09that's taking care of kids you have kids that
- 42:11might work you're kind of a kid that'll work
- 42:14too when he learns her name's catherine he's
- 42:16like oh my love catherine it's interesting i
- 42:19i i kind of want to push back i almost thought
- 42:22That the woman who's telling him that, because
- 42:24they're at the window and he looks out the window
- 42:26at her suggesting. I thought this was Elsa because
- 42:29she suggests that she was the fourth wife. Because
- 42:32he's like, my first wife was this. My second
- 42:34wife was that. My third wife was this. My fourth
- 42:36wife was great. But my fifth wife was this. And
- 42:39she's like, the problem was that she was not
- 42:41young. Or she was young. And you need to mature.
- 42:44You know what? I really don't know. Because when
- 42:46you said servant, I was like, no, I'm pretty
- 42:48sure this is one of his wives. Because he was
- 42:50like, hey, it's so great to see you again. How
- 42:51have you been? Like, you know, we had a divorce.
- 42:54That's what I thought. I could totally be wrong
- 42:56on that. I could be wrong, too. I thought that
- 42:57was his... That was the importance was like he
- 43:00was kind of noting, hey, what we had like ultimately
- 43:02wasn't going to work out. But like, look how
- 43:04we were able to separate this. And it was him
- 43:06kind of like looking back longingly at his relationships.
- 43:08So almost to a point where if it was a servant,
- 43:10that scene is less important to me because it's
- 43:12less of him like reconciling a little bit. Yeah.
- 43:16But also I kind of need you to explain to me
- 43:18what she was suggesting, whether it was the servant
- 43:20or Elsa Lanchester. I kind of need you to explain
- 43:22to me what she was suggesting, because it definitely
- 43:24sounded like you should hook up with one of the
- 43:26young nannies instead. Well, I think it is an
- 43:29older woman. Right. Yeah. Catherine, what is
- 43:32it? Catherine Barr? Catherine Parr. Right. Played
- 43:35by Everly Gregg. And I really think what it is,
- 43:38is it's like, look, this is a woman who's taking
- 43:40care of the children. You're kind of a big baby.
- 43:43Like, she doesn't say that, but that's kind of
- 43:45the nurturer that he needs. Yeah. And that leads
- 43:49to him being with his sixth wife and sets up
- 43:52the punchline at the end of the movie, which
- 43:55I don't like. Ultimately, he's being cared for
- 43:58by Catherine and she's she's very nagging to
- 44:01him. She's like, OK, you've had dinner time for
- 44:04your nap. And he like reaches over to eat some
- 44:06more chicken. And she's like, no, chicken disagrees
- 44:10with you. You can't have that. And he's just
- 44:11like, let me live my life. And as soon as she
- 44:14leaves, he runs over from his nap. He gets up
- 44:17from the from the bed, runs over and starts gnawing
- 44:20on another chicken. And he has a moment where
- 44:23he breaks the fourth wall and he says. Six wives,
- 44:26and the best of them's the worst. The end. And
- 44:34it's supposed to be like a summarization of his
- 44:40life and his relationship with his wives and
- 44:43how he feels about his wives towards the end
- 44:46of his life. Yeah, I guess. I also got that punchline
- 44:50from him at the end, and it kind of was delivered
- 44:52more like a Rodney Dangerfield, like, you know,
- 44:54the women of my life, like this kind of thing.
- 44:58Yeah, I mean, look, especially talking about
- 45:00it with you, I understand more what it was trying
- 45:02to go for, and I appreciate having these conversations
- 45:05so I can pick that up a bit more where I didn't
- 45:08get in the movie. It is just a tough hang if
- 45:12you're not fully on board with what it is. Yeah.
- 45:15And it was difficult for me, not a tough hang
- 45:17in the sense of like, oh, this is a really problematic
- 45:19movie. It was just more difficult to get past
- 45:22when some of the best parts happen halfway through.
- 45:26Sure. And that's Elsa Lancia. Like their chemistry
- 45:28is unreal how good it is. And it just doesn't
- 45:31carry on. Yeah. And to back that up, even beyond
- 45:36their chemistry. Elsa Lanchester is just such
- 45:39a bizarre character in this that she's a blast
- 45:41to watch. She almost feels like she came from
- 45:441960s or 1950s. Like she time traveled. She seems
- 45:48like a time traveler because she's not just from
- 45:50a different place. It seems like she's from a
- 45:52different time. Which is a lot of fun to watch.
- 45:55It's just kind of out of nowhere. Yeah. She's
- 45:58super cool. I like her a lot. She is super cool.
- 46:01But no, I agree with you. I think that the tone
- 46:04in this movie. Maybe it's lost to time a little
- 46:08bit. Lost to time, yeah. Yeah, like the way that
- 46:11you're supposed to digest this movie, like we
- 46:14just don't have that ability in 2026. Yeah. I
- 46:18will say like the highlights of the movie, obviously
- 46:21Charles Lawton and Elsa Lanchester, Meryl Oberyn,
- 46:24she's great. The performances of a lot of the
- 46:27characters are great. I think the set design
- 46:29is pretty cool. There are a lot of shots outside
- 46:32as well. They're like... duck or pheasant hunting
- 46:35or something and they're the wide shots they're
- 46:39really cool seeing just i don't know the outdoors
- 46:41yippee and then the castle design and things
- 46:44that all looks great and the costumes uh henry
- 46:47looks cool yeah i mean costume means good production
- 46:50design is good too um there's some outdoor scenes
- 46:53specifically with like the horse riding you just
- 46:55want to say as like a compliment to the movie
- 46:58long are far away are we from the in old arizona
- 47:02of like how we capture these scenes on camera
- 47:04um i'm not gonna say it's the most beautiful
- 47:07thing in the world but you can hear everything
- 47:09very clearly so it's nice when they're riding
- 47:11in distance so very cool that's the scene where
- 47:13he finds out that he's having a boy and he's
- 47:15like it's a boy and they all travel to the castle
- 47:18man you know that's a very small call out of
- 47:20how good his performance is after he gets off
- 47:23the horse from the long journey and he's talking
- 47:25to the doctor and he's like how's my boy And
- 47:29he's just completely out of breath. Props to
- 47:31you, Charles Lawton. I mean, it's a good performance.
- 47:34I don't intend to, I don't mean to make it sound
- 47:37like I'm dogging his performance at all. I think
- 47:40it's just a mismatch. It's hard to kind of read
- 47:42what the story was trying to, or the movie was
- 47:44trying to tell you. And it's hard to root for
- 47:46the villain, I think. Of course. Yeah, that's
- 47:48always a big thing too. But his performance is
- 47:50great. Obviously awarded very highly for this
- 47:52nomination. So we'll talk about that when we
- 47:54get to it. But yeah, mixed bag for me. Yeah,
- 47:57totally. I totally understand that. I don't know
- 48:00why I did that. I was going to say, is that a
- 48:02pun? That was me being jolly, like King Henry.
- 48:07So, yeah, my rating for this was very middle
- 48:10of the road. And I always say that when I give
- 48:11it above middle of the road. But three stars
- 48:14for it. I think I had more fun with it than you
- 48:17did. Again, I struggle a little bit with, like,
- 48:21the regality stories. Period pieces. Not even
- 48:25period pieces, because I'm okay with the time
- 48:27setting. Oh, it's the royal aspect of it. Yes.
- 48:29Okay, copy. But yeah, I think his performance
- 48:32was fun enough for me when I wasn't just completely
- 48:36disgusted by his behavior. And I just really
- 48:39like Elsa Lanchester a lot. So three stars for
- 48:43me. I was going down the casting list on Letterboxd
- 48:45looking for Dr. Butts, and I can't find him.
- 48:47But I promise you that's his name. Yeah, I was
- 48:50lower on this. I was two. Two stars. Oh, two.
- 48:52I can't say I cared for this too much. It just
- 48:54kind of felt like a chore to get through more
- 48:56than an enjoyment factor. His performance is
- 48:59notable. But to me, it was just kind of loud,
- 49:02boisterous, playing a fool. And if I had hung
- 49:06out with Charles Lawton a lot, maybe I'd be like,
- 49:08oh, wow, what a great performance because he's
- 49:09such a distinguished man. Yeah. It's just difficult
- 49:12to get through. And I think I was sensing a really
- 49:15big peak with the Elsa Lanchester scenes. And
- 49:18then it just kind of went back downhill. So it
- 49:20was hard for me to kind of even give an extra
- 49:21credit for that. Yeah. I had more interest in
- 49:25reading the behind the scenes of this than anything
- 49:27in the movie. So whenever that happens, I tend
- 49:29to go a little bit lower too. But yeah, not a
- 49:31big fan. Two stars. I mean, certainly there's
- 49:33some credits to the movie and Charles London's
- 49:37performance. My God, you're just ruining. This
- 49:39whole thing with dropping stuff. His performance
- 49:42is of note and worth watching for that alone.
- 49:44And to reiterate your point, Criterion Channel
- 49:47and Tubi. Free on Tubi. Yeah. Paid subscription
- 49:50with Criterion Channel. Worth watching when you
- 49:52can catch that. It's had a physical release on
- 49:54Criterion as well. It has, yeah. Been looking
- 49:56for that. Can't say it's very high on my list
- 49:58right now, but nice to have a completionist.
- 50:01Yeah. I think it's part of a set as well. I don't
- 50:04know what set. I don't think it's an individual.
- 50:05I think you're right. Yeah. It might be a Lawton
- 50:08set. Because I think it is a lot of like period
- 50:10pieces and things. While you look that up, I'm
- 50:13going to go ahead and get into my double feature.
- 50:14Please. I went with a film I saw in theaters
- 50:18like back when I was in middle school, I think.
- 50:20And I didn't fully grasp it at the time, but
- 50:24it did stick with me to where I was familiar
- 50:27with King Henry because of this. And also like
- 50:31Anne Boleyn and some of his other wives. So obviously
- 50:34it had some effect on me. And that is the...
- 50:38Natalie Portman, Scarlett Johansson, and Eric
- 50:40Bana film, The Other Boland Girl. Have we done
- 50:43it? This is mine. We've done it. We've done it.
- 50:45We've done it. The 2008 film directed by Justin
- 50:49Chadwick. Yeah. Yeah, we finally did it. We did
- 50:52it. Look at us. We did it, Joe. You know, kind
- 50:56of. Kind of obvious, I think. I think so. I mean,
- 50:59when you look at the kind of retelling of Anne
- 51:02Boleyn and Henry VIII, I would say two very different
- 51:06categorizations of Henry VIII. Sure. Right? Eric
- 51:09Bana. Do you do Bana? Bana? I do Bana. Like banana,
- 51:14but Bana? Yeah. I guess that makes a lot of sense.
- 51:16Yeah. Eric Banana. Yeah. So Eric Banana. Bruce
- 51:18Bana. Eric Bana does not change his look very
- 51:22much for his performance of Henry VIII in Other
- 51:24Boleyn Girl. He's just... very attractive, very
- 51:27different take. And I think that in a movie that
- 51:30wants to kind of study what looks like the story
- 51:34of Anne Boleyn, very minorly compared to Henry
- 51:37VIII, it's nice to see a movie that kind of tackles
- 51:40a little bit more of Anne Boleyn's story. And
- 51:42also, you know, her sister, Scarlett Johansson.
- 51:45Yep. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. This was kind of an obvious
- 51:48one for me too. So it's not surprising. No, I
- 51:50didn't think about it, but it's not surprising
- 51:52now. Yeah, I mean, I wanted to go with a story
- 51:55that kind of told this tale in a more serious
- 51:59tone because, you know, historically, this is
- 52:02a big deal. This guy was awful to women. He's
- 52:05kind of one of many of the poster childs of,
- 52:09hey, men suck. King Henry VIII, am I right? You're
- 52:14right. So it is available physically from Criterion,
- 52:18but only in the Eclipse Series 16, which is the
- 52:22Eclipse Series that we also have for Ernst Lubitsch.
- 52:25But this one is 16, and it is Alexander Korda's
- 52:29Private Lives. Okay. DVD box set, not currently
- 52:33available on Blu -ray, but same thing with Lubitsch.
- 52:36Lubitsch was the Eclipse series was on DVD, later
- 52:39released on Blu -ray. So there is a chance this
- 52:41can come out on Blu -ray later, but it is available
- 52:43in that collection on DVD. Gotcha. Good to know.
- 52:45I'm not going to seek it out right now, but nice
- 52:48to look out for. Yeah. And, you know, I imagine
- 52:50there's quite a few Charles Lawton performances
- 52:53in there. I don't know for sure. Just an assumption.
- 52:55Yeah, I was having trouble finding what movies
- 52:57were included in that. So I'll double check that.
- 52:59But that is the series that exists. Yeah. I mean,
- 53:02we just talked about 42nd Street and how there
- 53:05was also another Busby Berkeley musical nominated
- 53:07this year. Right. Charles Lawton was in another
- 53:09big film that was nominated for cinematography
- 53:12this year. And that's another period piece, The
- 53:15Sign of the Cross, which I started watching.
- 53:17And that's going to do a number on me. A Sign
- 53:20of the Cross? Yeah. Interesting. Cecil B. DeMille.
- 53:23So it's one of those big, like, exactly. But
- 53:25yeah, that's The Private Life of Henry VIII.
- 53:28Let us know what you thought of it. Did you like
- 53:31Charles Lawton in it? Did you think it was worthy
- 53:33of Best Picture? Or is it just one of those,
- 53:36like, yeah, this happened. This was a history
- 53:39thing. I don't want it. Guess which one we are.
- 53:41Guess. Well, I mean, I think we're kind of on
- 53:43both sides of the coin. Yeah, we're kind of split
- 53:45right down the middle, I think. Right. But...
- 53:48If you'd like to give us your thoughts, shoot
- 53:49us an email at outaopodcast at gmail .com. If
- 53:53you'd like to support the show financially, check
- 53:55out patreon .com slash outaopodcast. And stay
- 53:59tuned for the next episode where we will be covering
- 54:02our first Frank Capra -directed film, Lady for
- 54:05a Day. Yep. How do we feel about it? Let's see.
- 54:08Let's find out. That's available... I think you
- 54:11have to hunt for a little bit. Video on demand
- 54:13or there is physical releases of it as well.
- 54:16This is tough. I should have done the inverse
- 54:19of what I normally do because I do own, really
- 54:22excited to talk about this on the next episode,
- 54:24I do own the collection of Capra films. So I
- 54:28have those available on Blu -ray, so I didn't
- 54:30even look to see how you could watch it. Sure.
- 54:32But... If you can get your hands on it, the Capra
- 54:35collection does have Lady for a Day and all the
- 54:37others on there. So it is well worth your time
- 54:40to seek out. Yeah. So check that out if you can.
- 54:44But until next time, I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And
- 54:47we'll see you at the movies.