Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 256:1-5. Tzedakah: Collection and Distribution of Funds for Charity, Kuppah and Tamchuy, Visitors

Transcript

Yoreh De’ah 256:1-5. Tzedakah: Collection and Distribution of Funds for Charity, Kuppah and Tamchuy, Visitors · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:00
  OK, Simon Reishman. Vav Sidaka.
• 0:03
  Koopa VE Tampui aleph coeir Sheshba.
• 0:08
  Any Jewish city. There's Jews.
• 0:10
  Hayavim, Muhammad, Mayhem. Gabai Sidaka.
• 0:13
  You have to have a Gabai sidaka. Ones who collect and give out
• 0:17
  nashim yaduim. Is it known?
• 0:22
  Known individuals. Vanamanim.
• 0:24
  They're trustworthy, right? We know where they are.
• 0:27
  They have to be capable. You have to be intelligent
• 0:29
  enough to deal with this and honest shiu mukhazrim like Gabot
• 0:35
  Nicole Akhad, because they have to be able to go and collect
• 0:37
  from each one, go from house to house to collect mashhura UI le
• 0:41
  10 and figure out how much each person is able to give, right?
• 0:47
  That's very important. You have if one is able to give,
• 0:50
  one has to give. If one is not able to give,
• 0:52
  they're not allowed to collect. So they have to figure out how
• 0:54
  much Madhavar Cutsuvalla and they got to figure out how much
• 0:59
  each one is able to pay the Haim Mahalki Mahamaot, Maharav
• 1:03
  Shabbat, La Arab Shabbat. And they would divvy it out
• 1:07
  every week, era Shabbos to era Shabbos, right enough for the
• 1:12
  week. And we're going to keep we're
• 1:14
  going to explain the note means lako ani mashiaspiclo, the Shiva
• 1:20
  Yamim. And they would give out enough
• 1:23
  food that they would have for the week, seven days Mazzola
• 1:27
  Nikrez Koopa, that's in Khazzal, what they called a koopa.
• 1:34
  That's what you see in the times in the Mishnah that that's the
• 1:37
  that's what the Sedaka fund that's called a koopa.
• 1:41
  That's what it was for. It was for weekly allowance of
• 1:45
  food. And they would also go around,
• 1:51
  collect every day, Nikola Hatsur from courtyard, from courtyard
• 1:57
  pot Umine Maha. They go collect bread and foods
• 2:02
  or pay roads, fruits or vegetables, oma oats or cash.
• 2:06
  Mimi shumit Nadev Rafi Shah, whoever just donates, you know,
• 2:11
  for the moment, for that day, omakhalkin ETA gabui le ereb bin
• 2:16
  hanim. And every evening they would
• 2:18
  pass it out among the poor. The Notinimi menu will call ani
• 2:23
  parnassat yo MO and they would give him enough for the day.
• 2:28
  All right, until the next evening, and it would be a daily
• 2:31
  allowance. Viziani crowd Tam Hui and that's
• 2:35
  what is known khazal as the word tamkhle.
• 2:38
  That's the fund that Sedaka fund called tamkhle.
• 2:41
  It was for the day, it was enough and they would give out
• 2:44
  enough for the day. Me olam Laura Enu velosheimanu
• 2:48
  kahalmi sahalam Koopa schultzidaka and we have never
• 2:52
  heard of a city that doesn't have some form of Koopa
• 2:56
  Schultzidaka where they they look after their people, I guess
• 3:00
  on a weekly basis of all tamkhoy ishma kumat shalon nahagur Bo
• 3:06
  but this daily allowance or daily soup kitchen.
• 3:11
  So this is not every place has it Haga villa Hein MI Shi ishla
• 3:18
  Muslim shivayamim loika koopa. So therefore, it just means,
• 3:25
  right? Simple translation is if you
• 3:28
  have enough food for a week, you wouldn't collect for the from
• 3:31
  the from the koopa because it was a weekly thing and you
• 3:35
  didn't need it. If someone has enough food for
• 3:39
  the day, then they wouldn't collect from the tamqui because
• 3:42
  if you have enough for the day, then you would wait till the
• 3:43
  next day to go collect taking with the koopa.
• 3:46
  If you had enough for a week, then you'd wait for the next
• 3:48
  week. Obviously that's to be a little
• 3:50
  practical. And if there's only one day of
• 3:51
  giving it out, whatever, just work it out.
• 3:53
  But that's that. This is the concept.
• 3:55
  It means like you, you don't need to collect until the next
• 3:58
  time comes when they give it, when they give it out.
• 4:01
  Oh, it's Wikima Gabayim shiyu. Now these gabayim as we sort, we
• 4:07
  already alluded to or mentioned, they have to be trustworthy and
• 4:12
  wise deductible al hanim and they have to be very careful to
• 4:16
  scrutinize and figure out how you know, are these really a
• 4:20
  name? How much do they need for what
• 4:22
  Shiloh, you were a mayim so that they're not dishonest.
• 4:27
  It could be they have a lot of money.
• 4:28
  It could be it's easy for them to work and they don't want to
• 4:30
  work. Nicola Gabaye, Eno Nerman, I say
• 4:34
  So the whole is that when I just finished the whole, should I go
• 4:38
  by Eno Nerman, Asur Litaine Sidaka Al Yadav?
• 4:42
  Now, if you have this organization or the Skabaye
• 4:46
  who's you can't rely on for whatever reason, then you
• 4:49
  shouldn't give to that fund, that organization or person.
• 4:53
  You should give to one that is reliable.
• 4:55
  Shah just points out the obvious when we say they have to be very
• 4:59
  careful to scrutinize, that's in general.
• 5:02
  But if a person is starving and they say I need food, someone
• 5:06
  says I am starving and I need food just for right now.
• 5:08
  So then made with Doctor King, make sure he has enough food so
• 5:12
  that he has a chance to explain himself at least to give him to
• 5:17
  give him food for for right now. But you don't have to give him
• 5:20
  more than that quick it seems. In the old days it wasn't so
• 5:23
  hard because people weren't so transient and you could be
• 5:26
  careful, but people who are travelling, it'd be hard to
• 5:30
  know. You don't have to just.
• 5:31
  You have to do the best you can, but to aniot mahalkim, mezanod
• 5:35
  la Aniim, we get on. When at the end this has become
• 5:39
  the established Menhag. In those days, I'm not sure, I
• 5:42
  don't think nowadays. But in those days, again, it
• 5:46
  depends on the Matthias. At the end of every fast day, it
• 5:49
  was known that the Shoals or whatever that's Gabe Sedaka.
• 5:54
  They would give out a lot of food for any of the poor people
• 5:58
  who are hungry. And the minute was they were
• 6:00
  waiting for that meal, right? That neem they weren't they
• 6:04
  didn't then they they weren't neem.
• 6:06
  They didn't have food for the day.
• 6:07
  And they knew that once the once the fast is over, there's going
• 6:11
  to be a feast. Doesn't have to be lavish, but
• 6:14
  there has to be. They were expecting it.
• 6:16
  That was the custom. So therefore the whole TA anit
• 6:19
  shahluaam villanu. So therefore, if you have a
• 6:24
  shoaler at Seaboard, right, you can, it doesn't have to be every
• 6:28
  show, as long as the city and they work it out so that there
• 6:31
  is a place to go to. So it's saying if you'll say you
• 6:34
  have a whole city and everyone goes to show everyone Dobbins
• 6:38
  the whole day, then they go home and they eat and they go to
• 6:41
  sleep and they don't care for the onion.
• 6:44
  Cause the minog was that the onion were expecting food at the
• 6:47
  end of the fast. And now this city or this, this
• 6:52
  time they don't worry about it and they eat and they go to
• 6:55
  sleep. All the the people who have
• 6:57
  food. But then the poor starving
• 6:59
  people are left outside expecting food and there's no
• 7:02
  food anywhere in the city for them.
• 7:05
  So then the Sedaka la onion and they don't give them.
• 7:12
  So since it was expected and that was the custom, those who
• 7:15
  do not give food for the poor, they are like murderers.
• 7:20
  Ahmed Devari Memoriam, what are we talking about?
• 7:24
  That's if he didn't put out some some bread and vegetables that
• 7:31
  doesn't even cost that much. Just some be part of chillent
• 7:34
  doesn't cost much at all of all IME.
• 7:40
  Oh hakhi team. But if they were late, they
• 7:42
  didn't pass out cash and they didn't pass out wheat, you know,
• 7:47
  flour or wheat kernels. So that's not ready to eat right
• 7:49
  now. So then enam Keshokh Fei dummy,
• 7:53
  because it's that's not there's no requirement to give them
• 7:58
  Dafka food on a mosse Tainus means to get food for later,
• 8:05
  right, cash and and wheat kernels.
• 8:08
  It's not going to help them for tonight when they're hungry.
• 8:10
  It's going to take them a day or two to get food from that.
• 8:13
  So that is not Koshov Khedamim. They nobody was expecting that.
• 8:17
  Apparently there was they also, Oh, I don't know.
• 8:19
  It could be they also gave them money.
• 8:21
  It depends on the custom. I I don't know for sure, but
• 8:23
  that's not what they were expecting and therefore there's
• 8:25
  no problem. It's for people who are
• 8:27
  expecting it and they're starving.
• 8:29
  OK Gilmore have Koopa Ena niqbet the pakhot mishchnein collecting
• 8:34
  sedaka This is basic. This is pretty much by force
• 8:38
  Shane osseem serora alat sibor bin mamon the pakhot mishnayin
• 8:43
  there's Allah is there's no khazal.
• 8:47
  We don't give any power of force to single individuals.
• 8:52
  They basin can appoint 2 people or more to use force on other to
• 8:59
  coerce or force other people. Hey, we learned that when once
• 9:04
  it gets established that a person has to pay a certain
• 9:07
  amount and they they don't and the deadline passes right The
• 9:13
  the Bach Oracle points out we're not talking about like a same
• 9:16
  day decision, but we're talking about they were told you have to
• 9:19
  pay comes the deadline. Then we learned before in racial
• 9:23
  and correct, they're allowed to Mamashguni and they're allowed
• 9:25
  to go into their property and take a moshkon, an item until
• 9:31
  they paid the cash. I believe they can take cash as
• 9:34
  well, but they can even take a moshkon and even on air of
• 9:38
  Shabbos if that's when it was when they're busy, right?
• 9:41
  They they can't say, oh, I'm busy with air of Shabbos
• 9:44
  preparations. No, they can go in and take, but
• 9:47
  this is only because they have two people and it's mutter Avala
• 9:53
  Akash and nibet. Once they collect and the force
• 9:56
  is done, then Ekhad Neman Al Leah Liott Gisbach.
• 10:01
  So you only need one guy who can, who is in charge of the
• 10:04
  money. One guy can be dealing with it.
• 10:07
  That's fine. OK.
• 10:09
  And you can have two brothers. There's no problem.
• 10:17
  All right, The relatives. This is not a din of of.
• 10:21
  So it's not a basin issue over here.
• 10:23
  The Aina meet or Ada's issue. But that holds the money.
• 10:26
  The guy who's holding the money. Yeah.
• 10:29
  The Aina meet. Khalekat.
• 10:31
  Ella Bishlocha. Now, when you go to the houses
• 10:34
  to start giving out Sedaka, you need at least three.
• 10:39
  No less than 3. Ella Bishoja.
• 10:41
  Le Fischiihi kid DNA mamanos. The ayan.
• 10:44
  I'll call Ani the Ani Kamara Liten low because when they went
• 10:48
  from house to house, they would reassess every time.
• 10:51
  I mean, depending on the situation and anytime you're
• 10:54
  doing an assessment, an evaluation, how much can a
• 10:58
  person receive a need? So then it's a that's a, that's
• 11:02
  a din that's, that's a bit mishpat issue.
• 11:04
  And we don't do a act as it's a, you know, they're acting for the
• 11:09
  Bayes din act as a Bayes din to make this determination.
• 11:13
  And we don't do any kind of based in actions with less than
• 11:17
  3 individuals, 3 people. So therefore, that needs 3 to
• 11:21
  pass out. And it depends on what the
• 11:26
  situation is. If they're not making any kind
• 11:28
  of a Ding and they're just a Michelov, it's a delivery
• 11:31
  service. That's not what we're talking
• 11:33
  about. That's not a problem.
• 11:34
  You can have one person do that. The only time you need 3 is if
• 11:38
  they're making assessments. OK, the Tamaklay Kamosha MIT
• 11:43
  Colette Michelosha kach Ena niqva ELO vishlo shella fische
• 11:47
  Eno dovar katsu. So collect.
• 11:54
  It also depends when they take or get.
• 11:58
  If you're taking and you're reassessing every time you take,
• 12:01
  then you also need three. If you're just if it's already
• 12:04
  been accounted for, the Tom clue is a daily thing and they might
• 12:08
  need to reassess every day. But if you're a coupa and it's
• 12:13
  weekly or monthly or yearly, you know assumed it was done in
• 12:17
  advance. Basically anytime you're doing
• 12:19
  an assessment when you're going to collect or take or give out,
• 12:24
  then you need 3. Anytime you're you're using
• 12:27
  force to take you need 2 and just to hold the money or to be
• 12:32
  a delivery service. So then one, one is enough.
• 12:36
  Yeah, you're one person is a is one person.
• 12:39
  We're going to see this in a moment or later today, tomorrow
• 12:43
  and Eid Ekhad is now going to be Sunni and one person is 100%
• 12:46
  trustworthy. And we don't worry that one guy
• 12:49
  is stealing and playing around. Now I'll just point out I'm not
• 12:54
  I can't tell you Allah Kalamaisa, but I can tell you
• 12:57
  that the base Yosef and Reish Ananvag Gimo and then arrocha
• 13:02
  Shokhan R.E.M. Reishman khat good Gimel.
• 13:05
  So they say. Nowadays we don't do any.
• 13:08
  We don't take money by force, we don't go.
• 13:10
  It's not the Minogue. There are, Khashoghan says.
• 13:13
  We don't have power to go from house to house and pull out
• 13:17
  money and possessions. I don't know, Graciosa says.
• 13:21
  We just don't. I don't know.
• 13:24
  OK. Dalit Tamhui, Nikbe bakoyo.
• 13:29
  So the Tamhui is collected every day, right?
• 13:31
  It's a daily thing, we said via coupa.
• 13:33
  Me air of Chavez air of Chavez it's weekly and from era Chavez
• 13:37
  to era Chavez. So oumkoi la aniye olam VE a
• 13:39
  kupa Leni OTA. Now the funds that's under the
• 13:44
  kupa that's only collected for and given out to the anium of
• 13:50
  the city. That's what the fund is for the
• 13:53
  Tamkoi is because you're worried about strangers.
• 13:55
  You don't know who they are. So it's a daily thing.
• 13:57
  It's not that much money we're talking about anyway and if they
• 14:00
  say we're hungry so it's not a big issue.
• 14:03
  OK, so that's again, every every fund is what it is.
• 14:10
  The tamkhi and the koopas based on the minute of you know, from
• 14:15
  from a long time ago. And every city can adjust and
• 14:19
  make their own rules, more or less.
• 14:22
  Rashaim and Rashaim, Binet Haier Rashaim, they're allowed to the
• 14:26
  Binet Haier lasat koopa tamkhi. There are a lot of make right.
• 14:32
  That's what we just said. They can make a coupon to a Tam
• 14:35
  Koi, the Tam koi into a Koopa Relishinota and the coma
• 14:38
  Shahirtsu and they can change the funds, the money that's
• 14:41
  collected because it's they're the ones who are given in
• 14:45
  charge. It was when the money's given,
• 14:47
  we're going to see it's depends. But generally speaking, the
• 14:50
  money that's given to the Gavai Sedaka, it's given on their Das
• 14:54
  to do with what they think as appropriate.
• 14:58
  And so they can take funds from one fund to another, from one
• 15:03
  purpose to another, right meets Orcheed Sibor as long as Kolma
• 15:07
  Shiurtu meets Orcheed Sibor, as long as it's for Sarkheed Sibor
• 15:11
  and for some kind of good Sedaka cause the Alpha Peace, Lahiti
• 15:15
  Nouquin, the Shah, Chicago, even though they took the money from
• 15:18
  the people and there was no discussion, there's no, no one
• 15:22
  said anything. They just took the money.
• 15:23
  They knew it was for Sidaka imaya and so imayabe Medina
• 15:27
  hakamgado chaco gobi maldalto E halekwani entefima shira arreza
• 15:33
  Yahoo ishinoto la coma shira lo mitzer ET sibor.
• 15:38
  So just like the goodbye, Sidaka can do whatever they want when
• 15:41
  they give it to a Hakamgado who also has jurisdiction for for
• 15:49
  for more than their city. If you're having a in charge of
• 15:54
  the whole state or the whole country.
• 15:55
  So you know he's going to take care of each city appropriately
• 16:01
  according to the Anis anim's needs.
• 16:04
  And so therefore when you give it to him, you trust him.
• 16:07
  He's going to do Kamala shits like he needs to do like he
• 16:09
  should do, and he's able. And therefore he has the rights
• 16:12
  to do as he pleases. When you give it to the Gabi in
• 16:20
  charge of the city, The Who had been Biyaki cheats Nadev, it's
• 16:25
  sadaqa. So too, when you have an
• 16:26
  individual, he donates money, then that's not a goodbye.
• 16:29
  He gives it to a Gabi, right? Any individual goes up to any
• 16:33
  Gabi. So that's the same idea that now
• 16:35
  the Gabi has a leeway to do as he pleases.
• 16:39
  Ava in Mina the Atsma Gabi in Now let's say a person is
• 16:46
  wealthy and he has a person or a couple people who manage his
• 16:51
  Sedaka form. Not uncommon for people who have
• 16:55
  they donate a lot of money and so they give it to their person
• 16:58
  in charge of giving out their money as they please.
• 17:01
  So when they give it to their person, the Gabi hair has no
• 17:07
  right to do what he wants because it's still in the
• 17:10
  person's personal jurisdiction. It's in his personal gabai
• 17:16
  sidatha, so the Gabai of the city has no rights to mess or
• 17:21
  meddle with what it's used for. So let's keep reading Delo al da
• 17:26
  tamik nadev. He didn't give the money for the
• 17:29
  das of what the Gabai the ear wants to use it for of the city.
• 17:33
  He gave it for who want his own person or is in charge of giving
• 17:39
  out based on what he wants to Mahaling Piresh Anotein
• 17:42
  Villanmarshini Ola Anni Paloni or so to when you any individual
• 17:48
  at does give Sidaka to the Gabai City shul.
• 17:54
  Whatever he says. This money is for this purpose.
• 17:57
  It's for these poor people. It's for this onion and he gives
• 18:01
  his name. So then a Lahan Lashaunot he's
• 18:05
  not allowed to to switch certainly if it's for Annim.
• 18:11
  OK, maybe it if it's for a certain purpose, maybe it, they
• 18:17
  are allowed to switch. OK, But if it's for the poor
• 18:21
  people or a particular poor person, then he's for sure not
• 18:25
  allowed to switch. Because when you say that and
• 18:29
  you give it, when you give it to the Gabe of the Ear, and you say
• 18:32
  it's for this person or for the poor people, as soon as the Gabe
• 18:35
  ear takes the money, it's as if it enters the hands of the
• 18:39
  anime, the poor people. So therefore it can't be
• 18:42
  switched anymore. So then you're not allowed to
• 18:48
  take it because it was designated for people, poor
• 18:52
  people. Then it's as if they got it
• 18:54
  already. And so now it's no longer in the
• 18:56
  hands of the Gabe Tadak. Then you can't switch it from
• 18:58
  one fund to another. Yeah, there's no difference.
• 19:00
  If you want to, you can't switch it to the top thing because you
• 19:03
  can't switch it. It's not yours to switch.
• 19:06
  It's already owned by the anime Vinay Haeer Shiminu, right?
• 19:09
  That if that was the case, if he designated for these anime, if
• 19:13
  you designated for a particular Sedaka purpose, I think you
• 19:16
  could switch it, right? You could switch from one to
• 19:20
  another. Anime's thumb also goes to the
• 19:23
  anime. OK, fine.
• 19:27
  Vinay Haeer Shiminu Gabai Vinifer de Chavila Viniferdu
• 19:30
  Zemiser. Now, let's say the city appoints
• 19:33
  Adabai Sedaka for the city, and then they have a full fallout
• 19:39
  and they realize they want to go their own separate ways.
• 19:41
  This is not working for whatever reason.
• 19:44
  But I the difference is a reason we are dying.
• 19:47
  Sedaka. We had a goodbye, but the Gabi
• 19:50
  Sedaka was collecting money. And in the middle of them
• 19:53
  collecting. It's always going to happen like
• 19:54
  this. Yeah, Chimat always.
• 19:56
  He has money in his pocket. And then there's a little
• 19:58
  problem, a little fight between them, and they say this is not
• 20:00
  working. But right now he's holding the
• 20:02
  money that he's been collecting for the past days or weeks,
• 20:05
  whatever it is. So now and and he has the money
• 20:08
  in his pocket. So what what happens?
• 20:10
  Imayara should be out of Gabbai, but he will ask Mashi Yurtze.
• 20:14
  I'm not tell you I said Mashi Yurtze.
• 20:16
  We say like this. If the Gabbai Sedaka, they
• 20:21
  appointed him to raise money and give out money and he does not
• 20:26
  need or he doesn't consult with them every time he gives out the
• 20:30
  money, he's given a job and the job is collect and give out.
• 20:34
  And there's not supposed to be this discussion every day when
• 20:38
  he collects, who does he give to?
• 20:40
  They don't want to be bothered with it either.
• 20:41
  They want him to take care of everything.
• 20:43
  So then whatever is in his pocket, he continues to give out
• 20:47
  as as needed. But if every time he collects, I
• 20:54
  don't know, they have a weekly meeting, he's not allowed to
• 20:56
  give out the money until they discuss again who they're going
• 20:59
  to give to. So, so to now, they're not
• 21:02
  allowed. He's not allowed to give out the
• 21:04
  money without their permission. You should just give it to them
• 21:07
  to give out. What happens if they're not
• 21:14
  talking terms anymore? They're not talking, they're
• 21:17
  really upset at each other and they're not going to discuss it.
• 21:20
  So then, and they can't agree what to do.
• 21:25
  So then, yeah, I said goodbye, Mashi, it's goodbye, she has
• 21:29
  said about the bar mitzvah. So if they can't work it out and
• 21:33
  they're not talking terms, yeah, he's holding the money.
• 21:36
  So he gives out the money accordingly to how he sees fit.
• 21:41
  Just has to make sure it's for its seductive fund.
• 21:43
  OK, let's do one more. Hey, Michiyasha Medina, Shlo
• 21:48
  Shimyomo, Kofi Noto, a person that's been in the city for 30
• 21:52
  days. He moves into a city, he's
• 21:53
  living there for 30 days. So now we force him to chip in
• 21:58
  like he's part of the city. Letainstucca la Kupa.
• 22:01
  As long as he's visiting for at least 30 days now, he becomes
• 22:05
  obligated in participating, donating towards this weekly
• 22:08
  kupa. Even Binaya Medina like
• 22:11
  everybody else, Yashasham Shlo Shakodashim once he's there for
• 22:14
  three months, Kofi Natalie taking the Tamkoi.
• 22:17
  Now we force him to pay into this daily Tamkoi.
• 22:20
  Yashasham Shishakodashim, once he's there for six months, Kofi
• 22:25
  Natalie taking slack of a suit, Shima Khasimba and Yahir, if
• 22:28
  he's there for six months, then he's obligated to give to join
• 22:32
  the funds to contribute towards like everybody else, towards
• 22:36
  clothing for the like everybody else.
• 22:39
  Yasha Shamtisha Kodashian once he's there for nine months,
• 22:42
  Kofi. So then he has to chip in for
• 22:49
  the Khavra Kadisha. And nowadays I think they do
• 22:51
  well, but it depends on the situation and right they need to
• 22:56
  collect for the Khavra Kadisha. Then after nine months,
• 23:01
  whatever's needed, we're talking about a person who says I'm
• 23:06
  coming to visit and I'm not coming here permanently.
• 23:10
  I'm leaving after a week or after a few months, whatever it
• 23:13
  is, fine. But if he's planning to, he
• 23:17
  moves in there, he's not. He's planning to stay there for
• 23:20
  good. So then Kofino told me.
• 23:23
  So then that's immediate. Whenever you have a new city
• 23:27
  being formed. The assumption is if people are
• 23:30
  moving into this brand new city, they're not travelling, they're
• 23:33
  not just visiting for a few weeks or a month because they
• 23:36
  wouldn't go to this brand new city.
• 23:38
  It's not easy to live in a brand new city with all the dust and
• 23:41
  construction going on and lack of resources.
• 23:44
  So you wouldn't. So therefore, again, it depends
• 23:47
  on the situation, depends on them and see us.
• 23:49
  But then, right, if we're assuming you're there, it's for
• 23:52
  good, then Kofi, Intel, Miyaad, Vyesh, Omrim, the Bisman, Azem,
• 23:56
  Mishary, Mako, Mako, Bislosa, Yom and the Minagas.
• 24:02
  Some say for everything we go by 3030 days.