Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / 7th Heaven (1927)
Transcript
- 0:00Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome
- 0:03to once upon a time at the Oscars Hello everyone
- 0:38and welcome to Once Upon a Time at the Oscars.
- 0:42The show that takes you through every Best Picture
- 0:45nominee from 1927 to today. I'm your host Kyle.
- 0:49And I am your co -host Ryan. And today we start
- 0:53at 1927. I noticed you said both those things
- 0:56and it's funny. We can flip it and talk about
- 0:581927 today. Because we're doing our first entry
- 1:01of 1927. I am so excited to be returning to this
- 1:06year once again. It feels like, I don't know,
- 1:10just retouching such a pivotal point in my life.
- 1:14Because the first time I covered this on the
- 1:17first iteration of this podcast, it was episode
- 1:19one and it started a transformation in how I
- 1:24consume. Yeah, absolutely. Because it's less,
- 1:29I mean, it's all entertainment, but it's more
- 1:31looking at it through a historical lens, right?
- 1:34Like gathering information rather than just enjoying
- 1:37the emotion of it. Yeah, and kind of forcing
- 1:39myself to sit down with more of an open mind
- 1:42than I had been up to that point in my life.
- 1:44So it's almost like a weird anniversary that
- 1:47doesn't fall on a date, but rather an event.
- 1:50Happy anniversary, brother. Thanks, man. I appreciate
- 1:52it. I'm so happy for you. This was... It was
- 1:55interesting for me because, you know, I haven't
- 1:57really used any kind of streaming service like
- 2:00Tubi before. I think Tubi has always kind of
- 2:03been heralded as like, you know, if you want
- 2:05to watch Anaconda, download Tubi. And it has
- 2:08a lot of movies like that. So when you told me
- 2:10that, it was, you know, the first time I had
- 2:11actually downloaded it and actually watched something
- 2:13on there. So it was interesting for that. It's
- 2:15also just really interesting to kind of go back
- 2:17and watch a movie this aged. Right. Like just
- 2:201927 is what we're talking about today for this
- 2:24one. And I mean, the crazy thing is like, you
- 2:27can feel it, but you also can't like the way
- 2:30that it's shot and some of the scenes and especially
- 2:33like the acting, it just doesn't feel that old.
- 2:37Yeah. Right. It feels kind of like, and time
- 2:39gets away from me so easily, but you can kind
- 2:41of be like, you know, this is pretty good for
- 2:43the fifties and you're like, Oh, it's 27. Right.
- 2:45Yeah. Yeah. And it's, it's always funny to me.
- 2:49Certain movies that we'll be covering for the
- 2:51show have been restored and, you know, they're
- 2:55brought up to 4K resolution and things. Yeah.
- 2:58So what you're watching isn't really how it was
- 3:00presented back then, but it makes it that much
- 3:02harder to be like, oh, this is almost 100 years
- 3:05old. We'll definitely cover some movies on the
- 3:08show where you're going to feel it. Yeah. Yeah,
- 3:11yeah, yeah. I mean, we'll get to it here in a
- 3:13minute, but I certainly felt a bit of it with
- 3:15this one. I'm very excited. You know, this is
- 3:17the first one that we're talking about. This
- 3:18is numerically alphabetically the first one of
- 3:22the three lists of what we're going to be talking
- 3:24about. And, you know, I have I think I have a
- 3:28passion for all. forms of film. So talkies, silent,
- 3:34doesn't matter. And, you know, we talked about
- 3:36this. I ran into you. You texted me a couple
- 3:39months ago and you asked if I want to go see
- 3:41Wings at The Strand. And I so desperately did.
- 3:44But at the time that you texted me, I was at
- 3:46brunch with some friends and I was with them
- 3:50in the morning. I forget what we were doing.
- 3:51But anyways, we ended up at the square and I
- 3:53was like, oh, that's where The Strand is. And
- 3:55I looked at the time. I was like, oh, that's
- 3:57when Wings is getting out. I should see if Kyle's
- 3:59there. And like, lo and behold, you're just standing
- 4:01outside of the Strand. And we caught up for a
- 4:03bit. And we started talking about these movies
- 4:05and it being silent in our experience with them.
- 4:08And for me, I remember telling you, you know,
- 4:10I loved The Artist. And I know The Artist isn't
- 4:12like a true silent film because that came out
- 4:14in like, you know, 2012 or whenever it was. But
- 4:17I thought that it perfectly encapsulated how
- 4:20I like to think that I feel about silent films.
- 4:23And then I go and I watch, you know, A Trip to
- 4:25the Moon. Loved that. I go and watch Wings. I
- 4:29love that. So I feel like I have a passion for
- 4:32silent films and the structure of it. And for
- 4:34anyone who's unaware, maybe it's no one, the
- 4:36idea of these silent films is that it was at
- 4:38a time where they just could not capture the
- 4:40audio. This wasn't something they could include.
- 4:42So the idea was that it had an orchestral piece
- 4:45behind it. And that orchestral piece is meant
- 4:49to, much like normal scores now, fill the...
- 4:53void so to speak without any kind of um dialogue
- 4:56so of course while there's dialogue on screen
- 4:58for some things we'll get into um there's an
- 5:02orchestral piece behind it that is set to like
- 5:05you know remind you of the mood And make sure
- 5:07that you feel the tone that you were supposed
- 5:09to feel in that moment. And I think that's where
- 5:11the success kind of really stems for with me,
- 5:14right? Can you feel the acting despite not hearing
- 5:17them? Is the story interesting? And does the
- 5:19music really take you through that journey? And
- 5:22those are three points that I really tried to
- 5:24look at with these three movies specifically.
- 5:26And I'm very excited to talk about Seventh Heaven
- 5:28with you because I think there's a really big,
- 5:30I'll just say conspiracy, that has... recently
- 5:34been brought to my attention that I think would
- 5:37change how some people watch these movies. And
- 5:39I want to make sure, or at least this movie specifically,
- 5:41and I'd love to talk about that with people.
- 5:43So very much looking forward to this episode.
- 5:45Awesome. I'm so excited. So you dropped the title
- 5:50of the movie. Episode one, we're covering Seventh
- 5:53Heaven, directed by Frank Borzage. The studio
- 5:56that produced this movie was Fox, one of the
- 5:59big five. from back in the day. This was an adaptation
- 6:02of a Benjamin Glazer stage play, and it's starring
- 6:06Janet Gaynor, who I adore, and Charles Farrell,
- 6:10who is a tank. Did you feel that way? What do
- 6:13you mean? Don't you think, doesn't he just seem
- 6:15like a massive man? Yes. I think when I think
- 6:19of tank, I think of like big and beefy. He's
- 6:21not beefy. He's very big. Okay. Very tall, but
- 6:24not in a lanky way, right? It's not like he's
- 6:26a noodle. Sure, yeah. But he's very tall. I'm
- 6:29small, so tank is a broad word for me. Copy.
- 6:34Yeah, no, I understand now. I mean, to be honest,
- 6:36the way he stands is very broad. Yeah. Like his
- 6:39shoulders are kind of further out than you would
- 6:41think they would be. So yeah, I hear what you're
- 6:43saying. He's just, he's a very handsome, imposing
- 6:47force to me. To use his words, quite a remarkable
- 6:50fellow. Yes, he is. I really like that quote.
- 6:54I didn't love how he said it twice. I have thoughts
- 6:56on that. I think it's kind of the thing where
- 6:58you're like, I'm a really nice guy. It's like,
- 6:59you can't say that. Listen. Someone else has
- 7:02to say that. We're already fighting. I love that
- 7:04line. Do you mind if I get into the award nominations
- 7:08for this? Please do. Is that okay? Yeah, that
- 7:10would be remarkable. So for 1927, the awards
- 7:12that we saw specifically, or nominations for
- 7:15this rather, Outstanding Picture, which was very
- 7:17much the title at the time, whereas now we would
- 7:19see, you know, Best Picture. Best Director. They
- 7:22didn't care about that one. They just wanted
- 7:23to make sure everyone knew. Frank Borzage. Is
- 7:26that correct? That is correct. Frank Borzage
- 7:28was nominated for Best Director, and he won.
- 7:30Is that okay? You weren't talking about winning?
- 7:33Yeah, you know, I used to keep it a secret until
- 7:36the ceremony episode. Yeah. The idea is for this
- 7:39to be historical and factual. I think it's important
- 7:41to announce that. I think so, too. During the
- 7:43episode. Because theoretically, they should be
- 7:46like, I wonder if he won. Oh, he did. And then
- 7:47watch or listen to the ceremony and be like,
- 7:49yeah, I know that. You shouldn't listen to the
- 7:51history podcast and then be like, go find out
- 7:54for yourself. Can you imagine if we're like,
- 7:56yeah, the war happened, but if you want to know
- 7:58what happens? At the end of it, skip six episodes
- 8:01ahead. Yeah, good luck. No spoilies. Best Actress,
- 8:03as Kyle mentioned, Janet Gaynor was nominated
- 8:07and did in fact win for Best Actress. Best Writing
- 8:10for Adapted Screenplay was Benjamin Glazer, nominated
- 8:13and won that one as well. And for Best Art Direction,
- 8:16Harry Oliver was nominated but did not win. And
- 8:20it was nominated for Best Outstanding Film, which
- 8:22it did mention, or Outstanding Picture, but did
- 8:24not win. So right off the bat, the interesting
- 8:27thing about the nominations in general for this
- 8:30year. There was Outstanding Picture. However,
- 8:32there was also Unique and Artistic Picture. Why
- 8:36was that? I don't know. Oops. I think Outstanding
- 8:40Picture was meant to be what Best Picture is
- 8:44now. It's like the most... impactful movie of
- 8:49the year the most important and successful movie
- 8:52interesting outstanding and artistic i i think
- 8:55was meant to be more focused on the artistic
- 8:58elements of that film I have appreciation for
- 9:02that because I feel like there are definitely
- 9:04years of the Oscars since then where I have wanted
- 9:07to give an award to a movie because I knew it
- 9:10should win, but then give an award to a movie
- 9:12because it actually is the best. Right. And I
- 9:15think if we kept this same style of outstanding
- 9:19picture and outstanding achievement in picture,
- 9:21I guess, we wouldn't have Green Book as a best
- 9:24picture. Right, right. There's some benefit there.
- 9:27Yeah, I think it's interesting, too, because...
- 9:29The Academy or the audience, what the Academy
- 9:32thinks the audience wants, this is a very personal
- 9:35opinion, they want to add that category for like
- 9:38popular film. Sure. That's kind of how I feel
- 9:42this first year is, where the three movies that
- 9:44were nominated for Outstanding Picture kind of
- 9:47lean more towards what people enjoyed the most.
- 9:51Whereas the Outstanding, excuse me, the Unique
- 9:54and Artistic Picture is more of the... to sound
- 9:58pretentious or snobby, like the... Elevated choice.
- 10:02Yes. Thank you for that. And of course they did
- 10:05this because in 90 years they want to make sure
- 10:06they can get Endgame an honorary Oscar. Exactly.
- 10:09Yeah. Yeah. I do think these three films that
- 10:12were nominated for unique... an artistic picture,
- 10:15there's some great movies in there. But Seventh
- 10:17Heaven was not one of them, correct? No, it was
- 10:19not. Interesting. So I guess I should probably
- 10:20save that discussion for the ceremony. No, no,
- 10:22no, that's great. I just want to make sure I
- 10:23didn't miss that. And I was wondering if it did
- 10:25win, if it was nominated. No, no. The three there
- 10:28and the three for artistic are different from
- 10:31the three for outstanding. Isn't that refreshing
- 10:33when you can look at Best Picture and Best International
- 10:36and not worry about any overlap in that? As someone
- 10:39that... Makes an effort to watch everything that
- 10:42was nominated in every category. Okay, never
- 10:44mind. That's true. I like the overlaps. You've
- 10:46benefited from that. Right. But it was always
- 10:48scary for me seeing something like Amelia Perez
- 10:51not win Best International, and you're like,
- 10:52we're not out of the woods yet. Right, yeah.
- 10:55That's fair. Jeez. And that movie's going to
- 10:58be catching strays for a while. Another interesting
- 11:00thing about the nominations is these actors and
- 11:04these people nominated. they weren't held to
- 11:07just one performance or one entry. Janet Gaynor
- 11:11was nominated for Best Actress, but it wasn't
- 11:13just for Seventh Heaven. It was for three films,
- 11:16the other two being Street Angel and Sunrise,
- 11:20which was one of those unique and artistic nominations.
- 11:23So I appreciate you bringing that up because
- 11:25that was a question that I had was, I saw that
- 11:27she won Best Actress for two other movies, and
- 11:30one of them was in the same year. As Seventh
- 11:33Heaven, 1927. So the technicality there was that,
- 11:36was it that she won this one award for those
- 11:39three movies or she won three awards for those
- 11:41three movies? She won one award for her performances
- 11:45overall that year. Oh, so it's more achievement
- 11:48in your performance for those years and encompass
- 11:53these movies. Exactly. Rather than winning for
- 11:54this movie. Exactly. Interesting. So if you go
- 11:58back and you look at the records, you will see
- 12:00that Seventh Heaven. won an Oscar for Best Actress,
- 12:03but so did Street Angel, and so did Sunrise.
- 12:06Interesting. Is it because it was the same person?
- 12:09Or if it was different people, they still would
- 12:10have... It's because it's the same person. Like,
- 12:12I don't think they... She got one Oscar, but
- 12:15on paper, those three films won. Almost in the
- 12:18same way that every year there's like a Cecil
- 12:20B. DeMille award, right? And it's more like your
- 12:23achievement. Exactly. Overall. This was just
- 12:26for that contained time span. That makes a lot
- 12:28of sense. The Academy obviously did away with
- 12:30this very quickly. The next Academy Awards, they
- 12:33don't have any of this multiple movies business,
- 12:35and they don't have the unique and artistic film.
- 12:37There is just outstanding picture or best picture
- 12:39or whatever they called it at the time. I like
- 12:42that. I think that's great. I mean, one thing
- 12:43that's kind of blowing my mind about this, I
- 12:45mean, I know it's very much the first movie we're
- 12:47talking about and the first Academy Awards that
- 12:50existed. Can you imagine being the first best
- 12:53director, first best actress to win that award?
- 12:56Yeah. Like that's just got to be, you couldn't
- 12:58tell me nothing. Right. It's so weird because
- 13:02I kind of tiptoe the line of, oh, I would feel
- 13:04just like the. greatest person in the world i'm
- 13:08the first best this yeah cool but then also it
- 13:11being the first i wonder if there would be a
- 13:13part of me that's like oh the academy doesn't
- 13:15have the rep reason or the the reputation that
- 13:18it does now so is this is this a big deal or
- 13:21is it what everyone says about the academy it's
- 13:24just a bunch of my peers pat me on the back a
- 13:26little bit i'm gonna choose to believe that a
- 13:28uh actor or actress of any time receiving an
- 13:31award that says best is gonna be Pretty high
- 13:34honor. Totally. Yeah. Totally. If you're an actor
- 13:37now, an up and coming actor, and you're entering
- 13:41your movie into like a small film festival, local
- 13:43film festival, and you win best anything, covet
- 13:46that like it is an Academy Award. Yep. Feature,
- 13:49indie, doesn't matter. Yeah. That's the best.
- 13:51Yeah. When I said I didn't know how I would feel,
- 13:54that's because I have a low personal value. Oh,
- 14:00okay. And I'm trying to stand on the right side
- 14:02of that and be like, yeah, look what I did and
- 14:04not be like, it doesn't matter. I don't want
- 14:07to take the Eeyore stance. Yeah, no, of course.
- 14:09Nor should you. I got to tell you too, I'm not
- 14:13trying to talk down to celebrities or actors
- 14:16or actresses. If I went to a fast food restaurant,
- 14:19they're like, you're the best order we've ever
- 14:21had. I would be honored. I would take that. That
- 14:26would be the rest of my day. So my point is,
- 14:28if I was Janet Gaynor in this specific instance,
- 14:31I would just be like, well, there's the name
- 14:34of the movie, Sabbath Heaven. Yeah, there you
- 14:36go. Speaking of Janet Gaynor, her and Charles
- 14:38Farrell, how did you feel about their chemistry?
- 14:40Should we talk about the plot of the movie first?
- 14:43Let's talk about the plot, yeah. The movie takes
- 14:45place in... Paris. 1910s, right? 1910s, yeah.
- 14:49So Charles Farrell plays a street cleaner, a
- 14:52sewage worker, actually, named Chico. He works
- 14:56down in the sewers, cleaning them out. We first
- 14:58see him, he's taking clothes and rags and stuff
- 15:01that found their way into the sewer system. He's
- 15:03very ambitious. He believes that there are great
- 15:06things on the horizon for him. He is destined
- 15:09to do remarkable things. Because he is a remarkable
- 15:14fellow. I love that line. I think I said it on
- 15:17mic. Was that during mic? I believe you did.
- 15:20Yeah. Okay. Well, I'm saying it again now. I
- 15:22like that line. And then Janet Gaynor plays Diane,
- 15:26who lives with her sister? Nana is her name,
- 15:31but she is her sister. Yeah. Which, that was
- 15:33very confusing. Yeah. I was like, the dog from
- 15:36Peter Pan? Right. I did both. I was like, so
- 15:39the dog from Peter Pan or her grandmother. And
- 15:42it's neither. It's her sister. Yeah. Nana is
- 15:44very abusive to Diane. Very. It's honestly pretty
- 15:49rough to watch, even from today's lens. Especially
- 15:52if you have the right soundtrack. So, Diane is
- 15:55abused by her sister. Don't make me laugh while
- 15:59I'm talking about this. Diana's abused by her
- 16:01sister. It's not a funny thing, Kyle. No, it's
- 16:03terrible. You're right. She's physically abused
- 16:06by her sister. And at one point, they are specifically
- 16:09looking to be relocated to a nicer house, right?
- 16:13By their uncle, is it? Yeah. And in a moment
- 16:16that I don't fully understand, because they benefit
- 16:18both from it greatly, all she has to do in that
- 16:22moment, Diane, is lie and say that things have
- 16:26been fine and that they'll go to a different
- 16:28place. Right. But she can't lie to her uncle.
- 16:32Right, right. Because the uncle shows up and
- 16:33says, listen, if you guys have been good. Yes.
- 16:36Then you can come with us. We'll give you a place
- 16:38to live and we'll be a happy family. Right. And
- 16:40not being able to lie to her uncle, she says
- 16:43things have not been good. And she actually does
- 16:46abuse me a good bit. Yeah. To which the uncle
- 16:49says, I don't want any part of that. Right. And
- 16:52leaves. And Nana then proceeds to just think
- 16:56this is probably a good thing to keep going and
- 16:58just continues to abuse her enough to a point
- 17:01where they take it outside. Absolutely. Nana
- 17:03chases her down the street. It's very dramatic,
- 17:05very brutal what she's doing. She gets to the
- 17:08point where she is about to kill Diane. She has
- 17:11her choked out, right? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And
- 17:13our hero Chico shows up, sees what's going on.
- 17:16Literally out of the sewer. Yeah. Just like pops
- 17:18right out. And he sees what's happening. He's
- 17:21a good guy. He's destined to do great things.
- 17:24He rescues Diane. And in what I think is just
- 17:27a fantastic moment, he pulls Nana off of Diane
- 17:30and then grabs her by the wrist and dangles her
- 17:33over the sewer just to get her to calm down.
- 17:35And he's like, all right, now we can talk like
- 17:37adults. Yeah. And shoes her away, saves Diane.
- 17:41But Chico, you know, he stepped in to help her.
- 17:44But he's not there to take on that responsibility.
- 17:47You can tell. Well, he has Nana make a promise,
- 17:50not one that he's going to take very seriously,
- 17:51more just to your point to scare her, that she
- 17:54can never show her face around there again. Right.
- 17:57Which kind of pushes her into a area of seclusion
- 18:01where she's not really part of the picture anymore.
- 18:02Sure. But to your point, it's not a, hey, she's
- 18:05with me now. Leave me alone. Leave us alone.
- 18:07It's more. Don't talk to her again or don't see
- 18:10me. Thanks. I'm going back about my day. Exactly.
- 18:12Yeah. And it's not until Nana shows back up with
- 18:15the police. Yeah. Saying, oh, there she is. You
- 18:19want to arrest anybody? Arrest her. She's a vagrant.
- 18:22She doesn't need to be on the streets. Blah,
- 18:23blah, blah. Chico, again, wants to help. So he
- 18:27takes the opportunity to say, hey, this isn't
- 18:29right. I saw what was going on. You can't take
- 18:32her. This is my wife. And I love this part because
- 18:35the police officer is like, really? You sure?
- 18:38This seems weird to me, but okay. Sounds good.
- 18:41At this point, and this is one of my favorite
- 18:43parts of that moment, when he saves Diane, he
- 18:47kind of quite literally drags her to their eating
- 18:49spot and just sits her down, and then he and
- 18:53his buddies just eat, and that's when the cops
- 18:54come up. They're just like, hey, romantic couple,
- 18:57are you just eating on the street and chilling
- 18:59out by this car? Right. As you do. Exactly, yeah.
- 19:02So I share his hesitation. Really? Yeah, this
- 19:05looks a little weird. How come she's not having
- 19:07any of that bread? Yeah. What's going on? But
- 19:10the police officer says, okay, fine. If that's
- 19:13what's going on, cool. I want to make sure, though,
- 19:16I'm going to come back later. If you guys aren't
- 19:18still married, then one, I'm going to take her
- 19:21away, and two, you're going to lose your job.
- 19:24Yep. And Chico loves his job. He just had an
- 19:27opportunity to become a street cleaner. So he
- 19:31gets to come out from the sewers and actually
- 19:33work where there's sunlight. So, of course, Chico,
- 19:36he doesn't want this to happen. He's stressed
- 19:38out because now he's got to pretend to be married
- 19:41to this woman he knows nothing about. And doesn't
- 19:44seem interested in. Right. Yeah. But he says,
- 19:47okay, fine. They agree. You can come live with
- 19:49me. Just stick around until the cops show up.
- 19:53But then you're out. You're on your own. To kind
- 19:55of sum everything up, they end up falling in
- 19:57love. They do. It's very remote. remote remarkable
- 20:01what was i gonna say romantic it mostly takes
- 20:04place you went through all your r words yeah
- 20:06and you're like not there yet it is remote though
- 20:08it mostly does take place in the apartment that
- 20:10is true this is true yeah and the apartment so
- 20:13to to get out of the beat by beat story bits
- 20:15and to talk more about how this was filmed and
- 20:17just what kind of movie it is the apartment is
- 20:19a beautiful setting to me oh my god Like to a
- 20:23point where I thought that I kind of missed.
- 20:25I mean, I did, but I thought I missed a good
- 20:27bit in the first like 20, 25 minutes because
- 20:30I'm seeing them live on the street. I'm seeing
- 20:32them like eat on the street. And like he, his
- 20:34best friend, his coworker is named rat. Like
- 20:38I love the rat. Well, I thought it was like,
- 20:40I was like, that's rude. And then like the next
- 20:42shot is him close up. And like, he has the teeth.
- 20:45Okay. Nevermind. I understand right now. Yeah.
- 20:47So all of that to say. That when he's like, all
- 20:50right, come back to my place, I'm expecting like,
- 20:53you know, something from like Aladdin. Like,
- 20:55you know, I found this nice little hole in the
- 20:56wall. My guy has like at least a five bedroom.
- 21:00Right. Like. It's massive. It's huge. It's like
- 21:03when you first see Monica's apartment and friends
- 21:06and you're like. How? I'm so relieved that you
- 21:10said that because everyone entering in through
- 21:12his window made me think of Monica's apartment
- 21:14and friends. Yeah. Not that they would do that,
- 21:17but like it's just this large open space in the
- 21:18middle of the room. Right. And everyone would
- 21:21just walk right in. And seeing that, I was like,
- 21:23I mean, look, I understand it's 1927 and like,
- 21:26you know, not being very wealthy at the time
- 21:28may not have afforded you too much. This is a
- 21:30lot. Yeah. Like, I'd be very happy in this life.
- 21:32And it's overseeing the streets of Paris. Exactly.
- 21:35It's beautiful. Pretty great. Gorgeous. Pretty
- 21:38great. I love it too. Probably the best shot
- 21:42in the movie is when he's bringing Diane up to
- 21:45his apartment. Yeah. They're walking up this
- 21:47stairwell. Circular stairwell. Yes. Thank you.
- 21:51The camera starts, you can see through the wall.
- 21:54So you're looking at the ground floor of the
- 21:56stairwell. And as they walk up, the camera moves
- 21:58up as well, probably on a crane of some sort.
- 22:00And it follows them all the way up. So you're
- 22:03seeing. Just how high he goes from where he works
- 22:06in the sewers all the way up to this gorgeous
- 22:09apartment overlooking the streets of Paris. And
- 22:12that's what leads to my personal favorite quote
- 22:14of the movie, where he tells Diane, I work in
- 22:16the sewer, but I live near the stars. So nice.
- 22:20How do you not fall in love with someone who
- 22:23speaks that type of poetry? You know? It's a
- 22:26very good point. I think, you know, it was, should
- 22:29we get into it? Should I just say it? Yeah, let's
- 22:33talk about it. Okay. So there's a couple ways
- 22:36that you can watch this movie, audience. And
- 22:38the way that was introduced to me, because this
- 22:40is Kyle's fault, was that Kyle told me that you
- 22:42can watch all of them on Tubi, which is totally
- 22:44true. This is true. This is a fact. You absolutely
- 22:46can. Both. All three, Seventh Heaven, The Racket,
- 22:50and Wings are available on Tubi. However, I did
- 22:53watch Seventh Heaven on Tubi. And I texted Kyle
- 22:57halfway through the movie. I actually had to
- 22:59watch this in two sittings. I texted him halfway
- 23:01through and I was like, yeah, man, I need like
- 23:03one more song added onto the 7th Heaven soundtrack.
- 23:07And he was like, oh? And I was like... Just told
- 23:12them it's just unbearable. Like, I don't understand.
- 23:15Movies are supposed to be like, you know, I know
- 23:17it's 1927. I know it's a silent film. Movies
- 23:20are supposed to have, you know, like a score
- 23:22that really like soars with it, especially in
- 23:24a silent film. You need a score that's going
- 23:26to like meet you at the emotions and help you
- 23:28feel that grand nature. And having one song that's
- 23:32three to four minutes long on a loop where you
- 23:35can literally hear the record player stop and
- 23:38then start again. for two hours is miserable.
- 23:42And I believe that with my whole chest going
- 23:45into today's call or meeting, right? So it was
- 23:49in the end of the last episode, and I hope you
- 23:52can go back and listen to it, where Kyle mentions
- 23:55that you can also watch it on YouTube. And there's
- 23:57something that clicks in my head where I said,
- 24:00oh, no. And it's dawned on me now that there
- 24:05are two different versions that are available,
- 24:06one on Tubi and then the regular edition. the
- 24:10normal edition with the regular score, the intended
- 24:13score on YouTube. And that intended score is
- 24:16dynamic and meets the tone where it needs to
- 24:20be. And it's an amazing theme. And we listened
- 24:22to it off pod for like five minutes and it sounds
- 24:26great. And I'm very eager to go back and watch
- 24:28seventh heaven with the correct score. But with
- 24:30that being said, it did sour my experience of
- 24:33my first time with seventh heaven to a point
- 24:35and tying it back to what you were just saying.
- 24:37Where whenever Chico was saying he was a remarkable
- 24:40fellow, I was like, this guy is a pick me. This
- 24:42guy has to be like, I'm the nice guy. And that's
- 24:45not the case. And it's totally just me watching
- 24:47the score and being like annoyed by it. But to
- 24:50say what I loved about it. Oh my God, the sets.
- 24:53I thought that the set of him working like in
- 24:55the very beginning, working in the sewer and
- 24:57like being able to like see the water flowing
- 24:59through the streets of Paris and like look up
- 25:01and like see the streets of Paris as well. I
- 25:03thought that that's the set design was incredible.
- 25:06Again, the apartment is like what you would want.
- 25:09The streets are great. Like I thought that the
- 25:11set design was remarkable. And I wish that it
- 25:14got a little bit more love for that. But again,
- 25:17at the time, they didn't have awards for this
- 25:19specific thing. Well, they did. It was nominated
- 25:20for art direction. Oh, it was. So there was that.
- 25:23It did not win, but you know, it was recognized
- 25:25at least. Okay, very good. You're correct. Art
- 25:27direction. Thank you so much. Didn't win. I'm
- 25:29not going to say should have. We'll get to that
- 25:31with the ceremony. But I thought that was great.
- 25:33And I thought that Chico became much more likable
- 25:36over time. I thought that Diane and Jeanette
- 25:40Gaynor, correct? Janet Gaynor. Janet Gaynor.
- 25:42I thought she was remarkable. I thought she was
- 25:45great. She played it so well. It really did make
- 25:48me buy their relationship. It didn't just feel
- 25:50like, oh, we have to fall in love because that's
- 25:52what the story tells us to do. Right. You could
- 25:54see her actually like caring for him in that
- 25:56moment and like him being, I'm not saying this
- 25:59in a negative way, dumb enough to not realize
- 26:01he's falling in love. Yeah. Right. Like he's
- 26:03kind of going through the motions but doesn't
- 26:04recognize that's what he's feeling. Right. And
- 26:06it's not really until like he realizes what she
- 26:10does for him. and the life that he, she gives
- 26:13him. Cause at first I think he feels it as like,
- 26:15or sees it as he's getting a service for this,
- 26:18for being like the hero. Right. She's cooking.
- 26:20She's giving him haircuts. Yes. Which the haircut
- 26:24scene was interesting because he was admiring
- 26:25himself for a long time. He was like, this haircut
- 26:28rocks. He's a remarkable fellow. He's a remarkable
- 26:30fellow. It's true. It's a remarkable haircut.
- 26:33For a remarkable fellow. It was around that point
- 26:36where I think you can kind of see it click for
- 26:38him where he's like, well, I'd be a fool to pass
- 26:39this up. Right. I thought that was great. And
- 26:42I came back around in his performance. And I
- 26:45definitely view the movie a bit differently now,
- 26:46knowing. that it was a soured experience of an
- 26:49incorrect score. So anyone who's going to watch
- 26:51these movies, it is available on Tubi. However,
- 26:54do seek it out on YouTube where you can get the
- 26:56original intended soundtrack. Yeah, and just
- 26:59to speak on my perspective of that whole thing.
- 27:02You're a villain. Nope. I am a villain. And I
- 27:05had no idea that... That score did not exist
- 27:07on the Tubi version. I was just like, oh, cool.
- 27:09I mean, why would you? Yeah. Why would you even
- 27:11think that? Because I didn't watch it on Tubi
- 27:13the first time I saw it. Sure. Score aside, it
- 27:15is incredible that they are all available on
- 27:18streaming at all. Sure. At this point. They were
- 27:20not when I did the first iteration of the show.
- 27:23So I'm very excited that availability and the
- 27:25ease of access, the accessibility rather, for
- 27:28these movies has improved so much. Right. But
- 27:32when you sent me that text, I was like... What?
- 27:36What are you talking about, man? You know what
- 27:37I love about that? Not only was that for the
- 27:40first year, it's the first episode that we're
- 27:43covering. So a bit of you was probably like,
- 27:45did I pick the right co -host? This guy hates
- 27:48movies. And no, we've uncovered it. That was
- 27:51the problem. I am going to go back and show you
- 27:53the song or let you listen to the song that did
- 27:55play. I'm telling you it was misery. Oh, I believe
- 27:58it. Because I popped on the Tubi version. That
- 28:00was how I intended to be watched as well. You're
- 28:02right. And it started playing like it was one
- 28:05of those pianos in an old saloon that just plays
- 28:08by itself. Think about going into a saloon in
- 28:111917, okay, audience? 1917, you walk into a saloon,
- 28:15and the piano player is playing something. And
- 28:19you're like, this song is okay. And he says another
- 28:22one. and he does that for two hours and that
- 28:26was my experience of watching seventh heaven
- 28:28not ideal but still i can remove that from the
- 28:31equation and still very much say movie's pretty
- 28:33great i'm so glad i'm because when you did start
- 28:37saying like i've got my issues with it but we'll
- 28:40get to it i was like what happened well the issue
- 28:43was the experience and not the movie yeah and
- 28:45i thought about like oh should i tell you should
- 28:47i should i let him know hey you can watch it
- 28:50on youtube it's better no i don't want to expect
- 28:52him to have to watch it again blah blah blah
- 28:55so i was like i'll just leave it and it'll be
- 28:57content just so funny such good content uh you
- 29:00did it for the pod congratulations i think that
- 29:03was the right call and i i very much did enjoy
- 29:06my experience with it overall there's just a
- 29:09charm to it right i mean that's the whole point
- 29:11of it all but there's a charm of seeing like
- 29:13where these people came from and what they're
- 29:14able to achieve i think that there's there's
- 29:17some qualms that i have with it that don't necessarily
- 29:19like affect the grading you know if i was going
- 29:21to put it at b i don't think it's for this or
- 29:23another reason i think that there's some opportunities
- 29:26where there are dialogues happening between characters
- 29:29where there aren't title cards to share what
- 29:31they're saying right and there's a you know if
- 29:33someone's nodding or shaking their head or a
- 29:35very simple yes you don't need that but there's
- 29:37like a couple like 30 seconds where like people
- 29:39are having a conversation and you just don't
- 29:40know what they're saying sure and i think that
- 29:42there's some hesitancy there but the most important
- 29:45thing and that's how these movies existed back
- 29:47then was they're giving you the dialogue that
- 29:49you need for the story any other dialogue that's
- 29:52happening you have to trust in them that it's
- 29:53not pertinent to what you know about the story
- 29:57So there's like a tiny little thing that's a
- 29:59me thing and not a movie thing that stopped me
- 30:02from like really fully connecting with it. But
- 30:04that's on me and not the movie itself. That was
- 30:06very much of the time how these movies had to
- 30:08be made. Yeah. You know, it's interesting. In
- 30:11one of these books I'm reading, there was a title
- 30:14card writer that spoke about like how it is an
- 30:17art form. Oh, interesting. And the importance
- 30:18of it and how that really can make or break one
- 30:22of these silent films. Had they added a title
- 30:26card for every time they were having a conversation.
- 30:28Two and a half hours. You'd be sitting around.
- 30:30Well, yeah, the length of the movie would be
- 30:31long, but you'd also be reading so much. And
- 30:34ultimately, people were going to the movies for
- 30:36the visual. They weren't going to read. Of course.
- 30:39So it is hard to find this balance of providing
- 30:43enough information through text, but not just
- 30:46overbearing or overloading the audience with
- 30:49just hate. Read, read, read. Right. So that was
- 30:53really interesting. But I can totally understand,
- 30:55like, just being like, what are they saying?
- 30:57Yeah. Is this important? Well, imagine me being
- 31:00annoyed at the score. I know. And then that happening.
- 31:03And I just go full Omega, just like boomer parent.
- 31:07Just be like, well, am I supposed to know what
- 31:08they're saying? Right. So no, it was, again,
- 31:10totally a me experience. Of course, by me. I
- 31:13wasn't cursing your name at any point through
- 31:15it. I promise you. That's good. I mean, so overall,
- 31:18like, you know, you just saw. We talked about
- 31:21this a couple months ago. You've seen plenty
- 31:23of silent films. You've done your research with
- 31:24all these. How did Seventh Heaven hold up for
- 31:27you in that batch? I think the biggest element
- 31:31that makes Seventh Heaven an enjoyable film today
- 31:35are the performances, specifically with Janet
- 31:38Gaynor. Of course. The chemistry between her
- 31:43and Charles Farrell, I really, really enjoy.
- 31:45I think they make a great on -screen pairing.
- 31:48I think... specifically in this movie, his way
- 31:51of showing his love for her leads to so many
- 31:55cute interactions because he's almost playfully
- 31:58like, no, I'm, you know, I'm not super interested
- 32:01in you, but, you know, go ahead and open that
- 32:03box on the table. Oh, a wedding dress? How'd
- 32:07that get there? That kind of thing. Yeah. And
- 32:09her reaction to all of that and just the physicality
- 32:14behind her acting and just her appearance, her
- 32:16eyes are gorgeous and they are able to contain
- 32:20so much emotion. She's the highlight of this
- 32:24movie, without a doubt. Right. I think because
- 32:26of her and their chemistry, it allows this movie
- 32:30to hold up as something that can be enjoyed today.
- 32:34This is the type of movie that I would put on
- 32:35in the background. Well, I can't say background
- 32:38because silent movie, you kind of have to sit
- 32:40down and watch. A little bit. Well, the score
- 32:41is really good. Right. Yeah. If you're listening
- 32:43to it. I'm told. But, you know, something that
- 32:47I would sit down at night, wrap myself up in
- 32:50a blanket and just be like, you know, I'm going
- 32:52to fall asleep. I'm going to watch this and just
- 32:54enjoy the cute moments of their relationship.
- 32:57For sure. I enjoy this quite a bit. I think it
- 33:00holds up. Well, it's, you know, it has the...
- 33:02the the expected push and pull of she's very
- 33:06much i'm i'm committed i'm ready to win it and
- 33:09he's more hesitant right he's more this was an
- 33:12arrangement like you know there's a scene where
- 33:15she's cooking for him he said like you know typical
- 33:17the way through a man's heart is through his
- 33:20stomach i know what you're doing yeah once uh
- 33:22once the police come you're out of here And you
- 33:24start seeing him kind of like ease up on it a
- 33:27little bit because she's very much like, you
- 33:29know, the idea of getting married, having this
- 33:30dress, like being here with you. Your apartment's
- 33:32amazing, which it is. Honestly, more of a state
- 33:35than anything. Then you have him realizing that
- 33:37he's in love and seeing how eager he is to fall
- 33:41into that, I think was like just amazing. There's
- 33:44one scene I want to talk to you about, and it's
- 33:46where the police come to interrogate him. This
- 33:48is kind of like the crux of the story a little
- 33:50bit before the real crux comes in. And that was...
- 33:54interrogating them to make sure that they are
- 33:55actually married. Right. The whole purpose of
- 33:58the plot here. And the police officer does arrive,
- 34:01and he walks in, and he says, are you married?
- 34:04And they say, yes. And he walks into a room.
- 34:07That's the last time that we see that officer.
- 34:10Was there documentation? Did they have to wait
- 34:14three days? Did they not think that two people
- 34:18could be in a room and just be like, yeah, we're
- 34:19married? He'd be like, ah, damn it. You got me.
- 34:21Sorry. Well, he... He does ask them to kiss.
- 34:24Oh, he does, doesn't he? He says, hey, aren't
- 34:27you going to kiss your wife? Oh, yeah. And they're
- 34:29like, ooh, that's icky. Smooch. Yeah. Icky. Oh,
- 34:34Janet Gaynor like blushes or the equivalent of
- 34:37that when there's no color. Well, you could see
- 34:40the different color on her cheek, yeah. And that's
- 34:42why she's incredible. It's so good. Physical
- 34:44acting. So good. But him walking in just being
- 34:46like, are you still married? Just being like,
- 34:47okay. I love it too. The first thing he says
- 34:49when he walks in, he opens the door, he walks
- 34:51in and he says, I am a police detective. He does.
- 34:54That's true. So good. I got a big laugh out of
- 34:57that because he does hold his finger up too.
- 34:59Just like, it does feel a little bit like five
- 35:02seconds before the camera started rolling. They're
- 35:03like, hey, you're a police detective. He's like,
- 35:05I am a police detective. Yeah. You got to reassure.
- 35:08See, if Chico can say I'm a remarkable fellow.
- 35:11Then this guy absolutely can. Yeah. When I was
- 35:13taking notes, I told you I went to sit down and
- 35:15write notes. I started, I got to this part. And
- 35:18I wrote the equivalent of like, LOL, I am a police
- 35:22detective. I pulled out my notes from the original
- 35:24run of the show. Oh, no. I wrote the same thing.
- 35:27I really like that moment, I guess. It's great.
- 35:29No, it is a true. It is a true great moment.
- 35:32I do remember laughing really hard at that. I'm
- 35:34glad he said it, though, because he's not wearing
- 35:36like the typical police detective outfit. Yeah.
- 35:40So he kind of needs to say that. Right. I feel
- 35:43like you either need the attire, like you need
- 35:44the clothing department to help you out with
- 35:46that, or you need. a screenwriter to tell you
- 35:49what to say to sound like a police detective
- 35:50he was like i'll meet you in the middle i'll
- 35:52just say what a police detective would which
- 35:54is that i am a police detective which is good
- 35:56i hope they all announce when they enter but
- 35:59maybe not after the door open maybe when the
- 36:02door is closed and you're letting to know who's
- 36:03on the other side but fair play to be fair he
- 36:06is the only person who enters well that's not
- 36:08true i guess father uh vermillion was it at the
- 36:10end uh he comes through the door but otherwise
- 36:13everyone else just comes through the window yeah
- 36:16Yeah, it's very clear, so it explains it all.
- 36:17It's such a great show. Yeah. I love that show.
- 36:20We all need more windows that you can crawl in
- 36:22and out of. Inspired by this movie, actually.
- 36:24Was it really? No. Well, you know, the latter
- 36:29of it all. Yeah, which you would use to climb
- 36:31up to a window. Of course. So, tons of cute moments
- 36:34all leading up to that moment with... The police
- 36:37detective. Which is kind of the moment that he
- 36:40realizes that kiss is kind of like him recognizing
- 36:42what he has. Yeah. And if not that moment, two
- 36:46seconds later after the detective leaves, when
- 36:48she feels like, all right, that was the moment.
- 36:51Now I've got to leave. Yeah. And he says, you
- 36:54know, if you stuck around. It wouldn't be, you
- 36:57wouldn't be in my way. Yeah. I think like the
- 37:00line he says is something about like you're.
- 37:02You wouldn't be much in the way if you stayed.
- 37:05Yes. And it was just like, wow. Honestly, 1927,
- 37:09probably the most romantic thing a man has said.
- 37:11I think it's the perfect delivery for Chico,
- 37:14though. Yes. For him not to admit it. Right.
- 37:17It says, I want you here. I need you here. But
- 37:20don't make me say it. Right. Yeah. I loved it.
- 37:23She runs over. She's all excited. She kisses
- 37:26him again. There are so many cute moments like
- 37:29that. As we move forward, I mentioned a wedding
- 37:32dress. Chico's pretty much like, hey, there's
- 37:35a box on the table. I don't know. Maybe check
- 37:38it out. Yeah. She opens it, finds a dress, questions
- 37:42him about it, and he's like, you know. Won't
- 37:44fit me. Yeah. It's, it's, it's, I like his character.
- 37:51No, I do too. And I think a movie like this has
- 37:53to hinge on that, right? Because the dialogue
- 37:56can feel like them, but it's not very engaging
- 37:59on its own. So you really have to be all in on
- 38:01them. And you are. And I think for most films,
- 38:05it's worth pointing out that this is two hours.
- 38:07So I think feeling the length of the movie, you
- 38:11would kind of expect this to be the end. Right.
- 38:13We've reached the point where they've really
- 38:16overcome all of their struggles. They've found
- 38:18a way to be together and we're good, but it's
- 38:21not. And we have about 40, 35 minutes left in
- 38:23the movie. And that's where we introduce the
- 38:25idea of the war. Right. Right. World War One
- 38:30reaching France specifically is what really tears
- 38:33them apart because specifically Chico has to
- 38:36go join his brothers. Well, I say brothers, but
- 38:39he has to go join his. fellow frenchmen uh on
- 38:44the battle line and the thing that kind of got
- 38:47me i'm interested in your thought on this it's
- 38:49not a bad line i just made me laugh uh his buddy
- 38:51just shows up he's like hey man yeah we gotta
- 38:53go to war you got an hour he really does just
- 38:56tell him like yeah you know we're shipping off
- 38:58in an hour buddy you'll get everything you need
- 39:00and this is after they say that they're going
- 39:02to get married so they have to kind of rush the
- 39:05idea of getting married right now yeah And then
- 39:08that's the remainder of the movie is Chico off
- 39:10in war while I almost said Janet Diane stays
- 39:14back and very much has the apartment. That to
- 39:17me felt it was it caught me off guard because
- 39:22I felt like the natural progression of the story
- 39:25had kind of peaked. Right. Sure. So now we introduce
- 39:27this and then we kind of realize there's more
- 39:30to it in the sense that like Nana can still come
- 39:32back. and she does and she says a line that i
- 39:35thought was hilarious which is like i've been
- 39:36hiding in the sewers waiting for chico to leave
- 39:40and he finally did all it took was a war and
- 39:43now i can come back and get you to come home
- 39:47and i think that that again feels like a moment
- 39:49where you're like okay well here's the next 20
- 39:51minutes of her like being trapped by nana no
- 39:53she just like turns the table And just completely
- 39:56reverses roles and just actually like hits her
- 39:59until she leaves and runs out into the street.
- 40:01Which is beautiful because her inspiration for
- 40:04that comes from an earlier moment with Chico
- 40:06where he kind of teaches her not to be afraid
- 40:10anymore. Yeah. It's awesome. There's so many
- 40:12things that I think Janet, I'm sorry, I did the
- 40:15same thing. Diane learns from Chico that she
- 40:18then uses to find her independence from Nana.
- 40:20And Chico, you know, learns love. That he wasn't
- 40:24really focused on. He's focused on being something
- 40:26great. Yep. And he finds love instead. So they
- 40:29learn things from each other. But like you said,
- 40:32that scene with Nana, even though it's great
- 40:34when Diane finds her backbone and whips her away.
- 40:40Again, like, you know, good for her standing
- 40:42up for herself, but it is quite literally a scene
- 40:44of just like, they're beating each other with
- 40:47like a whip. With a belt, I think? Yeah, like
- 40:50a, what do they call them? Was it not a belt?
- 40:53Oh, no, it was like a bullwhip, wasn't it? I
- 40:55think so, yeah, it's a bullwhip. It was quite
- 40:57literally a bullwhip. Okay, great, yeah. Where
- 40:59they got that, who knows? But, yeah, no, she
- 41:01just quite literally grabs the bullwhip from
- 41:03Nana and just starts hitting her instead. I think
- 41:06there's a good 15 -minute scene, or 15 -second
- 41:09scene, where, like, Nana's just on the ground
- 41:11and she's just sitting here nonstop. Wailing
- 41:13on it. It's like, okay. I like that, too, though,
- 41:15because to your point, it was her, like, kind
- 41:16of, like, finding her self -confidence and her,
- 41:18like, you know, worth, but then very much still
- 41:20just, like, going in yeah right so she still
- 41:24has you know a little bit of built -up aggression
- 41:26on that and then that takes us back to the war
- 41:29right and chico is serving over there and ultimately
- 41:32what it leads to is uh chico has found his demise
- 41:35chico is dying and tells i just want to make
- 41:39sure i'm getting this right is it father chef
- 41:41chevilla chevillon chevillian i don't know how
- 41:44to pronounce that we'll say chevillon uh because
- 41:46i'm not going to say chevelle uh father chevellon
- 41:49he tells the father to pass on his necklace that
- 41:53he kind of acted as rings for them right right
- 41:56in lieu of rings they had necklaces they gave
- 41:57each other and he had his necklace and he told
- 42:00the father to give that to diane and to tell
- 42:02her that he uh was dying and was and died looking
- 42:06up right yes and he passes Father heads back
- 42:11to France. Word has already kind of gotten out
- 42:13through some other people. So Diane's being told
- 42:14in the moment. And it's not until the father
- 42:17shows up and hands her the necklace that she
- 42:19actually kind of starts accepting that this is
- 42:20real. And while this is happening, cue moments
- 42:23of the mist, the war is breaking up and the war
- 42:27has ended. And the streets of France are celebrating
- 42:30while she's having like the worst news of her
- 42:32life. And what happens, Kyle? Hard to say, actually.
- 42:37I'm glad you feel the same way. Yeah. The ending
- 42:39of this movie is pretty bizarre. You're made
- 42:42to believe that Chico died. At no point did it
- 42:45seem like, hey, the light is fading from my eyes,
- 42:48so I'm pretty sure I'm dying. It was just very
- 42:50much like an explosion has happened, a shot has
- 42:52happened, and I'm not going to make it. Yes.
- 42:54But the movie does kind of just say, like, this
- 42:57is what's happening. Yes. Very much like the
- 42:59detective. I am a police detective. My name is
- 43:01Chico, and I'm dying. Yeah. Chico comes back.
- 43:03The streets are celebrating. Chico's running
- 43:06up the street just as Diane is just... Accepting?
- 43:11Is that what it is? She's like accepting his
- 43:13death. Yeah. Because she's still very much in
- 43:16the room with their friends, their couple friend
- 43:19actually, and the father. And my beef with this
- 43:23is that it's not really clarified what he thought
- 43:26he was dying of or like what they told him he
- 43:28was dying of. But even if it was blindness, he's
- 43:31running pretty healthily. Like he's running through
- 43:35the streets. We see him again in the streets
- 43:37of Paris, running through the crowded streets
- 43:39of people celebrating, trying to get back to
- 43:41his apartment. And if he's blind, he's navigating
- 43:45it very well. So the whole thing is just communicated
- 43:47not very well. So you think he's alive and just
- 43:49completely well. And he makes his way to the
- 43:51staircase, the circular staircase you mentioned
- 43:54earlier, climbs all the way up, gets through
- 43:56his room. And there's a moment where he walks
- 43:58in. And maybe this is the grain and the filter
- 44:01of a camera from 1927. But there's a shot where
- 44:05on the left side of the apartment is Diane and
- 44:07on the right side is Chico. And there's almost
- 44:10like an almost hazy filter over Chico where a
- 44:13part of me was thinking that this was like the
- 44:15ghost of Chico. Sure. Because it was so unexplained
- 44:20what happened with him that we just assumed he's
- 44:21still dead. And no one's really reacting. They're
- 44:24kind of looking at a door that might have just
- 44:25opened. So I thought this was more of a like,
- 44:27you know, even in death, she still sees him and
- 44:30is still with him. Yeah. But no, it's quite literal
- 44:33that he has survived and he's just blind. Another
- 44:36line that I really liked was they shot every
- 44:39shell they could at me and it couldn't kill me.
- 44:41Yeah. Because he is a remarkable fellow. Because
- 44:43he is a remarkable fellow. It's a really hard
- 44:46line to survive the war and come back and be
- 44:48like, they shot every bullet they could and it
- 44:51couldn't pierce me. But he is blind and that
- 44:54he still is looking up and they're able to be
- 44:57together and the movie ends. The ending was a
- 45:00little confusing for me and I'm glad to hear
- 45:02that it was for you too. I thought I missed something.
- 45:04Yeah. Wasn't fully explained. Yeah. So what I
- 45:07actually think it is, it's confusing to me because
- 45:10I think it is supposed to be very open -ended
- 45:12and very open for interpretation. Okay. Because
- 45:15you mentioned him running through the streets
- 45:16and, hey, you're doing a great job for someone
- 45:19who can't see. Sure. And you're literally pushing
- 45:22through people to where you're not going to know
- 45:24where you are. Exactly. Him showing up and kind
- 45:26of appearing a little phantom -esque is another
- 45:30reason. The last shot of the movie has Chico
- 45:34and Diane embracing and a light comes through
- 45:38the window focusing on the two of them, giving
- 45:41it a very heavenly, which makes sense. Sure.
- 45:45feel to it so much of that is like implied little
- 45:49clues of maybe this isn't really happening maybe
- 45:53this is diane's interpretation or a hallucination
- 45:57of what she hopes happens chico didn't die or
- 46:01chico did die but she believes oh he's gonna
- 46:04come back to me and he's blind like that sucks
- 46:07but he's not dead the audience gets to sit there
- 46:10and choose oh i like that ending It's a bummer
- 46:13that he's blind, but they're together, and that's
- 46:15what should happen. Or, oh, he really is dead,
- 46:18and now Diane, you know, God bless her soul.
- 46:22See, and I get that, and I think that there is
- 46:25some... complications that i have i always look
- 46:27for other characters right because of course
- 46:29she's gonna see chico is the father gonna see
- 46:32chico is their couple friend gonna see chico
- 46:34and when they do and they are in the room and
- 46:37they're looking at the door and everything that's
- 46:39opened that to me now has like you know this
- 46:41is happening to all of us and not just me right
- 46:43if it were a separate shot of diane grieving
- 46:46after everyone has left and that happens I think
- 46:48that's the perfect ending of what you're saying.
- 46:50Of like, you know, is she imagining this? Is
- 46:52it really happening? Who's to say? But we're
- 46:54in the moment with them, so it doesn't really
- 46:56matter. It's the inception, right? It doesn't
- 46:58matter what's happening. It matters what they're
- 47:00doing and how they feel. Having them witness
- 47:03it, to me, that complicates both endings a bit.
- 47:06Sure. But the way that I ended up choosing to
- 47:09see it was that they had to make it a very happy
- 47:11ending. So it is, you know, well, you know, I
- 47:14pay the price, I am blind, but I am able to be
- 47:16with you and I am alive. And that's ultimately,
- 47:18you know, God shines down on them through that
- 47:20light and they're basking in his light together.
- 47:23That's the way I took it. Sure. I can't say for
- 47:27sure. I think Frank Borsage wants it to be interpreted
- 47:32that way. Sure. A lot of his films are very super
- 47:37romantic, almost to the... what you would call
- 47:40now like the cheesy level. Goes too far. Yeah.
- 47:44That being said, I don't know if you read what
- 47:47more recent film was inspired by the ending of
- 47:50Seventh Heaven. Was it just like Heaven? It was
- 47:53not. It was actually La La Land. Interesting.
- 47:56Yeah. So not to spoil the end of La La Land,
- 47:59but it is the ending kind of... A similar interpretation.
- 48:02Yeah. A whole... separate life plays out for
- 48:07the main character of seeing what could have
- 48:08been. That one to me is a little more defined
- 48:10of what actually happened. Completely agreed.
- 48:13Especially what it cuts to afterwards. Sure,
- 48:15yeah. But Damien Chazelle, director of La La
- 48:18Land, has gone on record and said that Seventh
- 48:20Heaven was the inspiration for that. Interesting.
- 48:22So I think that... He sees it in a similar way.
- 48:25Exactly, yeah. Chazelle might see it as, oh,
- 48:27Chico did die, but Diane is carrying on this
- 48:31dream she has. of what she would have hoped happened
- 48:35instead. Okay. That makes more sense. Yeah. So,
- 48:39I mean, I still think what happened is what you
- 48:43see on screen. I think so, too. That's my interpretation.
- 48:45Because the ray of sunshine that comes down on
- 48:48them when they're embracing, to me, feels more
- 48:51like a The End title card than it does like a
- 48:54hallucination. It just feels very much like,
- 48:56you know, of course they did. Like, they lived
- 48:58happily ever after. Why wouldn't they? So I think
- 49:01it's also intentional in that sense. You could
- 49:03look at it a different way, but I think it's
- 49:05intended to be the true ending. Yeah, I think
- 49:07so too. The light coming down as well, and the
- 49:10movie being called Seventh Heaven, something
- 49:11we didn't talk about at all, is the religious
- 49:14undertone throughout the entire movie. Sure.
- 49:17Chico is a devout atheist. Yeah. Literally denies
- 49:21getting married in a church because he doesn't
- 49:23believe it. Yeah, yeah. This is something that
- 49:26the first time I watched it, I felt like, oh,
- 49:29wow, look at what they're talking about in the
- 49:3120s. Now I have a better understanding that religious
- 49:34beliefs weren't as solidified in the past as
- 49:40I think they were. Sure. But I do think it's
- 49:42interesting in this movie that as Chico and Diane
- 49:45spend more time together, Chico's own religious
- 49:49beliefs start to shift a little bit as their
- 49:52relationship grows. Yeah. And I think that light
- 49:55shining down at the end, Chico has a few words
- 49:58about the Bondu god while they're embracing towards
- 50:02the end that kind of show, I do think I believe,
- 50:07and that beam of light hitting them on their
- 50:10apartment close to the stars, I think kind of
- 50:13emphasizes that shift in his beliefs. Yeah, I
- 50:18mean, interestingly, I wonder if that is maybe
- 50:20the reveal there of like, you know, He has now
- 50:24turned his beliefs because of his experience
- 50:26with Diane to a point where that's what saved
- 50:29him. Like, yeah, we're bringing you back. So
- 50:31we got to take something from you, you know,
- 50:32your vision, which is interesting. It doesn't
- 50:34fully like complete the puzzle for me, but that
- 50:36is an interesting idea. I think that it's something,
- 50:40obviously I've not seen the stage play, probably
- 50:42something that is a little more prominent in
- 50:44the stage play. Right. That. they explored the
- 50:48best of their abilities in a silent film from
- 50:50the 20s. Right. That whole element doesn't have
- 50:54a huge impact on me and my viewing experience.
- 50:57Really, I'm most interested in the cutesy relationship
- 51:01that they have. Right, which is definitely the
- 51:03appeal, and I think what works best about it.
- 51:06I did really appreciate that shot you talked
- 51:08about of scaling up the stairs, things that felt
- 51:10very impressive because, you know, we'll get
- 51:12to it, but this is a year where other nominees
- 51:14that are nominated for Best Picture have very
- 51:17remarkable moments in film, at least in the way
- 51:21that it's shot. So the ones we're talking about
- 51:23to this day. So very interesting to see, you
- 51:26know, a movie that tries to do the same thing.
- 51:28Not the same thing, but does something similar.
- 51:30Yeah. an achievement so no i mean great honestly
- 51:33i enjoyed my time with it overall uh now knowing
- 51:36what i know um please watch it on youtube everyone
- 51:40or if you can find it on physical fantastic i
- 51:42don't believe that you can i don't believe there's
- 51:44a criterion or anything of this at this point
- 51:47uh what there is impossible to get in 2008 there
- 51:52was a box set of merno borsage and fox Kind of
- 51:57like a documentary about their works in general.
- 52:00And then it had a few different movies, including
- 52:03this. Interesting. That was released by 20th
- 52:06Century Fox Home Entertainment. I looked for
- 52:08that. It's so hard to get. And it's so expensive
- 52:11if you find it anywhere. It's like $800. Is that
- 52:14DVD or Blu -ray? DVD. This is one of those things
- 52:19where we talked last week about the... Purpose
- 52:24of the Academy, and we talk about film preservation
- 52:26and... Conservation? Conservation, thank you.
- 52:29Of these movies, yes, it's available on Tubi
- 52:32now, which is great, but it's always surprising
- 52:34to me that the Academy doesn't make them more
- 52:37widely available and work with 20th Century Fox
- 52:41to put out, like, an Academy version of the film
- 52:44or something. I mean, I think it... ironically,
- 52:48that's kind of what Criterion is, right? Like
- 52:50Criterion is very much standing for that second
- 52:52best picture category that they had at the Academy
- 52:56Awards in that, yeah, this wasn't, you know,
- 52:58the most popular thing in the world, but look
- 53:00what it did for cinema. So I wish they had something
- 53:03like that. Honestly, at the very least, I wish
- 53:05they had a channel, you know, like a Criterion
- 53:06channel -esque to where they could have, you
- 53:08know, they already do it at their museums. They
- 53:11have like introspectives and like, you know,
- 53:12we're doing Troma Week and we're doing like,
- 53:14you know, Romance Week. Put all that on there.
- 53:17Like put it to where people can pay a certain
- 53:19amount every month or yearly and watch all of
- 53:22that. And then you really are speaking to the
- 53:24preservation and conservation of film and not
- 53:26just we celebrate it every year. Yeah. Celebrate
- 53:28it every day. So I'd love to see more of that.
- 53:31I'm a big physical media guy, so I'd love to
- 53:33physically own it. But at the very least, put
- 53:35it out somewhere to where we can view the true
- 53:38version. You can tell I'm salty. The true version
- 53:40of a film. That would be fantastic. Yeah. But
- 53:44again, you wouldn't even think that fake versions
- 53:46of the score would exist. Or alternate versions,
- 53:50I should say. I still don't know where that came
- 53:51from. I don't know why that is on Tubi in that
- 53:54way. You know, Tubi and I are going to throw
- 53:56down. But I have to use them for a little while
- 53:59longer. So we'll wait until that doesn't happen.
- 54:01I'm definitely going to check. each movie first
- 54:04and let you know if the score is... Look, if
- 54:06it works, I don't really think I care too much,
- 54:08but it just absolutely did not work for 7 -Eleven.
- 54:11Yeah, that's rough. The parts that have to hit
- 54:14kind of need that music. I completely agree to
- 54:17a point where like literally Chico's death scene
- 54:20when he's... I mean, war is happening. There
- 54:22are literal explosions happening and I'm just
- 54:25hearing the entertainer. And I'm like, this is
- 54:28not good. I need to be like in the moment and
- 54:31feel that like, you know, sorrow and terror and
- 54:34like, you know, uncertainty. Right. And not just
- 54:36the same feeling I've been feeling for the past
- 54:38hour and a half. So again, my own problem, not
- 54:42a problem of the movie. So don't take it out
- 54:43on it. But overall, very much enjoyed my time
- 54:46with Seventh Heaven. Yeah, I'm glad. I really
- 54:49am glad. I used to do ratings out of five stars
- 54:53with half star intervals. Interesting. What would
- 54:55you put Seventh Heaven at? It's tough. I wish
- 55:00I would have prepared this. I mean, I don't think
- 55:02that there's any reason to give this below four.
- 55:04I think that it's extremely respectable. It's
- 55:08extremely well done. The chemistry is really
- 55:11what you're looking for. And to be honest, at
- 55:13a time like this, you can ask for a couple great
- 55:15shots as a real cinema head, so to speak. But
- 55:19the main thing you're looking for is that connection.
- 55:21And I think that had I watched this with the
- 55:23correct score, I do think that I would have maybe
- 55:25a little bit higher, like a 4 .5. But to your
- 55:28point, you really cannot turn down that Diane
- 55:31and Chico chemistry. It's just extremely well
- 55:34done. So good. They play off each other so well.
- 55:37So yeah, I'd say 4. That's awesome. For someone
- 55:41that watched it with the wrong score and was
- 55:42bitter the whole time, I always give this a 3
- 55:45.5. Oh, okay. So it's interesting that you go
- 55:47higher. I think that... the third act of this
- 55:51movie, Chico going off to war, it kind of loses
- 55:54my interest. I love what's going on with Diane
- 55:56and how she stands up against Nana. But everything
- 56:01that happens on the front with Chico, there's
- 56:04a scene with the gentleman and his taxi, Eloise.
- 56:07Yeah. It's funny, but none of that, it's like
- 56:11I was talking about, all of the war and the action
- 56:13that's so prevalent in movies from this era,
- 56:16it's very hard for that to hold up. to a modern
- 56:20lens in a way that I think the romance and the
- 56:23chemistry between characters. It's timeless.
- 56:26Exactly. So I kind of lose interest towards the
- 56:29back half of this movie. That's fair. And to
- 56:32be honest, maybe I'm just on a redemption tour
- 56:34of talking garbage on this movie. So 3 .5 sounds
- 56:39like something I can meet in the middle on completely.
- 56:41And maybe with the original score, I would still
- 56:43have some of the complications that I have with
- 56:45it now. Because I do think that the war is kind
- 56:47of tacked onto it, to be honest. It feels like
- 56:49a means to an end to get to your final scene
- 56:51than anything else. Yeah. Especially how rushed
- 56:54it feels. Maybe you really did have an hour lead
- 56:57time back then, but just felt very comical in
- 57:00the moment. Totally. I completely agree. And
- 57:03man, that war, just a theme. It shows up so often.
- 57:09All the way up to, I don't know, the early 50s.
- 57:13Like the score? No, I mean the actual theme of
- 57:16war. Theming of the war. Got it, yes. You know,
- 57:18this is World War I, but the 40s, almost every
- 57:20movie that came out had something to do with
- 57:22the war. So it's going to get pretty exhaustive.
- 57:26It's interesting because it doesn't feel like
- 57:29it's played for, and maybe the score changes
- 57:31things, it doesn't feel like to me that it's
- 57:34played for like emotion. Like, oh my God, can
- 57:38you believe they're going to war? It felt like
- 57:40more like a happenstance. Like, he just happens
- 57:42to be going to war. And to me, I think that's
- 57:44an interesting time of, like, 1927, of just,
- 57:47like, accepting, like, yeah, this is just where
- 57:50we are. Right. Right? Like, we're not saying,
- 57:52isn't this terrible? Isn't this horrible? This
- 57:53is just what happens. To a point where one of
- 57:55the nominees, like, literally is set in the war.
- 57:58Like, there is very much that existence of it,
- 58:01but it doesn't feel for or against. It just feels
- 58:04very much, this is the setting. Yeah, this happened.
- 58:07Which is interesting. Yeah. It's always interesting
- 58:09too when one of these movies made in the United
- 58:12States is talking about the war from another
- 58:15country's perspective. Totally. I feel like they
- 58:17often just use the war as a setting like you're
- 58:21talking about. Right. Rather than provide any
- 58:23type of point of view of the feelings behind
- 58:26it. I also... Before we sign off, I want to make
- 58:29sure that I give credit where it's due. I mistakenly
- 58:32named a character earlier. I said that a character
- 58:35that Chico interacts with pretty early on is
- 58:38named Rat, and that was offensive. I'm really
- 58:40sorry. His full name is Sewer Rat. I just saw
- 58:44it. On Wikipedia, he is listed as Sewer Rat.
- 58:48So much love and apologies to Sewer Rat. Hey,
- 58:52you know what? Sewer Rat dies a hero. Sewer Rat
- 58:55was my father. Please call me Rat. You know,
- 58:58Georgie Stone that played Sewer Rat, he's going
- 59:00to show up in a couple years in another film.
- 59:03I'm looking for The Return of Rat. The Return
- 59:06of Rat. I love it. Like I said earlier, Janet
- 59:09Gaynor is the highlight for me. Absolutely. She
- 59:11won, like we said, not just for this film, but
- 59:14also for Street Angel and Sunrise. I know that
- 59:17we're only covering the outstanding pictures
- 59:20for this year, not the artistic, unique and artistic
- 59:23pictures. Sunrise is... Probably the most beloved
- 59:29movie that came out during this Oscar season
- 59:32to this day. In the book, 1001 Films to Watch
- 59:36Before You Die, it is the only movie from this
- 59:40Oscar season that is listed. Interesting. Sunrise,
- 59:44A Song of Two Humans. Correct, yeah. It's a great
- 59:47movie. I haven't seen it yet. Is it on Tubi?
- 59:49It is on Tubi. And it's got the right score.
- 59:53Excellent. Actually, it has a really good score.
- 59:55Okay. There's a moment that's... like horror
- 59:57driven. Excellent. Wow. With a name like sunrise,
- 1:00:00you wouldn't expect that. Yeah. It gets pretty
- 1:00:02dark. I'm very excited. Cause I did like Janet
- 1:00:05Gaynor a lot. Um, she has a perfect face, uh,
- 1:00:08for movies. Yeah. I mean, just like incredible
- 1:00:11emotion. I'm excited. I'm, I'm going to try and
- 1:00:13watch a street angel before the ceremony episode.
- 1:00:16I'm really excited to watch that. I think, um,
- 1:00:19the next time that I put on a waistband, I'm
- 1:00:22going to ask Taylor to help me put it on the
- 1:00:24way that Chico has, uh, diane put it on for him
- 1:00:27yeah it's very whimsical it's very funny that's
- 1:00:29it no i'm excited i was waiting for you to describe
- 1:00:32it because it's it's so beautiful well he just
- 1:00:35like it she he holds it to his waist and he has
- 1:00:37her go out about 20 feet or so and then he just
- 1:00:40kind of like almost pirouettes into her yeah
- 1:00:43and it's just almost uh uncharacteristically
- 1:00:47feminine of him which is like very refreshing
- 1:00:50to kind of not see like this toxic like you know
- 1:00:52ability like he's just he's very much having
- 1:00:54fun with it in the moment and it's very fun so
- 1:00:56that was another moment that just kind of makes
- 1:00:57you fall in love with them right yeah yeah listen
- 1:01:00if you do recreate that and you want to film
- 1:01:02it i know what not what song to not set it to
- 1:01:05man i love that so much It's so good. Honestly,
- 1:01:09just so part of the course for me with historical
- 1:01:12accuracy of just being completely on the wrong
- 1:01:16planet. So that was nice. It's perfect. It's
- 1:01:18great. It's so good. Did it for the pod. One
- 1:01:21last thing I'll say before we go. This was remade
- 1:01:23in the... Okay, 1937 it was remade, and Jimmy
- 1:01:28Stewart is in that version. Interesting. Never
- 1:01:30saw it. I've not heard great things about it,
- 1:01:33but I'd like to check that out one day. I'm a
- 1:01:36big Jimmy Stewart fan. Not successful, I noticed.
- 1:01:39Yeah, so... Which is weird. I don't know. They
- 1:01:41weren't into... Even back then, they were tired
- 1:01:45of the remakes. Yeah, they were. But yeah, that
- 1:01:46was the last thing I wanted to throw out. That
- 1:01:48pretty much does it for Seventh Heaven. Yeah,
- 1:01:52that would do it for our first episode of...
- 1:01:54Our first movie of the 1927 Academy Awards ceremony.
- 1:02:00So, that means that our next episode, if we're
- 1:02:02going in our... alphabetical, numerical order,
- 1:02:05is The Racket. Yeah. You've not seen this one
- 1:02:07yet. I have not seen this one yet, but I have
- 1:02:09very gleefully noticed that it is an hour and
- 1:02:1122 minutes. Always nice. And it is on Tubi, so
- 1:02:15I'm interested. I'm going to catch it, I think,
- 1:02:18later on today, and then I'm very much excited
- 1:02:20to finish things off with Wings, and then we'll
- 1:02:23be all set. Yeah. So next Wednesday, and next
- 1:02:27episode, if you're not following along, is going
- 1:02:30to be The Racket. Like you said, that's a Lewis
- 1:02:31Milestone movie. You said it was on Tubi, right?
- 1:02:34It is, as well as Wings. Okay, cool. So I'm excited
- 1:02:38for that. That was really hard to find like three
- 1:02:41years ago. Oh. So I'm so excited it's on Tubi.
- 1:02:44But also, see me in my office. Right, yeah. If
- 1:02:46you have any comments or feelings about Seventh
- 1:02:49Heaven or any of the movies nominated for this
- 1:02:52year of the Academy Awards, shoot us an email
- 1:02:55over at outaopodcast at gmail .com. Follow us
- 1:03:00on social media. All of the links will be in
- 1:03:02the show notes. And check out the Patreon, patreon
- 1:03:05.com slash O -U -T -A -O podcast. Is there anything
- 1:03:09else you wanted to add? I did double check the
- 1:03:11Instagram handle, and you're not going to believe
- 1:03:13this. It is Once Upon a Time at the Oscars. Wow.
- 1:03:15I can't believe I got that. Yeah, I know. I thought
- 1:03:18it would be hot commodity. Yeah. Perfect. So
- 1:03:21yeah, check us out there. TikTok, YouTube. But
- 1:03:24that's going to do it. Thank you all so much
- 1:03:25for listening. As always. I am your host, Kyle.
- 1:03:29I'm Ryan. And we'll see you at the movies.