Latest / Friendship Project: Friendship, community & belonging / Why I Stay Friends With My Ex’s New Girlfriend | Friendship Project
Transcript
- I accidentally tried to manage my best friend’s career last Tuesday, and it was as graceful as a toddler trying to fold a fitted sheet. Let’s sit with that for a second, because if you’ve ever loved someone enough to want to fix their problems, you already know this sting. It started with a text. Maya sent me a screenshot of an email from her boss, one of those passive-aggressive notes about 'proactive communication.' She was upset, rightfully so, and she typed out three paragraphs of rage. My finger hovered over the screen. I didn’t just offer comfort; I drafted a response. I rewrote her reply to be more professional, added bullet points for clarity, and attached a link to an article about workplace assertiveness. I hit send before I even realized what I’d done. Ten minutes later, my phone buzzed. It wasn’t a thank you. It was a question: 'Why are you writing my emails now?' That question hit me in the chest like a physical weight. I had crossed a line I didn’t even see until it was too late. I thought I was being helpful. I thought I was being a good friend. But in my eagerness to solve the problem, I had erased her voice. I had taken the steering wheel while she was still trying to start the engine. We’ve all been there, haven’t we? You see a younger friend struggling—maybe it’s dating, maybe it’s money, maybe it’s just general life direction—and your heart breaks for them. You remember being twenty-four and terrified. You remember making mistakes that cost you years to undo. So you want to hand them the map. You want to say, 'Don’t go left, go right. This path is paved with gold, that one has potholes.' But here is the hard truth that took me a long time to learn: mentoring your friends is not about giving them the answers they need. It’s about trusting them to find the questions themselves. When we step into the mentor role without permission, we aren’t just offering guidance. We are implicitly saying that we know better than they do. And nothing kills intimacy faster than feeling patronized by the person who is supposed to love you unconditionally. I realized I wasn’t helping Maya grow; I was preventing her from stumbling. And sometimes, the stumble is where the lesson lives. So how do we walk that tightrope? How do we care without controlling? It starts with asking for permission. Before you offer advice, before you share that book or that podcast episode or that story about your own failure, you have to ask, 'Do you want to hear my take on this, or do you just need me to listen?' It sounds simple, but it changes everything. It shifts the dynamic from me fixing you to me supporting you. When Maya replied to my rogue email, I apologized. I told her I was scared for her, and that fear made me clumsy. We talked for an hour about boundaries. We agreed on a new rule: if she asked for my opinion, I would give it. If she didn’t, I would just hold space. That small shift restored our balance. It reminded us that we are equals, not teacher and student. Friendship is not a hierarchy. It’s a circle. And when one person tries to stand above the rest, the circle breaks. Let’s dig deeper into why we do this. Why do we struggle to sit with someone else’s discomfort? For me, it’s always been about control. I am terrible at uncertainty. I hate seeing people I love in pain because it makes me feel helpless. So I rush to act. I rush to fix. But anxiety disguised as generosity is still anxiety. It’s not love; it’s fear wearing a nice coat. When I look back at that moment with Maya, I see my own terror. I was terrified that if I didn’t intervene, something bad would happen. I was terrified that she wouldn’t succeed. But her success isn’t defined by avoiding pitfalls. Her success is defined by navigating them. By taking the wheel, I robbed her of her agency. I robbed her of the chance to prove to herself that she could handle it. And that is a gift no amount of advice can replace. We have to trust that our friends are capable, even when they don’t believe it yet. Especially when they don’t believe it yet. This week, I’m practicing being a mirror instead of a map. A map tells you exactly where to go. It dictates the route. It ignores the traffic, the weather, the detours you might want to take. A mirror simply reflects what is there. It says, 'I see you. I see your frustration. I see your anger. I see your hope.' When I reflect Maya’s feelings back to her, she often finds her own solutions. She’ll say, 'You’re right, I am angry. But actually, I think I’m more disappointed that my boss doesn’t trust me.' Suddenly, we’re in a deeper conversation. We’re solving the real problem, not just the surface symptom. It requires patience. It requires holding back the urge to jump in. It requires sitting in the silence when you want to fill it with wisdom. But the results are so much richer. You get to witness their growth in real time. You get to celebrate their wins because they earned them, not because you handed them a trophy. That kind of pride tastes different. It’s sweeter. It’s shared. There is a sacredness in showing up consistently for people, not by doing things for them, but by being present with them. I used to think being a good friend meant having all the answers. Now I know it means having the courage to sit in the messy middle with them. It means trusting that they have the tools within them, even if they’ve forgotten how to use them. It means believing in their resilience more than they do. When we stop trying to mentor every aspect of our friends’ lives, we make room for true connection. We create space for vulnerability. We allow ourselves to be seen as human, flawed, and learning alongside them. We become peers again. And that peer-to-peer relationship is where the deepest bonds are forged. It’s where we realize that we are all just figuring it out as we go. No one has the master plan. We’re all just walking through the fog, holding hands, hoping to keep each other safe. Thank you for letting me share this mess with you. I’m Rhiannon, and I’ll be right here next week, ready to listen. Until then, be gentle with yourself. You’re doing better than you think. Take care.