Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Decennial Cost of Tesla Model Y Ownership
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome back to the Deep Dive. You give us the sources, we do
- 0:11the heavy lifting, giving you that definitive shortcut to
- 0:15getting up to speed. Today we're tackling a big one,
- 0:19really a question that kind of defines where cars are going.
- 0:22When you look past that initial price tag for an EV like a
- 0:25Tesla, does the math actually work out for you, You know, down
- 0:29the road? We're not just talking sticker
- 0:30price. No, we're doing a deep dive into
- 0:32the real number, the 10 year total cost of ownership, the
- 0:34TCO. And our focus today is pretty
- 0:38specific. We're looking at one person's
- 0:39detailed strategy, really trying to minimize the TCO on a used
- 0:442021 Tesla Model Y Long Range. It's like someone laid out their
- 0:47whole financial game plan for us.
- 0:50Yeah, and we. Need to be really clear about
- 0:51the assumptions here. It's a specific scenario.
- 0:54The car starts with 30,000 miles on the clock, and the plan is to
- 0:57drive at 10,000 miles a year every year for 10 years.
- 1:00So that takes it up to 140,000 miles total, which is, you know,
- 1:04quite a lot. And importantly, to make these
- 1:06numbers work, we had to sort of freeze things in time.
- 1:09No inflation figured in, no changes to like government
- 1:12incentives. And this is a big one.
- 1:14It assumes driving FSD basically stays as it is now.
- 1:18It's just a cost, doesn't really add functional value or make
- 1:21money in this calculation. OK.
- 1:22So we've pulled numbers from places like Edmunds, Bank rate,
- 1:26even specialized warranty companies to sort of piece this
- 1:28road map together. And the whole point is to see
- 1:31how this used Model Y compares long term against some
- 1:35benchmarks. We're talking the Toyota RV4,
- 1:37which is, you know, huge in a segment and maybe something like
- 1:40a BMW for a performance comparison start at the
- 1:42beginning that buying the car, OK?
- 1:45So the core idea is buying used. That way you skip that huge
- 1:48initial depreciation hit. This analysis kicks off with a
- 1:51purchase price of $29,682 for that 2021 Model Y. 29 six.
- 1:56OK, that immediately makes me think.
- 1:58What about the used EV tax credit?
- 2:00The source mentioned, didn't it, that if they could find one just
- 2:03under 25K, boom, $4000 off the PCO right away.
- 2:07That's a big chunk. Exactly a huge potential saving,
- 2:10but for this calculation they stuck with the actual $29,602.00
- 2:14figure they based the plan on. So no credit factored into the
- 2:18main number we'll get to. Then you've got the immediate
- 2:20costs, the fixed stuff, taxes and fees 1st and it's
- 2:23interesting how it works. Year 1 is pretty hefty, almost
- 2:252200 dollars, 2178 to be exact, and various fees.
- 2:30But after that first hit, the annual taxes drop way down like
- 2:33$46 a year. It really shows how front loaded
- 2:36those costs can be 46. Bucks a year.
- 2:38Wow. Then financing the plan uses a
- 2:40five year loan, 7% interest rate, which feels pretty
- 2:43realistic right now. Over the five years that
- 2:45borrowing cost adds, let's see, $6583 to the total cost.
- 2:50OK, 6 1/2 grand for financing. Now insurance.
- 2:52This is often the gotcha moment for Ev's, right?
- 2:55We hear all the time Tesla's cost more to insure than say a
- 2:58Honda or a Toyota. Something about the sensors
- 3:00repair costs? That's generally true, yeah.
- 3:02The complex tech, the specific body panels, it can drive up
- 3:06repair costs, which insurers notice.
- 3:08But the source here, they kind of relied on getting a good deal
- 3:13possibly through Tesla's own insurance, which can be, as they
- 3:16put it, aggressively priced in certain states.
- 3:19Colorado was the example given. So for this plan, they budgeted
- 3:23well, maybe a bit optimistically, an average of
- 3:25$1200 a year. 1200 a year? That number feels like maybe the
- 3:31shakiest assumption in the whole thing.
- 3:33Do they explain how they'd keep it that low?
- 3:34Because if that suddenly jumps to two grand or 2500, that gap
- 3:38between the Tesla and the Rif four starts looking a lot
- 3:40smaller, doesn't it? It does.
- 3:42The justification was that the owner would be actively managing
- 3:45it, shopping around each year, adjusting coverage, basically
- 3:49not just letting it auto renew at whatever rate the company
- 3:51offers. It relies on the owner being
- 3:53proactive about cost minimization.
- 3:55If they're passive, yeah, that number is definitely going up.
- 3:58OK, fair enough. Active management required.
- 4:00So let's move past the initial wallet hit.
- 4:02Let's talk about where the EV should shine, the running costs.
- 4:06This is where the Model Y is supposed to make up ground.
- 4:08And you know, I adore these detailed calculations.
- 4:11I really do, because they give you such a clear picture, a real
- 4:14vision of what it actually means to own an electric car.
- 4:17day-to-day. It takes it out of the abstract.
- 4:19It's about, well, fundamentally removing the engine from the
- 4:22whole equation. Exactly.
- 4:24And that removal translates directly to really minimal
- 4:28scheduled maintenance. We're talking wiper blades,
- 4:31washer fluid, cabin air filters. The budget for that is maybe
- 4:34$200 every other year over 10 years.
- 4:37It's almost nothing compared to a gas car. 200 every two years.
- 4:42Yeah. OK, but what about other stuff?
- 4:44Things that maybe gas cars don't need or things that still wear
- 4:47out. Right, good point.
- 4:48The plan did get specific there. It includes things like tire
- 4:51rotation. 50 bucks a year, that's important but the waiting
- 4:53instant torque could be VS then brake fluid replacement every
- 4:56four years. Budgeted at $200.
- 4:59And this one's interesting. The AC disicant bag replacement.
- 5:03Hang on to second bag. What is that and why is it a
- 5:06$350.00 line item? Sounds kind of important.
- 5:09It is, yeah. It's basically like a moisture
- 5:11absorber for the air conditioning system.
- 5:13Now, in a gas car, you might not touch the AC for ages, but in an
- 5:18EV, the AC system often does double duty.
- 5:21It cools the cabin, sure, but can also be crucial for cooling
- 5:25the battery pack. OK, battery cooling makes sense.
- 5:29So keeping moisture out is key for preventing corrosion and
- 5:32making sure that battery cooling loop works properly.
- 5:35Tesla recommends replacing that bag every four years.
- 5:37It's one of those specific EV maintenance things.
- 5:39Beyond that standard stuff, yeah, a 12 Volt battery EV still
- 5:43have one of those like a regular car, replace it maybe every four
- 5:46years, $200 and an alignment also every four years about
- 5:49$100. Got it.
- 5:50Now, tires. That's always a big cost, right?
- 5:52Especially on heavier E VS with all that torque they can chew
- 5:54through tires. But the strategy here sounds
- 5:56pretty clever. It really is a smart move in the
- 5:58plan instead of just slapping on expensive premium tires like
- 6:02Michelins or something which cost a fortune.
- 6:04The plan specifically targets high rated but lower cost
- 6:08alternatives. They mentioned the Radar Dymax
- 6:10brand as an example. Budgeting only $800 a set
- 6:13instead of maybe double that fundamentally changes the long
- 6:16term cost. It takes a potentially huge
- 6:19expense and makes it manageable. Smart cost control. 800 a set
- 6:23versus yeah, maybe 1600 or more. That's a massive saving over
- 6:26100,000 miles. OK.
- 6:28And now the big one, fuel or, well, electricity.
- 6:33This is where it gets pretty remarkable, but it hinges
- 6:35completely on how the owner charges.
- 6:37The plan assumes they have home solar and they cover 90% of
- 6:40their miles. That's 9000 miles a year using
- 6:43that solar power. Even pricing that energy
- 6:45conservatively at $0.05 per kWh, the home charging cost per year
- 6:50is only about $150.00. $150.00 for 9000 miles of driving, yeah.
- 6:54Then the other 1000 miles, maybe for Rd. trips or whatever that's
- 6:58assumed to be on superchargers, and even using the higher
- 7:00supercharger rate, say $0.45 per kWh, that only adds another
- 7:04$150.00 or so. OK.
- 7:06So step back the total annual fuel cost.
- 7:09Electricity for driving 10,000 miles in this Model Y?
- 7:12Just $300. $300 a year at that number alone, wow.
- 7:17Anyone paying, you know, hundreds a month for gas has got
- 7:20to pay attention to that. But that brings us neatly to the
- 7:23elephant in the room for older, high mileage EVs.
- 7:27What happens when things break outside of warranty?
- 7:30Let's talk risk mitigation. Right, this is probably the
- 7:32biggest fear factor. We've all heard stories about
- 7:35potentially massive battery or drivetrain repair bills, so the
- 7:38strategy in this plan was basically to neutralize that
- 7:41risk upfront. They decided to buy a really
- 7:43comprehensive extended warranty. Specifically a 10 year 100,000
- 7:47mile 0 deductible warranty from a company that can accelerate
- 7:51auto. The cost for that was 4819
- 7:53dollars. OK.
- 7:54Almost 5 grand, that's a significant chunk of change
- 7:57upfront, but you called it a strategic asset, not just
- 7:59insurance. Why?
- 8:00Well, because of what it does for the car's value later on and
- 8:03the flexibility, the source pointed out this warranty is
- 8:06transferable if you sell the car.
- 8:08So the next owner gets the coverage.
- 8:10Exactly, or if you sell it early, you can often get a
- 8:13prorated refund for the unused portion.
- 8:16So it's not just money spent on protection, it's like you're
- 8:19shielding the car's value against that catastrophic repair
- 8:22risk. It becomes a selling point.
- 8:24They also budgeted a little extra, like $200 a year for
- 8:28small things the warranty might not cover.
- 8:30That makes a lot of sense, locking in Peace of Mind and
- 8:32potentially bolstering resale value.
- 8:35OK, what about depreciation? That's the silent killer of TCO
- 8:38for most cars, right? They just plummet in value.
- 8:41Yeah, usually the assumption here is, well, maybe a bit
- 8:44aggressive, but there's logic to it.
- 8:46They use standard industry figures like from Edmonds for
- 8:49the first five years where depreciation is steepest, but
- 8:52after Year 5, the plan assumes the value only drops by about
- 8:55$1000 per year. Only 1000 a year.
- 8:57Why so slow? The thinking is that a well
- 9:00maintained EV mainly because its running costs are so incredibly
- 9:04low by that point, no big engine repairs looming uer cheap fuel
- 9:08should actually hold its value better than an equivalent gas
- 9:11car. The market theoretically should
- 9:14start valuing that low running cost.
- 9:16So the projection estimates the residual value after 10 years
- 9:19and 140,000 miles would still be at least $7570. 7 1/2 grand left
- 9:26after a decade and all those miles.
- 9:28So looking at the whole ownership period, the cost
- 9:31profile changes dramatically over.
- 9:33Time. Oh, absolutely.
- 9:34Once you get past those first five years you paid off the
- 9:36loan, you've absorbed the steepest depreciation.
- 9:39The actual cost of keeping the car running is tiny.
- 9:41According to the numbers, the second five years of owning this
- 9:44Model Y only cost about 38% of what the first five years cost.
- 9:4738%. Wow.
- 9:48Yeah. And even if you spread the cost
- 9:50of that big extended warranty evenly across the whole decade,
- 9:53the second-half still only cost about 46% of the first half.
- 9:57It's just incredibly cheaper to run long term.
- 9:59That is a really compelling long term picture.
- 10:02OK, we've laid out all the pieces, the assumptions, the
- 10:05strategies. Time for the big reveal.
- 10:08What's the final TCO number and how does it stack up?
- 10:11So under this very specific cost minimizing 10 year 100,000 mile
- 10:16plan, the estimated total cost of ownership for the used 2021
- 10:21Tesla Model Y comes out two $59,276, $59,000 which works out
- 10:28to about $0.60 per mile driven. Now to really get what that
- 10:32means, we need the comparisons. Definitely, and we have to be
- 10:34careful here. Comparing TCO across different
- 10:37sources is tricky. The figures for competitors like
- 10:40the Ravi 4 often assume more miles per year, maybe 15,000.
- 10:44Sometimes they even assume you buy two different cars over 10
- 10:46years. So we had to adjust.
- 10:48We tried to strip out extra financing, extra sales tax,
- 10:50extra fuel cost to make the comparisons close to the Model Y
- 10:53as 100,000 mile target as possible.
- 10:55Right, apples to apples as much as.
- 10:57Possible. Exactly.
- 10:58So after those adjustments, the estimated 10 year TCO for the
- 11:01Toyota Rav 4 landed at $77,099. 77,000 versus 59?
- 11:05That's what, almost an $18,000 difference in favor of the Tesla
- 11:09over 10 years? Yep.
- 11:10Not that much now. What about something with
- 11:12similar performance or luxury aspirations?
- 11:15The BMW comparison. Right.
- 11:16If you want that level of performance and sort of premium
- 11:20feel, you look at a comparable BMW.
- 11:22We had estimated depreciation in the later years using a similar
- 11:25ratio to the Toyota data and the estimated 10 year TCO for the
- 11:29capital BMW just explodes. It came out to 154,434 thousand.
- 11:36154,000 That's more than double almost three times the Tesla
- 11:40cost. Pretty much nearly three times
- 11:42as much. So let's.
- 11:43Just pause on that. This specific strategy for
- 11:45owning a used Model Y makes it 30% cheaper than a mainstream
- 11:48Toyota Rav 4 / 10 years and almost three times cheaper than
- 11:51a comparable luxury performance BMW, while still giving you
- 11:55arguably better performance, more tech, and that premium
- 11:58heavy experience. That's the core finding, that's
- 12:01the value proposition that's shaking things up.
- 12:04Getting that kind of performance in tech, that sort of crossover
- 12:07utility for less than the long term cost of a standard reliable
- 12:12Toyota, that's a huge driver for why people are looking at EVs
- 12:16regardless of anything else. And you know, source material
- 12:19mentioned being impartial about, say, high profile figures in the
- 12:22EV space because for most buyers, it really just boils
- 12:25down to economics. They're looking for the best
- 12:27vehicle they can get for their money, and this analysis at
- 12:30least shows that under the right conditions, the used EV can
- 12:34offer really compelling, quantifiable value.
- 12:36Absolutely. That financial outcome
- 12:38specifically driven by really thinking through the long term
- 12:41costs, getting that warranty, minimizing fuel costs, that's
- 12:43the aha moment. It shifts the perception of the
- 12:45used Model Y from maybe a slightly premium buy to
- 12:49potentially an outstanding long term value.
- 12:51It really does. And maybe one final thought to
- 12:54leave you with thinking bigger picture.
- 12:56We generally think electric vehicles, you know, fewer moving
- 12:59parts, maybe less wear and tear on core components, they seem
- 13:03like they're built to last potentially longer than
- 13:05traditional gas cars. So if that's true, how might
- 13:11these TCO calculations change? If we start thinking about
- 13:14owning cars for 15 years or even 20 years instead of just 10?
- 13:20That would likely just amplify the financial advantage we've
- 13:22seen today, wouldn't it? Something to think about.
- 13:24A very interesting thought. Stretching that ownership window
- 13:27could make the numbers even more dramatic.
- 13:29Well, thank you for bringing these sources in and going on
- 13:32this deep dive with us today. And thank you for tuning in and
- 13:35sharing your curiosity with us.