Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Breaking: NCUA Moves to Remove a Major Barrier to Board Service
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 2: It's an emergency.
- 0:05What is it?
- 0:06Just wait and see.
- 0:10Boardroom courtroom, footnotes.
- 0:12Fees.
- 0:13Policy shifts quietly.
- 0:17New regulation, new direction.
- 0:19Leadership in question.
- 0:21Insurance on camel.
- 0:22Watch, examine attention.
- 0:25We'll wait for next week when the meeting's on the NCU at
- 0:28well agenda drop something.
- 0:30And pops.
- 0:31Now.
- 0:31It's in your head.
- 0:35It's in your head.
- 0:40Third party cyber liquidity,
- 0:44concentration, rising risk model.
- 0:48Stress assumptions.
- 0:50Everybody,
- 0:54it's an emergency.
- 0:56Didn't plan it.
- 0:57Here we go.
- 1:00When the signal star flashing red,
- 1:05we hit.
- 1:10Speaker: Hey everyone.
- 1:11This is Mark Kel with another emergency episode of With Flying Colors.
- 1:17If you are a regular listen listener, you noticed a new intro song,
- 1:22which is my new emergency podcast.
- 1:25Song, we just got back from a credit union QS cruise to The Bahamas
- 1:32hosted by Scott Gladden and who was in charge of the local chapter.
- 1:36Had a great time.
- 1:38Todd Miller, myself, Steve Farrar.
- 1:40We talked to the group about a lot of things going on that we're
- 1:43seeing in our credit unions that we're seeing relative to NCA.
- 1:47And one of the discussions was about AI and how to use that with the credit union.
- 1:52And I went down a rabbit hole saying how I had created some music this
- 1:57summer just playing with it, which I'm sure a lot of you had done.
- 2:00I had a little bit of motivation.
- 2:01There's a podcast I may have mentioned on the cruise.
- 2:04That uses that has a Patreon site and when they have an emergency signing,
- 2:09even if it's of a backup catcher for the baseball team, Minnesota
- 2:12twins, they'll have a quick podcast.
- 2:15They'll throw it up.
- 2:16And when it works out for me to have something live that quick that I wanna
- 2:21talk about, I'm gonna be using this this type of intro, the emergency podcast.
- 2:25Music.
- 2:26And if you can figure out who I tried to make it sound like, send me a note
- 2:29and I'll tell you if you're right.
- 2:31NCA had a board meeting.
- 2:32They had two items on the agenda.
- 2:35And you can debate whether how you define emergency.
- 2:38If you think it's an emergency.
- 2:39I'm sure there's some people who'd want to hear it quickly.
- 2:42So time sensitive is probably better than emergency.
- 2:45But in this instance, they had two items, the proposed.
- 2:50A board briefing proposal on dependent care and board member
- 2:53expense reimbursement and a board briefing on the CLF.
- 2:57I noticed that Matt Belos, who usually is in charge of the office
- 3:02of Consumer Compliance was sitting in as acting head of the CLF.
- 3:06It sounded like he may have just taken that role here in January
- 3:10and that briefing, I'm not gonna go much into it other than.
- 3:14They said over the last year they've gone up 14 members in the CLF to four 50.
- 3:21They have borrowing capacity of 21.9
- 3:24billion and that their budget is down similar to the rest of the agency budget.
- 3:29I'm not gonna say a lot more about that.
- 3:31If you want to join the CLF, reach out to NCUA they always beat the
- 3:37drum about the importance of that.
- 3:39And the more members they have, the more borrowing capacity they have.
- 3:42So it's real.
- 3:42Really consistent with the credit union spirit.
- 3:45So back to the main item, which was the dependent care and board member expense
- 3:50reimbursement, which was proposed.
- 3:52It was interesting that board member, board chair Halman mentioned that at
- 3:58his testimony he ran into Brad Sherman or Brad Sherman asked from California.
- 4:03Where they were at, where NCOA was at on this rule.
- 4:06And that probably means by the way, that CUNA slash America's credit
- 4:09unions always gonna be calling them.
- 4:11America's credit unions may have planted that question with them to get some
- 4:16momentum here, because I know that CUNA America's credit unions has had
- 4:20written some letters relative to this.
- 4:22Basically Helpmann said here we are.
- 4:24Voila, we have the proposal.
- 4:26And it was a short, concise.
- 4:30Board briefing that didn't go into all the nuances that are in the regulation
- 4:34but I think this is very positive.
- 4:36For and by the way before I forget to say this applies to federal credit unions
- 4:40only, not state chartered credit unions, but if you are a state charter and you're
- 4:44listening and you're in one of those states that has immediate reciprocity,
- 4:48if this rule does get finalized, you may be able to apply it in your role.
- 4:51Of course, consult your state, when, if, and when it gets to that point in time.
- 4:56I also wanna say this doesn't impact anything about what might be.
- 5:01Treated it as income with the IRS.
- 5:03They said, reach out to your CPAs.
- 5:04And I'm not gonna get into that.
- 5:06I have an accounting degree, not a CPA, but I have no
- 5:08thoughts as it relates to that.
- 5:10But I'm excited about this because many states allow
- 5:13their board members to be paid.
- 5:14The Federal Credit Union Act does not allow federal chartered seat
- 5:18boards and officials to be paid other than the treasurer, of course.
- 5:23This provides a little bit of a equalized playing field in that
- 5:27dependent care can be covered.
- 5:29And they talked about it being covered.
- 5:30For the 12 meetings.
- 5:31Helpmann made an interesting point.
- 5:33That if you were on a board member of IBM or Facebook, you only have to have four.
- 5:37Quarterly meetings of the, of that board.
- 5:40NCA, the Federal Credit Union Act requires 12.
- 5:42So the burden is higher, yet you're not paid.
- 5:45So again, I I'm excited about the possibility of this rule being
- 5:49proposed and costs being approved so that you can have a more.
- 5:54Well-rounded board.
- 5:55So you can have a more diverse board in all ways, including diversity of thought.
- 5:59If there are people, you probably are listening, you've had people that, Hey, I
- 6:02can't make that commitment 'cause I've got kids, or I've got a grandparent, or I've
- 6:07got a mother that I have to take care of.
- 6:08I can't make that commitment.
- 6:09This allows some flexibility there, which again, I think is really a nice big step
- 6:15forward for the value of the federal.
- 6:19Credit Union Charter.
- 6:20So I'm gonna walk through I took some notes here.
- 6:22Bear with me a little bit more detail than what they talked about.
- 6:26My take and what I believe will be the take were this rule
- 6:31as written to become final.
- 6:34So what the proposed rule does, it allows federal credit unions
- 6:37to reimburse or directly pay.
- 6:39Reasonable dependent care costs for volunteer officials.
- 6:42So what's the definition of reasonable dependent care costs?
- 6:46It's in the eye of the beholder, of course.
- 6:47What's the definition of safety and soundness?
- 6:49Obviously you wanna be reasonable.
- 6:51You don't want to jump off the deep end and do any crazy things,
- 6:54but I am gonna suggest some things in here that they didn't talk
- 6:56about that this might apply to.
- 6:58So it does apply to when those costs are incurred, while attending board
- 7:02meetings or performing official duties.
- 7:04To me that's pretty big.
- 7:06Having just come back from a cruise where there was education on BSA,
- 7:10there was education on board member education, on financial information.
- 7:15There was many other programs that were put on, including what we talked to
- 7:19the folks about the NCA exam process.
- 7:21There could be scenarios.
- 7:23Obviously, there's scenarios where you can pay for some of that
- 7:25because it's linked to training.
- 7:27Now.
- 7:27Should this get put in place, you'd be able to pay for some
- 7:30dependent care related to that.
- 7:32And I'll have some more details on that as we come up and it.
- 7:35So what happens is this adds dependent care costs to the list of reimbursable
- 7:39expenses under the Reg 7 0 1 0.33
- 7:43applies to federal credit unions.
- 7:45It does not apply to state charters.
- 7:48Unless, of course they have a reciprocity rule, NSU a didn't mention that,
- 7:51but that always is a qualifier here.
- 7:54So who qualifies?
- 7:55Volunteer officials only not, who are not compensated for their services.
- 7:59So it wouldn't be the CEO, it wouldn't be the CFO, et cetera.
- 8:01It would be the volunteer officials only.
- 8:04It includes board members and other volunteers officially
- 8:06performing actual duties.
- 8:08Directors emeriti or honorable roles generally would not qualify
- 8:13unless they perform assigned duties.
- 8:15So what counts as dependent care defining, defined using the IRS standard?
- 8:20If there's a definition somewhere, it's always good to use that definition.
- 8:24Why create recreate a definition?
- 8:25So the care for a qualifying individual.
- 8:28Such as a child under 13, a dependent or spouse, incapable of self-care
- 8:32who lives with the official.
- 8:34It can include childcare, it can include adult dependent care.
- 8:38What the rule does not do, it does not allow reimbursement for lost wages.
- 8:42It does not cover paid leave indirect costs of volunteering.
- 8:46It does not require federal credit unions to reimburse dependent care.
- 8:49It's optional and discretionary.
- 8:51So if your board members come to you and you can't afford it this year.
- 8:56It's not something that you have to automatically do.
- 8:58But it's a nice to do and it would be something I think you'll see
- 9:02a lot of places do quite quickly.
- 9:05Should should this become final, which I anticipate it will.
- 9:08And I mentioned it does not impact the IRS tax treatment.
- 9:12Why does NCA say they're proposing this?
- 9:14They mentioned this in the briefing childcare.
- 9:17Dependent care costs have increased dramatically over 200% since 1990.
- 9:21A volunteering nationwide has declined significantly since pre pandemic levels.
- 9:26Current rules may discourage younger and working age members from serving.
- 9:30We talked a lot about on the cruise, about, the baby boom generation and
- 9:34the deposit to nature of those folks.
- 9:37And the challenge of getting.
- 9:40Younger members.
- 9:41One way to get younger members is to be able to encourage them to participate at
- 9:45a rule like this, I think would do that.
- 9:47And as I mentioned, it limits the diversity of board candidate candidates
- 9:50by eliminating people who have.
- 9:53Kids or have other people that they need to take care of.
- 9:55Now, is it gonna be a cure all and an end all?
- 9:57But no.
- 9:58I think there will be some people who will become on board members or stay
- 10:02longer as board members should they find themselves in that situation.
- 10:06And NCA acknowledged board duties are more complex Today, credit
- 10:09unions are more complex and volunteer expectations are higher.
- 10:12I can tell you with all.
- 10:15All the board governance we've seen in our discussions with
- 10:19credit unions, they clearly are raising the bar on the expectation.
- 10:22And this is nice that you can reward and compensate for some of the costs that
- 10:27these folks of your team are incurring.
- 10:29All right, so existing safeguards still applies.
- 10:32Federal credit unions must adopt written reimbursement policies,
- 10:35must ensure expenses are.
- 10:36Reasonable and appropriate must con, must consider the safety and soundness.
- 10:40If you're losing money this year and you know you're gonna make money next year,
- 10:42you might wanna wait till next year.
- 10:44NCA can object to policies that are unsafe or unsound or risky to the share
- 10:49insurance fund regulatory cost and impact.
- 10:52NCA says it's not a significant regulatory action.
- 10:55No major Im economic impact on small credit unions.
- 10:58This means.
- 10:59They didn't need to send it over for preapproval under
- 11:02the way the regulations work.
- 11:04It's not a major rule.
- 11:05It's a minor rule and it changes what kind of approvals they need to get and who they
- 11:10need to send it to through this process.
- 11:12So what is NCA?
- 11:13Asking to comment on whether to limit reimbursement to temporary
- 11:17or incremental costs only.
- 11:19Whether to require specific documentation standards, whether other situations
- 11:23should qualify training events.
- 11:25Here we go now.
- 11:26I had had written my notes here, but pulling this out, so they're saying
- 11:29training notes and conferences wouldn't apply, and my take on it would be that
- 11:34they would apply because they would fall into the what's the language?
- 11:40The performing official duties training is not an official duty.
- 11:45I would argue that training is an official duty.
- 11:47Okay.
- 11:47First takeaway here.
- 11:48I would encourage you to.
- 11:51Comment and say that training events and conferences should be covered
- 11:54under the, under that clause that it is performing official duties.
- 12:00Need to write that down here.
- 12:01Performing official duties.
- 12:04One second Gang.
- 12:05So a good opportunity here for you to impact the regulation since they proposed,
- 12:10and by the way, since they asked if they should expand it, should they decide to
- 12:13then expand it, which I think because they've asked it, they probably do.
- 12:16It had to have been contemplated in order to be in the final rule.
- 12:19So it's a positive thing that they're asking you to comment on that.
- 12:22And I would imagine they'll get a lot of comments saying that they that people.
- 12:26That should make that change.
- 12:28So what else?
- 12:29How many volunteers are realistically affected?
- 12:31What, whether safeguards used by other federal agencies
- 12:34should apply best practices from state chartered credit unions?
- 12:38So bottom line summary.
- 12:40This is a narrow targeted change.
- 12:42It does not change compensation rules.
- 12:44You still can't pay them as part of a salary, et cetera, et cetera.
- 12:48And again, the goal is to reduce barriers to volunteering so that you
- 12:51can get a better, more robust board and keep your board as the burden
- 12:55on boards keep, keeps going up.
- 12:58Now, Helpmann also made reference while we're on here, made reference to.
- 13:03Their regulation simplification project which is their spring cleaning.
- 13:07I've done some posts on that, on LinkedIn specifically on some of those details.
- 13:11Some of those are.
- 13:12Changing.
- 13:12Happy to, glad some of them are taking appendixes that are in
- 13:16regulations or as guidelines.
- 13:18But 'cause they're in the regulation as guidelines.
- 13:21They're in the regulations, so they're not really guidelines.
- 13:22They fix that.
- 13:23That was a pretty cool one.
- 13:25And I've got some podcasts on the sister podcasts.
- 13:27Samantha shares that walked through those changes in particular.
- 13:31Next week I'll be doing a podcast, recording a podcast on Monday with
- 13:35Steve and Todd of my team about the cruise presentation we did and n
- 13:40NCAA's priority letter that came out.
- 13:44Earlier this week.
- 13:45I had a 10,000 foot level podcast on the priority letter.
- 13:50Hopman made reference to it that they will be having.
- 13:54A webinar on it on February 19th.
- 13:57I'll issue a challenge to NCUA when you have that webinar.
- 14:00Please do more than just read the letter to Credit Union.
- 14:03Some of the recent webinars on NCUA guidance have been pretty mundane, not
- 14:09adding much in value in my opinion.
- 14:12What we're gonna try and do next week is say.
- 14:14Here's what we think this means.
- 14:16We, this is how this will be interpreted.
- 14:18Maybe this is what should have been in the letter.
- 14:20And then of course we'll talk about some things some fun things that came
- 14:23up in our conversations on the cruise.
- 14:25Again, emergency podcast wrap number one.
- 14:28And let me know what you think of this quicker, quicker hit podcast approach.
- 14:33I'll do it when it makes sense.
- 14:35I'll do it when I have the time to do it.
- 14:36And again, coming off the discussion on.
- 14:40On ai on the cruise.
- 14:42This was a really good opportunity to launch this.
- 14:45And again I worked on this morning before my coffee, I was playing
- 14:49around with with the software and came up with this new one minute intro.
- 14:53The emergency podcast.
- 14:54All right, that's it.
- 14:54Mark Trekel signing off with flying colors.