Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / FDIC and OCC Define Safety and Sound & What Credit Unions Should Take From It
Transcript
- 0:00Mark Treichel: Hey, everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Trakel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I'm excited to be here today with Steve Farr and Todd Miller.
- 0:05Guys, how you doing?
- 0:07Steve Farrar: Doing well.
- 0:08Thanks, Mark.
- 0:08Good.
- 0:08Beautiful morning here.
- 0:10Mark Treichel: Glad to hear it.
- 0:10Long time no see.
- 0:12Yesterday, we recorded ⦠What did we record?
- 0:14The NCUA entry letter, and we made references to some other
- 0:17things, maybe including what we're gonna talk about today.
- 0:20Today we're gonna talk about s- the safety and soundness regulation
- 0:24that came out for FDIC and OCC.
- 0:28Before we get into that, let's get give a, a 10,000-foot intro to
- 0:32your background at NCUA for those listeners or watchers who may have
- 0:36not seen an episode with you before.
- 0:38We'll start with Steve.
- 0:40Steve Farrar: Hey.
- 0:40Y- yeah, good morning, everybody.
- 0:41I, I break my career at NCUA into two parts.
- 0:44The first part is out in the field, predominantly as a problem case
- 0:48officer where you worked closely with credit unions with problems
- 0:52involving conservatorships, liquidations assisted mergers.
- 0:58My first assisted merger wa- it was assistance of $30,000.
- 1:03And I remember it being early in the morning, the guy calls me
- 1:07up and I was like, "All right.
- 1:08I'll do an assisted merger for this amount."
- 1:11And it was like, I had authority from the region for $30,000 and we got it done.
- 1:15It was in a remote area, and I was actually just standing
- 1:20in my bathroom negotiating it.
- 1:22So that was how times changed, but that was enjoyable.
- 1:26And all that time.
- 1:26Then after you went to the central office, I spent the next 15 years there
- 1:31in the central office, Division of Risk Management, and en- enjoyed that because
- 1:37the, the work was diverse and challenging.
- 1:40The, my favorite part was trai- training the examiners in problem resolution
- 1:45big communication section and then working on the en- enforcement manual
- 1:50and the then risk-based capital kind of towards the end, and finished my career
- 1:54as the, a vice president of the CLF.
- 1:58Mark Treichel: Yep, yep.
- 1:59Chock-full of good memories and good accomplishments.
- 2:01Todd.
- 2:03Todd Miller: Greetings, everyone.
- 2:04I spent 34 years with NCUA.
- 2:06Something we haven't talked about in other introductions is Steve and I
- 2:09were hired by the same person, and we were in the same SE group for a while.
- 2:13And we were in the same division of special actions
- 2:15under the same DSA for a while.
- 2:18But basically, the first 14 years of my career or so, I spent it as
- 2:23a problem case officer and examiner in the field in the Western Region.
- 2:27Then I spent a decade or so as a regional capital market specialist in the
- 2:31Western Region, but I also got involved in a lot of other team exams At the
- 2:36national level, like I was on Pena-- or Navy's exam for four years in a row.
- 2:41Did a lot of the training and had a hand in writing a lot of the
- 2:45interest rate risk and liquidity policy at NCUA during that decade.
- 2:49Then I spent another decade or so, a little bit more, as a director of
- 2:53special actions in the Western region, supervising problem case officer,
- 2:57regional capital market specialists, and regional lending specialists.
- 3:01Like Steve, I got involved in a lot of assistance cases, a lot
- 3:05of mergers, a lot of, or a number of liquidations, some involving
- 3:11assistance with very big amounts.
- 3:13Was involved in a couple conservatorships.
- 3:15Actually, at one time, I had six conservatorships at once in twenty eleven
- 3:19that I was managing but I returned a couple conservatorships to the members.
- 3:24They're still there today.
- 3:25That was always a gratifying part of my career.
- 3:28But all in all, I enjoyed my 34 years with MCUA.
- 3:31It was a veryâ¦
- 3:34I just enjoyed every bit of it.
- 3:35And you become ensconced in the whole credit union philosophy
- 3:41when you spend that much time with
- 3:42Mark Treichel: it.
- 3:43That's a fact.
- 3:43That's a fact.
- 3:44Six, six conservatorships at one time is is crazy.
- 3:47I would've had rules against that too.
- 3:48We were talking about some of the rules I had when I,
- 3:51Todd Miller: when I was- I was the only DSA, and I got a
- 3:52supervisor of the year out of it
- 3:53Mark Treichel: Lane Baumgartner, regional director in, in, in the
- 3:56eastern region used to conserve a lot.
- 3:58This was before the 2011 timeline, so this would've been I'm digressing
- 4:02here, but Dan Murphy was the regional director y- you worked for
- 4:06during b- before that 2011 period.
- 4:08I worked for Dan.
- 4:09Dan w- had a, when he retired he sent out an email and he, Lane Baumgartner liked to
- 4:17do a lot of conservatorships, like having six or seven at one time, and he said
- 4:21that he Lane, h- he joked that Lane had written a boat, or he, how did he say it?
- 4:27He said, "It's easier to put a credit union into conservatorship
- 4:30than it is to take them out."
- 4:31And that was the, that's what the, the book Lane should write because
- 4:34they had a hard time getting them out.
- 4:35And
- 4:36Todd Miller: I-
- 4:36Mark Treichel: I had
- 4:36Todd Miller: one-
- 4:37Mark Treichel: All three of us, all three of us were DSAs,
- 4:40all three of us were PCOs.
- 4:40It was my, and it was the, those two roles were what I, helped
- 4:44me be an RD more than anything.
- 4:46Todd Miller: I had one conservatorship similar.
- 4:47We gave them a capital note, and the NCUA board would not let them out of
- 4:52conservatorship until that was paid off.
- 4:53So they got stuck in conservatorship for five years, but realistically,
- 4:57every problem was fixed in probably 12 or 14 months.
- 5:00Mark Treichel: Yeah, the
- 5:00Todd Miller: politics get in the way sometimes.
- 5:01The political will of the board would not let them go back to the members.
- 5:04Mark Treichel: Yep.
- 5:05It'll be interesting when, so much turnover at the NCUA board and the,
- 5:08that plus the corporate knowledge that has left NCUA, what the new normal
- 5:11becomes, and whenever they have a board that actually is more political.
- 5:15Not that Hauptman wasn't political, but he drove it in one direction
- 5:18because there was only one vote.
- 5:19Re- a reestablishment of the board's gonna be interesting.
- 5:21All right lots of rabbit holes there.
- 5:22Let's jump into the, the rule that came out on safety and soundness.
- 5:27Of course NCUA relies on safety and soundness.
- 5:30Ha- the 34 years we were at credit unions, or at NCUA, and the six years
- 5:35we've been doing this, safety and soundness gets, has been referred
- 5:39to in exams from here to eternity.
- 5:41We talked a little bit in our last podcast that NCUA's, and we can dip into it here,
- 5:45that NCUA is using that a little bit less.
- 5:48But at the same time the banking regulators have defined
- 5:51safety and soundness after a proposal, the rule's final.
- 5:54So let's, I'm gonna open it up there for a free for all chat on this.
- 5:58Who wants to talk about what first relative to this rule?
- 6:02Steve Farrar: We'll just, go through that definition of unsafe and unsound.
- 6:06That's the main crux of it.
- 6:07I-- That was a question when I was teaching problem resolution to examiners.
- 6:12And then when they were taking that class, they'd been around a while,
- 6:14and I'd always start by asking them.
- 6:16I'd go, I'll go, "Okay, so you've been an examiner for a while.
- 6:20We always talk about unsafe and unsound.
- 6:22Who can tell me where that's defined in NCUA, the act or regulations or whatever?"
- 6:28And, they'd all be like, "I
- 6:30Todd Miller: It'sâ¦
- 6:31Steve Farrar: it's gotta be in the act."
- 6:32And it's like, "No, I'm sure it's in a regulation."
- 6:35It was not defined and it wasn't also defined for the banking industry.
- 6:39It was based on whatever case law was out there and where it had been challenged,
- 6:45and then it was somewhat defined in that.
- 6:47So there was kind of this, a, a little bit of a loose litigated
- 6:51definition of unsafe and unsound.
- 6:53And so the regulators, work now to place a solid definition on it, and
- 6:59we'll read that in just a little bit.
- 7:00Todd, do you have an introduction to�
- 7:02Todd Miller: Yeah, just a couple things ar-around that.
- 7:06If you actually go look at the act, the word safe, unsafe, safety, it's
- 7:13only in there 29 times in the act.
- 7:16And it says, "If you're gonna charter a new credit union in NCUA, they have
- 7:20to operate in a safe and sound manner.
- 7:23NCUA, if you're gonna take an administrative action, it's gonna
- 7:26be because they're operating in an unsafe sound manner."
- 7:30And that's all it says in the act.
- 7:32In, in the regulations, there's a thing about the whole
- 7:36insurance agreement in 741.3.
- 7:40Examiners cite that a little bit.
- 7:42It gives the hodgepodges of credit unions are gonna have
- 7:45policies, liquidity, this, that.
- 7:47Really where NCUA encapsulates what they think is unsafe and unsound is in their
- 7:53National Supervision Policy Manual.
- 7:55They have guidelines for issuing documents of resolutions, and
- 7:59they do have a number of criteria there, but that's not a regulation.
- 8:03And that's buried back in, I don't know, let's see, what page?
- 8:06I looked it up yesterday.
- 8:07That's buried back in page 225 of the Supervision Manual.
- 8:12But on page one, they have this new thing that helped them came up
- 8:15with, no regulation by enforcement.
- 8:19It's just interesting.
- 8:20And then it kinda talks about things that, that- examiner shouldn't do and how the
- 8:26agency should not be creating policies by issuing administrative actions or
- 8:32documents or resolution, what have you.
- 8:35So it puts NCUA examiners in kind of a hard point where they have to
- 8:39have regulatory cites to issue a DOR.
- 8:44They're supposed to not use the unsafe/unsound.
- 8:47But then now the other regulators, they gave their examiners a
- 8:51regulatory- Exactly ⦠unsafe/unsound.
- 8:53And I'm surprised NCUA didn't join in this.
- 8:56I'm sure Hauptman had a reason because more and more NCUA has been joining
- 9:01with the other FFIC agencies when they come out with stuff, and I'm surprised
- 9:05they didn't with this because what's in this regulation is really not
- 9:11that far away from the stuff that's in the NSPM for examiners' guidance.
- 9:16Mark Treichel: And that's a great point.
- 9:17And you can probably see as they look at the NSPM before we started
- 9:21c- chatting, I talked about the safety of traveling in crowds, right?
- 9:25The NCUA can look towards what the bankers have put in and if it isn't identical to
- 9:30what the regulation has now, you said it's similar maybe we can talk through that.
- 9:34It's a safe place to land, but it's just guidance, not, it's not a rule.
- 9:38And it's not even guidance.
- 9:40It's the, it's what they're telling their examiners to do.
- 9:43So it hasn't been put out for public comment and it's less
- 9:46binding or not binding when you get to the final analysis of that.
- 9:49I
- 9:49Todd Miller: don't, I don't think the examiners are allowed to cite their NSPM.
- 9:53Mark Treichel: Correct.
- 9:54Todd Miller: It seems it's an- It's not- ⦠internal operating policy.
- 9:56Mark Treichel: It, you know- I- an internal operating policy that has a
- 9:59version online which has some redactions and a lot of dead links and boar- Chairman
- 10:04Cruz, if you or your staff listen to this, go to that, that, that redacted link.
- 10:09Look at the dead links.
- 10:10You guys need to fix that, 'cause it violates the redaction rules.
- 10:14I, I get on this high horse on the podcast every once in a while relative
- 10:18to that, but it's a disservice to credit unions that there are dead links
- 10:22that that may be on those dead links.
- 10:25There's, 50 pages and they can't see any of it which means it has to be in
- 10:30violation of the redaction rule because some of it would have to be public.
- 10:33Clean that up.
- 10:34Maybe when you get a little bit more staff and ability to hire more people, that's
- 10:37something that NCUA can take a look at.
- 10:39All right, off that soap bo- soapbox.
- 10:41So mayâ¦
- 10:41should we walk through what that definition is and then maybe
- 10:44walk through what the NSPM says?
- 10:46Steve Farrar: Yeah.
- 10:47We can do it that way.
- 10:47While I read, the best one I found is the the information that
- 10:52OCC released on August 27th on the, when the rules are approved.
- 10:56It's succinct and very good.
- 10:58It defines unsafe, unsound practice.
- 11:00The final rule defines the term unsafe or unsound practice for purposes of both
- 11:06enforcement actions under 12 USC 1818 and supervisory activities as a practice act
- 11:14or failure to act alone or together with other practices, acts, or failures to act.
- 11:20That number one, is contrary to generally accepted standards of prudent operations.
- 11:25And two, I, if continued, is likelyâ¦
- 11:29We're gonna talk about likely in this one, too.
- 11:32To, A, materially harm a financial condition of the bank,
- 11:35or B, present a material risk of loss to the insurance fund.
- 11:40Or two, materially harm the financial condition of the bank.
- 11:45To qualify as an unsafe or unsound practice under the final rule, it would
- 11:50have to be likely, as opposed to, for example, merely possible, that a practice
- 11:56act or failure to act, if continued, would materially harm the financial
- 12:00condition of the bank or present a material risk of loss of insurance fund.
- 12:05The definition focuses on material harm to financial condition, i.e.,
- 12:10financial losses or other negative impacts to a bank's capital,
- 12:15asset quality, earnings liquidity, or sensitivity to market risks.
- 12:20The definition would not include risks to the b- bank's reputation
- 12:25unrelated to financial condition.
- 12:28An unsafe or unsound practice would also include a practice act or failure
- 12:33to act that, if continued, is likely to negatively affect the bank's ability to
- 12:39avoid FDIC receivership and present a material risk of loss to the insurance
- 12:45fund as a result of the failure
- 12:48Mark Treichel: There's a lot there to unpack.
- 12:50Todd, start unpacking it.
- 12:53Todd Miller: I'm gonna go to the end of the regulation.
- 12:56Steve read you the beginning.
- 12:58Okay.
- 12:58This reg's only two pages.
- 13:00The comments ran 70-some pages, and they're worth a read for people.
- 13:04But at the end, it's like, how does the regulators determine that?
- 13:09And they put in there, "Here's the basis for our determinations that
- 13:13something is unsafe, unsound."
- 13:15They will use objective facts and sound reasoning to determine this.
- 13:21That's good.
- 13:21So the examiners don't get to make it up.
- 13:23They have to have some basis for the regulation or some basis for determining
- 13:28that something is unsafe, unsound.
- 13:31There's also another caveat in the regulation.
- 13:34Things like BSA and agreements they've made with other people,
- 13:37they can enforce those even though they're not unsafe, unsound.
- 13:41They have a cop-out in the regulation that, "Hey, we get to
- 13:43enforce this other stuff as well."
- 13:46Because we have agreements with FinCEN.
- 13:47If you have BSA violations, you have to make those doors or as the
- 13:52OCC and then call them material, how come the word's escaping me?
- 13:57It's in the regulation even itself.
- 14:01Mark Treichel: Could you repeat the premise?
- 14:02Todd Miller: Their com- equivalent of a door.
- 14:06Oh, MRA.
- 14:06Steve Farrar: requiring attention.
- 14:07Todd Miller: we go.
- 14:07Steve Farrar: M- MRAs, yeah.
- 14:09Todd Miller: I had a brain lock for a minute.
- 14:11Mark Treichel: Yeah, that's all right.
- 14:12Todd Miller: They also say if they can make an MRA out of this other stuff,
- 14:16other regulations from other regulators.
- 14:19Just like MC- NCUA, we have agreements, hey, BSA violations,
- 14:23certain ones have to be made a door, whether they're unsafe, unsound.
- 14:27OCC and FDIC do have themselves a, a cop-out in this regulation where they
- 14:32can enforce those other items as well.
- 14:35Mark Treichel: Items lower than an MRA?
- 14:38Todd Miller: Other agencies ⦠that don't meet unsafe and unsound
- 14:41regulation, but they can still make them an MRA because they've got
- 14:45agreements with other regulators.
- 14:47Mark Treichel: On the repu- the reputation risk it's funny, I was having a credit
- 14:50union conversation the other day, and we went into the fact that I think
- 14:54generally it's good that reputation risk doesn't have to be in the exam because
- 14:59it's almost it's almost a given that if someone has to deal with reputation
- 15:04risk, they should be dealing with it.
- 15:05So if you're facing something that you did wrong that could lead to a lawsuit
- 15:09or a class action lawsuit it's not necessarily that the regulator needs to
- 15:13tell you to deal with it, because it goes to the heart of being an organization.
- 15:17Or if there's, a malware that takes over, you don't necessarily need the
- 15:20regulator to point that out and all things being equal, I think agencies
- 15:26not highlighting that is okay.
- 15:28On the material, the the MRA versus the door any, any thoughts, a- any other
- 15:36thoughts on how they deal with the MRA and how that m- how that differs now relative
- 15:42to where NCUA and credit unions are at?
- 15:46Todd Miller: I think NCUA is going in the direction of where this regulation is.
- 15:50MRAs have always been a big deal in banks because you're dealing with private
- 15:54investors, and so i-it's stockholders that you're arguing with, so there's
- 16:01always been a little bit more of a challenge for the other regulators to
- 16:05include an MRA than there is at NCUA.
- 16:09And this is a pretty high hurdle here, especially in larger banks, for them
- 16:15to declare something unsafe and unsound and to demonstrate with objective facts
- 16:22that this is gonna be a material risk
- 16:26Mark Treichel: And when you say the stockholder thing, that's
- 16:28because there's a cost, right?
- 16:30Todd Miller: Yes, and so when the owner is the board chair and the CEO, they don't-
- 16:36Mark Treichel: It is their money
- 16:37⦠Todd Miller: they don't like to agree to MRAs-
- 16:40Mark Treichel: Right
- 16:41⦠Todd Miller: that cost them money or handcuff them in different ways.
- 16:45Mark Treichel: Steve, any, any thoughts on that piece?
- 16:49Steve Farrar: No, I think we're fine on that.
- 16:50more consistency in what is a dir- a clear directive like the, the
- 16:56MRAs for the banking is helpful.
- 16:58Mark Treichel: Todd, you referenced the comments, and I think I
- 17:01picked up on, if I'm remembering.
- 17:03I've been reading a lot of different things lately the the likely or
- 17:05merely possible and all that I think there were comments that
- 17:08said there should be a list, right?
- 17:09Or there should be a bright line, and they resisted doing that, and
- 17:12they went with these, these words that are open to interpretation.
- 17:16And I guess, Steve, if you go back to what you said, that the def- definition
- 17:19of safety and soundness wasn't defined before, and it was case law, right?
- 17:22So now it's gonna turn into probably case law on what means likely and
- 17:27what means merely possible and what means material loss, right?
- 17:30It the you try and clean up and create something with the new rule, but
- 17:34it's still all based on words, and words have meanings, and then facts
- 17:38get applied to that or misapplied to that, and people end up suing.
- 17:41So it's gonna kinda walk through that whole timeline again perhaps.
- 17:46Steve Farrar: Yeah, I like this one quote that's in the OCC statement.
- 17:49"The final rule explains that the agencies will use objective facts and
- 17:53sound reasoning to determine whether they may take an enforcement action
- 17:57based on an unsafe or unsound practice or issue matter requiring attention.
- 18:05The examiners must share with the bank the basis for their
- 18:08identification of a unsafe and unsound practice or the issuance of a MRA.
- 18:15Examiner's use of objective facts and sound reasoning will promote objective and
- 18:19consistent application of the final rule supervisory and enforcement standards."
- 18:26done.
- 18:28Facts always win, and we always will tell our clients and stuff when they're
- 18:32dealing with NCUA, if the findings or whatever the examiners aren't have, aren't
- 18:38true in fact, that's your best value.
- 18:40That's where you push
- 18:41Mark Treichel: back.
- 18:41Steve Farrar: Yep.
- 18:41Great point.
- 18:41The facts always win.
- 18:43And me, as a problem case o- officer if I had a an institution that was
- 18:50doing a lot of things wrong, it would just be, here's just all the facts.
- 18:53Fact.
- 18:54And when you get to, 30-some facts, there's a ex- a conclusion that should
- 18:58be reached by the board of directors as to what's the root cause of a of all
- 19:04of these facts of of poor operations.
- 19:07Mark Treichel: Leading the horse to water, yes.
- 19:08Steve Farrar: Yeah
- 19:11Todd Miller: One of the criteria is harm to a financial condition.
- 19:14They said that refers to financial losses, negative impacts on an institution's
- 19:18capital asset quality, earnings, liquidity, or sensitivity to market risk.
- 19:23So it doesn't necessarily have to whack their capital, it can
- 19:25be something else that's risky.
- 19:27A- and they put that in there because the next section of the regulation is
- 19:31all about tailoring their MRAs or DORS.
- 19:35And it's very interesting because it brings up an issue where it says, "Hey,
- 19:42as potential losses increase the threshold for materiality or harm of institution
- 19:48decreases, but then the granularity of their actions has to get more detailed."
- 19:55And when I read that, I immediately think of something like Centrix.
- 19:58Okay, they might have a portfolio, it isn't gonna hurt anything, but it is gonna
- 20:02cause harm to the financial institution.
- 20:05Very specific goals.
- 20:06This is how you're gonna mitigate it.
- 20:08This is how you're gonna reduce the risk of it.
- 20:10And it's interesting that they put that tailoring thing in there, which means,
- 20:14hey, this whole DOR has to be commen- or MRA, it has to be commensurate
- 20:19with that scope of that problem.
- 20:21And it doesn't get to be broad general.
- 20:24It needs to get fairly specific when they've objectively decided that, this
- 20:31is going to be an unsafe, unsound issue.
- 20:34They have to be very specific in their MRAs as to how they're
- 20:38going to address those issues.
- 20:41Mark Treichel: And yesterday we were talking about the entry letter
- 20:44on exams, which talked about the fact that DORS are negotiable.
- 20:48They-- Not that they haven't been, but they're kinda
- 20:50highlighting that fact, right?
- 20:51That kind of plays into this too.
- 20:54It-- Well, from an NCUA perspective it does, right?
- 20:56But we're talking about the bank rule.
- 20:58But as you're tailoring that an advantage of that letter going out is a reminder
- 21:03to credit unions that they need to be If they're going to put a door in
- 21:07place, NCUA needs to work with you on coming up with something that makes
- 21:12sense for you, for the members that doesn't overstep as opposed to just
- 21:17being a, a grandiose, do 95 things and we're not gonna get your thoughts on it.
- 21:21Todd, you mentioned CAMELS the, that it, those losses have to be linked
- 21:25back to C, A, E, L, and S, right?
- 21:28And at the same time it's it seems pretty clear to me that this definition
- 21:34of safety and soundness rule and the reworking of FFIEC of the CAMELS rule
- 21:39which has been proposed, go hand in glove.
- 21:41Any, any thoughts on that or the other statement I made
- 21:44on doors and negotiability?
- 21:46Todd Miller: I think so.
- 21:47I have a quick question for Steve.
- 21:48Did you look at this proposal and did they change the rule
- 21:52much from the original proposal?
- 21:54'Cause the comments went for and against.
- 21:57There was a lot of comments that says, "You need to be
- 21:59e- even more specific, and-
- 22:01Steve Farrar: Yeah
- 22:02Todd Miller: you need to be harder on the banks than you are."
- 22:04And then of course there was comments that say, "Hey you're overstepping already."
- 22:09So i- it's interesting when you read their comments that they went both ways on this.
- 22:14Steve Farrar: Yeah, I was surprised.
- 22:15There was 36 comments, that isn't a lot, but they're pretty good ones.
- 22:20Mark Treichel: I actually have the data on what what changed.
- 22:23Yeah.
- 22:23Th- there were two changes between the proposal and the final rule.
- 22:26Go ahead.
- 22:27Steve Farrar: Yeah.
- 22:27Mark Treichel: Okay.
- 22:27The first one institution-affiliated parties were dropped from the scope.
- 22:32A def- a definition keyed to material harm at a large institution would effectively
- 22:37immunize an individual who underwrote badl- bad, underwrote badly at a big
- 22:42bank and then moved to a small one.
- 22:45Enforcement against in- institutional affiliated parties or IAPs continues
- 22:51under the agency's prior standards and controlling c- cor- law.
- 22:56So there was something in here about institutional affiliated parties.
- 23:00Yeah.
- 23:00And they were convinced to drop that.
- 23:02The other one is a new category, other violations.
- 23:07Actual violations that do not earn an MRA or an enforcement action.
- 23:11The agency may direct remediation.
- 23:13So this, I think, is Todd, the one you mentioned.
- 23:16And may not direct anything beyond remediation unless
- 23:19another law requires it.
- 23:20For FDIC-supervised institutions, an uncorrected or, un- uncorrected
- 23:25other violation can be cited as an MRA at the next exam.
- 23:30Todd Miller: If you violated a reg and you didn't fix it, then we can cite it even
- 23:34though it's not causing material harm yet.
- 23:38What I think is interesting is even though NCUA didn't participate in
- 23:41this reg, and this tends to change with different board members, what the
- 23:46other regulators do does inform NCUA.
- 23:50And quite often, even if they don't adopt the exact policy, or in this case they
- 23:55don't exact, or adopt the reg, their behavior still considers all of that, and
- 24:01it does change the way NCUA does things.
- 24:04Mark Treichel: Sure.
- 24:05And that goes to traveling with A they're doing it, so if we're gonna
- 24:08differ from them, credit unions will point out banks get to do X, right?
- 24:12And you're telling us to do Y.
- 24:13So it's a good rule to be looking at that.
- 24:16But you're exactly right.
- 24:17There, there were some board members who would say, "This is happening there.
- 24:22We need to do it."
- 24:23Or this isâ¦
- 24:25And the lesser side of that would be, "This is hap- happening there.
- 24:28Explain to me what we do and why we should or shouldn't."
- 24:33Todd Miller: There are different times over in our career where I thought
- 24:37NCUA's exam scope and some of our policies were actually ahead of theirs.
- 24:40Mark Treichel: Yeah, that and being nimble and being smaller and
- 24:42being able to be more flexible.
- 24:44There's no doubt that in and it's probably 50/50.
- 24:47Probably, if you went through them all, I would bet it's half the
- 24:50time NCUA is better than what the banks are doing, and vice versa
- 24:54Steve Farrar: Yeah.
- 24:54One thing, and I always look at, when I look at FDIC tech rules is that they
- 24:59specifically note that they apply to community banks because that's much more-
- 25:05Mark Treichel: Similar,
- 25:05Steve Farrar: Closely aligned with credit unions.
- 25:07And, they do specifically have the notice in there, "Yes, this
- 25:11does apply to community banks."
- 25:13That, that's not really the intent because the final rule clarifies how
- 25:18and when agencies may communicate informal observations called supervisory
- 25:24observations for weaknesses that do not rise to the level of an MRA.
- 25:29Unlike MRAs, the supervisory observation does not create
- 25:33a requirement or a supervisor expectation that will be presented
- 25:36to the bank's board of directors.
- 25:38This framework will allow examiners to share their expertise with management
- 25:43and the board of directors about potential enhancements while leaving
- 25:47decisions regarding the implementation of any enhancements to the bank.
- 25:52I love that, that wording there, that we put that responsibility
- 25:55back or they put that responsibility back on the board of directors.
- 25:59Mark Treichel: Todd, thoughts on that?
- 26:00I got a couple, but why don't you go first?
- 26:02Todd Miller: It's equivalent to NCUA's exam findings.
- 26:06And I think it ties back to that whole first piece of this
- 26:11regulation at the OCC and the FDIC.
- 26:14Contrary to generally accepted standards of prudent operation,
- 26:17the examiner's experience actually get to help them determine that.
- 26:22And, that's another piece of this.
- 26:24It will get litigated and turned into case law eventually.
- 26:28But, that throws a lot on the examiners to say, "Hey, what's generally accepted
- 26:32standards of prudent operation?"
- 26:34Mark Treichel: and the other thing that jumps into my mind is, again, the
- 26:36conversation we had yesterday where NCUA is talking about just because we
- 26:40have conversations with you and ask you questions about certain things
- 26:43and maybe talking about not, maybe not safety and soundness, but best
- 26:47practices and how you've got this new program and you're doing X, Y, and Z.
- 26:50Have you thought of this, and have you thought of that?
- 26:52Those dialogues can still happen, which is just the sharing of the expertise
- 26:56and the understanding of the situation.
- 26:58But that's not a finding that leads to them having to do X.
- 27:01And then the whole discussion we had yesterday about supplementary
- 27:03facts are not binding.
- 27:05Very similar, right?
- 27:06You can talk about different things in parts of the report that don't
- 27:10lead to required action but lead to a better understanding of all parties-
- 27:17Todd Miller: I think that's the way examiners, whether you're OCC,
- 27:20FDIC, NCUA, state, it's their way of helping improve the industry.
- 27:26'Cause frankly, I'd rather have an informal discussion in year one and
- 27:31have them reassess their policies and procedures than have to come
- 27:36back three years later and issue a DOR or an LUA because they let
- 27:41a problem grow from tiny to large
- 27:44Mark Treichel: Which goes back to the best examiners being
- 27:47the ones who communicate best
- 27:49Todd Miller: Yeah.
- 27:50Mark Treichel: You could be extremely skilled and not be able to get your
- 27:52point across, and a little less skilled but have the ability to
- 27:55communicate and have those discussions.
- 27:58Todd Miller: I think if you just take examiners in general from
- 28:01any industry, they want their institutions to improve and do well.
- 28:06Mark Treichel: Facts.
- 28:06Yep.
- 28:07Todd Miller: A liquidated credit union, I don't want to conserve one.
- 28:09I want you guys just to operate safe, sound, grow, do well.
- 28:14Steve Farrar: And on the other side, I don't want to be associated
- 28:16with a credit union that caused a large loss to the insurance fund.
- 28:21Todd Miller: Our advantage of the DSA is that you can always blame
- 28:23the FEs and the people ahead of you.
- 28:25Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 28:26I'm looking at the notes I had here.
- 28:28I think we've covered a lot of things.
- 28:30What else what else have we not hit on this that we need to hit, guys?
- 28:34Todd Miller: Like I said, for credit unions, there is a part
- 28:36of the NSPM that is public.
- 28:39And that public part, it does clearly enunciate for examiners what's
- 28:45a DOR and what's not, and when you take administrative actions.
- 28:49So it's worth a quick read.
- 28:51It's under a specific section on administrative actions and there's
- 28:56a whole flowchart for examiners to follow as to what rises to a DOR or not
- 29:02Mark Treichel: Very good.
- 29:03And Steve, any last thoughts?
- 29:05Steve Farrar: No we've covered all of the key points that I had listed for today.
- 29:09Mark Treichel: Very good.
- 29:10Todd, it looks like you might have had one more thing you wanted to mention.
- 29:12Todd Miller: Like I said, just, if you get issued a DOR and you disagree
- 29:16with it, credit unions do pull up the NSPM, look at what rises to a DOR,
- 29:23make the examiner say, "Hey, show me here where this is actually a DOR."
- 29:27Mark Treichel: Do we have that language in front of us anywhere, the NSPM?
- 29:31Todd Miller: Oh, I have it.
- 29:31I have it right here.
- 29:32Mark Treichel: All right.
- 29:33Let's say here's what NCUA says in the NSPM is safe and sound.
- 29:37Todd Miller: Okay.
- 29:38It's about a page and a half.
- 29:39Problems requiring immediate attention that examiners will address in a
- 29:43DOR include systemic, recurrent or willful negligent compliance
- 29:49violations that pose a material risk.
- 29:52So it's back to their FDIC thing, where you're not fixing a regulation,
- 29:56allow it to go uncorrected.
- 29:59BSA violations as per the agreement between NCUA and FinCEN.
- 30:03So it doesn't have to be material harm, but we're gonna get you a DOR because
- 30:08we've agreed to do so with FinCEN.
- 30:10Unsafe or unsound practices that present an immediate threat
- 30:14to credit union's viability.
- 30:16Unsafe or unsound practices are any action or lack thereof action that if left
- 30:23uncorrected, present material financial risk or harm to the credit union or its
- 30:27members, including but not limited to.
- 30:30Doesn't that sound exactly like the OCC regulation?
- 30:33Yeah, I'm saying
- 30:33Mark Treichel: this sounds,
- 30:34Todd Miller: it sounds like a rhyme.
- 30:35Mark Treichel: It rhymes, for sure.
- 30:36Great point.
- 30:38Todd Miller: Operating with an inadequate level of net worth or capital for the
- 30:41type, quality and concentration of assets.
- 30:45Operating with negative earnings that do not support operations
- 30:48and maintain appropriate capital and allowance for credit losses.
- 30:52Operating with material or systemic weaknesses in credit underwriting
- 30:57or administration practices such as excessive or inadequately managed
- 31:02credit risk or loan losses, extending credit without adequate controls.
- 31:08Operating without adequate liquidity.
- 31:11Significant non-compliance with the Federal Credit Union Act,
- 31:14NCUA regulations, and other applicable laws and regulations.
- 31:19Operating without internal, adequate internal controls.
- 31:24And underneath adequate internal controls, it gives examples.
- 31:27Persistent record-keeping errors, numerous loans granted outside of
- 31:31policy, manipulation of records Other next item, failure to
- 31:37keep accurate books and records.
- 31:38This includes an accounting and control structure, does not
- 31:41provide for accurate, full and fair disclosure of financial statements.
- 31:45Inappropriate or inadequate asset liability management.
- 31:49So that's basically their list, and it covers everything.
- 31:53And it says, when determining if a problem qualifies as a DORA,
- 31:56examiners will consider the following.
- 31:59If left unresolved, could the violation or problem cause the credit union
- 32:02serious financial operational damage?
- 32:04Does the problem result in significant non-compliance with laws or regulations?
- 32:09Is the problem something that would need to be escalated to the next level
- 32:13enforcement, PWL, LUA, cease and desist order, or conservatorship if unresolved?
- 32:22And is the problem widespread throughout the credit
- 32:26Mark Treichel: union?
- 32:26It's a good definition.
- 32:27Lot, a lot there.
- 32:28We could do a s- whole separate podcast on that as we drop it in here at the end.
- 32:31But and then so the thing that comes to my mind is something we mentioned
- 32:36earlier, is NCUA, if they're doing a DORA, they have to link it to a reg.
- 32:41A lot of those things.
- 32:42So this is the definition of unsafe and unsound, which is linked to one
- 32:46reg, but we're hearing through the grapevine that how do I wanna say this?
- 32:51NCUA's examiners are asked to be maybe more judicious in utilizing that than
- 32:56maybe they had two, four, six years ago.
- 32:59Thoughts on that, and then maybe a wrap.
- 33:01Todd Miller: Yeah, so the catchall for examiners was always the 741.3
- 33:05if they didn't have another specific loan reg or something.
- 33:08That regulation is basically requirements for insurance, and it lists
- 33:13a hodgepodge things about policies, qualified staff, liquidity, ALM.
- 33:19There's a number of things- listed underneath that whole insurability
- 33:24statement, and that's what they would use.
- 33:27And it doesn't really speak to this directly.
- 33:30It does for maybe half of it.
- 33:32And they're being told, "Hey, stop using that toâ¦"
- 33:36Or, "Make it very rare.
- 33:37We wanna see other more specific regs."
- 33:39And I think that's just driven by this whole thing, we're not gonnaâ¦
- 33:43No regulation by enforcement.
- 33:45And, using that insurance agreement, you're enforcing things that are
- 33:50not otherwise in the regulation.
- 33:52'Cause, we've seen it in some of our clients.
- 33:54They'll cite that and it's just "Wait,
- 33:56Mark Treichel: how does
- 33:57Todd Miller: that problem apply to any of these things listed here?"
- 33:59Exactly.
- 34:00Mark Treichel: Yeah
- 34:00⦠Todd Miller: that's what they've been instructed to cite
- 34:01when they have nothing else.
- 34:03And like I said, they've been told to be very judicious about that,
- 34:06or so we hear from other people still working for the agency.
- 34:11But in this case, substantively what's in NCUA's NSPM, which isn't
- 34:16guidance or regulation or anything, it's not materially different than
- 34:21what the OCC and FDIC came up with.
- 34:23Mark Treichel: Great point.
- 34:24Steve, any last thoughts on any of that dialogue?
- 34:28Steve Farrar: No.
- 34:28that was very good.
- 34:29Very good.
- 34:29It's always, facts speak for themselves,
- 34:31Mark Treichel: and fact- facts.
- 34:32You taught me that back in, ⦠1995, I believe.
- 34:35So Steve, I know that your team is the refs.
- 34:39Todd, who does your team play the first week?
- 34:41Todd Miller: Your team.
- 34:42Mark Treichel: Ah, the Vikings.
- 34:43Skol.
- 34:44You got any predictions?
- 34:45Let's predict the scores of game one.
- 34:47You go first.
- 34:49Todd Miller: Oh, so we're in Green Bay.
- 34:51Mark Treichel: I think it's Green Bay.
- 34:53Todd Miller: I always thought they started in Minnesota, but I hadn't paid
- 34:55attention other than it's on the calendar.
- 34:58Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 34:58Todd Miller: Yeah.
- 34:58Mark Treichel: But if it's in Green Bay, what do you think the score is gonna be?
- 35:01Todd Miller: 24-21 Green Bay.
- 35:04Mark Treichel: Oh, you're right.
- 35:05It's in Minnesota.
- 35:06You wanna change that?
- 35:08Todd Miller: Green Bay has had a problem winning in Minnesota for
- 35:11the last five or six years here.
- 35:1328-24 Minnesota
- 35:16Mark Treichel: 28-24.
- 35:17Todd Miller: Green Bay's defense sucks- ⦠and I don't know that they did anything
- 35:19to fix it either in the off-season.
- 35:22Mark Treichel: Yeah, they- they've got some issues.
- 35:24So I'm gonna say s- same point differentiation.
- 35:28I'm going 20 to 16 Vikings.
- 35:32And Steve, your refs will screw it up for w- we'll- We'll both be
- 35:35pissed at the refs, I know that.
- 35:37Steve Farrar: Yeah.
- 35:37We're gonna have a better year than last year, I think.
- 35:40It's gotta be better.
- 35:41Mark Treichel: Okay, that's good.
- 35:42Todd Miller: fun- I don't know why Green Bay can always jump
- 35:43out in the lead in Minnesota.
- 35:45Mark Treichel: That I would like to see that play out again.
- 35:48Steve Farrar: All right.
- 35:48Mark Treichel: And
- 35:48Steve Farrar: I'll do a shout-out to one of our loyal listeners, Frank.
- 35:52Glad that you keep hanging around.
- 35:55Mark Treichel: Yes.
- 35:55Lot of loyal listeners out there.
- 35:56I appreciate it.
- 35:57Steve and Todd, I wanna thank you so much.
- 35:59Have a good Labor Day weekend.
- 36:00And listeners, watchers, you'll hear this after Labor Day.
- 36:04I hope you had a good one.
- 36:06And this is Mark Trakel signing off with Flying Colors.