Latest / Don’t Worry, No One’s Listening (DWNOL) / EP.5 Kat Rosenfield: Winging It Like a Grown-Ass Professional
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, I'm Kat Rosenfield, and don't worry.
- 0:03No one's listening.
- 0:07I mean, the thing about it is I was watching it because I was reviewing
- 0:10it for the free press, and so I,
- 0:14this is when my husband looked over and he said, what the, and I said, it's for...
- 0:18reasons.
- 0:19I'm crying and screaming at...
- 0:20watching penises on TV on an airplane for professional reasons.
- 0:23I have to.
- 0:25The things we do.
- 0:26you know, as writers.
- 0:30Hey everybody, I'm screenwriter and novelist, Edward Savio.
- 0:33Welcome to the podcast.
- 0:35Kat Rosenfield is one of my favorite people to talk to.
- 0:39We've been on panels together, but this is the 1st time we've
- 0:42gotten to sit down and discuss process and
- 0:45writing in depth.
- 0:48Kat is a novelist, culture critic, an all
- 0:51around literary troublemaker.
- 0:53She co-authored Stan Lee's alliances with the
- 0:56legendary Stan Lee.
- 0:58She's also the author of the psychological thrillers.
- 1:01No One Will Miss Her.
- 1:02You Must Remember This and her latest...
- 1:05How To Survive In The Woods.
- 1:07It's out March 10th, which is today when I'm
- 1:10filming this opening.
- 1:11I had a chance to read an advanced copy of how to survive.
- 1:15It kept me wanting to know what happens next.
- 1:18It's suspenseful, sexy, and
- 1:20deliciously dark.
- 1:22And it asks us to consider what,
- 1:25and who we would sacrifice, to stay alive.
- 1:29If you like an intelligent thriller, you
- 1:32should definitely check this one out.
- 1:34Kat's writing is elegant, biting, and always smart,
- 1:38whether she's penning a page turner, or poking holes in the
- 1:41hot takes of the day, she brings precision and
- 1:44provocation to every sentence.
- 1:46We're going to dig into twisted relationships,
- 1:50unreliable narrators, and how to craft a story.
- 1:54That keeps you flipping pages and making you question everything.
- 1:58Including semicolons.
- 2:02And so, here's my conversation with
- 2:05Kat Rosenfield.
- 2:17I want to thank you for joining me.
- 2:19Thank you for having me.
- 2:23Great introduction.
- 2:24It's fun to write these.
- 2:25Because I get to...
- 2:26tell people about people I...
- 2:27Enjoy reading.
- 2:28And remember, we can say anything we want because honestly, no one's listening here.
- 2:33So semicolons.
- 2:34My battle cry for the last 20 years has been...
- 2:37Death to all semicolons long.
- 2:38Live the M dash.
- 2:39Where do you fall in this battle?
- 2:41Are you a Trader?
- 2:42to the cause or just a better person than me?
- 2:44Well, I am a better person than you, but it has nothing to do with punctuation.
- 2:48It's just like how we congenitally are.
- 2:50Yeah.
- 2:51But you know, I love all of the punctuation.
- 2:54I'm a big aficionado of the semi colon,
- 2:57followed by a clause, followed by an M
- 3:01dash, followed by another clause.
- 3:03I'm a big fan of the sentence that goes on and
- 3:05on and on forever.
- 3:07If I could make it last an entire page, I would, and
- 3:10my editors hate it, and that's just their cross to bear.
- 3:13I want a clause within a clause.
- 3:15If I can put a clause inside of a clause.
- 3:17That's the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow.
- 3:19I think it's the best.
- 3:20The best sentence by far.
- 3:22is one where you start out by saying
- 3:25something, then you add a parenthetical as like a little jokey
- 3:28aside, then you continue.
- 3:30Then you finish that thought, but you have a related thought that
- 3:33you don't want a full stop force, so you put the semicolon.
- 3:36Then you continue with another clause.
- 3:38Then you put the M dash.
- 3:41You write a little bit more.
- 3:43It's sort of an attached thought.
- 3:45Not an aside, more of like a, I don't know, a 2nd ending.
- 3:48And then...
- 3:49Just for a little ailon, you add an
- 3:52ellipsis and then like some kind of punch word.
- 3:56Oh, see, yeah, absolutely.
- 3:58So you got your semicolon M dash ellipse.
- 4:01This punch?
- 4:02Yeah, I think that's, I think that's the proper order, although I reserve
- 4:05the right to be completely lying about this because I have not...
- 4:09really given it a lot of thought until just now when you asked me.
- 4:11I'm glad this is how we start out because I think
- 4:14Writers need to have these kind of serious discussions about
- 4:17punctuation because it doesn't get enough airplay.
- 4:21I agree.
- 4:23Well, you know, the semicolon is so beloved.
- 4:25that people get tattoos of it, and you cannot say that for the M dash.
- 4:29No, I think the M dash just looks like.
- 4:32An accident.
- 4:33An accident or should have blood dripping out of it.
- 4:36It's a wound.
- 4:37We've been talking for about 3 minutes and we've already gotten to blood dripping
- 4:40out of open wounds, so I'd say this is going really well.
- 4:42This is good.
- 4:43Let's get into this.
- 4:45I always wanted to be a writer.
- 4:47Actually, I wanted to be a filmmaker, a director as early as I was 7th grade.
- 4:50And writing was my way in.
- 4:52replays and a musicals and screenplays.
- 4:54And then finally books.
- 4:56How did you get into this?
- 4:58So, I kind of feel like.
- 5:02everybody else in my life knew that
- 5:05I was going to be a writer before I did.
- 5:07I was either.
- 5:08in denial or ignorant of this being
- 5:11my destiny for a really long time.
- 5:13And so I tried to do other things.
- 5:14When I 1st graduated from college,
- 5:16which I did with a double major in fine
- 5:19art and French because I thought, I guess,
- 5:22that I was going to become a character in a Jane Austen novel when I grew up.
- 5:26I mean, those are such useful things.
- 5:27They really are both.
- 5:28You know, a very well-rounded young lady.
- 5:31Very marriageable.
- 5:32My mother said, you like to read.
- 5:34Maybe you should go to work in publishing.
- 5:37like to read.
- 5:38That seems like a really good idea.
- 5:39And what neither one of us knew is that publishing doesn't pay you a living wage.
- 5:42I eventually became a book publicist, which is a job that I was terrible at.
- 5:46I'm very, very bad at hyping things that I don't actually
- 5:49think are good.
- 5:50Um, I'm much better at.
- 5:53Uncovering and articulating.
- 5:55why a thing that seems good to everybody else is
- 5:58actually bad.
- 5:59And so I eventually realized that
- 6:03the best place to put this skill to use was by
- 6:06Pursuing.
- 6:07Some kind of writing career.
- 6:09I was going to pivot into coffee writing.
- 6:11This was kind of my big plan.
- 6:12I got a freelance job at the Brooklyn Public Library as
- 6:15a copywriter, and I think that this whole
- 6:19endeavor would have probably worked out for me except
- 6:22for one minor detail, which is that this was all
- 6:25happening in September of 2008.
- 6:28And so instead of becoming a successful copywriter, the
- 6:31economy imploded and I became unemployed and also
- 6:34extremely unshowered for a very long time.
- 6:37And eventually, my husband, who had, I had just married.
- 6:40We've been married for 5 minutes.
- 6:42I got laid off the day before we left for our honeymoon.
- 6:44He said,
- 6:45I think that you should just finish that novel
- 6:48that I know you are working on.
- 6:49Because nobody is going to hire you right now.
- 6:53And also, incidentally, I think that maybe you should bathe because
- 6:56you've been wearing the same sweatpants.
- 6:58Was
- 7:01that was that just like...
- 7:03The barely functional moment, we were like, hey.
- 7:05Hey, you know, I showered today.
- 7:07What more do you want?
- 7:10while I was like, please excuse me.
- 7:12I have a project going, it's that I am slowly fusing to the couch.
- 7:16I've built up a great patina of filth and I,
- 7:19you know, I'm not ready to let go of that.
- 7:21No, I'm just kidding.
- 7:22I took a shower.
- 7:23I took a shower.
- 7:25And so I finished that novel and ended up
- 7:28Selling it and that became my 1st novel, which.
- 7:32It was called Amelia and is Dead and Gone.
- 7:34And in the interim between,
- 7:38uh, finishing that manuscript and having the book published,
- 7:41I also started just doing kind of frantic freelancing
- 7:45and saying yes.
- 7:46to everything, every assignment that anybody would.
- 7:48offer me, which included some kind of really funny things,
- 7:51including a, uh, copywriting gig for
- 7:54a guy who thought he was going to make millions of dollars selling
- 7:58New York City tap water in bottles, whoever
- 8:01that guy is, I hope he's doing well.
- 8:03Um, and so basically I ended up
- 8:06Uh, just because I was so busy, you know, I,
- 8:10I would get work on Craigslist.
- 8:11or through friends, and it was always very piecemeal.
- 8:13It always was very, very low pay.
- 8:15But one of the things I ended up
- 8:17managing to kind of wangle my way into was a
- 8:20job as a blogger at MTV News.
- 8:22MTV had these various blog verticals.
- 8:25I wrote for the one called Hollywood Crush.
- 8:26It was all about young Hollywood gossip.
- 8:28And I did that for a few years, making
- 8:32$15 per post, and then at the end
- 8:35of that, they shuttered all of the blogs, but when they did,
- 8:38they took 2 writers from the blog world over to
- 8:41MTV news and made them into actual reporters, and I was one of them.
- 8:45So that was my entrée into journalism, really kind of fell backward
- 8:48into it, did not expect any of this.
- 8:50Wow.
- 8:50I mean, because there were a number of people, right?
- 8:52So 2 out of however many.
- 8:53Yeah, yeah, I got really, really lucky.
- 8:55Luck is being in the right place and being good at the right time.
- 8:59Yes, yeah, exactly.
- 9:00Exactly that.
- 9:01One of the things that I was looking at,
- 9:03I was rereading
- 9:04Uh, No One Will Miss Her.
- 9:06I was reading the acknowledgments at the end.
- 9:07And you had said something to your agent about, thank you for
- 9:10going through all these genre changes.
- 9:13You did YA, you did a little sci-fi.
- 9:17So, I ended up in YA initially, sort
- 9:20of by accident, just because the theme
- 9:24that I'd...
- 9:25Yes, absolutely.
- 9:26Absolutely, there is.
- 9:27I mean, I've never been an intentional person about anything in my entire life,
- 9:30including my career.
- 9:32So the YA thing, I had written a book,
- 9:35the protagonist of which was 18 years old and
- 9:38in the summer after high school.
- 9:41And at that time, it was just definitionally
- 9:44made the book young adult.
- 9:45It was like, Twilight had come out a few years pre.
- 9:48And then the Hunger Games came out and everybody was just
- 9:51like, oh my god.
- 9:52Everyone thought that's where every book is going to be.
- 9:55Yeah, and I mean, for a little while, it was tons
- 9:58and tons of adults were reading young adult fiction.
- 10:00Every Hollywood adaptation of a book was some
- 10:03YA, usually fantasy novel.
- 10:06It was just, I mean, it was a big moment.
- 10:08There was so much room.
- 10:10There was so much money flying around, people getting massive
- 10:13book deals.
- 10:15And that meant that there was also room for people like me who
- 10:18wanted to write stuff that was a little bit more mature, a little darker,
- 10:21a little more literary to, you know, to
- 10:25have a piece of the pie and play around in that giant pool where everybody else was just...
- 10:29splashing.
- 10:30I would say that lasted until about 2014.
- 10:32And then.
- 10:34I'm trying to think how to diplomatically put this.
- 10:36The young adult.
- 10:37world started to get
- 10:39A little self-consciously political,
- 10:43um, and it started to contract, and the range
- 10:46of acceptable ideas that you could be working
- 10:49with, um, and what was considered desirable, and
- 10:52what kinds of not just stories, but what kinds of authors were
- 10:56considered desirable, started to shift.
- 10:58None of this necessarily made that much.
- 11:01of a difference to me.
- 11:02What did make a difference is that eventually, people in
- 11:05the YA community started behaving very censoriously, as,
- 11:09The available pie started to shrink.
- 11:10The whole world became very identity obsessed.
- 11:12It became very, um, fixated eventually on these
- 11:15campaigns to cancel books from.
- 11:18Fellow authors.
- 11:20a professional sabotage thing, but wrapped
- 11:23up in the language of social justice.
- 11:25And this is where I got myself into trouble.
- 11:28I've always been.
- 11:28a really old school free speech liberal.
- 11:31And I looked around at what was happening in these private Facebook
- 11:34groups where, uh, petitions were circulating to, um,
- 11:37cancel people's books before they came out or to have them pulled
- 11:40and have edits forced upon them.
- 11:42And I just said without naming anybody, just,
- 11:45you know, I just said on social media, I
- 11:48notice this is happening broadly and I think it is bad.
- 11:51And that was...
- 11:54A terrible mistake, um, in terms
- 11:57of my.
- 11:59professional.
- 12:00Trajectory as a young adult fiction writer that
- 12:03was apparently very much the wrong thing to say.
- 12:06don't want to dwell on this part of things.
- 12:09But I did get canceled.
- 12:11And after that happened, I did
- 12:14have to find a way to continue writing that
- 12:17didn't involve writing in this world that
- 12:20was very small and full of people who hated me and
- 12:23wished me ill.
- 12:25Did the Stan Lee collaboration kind of,
- 12:28was that a culmination or was that a pivot?
- 12:31That was a pivot, yeah.
- 12:32What happened?
- 12:33to me in the young adult community was for
- 12:36as a fiction writer and personally, it was pretty devastating.
- 12:39I can imagine.
- 12:40I didn't really think about what I was going to do after that.
- 12:43And part of me was pretty convinced that I
- 12:46wasn't going to do anything after that.
- 12:48This was it for me.
- 12:49My, you know, I had been thoroughly sabotaged and it was not going to be able to write anymore.
- 12:52But I was also a working journalist, and the thing about,
- 12:56that is that if you say something and a lot
- 12:59of people come running out of the woodwork screaming at you not to
- 13:02say it and not to talk about it, that
- 13:05makes you really want to talk more about it
- 13:08and to investigate it and figure out what's going on.
- 13:11I had a sense in that moment that ended up being...
- 13:16Relatively prescient, that there was
- 13:19something interesting brewing in the young adult fiction
- 13:22world that had the potential to grow
- 13:26and escape containment into the broader culture.
- 13:30That was what I think we would
- 13:33eventually.
- 13:34come to describe as cancel culture or wokeness
- 13:37or whatever you want to, whatever it is, whatever
- 13:40it is that gripped the culture.
- 13:43And I saw that YA was
- 13:46potentially sort of the early warning system for this,
- 13:49which I think it often is.
- 13:50I think that if you're going to have a moral panic,
- 13:53It is very, very easy to get it going.
- 13:56In the world of content aimed at young people because it is so easy.
- 13:58to invoke the specter of a child being harmed by
- 14:01like some, you know, dirty, violent
- 14:04book or film or video game or whatever.
- 14:07And once you've gotten
- 14:11a certain number of people paying attention to you in that space,
- 14:14it's very easy to shift the conversation elsewhere.
- 14:17So I ended up reporting on one
- 14:20of these campaigns within the YA fiction space to destroy
- 14:24a book before it came out that was being spearheaded
- 14:27mainly by people who had not read it.
- 14:29This was a recurring phenomenon.
- 14:31I spoke to people sort of on all sides of the issue,
- 14:34who had different takes on it.
- 14:36And then that came out.
- 14:38vulture in August of 2017, and it
- 14:41turned out that a lot of other people thought it was really interesting,
- 14:45and it ended up going insanely viral.
- 14:47That was how I started writing about culture in the way
- 14:50that I still do now.
- 14:52You write pretty quickly.
- 14:54I got to imagine when you're doing these articles because you put out enough of them.
- 14:58Is that something that also kind of helps you in the?
- 15:00The fictional writing as well?
- 15:01Yeah, I would say the nice thing about.
- 15:05teaches you to let go of the
- 15:08sentence, just, you know, just get it out, get it on the page and
- 15:11continue on because you're working towards a deadline and you can't
- 15:15be precious about every single beautiful word that you're putting on the page.
- 15:18And yeah.
- 15:20I want to be.
- 15:22It's just a different muscle.
- 15:25I wouldn't say that I'm that I'm rushing it.
- 15:28But I did discover recently when I was
- 15:31sitting down to organize a new essay.
- 15:33And I realized that I was experiencing this sense of incredible calm.
- 15:37in the same way that I do when I'm chopping vegetables to make dinner.
- 15:40I just, I felt like I was in a,
- 15:42In my home.
- 15:43My mental home.
- 15:44The need to be precious, especially as a screenwriter.
- 15:48Because I was the opposite when I 1st came into it, right?
- 15:51I mean, he walks to...
- 15:53Through the door.
- 15:54pulls a knife.
- 15:55It was very...
- 15:55Hemingway.
- 15:56To, to, to, to.
- 15:58So when I went to write,
- 16:00Pros.
- 16:00I went the opposite way.
- 16:02Kat, what we do is at best.
- 16:04Weird.
- 16:05true, true, fair.
- 16:07And part of why I love doing this is
- 16:10because I want to talk to people who understand me,
- 16:13because I think sometimes the people we love, the people we live with,
- 16:16the closest people to us, don't get it.
- 16:20Do the people around you get what you do?
- 16:22or is it kind of they don't fully understand?
- 16:26I mean...
- 16:27I live
- 16:30with in a marriage to a man and I write at
- 16:33this point almost exclusively books in which some horrible
- 16:36husband gets murdered in some, you know,
- 16:39creative and often really horrifying way.
- 16:43And, um, you know, I...
- 16:47Is everything okay?
- 16:49Yeah, you know, sometimes I sometimes like I'll be working,
- 16:52I'll catch him looking at me in a way that's like, should I
- 16:55be sleeping with the kitchen knife under my fellow?
- 16:57But no, I think that he understands, um, he
- 17:01understands what I do to kind of an astonishing.
- 17:05Pushing degree when I think about it because he doesn't write himself.
- 17:09I mean, I've always thought that I married the right person for a variety
- 17:12of reasons, not least because, you know, when we had been married 5 minutes and I had no job.
- 17:16He was like, finish your novel and take a shower.
- 17:18I mean, like best man in the world, right?
- 17:21That's it, that's it.
- 17:21But he did that for me.
- 17:23It was nice.
- 17:23That's good partner.
- 17:25That is a good part.
- 17:26That really is.
- 17:27I think that the, The thing
- 17:30about writing that,
- 17:32is probably the most mystifying
- 17:35and also irritating to people around me is this
- 17:38is the same thing about reading or who I am as a reader is
- 17:41I just vanish into whatever world it is that.
- 17:45that I've decided to, you know, open up and immerse myself into,
- 17:49and, um, you know, people will speak to me and I won't hear them and.
- 17:53That's what I was going to say.
- 17:53I have to say to Kira, my partner.
- 17:54I have to say to her sometimes, I go,
- 17:56I'm in my head right now, I'm creating or I'm thinking about
- 17:59that last book that I read or whatever.
- 18:01But you need something right now?
- 18:03You've got my full attention.
- 18:05But there's just times where she'll start a conversation with me.
- 18:08And the joke in our house is that my...
- 18:12Initial words out of my mouth are always, what?
- 18:14Yeah, it's exactly that.
- 18:15It's like, excuse me, I'm sorry.
- 18:17I was in another dimension.
- 18:19I know my body was here, but I was somewhere else.
- 18:23What was it?
- 18:24Ray Bradbury said something like, you know, 99%
- 18:27of writing is...
- 18:30Thinking and the other one% is typing.
- 18:33I'm always writing and never writing.
- 18:35Yes, I remember somebody once said to me,
- 18:38That deciding to be a writer is like deciding to assign
- 18:41yourself homework every single night for the rest of your life.
- 18:44And it felt true at the time,
- 18:47but it really feels true now.
- 18:49Like, I feel it in my bones.
- 18:50I hear you.
- 18:52Do you ever feel like you're describing witchcraft to a bunch of Puritans?
- 18:56Um,
- 18:59yeah, it depends.
- 19:00Um, but, you know, I do think that it's easy for non-writers and and perhaps,
- 19:04reasonable um, for them to be suspicious inherently of what we do.
- 19:08It's like you've created,
- 19:10Let me get this straight.
- 19:11You created another world, and it's inside your head and
- 19:14it's full of people.
- 19:16And they're doing stuff.
- 19:17They're talking to each other.
- 19:18They have like completely formed personalities.
- 19:20There's an entire story happening in there.
- 19:23And it's all contained in your brain and you're
- 19:26going to eventually sit down in front of a piece of paper and you're going to
- 19:29transport it out of there and into.
- 19:31I mean, it does.
- 19:31It sounds insane.
- 19:32It sounds insane when you think about it.
- 19:34Speaking of people,
- 19:37I don't think of writers.
- 19:39But writers have stands and occasionally stalkers.
- 19:41I mean, it gets weird enough as a guy.
- 19:43I've got to imagine it's even weirder for a female writer.
- 19:47So, what's the funniest, strangest, weirdest interaction
- 19:50you had and feel free to change names to protect the strange or name them?
- 19:54If they should be punished.
- 19:56I don't feel like I have that many stands.
- 19:58It's a funny thing because, obviously, being a
- 20:01woman, and especially a woman who's, um,
- 20:04is sort of visible on the internet.
- 20:05People sort of assume that you're going to just be harassed and
- 20:08abused all the time, and I have not found that to be the case.
- 20:11And actually, I found that the, um, the guys who do
- 20:14follow me because they're, um, what do you?
- 20:17what do they call it?
- 20:18Um, it's the most respectful sim
- 20:22thing that you've ever seen, you know, sometimes just,
- 20:25you know, they'll send me like friendly messages, but never anything obscene.
- 20:28And one time, one of them asked me very
- 20:31politely if he could send me a picture of his penis.
- 20:35He asked first.
- 20:36And I said, no, thank you.
- 20:38Um, thank you.
- 20:41Thank you for offering, but no, thank you.
- 20:42He said, okay, and he didn't.
- 20:43Yeah, I mean, I think for guys,
- 20:47It's sort of the opposite of that.
- 20:48That's that's the kind of
- 20:49attention you'll get.
- 20:51Just like, okay, may I may I send you a picture of my boobs?
- 20:54Yeah, but well, a little more, yeah.
- 20:58I'm not literally asking.
- 20:59I'm quoting some hypothetical person.
- 21:04Suddenly sent me, uh, the code.
- 21:06to their vibrator.
- 21:07You know, like for a remote.
- 21:10See, but this actually...
- 21:14speaks to something that's sort of a well kept secret.
- 21:16Maybe it's just something that people don't want to acknowledge.
- 21:18Women are sick.
- 21:19Women are often so much sicker
- 21:22and more creative and more dedicated to
- 21:25the, yeah, to the groupie thing.
- 21:27But, you know, to return to the question of stans.
- 21:30I will say,
- 21:31I've taken so far a kind of a Taylor Swift
- 21:34approach to the rare event that I actually meet somebody
- 21:37who's like a fan.
- 21:39I met this one woman.
- 21:41She lives locally and she came to a book signing that I was doing.
- 21:44And she was like, I followed you for such a long time.
- 21:47It's so exciting to meet you and it was really heartwarming.
- 21:50I mean, she was, she seemed genuinely thrilled to meet me, but I was so genuinely
- 21:53thrilled to meet her that I just befriended her and now we hang out all the time.
- 21:57That's very cool.
- 21:58I've actually had interactions with, uh, some fans
- 22:01who are more like about the story, and there are some things that
- 22:05have happened in the 3rd book of of one of
- 22:08my series, um, where it
- 22:11was a throwaway line in the 1st book.
- 22:13I threw, had another throwaway line in the 2nd book.
- 22:15And they were like, what is this thing?
- 22:20They noticed.
- 22:21I ended up writing it into the 3rd book.
- 22:23But it was interesting how that conversation back and forth.
- 22:27brought about me doing something different.
- 22:31Mm-hmm.
- 22:32Yeah.
- 22:33So, worst roommate.
- 22:35Of all your characters, who would make the absolute worst
- 22:39roommate?
- 22:42Who would be the worst roommate?
- 22:45Mm.
- 22:46That is a really hard question.
- 22:49Because there's so many bad ones or you just, you just,
- 22:52it would give away too much if you'd said something.
- 22:54I mean, it probably would.
- 22:57Well, I won't, I'll avoid spoilers.
- 22:59Um, I think, Dwayne,
- 23:04from No One Will Miss Her.
- 23:05For the, you know, worst husband
- 23:08ever, but also terrible roommate.
- 23:11You just know that that man leaves his stained underwear on every
- 23:14surface.
- 23:16And when I say stained, I mean, stained, like,
- 23:20you know, substances you can't even identify kind of stained.
- 23:23I just remember thinking.
- 23:26These are such horrible characters.
- 23:28They're so horrible, but real.
- 23:31Is there something that you are drawing from?
- 23:34People you can't mention.
- 23:37I mean, one of the most embarrassing
- 23:40things I ever did is in my very, very 1st novel,
- 23:44I named a really obnoxious character after the
- 23:47guy who bullied me in high school, and I initially did it at a place as
- 23:50a placeholder, but by the time the book went to print, I had forgotten to change it.
- 23:54And so it's just in there.
- 23:55It's still in there.
- 23:56I don't think he ever noticed.
- 23:57I don't think he could read.
- 23:58But the...
- 24:01The truth about all of the characters
- 24:04and all of these books is like, I mean, they're
- 24:07all based on something, but
- 24:11a lot of them are also like at least a little bit me.
- 24:14Uh, either they're, you know, there's something that
- 24:17I that I wish was more about myself or sometimes it's
- 24:20something I really hate about myself that I've kind of isolated
- 24:23and turned up to 11.
- 24:25Um, Or it's, you know,
- 24:28or it's an experience that I had that I can imagine
- 24:31having gone slightly differently if only.
- 24:34The DNA, of
- 24:37any story and any character.
- 24:40is always traceable back in
- 24:43some way to something true in my life.
- 24:47Um, but not necessarily in a form that you would recognize.
- 24:50Yeah, I agree.
- 24:51I.
- 24:52There was a kid that was a total, like, bully.
- 24:56When we published the publisher, they were like, you got to change at least the
- 24:591st name, I'm like, I can't change the...
- 25:01The last name because the...
- 25:02The character's name is Kenny Oderman.
- 25:04And I mean, he was just such an odorman.
- 25:07I mean, it was so...
- 25:09Perfect.
- 25:10Um, all right, we're going to take a quick break and when we come back,
- 25:13we're going to go deep into the weeds.
- 25:14I'm doing what we do.
- 25:16Don't worry, no one's listening.
- 25:18Sponsored by.
- 25:18Procrastination, official sponsor of writers everywhere, probably...
- 25:22Delaying greatness since the dawn of deadlines.
- 25:24If at 1st you don't succeed, wait a week.
- 25:27Stick around.
- 25:28We've got more with Kat Rosenfield after this.
- 25:31We've got a lot more to come.
- 25:32Including going deep into the weeds on process.
- 25:36I want to give a big shout out to bookstore, home to a huge
- 25:39community of readers for partnering with
- 25:42us, so we can go deep with these writers.
- 25:45They said yes, so you can eavesdrop on our conversations.
- 25:49Readers, there's a lot of excellent
- 25:52content, recommendations.
- 25:55And Q and A's with authors.
- 25:57Writers, bookstore helps you reach new readers.
- 26:01Whether you're a reader or a writer,
- 26:04check out bookster, no e dot com.
- 26:08And now, even though you're not supposed to be
- 26:11listening, Back to the show.
- 26:14All right, welcome back to Don't Worry, no one's listening.
- 26:17I'm Edward Savio.
- 26:18Still here with Kat Rosenfield, who hasn't left yet.
- 26:22Let's get deep.
- 26:23into the weeds on writing itself.
- 26:25So what's your writing process?
- 26:27Take me through it.
- 26:28Tools you use, how you get organized.
- 26:30The 1st thing I do at this point almost...
- 26:32Always if I'm going to...
- 26:34Embark on a new novel is I have a conversation with.
- 26:37my little brother.
- 26:38I don't know why I'm calling him my little brother.
- 26:40Number one, he's the only one I have and number two, he is like 6 foot
- 26:433 and 37 years old, but he will always be my little brother to me.
- 26:46Um, For some reason, and
- 26:49I think this is a weird thing to say about one sibling, but nevertheless,
- 26:53he's like my muse.
- 26:54Um, and every time I talk to him, I'll end up having
- 26:57a whole bunch of ideas that I could spin out into stories.
- 27:00And so from there, once
- 27:04I've got the seed of something, which is usually...
- 27:07The twist.
- 27:08Or sort of the inciting event in
- 27:11a mystery or a thriller.
- 27:14I will start to build.
- 27:17A sort of a labyrinth.
- 27:19or a puzzle box around
- 27:21That.
- 27:22Moment.
- 27:23And the thing about.
- 27:24Writing to.
- 27:26A mystery, um, writing to reveal.
- 27:28Is your readership is going to know
- 27:31that there's something coming.
- 27:33Yes. part of the genre that they're anticipating a twist.
- 27:37And some of them.
- 27:39Are going to be so obsessed with trying to get there.
- 27:42before you do that they ruin their own ride.
- 27:45And so your job as the writer is to make sure they can't do
- 27:48that, or at least to do your best to make sure they can't do that.
- 27:51You have to allow little glimpses
- 27:54of little pieces of it so that the people who are super dedicated.
- 27:58To figuring out what happened, like maybe a
- 28:01couple pages beforehand, they might have a suspicion,
- 28:04they can get the the joy of reading it
- 28:07and saying, I knew it, you know, that feels good.
- 28:10The journey into the labyrinth of the journey through the labyrinth, even though you know.
- 28:14that you're ultimately heading towards this big reveal.
- 28:17The journey itself needs to be interesting.
- 28:18It needs to be engaging.
- 28:19By the time you get to that middle bit,
- 28:21You need to really care about these people and what's happening to
- 28:24them and why they do what they do and what's going to happen to them afterwards
- 28:28after something surprising.
- 28:30Probably horrible half it was.
- 28:32Then that's the 2nd half is you take this.
- 28:35into the center of the labyrinth.
- 28:37You meet the Minotaur, which is the twist.
- 28:39And then hand in hand with the Minotaur, you
- 28:42exit the labyrinth and you find out, you know, what happens
- 28:45after this moment.
- 28:47And that also needs to be not just interesting, but,
- 28:50um, it needs to feel satisfying in some way.
- 28:53I'll have sort of the.
- 28:54very basic skeleton.
- 28:56I'll have.
- 28:57The middle 1st, the, you know, the moment they reveal,
- 29:01the premise, you know, what is exciting about this, then
- 29:05I'll have populate it with people, um,
- 29:09who usually will already kind of be at
- 29:13the at the fringes of the story.
- 29:14By the time the premises come up.
- 29:15It's like, okay, we have this and here's who is obviously going to be part of this.
- 29:19I don't really write, um, like act structure because I'm
- 29:22not a screenwriter by trade, and so I still
- 29:25don't really, I'm always sort of winging it.
- 29:28Um, I sometimes read screenwriting books now to try
- 29:31and uh, organize my plot lines because it's the one thing
- 29:34I still really struggle with is pacing.
- 29:36Um, But I come up with, you know, a,
- 29:39a sort of a rough path, like what's the arc,
- 29:42what has to be revealed, um, what has to be sewn in so
- 29:45that people suspect or don't suspect something later.
- 29:47What are my red herrings?
- 29:49Who do I want people to be suspicious of?
- 29:51What's the kind of emotional
- 29:54arc happening behind the action?
- 29:57that also needs to be addressed.
- 29:59Um, and I will eventually, once I've got sort
- 30:03of enough of these pieces, I'll write through them literally in this very, very loose way.
- 30:07Um, it's something, it's not quite an outline, uh, because it
- 30:10doesn't have bullet points and it's not very organized.
- 30:12It's more like a plot vomit
- 30:16and it's got kind of everything.
- 30:19Um, anything that I think needs to go into a given chapter.
- 30:23And this is when the book will start to kind of automatically
- 30:27sort itself into scenes in the way that a movie does.
- 30:30I do, when I picture my stories.
- 30:34I do tend to think pretty visually and
- 30:37pretty cinematically.
- 30:38Um, and so I will have,
- 30:41you know, sort of scene by scene moment by moment, the chapter breaks will
- 30:44naturally start to emerge.
- 30:46And I'll write through, What has to happen?
- 30:49What does a person need to realize, you know, what is the,
- 30:52I don't know if it's going to be like a clue or something?
- 30:54What do they just stumble upon?
- 30:56Also, what's happening with this person emotionally?
- 30:58Um, I will sometimes write little snippets of
- 31:01dialogue that sort of mark the emotional beats
- 31:05or if there's like a really great line.
- 31:07I want to get in there.
- 31:08Sometimes I'll stubble on one in the process.
- 31:10Um, sometimes I'll know it ahead of time and I'll
- 31:13be like, okay, yeah, that that goes here.
- 31:15And once I have this sort of like mushy,
- 31:18loose, you know, it's the shape of a story.
- 31:21What is this in?
- 31:23Like, are you just writing this in word or are you putting this up on?
- 31:26Cards or on a...
- 31:28Gant chart or a timeline?
- 31:30What's that Gant chart?
- 31:31Oh, it's timeline.
- 31:32So the answer the answer to that is no.
- 31:34I alternate
- 31:37between using Google Docs.
- 31:40My Pages app.
- 31:41Every so often the inspiration will strike.
- 31:43And I'll, you know, I'll be lying in bed and I'm like, I'm not, yeah, not,
- 31:46but you know, I'm going to write some stuff down.
- 31:48Um, I'll put it in an email draft.
- 31:50It's hard to pull all those things together.
- 31:52Do you have a process?
- 31:53Where you can remember, all right, this note
- 31:56here needs a,
- 31:58Does it eventually get into one document?
- 32:00You know, it's interesting.
- 32:02The stuff that I end up typing.
- 32:03into you know, my phone or whatever.
- 32:05Sometimes I don't even actually end up going back to it.
- 32:09It's enough that I wrote it down and then it lives in
- 32:12my head in the kind of spaghetti of the story that
- 32:15is starting to take shape.
- 32:16Um, and yeah,
- 32:20I, I'm realizing as I'm talking to you about this,
- 32:23that I have really just been kind of winging it, um,
- 32:26I mean, it's like I make, I make a plot map, but my making of
- 32:29the plot map is just like, sit down with my
- 32:32fingers on the keyboard and prey, um, that
- 32:35something reasonably structured comes out.
- 32:40It's interesting you were talking about looking at the screenplay format.
- 32:44You know, I was I was brought up in the whole 3 act structure.
- 32:48Almost haiku.
- 32:49Everything's got to be so specific.
- 32:51As I've grown and know my own self.
- 32:55I find that the 7 act structure.
- 32:58or the 6 act structure is a little bit more broken down.
- 33:02I used to write things on literally on.
- 33:06cards and have the entire script written with
- 33:09Alluded to dialogue before I ever sat down to write them.
- 33:11dialogue, even though dialogue is my favorite part.
- 33:13Oh, wow.
- 33:14Your prose is.
- 33:16It's crisp, it's beautiful.
- 33:18You do have a cinematic air to it.
- 33:20But your dialogue is.
- 33:22One of the things that I enjoy.
- 33:24The most.
- 33:25Dialogue is something that a lot of writers don't do well.
- 33:28And and you don't have to, if you're a novelist as well as you would.
- 33:32If you were a screenwriter, Because that's all you've got.
- 33:35Yeah, I do also love dialogue and I
- 33:38find that the, you know, moments when characters
- 33:41are talking to each other.
- 33:43I'm not one of these writers who says, oh, my characters talk to me.
- 33:46If I ever felt that that was actually true, I would be, um, had made
- 33:49for the, you know, sanatorium for some much needed rest and relaxation.
- 33:53But these moments are very alive in
- 33:56my head, in a way that,
- 34:00Few parts of the book are.
- 34:02The only other thing that is sometimes comparable for me,
- 34:05that is that is truly alive in my head in the same way as these moments
- 34:08when characters are talking to each other, is the setting, you
- 34:11know, where I'm talking about, not just, you know,
- 34:14not just what things look like or where things are, but the quality of
- 34:17the light and the scent of the air and the sounds and
- 34:21the, you know, the way the air feels on people's skin.
- 34:23you know, that kind of stuff that really inhabiting the moment.
- 34:26By sketching the complete sensory
- 34:30and sensual.
- 34:32Portrait of of a setting.
- 34:35You're not just blocking it, um, but you're
- 34:38inhabiting it, if that makes sense.
- 34:40It does.
- 34:41You know, and one of the things that I thought was interesting is,
- 34:45you know, so I finished,
- 34:47Uh No One Will Remember Her.
- 34:49And then I picked up.
- 34:51Uh, you must remember.
- 34:55Yes, No One Will Miss Her and then you must...
- 34:59We could do a mashup.
- 35:00No One Will Remember Her followed by...
- 35:01You Must Miss This.
- 35:02Yeah, exactly.
- 35:03No One Will Miss Her.
- 35:05It's no spoiler or anything, but the opening where you're
- 35:08out on the ice.
- 35:09I felt like.
- 35:10That was.
- 35:11A really beautifully written part that
- 35:14just felt like that moment was, was
- 35:17real, and I could visualize it.
- 35:20And part of our deal is,
- 35:23We are the writers and the directors, but the reader
- 35:26is also the director of the movie that we're projecting
- 35:29into their head and...
- 35:31You have to give the reader.
- 35:33Something more.
- 35:35You did it.
- 35:36in a beautifully compact way, and I just felt like I,
- 35:40yeah, I was shivering a little bit when I was in that scene, like I felt it.
- 35:44Oh, I'm so happy to hear that because.
- 35:45that moment, that opening scene, that was the seed of that book.
- 35:49I was, um, I was on a walk with my brother, you know,
- 35:52my muse, and we started talking about we
- 35:55were near the Hudson River, which is the
- 35:59area where I grew up in the Hudson Valley in this little town called Kuxaki.
- 36:02We were walking around.
- 36:03It was really foggy, and the river
- 36:06was iced over, but also completely invisible because it was so misty.
- 36:10And I had this image of an old
- 36:13woman, you know, walking out and
- 36:16disappearing into the mist.
- 36:17And then, you know, maybe you hear like the sound of
- 36:20a splash or something like that.
- 36:21And I was sort of obsessed with it.
- 36:25and built this story around that moment.
- 36:27You got an old lady on the ice.
- 36:28What's she doing out there?
- 36:29But that moment was very real in my head, and so I'm glad to hear that it was so real on the page.
- 36:33It really was.
- 36:34Set the whole scene.
- 36:35Immediately, I wanted to protect this character.
- 36:39I think it's great.
- 36:40That there's so many.
- 36:42Terrible people.
- 36:43In the in that house.
- 36:46Oh, I love to hear that.
- 36:48So something that I've been sort of noodling on, as you've
- 36:51been talking about, story structure and putting things together and
- 36:55um, the, both similarities and differences
- 36:58between uh, writing for the screen as versus
- 37:01writing for the page, I, um, I do have,
- 37:05this new book coming out.
- 37:06March 2026, that the seed of that...
- 37:10Give me the title so I can butcher it again.
- 37:12It is called How to Survive in the Woods.
- 37:14Okay.
- 37:16Just Remember How to Survive in the Woods Or No One Will Miss You.
- 37:22Yeah, no, it's called How to Survive in the Woods.
- 37:25And it, um, is an erotic
- 37:28thriller that takes place on the Appalachian Trail.
- 37:31So it's like an erotic wilderness survival thriller.
- 37:34And The seed of
- 37:37that plot, like the premise is actually based
- 37:40very fully on.
- 37:42a French thriller from the 1950s,
- 37:45um, called, Diabolique
- 37:47where you have, uh, you know,
- 37:50there's a there's an affair.
- 37:52There's sort of a love triangle that, um, that turns murderous.
- 37:56What I'm working on now, my next novel, which I...
- 38:00only just beginning to sketch is the 1st time I've ever
- 38:03tried to adapt something that started as a screenplay.
- 38:06That I've already written.
- 38:08And make it into.
- 38:10Prose instead and make it into a novel and I am so
- 38:13struggling with this and I'm wondering how do you negotiate
- 38:17that transition because I think it is so much harder the other way to
- 38:21go from visual too.
- 38:22Okay, so let me tell you.
- 38:23The structure's probably the same.
- 38:25If you've already written this.
- 38:26Because I've done the opposite, right?
- 38:28I've taken a book, written a book, written the screenplay,
- 38:32gone out with the screenplay, then taken what was in the screenplay that changed a
- 38:35little bit, put that dialogue back into the book before
- 38:38it gets published.
- 38:39To me, it's so clear.
- 38:41I think because I came from that opposite side.
- 38:43Interesting.
- 38:45Yeah, when I, there was a moment where it seemed like no one will
- 38:48miss her was going to be adapted for television and
- 38:51I had the opportunity to write the pilot.
- 38:54I, you know, I wanted to take a stab at it and they said, okay, I
- 38:57don't think anybody thought that I was going to do a very good job.
- 38:59I did a good job.
- 39:00And, um, and it was so fun
- 39:03and interesting to take this novel that I'd
- 39:06already, you know, immersed myself in in one medium and to reinterpret
- 39:10it for a different medium.
- 39:12And it felt so natural.
- 39:14Um, and I think that maybe is just because I
- 39:17was already kind of in a cinematic headspace writing it.
- 39:20Now trying to go in the opposite direction,
- 39:23taking something that exists as a screenplay, and making it into this.
- 39:29More pros, like you have, you have to talk about internal.
- 39:32feelings on the page.
- 39:33You can't just, you know, show them with a look or whatever.
- 39:36I am I am struggling.
- 39:37I was struggling so hard.
- 39:39Do you know what I think it is?
- 39:41So with a book, you have a
- 39:44vast amount of information that could never make it into a screenplay.
- 39:48You have to, when you're going from a book to
- 39:51a screenplay, you have to cut, cut, cut.
- 39:55You have to, you have more,
- 39:58You have more source than you'll end up with.
- 40:02When you're going the opposite way, you have less source.
- 40:05Mhm.
- 40:06It's a floor plan to a house.
- 40:07Mm-hmm.
- 40:08Now you got to like, all right, well what else am I going to put in there?
- 40:11What kind of furniture are we going to put in?
- 40:12even once I build it.
- 40:13There's so many other decisions that have to be made that weren't
- 40:16made in a script.
- 40:18It's also like,
- 40:19Where are you putting the front door?
- 40:21Because the way into the story isn't necessarily the same.
- 40:24No, it can't, it can't be the same.
- 40:26It's like there's a visual that you will be hit with.
- 40:30In a movie.
- 40:32That might not be as impactful
- 40:35when you're reading it.
- 40:36Yeah, it's um, it's interesting.
- 40:39Most unexpected turn your career has taken.
- 40:44Oh god.
- 40:45Um.
- 40:47I really did not expect to become a published novelist, but.
- 40:50Honestly, the most unexpected turn my career has taken by
- 40:53far is
- 40:54despite my
- 40:56you know, best attempts to kind of stay out
- 40:59of the fray on this political space.
- 41:02I've ended up occupying as a writer.
- 41:05Um, if you had told me 15
- 41:08years ago that I would one day have a pretty
- 41:11thoughtful and devoted,
- 41:14contingent of readers who see me as
- 41:17speaking,
- 41:18Intelligently to.
- 41:21Libertarian slash center right concerns.
- 41:25I would have been...
- 41:26Shocked.
- 41:27I think that in the political world,
- 41:30You do not have takes that.
- 41:31Are generally obvious.
- 41:34I think that the thing is that, well, 2 things are happening.
- 41:37One is that I am always inclined to pick up the rock and see what's.
- 41:41underneath there.
- 41:42And, um, you know, what's wriggling around and and
- 41:45what, what is that?
- 41:47It has a lot of legs.
- 41:48What is it?
- 41:49and what does it mean that it's under there?
- 41:50I mean, this sounds very pretentious.
- 41:52I'm going to borrow from Joan Didian.
- 41:53When I'm writing, I'm trying to understand what...
- 41:54I see and what it means.
- 41:56I'm not really interested in prescribing solutions.
- 41:58are talking about how things should be.
- 42:00And, um, I think that we live in a world increasingly
- 42:03where people kind of get mad at you for for
- 42:06only wanting to do that.
- 42:08Um, they see it as an abdication of some duty to to
- 42:11take it a step further and and cross.
- 42:13The line from the is into the ought.
- 42:16I would imagine that this has a lot to do with being a novelist.
- 42:19Uh, I find it pretty easy to model the
- 42:22interiority of people who don't
- 42:26think the way that I do and to understand that they
- 42:29don't think the way I do.
- 42:30And it's not because they're, you know, they're stupid, crazy, and evil.
- 42:34It would be very convenient if that were true, but I just don't think it is.
- 42:37And there is the
- 42:40thing that I've observed, and I don't want to like get too soapboxy here.
- 42:43But I think it's a problem with the way that our current
- 42:46discourse operates and the way that everything has become political, including
- 42:49art is we've become a very negatively
- 42:53polarized society, um,
- 42:56you know, politically, creatively.
- 42:59People really define themselves, increasingly
- 43:02by being anti-something.
- 43:04They define themselves according to how much they hate what they hate.
- 43:07And I am not only
- 43:09incredibly resistant to that personally because I think it's an incredibly
- 43:13like intellectually and emotionally bankrupt way to understand the world.
- 43:16But I think it misses
- 43:20so much and it deprives us of the ability
- 43:23to imagine each other and
- 43:26to understand things in a way that we
- 43:29that we could if we were willing to just extend ourselves a little bit more.
- 43:34Yeah, I mean, I think that's I think that's true.
- 43:37And I think,
- 43:38Because of the way that social media is.
- 43:40You can find 25,000 people who can
- 43:43believe the most horrific thing.
- 43:46But because of the internet.
- 43:48It has empowered those people.
- 43:50To think that.
- 43:51There is other people like them where...
- 43:53Before this time
- 43:55Those people were isolated, and none of that in.
- 43:57information got passed between them.
- 43:59There's a meme about this.
- 44:01Am I allowed to say the F word on?
- 44:03You can fucking say anything you want
- 44:05Okay.
- 44:06I'm just, I'm I'm quoting here, but I want to, I want to quote accurately.
- 44:10So the meme is, you know, before the internet, a
- 44:13guy says, I want to fuck a toaster.
- 44:16And everybody says, what is wrong with you?
- 44:19You can't fuck a toaster, get your life right?
- 44:21And he feels shame and he goes and
- 44:24he, you know, he assimilates to society and he
- 44:27gets married and he has children.
- 44:28He doesn't fuck toasters.
- 44:29Now after the internet.
- 44:32A guy says, I want to fuck a toaster.
- 44:37finds, you know, a...
- 44:39Small, but vocal and existent contingent of
- 44:42people who share his exact same paraphilia.
- 44:44And they're all talking about how great it would be
- 44:47and is to stick your dick in a toaster.
- 44:50And and this is his life now.
- 44:52He is a toaster fucker.
- 44:53And um, and he never thrives, but he fucks a lot of toasters.
- 44:57And this is a microcosm for what the internet, you know, has
- 45:00given to us but also done to us.
- 45:02That's right
- 45:02All right, time for another quick break, and while we rethink.
- 45:06everything we just said.
- 45:09You're listening, even though you're not supposed to, to don't worry.
- 45:12No one's listening.
- 45:14Today's episode is brought to you by the delete key, for
- 45:17when your bravery needs a safety net.
- 45:20Use code no one's listening at checkout.
- 45:23It does nothing, but it'll make you feel better.
- 45:27Now back to the show.
- 45:36Okay, we're back.
- 45:38Time for a little bit of fun.
- 45:39We do a thing called Laugh Cry Scream.
- 45:41A book, a movie.
- 45:42a show, a scene that really made you laugh, one that made you cry.
- 45:45One that made you scream.
- 45:46What's your laugh?
- 45:47Um, okay, this is
- 45:50a kind of a weird.
- 45:52thing to land on, but it was immediately came to mind.
- 45:57During COVID,
- 45:58Which obviously is behind us now, but, uh, one of my
- 46:01formative experiences, when I start, I started watching, rewatching a lot of
- 46:04movies from like comedy movies from
- 46:07the, or early 2000s, and they feel
- 46:10like dispatches from another planet, and there
- 46:13are so many good ones.
- 46:15But I think one of my favorite ones, because it's so random and
- 46:18the cast is so great, is called The Watch.
- 46:20And it's about a neighborhood watch group
- 46:23that discovers that they've been invaded by aliens.
- 46:26Any
- 46:30particular moment or just the movie itself just kind of just made you laugh.
- 46:33Oh, God, everything about it, like, I love
- 46:35I love the premise.
- 46:36And I love how kind of free they are in exploring.
- 46:40it, they're not worried about being too gross or being politically
- 46:43correct or any of that stuff.
- 46:45It's just, you know, it's, yeah, it's, it's a very liberating,
- 46:48uh, doing experience.
- 46:50It's funny movie.
- 46:51All right, what's your cry?
- 46:54My cry.
- 46:55Um, Okay.
- 46:58So, the TV
- 47:01show dying for sex.
- 47:03Which starts out, it's actually also
- 47:06a laugh one, but over the course of 8 episodes,
- 47:09It's about a woman who is diagnosed with terminal cancer and she decides.
- 47:12to leave her marriage, to pursue sexual fulfillment in
- 47:15her final moments of years of life, however much time she has left.
- 47:19And it starts out as a kind of a comedy and then as,
- 47:22you know, her death is coming and you know that it is.
- 47:25Um, the last episode is
- 47:28one of the most profound and
- 47:31heartbreaking things I've ever seen, and I made the
- 47:34terrible mistake of watching it on
- 47:38an airplane, and I just ugly cried for
- 47:41like 30 minutes straight.
- 47:43Wow.
- 47:44That is the bad place to have the cry.
- 47:47Probably also a bad place to have a scream.
- 47:50What your scream?
- 47:51As luck would have it.
- 47:53In that same episode, there
- 47:56is a moment, quite unexpectedly, where there
- 47:59is a man standing in a room.
- 48:03He's a hallucination.
- 48:04He's fully frontally nude.
- 48:06In this room.
- 48:08And all the...
- 48:08sudden, his penis grows little gossamer wings and
- 48:11detaches from his body and goes flying all over
- 48:14the place.
- 48:16And did I scream out loud?
- 48:18Reader, I did, and to my fellow airplane
- 48:21people, I am really sorry, especially
- 48:24to the ones who were sitting behind me and looked through the seat,
- 48:27crack, and we're like, what is going on up there?
- 48:30That's when you're just like.
- 48:33You're like, okay, maybe
- 48:37this was not the best choice.
- 48:39I mean, the thing about it is I was watching it because I was reviewing
- 48:42it for the free press, and so I,
- 48:45this is when my husband looked over and he said, what the,
- 48:48and I said, it's for professional reasons.
- 48:51I'm crying and screaming and watching penises on TV on
- 48:54an airplane for professional reasons.
- 48:55I have to.
- 48:56Really?
- 48:58This is, this is, this is, you had to.
- 49:01There was no other choice.
- 49:02Absolutely not.
- 49:03I mean.
- 49:04The things, the things we do, you know, as writers.
- 49:08Oh, oh my god, we will get into that in
- 49:11a moment because that is so crazy.
- 49:13All right, rapid fire questions here.
- 49:16Uh, lawyer, agent, editor, whose life do you save?
- 49:19You can only save one.
- 49:20Um,
- 49:24Does it doesn't this make your skin crawl?
- 49:27Fortunately, I don't have a lawyer, but my agent,
- 49:31I've been with her for more than 15.
- 49:34years, she's...
- 49:36It's her.
- 49:37It has to be.
- 49:37Yeah, yes.
- 49:38Uh,
- 49:40You write some intense scenes.
- 49:42Has anyone ever been like, hey, Kat, are you working through some stuff?
- 49:46Um,
- 49:50you know, people have gotten, people have gotten
- 49:53more mad at me for writing, for instance, a scene where a cat dies,
- 49:56which, you know, I'm very sorry about.
- 49:58I hated writing it, but it was extremely necessary, even though I cried while I was writing it.
- 50:02Um, working through some stuff.
- 50:04You know, people seem more concerned with whether they
- 50:07are being depicted in the books than
- 50:11with my own mental health.
- 50:12It's like they actually don't care about me.
- 50:15It's just, Is that alcohol?
- 50:19actually me.
- 50:20Yeah.
- 50:23Oh, that's, yeah, I, uh, velvet sledgehammer.
- 50:27Um, I didn't think my family would speak to me.
- 50:30They laughed
- 50:31I was very surprised, but man, there was some,
- 50:34there were some moments I went, all right.
- 50:38What about writer's block?
- 50:40I've not dealt with that much,
- 50:43I, I've,
- 50:44I've always felt like,
- 50:46There's writer's block where you are,
- 50:49you sit down to put words on the page,
- 50:52you know, to write the sentences, to do the typing, and
- 50:56it doesn't really come.
- 50:58And for me, that's always just been
- 51:00a signal that like, whatever I'm baking inside my head isn't done yet.
- 51:04Um,
- 51:05you know, it will, it will be done.
- 51:07I've learned this over the course of.
- 51:08Uh, many years at this point that there
- 51:12will come a point at which I feel compelled
- 51:15to sit down and do the typing part.
- 51:17But before that, there's just a lot of thinking.
- 51:20It's like running.
- 51:21Background operations, like.
- 51:23Three days later, I'll realize that I've solved a.
- 51:25problem without even really meaning to, which is great.
- 51:28It feels like magic.
- 51:29It is magic.
- 51:30I think Writer's Block is this thing that people talk about.
- 51:33And sometimes it's usually, it's either,
- 51:37I can't make the decision I need to make right here.
- 51:40I have to think it through more.
- 51:42And I know that it's not true writer's
- 51:45block, because I could go pick up something else and write it right this second.
- 51:49You know, it's not, um, it's
- 51:52not an inability to produce words or meaningful words.
- 51:55It's an inability to, in that moment,
- 51:59like you said, to make the proper decision for
- 52:02the story that I was supposed to be working on.
- 52:04Yeah, it's like that that thing where someone says,
- 52:07you know, are you hungry?
- 52:08Do you want to, do you want to go out for like chicken wings and you
- 52:11say, ugh, no, I'm not, I'm not hungry at all.
- 52:13And a 2nd later, you're like,
- 52:15But I want pizza.
- 52:16My favorite
- 52:19thing is, is...
- 52:20in relationships.
- 52:21The illusion that women give men of...
- 52:25Choice?
- 52:26Where it's sort of like.
- 52:28Do you want to go out for...
- 52:29Chinese Mexican or Italian?
- 52:32How about Chinese?
- 52:33Okay.
- 52:34Uh, Mexican?
- 52:36Italian.
- 52:38That sounds great.
- 52:39This is really funny.
- 52:41This exact interaction happens in my house all the
- 52:44time, but it is gender swapped.
- 52:47Really?
- 52:48I'll suggest...
- 52:49different things for dinner and he'll say no.
- 52:51And I'm like, okay, then you pick.
- 52:52And he goes, no.
- 52:54That is very, very funny.
- 52:56So best.
- 52:57And worst riding advice.
- 52:58What's the...
- 52:59Best writing advice you've ever gotten.
- 53:01The best running advice.
- 53:04Um, oh, it was uh, to to
- 53:07let the story marinate.
- 53:08Yeah, to not worry if if I'm running the background operations
- 53:11and, you know, and I'm not ready to actually do the typing part.
- 53:15Yeah, that the thinking part is also really important.
- 53:17That was the best writing advice I got.
- 53:20Something
- 53:24that somehow keeps getting passed around as sacred.
- 53:27And I feel like there are many things income.
- 53:31competition for this.
- 53:34Um, There's more bad advice than good advice.
- 53:37Yeah, I mean, it's, Honestly, anything
- 53:40that is presented as a rule, and there are so many of them.
- 53:44I just I just feel like every single one of them,
- 53:47it's not even that the advice itself is bad.
- 53:50It's it's presenting it as an absolute.
- 53:52I think that's a good.
- 53:54that's a good one.
- 53:54Do you read reviews?
- 53:57If I'm really hating myself that day and I want to just kind of marinate in that feeling, yes.
- 54:01Yes I do.
- 54:02Okay, if you weren't
- 54:05a writer, what incredibly unsuitable job would you have?
- 54:09I think I would be a really good detective.
- 54:13And the reason, so I think, because I'm very good at making
- 54:16murders, I mean, doing murders in a fictional
- 54:19scenario.
- 54:21And I think that because I'm very good at constructing them, I would also
- 54:24be good at taking them apart, um, from the
- 54:27other direction in the real world.
- 54:28This is probably very self-flattering, but I'm convinced it is true.
- 54:31That's a good one.
- 54:32That's a very good one.
- 54:33All right, we're going to take another quick break.
- 54:36We're going to pause the plot and maybe pause the snack as well.
- 54:39And when we unpause, there'll be more with Kat Rosenfield.
- 54:44If you are listening, despite all our warnings not to,
- 54:47follow the show.
- 54:48Rate it.
- 54:49Drop me comments and recommendations.
- 54:51I read them very slowly.
- 54:54I can be reached pretty much on all social
- 54:57media at Edward Savio, except...
- 55:01Strangely, Facebook, where I'm at Edward
- 55:04Savio Writer.
- 55:06Lisa should be.
- 55:09Just about wrapping up giving her notes.
- 55:11So let's get back.
- 55:12To more with Kat Rosenfield.
- 55:21Okay, still us, still talking, still somehow allowed to
- 55:24express our 1st amendment rights.
- 55:26This is don't worry.
- 55:30We talked.
- 55:31a little bit about this outlier in your life.
- 55:35The Stanley Alliance's collab.
- 55:39How did that come about?
- 55:42How did it work?
- 55:43That was an incredible opportunity
- 55:46that my wonderful agent told
- 55:50me she wanted to.
- 55:52kind of put my name in the ring for it.
- 55:55It wasn't just Stan.
- 55:56It was also these 2 guys, uh, Luke Lieberman and Ryan Silbert,
- 55:59with whom he had created this entire new universe
- 56:03of sort of superhero lore and.
- 56:07He wanted it to be a novel
- 56:10length project, which was the only.
- 56:12think Stanley had not done in his life somehow.
- 56:15He had reached the age of like 95 and he'd done everything except for the novel.
- 56:20They were looking for a writer.
- 56:22And so they wanted somebody who could really write to the.
- 56:26more emotional side of things,
- 56:29someone who was used to doing character driven, long
- 56:32form work.
- 56:34And there were 4 people, I think, in the running.
- 56:37It was me and then it was 3 guys, all of whom were...
- 56:41franchise fiction writers who had written either Star Wars or
- 56:44comic book stuff.
- 56:46And then I was this lone outlier and that I had written two literary...
- 56:49young adult novels about feelings and death.
- 56:52And they decided,
- 56:56they thought, you know, they were like, feelings and death it is,
- 56:59and that was how I, how I got that going.
- 57:01And um, the collaboration was, it was really
- 57:04fascinating because I was coming into this structure
- 57:09that was already created for me.
- 57:10So I was just, you know, it was,
- 57:12Pure prose writing.
- 57:13It was a kind of a bye.
- 57:14coastal team of nerds collaborating on this thing.
- 57:16There was a lot of back and forth, a lot of conference calls,
- 57:19and, um, the thing that I think was really wonderful about
- 57:22it was that I was very intimidated,
- 57:27you know, to be part of something with Stan, and he was
- 57:31just the most energetic, enthusiastic, like
- 57:34super duper into it.
- 57:36Um, it was inspiring.
- 57:38It helped maybe not intimidated how excited he was about the project.
- 57:41I think, by the way, this
- 57:44also sounds like maybe one of the ways to look
- 57:47at how you can translate your script into, because
- 57:50it probably had a lot of structure to it.
- 57:52You know, but you brought
- 57:55the pros in that way.
- 57:57I mean.
- 58:00I'd not thought about it that way, that I could.
- 58:01give myself that like, you know, create the little step
- 58:04ladder and then climb up on it on my own.
- 58:06I could do that.
- 58:07I could do that for myself.
- 58:08So I'm going to try that.
- 58:09Yeah.
- 58:10Um, evolution of the process.
- 58:12How has your writing changed over the years?
- 58:14The process itself?
- 58:16I think I write a little bit more quickly than I used to.
- 58:19But I also have gotten comfortable with not writing too quickly.
- 58:23There was uh, a project.
- 58:26I think it was, you must remember this actually, where that was the one time
- 58:29that I sold a book just on a proposal and
- 58:32sample chapter.
- 58:33And then, you know, I was paid to write it instead of writing it and then getting paid.
- 58:37And at the time that that happened
- 58:40for me, I felt that I'd really arrived at like a
- 58:43new stage of my career.
- 58:44And then after I did that, I vowed I
- 58:47would never, ever do it again because I was
- 58:50not able to take the time that I wanted with the manuscript and time is important.
- 58:54So, I mean, which leads us to what's
- 58:57the most ridiculous thing you've ever Googled?
- 59:00And how thick do you think your FBI file is?
- 59:03I mean, considering that I write
- 59:06books where somebody gets murdered, maybe multiple people,
- 59:10often in kind of wild ways, I
- 59:13would imagine it's pretty thick.
- 59:15The, the worst thing I've ever Googled.
- 59:19Well, okay, this isn't exactly that.
- 59:22For this survival thriller.
- 59:24It takes place on the Appalachian Trail.
- 59:26It takes place in the woods, and for reasons I'm not going to
- 59:29go into in-depth because it would be maybe a little bit of a spoiler.
- 59:32I became obsessed with the idea.
- 59:35I needed to know how long it took
- 59:37A pressurized aerosol can to explode
- 59:40in a campfire.
- 59:42And I was writing the last of this book in Maine.
- 59:46in a cabin.
- 59:49On a lake where there was no internet and no cell service.
- 59:53And I would talk to my husband, Every
- 59:56day, and I called him and I was like, babe.
- 59:59I've got to throw.
- 1:00:01A can of hairspray into it.
- 1:00:02of fire.
- 1:00:04As like, this is my project for tomorrow.
- 1:00:06I'm going to make a fire and I'm going to throw a can of hairspray into the fire.
- 1:00:09And he said, no.
- 1:00:10No, you're not.
- 1:00:12And I said, I have to.
- 1:00:14I have to know.
- 1:00:16What happens?
- 1:00:17And he said,
- 1:00:18Like, okay, don't set anything on fire.
- 1:00:20Don't buy a bottle of hairspray, just sit tight.
- 1:00:23And about half an hour later, he called me
- 1:00:26and he said, okay, I have just watched 5 videos
- 1:00:29of people throwing hairspray into
- 1:00:32fires.
- 1:00:33And this way, you don't have to accidentally singe
- 1:00:36your eyebrows off.
- 1:00:37Or get some shrapnel.
- 1:00:40Yeah, yeah, or that.
- 1:00:42Yeah, I, uh, I once, uh,
- 1:00:45Had to find a weapon behind security.
- 1:00:49In an airport.
- 1:00:50And I'm with my kid.
- 1:00:538th grader, the time.
- 1:00:55He's doing the standard
- 1:00:57Washington DC trip.
- 1:00:59We're about to go back to San Francisco and...
- 1:01:01I'm I'm in Dulles.
- 1:01:04And behind the scenes, they have plasticine,
- 1:01:08Washington monuments.
- 1:01:10Mm-hmm.
- 1:01:12Which are just stabbing, you know, they're they're
- 1:01:15total stabbing weapons.
- 1:01:16And, you know, and they're selling them.
- 1:01:19The story takes place in Boston and I was like,
- 1:01:22Well, if they do that here, maybe they would do that with
- 1:01:25the bunker monument.
- 1:01:27You know?
- 1:01:28And I was just like, I was like, sometimes,
- 1:01:31man, I mean, TSA, they, you know, they take away your knives
- 1:01:34and your forks, but they're going to give you this total stabbing thing.
- 1:01:38It's true.
- 1:01:40And your peanut butter, because it's a liquid.
- 1:01:43Yes.
- 1:01:44Exactly.
- 1:01:45Peanut butter.
- 1:01:46Worry about the.
- 1:01:47Peanut butter.
- 1:01:48Yeah, that's what we need to worry about.
- 1:01:50What's the most surprising thing that you've
- 1:01:53learned about yourself?
- 1:01:55From the writing process.
- 1:01:56Um, gosh, so.
- 1:02:00I have learned that there's basically no scenario
- 1:02:03in which I don't feel the impulse to
- 1:02:07insert a fictional dead body.
- 1:02:09I just feel like everything is better with a dead body and
- 1:02:12um, and my friends accept this about me, which is nice.
- 1:02:15Yeah.
- 1:02:16That's funny.
- 1:02:18I found this Charles Dickens quote when I was rereading...
- 1:02:22David Copperfield after reading Demon Copperhead.
- 1:02:24It would concern the reader little to know how sorrowfully.
- 1:02:27The pen is laid down at the close of a 2 years imaginative task.
- 1:02:31Or how an author feels as if he were dismissing
- 1:02:34some portion of himself into the shadowy world when
- 1:02:38a crowd of the creatures of his brain are going from him
- 1:02:41forever.
- 1:02:42So how do you feel?
- 1:02:46When you've put these characters the bed.
- 1:02:49There is always a little bit of a sadness, isn't there, to,
- 1:02:53um, yeah, to have lived in this world.
- 1:02:57Um, although something that has been really
- 1:03:00nice for me over the course of...
- 1:03:02the writing process, especially for this most recent book, is
- 1:03:06that I had several moments where I would finish a
- 1:03:09draft and then step away for a
- 1:03:12long time and then come back to it and
- 1:03:15would have the pleasure of kind of reimmersing
- 1:03:19myself in the world and rediscovering
- 1:03:22the story, um, you know, not as
- 1:03:25a reader, but with maybe like a couple toes in the world of the reader.
- 1:03:29And it can be really nice to do that, you know, to come back
- 1:03:32to this place that you that you spent a lot of time that
- 1:03:35you were living in, that you were, you know, and creating it
- 1:03:38as you lived in it for months or years.
- 1:03:41Um, And then discovering that there
- 1:03:44are things in there that surprise you, that you'd forgotten that you created.
- 1:03:48That's always the most, I think that's the most surprising thing.
- 1:03:52is that you can forget that you created something.
- 1:03:57Yeah.
- 1:03:58I mean, have you ever read one of your own books, just sat
- 1:04:01down and read it?
- 1:04:02as though you were sitting down to read any novel.
- 1:04:05I've read so.
- 1:04:10So I did.
- 1:04:12The audiobook for Velvet Sledgehammer.
- 1:04:15So I had to read it.
- 1:04:17Like, I was, Not
- 1:04:21the writer in some ways.
- 1:04:23And,
- 1:04:24There were moments.
- 1:04:25sort of poignant in it that I
- 1:04:28could, I can hear on the recording where I felt
- 1:04:31it.
- 1:04:33And I had edited it a 1000 times and
- 1:04:36gone through it and never felt those feelings again after maybe my
- 1:04:391st initial thing.
- 1:04:40But it was much more of a visceral experience reading
- 1:04:43it in that moment as I was performing it.
- 1:04:46That's probably the most fresh.
- 1:04:49I've ever looked at anything.
- 1:04:51Kat, how can people follow you?
- 1:04:53And do you want them to?
- 1:04:54Uh, yeah, I mean, please follow me home
- 1:04:57from the grocery store, hide in my bushes,
- 1:05:00rattle them around, and it'll be really interesting for both of us.
- 1:05:03No, I can be found on Twitter,
- 1:05:08which is now called X by people
- 1:05:11who are not me.
- 1:05:13But I'm on there as at Kat Rosenfield.
- 1:05:16I am also on Instagram as Kat Rosenfield.
- 1:05:20and I have a substack that I contribute to very
- 1:05:23occasionally at Katrosenfield.substack.com.
- 1:05:26Um, and if you are interested in my work,
- 1:05:29I post pretty much everything I ever
- 1:05:32write on Twitter.
- 1:05:33So if you just want to like be a completist, which of course you should, then
- 1:05:37you can find it all day.
- 1:05:38kind of your one stop shop.
- 1:05:40Yeah, I think people who aren't listening should definitely
- 1:05:44take a look at, uh, at least the last 2 novels, I think.
- 1:05:48They're really great.
- 1:05:49Um, and uh, the Stanley
- 1:05:52Alliances, uh, that you co-wrote was also...
- 1:05:56very interesting, but these last 2 books, and I'm really looking forward to the 3rd.
- 1:06:00Did you say that you're looking forward to my last book?
- 1:06:03Yes, I am looking forward to your last book and I just was
- 1:06:06asking.
- 1:06:07Oh, it is called How to Survive in the Woods.
- 1:06:09And March 2026?
- 1:06:13March 2026.
- 1:06:14That's probably about when this will come up, right about that.
- 1:06:17By the time we finish all the editing.
- 1:06:20In that case, preorder it.
- 1:06:21Pre-order it right now.
- 1:06:23So I'm the worst at getting off the phone.
- 1:06:25My kids make fun of me.
- 1:06:27I'll start the whole goodbye and then
- 1:06:30begin an entire conversation.
- 1:06:32This happened last night with my oldest.
- 1:06:35So I'm saying goodbye.
- 1:06:37But one last thing before you go.
- 1:06:39Let's say we're still here talking a couple of hours from now.
- 1:06:43And we're not even online anymore.
- 1:06:46What's the story that you would end up telling me?
- 1:06:49What's the thing you would end up telling me in an hour or 2 or
- 1:06:523 that you haven't told me so far?
- 1:06:54In an hour or 2 or 3?
- 1:06:57I would be like, Edward, I got a pee.
- 1:07:03Gosh, I mean, I don't know, would we be telling jokes?
- 1:07:06Or, yeah, probably.
- 1:07:09Can I end with it?
- 1:07:10I hardly ever get to tell jokes.
- 1:07:11You know, I feel like it's actually kind of a, it's a dying art,
- 1:07:15you know, the, the kind of basic joke.
- 1:07:18Okay.
- 1:07:19Um, a pirate walks into a bar with
- 1:07:23a steering wheel strapped to the front of his pants.
- 1:07:27And the bartender says, Buddy.
- 1:07:31What's uh, what's what's
- 1:07:35with the apparatus there?
- 1:07:36And the pirate says, Ar, it's driving me nuts.
- 1:07:45I can't imagine a better ending.
- 1:07:48Oh, okay.
- 1:07:50So one of the joys of getting to do this is I get to talk to smart.
- 1:07:54Funny people, and...
- 1:07:56Kat, I want to thank you for coming on.
- 1:07:58I really have enjoyed this.
- 1:08:00Oh, thank you so much for having me.
- 1:08:02And to the rest of you,
- 1:08:03Shame on you for eavesdropping. Kat, you can tell them
- 1:08:06off as we go out.
- 1:08:07They, you,
- 1:08:09You promised me they weren't listening.