Latest / Arroe Collins Like It's Live / Wrongfully Convicted With A 90 Year Sentence Dax Devlon Ross Uncovers The Crying Wolf
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: It's actually been a fun adventure collecting all the conversations
- 0:02I have since twenty sixteen with those that have been
- 0:05featured on NBC's The Voice. Now, the question is can
- 0:08we put them all in one place and not let
- 0:10them be forgotten in history? Yeah you can. It's called
- 0:13arro dot net a R r Oe dot net. Look
- 0:17for that voice. Enjoy the exploration. Dax, I love your name, man.
- 0:21Why didn't you market that and put it up on
- 0:22like a rock star tour or something like that, and
- 0:25you know, make your way around the world with Madonna
- 0:26or even Bieber.
- 0:28Speaker 2: Right, you know what I mean. Well, listen, there's there's
- 0:30Dax Shephard. He's you know, he's out there doing his thing.
- 0:33You know, there's a whole story about these this. There's
- 0:36a few Daxes out there, and I've encountered a bunch
- 0:38of them. There's a new generation, but a bunch of
- 0:40us I found at one point, I know, we got
- 0:42to get into the story. But at one point someone
- 0:44put together a Twitter group and added me to it.
- 0:46This is years ago, and it was for all the
- 0:48Daxes that and I do think that there were a
- 0:50bunch of us that were probably born around the same time,
- 0:52whose parents saw the same movie and named us Dax.
- 0:55So that's what I that's what, you know, a little
- 0:57bit of the story.
- 0:58Speaker 1: Your podcast, Crying Wolfe. It really does get into an
- 1:01emotional place because one of the things that you know,
- 1:03we live in this age where it seems like that
- 1:05everybody's got a podcast, but my god, yours is the
- 1:07one that's sticking out right now, and it's like, what,
- 1:10what do you think is the secret sauce that you
- 1:11put into it?
- 1:14Speaker 2: Well, first of all, thank you. You know, there's a
- 1:15lot of incredible work out there, and you know, I'm
- 1:18impressed in aught every day by the things people are doing,
- 1:21the stories people are telling, and the way these folks
- 1:22are expanding the medium. And you're right though, there is
- 1:25a out there in the world. I think, honestly, man,
- 1:28you got to get out and do some real reporting. Yes,
- 1:31I think, I mean, I mean, this is no disparagement
- 1:33on folks, but I think there's a there's a you know,
- 1:36it's the podcast medium has enabled many of us to
- 1:40set it up and just get it going and start talking.
- 1:42You know, do we can do interviews, but to go
- 1:44out and do some footwork and get out in the
- 1:46world and get doing some deep research and talking to
- 1:49people and putting together soundscapes and really trying to pull
- 1:52We had to go through twenty years of prison interviews,
- 1:56between prison conversations between Robert and and and and Lee.
- 2:00I mean, this is this is a level of work
- 2:02in detail that my production team at Chalk and Blade
- 2:05did that. I'm just like in awe of myself. I
- 2:07am a small part of this story and just grateful
- 2:09to be part of it.
- 2:10Speaker 1: Well, I love your honesty and transparency on that when
- 2:13you call yourself something small, but yet you are the
- 2:15main driving force behind it. But I mean, but a
- 2:17lot of people don't have these beautiful teams such as yours.
- 2:20How is it you're able to keep it together? Because
- 2:22I mean, we live in twenty twenty five. There are
- 2:24a lot of egos out here.
- 2:27Speaker 2: Yeah, you know, I mean, my goodness, I think for me,
- 2:31I come to this work from print. You know, I've
- 2:34toiled away in the you know, in that old analog
- 2:38world for a long time, and so all I know
- 2:41is deep storytelling and all I know and someone has
- 2:43told me recently because this has been a year that
- 2:45I've rediscovered my own voice in a lot of ways,
- 2:47and this story is a part of it, which was
- 2:49that you do it for the people who are out
- 2:51there listening. You don't if you only do it thinking
- 2:53that the if you measure, if you only measure is
- 2:56if you get to the million people listening and x
- 2:58number of followers, then you know, good luck with that.
- 3:00But that's not going to be most people. But if
- 3:02you're doing it because you believe that there's somebody in
- 3:04the corner of the world that really is going to
- 3:06be touched by something you are doing, and you believe
- 3:09in that, then that's something different. And I'll say I'll
- 3:12add this last piece. You know, I always I'm being
- 3:15transparent like this. I I you know, someone like me doesn't.
- 3:17I don't get paid a lot of money to a
- 3:19project like this. You have to really care about it.
- 3:21You have to care about it, and you can't do
- 3:23it for that thing other than the fact that, like,
- 3:25I have an opportunity to tell a really powerful and
- 3:27important story and I'm gonna damn well do the best
- 3:29thing I can do and tell it as truthfully as
- 3:31I can.
- 3:32Speaker 1: One of the things that you do inside this is
- 3:34that you kind of really open up the eyes of
- 3:37anybody who might be you know, in prison or on
- 3:40the outside, going how can I get my guy my
- 3:42woman outside of prison? Because I don't know what we're
- 3:45doing right today, but a lot of people are coming out.
- 3:48What is it that you saw that is opening a
- 3:51lot of doors that we couldn't do back in the
- 3:53seventies or eighties.
- 3:54Speaker 2: I mean, I mean the short answer is like forensics,
- 3:58you know, short answer is D. But the longer answer is,
- 4:01I think momentum and movements. You know, once momentums, Once
- 4:05a momentum becomes a movement, a movement becomes a force
- 4:10of its own, and it starts to you know, capture
- 4:12different people who may not have always been the most extreme,
- 4:16like progressive life. This kind of a movement, I think
- 4:18captures people who are even more who are more mainstream
- 4:23in terms of their views regarding the criminal legal system,
- 4:25because I think all of us want to make sure
- 4:28we get it right. All of us want to make
- 4:30sure we get it right, because there before the grace
- 4:32of God goes us, you know, and these kinds of
- 4:34stories I think tell us that over and over again,
- 4:36Like this guy was walking down the street, this guy
- 4:38happened to be doing this. It could happen. You think
- 4:40it may not be you, but it could happen. So
- 4:42I think it's the movement. It's the momentum that becomes
- 4:45a movement. I think it's the technology and the forensics,
- 4:48and I think it's the broader awareness that we all
- 4:51have because of the storytelling that people have been done
- 4:54doing for so long. Now, over twenty some years, people
- 4:56have been telling stories, and I think it's helped us
- 4:59a lot.
- 5:00Speaker 1: Planted your listeners into the city of Chicago nineteen eighty nine,
- 5:04and you know what, My wife is from Chicago and
- 5:06she knows this story all too well. And it becomes
- 5:10you know, the star witness is your star suspect, and
- 5:13it's like, oh my god. You know if that doesn't
- 5:15sound like Hollywood, that's not supposed to happen in real life.
- 5:19Speaker 2: Oh it's you know. I think that's the thing that So,
- 5:22you know what drew me to it because I had
- 5:24just finished another podcast when I was was approached about
- 5:28working on this. I just finished them one on the
- 5:29Burden and we had done four year Deep Dive. I
- 5:32was like, I'm done. I can't do any moore of
- 5:34these wrongful convictions that just too gut wrenching. And then
- 5:36I got this invitation and I saw that piece, the
- 5:40crying wolf element of it, which is a guy Lee
- 5:42Harris is not you know, he doesn't have to clean
- 5:44his hands in the world. Let's be clear. He would
- 5:46you know, he'd be happy to sell up. But he'd
- 5:47be happy to sell up, sell some a you know,
- 5:49an unaware and a tourist entering Chicago, a bag of
- 5:54a regano and say and say it's something else. He'd
- 5:56be happy to do some little little jive hustle to
- 5:59get over. But he wasn't. He was a petty a
- 6:01petty criminal, a petty thief. He was not a murderer.
- 6:04He was not a killer, and that was never part
- 6:06of his mo So I think, like, you know, it's
- 6:08a it's a, it's a it's a. This story is
- 6:12is really powerful because it was powerful to me. It
- 6:15was because of the friendship between him and Robert. It
- 6:18was powerful because the way things flipped it is actually
- 6:23it's frightening. This guy goes from being star witness, meaning
- 6:26being he's being put up in a hotel by the detectives.
- 6:29He's being whined and dying for back of a better
- 6:31way of describing it. He's being brought, he there having it.
- 6:33He does twenty two statements for them, for the police
- 6:36as a witness, and then one day he becomes the guy.
- 6:43Speaker 1: Can you imagine No, no, no, we I you know
- 6:47more than most of us, but we all fear that
- 6:49moment where you know, wrong place at the wrong time,
- 6:51and sorry, the rest of your life is now. I
- 6:54don't know you're gonna get You're gonna get lost in
- 6:56a system right now.
- 6:58Speaker 2: I mean, he's he's a very expended he was an
- 7:00expendable person, unfortunately, and that's what I think happens quite often.
- 7:03But I'll stop there.
- 7:04Speaker 1: Wow, wow, you know you talk about that friendship and
- 7:07right away and maybe this is just the empathy or
- 7:09the compassion coming out of my soul, and it's like, wow, now,
- 7:12all of a sudden, that friendship is visible. Now. Now
- 7:15I've never been to prison. I don't know what prison
- 7:17is like, but when I hear that things are visible,
- 7:20you know, I have to take a second and a
- 7:22third breath.
- 7:25Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, you know, I think it's important to
- 7:29even recognize, like Robert Chatler was this young guy who
- 7:33got himself into he became an addict, for the lack
- 7:36of a better way of describing it. And he became
- 7:38an addict, and his addiction became so ferocious that he was,
- 7:41you know, stealing anything and everything from everybody in his life,
- 7:45selling anything and everything. And he was a young man,
- 7:48early twenties, and his life had just taken a really,
- 7:50really hard wrong turn, and he ends up in prison
- 7:53and he has he actually has a couple of sellis
- 7:55before he meets Lee that are kind of frightening guys.
- 7:58But when he meets Lee and he enters the cell
- 8:00with Lee, Lee shows him, shows him a kindness that
- 8:02no one has shown him in a long time, you know,
- 8:06and it's simple kindness, like you can use my radio
- 8:10his his I don't. Lee didn't smoke himself, but he
- 8:14always kept a pack of cigarettes because that was currency
- 8:16he gives. Because he would give cigarettes to Robert because
- 8:20he knew Robert needed him. They were cooked together, you know,
- 8:22they would they would do all sorts of things. And
- 8:25in many ways, Lee is twenty years older than this guy.
- 8:27I mean, it's they're not They wouldn't have been friends
- 8:29on the street. It's a black guy from the projects,
- 8:30a white guy from the suburbs and they find in
- 8:32a bond and ultimately, you know, the funny thing is
- 8:35Lee actually kicks him out. Lee actually asks to have
- 8:38him kicked out of the cell because he smokes too much.
- 8:41But even when even when Robert was leaving, even when
- 8:44Robert was walking out of the prison, he stopped and
- 8:47told Lee, I'm gonna look into your case. And he
- 8:51kept and he kept his damn word, please.
- 8:54Speaker 1: Do not move. There's more with Dax Stevelan Ross coming
- 8:56up next the name of his podcast, Crying Wolf. We
- 9:01are back with podcaster Dax s Devlin Ross. Maybe this
- 9:05is just my judgmental self, because we're all judgers, and
- 9:08that is when when they were moving, Robert Sell closer,
- 9:11I'm gonna tell you, I mean, in my heart, I'm
- 9:12going what are they up to? What are they doing?
- 9:14Are they going to try to do something? Are they
- 9:15going to try to get information? What's going on? You know,
- 9:17I mean, all of a sudden, you know, you're a
- 9:19part of an episode of Perry Mason.
- 9:22Speaker 2: Yeah. Yeah, it's funny because you know, Lee was already
- 9:26in largely because of a quote unquote jail house snitch,
- 9:30and that's a big part of the story is that
- 9:31there was a guy he actually never met but who
- 9:34said that he met, and he met Lee while they
- 9:36were he was in jail before he was actually convicted,
- 9:39and Lee confessed to him. So this had already happened
- 9:42to Lee. Somebody had already like tried to use the
- 9:45jail house snitch against him and been successful. And it
- 9:48was only because Lee's lawyers went through and found the
- 9:51FBI had paid this same informant in previous cases. That
- 9:55this guy his name was David Toles. The only ways
- 9:58they were able to start to really un open up
- 10:00Lee's case agame is because they were able to find
- 10:03out and pinpoint the fact that this jailhouse informant was
- 10:06on the payroll basically of the FBI, and that the
- 10:09city of Chicago knew about it and held it as
- 10:12and did not with and withheld that information from Lee's attorneys.
- 10:16So there was a Brady violation. For those of who
- 10:18know anything about Brady violations, you're not allowed to withhold
- 10:21information that could be exculpatory at least could be instrumental
- 10:24for the other side, and they had done so. They
- 10:26knew this guy had been paid by the FBI in
- 10:28the past for his jailhouse informant information and they didn't
- 10:32tell Lee's attorneys that became very uncritical in opening up
- 10:36Lee's opportunity to go to prison.
- 10:38Speaker 1: See now, now, come on, be honest with me, Dax.
- 10:40Would you trust anybody if they went through that, because
- 10:43all of a sudden, my trust factor factor is down
- 10:46and I wouldn't know where to jump from there, because
- 10:48it's like, Okay, I'm seeing something happen here, I'm feeling something.
- 10:51But man, trust is everything to me, and it's not
- 10:54always right though.
- 10:56Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah, I mean the reality is that, like you know,
- 11:00right when Robert first started and so Robert, you know,
- 11:03he was able to get his hands on all the transcripts,
- 11:06you know, very back in the early two thousand, he
- 11:08would pour through them. He found out about this David
- 11:10Toles character, he found out about him a long time ago.
- 11:13But it was the fact of the matter to your point,
- 11:16even when he found out that David Toles had been
- 11:18basically put up to and was actually willing to go
- 11:22on record and say he had been you know, paid
- 11:25or if you know, by by the police for his
- 11:28for his testimony against Lee. Least Lee's attorney said that's
- 11:32that's valueless. No one will care. It's actually not significant
- 11:36because because David Toles was not a credible person, right,
- 11:41so your point is actually true, Like you're right, Like
- 11:44trust is everything and credibility is everything, and David Tolds
- 11:47had no credibility. Even so, even when he tried to
- 11:50recant his statement in the early two thousands, the courts like,
- 11:53whatever nobody cares, doesn't matter because you are not credible.
- 11:57Speaker 1: So now, but but but now, when you said that
- 11:59you know that that ian these these you know, investigative
- 12:02reports of getting know, freeing people from prison and stuff
- 12:04has taken its toll on you. Let me ask you
- 12:06this deep inside, because we all deal with post production
- 12:08blues as podcasters, how did you get beyond that? Are
- 12:12you a d fragger in the Are you going in
- 12:14there and asking yourself then your own questions and then
- 12:17questioning the answers because you've got you've got to replenish
- 12:19that soul before you jump into that next story.
- 12:23Speaker 2: You're gonna love this. You're gonna find this hilarious. And
- 12:24maybe I shouldn't say it's gonna say I actually, as
- 12:26soon as I get off the call with you, guys,
- 12:28say I got to go to the studio and record
- 12:30the two last the bonus episodes for this project, because
- 12:34so I haven't even got to that point, but I
- 12:36can anticipate it. I'm actually feeling I'm going to the
- 12:39studio for the last time in a couple of hours
- 12:41and I'm gonna have to now to your point and deal.
- 12:44I don't even listen to the podcast. I can't listen
- 12:45to it, you know, And I don't know how you feel.
- 12:48I don't both. I don't like my voice, but whatever,
- 12:50that's the different story altogether. But I struggle with it
- 12:52because I think with your naming is that it comes
- 12:54like there's stuff that comes up because you just get
- 12:56through it. You just go in the studio, you do
- 12:58the work, but you're right and the stuff that you
- 13:00got to sit with, and I know it's going to
- 13:02hit me. I know it's gonna hit me, but I'm
- 13:04not even gonna I can't go there yet. I can't
- 13:07even let myself go there because I'm not done. You know.
- 13:09The second story, the bonus episodes are actually if you will,
- 13:12you know, indulge me for a moment. Last week in Chicago,
- 13:16there was a hearing involving a guy named Anthony Garrett,
- 13:19who's been in prison as well for thirty some years
- 13:21for a crime that happened in nineteen ninety two, the
- 13:23killing of a young boy named Dontrell Davis, seven years old.
- 13:25He was killed in Kaberini, being projects Garrett had always been.
- 13:31He was convicted of the crime same detective as Lee Harris.
- 13:35He had the same detective and Garrett had always maintained
- 13:39that he had been tortured and his conviction had been coerced.
- 13:43So this detective, his name is Zuli, who was actually
- 13:46Lee Harris's detective as well, also goes to Guantanamo Bay
- 13:50in the early two thousands. Yes, and he is the
- 13:53main detective, or he's the main interrogator of you of
- 13:56a man named Mohammadu Slahi, who is the star of
- 13:59a film that came out a few years ago called
- 14:01The Mauritanian starring Jerdy Foster and Benedict Cumberbatch. Right, so, people,
- 14:05this is a wild story that we're talking about. In
- 14:07any event, this case is still being litigated right now
- 14:11in Chicago and slow. He actually testified last week on
- 14:15behalf of Garrett to show and to talk about the
- 14:18torture he experienced at the hands of the same detective.
- 14:22Point of the matter is that this is live we
- 14:25are still waiting for the determination of that hearing. And
- 14:28the last two bonus episodes are all about this. What's
- 14:31gonna happen to Anthony Garrett who's been in prison for
- 14:34thirty some years for a crime he said he didn't
- 14:36commit and actually was. You know, so this is this
- 14:38is I'm in it, man, I can just say I'm in.
- 14:40Speaker 1: It minute, you know, And I was gonna save this
- 14:43or maybe not even go to it. But because you
- 14:45have touched on it, you know, you can't have a
- 14:47true crime podcast until you have a corrept detective. And
- 14:50my god, you're the one that brought it up. So
- 14:52there you go. So again, you cannot have a true
- 14:55crime until you have a corrupt detective.
- 14:58Speaker 2: Yeah, man, listen. You know, in my last podcast, we
- 15:02had a guy named Scarcella, you know, Louis Scarcella. He
- 15:07was quite a character, quite a character, you know, unbelievable,
- 15:10and he cooperated and he was not just a coo.
- 15:12He wasn't He was an enthusiastic voice in the project.
- 15:16In this in this story, it's the complete opposite. Zuli
- 15:19Detective Zuli has his He's wanted no parts of the story.
- 15:23He's never wanted to go on record. He's been able
- 15:25to even avoid any kind of He's not even been
- 15:28able to be They've not even been able to sit
- 15:31down and do an interview with him. He's avoided all
- 15:33of that. And he's always said and maintained, he's always
- 15:35maintained that he did nothing wrong. And so you can't
- 15:38even actually unpack the extent to which he actually engaged
- 15:41in full on. And I'm not even going to go
- 15:43on record and saying that we have he has this alleged.
- 15:47At this point, I have to legally say it's all alleged.
- 15:49But there are a number of cases, a number of
- 15:52cases involving this guy, and all of them point to
- 15:55the same sort of behavior, meaning like he doesn't he's
- 15:57not the physical one. He's not the guy who goes
- 16:00in and beats people up. There was a guy named
- 16:01John Birds who would actually he was a physical abuser
- 16:05of people, you know, and interrogation processes. This wasn't the
- 16:09same thing with Zuli. Zuli was much more psychological. He
- 16:12was much more, at least in his estimation, sophisticated in
- 16:14the way he operated, he would leave the room. At
- 16:17least that's what the story is. He would leave the
- 16:19room and have other people come in and do the
- 16:21physical violence, and then he would come back in. You know.
- 16:25So this is the thing, and that's part of what
- 16:26happened in Guantonimo as well. The same story that Anthony
- 16:30Garrett is telling in nineteen ninety two in Chicago is
- 16:33the story that Slah he tells from two thousand and one,
- 16:35two thousand and three, two thousand and four in Guantanamo Bay,
- 16:40and it's about the same guy comes in. He's white, charismatic,
- 16:43he's compelling, and he leaves the room and people come
- 16:47in and do the dirty work, and he comes back
- 16:49in the room, right, and that's his love.
- 16:50Speaker 1: Yep, yep. You know. I gotta ask you a question,
- 16:53and this is between a listener and a podcaster, and
- 16:56that is is that how does your stomach not get upset?
- 16:58Because in listening to it and experiencing the podcast, I
- 17:01do get an upset stomach because you get me so
- 17:04worked up on this. But that's your passion, that that
- 17:07is your emotion, that is your drive to, like you said,
- 17:10dig into the story. But how do you stay with
- 17:13no twisted tummy.
- 17:15Speaker 2: M I think honestly, man, you know, I mean it's
- 17:19gonna sound a little bit hokey, but you know, you
- 17:22you have it as well like Ero. You know you
- 17:24you're fortunate enough to be you know, have some some
- 17:26gifts in the world. Mine one of mine is listening
- 17:29deeply and being able to help translate people's stories. So
- 17:32I think I sit in this space of gratitude and
- 17:35appreciation of a gift and a responsibility to use the gift.
- 17:39And I'm a vessel for that work. You know, it's
- 17:42not about me, It's happening through me. That's why I said,
- 17:44I'm a small part of the story. And I'm a
- 17:45very fortunate person to be able to help tell a
- 17:48story that opens people's eyes and helps gifts some folks
- 17:50some closure and the sense of their story is being heard.
- 17:53And to me, that's a real there's a there's a
- 17:56sense of satisfaction associated with that to be part of
- 17:58that work, because there's a lot army of us out
- 18:00here doing this kind of work. And I am again
- 18:02like just a foot soldier in that army, and I'm
- 18:04a proud person to be doing it. And I mean,
- 18:06that's what helps me.
- 18:06Speaker 1: Man, Well, you've got to come back to this show
- 18:08anytime in the future, Dax. You know that door is
- 18:10always going to be open for you.
- 18:12Speaker 2: I appreciate you, I really do, and I just thank you.
- 18:15I appreciate you for listening, for sharing with your audience
- 18:18and sharing me with your audience. And you know, for
- 18:20all those out there listening, I want to say, I know,
- 18:21it's the holiday season. It's been a long, long year.
- 18:24Maybe a story, but a wrongful conviction. Its not sounded
- 18:26like very appetizing, but I promise you there's some funny moments,
- 18:29there's some light moments. There's a lot of levity in
- 18:31this project. It's not just all about the wrongful conviction.
- 18:34It's about friendship too, and it's about what happens.
- 18:37Speaker 1: You know, you'd be brilliant today.
- 18:38Speaker 2: Okay, okay, you do the same. Happy Holidays,