Latest / Serves You Right / #78 Mark Schatzker: Are Doritos Rewiring Your Brain?
Transcript
- 0:01Our food conversation and our concern is always about
- 0:04nutrients, fat, carbs, salt, calories.
- 0:08What made that Dorito successful was none of the above, that that
- 0:12was all the same. It was this dusting of flavour
- 0:15compounds that turned a snack that nobody wanted to eat into a
- 0:18snack that people have difficulty not eating.
- 0:24Welcome back friends. Thank you for listening to
- 0:26Safety Right. Today I am talking to Mark
- 0:29Schatzker, author of Steak, the Dorito Effect, and the End of
- 0:34Craving. Mark has one central question.
- 0:37What's going on with food and why does it taste the way it
- 0:40does? He explores the progression of
- 0:44industrial agriculture. What is going on with flavor?
- 0:48How is it possible that pigs, chickens, cows are all bigger,
- 0:54younger, and it seems less flavorful these days?
- 0:58Super fascinating guy. If you ever eat food, which I
- 1:03assume most of you do, if you are interested in cuisine, if
- 1:06you want to know what exactly is going on with Doritos, this is
- 1:10the one for you. All right, let's do it.
- 1:16Mark Schatzker, welcome to Sergio.
- 1:18Right. Thank you for having me.
- 1:20Yes, I promise not to put your last name anymore.
- 1:22I apologize. No, Doing great.
- 1:25Yeah. So I thought I would ask you
- 1:27about Doritos because you've written three books, one called
- 1:31The Dorito Effect, all fantastic books.
- 1:33And as I was thinking about how to frame this first question, I
- 1:36remembered something I saw, and it's probably been five to seven
- 1:40years. It was just a random throwaway
- 1:42thing on Facebook, but it stuck with me.
- 1:44And the post was, do you know that the average Cool Ranch
- 1:49Dorito has more Cool Ranch flavor than the average peasant
- 1:53in the medieval age would ever see in their whole life?
- 1:56It was like, you know, clearly just an absurd post to like as a
- 1:58joking thing. I remember when I saw it, I was
- 2:01like, OK, but after reading your book, I don't know, it's
- 2:04something weird is happening with our food and you point that
- 2:07out. So what's going on with Doritos?
- 2:09Let's start there and we can kind of.
- 2:11Go I think the kind of the insight behind that Facebook
- 2:14post you saw is, is the realization that the peasant of
- 2:18so many hundreds of years ago lived in a world where all the
- 2:21flavor they experienced was the production of nature of, of
- 2:24natural things like like plants and animals.
- 2:27And, and we've changed that significantly.
- 2:28And it's really a change that's I mean, it's, it's been ongoing
- 2:31for a long time. If you look at the very slow
- 2:34history of things like how we made, you know, fruit extracts
- 2:37and things that were started. But the the modern flavor
- 2:40industry really got going in the 1960s after the invention of
- 2:42something called the gas chromatograph, which which
- 2:45basically unlocked the door on flavor.
- 2:47So I'm giving you a very long answer to the question.
- 2:50That's fine, yeah. But but that's what made Doritos
- 2:53possible. And the reason I called the book
- 2:55The Dorito Effect is because Doritos are probably the most
- 2:58successful snack food of all time.
- 3:01They're, you know, every year they have a Super Bowl ad
- 3:04they're widely regarded as being crack like in their ability just
- 3:07just sort of keep you eating. But what so many people don't
- 3:10know is that the very first ever Doritos were just salted
- 3:13tortilla chips and they bombed. And they it almost never
- 3:18happened. And the guy who invented them, a
- 3:20guy named Arch W was sort of brought up to faces executives.
- 3:23And they said, what are you going to do about Doritos?
- 3:25And he said, let's make them taste like Taco.
- 3:28And this actually got laughs and and one of his, you know,
- 3:32colleagues said he doesn't understand the difference
- 3:34between a thing and a flavor. And this was a pivotal point in
- 3:38in the history of food because up until that time, different
- 3:41things that flavors. If you wanted the flavor of a
- 3:43Taco, you had to get a Taco. If you want the flavor of a hot
- 3:46dog, you had to make a hot dog roast chicken.
- 3:49We had sort of simple fruit extracts and rudimentary flavors
- 3:52that were pretty unconvincing. But but the gas chromatograph
- 3:55let us unlock flavor. It's interesting if you look at,
- 3:59you know, certain cookbooks that were interested in nutrition at
- 4:01the time, we knew a lot. We knew about a protein.
- 4:03We knew about the essential vitamins and minerals.
- 4:05We knew about carbohydrates. We knew about fat.
- 4:07We knew about the Omega threes, the Omega sixes flavor was a
- 4:09total mystery. Nobody understood why does
- 4:11coffee taste like coffee? Why does chicken taste like
- 4:13chicken? Why does grapefruit taste like
- 4:15grapefruit? And it's because flavor exists.
- 4:18It's measured in parts per million, parts per billion,
- 4:20parts per trillion. It was just this this kind of
- 4:22ephemeral ghost. What is it?
- 4:24And it was the gas chromatograph that unlocked it.
- 4:26And once we could identify the flavor compounds and food, we
- 4:29started producing them in factories.
- 4:31And that's what let us take a salted tortilla chip and imbue
- 4:34it with the sensory characteristics that are Taco
- 4:38like. Did they taste exactly like a
- 4:40Taco? Did people literally think I'm
- 4:41eating a Taco? No, but it had the sort of the
- 4:44Zing, that kind of umami depth that made a tortilla chip taste
- 4:48more like a food that it isn't. So it let us basically start
- 4:52faking. And what's so important is that
- 4:55our food conversation and our concern is always about
- 4:58nutrients, fat, carbs, salt, calories.
- 5:02What made that Dorito successful was none of the above.
- 5:04That was all the same. It was this dusting of flavor
- 5:09compounds that turned a snack that nobody wanted to eat into a
- 5:11snack that people have difficulty not eating.
- 5:15And that is the importance of flavor.
- 5:16And that's why I wrote that book.
- 5:18Yeah, I love how you frame so thoroughly like flavor used to
- 5:22be information and flavor still is information, but information
- 5:26can be misleading. Now you know it's it's the news,
- 5:30but now the News Online where you know it's crowd sourced and
- 5:35you can't really trust the sources.
- 5:36And all of a sudden, your Taco flavor is not a Taco, it's a
- 5:41Dorito. Yeah.
- 5:43I was thinking a lot and I don't feel like you got into this, but
- 5:45I wanted to see what you thought.
- 5:47I feel like one of the other things that this flavour science
- 5:51coming online allowed us to do was access flavours that are
- 5:55more seasonal because it's kind of a central problem and I'm
- 5:58more alcohol based because it's more like bars and that's my
- 6:02background. A lot of the different liqueurs
- 6:05and the different things that have been popular and were
- 6:08popular in the past were because alcohol could prevent the
- 6:13inevitable like decay and rot of the seasonal things.
- 6:16And so all of a sudden you now have 365 days a year access to
- 6:21flavors that maybe you'd only have brief windows.
- 6:24And so I think that that also kind of opened up the the
- 6:28floodgates, if you will. All of a sudden we have
- 6:31strawberry flavor 24/7 instead of just one short window.
- 6:34Yeah, that's an interesting observation. 11.
- 6:36I hadn't thought about, but, but it's basically in line with
- 6:39this, the central idea of being sort of a deception versus
- 6:43versus truth versus veracity. And that's the concern.
- 6:46What's so interesting to me is that flavour is how we
- 6:49experience food in the moment. You know, every time you sit
- 6:51down to eat, there's an expectation of a flavour
- 6:53experience and one that you want to optimize.
- 6:55Even if you're on like a diet, if you're doing like carnivore
- 6:58or Mediterranean or whatever, you buy like the cookbook to get
- 7:00the best recipes so that you can enjoy your food the most.
- 7:03Yet we never talk about it in our food conversation.
- 7:05We suddenly put on the white lab coat and now we're it's just
- 7:07about nutrition. It's about what happens from the
- 7:09neck down, the nutrients, carbs, fat, calories and so forth.
- 7:12And the question we never seem to ask is why does food have
- 7:15flavor in the 1st place? If it's all about nutrition, why
- 7:18is there this incredibly gripping experience that seems
- 7:21to be totally divorced from the important aspects of food, which
- 7:24is how it how does it sort of nourish you and it.
- 7:26And the answer is that it's not divorced from it that that
- 7:29flavor is how we evolved to sense and seek out nutrients.
- 7:35So the essential problem an Organism has is that the
- 7:37nutrients that we need are are difficult to sense in the
- 7:40moment. Like sugar, we can sense, we
- 7:42have sweet receptors, but but you know, the vitamins and
- 7:45minerals, they're very stable. They're really hard to sense.
- 7:48So what we do is we sense the things we can sense, which are
- 7:52odors, which are what we call volatile aromatic compounds.
- 7:55And we can sense those in the moment and, and the brain
- 7:57associates those things. So what we talk about, we talk
- 8:00about flavor. It's it's actually a blend of
- 8:02two things. It's the basic tastes that you
- 8:05experience with your tongue, sweet, bitter, salty, sour and
- 8:07umami. But it's also aromas and, and
- 8:10people like with that sounds weird, don't you?
- 8:12That's like sniffing. So when you sniff something like
- 8:14like, like you like you sniff your coffee or you sniff a
- 8:17bouquet of flowers, that's called ortho nasal olfaction.
- 8:20The air is going into your nostrils and your small receptor
- 8:22sense it. But there's something called
- 8:24retro nasal olfaction. And those are those vapors
- 8:27wafting into the back of your throat and they go up that, you
- 8:29know, that weird hole in the back of your throat that
- 8:31connects your nose to your throat.
- 8:32They go up in there and you sense the odor of the food as
- 8:36you're eating it. And that is where so much of the
- 8:39flavor comes from. That's what makes a strawberry
- 8:41taste like a strawberry. Chicken tastes like chicken.
- 8:44And that's what flavor is. And the reason is your brain is
- 8:47trying to get a handle on what's coming in because it's got to
- 8:49figure out, you know, we, we use different hormones to metabolize
- 8:53different nutrients. We want to get a sense of how
- 8:55much is coming in. So flavor is, as you said,
- 8:58information, and that signal was incredibly useful and truthful
- 9:03for millions and millions and millions and millions of years.
- 9:06It's not to say there was that you can find cases in nature
- 9:08where where you know that there can be some deception, but it's
- 9:11pretty rare. It's almost like footnotes.
- 9:14And then it went from being like like in evolutionary terms, in a
- 9:17blink of an eye, it went from being stable to being unstable.
- 9:21A great example would be something like artificial
- 9:23sweeteners. Sugar gives you a predictable
- 9:27sense of incoming calories. Artificial sweeteners take that
- 9:31stable signal and flip it around.
- 9:33Now something like sweetness can mean lots of calories, can mean
- 9:360 calories, or it can just mean some calories just depending on
- 9:39what additives have been put in. So I think this is, you know,
- 9:43we're so kind of concerned, even obsessed with what we now call
- 9:45ultra processed foods. What's going on?
- 9:47I think this is a huge aspect of it is how we've altered the
- 9:51sensory aspects of what we eat, how we've just basically changed
- 9:54the way food tastes. Yeah, for sure.
- 9:56And that disconnect, like I, I think you, you really put it in
- 9:59a way that I'd never thought. And I think it makes a lot of
- 10:02sense because like, I'll, I'll confess my weakness for the
- 10:06modern era is cheesecake. I love cheesecake and I know I
- 10:09shouldn't eat too much of it, but I also love, you know, like,
- 10:12you know, and I, I find myself even like when I'm thinking
- 10:15about my diet or just, you know, watching my weight, I'll still
- 10:19have these moments where I'm like, well, I'll just, I'll just
- 10:21get one. That's fine.
- 10:22And I've never been able to understand why I have that sort
- 10:27of desire, even though consciously I know I shouldn't
- 10:30be doing these things. They're like, I shouldn't be
- 10:32that I want to watch my health. You, you kind of walk through
- 10:35like this mismatch that you see where we're using, you know,
- 10:39these alterations where the information coming in, you're
- 10:41tasting things that maybe the sweetless levels don't match
- 10:45with what's coming into your body.
- 10:47You tie that to, you know, when there's uncertainty, the
- 10:50evolutionary directive is if you're not sure what's
- 10:53happening, work harder because that's, that's like a tried and
- 10:56true method to make sure you survive, which in terms of
- 10:59eating, working harder means eating more, which is not what I
- 11:02want to do. And that's, I mean, that is like
- 11:05the central problem with a BCD in the modern era.
- 11:08People have all this crave worthy food that has all these
- 11:12alterations and the body's confused, it seems like.
- 11:14And so just eats and eats. Yeah.
- 11:16Well, let me begin with your concern about cheesecake because
- 11:19I wouldn't be concerned about cheesecake.
- 11:21I mean, don't stuff your face with cheesecake every day.
- 11:24But if you've made real cheesecake from real ingredients
- 11:26in your kitchen, I don't think there's a lot to be concerned
- 11:28about. If you, if you look at the other
- 11:29parts of the world with the lowest rates of obesity, I
- 11:31talked a lot about this in the end of craving in the Western
- 11:33world, I would say Italy is the lowest rate of obesity in the
- 11:35Western world. It's less than 10%.
- 11:38It also has the best food in the Western world, arguably, I would
- 11:40say it's probably Italy and France, but I'll take Italy over
- 11:42France. So we tend to think that obesity
- 11:45is caused by this kind of overindulgence in the pleasure
- 11:47of eating. And if that were true, then
- 11:49Italy, the Italians would be the fattest in the world.
- 11:51In the Western world, they're the thinnest.
- 11:54OK, that seems wrong. Let's go look at the East.
- 11:56I would say that the two best food cultures, food cultures
- 11:59most obsessed with quality, would be South Korea and Japan.
- 12:02And they both have the lowest rates of obesity.
- 12:05You'll find that in all these cultures too, you can find rich
- 12:08indulgences. There's a lot of fried,
- 12:10delicious fried food in Japan. That's not to say they're always
- 12:12eating deep fried food, but it's not like they're they never eat
- 12:15it. There's no rule against it.
- 12:17Well. You describe them almost like
- 12:18they worship the altar fat. You know, Japanese love that
- 12:23they're aficionados of fat. It's not to say they they drench
- 12:26everything in fat. It's more like they have this
- 12:28deep reverence for fat. They love fatty tuna, they love
- 12:32fatty beef and they, they really enjoy that.
- 12:34That doesn't mean they stuff their faces with it, but they're
- 12:36not afraid of it and they're certainly not afraid of the
- 12:39pleasure that it brings. They indulge in it, they
- 12:41celebrate it, they become masters of it, they really
- 12:44exploit it and they create these meal experiences that are
- 12:47incredible. Same with Italians.
- 12:49And what's so much about Japan and Italy is they both have all
- 12:52these rules about food. Like if you're going to call
- 12:55something Matsuzaka beef, it has to be from Matsuzaka and it's
- 12:58got to hit all the, you know, you've got to do all these
- 12:59things otherwise you don't get to call it Matsuzaka beef.
- 13:01They have the same. Italy has more rules than any
- 13:03country in the world. But if you want to call this
- 13:05cheese Parmigiano Reggiano, it's got to be done this way in this
- 13:08area. And same with.
- 13:10City by city, too. Honestly, region by region and
- 13:13and there's, there's so many and we think it's kind of cute and
- 13:16funny, but I think there is a deep wisdom there.
- 13:19Whereas here we don't seem to care if you can, you know, put a
- 13:23flavor. A great example would be those
- 13:25little yogurt sticks that parents like to give to their
- 13:26kids. Any kids come home from school
- 13:29and they're hungry and you want to give them a healthy snack.
- 13:30So you'll see, it'll be, it'll say like forest Berry explosion.
- 13:34And there's little pictures of berries in the forest.
- 13:37Well, look at the ingredients. And there's actually no berries
- 13:39at all. There's food coloring and
- 13:41there's flavor and there's sugar.
- 13:42And that's our approach. And a lot of Italians would look
- 13:44at that and think there's just something deeply wrong with
- 13:46that. And you know, we would just say,
- 13:48well, look at the ingredients, look at the nutrients.
- 13:50We don't think about the experience that we're evoking.
- 13:53So you talk about something called uncertainty and that's
- 13:56really important. This is, and this is what I fear
- 13:58the effect is. I talked a lot about this in the
- 14:00end of craving, when you take when you take something that is
- 14:03predictable and you make it unpredictable, what is the
- 14:05brain's response? And there's a very deep body of
- 14:09research and knowledge. And this in psychology and what
- 14:11you're creating is the term for it is just uncertainty.
- 14:14And more technical term is reward prediction error.
- 14:17And there's a very predictable way that a brain responses and
- 14:20that is with increased motivation.
- 14:22And this is important because if you take something that's
- 14:24necessary and it goes from being a certain yes to a maybe, and
- 14:29you need that thing, well then the thing to do is to work
- 14:32harder to make sure that you get that thing.
- 14:34Because in evolution losses are bad.
- 14:37Because if you don't get that food you need or you don't get
- 14:39that mate or something like that, the consequences can be
- 14:43severe. Sorry to interrupt, we will get
- 14:48back to Andrew and Mark, but I thought I'd take a quick moment
- 14:52to say if you have not had a chance to follow the show,
- 14:55please do. It makes me very happy and
- 14:57don't, don't you want me to be happy?
- 14:59All right, back to the show. So brains, you know, there's
- 15:05this idea that we're just sort of the Stone Age crafted us to
- 15:08be voracious eaters because there was the threat of famine
- 15:11and, and calories were scarce. That actually makes no sense
- 15:14because if you're carrying around a lot of fat, you burn
- 15:18calories just to lug around that fat.
- 15:20It's like carrying a trailer behind your car.
- 15:22You, you, you full of fuel. Well, you need extra fuel just
- 15:25to lug around that fuel. So in a calorie scarce
- 15:28environment, it's not a really good strategy to carry around
- 15:31extra calories because there's an enormous cost.
- 15:34And that always, there's always a trade off that means that
- 15:36you're not, you know, seeking out a mate or hunting something
- 15:38or building a structure or building tools.
- 15:40So I don't think that that evolution crafted us to be
- 15:43voracious calorie seekers. But what we know that when we
- 15:47look at the neuroscience of obesity, we see that people with
- 15:49obesity that they don't enjoy food more, they crave it more.
- 15:53And what uncertainty does is it ramps up motivation.
- 15:56And so this, I think makes a lot more sense.
- 15:58If you make calories a question mark, you work harder to get
- 16:01them. And I'll make this intuitive
- 16:03because that might say like, what are you talking about?
- 16:04But if I if I said to you like you live in Omaha and if you had
- 16:07to drive to like how far is Kansas City from Omaha?
- 16:10Like 3 or 4 hours, nothing crazy.
- 16:12But OK, so if I said you can take my car and I said here's
- 16:15the problem, the gas gauge is broken.
- 16:17So it says full. It's just stuck at like in
- 16:20between. You have no idea how much gas is
- 16:21in there. What would you do driving?
- 16:24Top it off a lot, yeah. That's right.
- 16:26You'd, you'd just be like, I don't want to run out.
- 16:28That would be a disaster, right? You're stuck with.
- 16:30So you would just keep filling it and filling it.
- 16:32Now a car you can't overfill, but that is the effect that
- 16:35uncertainty has. If I told you, you have a flight
- 16:38that leaves in three hours and your watch is off by an hour,
- 16:41what would you do? Early, yeah.
- 16:43You'd go where? So you see how that sort of
- 16:45ramps up the motivation, right? Not only would you go early,
- 16:47you'd be like, you'd be like, crap, I might be late.
- 16:50Like you'd feel that, that burst of anxiety.
- 16:53And that is what uncertainty does.
- 16:54You know, in A twist even more if it's something like if it's
- 16:58just a short flight that I'm seeing a friend or something
- 17:00like, all right, maybe I'll push it a little.
- 17:02But if it's like international, I spend a lot of money, I go
- 17:05real early because that's like, I can't miss that.
- 17:07I got to get the bags checked. I got to get everything, you
- 17:09know, So the more important, the earlier you go.
- 17:12Yeah. So, so that, and that's
- 17:14essentially how gambling works. That's why gambling works.
- 17:17It's really interesting if you look at, you know, the
- 17:19psychology, the the psychological reason in
- 17:22gambling, because for a long time they thought, well, the
- 17:23reason people gambled is just the promise of riches.
- 17:26You know, I might strike it rich, I might hit it big.
- 17:28But then they notice it like, well, it's weird though, because
- 17:30then you'll have like a multi millionaire.
- 17:31We'll bet 10 bucks on a football game with a friend just for fun.
- 17:35These people can't even calculate their net worth, but
- 17:38they know that 10 bucks is really not meaningful.
- 17:40But yet they're engaged in this. And the reason is that a gamble
- 17:44is essentially an invitation to uncertainty and it draws us in.
- 17:48That's why when you walk into a casino, you know, one of the
- 17:50things they do is they show you a picture of the people that won
- 17:53like 20 million bucks on Lotto, whatever.
- 17:56Because that puts you in a position of of in this big
- 18:00status game we have of being in the realms of losses and you
- 18:03want more. That's one of the reasons in
- 18:05problem gambling, people do really dumb things like they'll
- 18:09bet their their child's college fund or they'll, you know, sell
- 18:13their car or their wedding ring or something.
- 18:15But that's because when you're losing, that's the worst thing
- 18:18you want to get back into the realm of of gains.
- 18:21And so on a very deep level, there's this this wiring for
- 18:25gains and losses that really has a propulsive effect on our
- 18:29behavior. And that makes this whole idea
- 18:31of uncertainty come into focus. And that I think that's how it
- 18:34can kind of click and you go, OK, that's what's happened.
- 18:37That that is so much about what's happened to our food is
- 18:39how we have created an unstable signal that that the information
- 18:44the brain gets on the way in no longer matches what winds up in
- 18:48the gut. Yeah, we we hate losses way more
- 18:51than we like gains, which is just always true, whether or not
- 18:55it's rational, it's just how we are.
- 18:57So I do think it'd be worthwhile to also touch a little bit on
- 19:01what is happening to flavor when flavor isn't modified, because I
- 19:06think that that's another central problem where we're
- 19:09growing food too quickly and not letting it ripen.
- 19:12And like even even yesterday I had on the show Expert in
- 19:17Mezcal, and it was the same exact thing.
- 19:19And it was so funny because I knew I was talking to you later.
- 19:22He's like, we used to let the agave ripen and now the demand
- 19:27for tequila such that we are shortening that cycle.
- 19:30We have an industrial diffuser to break down the fiber so that
- 19:34we can produce more instead of doing the old style roasting.
- 19:37And all the things that are a little wasteful end up in a
- 19:40flavorful product. It's like it's everywhere, you
- 19:43know? Yeah.
- 19:46No, listen, that that's a great insight.
- 19:47And that was the other half of what the Dorito effect was
- 19:49about, which is there's two things that happen to flavor,
- 19:52which is that we're getting really good at making fake
- 19:54flavor, but we're also draining out or bleaching out the flavor
- 19:57of natural foods. And that that has to do with
- 19:59just as you say, high output agriculture trying to get more.
- 20:03Now, this isn't all bad. If over the past century we've
- 20:08gotten much better at getting, producing more food from the
- 20:11same acre of land, and that's good because we have lots more
- 20:14mouths to feed and there's less and less farmland because we
- 20:16keep on, you know, building suburbs in the, in the best, you
- 20:19know, farmland and so forth. So it's not all bad.
- 20:22We do need food, but there is a trade off.
- 20:24It's not always the trade off that people think.
- 20:26It's not a 0 sum game, but I'd put it more like this.
- 20:28If you don't select a trade as your breeding, you know,
- 20:33vegetative plant, you're going to lose it.
- 20:35So the two best examples, it's probably tomatoes and
- 20:38strawberries are something that just we want them to be
- 20:40delicious. We've experienced them at their
- 20:42best, yet they almost always suck.
- 20:44They it's almost always a let down.
- 20:46And the reason is that they're being slowly bleached a flavor
- 20:49because when we breed new varieties, we look for what are
- 20:52called the agronomic traits, which is things like yield.
- 20:54We want lots, we want shelf life and that's a good thing.
- 20:57You don't want your strawberries to turn to mush in two days.
- 21:00We want disease resistance because you don't want some
- 21:02blight that wipes out your crop. And those are the things that we
- 21:04breed for. But nobody sits around going, is
- 21:07that a tasty strawberry? Is that a tasty tomato?
- 21:10So if you don't select a trait, you're going to lose it.
- 21:12So we've lost flavor. The same reason that we as
- 21:14humans don't have tails. Once Upon a time our answers did
- 21:16have tails. But when you don't select a
- 21:18trait, when there's no advantage to that trait, it goes away.
- 21:21So that's what's happened to flavor.
- 21:22So if you think of flavor is the incentive to eat, it's just you
- 21:25sit down, you want your food to taste good, to have flavor,
- 21:28remove the flavor from the Whole Foods that we should be eating,
- 21:30the stuff that comes from the farm.
- 21:32And we put it in the ultra process that we should not be
- 21:34eating. So it's, it's very simple.
- 21:36What we've done, we've taken the incentive from the good food and
- 21:39put it onto the bad food. And, and Dave is one example,
- 21:41but I would say that's the story.
- 21:43I mean, it started with my steak book.
- 21:44My, the first book I wrote was about steak and, and that's
- 21:47where it's, and what I really noticed there's some, some
- 21:51terrifically amazing steak in this world and there's some
- 21:53phenomenally bad steak in this world.
- 21:54But mainly there's just an awful lot of very mediocre steak.
- 21:58It's, I call it mature veal. It's just, it looks red.
- 22:02It doesn't taste red. And that's why we put Montreal
- 22:04steak spice on it. And anyone who works in a
- 22:06restaurant has to work awfully harder now to make food have
- 22:09flavor because the incoming ingredients are just it's just
- 22:12not up to the task. That's why the Italians and the
- 22:14Japanese have all these rules, because they care about flavor
- 22:17and they know that if you don't care, you're going to lose it.
- 22:20And we don't have that. We just basically buy what's
- 22:22cheapest. I grew up in Pampa, TX and it's
- 22:25next to Hereford and it's not far from Amarillo.
- 22:28So that whole section in the book where it's like 72 ounce a
- 22:32steak, I drove by that so many times and I drove near Hereford
- 22:36and I got to smell the smell of industrial beef raising.
- 22:40Yeah. So I know it.
- 22:42Yeah. It's it's something that you
- 22:44can't describe until you experience it.
- 22:47I feel like steak is an interesting one where, you know,
- 22:50there are two different ways and take this whichever direction
- 22:52you like. I like how you framed it as like
- 22:55the best steak you'd had was grass fed and also the worst
- 22:58one. So like they're these that's a
- 23:00different, like you need to know what you're doing to do it well,
- 23:05But I, I feel like with steak, we have accepted that the
- 23:09flavour is going down. So we've substituted out desire
- 23:12for tenderness. You know, just like I hear more
- 23:16people talk about how tender a steak is now than how flavorful
- 23:19it is. It's just like you, you have to
- 23:22aspire to something and people love steak.
- 23:24I mean, there's a reason you wrote the book about steak and
- 23:26not like pork chops. You know, I think you'd say
- 23:29like, no one ever said, I just made a big sell, let's go get a
- 23:31chicken. Like, no, that's we're going to
- 23:34a steakhouse and we're going to have a steak.
- 23:36Yeah, it's a weird substitution flavor for texture, but maybe.
- 23:40It's well, I think, I think some people have never experienced
- 23:43flavor. I think some some people now are
- 23:45frightened of it. I've also written a lot about
- 23:46chicken and I mean, modern broilers have no flavor and most
- 23:50people have never really experienced the flavor of
- 23:52chicken. And I've actually told some
- 23:53people, here's where you can get a good chicken and some people
- 23:55don't like it. They, they just want this sort
- 23:57of bland, you know, widget that they can impose flavor on.
- 24:02That's how alienated we have become from true flavor.
- 24:05And I think there's a real danger there.
- 24:06And I think you're right about steak.
- 24:07I, you know, I've been a place like my brother in Patagonia
- 24:10fishing, my brother and we went to this restaurant and got a I
- 24:12don't even know what cut it was. It was thin and quite large and
- 24:16it was chewy, like it had some serious chew, but my God, was a
- 24:19flavorful. And I will happily take a little
- 24:21chew if there's some real deep beefy flavor because that to me
- 24:25is just, it just speaks to my soul.
- 24:27I love it so much. An industrial kind of a, you
- 24:30know, tenderloin, almost fork tender, but no flavor.
- 24:33But what's the point? I'm just so not interested in
- 24:36that. But some people want that, yeah.
- 24:37And I mean, you get used to it, you know, like if if that's what
- 24:41you've grown up with, that's what you have known your whole
- 24:43life. Like, yeah, that's what you got.
- 24:46Yes. I'm also thinking, you know,
- 24:48it's it's one of those things that I always go back to again
- 24:51because I'm just so beverage heavy Scotch.
- 24:54Scotch back of the day was not very popular.
- 24:57And a lot of the reason it wasn't very popular is just
- 24:59because Scotch was so intense. And it even was more intense in
- 25:04the back of the day before industrial production.
- 25:06But Scotch started taking off when they started making blended
- 25:11whiskeys. So they they toned down the
- 25:13flavor just a little bit. And it's enough that people are
- 25:16like, OK, I could try this and start getting into it.
- 25:19So that reduction in flavor led to an increase in consumption.
- 25:23It was like, you know, I always go through the beverage lens,
- 25:26but it's, it's the exact same thing, you know, tone the flavor
- 25:29down you can eat. More yeah, that's a good point,
- 25:32although maybe maybe that opened the door to Scotch.
- 25:34I sometimes think I'm not a, I'm not like a total wine person,
- 25:37but if you look at Merlot, it's a very accessible grape.
- 25:40And some people like to judge it, but Merlot's often opens the
- 25:43door for people to start enjoying red wine.
- 25:45And then as they get more into it, they start to discover some
- 25:47of the more complex grapes. So, so maybe that's part of the
- 25:50journey. But that's an interesting
- 25:51observation about Scotch. I'm also curious, though, you're
- 25:54in the restaurant world. A lot of people don't realize
- 25:57the degree to which a lot of the food they eat in restaurants
- 25:59isn't actually cooked in the restaurant.
- 26:02And there's a, there's a, it's kind of like a spectrum.
- 26:03Like you can go to some, you know, franchise restaurants and
- 26:06people don't realize that. They think the food's coming
- 26:09from a kitchen, but it's, it's really more like a reheating
- 26:12room. They call it re thermalization
- 26:14and that these foods are actually made in factories
- 26:16hundreds of miles away and they're just heated in the
- 26:18moment by they're more like technicians or something like
- 26:21that. Like they're certainly not
- 26:22chefs, they're not cooks, but there's even little things.
- 26:25I went to a like a pub and I ordered eggs Benedict and the
- 26:28holidays just tasted fake. It was just like a cartoon
- 26:32hollandaise. I'm like, what's going on?
- 26:33And I asked and I got an honest answer that they didn't make it.
- 26:37It just came out of a box. Even though this is a kitchen
- 26:39where somebody was actually making eggs Benedict, they were
- 26:41poaching the eggs. I guess for them it's just
- 26:44easier to, you know, open a box of hollandaise or I don't even
- 26:48know how it arrives. Maybe it's a powder, I have no
- 26:50clue, than to actually make a hollandaise.
- 26:52Yeah, yeah, a palette of hollandaise arrives and I, I'm
- 26:55just curious your perspective from seeing the inside of
- 26:57kitchens. I think a lot of people don't
- 26:58realize the degree to which even in even in restaurants that are
- 27:01cooking still a lot of the stuff is is pre made.
- 27:05It wasn't made in the kitchen. You know, I definitely think
- 27:07that it's more than people realize.
- 27:09And I have worked in that style of restaurant before.
- 27:12I will say I'm not going to name the restaurant, but I I've tried
- 27:16to spend most of my time in places that have higher check
- 27:19averages to, to my really long or three of my long stints of El
- 27:24Piado and then Coyote Cafe, both in Santa Fe and then Namel
- 27:29Mahogany. And part of the reason I do like
- 27:32those things, I'm very wine heavy, but El Piado is a great
- 27:35example is a farm to table Italian spot.
- 27:39So it was a lot like even the pasta was made fresh in house.
- 27:43So you know, you do find restaurants where they do it And
- 27:46usually if they are doing it and making it fresh, like we make
- 27:49the hollandaise fresh every day, which sucks because we have to
- 27:52throw it away. It's part of our waste now, the
- 27:54restaurant, but it doesn't taste like it's from a box, because
- 27:57it's not. Yes.
- 27:59I think, I think that a lot of people would be shocked at what
- 28:02they would have to pay to have all the restaurants make things
- 28:06from scratch because there there is a reason that they a lot of
- 28:10restaurants do purchase a lot of these things.
- 28:12It is more economically viable than paying someone to make
- 28:15them. Sometimes.
- 28:16You know, coming coming from some central distribution system
- 28:19from Cisco or Bennekeith, whoever you use frozen to where
- 28:23you can pop it straight into the fryer.
- 28:25One of the hardest parts of running a restaurant is waste
- 28:28because you can't make money on the food you throw away.
- 28:30So there's almost no risk there. It's really just a projection
- 28:33problem. If I ran a restaurant where I
- 28:35was trying to charge people $10 a plate, I don't know how I do
- 28:37it otherwise in America right now, you know?
- 28:40Yeah, so this is something I don't understand because I go to
- 28:42Europe. My wife was there recently and
- 28:44she, she was in Spain and she got a like a pork burger made
- 28:48from that wonderful Spanish pork, the Iberico pork.
- 28:53Now it's not, you know, that it's the hams that really have
- 28:55the value. But, but other parts of it, I
- 28:56guess, I don't know if they ground the shoulder or
- 28:58something. I, it came with a salad and some
- 29:01fries. And I think it was €13.
- 29:03And she was just like, it was just incredible.
- 29:05And here, what would that be like $40 or something?
- 29:08It would be a lot if somebody even did that.
- 29:10It would be a lot. And I don't understand why I
- 29:13love fresh pasta. I, I love it so much.
- 29:16And I think people who don't realize, who've never had it,
- 29:18don't realize it's like a whole the world.
- 29:20I like dried pasta too, but it's just in a way, they shouldn't
- 29:22even have the same name because they're really quite different
- 29:24as far as how they taste. And fresh pasta is so
- 29:26inexpensive in Italy. You can go to these little hole
- 29:29in the wall places in Tuscany and get a bowl of fresh pasta
- 29:32for 12 or €13, which is just amazing, like so good.
- 29:36And here you tend to find fresh pasta in the very expensive
- 29:38restaurants. And I, it's something I don't
- 29:40understand. I feel like I need to like,
- 29:42someone should do a PhD, like getting really into the
- 29:44economics of tracing like these value chains all the way back.
- 29:47Because why? Why is what I would think, if
- 29:49it's real, honest food, so much more expensive here than it is
- 29:52there? Because that's one of the
- 29:53barriers. And a lot of people are stuck
- 29:56because of their income bracket eating really crappy food.
- 29:59It's like they're in a prison. I mean, you even said one of the
- 30:02strongest indicators of obesity is the value of the house.
- 30:05And like when you said it, I was like, that makes sense.
- 30:09I forget in which book it was, but you know, I will say that I
- 30:12have not ever owned a restaurant.
- 30:13So what I what I am saying is parroting what I've heard other
- 30:17people say, people in different management positions or
- 30:20ownership positions, there is very much a possibility that
- 30:24it's just too much of A hassle. They don't want to do it.
- 30:26I do think that part of it is probably the demand and just
- 30:30kind of the general sense because like if there were a
- 30:33demand for high quality, tasty fresh pasta, I have to admit,
- 30:36like I wouldn't know why people wouldn't do that.
- 30:39It's flour and water and eggs. Like, like it is probably the
- 30:44best cost item that you could make If you're making it, you
- 30:48know, you just have to pay someone to do it, make sure they
- 30:50do it well. Yeah.
- 30:51I mean, but if they're if they're quantities getting up
- 30:53there, it shouldn't be that much of a hit in terms of, you know,
- 30:56the cost. Yeah, but I mean, I mean, you
- 30:59put this really well, like our attitude towards food versus the
- 31:02Italians in American and I even slipped into it without meaning
- 31:05to. You could just I'm here, I've
- 31:06I've been here my whole life. I was like, what does this food
- 31:09do to me? Where is the Italian perspective
- 31:12is like, is this the best recipe?
- 31:14And it's like, yeah, there's. A few other things I've noticed,
- 31:20I think countries that do food well specialize in it more.
- 31:23One of the things I notice you go to a restaurant here, let's
- 31:26say one of the sort of the the more upscale franchise
- 31:29restaurants and there will be like there'll be a Pokey Bowl,
- 31:32there'll be pizzas, there'll be pastas, there'll be a burger,
- 31:35there'll be a sloppy Joe. There might be like like a baked
- 31:38potato. There'll be a stir fry.
- 31:41There'll be this huge range. You can have whatever you want.
- 31:44So that customer comes first. You go to go to Japan and you go
- 31:48for yakitori, which is grilled chicken and ask for sushi.
- 31:51And they're like, well, that's across the street.
- 31:52They do one thing and they do it well.
- 31:55And the same in when I said about that whole and well place
- 31:57in Italy, they do pasta. They do pasta really well.
- 31:59They might have a main, a secondo, which is really good,
- 32:02but the whole, the range of what they're offering is very
- 32:04limited. And I think it's kind of this
- 32:05Japanese idea of omakasi. I don't think the customer is
- 32:08always right. I think the customer often is
- 32:10wrong. I mean, the reason you're going
- 32:11to a restaurant is because in theory the person in the kitchen
- 32:13knows more about cooking and you do.
- 32:15So I think part of our problem is we ask restaurants to do too
- 32:17much and satisfied and we've all these, you know, put the sauce
- 32:21on the side, you know, I can't have red pepper, I can't have
- 32:24this and that. So it's the kitchen has to be so
- 32:26much more accommodating and produce such a wide range of
- 32:29options for people. Whereas in the really food
- 32:31dedicated cultures, they have a very narrow target of what they
- 32:34do. They do it really well and I
- 32:36think that's and that gets into a culture thing where I think
- 32:39people here wouldn't put up with that.
- 32:40But I think if you're going to be really serious about food,
- 32:42especially if you want to do something inexpensively, there's
- 32:44restaurants in Europe where they have one dish, you go there and
- 32:46you get 1 dish and they do it really well.
- 32:49And I think there's something so beautiful about that model
- 32:51because it's so economical. It's probably going to be way
- 32:52less waste. Your labor costs are going to be
- 32:54much lower. But that would be a tough thing
- 32:57for people here to swallow. They would probably outraged.
- 32:59I remember I interviewed Alan de Cast, the French restaurateur,
- 33:03and he had just shut down, I think one of his Michelin places
- 33:06in New York, and he said the problem is the US and France.
- 33:10If I get a really gorgeous piece of COD in France, I just post
- 33:14that and put some beautiful butter on it and people love it.
- 33:17But if you serve that New York City, you have to put black
- 33:20truffle or yuzu or something on it to imbue the sense of value.
- 33:25Otherwise people think they're getting ripped off.
- 33:26The food needs to be an endorsement of their wealth and
- 33:28their status, whereas I think Europeans have a more in touch
- 33:31with with quality. Yeah.
- 33:33And I think that does touch on something that's interesting.
- 33:37It's what is American cuisine, You know, it, it hamburgers and
- 33:41pokey bowls. It's we, is it that we haven't
- 33:44been around for long enough that we've developed a strong enough,
- 33:48you know, different localities with different identities?
- 33:51Or is it that we grew up while things were changing?
- 33:53So we we kind of grew up with the change.
- 33:56And so we didn't have an identity in place.
- 33:59And America was coming online when globalization was
- 34:02happening. And so all the food from the
- 34:04whole country crisscrossed. And then we got some flavors and
- 34:08said, all right, put it in. Yeah.
- 34:10I think that story's broadly correct, but but what I will add
- 34:13to it, which I think most people don't realize, is that there's
- 34:16this idea that in France and Italy, in Japan, everybody's
- 34:18eating traditional food, that the food on their plate is
- 34:20something like it was 100 or 200 years ago.
- 34:22And it's kind of a little bit true, but it's mainly wrong
- 34:25because the same agricultural revolution that changed food for
- 34:28us also changed their agriculture. 120 years ago in
- 34:32Italy, they were eating way less meat, way less cheese.
- 34:35They were poor, and their diet was much simpler.
- 34:37So everybody's diet has undergone a revolution.
- 34:41But for some reason in these countries we're talking about,
- 34:43perhaps there's more tradition informed how their cuisine
- 34:48changed, but they were just like, it's really interesting.
- 34:51I talk about this in the Dorito effect.
- 34:52Chickens really start to change in the 19 late 1940s nineteen.
- 34:55So we start to get much better breeding chickens for growth.
- 34:57Chickens used to be really expensive and eating, you know,
- 34:59roast chicken was quite rare. Chickens were mainly for eggs.
- 35:02The French noticed that chicken was changing and they formed the
- 35:04La Belle Rouge label. La Belle Rouge in the, I think
- 35:07it was 50s or 60's. The French farmer said something
- 35:10not good to happen to chickens. We're going to make sure we do
- 35:12it the old fashioned way where chickens have access to pasture
- 35:14and they're slow growing. We noticed it here too.
- 35:17I've documented in cookbooks where chefs are saying chickens
- 35:19are getting, you know, Julia Child said they taste like teddy
- 35:21bear stuffing, but we didn't care.
- 35:23So it just gets down with this weird cultural thing that I
- 35:25can't put my finger on. Do some cultures care about
- 35:29flavor and quality so much more than other cultures?
- 35:31It's not money. GDP per capita is is in the US
- 35:34just destroys Europe, way more wealth.
- 35:36But Europeans put more money towards food and seem to care
- 35:39about it more deeply. Yeah, I can't answer it.
- 35:42It's just one of these strange riddles.
- 35:45You know, so it reminds me of something.
- 35:46And again, I always just go to alcohol examples because that's
- 35:49what I'm steeped in. There's a very interesting
- 35:51debate going on about the word terroir.
- 35:54And so there, there are people on both sides of the fence in
- 35:57wine saying it doesn't exist on the FARC stream and on the other
- 36:00extreme saying it's everything. And there there's AUC Davis
- 36:03Professor, and I'm kicking myself.
- 36:04I can't remember his name, but he he wrote a large diatribe
- 36:08against the word. And so he traced it to where
- 36:11where it started and where it ended up.
- 36:14And so originally it used to be a pejorative where it'd be like
- 36:17Gouda. Terroir is like your wine tastes
- 36:19like dirt, essentially. And then it had two upticks in
- 36:24common usage, and both of them happened when French wines were
- 36:28threatened, when Philoxra got really big, and all of a sudden
- 36:32they're all these imports from Algeria.
- 36:33And so the French first starts saying no, no, you need a
- 36:37terroir to make a wine. And then when Judgement of Paris
- 36:41happened and American Napa Cabs and Chardonnay beat French wines
- 36:46in a blind taste test, it was used kind of a bludgeon.
- 36:49It's like, well, no, you need to have a place in America's too
- 36:52young. We have terroir.
- 36:54They just have grapes. It seems like there's a
- 36:56reflexive defense of regionality that happens in Europe.
- 37:00And I thought about it with terroir, but it's also true in
- 37:03Italy where every little province thinks that it's
- 37:06version of pasta is the right one.
- 37:08And like, no, don't go to, you know, Campania or the market.
- 37:12Like we in Tuscany know what we're doing.
- 37:14Whereas there is nothing that we can defend in America, at least
- 37:18like it doesn't seem like it because we're a nation of
- 37:21immigrants. There's like, there's no like,
- 37:23background, maybe like Native Americans, but even them, like,
- 37:26they were pretty much shuffled to the side and treated pretty
- 37:29horribly and there was not a lot of celebration of their
- 37:32traditions. And so we kind of took over the
- 37:35land and there was no background to protect.
- 37:38Yeah, No, no, I think with that a lot.
- 37:41I mean, I think there is a tear war thing in wine.
- 37:43I don't consider myself a wine expert, but some of the I've had
- 37:45a 2 3/3 times to my wife, I've had like in my life, I've had a
- 37:49Burgundy that like blew my mind. Now the problem is then you go
- 37:51chasing it and you spend lots of money on 10 more bottles of
- 37:54Burgundy and it doesn't happen. It's a.
- 37:55Lot easier to fall in love with like Merlot than Pinot Noir.
- 37:58But. Yeah, no.
- 37:59Well, Pinot noir is like grass fed beef when it's on it, like
- 38:02it changes your life. You're just like, Oh my God,
- 38:04that was incredible. But man, is it easy to screw up.
- 38:07But I think a lot of people don't realize the degree to
- 38:09which wine is processed. Things like oak.
- 38:11I mean, oak really moderates the flavor.
- 38:13It takes out the peaks, it takes out the valleys and things like
- 38:16that. But I do think terroir is a real
- 38:18thing. And so far as plants are
- 38:19essentially chemical factories and, and it's chemicals that we
- 38:22sense and that is influenced by the soil.
- 38:25It's influenced by what side of the valley you're on.
- 38:28If you get morning sun, if you get afternoon sun.
- 38:30And one of the things I don't like about the industrialized
- 38:32food world is that everything tastes the same.
- 38:33The thing about a Dorito is it always tastes the same.
- 38:36It's kind of amazing that we can do that, that we have that
- 38:38technology. But if you think of something
- 38:40like fruit, I love Peaches. Do any two Peaches taste exactly
- 38:44alike? There's and maybe so.
- 38:46OK, so this batch this week, they taste alike.
- 38:48But there's always some variation.
- 38:50And that's what our brain is really good at sensing is this
- 38:52variation. And I think that's part of what
- 38:54makes food exciting. You know, my state book was the
- 38:56search for the world's best steak.
- 38:58But the truth is it's the variation that makes it so
- 39:01exciting. But you can go to Scotland and
- 39:03have a highland steak that has a particular texture and feel to
- 39:06it. And that's very different from
- 39:07Wagyu beef in Japan. And so I think I where I put the
- 39:11difference is that nature specializes in complexity and
- 39:15humans are simplifiers. So in a flavor there, there,
- 39:18there's so many flavors. It's funny.
- 39:20We're we're we're afraid of chemicals.
- 39:21You know, there's like 38 chemicals, whatever in a
- 39:23Twinkie. If you look at the ingredients
- 39:25of a strawberry go from here to the moon, there are are
- 39:26thousands and thousands of chemicals.
- 39:29That's why a truly authentic strawberry flavor will have
- 39:31maybe if you want to really make an incredible strawberry flavor,
- 39:34might have 35 flavor compounds or something.
- 39:36Our strawberry flavorings that that's just too expensive.
- 39:38It's too complex. So humans are just great
- 39:41simplifiers. So you can you can use terroir
- 39:43in a sort of snobbish way. I think there is some truth to
- 39:46it. I think sometimes I like some of
- 39:48the weird tasting European wines because for some reason they
- 39:50taste actually better when you're there than when you bring
- 39:52it home. But we have a tendency as humans
- 39:55to constantly make things cheaper, to try and take
- 39:57shortcuts, and we narrow things. And what nature brings that we
- 40:01can't knock off is complexity. Agreed.
- 40:03Agreed. And you know, I think a lot of
- 40:05the argument and pushback against Tarwar from scientists
- 40:08is the fact that you can't put your finger at one thing.
- 40:12It's like it's the amount of XYZ chemical that comes in through
- 40:15the vine that is determining it's, it's a summation of all
- 40:19sorts of different things. And just because each different
- 40:22region has different things that impact the taste doesn't mean, I
- 40:25think the best argument I've heard against it is, you know,
- 40:28Psalms who are going through certifications, blind tasting.
- 40:31So even people who may not see the bottle, people that maybe
- 40:35have not tried that wine, but only other wines from that
- 40:37region could still reliably tell you this wines from Chablis, you
- 40:41know, so there has to be something there.
- 40:44And think I think you're spot on when it comes to our desire to
- 40:48simplify things. I forget if this is an example
- 40:51from my world or from your book. I think it might be your book
- 40:54where, you know, in terms of like vitamins and extracts, we
- 40:59look at the strawberry and there's fifty different
- 41:01chemicals that make it up. But we picked the one and we put
- 41:04it into a pill. And I think it was you that said
- 41:07it's like looking at the Symphony and pointing to the
- 41:09second chair violin. And like, that's what makes this
- 41:12Symphony sound good. You know, it's this one chemical
- 41:14we're going to take, whereas the truth is there may be a reason
- 41:18that that strawberry has all 50 chemicals.
- 41:20You may need trace amounts of that.
- 41:22And by focusing on one, you're losing the whole.
- 41:25You're losing the protective. Yes.
- 41:28And, and this is something we may never truly know.
- 41:30You know, one of the things I find interesting about natural
- 41:32foods, you know, especially fruits and vegetables, is all
- 41:35these what we call phytonutrients, these chemicals
- 41:38that say it's, you know, neuroprotective or it's good for
- 41:40respiration or it's good for this or that.
- 41:41And the truth is that mainly comes from what they call, you
- 41:43know, in vitro in the, in the Petri dish, they, they take
- 41:47this, this compound in broccoli and it, and it kills cancer
- 41:50cells. They say, oh, protective against
- 41:52cancer. It might not be that, that the
- 41:54in vitro stuff is not the same as in vivo, which is in the
- 41:56body. And often when they turn that
- 41:58like into a pill into a drug, it fails.
- 42:00But what is so hard to know is what is the interaction of all
- 42:04these things over a long period of time?
- 42:06And that's something that's really difficult to test using
- 42:08the scientific method. You can test this one chemical.
- 42:10What effect does it have? What about what about them all
- 42:13in unison? And that's where, you know, we
- 42:16use words for like holistic, and that's the kind of a problematic
- 42:19word too, because they can be used in a very silly way
- 42:21sometimes. But that's where nature really
- 42:24is different and natural foods really are different is in the
- 42:26complexity. And it's very difficult to know.
- 42:28I can't say with certainty that, you know, eating these foods
- 42:32will be a neuroprotective or shield you from cancer.
- 42:34It's hard to know with certainty.
- 42:36But that's what also makes it so interesting, is that it's not
- 42:38the kind of thing that can be easily tested in a scientific
- 42:41paradigm, But that doesn't mean you throw it out either.
- 42:44And I mean, the alternative is continuing in the way we are and
- 42:48we look around. I mean, I see it every day in my
- 42:50restaurant. I see it as I walk around.
- 42:51There is a problem with food. People have a problem with food.
- 42:54We as a society are getting heavier and it's not doing us
- 42:59any justice, honestly. I would also argue that
- 43:02strangely, we're getting heavier as a lot of the time the food is
- 43:04getting worse. I think, you know, another
- 43:07really interesting thing about eating is we talk about how food
- 43:10tastes in the moment. I've written an awful lot about
- 43:12that flavor, how we sense it. But what we really talk about is
- 43:14how you feel afterwards. And there's this idea of the
- 43:17food hangover, like, wow, we really went for it and we felt
- 43:19terrible. And it's like, that's good Food
- 43:21should not make you feel horrible afterwards.
- 43:23That's a sign you've eaten the wrong meal.
- 43:26I remember I was very fortunate I was taking to the restaurant
- 43:29or near San Sebastian called Ex Tabari Echebari.
- 43:32I don't know the pronunciation exactly.
- 43:34And I remember the profound glow I experienced after that meal.
- 43:37It was just such a feeling of can't even describe it.
- 43:40It was just like just so content and happy in this sort of post
- 43:44meal glow. And we often don't think about
- 43:47food as supposed to make you feel good in the moment, but
- 43:49also after the moment after you eat.
- 43:52And that's also a big part of food.
- 43:53I love that. Do you mind if I read one of my
- 43:55favorite sections as we're kind of getting close to the at the
- 43:59end. I think it's right around what
- 44:01we were talked about here and it's so it's from the end of
- 44:05craving. It's the old road runs through
- 44:08your brain. It is a path laid down by the
- 44:10trillions of organisms that preceded you, that lived and
- 44:13died by the brute circumstances of evolution.
- 44:16It possesses a wisdom and computational power.
- 44:19Our conscious selves are only beginning to understand.
- 44:22We are alas too stupid to understand how truly smart we
- 44:26are. And I, I even, I even use that
- 44:29because I I write our pre shift notes and different things for
- 44:32work and I put that in as our quote for the week.
- 44:35We are our last too stupid to understand how smart we are.
- 44:38I was going to end by asking, is the solution truly just to eat
- 44:42really delicious food? Can it be that simple?
- 44:45I will say so with with a caveat.
- 44:48With a big star, it's got to be real food.
- 44:50It's got to come from, I don't want to sound kind of old, you
- 44:53know, but it's got to be natural in the sense that it's got to
- 44:56come from a farm, from plants, from animals.
- 44:58Where we get into problems is when we engineer it.
- 45:01Now we may be one day, we may be good enough to engineer food
- 45:04that's really healthy and good for you, that delivers that that
- 45:08pleasure, where pleasure is in line with with nourishment.
- 45:11But I think following the examples of the cultures that
- 45:14really care about food, Japan, Italy, France, South Korea, and
- 45:18we see pockets of it in our own culture.
- 45:20These people have a joyful relationship with food.
- 45:22It nourishes them. They're happy.
- 45:24That's the model to follow. There's a reason.
- 45:26There's a reason nature has a seat.
- 45:28There's a reason we do these things.
- 45:30We've got to honor it, yeah. Yeah, I think instead of trying
- 45:34to conquer it or manipulate it, is understand why it's there,
- 45:38what it's meant to do, and I think that unlocks something.
- 45:41Are you hopeful for the future? I am actually.
- 45:43I mean, things go in two directions at once.
- 45:46It's not all, you know, ultra processors continue to get
- 45:49better at ultra processing. I have a sub stack and I wrote
- 45:52about, I went to the some trade show where basically it's a
- 45:54trade show of all the world's ultra processors.
- 45:56It's called, I titled it the ingredients, Ingredients, which
- 45:59is say this is what goes into what you see on an ingredient
- 46:01label. And it's so much more complex
- 46:03than even the scientists realize.
- 46:05It's not just things like artificial sweeteners or
- 46:07flavourings. There is an arsenal of additives
- 46:10that are being put into food for lots of reasons, for shelf life,
- 46:13for restaurant economics. But it all and, and I'm not a
- 46:17chemophobe, I'm not saying these chemicals cause cancer.
- 46:19I'm saying when they have a sensory effect, when they have
- 46:21some impact on the way your brain senses a meal, I think
- 46:24that's a problem. I think we should be spending a
- 46:26lot more of our resources investigating what are the
- 46:29effects of that. But that is galloping at
- 46:311,000,000 miles an hour and a scientist studying this, it's
- 46:34like the tortoise and the hare, except the tortoise really is
- 46:36losing the race. They are so plotting and I I'm
- 46:39not faulting them. Science has to be that way, but
- 46:44our your understanding is 1% of our of our ability, if that
- 46:50makes sense. So, but that said, you know,
- 46:52there are people like you, you're representative of a
- 46:55culture that does care about these things, where we care
- 46:58about where ingredients come from.
- 46:59We honor them and we honor the people that create them and
- 47:02present them. And I think that's also, you
- 47:04know, craft beer is a great example of how things have
- 47:06gotten better. The world of beers way rather be
- 47:09a beer drinker in today's world than in the when it was just Bud
- 47:12Light, Coors Light and Michelob Light.
- 47:14Yeah, no, I mean, I think that we got a taste of what
- 47:18globalization and homogenization does to food and beverage.
- 47:23And I think like any trend, you play it out to the end and it
- 47:27becomes its own caricature. You're like, OK, we're all
- 47:30drinking Coors Light and we're all drinking that.
- 47:32And maybe like vodka sodas. So as low flavor as you can
- 47:36imagine, industrial wine, some Moscato grown in the middle of
- 47:39California, hyped up with sulfur uric acid just to make sure
- 47:42it'll stay self shelf stable. And we're eating bland chicken.
- 47:46It's like we went all the way there.
- 47:48And I think a lot of my generation is asking like, it
- 47:51seems like there should be more here.
- 47:52It seems like there should be something more.
- 47:54What is going on here? And I think that that question
- 47:58of like, can we have less but better is starting to pop up.
- 48:01I do think a lot of the like no and low alcohol movement from
- 48:05what I can see and from talking to younger people is not that so
- 48:09many people are going sober. Just why would I pay for kind of
- 48:12substandard things? I'd rather just have one drink
- 48:14than three and make it a really good drink.
- 48:17And so I think there is that movement towards quality and
- 48:20we'll see because again, it's like you're saying 2 paths.
- 48:23We got hopefully a path bringing us back to how things happen and
- 48:27the the makers of chemicals keep getting better.
- 48:30So I do think a shout out one of the best examples, one of the
- 48:33best descriptions I've ever heard about the tricky issue of
- 48:38describing chemicals synthesized for natural products as natural.
- 48:42Your your analogy of like that's saying only going through the
- 48:46Golden Gate Bridge is you're in real San Francisco if you fly
- 48:49and that's fake San Francisco. It's like, yes, you may have
- 48:52synthesized this chemical from a pine cone, but that doesn't make
- 48:55it natural. And also my friend Camper
- 48:57English is big into safety when it comes to cocktails.
- 49:00He runs a website and his thing is natural does not mean edible
- 49:05and like. Nature filled with poisons.
- 49:07I mean, yeah, absolutely. I think people don't realize
- 49:11that I actually sometimes I have an issue with red wine.
- 49:13It keeps me up at night. And red wine is very rich in
- 49:16things like tannins. And I may just be there's so
- 49:18much that I can take before my buddy doesn't love it.
- 49:20For the listener at home who wants to know more about you,
- 49:23where they can find out more about what you do, where should
- 49:25they go to check you out? I have a sub stack my name, Mark
- 49:28Shatzskirt. Just Google it, Schatz said.
- 49:32If you're Canadian like me, Kate Barf, I'm on Instagram and on X,
- 49:37just search my name. I'm not awfully.
- 49:38Maybe I'll I'll get a little bit more active on social media, but
- 49:41that's where they can find me and they can read my books.
- 49:43Perfect. Yeah, perfect.
- 49:44And the books are The books are Steak, The Dorito Effect, and
- 49:48the end of Crate. Yeah, yeah.
- 49:49And produced in that order if I remember correctly.
- 49:52That's correct, yeah. Awesome.
- 49:54And probably best read in that order I would say if you want
- 49:57to, if you want to see how the how the journey went.
- 49:59I know. I actually read the Dorito
- 50:01effect before steak. Yeah.
- 50:03I just, I didn't look at the chronological order when I
- 50:06first. I just the Dorito effect caught
- 50:08my eye at some point. And so I was like, Oh yeah,
- 50:10yeah. So they held up even if you go
- 50:13different. So you know.
- 50:15You definitely don't need to read steak first, but if you do,
- 50:17you'll see how I got the idea. Oh, yeah, it definitely was
- 50:22like, oh, this is where things started.
- 50:24OK, It makes a lot more sense. Yeah.
- 50:27The end of craving, breaking out, wanting from liking.
- 50:31And I know I've heard similar things, but how thoroughly you
- 50:33do it, it's yeah, I definitely recommend every book if you're
- 50:37listening at home and you did not have the ability, like
- 50:40you're in a car to write down where to go.
- 50:42See Mark, I will have that in the show notes.
- 50:45Thank you for coming up. Thanks for having me.
- 50:47Great discussion, really enjoyed it.
- 50:52That's the show, my friends. Thank you for listening to
- 50:55Serves You Right. If you have not checked it out,
- 50:57go to servesyourightpod.com to see what we're up to, see old
- 51:02episodes and so much more. All right, I'll see you next
- 51:07time.