Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Mega Edition: Stacey Plaskett And Her Motion To Dismiss The Epstein Survivor Lawsuit (Part 3-4) (7/3/26)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome back to the Epstein Chronicles.
- 0:03In this episode, we're picking up where we left off
- 0:06with Stacy Plaskett and her amended motion to dismiss the
- 0:10complaint filed against her by the Jeffrey Epstein survivors. Five.
- 0:15Count three should be dismissed because the SAC fails to
- 0:19identify knowledge of an effort to enforce the TVPA against
- 0:22Epstein or any action taken to interfere with enforcement. Obstruction
- 0:27of the TVPA requires a showing of one knowledge of
- 0:30an effort to enforce the TVPA and to an intentional
- 0:35action to obstruct or attempt to obstruct enforcement. Though one
- 0:39versus Deutsche Bank six seventy one f Dot supp. Three
- 0:42D three eighty seven four to OH nine SDNY twenty
- 0:46twenty three, the SAC fails to allege the Congresswoman had
- 0:50knowledge of any investigation or other attempt to enforce the
- 0:54TVPA against Epstein. It also fails to allege any action
- 0:58purportedly taken by the congress Women to obstruct enforcement. Count
- 1:02two should be dismissed. B Count four should be dismissed
- 1:05because plaintiff fail to plead nearly every element of a
- 1:08Rico claim civil Rico's trouble damages an almost inevitable stigmatizing
- 1:13effect on defendants, renders it an unusually potent weapon. Catsmen
- 1:18versus Victoria's Secret Catalog one sixty seven fr D six
- 1:22forty nine six fifty five sdn Y, nineteen ninety six.
- 1:26Courts therefore must scrutinize claims carefully and should strive to
- 1:29flush out frivolous reco allegations at an early stage of
- 1:32the litigation. Plaintiffs have two burdens to state Arico violation. First,
- 1:38they must establish Rico standing by showing they suffered an
- 1:41injury by business or property as the direct and approximate
- 1:45cause of a Rico violation. Moss versus Morgan Stanley Incorporated.
- 1:49Seven nineteen f Dot two d five seventeen, Second Circuit,
- 1:53nineteen eighty three. Base versus Galina three forty six f
- 1:58dot three D three sixty six x three seventy two,
- 2:01Second Circuit, two thousand and three. This is more of
- 2:04a rigorous matter than standing under Article three. Denny versus
- 2:08Deutsche Bank four forty three f Dot three D two
- 2:11fifty three two sixty six, Second Circuit, two thousand and
- 2:14six second, plaintiffs must allege a substantive violation of the
- 2:18Rico Statute Moss seven nineteen f Dot two d At seventeen.
- 2:22The sac fells both burdens. One plaintiff's RICO claims are
- 2:26barred by the statute of limitations Sybil. Rico has a
- 2:30four year statute of limitations running from the date the
- 2:33plaintiff new or should have known of the injury, not
- 2:36from discovery of the pattern of racketeering activity Rotella versus
- 2:40Wood five twenty eight US five forty nine five point
- 2:42fifty two two thousand. Each plaintiff alleges personal injuries of
- 2:47which they were presumably aware at the time the injuries occurred.
- 2:51No injuries could have accrued after Epstein's arrest After July sixth,
- 2:54twenty nineteen, which event put an end to Epstein's sex trafficking.
- 2:59The latest plaintiffs or a class could conceivably file a
- 3:03claim on du Rico would be July sixth, twenty twenty three.
- 3:06Plaintiffs file the first complaint on November twenty second, twenty
- 3:10twenty three. All plaintiffs Rico claims fall outside the statute
- 3:14of limitations. Two plaintiffs fail to establish RICO standing because
- 3:19they have failed to allege injury to business or a property.
- 3:23Plaintiffs cannot establish RICO standing because they allege only personal injuries,
- 3:28not injuries to business or property. US Code eighteen, Section
- 3:32nineteen sixty four c providing a civil right of action
- 3:35for those injured in their business or property by a
- 3:38RICO violation. R JR. Nibisco Incorporated. Versus Eureka County, five
- 3:44seventy nine, US three twenty five three fifty twoenty sixteen,
- 3:49noting that the RICO private right of action excludes personal
- 3:52injury claims. Busconen versus. Alaska, eight seventy four ft three
- 3:57d eight oh six eight seventeen, Second Circuit, twenty seventeen,
- 4:01noting that a plaintiff cannot recover for personal injuries under RICO.
- 4:06Goony versus. Sutton Park Cap Llc. Number twenty two eighteen
- 4:10thirty twenty twenty three, WLA twenty three five zero one
- 4:14nine add one, Second Circuit, November twenty eighth, twenty twenty three,
- 4:19observing RICO does not allow recovery for personal injuries such
- 4:22as bodily harm or emotional distress. Three plaintiffs cannot establish
- 4:27the violation of substantiative reco offense. To state a violation
- 4:31of US Code eighteen, Section nineteen sixty two, plaintiffs must
- 4:35allege one that the defendant two, through the commission of
- 4:38two or more acts, three constituting a pattern four of
- 4:42racketeering activity, five, directly or indirectly, invests in, or maintains
- 4:46an interest in, or participates in, six an enterprise seven
- 4:51the activities of which affect interstate or foreign commerce Moss seven,
- 4:55nineteen f Dot two d at seventeen. Plaintiffs fail to
- 4:59a li edge nearly every one of these elements. A
- 5:03Plaintiffs fail to allege the existence of a rico enterprise.
- 5:06The existence of an enterprise in the cini equa non
- 5:10of a civil reco claim Heinrich versus Dan six fifty
- 5:13five f Dot su Pp. Three d one eighty four
- 5:16one nine dy sdn Y twenty twenty three. There can
- 5:20be no reco claim without a rico enterprise. Thus, many
- 5:23courts evaluate the existence of an enterprise before considering the
- 5:26other factors. Biz now LLC versus Lopez per Number twenty
- 5:31Civ three four four one pa E s LC twenty
- 5:36twenty two, w L one seventy five, four oh five
- 5:39five seventy three at nine, SDN Y November two, twenty
- 5:43twenty two. Report and recommendation adopted Number twenty CIV three
- 5:48four four one PAE SLC twenty twenty two, w L
- 5:52one seventy five zero four three nine SDN Y, December fifth,
- 5:56twenty twenty two. Collecting cases, plaintiffs sport to plead in
- 6:00association in fact enterprise and enterprise as a group of
- 6:04persons associated together for a common purpose of engaging in
- 6:08a course of conduct United States versus Turket four fifty two,
- 6:12five seventy six, five eighty three, nineteen eighty one. Arico.
- 6:16Association in fact is proved by evidence of an ongoing
- 6:19organization formal or informal, and by evidence that the various
- 6:24associates function as a continuing unit, such as an enterprise,
- 6:28and it must have at least three structural features, purpose
- 6:31relationships among those associated with the enterprise, and longevity sufficient
- 6:36to permit these associates to pursue the enterprise's purpose. Boil
- 6:40versus United States five fifty six US nine thirty eight
- 6:43nine forty six, two thousand and nine. A plaintiff must
- 6:47also plead an enterprise distinct from its members and the
- 6:50alleged predicate acts. First Capital Asset Management Incorporated. Verus Satinwood,
- 6:55three eighty five ft three d one fifty nine, one
- 6:58seventy three, Second Curit two thousand four. First plaintiffs fail
- 7:03to plead a common purpose to engage in a particular
- 7:05fraudulent course of conduct and work together to achieve such purposes. Satinwood,
- 7:10three eighty five f. Dot three, d at one seventy four,
- 7:14quoting First Nationwide Bank, First Gelt Funding Corporation A. Twenty
- 7:18f Dot supp. Eighty nine, ninety eight sdn Y, nineteen
- 7:22ninety three. The sac offers no plausible basis to infer
- 7:26that the purported members of the alleged enterprise acted on
- 7:30behalf of the enterprise, as opposed to on behalf of
- 7:33themselves in their individual capacities to advance their individual self interests.
- 7:38Penguin Bros. Versus City National Bank, five eighty seven, Appendix
- 7:42six sixty three, six sixty eight, Second Circuit twenty fourteen,
- 7:47quoting United Food and Community Workers Union and Employer's Midwest
- 7:51Health Benefits Fund Versus Walgreen Company seven nineteen f Dot
- 7:56three d eight forty nine eight fifty four seven Circuit
- 7:59twenty thirteen. This is fatal to plaintiff's RICO claim. Moss
- 8:03Verus BMO Harrisbank, North America, two fifty eight f Dot supp.
- 8:07Three D two eighty nine, two ninety nine Eastern District,
- 8:11twenty seventeen. Failing to allege that members of an association
- 8:15in fact enterprise shared a wrongful intent to violate RICO
- 8:19is fatal to US Code eighteen, Section nineteen sixty two.
- 8:23See also Penguin Rose five eighty seven, Appendix sixty sixty seven.
- 8:27Finding the complaint lacked any factual detail sufficient to allege
- 8:31a plausible common purpose among the RICO defendants. Black vers
- 8:35Ganieva six nineteen f Dot supp. Three d three oh
- 8:40nine three thirty one sdn Y twenty twenty two. Holding
- 8:43a RICO enterprise requires a common intent to violate RICO
- 8:47or to act unlawfully. Second the SAC fails to allege
- 8:51any ascertainable structure, it should be dismissed. Because the SAC
- 8:55contains no factual allegations allowing an inference of the existence
- 8:59of an ongoing organization formal or informal, or any evidence
- 9:04that the various associates of the alleged enterprise functioned as
- 9:08a continuing unit Satinwood three eighty five ft three d
- 9:12at one seventy four. The SAC lacks any facts at
- 9:16all concerning the relationship between the members, how they came
- 9:19to an agreement, how they knew each other, whether they
- 9:22acted to benefit each other, or any other consideration. Black
- 9:26six nineteen f supp three d. At three thirty four
- 9:29and three thirty five, listing factors considered by courts when
- 9:33evaluating an enterprise's structure. At best, the SAC alleges mostly
- 9:39in conclusiony fashion that various defendants had agreements with Epstein,
- 9:43and contains no allegations about the interpersonal relationships among the defendants.
- 9:48CID relationships among those associated with the enterprise are essential
- 9:53structural features of the Rico association. In fact, quoting Boyle,
- 9:57five point fifty six US at nine forty SI, it's
- 10:01well settled law that the rimless hub and spoke structure
- 10:04alleged by the SAC cannot be classified as a Rico enterprise.
- 10:09Diodoro nine oh one f Dot three d at one
- 10:12O one second Circuit twenty eighteen. All Right, we're gonna
- 10:14wrap this episode up right here, and in the next episode,
- 10:17we're gonna pick up where we left off and finish
- 10:20this bad boy up. All of the information that goes
- 10:23with this episode can be found in the description box.
- 10:26What's up, everyone, and welcome back to the Epstein Chronicles.
- 10:31In this episode, we're picking up where we left off
- 10:33with Stacey Plaski and her amended motion to dismiss the
- 10:36claims made against her. Third plaintiffs fail to plead and
- 10:40enterprise distinct from Epstein or the purported racketeering conduct to
- 10:45the extent the SAC pleads anything concrete. It pleads actions
- 10:48taken by Epstein or on Epstein's behalf to ford Epstein's goals.
- 10:53As pleaded, the alleged enterprise in Epstein are one and
- 10:56the same and cannot be Arico Enterprise Cedric Kushner Produc
- 11:00Uctions Limited versus King five thirty three US one fifty
- 11:03eight one sixty one, two thousand and one. One must
- 11:07allege and prove the existence of two distinct entities, one
- 11:11a person and two an enterprise that is not simply
- 11:14the same person referred to by a different name. Further,
- 11:18as alleged, the SAC does not plead a coherent entity
- 11:21separate and apart from the alleged fraudulent scheme itself. Is
- 11:25a fatal flaw b the sac fails to allege any
- 11:29predicated acts. A rico plaintiff must plead that the defendant
- 11:33committed at least two related predicated acts occurring within ten
- 11:36years of each other. Coca Credit Say versus Wins or
- 11:40a plumbing supply company one eighty seven f Dot three
- 11:43D two twenty nine two forty two, Second Circuit, nineteen
- 11:46ninety nine. Predicate acts must be pleaded in accordance with
- 11:50federal pleading standards see mackin versus Allburger, fifty nine F.
- 11:54Supp three d five twenty eight five fifty three w
- 11:59d NY twenty fourteen. Failure predicate act of bribery because
- 12:03the allegations fell woefully short of the pleading and lack
- 12:07the factual support to constitute a sufficiently alleged predicated act.
- 12:11Plaintiffs allege bribery generally, but does not identify any particular
- 12:16bribery statute alleged to have been violated. This is fatal
- 12:20in and of itself. Plaintiffs also do not allege any
- 12:23specific act of bribery occurring in any given time, certainly
- 12:27not too in a ten year period. The SAC does
- 12:30not identify any meeting, any plausible action, or a non
- 12:34action taken by Plasket, much less in return for anything
- 12:37of value. It's impossible to tell from the face of
- 12:40the SAC what wrongdoing the Congresswoman is alleged to have done.
- 12:45The SAC should be dismissed because plaintiffs fail to plead
- 12:48any predicated acts see plaintiffs fail to allege a pattern
- 12:52of racketeering activity. Predicate acts must be related and demonstrate
- 12:57a pattern of racketeering activity requires a showing of either
- 13:01open ended or close ended continuity. Open ended continuity does
- 13:06not apply because it requires a showing of a continued
- 13:09thread of criminal activity copha credit say one eighty seven
- 13:14f Dot three d at two forty two Epstein's dead
- 13:17and there can be no plausible claim of a continuation
- 13:20of his enterprise. To establish close ended continuity, the plaintiff
- 13:24must prove a series of related predicates extending over a
- 13:28substantial period of time. The falco versus Burness two forty
- 13:32four f Dot three D two eighty six three twenty
- 13:35one Second Circuit two thousand and one, quoting HJ. Incorporated
- 13:39versus Northwestern Bell Telephone Company four ninety two US two
- 13:43twenty nine, two thirty nine, nineteen eighty nine. The mere
- 13:46fact that predicate acts span two years is insufficient without
- 13:50more to support a finding of a close ended pattern
- 13:53Satinwood three eighty five F dot three d at one
- 13:56eighty one. Plaintiffs must provide some basis for a core
- 14:00or to conclude that defendant's activities were neither isolated or sporadic.
- 14:04The Falco two forty four F dot three d at
- 14:07three twenty one, quoting GICC Capital Corp. Verse Technology Finance
- 14:12Group Incorporated. Six seventy seven F Dot three d four
- 14:15sixty six four to sixty seven, Second Circuit, nineteen ninety five.
- 14:19The relevant period, moreover, is the time during which RICO
- 14:23predicit activity occurred, not the time during which the underlying
- 14:26scheme operated or the underlying dispute took place. Spool versus
- 14:30World Child International Adoption Agency, five twenty f dot three
- 14:34d one seventy eight one eighty four, Second Circuit, two
- 14:38thousand and eight. Plaintiffs have not alleged any specific RICO
- 14:42predicit act by Congresswoman Plasket and cannot show a pattern
- 14:46of predicate acts. Plaintiffs cannot establish a pattern of racketeering
- 14:50activity sufficient to sustain a reco claim d Plaintiffs fail
- 14:54to allege that Congresswoman invested in, maintained an interest in,
- 14:58or participated in a Rico enterprise. Plaintiffs fail to allege
- 15:02that Congresswoman Plasket participated in any Rico enterprise. To participate
- 15:07in a Rico enterprise, a defendant must participate in the
- 15:10operation or a management of the enterprise itself Reeves versus
- 15:15Ernst vers Young five oh seven US one seventy one
- 15:18eighty five, nineteen ninety three. That means a defendant must
- 15:22exercise some discretion or have some role in directing the
- 15:25affairs of the enterprise West seventy ninth Street Corporation for
- 15:29his congregation call mensches Chinook number zero three SIV eight
- 15:34six zero RWs two thousand and four, WL two P
- 15:39one eight seven zero six nine AT thirteen and fourteen SDNY,
- 15:43September twenty ninth, two thousand and four, and collecting cases.
- 15:46Providing goods and services to an enterprise, or undertaking necessary
- 15:51and helpful tasks does not satisfy the operation or a
- 15:55management test. United States Fire Insurance Company versus United Limousine
- 16:00Incorporated three zero three F. Supp. Two d. Four thirty two,
- 16:04four fifty one and fifty two SDNY two thousand and four.
- 16:08The sac contains no allegations permitting an inference that Congresswoman
- 16:12Plasket exercised any control, discretionary authority, or management of the enterprise.
- 16:18There are also no allegations that Congresswoman Plasket made any
- 16:21investment in, or maintained an interest in any organization with Epstein,
- 16:25elicit or otherwise see Plaintiffs fail to allege a RICO conspiracy.
- 16:30First plaintiff claim for RICO conspiracy fels because plaintiff fails
- 16:34to plead a substantative reco violation Zamora versus Fit International
- 16:38Group Corporation A. Thirty four f Appendix six twenty two
- 16:43six twenty six. Second Circuit, twenty twenty. Plaintiff failure to
- 16:46a claim for a substantative reco violation is fatal to
- 16:50their Rico conspiracy claim. Plaintiff must also plead that the
- 16:53congresswoman knew about and agreed to facilitate at pattern of
- 16:58racketeering activity Blacks nineteen f. Supp Three d at three
- 17:02thirty at the very least, this requires a showing that
- 17:06there was an agreement to commit predicate acts. Because the
- 17:08core of a Rico civil conspiracy is an agreement to
- 17:11commit predicated acts hect versus Calm Clearing House, Incorporated. Eight
- 17:16ninety seven f Dot two d twenty one, twenty five,
- 17:19Second Circuit, nineteen ninety. Plaintiffs must thus establish that the
- 17:23defendant agreed to participate in the affairs of the enterprise
- 17:27through a pattern of racketeering activity, which, if completed, would
- 17:31satisfy the elements of the substantative Rico Statute Blacks six
- 17:35nineteen f Dot supp. Three d at three, twenty nine
- 17:39and thirty. This requires a showing of one an agreement
- 17:42to join the conspiracy, two the acts of each co
- 17:45conspirator in furtherance of the conspiracy, and three that the
- 17:49co conspirator knowingly participated in the same Idea three forty eight,
- 17:54quoting Valenti versus pen Mutual Life Insurance eight fifty supp.
- 17:59Two d four to forty one, five four fifty through
- 18:01fifty one SDNY twenty twelve. No allegations in the sac
- 18:06support such an inference. Further, because the Rico conspiracy claim
- 18:10is entirely derivative of the allegations of a substantative reco violation.
- 18:16The claim should be dismissed. Four count five should be
- 18:19dismissed because the sac fails to state the existence of
- 18:23illegal duty. Negligence requires a showing of one illegal duty
- 18:28of care to the plaintiff, to a breach of that
- 18:30duty of care by the defendant, three constituting the factual
- 18:34and legal cause of four damages to the plaintiff. Robbins
- 18:39Versus Port of Sale Incorporated Number St twelve CV ninety
- 18:43twenty eighteen w L five zero two four nine two
- 18:47zero at four, Virgin Island Superior Court, October tenth, twenty eighteen,
- 18:52citing Machado Versus Yacht Haven USVII LLC sixty one VII
- 18:57three seventy three three eighty VI two thousand. See also
- 19:01David Weinstein Company, LLC F Dot supp three D two
- 19:05ninety three oh five SDNY twenty nineteen, citing the elements
- 19:10of a negligence claim in New York as one a
- 19:13duty owed by the defendant to the plaintiff, two a
- 19:16breach thereof, and three injury approximately resulting therefrom plaintiffs also
- 19:22failed to allege any injury within the two year statute
- 19:25of limitations for negligence. Plaintiffs alleged no legal duty by
- 19:29the Congresswoman to the plaintiffs. She had no authority over
- 19:32the United States Coast Guard or the United States Customs officials,
- 19:36both under the auspices of the Department of Homeland Security.
- 19:40She never had any authority over air traffic controllers, who
- 19:44were under the control of the Federal Aviation Administration. She
- 19:48never had any authority over the privately employed baggage handlers,
- 19:51and she certainly was never in a position to have
- 19:54supervisory authority over the police. Of course, plaintiffs have not
- 19:58offered any concrete alleygations of anything done by the Congresswoman,
- 20:02even approximating a breach. Count five should be dismissed. Conclusion
- 20:08Plaintiffs conclusiony SAC contains no concrete, factual allegation that supports
- 20:13any of their claims. Even with conclusiony allegations, most of
- 20:16the claims fail as a matter of law under incontrovertible precedent.
- 20:21The SAC lacks any legal merit, is wholly frivolous, and
- 20:25should be dismissed in its entirety. This was dated June
- 20:28twenty seventh, two thousand and four, and it was signed
- 20:32by Eric Breslin. All Right, that's gonna do it for
- 20:35the Stacey Plaskett amended motion to dismiss. All of the
- 20:39information that goes with this episode can be found in
- 20:42the description box.