Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Child Development & the Law: Can Kids Really Be Reliable Witnesses in Court?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the psychology undergrad. So I want
- 0:02you to pull up a chair, because today we are
- 0:04getting into something pretty wild. Imagine you
- 0:07have a three -year -old child, right? And she
- 0:10makes just this random passing comment to her
- 0:12mother about being poked with a pink rope at
- 0:15daycare. Right. It sounds like, you know, just
- 0:17weird toddler talk. Exactly. But that single
- 0:21strange phrase triggers an absolute avalanche.
- 0:25Like within months that one comment spirals into
- 0:29a multi -million dollar malicious prosecution
- 0:31disaster. Yeah, it is honestly terrifying. It
- 0:34really is. You end up with kids claiming they
- 0:36were stripped naked, locked in cages, suspended
- 0:39from ceilings, forced to watch animal sacrifices,
- 0:41and abused in a literal devil church. And lives
- 0:44were just utterly ruined by this. Totally ruined.
- 0:46We are talking about the infamous Martinsville
- 0:48daycare scandal in Saskatchewan back in 1991.
- 0:51And today we are doing a deep dive into our source
- 0:54material to pull apart the central paradox of
- 0:56forensic psychology. Which is basically, how
- 0:59on earth does a child's mind go from a single
- 1:01confusing interaction to like a fully hallucinatory
- 1:04devil church. Right. And as undergrads prepping
- 1:07for this conceptual exam, we really need to figure
- 1:10out what breaks a child's mind so thoroughly,
- 1:13right? Because it forces us to look at this core
- 1:16paradox in the material. Yeah, this deep contradictory
- 1:19split in how a child's brain operates in a legal
- 1:22setting. Because on one side, children can be
- 1:25these remarkably accurate human tape recorders.
- 1:28capturing unbelievable levels of detail. But
- 1:31then on the other side, they are highly vulnerable
- 1:34victims, capable of having massive complex fictions
- 1:39just seamlessly planted into their minds by adults.
- 1:42Exactly. So our mission for this deep dive is
- 1:44to unpack all of this. We're going to look at
- 1:46the historical baggage, the actual science of
- 1:48how memory works, and how the justice system
- 1:51tries to find the truth. And to help you, and
- 1:53frankly to help us remember all this dense text,
- 1:55we are going to use some memory aids and mental
- 1:57models throughout the discussion. Perfect, because
- 1:59before we even get to the science, we have to
- 2:01talk about the history, which is, well, it's
- 2:03dark. Super dark. Like, prior to the 1980s, the
- 2:07legal system's baseline assumption wasn't just
- 2:09that kids had bad memories. It was deeply moralistic.
- 2:12They basically viewed children and women as inherently
- 2:16sinful or naturally deceptive. Yeah, it was heavily
- 2:19rooted in this puritanical way of thinking, like
- 2:21with the recent complaint doctrine. Oh, right.
- 2:23That was an actual law in Canada until, what,
- 2:261983? Yeah, 1983. Yeah. It mandated that victims
- 2:29of sexual offenses had to report the crime at
- 2:32the very first available. opportunity which is
- 2:34crazy because we know most abused kids delay
- 2:36reporting out of pure fear right but if they
- 2:40delayed the judge or jury was legally required
- 2:42to assume the child was lying or had consented.
- 2:45It was literally an institutionalized assumption
- 2:47of deceit. And that completely aligns with John
- 2:49Wigmore. He was this incredibly influential legal
- 2:52scholar in the 1940s. The source text talks about
- 2:55how his writings shaped courtroom procedures
- 2:57for decades. Oh, Wigmore. Yeah, he argued that
- 3:00errant young girls had these, I think the quote
- 3:02is, abnormal instincts and complexes that made
- 3:05them contrive false charges against innocent
- 3:07men. Yeah, abnormal instincts. So it wasn't about
- 3:10cognitive development at all. It was framed entirely
- 3:12as a moral panic. Exactly. The system operated
- 3:16on this theological premise that children were
- 3:19corrupt until proven pure, which meant an unsworn
- 3:23child like a kid under 14 who couldn't formally
- 3:26swear a religious oath on a Bible needed hard
- 3:29corroborating physical evidence just to be heard.
- 3:32Right. So if the kid gave a totally coherent
- 3:35terrifyingly accurate account of abuse, but there
- 3:37was no secondary evidence, the law demanded an
- 3:40acquittal. They just refused to believe the child's
- 3:42route word. But then you look at case 6 .1 in
- 3:45our source material, and it completely shatters
- 3:47that Wigmore assumption. Oh, the incredible witnesses
- 3:50section, yes. This part was mind -blowing. There's
- 3:52this 13 -year -old girl who is being abused by
- 3:54her grandfather, right? And she knew no one would
- 3:57believe her. because of the whole system we just
- 3:59talked about. Exactly. So she secretly pushes
- 4:01record on a tape, Greg, before he comes into
- 4:03the bathroom. And later in a police interview,
- 4:07she gives 189 distinct details. And because they
- 4:11had that secret tape, investigators could literally
- 4:14map her memory. directly against reality. Right.
- 4:18And 98 % of the central critical details were
- 4:22entirely corroborated by the audio tape. She
- 4:25was practically a human wiretap. And we see that
- 4:28raw retention even in much younger kids. Like
- 4:30case 6 .1 also mentioned Susie, a three -year
- 4:33-old. Oh, Susie's case is wild. She was abducted
- 4:36and left in an outhouse toilet, right? Yeah,
- 4:38just horrific. But five days later, she gives
- 4:41a highly accurate physical description of the
- 4:43attacker. And the really fascinating part is
- 4:46how she handled the police lineups. Because they
- 4:48tried to pressure her, didn't they? Big time.
- 4:51Investigators deliberately showed her a false
- 4:53photo lineup, and they explicitly told her the
- 4:56bad man was in it. So you have this towering
- 4:58authority figure pressuring a three year old.
- 5:00And usually a toddler's instinct is just to please
- 5:03the adult and point at someone. Exactly. But
- 5:05she rejected every single photo. She didn't cave.
- 5:08It was only when they introduced the actual attacker's
- 5:11photo in a later lineup that she immediately
- 5:13picked him. Her visual memory completely overrode
- 5:16the adult pressure. Wow. OK. So we have undeniable
- 5:19proof that an uncorrupted child can be a phenomenal
- 5:22witness, which brings us right back to the nightmare
- 5:25of Martinsville. the dark side of the paradox.
- 5:28Right. If Suzy can reject a false lineup from
- 5:30a scary police officer, how do the Martinsville
- 5:34kids end up hallucinating a satanic cult? Like
- 5:37what actually breaks down in their minds? So
- 5:39the text breaks this down into the science of
- 5:42suggestibility, and it relies on three specific
- 5:45pillars. preconceived stereotypes, repeated leading
- 5:49questions, and peer influence. Okay, so the adults
- 5:52in Martinsville were basically building a narrative
- 5:55framework and forcing the kids into it. Precisely.
- 5:58And we can see exactly how this works under controlled
- 6:00conditions with the Sam Stone study. Oh, the
- 6:02Sam Stone study. Okay, this is a perfect mental
- 6:05model for how to manufacture a lie. So researchers
- 6:07bring this totally boring, unremarkable guy named
- 6:10Sam Stone into a daycare. He literally just walks
- 6:12around, looks at a book, and leaves. Nothing
- 6:14happens. Nothing at all. But the researchers
- 6:16spent an entire month before he got there just
- 6:19planting a stereotype. They'd tell the kids,
- 6:21Sam is a nice guy, but he is incredibly clumsy.
- 6:25He's always breaking things. Right. They're priming
- 6:28the semantic network, building a neurological
- 6:31expectation in these kids' brains. So then after
- 6:34his totally boring visit, They use the second
- 6:37pillar, suggestive questioning. They don't ask,
- 6:40what did Sam do? They ask, Remember when Sam
- 6:43ripped that book? Remember when he spilled something
- 6:46on the teddy bear? Right. Introducing false data
- 6:49points that perfectly match the clumsy stereotype
- 6:51they already planted. And 10 weeks later, a substantial
- 6:54minority of those kids confidently claim they
- 6:56saw Sam ruin those things. And when a new interviewer
- 6:59pushes back and says, are you sure you saw that?
- 7:02The younger kids actually stubbornly defend the
- 7:05false memory. Because in their minds, it isn't
- 7:06a lie. The adults basically installed a software
- 7:09update and the kid's brain just accepted it as
- 7:12a programming. It's so scary. But the third pillar,
- 7:15peer pressure, makes it even worse. Look at the
- 7:18archaeological dig study. Oh, this one is crazy.
- 7:21It proves you don't even need to interrogate
- 7:23a child directly to plant a false memory. Yeah,
- 7:26the social consensus mechanism. Researchers set
- 7:29up a fake archaeological dig. One group of kids
- 7:32sees a researcher accidentally ruin a prop. Another
- 7:35group sees absolutely nothing. But then the researchers
- 7:38inject all this drama, making sure all the kids
- 7:40talk and gossip with each other about the disaster
- 7:43afterward. And the kids who didn't see anything
- 7:45happen, but were subjected to leading questions
- 7:47and the gossip of their peers. They were just
- 7:50as likely to confidently report the misdeeds
- 7:52as the kids who actually watched it happen. Their
- 7:55reality was entirely overwritten by the classroom
- 7:58gossip. Groupthink literally overriding sensory
- 8:01perception, which, um... actually leads to a
- 8:04super counter -intuitive aspect of the source
- 8:06material. Oh, wait. I know what you're going
- 8:08to say, and I definitely want to pull on this
- 8:09thread, because this completely inverted how
- 8:12I think about the brain. Right. Because logically,
- 8:15you'd assume a four -year -old is wildly suggestible,
- 8:17and a 24 -year -old is practically immune, right?
- 8:22Because... Adults have a fully developed prefrontal
- 8:25cortex. Exactly, but the data shows that when
- 8:27you're dealing with thematically related items,
- 8:30older children and adults are actually way more
- 8:32suggestible than toddlers. It's such a great
- 8:34twist, like the semantic word studies. Researchers
- 8:37read a list, bed, rest, awake, snooze, nap. And
- 8:43then later they ask people to recall the list,
- 8:45and adults and older kids overwhelmingly falsely
- 8:48remember the word sleep being on that list. But
- 8:51toddlers rarely make that mistake. Because of
- 8:54how older brains group concepts. Which brings
- 8:57us to our first memory aid for you guys listening.
- 9:00The autocorrect brain. Yes, the autocorrect brain.
- 9:02Think of your adult brain like your smartphone's
- 9:04autocorrect. Your phone sees the letters, figures
- 9:07out the pattern, and just fills in the rest of
- 9:08the word to save time. And our brains do the
- 9:10exact same thing with concepts. We have these
- 9:12massive thematic webs. So we hear bed, rest,
- 9:16snooze. And our autocorrect categorizes it as
- 9:19sleep. So when it searches the memory banks later,
- 9:21it says, well, sleep fits the pattern perfectly,
- 9:23so it definitely must have been there. But a
- 9:26young child's brain hasn't developed those dense
- 9:28webs yet. They process things in a much more
- 9:31literal, disjointed way. They don't hallucinate
- 9:33the missing link because they aren't grouping
- 9:35things together efficiently. It's crazy. The
- 9:38exact thing that makes our adult brains faster
- 9:40and smarter is what makes us so vulnerable to
- 9:43categorical false memories. So true. But then
- 9:47the question is, if our autocorrect brains love
- 9:50patterns and young kids are vulnerable to social
- 9:53pressure, how does a forensic interviewer actually
- 9:56talk to kids without planting evidence? Right,
- 9:59because you can't just not investigate abuse.
- 10:00You have to ask questions. Well, it demands a
- 10:03rigorously disciplined, almost unnatural way
- 10:06of talking. It starts with non -contentioned
- 10:09social support. Which means, like, no saying
- 10:11good job when the kid gives you a specific answer,
- 10:13right? Exactly. Most adults naturally use contingent
- 10:17support. But forensic interviewers have to strip
- 10:19that away. The support has to just be the environment,
- 10:22warm vocal tone, relaxed posture, regardless
- 10:25of what the child is saying. And they establish
- 10:27the rules through a practice interview first
- 10:30about something totally boring, like a recent
- 10:33birthday party. This is where they drill the
- 10:35difference between open and closed prompts. Right,
- 10:38because a closed prompt like, was the car red
- 10:41or blue, forces the child's autocorrect to pick
- 10:45a category, even if the car was actually green.
- 10:48But an open prompt like, tell me more about the
- 10:50car, removes that framework entirely. Right.
- 10:53And kids trained with open prompts provide two
- 10:55and a half times more accurate input later. And
- 10:58during that practice, you also have to teach
- 11:00them the most critical ground rule. giving them
- 11:03explicit permission to say, I don't know, or
- 11:06I don't remember. Okay, but the text pushes back
- 11:08on this, and so do I. Because if you take a highly
- 11:11stressed kid sitting in a weird room and they
- 11:13just want to go home, won't they just use, I
- 11:16don't know, as a cheat code? Yeah, they will.
- 11:18The data backs up your fear, exactly. Just giving
- 11:20them that instruction actively increases omission
- 11:23errors. They start leaving out true facts just
- 11:25to get out of the room faster. So how do they
- 11:26fix it? You have to actively calibrate the response.
- 11:30So in practice, the interviewer asks an impossible
- 11:33question, like, what is my dog's name? And the
- 11:37kid has to say, I don't know. Right. And the
- 11:39interviewer validates that, but then immediately
- 11:41asks, well, what is your dog's name? And the
- 11:44kid gives a real answer. Oh, I see. You're behaviorally
- 11:47training their brain to recognize the threshold
- 11:49between actual ignorance and just being reluctant.
- 11:52Exactly. And the whole time, the interviewer
- 11:55has to remain completely neutral. Which is so
- 11:58hard. Look at the magic show rabbit study. Oh,
- 12:00the magic show rabbit! This shows how easily
- 12:03good intentions cause autocorrect failures. So
- 12:07researchers had moms talk to their kids about
- 12:08a magic show they saw, but they subtly tricked
- 12:11the moms into thinking a rabbit might have escaped
- 12:13its cage. Even though the rabbit definitely never
- 12:15escaped. Right, and the moms genuinely thought
- 12:17they were helping their kids remember a fun detail.
- 12:20But... Just their subtle body language, a slight
- 12:23lean forward, a raised eyebrow made the kids
- 12:26vastly more likely to invent a vivid false memory
- 12:29of the rabbit escaping. Just microscopic social
- 12:32cues. And the child's brain automatically constructs
- 12:35a memory to get the mom's approval. It's wild.
- 12:38Okay, so let's say the interviewer does everything
- 12:40perfectly. Clean interview, open prompts, calibrated,
- 12:43I don't know. Now you face the ultimate hurdle.
- 12:46You have to take this kid to a courtroom. Right,
- 12:49and first... The court has to decide if the child
- 12:51is even legally competent to speak. Right. Which
- 12:54brings us back to the legal system's weird obsession
- 12:56with morality. Oh, man. The truth lie discussion.
- 13:00Up until 2006 in Canada, kids under 14 had to
- 13:04pass this deep philosophical morality exam with
- 13:07the judge before testifying. Just imagine a judge
- 13:10sending a six year old down. to discuss the abstract
- 13:13concepts of truth and the theological implications
- 13:15of a promise. Expecting a first grader to pass
- 13:17a philosophy exam just to report a crime, it's
- 13:20absurd. And behavioral scientists proved it was
- 13:22useless with the temptation and transgression
- 13:24paradigms. These study designs are so brilliant.
- 13:26So in the temptation paradigm, a researcher leaves
- 13:29a kid in a room with a cool toy and says, don't
- 13:31peek while I'm gone. And of course, the kid peeks.
- 13:34Obviously. And the transgression paradigm is
- 13:37about protecting someone else. A parent... accidentally
- 13:40breaks a puppet, turns to their kid and says,
- 13:43please don't tell them, I'll get in huge trouble.
- 13:46Right, high stakes. The kid is highly motivated
- 13:48to lie for self -preservation or loyalty. And
- 13:51the researchers found that giving these kids
- 13:52a long, complex, philosophical lecture about
- 13:55why lying is morally wrong did absolutely nothing
- 13:58to reduce lying. Right, because the cognitive
- 14:00load of abstract morality just vanishes when
- 14:03a kid is stressed. So what actually worked, it
- 14:06wasn't theology, it was just a simple secular
- 14:08promise. Having the child explicitly say, I promise
- 14:11to tell the truth, right before questioning.
- 14:13Because a promise is a concrete behavioral contract.
- 14:17It's an immediate rule, not a vague concept.
- 14:20So that simple promise establishes competence.
- 14:23But competence just gets you into the witness
- 14:24chair. Right, then you need credibility. Does
- 14:26the jury actually believe you? And in Europe,
- 14:29they use CBCA criterion -based content analysis,
- 14:32where experts analyze the transcript against
- 14:3419 criteria. Like spontaneous corrections. That
- 14:37was a big one. When people rehearse a lie, it's
- 14:40a perfect script. But if a kid says, he had a
- 14:42blue hat, wait, no, it was green, I remember
- 14:45the logo, that shows real -time data retrieval.
- 14:47Exactly. But the Supreme Court of Canada bans
- 14:50experts from testifying using CBCA. They say
- 14:54deciding the truth is exclusively the jury's
- 14:57job. So instead, courts are leaning on reality
- 15:00monitoring. Yes, which gives us our second memory
- 15:03aid, the senses versus thoughts test. Reality
- 15:06monitoring says real memories and fake memories
- 15:08are built from completely different materials.
- 15:11Right. When you invent a memory, your brain has
- 15:13to build the architecture from scratch. So an
- 15:15imagined memory is heavy on cognitive operations,
- 15:18internal logic, and reasoning. It sounds like
- 15:20an essay. You're explaining why things happened,
- 15:23but a true memory doesn't need logic, it just
- 15:26happened. So it's dense with chaotic, messy sensory
- 15:29data. The weird smell of a carpet. A random sound
- 15:32in the background that has nothing to do with
- 15:33the event. Exactly. Real memories are messy sensory
- 15:37data. Fake memories are clean cognitive logic.
- 15:40But here is where the entire legal system clashes
- 15:43with psychology. even if you have a perfect sensory
- 15:47-rich memory. Forcing a child to deliver it while
- 15:50staring at their abuser can break them. Oh, the
- 15:53trauma of the stand. The anticipatory stress
- 15:56alone is linked to long -term mental health pathologies
- 15:59in adulthood. So Canada adapted. Under Section
- 16:02486 of the Criminal Code, courts allow testimonial
- 16:05supports, closed -circuit TV, or testifying from
- 16:09behind screens, or having a support person nearby.
- 16:11And the Supreme Court said this doesn't violate
- 16:13a fair trial. You have a right to cross -examine,
- 16:15but you don't have a right to force a traumatized
- 16:18kid to look you in the eye. It's a vital psychological
- 16:20shield. But, and this is the crazy twist, it
- 16:23revealed a deeply irrational bias in human juries.
- 16:27The vividness hypothesis. This blew my mind.
- 16:30You would assume seeing a kid behind a screen
- 16:32makes the jury think, wow, the accused must be
- 16:33a monster. You'd think it inflates conviction
- 16:36rates. Right. But the sticker movie study tested
- 16:39this. Adults put stickers on kids, and later
- 16:41the kids testified in a mock court, some live,
- 16:44some on closed circuit TV. And the jurors who
- 16:47watched the child on TV rate the child as vastly
- 16:50less accurate, less intelligent, and less honest
- 16:53than the live kids. Because of locational proximity,
- 16:56humans equate emotional immediacy with truth.
- 17:00The physical distance of the screen flattens
- 17:02the emotional distress. So because the testimony
- 17:04is less vivid, The jury's brain automatically
- 17:07down rates the credibility. It's a devastating
- 17:09irony. The exact tools needed to protect the
- 17:12kid's mental health inadvertently reduce the
- 17:14chance of conviction. You save the child's mind,
- 17:17but you lose the case. It's a tightrope. Which
- 17:20is why Canada is now heavily funding child advocacy
- 17:23centers or Seacocks. Oh, right. To put police,
- 17:26therapists, and medical staff all under one roof
- 17:28so the kid doesn't get bounced around a scary
- 17:31legal labyrinth, fracturing their memory at every
- 17:33stop. Exactly. A single wraparound environment
- 17:36to capture the uncorrupted truth. So as psych
- 17:39undergrads, if we summarize everything we've
- 17:41learned today, the legal system evolved from
- 17:44assuming kids are inherent liars to realizing
- 17:46they are phenomenal, sensory -rich observers.
- 17:49Provided adults don't overwrite their autocorrect
- 17:52brains with leading questions or peer pressure.
- 17:55Exactly. But before we wrap up, you had a final
- 17:57thought that really freaked me out when we were
- 17:59studying earlier. Oh yeah. I want you, the listener,
- 18:02to mull this over. If reality monitoring dictates
- 18:05that a true memory is chaotic sensory details
- 18:08and a fake memory is clean narrative logic. Here
- 18:12it comes. Think about your absolute oldest earliest
- 18:15childhood memory. if it plays in your head like
- 18:18a perfectly structured movie scene with clear
- 18:20logic but lacks that random, messy, sensory noise
- 18:25of real life. Is it possible it never actually
- 18:28happened? Exactly. Has your own autocorrect brain
- 18:31been cross -examining you and silently maintaining
- 18:33a false narrative your entire life? Well, I'm
- 18:36going to be questioning the reality of my entire
- 18:38childhood for the rest of the week. Thank you
- 18:40all for joining this deep dive into the source
- 18:42material on the psychology undergrad. Keep questioning
- 18:45your own perceptions and we'll catch you next
- 18:47time.