Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Mini Cooper SE: Electric Icon and Dynamics
Transcript
- 0:09When you think of a Mennonite Cooper, you think style, you
- 0:12think agility. And you think of that go Kart
- 0:14feel that low to the ground, just fun driving experience.
- 0:18Exactly. It's a car you buy because it's
- 0:20fun. But the whole world is changing,
- 0:22and so is the the equation for what makes a car like that work.
- 0:26Today we're actually digging into a listener request.
- 0:29Someone who loves that MINI feel.
- 0:31But needs to know if that experience holds up and if it's
- 0:34worth the price when you swap the gas engine for an electric
- 0:37motor, right? So that's our mission for this
- 0:40deep dive. We've gone through a huge stack
- 0:42of sources for you. We've got detailed five year
- 0:44cost models. We have the official tech specs
- 0:47from BMW Group. And we even dug into the really
- 0:50interesting stuff, the real world reliability reports from
- 0:53owner forums, the nitty gritty. Our goal is super specific, a
- 0:58direct head to head comparison, the 2025 gas powered Mennonite
- 1:02Cooper S versus the all electric Mennonite Cooper SE.
- 1:07We want to find the answer which one keeps that fun factor and
- 1:10you know which one is actually cheaper to own in the long run.
- 1:12OK, let's unpack this because historically the biggest hurdle
- 1:18for going electric has always been that initial sticker price.
- 1:21You usually pay a big premium for the battery.
- 1:23That's what everyone expects, right?
- 1:25You pay 5, maybe $10,000 more for the EV and then you have to
- 1:29wait years for the fuel savings to, you know, catch up.
- 1:32But our sources show that MINI has completely flipped the
- 1:36script for 2025. This is where it gets really
- 1:38interesting right from the start.
- 1:40It really does. So let's look at the starting
- 1:42prices. The 2025 gas Cooper S starts at
- 1:46around $33,000, OK? And the brand new electric
- 1:50Cooper SE, it starts at just $34,000.
- 1:54So it's $1000 difference. I mean, in the world of new
- 1:56cars, that's nothing. That's a paint color.
- 1:58Exactly. But that's before the real game
- 2:01changer, the thing that gives the electric model a massive
- 2:03head start. The incentives.
- 2:04The incentives? That tiny price difference turns
- 2:07into a huge financial win once you factor in tax credits.
- 2:10The SE can qualify for up to $7500 in federal tax credits
- 2:14here in the. US.
- 2:15And that's not even counting potential state or local
- 2:18rebates, which you'd have to check for yourself.
- 2:20So if you, our listener, can get that full federal credit, you
- 2:25could be buying the electric MINI for well under $30,000.
- 2:29Which means the electric version is actually the cheaper car to
- 2:32buy from day one. It's a massive psychological
- 2:34shift. You're not waiting to break even
- 2:36on some EV premium. You're actually saving money the
- 2:39second you drive off the lot. But, and this is a big but, it
- 2:43all depends on you qualifying for those incentives.
- 2:45That's the first piece of homework you have to do.
- 2:47OK. So if the upfront cost already
- 2:50favors the SC, let's talk about where those savings really start
- 2:53to pile up. I'm talking about running costs,
- 2:55fuel and maintenance. This is where the gap gets huge.
- 2:59Right. So let's just imagine an average
- 3:00driver, someone doing say 12,000 miles a year.
- 3:04The gas Cooper S needs premium fuel.
- 3:06Which is not cheap. No, our sources are estimating
- 3:09gas around $4.50 a gallon and that adds up fast.
- 3:12We're talking somewhere between what, 1800?
- 3:15Two, $1000 a year just to keep gas in the tank.
- 3:17It's a constant expense. A.
- 3:18Constant expense. Now let's compare that to the
- 3:20electric SE. It's got a 54.2 kilowattr
- 3:23battery if you're charging at home, which is the cheapest way
- 3:26to do it. A full charge might cost you
- 3:28what, 6 to 8 bucks depending on where you live.
- 3:31Exactly. So your total energy bill for
- 3:33the year, for those same 12,000 miles, it drops to maybe 400 to
- 3:38$500. OK, hang on.
- 3:40That's a $1500 saving every single year.
- 3:43That's incredible, but that's assuming you're disciplined
- 3:46about charging at home. What about people who have to
- 3:49use public chargers? That is an excellent point.
- 3:52And yeah, those public DC fast chargers can be a lot more
- 3:54expensive, sometimes two or three times what you pay at
- 3:57home. So that narrows the gap a bit.
- 3:58It does. Your annual cost might jump to
- 4:00maybe $900, even 1000 bucks, but even then you're still saving
- 4:05almost $1000 a year. Compared to filling up with
- 4:07premium gas, the economic advantage holds.
- 4:11And if you stretch that $1500 annual savings over five years,
- 4:15you're at $7500. Which is fascinating because
- 4:18that's almost the exact same amount as the federal tax
- 4:20credit. It's like a double discount.
- 4:22It really is. You get the discount when you
- 4:24buy the car and then you say that same amount again over the
- 4:26next five years just by driving it.
- 4:29And we haven't even talked about maintenance yet, the E VS other
- 4:32huge advantage because it's just so much simpler mechanically.
- 4:35Oh absolutely. The Gas Cooper S is a
- 4:37performance car. It needs premium service.
- 4:40You've got oil changes, filters, spark plugs, all the fluids
- 4:43that. Complicated transmission.
- 4:44All of it. The sources put the annual
- 4:46maintenance bill for the S at around 800 to $1000.
- 4:50Whereas the SC is basically tires and wiper fluid.
- 4:54Well, and it benefits so much from regenerative braking.
- 4:57When you slow the car down, the motor does most of the work,
- 5:01which means your brake pads last way, way longer, right?
- 5:05So without a transmission or an exhaust or turbos, the annual
- 5:09maintenance bill falls to just 300 to $400.
- 5:12So just on maintenance, the SC saves you another, what, 2500 to
- 5:16$3000 over those five years? It's really starting to add up.
- 5:19The spreadsheet definitely definitely loves the electric
- 5:22model at this. Point.
- 5:23OK, the finances are clear, but if it doesn't feel like a man
- 5:26and I, then what's the point? Let's pivot to the driving
- 5:29experience. Does the SC still have that go
- 5:31Kart magic? It does, and a big part of that
- 5:34is where the battery is. It's placed low down in the
- 5:36floor, which actually improves the center of gravity and helps
- 5:39maintain that sharp handling. So both cars are quick, but the
- 5:42electric SC has that that instant punch.
- 5:45Yes, the sources confirm some serious performance numbers.
- 5:49We're talking 218 horsepower and 330 Newton meters of torque
- 5:54instantly. It gets from zero to 100
- 5:56kilometers per hour in about 6.7 to 6.9 seconds.
- 6:00Very quick. Yeah, I know the gas as can
- 6:02sometimes be a fraction of a second faster in certain tests,
- 6:05but in the real world, does that really matter?
- 6:08Or is the instant torque of the EV just more fun?
- 6:11For city driving. For suburban driving, the
- 6:14reports are almost universal. The instant torque is way more
- 6:16engaging and fun than waiting for a turbo to spool up.
- 6:19That immediate punch off the line just is the electric
- 6:21experience. We have to talk about the
- 6:23friction point, the big drawback for the SCE range and charging.
- 6:26This is its defining limitation, no question.
- 6:29The SE has that 54.2 kilowatter battery and the number you
- 6:31really need to remember is the EPA rated estimate around 155
- 6:34miles. 250 kilometers. Right, 250 kilometers.
- 6:37Now you mentioned the sources also quote AWLTP figure of up to
- 6:42402 kilometers. Can you explain that for our
- 6:45listener? Why are there two different
- 6:47numbers and why is 1 so much higher?
- 6:50That's a really important technical point.
- 6:52The European WLTP test cycle is just less demanding than the
- 6:56USEPA cycle. It has more varied speeds, fewer
- 6:59long high speed runs. So the EPA test is closer to
- 7:02real world highway driving in America.
- 7:05Much closer. So while 402 kilometers sounds
- 7:07amazing for anyone doing highway travel here, that 155 mile EPA
- 7:12number is the one you need to plan your life around.
- 7:14And when you put 155 miles next to the gas Cooper S, which gets
- 7:18what, 400 miles on a tank and refills in 5 minutes?
- 7:21It feels restrictive. It is restrictive, but the SE
- 7:24does try to make up with pretty quick charging.
- 7:26It can handle DC fast charging up to 95 kilowatts.
- 7:29Which means. Which means you can get from 10
- 7:31to 80% charge in about 30 minutes.
- 7:34And of course, if you have home charging, you can just top it up
- 7:36overnight. So the range isn't a deal
- 7:38breaker, but it does draw a very clear line in the sand between
- 7:41the ideal buyers for each car. It defines the target audience
- 7:45perfectly. The SE is for the city commuter,
- 7:49the person with a short ish drive, or anyone who has
- 7:52reliable charging at home or at work.
- 7:54While the gas Cooper S is still the king for the person who does
- 7:57a lot of long road trips or frankly, just doesn't want to
- 8:00think about planning their route around charming stations.
- 8:03Exactly. OK, let's talk about the long
- 8:05term worries, the things that you know, keep people up at
- 8:08night, insurance, depreciation and the elephant in the room,
- 8:12the battery. Right.
- 8:13So first, the financials. Insurance on the electric model
- 8:17is probably going to cost you about 5 to 10% more.
- 8:20Why is that? EVs just have more specialized,
- 8:23expensive parts, and collusion repairs can be more complex, so
- 8:26premiums tend to be a little higher.
- 8:28What about resale value? Is the EV still taking a big hit
- 8:31after five years? The gap is getting much smaller.
- 8:34The Gas S still holds its value a little better, around 50 to
- 8:3755%. After five years, the SE is
- 8:40projected a bit lower, maybe 45 to 50%.
- 8:43But the gap is closing. It is, yeah.
- 8:45The demand for good, reliable used EVs is really high, so that
- 8:49helps a lot. OK, now the battery 8 to $10,000
- 8:53is the number you see for an out of warranty replacement that
- 8:55would make anyone nervous. It would, but MINI provides the
- 8:59industry standard warranty. Eight years, or 100,000 miles.
- 9:04For most people, that covers their entire ownership period.
- 9:08And battery failure outside of warranty isn't that common,
- 9:11right? It's becoming increasingly rare,
- 9:13and analysts expect that 8 to $10,000 price tag to drop
- 9:17significantly by the time these cars actually need new
- 9:19batteries. And you always have to compare
- 9:21that to the risks of an aging gas car.
- 9:24A turbo goes, the transmission needs a rebuild.
- 9:26Those are multi $1000 repairs too.
- 9:28It's just a different set of risks.
- 9:30And this actually leads to the most surprising thing we found
- 9:33in the owner forms, the. Reliability.
- 9:34The reliability, yeah. Despite all the anxiety around
- 9:37new EVs, the main ISE is reported as being incredibly
- 9:41robust, almost an anomaly. And this is the aha moment from
- 9:45the sources. The reason for that reliability
- 9:47is because it's essentially a parks bin car that.
- 9:49Sounds like a negative negative term, but here it's a massive
- 9:51positive. It means Mii chose proven
- 9:54reliability over, you know, bleeding edge tech.
- 9:57So they took the electric motor and controller from the BMW I3.
- 10:02A system that's been proven for years.
- 10:04And put it into the existing F56 body shell that they know inside
- 10:08and out. Exactly, they just skipped all
- 10:10the new engineering headaches so the issues owners report are
- 10:13really minor. Things like loose grill shutters
- 10:16or AUS big port that doesn't work.
- 10:18Nothing major with the drivetrain.
- 10:20That simple engineering choice does have one really important
- 10:23trade off, especially for people in cold climates.
- 10:25Yes, the sources are very clear on this.
- 10:28The SE does not have a dedicated battery here.
- 10:31What does that mean in the real world?
- 10:33It means in really cold weather, around freezing, owners report
- 10:38that the car's power can drop to about 80% until the battery
- 10:42warms up from just being used. So you get in your car in a
- 10:44freezing morning and for the 1st 15 minutes you only have 4/5 of
- 10:48your normal power. That is a critical detail for
- 10:50you to know. OK, let's bring it all together.
- 10:51Let's get to the final scorecard, the five year total
- 10:54cost of ownership with everything factored in.
- 10:56Right. They had to crunch all the
- 10:57numbers, the insurance, the brake pads, gas prices, and of
- 11:01course, that huge federal credit.
- 11:03And when the dust settled, what was the final difference?
- 11:06The estimated 5 year total cost for the Gas Mini Cooper S comes
- 11:11out to about $52,000. And the electric SE.
- 11:15After you factor in the incentives and all the savings,
- 11:18the five year cost for the Electric M and NI Cooper SE
- 11:21drops to roughly $39,800. Wow, that is a massive,
- 11:26undeniable difference. The sources are concluding that
- 11:29the electric M&I Cooper SE is about $12,000 cheaper to own
- 11:34over five years. That huge financial win means
- 11:37the SE is just the smarter economic choice for the vast
- 11:40majority of people who are commuting or driving locally.
- 11:42It keeps the fun, but it slashes the cost.
- 11:45So the Gas Cooper S really only makes sense for that one
- 11:48specific person, the dedicated long distance driver who can't
- 11:51compromise on range, or someone who just can't get a home
- 11:53charger installed. It really narrows its use case
- 11:57and that whole discussion we had about the SE being a parts bin
- 12:00success using the reliable BMW I3 motor instead of some new
- 12:05untested system, it raises a really big question for the
- 12:09whole auto industry. Go on.
- 12:11In this huge push to get everyone into EVs, is it a
- 12:15better strategy to prioritize proven reliability and a lower
- 12:18cost of ownership by smartly reusing components?
- 12:22Or should companies keep chasing the absolute maximum range or
- 12:25power with brand new, complex and maybe less reliable tech?
- 12:30That trade off between maximum innovation and maximum
- 12:33reliability, that's something we are all going to be thinking
- 12:36about for years to come. What a perfect thought to leave
- 12:39everyone with. It really is.
- 12:40Thank you so much for bringing us this deep dive.
- 12:42I mean, digging into the real economics and performance of an
- 12:45icon like the mini is always fascinating.
- 12:47We really appreciate you sharing your curiosity with us, and if
- 12:50you want to make sure you catch every future deep dive where we
- 12:52breakdown complex topics just like this, please make sure you
- 12:55follow the channel. We'll see you in the next one.