Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / From Gold Rush to Bitcoin Standard: Inflation’s Coming for Your Balance Sheet
Transcript
- 0:01Hey everyone. Welcome to another episode,
- 0:03episode 3 of the Bitcoin for Businesses podcast.
- 0:06I'm joined as always in studio with Michael Tanguma, Liam
- 0:10Nelson and Matthew Ball. And I'm your host, Chase
- 0:13Palmieri, and this group here are folks that are actually
- 0:17operating in the world at the intersection of Bitcoin and
- 0:20business. So Michael here is the CEO of On
- 0:23Ramp and managing partner at Early Riders.
- 0:26Liam is also a partner at Early Riders.
- 0:29And Matthew Ball here is sharing time between product at On Ramp
- 0:33and Acropolis. And I'm the CEO at Acropolis.
- 0:36So this podcast is for actual builders and operators in the
- 0:39Bitcoin space or CEOSCFOSC suites that are looking to
- 0:45integrate Bitcoin into their balance sheets and other areas
- 0:48of their business. So we've got some really
- 0:51important news stories that we're going to start off with,
- 0:54but then we're going to tie this always into practical
- 0:57implementation for folks that are listening.
- 1:01One of the big stories this week was Square overnight allowing
- 1:05merchants to now accept Bitcoin as payment through their point
- 1:09of sale platform. This is obviously a huge unlock,
- 1:13incredible news for kind of the medium of exchange argument, but
- 1:17I think we would all agree that it's equally important for these
- 1:22businesses to consider what they do after they've accepted
- 1:25Bitcoin as payment. So who'd like to take it first?
- 1:27I'm happy to to jump in. I think it's very interesting
- 1:30and unique the timing of it because I think we're going to
- 1:32talk a little bit later, maybe we need to have a component of
- 1:36this for gold. I don't know how businesses
- 1:37would get their gold, you know, treasury, but it's about to hit
- 1:41$4300.00 an ounce. And the point in that is that
- 1:45that notion of debasement trade the past couple weeks has picked
- 1:48up steam, basically inflation and businesses are feeling it.
- 1:52And so I think it's really timely and interesting the
- 1:54timing that they launched this because obviously they've been
- 1:56working at it on it for a while. If there was somebody that's
- 1:58going to win in the existing space, whether it's technology
- 2:01or tratify space around Bitcoin and full stack, it feels the
- 2:05closest that Square would be able to do that because they
- 2:08have both sides of the the market.
- 2:10When you think about cash app in the number of users and the
- 2:13ability for somebody to buy, hold, start their relationship
- 2:16with Bitcoin and then the amount of merchants on the other side
- 2:20of that when it comes to the point of sale system, but then
- 2:22also the right tooling. So it's, it's a really cool
- 2:25thing to see, especially when you think about millions of
- 2:27people getting exposure that now you still have to.
- 2:30I think it's, it's a long road for payment use case for Bitcoin
- 2:33just naturally, because individuals that are purchasing
- 2:36Bitcoin are generally using it to hold and protect their
- 2:38wealth. But I do think overtime the use
- 2:41cases will grow, whether it's merchants requiring it, giving
- 2:44discounts, and then obviously for certain payments, it makes
- 2:47more sense to pay over Bitcoin versus traditional like, you
- 2:51know, Fiat rails. So it's really cool to see.
- 2:54And I would imagine we're going to see more of this between
- 2:56PayPal and other competitors. Yeah, it's going to be great to
- 2:58see because it's a lot of small businesses too.
- 3:01I mean, in the V1, I think it's primarily just going to be a lot
- 3:05of merchants that are seamlessly moving a certain amount of their
- 3:10revenue over to Bitcoin just by buying it directly through cash
- 3:14app and then using their exchange.
- 3:16But it's also a telling sign of just Bitcoin getting more in the
- 3:19zeitgeist. Having those Bitcoin stickers at
- 3:22every single pay like register for small businesses too, just
- 3:25kind of puts it more into the zeitgeist of everyday people in
- 3:28Americans that are like, OK, well, wait, people are actually
- 3:31using this Bitcoin thing. And so it's going to.
- 3:34And then it's, you know, less just, you know, the scammers and
- 3:37the president that just only think about Bitcoin too.
- 3:40But it just gets into everyday life.
- 3:44And it's also going to be great to see because small businesses
- 3:46are the ones that need this most.
- 3:48You know, we're going to go into this a lot later on too.
- 3:50But it's also going to be great to see a lot of the challengers
- 3:53who are relatively small businesses understand the
- 3:56impacts of being able to just save their money in a better
- 3:59store value as inflation does kind of RIP out of control,
- 4:03especially for those who don't necessarily have a massive
- 4:06amounts of capital and cash flows in order to protect their
- 4:09business for the long term. Yeah.
- 4:11And one thing that we talk a lot about at ER and on Ramp and at
- 4:16Acropolis is the idea of these large businesses that have
- 4:19existing corporate treasuries coming into the Bitcoin space
- 4:21and allocating, you know, a risk manage percent of that a
- 4:25corporate balance sheet into Bitcoin.
- 4:27But when it comes to smaller businesses, they don't typically
- 4:29have those big reserves in place to convert into Bitcoin.
- 4:33And so this is really a great way for small businesses, as
- 4:36you're mentioning, Liam, to start acquiring their initial
- 4:39Bitcoin treasury. Yeah, this is a huge unlock for
- 4:43small businesses. I think Liam hit on it well and
- 4:46just the fact that they're able to use Cash App and Square in
- 4:49just such a good company with, with wonderful user experiences
- 4:52and designs. It's going to sort of demystify
- 4:55Bitcoin for so many people who are interested in kind of
- 4:58getting involved. And I think it's a, it's a
- 5:00really great thing for the space to have this company in
- 5:03particular kind of leading that, leading the flagship of the
- 5:07businesses, being able to get that exposure to, it's a, it's
- 5:11going to be a really cool to see who, who begins to pick this up.
- 5:15So, Michael, now there, there's going to be millions probably of
- 5:19businesses in the next 12 to 24 months that have some amount of
- 5:24Bitcoin on their balance sheets. But it looks like a lot of that,
- 5:28you know, they're going to default to just letting it sit
- 5:31on their square dashboards. What do you think about what
- 5:34they need to consider next? Yeah, I think it's a great
- 5:37question. I think there's a certain
- 5:39component around it sounds funny, but the reality of when
- 5:44you recognize you want exposure to Bitcoin and then you want
- 5:47material exposure once you get to a certain threshold, you get
- 5:51really uncomfortable no matter how you custody it when you
- 5:54first get in, you either leave it on exchange, Maybe somebody
- 5:56helped you set up a hardware device, maybe didn't necessarily
- 5:59do everything you needed to to fill rock solid with it because
- 6:01it was a nominal amount. Call it something immaterial to
- 6:04that individual. And this is relative to whoever.
- 6:06And so in this use case, whether it's because it's a gimmick or
- 6:10the company has a, you know, barista that wants to do it and
- 6:14says, hey, let's put out the sign.
- 6:16Eventually the numbers start to grow or the conviction or
- 6:18confidence starts to grow or a number of other things.
- 6:22Somebody gets hacked and he starts a really question like,
- 6:24what are we doing here? And so I've always been able to
- 6:26reconcile. The only way you can end up in
- 6:28material, if not all of your wealth being stored in this
- 6:31asset is understanding how keys work.
- 6:32Like just full stop. Because once you get that the
- 6:35keys don't just, you know, plug themselves in and like walk over
- 6:38the computer. If you're doing self custody or
- 6:40multi institution, however, it's frame, you start to really get
- 6:43confidence because if you understand the monetary
- 6:45properties, how consensus works, why there's 21 million.
- 6:49The last part is ultimately just deeply understanding what your
- 6:52custody solution is because that allows you to hold more and more
- 6:55Bitcoin. So I think it will naturally a
- 6:57progression whether it's Square opting into something like multi
- 7:01institution, having a more robust setup, because I would
- 7:04imagine, well, there's a lot of great security with the Square.
- 7:07And however they're custody and back end, it still opens up when
- 7:10you have single custodial risk like social engineering and
- 7:13everything under the hood that exists at Coinbase and why
- 7:15people move assets off a coin base into some form of cold
- 7:18storage. And so I think that'll naturally
- 7:20be this progression for businesses to start looking
- 7:22deeper. How do they buy it?
- 7:24How do they hold it long term? But to Liam's point, right,
- 7:27yeah, it's a Liam and man balls point.
- 7:28Like there's such a great brand and it's, they have such huge
- 7:31exposure not only in the individual side, but in like
- 7:34Silicon Valley that I think it's a great starting point.
- 7:37And then you naturally just have to go through.
- 7:39And that's why this is going to be such a long game because some
- 7:42will end up maybe buying or holding 2 larger positions and
- 7:45then they'll lose their account and we'll get it closed because
- 7:48that does happen at cash up to as great as they are.
- 7:50I mean, I've had my cash app flat things, old cash app
- 7:53account flag for, for whatever reason.
- 7:55And then he just locks your funds.
- 7:57And I've actually never got him out of there because it's almost
- 7:59impossible to get a hold of them.
- 8:01So there's a number of reasons why you literally wouldn't want
- 8:03to leave large balances on any single custodial relationship.
- 8:06And I so I think it'll be a natural progression as companies
- 8:09get into the space that they will look for best in class ways
- 8:12to store and, and also interact and integrate with other, you
- 8:15know, offerings and kind of Bitcoin and stable coins.
- 8:18Yeah, I mean, that's exactly right.
- 8:20And I think of this exactly as pretty much Coinbase in the V1
- 8:25instance of just the fact that prior to them you essentially
- 8:28had to figure out how to buy Bitcoin non custodially and
- 8:32there just wasn't a setup. And Coinbase, especially in it's
- 8:35very early days was just almost, it just had a great UX and it
- 8:39felt like an online brokerage. And so people who just saw
- 8:43Bitcoin as another asset, they're like, OK, this is easy.
- 8:46I can just go there, I can buy Bitcoin and it will just show up
- 8:49in my account. And that's great for V1 for
- 8:52people who are curious about the asset and, you know, just maybe
- 8:55want to invest, then investigate on what that set actually is and
- 8:59how to store it. And they'll figure all that
- 9:02later on. And even if there is anything
- 9:05later on, because sometimes people buy it and they don't
- 9:08necessarily have a really high level of conviction or thesis
- 9:11around it too. But you know, even naturally, if
- 9:13you just don't rebalance overtime and just allow yourself
- 9:16to DCA just from an individual or a business perspective too,
- 9:20it's just naturally something you're going to want to figure
- 9:22out as long as that's the last thing that you sell.
- 9:25So it's just kind of like a great V1 and there's just going
- 9:28to be more competition around the space because cash App is
- 9:31not the only person trying to do this.
- 9:32They're probably going to be the one who's best at it from like
- 9:35kind of a merchant base, small point of sale system.
- 9:39But on the business to business side, like there's, there's a
- 9:42bunch of other payment companies that are coming into this too,
- 9:45everything from Stripe and, and they're going to try to, you
- 9:48know, get some of this business as well.
- 9:51Yeah. One thing we're just adding,
- 9:53this is really I think important for why we do this podcast.
- 9:57We're Acropolis on Ramp Shine and also River to give a shout
- 10:01out to a business that operates not only the right way, but
- 10:04offers client services. Like we're so early in Bitcoins
- 10:07adoption and people forget that it's money and money requires
- 10:10financial services and those are generally relationship driven to
- 10:13start. And so if you start to build any
- 10:16kind of position or investment from your business, naturally
- 10:19need to talk to a human, you know, all the things we're
- 10:22talking about here, you need to have contingency planning.
- 10:24You need to be thinking about it in a very strategic way.
- 10:27Easy example is if you start with one franchise or business
- 10:31that starts to accept it and then they collect, they talk.
- 10:34A toast is another great example of some family members that work
- 10:37with them. And you think about like when
- 10:39you sign up 1 doesn't mean you sign up all 13 of the accounts.
- 10:43So eventually gets to the lead account or whatever region, they
- 10:46need somebody to talk to, they need somebody to explain this,
- 10:49all of this stuff. And then like what happens if
- 10:50the balance gets too great? And how do you think about it?
- 10:52And you know, I think we're going to talk about what
- 10:54happened last week and the deleveraging.
- 10:55It's like, well, is this crypto or is this Bitcoin?
- 10:57There's a lot of value and still a lot of businesses and
- 11:00opportunity. And my favorite thing in
- 11:02building businesses and especially early stages is
- 11:05counter positioning the incumbents because the
- 11:06incumbents can't do this like cash up full stuff like cannot
- 11:09handle the amount of demand or requests that will be needed to
- 11:12educate in the same way Coinbase can't.
- 11:14And that leaves a huge opportunity and gap to build
- 11:17things, do things that don't scale and then you ultimately
- 11:19can build the workflows and processes that can get to a
- 11:22larger cohort base. It just gets really hard on the
- 11:24other way to do it, but if there's anybody that's going to
- 11:27do it, I do think Cash App and Squares simply because of Jack's
- 11:30leadership and this they seem like they're playing a long game
- 11:32when it comes to Bitcoin adoption with within everything
- 11:35that they do in their product met.
- 11:37Yeah, I think it's probably worth calling out that cash app
- 11:40Square, the parent company Block, is a holder of its own
- 11:44Bitcoin treasury and is doing it the right way, where they're
- 11:47using a percentage of free cash flow from their Bitcoin line of
- 11:50businesses to basically DCA into their own Bitcoin treasury.
- 11:54So really an eater of their own dog food here.
- 11:57And what I'm kind of hearing is maybe a take away to put a pin
- 12:00in the Square news is that, yes, this announcement makes it
- 12:06incredibly easy for merchants to accept Bitcoin.
- 12:09But perhaps so easy that they're going to take their eye off the
- 12:12ball and almost not pay attention to what it really
- 12:15means to be holding and accepting Bitcoin until they see
- 12:18a material enough amount on their balance sheets that they
- 12:21actually start to dig in and learn and start to consider
- 12:24taking it into cold storage. One of the things we know that
- 12:27business owners are probably more likely to be thinking about
- 12:30now as opposed to Bitcoin custody is how inflation is
- 12:34affecting their business. We're seeing gold start to
- 12:37rally, which you can take as a signal that the the debasement
- 12:41trade is on, that dollar is weakening or that folks are
- 12:44trying to flee out of a Fiat based currencies into hard store
- 12:48value assets. Michael, I'm not sure if you
- 12:50wanted to kick us off, but you kind of wanted to touch on how
- 12:53the gold Bitcoin denomination is breaking.
- 12:56Yeah, I think the the biggest thing here is especially for
- 12:59listeners like we know the thesis, I think it makes
- 13:03complete sense. If you just look at the past 50
- 13:06years, it can be 30 years or it can be the past five years or
- 13:08the past year. Gold and Bitcoin related to the
- 13:11the dollar specifically this past year with the dollar
- 13:14depreciating, it's actually by now more than 50% given gold
- 13:17like at 4300. What I think though is change
- 13:20and what's most important is whether it's somebody listening
- 13:23that has to get their internal team because that's really the
- 13:26problem with businesses and institutions in general is that
- 13:29there's a governance process. So you really have to get the
- 13:31buy in to realize there's a problem, right?
- 13:34If we're all, you know, Alcoholics on inflation, like
- 13:37the first step is we got it. We got to realize we got a
- 13:39problem here and that we're losing money, you know, via the
- 13:43basement. And I think this is a really
- 13:46interesting time, which ties back to squares launch because
- 13:50of the fact that it's now into the ether.
- 13:53Travi has blessed the the name with the debasement trade.
- 13:57Now it can be discussed and now people can recognize it because
- 14:00before the gold bugs were kooks and then the bitcoiners were
- 14:03kooks. But the reality is like this is
- 14:05now just being understood that inflation is here.
- 14:08It's running rampant. The thing that gets widely under
- 14:11discussed and visually felt is we've kind of hit the the event
- 14:15horizon post 2020 where like more monetary units and more
- 14:18debt just increases the amount for needs of the need of debt
- 14:22and more capital be inserted, which increases inflation.
- 14:25So it only goes faster from here.
- 14:27It doesn't like temper out. There's no transitory.
- 14:29And I think that's the important function here where people can
- 14:33see their goods, they can see the eggs, whatever they're
- 14:35buying going up and them having to increase purchase of the cost
- 14:38or redo, or they're seeing the reduction in volume and revenue.
- 14:42But they haven't been able to feel confident, whether it's
- 14:45themselves personally or going to their board or their team to
- 14:48say, hey, we should be looking for external options.
- 14:50And I think this is the time, if there's ever going to be 1, The
- 14:53tooling's right, the price is right.
- 14:55When you look at these alternative assets, specifically
- 14:57gold and Bitcoin. And then now you can point to no
- 14:59shortage of publicos, social proof, and also just your
- 15:02favorite macro economist or JP Morgan or Larry Fink explaining
- 15:06that this stuff's out of control.
- 15:07Yeah, Liam, I'll kick it over to you next.
- 15:09But the story here is, according to Axios, 47% of Americans say
- 15:14that groceries are harder to afford than they were last year.
- 15:17And at the same time, we're seeing the Fed begin its
- 15:21interest rate cut cycle, which you would assume that if
- 15:24inflation is still persisting or on the horizon, that they
- 15:28wouldn't necessarily be doing so.
- 15:30But I think to Michelle point, we kind of have this problem
- 15:34where it's inflationary whether they cut or it's inflationary
- 15:37whether they increase interest rates at this point.
- 15:40Yeah, that's right. And I would just say it's it's
- 15:43getting out of the bottle. Now, just to Mike's point of all
- 15:46the different products and services, the central banks know
- 15:48that this is going to be a problem and they see the writing
- 15:51on the wall of inflation coming down the pipeline and they're
- 15:55trying to acquire as much gold as possible.
- 15:57And there's probably some counterparty risk being
- 16:00understood in the background. If gold's going up over 60% in a
- 16:04year, just shouldn't be going up that quickly for an asset size
- 16:07this big unless there's something that's very, very
- 16:10wrong in the background. And I would just say, yeah, I
- 16:14mean, inflation's, you know, continually been a problem.
- 16:17It's really accelerated as the information just kind of become
- 16:22more clear on everything from grocery prices being online and
- 16:27everything like that to actually being able to understand that
- 16:30there is massive deflations in in certain sectors of the
- 16:33economy, everything from TV's, technology, AI, etc.
- 16:38But in everything that is, you know, non discretionary goods or
- 16:41everything that they actually take out of core inflation of
- 16:44the housing, food and energy costs, which we all need are the
- 16:48only things that are core to living are actually taken out of
- 16:51the inflation bucket. And so, yeah, I mean, I think
- 16:54that it's, it's very well known that there is a problem and some
- 17:00people are still denying that the solution is gold and Bitcoin
- 17:03because everywhere that you see people are saying then why
- 17:06aren't we all allocated to gold, to Bitcoin already?
- 17:08It's just like, well, you have a different mental framework of
- 17:11the world that you have essentially just put your career
- 17:15on the line of being allocated to equities and bonds.
- 17:19It's very difficult for you to change your mind unless you
- 17:21actually are forced to be forced to change your mind.
- 17:23And so we're seeing it happen on the margins, but it's only going
- 17:27to accelerate as the products are now right as well as just it
- 17:32increasingly goes into the mainstream.
- 17:33Yeah. And you touched on counterparty
- 17:35risk there, which is obviously an important aspect of holding
- 17:39actual physical gold or Bitcoin in cold storage.
- 17:42And perhaps all the more important during something like
- 17:45what happened last week with kind of the deleveraging and the
- 17:48Bitcoin flash crash, if you will.
- 17:51Michael, do you want to speak to maybe how counterparty risk
- 17:54plays into a volatile Bitcoin price like what we saw last
- 17:58week? Yeah, I think this is easily one
- 18:01of the most discounted reasons to hold Bitcoin and one of the
- 18:05highest. The value problem is the
- 18:07greatest because number go up is great, but the reality is we
- 18:12used to pitch Bitcoin is the most asymmetric bet and the
- 18:15general term would be asymmetric and its purchasing power
- 18:18increases relative to dollars. And then the downside is if
- 18:20you're not holding it, you're holding dollars that are
- 18:22depreciating. And I still think that's true.
- 18:24But I think the thing that gets discounted for is what else are
- 18:27you going to be holding and where does the risk lie?
- 18:30And so before going into what happened last week in
- 18:33deleveraging, I get in a little trouble because I'm not supposed
- 18:36to show screens, screens here. But I'm going to pull something
- 18:38out because there's a market dip in equities, but also Bitcoin.
- 18:43And part of its coming on the back of it says US regional bank
- 18:46stocks hit as Zions charge off fraud allegations.
- 18:49It's effectively a bank. And I believe the Southeast,
- 18:53maybe Georgia, but the point is that there was a $50 million
- 18:57loss via like a fraudulent claim on some kind of like loan
- 19:03relationship that somebody was extending loans and they were
- 19:06fraudulent. But the point in this is the
- 19:08bankruptcy of auto parts maker first Brands and subprime
- 19:11blender chart color and recent fraud allegations.
- 19:13They put a spotlight on risk controls of banks and OPEC
- 19:15credit market where complex loans and new facilities have
- 19:17made it harder to gauge participants exposure.
- 19:20This isn't happened in a vacuum. This is fundamentally part of
- 19:23the system is you have more monetary units, you go further
- 19:26and further out on the risk curve and you make more loans.
- 19:28And this happens in the traditional system.
- 19:30And then this is just gets mirrored and kind of like
- 19:32exponentially increased in digital assets.
- 19:34When you think about all the different levels that it's duct
- 19:37tape and you hear about perpetual features and all the
- 19:39just craziness that happens, the derivatives.
- 19:41And the main take away my mind is most businesses are going to
- 19:45be thinking about, you know, short term, you know, cash
- 19:48equivalents, money market funds, how they're thinking about risk
- 19:50because they have to plan and everything looks great until you
- 19:55see an SVV pop up or you see whatever.
- 19:57If you're in a 12 month duration, some kind of credit
- 19:59facility, you don't necessarily know where that risk lies.
- 20:02And as the market gets more and more volatile, it'll only happen
- 20:05because the amount of debt in the system, you don't know where
- 20:08those air pockets where you potentially could be holding
- 20:10zeros. This exists for everyone,
- 20:12institutions, individuals, but for the sake of this businesses.
- 20:16And so this fundamentally goes back to the reason why you don't
- 20:18really want to play with crypto because crypto and in general
- 20:21and that deleveraging event. The reality is it's only a few
- 20:24market makers. They're not really high volume
- 20:27assets because nobody really wants them.
- 20:28And the second that the market dries up, the market maker Start
- 20:32Stop trading. And then you see this crazy
- 20:34reflexivity where some went to zero and margin calls and the
- 20:38auto deleveraging and all the other craziness that goes on in
- 20:41crypto happens. But that's really where your
- 20:43counterparties matter. Why you don't want centralized
- 20:46custody because you also don't know the liabilities at a
- 20:48central custodian could have. So even if the assets are
- 20:50secure, you may never get them out because they have other
- 20:53claims on them. So, yeah, it's a, it's a, it's
- 20:55really the Wild West right now. When you think about the
- 20:58financial markets and the fact that there's so much leverage
- 21:02built in, you don't know where things are secure.
- 21:04That's why eyes or hands or keys on the underline in transparency
- 21:09matter most if you're going to, you know, protect your wealth
- 21:12into the future. Yeah, IA 100% echo that.
- 21:15And the point or the small differences between, you know,
- 21:20the traditional system and the digital asset system as a whole
- 21:23is like in the traditional system, there is continual
- 21:27debasement and perpetual bailouts just through the fact
- 21:31that there are additional monetary units coming into the
- 21:33system. But that's not always the case
- 21:35in Bitcoin. And there are just no bailouts.
- 21:36So they're just these accelerated business cycles.
- 21:39And so if you lend out consumer deposits by just putting the
- 21:43existing framework of how you should, you know, maintain
- 21:47client assets like a bank and craft it over to the digital
- 21:50asset space, it just doesn't necessarily work out.
- 21:53You know, we've seen in the past, every four years there are
- 21:57bodies that, you know, wash up on the beach that have been, you
- 22:01know, lost because there's a ton of just a ton of leverage that
- 22:07goes into the system. And then events like these
- 22:09happen. And then people are, you know,
- 22:12almost like, you know, dead in the water, but other everybody
- 22:15hasn't realized that yet and they still have their assets on
- 22:17the platform. And then there is a real risk
- 22:19off movement and a lot of those digital asset bodies come to the
- 22:23future. I'm not saying that that's where
- 22:24we are today, but you know, this ties back into a lot of those
- 22:27companies out there trying to get yield on their Bitcoin.
- 22:30You know, it just hasn't been done over the past four years
- 22:32and you know banking on everything such as relatively
- 22:37well functioning market in order to get that yield just doesn't
- 22:40necessarily make sense. And so we definitely advise
- 22:44against that especially just you don't want to be the first
- 22:47person and to try to do it especially it hasn't been done
- 22:51on scale yet. Every business will hold
- 22:54Bitcoin. Some already do.
- 22:55Others are developing a plan. Acropolis is how smart companies
- 22:59take action today. Built on Multi Institution
- 23:02Custody, Acropolis delivers a turnkey Bitcoin treasury
- 23:05solution designed specifically for businesses.
- 23:08Here's why that matters. Multi Institution custody is the
- 23:11breakthrough that unlocks the corporate adoption of Bitcoin.
- 23:14It eliminates the need for employees to hold cryptographic
- 23:17material and removes reliance on any single custodian.
- 23:20Instead, Bitcoin is secured using A2 3 Multi Signature
- 23:24Quorum, where each key is held by a separate regulated
- 23:27institution. No single party can move funds
- 23:30on their own, eliminating single points of failure and greatly
- 23:33reducing risk. We act as an extension of your
- 23:36treasury team, managing institutional grade custody,
- 23:39insurance, continuity planning and strategic advisory so your
- 23:43company can adopt Bitcoin confidently and securely.
- 23:46If your team has been sitting on the sidelines, unsure of how to
- 23:49get started or worried about getting it wrong, this is your
- 23:52signal. Visit acropolistreasury.com and
- 23:55schedule a consultation. Bitcoin is reshaping corporate
- 23:58finance. Don't get left behind.
- 24:00So we see this all the time at On Ramp, you guys see it with
- 24:03individuals a lot. And at Acropolis we see it with
- 24:05businesses where they get the thesis right.
- 24:07They know that they need to own Bitcoin, but then they get a
- 24:10little, you know, too cute by half and they start to pursue
- 24:14too much leverage or they start to pursue yield.
- 24:17And that's when they take on that counterparty risk.
- 24:19That's when they take on a Bitcoin price volatility risk.
- 24:23If you can be early to Bitcoin and write about the thesis, but
- 24:26you can still lose your position over the long term if you if you
- 24:29engage in these activities. Let's see.
- 24:31So maybe next we can speak to the gold Bitcoin denominator
- 24:36being broken. There was something I think you
- 24:38wanted to tease out there, Michael.
- 24:40I think we kind of touched on it earlier, at least from that lens
- 24:43in the sense of just like in the market understanding like
- 24:47there's something wrong, they've known it, but now it's being
- 24:49called out. And so I think that's what makes
- 24:51a lot of these discussions easier moving forward.
- 24:54Specifically, if you're listening, you work at a
- 24:57business. If you're a founder or a partner
- 24:59at a business and you're looking for that air cover, there's no
- 25:02shortage of opportunity now to point directly to what the
- 25:05problem is. And then really naturally, once
- 25:08you get the problem, it becomes a lot easier to recognize the
- 25:10solution. And Liam, I know you wanted to
- 25:12touch on some of the new multinationals that are entering
- 25:15the space thanks to things like the Genius Act and the
- 25:18attraction of things like stable coins for cross-border payments
- 25:22across these multinationals and and all their various
- 25:25subsidiaries spread out over the globe.
- 25:28Where do you want to go with that?
- 25:29Yeah, I was more so Erebor Bank, founded by, you know, Palmer
- 25:35Luckey and Joe Lonsdale from ABC got approval to operate today.
- 25:39I think it's the fastest bank ever to get approval.
- 25:41They came in after the wake of SVB.
- 25:44We all know what happened there. There's so much, there's too
- 25:47much loan concentration on a certain industry as well as just
- 25:51the fact that they were over the skis on their lending
- 25:54capabilities. Guys have pretty much they're
- 25:56very smart and well connected. So I've, you know, know, like
- 26:00they'll definitely be incredible successful.
- 26:02They said that they're only going to be lending out 50% of
- 26:05the loan to deposit ratio at the launch rather than, you know,
- 26:08the typical 90 ish percent for a number of different players out
- 26:12there. And so that's pretty much like,
- 26:13okay, we solved it. We're the adult in the room now.
- 26:17There's we're going to be very safe with your actual deposits,
- 26:21but most people don't actually want that.
- 26:23There are some instances where you do want to be able to get a
- 26:27loan on your assets, but just because, and they'll be
- 26:29specialists in everything from defence tech to stable coins and
- 26:33things like that. But at the end of the day,
- 26:35especially for Bitcoin related to you really want just your
- 26:38assets to be held in your own vault where there isn't going to
- 26:42be liabilities and defaults should anything happen to the
- 26:46custodian. So I think that just kind of
- 26:48goes into the fact that like the existing system thinks about
- 26:51counterparty risk but and there are being marginal improvements
- 26:54on the sides, but they haven't really thought about it
- 26:56necessarily in the complete correct way.
- 26:59Yeah, I think I have two different they're they're
- 27:03they're opposite sides of where I find this stuff interesting
- 27:06because on the air war, however you pronounce it, those guys
- 27:08love like their fiction. What is the other one?
- 27:12Lord of the Rings rings. There's the angle of there's
- 27:17something there and will persist around efficiencies of
- 27:22cross-border stable coin usage, whether it's from payments to
- 27:28payroll. I think the, the quote was like
- 27:31Stripe as big as they are, only manages 1% of all B2B payments.
- 27:35So there's something definitely there from a business
- 27:37perspective, whether it's dollars a stable coins or
- 27:40Bitcoin. But the other side of that, and
- 27:42this came, you know, confidentially from somebody
- 27:45within the industry was referencing how like Coinbase as
- 27:47an examples looking for this trust charter and said, well,
- 27:49why do they need a trust charter?
- 27:51And through their view, it's because they want to become a
- 27:53bank and because banks can effectively lend out fractional
- 27:56reserve assets and client deposits.
- 27:59And so that ties into, I think a little bit what Liam was
- 28:01alluding to with some of these trust codes.
- 28:03They're going to be allowed to do this.
- 28:05And we obviously know that that's where risk starts to get
- 28:07inserted in the system. And I think that's worth calling
- 28:09out because you want to be careful.
- 28:12You know, that's the sad part about all of this is it's
- 28:14already hard enough to get back when it's already hard enough to
- 28:16get your firm to allocate. And then there we, we naturally
- 28:20as humans gravitates towards social proof.
- 28:22So there's all these companies that have the right backing or
- 28:24groups and people will go there and then they won't realize the
- 28:27counterparty risk. And we saw this first hand with
- 28:30Block Fire personally just was like, you know, Peter Thiel's
- 28:32back in this firm. I think it was Valor Ventures
- 28:34but they always use Peter Thiel's name.
- 28:36It's like man, even if they got caught offsides like they'll get
- 28:39bailed out, their equity value will be worth something because
- 28:41they were, you know, multi billion dollar firm at its peak.
- 28:44But the reality is, and this just really doesn't get felt as
- 28:46the math is the math and if you have enough losses from the
- 28:50underlying it doesn't matter. Like including BlackRock and
- 28:53Fidelity, if Bitcoin gets to trillions and trillions of
- 28:56dollars from here in market cap and they're holding trillions of
- 28:59dollars, they don't have the equity value to get bailed out
- 29:02there. Makes zero sense.
- 29:03So you just end up with a loss. And that's one a long enough
- 29:05time horizon. It doesn't make any sense for
- 29:07any custodian to have full unilateral control or title to
- 29:10that underlying asset. So we have a long ways to go
- 29:12from here. And I think it's not until we'll
- 29:14see some really sizable losses that people will wake up.
- 29:18But that's, you know, the point of this podcast.
- 29:20Yeah. And we saw Sony also apply for
- 29:23their bank charter, which probably comes to as a surprise
- 29:27to some folks that haven't been following their previous work in
- 29:30the space, but they actually had previously launched A Ethereum
- 29:34layer 2 token. So they've been kind of doing
- 29:37some things with one of their subsidiaries.
- 29:39What do you think about this? Is this just a way for them to
- 29:42have stable coins and can kind of control that from top down or
- 29:46is there more to the play do you think?
- 29:48Yeah. I mean that that was what I
- 29:50touched on just a second ago. I think it's mainly from like B
- 29:52to B. If you have a Japanese based
- 29:54firm that does you know, payment, they accept payments,
- 29:58but they're also fulfilling obligations via vendors.
- 30:00It probably makes a lot of sense there, but TBD on how close
- 30:05they've been to, you know, the banking side.
- 30:08Like this is a subsidiary of IT. And so obviously you think of
- 30:12Sony as a electronics business, but if they have any kind of,
- 30:17you know, different areas of their business that have focused
- 30:20anywhere near financial services, they might have been
- 30:22doing diligence in the same way Stripe has been doing diligence
- 30:24for years on crypto. And now they fully went, you
- 30:27know, head it, head into it, because like Stripe as an
- 30:29example, has gone past 24 months, executed pretty wildly
- 30:33and fast when it comes to the whether it's the launch of like
- 30:37the purchase of bridge, they had another wallet they acquired.
- 30:41I think they're actually going for a license.
- 30:43They're going to let people like a banking license.
- 30:45They're let people launch stable coins.
- 30:48So I think there's a lot there if somebody sees it where we're
- 30:50still early enough that there's going to be multiple winners in
- 30:53that kind of like whole field. Hey guys, a quick word from
- 30:55Early Riders. If you like concepts like
- 30:58Bitcoin is a hurdle rate, as well as following along with
- 31:01everything across Bitcoin infrastructure, Bitcoin startups
- 31:05today, I highly recommend you check out Early Riders and
- 31:08everything that we're doing there.
- 31:09We're putting out a ton of research, so please subscribe at
- 31:12earlyriders.com/research and please reach out if you're ever
- 31:16interested in how to get involved.
- 31:18Thanks. OK.
- 31:18Maybe wrapping up the show with one last question that's maybe
- 31:22on the boring side for us, but a little bit practical for
- 31:26business owners and operators. Let's let's pretend we're
- 31:28talking to one of these new merchants that has begun
- 31:31accepting Bitcoin as payment. Do they need to think about
- 31:34hiring the specialized CPA or tax attorney now that there's
- 31:38Bitcoin involved on their balance sheet and in their
- 31:40business? Or is it simple enough that the
- 31:42average CPA that they already use for their normal tax returns
- 31:47can kind of quickly get up to speed on best practices?
- 31:49How do you think they should treat it when tax season comes
- 31:52around? I'm happy to take this one.
- 31:54I think it's pretty straightforward and most Cpas,
- 31:58as long as they have even some understanding or willing to
- 32:02learn about Bitcoin, are able to do that.
- 32:05I mean, there are certainly some edge cases if you're like
- 32:08business on Noster accepting like a ton of, you know, notes
- 32:12like that and just like a ton of payments.
- 32:13I think that's like one that's a little bit different.
- 32:15But you know, and in general it's going to be 99.9% of
- 32:19businesses I think should just be able to use current tax
- 32:22people in order to help them just put their business as is.
- 32:27Yeah, I would take a little bit of a different lens in the sense
- 32:30of a lot of things in Bitcoin are relatively straightforward.
- 32:33The problem is that the market doesn't know that there's a lot
- 32:36of stigmas to them. So anything about inheritance,
- 32:38you can go to like a trust lawyer and a lot of them won't
- 32:41touch it. And our A's have historically
- 32:43been like this. There may be moving a little bit
- 32:44more into the middle, but I would imagine how a lot of Cpas
- 32:48would either feign like that. They can't touch it, they don't
- 32:51feel comfortable. They may build, you know,
- 32:53greater amounts. So I think like there are a
- 32:55number, the one that comes to mind is Satoshi Piccoli as an
- 32:59example of somebody you can reach out to and then get a good
- 33:02lens. So then you can even educate
- 33:03your CPA and reference them. There is some a little bit
- 33:06complexity in the sense of like, what are you accepting?
- 33:09Is it being converted? Is all of it being converted?
- 33:11And really it's the, the, the gain on that.
- 33:16And then if you're selling, it is really where you have to like
- 33:19manage it, right? Because if you accept Bitcoin
- 33:22and let's just say one Bitcoin, you sell a car or whatever and
- 33:25it's 100,000, the car's 100,000 will, if you accept the dollars,
- 33:28the dollars are just getting marked there versus if they're
- 33:30appreciating Bitcoin and it's 150,000 and then you're selling.
- 33:34We effectively have your cost basis you inherited at the time
- 33:37of the sell. And like that just requires some
- 33:39minutiae, but it's nothing that's unachievable, especially
- 33:41if the plan is to, to, to like buy and hold versus if it you're
- 33:48just taking it on the payment side that you're just like, you
- 33:50know, converting the dollars. Because I think a lot of these
- 33:52people may accept Bitcoin, I would imagine, and that's part
- 33:56of like the Square announcement until 2027.
- 33:59There's no interchange fees, there's no merchant fees.
- 34:02So if a lot of these people are like, hey, this is cool, but I'm
- 34:04going to convert it all to cash, then there really is no there
- 34:07should theoretically not be a big tax headache there.
- 34:11Yeah. And I would imagine with Square
- 34:13that they've got things like reporting and exporting
- 34:16accounting statements pretty well baked into the product at
- 34:18this point. So I think that's a wrap for
- 34:21today. I'll kick it around for maybe
- 34:23some closing thoughts on just what we saw in the past couple
- 34:26weeks. I'll, I'll go 1st and then Matt,
- 34:29I'll kick it over to you next. I just think we saw a lot of
- 34:31volatility in Bitcoin price action.
- 34:33But I want to remind, especially business owners who get maybe
- 34:38turned off by that level of volatility, that what you're
- 34:41actually seeing there is people who needed to access value,
- 34:45access economic wealth during a time when market hours were
- 34:49closed. And the only thing that was
- 34:51there for them in that moment was Bitcoin.
- 34:53And so yes, a Bitcoin was sold off.
- 34:55Bitcoin was able to come up with that economic value that those
- 34:58individuals needed, whether to meet margin calls or, or, you
- 35:01know, right size their plans for the next week.
- 35:03But that that is part of the value prop of Bitcoin is that it
- 35:07is liquid 24/7 and that is actually a very big positive.
- 35:12It will create near term volatility, but it's a huge
- 35:15positive for any business that kind of understands that we have
- 35:20really rocky, WAVY landscapes ahead.
- 35:24Yeah, Well said, Jason. I think it's important for us to
- 35:26highlight us on the call. Is that on Ramp just released On
- 35:31Ramp business, which allows business clients to go from
- 35:35consultation to a secured allocation in just days.
- 35:38And so this offering that we're releasing and we have released
- 35:42comes with multi institutional custody, enterprise controls, a
- 35:47proof of reserves and just a business native interface that
- 35:51we've worked really hard to put out for our clients and super
- 35:54excited to get this product out there.
- 35:56I'm not sure, Michael, if you had anything you wanted to say
- 35:59about the product, but we're super excited, especially in
- 36:02relation to this podcast to just begin taking on clients as we
- 36:06already have, but in official capacity as we've rolled out on
- 36:09ramp business. Hell yeah.
- 36:12I think when you get Matt Ball on the sales side, no, I
- 36:15appreciate the the call out there.
- 36:18And yeah, Matt was instrumental in getting this out.
- 36:20It's huge for a number of reasons.
- 36:22One is we've been we've been working in onboarding
- 36:24businesses, but the reality is there's additional controls that
- 36:26are needed. It's kind of crazy when you
- 36:28think about it for 15 years including the past year with
- 36:32funds, I think it's this past year 1.2 million Bitcoin, maybe
- 36:36more than the past year. But between pub Co's and the the
- 36:40ETF's are securing 1.2 million plus BTC and it's generally
- 36:44secure to the single custodian. And then generally those
- 36:47custodians don't really have enterprise grade control.
- 36:49So you may get one person, maybe multiple people, and then
- 36:53there's very little governance when it comes to how many people
- 36:56need to move it, which generally these exists in the traditional
- 36:58financial system when you think about moving of wires as an
- 37:01example in the amount of control that take place.
- 37:03So really excited about that. And I think it really stems from
- 37:06the entire conversation of we have a lot of podcasts and we do
- 37:10a lot of work. The reason we're here is because
- 37:12the importance of this, that it's really binary in the sense
- 37:15that if businesses, the backbone of any economy, don't protect
- 37:19their wealth, they're going to go out of business.
- 37:21And so it's a really important thing to just kind of do the
- 37:24diligence, look deeply, and then I think we're chase hit it
- 37:27earlier was about leverage. Leverage is just a kind of form
- 37:29of like cutting corners and not doing the work because reality
- 37:32is like bitcoins, enough leverage and enough risk.
- 37:34If you get it to size it appropriately and then park it
- 37:37and then deal with the volatility, which is never fun,
- 37:40but at least you've been educated to understand why
- 37:42structurally will go up into the right because of its monetary
- 37:45properties versus the easy way out is, oh, I want this, Maybe I
- 37:48can make a quick buck. And that's when people lose all
- 37:50their money and then they get like kind of burnt by the
- 37:53industry and they never come back.
- 37:54And so human nature is human nature.
- 37:57But ideally we can help with, you know, the former and then
- 37:59really get people doing it the right way.
- 38:01And as we build a bigger and bigger brand across all the
- 38:03portfolio companies will be understood as kind of like the
- 38:06folks that are helping people because it's just naturally the
- 38:09right thing to do. And if you do the right thing
- 38:10and provide value, you end up making money.
- 38:13Yeah, I'd just say, you know, despite any volatility, the
- 38:17debasement trade is well within the zeitgeist of public opinion.
- 38:21It's seeming like Bitcoin or gold almost went up like another
- 38:24100 bucks during this call. And Bitcoins, you know,
- 38:28certainly been a little bit more volatile just over the past few
- 38:31weeks, but just, you know, generally up and to the right
- 38:34over the long term. So it's just like Bitcoins not
- 38:37going away, hard assets aren't going away and you don't
- 38:39necessarily need to figure it out all today and the long term
- 38:44strategic plan to how to align yourself with, you know, the
- 38:48sound money and scarce assets. But it's a good thing to learn
- 38:51about because it's a it's going to be a great tool within your
- 38:54toolbox And you know, you're you're going to want to have it
- 38:58because you're sure that your competitors are trying to
- 39:01identify what these tools actually are in the same time as
- 39:04you. So it's valuable to do the work
- 39:07yourself as well. Yeah, well, well said gang.
- 39:10Thanks to everybody that tuned in to episode 3 of the Bitcoin
- 39:14for Businesses podcast. Please share this episode or any
- 39:17previous episode with a business owner, a founder, an
- 39:21entrepreneur that you want to protect from what is bound to be
- 39:26a lot of new monetary units coming in over the next decade.
- 39:29And if you want to protect them and their business and their
- 39:32family and and their employees and their employees families
- 39:35that they support, this is really a lot bigger than just
- 39:38making a buck. This is about making businesses
- 39:41sustainable over the next decade.
- 39:43So give us a like a share a subscribe and TuneIn for the
- 39:47next episode where you get to hear from folks like us that are
- 39:50actually builders and operators, Bitcoin space trying to pass
- 39:53down best practices to the next round of business operators
- 39:58coming in behind us. So thanks again.