Latest / new renaissance capital / On the Iran Conflict and Bitcoin in the Middle East w/ Faisal Saeed Al Mutar
Transcript
- 0:00From kind of a cultural standpoint, they don't really mind the volatility of Bitcoin.
- 0:05They will be like, you know what, I'm already used to my currency falling upon 80% and there
- 0:10has never been, like Bitcoin actually is far more stable. When people criticize Bitcoin is
- 0:15volatile, etc. It's exactly far more stable than many of these currencies and far more usable. You
- 0:21can just open a min wallet or any wallet that you want to use and so easy.
- 0:30Hey everybody, Frank here. Just a quick note before we get started with this episode.
- 0:34I'm aware that what's happening in Iran right now is both a sensitive and controversial topic.
- 0:40I have very mixed feelings about it and I'm covering it to personally gain a better understanding
- 0:44of what's happening in Iran and in the region more broadly. So please know that I'm coming
- 0:49to this from a place of curiosity more than anything else. That said, please note that
- 0:54this conversation was recorded before President Trump's completely insane Truth Social post on the
- 1:00morning of April 5th. I'd like to say here that I was ashamed to be an American when I read that
- 1:05post and that I vehemently disagree with Trump's stance on Iran. As far as my guest for this
- 1:12episode, Faisal Saeed Al-Muttar, he's an Iraqi-born Bitcoiner with very nuanced views on what's
- 1:19happening in Iran and the Middle East more broadly. And I'd like to note that he is also still working
- 1:24through what's going on right now so please afford him some grace that said if you like this sort of
- 1:31content content in which bitcoiners share what's happening in the region of the world that they're
- 1:36from please like and subscribe and leave a comment and or review i'd sincerely appreciate it and to
- 1:42show my gratitude i will send 1000 sats to the first 10 people who leave a comment and or review
- 1:48and then email me with proof of this as well as their LNURL.
- 1:54My email address is newrencap at gmail.com.
- 1:57That's N-E-W-R-E-N-C-A-P at gmail.com.
- 2:02I look forward to hearing from you.
- 2:04Okay, now let's get to the show.
- 2:06Here's my conversation with Faisal Saeed Al-Muttar.
- 2:10Welcome, everybody.
- 2:12Frank here, joined by a very special guest, Faisal Saeed Al-Muttar.
- 2:18a man who wears many hats.
- 2:21So Faisal is from Iraq originally.
- 2:23He's also a social entrepreneur and the founder and president of Ideas Beyond Borders,
- 2:27which is a platform that translates classical liberal thought throughout the Arab world.
- 2:32He's also the founder of an excellent sub-stack called Middle East Uncovered.
- 2:36And he also is a scholar at the Center for Governance and Markets at the University of Pittsburgh.
- 2:42I'm going to give the mic to Faisal in just one second to maybe fill in any gaps I may have missed in that introduction.
- 2:47But I wanted to say to the audience that I'm excited to have Faisal on, not just because he's from the region, because he's from Iraq and is familiar with what's happening on the ground right now concerning the Iran war and what's happening in countries around Iran right now.
- 3:02But oftentimes, I think whenever I see Faisal in person, he's always optimistic right now.
- 3:08And I've seen him posting certain things saying he's always optimistic in general.
- 3:12And I've seen him posting certain things right now saying things are kind of a little bit heavy.
- 3:17So I wanted to get a little bit of an idea of what's going on through his eyes.
- 3:21But before we do that, Faisal, please, if you wouldn't mind just introducing yourself a bit.
- 3:25And as I said, fill in anything I may have missed there.
- 3:29Sure. Thank you so much, Rakh. I was enjoying seeing you as well.
- 3:33You've always been very kind in giving not just me, but many others a platform to speak their minds.
- 3:40And I'm originally from Iraq, so I grew up after the first Gulf War.
- 3:46under the sanctions and the regime of Saddam Hussein,
- 3:51followed by the U.S. intervention in Iraq in 2003 and regime change,
- 3:55which probably we might touch on in this call,
- 3:58and really growing up in the civil war that happened as, to some extent,
- 4:04a result of the removal of the former regime.
- 4:09And in my kind of teenage years, I became outspoken,
- 4:13predominantly against extremist forces that wanted to divide the country.
- 4:19I ended up on a death list as a result of that, lost friends and family,
- 4:24jumped from different countries, eventually ended up in the United States as a refugee.
- 4:31And then within kind of months after I arrived in the United States,
- 4:36I started getting involved more closely, especially on the space on how to utilize technology,
- 4:44how to be able to kind of spread the values of freedom, utilizing some of the modern tools we have,
- 4:51and worked in a project funded by Google Ideas for the first couple of years
- 4:55until I started my organization, Ideas Beyond Borders, that does a lot of things.
- 5:01One of them is, of course, the translation, but more of a media platform for these ideas into the Arab world.
- 5:10Appreciate that. Thank you, Faisal.
- 5:12And speaking of technology, I know this is a podcast where we talk about Bitcoin.
- 5:17We will get to a Bitcoin towards the end right now, though.
- 5:19I think what I want is more what's happening in the world through the lens of someone.
- 5:24And, you know, I think what what a lot of people who are into Bitcoin, what they're maybe torn about here is that there are maybe people who don't agree with maybe the IRGC, the Islamic regime, because they're freedom maximalists.
- 5:35And then but at the same time, they're also anti-war, so they don't want to see U.S. intervention and causing issues.
- 5:41So I think that there are some people who are really torn right now.
- 5:44But before I get to that exact question, I just wanted to let you just want to ask if you might be able to give us a little bit of an overview of your perspective on what's happening right now.
- 5:52But then also, I think something you've done really well online is you've offered it through different perspectives.
- 5:57This is probably what Israel is seeing. This is what Iran is seeing.
- 6:00I think you have this ability to see things through multiple lenses.
- 6:03So if you could offer us that a little bit, I would greatly appreciate it.
- 6:07Of course. I mean, that's, I guess, one of also the benefits of speaking multiple languages is being able to follow the media in many of these countries.
- 6:16So really, I mean, my side of the story is that this has been going on for a very long time.
- 6:26And the question of, which is a very common thing in the Middle East, is that when do you start the clock?
- 6:34It's a region of 5,000 years old, and it has had multiple conquests and wars and civilizations that have existed all across this time.
- 6:45But for the sake of this conversation, especially the three parties that are involved in this war, which is Iran, United States and Israel, it started predominantly in 1979 when a man called Ayatollah Khomeini had taken over the regime, created a revolution, which is called the Iranian Revolution, but then it was pretty much hijacked by him and he called it the Islamic Revolution.
- 7:12And within the first weeks, he captured the U.S. embassy in Tehran and kind of declared from 1979 that the United States is the great enemy called the big Satan, followed by the small Satan, which is the state of Israel.
- 7:29And since then, every U.S. president started from Jimmy Carter, followed by Reagan, and then the Bush, Clintons, and the Bushes.
- 7:41Everyone has been kind of, well, that's all the Iran question.
- 7:46Everybody has been sucked to the Iranian question.
- 7:48that even if you, regardless whether you're an interventionist or you are from diplomacy,
- 7:54as what happened with President Obama with the GCPOA, except that it's called the Iran deal.
- 8:00So really, this has been going on for a long time, not as intense as it is in the past five weeks now,
- 8:08but there has always been some sort of any form of intervention, whether sanctions or proxy wars,
- 8:18across the region.
- 8:21So the interesting thing about this Pacific operation or war
- 8:28is that kind of the three players have very different objectives
- 8:34to some extent in how they are conducting this war.
- 8:38The Israeli side, which has kind of been the main advocate
- 8:42for this war itself,
- 8:45is that they are interested in kind of entire change of the regime
- 8:51and creating a country that is sympathetic to Israel
- 8:57and also a place that's not going to fire rockets
- 9:00and is not a threat to kind of Israeli interests.
- 9:03The U.S. side of the story is,
- 9:08especially within kind of the Trump formula of foreign policy,
- 9:12is that the standards are a bit lower,
- 9:17and the goal is that as long as we can have a regime
- 9:20that we can play with,
- 9:22as kind of what's happening right now in Venezuela,
- 9:24like finding an equivalent of kind of Delce Rodriguez in Caracas
- 9:32and try to find someone we can play a ball with inside Iran
- 9:37who can achieve some of the same objectives
- 9:40as somebody who is not going to be necessarily a threat to U.S. national security,
- 9:45but at the same time part of the establishment, for the lack of a better word.
- 9:51And because the establishment in this situation has been around for 47 years.
- 9:56So it's not a new regime.
- 9:58And I can explain kind of the dynamics of how this regime all operates,
- 10:03which are a bit kind of unique to Iran itself.
- 10:06And then the third player which is Islamic Republic or Iran itself and they have to some extent two objectives One is survival So that really part of the reason why they have been moved
- 10:22I would call it just the Iran-Israel-U.S. war.
- 10:26It's a regional war right now.
- 10:27And it might become more than regional war.
- 10:29So there's one part of survival.
- 10:31The second part is dominance, is that if they can prove that they are able to survive
- 10:37and be able to kind of teach America, quote-unquote, a lesson or teach Israel a lesson,
- 10:43then this could be the opportunity for them to really establish dominance over the entire region,
- 10:50particularly on other Gulf states, which are just next door to them,
- 10:55and kind of show that there is a new Boston town.
- 10:58This is really kind of the opportunity that they're seizing.
- 11:02So with these kind of—that's on kind of a big-picture country level.
- 11:07And then you get to start talking about the individuals between Donald Trump and Netanyahu and kind of the IRGC, whoever's taking leadership in Iran right now.
- 11:17And all of them also have their own personality, have their own interests, and sometimes their own egos.
- 11:22So it makes it very convoluted between people with very strong personalities and advanced weaponry, which makes kind of the opportunity for diplomacy or kind of peaceful resolution to be quite unlikely.
- 11:42Understood. Appreciate all of that.
- 11:44with all of this said, you know, as I said earlier, you tend to be optimistic. You tend to be
- 11:49looking for the bright side of things. But you said right now, this is sort of heavier. And I
- 11:54think you're probably in the middle of this because obviously you're a scholar. You're somebody who
- 11:58has a great understanding of this. You speak multiple languages, as you said. So I'm sure a
- 12:01lot of people are asking for your time. And again, we thank you for coming here to share it with us.
- 12:06But in your mind, what's the best possible outcome here? And what's the worst possible outcome?
- 12:14Well, that's itself is an interesting question on its own. It's all going to depend on your
- 12:27value proposition. And my value proposition is two things, is the freedom and stability. So
- 12:33these are the things that I'm looking for and I want to maximize. So from an ideological standpoint,
- 12:39That's where I come from.
- 12:41The Iranian regime, I mean, in its current form, has been pretty disastrous for the entire region.
- 12:51From 1979, their kind of revolutionary approach to things, not just against Israel, but against the entire Arab world,
- 13:02has really kind of added a very big layer of radicalization to the entire region.
- 13:08It's part of the reason why Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states and others start funding Islamic
- 13:15extremist schools to kind of push back against the Shia extremist schools from Iran.
- 13:22So really, that regime has been really bad news for many of us who actually have lived
- 13:30in the region.
- 13:31I saw you in the Bitcoin conference in Abu Dhabi, and I've been there afterwards.
- 13:38And you see that there's big attempts within the region to kind of move towards more prosperity,
- 13:44more especially on the economic side.
- 13:47And then there is kind of this bully next door called the Islamic Republic that has
- 13:53been a threat that is making it very harder for any of these countries to attract investors,
- 13:59attract capital, attract people to come.
- 14:02because everyone knows, as we are seeing right now in the news, Dubai is not that far away from Iran,
- 14:08and it can be threatened at any moment, and pretty much all your money can be gone.
- 14:13So in a way, this kind of regime has been really kind of a bad state in the region.
- 14:21Now, with the war, one silver lining is that many of these countries that are, for the most
- 14:32part, agree on the points of stability and prosperity are figuring out more need for
- 14:39unity within these countries, because there's been a lot of minor divisions that sometimes
- 14:43go out of proportion between many of these Gulf countries over sometimes really petty
- 14:49things.
- 14:50when there's ballistic missiles thrown at them, they're realizing there's a much better chance of us being united
- 14:56and build a more strong economy, strong military, strong everything.
- 15:00So that's really kind of an optimistic, but I think it's very good in the long run.
- 15:08In terms of, I mean, so that's really, I would say, the best outcome is that if the regime is either changed,
- 15:17changes, which is unlikely in my assessment, an assessment a lot of intel people, but a weakened
- 15:26regime is a pretty decent thing for the entire region. And it seems that the U.S. administration,
- 15:38meaning Donald Trump, the first day they gave this talk, there is a lot, of course,
- 15:43push for him to stop the war, because of the rising prices of oil.
- 15:48And for a reminder, the Middle East produces roughly 20-25% of the world energy.
- 15:54That's really been kind of the cornerstone of that region.
- 15:58And it seems to me that the US, the Massachusetts is really pushing to finish the job.
- 16:06of now stopping and then having the ability for the Iran regime to restore ability kind
- 16:14of quickly.
- 16:15So if that's the outcome, of course, the ultimate goal is that that can done with the minimum
- 16:21human costs possible.
- 16:25And if that happens, I mean, Trump said two to three weeks, I think that's pretty optimistic.
- 16:33It's really hard to weaken a regime of 47 years in two to three weeks or 47 days.
- 16:39I think you probably need much more than that.
- 16:42But I think that would be, in my opinion, the best outcome.
- 16:45The worst outcome is if the U.S. pulls out right now because then it means that's a signal to Iran that, okay, the U.S. is not going to follow through, and they're going to utilize that to really expand.
- 17:00I mean, the third, possibly maybe a better outcome is that maybe the United States should not have to interfere in the first place.
- 17:06But now, because we don't know yet the outcome, it's going to be great or bad.
- 17:13But if I have to choose between, I think the good choices would have been no intervention or finish the job and not what we have right now.
- 17:20Because it's in the middle of a war.
- 17:21And I think if the United States stops, then I think the repercussions are much higher or negative than both of these options.
- 17:30Oh, good. Yeah, I appreciate that perspective. Yeah, I think a lot of it, though, I think is going to have to do with whether or not the Strait of Hormuz gets opened. I think there's been a few different people saying like, look, we can talk about boots on the ground. We can talk about these attacks, who's been killed, who hasn't been killed. But it kind of doesn't matter because a lot of this conflict right now revolves around the fact that Iran is basically cutting this artery off from blood flow right now. And it's a huge issue for the world.
- 17:55We're seeing it greatly affect Southeast Asia right now. It's eventually going to come to affect the United States. But the bigger issue there is that as it's affecting Southeast Asia, as it's affecting other allies of the United States around the world, they're going to be getting mad at the United States that basically one of the effects of this war is the strait being closed.
- 18:14So do you feel like the strait has to be open before this is done? And is there any way to peacefully negotiate that?
- 18:25So, I mean, I think that is what the regime wants the war to be centered on.
- 18:33I mean, in a way, holding the kind of the Strait of Hormuz hostage is against most norms of international waters agreements, free trade agreements, etc., because they actually don't own that water.
- 18:48I mean, these are international waters in which any ship from any country, including non-U.S. allies, can operate from.
- 18:56So that, I think, shows to some extent how much of a bully this regime is.
- 19:06And they're willing to starve the entire world of energy, and especially the sometimes called the global south of the developed world.
- 19:15they're dependent on day-to-day when it comes to energy.
- 19:20They're not like countries like Canada or the United States
- 19:23and others which have massive high production of oil.
- 19:26So the way the United States is the least affected,
- 19:28even though there are some who are now seeing that the price of gasoline in the U.S.
- 19:33has increased as well, I think 20% so far.
- 19:35So the United States, it will come to the pockets of the middle class very soon,
- 19:42But it's not consequential as it is in countries like Sri Lanka or the Philippines, where now they're talking about canceling most of their flights, shutting down some of the airports.
- 19:54And because many of their airlines cannot have fuel, their supply chains are all disrupted.
- 20:00So they're suffering quite a lot.
- 20:02And and that could have, I mean, two two things is that either these countries will be like, OK, we didn't want this war, but we have to do something to the side of hormones because we're we're being suffocated now.
- 20:17That's one outcome.
- 20:20And the other outcome is, of course, blaming the United States and saying that Trump shouldn't
- 20:24have done this and kind of directing the energy which is also possible especially among kind of European allies or European friends or in some cases because Trump has just largely insulted them for the past couple of years with saying that he going to take Greenland and say that he going to send the U military into Europe and take some of their territory which in a way is that for them is like hey in this Davos we talking about U military taking over a recognized part of Denmark
- 20:57And now you're asking us to use our military to open up the Strait of Hormuz.
- 21:02I think there might be a bit difficulty convincing the Europeans that this is in their interest.
- 21:08But I think I have a feeling that if Trump continues the war and the situation continues as it is with the closure of the strait,
- 21:17I think they will be forced to interfere.
- 21:20because also Europe, especially since the Russian invasion of Ukraine, has been struggling with energy prices.
- 21:27I think some of my friends in Berlin have been talking about electricity prices.
- 21:32Monthly fees have rose up by 400, 500 euros.
- 21:37So a lot of people, Europe has been struggling with energy since the Russian invasion.
- 21:42And now they have another blow coming from the Middle East not being able to.
- 21:47So I think that there might be, it's not like they like it, but I think they might probably be forced to try to open it.
- 21:57And it's not an easy, for those who may not be familiar with that, I mean, this is one of the most important straits,
- 22:04it's not the most important straits in the world, and it's extremely narrow, but the terrains, especially on the Iranian side, are extremely difficult.
- 22:12So it's very mountainous. There's a lot of mountains, a lot of. So it's not really an easy area to take over.
- 22:20It's it's and this is the IRGC and kind of this is an army or militia to some extent that has been trained on civil wars and trained on kind of domestic kind of conflicts.
- 22:36So they have really mastered this kind of that we're not talking about the pirates of Somalia or pirates of Yemen, etc.
- 22:45These are far more sophisticated, military trained militia that has been that has kind of seen that straight or controlled it for 47 years.
- 22:58So they know all the ins and outs that they know when to escape.
- 23:01And now they're utilizing, of course, many of most of this cheap technology that it's really not that, I mean, they have noticed that it's not really not that difficult to do it.
- 23:11You just need a couple of what they call Shahada drones that are kind of cheap.
- 23:15You build up some mines that are also they are able to do on kind of mass production rate.
- 23:22And it's also a country of 92 million.
- 23:25The question about how many people are sympathetic or not is always a very big question.
- 23:30but they do have the human population to sustain kind of a constant conflict.
- 23:37They have the cheap technology, and then they have the terrain on their side.
- 23:41So the opening of that is not as easy as many people think.
- 23:48It's kind of because of just pure geography
- 23:52and the fact that the geology of that area is not a desert.
- 23:57I know that a lot of people, their immediate thought about when they hear the Middle East is that they think it's just a Western Sahara with open land and you can see everything.
- 24:08But that's not the case in that part of the region.
- 24:13Would you say it's more comparable to maybe something like Afghanistan, more mountainous, whereas also the people are sort of trained to fight on that terrain?
- 24:20Yeah, so it's more like that.
- 24:23The interesting part, which also might be surprising to your audience, is that a significant part of the population of that area is ethnically Arab.
- 24:37So that's something that there's a lot of misconceptions about Iran as a nation is that especially now you hear kind of some of the rhetoric from people like Ted Cruz or even Michael, for the Republican.
- 24:49And they immediately say, well, Iran is Persian.
- 24:52Now, you really think, oh, Iran is a Persian country, but that's actually not true.
- 24:56Iran is a multi-ethnic.
- 24:58I mean, technically, Iran is a country that colonized a lot of areas, and that, what we
- 25:04now know as Iran, is a kind of the consolidation of all these controls.
- 25:10So the area that is within that, and that's, I think, what also some of the administration
- 25:15and others are looking at, is that these are ethnic groups that, to some extent, are very
- 25:20dissatisfied with the regime.
- 25:23So that could be, I guess, is a player in that space is that there might be or maybe
- 25:31need to be external support to kind of create change from the ethnic groups which are familiar
- 25:37with that terrain.
- 25:39That is kind of difficult, more, much easier than sending boots on the ground.
- 25:45and also it is the area with the largest oil reserves for Iran.
- 25:52So there's kind of a lot going on there
- 25:55and there's a lot of options that could be activated
- 26:00and if that happens, then we might wake up in a different reality
- 26:07and depending, of course, that nothing in the Middle East goes straight forward.
- 26:12so there won't be a lot of complications but that's definitely one option that i think worth
- 26:18looking at okay appreciate it also just a quick question we don't get too far into this do you
- 26:22think that given what happened in venezuela how quick smooth you know that operation was sort of
- 26:27like it took 20 minutes it was done maduro was in brooklyn hours after they captured him do you
- 26:32think that trump sort of had like a hot hand mentality like oh we just did this there this
- 26:36will be just as easy we're going to go do this in iran we have good intelligence we're going to drop
- 26:41this bomb we're going to kill this leader and then this will all be done within maybe not the exact
- 26:45amount of time that the maduro situation was done but maybe something sort of comparable in his mind
- 26:50do you think he was suffering from maybe that sort of hot hand fallacy sort of thing well i hope not
- 26:55uh so i i uh i wrote this because sometimes and and i mean even like sometimes the human rights
- 27:04circles and and sometimes always this common area is like well iran and venezuela they're
- 27:11both authoritarian, therefore they're the same. And I said, except that they speak a different
- 27:15language, they follow a different religion, they have a completely different geography,
- 27:19and a completely different history, and one of them never had a democracy, which is Iran.
- 27:23So they actually have nothing in common,
- 27:26other than the fact that, yes, the Maduro regime and the
- 27:30Iranian regime have been allies in kind of this
- 27:34anti-imperialist alliance, if you want to call it,
- 27:38It was sometimes called the axis of resistance or axis of anti-imperial resistance.
- 27:43And that's in a way like a loose alliance.
- 27:47It's not as I mean, we have seen that if they get busy somewhere else, like, for example,
- 27:52Russia is busy with Ukraine, they kind of they ignore their other bodies.
- 27:57So. So, yes, I hope that he didn't get excited thinking that this is another.
- 28:02and that's I think it's
- 28:05I think extremely
- 28:07important
- 28:09thing to understand about
- 28:11the Middle East compared to Latin America
- 28:13is that and that explains
- 28:15to a large extent why the Iraq war
- 28:17failed, why Afghanistan
- 28:19failed to a large extent
- 28:21and it's hard to kind of get people wrapping around
- 28:23this but the Middle East
- 28:25never had a democracy
- 28:27it never really had the concept
- 28:29of democracy
- 28:30It's a different, I mean, it's, and I'm not looking necessarily of like, oh, democracy is better or monarchies are worse or any of that.
- 28:38But just from kind of a cultural standpoint, and the region has existed in 5,000 years.
- 28:45So it's pretty old.
- 28:47The first writing in the world is in Sumeria and in southern Iraq.
- 28:51You can go and see the first law, the first constitution.
- 28:54and from all of the history of that region,
- 28:59the first writing was really about establishing laws.
- 29:05So the Middle East is a very pro-order.
- 29:09It's less culturally, it's a more collectivist.
- 29:12And I'm not necessarily being more relativist here,
- 29:14but it's just I acknowledge that some cultures are different than others.
- 29:19And Venezuela and Iran are very different in that regard.
- 29:21And it's, I mean, some, I think Felix Malteaga, one of the most known, I mean, mentioned that, like, for example, Latin America has the Judeo-Christian connection to the United States and has kind of like, Latin America is not that different from the West because they are, to some extent, are connected to the West.
- 29:44I mean, they are also a continuation to some extent of Spanish control of the.
- 29:49So that is very different than, let's say, the Arab empire, the Persian empire.
- 29:56So I hope he didn't get these two things mixed up.
- 30:01And that is a point that Marco Rubio, the secretary of state, has made multiple times during the intervention in Venezuela.
- 30:11and he said that, well, Venezuelans are very different than the Middle East.
- 30:16So we expect that.
- 30:18We expect that there is going to be a bit easier operation
- 30:20because we're still dealing with a country that is, to some extent, sympathetic
- 30:25and doesn't see things like, for example, from the Iranian perspective,
- 30:30they see this as a holy war.
- 30:31So they see this entire operation, Operation Epic Fury, the United States side.
- 30:36They see it as a holy war against Shia Islam and against Islam.
- 30:40and watching Iranian media and watching some of the commentators they have from there,
- 30:46their commentary is all about no matter what ethnic group you are no matter where you from this is a holy war If you want to defend your religion this is your best time to do it because our religion is under attack not as a nation under attack
- 31:02And the leader of Iran, who is the Ayatollah, the title of that technically translates to the representative of God on earth.
- 31:13So that is what Ayatollah means.
- 31:14So United States technically killed what some people think is the representative of God on earth.
- 31:20And I think that's like the pope of the of the of the Islamic faith of Shia Islam.
- 31:25Yes. So and that is quite different than the title of Maduro.
- 31:30I don't think I don't know enough about Maduro, but I don't think he claimed to be the representative of the Catholic or any religion in that regard.
- 31:38But so that makes these distinctions, I think, better a lot, especially now with the Trump announcement that he wants to kind of continue and extend the war for the at least next couple of weeks.
- 31:51I think these distinctions are very important to know.
- 31:53Yeah, I appreciate all that. Thank you.
- 31:55One of the things I want to comment on some of the words you've used, you've talked about Iran sort of being bullies in the region.
- 32:01We've also talked about this misconception that, you know, the Islamic dream took over what was once Persia.
- 32:07It was only Persia filled with Persians.
- 32:09And, you know, just in the last 50 years, it's changed drastically when the reality is a bit different than that.
- 32:17But one of the things that has been sort of I've been sitting with and trying to figure out how I feel about, you know,
- 32:22something that's almost been haunting me a bit is that I very much I can hear where the Masa Alinejads are coming from.
- 32:28So Masa Al-Najad, I think it was Khomeini himself or the IRGC, tried to kill her three times, one time here on U.S. soil, which is quite wild to think about.
- 32:37Multiple times on U.S. soil, yeah.
- 32:39Multiple times on U.S. soil.
- 32:41And then we had Zia Saad on this podcast.
- 32:44We had him on a few guests ago.
- 32:46He was detained by the IRGC.
- 32:48He was imprisoned by the IRGC for two years.
- 32:50He was the lead Bitcoin educator in the country.
- 32:52and he talked about the desperation that the in his words i think he was saying like that the
- 32:57majority of iranians feel and i think on a certain level we saw in social media we saw the the women
- 33:03burning lighting cigarettes burning pictures of khameini and stuff and so i don't the thing about
- 33:09social media is that we're all in these bubbles we're all following these people who basically
- 33:13feed our own biases how many people do you think are sympathetic how many iranians do you think
- 33:19would like to see the regime not be in charge anymore?
- 33:23So that is definitely the million-dollar question
- 33:27as an observer in that part of the world.
- 33:33And here's, I would say, I will add the kind of layers and the nuances.
- 33:36As somebody who I've witnessed a regime change in front of my eyes
- 33:40with the U.S. intervention in Iraq,
- 33:42so there is
- 33:44kind of the
- 33:46there is disliking the regime
- 33:48that is one
- 33:50side of the story
- 33:51the other side of the story is whether you are
- 33:54willing to work with a foreign invader
- 33:56against the regime you dislike
- 33:57so there is a very multiple
- 34:00layers of
- 34:01disliking the regime
- 34:03it's like kind of
- 34:04when somebody kind of disliked their family
- 34:08and then they would be
- 34:10willing to be adopted
- 34:11So there's multiple layers of the action that people are willing to take as a result of that feeling or that emotion.
- 34:23So that, I think, is a struggle.
- 34:26And here's what I kind of struggle with, because it's hard to talk about the Middle East without talking about religion.
- 34:33Religion and religion, to a large extent, are very intertwined for a lot of different reasons.
- 34:39And as many of us who have grew up in the region and studied in the region, I mean, one of the first things that we get taught in most of the schools in the Middle East is looking at Israel as a colonial kind of state, Jewish state that is an enemy of the entire Muslim world.
- 35:01and their existence is kind of a cancer to the region.
- 35:06And that is a view, I would say, is shared maybe at least by 80, 90 percent of the population of the region.
- 35:15And if anybody can deny that, please, I would like them to show me the evidence of that not being the case.
- 35:22So it is hard for me to believe that, let's say, an Iranian who is kind of grew up in a Muslim society, Muslim schools, etc., who may be completely dissatisfied with the country would be like, my salary is gone.
- 35:39I'm no longer middle class.
- 35:41I'm struggling.
- 35:42My currency collapsed.
- 35:44I don't have a job.
- 35:45So that's that.
- 35:47I'm very sure that's a very common sentiment because the currency has collapsed.
- 35:51the economy has collapsed. I mean, there are so many things that have really made it
- 35:56absolutely impossible for, let's say, the normies, the people who are not necessarily political or
- 36:03ideological, but certainly. Sorry. Yeah. Could I just want to I just want to touch on that point
- 36:08for a second, just for people to understand. Sometimes people, if you're just following the
- 36:12mainstream media on this, you're thinking that what's happening in Iran is just women being
- 36:17upset because they have to wear hijabs. And maybe that's part of it. Maybe certain people who don't
- 36:21want to live. That's the former podcast. Yeah, the former. But the other side of things, as one of
- 36:26the guests on this podcast recently explained to us, is that Iran has seen currency debasement that
- 36:31has been horrific. And most recently, right before this started, I think there was a 50 percent drop
- 36:36in the value of the fiat currency in Iran. I'm sorry, I'm forgetting the name of that currency
- 36:40off the top of my head. But real, the real. So getting by in Iran has been very, very difficult
- 36:46as a result of the leadership, the decisions that have been made over the last five decades,
- 36:50probably in the last decade or two, even more so than the last five decades at large.
- 36:55So I think that that's it. I wanted to harp on this because I think people think this is just
- 36:59about religious struggle or that. For the normies, as you said, for certain people, it's just, hey,
- 37:03it's really difficult to pay my bills here. How is that possible when I live in an oil-rich country?
- 37:08How is that possible to know that the regime is siphoning these resources off to do whatever
- 37:12they're doing with the money when I'm really struggling to pay for food and to get by right
- 37:16now. So I think that that's part of the tension that most people don't understand. I didn't mean
- 37:20to interrupt you. I just wanted to clarify that point. No, and you explained it perfectly. I mean,
- 37:24and in addition to that is that they see the countries next door. They go to Dubai. Many
- 37:32Iranians have been to Dubai. The relatives have been to Dubai. And they see skyscrapers and good
- 37:37economy and investors and businesses. And so there is I think that's a pretty common sentiment.
- 37:44So that's that's I would say that the dislike of the regime. So so there is a there's two.
- 37:50That's the other. So there's just like a name. Then the second layer is is we're willing to work
- 37:55with a foreign country that is kind of disliked predominantly by a lot of people in the region
- 38:01against that regime. And then there is the other element, which is kind of the, there's
- 38:10no organizational structure of the opposition. That's an entire, I can give you, give a 20
- 38:16hour lectures on how, how opposition movements work in the region. So, and so all of these
- 38:22things have to really coincide for things to change.
- 38:29And there hasn't been any kind of significance that thing about kind of defections within
- 38:37the regime or so if that kind of and I recommend people to write to read my article about kind
- 38:44of regime change in the in the region of kind of how public sentiment works in terms of
- 38:49changing the regime or not.
- 38:51And I mean, the main thing for the regime to be toppled is whether the people who are
- 38:55loyal to it and the people who have got the guns are willing to give up power.
- 38:59That's really the standard.
- 39:01That's when the regimes actually fall.
- 39:03So far, even with all this bombardment, there has not been any kind of defections.
- 39:09And so, yeah, it's hard to which I think why the Trump administration has kind of lowered
- 39:16their expectations is instead of I mean, he did mention here and there, like people go
- 39:23take over your buildings and and some of these things.
- 39:26But Marco Rubio, who I listen to more because I understand the language he speaks more than
- 39:33I understand Trump's language.
- 39:35He said that the goal is not kind of regime change and kind of just weakening the regime.
- 39:40And yeah, so so and I think that's that's likely even.
- 39:46So we'll have like a population that still hates its regime, but maybe not enough to that they're willing to overthrow it.
- 39:55Understood. For if let's just say theoretically there is let's just say there's a support, 51 percent support for something.
- 40:03Again, as you said, it's complicated, but for people who want to see the regime overthrown and to also side with maybe a side that they don't agree with, you know, the United States, even Israel, in the case of some people that I've spoken with.
- 40:14So to say, like, I'll just take anything to change the situation here in Iraq.
- 40:19I'm curious. I'm sorry, in Iran. I'm curious as to how you would think about that.
- 40:22So you you ascribe to very much the Western tradition of liberal thought.
- 40:27But, you know, the U.S. has a conflicted history. Imperialism is a real thing.
- 40:31U.S. interventionism gone wrong is a very real thing.
- 40:34So when it comes to this, as somebody who believes in a certain level of personal freedom, how do you how would you reconcile that?
- 40:41How do you reconcile the idea that, so I'll contextualize this a little bit differently.
- 40:45I recently spoke with two Cubans and I said to them straight up, I said, I'm sure that you're watching what just happened in Venezuela.
- 40:52I'm sure you're watching what's happening in Iran.
- 40:54And then the likes of Rubio and Trump saying, maybe Cuba's next.
- 40:57And they're like, we don't care.
- 40:58We just want to see anything change there.
- 41:01We can't do it on our own.
- 41:04There's nothing left for us to do.
- 41:06Do we want that to be the case?
- 41:07Do we want it to be the US?
- 41:08No, we do not want that. But on a certain level, how do you look at it when it comes to the idea of freedom?
- 41:14If the people there are not going to have a certain degree of freedom, and let's just say theoretically 51 percent want that degree of freedom,
- 41:21and the only way for that to happen is for an entity like the United States to get involved, how do you reconcile that?
- 41:27So, I totally agree with your Cuban guess is that, I mean, in reality, the regime is
- 41:38too brutal to be kind of dealt with from a civilian level.
- 41:44And to be fair, I mean, many of the Iranians have tried most of it in the latest protest
- 41:50in a couple of months ago, a couple before this war.
- 41:54And the immediate response from the regime is really just mass slaughter.
- 41:59And nobody knows until today how many people were killed.
- 42:03I mean, there is the reports of 15,000.
- 42:06Trump measured 45,000.
- 42:07I think that's a bit of a jump from some of the numbers of the human rights groups are saying.
- 42:11But it is really extremely difficult for civilians to do the heavy lifting of trying to overthrow the regime, knowing that the costs are extremely high.
- 42:27So I understand why kind of violence could actually become a reason why people don't do something.
- 42:36But again, the thing that I am kind of stuck with and the way that I kind of deal, I've been dealing with this war is really try to ask as many questions as possible.
- 42:51Because always kind of challenge my own biases, including the bias that I sometimes have is that there is that kind of urge for people to be free.
- 43:02that there is kind of this internal DNA within us
- 43:07that regardless of what culture we are, what background we are,
- 43:11eventually we just want to have a good life and be free.
- 43:15So I always like to kind of challenge that assumption that I have
- 43:19because it's not necessarily, I mean, and even in my case,
- 43:28when you mentioned that I'm kind of a big fan of Western kind of literature,
- 43:32in particular, the classical liberal.
- 43:35I'm also very aware that many people in my country are also not classical liberals.
- 43:41And even in my new country of United States, classical liberalism is not necessarily the
- 43:48most common belief system that exists.
- 43:51I mean, I lived in New York, and so do you.
- 43:53I'm very sure you go to a lot of cafes and bars and restaurants, and you ask about classical
- 43:59liberalism.
- 43:59I mean, our mayor is Zahar Mugnani.
- 44:03Talk about the warmth of collectivism here with our mayor.
- 44:06So, yeah.
- 44:08Exactly.
- 44:09So our mayor talked about the warmth of collectivism and he got elected.
- 44:13So it shows that, like, really the kind of the classical liberal landscape is not as big as we would like it to be.
- 44:24So, with that in mind, because of the fact that the Internet is shut down in Iran, thank
- 44:37goodness, because we're a neighboring country, we have the ability to talk to them quite a
- 44:40lot and be familiar with what they come to us sometimes.
- 44:46They come to Iraq for Internet connection, and that's one of the ways where they have
- 44:51accessibility and really have had all types of conversations.
- 44:58And you mentioned something very interesting about the kind of the silos that we have.
- 45:03So the Iranian migrants or diaspora that come to the US are predominantly people who have
- 45:10escaped the revolution.
- 45:11So this is by default, our self selection of people, right?
- 45:16It's like you come to Los Angeles or other places because you have escaped that part
- 45:20of the world. And then kind of like when you are from small town, there are who moved to
- 45:25the big city. There are people who stayed in the small town and there's and there is
- 45:28a reason why they sit in the small town. And those people who stayed in the small town
- 45:32come to Iraq. So these are the people who come because Iraq has the religious holy sites
- 45:37of Shia Islam. So the Iranians come to us in millions every year, too. And then you're
- 45:43going to meet the other side of the kind of the Iranian population. And I wrote about it
- 45:48It's called the tale of the two Irans.
- 45:50There's the Iran that I grew up with, and there's the Iran that I saw when I moved to America.
- 45:55And they are a pretty different type of people.
- 45:58In a way, one thing that I've also been kind of questioning is how some of these people can even live together.
- 46:08They are so different in terms of kind of mindsets and belief system.
- 46:14and because many of those who come to Iraq are people who are, to some extent, sympathetic to the regime.
- 46:20I mean, and they believe that he's the representative of God on earth.
- 46:25They believe in all of the spiel of what's called Wulayat al-Faqiyah, which is the regime in Iran.
- 46:31And then you come to Los Angeles and you see that many of them are, if not atheists, they're secular.
- 46:39So it's predominantly more non-religious in its kind.
- 46:42And it's really hard to kind of sequer how these people can coexist.
- 46:53And the closest example I can think of, which is an original example, is Tunisia after the Arab Spring.
- 47:00So Tunisia is one of those very interesting countries in which they have an extremely secular population, an extremely Islamist population.
- 47:10Tunisia has one of the highest ISIS recruitment of North Africa.
- 47:15So on one hand, they have a lot of ISIS.
- 47:18On the other hand, they have a lot of secular people.
- 47:20And I think the closest I can think of is Iran.
- 47:24They probably have these two kind of conflicting...
- 47:29They don't necessarily have a center.
- 47:31They have people who despise the regime, and they have people who love the regime.
- 47:36And there is kind of very little in between.
- 47:38And that's one assumption.
- 47:42I'm sure that some of the audience might, especially from that, might disagree with
- 47:45that.
- 47:46And ignoring of course all the ethnic deficiencies and the Kurds versus the Baluches versus the Arabs And one other interesting thing is that that another ethnic kind of
- 47:58When you talk to the Persians, they will tell you,
- 48:01well, everybody is happy to be part of Iran.
- 48:03Like they all want to be part with Persians,
- 48:05except when you talk to non-Persians.
- 48:07So when you talk to Kurds, when you talk to Arabs, when you talk to Baluchis,
- 48:13none of them want to be part of the Persian...
- 48:17the person will be like, no, many of the Kurds in Iran are very integrated
- 48:20and they love being part of Iran.
- 48:22And then I go talk to Kurds and they're like, no, we hate that country.
- 48:26I'm like, okay, what do you guys want me to believe?
- 48:30Like, should I believe this person?
- 48:31Should I believe this person?
- 48:32And it's possible that both of them are true, right?
- 48:34It's possible that, yes, there's, like, many of these societies
- 48:37are polarized and conflicted and they don't necessarily have a cohesive
- 48:43a framework of beliefs. And so it's going to be kind of interesting how Trump will pull
- 48:53it out. But I think I mean, back to the positive note, everything will be better if the regime
- 48:59is weaker. Now, if this regime is just continuing to massacre every protester and continue its
- 49:07aggression against the region, then it's only going to deteriorate. So at least this could
- 49:13open up a window of opportunity that whether it's the Iranians sees it or the rest of the region
- 49:20sees that opportunity, then I think it's a really, at least America has given it a shot.
- 49:31Okay. So in your mind, it's not all or nothing. It's not that the regime is either gone or it's
- 49:35full straight. There is a middle ground of like the regime just didn't have the power that it once
- 49:38had, and there's a benefit to that in your mind?
- 49:42Yeah, definitely.
- 49:44Yeah, because it's, again, it's like in the Middle East, it's never a straight line.
- 49:50And I think that if, I mean, of course, all can happen, what happens afterwards, when
- 49:59after the regime gets weakened.
- 50:00But I think that at least it's better than having a strong, brutal regime, a weaker,
- 50:08regime. So I think that could be common sense for a lot of people.
- 50:13Okay. Understood. I want to be mindful of your time, but I just had one last thing I wanted to
- 50:17touch on. You and Afghani tech entrepreneur Roya Mahbub wrote an excellent piece this past December
- 50:23called What Bitcoin Reveals About State Failure in the Middle East. This was for your sub stack.
- 50:28Again, we'll mention that at the end. We'll let everybody know where to go to subscribe. You can
- 50:32also check for it in the show notes. I will be sure to include it. But you talked about the
- 50:36situation in Afghanistan and Iraq and Lebanon. Lebanon, I think a lot of people know 98%
- 50:41currency, most of the currency has lost its value. In Afghanistan, the work that Roya does
- 50:47in paying teachers who educate women who otherwise cannot be educated, paying them in Bitcoin,
- 50:53tremendous effect on the region. So beyond a little bit about what's happening with the war here,
- 50:59given that we do predominantly focus on Bitcoin here, cross-section of Bitcoin culture,
- 51:03current events, all that stuff. Could you give us a little bit of an overview of Bitcoin in the
- 51:07Middle East, but not that you would do this, but not from a cheerleading perspective. A lot of
- 51:12Bitcoiners, I think, there's a world that they've imagined that Bitcoin is going to create. They
- 51:17think we already live in it. And so I think a realistic perspective, what problems does Bitcoin
- 51:20actually solve? What does it not solve? How are people actually using it? So there are kind of
- 51:29multiple use cases and it's all going to depend on the kind of the socioeconomics of many of these
- 51:37countries. You have the most adoption is available in the Gulf region and they as a finance hubs
- 51:46that is predominantly connecting the entire world. I mean, you've been to Dubai and you see
- 51:53people from Congo all the way to Russia to China to Japan all of them buying a property in Dubai
- 52:03all of them are investing in Dubai and kind of Bitcoin in a way is is an alternative to some
- 52:09extent the swift system in which many of the people are transfer money because if you are
- 52:14sending money from let's say Russia which is sanctioned or places that are not not have advanced
- 52:21best structures. This is Bitcoin and kind of generally the blockchain technology is being
- 52:27utilized kind of significantly. And that's why you see them hosting events about Bitcoin,
- 52:33conferences about Bitcoin, etc. Because they are a global hub and for the global hub of finance.
- 52:40So then, so they're kind of the rich ones. So there are the different socioeconomics. Then you
- 52:44have the Iraqis where I'm from, where we have extremely archaic business infrastructure
- 52:53or banking infrastructure.
- 52:55We're not on a swift and it's a predominantly cash-based society.
- 53:00And so, and with a very large diaspora.
- 53:04So then, as a result of like four wars in a row.
- 53:07So, so then comes in the people of like, okay, I live in Germany and I want to sit
- 53:14money to my cousin and then what Iraqis have built is kind of what I call the human ATMs so these are
- 53:22people that who want to buy Bitcoin but again cannot buy it because they don't they cannot go
- 53:28on exchange or so it's not easy for them to buy Bitcoin so what they do is that they became Bitcoin
- 53:33traders of people who are sending money from overseas and that would be the P2P they have
- 53:39cash, you go to them in order for the instead of them going on Coinbase and buy Bitcoin or anywhere,
- 53:44like they would just get it from somebody who getting money from Germany or from the US. So
- 53:50that is like a very common use cases. And people find this human ATMs, common human ATMs, like
- 53:55on Telegram groups, WhatsApp groups, signal groups, and which are kind of for different purposes. Like
- 54:01if someone is, let's say, is a political activist or opposition, they have kind of their own
- 54:07ecosystem of Bitcoin. These are kind of the more political types that have like very different
- 54:14even security infrastructure of what these people need to transfer the Bitcoin, how they interact
- 54:20with each other, in many cases anonymous. But then there are the people who are like right up in the
- 54:24open, which is like, hi, I'm going to be at this supermarket standing there. And if you want to
- 54:30give me Bitcoin just this I guess use your wallet Similar because that kind of Iraq which again it like it not a finance hub It not trying to have any foreign investors nothing
- 54:42It's just really diaspora sending money to back home.
- 54:46And generally, the interesting thing about Iraq, and that's probably what your audience
- 54:51knows, is that our oil sales are actually managed by the US government.
- 54:56So as a part of the Iraq war, when Iraq sells its oil, the money actually goes to New York
- 55:02Federal Reserve. It doesn't go to Iraq. And part of the reason why that happens with that
- 55:07the case, at least from the American side, is to keep the currency stable. So our currency
- 55:10is a bit different than Lebanon and stuff because it's hashed to the US dollars, got
- 55:14to pick the US dollar and also back to the oil. So it kind of makes it we don't have
- 55:18this like fluctuation of 80 percent losing the currency. We don't have that. But that's
- 55:23where Lebanon comes in. So part of the reason why like Lebanon kind of spread the Bitcoin
- 55:29also ideas and we have we know a lot of people use it is that from kind of a cultural standpoint
- 55:35they don't really mind the volatility of bitcoin they they will be like you know what i'm already
- 55:40used to my currency falling upon 80 percent and there has never been like bitcoin actually is far
- 55:45more stable and when people criticize oh bitcoin is volatile etc it's exactly far more stable than
- 55:52many of these currencies and far more usable you can just open a man wallet or any wallet that you
- 55:57want to use and so easy and and many people are hooked to to some extent a good internet not
- 56:02necessarily a perfect internet so so that's where kind of the the Lebanese they some of them just
- 56:09see it as a an investment mechanism it's like if especially those who are like middle class to
- 56:14upper middle class that some of the people I know who experienced putting their money in a Lebanese
- 56:21bank account and then waking up and saying they cannot withdraw any of the money like that's the
- 56:27situation in lebanon for for many years almost a decade now that in some in weeks you can only
- 56:33withdraw like 200 from the atm and some other weeks no you cannot withdraw from the atm so a lot
- 56:39of people have lost access to their money and they have lost the entire value of their money so they
- 56:46start looking at at bitcoin as a way to release like save up your your money like and and and and
- 56:55that way so really it's it's uh uh and and the same example the same example i said about saving
- 57:02the money is also applies in turkey because turkey has also had a lot of fluctuations with the with
- 57:07the currency so it's really every kind of country based on its own socioeconomics has really have
- 57:15developed a different use case.
- 57:19And that's generally like there's that
- 57:22and the second most adopted
- 57:25or same numbers is kind of the tether
- 57:28and the digital dollar
- 57:29because people don't have access
- 57:32to kind of the usual backing infrastructures
- 57:35or credit cards.
- 57:35So this is a bit something to some people,
- 57:38especially older kind of generation,
- 57:40they know the dollar.
- 57:41They're like, we're just going to use digital dollar
- 57:43and call it a night.
- 57:44So that's really kind of how it's used.
- 57:48And the article, Mia Royer, it focuses more on like the non-advanced economies, like not on the UAE and others, but more on the places where kind of the currency either collapsed or like there's, and that's where Bitcoin is being like really like an underground infrastructure of finance that gave access to so many people to this kind of money.
- 58:11Yeah, 100%. Yeah. And I appreciated that you highlighted that. I think a lot of people, especially I give you a lot of credit because I know that you're involved in academic circles and working with people in think tanks and stuff. And I think still oftentimes in that sort of ivory tower world, there's a little bit of like, oh, Bitcoin, we don't need to pay attention to that.
- 58:29So I think that your speaking to its value actually has a really it does it.
- 58:35It's a benefit for Bitcoin.
- 58:37It's really important that people like you, people as educated as you with the experience that you have can speak to it in these ways.
- 58:43I say this as a former college professor, taught at a bunch of places here where if you mentioned Bitcoin in the lunchroom or something like that, you would just be left out of it.
- 58:51So I think that what you're talking about.
- 58:53I think that's privilege.
- 58:54I think that's to some extent where people didn't really have to struggle with waking up one day in Beirut and suddenly your entire bank account has disappeared.
- 59:07I think that's – and first and foremost, regardless of all my kind of academic research, I care about what works.
- 59:15I mean, I think – and that's where I come from.
- 59:19And I think that's where people should come from.
- 59:22Is this something that is helping people and is it working to help people or are we just going to publish another paper on what to do about things?
- 59:34What we could theoretically do about things, what we hope will happen in the long term.
- 59:37Right, exactly. So I appreciate all that. I want to be mindful of your time.
- 59:40But there's one thing, one last thing I want to give you some space to talk about, which is Shelley Kittleson, which is a journalist, a U.S. journalist who was just kidnapped in Iraq.
- 59:49I did not know up until just a little bit before we started this that this was a friend of yours, someone who has contributed to your sub stack.
- 59:56This is a freelance journalist who I believe has been working in the region for upwards of 10 years, if I'm not mistaken.
- 1:00:02You recently launched a website to help support finding or please tell me exactly what you're trying to do for Shelley right now.
- 1:00:11So we have for context. So she's a freelance journalist who has been covering really, I mean, many of the countries I was talking about.
- 1:00:19She's also been to Afghanistan. She covered the Syrian conflict.
- 1:00:23And then she came to Iraq. She's originally from Wisconsin.
- 1:00:27And so she was kidnapped by an Iranian militia.
- 1:00:31Now I think they're trying to use her as a negotiation against the United States to achieve certain things from this war,
- 1:00:39which kind of connects us to the war because it is connected.
- 1:00:42And really, I've launched a website first for Iraqis to provide tips on where she could be.
- 1:00:55I mean, Iraq is not a small country, but it's not a huge country.
- 1:01:01So there's a lot of potential where a lot of these militias,
- 1:01:04where they kind of drop hostages in people's houses and things around the country.
- 1:01:11So that is one part of the website.
- 1:01:16It now getting actually popular in Iraq I said it to a lot of people who hey if you have tips the FBI has a tip because the FBI is handling her case
- 1:01:28So that's one part of the website.
- 1:01:30The other is to get kind of letters of support to show some of the work she did,
- 1:01:37because that's where a role of like really international kind of correspondence
- 1:01:43is really kind of humanize the people in these wars.
- 1:01:48And I think she did a very good job in showing that we are people in the Middle East
- 1:01:54are humans as well, which is a bias I have because I think in many cases,
- 1:01:59our region is only discussed through kind of the lens of security and terrorism
- 1:02:04and geopolitics.
- 1:02:05And I'm guilty of that because I worked in that space.
- 1:02:07But so she did a very good job at like talking to a lot of people.
- 1:02:14And she like really has done a very good job at that.
- 1:02:19And that's how I actually get to know her because she was covering people I know in like civil society and women's rights groups.
- 1:02:27And these are not people that get coverage, right?
- 1:02:31Like they're not, they're not, it's not the top of news.
- 1:02:33That's not, we're not talking about the state of hormones, right?
- 1:02:36This is kind of hormones as a matter of fact, or global energy and and all of that.
- 1:02:40And that's what it gets the most attention.
- 1:02:42But a woman who started a school for, I don't know, other widows who got affected by the war or something like that is not the sexiest news that will make it on the headlines.
- 1:02:53And and Shelley has done a really amazing job in like being there and listening to these people and kind of getting giving them a voice.
- 1:03:02I haven't met her myself, but I have dealt with her so many times and seeing her covering
- 1:03:09a lot of the people I know and I've connected her to people and et cetera.
- 1:03:15So yes, she got kidnapped on March 31st.
- 1:03:18So that's really a couple of days ago.
- 1:03:21And of course, her family is struggling.
- 1:03:25There's a point, a US point of contact that got created.
- 1:03:31And so he's been like, I've been working with him just like,
- 1:03:35I wanted to make sure there's like an aggregator website
- 1:03:38where people can know also some of the latest updates.
- 1:03:41And yeah, so the website's called Free Shelley
- 1:03:44with double L, freeshelly.net.
- 1:03:46And people can see and hopefully this story doesn't die
- 1:03:52or she doesn't die.
- 1:03:53because she's really done an amazing work
- 1:03:56in humanizing many of the people in the region.
- 1:04:00I appreciate that.
- 1:04:01And I appreciate that work.
- 1:04:02I did not know that about her.
- 1:04:03And I appreciate the fact that you're out there
- 1:04:06trying to help people find her.
- 1:04:08It's really, really important.
- 1:04:09And it does not surprise me.
- 1:04:10You have a great heart, Faisal.
- 1:04:12You're a great human being.
- 1:04:13Pleasure.
- 1:04:13It's been a pleasure to get to know you
- 1:04:15in the last few years.
- 1:04:16Yeah.
- 1:04:16And it's a pleasure to have you on the show here.
- 1:04:18This has been very enlightening for me.
- 1:04:21I think that your ability to speak about all of this with nuance, being from the region to, I think, speak about it in a way that you're passionate about wanting things to get better in the region, but dispassionate in the way that you have this ability to see it from multiple angles, which I think is really important.
- 1:04:37And it really helps people to see that this is a far more complicated scenario than most people realize.
- 1:04:42And there's just no overlooking that. It's just complicated. And you're and you're and you're trying to kind of spell out what all of it looks like and what all the moving parts are. And that's quite difficult.
- 1:04:51And I think a lot of people don't necessarily want to listen to that.
- 1:04:54There's a lot of this is my tribe and this is the way I want to see it, because if I believe that there's all this other stuff happening, there's cognitive dissonance.
- 1:05:02And I don't want to have to think like that. So I think that your ability to do this in a way that feels very non-threatening, very, hey, I just want to kind of spell out what all this looks like.
- 1:05:11It's really, really important. So I appreciate you taking the time to do that here with us.
- 1:05:16On the last note, where can people find you and your work? Where can they follow what you're doing?
- 1:05:21Well, thank you so much, Fragi.
- 1:05:23You've always been an amazing friend.
- 1:05:24And you've also been giving us a voice in the community, within the Bitcoin community,
- 1:05:29whether it's me or Roya or many of the people in the Oslo Freedom Forum circle.
- 1:05:34So thank you.
- 1:05:34You deserve credit as well.
- 1:05:37Where can people find us?
- 1:05:38The organization that I run is ideasbeyondborders.org.
- 1:05:42Our sub-stack is called Middle East Uncovered.
- 1:05:46I am actually creating a sub-stack within the sub-stack called The Day After.
- 1:05:50in which I'm going to be interviewing a lot of experts
- 1:05:54in post-regime transitions of like,
- 1:05:58what happens when a regime falls?
- 1:05:59Because a lot of people focus on like,
- 1:06:03okay, the regime is to fall,
- 1:06:05but I have seen regime fall.
- 1:06:07I've seen Saddam Hussein fall.
- 1:06:09And then we had a civil war after war.
- 1:06:11We had chaos.
- 1:06:12So the subject of like the day after
- 1:06:14is something of extreme importance.
- 1:06:16So on Middle Eastern cover,
- 1:06:17there will be a section called the day after
- 1:06:19and that is going to cover a lot of these issues,
- 1:06:21not just in the Middle East,
- 1:06:23but I'm going to talk to a lot of people
- 1:06:24from other regions as well.
- 1:06:28Yeah, and on social media,
- 1:06:31people can search my name
- 1:06:32and if they're interested in Shelley,
- 1:06:34the journalist being kidnapped journalist,
- 1:06:36they can just go to freeshelly.net or .com
- 1:06:39and they can hear the latest update about her.
- 1:06:42Amazing, I appreciate it.
- 1:06:43All of those websites, including Faisal's handle,
- 1:06:47they'll all be linked in the show notes.
- 1:06:48Again, Faisal, thank you so much for taking the time to do this. I hope you get some rest,
- 1:06:52and I'm hoping for the best in the region and that everybody you know, your loved ones,
- 1:06:55your connections, the journalists, you know, that everybody stays safe and this resolves in
- 1:06:59whatever the best way possible is. Thank you. I hope so as well.
- 1:07:03Pleasure's all mine. All right, everybody, thanks for listening. We'll talk soon.
- 1:07:07Hey, everyone. Frank again. I just wanted to say thank you very much for listening.
- 1:07:11I hope at the very least this conversation offered you some more insights into what's
- 1:07:16happening in Iran right now. And as I mentioned, if you like this sort of content, please like and
- 1:07:21subscribe and leave a comment and or review. To show my gratitude for your doing so, again, I will
- 1:07:27send 1,000 sats to the first 10 people who leave a comment and or review and then email me with both
- 1:07:34proof of this as well as their LNURL. My email address again is newrencap at gmail.com. That's
- 1:07:43newrentcap at gmail.com. And I look forward to dispensing these sats. Thanks again for listening.
- 1:07:50We'll talk soon, everyone.