Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Entertainment Ethics and Malpractice Year-in-Review: "The Ethics Factor"
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to the Entertainment Ethics and Malpractice
- 0:06Year in Review, The Ethics Factor. I'm Keith
- 0:09Kelly, Chair of the Beverly Hills Bar Association's
- 0:12Entertainment Law Section. We have a few housekeeping
- 0:15items to go over before getting to the program.
- 0:18The Entertainment Law Section is sponsored by
- 0:21Lawyers Mutual Insurance Company. For five decades,
- 0:24Lawyers Mutual Insurance Company has been the
- 0:26only California -based company to continuously
- 0:30provide lawyers throughout the state with professional
- 0:32liability insurance coverage. Their experience
- 0:36and expertise are complemented by the fact that
- 0:38they are directed by a group of dedicated lawyers.
- 0:41They offer special rates with competitive premiums
- 0:44for a wide range of areas of practice, including
- 0:47entertainment law. Learn more at lawyersmutual
- 0:50.com. I'm delighted to introduce our speakers,
- 0:54Aaron Joyce and Marshall Cole. Moderating today's
- 0:58program is Neville Johnson. Just quick bios for
- 1:01each of them. Aaron Joyce has extensive experience
- 1:05in state bar investigations and disciplinary
- 1:08proceedings, plus over 30 years of civil litigation
- 1:12practice. Aaron has over 25 years of experience
- 1:16handling all aspects of discipline cases against
- 1:20attorneys. in state bar court from the filing
- 1:23of complaint through trial and review. Aaron
- 1:26has comprehensive understanding of how state
- 1:28bar investigations and proceedings unfold. Before
- 1:32going into private practice, Aaron served as
- 1:34chief special investigator for the Los Angeles
- 1:37Fire Department, as prosecutor for the State
- 1:39Bar of California, and as a lawyer for multiple
- 1:42private practices. Thank you for joining us.
- 1:46Marshall Cole is the managing attorney at Nemesek
- 1:49& Cole and a nationally recognized trial lawyer
- 1:52for his success in complex, high -profile professional
- 1:56liability and civil litigation matters. Named
- 2:00by the Daily Journal as one of California's top
- 2:02professional liability attorneys, he is renowned
- 2:05for his proactive, solutions -driven approach
- 2:08and consistent record of winning results at trial.
- 2:12Thank you. And our moderator today is Neville
- 2:15Johnson, a nationally recognized entertainment
- 2:17and media litigator and founder of Johnson &
- 2:20Johnson, widely regarded as one of the most formidable
- 2:23advocates for artists' rights in Hollywood. A
- 2:26Phi Beta Kappa graduate of UC Berkeley and a
- 2:29Southwestern Law School alum, he has recovered
- 2:32more than $350 million for actors, writers, and
- 2:36creators in royalty, profit participation, and
- 2:39writing publicity disputes. Designated as a legal
- 2:42legend by The Hollywood Reporter and a top 100
- 2:45attorney by super lawyers, Mr. Johnson is also
- 2:49a leading authority on defamation and privacy
- 2:52law, having successfully litigated a landmark
- 2:55invasion of privacy case before the California
- 2:58Supreme Court. He brings exceptional passion
- 3:01to protecting creators while continuing to oversee
- 3:04all matters at his firm and teach entertainment
- 3:07and media litigation. as an adjunct professor
- 3:10at Southwestern Law School. Over to you, Neville.
- 3:13Well, thank you. And I should add that I also
- 3:16represent, I have represented lawyers in malpractice
- 3:20cases, been an expert witness and also prosecuted
- 3:24cases against lawyers. I'm going to make a couple
- 3:28of general comments before I turn it over to
- 3:31Aaron. Who, by the way, I'll mention when she
- 3:36was a state bar prosecutor, she prosecuted successfully
- 3:39a case against someone I was representing. Look,
- 3:44the client is not your friend. I always say this
- 3:46at the beginning of these. It's illusory, the
- 3:49relationship that lawyers have with their clients.
- 3:51You will be invited to weddings, bar mitzvahs,
- 3:54to go on vacations with the client, but at the
- 3:57end of the day, you're a fiduciary and you're
- 4:01not family to them. And I think we all have had
- 4:05experience that when the money comes in, oh,
- 4:07any lawyer could have done that. And when the
- 4:10case goes south, it's all your fault, Mr. and
- 4:14Ms. Attorney. That's why fee agreements are so
- 4:17important. And I highly recommend you check out
- 4:23the seminar that is available for download that
- 4:25I did two years ago with Marshall Cole and another
- 4:28lawyer. called Complicated Ethics Issues and
- 4:31Fee Agreements, in which we cover a variety of
- 4:34topics such as contingent fees of more than 50%,
- 4:38changing fee amounts in midstream, taking a percentage
- 4:43of the client's income, arbitration agreements,
- 4:47and the like. We'll be covering some of that
- 4:50today as well. The big deal for entertainment
- 4:54lawyers or conflict of interest situations, just
- 4:58know that when you have a wholly owned company
- 5:02for the client, that creates a conflict and you
- 5:05have to advise them. They need to waive it and
- 5:09give them the right to seek independent advice.
- 5:12The other issue is referral fees overall. I'm
- 5:17not going to get into the specifics of it, but
- 5:19you can make a lot of money and get into a lot
- 5:21of trouble with referral fees. With that, I'm
- 5:24going to turn it over to Aaron, Joyce, take it
- 5:27away. OK, give me a moment as I set up our screen
- 5:33share again. Is it, let me just do the launch
- 5:39up from the beginning. OK, are we good? Or are
- 5:44we seeing the wrong one? We're good. OK, so sorry.
- 5:48Actually, Aaron, can you switch the display settings?
- 5:51Yeah, I certainly can. Swap. Yes. Perfect. Perfect.
- 5:58Okay. All right. So yeah, we're going to talk
- 6:01about some of the recent happenings within discipline
- 6:07and their special responsibility area. And I
- 6:11do think it's, it's bears discussing what, what
- 6:15Neville started with is that your client today,
- 6:18I see them as complaining witness tomorrow. So
- 6:22How many times, and I'm sure Marsha can talk
- 6:24about this too, how many times would a case just
- 6:27be stopped in its tracks if the attorney took
- 6:30the time to dot every I cross every T? And when
- 6:35you're under exigent circumstances, which by
- 6:37the way, not your exigency, it's the client's
- 6:41exigency that get lawyers to maybe not finalize
- 6:46that fee agreement in advance, or not secure
- 6:50that conflict waiver when there's more than one
- 6:52client. Because, you know, you want to make sure
- 6:55you provide great legal advice. Or even worse,
- 6:58when you don't document that important phone
- 7:01call with the email follow up, that is when,
- 7:05you know, it takes longer to resolve a state
- 7:08bar complaint or, you know, deal with potential
- 7:11legal malpractice. Because as Neville said, I
- 7:14think this is absolutely true. If the great result
- 7:17that they always wanted and expected occurs,
- 7:20there's a sense of, well, that's just what's
- 7:23supposed to happen. So there's some gratitude,
- 7:26clearly. And I guess a different program can
- 7:29talk about whether or not there can be a built
- 7:31-in kicker or extra bonus into the fee structure
- 7:37with that great result. That's really maybe beyond
- 7:40what we can talk about today. But if the case
- 7:43doesn't go well, It's not like the client or
- 7:45complaining witnesses has a lot of introspection.
- 7:49So it's practicing defensive law will solve a
- 7:52lot of the concerns and problems I can be facing
- 7:54later on. Yeah, real quick. And one of the real
- 7:58important reasons why is, you know, it's all
- 8:01well and good when things go great, but I've
- 8:03got a ton of legal malpractice cases that I'm
- 8:06defending, some of which went through trial and
- 8:09the result that was obtained wasn't very good.
- 8:12It wasn't necessarily a complete loss, but it
- 8:14just wasn't very good. And the clients are now
- 8:17suing lawyers saying, look, you should have saved
- 8:19me from myself, right? You should have told me
- 8:21I should have never gone to trial. And it's hard
- 8:24to think about in real time communicating clearly
- 8:28those types of details regarding someone's case.
- 8:33And so if you take a step back when you're representing
- 8:36your client, and communicating with them. And
- 8:39I know we all text regularly. I would discourage
- 8:43texting clients anything of importance other
- 8:45than just some scheduling details. But you really
- 8:48want to lay out the good, the bad, and the ugly,
- 8:51because you just don't know how a case is going
- 8:53to transform over a period of time and potentially
- 8:56through trial if you're a litigator. And if not,
- 8:59even in a transactional setting, if a deal blows
- 9:01up. And the client then comes back and says,
- 9:04well, you didn't warn me about X, Y, and Z. And
- 9:08so it's really important to keep that communication
- 9:11ongoing and updated as things develop, as bad
- 9:15facts come out, and things that you may not think
- 9:17are necessarily bad. are still worth communicating
- 9:21to your client because down the line you just
- 9:24don't know how, when people look at things nine
- 9:27side 2020, how it's going to look when you didn't
- 9:30effectively communicate as you should have. And
- 9:33so if you do it on the front end, it creates
- 9:35a real easy defense if a client sues you for
- 9:38me to come in and help you out and get you out
- 9:40on a summary judgment motion or otherwise. Sorry
- 9:42about that, Aaron. Go ahead and jump back in.
- 9:46I would have said five years ago, don't text
- 9:48message with your clients. But then again, I
- 9:52would know you're not gonna listen to them. Just
- 9:53like, you know, there's a lot of great advice
- 9:56that maybe people can't follow. But if you're
- 10:00going to engage in text messaging with a client,
- 10:05you have to have a way to document it. And there
- 10:07are commercially available programs now that
- 10:10don't cost a lot of money. that can document
- 10:13those type of communications. You can even build
- 10:15it into your, or a lot of these different case
- 10:18software does the same thing. It acts as a text
- 10:21message or instant message that documents those
- 10:24kinds of communications. Because you may be dealing
- 10:27with people on the fly, on your phone, and that
- 10:31becomes, if it's a substantive communication
- 10:34about the case, it has to become part of client
- 10:37file. You have to have a way to maintain it.
- 10:39So we're going to cover these topics here and
- 10:42maybe more. The new stability oath, we'll talk
- 10:45about CTAP and how the random audits are going.
- 10:50They're still underway, as far as I know, on
- 10:52the first cohort of 100 people. The MCLE audits
- 10:56that are going forward, they continue to go forward.
- 10:58We'll talk about some big discipline cases from
- 11:012025. We'll talk about, oh, there's the end of
- 11:052023. the state bar's co -prac committee put
- 11:09out AI guidelines and they're basically underway
- 11:12to be revamped right now because that technology
- 11:16is moving so fast most of what was said before
- 11:18really isn't as helpful as it could be and the
- 11:21supreme court is actually asking for more guidance
- 11:23because of all the stuff that's happening in
- 11:25that area and we'll end with some conflict of
- 11:28interest. So first of all the state bar spent
- 11:31with their blue ribbon commission between the
- 11:35California Lawyers Association and the California
- 11:38Judges Association, putting together, you know,
- 11:41guide, not just guidelines, but new rules of
- 11:43professional conduct to basically require something
- 11:48like civility, whatever that means, from practitioners,
- 11:52both in the transactional and litigation setting.
- 11:54And they sat with the Supreme Court for a while.
- 11:57And this has happened more than once. This is
- 11:59not the first and only time this has happened.
- 12:01The Supreme Court determined they're not viable.
- 12:04So the only thing that was actually adopted is
- 12:07that we all in the connection by April 1st are
- 12:11going to have to renew or take for the first
- 12:14time the civility oath that new lawyers have
- 12:17had to do in the last couple years. That's not
- 12:20to say that civility has no place in the practice
- 12:24of law, clearly not. And there have been some
- 12:26really pretty egregious cases in the last couple
- 12:29years where lawyers really took it in the chin
- 12:33by increasing the cost of litigation because
- 12:37of their incivility and, you know, having their
- 12:40attorney's fees award gutted, even if they won.
- 12:44So it's not to say civility doesn't matter, but
- 12:48the potential discipline from civility, which
- 12:52was kind of hanging over practitioners, that
- 12:55has been at least averted for now. They're back
- 12:59at the drawing board, though, with trying to
- 13:01come up with something that would pass muster
- 13:03in that area. So I think it's really I think
- 13:06it's really important regardless of a rule or
- 13:08not to read this and adhere to it regardless,
- 13:12you know, it's it being uncivil to your opposing
- 13:17counsel does not look good at any point in time
- 13:20during litigation representation. Of course,
- 13:23bad emails are going to make their way in front
- 13:24of the judge. Nobody's going to look good. Neither
- 13:26the person submitting the email nor the person
- 13:29who wrote it. Either way, it looks bad. And of
- 13:32course, down the line, if a claim arises and
- 13:35you're a defendant and these types of uncivil
- 13:39emails firing back and forth. It just doesn't
- 13:42help the situation. And most importantly, at
- 13:45no point in time are you ever advancing your
- 13:47client's interests if you're just getting into
- 13:49it with your opposing counsel and hurling personal
- 13:53attacks or if you're on the receipt of those
- 13:54personal attacks, don't engage. You just need
- 13:57to take the high road and let it fly and recognize
- 14:02that you're being the better person. throughout
- 14:05that process and you're ultimately protecting
- 14:07yourself down the line. You know what I say in
- 14:09a deposition if they come after me is I say that's
- 14:13a personal attack and then I just ask the witness
- 14:16to answer and the sixth time I say that's your
- 14:18sixth personal attack in accordance with the
- 14:20principles of Mahatma Gandhi I reject your personal
- 14:23attack but I will not answer it and at that point
- 14:26everybody starts laughing and he looks like or
- 14:29she looks like a fool so the bottom line is do
- 14:32not get emotional courts judges hate it when
- 14:36you get into with each other. It's we're all
- 14:38advocates and we have emotions and we want to
- 14:41win but the key is to be uh operate with equanimity
- 14:45and uh and uh kindness. And one other point on
- 14:53that you can and I would strongly suggest you
- 14:56consider putting into your pre -agreement in
- 14:58the section where it talks about you know attorney's
- 15:01duties and then pivots to the client's duties,
- 15:03you put in there that decisions with respect
- 15:07to scheduling and reasonable continuances are
- 15:10the purview of the lawyer in the context of the
- 15:14civility guidelines. Because sometimes it might
- 15:16be the client that thinks they want the bulldog
- 15:18lawyer, at least until the end of the case, when
- 15:22it costs them so much more. So yeah, you can
- 15:24put and start managing the client's expectations
- 15:28about civility from the very beginning in your
- 15:31fee agreement. So let's talk a little bit about,
- 15:33you know, here we are looking at the fourth year
- 15:36where all lawyers have to, under penalty of perjury,
- 15:43appear to the state bar that they are in full
- 15:46compliance with rule 1 .15 of the rules of professional
- 15:49conduct and all the CTAP rules, client trust
- 15:52account protection program. And last September,
- 15:56they launched their first set of compliance reviews
- 16:00They're supposed to be random -ish, but not random
- 16:04like everyone's name isn't a hopper. It's random
- 16:07in that they want to have, based on everybody
- 16:10that has to now identify what your practice area
- 16:13is, at least your number one practice area and
- 16:16size of your firm. They're trying to have a representative
- 16:20sample of lawyers that are subject to these compliance
- 16:23reviews so that they're not heavily weighted
- 16:25only as they normally are on small firms. I can
- 16:30tell you that they have not completed, as far
- 16:33as I know, any of the audits that started last
- 16:35September. I can tell you that only four CPA
- 16:38firms in the state of California went through
- 16:41the vetting process that are available for the
- 16:43lawyers to hire for these audits. Because you
- 16:47as the cohort or the unlucky lawyer or law firm
- 16:53that gets chosen, you're the ones that you have
- 16:56to pick one of their CPAs. in order to go through
- 16:59this process. So according to the attorney of
- 17:05division regulation, they're going to be expecting
- 17:10to do about 400 audits each year. So after April
- 17:141st of this year, they'll pick the next 400.
- 17:17And I think they're really doing a lot to calibrate
- 17:20how to do the audits with respect to this first
- 17:23100 that are going forward right now. And to
- 17:28put some relevancy on the issue, I'm in a trial
- 17:30right now. In about 45 minutes, I'm going to
- 17:32start cross -examining a partner of a law firm.
- 17:36And several of the questions, though it's not
- 17:38an ethics -related trial, are going to be touching
- 17:41on CTAP compliance and when the rules came into
- 17:44effect and knowledge of those rules. So this
- 17:46is relevant in many areas, separate and apart
- 17:48from just your state bar compliance. Just with
- 17:51respect to your governance and management of
- 17:53your law firm, it's important to... comply because
- 17:56these issues are coming up, and they're going
- 17:59to be very important for this particular witness
- 18:01in about 45 minutes. Well, another thing that's
- 18:04important, and I've got a lot of people consulting
- 18:07with me about this issue. And I can say, like
- 18:10anything else, when it's new, it's going to be
- 18:13kind of glitchy. So the state bar profile screens
- 18:17on CTAB are really glitchy. They've gotten them
- 18:19a lot more smoothed out, streamlined. The questions
- 18:23and the self -assessment, they've certainly made
- 18:25a lot better. They're more understandable to
- 18:28lawyers. I mean, all of us have advanced degrees,
- 18:30and many people didn't understand those questions.
- 18:33But I can tell you haven't looked at the questions
- 18:35again for this year, which are very similar to
- 18:37last year, because they kind of dialed it in
- 18:39as of last year. Those self -assessment questions
- 18:42are basically all you're doing is you're saying,
- 18:45yeah, I know what the rule is. I know what the
- 18:48particular requirement is. You're not avering
- 18:50that you 100 % follow the policy all year. So
- 18:53if it turns out as an example, that in one case
- 18:57during 2025, you didn't notify every single claimant
- 19:01of the receipt of the money within two weeks
- 19:03as what the rule requires. As long as you have
- 19:06that policy in your office and you are aspiring
- 19:09to do that, I mean really trying to do it, you
- 19:11have policies and procedures, a place to do that,
- 19:13you can feel comfortable saying yes to those
- 19:15questions because a no is going to get an audit.
- 19:18You cannot be in compliance without certifying
- 19:21CTAB compliance. There's no such thing as certifying
- 19:25non -compliance. And just to let you know what
- 19:30happens internally in the state bar, the state
- 19:33bar is basically taking a more regulatory approach
- 19:36rather than simply, not instead of, but at the
- 19:41same time as they're taking the discipline approach.
- 19:44So the first thing that happens if you have problems
- 19:47with CTAP is they assess, just like anything
- 19:49else, any kind of non -compliance. We assess
- 19:52a fee. And then you have to pay fees to get reinstated.
- 19:55And if you let it go long enough, as of July
- 19:581st, you're going to go on an inactive status.
- 20:00And you might think, OK, that's all regulatory.
- 20:02That's all automatic. But non -compliance can
- 20:06be referred to the disciplined side of the state
- 20:10bar, which is the Office of Chief Trial Counsel,
- 20:12because the CTAP compliance is all basically
- 20:15centered in the Division for Attorney Regulation.
- 20:19So it's a new regulatory, not new. It's what
- 20:21used to be member services is now becoming a
- 20:25much bigger part of State Bar. That's where you're,
- 20:30all of the, all of everything that goes through
- 20:33the State Bar profile, including renewal of your
- 20:37professional law corporation, et cetera, is now,
- 20:39along with the audits, going to be in a regulatory
- 20:43function in the Division of Attorney Regulation.
- 20:47Hey, Erin, we got an interesting question. I
- 20:50don't take retainers and only bill for services
- 20:53already rendered. I am not required to have a
- 20:55client trust account, correct? I would say if
- 21:00that were 100 % always true, then that would
- 21:04probably be correct. That does not obviate your
- 21:07obligation to still do the self -certification.
- 21:10And here's the thing. Many, many lawyers are
- 21:12freaked out by, oh my god, all these CTAP rules.
- 21:16and they've like abandoned their trust accounts,
- 21:19which by the way, if you open or close a trust
- 21:21account, you have to notify the state bar within
- 21:2330 days on your state bar profile. It doesn't
- 21:27really save anything. Once you get yourself into
- 21:29compliance, it's not that hard to stay in compliance.
- 21:32And what happens if you get that one off case
- 21:34that you want to take an advanced cost on like
- 21:38an expert fee, et cetera, you have nowhere to
- 21:40park that money. You don't have a trust account.
- 21:42So it's a very dangerous thing not to have a
- 21:45trust account. And it's not that hard. Yeah,
- 21:48I think it's not that hard. You can have it.
- 21:50Don't use it. You might get a settlement. The
- 21:53money's got to go somewhere. It's the easiest
- 21:55place to put it. And I've defended state bar
- 21:59matters where clients didn't have trust accounts
- 22:02claiming the exact same thing. I don't have money
- 22:04that flows through. And it just still creates
- 22:07an issue because it's a rare circumstance for
- 22:10a lawyer to be in. So there's really no downside
- 22:12in having it. Yeah, once you get yourself into
- 22:16compliance, you're going to be fine. The other
- 22:18thing is this year, 2026, every financial institution
- 22:23that maintains trust accounts needs to have on
- 22:25record now who is the licensee, at least one
- 22:28lawyer that's responsible for that trust account.
- 22:31So you're going to have to do best reform this
- 22:33year for every trust account associated with
- 22:36your firm. Okay, and if you do get selected,
- 22:46the audits basically go back one year. They go
- 22:49back through the compliance period, which would
- 22:51be January to December of the year. So once you
- 22:56do your certification by April of this year,
- 22:59it'll be for 2025. So you wanna make sure before
- 23:02you do that certification, you at minimum have
- 23:05the required records in place, meaning an account
- 23:08journal. And then if you have an account journal
- 23:11in Excel or anything, it will create a client
- 23:14ledger card because each of the transactions
- 23:17for the year are keyed to an individual case.
- 23:21And so you just want to filter, and that creates
- 23:24the client ledger card. Almost nobody maintains
- 23:27a separate client ledger card anymore, like they
- 23:29had 20 years ago. It's just a report in your
- 23:32online software. And if you get, unfortunately,
- 23:37if they find any problems, or big enough problems,
- 23:40they can expand that one year look to three years,
- 23:44according to the CTAP guidelines. So you really
- 23:47wanna be careful. We're gonna spend one minute
- 23:50on MCLE compliance. The auditing of MCLE is also
- 23:56in the division of attorney regulation. And thankfully,
- 24:02they've now moved this to be a more regulatory
- 24:04rather than disciplinary approach. So if you
- 24:07get... you know, selected, you'll just have to
- 24:09be able to provide your certificates for the
- 24:1240, you know, for the 25 hours in the different
- 24:14areas. And whereas initially the state bar was
- 24:18coming out guns blazing in 2011, looking for
- 24:21actual suspension for people that had MCLE non
- 24:25-compliance. I'm not saying it's a good thing.
- 24:27I'm just saying now they're trying to make it
- 24:30a regulatory approach. And you could really...
- 24:35If you are an active lawyer, you need to basically
- 24:38ensure you keep your certificates. The State
- 24:41Bar is trying to move to a system where it's
- 24:43going to be the MCLE provider directly provides
- 24:47information to the State Bar, but that hasn't
- 24:49happened yet. So before we get into the other
- 24:53meatier, I guess, beefier parts, I want to talk
- 24:56about a couple of cases that came out of 2025
- 24:59in the State Bar area. And they do have application.
- 25:04One thing I could tell you, is that while the
- 25:06number of complaints that hit the state bar have
- 25:09steadily become leveled off now, but once they
- 25:12made an online portal, the number of complaints
- 25:15coming in has increased. It's like 16 to 18 ,000
- 25:19complaints come in a year. But the number of
- 25:23cases that make their way through State Bar Court
- 25:25is very steady. It's like the same, you have
- 25:29the same five judges, not the same exact people,
- 25:31but five slots for hearing department judges.
- 25:34as they did when I started back in the 90s. The
- 25:38number of cases and discipline, either by a disciplinary
- 25:41stipulation or a trial in state bar quote, has
- 25:44remained remarkably steady. So the truth is,
- 25:47what's the difference? The difference is the
- 25:49number of cases that are closed, the percentage
- 25:53is higher, actually. The percentage of cases
- 25:56that come in as an investigation are higher,
- 25:59and I would say the backlog is increased. That's
- 26:04what's happened. So what do you do if you get
- 26:07a state bar letter? Chances are it's going to
- 26:11close. So that's a good news. Here's another
- 26:15thing that I could share with you. A lot of times,
- 26:18because the investigators are such a new cohort,
- 26:21it's a revolving door in the Office of Chief
- 26:23Trial Counsel. They're not really highly experienced.
- 26:26So most of the investigators Since they can't
- 26:28just share with you the complaint that they received
- 26:31because the complaint and everything in an investigation
- 26:34file is confidential, they have to kind of summarize
- 26:37it when they reach out to you. And they're not
- 26:40really going through and letting you know what
- 26:43makes sense and what doesn't. They're not really
- 26:45assessing it at all. They're literally just kind
- 26:46of regurgitating what the issues are. So don't
- 26:49get your back up and think, oh, my God, I can't
- 26:51be accusing you of this and that and get really
- 26:55upset. That's coming from the complaining witness.
- 26:58They don't have any dog in the fight as the investigator
- 27:01They're just as happy with the closer as they
- 27:03are in the case forward. So your response should
- 27:06be measured Professional and honestly probably
- 27:11through counsel. I was gonna say if you're if
- 27:13you want to handle this on your own It better
- 27:16be really, really simple and straightforward.
- 27:19Otherwise, call Aaron, call me to walk you through
- 27:21it and assist you. And a lot of times, your professional
- 27:24liability insurance coverage is going to have
- 27:27a rider in it that will cover state bar matters.
- 27:31It's sometimes a no -deductible 25 ,000 limit,
- 27:3450 ,000 limit, whatever it might be. you should
- 27:37use it. And if you don't know whether you have
- 27:39it or you don't have it, the next time you're
- 27:41up for renewal, you should inquire as to whether
- 27:43you can get that. Because as Aaron said, there's
- 27:46so many more referrals. You're going to get a
- 27:50letter that says your state bar license is at
- 27:52risk, but it might be shut down relatively quickly.
- 27:54It's going to cause you a lot of stress. And
- 27:56if you have that coverage, someone who's experienced
- 27:59in the field will take care of it and hopefully
- 28:01get it shut down right away. Exactly. And I think
- 28:05that the problem when you try to respond on your
- 28:07own are twofold. One, a lawyer gets their backup
- 28:10and they get aggressive with the investigator
- 28:12and they withhold necessary information. And
- 28:15the last thing the investigator wants to do is
- 28:18have to touch that file for them once. They just
- 28:20want to be able to send out the letter to you,
- 28:23send out the letter to the complaining witness
- 28:24asking for more information. If there's something
- 28:28to do with the court file or something to do
- 28:30with the... They'll send out the subpoenas for
- 28:32those records. They want to look at everything
- 28:34once and write up either the closing memorandum
- 28:38or the investigative report. If they have to
- 28:41get into a back and forth to get more information
- 28:43from you, chances are, you know, first of all,
- 28:45you're making it harder on them, which is never
- 28:48good for any agency. And also you're making it
- 28:53more likely that the case, if they're confused,
- 28:56this is unlike anything else you've ever seen.
- 28:59If they are confused and they're not sure, unlike
- 29:02in other normal circumstances where you might
- 29:04think, oh, they may not think they have their
- 29:06case, they'll close it. No, if you don't make
- 29:08it crystal clear why they should close the case,
- 29:12it will move forward. So it has to be super clear.
- 29:17So you don't withhold information. But then again,
- 29:21on the other side, sometimes lawyers feel like
- 29:23they have to give too much information. And if
- 29:25you give too much information, guess what? You
- 29:27opened up other areas of inquiry that they can't
- 29:29close the case. They have to follow up on that.
- 29:32So you need to calibrate the response. And that's
- 29:35why if you do it through counsel, it probably
- 29:36makes more sense. Now let's talk about some of
- 29:39these cases that did come out of State Bar Court
- 29:41and through the process this year. The Bradshaw
- 29:44case actually was a Supreme Court case. And that
- 29:47happens so rarely because the only time a disciplined
- 29:50case makes its way to the Supreme Court is by
- 29:53cert. It doesn't happen very often, but then
- 29:56Mr. Bradshaw's case he did. And this is a case
- 29:59that bounced around a lot of procedural nightmare
- 30:02in the proceedings before the state bar court.
- 30:06But basically, the Supreme Court found that he
- 30:11was engaging in conflicts of interest in the
- 30:17context of conservatorship and with respect to
- 30:21a fixing up a house up in this bay area for a
- 30:26woman that wanted to stay in her house and not
- 30:28move into assisted living. And so as far as I
- 30:31understand reading the file, seeing some of the
- 30:33earlier case law, you know, write ups of the
- 30:36case, it was really this attorney, you know,
- 30:39spending a lot of money to try to keep a woman
- 30:40in her house when she didn't, you know, she wanted
- 30:42to stay in her house, but the rest of the beneficiaries
- 30:44didn't want that money spent. And some of the
- 30:47contractors who used he may have had an interest
- 30:50in. So the Supreme Court found he was disbarred.
- 30:53So conflicts of interest are really, especially
- 30:55if there's any financial issues, they're no joke.
- 30:59I mean, that's the Supreme Court took a much
- 31:01more harsh read than the State Bar Court did,
- 31:03and even at the Review Department level. Okay,
- 31:08so this one is another case that came out of,
- 31:10this is out of the Review Department. In the
- 31:13State Bar, we have five hearing judges, two up
- 31:17north and three down south. in LA, and then we
- 31:21have a special review department that handles
- 31:25all the appeals. And then you have an appeal
- 31:27as a right to the review department and only
- 31:29by certain Supreme Court, which happens almost
- 31:32never, very, very rarely. So this case stands,
- 31:36Mitchell stands for the proposition that anytime
- 31:39you have any actual suspension, it triggers California
- 31:43World Court 9 .20. 1 .20 says that if you have
- 31:47any actual suspension, it used to be 90 days
- 31:49actual suspension, but now it's any actual suspension,
- 31:52you have to notify every client, every opposing
- 31:56party or council by certified mail and keeping
- 32:00the little green card or term receipt requested
- 32:03and file notices in every open matter. And it's
- 32:07that snapshot of your open files as of the time
- 32:10the Supreme Court ordered issues. Basically the
- 32:12state bar, finds that a violation of 9 .20 and
- 32:15a lot of other violations here, they take that
- 32:18as a disbarment level of offense. So again, it
- 32:21is extremely serious. Now, this case, Trimarsh,
- 32:28is about a situation where this is one of the
- 32:32very rare instances where the bar gets involved
- 32:35in what looks like an advertising type case.
- 32:37It happens almost never. Because most of the
- 32:39time, if there's an advertising problem, the
- 32:42state bar basically issues cease and desist letters
- 32:45and people correct their actions. But here, this
- 32:51was basically a student loan debt servicing operation
- 32:58trying to consolidate student loan debt. And
- 33:02it persisted, the attorney persisted after multiple,
- 33:06I guess I would say warnings. And that's why
- 33:09this resulted in a significant actual suspension.
- 33:12One thing I can say is that after the latest
- 33:15SB 37 and the changes in attorney advertising,
- 33:19there may very well be more advertising cases
- 33:21coming through the state bar court. This is just
- 33:25if you're not familiar with the rule Aaron just
- 33:28cited the new law that's coming into place regarding
- 33:30advertising which creates a private right of
- 33:32that cause of action for consumers out there
- 33:36to bring a case against attorneys for false or
- 33:39deceptive advertising that aren't in compliance
- 33:42with the statute. You should familiarize yourself
- 33:44with it. Take a look at your firm's website and
- 33:46make sure you're in compliance. It's going to
- 33:48be really interesting how those cases eventually
- 33:51make their way through the civil court system.
- 33:53I think it implicates a lot of First Amendment
- 33:56issues, a lot of protected activity issues, potentially
- 33:59slap motions are gonna come into play, but you
- 34:01really should familiarize yourself with that.
- 34:03If you have billboards and advertising at that
- 34:06type of level, you definitely need to be familiar
- 34:09with the new law. Yeah, just a couple of points
- 34:12on that. Neville, do you want something? Oh,
- 34:20I thought you were gonna say something about
- 34:21this, but. The basic points are, first of all,
- 34:26unlike under rule 7 .1 and that series where
- 34:30it's just basically anything that's not false
- 34:32and misleading pretty much goes as long as it's
- 34:35attorney advertising and either in context or
- 34:37identified as attorney advertising. Now, an actual
- 34:41lawyer has to be identified with each ad and
- 34:45a bona fide office. So if you're saying you have
- 34:49statewide reach, you have to have an office identification.
- 34:53And before you have that private cause of action,
- 34:56you have to make a complaint to the state bar.
- 34:59And the state bar has to take action on your
- 35:02complaint, which is interesting because the statute
- 35:05doesn't have any extra money for the state bar
- 35:07to process all these advertising complaints.
- 35:10So like I said, they've never put a lot of emphasis
- 35:13on advertising cases to begin with. We'll see
- 35:16how that goes. Now, let's talk about the Eastman
- 35:22case. This case is actually still before the
- 35:26Supreme Court, but John Eastman disbarred a series
- 35:31of actions that were related to the 2020 or,
- 35:36I guess, challenging the election results in
- 35:392020. So this case, the review department, which
- 35:45again is the state bar or its appellate court,
- 35:48level found culpability on all 10 counts that
- 35:51the hearing judge had found. And the disarmament
- 35:56recommendation is right now before the Supreme
- 35:57Court in California. I just wanted to let you
- 35:59know that's making its way. And this is another,
- 36:02I guess, for disciplined nerds, interesting case.
- 36:07Joe Dunn was the prior executive director. And
- 36:10some more than 10 years after his term, the state
- 36:16bar brought brought charges for supposedly, not
- 36:21supposedly, they found, I guess, a misrepresentation
- 36:24to the board of trustees and imposed a 30 -day
- 36:28actual suspension, which is actually, I think,
- 36:33the review department decision has not yet come
- 36:35out. So I never want to talk about Chom. Yeah,
- 36:42I mean here this is just an important case where
- 36:45the client wanted to get out of the deal Out
- 36:48of the fee agreement got rid of the got rid of
- 36:50the lawyer and then went and settled the case.
- 36:53And the court said the lawyer had already agreed
- 36:57to basically the terms but without authorization.
- 37:00Then the client came in and accepted the deal.
- 37:02There was litigation and the law firm won on
- 37:07the basis that, look, you took the deal, you
- 37:09ratified it overall. So that was important there
- 37:13to know that that happened and that you can in
- 37:16fact get paid because, you know, not the client
- 37:19here was trying to welch on the deal. And I think
- 37:22a lot of components from this case are important.
- 37:25Number one, if you as the lawyer handle the case
- 37:30all the way through close to the final steps
- 37:32or the courthouse steps or whatever it is, there's
- 37:35another Martirossian case from years ago, you
- 37:39should be entitled to your full contingent fee
- 37:41if the case then settles after the client fires
- 37:44you like the client did here. One thing we're
- 37:48seeing a lot of as well and it dovetails into
- 37:51referral fees, rule 1 .5 .1 if you're not familiar
- 37:55with it and you accept or get referral fees.
- 38:00You need to have a separate document with the
- 38:03client's informed consent along with both lawyers
- 38:05at the time the agreement's made. And what we're
- 38:08seeing a lot of is cases that get inherited by
- 38:12a new firm, and there's no referral fee agreement.
- 38:15But nonetheless, the prior firm asserts a lien,
- 38:18and they end up being heavily litigated between
- 38:21the two firms. and it's something that could
- 38:23be easily avoided at the outset because if you're
- 38:27not going to acknowledge a referral fee or not
- 38:29going to or going to dispute a lien do it right
- 38:32away before it gets to the end of the point in
- 38:35the case where you get a bunch of money and now
- 38:38you've got to hold up your fee in a trust account
- 38:40because there's a lien and deal with all those
- 38:43issues. And so it's just something that we're
- 38:46seeing a lot more of on the civil side. And this
- 38:48is not something that's covered by insurance.
- 38:50Lawyers are having to pay out of pocket to fight
- 38:52over fees when a lot of it could be avoided.
- 38:56Now, look, you can't necessarily prevent a prior
- 39:00counsel from asserting a lien no matter how many
- 39:03previous attorneys have been there. But I think
- 39:06the more you document it early on and dispute
- 39:09it, It's going to undercut it down the line when
- 39:11they ultimately file a lawsuit against you. And
- 39:14they also at the same time have to sue the client
- 39:16as well. But we're seeing these come up. And
- 39:18so I think, again, communication and documenting
- 39:21things with predecessor firms is really important.
- 39:25And if they are going to assert a lien, I think
- 39:27right off the bat, when they do so, request all
- 39:30the work that was done. They're generally going
- 39:32to be entitled to the reasonable value of their
- 39:34services and nothing more. So a lot of times,
- 39:37Big settlements come out, multimillion dollar
- 39:40settlements. The prior firm did four things.
- 39:42They drafted a complaint, propounded some discovery,
- 39:44and took a depot. And they want half the fee.
- 39:48Well, that's not necessarily what they're entitled
- 39:50to. So if you request what their hourly rate
- 39:54is, a reasonable hourly rate, even at $1 ,000
- 39:56an hour or some crazy rate that they want to
- 39:59choose, have them put the... give you the backup
- 40:01of the amount of hours and try to resolve it
- 40:04early on before it ultimately leads to litigation.
- 40:07Because again, once it's there, it just starts
- 40:10eating into your feed. The money we have to spend
- 40:12to defend them, they can sit around for a long
- 40:14time and predecessor firms can create a lot of
- 40:18problems with fees and ultimately grind you down
- 40:20and you end up giving away money you probably
- 40:22didn't have to give away. A very big area because
- 40:28when you're a contingency fee lawyer, it's not
- 40:31simply amount of time put in and the prevailing
- 40:35hourly rate, because basically all of the factors
- 40:38that are identified in global professional conduct
- 40:411 .5, those 13 factors, some of them apply, some
- 40:45of them don't, but those are the kind of factors
- 40:46you look at when you evaluate quantum merit,
- 40:51because you're entitled to what the value of
- 40:53your services were. And one of those most important
- 40:56ones is results obtained. That's why this case,
- 41:00the Chong case, went the way it did. Because
- 41:02what you're dealing with when you have attorney
- 41:04one and attorney two, like in this case, if attorney
- 41:08one already got, let's say the whole policy limit
- 41:11demand made, let's imagine that case. The policy
- 41:14limits are tendered to the first lawyer, and
- 41:17then the client says no. And then the second
- 41:20lawyer spends another six months and gets the
- 41:22same policy limits demand. Then the second lawyer
- 41:24that might've churned the file, they might've
- 41:26done a lot of busy work, But they didn't get
- 41:28the results. Because the first lawyer, if they
- 41:30got the policy in its demand, will, when you're
- 41:33apportioning the attorney fees on a contingency
- 41:35fee, it's apportioned between attorney one and
- 41:38attorney two. It's never going to be increased
- 41:40from that. And that's a big issue. That's the
- 41:42Vance Sickle case, which is a big discipline
- 41:44case. Even if you're the second attorney in line,
- 41:48let's say, and you have a 40 % contingency fee
- 41:51and it's, let's say, $100 ,000 or a million dollar
- 41:53settlement. And there's $400 ,000 of attorney's
- 41:56fees. And you want to stand on, well, I have
- 41:58a contingency fee. I earned all of it. No. Attorney
- 42:01one, or all the attorneys before, you all get
- 42:04to apportion whatever the total attorney's fees
- 42:07are. It never eats into the client's attorney's
- 42:10fees. So you have to be very careful if you're
- 42:13attorney two or attorney three. Is there going
- 42:16to be enough money to make sense for us to continue
- 42:18working on this case? Because we're likely to
- 42:20have to apportion it. But depending on If you're
- 42:24the one that got the results, then as that being
- 42:28a very major factor, that might mean, as in like
- 42:31in this case, the full contingency and fee was
- 42:33really earned by the first lawyer. And when you
- 42:35get a settlement, that's when the contingency
- 42:38is met. So you get a situation, and I'm sure
- 42:40Marshall has seen this, where the case is settled,
- 42:43client agrees to the settlement, and as an accommodation,
- 42:47the lawyer resolves liens because they're nice.
- 42:51But that's not part of their contingency theme.
- 42:53So if the client starts making trouble about
- 42:56challenging the fees to be earned by that lawyer,
- 43:00then it creates a conflict. And so what are you
- 43:02going to do about all those liens? Then it's
- 43:04really for the client to have to deal with their
- 43:06liens and maybe interpleading the funds. But
- 43:09again, even if they get a second lawyer involved,
- 43:12if you've already gotten the settlement, that
- 43:15second lawyer doesn't get part of your contingency
- 43:17fee because you already earned it. Don't you
- 43:20recommend that you put in the elements of? 1
- 43:24.5 and say here if you if I'm substituted out
- 43:29I'm going to get and as a floor my hourly rate
- 43:33as Against may perhaps more depending on result
- 43:37achieved in the other aspects of the rule I Think
- 43:42that's important to establish your lien if you're
- 43:45the first lawyer You bet you should have in your
- 43:49retainer agreement a contractual lien provision.
- 43:51And if you put in the hourly rate that you are
- 43:54going to seek, that's very helpful because the
- 43:56client's understanding and agreeing to that hourly
- 43:59rate and the contractual lien. So down the line,
- 44:02you've already checked one of the boxes off if
- 44:04you're going to be trying to get money in the
- 44:06event you get terminated as counsel. Right. And
- 44:10I just want to raise another area that's tricky
- 44:12is there are fee shifting statutes And what happens
- 44:16when you have a case that's worth $100 ,000 but
- 44:20you do $300 ,000 worth of legal work? Then you
- 44:23have a potential, you have to advance, talk with
- 44:26the client, how am I going to handle this? Or
- 44:29if it's a case where it's a breach of contract
- 44:32and the prevailing party gets attorney's fees,
- 44:34commonly what happens is I get to make a choice
- 44:37as to whether I want to throw it all into one
- 44:39pot and take 40 % of it or whatever the percentage
- 44:42is or take just the attorney's fees. But that
- 44:46can raise a conflict. I think when you're settling
- 44:49a case, say under a statute that provides for
- 44:52attorney's fees and the attorney's fees are much
- 44:54higher than the amount that the client's going
- 44:56to get. So I think what do you do? I guess tell
- 44:59the client they can seek independent advice if
- 45:02they want. No, I think what you do is never you
- 45:04should probably have in your fee agreement at
- 45:06the front end. It's at the attorney's election.
- 45:09Either the contingency fee on the total recovery
- 45:12lumping in the attorney's fees. or at the attorney's
- 45:16election, the statutory treats. But I'm just
- 45:19saying it gets tricky when you're settling the
- 45:22case. And there, you know, you've got 300 grand
- 45:26in attorney's fees and 100 grand for the client.
- 45:28Overall, if you can get the client to agree,
- 45:30OK, fine. But sometimes I think the class can
- 45:33say, hey, wait a minute. Maybe you cut me in
- 45:35for some of those some of that amount that you're
- 45:37going to get as well. That's just the realities
- 45:40of life. I don't disagree, and I've actually
- 45:44seen, and I don't know what Marshall's opinion
- 45:45would be on this, not only at the election of
- 45:49the attorney, or I've seen and in some contracts.
- 45:53Basically, statutory attorney's fees and my contingency,
- 45:56which I would say probably is a violation of
- 46:00the Conscionability Rule 1 .5. But so far, the
- 46:04state bar hasn't taken any action on that directly,
- 46:07as far as I've seen. All right, let's get into
- 46:09AI. That's a fun topic. Fun stuff. So I probably
- 46:14spoke on this, I don't know, 18 to 20 times last
- 46:17year. And it never ceases to amaze me that lawyers
- 46:22are still misusing AI. At this point, it's a
- 46:28great tool. It's here to stay. It's fully ingrained
- 46:32in all of our practice areas. It doesn't matter
- 46:35what you do. Lawyers are using it. Other types
- 46:38of companies are using it. I was just on the
- 46:40AAA website and noticed that they now have an
- 46:44AI arbitrator, fast, cost effective, and trusted
- 46:47dispute resolution with an intuitive, easy to
- 46:50use platform. You are services all these companies
- 46:55maybe using it triple a is advertising that you
- 46:58can now have an arbor trader. I think there's
- 47:01still a human component to it as they indicate
- 47:03but nonetheless you have to know how to use it
- 47:06and you have to know when it's being used against
- 47:08you because it's extremely valuable and if you
- 47:13look at rule one point one. If this is the first
- 47:16time you're you're you know attending a seminar
- 47:18regarding ai. You're honestly a little bit late
- 47:21to the game. You should be aware of this because
- 47:26this rule dictates that we're all required to
- 47:28be competent with respect to a number of things
- 47:31in particular. Emerging technology and so if
- 47:37you leave this seminar if nothing else start
- 47:39to dabble in AI there's a bunch of other seminars
- 47:42I've done with the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 47:44where we talk about various applications that
- 47:46can be used if you're a litigator if you're a
- 47:49contract transactional attorney there's companies
- 47:52that offer so many different types of services
- 47:54and you can start to learn about what might benefit
- 47:58you and your service. For me, I use artificial
- 48:01intelligence for trial work, a lot of creative
- 48:04issues, themes, cross -examining witnesses, all
- 48:07sorts of things come up. And it's just another
- 48:10tool in my tool belt to effectively represent
- 48:14my clients. We do not use artificial intelligence
- 48:19for briefing or anything like that, because obviously
- 48:22I think the work product we put out is far superior.
- 48:26but also if you go to the next slide, there's
- 48:31the ABA formal opinion 512, or you can go one
- 48:37more. Oh my goodness. It's okay. It's all right.
- 48:46We have a different PowerPoint up, so I'll go
- 48:50from memory here. So there's an ABA formal opinion
- 48:52512, which is the first ABA opinion really that
- 48:57addressed artificial intelligence and the risks
- 49:00that came out from it. And you should all be
- 49:03familiar with that opinion. It talks about a
- 49:07number of things. It's very useful to you to
- 49:09use how to guide yourself in dealing with artificial
- 49:13intelligence. I think a couple key points here
- 49:18are number one, if you have a firm, even if you're
- 49:22a sole practitioner, it's useful to create a
- 49:25firm policy. Regarding AI, if you're the managing
- 49:28partner of a firm or a partner of a firm and
- 49:31you oversee younger lawyers, and you're allowing
- 49:34the use of AI or you don't know whether your
- 49:36younger lawyers are using it, you definitely
- 49:39want to have a policy because California rule
- 49:41of professional conduct 5 .1 states that a lawyer
- 49:45who has managerial authority in a law firm is
- 49:48required to ensure that the firm is giving reasonable
- 49:52assurances that all lawyers are complying with
- 49:54the state bar. And so it's really easy to create
- 49:57a simple policy identifying when AI can be used,
- 50:01when it can't be used, who can use AI, how it
- 50:05can be used, all the different things. And you
- 50:07can limit it as much as you want, but when you
- 50:09look down the line, and I already have two cases
- 50:12now in the civil court arising out of malpractice
- 50:15claims for the use of AI, I was honestly a little
- 50:18bit surprised at how quickly I got those cases
- 50:21from the time AI has really... taken off in the
- 50:24legal field, but they're here and there's only
- 50:26going to be more of them. And so if you have
- 50:31a policy, it really creates a nice framework
- 50:33for you to defend a claim that says, look, this
- 50:37person either violated the policy or did something,
- 50:40went rogue, wasn't allowed to do it, whatever
- 50:41it might be. But in both matters I'm dealing
- 50:44with, there's no policy. It was too early. No
- 50:47one knew what was going on. And obviously, they
- 50:50used AI inappropriately because they were sort
- 50:53of ignorant of how to use it. And it spit out
- 50:57cases where hallucinations occurred. And the
- 51:00cases were fabricated. And now there's problems
- 51:02to deal with it. And I'm sure if you haven't
- 51:05heard about it, then it surprises me how many
- 51:08lawyers are still getting into trouble over this
- 51:10because It's not just in the Daily Journal that
- 51:13it's reported. It's in the New York Times. It's
- 51:16in the Wall Street Journal. It's all over the
- 51:19place. Firms nationwide are getting sanctioned
- 51:23more and more because they use artificial intelligence
- 51:28to draft briefs, which undoubtedly hallucinate
- 51:32and create cases that don't exist. Or not even
- 51:35that. It might cite a case that exists. but misconstrues
- 51:41a holding within that case. And a lot of these
- 51:45companies that are out there, for instance, Westlaw,
- 51:47Lexis, we know about them, they all offer an
- 51:50AI component. And a lot of them advertise that
- 51:52it's hallucination -free. And what that means
- 51:56is their artificial intelligence is built on
- 52:01a closed network. It's built on just the data
- 52:03that they choose to feed it, which is reliable
- 52:06data, right? It's treatises. You know case law
- 52:10it's all the things that westlaw traditionally
- 52:12has it doesn't allow it to feed from third party
- 52:15websites reddit things that chat gpt and other
- 52:19open source eyes. Allow the information to come
- 52:23from but the issue that's come up even when using
- 52:26westlaw is well you're gonna get a case that's
- 52:29valid and it's not gonna make it up completely.
- 52:32It might misconstrue the holding. It might pull
- 52:35from the descent of an opinion and get confused
- 52:38and give you a holding that you think, aha, I
- 52:40can cite this case. I know I'm safe. It's in
- 52:43Westlar Lexis. But if you don't check it to make
- 52:45sure, and then you file that brief and you intentionally
- 52:50misquote a case, you can get yourself into trouble
- 52:53that way. And there was a recent Court of Appeal
- 52:57opinion that came out here in the state of California.
- 53:00And they made the opinion published only for
- 53:04the reason that the lawyer used artificial intelligence
- 53:08on appeal. The actual appeal had no reason to
- 53:13be published. It was just a meaningless decision,
- 53:17nothing of merit. But they published the decision
- 53:20solely for the reason to basically chastise this
- 53:24lawyer in public. And then they were They took
- 53:26the decision and sent it to the state bar, and
- 53:29in the decision, it says this decision is being
- 53:31sent to the California State Bar for disciplinary
- 53:34proceedings. I mean, that's how seriously these
- 53:37issues are, and that's how careful you have to
- 53:40be. But again, I'm a big proponent of it because
- 53:44it's here to stay. And if you were just gonna
- 53:46say, I'm never gonna use it, I'm never gonna
- 53:48look at it, I do not think that is the right
- 53:52approach at all. One of the more extreme examples
- 53:57that have been used to date, and I think this
- 53:59just shows where it's going, is there was a criminal
- 54:03case, I believe, in the state of Arizona. It's
- 54:06called the Pelkey case. And this was a criminal
- 54:12case where the victim was deceased. And at the
- 54:17victim impact phase of the trial, which again,
- 54:21there's no jury present for this, right? This
- 54:22is just a victim impact statement that's being
- 54:25made to the court for determining sentencing.
- 54:28They created a artificial intelligent victim
- 54:33impact statement. This was video and audio. So
- 54:37the judge literally saw the deceased person give
- 54:42a victim impact statement of compassion, of accepting
- 54:46apologies, whatever it may have been that occurred.
- 54:50And the judge was quoted saying, among other
- 54:52things, I love that AI. And then the criminal
- 54:57defendant was sentenced to 10 and a half years
- 54:59in prison, which was in excess of what the prosecutors
- 55:02had sought for punishment. Now that case is on
- 55:07appeal. Okay, and it's going to be very interesting
- 55:09to see what happens with that case, but it's
- 55:13really, really important to understand that's
- 55:15how creative lawyers are being with artificial
- 55:18intelligence. And so if you're in depositions,
- 55:22if you're dealing with things, you need to start
- 55:25to learn how to ask questions about whether or
- 55:28not artificial intelligence was used by your
- 55:32clients, right? Because now your clients are
- 55:35clearly using artificial intelligence for emails,
- 55:40whatever it might be, you need to understand
- 55:42there's a whole new world and line of questionings,
- 55:45line of questions that have to come out through
- 55:48discovery and things like that, attacking and
- 55:51understanding the use of artificial intelligence.
- 55:54So again, you really just need to learn about
- 55:57it. This the California legislature is also playing
- 56:02catch -up, right? And it makes perfect sense
- 56:04and in one regard there's a new bill AB2013 and
- 56:10if you're a firm or an individual who's taking
- 56:12artificial intelligence and modifying the platform
- 56:16to conform to something you want like if you're
- 56:19really creating your own AI and plenty of firms
- 56:22are doing this they have taken it on themselves
- 56:24They're creating workflow systems, whatever it
- 56:27may be you are required to now disclose that
- 56:31to the public as to what your particular AI platform
- 56:36is. And so, again, that's just a rule if you're
- 56:39ahead of the game and adopting it. A lot of plaintiff
- 56:42big firms I know about have their own types of
- 56:44AI systems to manage cases, to deal with demand
- 56:48letters. Whatever it might be, you've got to
- 56:50be aware of AB 2013. I should mention that As
- 56:57I understand, a chat GBT is public to some degree
- 57:01and it can be discoverable if you're using it.
- 57:05And you may want to be on another platform that
- 57:09does not disclose what you're working on. I think
- 57:11Claude is one that. that does it that way as
- 57:14well, but that is a very troublesome area if
- 57:18you're trying to keep private whatever it is
- 57:20that you're researching. I should also mention
- 57:23I've had at least five clients in the last three
- 57:25weeks come in and say, here's how we're going
- 57:27to win this. case. I did it on chat JVT and I
- 57:30have to tell him, hey, I got to tell you something.
- 57:32I went to law school and that is not what fraud
- 57:34is in California. So be very wary and clients
- 57:38are showing up with pleadings. Here's the complaint.
- 57:41I've drafted it myself. It's a whole new world.
- 57:44Yeah. And look, pro plaintiffs are going to get
- 57:47to do these types of things. There's a couple
- 57:49of questions I want to hit real quick. Yes, the
- 57:51victim impact statement was AI generated voice
- 57:55and image. There's another question, do you consider
- 57:58it unethical for an attorney to double book a
- 58:01trial without disclosing the schedule conflict
- 58:04to both clients and not offer an opportunity
- 58:07for a continuance? I think that you just have
- 58:14to be able to represent your clients zealously
- 58:16and competently, right? And oftentimes trials
- 58:18get scheduled not necessarily on the same day.
- 58:20I have trials scheduled sometimes 10 days apart.
- 58:25I'm confident that I can deal with those schedules
- 58:28effectively. A judge can only force you to be
- 58:31in one trial at a time. And generally speaking,
- 58:33the older case is gonna go first. So while you
- 58:36might have two trials on the same day, there's
- 58:39a little bit of a glutton for punishment. I don't
- 58:41think there's anything unethical about it unless
- 58:43you can't effectively prepare for those trials
- 58:46at the same time. You probably should let your
- 58:49clients know that this has happened and you're
- 58:52gonna try to deal with it. which I think you
- 58:55should do. And then this question I think, Erin,
- 58:58you should hit, which is, if you receive funds
- 59:01in your trust account and the client dies without
- 59:04a will, preventing distribution of client funds
- 59:07within 40 days, what is one required to do? Same
- 59:10question if there are claims or lien against
- 59:13the funds. Well, you only have to distribute
- 59:16undisputed funds within 45 days. So, but it's
- 59:20on you. because it creates not having money in
- 59:24your trust account distributed within 45 days
- 59:26of receipt creates a rebuttable presumption that
- 59:29it wasn't promptly unless it's you have to prove
- 59:33that the money was disputed or other good cause.
- 59:36So the fact that the claimant has died and there's
- 59:39no probate from which you could just pay the
- 59:41money into would establish good cause. But it's
- 59:44up to you to have to build a prove it because
- 59:46that's one of the things that the changes to
- 59:491 .15 did. which is basically to create that
- 59:53verbal presumption in a discipline case. So it's
- 59:55up to the lawyer. So you're the one that has
- 59:58to prove that, oh, if there's liens, et cetera,
- 1:00:00et cetera, against those funds, the face value
- 1:00:03of the lien is disputed. But you have to show
- 1:00:06that you're taking diligent steps to distribute
- 1:00:09the funds. So if you can no longer probably safely
- 1:00:12continue just to do lien negotiation orally,
- 1:00:16you're going to have to have a component of it
- 1:00:19documenting those those efforts to resolve the
- 1:00:21liens to show why you weren't able to do it within
- 1:00:2345 days. And just to tag on one moment about
- 1:00:27the AI issue, I would 100 % agree with Marshall,
- 1:00:31it's here to stay. So the answer cannot be if
- 1:00:34you're an older lawyer, I don't use AI, because
- 1:00:36you may not use AI, but your associate, you could
- 1:00:39believe does. So to say, oh, you don't do that
- 1:00:42is just like telling your, I'm not going to text
- 1:00:44your client. Of course you are. So this is the
- 1:00:47kind of policy that I would say is the no -nonsense
- 1:00:49policy, because even though your associate drafted
- 1:00:51that document, you're the one signing it. So
- 1:00:54you're the one that would be sanctioned, even
- 1:00:56if you didn't even know how that competent lawyer
- 1:01:00has her own license did. So what you have, this
- 1:01:04is the policy I would suggest, that with every
- 1:01:06single pleading someone can prepare for you or
- 1:01:09letter that has any case law, that they also
- 1:01:12have a link in a folder. that they pulled the
- 1:01:16actual case off of Westlaw, or if you use Lexis,
- 1:01:18Lexis. That way, and if they quote in any language
- 1:01:22from a case, they have to highlight it. Because
- 1:01:24then it's easy to go back and for you to check
- 1:01:26and make sure everything's good. And that way
- 1:01:28they can, even if they drafted it with AI, they
- 1:01:30had to go do the checking themselves in order
- 1:01:32to pull all the cases. And a policy is important,
- 1:01:36but training is also important. So what you should
- 1:01:39do is that periodically, you know document that
- 1:01:42you've done training on whatever your policies
- 1:01:43are including AI and have your staff sign off
- 1:01:48that they got that training because that's how
- 1:01:50you're going to prevent the case being brought
- 1:01:53up against you by the state bar for lack of supervision
- 1:01:56either of your non -attorney or attorney staff.
- 1:01:59All right, well our hour is up. I'll just say
- 1:02:02one other final thing for all practitioners out
- 1:02:04there is when you have a case where your client
- 1:02:06could get hit with attorney's fees on the other
- 1:02:09side, either because of contract, law, or fee
- 1:02:13shifting, or for example, SLAP, anti -SLAP, make
- 1:02:17sure you let the client know that that is a possibility
- 1:02:21and have them sign off on that. I want to thank
- 1:02:23Marshall Cole and Aaron Joyce for participating
- 1:02:26in this and all of you. staying hanging in there
- 1:02:29and watching this to the end. Thank you very
- 1:02:31much. Thank you. Bye.