Latest / Newcomer Pod / Another Shoe to Drop (w/Jeremy Levine)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome, silicon salad. Hey everybody.
- 0:13Welcome to Dead cat. Eric newcomer here, very
- 0:16excited. I have Jeremy Levine an investor
- 0:20partner at best summer on the board of what Pinterest Shopify
- 0:25are you still on the board of Yelp.
- 0:26Also, not, not anymore. You stepped off on run button.
- 0:3014, 14 years years time but you still Pinterest and Shopify,
- 0:34right? I'm getting that right, chaos?
- 0:36Best summer. Last year announced 4.6 billion
- 0:40sort of sweet of funds including 780 million dollar buyout funds.
- 0:44So we'll be interested to talk about that later.
- 0:46The downturn but really have Jeremy on because I feel like
- 0:51you know, someone who's been at Bessemer for over two decades or
- 0:54real sort of VC who's willing to be honest in skeptic sort of
- 1:00Nails, the, the line between skeptical about some of the
- 1:04Euphoria while being sort of a long-term optimists in the
- 1:08technology industry. Do you think?
- 1:10Is that a fair characterization Jeremy?
- 1:12Yeah, I like that a lot, actually, I think that I'm a
- 1:15semi borrow that, so I just, I just wanted to start off since
- 1:19you're sort of, you've seen it all, could you?
- 1:22And this is like a, I don't know, business school type
- 1:25question, but could you just sort of chart out from the view
- 1:28of, like, the It markets, like the 2000, 2008, 2008 to this
- 1:35moment sort of, because, you know, we're going to be
- 1:37searching for metaphors in what this moment is.
- 1:41But can you just sort of chart out sort of the startup hype
- 1:44cycles that we've experienced starting with the 2000?
- 1:47Boom. Well that's like trying to teach
- 1:50a history course without having prepared any lecture notes not
- 1:53you don't have to hit every you know this sort of you live
- 1:56through it. Yeah I so well I joined
- 1:59Bessemer. In 2001, and really, chew
- 2:04bubbles. I guess had burst within a year
- 2:07of each other. Just before I became a venture
- 2:10capitalist or actually, what happened?
- 2:12Just before what happened, just after the first was the internet
- 2:14bubble, people refer to that, as the.com crash of the.com, boom.
- 2:19And that were less came to an end in April 2000, precipitated
- 2:24by a massive fall in the Nasdaq, all of a sudden.
- 2:26And then a little more than a year later.
- 2:29There was a second. One that Two men, a lot less but
- 2:31it was essentially the end of a telecom boom.
- 2:33And so those two Trends, the development of the consumer
- 2:36internet and this massive Telecom boom, which was actually
- 2:39driven largely by a regulatory change in 1996.
- 2:43The Telecom deregulation. Act in 1986 create two huge
- 2:47trends, that Venture capitalists and entrepreneurs capitalized on
- 2:51by funding for the Reese's and building to the entrepreneurs,
- 2:54all these great companies. But it got in both instances.
- 2:57Euphoric, as you said, and people started you Crazy things
- 3:01build companies that had no, no Traer had a gravity's invest in
- 3:05companies at crazy valuations, despite the fact that there is
- 3:08no prayer having revenues in both the internet, boom, and the
- 3:13Telethon being. And eventually as happens over
- 3:17and over and over history, people came to their senses and
- 3:20said, wait a minute. There's some really great stuff
- 3:23here but there's a lotta stuff that isn't so.
- 3:24Great, was there a key trigger to people coming to their
- 3:27senses? You know, it's funny, it's I
- 3:30don't having lived here. I'm not sure what the trigger
- 3:32was. It was sort of like somebody
- 3:34woke up and said, wait a minute and then everyone else like, oh
- 3:37yeah, wait a minute. And it's there wasn't a sudden
- 3:41interest rate pipe or the beginning of some interest rate
- 3:43hikes like there were in 2021 2022.
- 3:47So I'm honestly not sure I think eventually maybe some fatigue,
- 3:52finally, enter the picture but I don't know.
- 3:54Good question. Okay.
- 3:55So then.com this sort of double And boom sort of unwinds and
- 4:03people really like there are questions of whether the
- 4:06technology industry is really a thing, or what was this sense of
- 4:09pessimism at the bottom of that bus?
- 4:13I mean, it was it was wild. It really shuang dramatically
- 4:16the other way to the point where they were at, it won't take more
- 4:19than two seconds of Google searching, but there were
- 4:21multiple cover stories of like Amazon being a sham, right?
- 4:26And that the thing was going to go to zero and by the way, at
- 4:29some point I can't do the math in my head on, like a split
- 4:31adjusted basis, but the stock is trading at like $2 a share and
- 4:35that's tree splits, that would be relative to like several
- 4:38thousand dollars or shared today.
- 4:39I think the people just basically threw in the towel or
- 4:43the proverbial baby with the bathwater and no one wanted to
- 4:47touch anything. It was kind of funny.
- 4:48Actually, there's this, you know, there's there's virtue
- 4:52signaling all over the place and as the.com build-up was
- 4:56increasing, people literally started adding.com to the end of
- 4:59a random. And that's some had doubled
- 5:01evaluation. I think, at one point, even
- 5:03like, Barnes & Noble became barnesandnoble.com.
- 5:06And then as the bubble bursts people did the opposite, they
- 5:09just remove.com from all the names.
- 5:11It was like the most she would obvious kind of Shameless thing.
- 5:15I one day I'm in a company or what am not the next.
- 5:18I am in the next. I'm not again.
- 5:19Well that's like with crypto today as the x-rays.
- 5:22He really thought XYZ it was it was it was really hot sure the
- 5:26minutes but I will say after when the despair Are got got
- 5:31deep, that's when the real, that's who the true art of
- 5:34nerves began to merge, they didn't give up on it at a out of
- 5:37the ashes of the.com implosion came three really valuable and
- 5:44important companies. One was Amazon one was eBay and
- 5:50then one was Yahoo which quickly got eclipsed by Google, they all
- 5:54all existence so maybe good for now.
- 5:56Obviously, Google remains important today.
- 5:57Yahoo not so much but then a whole bunch.
- 6:00Bodybuilders who were truly passionate about building
- 6:03something new capitalizing on these new Talons and trends,
- 6:08like the fact is millions and millions of consumers in the
- 6:11United States, were not connected to the internet.
- 6:13That wasn't true in 1996. I was sure in 2001 the speed of
- 6:17these connections use increasing dramatically the power of these
- 6:21web applications also proved like in the early days of the
- 6:23internet, you could just get kind of checks and basic images
- 6:27on your website. There was no interactivity this
- 6:30Was about Ajax which allowed a little bit of interactivity.
- 6:32Inside the web browser came and that allow all these new
- 6:36applications of like true entrepreneurs despite the affair
- 6:39started building things. I remember in 2001 2002 and my
- 6:43first year, so Adventure Capital, there was not a lot of
- 6:47activity and the pace of new Investments and engage meet with
- 6:51conduct charges quite slow, right?
- 6:53But those who were doing it back then, like boy, oh boy, they
- 6:56were really serious. And really passionate because
- 6:58they were not deterred. By all the naysayers and it was
- 7:02very unpopular to be an entrepreneur particularly the
- 7:05internet in 2002 2003 2004 and then 2008.
- 7:10So then what I guess what? 2003-2004 people start to regain
- 7:15their confidence and then 2008-2009 is sort of the next
- 7:20dip. Yeah, I think let's show it a
- 7:21true except that the 2000-2001 crashes, you know, until a
- 7:25couple. But we're really tech industry,
- 7:28specific issues and then Then slowly things started to build
- 7:32from 2002, to 2007, you know, TechCrunch emerged, I think in
- 7:382005. Hmm, and we start to meet really
- 7:42compelling entrepreneurs, folks like Jeremy, stoppelman who
- 7:44would have dropped out of business school in 2004 to build
- 7:48Yelp, that was a very unpopular thing to do.
- 7:51That's some serious guts. And obviously, he was, he was
- 7:54passion driven to do it, but by 2007, 2008, funding had started
- 7:59to increase. These companies are getting
- 8:01publicity notoriety and fame through New Media.
- 8:04Outlets like TechCrunch that emerge.
- 8:06I should replace predecessors shower gel.
- 8:09It offline things like, you know, Fast Company magazine and
- 8:12Wired Magazine which were at, like 300 Pages, thick mostly ads
- 8:16at the peak of the.com bubble, and then became 15 pages if I
- 8:19change the name, right? Non-existent so funny Chris but
- 8:22there are no exits literally, no exits.
- 8:24I think the only notable exit during that period in the
- 8:27consumer, internet was Maybe YouTube, I can remember exactly.
- 8:30They are. Which appeared is this?
- 8:31This is from 2001 to 2007 2008. Yeah.
- 8:34And so the funding and those startups, the creation of
- 8:37startups, in the willingness, should people to take chances
- 8:40and be entrepreneurs and build something steadily increased
- 8:43during that period. But there wasn't yet a lot of
- 8:46evidence that he was working, right?
- 8:48Companies were starting to work. Consumers were engaging,
- 8:51software was a version but there are no exits.
- 8:54The Venture industry in general had very few compelling exits.
- 8:57When you sold a company to the company public, And generated
- 9:01three or four extra turn, that was noteworthy.
- 9:03Wow, you know, congratulations that's impressive.
- 9:06There wasn't a lot of it. And then the financial crisis
- 9:09happened and everything kind of pause for a brief moment and
- 9:14those who were building companies, kept building
- 9:16companies really smart acquirers like Google got aggressive and
- 9:20said, wow, like everything is cheap.
- 9:23Maybe we can buy a bunch of great stuff and they made
- 9:25overtures and try to do things. Like they dance with the up
- 9:28further to get, trying to buy you.
- 9:29Hmm. Each didn't ultimately work out
- 9:31but it just sort of put a pause on things, but it was kind of
- 9:33had nothing to do with the tech industry.
- 9:35Like nothing had changed inside Russia.
- 9:37Had kept by me so he's like a reset because everyone's like
- 9:39wait a minute is my bank account?
- 9:41Even gonna allow me to withdraw cash tomorrow.
- 9:44Money market funds started locking up, the government
- 9:47intervened and came in with these, you'd rescue packages,
- 9:50right? I mean, it's sort of, this is a
- 9:52very easy simplification, but 2000.
- 9:56There were real valuation questions.
- 9:57Like what is the opportunity for the tech markets?
- 10:00It was 2008. It's like what happens if we
- 10:02have a recession and just you know there's less consumer
- 10:05spending on what's the effect on the technology industry and I'm
- 10:09going to skip ahead. You know, I think that is sort
- 10:11of a big question now where some people are worried about
- 10:14valuations and some people are worried about the recession.
- 10:17I'll let you respond to that in a bit, but I want to, I want to
- 10:19get there. So we have this 2008.
- 10:22Not specific to Tech but you know, the markets generally are
- 10:26pessimistic. We dip a little bit and then we
- 10:28sort of enter You know, in this is where, you know, Facebook's,
- 10:32you know, emerges and everything like that.
- 10:36Sort of bull period up to like 2015 2016.
- 10:39Or yeah, get us there. Yeah.
- 10:41Well, so the financial crisis, I view as a pause and basically
- 10:44the public market prices dropped precipitously, things started to
- 10:48walk up. And that was on after seven
- 10:51years of slowly gradually building confidence, building,
- 10:55valuations, building Ontario, activity and building d.c.
- 10:58investment. It's a during that pause
- 11:01basically because the public market price is adjusted,
- 11:03tyrannically entrepreneurs and investors were like, we're not
- 11:07sure what you do entrepreneurs, like, hey, is going to bounce
- 11:09back up at best destroy. Hey, we're not so sure.
- 11:11And so, it was just kind of waited for a little bit.
- 11:13In the meantime, those who are out there building folks, like,
- 11:16you know, Jeremy stop my Yelp or rehab, but I like to damaged
- 11:18building and they're like, you know what?
- 11:19This is a bomber. Maybe we can't raise Capital the
- 11:23same price as we thought we could.
- 11:25It's okay. They just kept building and the
- 11:26ucg kept increasing and no quality business kept
- 11:29increasing. NG but they weren't affected so
- 11:32much directly by the financial crisis and the very brief
- 11:35recession except that they realized they couldn't spend
- 11:38quite as freely because money wasn't as available.
- 11:41But within almost 18 months, that kind of reversed, I think
- 11:45government, Regulators did a politicians even did a really
- 11:48nice job, preventing a total tailspin and injecting a bunch
- 11:52of money into the economy. Not too much money, and it picks
- 11:55back up again. And so if you almost ignore In
- 12:002009 time period and just take it out its history, you could
- 12:04probably just draw a straight and steady line and then 2010
- 12:08came people relax a little bit and even more her company.
- 12:13So you get started folks. Like I think Geoff Lawson, truly
- 12:16was 2009. Toby hiki.
- 12:18Started shop, quite like in the middle of all that nonsense.
- 12:22He was unable to raise much money.
- 12:24I think he Factory favor sir, is he you went to Silicon Valley
- 12:27from Ottawa Canada, raised money, he was Is so Scrappy that
- 12:31and bowed, there's no boober, yeah, in 2 thousand, drag
- 12:35whatever a when he went. There is no, it's impossible to
- 12:38get a taxi and how out to, he bought a bicycle on Craigslist
- 12:43and he bites up and down Santo Rey's to meet with Venture
- 12:46firms. And everyone told him no, no
- 12:48Ray, no way, no chance. He went back to aw that are to
- 12:51keep doing it the hard way folks, I just started to notice
- 12:54him in 2010 and start investing is so who's a lot of building
- 12:57going on? And then I think a breakthrough
- 12:58moment happened. I think it was two Thousand
- 13:00Eleven when LinkedIn went public and that was a like, oh, my and
- 13:05Linkedin had a it was a multi-billion dollar market cap,
- 13:08but it was it was definitely south of 10, but that was a huge
- 13:11deal, the most notable internet BC exit.
- 13:15Before that, I think, like I said before, was YouTube to
- 13:17Google, that was maybe one and a half billion dollars.
- 13:19This is a multiple of that. And people like wow, maybe this
- 13:22internet thing, is it thing? And it just took a little while
- 13:25it means I'm Amazon, you know, it recovered.
- 13:27It was a two dollar stock and was bacteria.
- 13:30Significant business eBay, continue to generate massive
- 13:33profits and I kind of skipped a Google story but they also what
- 13:37public you know I appreciate the best more portfolio.
- 13:40Are the main. It was in my Milestone.
- 13:43Those are my markers, totally fair, just flagging.
- 13:45That twilio. LinkedIn Shopify.
- 13:48Yeah. I mean in the sort of Bull Run,
- 13:51I guess I got to live through covering Silicon Valley.
- 13:53It feels like we were incorrectly worried or what's
- 13:55been amazing about this period? Is that it was actually a very
- 13:58long period. Of optimism, right?
- 14:01Or, you know, you think like, whatever skepticism in 2015,
- 14:052016 was just sort of missed place.
- 14:08Now, where I was just looking back at my old stories and I
- 14:11had, you know, the fuzzy insane math of valuations basically
- 14:15warning about, you know, preferred shareholder perks,
- 14:18which is much more relevant today than it was.
- 14:20Then I think Bill girly, tweeted out an old blog post of his,
- 14:24it's sort of flagged, you know, some warnings that weren't
- 14:27really app then but now No matter about debt and sort of
- 14:31the risks of the debt. I mean, do you think we were
- 14:33just worried in that period because it seemed about time or
- 14:37do you think we saw sort of behavior that led to today?
- 14:42I think two different things happen, they're interrelated.
- 14:44The first is that historically, the economic cycle is between 5
- 14:48and 10 years over and over and over again and while there's
- 14:51that blip it with 08-09, like I said, if you took it out, you
- 14:55could just keep drawing a straight line where I wouldn't
- 14:58say there was like enthusiasm and Demelza minnow fiber or six
- 15:01or seven, but it was starting to build from the despair of 2001
- 15:05by 2010 or 11. We're kind of back to normal.
- 15:08Now we're seeing really significant exits.
- 15:10Like I said, linked in public. I think he'll probably likes
- 15:13your Facebook was emerging and growing it eventually and
- 15:15public. And so we're starting to see
- 15:17like the fruits of the labor while these hard-working
- 15:20entrepreneurs and lucky BC is it just kept going and by 2015 2016
- 15:25it's like oh my yes, there was this blip of the financial
- 15:29crisis, which is More or less independent check, but it's now
- 15:31been like 14 or 15 years, right? Everything is moved up into the
- 15:35right year after year, after year.
- 15:37And so I think some people were just freaking out.
- 15:38Saying, I, of course, it's coming because it's come every
- 15:40time in history once these cyclists get Beyond five or six
- 15:44years, and then other people were just looking at
- 15:46fundamentals and saying, wow, in the despair of 01:02.
- 15:51We thought everything was worth nothing including amazing
- 15:54businesses, like Amazon, and we've gained increasing copies
- 15:58every year since then, some It were by 2015, 2016 things were
- 16:02valued really well and you saw multiples for software companies
- 16:06and other companies, get you a really healthy levels.
- 16:09They were massively higher than what they were in 2002 but a
- 16:14bathing in hindsight would benefit has it.
- 16:16They were probably about rights. Hmm.
- 16:18And then from 2015 to 2020 one, they just kept going up by 20 or
- 16:2425 percent every year. And as things get bigger and
- 16:26bigger and bigger, it encourages more people to start building
- 16:29it. Hers is working and start
- 16:30investing and by 2021, it had gone so far beyond rational that
- 16:38you eventually, when the first sign of a, oh my goodness, maybe
- 16:41there's something else you can use your money.
- 16:43But speculate happens, which was the initial interest rate, jack
- 16:47up everyone freaked out, right? And I think if you look at where
- 16:50we are today, in the sort of post adjusted world, I think is
- 16:54kind of back to where it was in 2015-16.
- 16:57I have actually gone to run the bat but I suspect Multiples that
- 17:01people are willing to pay the wiki or value companies.
- 17:03Today is about where was that. And so those, you were freaked
- 17:07out that it had kind of started to get too hot were probably
- 17:10right in 2015, 2016, because now that we have a bit more
- 17:13perspectives, I think we're more or less right back to where we
- 17:16were right. 20:21 was sort of a uniquely insane.
- 17:21You're right. I mean, we had, we sort of
- 17:23skipped over the covid head fake, where people thought,
- 17:26okay? Maybe it's all going to unwind
- 17:28and covid you saucer? Okoye warning, people.
- 17:31But then because of covid, you know, the bank's lowered
- 17:34interest rates and people were working from home, all of a
- 17:36sudden, it was a boon to Tech. So then that helped actually
- 17:39fuel growth and then we really sort of saw everything on wine
- 17:43starting maybe, you know, December 20, 21, and onward, did
- 17:47you as sort of as an investment firm?
- 17:49Try to do anything different in 2021.
- 17:52I mean, like a phenomenon. I see specifically is just like,
- 17:55you know, firms return so much too good.
- 17:59You know, if you were a good investor, I think you were
- 18:02quoted in the information. Basically saying, like anybody
- 18:05who is anybody should have returned in this bull market.
- 18:08The thing is, people would return a ton of money but then
- 18:11they're like, well, if I'm returning it, I'm also going to
- 18:13deploy a similar amount of money in 2021.
- 18:16So the question is, you know, how did you play it and do you
- 18:19think it was a mistake for people who sort of basically
- 18:23tried to deploy as much as they were returning to investors?
- 18:27So there's no doubt that I think that are very Very few
- 18:30Investments that will have been made in 2021 that weren't very
- 18:34early stage companies that people want with hindsight from
- 18:37rent. Because they paid such a crazy
- 18:39price, there will be exceptions for sure.
- 18:42But up until from 2015, to 2020 one, the winner of the game.
- 18:47So to speak from an Investor's perspective, was he who invested
- 18:50the most is when things go up by 25% a year, you just want to get
- 18:53as much of everything as you can and a bunch of folks, literally
- 18:56Embrace that trying to do as much as I could.
- 18:58This was like the and Model then the SoftBank model and the tiger
- 19:02model. You know, there's sort of a game
- 19:04of who can be sort of the top price sticker.
- 19:07I mean, I don't think anyone was out there trying to pay the
- 19:09highest price possible. But a lot of people are like, oh
- 19:11wow, these Trends are amazing. They're powerful.
- 19:15We want to get as much of these Trends as we possibly can.
- 19:18And so people got really aggressive and there's nobody
- 19:21who didn't get aggressive because it was impossible to
- 19:23invest if you weren't going to be really aggressive.
- 19:26When that changes, all of a sudden, like I said, I think
- 19:29people regret a lot of the decisions they made in 2020 or
- 19:322021 because the pricing would have been objectives besides it
- 19:35was really really high and so I think might my simple rubric is
- 19:39that valuations for a she takes a somebody's as an example,
- 19:45they're down about 75%. So insane.
- 19:49If you are a 10 million dollar Revenue SAS company, in 2021 you
- 19:54can raise money at a 500 million dollar valuation.
- 19:59Growing very quickly today. I think you could raise money at
- 20:03about 100 billion dollar valuation so that's actually
- 20:0680%. So in order to get if you did
- 20:08raise money at a 500 million dollar valuation, in order to
- 20:11get back to that level, you need to grow your business almost
- 20:15five times and so that will just take time.
- 20:18If your SAS company and you you had 10 million dollar of Revenue
- 20:23under management. In 2021, you could raise money
- 20:26at a 500 million dollar valuation and many did today.
- 20:30Assuming you're growing really quickly and have a high quality
- 20:32business, you're probably raising Capital at.
- 20:34We're like 100 million dollar valuation.
- 20:36So to get back to the 500 million dollar valuation that
- 20:39you had in 2021, you roughly have to increase in size of your
- 20:43business. By fivefold, get from about 10
- 20:45billion, dollars Revenue, 250 and there are a lot of really
- 20:48high quality companies that will in fact, do that and that when
- 20:52they go to raise Capital, next when there are 50 or 60 million
- 20:54dollar Revenue business, there is nice up rounds and the folks
- 20:58who invested even at these Really aggressive valuations in
- 21:012021, will feel good about themselves on average?
- 21:04However, it's really hard to do that, not that many companies
- 21:07grow their businesses by 5x in relatively short periods of
- 21:10time. So I think most will regret the
- 21:13prices that they paid, but we'll get a boon to the other peers.
- 21:16You were smart enough to raise a capital and they can get it.
- 21:19And now if they invest it wisely, even if it takes a while
- 21:23to get to a larger scale. It's okay, they have the cats to
- 21:26get there and in park has a raise so much money. 20, Anyone,
- 21:30I mean, there's a flip side to this, which is people also
- 21:34needed to seize the bull market, right?
- 21:37Or it was a time to harvest wins.
- 21:41I mean, I look back you know, I did it in a big profile of best
- 21:44summer while the boom times were going.
- 21:47I think I gave you guys a little bit of a hard time, just how big
- 21:50Shopify and twilio are. And it was the moment when, you
- 21:54know, Sequoia was out there sort of beating his chest about
- 21:56holding public stocks and then With the benefit of hindsight.
- 22:01It's like, okay. Yeah.
- 22:02Makes sense to sort of sell down your position in cash and
- 22:05winners. Even if you have these
- 22:07generational companies, I mean at the same time, what author
- 22:11zero was a big one of yours, right?
- 22:13That you they got sold when things were way up.
- 22:17So, yeah, I don't know with a little bit of distance from it.
- 22:20How would you score yourself on sort of getting the most out of
- 22:24the bull market, while being sort of, well, situated for the
- 22:27downturn? We've made every mistake?
- 22:29Possible. But we've also got some things,
- 22:32right? And so with the benefit of
- 22:33hindsight, we distributed our stock and Shopify way too early.
- 22:37And the same time, we held onto some stocks in 2021, a bit too
- 22:41long. I think, if you're were not all
- 22:44that focused on getting that exactly right, of course, we're
- 22:47always trying to do better, but the real win, if you will.
- 22:50And the excitement of what motivates us is to invest in a
- 22:53company, like Shopify or 0, 0, when it's really small and
- 22:58nurture, it and help that, Company become really big.
- 23:01And if you manage to top ticket and exit your position, exactly.
- 23:05When the market cap is really all the power to you, that's
- 23:08just not that interesting of a game and made a sure.
- 23:11It might improve your returns a bit, but the real energy if you
- 23:14will the real effort into generating investment returns.
- 23:17And finally, the reward of playing in The Venture game is
- 23:20going to work with the entrepreneurs when they got
- 23:22something really compelling and small and Healthcare dozen or
- 23:26less focus on. Like, how do we get out at
- 23:28exactly the right time. And in fact, We invested in
- 23:30Shopify had 2010, I'm still in the board in 2022. 12 years
- 23:35later, we're even though Bessemer doesn't own a
- 23:37significant position. It's incredibly rewarding to
- 23:40partnering these entrepreneurs when they have a mission and
- 23:43stick with it for a really long time.
- 23:45So, okay in our search of, you know, this downturn, what's the
- 23:49right metaphor and you know what can we learn from the past?
- 23:54What's Your Gut read on the percent of like bullshit right
- 23:58now or like I In judging whether we're similar to.com or not, it
- 24:03just like we had all these companies that got out via spax,
- 24:06you know, on demand. When crazy, there's a lot of
- 24:08stuff outside of like pure SAS. That to me, looks questionable,
- 24:14but I guess from your read, just like how much bullshit is there
- 24:17out there? How many companies are there
- 24:19that? That have no path.
- 24:21I know that's hard to calibrate. Yeah, I don't.
- 24:23So I think it's really different from the.com explosion in the
- 24:27sense that one when that was over.
- 24:30As I mentioned before, there are like three or four really strong
- 24:32internet companies left standing and they've all endured even
- 24:36Yahoo is still worth billions of dollars.
- 24:38Generates, lots of Revenue, I believe Apollo owns it today but
- 24:41only three or four atoms hundreds.
- 24:43I mean hundreds as a brief aside.
- 24:45So why and I'll come back to what I think of today in a
- 24:48moment. But when I joined the Venture
- 24:50industry in 2001, I looked at these entrepreneurs and
- 24:53businesses and these venture capitalist who funded them from
- 24:5696 to 2000 and I was jealous. Oh my Lord.
- 25:01Like they generated enormous value and enormous wealth in
- 25:05such a short time and I said, to myself, the world is never going
- 25:08to get this crazy again, right? Like, like that the entire world
- 25:12smoked a giant joints and I was high as a kite like what fun, it
- 25:16would have been to be part of that, but I and I missed the
- 25:19party but I thought you know, it's really rewarding and fun
- 25:22and challenging to find compelling entrepreneurs, invest
- 25:25in startups. So even though it's never going
- 25:27to get as good as it was in 2000 again, I'm gonna try to make
- 25:30this my career because I think I'll find it fun and well holds
- 25:3420 years later it happened again like they someone passed a joint
- 25:38around the party a second time and no one remembered what
- 25:40happened the first time and things got crazy.
- 25:43So in that sense it's really similar and enormous wealth was
- 25:46created, enormous companies are created, but the difference is
- 25:49when that party ended at the end of 20 21, it wasn't three or
- 25:53four companies left standing, it was dozens and dozens of strong
- 25:58public companies. And hundreds of religion in
- 26:01private companies. Now not every unicorn and not
- 26:04every company that raised a lot of money will be successful, but
- 26:07the industry is I don't say two orders of magnitude larger than
- 26:12it was. Yeah, 2008.
- 26:14Obviously I'm not saying that this period could be a total
- 26:17invalidation of like technology, right?
- 26:19And in the way that the.com bust was.
- 26:23So I feel like, you know, you do sort of have to distort the
- 26:27metaphor slightly and that it's not everything but it's just, I
- 26:30guess to me, the question is Was there so much optimism that you
- 26:36know, the next round will be higher than the last that sort
- 26:40of any sort of cash flow modeling or real rigor was
- 26:44thrown out the door and therefore we can't really trust,
- 26:48you know, even like Deca core and level valuations.
- 26:52There were granted in 2021. Yes and no I think clearly the
- 26:56valuations are often. You can see it in the public
- 26:57markets. The public valuations are down
- 26:59by three quarters, not every single company but we're less
- 27:02across the board. So, you can basically apply that
- 27:05to the private companies, just the same.
- 27:07And so, if you had a private company valuation of 10 billion,
- 27:10a rule of thumb is assume it's two and a half billion today.
- 27:13Yeah, I come in. Yeah.
- 27:14But that, and that doesn't mean you won't get back to 10 billion
- 27:17that just means you got to grow the business is essentially two
- 27:20doubles, if you can double your size this year and double
- 27:22yourselves. Again next year, I'm not that
- 27:24good at math, but two times, two is four I believe four times two
- 27:27and a half million, you're right back to 10, right?
- 27:29So the best case scenario or I should say that there's probably
- 27:33Better case. But a really good case scenario,
- 27:35is, you still have a great company still growing quickly.
- 27:38You can double two more times and in Chu, here's your back to
- 27:41a ten billion dollar renovation. No one is crying for those
- 27:45writer, printers are investors. That's a pretty table album.
- 27:48And by the way, if you fall short of that and because you're
- 27:51trying to be a little bit more conservative with your Capital,
- 27:54you don't have access to quite so much and therefore, you can't
- 27:57be as aggressive in your growth. Maybe you grow your business, 40
- 28:02percent this year, And forty percent next year.
- 28:05Well, 40 percent growth followed by 40 percent growth will make
- 28:09you about twice as big as you are today.
- 28:12And so if you translate that to the value in the mock exercise,
- 28:17you're doing here. That turns a two and a half
- 28:18billion dollar company. 25 billion, is it a decade Corner
- 28:21know there's 25 billion dollar Equity that's pretty amazing.
- 28:25I was dunking on lift for being exactly like four to five
- 28:28billion dollars and somebody I think it was Jason lemkin
- 28:31tweeted at me like that. There was a time where it was
- 28:34cool to be a four or five billion dollar company and to
- 28:37some degree we've just totally lost perspective, like lots of
- 28:40people get rich at a four to five billion dollar company.
- 28:42It's not, it's not the end of the world, it can still be a
- 28:45good return for VCS if they got in at the right price.
- 28:48So some of it is just resetting how much wealth is supposed to
- 28:52be created and in a win scenario.
- 28:55That's right. And I'd argue.
- 28:56It's not just a good, it's a phenomenal outcome, it's a
- 28:58phenomenal. Come to be part of something
- 29:01earlier, even in the middle stages, up becomes worth.
- 29:03Two or three or four five billion dollars.
- 29:06It's about it doesn't happen that often but what's amazing is
- 29:08that there are actually hundreds of examples that we can point
- 29:11to. But it's still his hundreds out
- 29:13of tens of thousands or more attempts and so it still is so
- 29:17long odds. Do you have a view on what 2023
- 29:21will look like here? So in the end of 20 21, I was
- 29:25optimistic about 2023 and I felt like the imbalance in the system
- 29:29will start to work itself out. Now, there were in 2023 I'm a
- 29:33little bit less optimistic as to how quickly that imbalance work
- 29:36itself out. But we're still seeing a lot of
- 29:39really interesting entrepreneurs much like we did in 2002 and
- 29:432003, say, forget, I don't care about the capital markets, like,
- 29:47I have an idea, I have a vision for what I want to build, and I
- 29:50want to build it. Now, I don't want to wait five
- 29:52years before it's trendy again, right?
- 29:54And many ways, I think they're playing to an advantage because
- 29:58I think today, Google announced it was laying off. 12,000
- 30:01people, you know? Was understand, significant
- 30:04Cuts. Stripe, has none to give me a
- 30:06call at ShopRite and significant has, these are all really great
- 30:09companies with phenomenal people and teams.
- 30:12And I'm certain that not everybody.
- 30:15They've let go is an amazing, you know, wildly, talented
- 30:17person, but many of them are. And if you were trying to build
- 30:20a company over the last five years, you couldn't get access
- 30:23to those people because they had these amazing jobs that
- 30:25fantastic companies. Now, all of a sudden you can
- 30:27recruit and build teams at a quality level for a really young
- 30:31company, that was fun. Heard about five years ago.
- 30:34I'm so while yes, it's much harder to raise capital and
- 30:37there's just less of it out there.
- 30:39It's also much easier to find great people and I'd argue and
- 30:43now that big you might even be able to recruit them and lower
- 30:46the mature company and pay them. Less rice means, you don't
- 30:48actually need as much capital and so the - stop me really
- 30:51helpful. Sure company formation and idea
- 30:54generation. And it's also the case that, you
- 30:56know, maybe the mood at a company like Google or Facebook
- 31:01Isn't So cheery. So, But out to people who were
- 31:05just having a blast for a few years now like, hey, this isn't
- 31:07so much fun anymore. Much more fun to go.
- 31:10Start something were to go build something.
- 31:12Part of being a successful investor is you have to have a
- 31:15sort of Divergent thesis or it just feels to me like right now,
- 31:19like every VC is evoking, this sort of metaphor that great
- 31:24companies were built out of the aftermath of a bust and that
- 31:29it's like a good time to start and some of what we're seeing
- 31:33there. N is that seed in series a
- 31:35prices, just haven't fallen, any certainly anywhere near the
- 31:39super late stage yet. And so I guess my question is
- 31:44like are those rounds priced appropriately given the risk and
- 31:50like isn't it? If, you know, even a coat or
- 31:53whatever with all this money is rushing to series a because they
- 31:56need to do something. Are there really going to be
- 31:59great deals and series a this year?
- 32:01If it's so competitive? Because a lot of people have a
- 32:04similar intuition. Yeah, I think it's AI mean.
- 32:08I think when you're making a seed or a series a, or even a
- 32:11series be investment. What's most important is that
- 32:15you're filing a great company, great entrepreneur, great idea
- 32:19that can grow for a while. If you overpay, and by the way,
- 32:22like, I'll go back to our LinkedIn invest in, which was a
- 32:25series C investment in 2006. At the time we wildly overpaid
- 32:31Lincoln was maybe a ten billion dollar Dollar Revenue company we
- 32:34invested at a 225 ish million dollars hundred thirty million
- 32:39dollar valuation that was unheard of AG.
- 32:41Nobody paid 25 times Revenue to invest in coming 2006 so much so
- 32:46that linkedin's existing investors both invested zeroing
- 32:49a financing. They thought we had overpaid by
- 32:51such a dramatic amount but it was a phenomenal company and
- 32:54maybe we did overpay relative to what the court Market was or we
- 32:58should have paid by 20 or 30 or 50 percent but the company still
- 33:02grew to the point. Where I think our position was,
- 33:04right at 100 x by the to a company.
- 33:06And they said, and so, when you're investing at a relatively
- 33:09early stage, there's so many ways to get bailed out.
- 33:12If you've caught a tiger by the tail and of back, somebody truly
- 33:15phenomenal, as you get to a later later, stage, your
- 33:18opportunity to get bailed out, shrink dramatically and so I
- 33:21think that's why we're seeing the price adjustments at the
- 33:23later stage in today's market, have been much more dramatic of
- 33:26the earlier stage. That said, I think there's
- 33:29another shoe to drop. I don't think it will be as
- 33:31dramatic, I think will happen. In in some slow motion.
- 33:34But there's another challenge that the whole industry is
- 33:37facing, as everybody gets a little bit more conservative and
- 33:40a little bit more concerned and the challenges as an investor.
- 33:44When I see someone else's series, a investment become a
- 33:48series be company or someone else's Series, be investing
- 33:50become a serious C company and I may have an opportunity to
- 33:53invest in it. I want to feel like I'm
- 33:56investing in a phenomenal company.
- 33:57I'll stretch really aggressively, but I also like
- 34:00understand there's a market and I Don't Want to Be Wild.
- 34:03Out of line with the market, I want to be sort of at the full
- 34:05end of the market. If you want to make sure
- 34:06everyone feels like they got a good deal, right?
- 34:09And what is happening is that if there are no opportunities to do
- 34:12that and I'm a little bit more skeptical or a little bit more
- 34:15cynical. The existing ambassadors will
- 34:17feel like we need to support our company because it's hard to
- 34:20find a lots of right outside interest.
- 34:22And then when they do that, they realize that wait a minute.
- 34:25We can't be aggressive in investing in someone else's
- 34:28portfolio company, right? Because we need to save more
- 34:30money for our own portfolio. This is super real.
- 34:33Anon if you like, yeah, everybody's doubling down on
- 34:35their own, but it become self-fulfilling because if you
- 34:38feel like you need a reserve or Capital to your own companies
- 34:41even more tight, right, what it comes to evaluating some new
- 34:44company, which means those investors have to be even
- 34:47tighter with their Capital because the end and so just
- 34:49Aspire. And so I think we're in a little
- 34:51bit of a spiral. And so I think what will end up
- 34:53happening is if you've invested in a series a and price of Acts
- 34:57today in a year you might say, gosh given how hard it is to
- 35:01raise a serious me. Should be investing in a price
- 35:04of each point 7 x naught X. So I anticipate it will continue
- 35:08to slip back inside down rounds. Basically, I don't even know
- 35:11that they'll be down rounds because it's it down.
- 35:14Roads are really hard and really destructive for private
- 35:16companies. Yes.
- 35:17Can you explain that? That was my next question.
- 35:19So, as part of why is it that a series, a company, just can't
- 35:22just raise at a lower Sirius, B, if everybody's doing it.
- 35:26So the reason why the math is so tricky is because of the
- 35:29structure of a typical Venture Capital deal.
- 35:31And so the way it typical been Your deal worse.
- 35:34Let's say someone invests in let's say a venture capitalist
- 35:37leads the series a investment invests, five million dollars
- 35:41and a 20 million dollar pre-money valuation, which is a
- 35:4325 million-dollar post-money valuation.
- 35:46And the investor essentially owns five twenty fifths or 20%
- 35:49of the company. That's like a down the middle of
- 35:51the Fairway, series a deal. Let's say 18 months go by and
- 35:56there's still promise for the company, maybe the market
- 36:00feedback is like, hey, that's interesting at a Two million
- 36:03dollar pre-money valuation today.
- 36:05Not a 25, let alone 50 million dollar, pre-money valuation.
- 36:09Why is it so hard to like, comment just accept that they
- 36:12shouldn't raise money to 15 million dollar valuation.
- 36:16The reason is because number one, there's five million of
- 36:19preferences in the company from the previous investors
- 36:22investment and to almost every gaudio comes with what's called
- 36:27a weighted average Auntie dilution protection.
- 36:29And so if the company raised five million is initial
- 36:32financing, And now needs access to ten.
- 36:36First of all, if you were to raise 10 million out of 15
- 36:38billion dollar pre-money valuation, you're selling 40% of
- 36:41the company because it becomes ten twenty fifths of the of the
- 36:45company's value. Take the 10 of new capital, you
- 36:47added to the 15 million dollar valuation.
- 36:49We get your 25 post 1020 business for yourself.
- 36:51That's a huge chunk of the company to be selling and the
- 36:55previous investor is going to get into delusion protection,
- 36:59which means they're automatically issued more shares
- 37:02to compensate for the fact that Sit down.
- 37:04And so, in addition to the 40 %, UB Sally to a new investor, you
- 37:08also have to give up more Equity ownership to the previous
- 37:11investor because of the terms of the security.
- 37:13And so you could suddenly find out that you've sold 50 or 60
- 37:17percent of the company in a financing and it just doesn't
- 37:20work like you still longer interesting for an entrepreneur
- 37:22who just got recruited so dramatically.
- 37:25And so, it's really hard. And then on top of that, you
- 37:27have a massive communication challenge for all of your
- 37:29employees. What are you telling all your
- 37:31place? Like if they worked at the This
- 37:33for two years and their stock is now worth less than when they
- 37:36join two years ago. That's really depressing and
- 37:39it's it's hard to maintain momentum in enthusiasm.
- 37:42Intermission if ass that ship is slowly sinking but this logic
- 37:46pushes Founders to pursue debt and structured Equity or
- 37:50basically structures that allow them to maintain the illusion of
- 37:55their valuation. While putting the company at
- 37:57Great risk, if they cannot continue to sort of justify it,
- 38:02would you agree? That articulation.
- 38:04And what what's your view on is for the, some of these structure
- 38:06Equity proposals being floated. I would agree that it's kicking,
- 38:11the can of taking painful medicine, down the road, and
- 38:15there's a chance that it all works out, just fine.
- 38:18But there's a bigger chance that the company does well.
- 38:21And the financing starts to become a serious problem or the
- 38:25financing eats into all the equity value.
- 38:28Subtly of all the founders in the employees because it has all
- 38:32sorts of crazy. And suddenly you realize that
- 38:34you own very little of the company because you sold all
- 38:37these graphs each term to be some investor to maintain a
- 38:40headline price that seems good. So it's sort of like a wave.
- 38:43Hiding the problems under the rug, eventually someone's going
- 38:47to lift up the rug and see all the problems there and so it's
- 38:51treacherous. What should happen is that you
- 38:54should have an honest investor. Who says he I invested a year
- 39:00ago at a 25 million-dollar valuation.
- 39:02I got it. The company is worth $25
- 39:04anymore. And so, let's own up to where we
- 39:07are. Let's work something out where,
- 39:10you know, I made a bad investment, it shouldn't be the
- 39:13entrepreneur that has to suffer all the pain.
- 39:15Let's figure out together. Like we're business partners.
- 39:17And so maybe I give up some of my ownership, maybe you give up
- 39:21to me or ownership. Let's start this company off on
- 39:23a clean slate and a 15 million dollar valuation.
- 39:26If that's what we believe is sensible and we still believe in
- 39:28the vision and that the opportunity so forth.
- 39:31But it turns out that that's like having a Really tough
- 39:33conversation. You have to be really honest.
- 39:36It's like no, you're great, you're great.
- 39:39And then one comes to you and says, you're not as great as you
- 39:42think you are. Like, nobody wants to have to be
- 39:43the one to do that, even if the other board members, secretly
- 39:46agree, and also, nobody wants to like concede some of their
- 39:50rights rise, like I bought something, I don't want to give
- 39:53something up for nothing but guess what?
- 39:55In the spirit of what's best for the company you need to or there
- 39:59is no company and people are remarkably short side, he
- 40:01better. So, the other way to do is Like
- 40:03to kick the can down the road you pretend and to create all
- 40:05these other structural issues that can come back to haunt you
- 40:08later. Have you done this?
- 40:10Like are you have you done this with a startup?
- 40:13Like reset the cap structure, yeah?
- 40:15Bessemer yeah absolutely. In the in this period.
- 40:19Yeah in fact just in fact just yesterday I was on the bed on
- 40:21the phone with with the not prove who had seated and the
- 40:24company had raised maybe a total of four million dollars and she
- 40:27was a working and so has up to attend her.
- 40:31I'm not going to name a company because I don't wanna embarrass
- 40:33him but he cut costs dramatically.
- 40:37It had been up to 30 or 35. People was trying to do a really
- 40:39aggressive lie. It didn't work.
- 40:41Took us dramatically. But it is a still doing three
- 40:44hundred thousand dollars or so a, what the revenue and with a
- 40:47much thinner staff. Then I mix a little bit of
- 40:50profit and so it's never unless the team invent something while
- 40:54they knew, I don't know where which is always possible.
- 40:57It's never going to be a multi-billion dollar company.
- 41:00It probably won't be a multimillion-dollar company and
- 41:03so we could insist that we just keep going to Bro, said by
- 41:07admitting what, you've got and right-sizing it accepting your
- 41:11current fate. You go from being on defense and
- 41:14worrying about running out of money or getting your team to
- 41:18being an offense. Now, it's okay, we have d66
- 41:21person company. It generates just enough regular
- 41:24every month to wash its own face.
- 41:26Is that washing his cash? Cows, go down, and down, and
- 41:28down. And now, the founders can sit
- 41:30back and say, what do we want to do, do you want to sell this
- 41:33little company and try to move on to something else?
- 41:36Or do you want to show you invent something new with what
- 41:38we have as a company as a base and what I've sent name is
- 41:41Ursula. In order to keep it interesting,
- 41:44while you cogitate and brainstorm ideas, every penny of
- 41:49extra cash. You generate, why don't you keep
- 41:5280% of it? Just pay yourself really nicely
- 41:55and set it and 20% of it back to the investors.
- 41:58That's not the deal we have. In fact, the deal we have here
- 42:00of preferred stock and turned Theory, the first four million
- 42:02dollars as to all come back to the Avengers.
- 42:05Let's not lie. I mean we can insist on that.
- 42:08Let us say that's really short sighted and it's not very
- 42:10partner. Like and so I would rather use
- 42:13them. They just say we don't care
- 42:14about the company more. We're going to do something
- 42:16else. Yeah, exactly.
- 42:17And by there's bitterness and they spent years of their life
- 42:21honestly, yes, we lost the money.
- 42:22That's a bummer. But they lost time.
- 42:24Maybe that's an even bigger bomb.
- 42:25And so you have to acknowledge everyone's position, you're all
- 42:28business partner. See, I have to acknowledge
- 42:30what's good day for everybody. Our employees, the ones getting
- 42:33screwed in these deals or I mean, there's just like an
- 42:35inherent there to the one, not at the table when these things
- 42:38are being reset right? Or how do you think employees
- 42:41should I don't know what's good news when they hear their
- 42:44founder sort of announced some changes and what's bad news or
- 42:48what do you think about the employee position here?
- 42:51Look, it's really across the board.
- 42:52Some Founders and leaders are great about taking care of their
- 42:55teams and some are less great. An example I was just
- 42:59describing. There were 32 people who had
- 43:01been recruited to the company who are working really hard.
- 43:04There are all these six now and so 26 of them, no longer have a
- 43:07job or they're working somewhere else where they screw and I
- 43:12don't know. What does that mean?
- 43:13Like they worked hard, they were paid Market rates and then the
- 43:17job ended, that's a bummer. Like nobody likes to be in that
- 43:20position but that's the nature aged entrepreneurial startups.
- 43:23Like I don't always work, we hoped, but no one stole from
- 43:27now. No one took anything away,
- 43:29right? It just didn't work out like if
- 43:31that's always a potential outcome and and argue Luck plays
- 43:36quite a bit of character and maybe those boys got unlucky.
- 43:40Just like the employee happen, to joined Shopify, and you guys
- 43:44intend as opposed to joining, you know, some other random
- 43:47company got really lucky hmmm and I'm sure they contribute it
- 43:51important things that company. But like, you know, all of a
- 43:53sudden, they're making millions and millions diuretic.
- 43:55Do they deserve? Yeah, I don't know.
- 43:58So, look worked with words. But yeah, that but I'm not, I'm
- 44:01not anyway, anti layoff or anything like that.
- 44:03I'm just asking when they're these.
- 44:05Relations where it's like, okay employees got their shares under
- 44:08an old regime and now there's like a new regime.
- 44:11It's clear the negotiation sort of happening without them, for
- 44:14sure. And then but it's much like a
- 44:16Founder will negotiate an ambassador with the Venture
- 44:19capitalists. Once that is done then the
- 44:23founder has to decide. Okay, how do I want to apply
- 44:25this to all my team? And some Founders are really
- 44:27generous and issue. Lots of equity and bonuses, and
- 44:31so forth to team, particularly when there's great performance
- 44:34and others are a little bit, Tighter about it but they're
- 44:36building a culture and every country has a different culture.
- 44:38Some company called Jews. Are you get nothing until you
- 44:41are in it. Other company cultures are you
- 44:43going to lat until you prove that you don't deserve it and
- 44:45everything in between. And so in this instance, if this
- 44:48coming Swardson have to start to grow, its revenues and start to
- 44:50generate your profits founder could family.
- 44:52Keep it all for myself or he could say, I'm going to share
- 44:55with my team, my guess, knowing this one is going to show you
- 44:57the seem right. And so I'm not going to I can't
- 44:59negotiate with all six people. It's his company.
- 45:01I like company but we'll set up a structure together and then
- 45:04history had a role Or probably part of what happened in 2021,
- 45:09you know, we saw the entrance of like hedge funds, private Equity
- 45:13Funds, VC funds, do you think like the incentives of hedge
- 45:18fund compensation and just some of how these managers made money
- 45:22outside of just like maximizing returns for the, LPS was a major
- 45:28contributor of the environment. We saw in 2021, I think.
- 45:31Are you asking those are really bad behavior by investors to
- 45:34help themselves to these? Spence of others.
- 45:36Just like if I'm a hedge fund and I get paid on some of my
- 45:40investments based on the performance in a year.
- 45:42I have a strong incentive just to Mark things up and go wild in
- 45:46a year and make some returns. That's not the Venture model but
- 45:50there's also a I don't I'm just trying to maybe it's too big of
- 45:55a question but the disconnect between how like investors are
- 46:00compensated versus how funds flow to their LPS.
- 46:05Like, do you think there have been any like poorly set up
- 46:09compensation structures? That incentivize sort of
- 46:13irrational, Behavior humans are remarkably creative and
- 46:16inventive and it comes to their own compensation.
- 46:18I've learned that and I think the holds back phenomenon had
- 46:22some really interesting combination Dynamics to it where
- 46:24I suspect sponsor would get a significant chunk of the
- 46:29combined company, they make even more money, if the company
- 46:32traded above the dese packing price, but even the Tres Beau,
- 46:35Hello, they still walk away with a good chunk of the company and
- 46:38so there's no profit generated and yet the spectrometer makes
- 46:41much money. That's, that's not well aligned
- 46:43incentives, and I think it's no surprise that as more and more.
- 46:47These stock companies have fallen below, their stock prices
- 46:50were seeing the stock market drives up entirely big.
- 46:52All right, now is not great alignment here, let's not, let's
- 46:55not do it. In terms of people investing in
- 46:57tech companies that are in the broader bencher Tech ecosystem.
- 47:01I haven't seen much of that. I think most of the firm's that
- 47:04were In any meaningful amounts of private capital and private
- 47:07companies had separate private funds.
- 47:10That worked exactly the way better Fun Works.
- 47:12And look, I, I joke with my wife from time to time.
- 47:14She also works in business, but not in the investing world and
- 47:18she has a family of academics, and so I get it working to make
- 47:21money is somewhat some unappealing or distasteful.
- 47:24But as I joke with early venture capital is the noblest of the
- 47:28finance professions because you can't really make any money as a
- 47:31venture capitalist. Unless you're part of creating
- 47:34something that creates value in the World's.
- 47:35Right? Because we generally get paid
- 47:38when the investments in which determines, which we've invested
- 47:42become worth more. And then we return profits of
- 47:46those companies back to our LPS and we keep a piece of it.
- 47:50And so there's there's really good alignment between us now
- 47:53Tanner, we do better as they do better and they're really good
- 47:56on. But, you know, self is and
- 47:58whereas in most other investing businesses, you can trade, you
- 48:01can buy something when it's cheap and sell it when it's high
- 48:04or sell it. Designed by ownership and your
- 48:06nest security, any value Europe, making smart raids and there's
- 48:09not a lot of that that happens in Venture Capital.
- 48:12Yeah, so it's a noble assertiveness hangers.
- 48:14I mean, I think a lot of the companies you mentioned our are
- 48:17safe but there are lots of cyclical plays and Venture where
- 48:20people do make a ton of money career-making exits on companies
- 48:25that don't sustain, I don't want to.
- 48:27Yeah, it happens. It look at it happened even more
- 48:30over the past several years, right?
- 48:31With all these crypto currencies, like the number of
- 48:33people who made lots of money, Buying a new cryptocurrency at,
- 48:37you know, for a penny and red spiked up to something huge.
- 48:41It was never used in any material way in any application
- 48:44and then it fell wildly back down to earth like that's and
- 48:47trying to that was a little bit. What happened in the internet
- 48:49bubble? All these companies went public
- 48:50with big values, until they weren't worth anything.
- 48:54And so yes, it's not, it's not perfect, but it's generally hard
- 48:59to do really well financially unless you create something of
- 49:03value that is durable. Not impossible, but it's hard.
- 49:07I wanted to shift gears a little to some of the themes that
- 49:11you've been a big investor and I mean like consumer and Market
- 49:15places, particularly and just take stock of where they've been
- 49:19and you're, like level of optimism about finding new bets
- 49:23in those areas and they're very, very poorly defined categories
- 49:28and maybe yeah, but I mean, I don't know, let's actually start
- 49:31with marketplaces. Like, what's your scorecard on
- 49:34the Success of marketplaces, are you still bullish on like
- 49:38chasing Marketplace businesses? And I think the underlying
- 49:42question is just like are there that many great Marketplace
- 49:46outcomes to justify how much of a category of pursuit.
- 49:50It is been for the Venture Capital industry.
- 49:54Yes and yes. And so I remain very exciting
- 49:56and I think there have been tons of successful companies and I
- 50:00think there's tons of opportunities still for growth.
- 50:03I think it's not as easy. There's more Petition and the
- 50:06remaining categories are smaller, but many of our best
- 50:10investments, historically have been marketplaces and I think
- 50:13that will continue for some time and we have some great and
- 50:16sizable Market places in our portfolio.
- 50:18Today on StubHub was the example and that's going to existed for
- 50:22the better part of 20 years. Now, we sell flake.
- 50:24There's fantastic opportunities for it to continue to grow and
- 50:28expand into adjacent another areas.
- 50:31The challenge though, is how do you one get something going?
- 50:35From scratch, there's the classic chicken and egg problem,
- 50:38and you need to really creative and innovative ways of
- 50:41circumventing that challenge. And then to particularly outside
- 50:45of China, which is where I focus my investing.
- 50:48There are small number of companies that really control
- 50:51the consumer internet, both on your desktop and on your phone
- 50:54and you start almost everything you do at Google Facebook, apple
- 51:01or Amazon and their massive companies with enormous
- 51:04resources. And huge lovers of control and
- 51:07it's very hard to get something in front of a consumer with
- 51:10going through one of those companies, right?
- 51:13And in the earlier days of the internet, they would let you get
- 51:16access to your their consumers sugar-free and as they've gotten
- 51:20more sophisticated, and what I'll call less evil or more
- 51:24evil, they have been based, they stuck their hand out of put up
- 51:29more toll booths, which make it harder for you to get to get his
- 51:31room without paying. And so I can classic example, is
- 51:34in the early. Days, you could generate lots of
- 51:37free traffic from Google. And now in order to find a free
- 51:40link on Google, you got a scroll way down past the fold to find
- 51:43the free links. Right?
- 51:44All the ones at the top, someone's paying for that wasn't
- 51:47the case and the rest of your go-to just like Google gives you
- 51:50the answer and you don't even have to leave Google.
- 51:52Yeah, even worse they push all the results back and they favor
- 51:55their own services or the his of Apple you know in the beginning
- 51:59you'd find lots of stuff in the App Store.
- 52:02Now a lot of the App Store placement is paid.
- 52:05So, he won't admit there's a way for us to make more money.
- 52:06So and they've all done this more and more and more Chi their
- 52:09market caps and their own Revenue growth, and so it's just
- 52:12harder. And so in fact, there's a good
- 52:14write-up about the forget. It's called temu, they're
- 52:18spending a ton on advertise right there, sort of running The
- 52:20Tick-Tock playbook for Tick-Tock spent billions and advertising
- 52:23to just force their way into the consumer.
- 52:26If you think of the great internet companies that emerged
- 52:29up until 2015, none of them spent money on marketing.
- 52:33None of them they built. Massive you Your base to have
- 52:35doing it. Yeah.
- 52:37Companies like LinkedIn TripAdvisor, and Yelp and
- 52:40Facebook, and YouTube and so forth, Snapchat Pinterest, but
- 52:45since around you guys and 15 as the, what I call the oligopolist
- 52:49started to get more aggressive about monetizing, everything and
- 52:52limits redistribution. The only way that you could
- 52:55reliably get in trying to passive consumers is to buy your
- 52:58way. And the problem with buying your
- 53:00way is that often times you have to pay the toll collectors say
- 53:05Two dollars to your consumer that you could only monetize to
- 53:08the junos 2005 sense, right? Worse.
- 53:12A dollar fifty and if you're only getting backed a little bit
- 53:15more than you paid or even worse less than you paid, you just
- 53:18can't sustain. And of course, the complicating
- 53:20factor is startups are telling a story about their lifetime value
- 53:23that they haven't validated yet. So there's also just the mystery
- 53:26of what the actual lifetime value is, and how much investors
- 53:29are going to trust them in that bull market, environment that we
- 53:32just experienced exactly. And during the Daisy Market.
- 53:35People said, yeah, sure. Now is everyone's done a bit
- 53:39more consideration for their cash.
- 53:41You're saying, wait a minute, but even if you believe it, if
- 53:44the way you get to, if you spend $2 see, a consumer that
- 53:46generates six dollars in lifetime value.
- 53:48The way you get there is, you spend that you dollars today.
- 53:52Over the course of the next year, you get the two dollars
- 53:55back. And in the next year, you get
- 53:57another two dollars next year. Another $2 you do in fact have a
- 54:00positive Unity comic equation but to get 100 million
- 54:05consumers, you got to spend two hundred billion dollars and you
- 54:09want actually even get that money back for a whole year.
- 54:13And in the meantime you have all your employees and your
- 54:15internship knows other costs that you're spending.
- 54:17So to get to scale requires enormous amounts of money.
- 54:20None of the companies I mentioned Pinterest LinkedIn
- 54:24Yelp, they all built real user bases with less than 10 million
- 54:29dollars. And so the costs to go after
- 54:32large, consumers has gone up by 12 Erza by G.
- 54:36And so far, there are two examples of really cash-rich.
- 54:40Chinese companies, not startups, there are large, Chinese
- 54:43companies have said, oh, we see the game, this is amazing is
- 54:46great, trust is starts, can't do it.
- 54:48These came instead of go and do what I saw Tick-Tock spending
- 54:52$60 to acquire a user. I thought they're off their
- 54:55rocker on righty but in hindsight he's brilliant and
- 54:58they built the massive user visiting.
- 54:59You got a 4.6 billion dollar fund advertising is cheaper than
- 55:03ever. This would be true.
- 55:05Kareem is Amar, you should consumer investors, come to you
- 55:08and say, hey, I have a plan to blow five hundred million
- 55:10dollars. And at that point, I will be a
- 55:13legit consumers, start up, or is this A playbook?
- 55:15You're willing to run with your own money?
- 55:18I'm not sure I'm comfortable with that.
- 55:19Just yet, that would take, you know, risk gods in part.
- 55:22Because even spending a lot of money, that chances aren't that
- 55:25great, right? And so, I had soft to chip both
- 55:31within Jojo. And, and by dance, or doing it
- 55:33in the u.s. from is Courageous and like there once or two may
- 55:37be heading two two for two and so maybe that Playbook become
- 55:40more mature, but I'm obsessed with our Founders who are way
- 55:45more creative than that. It doesn't take a great tivity
- 55:48to spend a billion dollars. It takes good execution, and a
- 55:52big piggy bank but not that much inventiveness.
- 55:55And when I'm much more interested in is the inventive
- 55:57founder, who says, despite the fact that is a small number of
- 56:02really large internet companies, that incredible control over it.
- 56:05Vision. I'm going to find a way to get
- 56:07my product to Consumers and they obsess about it.
- 56:10They don't just obsess about the product itself but also how
- 56:12they're going to get it to Consumers.
- 56:14And, you know, my my favorite kind of modern era example, is
- 56:18Discord and we're really proud to be very small advisors and
- 56:22just great. I wish we were more significant
- 56:24investors and Discord Jason and cheap bills such a compelling
- 56:29service or utility that they got influencers makers.
- 56:34Streamers He's called them super humans, should embrace the
- 56:38service and use it to communicate with their fans and
- 56:41followers to the point where Discord has never spent any
- 56:44material money on marketing and hands, hundreds of millions of
- 56:47users. And so, while it's much harder
- 56:50to do that and if to be more creative and inventive today,
- 56:53and you did in 2005 to build massive distribution, it is
- 56:56still possible. And those are the kinds of
- 56:58companies. I'm obsessed with anyone.
- 57:00Who's doing anything like that. You please call me.
- 57:02Do you have any takes on the, the gas acquisition?
- 57:05You know, I feel free if not but Discord, you know, just bought,
- 57:09you know, a very rocket ship. You know, Zeitgeist e lightning
- 57:14in a bottle teen app that I don't know questionable how long
- 57:17it'll sustain Nikita, the founder, you know, sold a
- 57:20similar company to Facebook. I don't just just an interesting
- 57:23model, I guess of a Founder who is like, okay I can achieve
- 57:26virality and then I'll just like dive into the big consumer
- 57:31company the day or any observations.
- 57:34Yeah. Well they look the story.
- 57:35He is not yet rigging, but I think it's really smart a
- 57:38Discord because as you put it, capturing lightning in a bottle
- 57:41is very hard to do. And it happens very infrequently
- 57:45and when you see that happening, it's much smarter to buy it.
- 57:49And co-opt the wildly, inventive and creative founder than it is
- 57:52to try to bring yourself. And I think that's what Discord
- 57:54is saying, like by their just, where did it itself create a
- 57:58lighting about for its own app and everyone is costly trying to
- 58:01recreate that of create more of it.
- 58:03And now they're saying, but let's try We can leverage some
- 58:06of the power of what, as we create a gas that Discord, I'm
- 58:09not sure what the plans are, or how it's going to work, but it's
- 58:11exciting, the average. And I'm saying, average, and
- 58:15median VC did better since 2008 if they were in sort of SAS
- 58:22Enterprise World versus consumer world.
- 58:25Do you agree with that? I think the hit rate is much
- 58:28higher. So the adage is the most giant
- 58:31outcomes come from consumer companies and that's no
- 58:34surprise. You know, but three of the four
- 58:37trillion dollar companies. So that's Apple Google
- 58:41Microsoft, and who am I forgetting?
- 58:44Amazon Amazon? Thank you through the for our
- 58:46consumer companies and one of them is a little bit more
- 58:50Enterprise but also consumer that, of course, being
- 58:52Microsoft. So, if you want to go for
- 58:54trillion dollars, you gotta go for a consumer company, but the
- 58:57number of really high-quality Cloud software businesses,
- 59:02outstrips the number of impressive consumer companies,
- 59:04but At least a healthy multiple. And so if you're going for in
- 59:09baseball terms, you're going to church or slugging percentage,
- 59:11you go for Consumer companies. If you're going for batting
- 59:13average, you go for software companies.
- 59:15Yeah. Safer way to make a bunch of
- 59:17money, a bed in bed on SAS companies.
- 59:20The generative a, I like the buzz you things of the moment,
- 59:23like, what are you looking at it?
- 59:24The moment are you optimistic personally about generative Ai?
- 59:27And what are the things that in 2023?
- 59:30You think you'll be looking at, I know you like to keep you like
- 59:34to keep some, you got mad. To me because I think I skipped
- 59:36one of your Investments. You added me.
- 59:39Yeah, that was cambly other. There are doing great.
- 59:41So now you can talk about it as much as you want, but yeah, I
- 59:44liked it, I liked to see young companies, get your certain
- 59:47scale where they can handle the attention, the competitive
- 59:50pressures. And at a really small stage is
- 59:52no reason to embrace those things until you have to.
- 59:54So, the short answer to your question is I got so we as you
- 59:58might imagine in the in the Venture business we get to see
- 1:00:01lots and lots of product demos and in fact we get some somehow
- 1:00:05Almost done namjoo product demos because we were previously get
- 1:00:08to see them all the time and it's really rare that we see a
- 1:00:12product demo or that I've seen your product demo in 20 plus
- 1:00:14years, doing this for my jaw, literally hits the table and
- 1:00:18when we had the Jasper team come present to us my jaw.
- 1:00:22Literally at the table in part because I was so impressed by
- 1:00:25what they built. But also I was like an oh shit.
- 1:00:28Moment like the machines are coming to our me too.
- 1:00:31Right. So for a while, I thought like
- 1:00:33I'm pretty safe. I have a Sophisticated
- 1:00:35complicated job that requires high-level thinking it's the
- 1:00:39folks who are driving a car for a living that need to be
- 1:00:42worried. Because like we're going to
- 1:00:44driverless cars and like the machines are coming from now.
- 1:00:46But I'm relatively safe and then I saw Jasper and I said oh my
- 1:00:50none of us is safe. There's a text generator, right?
- 1:00:53Chad gbt competitor? Yeah, so the founders came in
- 1:00:56and they basically said, what do you want Jasper to write about
- 1:00:59and I can't remember who said it, but I think someone said
- 1:01:01write an essay about why Hilton And is a good place to go on
- 1:01:06vacation if you like golf, huh? Like okay.
- 1:01:09That's kind of and they literally type that into Jasper.
- 1:01:12And within a moment, Jasper spit back that back the past, that's
- 1:01:19a spit and Jasper produced, eight paragraph essay, and we
- 1:01:24all proceeded to read it and I, my reaction was like, holy cow.
- 1:01:29I can write that and I could probably even write something
- 1:01:32that's better than that, but not by much.
- 1:01:35Much and it would take me a few hours, right?
- 1:01:37And that's when I realized this thing is real.
- 1:01:40And so of course we begin best version Jasper and are super
- 1:01:43excited about it. But yeah.
- 1:01:45So I think the power egg, these large language models in
- 1:01:49generating, artificial intelligence that is
- 1:01:53indistinguishable and perhaps even better than human
- 1:01:55intelligence is Ramekin. I thought it would not happen in
- 1:01:58my lifetime, I thought, when I heard about open a.i. several
- 1:02:01years ago, as a non-profit, I thought, hey, that's a cute.
- 1:02:05Experiment and it'll be relevant to my children perhaps but not
- 1:02:08me and now I'm realizing no no it's here.
- 1:02:10I'm super excited about that but you're someone you ate like
- 1:02:14bullshit and I feel like the text generators are very good at
- 1:02:17it, right? I mean they, they say with
- 1:02:19confidence a lot of stuff, you know?
- 1:02:21And if they get maybe 90% of it right or do you worry that sort
- 1:02:25of just the self-driving cars have struggled with sort of
- 1:02:28perfection, the lack of perfection on accuracy for text
- 1:02:31generators will be in sort of a barrier to widespread.
- 1:02:35Widespread adoption in the short chain for sure but it's a
- 1:02:39problem be worked on so gradually, I believe it will get
- 1:02:42solved until it solves, they're a bunch of uses that you can't
- 1:02:46really take advantage of with these Technologies and or it
- 1:02:50creates purpose for humans. And so at a minimum like the
- 1:02:53human has to be to proofread her and just because the machine put
- 1:02:55it in the story doesn't mean you have to leave it there.
- 1:02:57You got to go fix it and that maybe the role of humans and
- 1:02:59I'll make us wild and more productive right.
- 1:03:01Eventually when they figure out how to create ground trees for
- 1:03:05These large language models, you will need the humans anymore and
- 1:03:08that is kind of scary, but I'll give you an anecdote with young
- 1:03:11professional in our office, who was relatively new to excel, who
- 1:03:14is working on a financial model and this person wasn't that
- 1:03:18familiar with how to transform some data in Excel.
- 1:03:21And so they asked chat GPT, they describe the situation said, can
- 1:03:26you write a macro Edge For Me, Right?
- 1:03:28A chat gbt produced the back row in text, they copied it from
- 1:03:31Japanese GP T, paste it into Excel and it worked, yum.
- 1:03:35I said, wow, this is a mate like dry productivity benefits from
- 1:03:38these tools are just incredible. Yeah, it's amazing.
- 1:03:42I wanted to because you have this buyout fund and I was
- 1:03:45curious, we haven't talked about that, what this strategy will
- 1:03:49be. Yeah.
- 1:03:50So what you're referencing is? We launched something new called
- 1:03:54DVP Forge, which is about fund. Yeah.
- 1:03:56And at a high level, like, we believe, the way we succeeded by
- 1:04:00being in great service to entrepreneurs and the
- 1:04:03entrepreneurs that Everyone likes to talk about The
- 1:04:05entrepreneur is you end up building?
- 1:04:07Massey businesses, they become household names and they quote
- 1:04:11unquote, go all the way with them.
- 1:04:12And so these are like the Jeremy, stoppelman, he's still
- 1:04:14running Yelp, you know almost 20 years.
- 1:04:16After you started here, Toby looky who's still running
- 1:04:18Shopify, almost 20 years after he started or Geoff Lawson and
- 1:04:22not on. And I, by the way, we love
- 1:04:24partnering with it goes out of burgers.
- 1:04:26At it's a lot of fun. It's really rewarding and we
- 1:04:29think we do a pretty well but they're not the only types of
- 1:04:31entrepreneurs out there. And so, as we thought about our
- 1:04:34mission to serve, Entrepreneurs, we realize there any types.
- 1:04:37And now there's some types that were not yet ready or willing to
- 1:04:40partner with. And so another type of
- 1:04:41entrepreneur is the one who opens up the Taco Bell franchise
- 1:04:45the Nogales franchise and they're also entrepreneurs are
- 1:04:47not going to be the next to be geeky but they could go from one
- 1:04:50chai's. Tajiri stores to five stores and
- 1:04:52it's a really great business and there are other sources of
- 1:04:55capital or partners that they can work with to do that.
- 1:04:58But there's this other entrepreneur that we started to
- 1:05:00come across more and more often in the course of our day jobs.
- 1:05:03And those aren't murderers, who might Say a cloud software
- 1:05:06company and we might have had a chance to meet them when they
- 1:05:08were a two billion dollar Cloud software company for one reason
- 1:05:12or another, it just wasn't a great fit and they're very
- 1:05:14quickly and maybe there will be strapped or maybe there is a
- 1:05:18little bit of money. And what we check back in with
- 1:05:20them or they reach out to us two or three or four years later,
- 1:05:23it's a fifteen million dollar Revenue business which is like
- 1:05:25amazing. Like to grow your business from
- 1:05:27two million to 15 million. Like that is no small
- 1:05:29achievement but by the time it gets to 15 million in Revenue.
- 1:05:33It's now growing a year, right? And so if you do the math and
- 1:05:37even if 06 up a little bit, it takes forever to compound.
- 1:05:41A business, at 20 percent per year from 15 billion Revenue to
- 1:05:44get to what I'll call a venture scale outcome.
- 1:05:47And so we tend to rule those out as potential fits for our
- 1:05:50Venture Capital business because they can't have the kind of
- 1:05:53Outsiders outcomes that were generally looking for.
- 1:05:55But that doesn't mean you're not great businesses.
- 1:05:57And in some instances, those Founders want a different set of
- 1:06:00services and the ones that we offer as Venture capitalists.
- 1:06:03As Venture capitalists were almost always a minute.
- 1:06:05Ready investor. We provide all sorts of help
- 1:06:08access to other Executives and a we know.
- 1:06:11But as a minority shareholder where we think of it as invited
- 1:06:15guests phenomenal it's your house entrepreneur.
- 1:06:18We have all these things that we can bring over a chair, might
- 1:06:20help you take your pick from them, will give you ideas and so
- 1:06:23forth but were a guest in your house.
- 1:06:25Hmm. Other entrepeneurs when they
- 1:06:26enter certain size they may not walk to be the host anymore and
- 1:06:30they may say gosh I built a business from nothing to 15
- 1:06:33billion of Revenue. If I could put 10 or 20 or 30 or
- 1:06:3740 million dollars in my pocket, that's the as a fortune, right?
- 1:06:41I don't need to go for the billion-dollar outcome or I
- 1:06:45might like to go for it with your help.
- 1:06:47So, you best were, you take over and I want to stay involved or
- 1:06:51maybe I don't want to stay involved and I and and maybe
- 1:06:54I'll sell most of my stock or some of my stuff.
- 1:06:56And that, if it, if you can help turn this into a billion dollar
- 1:06:59Venture, I'll benefit even more, but I don't want to make it my
- 1:07:03only, you're my main thing necessarily any More or maybe
- 1:07:05you can help me recruit a new team or whatever.
- 1:07:07And so, there's a whole bunch of entrepeneurs are in that
- 1:07:09category. It's not the Venture model of
- 1:07:11all that is essentially a software by, oh, and you'll
- 1:07:14bring in operators, or your, we will, we will we have internal
- 1:07:18folks, you have expertise in different domains.
- 1:07:21They'll get deeply involved even more so than we will in a
- 1:07:24venture business because we will own the company where were their
- 1:07:28rent rolling shareholders? You will.
- 1:07:30And by the way, I think it's really interesting to be a
- 1:07:32controlling shareholder in one business went in Other business,
- 1:07:36you're a minority shareholder because you know how a majority
- 1:07:39shareholder wants to be treated, right?
- 1:07:40If that's how you are all the time.
- 1:07:41And so I think whether it's new, so I can't say we're necessarily
- 1:07:45proven to be great at it. I'm really optimistic.
- 1:07:48I think we understand. How would you treat a minority
- 1:07:50shareholder? Is your partner because we're
- 1:07:52usually wearing that pair of shoes, the biker.
- 1:07:55She's and so it's a new initiative, we're really excited
- 1:07:57about it because we frankly, the number of companies and
- 1:08:00entrepreneurs who fit that sort of characteristics actually out
- 1:08:04numbers. The number of companies fit the
- 1:08:07classic denture characteristics. I want to build something
- 1:08:09really, really big and take it all the way to the finish line
- 1:08:12and we didn't want to just turn them away and say, Ray, sorry,
- 1:08:15nothing for you. Here, we wanted to be able to
- 1:08:17work with them to I wanted to end with an introspective
- 1:08:22personality question. I'm a reporter.
- 1:08:25Who's a dispositional e, skeptical and overtime, trying
- 1:08:29to shed a little bit of that. I watched the bull market in
- 1:08:332021 and I laughed. People they you know next Bull
- 1:08:36Run. I need to just be like sort of
- 1:08:38Shameless like there are so many people who made a bunch of money
- 1:08:41just like forgetting their Scruples like go even if crypto
- 1:08:44implodes you could have made a ton of money there.
- 1:08:46You could have made a ton of money on spax, just like being
- 1:08:49like the booster in the good times.
- 1:08:51Like, how did I sit that out? I was right there.
- 1:08:53You know, I've seen Bitcoin so long, but disposition Ali.
- 1:08:57It's like everything I'm against, and obviously, I care
- 1:09:00about things, you know, beyond money.
- 1:09:02But, you know, I did sort of set up in the beginning.
- 1:09:04And this idea that you're someone who's optimistic about
- 1:09:09technology, but sort of skeptical of some of the hype
- 1:09:12and I'm curious. Yeah.
- 1:09:15How do you keep your head when other people are losing theirs
- 1:09:19or what sort of the practice of? How does one actually maintain
- 1:09:23sort of both sensibilities at the same time?
- 1:09:26It's not easy. And I honestly it's I think the
- 1:09:28benefit of working with Partners is significant here because
- 1:09:33there are so many things one Keep get excited about and my
- 1:09:37personal style, or my personal taste is to try to find the
- 1:09:40stuff. I have high conditioner
- 1:09:42competition. The most people don't care
- 1:09:44about. I don't like to go where all the
- 1:09:47cool kids are or all the popular kids are.
- 1:09:49I like to kind of go off in a corner of the playground and
- 1:09:52find someone who's doing something over there.
- 1:09:54That's really compelling that most people are prepared to
- 1:09:57dismiss or aren't that. Excited about Partners, who are
- 1:10:00much more interested in like like what everyone's talking
- 1:10:03about and want to compete. Eat and chase after the most
- 1:10:06exciting, things are conventionally exciting.
- 1:10:09And for me, like the challenge is, how do you find something
- 1:10:12that today? Nobody thinks is all that
- 1:10:14interesting, but in three or four years, they will and you
- 1:10:19managed to find an entrepreneur or get excited about an idea
- 1:10:23before. And it's really rewarding when
- 1:10:26you're Vindicated or validated in that way and actually think
- 1:10:30most impressive results are returned.
- 1:10:33Your companies are Founded when there's someone out of favor and
- 1:10:37funded. When there's someone out of
- 1:10:38favor and go back to your analogy about like wow I wish I
- 1:10:43didn't have his Scruples and I are so loaded up on Bitcoin.
- 1:10:46In 2021. The truth is that would have
- 1:10:48worked well not interested. Why do you know I was writing
- 1:10:50about it in 2014. Super skeptical.
- 1:10:52Yeah that would work that would work and so but it's in some
- 1:10:56sense. It's easier to jump on the
- 1:10:57bandwagon for something in 2021 like everyone's doing right
- 1:11:00hard. So it's not so it's also
- 1:11:03honestly all a really useful exercise.
- 1:11:05You guys is to write down what you really think at a point in
- 1:11:09time. So if you wrote down what you
- 1:11:11really thought about good for in 2014, it could look back on it,
- 1:11:15I assure you, it would be different from what you think
- 1:11:17about. We thought about Bitcoin in 2020
- 1:11:19and today and that we tend to alter our memories, right?
- 1:11:23Because it's like it's like I self-preservation check me to
- 1:11:26have liked the thing early that we know is great today and to
- 1:11:29have not like something early that we go.
- 1:11:31Isn't so great today and is really hard to be truthful about
- 1:11:33what you really thought. And so, one of the ways that we
- 1:11:36do it is at best result. When we invest in companies, we
- 1:11:39each specify how much money week personally, would want to invest
- 1:11:42in a company. So that five years later when it
- 1:11:44becomes really big, we can look back and like, oh my gosh, I
- 1:11:48only read a five hundred dollar check, I wish I wrote a five
- 1:11:50hundred thousand dollar check, right?
- 1:11:51And you can't miss A Rambler that that shows up on like a
- 1:11:53financial state, right? But having some way of keeping
- 1:11:55yourself honest allows you to, in theory get better at these
- 1:11:59over time because you're not working, you're marrying the way
- 1:12:02most people do. Thank you.
- 1:12:04Jeremy Levine. Thanks for coming on the
- 1:12:05podcast. I really appreciate it.
- 1:12:07Such a pleasure thanks for having me here.
- 1:12:21Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:12:23Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:12:21Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:12:23Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.